We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

Financial Resolution No. 26—General—Report (Resumed).

Contributions 215–428 of 626. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 3 parts.

I have a certain amount of sympathy with the Minister in dealing with a matter of this kind. Many of us appreciate the desire of the Minister to give employment. But may I say, as one who has some little knowledge of the subject, that the bending of corrugated iron is a very simple process, done with a very simple machine and that it gives only a very small amount of employment? The difficulty that I see in connection with this particular tariff is this: that corrugated iron is not manufactured in this country, and it is not likely to be manufactured here. Corrugated iron is imported through certain centres and it goes through certain routes, in many cases through direct routes from certain towns and cities on the other side, where it is manufactured. This particular tariff will upset that. In other words, the corrugated iron will have to go from the port where it comes in to the rolling mills to be bent, it will have to be carted to the rolling mills, and having been bent there, it will have to be carted back to the railway station, and then sent to its destination. That is to say, the cartage and the cost of delivery will be inflated very considerably. It is not the bending process that is going to cost so much at all, but it is the difficulty that is going to be created and the expense that this particular bending is going to be. I do not know whether that particular point was clear to the Minister or not. But there is another point that I should like to make clear to the Minister. It is that I am quite satisfied that 90 per cent. of the bent, corrugated iron coming into this country is used by farmers; and the extraordinary thing is that, under this particular tariff, this is the only item of corrugated iron that is going to be tariffed. I want to be fairminded, I want to be helpful, that is always my desire; and what I want to make clear is this: that, as regards this particular item, 90 per cent. of it is used by the farmers and that that is the only commodity in connection with imported corrugated iron that is tariffed. It does seem to me, knowing something of the position of the agricultural community at the moment, that it is an unfair tariff, an unfair burden; and I am sure that when the Minister comes to look into it he will find that the amount of additional employment that will be created by the rolling and bending of corrugated iron will be infinitesimal in comparison with the amount of trouble, worry and additional expense that will have to be borne by the farmers.

Comment on this

It is with a view to amending the wording of this Resolution, that I rise. The wording here is: "Galvanised corrugated iron." If the Minister is serious on the distinction that he has made——

Comment on this

"Galvanised corrugated iron or steel, excluding unworked sheets of such iron."

Comment on this

I know what you mean. I have a clearer idea of this than the Minister seems to have. If the Minister puts in the words "galvanised bent or curved corrugated iron," I am satisfied. If he does not, then the provision will apply to every kind, straight or curved. Whoever advised the Minister included straight as well as curved iron. If we cannot argue it on the basis that it will be bent or curved sheets of corrugated iron, we cannot argue it at all— unless the Minister agrees to put in that. Will the Minister agree to that?

Comment on this

I think the Deputy is reading from the first copy of the Resolution. In the second copy the matter is much clearer.

Comment on this

I want to know what it means.

Comment on this

"Galvanised corrugated iron or steel, excluding unworked flat sheets of such iron."

Comment on this

I hope that is right. When Deputy Moore rises in this House he always takes up the attitude of a student. He is always looking for information from somebody, generally from the Opposition, he never looks for information from his own side of the House, and he never seems to know anything about the matter himself. I wonder has he any idea of the life of galvanised iron in the different localities in the country. Has he any idea of the life of galvanised iron in Dublin or in any other city? Has he any idea of the life of galvanised iron around our coast where the salt breezes play on it, as compared with its life in the inland towns? Does he know anything about that? Does the Minister know anything about that? He wants to know how long it will be before the corrugated iron will have to be replaced, how often it will have to be replaced. If he would tell me the particular locality that he has in mind I can tell him to within a few years the life of it.

For the last half dozen winters the necessity of shelter for stock has been more apparent than it ever was before, and farmers who have had the experience of three or four winters have been forced to the idea—I have heard several farmers speaking about it— that if they are going to keep their stock, they will have to put up additional winter shedding. What is the effect of this tariff on them? It is going to deteriorate our stock, it is going to prevent farmers from putting up any shelter, and this at a time when cattle are undoubtedly cheaper than they were four or five years ago. These are serious considerations. Galvanised iron is used extensively in the country. If the Minister's intention is right, it relieves the situation, to an extent. If the straight sheet is on a different basis to the curved sheet, this relieves the situation to a very considerable extent, but the difference in price between the straight corrugated sheet and the curved sheet is so little that this tariff of 10 or 15 per cent. is very little short of robbery, having regard to the difference in price. The charge is not justified at all by the labour required.

Let us get at it from another angle. Perhaps the Minister can tell us what is the value of the annual imports of corrugated iron. The Minister has the figures. He has a Department to get them for him, and it is information that we should have also. We should also have the difference in value of the imports of the curved sheet and and the straight sheet. Another reason why corrugated iron is so popular in the country is that it does not require tradesmen to put it up. It is easy to erect, and it may be handled by the people themselves, who could not afford to pay fancy prices for labour, who certainly could not afford to pay 1/2d an hour for having it put up. Because it is popular it will be always used in preference to some of the heavier materials. I do not see any prospect of an alternative in this country either in the manufacture of corrugated iron, asbestos, or any other material for roofing to take its place, and the tariff is simply a burden on the agricultural community without any resulting benefit.

Comment on this

Deputy Moore informed us in the course of this debate that he spent half his life on a farm. And he gave us the full fruits of that half life experience, and told us that a farmer who purchased galvanised corrugated iron did not remember from one purchase to another the price that he had paid for it. If the Deputy was at the other end of the transaction he would know that not only did the farmer remember the price of it but that he offered a few pence or a few shillings less than at the previous purchase before getting back to bedrock again. The serious matter in this is the definition that has been used, and it will certainly bear looking into. The phrase is "galvanised corrugated iron or steel, excluding unworked flat sheets of such iron." The words "or steel" are part of the definition. The words "or steel" do not come into the exclusion part. I wonder why. I do not know that the addition or the exclusion matters much. But I do think that this is going to be a matter of considerable difficulty for any Customs officer to interpret, according to the views set out here. He will find before him the phrase "excluding unworked flat sheets of such iron." The Minister stressed the phrase "such iron" as bringing in the phrase "galvanised corrugated." But even so, there is such a contradiction that the Customs officer is bound to decide for the narrower and more rigid interpretation. He will be faced with the phrase "excluding unworked flat sheets of such iron." As regards the word "flat" we might be able to get the definition made clear, that a sheet of iron is flat if it has no other shaping than the corrugative. But that could be precisely stated. The Officer of Customs has that other phrase to add to his difficulties—"unworked." Surely he has got to take the interpretation that it is a sheet, that it will eventually be a galvanised corrugated iron piece of work. But at the time that he gets it, it is unworked inasmuch as it is neither corrugated nor galvanised.

At any rate I suggest that there is a possibility that the definition might then be too wide and that it might bring in things not intended—say sheets of iron that have not been subjected to other processes than galvanising. That is certainly not the intention of the phrase we have here. The material, apart from the definition as to the cost of the goods, is the only test in the end. The cost includes more than the price which has been increased on the article itself by reason of the operation which it is intended to have done in the country because of the tariff. The cost here of the actual operation of bending or shaping these sheets may not be very much but the inconvenience and the trouble that may be caused by the rehandling and the stoppage of direct deliveries will also add to the final cost, whatever that may be. All these extra costs and inconveniences in the charges for rehandling have all to be worked out against whatever the estimate is as to the number of men to be put in employment or added to the number already in employment. What that number may be I do not know. I look upon this as a supreme test of the optimism of the Minister. I do not think the figures will help him. The imports of corrugated iron in the year may run to about £200,000 but I do not know that there has been any segregation of that made on any proper basis as between corrugated iron which has been bent and corrugated iron which has been brought in in the flat unworked state. Some estimate of that has to be given before we can form any proper estimate of the tariff. The wording has to be looked to if we are to have the full intention of the Minister carried out.

Comment on this

The wording in my opinion clearly expresses the intention we had. I do not anticipate that any interpretation will be put upon it by the Revenue Commissioners other than that which we meant to imply. The intention is clearly that the sheet of galvanised corrugated iron which has been worked or fabricated for use in any way is subject to duty. If that has not been worked or fabricated for use then it is free of duty. It is not possible to give the figures relating to the import of galvanised corrugated iron whether flat sheets or fabricated iron. The import figure relates only to galvanised plates and sheets. That includes not merely corrugated sheets but also uncorrugated sheets. It is not possible to give anything like an estimate of the amount of employment that is going to be given through this tariff. And that is so for a number of reasons. One is that we have no precise information as to the annual requirements of the country in this case, secondly, because the firms that engage in this work also engage in other work. The employment given directly might, and in our opinion possibly will, be supplemented by the fact that the bringing of the work to these firms will also lead to bringing them other orders that might not have been available to them if the work had not to be done here.

It is, if I may say so in parentheses, rather a remarkable fact that since the imposition of certain duties, firms have become aware of the work that can be done in certain factories here; they have become aware of the facilities that are available for getting the work done. Even where there is no duty, the fact of getting the work done here has meant a considerable increase of orders to Irish firms even in the case of goods not subject to the duty at all and this merely because the imposition of these duties has focussed attention upon the industrial resources of the country. A rather remarkable instance of that has been brought to my notice. This is not going to mean any extra cost to the farmers and neither is it going to mean any extra inconvenience to the farmers. It will only mean that when a merchant is ordering a rolled sheet or anybody is proposing to erect a building, he is going to get the corrugated iron from the Irish merchant and have the fabrication and rolling done here. It can be done here, as has been pointed out by a number of Deputies. It is quite a simple process. That is why I was at a loss to understand Deputy Dillon. He started off by saying that this duty was of little importance to the Department of Finance and then he proceeded to say that it was an extravagant duty. In one place he said that it was not worth the printing of the forms in the green paper and he ended by saying that it was so oppressive that the farmers of Roscommon were marching on Dublin.

Comment on this

I drew the attention of the Minister to the fact that the amount of employment it will give is negligible, that the amount of revenue it will give is small, but that the inconvenience it causes is quite out of proportion. I could not reasonably expect the Minister to understand my arguments as he is not an agriculturist. It is the annoyance to the farmer I was referring to.

Comment on this

If the small farmer in the country is buying corrugated iron he will go to the merchant in the small towns and it is the merchant in the small towns and not the small farmer in the country who will be annoyed. The Irish merchant is to have the rolling done here rather than have the rolling done in England. I must say that I cannot feel any deep regret that the Irish merchant will be annoyed because of that.

Comment on this

The Minister will not get much sympathy in the country for that viewpoint.

Comment on this

It is rather interesting to find this rapidly developing interest for the small farmer.

Comment on this

For the farmers.

Comment on this

It is quite a new development and I wish it every possible success in its development.

Comment on this

It is going to develop certainly.

Comment on this

Yes, the electoral needs of the Cumann na nGaedheal Party will cause it to flourish quite rapidly. Deputies opposite will bear in mind that the small farmer will feel offended if he is going to be held up here as the bogey to prevent anything being done in the direction of helping to solve unemployment. The fact that the small farmers to the extent of 75 per cent. or more voted for the policy which we are now putting into operation; the fact that the small farmer can see benefits in this policy that we are putting into operation is an answer to what the Deputies on the other side have been saying. It is not the fault of the Deputies that they are unable to understand a reasonable viewpoint like that. It is a natural handicap on them. When we raise the prosperity of any one class in the community we are rendering assistance to every class because the prosperity of one class means benefit for all.

Comment on this

I ask the Minister to go down and make that speech to the employees of Gallaher's factory.

Comment on this

Is there not an omission in the description in the Schedule? Should the Minister not have added the words "of such iron or steel"?

Comment on this

I am informed that although it is called galvanized iron it is in fact galvanized steel. That is why that amendment was suggested to me. It certainly does appear to me that the words "iron or steel" should be put in twice.

Comment on this

With regard to Reference No. 31, I would like, on the question of pipes, to direct attention to what seems to me to be a curious form of wording:—"Pipes made wholly or mainly of wood and designed or intended for use in smoking tobacco or other substances." What are the other substances that the Minister believes the people of this country are smoking and that he must put a tax on pipes to keep out? I would also like to know from the Minister whether there are any very cheap wooden pipes made in this country. I mean the type of pipe which the ordinary workingman smokes, wooden pipes costing 6d. or 1/-. I am perfectly aware that Kapp & Peterson make very good pipes of a higher grade, but I am not aware that they put upon the market any pipe at a small figure like 6d. or 1/- which the ordinary workingman or the ordinary small farmers smoke.

Comment on this

One fault in this proposal is the exclusion of the chalk pipe. Chalk pipes are still made in this country.

Comment on this

How many are imported? What imports are there of clay pipes?

Comment on this

There are a considerable number used, especially in the West of Ireland.

Comment on this

I can assure the Deputy that there are no clay pipes now used there.

Comment on this

Indeed there are. Lately I went through the only factory in Ireland making clay pipes and the proprietress informed me that clay pipes made in Scotland are imported into the West of Ireland and she is unable to compete with them for the reason that the clay from which the pipes are made comes from Scotland. The Scottish manufacturers get the clay on the spot and they are able to send the ready-made article here at a price with which this lady is unable to compete. The clay pipe is still used in many country places and at one time the manufacture of it gave employment to considerable numbers. In this factory I inspected the other day upwards of 20 or 30 people were constantly employed at one time. These people are still in the locality. I saw some of them making pipes. If they were given an opportunity of holding their own against the Scottish importers it would be a good idea. It would do no harm. The pipes would be sold at the same price and we would have the satisfaction of smoking home-made ones.

Comment on this

I suggest that the Minister should consult with his medical colleagues on the subject of certain pipes. There is a general belief that one of the causes of cancer is the smoking of clay pipes. The Minister might think it wise to investigate that.

Comment on this

I think that is briar pipe manufacturers' propaganda.

Comment on this

Possibly, but it might be worth investigating.

Comment on this

What is the import value of pipes in any of the years past? I think it is so small that it is included somewhere under the miscellaneous group.

Comment on this

The import value was £10,000.

Comment on this

Has there been any segregation made, indicating whether the pipes were clay pipes or briar pipes?

Comment on this

The figure I gave refers to briar pipes.

Comment on this

I believe the only people who purchased clay pipes within recent years were unfortunate tourists, who came here and looked upon them as characteristic of the country and took them away for that reason. That represents the bulk of sales of clay pipes. There are numbers of clay pipes used by young people for blowing bubbles. If there was propaganda on the part of the briar pipe manufacturers it was successful propaganda and, in my opinion, it is a good job that the clay pipe has gone out. I want to know if the imports do not mainly consist of very superior pipes, presentation sets, and things like that. I believe that is the type of article that is most imported. The other type of pipe that is imported is very definitely the absolutely cheap pipe which certain people buy. Apart from the presentation sets, upon which one does not mind a tax being put, there is definitely a very cheap pipe imported.

Comment on this

With regard to the wording in the Schedule—"or other substances"—surely the Minister is not suggesting that we are becoming addicted to the habit of smoking hashish?

Comment on this

The necessity for putting in the words "or other substances" arises out of the word "designed." The Revenue Commissioners said it would be possible to evade duty because someone could say: "This pipe may look like one in which to smoke tobacco, but I intend to smoke brown paper in it" or something of that sort. We do not anticipate that there will be any considerable smoking of substances other than tobacco. Nevertheless, it is contended that the words are necessary.

Comment on this

Is this to be interpreted subjectively instead of objectively?

Comment on this

The words in the Schedule are "designed or intended." There are two firms engaged in the manufacture of briar pipes in this country. One firm has a very substantial export trade; about 75 per cent. of its products are or have been exported. It is incorrect that the imports are represented by either very expensive or very cheap grades. It is true there is a very cheap grade of briar pipe imported that is not likely to be made here. If there was any medical reason for the disappearance of the clay pipe. I think a medical man would say there is equally good reason for the disappearance of the very cheap wood pipe which is imported. There is a factory in Dublin engaged in the manufacture of cheap pipes.

The greater part of our imports in pipes is represented by those of medium grade similar to the products of factories here. One of the factories has been subjected to very intensive competition recently and, in fact, the number of people employed has diminished. It is anticipated that this duty, although small, will help it to regain its old position and to ensure that some increase in employment in the industry will be afforded. There is a considerable amount of skill required in the manufacture of a good pipe. We have the skilled workers here, skilled workers with an international reputation, and it is hoped by this duty that we will be able to save them from unemployment.

Comment on this

I know the West of Ireland better than Deputy Goulding because I spent my whole life there and I am aware that clay pipes have entirely gone out of fashion. When I was a boy clay pipes were very extensively smoked, but during the last ten years I do not think I saw one. They have completely and entirely gone out of use in the West. The Minister said the danger of disease would come through cheap briar pipes the same as through clay pipes. That is not so. It is alleged by certain medical opinion that the smoking of clay pipes brought cancer of the lip. Cancer of the lip was very prevalent amongst the smokers of clay pipes. It was the contact of the clay with the lip which was supposed to bring on cancer and, I believe, did bring it on in many cases. That would not apply at all, of course, to the cheap briar pipe. If the cheap briar pipes are not being manufactured here, as I take it from the Minister they are not —

Comment on this

They are.

Comment on this

Who manufactures them?

Comment on this

All the firms now in this industry are manufacturing a cheap briar pipe.

Comment on this
A Deputy

What is a cheap pipe?

Comment on this

A pipe retailed at about 1/- in the shops.

Comment on this

Who retails them? I do not know of any cheap Irish-made pipe except a pipe with a hopeless flaw which is filled up with putty and would be valueless. I ask the Minister to inquire further into the matter, and see if he could not exempt pipes retailed at 1/- from this tax.

Comment on this

From what I know of the process of pipe manufacture, blocks of wood are imported from Greece, or wherever the wood is grown. These are carved into pipe heads. It is not until the pipe head has been actually produced that the manufacturer knows at what price he is going to sell the pipe. It may turn out to be a first-class quality, a second-class quality, or a low-grade head, and the value of the pipe ultimately produced varies accordingly. There is, however, another firm, besides the one which has an international reputation, engaged in the manufacture of pipes in Dublin which is producing cheap pipes and selling them as such.

Comment on this

I have never seen them.

Comment on this

Has the Minister considered that the diminution in the industry of pipe-making is largely due to the increase in cigarette smoking?

Comment on this

That is so.

Comment on this

As to the statement that the smoking of clay pipes is injurious to health, I should like to have that borne out by medical testimony.

Comment on this

I only put it as a question.

Comment on this

I have heard it frequently stated by medical men, but I do not put myself forward as an authority.

Comment on this

I never heard any authority express an opinion in connection with it. Apart from that, the fact is that clay pipes are still in use in the West of Ireland. The proprietress of this factory assured me that she had a considerable trade with the West of Ireland until she was cut out by Scottish importers. I think it would be only fair that the Minister should include clay pipes in this and give this factory a chance of keeping on the industry, small though it is. The people engaged in it are living in a very poor district, and were in constant employment before the Scottish importers cut them out. It is not too much to ask that clay pipes should be included.

Comment on this

To clear up the difference between Deputy Fitzgerald-Kenney and the Deputy on the other side, I should like to say that, oddly enough, both of them are right. Clay pipes are not smoked in the West, but they are still used as a token of mourning. They are used on the occasion of funerals as a token of mourning. Oddly enough, the consumption is still substantial. I think there is a good deal to be said for Deputy Goulding's theory, that if there is any little business done in them, there is no reason why it should not be done here. The price of the commodity is so trifling in any circumstances that it is one of these tariffs on something used by the agricultural community which I would be prepared to support.

Comment on this

In support of Deputy Goulding's statement, I might say that in the county we represent clay pipes are sold in practically every small shop in the villages. I constantly see them smoked and yet I claim that we have no more cancer than any other county. The old people think that a clay pipe is the best pipe to smoke. They have been advised by doctors to smoke them and not to smoke wooden pipes.

Comment on this

I support Deputy Goulding's proposal. I should like to point out to him that in the County Cork we have ideal clay for making these pipes and that they need not go to Scotland for it. I suggest to the Minister that if, as he says, there is no great importation of these pipes, the tariff will not do any harm to the poor farmers about whom Deputy Dillon has so much concern. I suggest to the Minister that he should include clay pipes under this tariff, and if there is any employment to be given, let it be given at home.

Comment on this

There seems to be an impression in some quarters of the House that clay pipes are not generally smoked in this country. I know one part of the country pretty intimately and the clay pipe is in general use there. A good many people prefer it to the wooden or briar pipe. We are all accustomed to the person in the countryside who seasons his clay pipe and then, on a winter's day, he often breaks off a portion of the shank and converts it into what is called a jaw-warmer or a "dudeen." Deputy McGilligan thinks that clay pipes are simply sold as souvenirs to gullible tourists who will take them away under the impression that they have something redolent of the country when they are taking their departure from our midst. That is not so. Clay pipes are a general utility in the countryside, as I know it. I wish to support Deputy Goulding's plea, that as we have a factory turning out these pipes the Minister should extend the benefit of the protection to that industry. Prices, we are assured, will not be altered. As clay pipes are in general use in many parts of the country and cost so little, why should they not be manufactured at home and the employment given to our own people, even if we have only one factory? We have the protection for the consumer that the price will not be raised and it is very small. Even Deputy Dillon is with us in this. I hope he will pardon me when I say that I have some ironical feeling when I notice the solicitude for the agriculturist and the working farmer on the part of some people who are not engaged primarily in agriculture.

Comment on this

Does the Deputy refer to me, because he is quite mistaken if he does?

Comment on this

Do you derive your living primarily from agriculture?

Comment on this

Yes, and farming.

Comment on this

I am glad to hear that. As to clay pipes being a potential source of cancer, Deputy Fitzgerald-Kenney said the clay pipe is falling into disuse in the West. I do not dispute that, because I have not the same knowledge as he has of the West. It is, however, generally known that, unfortunately, cancer is on the increase in the country. The use of the clay pipe, it is said, is decreasing, so that you cannot blame the clay pipe for the increase of cancer. My intention in intervening was to support Deputy Goulding's plea, that the clay pipes used in this country should be manufactured at home.

Comment on this

Do I understand the Minister agrees to include them?

Comment on this

I shall have the matter considered.

Comment on this

That will be an extension of the tariff.

Comment on this

It could not be done except by Resolution.

Comment on this

Item 32 deals with roof felting and felting substitutes and other like substances intended for use as roofing material. I would like to know from what source the demand for this duty comes. It seems to have some connection with No. 30.

Comment on this

None whatever.

Comment on this

Does it include asbestos roofing?

Comment on this

We are assured by the Minister that it does not include asbestos, which is a substitute for slate. "Substances intended for use as roofing materials." It is very like a substitute. These Resolutions should have a specific definition. If it is not intended to include slates and asbestos roofing, it should be stated. I am afraid you will have confusion on this question of asbestos as soon as this Resolution becomes law. Again I ask is this a revenue Resolution or is it going to induce any activities here? Is it meant to handicap the importation of this class of material here in order to give Irish slates a better market?

Comment on this

These materials are manufactured in the country.

Comment on this

The Minister says they are manufactured in the country, but the only question I want to be clear about is that asbestos slates are not included.

Comment on this

They are not included.

Comment on this

I should like to assure Deputy Gorey——

Comment on this

I do not want any assurance.

Comment on this

I should like to assure him that in a very short time he can get these asbestos slates here. I want to make that clear to him. If he is satisfied with that reassurance, I am satisfied.

Comment on this

Can the Minister tell us whether canvas would come in under this heading, as we know canvas is used largely for tents and covering and is a substitute?

Comment on this

There is a duty on it already.

Comment on this

I think if it is intended to exclude it it should be mentioned. It is often used as a temporary roof covering just the same as felt is used as a temporary roof covering. There are other substitutes for felt that have asbestos in them as their basis. For instance, you have asbestos slates. Would they be used as a substitute? There is an ambiguity about the wording that one would like to see cleared up, because, while it may not be the intention of the Minister to regard these commodities as "substitutes" for felt, the Revenue Commissioners may take a different view. I think if it is not the intention to include these they ought to be specifically excluded.

Comment on this

I might draw the Minister's attention to the fact that there are asphalt preparations and that the number of these preparations is legion. The absence of a definition will leave the Revenue Commissioners in a very grave state of confusion.

Comment on this

I want it to be clearly understood that roof felting and felting substitutes and other like substances intended for use as roofing material are subject to duty definitely and clearly, but asbestos and canvas are neither roofing felts nor other like substances.

Comment on this

Does not the word "like" depend upon the word "felt"?

Comment on this

Do I understand canvas is not tariffed?

Comment on this

That is so.

Comment on this

What about tarpaulin or linen?

Comment on this

That is a different matter.

Comment on this

Has the Minister no explanation with regard to this Item No. 32?

Comment on this

Roof felting and felting substitutes are manufactured in this country, and all we hope to do is to get the imports worth about £20,000 in felt stopped and the home product substituted.

Comment on this

Would rubberoid be a felt substitute?

Comment on this

I take it it would be.

Comment on this

I understood the Minister to say that in the definition of "roof felting and felting substances and other like substances intended for use as roofing material" you had to bring down to the word "like" the word "felt."

Comment on this

And anything that is not of felt is not a like substance even though intended for roofs. The question as to rubberoid is as to whether it is a felt substance.

Comment on this

That is so.

Comment on this

Deputy Gorey might like to know that Messrs. Graves, Waterford, are extensive manufacturers of roof felting.

Comment on this

On Item 33, floor-covering, I notice that the exclusion is precise as far as oilcloth and linoleums go, and then we get one of those general phrases "substances of a nature kindred to oilcloth or linoleum." I would like to ask is it intended to exclude cork lino? There is such a thing as cork lino which is not really lino.

Comment on this

That would be excluded but rubber flooring would not.

Comment on this

This definition will have to be cleared up later in connection with the main things including carpets and rugs, but I want to ask about one or two main things. As far as I understand there was an importation of about one quarter of a million pounds of carpets and floor rugs, linoleums and oilcloths and things like that. Of that sum about £150,000 represented the carpets side and £100,000 the substitutes side. I do not know whether in this country there has been any development of the carpet industry. There are two of the luxury type but their business is mainly export or used to be. In recent years these carpets were getting more fashionable with people who can afford them. In the main it was an export business. What hope is there of having the carpet industry or the floor rug cloth industry extended in this country, and if it is to be extended, is it not rather going to be at the expense of the export which is at present the main part of that industry in the country?

Comment on this

For this year this duty is mainly intended for revenue purposes. It has a slight protective effect, but only slight. The two firms engaged in the manufacture of carpets and rugs here are mainly engaged in the manufacture of the better class goods. We have had certain enquiries and discussions going on as to the possible development of the industry at the other end. I would not like to say that we are clear that immediate progress will be made in the matter but the thing is being considered. However we decided on the imposition of the duty knowing that in a sense it would be mainly a revenue tax. We were not opposed to it as a revenue tax but the protective effect of it is of some value and it gives us scope to secure that if possible an industry will be developed in the production of these goods.

Comment on this

Can the Minister say whether ordinary matting — it is sometimes called cocoanut matting and at other times coir matting — would come within this particular item? It is a rough class of matting that is used very extensively, and so far as I know it is not manufactured here.

Comment on this

If the Deputy is referring to ordinary matting it is subject to duty.

Comment on this

Would rubber matting be subject to duty? It is extensively used now.

Comment on this

It applies to floor coverings, excluding oilcloth and substances of a similar nature.

Comment on this

Will the Minister say whether rubber flooring would be included?

Comment on this

Rubber flooring would be dutiable.

Comment on this

I am not quite clear about cork floor covering. Is that under the exclusion or is it not?

Comment on this

In my opinion it would be covered by the term "substances of a nature kindred to oilcloth or linoleum."

Comment on this

In the case of cocoanut matting you can run into a very serious position in connection with it. It can be used for floor covering, but it can be used for other purposes as well. It is used, for instance, to cover the ordinary spring board, and one would hardly call a spring board a floor. It is also used on golf tees and one would hardly call a golf tee a floor. I am anxious to know if cocoanut matting used for these purposes would be subject to duty, and how you can differentiate and know for what purpose it is being brought in?

Comment on this

I think the benefit of the doubt will have to be given in favour of its being imported for the purpose of covering floors. In connection with Reference No. 34 —"manufactured articles which are made wholly or mainly of brass, tin or lead," etc. — it may help to shorten discussion if I announce that it is intended to alter this duty to some extent. It is proposed, at any rate, to divide it into three parts. So far as lead is concerned, the duty will apply only to lead pipes and lead sheets.

Comment on this

And to lead pipes and to lead sheets only?

Comment on this

Yes. So far as tin is concerned, it will apply to a specified list of articles of tin, and in the case of brass goods it is proposed to prepare a list of the articles that are to be excluded. I had hoped to have an amendment ready for the Report Stage of the Resolutions, but owing to pressure of work in the draftsman's office it was not completed in time. This matter, however, will be dealt with in the Finance Bill. Arrangements are being made with the Revenue Commissioners by which the modifications will be brought into force at once so that no inconvenience will be caused. In any case, we are arranging for the publication as early as possible of the duty in the form in which we intend to apply it in the future, so that importers and merchants will know exactly where they stand. In the meantime, if duty should be collected it will become repayable on the making of the amendment. We also intend to take power in the Finance Bill to permit importation under licence, free of duty, of certain articles of these materials which are used by manufacturers in the process of manufacture. There are some articles of that nature, the importation of which is very small in quantity, and if a duty were to be collected on them it might be a considerable inconvenience to manufacturers. It is not possible to provide against every such possibility and to enumerate all these articles. Therefore, it is proposed to take this licence power which will enable us to secure that manufacturers will not be impeded by the holding up of small articles of brass, tin or lead required by them in the process of manufacture.

Comment on this

Is the Minister satisfied that in introducing his amendment in that form the interests respecting which I have put down an amendment will not be involved?

Comment on this

If the Deputy is referring to scientific instruments, the answer is "No." There, as in the case of brass, it is proposed to bring in a specified list of articles that are to be excluded.

Comment on this

It would, I suggest, be impossible to deal with the point that I raised in that way. Very many of them are only made to order as the occasion arises, and very often they are made completely of brass. I suggest to the Minister that he should consider some general proviso, somewhat on the lines of the one that he has just referred to dealing with other articles, allowing the Revenue Commissioners to admit articles of a type required for scientific, medical or surgical work either on licence or definitely excluding them from the tariff.

Comment on this

It is intended that surgical, scientific or optical appliances or apparatus will be excluded.

Comment on this

I think that making the publication the Minister has referred to is a better way of dealing with this than that outlined under Reference No. 34. The Minister has stated that lead sheets and lead pipes are dutiable. I would like to know if lead bends and lead traps are dutiable.

Comment on this

I take it that what the Deputy is referring to are types of pipes.

Comment on this

They are definite specified articles. I do not think that you could describe them as pipes, although a bend might be described as a pipe and a trap as a pipe. I would like to know into which category the Minister is putting the two items I refer to? Perhaps he would prefer not to answer at this stage.

Comment on this

I will look into the matter, but it is intended that lead pipes and lead sheets of all kinds will be subject to duty. In fact, there is not a very large importation of these things. They are mainly made here, but there is some importation of them which it is intended to stop.

[An Ceann Comhairle resumed the Chair.]

Comment on this

I take it that the Minister knows what a lead trap is? Is that intended to be dutiable?

Comment on this

I will look into that. I will have to be clear about it.

Comment on this

The reason I ask the question is because that article is not made in this country. In connection with tin, the Minister's proposal to enumerate certain articles is. I think, a good one. It is also proposed in the case of brass to enumerate certain things that are dutiable.

Comment on this

There was considerable difficulty in doing that in the case of brass. In fact the decision at the moment is that instead of enumerating the articles that are taxed we are going to take the reverse course: to enumerate the things that are not dutiable.

Comment on this

While that is satisfactory so far as lead and tin are concerned, I would press on the Minister not to abandon the idea of enumerating the list of brass articles. The number of brass articles made in this country is not very great, and as the House knows, brass enters into a variety of goods. It is present in all sorts of things, in articles in which the Minister would never guess it is used. It is used so extensively that it is not fully realised until the unfortunate importer gets up against the question. I hope the Minister will not abandon his idea of making a list of brass articles.

Comment on this

When the Minister is preparing his list of brass articles to be excluded I hope he will not forget the component parts of corsets and their suspenders. A great portion of these goods is made of brass. The Minister may not be aware of that. I am quite serious in putting forward this suggestion. We have a corset industry here — the Twilfit Corset industry — as the Minister is aware. As the law stands at present the component parts of corsets, brass or steel, are subject to duty, and I am quite sure that it was not the Minister's intention that they should be subject to duty. Therefore, when he is preparing his list excluding articles made of brass I hope he will include the articles I refer to — the component parts of which are of brass and steel.

Comment on this

In any case, there will be definite power to license in that case. That would be a minor article required by a manufacturer for the process of manufacture.

Comment on this

A Deputy has handed me this article for the information of the House. This is a portion of the corset to which I refer.

Comment on this

Where did the Deputy get that?

Comment on this

From the manufacturer, I presume. This corset industry is a big industry in which there are 200 employees, and it is certainly beyond a joke. Half of the component parts of corsets come under the heading of manufactured articles of brass and steel, and I am quite sure it is not the intention of the Minister to put a tariff on them. The textile parts are not dutiable, and I am sure the Minister will include the other parts in his list of articles that will not be subject to tax.

Comment on this

There is no duty on articles of steel at all. The duty applies only in the case of brass, tin and lead. However, it is intended to modify this duty in the way I have indicated, and I hope soon to be able to circulate the modified proposals to Deputies.

Comment on this

I take it that it will not be necessary to put down a specific amendment to exclude these articles, on the Finance Bill?

Comment on this

Might I join with Deputy Dockrell in suggesting to the Minister that he should adopt, in respect of brass, the course he proposes to adopt in respect of the other metals, for the simple reason that it is perfectly astonishing where brass will turn up in almost every trade, in all sorts of combinations, such as boot buttons, buckles, tags of laces, and in all sorts of odd places, which the Minister, I have no doubt, has no desire to bring within the scope of the tariff? If he segregates the particular products of the Irish brass industry, he can very easily schedule them and, at a later date, add to the Schedule, if it should become necessary, by special legislation.

Comment on this

Does the Minister propose to exclude from the duty what are known to the trade as leads and brasses in newspaper production?

Comment on this

There is one important matter to which I would like to draw the Minister's attention. This tariff will cover machine parts. There are parts of machines which it is absolutely essential to get as quickly as possible, because a factory or workshop is held up until those parts are obtained, and it might mean the stoppage of some hundreds of workpeople. Some means will have to be found whereby these parts can be got through quickly. At present, what is done is that the manufacturer, who has all the models for these particular parts, sends them, in many cases, by passenger train, so as to expedite delivery, and what will now happen, under this proposal, is that they will be held up in the Customs, and we who are in business, know that once a matter gets into the hands of the Customs authorities, it takes some little time to get it out.

I have to deal, at the moment, with a number of commodities, and it may surprise the Minister to hear that some of these commodities, which are excluded from duty, are held up. That is the extraordinary position in which we find business at the moment. If a factory is not to be held up for want of some small minor items of brass work, in connection with machines, it will be necessary to devise some means of getting these parts through and avoiding this delay at the Customs. Some permit can be given, which can be accompanied by a docket, or something of that kind, whereby expedition will be ensured. in regard to obtaining these articles quickly, and avoiding a long stop or a stoppage of some days, which is very material to some of these factories. I would suggest to the Minister that attention might be given to that matter arising out of this particular tariff.

Comment on this

Would ordinary drawn brass wire be regarded as manufactured brass for the purpose of the duty?

Comment on this

Might I ask the Minister if it is his intention to exclude from the duty manufactured tins?

Comment on this

It has been put to me by one merchant that a tariff on these particular articles will have a very bad effect. As a matter of fact, it has been put to me, that he would have to go out of that line of business if the tariff was imposed. This particular merchant has, this year, given a number of these tins free to the farmers, for the purpose of establishing trade, and he informs me that if he is prohibited from buying the tins, he will not be able to carry on his business. I would ask the Minister to look into this application I make on behalf of this merchant and to see his way to remit this tax.

Comment on this

I received representations, on behalf of a merchant in Limerick, for the exclusion of ordinary tins required in the packing industry, and, in support of that application, it was stated that the manufactured tins could be imported cheaper than the raw materials. I had investigations made and I find that that is completely incorrect. There is a very large number of firms in this country engaged in industries which involve packing in tins of one kind and another, and, in the majority of cases, these firms engage in the manufacture of their own tins, and when I approached a number of those best competent to pronounce on the matter, with the statement that it was possible to import the manufactured tins cheaper than the raw material, they told me it was nonsense, and stated that, if that were so, they would not be making the tins themselves. They were all making their own tins, and they found it more economical to make them than to import them. In any case, there is a number of firms in the country engaged in the commercial manufacture of these tins, and there is no reason whatever why we should not be able to meet all our requirements in them. There are certain exclusions that must be made. There are one or two special types of tins required in particular industries, and we propose to take power to exclude these, but the ordinary commercial tin required for packing peas or vegetables or polishes or anything of that kind can be made here and made cheaper than they can be imported.

Comment on this

This particular merchant I have in mind informed me — and he is prepared to substantiate his statement by facts and figures — that he is in a position to buy the manufactured article cheaper than he could buy the raw material, and I would ask the Minister would he reconsider his attitude, if this man definitely proves his statements?

Comment on this

Undoubtedly. If he proves them, I will be very interested.

Comment on this

In the case of highly specialised patent machinery, of which about two-thirds of machinery parts are not brass, but which has a small attachment of brass, would it come under the duty?

Comment on this

No; the duty applies at present to articles wholly, or mainly, of brass, but I have mentioned that we propose to modify that duty to make sure that there will be no misunderstanding as to the articles we intend to make subject to the tax.

Comment on this

Previously, in connection with the wooden articles tariff, I raised a point about devotional objects, religious emblems and so on, and I think a promise was given that these would be released immediately, where they were held up in the customs.

Comment on this

I promised to look into the matter.

Comment on this

I want to find out whether it is proposed, in any of these lists that were to be furnished to us, to include such things as religious medals, such as those spoken of here, and certain additions to crucifixes and fonts, sometimes made of the metal described — is it proposed to have a comprehensive exclusion of religious articles or to exclude a certain type of small religious trinkets which at the moment is being held up in considerable quantities. These were purchased in considerable quantities for immediate purposes, and if there is not a decision on this matter within the next few days, it will be too late, and will be no use at all. I refer to articles such as medals, brooches, rings, etc., made of metal such as here described, and I suggest that it would be wise to have the exclusion in regard to such articles implemented at once.

Comment on this

As far as medals are concerned, the majority are, in fact, not subject to duty, and we are considering how far we can exempt the others. As far as articles made of wood are concerned, having gone into the matter, I would be very slow to exclude such articles from the duty because I find that there are three firms in Dublin alone engaged in the manufacture and sale of these things, and they are, in fact, subject to competition of a rather peculiar kind from the Continent. They will possibly find that the suggested duty will be a very great advantage to them in the developing of the business and maintaining their grip upon it. The duty on woodwork in this respect has a very definite protective effect, and while I do not like to give the impression that a definite decision has been come to, we will have to be very careful as to the articles we exclude.

Comment on this

I may have misunderstood what was said on the last occasion, but I thought that the articles were not intended to be brought within the woodwork tax. At the moment, however, I am talking of the metal side, and I do hope that whatever decision is come to, in regard to the exclusion of certain religious emblems of a metal type, will be speeded up so as to enable these things to be cleared, because if it is not done within the next few days it will be no use.

Comment on this

The Minister referred to two or three firms manufacturing certain religious objects. For his own guidance I would suggest that he refer to one firm that makes rosaries, for which industry Deputy McGilligan got protection from this Dáil. I would be interested if the Minister would apply to that firm, engaged in the manufacture of rosary beads, and ask them what relation their prices bear to-day to the prices when Deputy McGilligan got protection, and he will find that in many other things, as soon as protection descended on the industry and a decent interval elapsed, full advantage was taken of the protection.

Comment on this

I want a point cleared up. A contractor to the County Council who supplies sheep dip has been held up for the want of iron drums, which the customs authorities are withholding. Are these drums being held up because they have brass outlets? Are they subject to a duty?

Comment on this

The tax has been mentioned by Deputy Dillon. I want to make the position quite clear on that. I did not give that protection, but the Tariff Commission did. The report, having regard to the condition in which the industry found itself, was brought before the House and accepted with certain recommendations of the Tariff Commission, which recommendations have not been adhered to. I have heard certain similar statements in regard to that industry made publicly. My only knowledge of the industry was that they made a further application to me on the basis that the tariff was not sufficient. I suppose they really meant it did not give them a sufficient price.

Comment on this

Will the Minister reply to what I said with regard to machine parts of brass, and what can be done in that connection?

Comment on this

I will have that examined. It is to be understood, of course, that the whole question is at present in a state of flux.

In item 35 it is intended to delete the words "and component parts of such appliances, apparatus, accessories and requisites," which were inserted through a misunderstanding. The duty only applies to the completed articles. The intention is to secure the assembling of these parts here.

Comment on this

I suppose this is a revenue tax?

Comment on this

Oh, no. There is a very large number of golf clubs for instance made here.

Comment on this

Made here?

Comment on this

Well, assembled here.

Comment on this

Oh, yes; but that is different.

Comment on this

In my opinion the Minister is penalising quite considerably and avoidably such institutions as schools, sports and pastimes.

Comment on this

Will the Minister consider the danger of gravely interfering with tourist traffic, and will the Revenue Commissioners instruct the customs men that any appliances carried in the way of personal luggage will not be subject to the tax?

Comment on this

That is so. The Revenue Commissioners will exercise the powers they have always exercised in that respect. Certain dutiable articles taken in by a person for his own use, such as a pack of cards, will not be interfered with, and that would also apply to such things as a camera, a tennis racquet, etc.

Comment on this

Will the Minister assure us that the customs men will be specially instructed not to interfere unduly with tourists. It is extraordinary how a lady when she goes back to England can spread the good news about how the nasty customs men held her up and interfered with her.

Comment on this

Will the Resolution apply to such things as hunting requisites such as saddlery and harness?

Comment on this

Saddlery is excluded. It may be necessary to make that definitely clear. There is, of course, a duty upon manufactured harness of one kind or another, but this duty does not alter, in any way, the duty already imposed on harness.

Comment on this

I have heard the Minister say more or less the same thing several times: that the Revenue Commissioners have power to exempt certain small articles? Why is it necessary to have special provision at the end if there are general regulations covering it? I thought the Minister was tearing a rather big hole in the regulations when he spoke to-day of a person coming in for, say, a month's holiday bringing in, say, 500 cigarettes. Surely there is a limit?

Comment on this

Oh, there is.

Comment on this

Well, will he tell us then how many golf balls would be allow in the case of a golfer coming into this country with a handicap of 18, and playing at a seaside course? What would he call personal use under these circumstances?

Comment on this

There are regulations made in these matters. There is, for instance, a definite number of ounces of tobacco allowed for personal use, or a certain number of cigarettes. I take it that the number of golf balls will also be regulated.

Comment on this

What is the regulation in regard to the number of plates or films that may be allowed in?

Comment on this

I am afraid I could not say.

Comment on this

Would the Minister consider sympathetically the question of requisites for boys' and girls' school games or requisites used in school pastimes? It is a very serious question.

Comment on this

I should like if the Minister would give us some idea of the amount of revenue he hopes to get from this tax. Personally, I am against any sort of tax or tariff in connection with outdoor games because I consider it is a tax on the health of our people. This is a tariff on our school-going boys and girls. I think it deprives us of the good name that we enjoyed as sporting people, to put a tax on these articles. If the Minister could give us some idea of the amount of revenue which he hopes to derive from this tax it would be very interesting.

Comment on this

I cannot give that information, but it seems to me that this duty is intended to have a protective value. It will be a protective duty and at the same time, will bring in a certain amount of revenue.

Comment on this

We are now allowing in such things as the heads of golf-clubs so as to allow of their being assembled here?

Comment on this

The item in the Schedule enumerates appliances, apparatus, accessories and requisites for sports, games, gymnastics and athletics other than personal clothing and wearing apparel. Does the description "requisites for sports" change the meaning of the term "wearing apparel"?

Comment on this

It is proposed in another Bill, the Finance Customs No. 2 Bill, to remedy that old standing grievance by taking out of the definition of wearing apparel "sports requisites." Certain sports requisites such as boxing gloves and cricket pads were heretofore regarded as wearing apparel and were subject to the apparel duty. It is now intended to make clear that they are not to be regarded as wearing apparel and to make them subject to this duty which is the smaller duty.

Comment on this

Will that apply to sports clothing such as tennis whites?

Comment on this

Oh, no.

Comment on this

I should like to suggest that the tariff should be retained on these articles. I suggest that they be put back in the original category in view of the inducement that this offers to a special class of farmers represented by Deputy Gorey to leave their fields and go cricketing. I would make an appeal to the Minister to increase the duty.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Deputy is not in order in suggesting increased taxation at this stage.

Comment on this

Might I suggest to the Minister that equipment for hunters might be examined from that point of view?

Comment on this

Would the Minister say that the lesser duty will apply to such things as pads or are they exempt altogether?

Comment on this

Oh, no. Sports goods that were hitherto regarded as wearing apparel will now be subject to this duty, but will not be subject to the much higher duty imposed on wearing apparel.

Comment on this

They will not be subject to duty at all?

Comment on this

They will be subject to the duty on sports requisites. In regard to item 36 it is intended to exclude certain binding material.

Comment on this

I would suggest that fishing nets be excluded.

Comment on this

They are excluded. In one or two cases I received a report from Donegal that the Customs officers collected duties on nets imported. That was an error and the duty has been repaid.

Comment on this

I should like to bring to the Minister's notice the fact that there is a number of fishermen on the Donegal coast who catch salmon and who get their nets from fish merchants in England. They are supposed to pay for their nets out of their catches. They have not the money to pay the duty on them and in some cases the nets have been held up. I wrote to the Minister and he said he would look into the matter. I should be obliged if their dispatch could be expedited.

Comment on this

I shall look into that.

Comment on this

Would the Minister say that the necessary material for mending nets would not be tariffed? It would inflict much hardship on fishermen along the Cork coast if they had to pay for the material for mending their nets. The Minister must be aware that these men are not able to pay the duty.

Comment on this

A Deputy has referred to net twine. Is that excluded?

Comment on this

The duty is imposed on ropes and twine, or hemp, or like materials. Does that include shoemakers' hemp?

Comment on this

There are one or two classes which are used by manufacturers and shoemakers and brush-makers and it is intended to exclude these from the duty. There are three firms engaged in the manufacture of ropes in this country. At one time, it was quite a substantial industry here. It has recently declined, due not merely to competition but also to the decline in the use of ropes for one reason or another. There is, however, a fairly substantial import and there are possibilities of reviving the industry to a substantial extent. There are three firms engaged in the industry at the moment and there are others who propose to engage in it. There is no reason why we should not be able to supply our requirements in all classes of cordage and ropes.

Comment on this

What is the percentage supplied by the home manufacturers?

Comment on this

It is less than 50 per cent.

Comment on this

It used to be only 20 per cent.

Comment on this

Is all shoemaker's twine excluded?

Comment on this

Might I draw the Minister's attention to the fact that this is one industry in which the people who are going to be hit hardest are people inside Ireland but outside the Free State? I imagine from my experience of the rope industry that the bulk of our rope comes from Northern Ireland. I think that it is a pity as we shall never have in the Twenty-Six Counties rope works such as are to be found in Armagh and Belfast. You may smash some of the rope works in the North of Ireland, and as I do not despair of seeing a united Ireland some day I think it is a great pity to destroy these industries if you have no prospect of building up industries here.

Comment on this

This was a very substantial industry in Dublin and in other parts of the country at one time. Waterford is a case in point. It has been very badly hit. In fact, there is only one firm of any substance left in the industry in Dublin. There is also a firm in Waterford and a firm in Clara which makes jute twine. The production of the home industry in 1929 was only 25 per cent. of the requirements of the country and about one-third of the value of the imports. The existing firms are entitled to get some encouragement to increase their production. The duty is a very small one. It is designed to give encouragement to the industry in the hope of getting it going again. Discussions have taken place with one firm in the Six-County area which is contemplating establishing a factory here, but I cannot say how far these have gone at the moment. The design is to encourage this industry here.

Comment on this

Allowing that this is an industry which at one time might have been substantial in relation to what it is now, that was a time when rope was in much greater use than now. Even with what would be called a substantial trade in relation to what it is now, it was never very substantial in relation to the Belfast industry.

Comment on this

There was a substantial export trade from Dublin at one time.

Comment on this

It was a very long time ago.

Comment on this

Irish rope was indigenous to the northern province.

Comment on this

I should like to draw the Minister's attention to the very serious impediment that is likely to result to the fishing industry if impositions are placed upon this class of rope. In the salmon fishing industry special kinds of rope are required and, unless they can be obtained the fishermen may not be able to carry on. In order to do so they will have to pay the tax, whether they like it or not, if they want to obtain a class of rope which is not manufactured in this country. I have something to do with the salmon fishing industry, so far as starting schemes goes, and I have to import a particular class of rope from Bridgeport because it is suitable to the industry. No such rope is manufactured here. The Bridgeport rope is superior to that manufactured in Belfast. I draw the Minister's attention to the need for leniency in this matter until an industry is definitely established. I am in sympathy with the establishment of the rope-making industry. If requirements can be had here nothing will please me better. To place an imposition on an article of this description will, I think, result in hardship on a very poor class of people. Efforts have been made to establish the fishing industry, particularly by the Sea Fisheries Association, and unless care is taken serious loss will be caused to poor people. I respectfully ask the Minister not to impose this tax until an industry is established here.

Comment on this