We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

Financial Resolution No. 26—General—Report (Resumed).

Contributions 429–626 of 626. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 3 parts.

Is item 37 intended to be by way of an addition to hosiery?

Comment on this

Yes. As the Deputy is possibly aware, there is a certain class of tubular knitted fabric imported, and there is considerable danger to an industry which might develop here. It is to prevent the genuine hosiery industry being damaged by what would be a sewing industry of that kind, as well as to give protection to this industry in the production of the other class of knitted fabric, that the duty is prescribed in that form. There are two firms engaged now in the knitted fabric industry and a third firm is installing machinery to engage in it. It will take some time before that is done. In the meantime it is desirable that we should not hold up certain firms importing this knitted fabric which cannot at the moment get the particular fabric they require made here, or made in sufficient quantities. Consequently we have this licence arrangement which is designed to secure that in future all the requirements in knitted fabric will be manufactured in this country.

Comment on this

As regards Resolution No. 8, the newspaper and periodical tax has been brought down to something more reasonable than it stood at, but there are still a big number of papers coming under the impact of the tariff, and that will cause considerable inconvenience and hardship. As far as it is possible to understand it there are mainly two changes made in the Resolution. There has been a change allowing for a rebate on returns, and the simpler point — one of value — a reduction of the duty from 1½d. to 1d. and the preferential rate from 1d. to ¾d. Outside of that we have what is put down in the amendment. That excludes daily papers, and also newspapers and periodicals "which are in the opinion of the Revenue Commissioners, trade or craft, or trade union, or scientific, or religious, or educational publications". The difficulty is to discover what is intended to be hit by the tax. Apparently it is intended to bring periodicals to a point that is somewhat comparable with the fiction point to which the book tax has been brought. Under the new situation with regard to books the only books taxed are books of fiction in English, or books in English printed here and sent out to be bound, or books whether printed here or not that come in bound in leather. You have something now approaching the fiction point, and with considerable further exceptions which make it difficult to understand why the tax is kept at all. We are having excluded daily newspapers, irrespective of size, and we also exclude newspapers and periodicals of these peculiar types "trade or craft, or trade union, or scientific, or religious, or educational publications". The whole point is going to turn on the interpretation given to what is "educational", and the same difficulty comes up in the interpretation likely to be given to the word "scientific". A religious periodical will mark itself. To a certain extent the trade or craft papers will mark themselves. What is an educational paper? A more rigid interpretation would be a periodical which has in it only items which refer to some part of the science of education. I do not presume that is what is meant. I hope that is not what is meant, and that there will be something more liberal in the way of interpretation than that. If one sets out from that and takes periodicals which would be of use only to teachers, that is a clear cut thing. Supposing one sets out from that, what is the definition? What is the interpretation likely to be given to the definition? Almost every periodical has some educational value, even the scrappy sort of periodicals that come in such as "Pearson's Weekly,""Answers" and "Tit-Bits." They set out to give information and are presumed to be of educational value. Sometimes they set out to give information which is alleged to have scientific value. They give certain facts which they say are of value to people with a scientific turn of mind. Are these things going to be brought in under the exclusion clause and, if so, what is the tax now intended to get and what type of paper? I have heard this argument since the amendment came in. It was pointed out that possibly one thing that would come under the tax would be certain journals which circulate almost entirely amongst, and are read by, womenfolk. I have heard the ingenious argument put forward that they can be brought within the exclusion clause as craft papers. There are articles in these publications which are of definite value, even from the educational point of view. If they are going to go, I do not see what the tax is going to catch. If I could get some information on the point, by way of a concrete illustration, as to the types of periodicals that will be caught, it would be much easier to discuss this matter. If I thought that a liberal interpretation would be given to the words "educational" and "scientific" I feel that the tax is almost definitely wiped out, but I am not altogether clear on the point. I am anxious to know what would be caught by a more rigid interpretation.

Comment on this

I do not think that the exemption will be interpreted — I hope it will not — with undue liberality. I do not think that any person can have any difficulty in apprehending what is going to be covered by the designation "trade" or "craft." They are journals the subject matter of which appertains entirely to one craft or one trade or another. For instance, an engineering review would be a trade or craft or scientific journal. It would possibly contain features as a result of which if might be allocated to one or other of these categories. I do not think that the Deputy has any doubt in his mind as to what would be covered by the category "religious." With regard to educational, it is not intended there to confine the exemption solely to journals used merely by teachers or by those concerned only with the science of pedagogy. The type of journal in mind in that connection is a journal which is concerned with the teaching of stenography or shorthand. A concrete instance which possibly might help the Deputy is a journal published from week to week in relation to shorthand —"Pitman's System of Shorthand." I do not think that a series such as these, popular educational works which come out in weekly parts connected say with engineering in various forms—I do not think that they could be described as periodicals. They would come definitely under the heading of "books printed outside Saorstát Eireann and bound in paper covers."

With regard to women's journals, unless these were mainly devoted to women's crafts such as needlework or dressmaking, I think that they should not be exempt from duty. Works like "Vogue" and publications of that sort would, I imagine, be liable to duty, because I do not think that they mainly relate to trades or crafts. A gardening magazine, like "The Amateur Gardener" I am afraid, would be liable to duty. If they were designed or intended mainly for professional use, then I think, they would be excluded under the category "trade or craft." But in connection with the duty, if there is good reason shown for the extension of the exemption to gardening magazines it would be considered. But at the same time I am quite certain that if the demand for these magazines is sufficiently large, we shall be able to produce them in this country, so as to give a certain amount of employment to our writers and our printers, and that consequently they should not be exempted.

Comment on this

May I ask the Minister are the weekly religious newspapers subject to the tax as against the Sunday Press coming into this country?

Comment on this

They are religious periodicals and they would be exempt now.

Comment on this

I wish to draw the Minister's attention to a class of journal which might be within the exemptions, which I think ought to be within the exemptions, which are probably intended to be, but whose position is not free from doubt. I refer to the legal weekly journals which are coming into this country and which are of very considerable educational value. They are educational publications and are of use to the profession and others. I would suggest that the Minister should put it beyond doubt that such journals come under the word "educational," if there is any doubt about it. It would also be contended that they are trade or craft papers and they may come within that designation. I do not use the terms in any unpleasant sense. I am sure that the Minister intended to exempt these weekly journals which are of the very greatest importance to both branches of our profession and of very great advantage to law students. If a tax is put upon them it will make them still less frequently found in this country. The more publications of that sort that come into the country, the better it is for the profession, for the students, and for the public.

Comment on this

I think there is no doubt that the legal journals are exempted.

Comment on this

Under what head?

Comment on this

Craft or educational.

Comment on this

I should like to have a pronouncement from the Minister upon the subject of such publications as "Weldon's Own Journal" and "Weldon's Bazaar for Children," and quite a number of similar two-penny papers. I certainly think that they would come under the head both of trade journals and of educational journals. Most of them contain no fiction whatever. There are paper patterns given away with them and they are used largely not alone by dressmakers but by thrifty housewives. I am not referring to such publications as "Vogue" and "Modern." I mean those dealing exclusively with the trade, the dressmaking trade, and with the making of garments both for women and children. Some of them such as "The Bazaar" have features for children and contain most useful reading matter and paper patterns. I should be sorry if the Minister would put a tariff on these publications, and thus exclude them not only from those engaged in the dressmaking business but from thrifty housewives as well. They are used throughout the Saorstát, and I do not think that there are any journals published in this country that would perform the same purpose. I should like a pronouncement from the Minister on this matter.

Comment on this

I am sure Deputy Mrs. Collins-O'Driscoll will recognise that I am rather at a disadvantage in discussing this aspect of the tax, because, after all, these publications are only names to me. But I gather that these publications are used very largely by professional dressmakers for the purpose of their business, and speaking, of course with every reservation and subject to the determination of the Revenue Commissioners, I think that they would be exempt from the tax if it is proved that they are used mainly or almost entirely by professional dressmakers for the purpose of their business.

Comment on this

I do not know if the Minister has been approached on the subject of this tariff by the people who are most hit by it. If he has been approached at all he must have heard a great deal more about it than I have. But I can tell him that in my constituency the hardship arising out of this tariff is really distressing. As the Minister no doubt knows a very large number of defenceless people, old ladies, delicate people with pensions, have set up stationery shops in my constituency. Well, of course, all Donegal is close to the Border and these small stationers have been obliged to increase their prices for the periodicals that they have been in the habit of getting in regularly for their subscribers. These subscribers are now buying them across the Border and thus these small stationers are being put out of business. Would the Minister say whether this is a revenue tariff or a protective tariff?

Comment on this

A protective tariff.

Comment on this

To protect what?

Comment on this

The printing industry.

Comment on this

I cannot see how it will. I quite see how very desirable a thing it is to stimulate Irish publications and Irish literature, but can the Minister honestly feel that he is not inflicting a heavy injury on that section of the population who, in my opinion, is far more deserving of sympathy than the labouring class? These are the people largely who are trying to keep up a quality for which I have reverence and admiration but for which there is a good deal of scorn in the world to-day and that is, respectability. These people are trying to make ends meet. Their custom has been taken away from them. Their customers are writing abroad for these books and publications or they are going across the Border to purchase them. In Dáil Eireann perhaps that sounds a triviality, but there are many small houses in this country in which a great tragedy has been caused by these tariffs on books and papers. Many of the people who conduct these stationers' shops are being placed on the list of the very poor, though these people hitherto prided themselves that they were not a burden on anybody.

That is the aspect of the situation that I put to the Minister. They have made some attempt, I believe, to bring their case before him, but as the Minister will readily understand, the great bulk of these people have nobody to speak for them. They are not very articulate; they have not the gift of expressing themselves and very many of them do not want to pretend that it makes as much difference to them as it really does. I have already communicated with the Minister on this matter. Because of the enormous burden of work with which he is faced I have been reluctant to pour any additional correspondence on him. I could, however, send the Minister the bulk of communications I have received from a number of people who are suffering through this tariff. If the Minister were to look through this correspondence he would see the minor tragedies of a large number of people. In the matter of newspapers and periodicals I think it is extremely difficult to interpret what is "scientific," or "religious," or "educational." I am not trying to be facetious, or trying to make points against the Minister. Deputy Wolfe drew attention to publications dealing with the law. There are a number of political journals that are highly educational and very valuable. I think it would be very difficult to deny that political reviews are educational. If one looks at the religious papers we have "The Church Times," which is a Protestant paper; "The Universe," which is a Catholic paper, and a number of Church papers of that kind primarily designed for consumption by members of one particular religious persuasion. Will it include these papers? The general tone of these is concerned with religious matters. I cordially join with Deputy Mrs. Collins-O'Driscoll in urging on the Minister the necessity for letting in dressmakers' papers, because they are a vital necessity to all dressmakers in the country, and Deputy Mrs. Collins-O'Driscoll will agree with me in saying that these people could not carry on their business without these pattern papers, which are essential to them. They are trade journals which are essential to many people in this country. Reference No. 6 deals with books printed outside this country. I do not suggest that those who pay 9d. for a book would object to pay 10d. instead, but it would seem hard that these books should be taxed. I cannot help lamenting that Ernest Benn's enterprise in making literature cheaply available to the public should suffer.

Comment on this

The point to which I drew attention at first has been further elucidated to some small extent in the direction of causing more confusion, which I hope will be the result, because it may help to get this tax entirely removed. We were told by the Minister that "educational" publications are not going to be interpreted in that precise way. Very good. Then there is to be some wider meaning or extension than that. Yet I did gather that the Minister thought that legal journals or periodicals would come in not under the heading of "educational" but under the heading of "craft," and still he excepted engineering from the exceptions; one must infer that it would be a thing that would be taxed.

Comment on this

No.

Comment on this

Why? There is a journal called "Practical Electrical Engineering."

Comment on this

That will come in.

Comment on this

Will that be exempt?

Comment on this

I want to make it clear that I am not interpreting this Bill and am not the final arbiter.

Comment on this

I object entirely to that point of view. It will not do to say hereafter that we have passed financial legislation here and that there is a body to interpret it. We ought to know at the moment what it is intended to tax. Is it intended to tax "Practical Electrical Engineering" which comes into this country every Friday? Is that intended to be taxed?

Comment on this

Is that an engineering work published in weekly parts and when 52 of these parts have been issued the publication is complete?

Comment on this

So far as I know it is of that type, a weekly educational engineering paper. There is a paper called "The Nursing Times." It is a journal of educational value for those in the profession.

Comment on this

Is that not under craft?

Comment on this

That is the nature of it. Others of those journals, such as "The Tailor and Cutter," will show by their terms that they are journals that should be exempt. Then there are such papers as "Our Dogs," a paper of tremendous value to people who keep dogs. Is that to be exempt? I think Deputy Dillon has referred to certain political journals as of value. What about "The Statist" and "The Economist"? These journals are of tremendous educational value. Are they to be taxed? They have hardly got to the point when they are called scientific.

Comment on this

Nor are they educational.

Comment on this

They do lead to the point that they are an advance on financial and economic thought. There is no person of average intellect who would not say about them that they are of educational value.

Comment on this

Are they educational in their general character?

Comment on this

We must get somewhere. According to the Minister, education is not to be interpreted so strictly as to be defined merely as bearing on the science of pedagogy. We would like something approaching a definition of the term. Does it come to the point that it will mean that some papers on engineering can be brought in?

Comment on this

"Practical Electrical Engineering," which the Deputy has referred to — could that be described as a periodical?

Comment on this

Undoubtedly.

Comment on this

Why?

Comment on this

From the trade point of view, it is not described as anything else.

Comment on this

If it is a periodical there is no difficulty about it. It is an educational work and will be exempt. If it is not a periodical, in so far as it is not the intention of the publishers to bring it out at stated intervals from year to year, then quite clearly it is not covered by this duty, but it may be by another duty.

Comment on this

"Practical Electrical Engineering" comes into this country on the Friday of every week. I think it is a weekly. Therefore, it is a periodical.

Comment on this

It may be a work published in instalments.

Comment on this

It is not a book, in fact.

Comment on this

It may be.

Comment on this

Let us leave it, then. There is a paper called "Wireless," which has nothing to do with the announcement of radio programmes, or if it has, it is a minor section of it. It is for the use of the rather expert type of amateur in fitting up sets or enlarging or adding to sets. Is that scientific? Is it educational?

Comment on this

It may be both.

Comment on this

I imagine it could be caught by both terms, yet I was amazed to hear the Minister when he was speaking on this line. He said a book called "Engineering" was not going to be exempt.

Comment on this

I said the "Engineering Review" was exempt.

Comment on this

Let us take the book on gardening to which Deputy Mrs. Collins-O'Driscoll referred. Are there any books that come in relating to gardening that are not of educational value? There are many people interested in that particular type of outdoor occupation. Where does the term stop? We want to know what the Revenue Commissioners are to have by way of terms of reference. It may avoid many references to possible misinterpretations later on. I shall try to get at some definition by the process of exclusion. It seems to me what is intended to be caught by the tax are purely children's papers and, if that is so, it is rather a scandalous thing. I have in mind these little coloured prints that children buy and for which there is no substitute in this country; I doubt if there ever is going to be a substitute for them. They are not tremendously attractive themselves.

Comment on this

Can the Deputy think of no other papers?

Comment on this

I am thinking of racing papers and periodicals. They will probably be caught. When that is known there will be a bigger outcry than the Minister possibly imagines. Then there are papers of the society type. It does not matter very much to anybody whether those papers are taxed, because they are of the type that the people who buy them can afford the little extra. From the point of view of the revenue to be derived from them they will certainly not be lucrative. It is merely a case of causing inconvenience without having any protective effect from the angle of getting papers of that type established here.

In the fourth category we find women's journals. We have got certain exceptions at least envisaged. Certain women's papers which are wholly or mainly of use to dressmakers, whether professional or amateur — they will, I hope, be exempt. How many women's journals do not include paper patterns, do not make them a regular feature of the publication? If it is merely a question of paper patterns, I doubt if any of the smaller women's journals are going to be caught by this at all. It will be necessary to get these things examined in much more detail. I think it is fairly clear that children's papers are going to be hit, that the racing papers are going to be hit— although there are people who say that they have a highly educational value — and that society journals will be hit.

There are numbers of papers dealing with animals. Quite a number of people are dog fanciers and there are many who are very interested in birds. You can go down the whole list of domestic animals and you will find books relating practically to them all. I do not know whether it is intended to catch these. I am not quarrelling about definitions, because we do not know what is intended to be caught within the scope of this tax. It seems to me that this thing is brought down to the point where there is going to be very little in the way of revenue and I cannot see any reasonable claim that there is going to be the slightest possibility of substitute journals being established here; in other words, that there is going to be a protective effect.

I have never been able to understand why it was thought necessary to impose this tax without having some touch with the people interested in the trade. There could not have been any question of forestalling. In the case of a weekly there might be a week's supply, and in the case of a monthly a month's supply, delivered in advance, but that would not set back the revenue considerably. The changing and chopping has caused a lot of inconvenience. I think the trade should have been consulted. The only explanation is that this was taken in a scattered sort of way and thrown in with a lot of other things.

There is another matter that is causing confusion. For the purpose of making discriminations, I understand certificates of origin have been demanded. They certainly were in the beginning. Most of these papers bear the certificate of origin on their front page. The place of publication is indicated. On the Continental ones, I think it is universal. At the beginning it was not the practice to accept the designation on the front page as indicating where the publication came from. If that is cleared by now, another advance has been made.

Comment on this

I would like the Minister to give some indication of the protective effect that he anticipates will result from this tariff. In reply to a question as to whether or not this was meant to be a revenue tariff, the Minister said it was meant to be protective. It is extremely hard to see what employment can possibly follow from this tariff. Numbers of these periodicals are imported in small quantities. I saw a return prepared by some trade organisation which indicated that on the average, out of a very large number of papers habitually imported to Dun Laoghaire, 200 or 300 of each issue would be all that came in. It is quite impossible in the case of the vast majority of them that substitutes could be established or carried on here. If the circulation of these papers is cut down, it can scarcely follow that the circulation of any paper that is in existence here or that may come into existence will be increased. If, for instance, the society papers referred to by Deputy McGilligan have their circulation reduced, it does not follow that very small substitutes here will have an increased circulation. I scarcely think it will affect them at all. People who want the bigger and more ornate publications will probably pay for them. Those who are not willing to pay are not very likely to be satisfied with the very much smaller journal it is possible to run here. So far as papers like The Economist and The Statist which were mentioned are concerned, if to any extent their circulation is discouraged, it does not mean that any journal existing here is going to have a larger circulation. If you put a tax on any of the papers mentioned you may get a little revenue. The revenue certainly will not be of a very large amount. If the Government had been wanting either revenue or employment on any substantial scale, the main periodicals that are exempt should not have been exempt. After all, so far as the importation of periodical literature is concerned the daily papers are the main thing. It is quite possible that if there had been a tax at this rate on the daily papers quite a lot of citizens might have been driven to reading the Irish Press who ordinarily do not read it, and the Government would have been killing several birds with that particular stone. But, with the tax as it is, it looks as if simply this was happening: that having, without consideration put this duty on, the Government were obstinately clinging to some remnant of it; that they were behaving in this matter exactly as they are behaving in connection with the book tax, where they have practically retreated from the position they took up, but maintaining a hopeless sort of tax on certain classes of books in order to be able to say that their great tariff policy is intact. So far as newspapers and periodicals are concerned, they seem to be doing something of the same sort. These exemptions that are being given in respect of trade, craft, and educational periodicals will result in so many borderline cases, and so many complaints arising, that the need for further exemptions will become so apparent that I should say this particular tax will ultimately break down and have to be abandoned.

I think some member of the Government has boasted that if they found they had made an error they were not too proud and were not too frightened to confess that an error had been made and to make a change. I would think that this is one of the particular taxes where they ought to confess they had blundered and that they ought simply to abandon it. The discrimination that will be required to be exercised by the revenue authorities will cause trouble and annoyance, and from that point of view I think it is clear that this is not worth persisting with. There is no revenue in it to any extent, and there is no employment in it. It is not going to have any effect on public opinion. If one wants to enable national feelings to take a better tone, that is not going to happen as a result of this. If you want to affect public opinion or national sentiment, then you will need to exclude the daily papers. In this case the Government certainly seem to be straining at the gnat and swallowing the camel. Even as regards children's papers, I think there is nothing to be said for merely trying to make papers dearer or to cut them off. There would be a good deal to be said, and later on the Government may have to take certain steps, in regard to papers in Irish, especially papers of various classes suitable for children, very young children and children a little older. But, whatever may be done in regard to these papers, it will have to be done in a direct way. No purpose is going to be served in that direction by a mere tax on the papers which will be hit by this particular tax.

Comment on this

I should like to reinforce the remarks made by Deputy Blythe. I think this tax is a mistake. I agree that in its present form it is a great improvement on the form in which it was presented first. A tax on papers and on books is equivalent to a tax on light. The Government has denounced certain things as medieval. If ever there was a medieval step it is this. It is simply bringing back the stamp tax, which the English publicists had such difficulty in getting removed. There had to be a crusade to get freedom of the Press. As this is an improvement on the form in which it was first presented I hope the Minister is going to interpret the word "educational" in a very wide and generous sense, so as to include the papers to which Deputy Blythe alluded. Children's papers are most important. They are most educational. I think there is something petty and cruel in putting a preposterously heavy tax on small papers like children's papers and other papers. A child is just as much interested in the adventures of "Tiger Tim" as the Minister himself. I have had strong protests from my young friends that they have to pay an extra penny for their penny papers. I hope the Minister will see his way to modify the tariff, so that it will bear some relation to the cost of the paper. It is rather absurd that a tax of 100 per cent. should be put on a little paper of this sort. I would, of course, if I could, like to persuade the Minister to wash out the tax altogether. I think you will effect nothing from a cultural point of view and gain very little from a revenue point of view by this tax, and you will succeed in irritating every class of the community. I make a very strong appeal on behalf of the children. Also from an educational point of view, those smaller magazines which teach our wives how to cook a good dinner or sew on a button, are very necessary and I think they should come under the exception of educational.

Comment on this

I should like to join in the appeal to the Minister to drop this tax altogether. I do not think it is going to have any useful effect, and I doubt if it will pay the cost of administration. There is just one aspect of it which occurs to me. The vocational schools all over the country are developing a genuine interest in various handicrafts that have not been much practised heretofore, at all events have not had the very considerable following which they will have as a result of these vocational schools. Most of the pupils in these schools, if they are to profit by the instruction given, have to follow up the literature attached to the subject. There is no literature, generally speaking, in this country dealing with many of them, and it is doubtful if there will be until we have a bigger population. There will, undoubtedly, be hardships caused to many people who are not in a position to pay more for journals from which they get great educational experience. For instance, in connection with motor transport, I think there are up to half a dozen journals that can be called partly trade journals and partly general. If they are dubbed general and are taxable, it is largely ambitious mechanics, who are anxious to know all about their own business, who will have to pay the tax. I do not think the Minister desires to tax such a class. I can see hardly any business or trade in the country in which the employees would not be affected to their detriment by this tax. It may mean that they may miss ideas with regard to their vocation that would be very valuable to them. I can conceive many difficulties resulting from the tax. It will have hardly much effect, I think, in keeping out undesirable papers. Those who value undesirable publications will probably be content to pay a higher price for them, and I doubt if the money that is, perhaps, foolishly and thoughtlessly spent upon a lot of journals of a rather anaemic type, and which represent rather futile reading to the general public, will be more wisely spent if these journals cease to circulate here. On the whole, there are so many flaws in this proposal and it will cause so much dissatisfaction in its administration that I suggest to the Minister that he should consider if he would not be well advised in removing it altogether.

Comment on this

I am very glad that Deputy Moore has forestalled me, because I am inclined to think that the Minister will pay very much more attention to the remarks of Deputy Moore than any remarks that I might make upon this subject. I should like to support very strongly the statement that Deputy Moore has made. I put it to the Minister that the number of periodicals which will be affected, in view of the modifications he has made, will be very few, and that the collection of the tax will cost the State very much more in revenue than is likely to accrue as a result of the duty. We must bear in mind that any undesirable publications are kept out under the Censorship of Publications Act, I agree with Deputy Moore that most of the periodicals coming into the country are of some value, and in many cases of very great value to employees in different occupations in this country, and are of particular value to pupils attending vocational schools. I put it, also, to the Minister that so far as the majority, if not all, of these journals are concerned this is not a protective tariff. There is no possibility, I think, of producing, in this country, any substitute for these periodicals that we are now proposing to tax. In the first place, the circulation, if confined to this country, would be very small, so small indeed that it would be utterly impossible for us to get the contributions of the best brains or to pay the price that is paid at the moment, in order to get experts to contribute to these journals. That is a point that I certainly would put to the Minister and I think he will realise the force of it. Many of these journals imported here and sold at a comparatively low price are very useful, and particularly from the domestic point of view are valuable, because of the fact that the contributors are experts. These experts can only be commissioned to write various articles because of the very large circulation that these journals have.

But there is another aspect of the matter. The circulation of these journals gives a considerable amount of employment in this country. There are many people in this country particularly in the cities dependent altogether for their livelihood on the sales of these journals or they go a long way to help them to earn a livelihood. I am sure the Minister has had some representations made to him before now on this matter. A number of cases have been put to me of very great hardship that would be inflicted, not only on the readers of the journals, but on the distributors of the journals, if the Minister insists upon this tax. I submit that when we consider the number of journals that will get through the strainer between the Censorship of Publications Act and modifications he has now introduced this tax is worth nothing. I strongly support the suggestion made by Deputy Moore that the Minister should drop the tax altogether.

The Minister for Industry and Commerce, speaking in this House about a fortnight ago, said they were not going to be as unreasonable as the late Government, and he went on to say that if a good case could be made they were prepared to drop the tax. If we could show them, he said, that they were making a mistake they would be prepared to admit it. They were not going to stand on their dignity. I think, in this particular case, the Minister ought not to stand upon his dignity. I cannot hope that he is satisfied with anything I have said, but I hope he will find that his colleague, Deputy Moore, has made what I consider to be a very good case and that he will, at least, consider the matter seriously. I certainly urge that he should drop the tax altogether. I do not think it is going to do any good from the point of view of revenue or protection. I am certain it will not. As I know how the Minister and his colleagues have always, one by one, stated that they are anxious to get the youth of the country on their side, I warn the Minister that this tax will undo all his propaganda for the last ten years. Even at a cost of undoing that propaganda I am still advocating the abolition of the tax, because I know that nothing the Minister could possibly do would have a worse effect, from his point of view, upon the youth of the country than if he insists upon this tax.

I do not know whether the Minister is a married man. I presume from his Budget he must be. If he is, and, like many of the other married men in this House, has been asked for an extra penny or three-halfpence for every penny he was asked for before the Budget in respect of children's papers, that in itself might have some effect upon him, but I say, in view of the modifications such as have been put into the Schedule and the effect of the operations of the Censorship of Publications Act, it is not worth while going on with this tax, and I suggest it should be dropped.

Comment on this

I should like to add one or two words to the strong case made by Deputy Moore and Deputy Morrissey against this tax. I think it is possible that you might have one or two papers started in view of a tax like this, but I am convinced with Deputy Morrissey that to run them for a time satisfactorily and successfully would be quite impossible with the small circulation that they would get here. I wonder has the Minister any figures to show him how small would be the number of papers that would be affected by giving the modifications he has promised. I wonder has the Minister realised how many small shopkeepers throughout the country are really making their living out of the sale of these weekly papers. I wonder does the Minister realise what a serious thing is the delay in the distribution of these weekly periodicals that used to come in with the morning mail, and which were distributed through the country by the trains. That is now going to be exchanged for a period of slow getting through the customs, which will lead to these papers reaching their destination days after the time when they used to reach them. The trouble of administration that is going to arise from these daily newspapers is going to be a most serious thing in connection with this tax. Lastly—and I think the point is of very considerable importance—I wonder has the Minister realised what kind of reaction is going to follow this type of tax? I cannot vouch for the truth of the statement, but it has been made to me on what I would take to be fairly satisfactory authority, that this tax has been followed by the withdrawal from these papers which are published in the Free State of English advertisements on a wholesale scale, so that all that is going to come to these papers from the confinement of sale to them is almost, if not quite, neutralised by the revenue loss they are suffering as a result of the withdrawal of these advertisements. Putting all these considerations to the tail of what has been said by Deputies Moore and Morrissey, I hope the Minister will seriously consider whether it is worth while going through with this tax or not.

Comment on this

In reading through this list of exceptions, I notice that scientific or religious or educational publications are excluded. That word "scientific" may, of course, be used in various senses, but I take it that the Minister means applied science purely, physical science, so to speak. I would point out, however, that there is a considerable number of what I will call technical publications which, so far as I can see, would not come in under this word "scientific." For instance, medical journals like the "Lancet" would seemingly be liable to duty. I cannot see any reason why that should be. Then you have legal publications, like the English "Law Times," and various other English or foreign weekly papers, dealing with legal subjects, which could not be published in this country. For instance, I will take what I know something about —the Irish "Law Times." That is a very excellent paper, published in this country, but the English "Law Times," or the American, or various other legal publications which come in here, are not, in the slightest degree, in rivalry with the Irish "Law Times," and I cannot see why the importation of these legal publications should be taxed. I cannot see what good it will do.

Again, this word "periodical" is very wide. Take, for instance, the English law reports, which it is necessary for Irish practising barristers to have, and which must certainly be in all libraries. They are published in monthly parts, and I take it that whatever is published in a monthly part is a periodical, and, as such, will be liable to this tax. I will seriously ask the Minister to consider these classes of papers, which cannot conceivably be said to be rivals of papers published in this country. They are completely different from the papers published in this country. Then, again, if you take the ordinary English, French or other reviews which are periodicals, and which come in—they are published weekly, fortnightly, monthly or quarterly, and all these are subject to tax, and yet they are not in the slightest degree in rivalry with any paper that is published, or could be published in this country. I am sure that if the Minister himself reads such periodicals as, let me say, "The Nineteenth Century Review," or the "Fortnightly Review," he does not read them for a certain thing in one of the publications, but because he sees, here and there, an article written by a particular person that interests him. He does not read the whole "Fortnightly" through, but he reads it because there is an article in it by some person whose writing interests him, and because that person will not be writing an article on that particular subject in any weekly, monthly or quarterly which is published in this country.

I cannot see how it would be a help to any quarterly that is published in this country that other quarterlies should be excluded. I cannot, for instance, see that it would be the slightest help to the circulation of "Studies" that the "Dublin Review" should be subjected to duty. I cannot see the sense of putting a duty on high class literary papers. If you do put the duty on, I do not suppose that you will kill their circulation to any extent. I grant you completely that, on a 2/6 periodical, the fact that you are going to pay ¾d. extra will probably not hit its circulation in the slightest, but it is an annoying tax, and it is the principle that lies behind it that must be considered. It is the putting on of a tax on knowledge that appears to me to be a very bad principle, and there is no compensating gain that I can see.

Comment on this

I would like to ask the Minister, if this tax is going to stand, what is going to be the position of provincial importers of these periodicals? Are they to employ a staff in Dublin or Cork, or at the importing port, to deal with the acceptance of a parcel from the customs authorities there? In what way does he expect that provincial periodical importers are going to deal with the position at the ports? It has also been found in respect of a certain number of publications, not so very long ago, that the people issuing these publications made a definite campaign through the country, with a view to getting people in certain areas to take their papers by post from Great Britain, so much so, I understand, that some of the organised newsagents had to deal with the matter in an organised way, and approach some of the publishers or distributors in Great Britain with a view to getting that practice stopped.

If, without any tax here, it was a paying matter for newspaper people in Great Britain to carry on a campaign like that, the position under this is likely to be that persons who want to continue to get certain journals will be induced to get them by post from either the agents or publishers in Great Britain. The general effect of this tax will be to put a certain type of newsagent completely out of business. Already, some of them have pointed out that their sales have been reduced by from fifty to seventy-five per cent., and that reduces their general working margin. In most of these cases the business that is carried on is a kind of composite business, such as a tobacconist selling sweets, stationery and other items, and the loss of clientele for newspapers, or for these periodicals, is going to mean a loss in some of the other branches of their trade. I appreciate the fact that the Minister has, on his own benches, Deputies who are definitely out against this tax, and I think that a consideration of the position, in which a particular type of newsagent finds himself, is going to persuade him that this tax ought to be done away with. As a revenue tax, it is not worth having, and as a tax itself it is going to injure a fairly widespread section of the people.

Comment on this

I think it is no harm to get quite clear the purpose which the imposition of this duty is intended to serve. This country is probably unique in the world, in its situation, in so far as we are a small people, adjacent to a much larger and wealthier nation, and speaking, for the most part, the same language. Because of that fact, almost the entire weekly, monthly and quarterly Press of this country has been imported. Because of the fact that we are adjacent to another country speaking the same language, there has been a continuous flood of foreign periodicals into this country, and any possibility of developing a series of Irish periodicals, representative of our people, and serving the needs of our people, has been stifled. The effect of that, I think, has been nationally bad, and if the effect of this duty were to stop in part that flood of foreign periodicals, I think it would be all to the good. It is not going to do that, but it is going to slow it up, to some extent, and make it possible for native periodicals to take the place of those now being imported. In so far as that takes place, a very definite national gain would have been registered. I do not think it will take place to any substantial extent.

There is no reason whatever why the bulk of the periodicals which are being imported cannot be printed here. When the tax was first imposed certain approaches were made to my Department by people interested in the publication of these periodicals. I think, in respect of quite a number of them, a very definite move to have them printed here would have been started by now were it not for the continuous statements that appeared and reappeared in the Press, that the tax was likely to be removed at some date in the near future. The position is that if anybody with journalistic leanings in this country desires to get an opportunity of developing his talents in that respect, he is practically compelled to go abroad at the present time. There are only a few weekly periodicals published here and these few are having a very hard fight to carry on. It is hoped and intended that, as the result of this duty, a number of new publications may start. Some move has already been made in that direction. It is true that in order to give effect to the intention behind this duty periodicals are being made subject to the tax that are not likely to be substituted by any periodicals produced here. I do not think that that is a thing to be regretted. It is true that very informative and interesting reviews and journals of one kind and another will have to pay duty, but most of these are sold at substantial prices, and the increase in the prices of a 1d. or 1½d. will not retard their sales or impose any hardship on readers. Reference has been made to children's newspapers. It is true that there is a fairly considerable sale of these newspapers in this country and that some of them are of a type not likely to be produced here. Cumann na nGaedheal have stepped into the breach to take the place of some of them in recent weeks, though it may have been an entirely unintentional action on their part. However, to some extent the idea has been met by what they did. The position is, however, that it is nationally desirable that the influx of these foreign journals should be checked in some way. We can get on here and get on quite successfully without "Answers," without "John Bull," and without "Ideas."

Comment on this

And without the "Daily Mail."

Comment on this

Is the Deputy arguing in favour of the extension of the duty?

Comment on this

I am not allowed of course to advocate it but I say I cannot see the Minister's argument if he will not apply it to the "Daily Mail," the "Daily Express" and the rest of them.

Comment on this

If I propose it will the Deputy support me?

Comment on this

Certainly, as regards, the "Daily Mail."

Comment on this

I will hold the Deputy perhaps to it.

Comment on this

Why not be clear and name the things you want to keep out?

Comment on this

We have excluded from this duty a series of certain types of journals. Most of the journals that will be excluded under this Resolution are journals of small circulation in this country. Journals with a circulation of 10,000 upwards are not excluded. It is not unreasonable to ask that they should be printed here. They can be printed here without any substantial increase in cost and without any inconvenience. We have printing works and printers and all the facilities for producing them here in the country. We are putting it up to these journals that if they want circulation in this country they should at least give that amount of employment to our people.

Comment on this

How many weeklies are there with a circulation of half that figure?

Comment on this

There is quite a substantial number with double that.

Comment on this

I am informed that there are 16 with a circulation of half that.

Comment on this

We know that there is a large range of these journals with a circulation of 20,000 and upwards in this country.

Comment on this

Nonsense.

Comment on this

"Answers."

Comment on this

A large number!

Comment on this

A fairly large number.

Comment on this

"Answers" is one.

Comment on this

I am afraid that I cannot give a complete list of them but there is a substantial number of them with a fairly large circulation.

Comment on this

With a circulation of 20,000?

Comment on this

I am not saying that. I am saying that those with a circulation of 10,000 upwards at least should be printed here. I think we are doing no harm in restricting them.

Comment on this

Is it on account of their quality?

Comment on this

Not on account of their quality, but on account of the fact that they are foreign products and because there should be some opportunity given for the development of Irish periodicals to supply the needs of the people.

Comment on this

Why not apply that to the English daily papers? What is the case?

Comment on this

I do not see that there is any strong case against it but we have decided to start with certain periodicals.

Comment on this

The Minister has argued for employment. The dailies will give more employment than the weeklies.

Comment on this

Are you sure of that?

Comment on this

I want the Minister to make the case.

Comment on this

The Deputy is making the case. I am not proposing to apply it to the dailies.

Comment on this

Why?

Comment on this

Because I am not at all sure that it is going to mean increased employment.

Comment on this

I suggest that it is not a tariff that is wanted but an extension of the Censorship of Publications Act.

Comment on this

Evidently it is a cultural aim, although the Minister for Finance told us it was an economic idea—a revenue matter.

Comment on this

There are two classes of workers whom it is intended to help by this duty, one the printers and the other the journalists. There is certain raw material here. There is an unlimited supply of journalistic talent. We want to give it some chance of developing. It has had no chance up to the present. It has been stifled by this flood of publications. The imposition of this duty is going to give it some chance. Already there are indications to some extent that the needs of our people are going to be met by native publications and native publications of quality, just as good, if not a lot superior, to those that are being imported. Talking of this duty as a tax upon knowledge or culture or anything of that kind is altogether wide of the mark. It is nothing of the kind and it is not intended to be anything of the kind. It is intended to secure for this country some advantages which the keeping out of these things secures for other countries. This nation is perhaps in a unique position. It is beside a much larger and wealthier nation, speaking the same language and the natural thing is to expect that these publications will come in.

Comment on this

What about Switzerland? They import publications in three languages and yet they have a strong nationalism.

Comment on this

I will concede to the Deputy the point as regards Switzerland.

Comment on this

I could name other countries.

Comment on this

The effect upon newsagents if it has any substance at all is likely to be purely temporary. In so far as there is a demand for such publications that demand will be met. It will be met either by native publications or by these English publishing firms coming in and having their journals printed here. I am satisfied that that is the development that is most likely to take place. The majority of newsagents are only dependent to a very small extent upon the sale of weekly journals. In so far as they are newsagents only the daily press must constitute a very large part of their business. The vast majority of them are also tobacconists and some of them are engaged in selling fancy goods as well.

Comment on this

Did the Minister consult them recently on that?

Comment on this

Undoubtedly, the Deputy knows what I am saying is a fact.

Comment on this

I am informed that quite the opposite is the case.

Comment on this

The Deputy cannot pick out one firm in the City of Dublin engaged in the sale of weekly papers only.

Comment on this

I have not said that. They sell fewer morning papers than they do weekly ones.

Comment on this

The vast majority are only newsagents as a side line.

Comment on this

I quite agree. But they are not selling more daily papers than weekly ones.

Comment on this

I cannot speak as to the actual number they sell but the sale of evening and daily papers constitutes a large part of any agent's business. The imposition of this duty is not going to involve a lot of delay in the circulation of such papers. If the undergraduates of Trinity College have to wait until Friday or Saturday for their "Home Notes" it will not entail any great hardship on them. Neither do I think it is likely that English advertisers are going to retaliate by refusing to advertise their goods in this country. They do not advertise in Irish periodicals as a concession to us. They advertise here because they want to sell their goods.

Comment on this

That is not the point. It is a matter of circulation.

Comment on this

If a paper has not got the circulation, it will not get the advertisements. The English firms that advertise in Irish newspapers will advertise only if they are satisfied that they will get a return for their money and because they want to sell their goods. It seems to me that this duty is justified from every point of view. It has a very definite protective effect, not alone in the increased employment of skilled workers, but it is also going to be of definite advantage in creating the possibility of the development of a weekly national press, that will serve the country's needs, not merely in political matters, with which we are already supplied, but other classes of periodicals now supplied from abroad.

Comment on this
Mr. Hayes

The Minister's explanation of this tax, sir, resembles very much what he had to say about books, with one difference. It appears to me that, although the Minister does talk about giving employment to skilled labour, his aim in this matter is really a cultural aim. He spoke of us as a small country side by side with a big country, which has a language which we all speak. I am just as interested as the Minister in the development of the Irish language and of Irish culture, but the difference between us is that I know what I want and I have some clear ideas as to how to get what I want. The Minister, in his enthusiasm for a tax, simply taxed books at first; then he taxed periodicals; then he created confusion; then he made certain exemptions; and then he made a case for the tax when he was finished. Now he comes along to tell us what he meant, which includes not only getting revenue, increasing employment, and the development of industry, but the development of an Irish culture. It seems to me that in this tax on periodicals, which I admit applies mostly to periodicals in the English language, if it was a cultural aim it was a matter for the Minister for Education, and if it was censorship aim it was a matter for the Minister for Justice. If it was a mixture of both, to help the various things being done for the spread of the Irish language and the cultivation of a distinctive national culture here, then the Executive Council should have sat down and done some thinking as to what effect such a tax would have on their general educational and cultural programme. That was not done. Instead of that, they slapped on a tax on periodicals, and for my part I cannot understand why English daily papers, and more particularly a certain type of English Sunday paper, were exempted on cultural grounds. The Minister's point of view is that the English periodicals which we get in stifle local periodicals. It is a matter of doubt, as long as we speak the English language, whether we ought not, in fact, to be cut off from a great many publications printed in England. I would make bold, as a person who knows the Irish language and is very strongly in favour of it, to say that it would be a great pity that we should be cut off from a good deal of what is published in England. If certain publications are bad for us, intellectually or otherwise, we should find out what these are and we should keep them out entirely —not by way of a penny tax. If the Minister is interested in keeping out something that has a bad effect, I suggest it is not through the Minister for Finance or the Revenue Commissioners, but by some other process, that it should be effected.

The more we examine the question the more difficult it is to work it out. I wonder whether the Minister would tell us how the word "religious" is going to be construed? What kind of paper will it include and therefore exclude from the tax? "The Universe," for instance, was taxed in the beginning because its superficial area did not exceed 320 square inches. Now I take it, it will not be taxed because it is regarded as a religious publication. But there are a great many papers which, while being very sound from a religious and moral point of view, might not be considered by the Revenue Commissioners as religious publications. I think it is an absurd burden to place on the Revenue Commissioners to define what is a religious publication. For instance, I get from America what I regard as the finest periodical of its kind printed in English — the "Commonweal"—but I think if I were put to it I could make out a case that it is not a religious paper, although it deals with social, political and other questions from the Catholic viewpoint. It has generally an article on Catholic apologetics, but some weeks it has not. I suggest that it is absurd that such a paper should be taxed; because it is not entirely devotional, it may not be deemed a religious publication.

There is another type of periodical such as publications from England which are devoted entirely or almost entirely to dressmaking and knitting and to the cutting of patterns. I am not speaking with personal knowledge of these but I got a domestic brief on them. It stands to reason that in a country of three millions with a comparatively small urban population we can never produce out of those three millions as great a variety of that kind of periodical as they do in England. The people who buy that kind of paper are the poorer or lower middle class people who want to make clothes for themselves. I take it that the Minister in his great crusade for national uplift would be all for home dressmaking. It would surely please his soul, if not his eye. It just illustrates how difficult it is to frame a tax of this kind at all without becoming foolish and futile.

Some mention was made of "Studies." Take the similar publication in the United States to "Studies"—the paper called "America." This paper I assume will not be either educational, religious, or scientific and it will be taxed. The thing amounts to this, that to keep out a considerable amount of rubbish the Minister imposed a revenue tariff and that means for the people who read such publications a tax upon light and nothing else. One can think of all kinds of publications which are going to be kept out which are very useful—publications which could not possibly be produced here and which the Minister is going to tax. I would suggest that such periodicals and particularly that type of pattern book for dressmaking and the making of children's clothes and so on, should not be taxed but should be encouraged. Such a tax is a tax on home industry.

The Minister mentioned that a number of publications have a circulation of over 20,000. My information, as far as I have been able to get it, is this, that there are coming into the Free State 17 religious publications, 33 technical and trade journals, 17 journals dealing with agriculture and allied topics, 20 racing papers—they will not come under the exemption I am sure— and not more than 16 publications out of the 400 have a sale of more than 5,000 in this country.

Comment on this

That is not right.

Comment on this
Mr. Hayes

It may not be right, but it is the information supplied by the people who profess to know, the wholesalers. This tax, like the book tax, shows that it was imposed without any thought. It created a great deal of confusion amongst people who are carrying on a legitimate business, who are entitled to carry on that business and who are entitled to get due notice if their business is going to be dislocated. There could be no such thing as forestalling in periodicals. The tax having been imposed, the Minister had indicated to him a number of difficulties and the proposals intended to remedy these difficulties only make them worse.

I suggest that the Minister's case, more particularly on the cultural side, is entirely without forethought, that he put the tax on first and then he did some thinking, that then he made the cultural case and that that case is not worth considering. The proper position with regard to periodicals and English publications was this, that if we are going to consider them from the national or cultural point of view, we should get a general idea of what we want and apply a censorship of some kind which would enable us to keep out those we did not want. Simply to apply a revenue tax instead of having the effect of improving us culturally, socially or morally, will have no such effect at all. The whole matter requires reconsideration. The more exemptions recommended to the Minister and the more the Minister yields to the demand for exemptions, the more clear it becomes that the tax in itself is bad and should be withdrawn in its entirety.

Comment on this

Listening to the remarks and the contributions of the Opposition on this particular tax, one is struck by the amount of knowledge that could be acquired by the Opposition if they were really to sit down and examine what this tax really covers. The only speaker that contributed anything that showed that he was either briefed or, as he said himself, knew something about the subject, was the last speaker, Deputy Hayes. People forget themselves when they talk about these papers. They talk, first of all, as if every periodical that came in here was printed by a particular producer and that he looked after his trade here on his own merits. Nobody has said how many periodicals there are, and yet it is very easy to find out. I am informed that there are roughly 370 and that these periodicals are controlled by two big concerns, one of whom, I think, controls somewhere in the neighbourhood of 240 and the other the balance. It has been suggested that this was a tax on light. I do not think even the wholesale agents know the number of periodicals they sell——

Comment on this

They could give you a printed list of them.

Comment on this

We have seen the printed list.

Comment on this

There is not the slightest difficulty in knowing what all this is about.

Comment on this

Take the argument first of all that there is one class of periodical that has a circulation of a certain amount. If it pays them to look after that trade here, it will pay these people, provided they have a certain circulation, to get it produced here. If the circulation is small it will prove that the demand is not so great, and that it will not be a terrible loss if the circulation of that periodical is discontinued, with the exception of religious journals or periodicals which are educational or scientific in their nature. Reference was made to American periodicals printed in the English language. If anybody bought an American periodical here he had to pay a price largely in excess of the American price even before the tax was imposed, and nobody cried out against it. A copy of any publication printed at 5 cents in America, costs 9d here. There can be no hardship in that case. Such papers as the "Literary Digest" and the "Saturday Evening Post" cost 9d. even before England went off the gold standard. If I am wrong in that I would like somebody to correct me. I have paid 9d. for these papers.

Comment on this

How much is 9d. in gold ounces?

Comment on this

We shall come to that a little later. Has anybody grumbled as to why we should be charged 18 cents. for a paper retailed in America at 5 cents? To get back to the periodicals which are taxed; if a certain number of these periodicals have a circulation, and if the people who control them wish to preserve their circulation here, they can very easily pay the tax themselves until such time as they can come over here or get some other people to print them for them here. As regards the smaller publications, whether the circulation is 5,000, 10,000 or 15,000, I understand a great number of them can be turned out here. I shall not give the names of any of them here, but they can be turned out and employment given if there is a demand for them. If there is not a demand, it is not going to be the great hardship on the general population that has been argued here. I do not know whether Deputy Hayes is going to argue that the fact of the 20 racing papers being taxed is a tax on light.

Comment on this
Mr. Hayes

I have never read a racing paper in my life, and I did not refer to a tax on light in that connection. I said that a number of people who read good papers that could not come in under the exemption here, were going to be taxed, and the people who read Sunday papers are not. It is going to be a tax on light for the people who wish to read these papers.

Comment on this

The Deputy did not say it was a tax on light. Is the Deputy going to say that his point of view is the point of view that is to be accepted as to the papers to be allowed in free or exempted from the tax? Might not somebody else have another point of view as to what would be considered light? The man who picks out winners considers that he is being taxed from his point of view. Deputy Hayes might consider that the papers he mentioned should be exempted, but probably the people who read the racing papers think that they should not be taxed. Are we going to argue that this is a case of a tax on light?

Comment on this
Mr. Hayes

It is a tax on loss.

Comment on this

Some of them say that they make good investments in these papers, and that they pick out a lot of winners. These people sell their papers by displaying posters such as "50 winners last week, 60 the week before." I have been approached by wholesale newsagents in my constituency, and they are satisfied that this matter will right itself in the end, and that eventually the greater good will be achieved. There is a lot in what has been said about stopping certain journals from circulating here, but that comes under a different heading, and can be dealt with in a different manner. If Deputy Hayes thinks certain Sunday newspapers are not desirable, he has the means at his disposal of getting rid of them. If he sends to the Minister for Justice a copy of any periodical which he thinks should not be circulated here, it can be dealt with. We have certain gentlemen engaged in reading these papers to see that those which should not be circulated here are not circulated.

There has been a lot of talk about this tax, but not many of those who contributed to the discussion seemed to know what the tax was intended to achieve, eventually, for this country. It is going to put the printing into the hands of people here in the case of a great many of those periodicals which boast of a large circulation here. There are certain other little organs with a small circulation here, and it would not pay to have them printed here. The price to be charged for the amount of literary matter and paper would be too great in comparison with the amount of material, labour and journalistic cost. It is about time that this step was taken and I hope the Minister will stick to his original idea and exempt only such journals as it is desirable to exempt. There are, of course, certain scientific journals which could not be printed here; but, generally speaking, I hope the Minister will stand firm and treat exemptions on their merits.

Comment on this

It is rather hopeless to make any appeal to the Minister for Industry and Commerce on the ground that papers have a literary value. Obviously, the Minister considers that it is bad for people to read any high-class English periodical, that it is bad for our culture to read high-class criticism, by first-class English writers, of books which are written in the English language. When the Minister puts forward an argument of that sort, I am afraid that I so completely fail to follow him that it would be useless for me to make any further appeal on that head. I should like to ask the Minister to deal with a matter I raised before, which he has completely overlooked. That is, the taxation of publications such as legal and medical publications.

Comment on this

In my opinion, they could be held to be trade journals.

Comment on this

I do not think they could. As a matter of fact, the Revenue Commissioners do not treat them as such.

Comment on this

Do they not relate to the science of law?

Comment on this

I do not know whether the Minister is trying to be funny or not. I cannot hear him.

Comment on this

Do they relate to the craft of law?

Comment on this

The Minister for Finance is so taken with his own humour that he has become inaudible. I should like to ask the Minister for Industry and Commerce, who can treat a serious matter seriously, whether he does not consider that publications of a legal, medical, dental and generally scientific nature should be exempt, as also journals dealing with farms, horticulture, and so on. These journals are not in substantial rivalry with any paper published here. They have a limited circulation and should be exempt. If the Minister refuses to do as I suggest, I should like to know why he refuses.

Comment on this

It is intended that legal journals should be exempt. If they cannot be exempted as trade journals, or craft journals, they can, I think, be exempted as trade union journals.

Comment on this

We all appreciate the Minister's humour, but I should like him to be serious on this occasion. As a matter of fact, these journals are being taxed at present. I happen to know that tax was demanded on these journals last week and that the acceptance of them was refused.

Comment on this

Application for exemption must be made. That is, possibly, why they were subjected to duty. It is intended that journals of that kind should be exempted from duty.

Comment on this

There is no statement in the Resolution that application must be made for exemption. Will the Minister give instructions to the Revenue Commissioners that duty is not to be demanded on periodicals of that nature?

Comment on this

Undoubtedly, the journals in question will get out of paying the duty if they come within the terms of the exemption. I am afraid the publishers of the journals will have to show whether a legal newspaper relates to a craft, a trade, or a science. I am quite certain that it is within the scope of legal ingenuity to bring these journals under the heading of "religious," if necessary.

Comment on this

I agree with the remarks made by Deputy Morrissey and I hope he will bring in an amendment to include the Daily Mail and the Daily Express in this tax. Within the last two weeks, the Daily Express dismissed some thirty hands in Cork. The whole lot seem to be acting on a set plan to throw as many on the unemployed market as possible. The number of copies of this paper sold per week in Munster alone is 175,000. Still, they threw all their staff out of employment. I ask the Minister to see that some revenue is got out of these 175,000 copies by placing a tax on them. If they are not going to give employment here, why should they not be taxed? After all, the newspapers produced in this country—I do not care what colour they are, or how dirty a lot of them are, even the United Irishman—give employment in printing here. I ask the Minister to impose a tax on English daily papers in view of their present boycott of Irish labour. Apparently, they have joined the ring for creating unemployment, and they should be made to pay through the nose. Some of the money got from them could be used to provide employment for those whom they disemployed. I suggest, after the argument Deputy Fitzgerald-Kenney put up a little while ago, that they should brief him to make an appeal for them for exemption. We see these English daily papers coming in every day, and we see their definite plan—I do not know whether it is at the instance of the Deputies opposite or not, or whether there is any special association formed for creating unemployment. I do not know which of the two rings is dealing with the question, but, apparently, the “Daily Express” has given way to one of them. I ask the Minister to clap 1½d. on each copy. Let the people who want to read these papers pay for them.

Comment on this

I think Deputy Fitzgerald-Kenney is somewhat wrong in what he has said about legal papers. It is only fair to say that I am a subscriber to an English legal paper, and that it comes to me free of taxation without demand on my part.

Comment on this

By post?

Comment on this

That is the way they will all come soon.

Comment on this

Can they come free by post?

Comment on this

I want to get some information from the Minister in connection with a particular journal. The British Legion—an organisation which is largely benevolent and philanthropic in character—in addition to dealing with social work, advises its members on pension matters, pension warrants and items of that kind. It publishes a journal which has a certain limited circulation in this country. I should like to know from the Minister if that journal will be considered a trade journal, a craft journal, or a trade union journal, having regard to the special character of the structure of this organisation. The admission of the journal is of considerable benefit to the members of the British Legion, many of whom, like other workers, are suffering from the effects of long-continued unemployment.

Comment on this

How would Deputy Norton describe the journal?

Comment on this

It falls into one of these categories because the organisation does a good deal in the way of providing work for its members. In isolated districts particularly, it does some of the work which, in other places, devolves on trade union organisations. I should be glad if the Minister would exempt that journal, having regard to the character of the organisation.

Comment on this

It would be impossible to offer an opinion on the matter without being familiar with the general trend of the contents of the journal. The interpretation of this section rests with the Revenue Commissioners, and it is for those interested to make a case to them. If the journal is within any of the descriptions mentioned, it will be exempted.

Comment on this

Will the Minister say that that is not the kind of journal he desires to tax?

Comment on this

I am not familiar with it.

Comment on this

It is perfectly easy to get the names of all these journals circulating here and to classify them, because you are only dealing with a couple of large wholesalers. There are only four groups, and at present we have a very blurred objective. To assist us, will the Minister undertake, before we come to the Committee Stage of the Finance Bill, to circulate a list showing a sample group of papers that, on cultural and other grounds, ought to be stopped, a group of papers the producers of which would be likely to print an Irish edition here, a group showing the type of periodicals which it would be reasonable to expect would be produced by Irish writers and publishers and printed in the Free State, and, fourthly, a group of publications which we ought to allow in free of tax?

Comment on this

I am afraid I could not undertake to do that.

Comment on this

We do not know where we are going at present. Neither the Revenue Commissioners nor anybody here can help us along the pathway which the Minister thinks he sees in front of him. It will take a group representing the Department of Education, or an inter-departmental group, to look after the situation and see what path is to be mapped out.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

We will deal with Resolution No. 9 now.

Comment on this

I should like to ask the Minister to consider the question of application forms. A number of ex-servicemen's associations, such as Deputy Norton has referred to, deal with relief here. Application forms sent in now to be filled up by certain societies are, in certain cases, taxed. Would the Minister be prepared to exempt these forms?

Comment on this

I understand that the cheapest quality of tea comes from outside the area entitled to the preferential rate. I do not think that it is good business to buy very cheap tea. Other people disagree with that and buy it. I think it was not the intention of the Minister to place a tax of 6d. on the cheapest quality of tea. At all events, it should not have been his intention. Perhaps the Minister would look into the matter before it comes up on the Finance Bill. The tea is from Java.

Comment on this

I want to draw the attention of the Minister to a circumstance to which I drew his attention personally some time ago. Is the exemption provided for in this Resolution?

Comment on this

This only refers to the Customs duty.

Comment on this

Would it not be better to deal with Resolutions 9 and 10 together?

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

We will take the two together.

Comment on this

There is a provision in the Resolution that any person having more than 1,000 lbs. of tea in his possession would become liable to this excise duty retrospectively, and would require to make a return of the actual quantity of tea in his ownership on the 12th May. It is further provided that any person who had less than 1,000 lbs. in his possession should pay nothing by way of retrospective tax. That means that a man who made a return showing that he had on the 12th May 999 lbs. of tea, pays no retrospective tax, while a man who had 1,001 lbs. of tea pays tax on the entire 1,001 lbs. I think I am right in saying that. The Minister subsequently announced that he had resolved to make a concession to the latter class, and that they would not be taxed on the first 500 lbs. of tea, but, if they had more than 1,000 lbs., they would have to pay tax on all over the first 500 lbs.

I want to submit to the Minister that such an arrangement is inequitable. There is an obvious difficulty, and it is obviously the desire of the Minister, in so far as he can, to relieve anybody from retrospective taxation except those who are trying to forestall the duty. I think it is a bad principle for him to introduce that system in taxation at all. I know he follows the practice of the British Government in making taxation retrospective, but that does not improve the principle in any way. I would submit to the Minister that the circumstances prevailing in Dublin and London are different.

London is the great market of the world for tea, and at the time the tax was imposed it became eminently desirable to capture the tea that was awaiting auction in Mincing Lane. No such state of things exists in Dublin, though it is admitted that certain persons attempted to forestall. I also submit that if that retrospective policy had not been adopted the price of tea would not have advanced at all, and the reduction in sugar would have been passed to the consumer. There would have been no necessity to advance the price of tea, because the present stocks could have been replaced by prudent buying and the extra tariff of 4d. per lb. on tea would mean that virtually the same quality of tea would be sold. But where you have tea already purchased for sale at a certain price, and knew there was to be a retrospective duty at 4d. per lb., frequently the tea would be sold at a narrower margin of profit than the excess demanded. The consequence was that it became necessary for every trader to increase his price.

If anyone is going to get 1,000 lbs. of tea free of tax, I submit to the Minister everybody should get it. I cannot see any grounds upon which the Minister can defend allowing a man who has 1,001 lbs. of tea in his possession a remission extending only to 500 lbs. and allowing a remission of 999 lbs. of tea to a man who has that quantity of tea in stock. I do not think it is necessary to elaborate that at very great length, and there is no need to suggest remedial measures; but I do suggest to the Minister that it does not make very much difference to anybody. It is only a question of, say, £10 in round figures to anybody, so that the sum of money in that is not so very much. Then it will create a feeling of dissatisfaction and discontent if this concession is not given, and I think there will be legitimate grounds for asking for it.

Deputy Cosgrave asked the Minister to look into one matter. I would ask him to look into it, too, and to reassure himself that he is not getting a biassed view on that question. There has been a lot of irresponsible talk amongst interested parties about the virtues of Java tea, and we have heard a lot about the cry of the poor and the needy for the delicious beverage that is to be extracted from Java tea. I have no hesitation in saying that it would be difficult to find a more inferior grade of tea than Java tea. I have no hesitation in saying that any competent tea merchant can secure an Indian substitute for Java tea. It may not have in appearance quite as attractive a quality as Java tea, but in true beverage quality it is much superior to Java tea. There is undoubtedly a temptation as far as I know and as far as my experience goes amongst certain merchants to deal exclusively in Java tea, because Java tea selling at 10d. per lb. looks like Assam tea selling at a cost of 1/4 per lb. Assam tea, at the same price as Java, has not the same appearance and will not command in the market as good a price. I am not saying for a moment that other merchants could not put forward a case to the Minister which would induce him to grant the remission Deputy Cosgrave suggested, but I think it would be to the Minister's advantage if he took the opportunity and precaution to see that the experts he consults are not persons who are interested in the promotion and sale of Java tea in this country.

Comment on this

I join with Deputy Dillon in entering my protest against this proposal in connection with the question of the 4d. per lb. retrospective tax on tea on the ground of its being inequitable and unjust. To start with, the trader who is carrying a stock of 1,000 lbs. of tea gets off free of duty, whereas the trader who was carrying a much greater quantity has got to pay duty at 4d. per lb. on the whole quantity. On reconsideration the Minister has retreated from the position he took up at first. He has taken a backward step but it was a backward step in the right direction inasmuch as he has mitigated to some extent the penalty which he inflicted on men from whom he was likely to derive the biggest revenue. The trader who was carrying a large quantity of tea was in the position that his capital was locked up in that stock. He has to carry that stock for a considerable time and he has his money invested there because he is carrying that large stock. The Minister is going to derive from him very much greater advantage in the way of revenue than he is from the other trader. But in this matter of the tax the Minister penalises him from getting on an equal footing with his competitors in the trade. That is an unbusinesslike law. It is fantastic. I certainly would not like to imagine for one moment that any Minister, charged with the grave responsibility of administering affairs such as the Minister for Finance is managing in this House, would act in that way. I would like to be fair, generous and sympathetic, for this reason that the Minister's is a very difficult task and that it is one that requires grave and serious consideration. It is quite evident to me or to anybody that the Minister might be fully justified in saying "well I had not an opportunity and I had not time." If the Minister said that I, for one, would be quite willing to acquit him of any error of judgment or any intention of being unjust. But I think seriously and sincerely that a grave injustice is contemplated. The proposal is unjust to the man from whom the Minister is to derive the greatest revenue.

Under this proposal the Minister is placing a trader at a disadvantage compared with his neighbour who has the advantage of being free from the 4d. tax. Already the Minister has made an adjustment by remitting the 4d. tax on 500 lbs. of tea. The trader who has a quantity greater than 1,000 lbs. in stock has to bear the burden. There is certainly an injustice. There are various reasons why certain traders carry much larger stocks than others. One of the principal reasons is the cost of freight. To secure freight on the best terms a trader will buy a large quantity of tea. That brings him certain advantages, but there are certain disadvantages also, because he has to take that large quantity into stock and he has to pay for it in due time. His capital is locked up in that stock and if he has not the cash he has to go to the bank for an advance with which to discharge his obligations. Very few bankers will be so obliging as to give an overdraft free of interest.

The only place one will get any consideration is when one will be dealing with the Revenue Commissioners. They are always generous. I have no doubt the Minister will be more generous still. On this occasion I will not ask him to be generous, but to be just. I appeal to him to hold the scales evenly between one individual and another. I ask him to be just to himself and to prove that he is capable of taking a clear view of this situation and can be trusted to carry out his obligations as Minister for Finance. I ask him not to inflict injustice on one set of traders and give very great advantage to another. I appeal to the Minister to reconsider this matter. He has already gone 50 per cent. of the way to remedy the position. I ask him to go the other 50 per cent.

Comment on this

I join in supporting the appeal made by Deputy Dillon and supported by Deputy Davis. I admit the Minister has already made a substantial concession to meet the difficulties occasioned by his first proposal. I think he might go the one step further, delete the 500 lbs. and substitute therefor 1,000 lbs. If he does that, he will meet what is manifestly the justice of the case. Deputy Dillon referred rightly to the fact that retrospective fiscal and penal legislation is undesirable where it can be avoided. From opinions expressed by the Minister when he was in the Opposition I think he is not in favour of retrospective penal or fiscal legislation where it can be avoided. I agree that this is the one exception where it might be justified. The Minister is quite right in taking steps by retrospective legislation to anticipate anything in the nature of a gamble on what the Budget was likely to contain.

I respectfully submit that no man will buy the difference between the stocks he has and 1,000 lbs of tea in order to anticipate the Budget. If he buys at all he will buy a great deal more. If a man wanted to anticipate the Budget he would run up to 3,000 lbs. or 5,000 lbs. of tea. I do not complain about this legislation being retrospective. It is on a different basis from the fiscal and penal legislation that was made retrospective by the last Government. The Minister is just as consistent to-day in proposing that this legislation be retrospective as he was in proposing that the legislation introduced by the last Government should not be made retrospective. I recognise the difference. In these cases, where people endeavour to anticipate duty and try to gamble in regard to future duty, I think the Minister is bound to intervene.

The difference in this matter works out at something like £8 6s. 8d. No man, in order to make that amount, would anticipate the Budget. The Minister in this instance might extend the concession to 1,000 lbs. of tea. It is a comparatively small matter. It will not make much difference to the Budget and perhaps it will remove a certain temptation which might otherwise exist. I would not ask the Minister to increase the exemption to an extent that would exempt people who endeavoured to anticipate the Budget. The figure of 1,000 lbs. of tea will not exempt such people. The Minister has already made some effort to remove a manifest injustice from his first proposal. I will ask him to go the whole hog and, in view of the trifling difference, he should exempt the additional 500 lbs. of tea.

Comment on this

Before the Minister replies might I ask, in view of the fact that the agreement is that this Resolution will be passed to-night, and in view of the importance of Resolution No. 14 dealing with the tobacco tax, whether we could not from 10 o'clock pass on to the tobacco tax so as to give the Minister for Industry and Commerce an opportunity of explaining the Resolution?

Comment on this

I think it would be very unfair to limit the discussion on the tobacco tax to half an hour. There will be ample opportunity of discussing it on the Committee Stage of the Finance Bill and possibly on the Second Stage. A large part of Thursday and all day on Friday were devoted to a rambling discussion on superphosphates and a large part of this afternoon was also given over to the same subject. I think it would be exceedingly unfair to discuss the tobacco duty in half an hour in order that Deputy Mulcahy might launch the speech which he has prepared.

Comment on this

I have no speech prepared. I am merely anxious to hear some explanation from the Minister for Industry and Commerce of the proposals submitted here. The Minister can have the whole half hour for the purpose of going through the proposals contained in the Resolution. It is desirable that as much light as possible should be thrown upon the matter, particularly when one takes into consideration that the workers in Gallaher's factory will have their original notices expiring to-morrow. I contend we are meeting the Minister in every possible way. One should take into consideration the number of important items that could be further discussed on this General Resolution, such as the tea tax, the tobacco tax, the corporation profits tax, surtax, the entertainment tax and Hospitals Sweepstakes.

Comment on this

Were they not all discussed on Friday here?

Comment on this

I do not think the Minister can object in any way to the type of discussion that has been on these Resolutions. The matter discussed on Friday was a relatively important matter. That discussion speaks for itself. We have now half an hour before the Dáil rises, and I think that the importance and urgency of this question would suggest that the Minister for Industry and Commerce should take the opportunity of explaining this Resolution.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

Of course, the Chair is in the hands of the House. The Chair cannot instruct Deputies how to proceed.

Comment on this

An agreement on the lines Deputy Mulcahy suggested might have been made if the proposal had been put forward earlier in the evening, when there would have been an adequate opportunity for discussion on this matter. But the Opposition, judging from the manner in which they handled the debate so far, deliberately shut this thing out from discussion. They could have dropped the footy points they were making in regard to the tax on periodicals and come to this, when the Ministers were ready to discuss the matter if the Opposition wanted them.

Comment on this

Are we to understand that the Minister for Industry and Commerce will not take the opportunity to-night to explain the proposal in this Resolution which has not yet been explained because of the way in which the Budget is going through the House?

Comment on this

Again I should like to emphasise that if the Opposition wished to have a prolonged discussion in this matter they had ample opportunity during the last four or five hours to discuss it.

Comment on this

I am not looking for a prolonged discussion on anything. I am looking for an explanation of the terms of this Resolution here.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

Obviously if we are not going to have agreement we are wasting time.

Comment on this

I suggest that it is not a waste of time for any member of this Assembly to raise any question affecting 300 employees.

Comment on this

First of all, there are not 300 concerned.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

I suggest that the Deputy should not try to misrepresent what has been said by the Chair. I said that unless we were about to reach an agreement on the matter raised by Deputy Mulcahy, we were obviously wasting time. The Chair should not be misrepresented.

Comment on this

We have had four days in which this matter might have been discussed in detail and it has not been discussed. The Opposition made no attempt to bring it into discussion until 10 o'clock to-night, when they had Wednesday, Thursday, Friday and to-day to do it.

Comment on this

Does the Minister forget how many Resolutions this House gave him on Thursday with practically no discussion, because he delayed his Resolutions so that it was impossible to have a discussion if he was to have the Resolutions that night?

Comment on this

Because there was no person on the Opposition side competent to make an agreement and keep it.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

This is getting us nowhere.

Comment on this

I should like to support the appeal made by Deputy Wolfe. It certainly looks anomalous that a trader with 1,000 lbs. of tea should be mulcted and that a trader with 999 lbs. should get off. One must draw a limit somewhere, but still there is a good case for exemption. I think the Minister would not be straining the point too far if he were to agree to the suggestion made by Deputy Wolfe. After all, it is rather hard on the man who accidentally had 1,100 lbs. of tea in his possession. If he had sold some of that tea the day before he would be clear of the duty. If the Minister could see his way to agree to this suggestion it would be only fair.

Comment on this

With regard to the point which has been made by Deputy Dillon and, I think, by Deputy Davis, I should like to say a word. Deputy Dillon, I think, went rather further than Deputy Davis, and very much further than Deputy Wolfe. He suggested that there should not have been an excise duty on tea at all. I think that Deputy Dillon must have been unaware of the conditions which existed a short time before the Budget, when there was a very considerable amount of forestalling indeed. The Revenue Commissioners know of importations of tea as large as 100,000 and 200,000 lbs. brought in definitely with the idea of forestalling the customs duty and profiteering. I do not think that any Government is entitled to disregard a fact of that nature and to allow a person to speculate in that way, when speculation can be prevented. I am perfectly certain that because an excise duty has been imposed on this occasion, and because some people have been very badly caught—possibly quite a number of people have gambled and have imported three or four times their normal stock—because fingers have been burned once, we are not likely to have an attempt again to anticipate either a duty upon tea or upon any other essential article of food.

It has been argued that so far as the exemption limit is concerned we are creating anomalies. Admittedly, we created anomalies when the limit was fixed at 1,000 lbs. and we were presumably creating a lesser anomaly when we reduced the limit to 500 lbs. But is there any way in which a tax can be imposed or remissions granted and the creation of anomalies avoided? It does not matter what you do; some lucky individual is going to benefit more than another and some unlucky individual is going to suffer greater loss than others. The reduction of the exemption limit has been argued from the point of view of the man who is fortunate enough to possess or to be able to buy, more than 1,000 lbs. of tea. It was stated originally that it was unfair that he should be charged upon his old stock. Admittedly, there was an element of inequality in that. But, think of the case of the man who has not 1,000 lbs. of tea, but only 100 lbs. of tea. The man who has more than 1,000 lbs. is going to get 500 lbs. of tea duty free, and is going to get what profit he can secure on that. But the man who has only 100 or 200 lbs. of tea, the moment his little stock is exhausted, has immediately to go into the market and pay duty upon the tea which he purchases to replenish his stock. From his point of view is not all the anomaly in the fact that his more fortunate neighbour, who is able to carry a bigger stock, gets off free of duty with 500 lbs. of the stock which he holds? It is because of that that we have decided to take the middle way. We hold that in the case of a man who holds more than 1,000 lbs. if we exempted the first 1,000 lbs. of stock we would do an injustice to the man who held only 100 lbs. We are taking the average figure between the two and granting an exemption to the first 500 lbs. of tea and we say that that on the whole represents the best solution of a very difficult problem in equity. That is why the 500 lbs. was taken. I heard it said here, and I think it was Deputy Dillon who used the argument, that if we had not put an excise duty on tea at all, or if we granted an exemption up to 1,000 lbs. there would be no increase in the price of tea. Does any Deputy for a moment believe that that would be the case? What did the gentleman who brought in 100,000 lbs. of tea bring it in for, or what did the gentleman who brought in 200,000 lbs. of tea bring it in for, except to increase the price the moment the duty was put on, and to take advantage of the 4d. and to put it in his pocket? Even if that was not his intention, it has been represented to me that the smaller traders who carry the smaller stocks, the moment their stocks were exhausted, even if they had refrained from putting the price up in the first instance, would in two or three weeks have had to increase the price of tea. There was no possible way, human nature being what it is, and the facts of the trade being what they are, in which an increase of the price of tea could be prevented. That is the plain and simple fact in regard to the matter. We cannot achieve equality all round. We have to strike a mean, an average. There is going to be advantage on one side of the line and disadvantage on the other. We have to find a middle way, and the middle way between making the man with 1,000 lbs. of tea or over pay the tax upon his full stock or nothing is to take it half way and grant exemption on 500 lbs.

Deputy Cosgrave made a point about Java tea. I was very glad to hear Deputy Dillon put up the counter case to that. I am told that Java tea is very inferior tea and the cheapest class of tea. I am told that possibly most of it might be described as rubbish and dirt and the sweepings of the tea house floors, and that it might not be any harm, from the public health point of view, if we kept out altogether, at least, the very cheapest qualities of it. For that reason there is in regard to Indian tea a substantial inducement contained here in the Resolutions for merchants to import Indian teas direct from the gardens and to blend them here. I have been struck by the fact that no one person has adverted to the advantage which the amendment, introduced in this Resolution on Report Stage, will bring to our home blenders.

The position, hitherto, in regard to the blending industry in this country has been that our blenders were being driven off their own market and that virtually all the tea consumed in this country was being blended elsewhere. The blending industry, at one time, was quite a considerable one, not merely in large cities but in every large town. There was blending going on all over the country. I believe it is possibly the way in which tea best suited to a district can be got. Although I do not know much about the tea industry, I am told the blend must be suited to the water of the district. I am informed that hundreds of people were engaged in this industry until the last twenty years or so and that the industry, as a whole, has declined, particularly since the advent of the cheap package teas which are blended and made up in Great Britain. In the attempt to revive the industry here it will be noted that the amendment introduced into Resolution No. 9 provides that the 4d. rate of duty shall apply only to teas which have not undergone any blending operation outside the country of origin, and, so far as the present intention of the Government is concerned, the 4d. rate will be applied mainly to Commonwealth teas, that is to say, mainly to Indian and Ceylon teas. The cheaper Java type to which Deputy Dillon referred will be excluded from the benefit of the preference.

[An Ceann Comhairle resumed the Chair.]

I have not a closed mind upon the matter. If it can be shown to me that this clamour for the cheaper rate on Java tea is not a ramp for the benefit of a few people who specialise in that particular type of tea I shall be prepared to consider whether I will grant the low rate of duty on all teas imported direct from the gardens, that is to say, in the words of the Resolution, on all teas that have not undergone any process of blending outside the country of origin. I have an open mind upon it. I have not sought the advice of any person as to whether the Java tea should come under the 4d. or 6d. rate. The original intention was to apply the principle of Imperial preference. We are not wedded to that principle in regard to tea. We have given effect to it in regard to virtually every other commodity, but if impartial people whom I can regard as disinterested will come to me and make a good case for applying the preferential rate to Java tea or any cheap tea I shall be prepared to consider it.

But we are not at the present moment disposed to yield to clamour which I believe is not disinterested. I would like if Deputy Cosgrave or those who are asking that the 4d. rate should be applied to Java tea will give some reasons why the 4d. rate should be applied to that commodity. Up to the present I have not heard a single reason for it. They have not put forward a single argument to back up their contentions, but we have heard here from a Deputy, who, I think, is competent to speak on the matter, very strong and very cogent reasons why the 4d. rate should not be applied to that particular brand of tea.

Comment on this

In view of the lateness of the hour, and of the fact that this Resolution is to be taken to-night, I suppose I may deal with the subject matter of Resolution No. 14?

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Might I interrupt the discussion on this point—can I assume there is agreement to give a first reading to the Finance Bill, 1932, now?

Comment on this

There will be no difficulty about taking the first reading of the Finance Bill.

Comment on this

Will you divide on the Resolution?

Comment on this

No. We have already divided on the general Resolution on Committee Stage. The Minister is pressing so much on the matter of time that we want to cut down as many divisions as we possibly can. There are many of these Resolutions against which we would have divided very definitely last Thursday, but it would simply take time from discussion. I want to ask, in connection with Resolution 14, whether the Minister has anything to say that will alleviate in any way the position of anxiety felt with regard to Gallaher's factory in Dublin. If I might call it so, the Resolution is a half-baked Resolution, that is supposed to enshrine a policy, and, arising out of the discussions that have taken place, the discussions which I understand the Minister has had with the directors of the firm, and with some of the labour bodies, I would ask him if he has anything to say that would in any way alleviate the position. I would point out in connection with this Resolution that it is very difficult for anyone not in a responsible position to understand what may or may not be the effect of it. For instance, the President to-day is, on behalf of the nation, discussing certain important matters with the representatives of another nation. Section 3 of this Resolution provides that there shall be certain discrimination in favour of a manufacturer of tobacco, who, on 1st April, 1922, was and has been continuously since that date a licensed manufacturer of tobacco carrying on business as such manufacturer in Saorstát Eireann, and whose business as such manufacturer is shown to the satisfaction of the Revenue Commissioners to be in the beneficial ownership of an individual who is an Irish-born resident. If the President were in the position of being a beneficial owner of the factory that is most benefiting under this discrimination, the factory would not be entitled to the discrimination. That is a fact and that is why I call——

Comment on this

Is that what the Deputy wanted to bring out?

Comment on this

That is why I call this a half-baked Resolution. Some explanation is wanted of the policy behind this, particularly in view of the fact that whether Messrs. Gallaher do close down their factory from to-morrow or not, they are in the difficult circumstances, that the Minister understands, that they have notified their employees of the possibility of their closing down to-morrow.

Comment on this

Paragraph 3 of the Resolution is designed to save the native manufacturers owning factories established here for over 100 years from extinction in this present year. That is the purpose of it and nothing else— not to differentiate against anybody, not to drive anybody out of business, but to ensure that the ten native manufacturers, many of them established here since the year 1800, will be kept in existence. They were dying and they were decaying under the policy of the last Government.

Comment on this

Nonsense.

Comment on this

The former Minister for Industry and Commerce got up here, and in one of the most pitiful speeches ever listened to on these benches, threw up his hands and said he could not protect those——

Comment on this

When was that?

Comment on this

——against the inroads and encroachments and pressure of their wealthier competitors.

Comment on this

When was that?

Comment on this

When Deputy Dr. O'Higgins——

Comment on this

Will the Minister explain that he is doing that, because it is an important thing?

Comment on this

Yes, I am doing it. The point about it is that the native manufacturers are prepared to take into their industry virtually anybody who will be unemployed under this Resolution.

Comment on this

Rubbish.

Comment on this

Deputy McGilligan says "Rubbish." When Deputy Dr. O'Higgins got up, prompted by Deputy McGilligan, twelve months or eighteen months ago, and pleaded the case of the Irish manufacturers who would not be allowed to show their Irish goods in Irish shop windows, what remedy had Deputy McGilligan then to offer? None. He turned tail, and flew away.

Comment on this

Not at all.

Comment on this

Because Deputy McGilligan would not stand up to anybody, but this Government is going to stand up to this, and is going to say that, so far as we are concerned, Irish factories which have been established here for over 100 years, whose products are known the world over, and who have given continuous employment to our people, are going to get the chance, not merely to live, but to flourish and expand in this country.

Comment on this

Under 7d. extra?

Comment on this