We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

Finance (Customs Duties) (No. 2) Bill, 1932—Committee Stage (Resumed).

Contributions 1–122 of 238. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

Bill Finance (Customs Duties)(No. 2) Bill, 1932
Enacted

No. 10 of 1932 ›

Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Amendment No. 12 is out of order. It proposes to delete an operative section.

Comment on this

I move amendment 13:

In sub-section (1), line 45, to delete the word "fifty" and substitute therefor the words "twenty-two and one-half."

I regret very much that amendment 12 is being ruled out of order because it more clearly expresses our minds than amendment 13 does.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

If the amendment is out of order the Deputy cannot discuss it now.

Comment on this

Except to make a case for the other.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

On the section?

Comment on this

Yes. Although amendment 13 admits the principle inasmuch as it proposes to reduce the percentage from 50 to 22½, I still believe that there should be no imposition at all on spades and shovels, for there is no justification for it. Above all the items in the whole of the tariff Schedule this one is perhaps the least justifiable. I have here a list of the British and other imports of spades and shovels coming into the country. There is no occasion to go back very far. In 1927 the value of imports of spades and shovels from Great Britain amounted to £7,895. From Northern Ireland the imports were £3,739. This was slightly varied in 1928. In 1929 they varied considerably, to the extent that Northern Ireland came very far up in the list and Great Britain went down. More extraordinary still, in 1930 Great Britain in or about maintained its position, and Northern Ireland again went down, practically to the lowest point. We have not been able to get from the Minister what is the Irish output during any of these years, or in what favour the Irish product is held. We understand that there are two or three firms which have been named in the House, and it is hoped that one other firm, at least, will resume production. I made a statement in the House here on a previous occasion about my experience of some of these Irish tools. It was not a pleasure to me to have to state it, but in the interests of efficiency I thought it my duty to say it, and I have since had corroboration of that experience by two or three other users to whom I talked about these articles some time ago, or certainly before the firms went out of production.

This class of tool, above all others, is the tool in respect of which the public are least educated. In regard to the other machinery and tools coming into the country, you have the different designs exhibited at the Spring Show here and one is comparable with another. When a good article is produced, manufacturers get more alive, and start to produce something like it, but that is not so at all with these smaller tools. We did see one set of small tools, the saw-edged tools, produced by Irish firms, and they were really good tools. Some of their lines are as good as anything on the market, but they have the advantage that people can see this line, and it is educative, not only to the users, but to the manufacturers. We have never had anything like that with regard to the other tools, and, certainly, we have not had anything like it with regard to spades and shovels, and I think it is the Minister's duty, if he wants to bring Irish products up to date, to make an order that these implements should be exhibited at the Spring Show, or have some means by which buyers can come to a decision. This is important, and some opportunity should be given of making a comparison in regard to design, quality and price. We have not got that, and you have as a result to take their word for it.

I have seen some of these implements in use in parts of the country, through the instrumentality of a particular trader, and I, or a working man, would not work with them, and I would not ask the working man to work with them. That might seem strange, but it is so, and I speak as an expert. I made use of the phrase yesterday that a method of comparison was one of the best things the Minister could have in relation to design, price and quality, but, if this tariff is put at 50 per cent., the Minister obviously intends definitely to wipe out anything in the way of competition and comparison. That is inherent in the Resolution as drafted. If it is reduced to 22½ per cent. there is still a possibility of some, at least, being imported. Anyhow, enough will be imported to give us an opportunity of comparison. I would ask the Minister to view this thing altogether differently from the point of view he takes with regard to machinery, where you have a certain amount of efficiency. In this case you have not got the efficiency. We have no objection to any Irish tool, and I have gone out of my way to mention an Irish tool yesterday, and, to-day, I mentioned one as being the best on the market. That is the McBride thistle cutter, which is the best of its kind on the market. Let the Minister not think that there is any prejudice on this side of the House against the Irish tools. There is not, but it is a question of merit where merit is due.

I ask the Minister, in all seriousness, to reduce this prohibitive tariff of 50 per cent. It is a joke and it is, at the same time, tragic, because this is not an article that will have to be used by horse or power labour but by human beings. We have not got the physique that we had fifty or sixty years ago, and if we want to get an output we must have tools of quality, of perfectly good design and of the right price, and you will do nothing in this Resolution but exclude competition, kill comparison and hand the manufacture over to Irish producers regardless altogether of price, quality or design.

Comment on this

I wish to support Deputy Gorey's amendment. This tax will, be almost certainly prohibitive, and I think we can make a better case, or as good a case, anyhow, for a reduction of this tariff than most of the others on the Schedule. The tax will fall perhaps more heavily on the poorer classes than any other tax on the Schedule. It will fall on workers of practically every description in the country, because a spade or shovel is an indispensable article of trade. With a prohibitive tariff, there is no doubt in our minds that the price of these articles will go up by sixpence each. We do not know exactly what was the number of these shovels imported in recent years. Deputy Gorey mentioned a figure of cost of somewhere about £10,000 and, roughly speaking, with the price at which these articles are sold, that would represent an import of 80,000 of these articles, which is a very considerable number.

Comment on this

Over 100,000, including Northern Ireland.

Comment on this

I do not know what the figure is but I was engaging in a calculation of my own. One hundred thousand of these articles come in, and that figure illustrates the number of hands into which these tools fall. They are used altogether by the poor and the working classes. They are not always bought by them but, in the main, the workers buy their own tools in the country. Certainly road workers always have their own spade and shovel, as well as numerous other workers, and if we are going to add this imposition now, at a time of hardship and of difficulty in obtaining employment, we are putting an unnecessary burden on these people.

I do not want to go into the merits of the Irish article and the foreign article. That does not concern me very much in debating this. Possibly the Irish article is quite a good article, but, in the county I represent, it has not, up to the present, a very big sale. There is a certain amount sold, but 80 or 90 per cent. of the tools sold are imported. The workmen have got into the habit of using these tools, and, for a while, at any rate, they will continue to use these tools. There is no provision made to any great extent for obtaining others. I have made inquiries in the villages about me, and I find that, at the moment, it would be almost impossible to obtain these particular Irish tools certainly until present stocks have been disposed of, and, I venture to prophesy, for a good while after. If the Minister accepts this reduction, it will be a relief at any rate. Personally, like Deputy Gorey, I am against the imposition, but I would appeal to the Minister to accept the amendment and I am sure the Labour Deputies will support us in that. This tax, if it goes through, will probably concern a great number of people, and it inevitably will lead to putting anything up to sixpence each extra on these articles.

It will have the effect of increasing prices, I am informed by retailers, in the country and everywhere else if there is absolute prohibition of the imported article such as this section will lead to. The Minister will acknowledge himself that it is a prohibitive tariff. We are under the impression rightly or wrongly that the effect of this will be to raise the price of the home article and raise the average price of any article that cannot be obtained here.

Comment on this

In view of the fact that we have a considerable number of amendments to dispose of and that this particular duty was discussed at very considerable length ——

Comment on this

Not at all. The Minister asked us to discuss it specially on this Stage. He said that we were to get an opportunity later.

Comment on this

We had a discussion on it but we need not argue that point at this stage. I merely want to state that there is no reason why we should import these articles. The total imports are value for £10,500. Of these total imports spades represent a very small part indeed. Further, the whole of our requirements in spades are made and have always been made from within the country. There are a number of small firms engaged in the manufacture of spades.

Comment on this
Mr. Byrne

How many firms?

Comment on this

There are a very large number of small firms throughout the country. I explained before that there are local habits in respect to spades. People in one district require one type of spade, while people in another district require another type. The fact is that a number of local industries exist for the manufacture of spades.

Comment on this

There is a much more substantial importation of shovels. The bulk of the shovels are the product of a specialist firm making a particular type of shovel in Birmingham. A large number of shovels are imported for the work done by local authorities. There is no reason why an equally satisfactory shovel should not be produced here. I gave as an example that the Galway County Council recently decided to procure its supplies from the Galway foundry and found that the shovels they got from the Galway foundry were quite satisfactory. I am sure that if other county councils get their shovels from that foundry or from other native firms they will be found to be equally satisfactory. It seems to me that if we cannot make spades and shovels in this country we cannot make anything and any opposition to this duty is most short-sighted and we should not waste the time of the House with it. The fact is that we can make our requirements in these articles and the making of them gives a considerable amount of employment in relation to the value of the output. There is no reason to anticipate any increase in price whatever.

Comment on this

I do not think the Minister should say that we are wasting the time of the House discussing a tariff which affects 100,000 workers.

Comment on this

On the 13th May, in discussing this matter in Committee, the Minister said:

Deputies are aware of the fact that when they come before the Dáil again in the shape of a Bill they can be discussed without a time limit.

After that there was half a page of speech. But there, apparently, is a time limit to the discussion to-day.

Comment on this

Deputies had a further opportunity of speaking on it afterwards. We had the Resolution before us then.

Comment on this

We had the Second Reading and the Report.

Comment on this

We had the Report Stage of the Resolution.

Comment on this

We had no discussion on the Report Stage of the Resolution. There was no discussion on it because of the statement that this could be discussed later. What are the items the Minister is anxious to get on to discuss?

Comment on this

None.

Comment on this

None at all. He has the same attitude on the whole lot — it is a waste of time discussing any of them.

Comment on this

I understand that there has been agreement to dispose of these amendments to-day and we have given considerable time to these matters already.

Comment on this

The point is that we were given no time to discuss them. It was pointed out that we should not waste time discussing them because there would be an opportunity given later to discuss them without a time limit. After that there is only half a page of print. That is what the Minister calls adequate discussion, so that we are not to have this discussion without a time limit. I should like to know what are the points he wants discussed. What are the points on which he is likely to offer us concessions? We know very well the answer to that. This matter can be divided into spades and shovels. This is a matter worth while discussing because it shows the Minister's mind on tariffs generally in the country. Spades, we are told, are manufactured locally. The Minister stated in his previous statement that there were three principal firms engaged in the industry. One of them is an in-and-out factory. He is not sure whether it is in the Twenty-Six Counties or the Six Counties. Another is going to be re-opened. Then we got the world-shaking announcement that a new factory was to be established at Nenagh. Later, when we got on to that, the Minister, instead of the strong case he made in his opening statement, when questioned said:

As regards the Nenagh factory I have seen a statement in the Press that the proprietors have already purchased machinery and propose to instal it. I do not know what truth is in that.

That was one of the great cards which the Minister played on this tariff. Does he now know anything about the Nenagh factory? I have made inquiries about this supposed factory and I cannot find any foundation for it. I have heard the statement that the local blacksmith has taken on two extra hands. Is that what the factory amounts to? That is what the Minister designates as a factory. Those are the type of factory from which all our requirements are going to be met.

I want to say in relation to the amendment moved by Deputy Gorey that it will not have the effect of taking away the tariff but merely to reduce it. An application for a tariff is an application for leave to increase prices. The granting of a tariff is the granting of leave to increase prices. The only way by which prices can be regulated under a tariff is by fixing some sort of decent upper maximum. What did the Minister tell us in regard to shovels? He said:

We will be able to produce shovels here in or about the cost at which they are now procurable, but the cost at which they are now procurable is the cost of a highly centralised mass production firm which is supplying huge quantities of these shovels, not merely to this country but to a number of other countries as well. The smaller unit, having proportionately larger overheads per unit of production, will not be able, except by rigid economy and efficiency in every department, to compete with that huge English firm in the matter of price.

Having said all that by way of warning about what we might expect in regard to shovels, the Minister went on— this is his statement, not mine — to make this statement derogatory to Irish industry —

There is no single industrial commodity which we are capable of producing here which we could not buy more cheaply somewhere.

That is the Minister's statement about Irish industry, that there is not a single type of article which we can produce here which we could not buy more cheaply elsewhere. In this situation we ask, instead of putting on a prohibitive tariff on an article which the Minister says we cannot produce as cheaply as it can be manufactured outside, that a tariff be imposed sufficient to enable native firms to compete with this mass production. We say test it out for a year. Test it on something that is not prohibition. Test it with the smaller tariff, which will give some check. It may not stop an increase in prices, but it will put some check on the point to which that increase will rise.

Comment on this

I appeal to the Minister to deal with this matter in a reasonable way. There can be no doubt that a 50 per cent. tariff virtually amounts to prohibition. If you impose 50 per cent. on a spade costing 3/6, I need not enlarge upon the consequences. The Minister said that there is no reason why these goods should be imported — that the home firms are capable of supplying practically all the goods required in the home market. I can speak with some experience of this matter, and that statement is not correct. The home firms are not able to supply the needs of the home market.

The Minister says that there is one large Birmingham firm specialising in this particular trade. There are a number of firms specialising in this trade. There are a number of spades required for nursery work which are not produced in this country. Spades of a peculiar type, necessary to get proper results from high-grade, scientific, gardening work, are not produced here. The Board of Works buy quite a number of those implements. Can the requirements of the Board of Works be supplied by Irish manufacturers or have these manufacturers ever endeavoured to supply the requirements of the Board? Are the Irish manufacturers in a position to supply the types of spade required for this class of work? The closing down of the Dublin firm was not due to lack of demand for Irish spades. The firm had some trouble with its workers. I can give the House no information as to that, but the closing of the firm was due, not to lack of demand, but to inability to produce the goods, due to the trouble which arose. The demand was here for the goods, but the supply was not forthcoming. It was purely a case of inefficiency in the industry and nothing else. How is that inefficiency going to be cured? Will it be cured by a prohibitive tariff of 50 per cent.? The Minister tells us that this firm is about to re-open. What foundation has the Minister for that statement? Is it not a fact that those who supplied the capital for that mill are now declining to have anything to do with it even under the tariff? I ask these questions because it is important that the information should be available to the House. We, on this side of the House, are as anxious as the Minister that the requirements of the home market in these commodities should be supplied by the Irish manufacturer. But they are not being produced at home. Further, I am aware that the difficulties were so great in this mill that patterns were sent across the Channel to be produced there because they could not be produced here. By placing a prohibitive tariff of 50 per cent. on these goods the Minister is stabilising that position of affairs. Let us encourage the Irish manufacturer in every reasonable way, but do not let us put him in the position to say: "I can now produce what I like and what I produce you have to take."

When the Minister states that there will be no increase in prices, does he know anything at all about the industry? There is an increase of prices already. I had to pay a customs duty of £5 on a lot of spades the other day. Does the Minister suggest that I am going to bear that cost out of my own pocket and not pass it on to the consumer? There is already an increase of price equal to the tariff imposed on those goods. I am very much in sympathy with the shovel end of the proposal, but the spade end is much more difficult. I am sure the Minister does not desire to take up an adamantine attitude on this matter, that he is open to reason when sound arguments are adduced to alter his course of action. Fifty per cent. is a prohibitive tariff. Twenty-two and a half per cent. would give all the encouragement the home manufacturers require. As the Minister was approached by this trade to impose a tariff, it would be interesting to know what reasons were adduced by those engaged in the industry for the imposition of the tariff. A tariff of 50 per cent. should not be imposed on the mere fiat of the Minister, without reason stated. That is not a sensible way of developing industry. A prohibitive policy, if we have not efficiency in industry, is suicidal, and a 50 per cent. tariff amounts to prohibition. Will the Minister, in his reply, tell us definitely whether this firm is going to reopen, under what management it will reopen, and with what technical guidance and skill? I read in the papers the other day of a meeting in the Mansion House at which Mr. James Larkin presided. At that meeting subscriptions were handed in to get this mill started on a co-operative basis. Surely the Minister has sufficient business training to know that that mill can never operate effectively or produce economically under a system of management of that kind. The Minister stated that this is a rather technical industry and that certain men have been engaged for a number of years in the production of those goods. The Minister is perfectly correct in that statement. The industry does require a certain amount of skill. Does the Minister know that in the mill to which he refers the steam hammer which produces these particular goods is dependent on the flow of the river Dodder for its water power? If the water power from the Dodder is not sufficient, the mill has to stand idle for a week or, perhaps, ten days. I want to see Irish manufactures developed, and developed as speedily as possible, but is development humanly possible under conditions such as these?

Can the Minister visualise the position of Irish manufacturers in the future if he establishes those conditions? Does he imagine that they will be able to compete with the mass production firms on the other side of the Channel? Irish consumers are entitled to receive the same value in goods produced by Irish manufacturers as they would in the case of similar industries on the other side. The price of these goods has already been increased and if this tariff remains on that increase will become permanent. The trader must expect a return from a cash payment for goods and he must add the extra charge to the cost of the article. The consumer will, therefore, have to pay.

I earnestly appeal to the Minister to meet Deputy Gorey in the amendment which he has submitted. It is a reasonable amendment and, if accepted, it will encourage efficiency amongst Irish manufacturers. I am sure the Labour Deputies know something about this question. We do not want to discuss these matters upon Party lines at all. I hate to discuss matters which are concerned with the national upliftment in a party way. I have, on many occasions, found myself differing from my own Party on various economic questions.

Comment on this
A Deputy

Will o' the wisp.

Comment on this
Mr. Byrne

Although we have certain will o' the wisps in the Party, it can never be said that J.J. Byrne was a will o' the wisp. The Deputy who has just interjected should know something about this matter and we should be glad to have his wisdom added to our own. We want to get this industry set up properly when it is set going. Let it be set up on a business and economic basis, on a competitive basis, and then we will have an Irish industry which will be worth while. That is what we want and not stabilisation of inefficiency. I earnestly appeal to the Minister to reduce this tariff from 50 per cent. to 22½ per cent. and I assure him, as one with some knowledge of the trade, that he will not be inflicting any injustice on Irish manufacturers but that on the contrary he will be helping the consumer at no expense to those who produce the goods on which the tariff is imposed.

Comment on this

I support the amendment. I believe the popularity of the Irish article, manufactured in this country, is sufficiently strong to justify us in thinking that a tariff of 22½ per cent. will help this industry very materially. It is within the memory of Deputies that there was a manufacture of this kind in Cork, namely, the old Shovel Mills. You could not wear out the article manufactured there, it was so good. Unfortunately, the price was prohibitive. I believe if you put on a 22½ per cent. tariff now it would give the necessary impetus to revive the industry and would make an appeal to those who want to use the article. Road workers and road contractors use this article in very large quantities. But there is another class of users and these are the small holders, to whom spades and shovels are necessary in the carrying on and in the working of their allotments. You will place an undue burden upon these men if the article can only be sold at a prohibitive price. There is not the slightest doubt but that the price of spades and shovels will rise to the full amount of the tariff. A high tariff offers an undue temptation to place a high price upon the shovel and that will have a tendency to defeat the very object that the Minister has in view. When prices rise to an almost prohibitive point there is a tendency on the part of the people to do without the article altogether. I believe we are not helping the industry or assisting the manufacturers by putting a prohibitive price upon the article. Tariffs of that size will be undoubtedly unpopular amongst the class that want to help this particular industry. I believe if the Minister agrees to this amendment of Deputy Gorey's he will be doing more to help the industry than by placing an undue tariff upon it that would certainly lessen the output.

Comment on this

Deputy Byrne said that the Irish consumer is entitled to the same value in the article he buys, wherever it comes from. He is; and the Irish consumer is entitled to protection against the type of article that is admitted free here. There are several firms in the Free State making other classes of spades and shovels than those coming in. If you get one of those Shamrock shovels, made in Manchester, with a grand shamrock on it, and give it to one of your men he will come back to you the next day with the shovel completely bent up and tell you it was laughing at him.

Comment on this
Mr. Byrne

You know nothing about it.

Comment on this

It is all very well for Deputy Byrne to complain of the tariff. He can bring in a dozen of these shovels at 3d. a piece in competition with Irish articles of the same kind sold at 2s. 6d. and 3s. apiece. We must protect Irish consumers against articles of that description.

Comment on this

The Deputy has referred to Shamrock shovels made in England coming into this country. Would it not be illegal, under the Merchandise Marks Act if that happened? I would refer Deputy Corry to the legal position. He has a remedy by which he could easily prevent what he says is taking place. Whenever the Deputy hears of a lot of these shovels coming in he should have resort to the legal position and put a stop to it at once.

Comment on this

I assure Deputy Dockrell the legal position has been investigated on this matter. Messrs. Scott of Cork are making shovels at the present time. I am rather surprised at the attitude Deputy Brasier takes up on these matters. During the last election he went through my constituency and right, left and centre complained of the unemployment. He took his stand in favour of tariffs as against the other farmer Deputy who was not in favour of tariffs. He talks now as if he were an out and out free trader.

Comment on this

Not at all.

Comment on this

I hold the ordinary plain people are entitled to protection against the kind of articles that are dumped in here. They are quite inferior stuff to those manufactured here. They are made by mass production.

Comment on this
Mr. Byrne

On a point of information I may say that the statement made by the Deputy is absolutely incorrect. English shovels I must say are very good value.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The House is not discussing the relative values of Irish and English goods.

Comment on this

As I say, the Irish manufacturer is entitled to protection. We have these articles dumped in here; they are of inferior quality, and we are entitled to deal with that. I had personal experience of them. I have used both English and Irish shovels. I could show Deputies shovels made in the shovel mills of Killeen many years ago, that are still good and are still in use, while articles bought years after bent up and had to be thrown away. They were practically worthless and useless articles; therefore, I maintain that the people are entitled to protection against this kind of article being dumped here. We hear a lot of talk about unemployment, and we heard all about the assistance that was to be given us to end unemployment. We see the value of that assistance now; not a single attempt made to help the Fianna Fáil Government to protect Irish industry. In trying to find employment for our people we are attacked tooth and nail. There are Deputies in this House who have attacked every single attempt made to protect Irish industry. Not one amongst the Opposition supported it and that is the assistance they have given towards dealing with the unemployment problem.

Comment on this

I do not propose to delay the House because the Minister knows my views about putting duties on things which the agricultural community must have. I put him this question. If, after a reasonable lapse of time, we can prove to him that the Schedule of prices for Irish spades has increased since the Budget of this year, will he take off the tariff? Is he prepared to give that assurance to the House? His contention is that tariffs do not increase the cost of living; that tariffs do not place a burden upon the consumer?

Comment on this

He never said that.

Comment on this

Is it his contention then that tariffs do raise the cost of living? Perhaps the Minister will resolve this difficulty — do they or do they not? The Minister does not care to resolve it. I suggest that the Minister is labouring under the happy delusion that they do not. Will he give an undertaking that if we can prove to him that after a reasonable period of time the prices of Irish manufactured spades and shovels have advanced since Budget day, will he undertake to take off the tariff and expose the people, who are trying to take advantage of the tariff in that way, to the fair breeze of competition again?

Comment on this

I do not quite agree with Deputy Corry on this question of shovels. He is right and he is wrong. There has been coming in to this country a cheap type of shovel which is very accurately described by Deputy Corry as crumpling up when you try to use it and smashing off at the handle. Against that however there is coming in and has been coming in for many years from England a first class type of long-handled shovel used in road work and farmers' work. I know something about shovels, I have handled thousands of them, and up to late years the shovels sold in the South of Ireland were made in Cork City. To-day the majority of shovels used in Ireland are made there. There is no necessity to increase the price of these and they will not be increased. There is the class of shovel, however, a good type of long-handled shovel that has come into extensive use practically all over Ireland. The Minister says this class of shovel is made in Galway. I must say that so far I have not seen any. The English shovel is being imported and I think the price will be increased. I think he should discriminate in favour of this class of shovel at the moment. As far as I know it is not being made in the South of Ireland. I should be glad to hear from the Minister that the Galway men are turning out as good an article as this particular type.

Comment on this

One would think by the general trend of this discussion that opinion was divided as to whether this branch of industry should have a protective tariff or not. The amendment suggested by Deputy Gorey asks for a tariff of 22½ per cent. as against 50 per cent. Representing the Borough of Cork, in which we have a very important mill turning out these spades and shovels, and the prospect of another being established in the near future, I feel that whilst I would be inclined to support the section as it stands, at the same time I must have regard, whilst also having regard for the amount of labour to be given as a result of this tariff (I believe some will be employed but the extent of that employment is, of course, a matter for conjecture), for another class of the community which deserves some kind of protection also — the agricultural class and the labourers on road work and gardening work and so on. I feel that the industry would be sufficiently protected by extending to the 22½ per cent. instead of the 50 per cent. as in the section, but I want to disabuse the minds of anybody who may think that I am against this tariff on spades and shovels, because I do believe, with Deputy Corry, that the Irish-manufactured article, as far as I know it in Cork at any rate, is a far superior article to any that would be imported. If this tariff will result in extra labour, therefore, I will give it my support, but I appeal to the Minister to accept Deputy Gorey's amendment as I do feel that the extension of that much protection to the industry would be quite sufficient to meet any outside competition because, value for value, the article would be better and would last longer, and with this 22½ per cent. you will have sufficient protection.

Comment on this

I want to reply to Deputy Corry. He said that no one Deputy on this side of the House gave any help to the Government in any way to reduce unemployment in any Bill intended to reduce unemployment. I take up that challenge of Deputy Corry's, and I say that I think three or four Deputies on this side of the House did, and we went into the Lobby with Deputy Corry supporting a Bill which was for the benefit of the basic industry of this country. That was the Butter Bill — not that we thought it a good Bill, we tried to amend it — but I personally did support it because I expected it would give a small benefit to one section of the community, the farmers of this country. I do not say it was going to do everything but simply because it was going to give a little help to the creamery supplier I, for one, and Deputy Gorey, I think, supported the Government on it.

Comment on this

I think it has dawned on the Minister now that for the next year or two there is no possibility of getting out supplies to meet the Irish demand. This 50 per cent., therefore, is only for revenue. There is no possibility of the Irish firms meeting the demand for imported shovels. I think the value of these shovels is £210,000. Does not the Minister think that 22½ per cent. would be enough? He could raise it to 50 per cent. next year. I want to reply to Deputy Goulding because he talked sense and he knew something of what he was talking about. The Minister talked about time. I think the Minister ought to put his own house in order. More time is always wasted by Deputy Corry than by anyone else in the House. We heard here about protecting the people from the import of shovels and spades—protecting the people from themselves. We are forcing the people to buy them. The county councils and other local bodies make their choice from experience and they have got to be protected from themselves, not from the English manufacturer, but particularly from Deputy Corry. There is no such thing that I know of as a manufacturer here manufacturing the two-footed spade—the agricultural spade. The spade made in Cork is the wooden tillage spade. The other, which is a different thing altogether, is subject to this 50 per cent. tax. I can see the time coming in the next few years when we may have to make arrangements to ask our neighbour for the loan of a spade or a shovel. We may even have hi-jacking and bootlegging of spades and shovels. Leaving jokes aside, I ask the Minister in all seriousness to ease off for the first year anyhow and make a distinction between the first and second year. This year it is going to cause tremendous inconvenience and his factory will not be set for anything like the production that will be required, and it will mean a tax on the people who can least afford it. If the Minister has any regard for those who are not using steam or petrol power he should have regard for people who have to use these tools with their hands.

Comment on this

Does the £10,000 of imports include implements manufactured in Northern Ireland?

Comment on this

Of the £10,500 in imports, £3,744 represented goods consigned from Northern Ireland.

Comment on this

There are spade factories in Coalisland and Dungannon.

Comment on this

We can either put on a smaller duty and in effect say to people continue to import spades and pay the duty or have a general all round increase in prices. That is what Deputies opposite are advocating and was the policy adopted by the late Government, or else we can put on a duty which will stop imports. This duty is intended to stop imports and we say to the firms here: Go and supply the requirements of the home market.

Comment on this

They are not able.

Comment on this

Let us face the realities. We are attempting to face the task of supplying the home market. The imports represented £10,000 which would keep four or five factories engaged in the manufacture of these goods. If, as we anticipate, this stops imports completely, and if our requirements are met from these factories the increased output will mean £2,000 or £2,500. It seems trivial in relation to the total production of a factory, but there can be no question at all of our ability to supply the needs of our people. I think it is clear to most Deputies that it is only in respect to the implement mentioned by Deputy Goulding, the park shovel, that there can be any question. In relation to spades and shovels I think the requirements of the country are capable of being met, and met to a greater extent than at present by existing concerns. In respect to the park shovel there is undoubtedly a preference existing amongst those who have been using it for that particular type. As I explained, in the case of one county council they tried to get a similar product from Irish factories, and they succeeded in doing so. They found the Irish product equally satisfactory. Other county councils can do the same.

Comment on this

Has the Minister any information to show that these shovels are really satisfactory? I have had some information to the contrary.

Comment on this

I have this information that Galway County Council expressed themselves satisfied.

Comment on this

I am informed that Galway County Council was not satisfied with the shovels.

Comment on this

We cannot reconcile these statements here.

Comment on this

I want to know if the Minister had any inquiry made to ascertain if the shovels which were supplied to Galway County Council were found satisfactory.

Comment on this

The fact is we have a number of firms engaged in this industry, and some additional firms propose to come in by excluding imported products. We know that a better way to keep down prices than by adopting the alternative method suggested, would be to permit imports subject to a small duty of 15 per cent. That method of tackling the problem is similar to giving an invitation to firms to raise prices. There is going to be effective competition between Irish firms, and it is as a result of that competition that prices will be kept down. I was asked if the prices went up would the duty be removed. That question is so hypothetical that it is impossible to answer it. It is not the cost price I am talking of, but of this duty which is intended to increase the price of imported goods so high that no one will buy them.

Comment on this

Is the Minister aware that four of the firms to which he referred were written to for prices and quotations and not one of them replied? That happened over a month ago.

Comment on this

I am not aware.

Comment on this
Mr. Byrne

I am telling you what is a fact.

Comment on this

If we found that Irish firms were constituting themselves into a ring, and by ring methods tried to force up prices unduly, we would be quite prepared to remove the duty, if there were no other means of defeating that attempt to exploit the market and fleece the consumers. There are other means by which it could be done, but I assure the Deputy that if we find an unreasonable increase in prices taking place we will have some effective method of dealing with the position. I do not anticipate that that will take place. I do not anticipate any likelihood of a ring of manufacturers here in the case of this particular industry. It is an industry in which there is likely to be very intensive competition, and certainly there has been no indication up to the present that what he fears is likely to prevail. It seems to me that this duty is thoroughly justifiable. The value of the imports is small, but the competence of the Irish firms to supply goods now imported cannot be questioned. In respect to the park shovels, a certain balance of opinion is possible. There is no doubt that good shovels can be procured here, and they should be sufficient in addition to the imposition of the duty.

Comment on this

Has the Minister any application for the establishment of a new factory to supply these things?

Comment on this

Any information about the Nenagh factory?

Comment on this

People proposing to start a factory; not making application.

Comment on this

The Minister founded his case previously on a new factory at Nenagh.

Comment on this

Nothing additional. I did not found my case on that. If that factory was not contemplated there are enough firms to supply these things.

Comment on this

The Minister must not get away from that. No one questions the competency of Irish firms to produce shovels. The question is: can they produce shovels in sufficiency and at a price the people will pay? The Minister does not see any reason why there should be an increase in prices. He stated previously that there would be an increase in prices. The only thing we are asking is to have a check on prices. It is not a question of not giving a tariff. Have a check on prices. That check is the imports coming in here. Such importation is good and should be favoured. It is not a question whether a tariff should be given or not, but of having some check on prices. In the circumstances which the Minister mentioned there are going to be increased prices.

Comment on this

Is the Minister satisfied that Irish firms will be able to turn out all that is required this year? Our information from experts seems to be to the contrary, that Irish firms are not able to supply these goods this year. If that is so, will the people have to buy the goods subject to a 50 per cent. tariff?

Comment on this

The output of Irish firms plus the stocks in the country should be adequate to meet the requirements of the country this year.

Comment on this
Mr. Byrne

In view of the information that I have, that these people were asked for prices and never gave a quotation, is it not fair to conclude that they had no goods to offer?

Comment on this

I am not accepting that information.

Comment on this
Mr. Byrne

The Minister will accept nothing. That is what it amounts to.

Comment on this
Division

Question put: "That the word proposed to be deleted stand."

Tá 66
·
Níl 47
Result Carried The question put was agreed to.

Do you agree with this result?

Before Deputy Murphy moves his amendment I would like to say that the amendment and another amendment relating to second-hand clothing, if passed in the form in which they appear on the Paper, would render necessary a number of consequential amendments in this and other legislation. Since the matter was raised on the Second Reading I have given it some consideration with the object of seeing if there was any way out of the very considerable difficulties that would be raised if there was any differential treatment in respect of second-hand clothing. In the circumstances, I would like the Deputies concerned to postpone their amendments until the Report Stage. I may be able to arrange to have an amendment moved which, if carried, would overcome these difficulties. I am not promising to support the amendment, but it would be in a form which would permit the enactment of it without any consequential difficulties arising. If, therefore, we allow the matter to stand over until the Report Stage, I think it would be better.

Comment on this

Is the Minister prepared in the framing of that amendment to go as far as wiping out the duty completely?

Comment on this

No. I think in no circumstances can we contemplate wiping it out completely. It would mean practically making a breach in the ready-made clothing duty which might have very serious reactions upon the industry. There always has been a duty on second-hand clothing, and I think that the wiping out of the duty completely is something which could not be contemplated under any circumstances.

Comment on this
Mr. Murphy

How far is the Minister prepared to go? This is a very heavy duty.

Comment on this

I am not promising to go anywhere. The more I have examined it the more difficulties I see in the way of any modification in respect of it. What I am promising to do is to arrange to get an amendment drafted and to have that amendment moved on the Report Stage. The amendment will be in a form which, if carried, would mean that there would be a concession in respect to second-hand clothing enacted by an amendment of this Bill alone. I could argue that the Deputy's amendment is not in order, but I do not want to do that. If it were carried, it would involve not merely consequential amendments in this Bill, but further amendments in the main Finance Bill, or else the introduction of a special proposal, because it is proposing to take off a duty which was imposed by another Bill and not this Bill. If I can get an amendment in the proper form, we can have a discussion on the Report Stage.

Comment on this
Mr. Murphy

I do not think the Minister will succeed on that point. He unsuccessfully contested that point last night. In any case, there is this difference, that this particular Bill heavily increases the duty already in existence. I am not disposed to argue the matter at any length, but if the Minister will give me an undertaking that the amendment in the terms he has mentioned will not be opposed by him, I would be disposed to withdraw my amendment.

Comment on this

I have had representations made from every Party in the House for a modification in respect to second-hand clothing and also against the modification. It is quite clear that there is no Party feeling on the matter. There are strong feelings both ways within the ranks of every Party. I would be inclined to have an open discussion and to leave it to the decision of the House, if the administrative difficulties, which are very considerable, can be surmounted. I think it will be possible to surmount them, and to have an amendment introduced which would avoid the more considerable difficulties. We can then have a discussion on the amendment and an open vote of the House upon it. It would not, however, mean the entire abolition of the duty—that could not be contemplated—but it would mean a reduction of the duty that is being charged at present, because at present the full rate of duty is being charged. In view of the difficulties of producing certificates of origin, the preferential rate of duty cannot be given by the Revenue Commissioners. In any case, I think it would be desirable to have in respect of second-hand clothing no preferential rate of duty at all, but merely one rate which would apply to all second-hand clothing, irrespective of where consigned from. An amendment on those lines, which will involve also a reduction of the duty, can be moved on Report and discussed, and would, I think, meet the main objections to the increased duty which have been raised and, at the same time, meet the big administrative difficulties which would arise if a reduction were decided upon by the Dáil.

Comment on this
Mr. Murphy

I am not quite happy about the attitude of the Minister. I do not like to press him too far, but in view of the statement he made on the Second Reading, he ought to give an indication that he will approach the consideration of the amendment sympathetically. Leaving it to a free vote of the House is a rather doubtful method of dealing with a question of this kind, as all of us know from experience. In view of the attitude the Minister took up on the Second Reading, and the appeal made to him by a member of his own Party, he ought to indicate that he is prepared to accept the amendment.

Comment on this

I understood from the Minister, on the Second Reading that he was prepared to concede something to the expressed views of many Deputies who must have come into personal contact with him in the matter. That was the inference I drew from his statement. The Minister has used the words "proper form." Am I to understand that a form of words will be introduced which will mean that if the duty is not removed entirely the greater part of it will be removed? When the Minister suggests a free vote of the House, does he mean that the Government Whips will not be put on? In view of the relatively large sum that these dealers in second-hand clothing have to pay for a hawker's licence, namely £10 per annum, and as they are a very deserving class of the community who go from fair to fair——

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Deputy is now discussing an amendment which has not been formally moved.

Comment on this

I understood the amendment had been moved by Deputy Murphy.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

No; the amendment has not been moved.

Comment on this

Is the Minister prepared to say now that the amendment he suggests will mean, in effect, the removal of this duty altogether on second-hand clothing, or a modification of it in some way?

Comment on this

An amendment will be moved which will propose to the Dáil a substantial modification of the duty now chargeable, but it will not mean the removal of it. My attitude towards that amendment will be largely determined by the manner in which we find it possible to prevent the remission being used to defeat the main duty on ready-made clothing. It is obvious that if we give a concession in respect to second-hand clothing it might conceivably open the way for a wholesale evasion of the main duty. I think Deputy Blythe had that problem under consideration for some time after the first ready-made clothing duty was imposed and refused to modify the duty in respect of second-hand clothing because he could see no way out of the administrative difficulties. I think it will be possible to surmount the major difficulties and to get an amendment in a form which will make it not so easy to use the concession for the purpose of evading the main duty. My attitude will be determined by the success of our efforts in that connection. An amendment which, if carried, will mean a definite concession in respect to the duty upon second-hand clothing will be moved upon the Report Stage, and I would be inclined to take the opinion of the House upon the amendment—to leave it to a free vote of the House to decide one way or the other.

Comment on this

Before this amendment is allowed to be withdrawn, will the Minister give us an undertaking that he will consult the public health authorities about the importation of these garments? Will he further give an undertaking that he will consult the ready-made clothing manufacturers to ascertain whether, if these clothes are allowed in under a preferential rate, or under the low rate, without producing a certificate of origin, they will in effect destroy the whole measure of protection?

Comment on this
Mr. Murphy

I suggest that the Deputy is not in order in dealing with that, because he is dealing with the effect of an amendment which has not been moved.

Comment on this

I am asking if the Minister will give a certain undertaking in order that the House may unanimously permit the withdrawal of the amendment. If Deputy Murphy does not like that, I will not consent to the withdrawal.

Comment on this
Mr. Murphy

I object to Deputy Dillon killing the proposal with kindness in that fashion. He has gone into the merits of the question and I think that is unfair.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Discussion on an amendment not moved is, of course, out of order.

Comment on this

I am not discussing the amendment. I am asking the Minister a question as to whether he will ascertain the views of the public health authorities on this matter.

Comment on this

I can assure the Deputy that the views of the public health authorities will be ascertained.

Comment on this

I want to ask the Minister in view of the unusual procedure suggested by him, first will he move an amendment himself?

Comment on this

That is a matter that will come on afterwards. It will be moved all right.

Comment on this

It is a very important matter. It will be the Minister's amendment framed by himself, and I want to point out and to ascertain first by whom will it be moved, and if it is moved on the Report Stage will the Minister go into Committee for a discussion, at least on that amendment, because I do not think it could be adequately discussed if we are to be tied down to the usual procedure on the Report Stage. This is rather an important matter and I think we ought to be told by whom this amendment will be moved.

Comment on this

The amendment will be moved all right.

Comment on this

By whom? Is it to an official amendment? Am I to understand that the Minister proposes to put down an amendment himself for the Report Stage in regard to second-hand clothing, and does he propose that that amendment will contain modification of the present tariff and, if so, will it contain modifications in the direction of a lower tariff than the tariff proposed at the moment? Will the Minister go further and say that any reduction that he will propose will be at least as low as the tariff that at present exists?

Comment on this

The answer to the first two parts of the question is in the affirmative and to the third part in the negative. I propose to get an amendment which will reduce the duty on second-hand clothing and at the same time provide for the consequential amendments that would follow. I do not mind moving it myself if that is the most suitable arrangement, and I may adopt the practice set by the Deputy's colleagues of voting against it afterwards. We can have a free vote of the House as to whether there should be any concession in regard to second-hand clothing.

Comment on this

And a further free vote in the House as to further modifications that may be moved to the amendment proposed by the Minister? If the Minister is to bring forward an amendment that may not meet the case we may require to move further amendments to it and we want to be in a position that we would be able to do this after the Minister's amendment has been circulated, if the Minister's amendment will be circulated to the House in time.

Comment on this

The amendment will be circulated to the House all right.

Comment on this

Is the whole matter to be left to a free vote of the House?

Comment on this

I am prepared to consider that concessions will be given but we may get to the stage where the amendment may nullify or destroy the whole tariff on ready-made clothing and thus do irreparable damage to an Irish industry. If there is any case at all to be made for the concession it must be a case for a modification of the duty only to the point where it will not damage the main industry of ready-made clothing in this country.

Comment on this

Supposing it were possible to have an arrangement by which second-hand clothing could be admitted free without nullifying the effect of the tariff already imposed is the Minister disposed to admit second-hand clothing free?

Comment on this

I would not say so.

Comment on this

Supposing that there would be no considerable reaction in the ready-made clothing trade, would the Minister still require ——?

Comment on this

There are other considerations. As the Deputy is aware, the public health authorities impose very stringent regulations on the importation of ready-made clothing.

Comment on this

They would have to be made.

Comment on this

And the public health authorities are in fact proposing to favour the closing or the stoppage of these imports. These considerations would have to be taken into account.

Comment on this

I would like to ask the Minister if in this particular point he is making a departure from his usual view on tariffs? Is he making a departure in the woollen and ready-made industry from his usual viewpoint? I think he told us that a cheaper class of garments would be made here and in increasing numbers; and that the price of this particular class of goods would place them within the reach of persons who hitherto had to depend on the imported ready-made clothing.

Comment on this
Mr. Murphy

I call attention to the fact that we are going into the whole question again. Deputy O'Neill should not be allowed to say what I am not allowed to say.

Comment on this

I think the question of the duty ought to be decided here and now.

Comment on this

I discussed with the Minister previously the question of dispensing from duty second-hand clothing sent from one charitable organisation outside this country to a charitable organisation inside this country. The Minister was disposed then to give sympathetic consideration to that matter. I ask now if the Minister would give some consideration to that before the Report Stage, and that the necessary licensing provisions would be introduced in the Finance Bill.

Comment on this

I would like to support Deputy Norton in the first part of this question. I know that there is a big amount of charitable work done between one charitable organisation and another, and that it is a matter of great importance to poor people in this country.

Comment on this

I have given consideration to that problem, but there are very important administrative difficulties arising and it may not, in my opinion, be possible to get over these. However, we are to have the question again before us on the Report Stage, and if we can find the means by which that can be done without doing damage in other directions or widening the area of concession to an extent much larger than Deputy Norton contemplates, then we can have a decision in the Dáil upon the merits of the proposal when the matter is next before us.

Comment on this

Would the Minister give consideration especially to the licensing feature? A concession in that direction would make it possible for these charitable organisations to work on the lines I have put before the Minister.

Comment on this

If these concessions can be made is the Minister prepared to grant exemption for second-hand clothing in support of a charity?

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The House has spent sixteen minutes in discussing an amendment which has not been formally before the House. Amendments 14, 19 and 25 are not moved.

Comment on this
Mr. Murphy

I ask the Minister in accordance with Deputy Morrissey's suggestion if he will permit the widest possible discussion on this amendment on the Report Stage, because it is obvious that there will need to be such a full discussion. Will the Minister permit the widest possible discussion?

Comment on this