We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

Finance (Customs Duties) (No. 2) Bill, 1932—Committee Stage (Resumed).

Contributions 123–238 of 238. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

Bill Finance (Customs Duties)(No. 2) Bill, 1932
Enacted

No. 10 of 1932 ›

Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

I take it that amendments 14, 19, and 25 are not moved.

The following amendment stood in the name of Deputy McGilligan:—

Amendment 15.—In sub-section (1) (a), to delete all words from and including the word "all" line 50 to and including the word "substitutes" line 54.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Amendments 16, 17, 21, 22 and 74 have some relation to this amendment.

Comment on this

Yes.

The following amendments stood in the name of Deputy McGilligan:—

16.—In sub-section (1) (a), line 56, to delete the word "sixty" and substitute therefor the words "forty-five."

17.—In sub-section (1) (b), line 60, to delete the word "all" where it occurs the second time and substitute therefor the words "other than" and in lines 60 and 61 to delete the words and brackets "(other than straw hats and felt hats)".

21.—Before sub-section (2) to insert a new sub-section as follows:—

"Notwithstanding the provisions of Section 16 of the Finance Act, 1925 (No. 28 of 1925) as amended by subsequent enactments, or of the foregoing sub-section of this section of this Act no duty of customs shall be charged, levied or paid on any of the articles mentioned in the Third Schedule to this Act."

22.—In sub-section (2) to delete paragraphs (c), (d) and (h).

THIRD SCHEDULE.

74.—Before the Third Schedule to insert a new Third Schedule as follows:—

"THIRD SCHEDULE.

1. Component parts of personal clothing or wearing apparel made wholly or mainly of non-textile material other than leather.

2. Component parts of personal clothing or wearing apparel made wholly or mainly of leather and suitable for and intended for use in the manufacture of hats or caps.

3. Component parts of corsets made wholly or mainly of non-textile materials.

4. Hats of any description for wear by women or girls and all component parts and accessories thereof.

5. Gloves, other than knitted gloves.

6. Ladies' and children's stockings of silk or artificial silk.

7. Girls and children's coats.

8. Woven underwear of silk, or silk and wool.

9. Woven wool bathing costumes and caps.

10. All articles of the following types: Belts of leather or suede, scarves of crepe-de-chine, silk, or artificial silk, neckwear of lace, crepe-de-chine, silk, artificial silk or cotton, collars and cuffs of rubber, shaped frillings in silk, cotton and lace."

Comment on this

I think the discussion can be abbreviated if it ranges over the totality of these amendments. That is to say, I might be allowed to discuss amendments 15, 16, 17, 21, 22 and 74 together. Really the vital parts are amendments 21 and 74. The other things are subsidiary, though of considerable importance. I briefly want to have certain things removed from the tariffs altogether, and the things which I want to remove are those which are set out in the new Third Schedule which I propose to have inserted. In order to do that I must get amendment 21 considered.

The framework to which I move these amendments will have to be explained. At the moment, there are two rates of duty chargeable upon personal clothing and wearing apparel. An original 15 per cent. duty was imposed without any preferential rate and at a later stage the 15 per cent. duty was raised to 20 per cent. and so I say the items that are down in paragraph (a) of (1) of Section 7 are mainly these. I can refine it further by saying that the duty must relate to clothing made of woollen or worsted materials.

Into that position comes the present proposal of the Minister, that certain rates of duty should be put on certain specified articles, with a preferential rate of two-thirds, as stated in paragraph 3. The operative duties, therefore, are proposed to be 40 per cent. on everything contained in lettered paragraph (a) sub-section (1) of Section 7, that is to say, on all suits, overcoats, hats and caps made wholly or mainly from woven tissues, wholly or partly of wool or worsted and suitable for wear by men or boys, all proofed personal clothing and wearing apparel (not including umbrellas), all personal clothing and wearing apparel (except gloves) wholly or mainly made of leather or leather substitutes, and all component parts and accessories of any of these things. It is proposed to have a duty at the rate of 22½ per cent. with a two-thirds preferential rate on shirts and collars not made of woven tissues which are wholly or partly of wool or worsted, all straw hats, all felt hats, all hats of any description (other than straw hats and felt hats) intended for wear by women or girls and all component parts and accessories, and, finally, on all personal clothing and wearing apparel not mentioned in either of the foregoing paragraphs and all component parts and accessories, it is proposed that there shall be a 45 per cent. duty, operatively 20 per cent. There is a series of exemptions, but these exemptions really, in the main, only go to exempt from the new section things which were previously exempted from the old rate, and, therefore, to a certain extent, they make no change.

I am proposing to take out of paragraph (a) of sub-section (1) of Section 7, proofed personal clothing and personal clothing made of leather or leather substitutes, and I am proposing to take out of the second section hats intended for wear by women or girls, and then I get the whole thing brought down to the exclusion section which I propose to the Third Schedule, and, therefore, I ask the House to agree that there should be excluded three certain items, but mainly I want to get taken out from the section the items I have enumerated—hats of any description intended for wear by women or girls and all component parts and accessories, all gloves, other than knitted gloves, ladies and children's stockings of silk or artificial silk, girls and children's coats, woven underwear of silk or silk and wool, woven wool bathing costumes and caps and articles of a number of types mentioned. Again, this is an industry in which I have a very definite interest, because it was one of the industries which we picked out as suitable for a tariff, and, consequently, I am very anxious to see that the best possible success should attend that industry, and that the duties should be so adjusted as to enable those firms, which have got going under the tariff, to concentrate on the articles in which they have shown considerable efficiency in production, and, to aid them in their endeavours, to remove from them certain articles in which they have not shown any great progress, and about some of which, at least, they have said they are not likely to be manufactured in the country.

I should make the point, first of all, that when I move to reduce the rates of duty, as I propose to reduce, say, the 60 per cent. to a certain point, and the 45 per cent. to a certain point, I am founding that upon the meetings which I engineered myself as between the clothing manufacturers and the woollen manufacturers last year, and in the early part of this year, in an attempt to get an accommodation between them. To a considerable extent, the rate of duty imposed on wearing apparel must depend on the rate of duty imposed on woollen fabric. The two industries run together, and the tariffs associated with them are what have been described as the two-tier tariffs. If one goes up, the other must go up something, if the old rate of protection is still to be continued.

At the most favourable of these meetings which took place between the two sections of the industry, it seemed to me that accommodation could have been got as between them, on the basis, that if the whole exemption limit went for the woollen fabrics, then the clothing manufacturer would require a duty of something between 30 per cent and 33? per cent. operatively. There was no case made for 33? per cent. A case was attempted, but when the figures were analysed, it was proved that not merely were they getting the particular type of suit put forward that they said was essential but an addition of 6/- item of profit, and that was left over for further consideration and when the meetings were held, no accommodation was found to be possible between the two sections of the trade. I am consequently moving to bring the duty back to what was a suitable point, and which I think would be regarded by the trade itself as suitable, if they were forced to argue this point, in detail, as they might have been forced to argue it before the Tariff Commission, and to justify themselves in asking for a licence to charge more for certain types of clothing.

The exclusions are the main things, although the other things are of considerable importance, and, again I base myself on this, that, if we are going to give the apparel manufacturers an extra tariff, we have got to recognise that it is going to be, for some period, at least, an extra burden on the consumer, because it is going to give them a chance to raise prices still further, and I think we should equate that by remitting taxation to the family as opposed to the individual, and that if we are going to give the clothing manufacturers a chance to raise prices on articles intended for wear by men and boys, we should consider the family and remit taxation in respect of women's clothing to some extent, and in respect of children's clothing to some extent. I I picked out, as suitable for exclusion, hats for wear by women or girls and all component parts or accessories, because, in the main, there has been no great improvement in the business here, and if that business were taken away and other lucrative businesses given to the firms, I doubt if they would have very much objection to start off. If they got the point where they could handle these businesses we can later on accommodate them. I picked out gloves, because it is admitted that, other than knitted gloves, there are very few gloves made in this country. There are one or two individuals who make, to order, gloves of a specialised type, and who will still continue to make them, but, except for knitted gloves, there are really no gloves being made in the country, and that after five or six years of a tariff.

With regard to the third item, stockings of silk or artificial silk, I have more hesitation. These are not being made here and attempts to get factories established here for the making of them failed, because it was understood that the purchasing unit here was not sufficient to enable any factory even specialising in these things to be started. No factory was started. The only hesitation I have in this is the possible reaction of this on the woollen stocking trade. It may be argued, and argued with some force, that if silk or artificial silk stockings are let in here free of duty, certain people, who are now using woollen stockings, will turn over to the use of these things, but I do not think that that will bear much investigation. I do not think there was ever a fashion which so completely ran around the whole world, and this country, even penetrating to the bogs, as the artificial silk stocking fashion, and it is very doubtful if there are any people likely to fall for that fashion who have not already fallen. I picked out also, as suitable for exclusion, girls' and children's coats. I have often had it represented to me by the trade that the reason why there was not more progress made in the manufacture of coats for children, particularly, and for girls, even especially, was that more work had to be put into these things, that more work was required, and that the prices on the whole were not remunerative, not at all as remunerative as the price relative to the work employed on men's and boys' clothing.

On the footwear side, as far as footwear of silk or silk and wool is concerned, there is no production here. A bathing costume is perhaps a small item, but it is one for which the demand has not been met in this country to any extent at all. The articles I have enumerated in sub-section (10) which I am proposing to the Third Schedule are I think ones that may simply be noted. There is no production in belts made of leather or suede; scarves made of the material I have mentioned, neckwear of the material mentioned, or rubber collars and cuffs and shaped frillings in the materials mentioned. I am accordingly proposing to exclude articles that are not being made here in the main or, where they are being made at all, can certainly with the goodwill of the firms be excluded, if and when we are proposing to give an additional tariff on the manufacture of the goods which they have been able to produce to some degree, with considerable efficiency where they are produced at all, but which are not at all yet being introduced in sufficient quantities to meet the requirements of the country. I ask again that we should not speed the machine too fast and beyond what the factories can cater for. We can give them a better situation than that in which they now find themselves, by removing from the scope of the tariff all articles in the manufacture of which they have not to any extent engaged up to date.

Comment on this

The duty imposed by this section is 60 per cent. with a preferential duty of 40 per cent. on all woven tissues made wholly or partly of wool or worsted, in the main for wear by men or boys, also on personal clothing and wearing apparel, except gloves made wholly or mainly of leather or leather substitutes and their component parts. In regard to the items mentioned in paragraph (b) the position remains the same as it was. The effective rate of duty there is 15 per cent., which duty has been in operation since 1925. Under paragraph (c) the main items which are made the subject of a higher duty than that heretofore prevailing are women's ready-mades and garments of one kind or another. The Deputy is proposing to reduce the duty in respect of men's and boys' ready-made clothing.

Comment on this

To reduce the new duty and to increase the old one.

Comment on this

He said that by doing so it gave those engaged in the industries an ample measure of protection, a measure of protection at least as great as it was before and would enable them to retain or extend their position in the market here. In order, however, that the measure of protection should be as the Deputy stated, it is necessary for him to bring in an amendment later on in the Bill reducing the duty now imposed on the cheaper woven cloths and he is proposing to do that.

Comment on this

This is founded on the duty being as it is in the Bill.

Comment on this

I certainly think that the Deputy will find it very hard to argue that with a duty of 20 per cent. on cloth, and a duty of 30 per cent. on clothing, the ready-made clothing manufacturers will have the same amount of protection as they had before these duties were imposed. In any case I think it would be undesirable to limit the duties to that extent. The Deputy said that raising the duties to the point at which he proposes it it should be placed, gives these manufacturers a chance to raise their prices still further. In fact these manufacturers have not been raising their prices at all. I do not think the Deputy denied there has been very keen competition in the ready-made clothing trade. The firms who are engaged in that trade in the Free State and also in other countries, say that the margin of profit available here is much lower than elsewhere because of the keenness of competition and prices have been cut down to the minimum. In fact they have been cut so low that the firms engaged in the business are making, generally speaking, lower profits than firms engaged in kindred industries.

In respect of the articles which the Deputy proposes to exclude from duty altogether the position is as follows. In so far as the articles are covered by paragraph (b) we are leaving the position unchanged and they will be only subject to the duty which operated heretofore. Again, I think it would be a mistake to remove the duty which was imposed in 1925, because by doing so we would announce our abandonment of all hope that the manufacture of the various classes of goods could be undertaken here. In respect of gloves, the position is, as the Deputy stated, that heretofore only knitted gloves were made here, but the Deputy will know that we have an amendment on the Paper which is designed to give us power to permit of the free importation of parts of gloves made of leather or similar materials for a period of twelve months from this date. That concession is required because the manufacture of leather gloves is now about to commence here and those about to engage in the manufacture of these gloves have asked us for that period of twelve months in which they can be engaged in training workers in the apparently very highly skilled process of cutting the different parts. The process of stitching parts, stretching and shaping gloves is, although involved, nevertheless capable of being done here without any very prolonged training by Irish workers. In any case, it seems to me the position is different to that which the Deputy had in mind when tabling the amendment. He was assuming that the manufacture of these classes of goods would not be undertaken here. That is now about to be undertaken. One factory for the manufacture of that class of gloves is likely to be opened here in Dublin next week.

In respect of artificial silk stockings, I do not think that the Deputy is correct in saying that the size of the market here does not make their economic production possible in the country. We have had some tentative approaches from people who are contemplating the manufacture of these articles here and on the other hand we have been ourselves considering the possibility of, as it were, inviting certain firms operating at the moment plants in other countries similar in size and in output to that which would be required here. If we fail and if we find after an experimental period that there is no possibility of getting the industry established, that there exist difficulties here that do not exist elsewhere, then the duty can be removed but there is no indication that such failure is likely to result as yet.

Certainly I will say to the House that in so far as these articles are not essential, in so far as they are capable of bearing for a time a duty at the rate we impose, and that we think should be imposed, that duty should be maintained until all the possibilities of getting them manufactured here have been thoroughly explored. It seems to us that if a serious and consistent drive is made to get them produced here we can get that done. The position in respect of women's ready-mades, and particularly girls' and children's goods, has been unsatisfactory heretofore. The import duty has been operating, but only quite recently has any start been made in the factory manufacture of these things here. There has always been, of course, a very considerable business in the manufacture of this class of goods by private dressmakers and people of that kind, but only quite recently was a start made, to any extent, in the manufacture of these things by factory methods. Other firms are now proposing to engage in the industry—some of them external firms with very long established and very widespread reputations. It would seem to be very undesirable that we should, at this stage, remove that duty, because it now seems possible to get as rapid development in respect of that end of the industry, which heretofore remained undeveloped, as we got in respect of the men's ready-made clothing industry when the first duty was imposed. There are, it is true, a number of articles of wearing apparel of comparatively minor importance which are covered by the general duty and which have always been covered by the general duty but which have not been made here and, conceivably, will not be made here. We have given some consideration to the possibility and advisability of excluding these articles from the duty but it was found to be almost impossible to do so inasmuch as definitions could not be found that would cover precisely the article in mind and not a much wider range of articles. The articles in question, however, are of comparatively minor importance and are by no means essential. Consequently, it is considered best that we should maintain the duty rather than risk the doing of something which would mean a general reduction in the measure of protection afforded.

A case has been made in respect of certain classes of children's socks which are now imported from Japan at remarkably low prices. That case has also been examined but the examination convinces us that it is undesirable that a concession in duty should be given in respect of them. Children's socks are manufactured here and the factories engaged in the business are undergoing considerable extensions at the moment, so that we will have a much larger supply from these factories in the near future. It is, of course, absolutely impossible for any factory here to engage in the manufacture of these goods at prices which would compare at all with the prices at which the Japanese goods are sold here. We could not do that unless we were prepared to reproduce here the conditions in respect of wages, labour and so forth which exist in the factories from which these goods are being sent. I do not think we should try to do that. If these goods are imported, the amount of duty payable upon them will be very small but the duty should be maintained in order to give protection to the factories which are making similar articles here.

In the woollen industry, there is also a prospect of considerable development in the near future. I have mentioned that some of the factories are putting in additional plant and, generally, extending their business. There have also been approaches by Six-County firms and other firms proposing to engage in particular ends of this business. They have been encouraged to do so where the proposals were such that they were considered satisfactory. Certain proposals came forward—proposals which involved merely the importation of certain prepared fabric, the cutting out of the neck and some small sewing here. In that case, we could not consent to these firms coming in because it would have meant that instead of having a proper fully-developed hosiery industry here, such as we will have, we would rather have a mere sewing and finishing industry. This duty was fully considered before its imposition and it seems to me that the exemptions mentioned in sub-section (2) are the only ones that should be contemplated by the Dáil. It would be a mistake, in my opinion, to extend these exemptions to any considerable extent because there can be no doubt whatever that it is an industry suitable to this country, one which is quite capable of rapid development and one in respect of which the difficulty of supplying skilled workers, and similar difficulties, do not exist. The protection which has been given to it is sufficient to secure its development and is securing its development.

In my opinion, a reduction in that measure of protection would have the effect of definitely slowing up development, if not preventing it altogether. I do not think that should be done. In this case, it is not possible for Deputies to argue that any increases in price are likely to take place in consequence of the duty. I have mentioned the very keen competition that exists in the readymade clothing trade. I should also like to mention that the leading firms engaged in the hosiery end of the business have definitely reduced their prices and sent out an amended price list for this year since the imposition of the duty.

Comment on this

What about the price of raw wool? Has that gone down?

Comment on this

The price of raw wool is remarkably low at the moment.

Comment on this

I thought so.

Comment on this

I am talking of the amended price list which went out since the imposition of the duty—the price list for this year.

Comment on this

What does that prove?

Comment on this

Deputies can always explain a reduction of price. The fact is that a reduction of price has taken place, not an increase.

Comment on this

The fact is that raw wool has gone down considerably in price.

Comment on this

Presumably, there is always an explanation of a reduction of price. The only other point I wish to deal with at this stage relates to the proposals contained in another amendment in my name, to reduce the 15 per cent.—that is, the old rate of duty—chargeable upon certain forms of sports goods which are enumerated in amendment No. 18 and also to exclude from duty the carnival cap which has heretofore been taxed as wearing apparel. That is referred to in amendment 23. These are, I think, the only amendments which could be considered of the duty imposed by this section. It seems to me that this is a duty which should be maintained because it is likely to give, in employment and in the establishment of new factories, much more rapid results than some of the other duties. I should be very sorry indeed if the Dáil were persuaded to modify it in any substantial particular.

Comment on this

I want to intervene again on this question of prices. The Minister says this is not a tariff in respect of which anybody can allege that the prices charged are unreasonable or bear hardly on the Irish consumer. He says that there is fierce home competition. There can be no such fierce home competition, seeing the big revenue still derived from the apparel business. What does it amount to? Does the Minister know what last year's figure was? It amounted to well over half a million. In answer to a question I put down, the Minister said that this year he estimated the revenue would benefit by £150,000 extra.

Comment on this

I should say that I referred to the competition which operated in the men's readymade clothing industry. The Deputy is talking about the whole wearing apparel industry.

Comment on this

I am talking about the whole apparel duty and I thought the Minister was talking about that too. As far as the whole wearing apparel duty is concerned there is something in the region of £600,000 still levied by way of tax which people have to pay on the goods they purchase, and the Minister estimates that there will be an additional £150,000. In answer to a question of mine the Minister said, on 12th May, that in the case of men's and boys' clothing, the existing factories are in a position to produce the entire requirements of the country, and, he went on to say, in the case of certain branches of the women's clothing trade and the hosiery trade, the existing firms are not now in a position to cater for the total home requirements but he anticipated that rapid developments would take place in these industries. In answer to a supplementary question of mine as to whether the Minister would give an estimate of the revenue that was likely to accrue from the tax the Minister said about £150,000. I take it that this amount of £150,000 was expected to come mainly from the women's clothing trade and the hosiery trade, while he believes that men's and boys' clothing was likely to be made at home. I am discussing, in the main, women and children's clothing trade, and the Minister has made no satisfactory answer to that. I am moving to have certain things excluded and to have an extra tariff on those items upon which he is convinced satisfactory progress is being made, and about which he said the existing factories are in a good position to produce the entire requirements of the country. But he did not give any detail.

I have an amendment down to have this tariff of 60 per cent. imposed upon men's overcoats, suits and caps made wholly or mainly from woollen or worsted reduced from 60 per cent. to 45 per cent. I have moved to reduce the effective duty from 40 to 30. The Minister said that that was on the basis that a certain amendment I had down was passed and I answered it was not. I am confining myself to the clothing manufacturing side when putting up their case.

They were considering the situation that would exist if the total exemption limit were abolished. If it were abolished then such duties as were on would fall upon the cloth now exempt. The Minister is moving to put the rate on cloths we exempted a little bit higher—two or three per cent.—than what it would be if the exemption limit was abolished while the old duty remained. In these circumstances the clothing manufacturers put forward a demand for a 33? per cent. increase. The duty on their materials would be raised from 20 to 33?. I am proposing to raise it from 20 to 30 and I am doing so, because when their case was examined and the number of items that they brought forward as typical were examined, it was discovered that not merely would they get a contribution but that they would gain something like 6/- extra profit on a suit of a fairly cheap type. Therefore I say there is no case for 33?. I am putting it that there is a case for 30, but that is on the basis of the existing cloth coming in. I do make my case definitely inside the limits I describe. When the two groups met those who met them were convinced that accommodation was going to be easy enough on a tariff ranged between 30 and 33? per cent. I do not know whether we should raise it to 60 or operatively to 40. I say that while raising this tariff to the point they want, in the conditions we can envisage happening under this Bill, why not take other steps and limit this extra burden which is going to be put on, in addition to the old amount, which used to be charged on women's clothing and hats and other wearing apparel? They are going to get an additional £150,000 this year from that. If we are to give these people a chance by giving them 10 per cent. more on an article that they can manufacture than what they asked to have given them, why not pass the other way, and say, "Very good, we will give you an amount that will be prohibitive and we will insist on your meeting the requirements of the country"?

That does not mean an abandonment of the tariff with regard to any of these items excluded in a temporary way. It is only taking out these things in which you are not making any progress here, and in regard to which the Minister admits there is no production in the country. I ask again that there should be serious consideration given in the Resolution to the terrific burden of taxation that is being put upon the people. We are giving an amount of protection on the side where it is necessary, under certain conditions, and I take the Minister's own statement that some of the articles that I moved to exempt are not made in this country at all. In such cases the tariff is pure taxation. I do not see why we should not exclude all articles of footwear from sizes 4 to 10, women's and girls' hats and gloves other than knitted gloves. If necessary when there is some better approach to a factory in the leather glove side, the Minister has under his control the Provisional Imposition Order, and in that way he can come in. But why include with this, other gloves, not leather and not knitted and about which there is no attempt at manufacture here? Similarly with regard to artificial silk stockings. They could be considered when we are to have a factory established here for the purpose of manufacturing them. The other things are not manufactured here and the Minister has admitted it. There ought to be this year remission of £150,000 which is going to be landed on things that are not made here at all. Give the remission from that £600,000 or whatever portion of it is tariff which is put upon those articles not made here at all.

Comment on this

I am rather surprised that the ex-Minister for Industry and Commerce should make a statement here that artificial silk stockings are not made within the Twenty-six Counties.

I have seen artificial silk stockings and socks made here. I have washed them myself. The best machinery in the world is in the Twenty-Six Counties and the former Minister for Industry and Commerce should be well aware that the machinery is lying there —the most up-to-date machinery—and the workmen are walking the streets of the town. The town I refer to is Balbriggan. It is well-known that the hosiery made in Balbriggan is the most up-to-date and they have the best workers in the world. They have proved that in the medals and awards they have from exhibitions all over the world. The best class of machinery is there lying idle and the men are hardly able to get the dole. I invited the Minister for Industry and Commerce to go down this day week and I think it is his duty to go down. I said the late Government had gone there and nothing had been done.

I worked in that hosiery firm. I was a washman, and I know what I am talking about. I went in to work there when I was 17 years of age. You can go to Ballsbridge and see the work on exhibition there and I defy contradiction that you can get a better class of work in the world. If he allows this duty to be taken off you will have all kinds of cheap stuff coming in. You can go down to Guiney's in Talbot Street and get the German stuff for 2½d, and I say it should be prohibited altogether. The Minister should investigate the workings of this firm.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Deputy is not in order in referring to a particular firm.

Comment on this

It has been stated that there is no machinery to make artificial stockings. I deny that. The machines are there and the men are there. I agree that they are not being made now; but why? About seven years ago in the Press I challenged a certain man that he was giving his orders to England and getting them sent from England under the name of Balbriggan. That is why I asked the Minister to investigate this. There is something radically wrong because he does not want to cater for the Twenty-Six Counties. The best men and women in the world are there and they can make any class of hosiery.

Comment on this

Why are they idle?

Comment on this

I am asking the Minister to enquire into it, unless he is, just like some of you on the Opposition Bench, catering to the foreigner. They are playing too much to England and that is why these works are idle. The staff, however, are fully paid. They are never idle and everybody knows that you cannot pay a staff £300 a week and the workers not working unless there is something wrong. The machinery is there and I invite the Minister to go down and see for himself.

Comment on this

Are artificial silk stockings being made there now?

Comment on this

Not at the present time. I cannot tell you the reason. Practically no class of sock or stocking is being made and all the workers can get is one day's pay for the stamp.

Comment on this

Are they stockings or works of art?

Comment on this

I find some difficulty in following Deputy Curran's line. I am very much interested to hear that artificial silk stockings are to be had from Balbriggan. I have been looking for Irish made artificial silk hosiery for the last five years and could not find them.

Comment on this

I did not say they were being made, but that they can be made.

Comment on this

But I am much interested to hear that they were made at one time. If so, it would be a source of profitable information to the Minister to enquire why the trade perished. I think it may be because they took no means of bringing their product before the public. I think the Minister himself has some experience, as I have, of this trade, and certainly it was never before brought to my attention, and I doubt if it was ever brought to the attention of anyone else.

I find it difficult to follow the attitude of the Labour Party with regard to tariffs. An amendment in the name of Deputy Murphy was withdrawn to allow second-hand articles to be sold at 1/2 or 2/- which will compete in the same way as the artificial silk.

Comment on this

Is the Deputy aware that I asked the Minister to prevent the second-hand stuff from coming in?

Comment on this

I have been charged with being a will-o'-the-wisp, but at least I am not a detached fragment of a Party. It is becoming bewildering. I listened to members of the Cumann na nGaedheal Party getting up and saying that if the rest of the Cumann na nGaedheal Party betrayed the unemployed, at least there was a faithful few. One Labour Deputy said that in the interests of the poor this Government must admit secondhand clothes and a colleague of the Labour Deputy gets up within an hour or two and says that it is absolutely murderous of the Minister to adopt the suggestion of his colleague. The position of the will-o'-the-wisp may apply to some of the Deputies on my left, but at least it does not apply to a member with no Party affiliation. A group manages generally or should usually manage to say the same thing. I do not think that that is a matter of any importance and I appreciate very much that the deplorable party system is dying and that members are not merely for a political party but for the people who sent them here. I think that is healthy and I hope that at a later stage certain members on my right will come to realise that they are members for their constituencies and not merely for Fianna Fáil.

Comment on this

We are always for our constituencies.

Comment on this

We will give them a chance later on. I think it very desirable that this House should be brought to a full consciousness of the situation arising out of these matters, and that Parties, on certain policies within the House, do not seem to need the support of their own members. I venture to say that it is desirable that members should become a little more independent in viewing these proposals than hitherto and that they should examine each thing on its merits and act with the courage of Deputy Curran, and when others are going off the rails to bring them back with a jolt. I suggest to them to follow his example and when they feel that their own Minister for Industry and Commerce is going off the rails put on the harness and bring him back with a jolt.

Comment on this

I think these Resolutions are drawn wider than the Minister intended to draw them in order to secure his object. I think that was the substance of the point Deputy Dillon was making. I want to pass on to the Minister certain representations that were made to me, some of which may, or may not, have been made to the Minister already. The first refers to the very cheap line of clothes, rather a new line. I am informed that comparatively recently certain cheap raincoats and waterproof coats were introduced into this country which would only be purchased by the working classes; that it was impossible to get such coats made within the borders of the Free State; and that there is no chance of their being made here, as this is a class of article that manufacturers here did not wish to undertake. The effect of the duty will be, not merely to increase the price of the article, but to make it impossible for working people to get such garments at all. The second case deals with gloves to which Deputy McGilligan referred. I am informed that there is not the smallest hope of kid and suede gloves being made in this country. I think the result of the duties will be that certain of the better types of gloves will not be purchasable within our borders, and that damage will be done to persons at present interested in selling these articles.

Comment on this

As to the point raised with regard to gloves, developments are taking place so that leather gloves will be made here in the near future. There is an amendment down which we are moving in order to enable those engaged in the industry to bring in the cut parts free of duty for twelve months. After that they will have to engage actively in making them.

Comment on this

Does not that refer to leather?

Comment on this

Yes, and materials similar to leather. Cheap waterproofs are being made here. I got a circular this morning from a certain Dublin firm asking me to buy a gent's featherweight waterproof coat at 8/11d. and that is cheap enough.

Comment on this

With the new duty?

Comment on this

Irish made.

Comment on this

Since when?

Comment on this

I had to pay one guinea for mine.

Comment on this

Does the Minister mean that Irish-made waterproofs of the quality mentioned can be supplied to meet the existing demand for such things in the near future?

Comment on this

I say that Irish-made waterproofs can be purchased at certain shops in the city for 8/11.

Comment on this

My informant assured me that he required a certain number of articles every week and he found it impossible to get them.

Comment on this

There is a large number of firms engaged in the manufacture of waterproofs here, and two additional firms are engaging in it.

Comment on this

A large number?

Comment on this

A large number. I think we might say that we have almost reached the saturation point.

Comment on this

Could the Minister give some of the names?

Comment on this

I could give them but I have not got them now.

Comment on this

Does the Minister say that there are a dozen firms?

Comment on this

I do not know how many.

Comment on this

Are there six?

Comment on this

Yes. As I mentioned, two additional firms have commenced operations since the imposition of the duty, and some of the existing firms are extending the scope of their establishments.

Comment on this

Might I read an extract from a letter I received for the Minister's information?

Comment on this

I think the letter received from that particular person has been received by every Deputy.

Comment on this

I need not press the matter so.

Comment on this

I think it will be found that possibly every Deputy has a copy of it.

Comment on this

I have not got it.

Comment on this

As I believe there is justification for it I will read it.

I require an average of 200 waterproofs of this class each week, and I find that none of the Irish factories can guarantee me such a delivery, even at high prices. In fact, I find that the Irish factories are not anxious to handle this class of trade.

If that is true, what I have said is correct.

Comment on this

I would be inclined to take that statement with very grave doubts—either the 200 waterproofs per week, or the inability of the manufacturer to give supplies at any price from factories here. It might be that there was a period immediately following the imposition of the duty in which they could not say that requirements would be met. That period has certainly passed, and there is no difficulty at present in getting adequate supplies of these goods at various prices. The main question arising out of it is in respect to women's apparel. As far as men's ready-made clothes are concerned there is no reason for importations. Existing firms are quite capable of supplying requirements, although it is quite true that under the original duty considerable importations of these goods took place mainly by certain firms which operate multiple stores here. The raising of the duty to 30 per cent. would not have interfered with them at first, but the raising of the duty to 40 per cent. has definitely limited importations. Certain of the firms in question are still importing goods, paying the duty and selling here at the old prices, presumably charging the extra cost on the entire cost of running their business over the whole of the United Kingdom and Ireland. In due course, if necessary, in order to ensure that that particular trade will stop, and to ensure that the requirements of the people will be met from Irish factories, that duty of 40 per cent. may have to be further increased. As far as the cheaper ready-made clothes are concerned, the bulk of the requirements are met here. Existing factories are capable of meeting them, and there is very intense competition between them.

In respect to women's clothing, the position is that, as far as lighter outer and under clothing is concerned, existing factories, and certain new factories which have started, will be sufficient to supply all the requirements of our people, plus certain developments in the way of the manufacture of these goods by people in their own homes. It is in respect to women's heavier outer garments that the most difficulty exists, and where developments will be slow. However, a start must be made some time. A start has been made, and I am informed that there will be a considerable development of the whole industry, and the manufacture of these goods at home by women and girls, or through the instrumentality of dressmakers. I have been informed that since the imposition of these duties the sewing machine companies operating here have been unable to cope with all the orders they received for machines, which would seem to indicate that very considerable developments in the way of making these goods in their own homes are taking place amongst the people. In my opinion, that is a desirable development. Progress is now being made, but progress will be certainly arrested by the removal of the duty as is suggested by Deputy McGilligan. I do not think we should remove the duty. Even though, in respect to women's outer garments, we have no factory to meet requirements, we have a very large number of skilled dressmakers, and the imposition of the duty is going to mean more business for them. In respect to lighter outer garments, existing concerns are supplying the requirements, and new firms can come in. I do not think there is any case for the modification in this duty and I urge the Dáil not to accept the amendment.

Comment on this

Will the Minister consider the advisability of admitting free certain articles, such as lace motifs, that are used for trimming up light underclothing? There is no possibility of manufacturing them in this country. I spoke privately to the Minister on that matter and I would like him to consider the advisability of admitting these articles free of duty. The articles I have in mind are used by certain firms for trimming underclothing. If they were admitted free it would be a great advantage and it would help those firms to sell their produce at an economic price compared with the foreign article. The amount of duty will be very small. I do not advocate having them sent in free of duty to shopkeepers, but to the firms that use them in the process of manufacturing ladies' underwear.

Comment on this

Since the Deputy spoke to me I have had certain inquiries made but they have not been completed. If we find it is feasible or desirable to make an exemption of the kind suggested by the Deputy, we would be very favourably disposed to do it and we could have an amendment on the next Stage.

Comment on this

The remark might also apply to shaped frillings in silk, cotton and lace and neckwear of the same type. If these things are not made here they are imported and are used mainly as component parts in the trade.

Comment on this

I think it was Deputy Thrift who made the statement that certain people wanted 200 cheap waterproofs and they wrote to an Irish firm but could not get them. If the Deputy gives me the name of the people requiring the waterproofs I will get them all the supplies they need.

Comment on this

Go to Mr. Richardson.

Comment on this

Owing to the very ingenious manner in which the ex-Minister for Industry and Commerce dealt with tariffs on these materials, Irish firms found themselves practically driven out of competition. I know that in one instance, by reason of the manner in which the last Government imposed tariffs, a firm was obliged to close down. That was four months before the Fianna Fáil Party took office. This firm is situated a couple of miles from where I live. When Fianna Fáil formed a Government the firm reopened. At first they were able to give employment to 30 hands, then to 60, and later they employed 90 hands working double shifts. I believe that ultimately they will be able to engage 200 people in that industry.

Deputy McGilligan asked for a reduction in certain tariffs. I ask the Minister not to reduce the tariffs he has imposed. In the case of a certain manufacture, the relief afforded by the Minister by taking the tariff off the raw material has resulted in a 20 per cent. reduction in the price of the article. The increased tariff in another instance resulted in an English firm coming here and giving orders for £15,000 worth of waterproofs. That represents the business they have in this country. The contract has now been taken by an Irish firm and these English people find they can sell waterproofs cheaper under the new conditions.

Comment on this

Because they are completely escaping all the tariffs by coming over here and getting their articles manufactured by an Irish manufacturer. That gives employment here that was formerly given across the water. The manner in which this whole matter has been conducted by the Department of Industry and Commerce is worthy of the highest appreciation. At any rate, extra employment is being given instead of, as in the case of the last Government, conditions resulting in the closing down of factories. As a result of the way in which the problem has been tackled by the Government, employment has been given to 90 people in my constituency, and it will probably mean later on employment for 300 people. In addition, there has been a reduction in the price of the article here.

Comment on this

That is great.

Comment on this

These are points that I would advise Deputies opposite to consider. With regard to Deputy Dillon's argument, it seems to me the Deputy cannot make up his mind on matters that would be of very great interest to his constituents. So far as we are concerned, we at all times do our duty by our constituents. I am deeply interested in Deputy McGilligan's amendment. If it were adopted I believe it would hurt the industry which the last Executive Council almost succeeded in wiping out of existence. Thank God, under the new régime that industry is again flourishing and giving employment to our people.

Comment on this

After the notorious political economist on that side has spoken, I suppose we should all be silent. However, I will venture to ask two more questions. An amendment is down later with regard to gloves of leather or other material. Will that include gloves of taffeta silk, nap, crepe, suede, doeskin, chamois and fur-back? These gloves are not being made in this country. With regard to the section, the things in regard to which the rate of duty is not being increased under the proposals are shirts and collars not made of woven tissues. Probably the most successful tariff of the whole lot is that on shirts and collars. It is the best of the whole lot. It can be said that these articles are now being produced more cheaply and sold at a cheaper rate in this country than possibly on the other side; even our exported material that goes to the other side is sold more cheaply. Why is it not proposed to increase that duty? There is only one item of production coming in against it, a proprietary article made in Belfast by the firm of Faulkiner and Latimer. They manufacture a folded collar. It is the only thing that could be kept out.

Comment on this

There was no need to increase the duty. That firm has now opened a factory in Dublin and is manufacturing here, so that import will be stopped.

Comment on this

Why should they open here? Is it not going to be a blind and they will continue to produce in the main factory in Belfast? There is no extra tariff imposed.

Comment on this

I am afraid I cannot answer for the firm. We considered with great care whether or not this particular tariff on shirts and collars should be increased. The position in regard to shirts is that we do a much more substantial export than an import business. The exports are several times the imports. It was not thought desirable that the duty should be increased. The same situation does not altogether apply in respect of collars. We examined the matter for some time and we decided to leave the position as it is in respect to collars. The general position in that respect is still being examined. As regards the other question concerning parts of gloves, the amendment only remits the duty in respect of the parts of gloves made of leather or a similar material. That would not cover gloves of silk or woven materials of any kind. But it would cover suede and articles of that kind.

Comment on this

Doeskin.

Comment on this

Chamois.

Comment on this

Yes, in my opinion. It is intended that it should, but that it should not cover merely woven and knitted materials.

Amendment put and negatived.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

That governs several other amendments.

Comment on this

Yes, that rules amendments 16, 17, 20, 21, 22, and the amendments to the Schedules.

The following amendments were agreed to:—

18. In sub-section (1), page 5, before paragraph (c) to insert a new paragraph as follows:—

"(c) on all gloves, guards, and protectors which, in the opinion of the Revenue Commissioners, are constructed, designed, and intended solely for use in sport, all bathing costumes, bathing caps, and bathing wraps, and all clothing which is suitable and intended for use when wading—an amount equal to fifteen per cent. of the value of the article"; —Aire Airgid.

23. In sub-section (2), page 5, before paragraph (e) to insert a new paragraph as follows:—

"(e) on any personal clothing or wearing apparel made wholly or mainly of paper, nor"

—Aire Airgid.

24. In sub-section (2), page 5, to add to the end of the sub-section a new paragraph as follows:—

"nor

(j) on component parts of gloves made of leather or material similar to leather, where such component parts are imported into Saorstát Eireann before the 1st day of July, 1933, and, in the opinion of the Revenue Commissioners, are not substantially completely manufactured gloves."

—Aire Airgid.

Comment on this

I move amendment 26: The three amendments I have down have one purpose and can be discussed together. The object is simply this: that all brushes heretofore taxed remain liable to the old rate of duty and that brushes which have not been heretofore taxed instead of being taxed at the rate proposed in the Bill be taxed at 22½ per cent., with the preference set out in the Bill, making it an effective 15 per cent. A great range of brushes has already been protected and great progress has been made. As a matter of fact, a high rate of protection has been given to the brush industry, and it seems to me that, with that protection, it is excessive to levy the rate suggested in the Bill on these classes of brushes that have been heretofore free. Ample additional stimulus, if it is required, would be given to the industry by a much more moderate rate of duty.

Comment on this

I do not think we can accept the amendment. There is no reason why brushes should be imported. There is one very large firm engaged in the industry; there are four, shall we call them, medium firms and a large number of smaller firms throughout the country. Consequently, it does not appear likely that there will be any diminution in competition, in view of the fact that the activity of all is quite sufficient to supply our requirements, particularly in the class of brushes which are in commonest use. The duty imposed when the tax was placed upon imported furniture was of considerable benefit to the industry. There was a considerable increase in the number employed, although that increase was offset by the fact that during the same period a change from the production of brushes by hand to the production by machines took place which, of course, diminished the amount of additional employment given. There was, however, a large range of brushes excluded from the scope of that duty, some of them classes which have a considerable sale, and they are now made subject to this duty. In fact, the duty is intended to prohibit the importation of brushes altogether, to give these firms engaged in the production of brushes a market here and let them compete amongst themselves for it. The competition in respect to brushes in commonest use will be sufficiently keen to ensure that no undue increase in price will arise.

Comment on this

There are ranges of brushes in which the competition probably will be very keen—the simple sort of brushes which even the smallest firms can make. There are, however, other ranges of brushes that are required and which are very numerous, and there are classes of them where certainly competition will be slight; where these small firms may be ruled out of account, where, perhaps, even what the Minister calls the medium firms will be ruled out of account; and, in fact, the production solely confined to the large firm. It seems to me that, while there may be classes of brushes as to which the duty proposed will do no harm, because there is likely to be competition, there are other classes where there will be no effective competition, and where this policy of exclusion will have all the faults that have been mentioned in regard to it from time to time. It may not be the wish of the firms here, as I know from what they have been doing, but I think the whole effect will in time, if not immediately, lead to the home price being the price of the outside article, plus the tariff. I think it is not good policy here, any more than in respect of any other article, to put on a duty higher than can be shown to be necessary.

The Minister made no attempt to show that the particular duty levied here is necessary. As a matter of fact, the duty of 33? per cent. probably would never have been put on brushes if the duty had been confined to brushes. What happened was that a furniture duty was imposed at a very high rate in order to give a great stimulus to an important industry which would be fairly widespread through the country, and which, unlike many of the other industries here, required a high degree of skill. Brushes were simply swept in accidentally and the rate applied to them was probably much too high. What is happening now is that, in so far as the preference is concerned, the Minister is bringing all sorts and classes of brushes under that rate, and I think some further consideration ought to be given to it. If the Minister is not prepared to accept the amendment, he ought to examine those lists of brushes with a view to ascertaining those in which there is not likely to be very much competition, and consider whether a prohibitive duty should be applied to those classes that can be made only by one or two firms.

Comment on this

We did consider the various classes of brushes in respect of which there was not at the moment competitive production. We excluded toothbrushes as a result of our examination and, presumably, there are certain classes of brushes in respect of which only one firm at the moment is engaged in producing. I refer to such brushes as shaving brushes and brushes required for special purposes. But it is extremely likely that other firms for the manufacture of brushes will go into these lines if there is business to be done in them. I do not think that we need fear that the one firm to which I have referred is at all likely to endeavour to exploit the market. If it does, the logical position or sequence will be that other firms will become equipped to deal with this work, go into the business and take what higher profits are to be made.

The position is that there is a certain limited export trade for the brush products of Irish factories which would indicate that the prices are at least competitive. It think it is better that we should impose duty that will operate definitely to exclude foreign products than that we should impose small tariffs or duties which might be taken to indicate that we contemplate that the prices of the home manufactured articles would go up that amount. We do not contemplate that. If prices are not kept down by competition then we hope to have other machinery by which we can deal with any danger of prices being unduly pressed up by the home manufacturers.

Comment on this

The Minister ordinarily would argue that the imposition of a duty means that the foreign manufacturers will pay. Now he is, for the purposes of this Bill, arguing that prices will go up all round.

Amendment put and negatived.

Comment on this

Amendments 29, 31, 32 and 33 are standing in my name:—

In sub-section (1), line 47, to delete the words "forty-five" and substitute therefor the word "thirty". —Earnán de Blaghd, Patrick McGilligan.

In sub-section (2), line 55, to delete the word "thirty" and substitute therefor the word "twenty".— Patrick McGilligan.

In sub-section (2), line 62, after the word "value" to insert the words "exceeding one shilling and sixpence per square yard and".— Patrick McGilligan.

To add at the end of sub-section (2) a new sub-section as follows:—

"(3) A customs duty of an amount equal to 10 per cent. of the value of the goods shall be charged, levied and paid on all woven tissues made wholly or partly of wool or worsted (other than blanketing and floor coverings) which are imported into Saorstát Eireann on or after the 26th day of April, 1932, and are so imported in the piece and are of the width of 12 inches or more and of the weight of seven ounces or more per square yard and are of a value not exceeding one shilling and sixpence per square yard."

There is an amendment down by Deputy Blythe, Amendment No. 30 to delete sub-section (2). My amendments are more comprehensive than the one in Deputy Blythe's name. I ask leave to move and discuss the four together. The situation here can be explained simply enough, except for this explanation that I have to offer, that I had understood that the old preferential rate of four-fifths was being continued in the new proposals. I understand from the amendments now being put down by the Minister that the preferential rate, instead of being four-fifths, will be two-thirds. That, of course, has knocked out some calculations I was making. Nevertheless, the position is simple enough. At the moment there is a duty of 20 per cent. with an exemption limit for clothing of a value under 2/- per square yard. The duty on clothing exceeding 2/- per square yard is 20 per cent., that is a 25 per cent. duty, which works out at 20 per cent. at the preferential rate.

The Minister proposes to increase the duty in the higher grade of clothing from 25 per cent. with a four-fifth preference, or 20 per cent. for Commonwealth goods, to 45 per cent. duty with a two-third preference, which puts it at 30 per cent. for Commonwealth goods. That is to say, to increase the duty from 20 per cent. to 30 per cent. for British goods. Then he proposes to drop the exemption limit altogether, but to charge these cheaper cloths at 30 per cent. or, apparently, on the two-thirds basis—20 per cent. My amendment proposes that instead of placing on the higher grade of fabric a duty of 45 per cent. which, with the preferential rate explained by me will amount to 30 per cent., we should impose a lower duty. That 45 per cent. is a higher tariff than has ever been claimed by the trade.

As far as I understood the trade recommendations there was no complaint whatever on the higher grade cloth or there was no complaint of any substance that the duty on the higher ranges was not sufficient and was not satisfactory. The complaint that was made was this, that certain cloths that should have been caught by the tariffs were coming in either because the cloth had dropped in value or else that they had been invoiced at a lower rate. The fabric was coming in invoiced under 2/- per square yard, and the cloth, therefore, escaped the tariff altogether. But there was no appeal made by the trade that the duty, so far as it caught the cloth at all, was insufficient. Yet in spite of that it is proposed to raise the duty now from 20 to 30 per cent. In sub-section (2) it is proposed to put a duty of 30 per cent. tariff on cloth under 2/- per square yard or with a preferential rate of 20 per cent.

The complaint has been made that the preferential limit is letting in goods which should have been tariffed. I propose to meet that in this way. I am moving an amendment that cloths exceeding in value 1/6 per square yard should be tariffed up to 20 per cent. I propose to modify the rate proposed in the Bill for cloths under 1/6. Personally I would prefer to leave the lowest grades without a tariff, but again a difficulty might arise. There is a possibility through invoicing of a peculiar type going on that an article which might be subject to duty might escape. In order to avoid that I would put some tariff on the lower grade. This whole thing can be divided into two parts. So far as the upper range is concerned there has been a tariff and it has been admitted that it was successful. There has been no complaint that the tariff was insufficient. Nevertheless, the proposal of the Minister is to increase that tariff on the upper range from 20 per cent. to 30 per cent. I think there is no justification for that and I propose to have some increase, some very small increase on the lower grade. The case has been made with some substance that owing to the decrease in the price of wool, cloth, which it was expected to catch by the tariff imposed on a fabric of 2/- and upwards, is now coming in free. I propose to meet that by having a grade between 2/- and 1/6 per square yard and put on a sufficiently good tariff to keep out that cloth. I would prefer to leave the lower end without any tariff at all, but if there is to be something so as to be able to cope with the shifting down of the values of the cloth, there should be a duty of ten per cent. The cloth at the moment comes in free. I found on the application made by the woollen and worsted manufacturers before the Tariff Commission and on their adherence to the case, that they pleaded and they have since made the case that there were these cheap classes of cloth coming in and that they were not going to make them. When the Tariff Commission made the suggestion to them that while the reputation of an individual firm might be prejudiced because the firm was going into the lower type of cloth, a number of the firms should come together and establish a factory between them for the manufacture of these cheap cloths here they refused to accept the suggestion. I do not see now what is the reason why we should propose a substantial tariff on these cheap cloths when the manufacturers themselves have declined, or when they are unwilling to go into that line of manufacturing cheap cloths. At one time the firms said they declined to go into the cheap line because the good name and the reputation of their firms would suffer by turning out this cheap material and at another time their argument was because of the higher type of machinery required for this class of goods. In either case they did not propose to manufacture them.

At any rate, the fact emerges that they do not propose to manufacture. For that reason, I ask that this division should be made. I assert that I am giving them, under the first proposal, adequate protection on the cloths they want tariffed, and which they have a right to have tariffed, and I say it is adequate, because there has been no complaint made as to its inadequacy to date. In the lower ends I make two divisions and give again what I think would be considered adequate protection on the intermediate classes between 2/- per square yard in value and 1/6 per square yard. For the rest, I propose a very small tariff, and I do not propose to give more than should be granted simply because these people do not admit that they are going to manufacture. As to the whole tariff on this woven tissue, it is probably the best tariff that ever was introduced, not the best, judged by results, but the best from this angle, that there has been a tradition in regard to the manufacture in this country of this material, and that there has been a sufficiency of firms, properly scattered and giving good employment, in the main, and this is, even more than the making up business, one that should be protected, but protected within the limits of what the manufacturers say they are going to engage in. They have not said that they are going to engage in the lower cloths.

Comment on this

The time left for the discussion of this is very inadequate. The position is that there are certain types of cloths utilised in the clothing industry. There is an all-cotton cloth that is not subject to duty. There is a cloth which is a mixture of cotton and wool which is subject to duty, and which is the type of cloth which the wool makers here say that they do not intend to make and should not be asked to make. I understand that the cloth is of very poor quality, which can be given a certain finish and gloss which cannot be given to the cheaper woollen cloth, and it is bought because of that finish, but that its wearing qualities are very limited indeed. They argue that it would require the establishment of a separate mill for each, and that the existing mills making that cloth would get into serious difficulties by the mixing of yarns and the probable deterioration of the reputation for quality of the mills in respect of their woollen cloths. In any case, if there is a desire that that cloth should be made available for ready-made suits here and that the duty should be payable, the difference in price is 6d. or 7d., and I think we can risk the imposition of that duty upon people who desire that particular type of suit, in order to avoid the very great disadvantage, which the price exemption had in the old duty, a disadvantage in fact, amounting, to a very considerable extent, to a complete reversal of the duty.

Comment on this

Oh, no; what percentage came in?

Comment on this

By far the bulk of the percentage. Well over 80 per cent. of the cloth was imported duty free.

Comment on this

Came in duty free? I do not know where the Minister got that figure.

Comment on this

Yes; the figures are available in the Shipping Statistics.

Comment on this

I mean the percentage the Minister gives and not the value.

Comment on this

From 1/10 per square yard up, the Irish mills will, this year, supply the woollen manufacturers in all wool cloth. Heretofore, the cheaper grades of cloth were only made in some mills and other mills concentrated on the production of the higher grades, but, in consequence of certain requests made to them, every mill in the country is engaging in the production of cheap cloth, so that it will be available to the ready-made clothing manufacturers, and the variety, design and price will range over all wool cloth, and, by that, I mean, cloth made in part from reclaimed wool from 1/10 per square yard up, that is 2/8 per trade yard. The bulk of the requirements in the ready-made clothing industry has been for cloth of about 3/6 per trade yard, and the entire requirements of the industry will be supplied by Irish mills this year. The duty, therefore, seems to me to be one completely justifiable and the increase of the duty in respect of cloths in the higher grade is, in my opinion, justifiable also. The mills here are quite capable of supplying all the needs, but, as Deputies opposite know, there are certain trade connections, as a result of which importations of dutiable cloth have been continued. Quite a number of merchants buying even the product of the Irish mills, buy it through English warehouses, and the trade connections that have persisted in consequence of that arrangement, have meant that there has been a fairly considerable importation of dutiable cloth. The increase in duty was intended to stop that and to secure the entire trade for that better class of cloth to the Irish mills, which are quite capable of dealing with it.

Comment on this

Might I ask the Minister whether he would consider the desirability—I am raising this point for the two thousandth time—of suggesting to the Irish woollen manufacturers the establishment of a central spinning factory in this country?

Comment on this

We can discuss that at another stage. This must be disposed of before 2 o'clock and there is no time for side issues.

Comment on this

Before the amendment is put I think the only thing to be done at this stage is for those who have amendments down not to move any further amendments, except, of course, the Minister's amendments, and that certain of them could be moved on Report Stage. Some of them that are down now need not be moved, and some, perhaps, which are alternatives will not need to be put down on Report Stage. Where there are alternatives, one might do, but there is one part of the Bill which, I think, a lot of people want to discuss—the maize meal section. There is no amendment down to that, but I think an amendment could be put down for Report, even although it is not down now, in order to allow the section to be passed and to have a fair opportunity of discussing it on Report Stage.

Comment on this

I do not wish to be unreasonable, but I understood that an agreement was made that all these amendments would be disposed of by two o'clock.

Comment on this

But not that the Stage would be given.

Comment on this

The mere giving of the Committee Stage without disposing of the amendments is of little advantage.

Comment on this

That was never contemplated. It was intended to dispose of as many amendments as possible, but giving up the right to discuss points that can only be discussed on amendments was never contemplated, but, of course, we have not very much time for these things. The point was whether we were going to give the Stage, and give as many of the amendments as possible, but there are certain amendments that really must be discussed, because the points that arise on them cannot be dealt with in any other way.

Comment on this

Last night, the Minister pointed out that, as this was to be concluded by two o'clock to-day, it was not wise to spend too much time at a particular thing.

Comment on this

We do not want to hear the Deputy.

Comment on this

What does the Deputy mean by saying that he does not want to hear me? He will have to hear me whether he likes it or not.

Comment on this

Order, order!

Comment on this

And that applies to Deputy McGilligan, too.

Comment on this

At this point, I want to say that I was definitely informed by our Whips that this agreement involved the disposal of these amendments before 2 o'clock. This is the second time that an agreement of that kind was destroyed by the postponement of amendments to Report Stage and it seems to me that we will have to get a very clear idea of what arrangements are made.

Comment on this

There was never any arrangement to dispose of all the amendments. We agreed to take the Stage and, naturally, that means taking as many amendments as possible.

Comment on this

I was the last person who spoke to the Government Whip yesterday and I said it was my hope that nine-tenths of the amendments would be got through at this stage.

Amendment put and division challenged.

Comment on this

Is this going to mean that we are not to get the Government amendments?

Comment on this

In order that there may be time to move all the Government amendments we propose not to divide on this amendment.

Amendment negatived.

Comment on this

I move amendments 34, 35 and 36:

34. Before sub-section (3), page 7, to insert a new sub-section as follows:

"(3) The provisions of Section 8 of the Finance Act, 1919, shall apply to the duty imposed by this section with the substitution of the expression "Saorstát Eireann" for the expression "Great Britain and Ireland" and as though the articles chargeable with the said duty were included in the Second Schedule to that Act in the list of goods to which two-thirds of the full rate is made applicable as a preferential rate."

35. In sub-section (3), page 7, line 7, after the word "tailors" to insert the words "or for use in the upholstering of furniture or vehicles."

36. To add to the end of the section on page 7 a new sub-section as follows:—

"(5) Whenever it is shown to the satisfaction of the Revenue Commissioners that any woven tissue imported into Saorstát Eireann and chargeable with the duty imposed by this section was manufactured in and exported from Saorstát Eireann and has since such exportation undergone the process of shrinking and no other process of manufacture, Section 6 of the Customs and Inland Revenue Act, 1879, shall apply to such woven tissue notwithstanding that it has undergone outside Saorstát Eireann such process of shrinking."

Section 9, as amended, ordered to stand part of the Bill.

Section 10 and 11 ordered to stand part of the Bill.

SECTION 12.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 40:—

In sub-section (3), page 8, line 56, after the word "duty" to insert the words "as fruit shall continue to be chargeable with duty."

Comment on this

I move:—

42. Before sub-section (5), on page 10, to insert a new sub-section as follows:—

"(5) If it appears to the satisfaction of the Minister for Finance, in consultation with the Minister for Industry and Commerce, that any article or class of articles mentioned in paragraph 4 of the Third Schedule to this Act and chargeable with duty at the rate mentioned in that paragraph is suitable for use in the making of motor car bodies in Saorstát Eireann and is not manufactured in Saorstát Eireann, the Revenue Commissioners may by licence authorise subject to compliance with such conditions as they think fit to impose and shall specify in such licence, the importation of such article or class of articles without payment of duty."

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 79:—

In paragraph 4, page 13, line 43, to delete the word "or" where it secondly occurs and substitute the word "of."

Comment on this