Additional Financial Motions by the Minister for Finance. - Finance Bill, 1932—Committee.
Contributions 189–377 of 377. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
No. 11 of 1932 ›
The introduction of these words, I submit, leaves this liability on the executor, that if a return is wrong he may have to prove that it was made to the best of his knowledge and belief. Is not that therefore the point that arises under this section?
Comment on this
I do not know. I think that is different from the position previously. Now he is obliged to make a return to the best of his knowledge and belief. The man may be acting quite honestly, but if he makes what is a wrong return has he not thereby incurred the necessity for proving that he did not make a wrong return?
Comment on this
Is it not rather for the State to prove that the case the man made was or was not made to the best of his knowledge and belief?
Comment on this
Is it to be the practice that for the future the onus will be on the taxpayer or executor?
Comment on this
I would say it will ultimately become a matter for the courts, but I think at present the onus would be on the taxpayer. He would be liable for the penalty if the return were not made to the best of his knowledge and belief. I think as a matter of abstract justice the onus would be upon the Revenue Commissioners to prove that it was not made to the best of his knowledge and belief.
Comment on this
I am glad that the Minister agrees that as a matter of abstract justice the onus should be on the Revenue Commissioners. Will the Minister introduce an amendment to that effect on the Report Stage? The Minister has talked about the principle of abstract justice and Deputy Moore thinks that on the principle of abstract justice it would be quite unreasonable to ask the taxpayer, that is, the executor in this case, to bear the onus of proof. I want Deputy Moore and the Minister to collaborate and to find out whether in fact the onus of proof is to be upon the executor, and will they make the far-reaching alteration in the income tax code embodying that change, one which they have characterised as a principle of abstract justice? I would have thought that this came under a completely different rule, where things are supposed to be within the knowledge of those who are supposed to sustain the burden of proof.
Comment on this
Let me leave that point, for it is one that we will have to raise on the Report Stage. I want to ask the Minister a simple question again. Section (2) of the new Rule 18 makes no change in the law—the Minister said that. Would he say that again?
Comment on this
It makes no change in the existing practice, that is that assessments are not made later than three years after the year of death.
Comment on this
That it makes no change in the existing practice, is what the Minister is taking refuge in now?
Comment on this
Sub-section (2) makes no change in the law in any other respect. Will the Minister say if he thinks it has had any other relation?
Comment on this
I want to see if there is any change. I am told there is no change as regards the time limit. I was criticised for my lack of intelligence for not understanding the Minister's implications. Is there not something more than time in this? Surely there is a wider scope.
Comment on this
Has this any relation to No. 1 of the new Regulations? Clearly it has. It is clearly making no change in the law. Therefore the time relation is now extended to a new type of person. Is not that a fact?
Comment on this
I am sorry that has not been clear to the Deputy. I think it is clear to everybody else but to the Deputy.
Comment on this
I am asking permission of the House to move amendments 5, 8 and 11 together as they are on the very same point. The point is a simple one and I think it can be explained briefly. The matter was raised here at an early stage of this Bill as to what was going to happen to a person who was going to be assessed on the new basis with regard to rent from business premises, business premises being defined as in the section. A special point was made as to what alleviation of the hardship was going to be if hardship arises by reason of this fact that a man might be assessed for rent payable to him whereas he may not receive the rent for a variety of reasons (1) the person who was renting the premises from him might have fled, or might have departed before the rent was due, (2) the person who had rented the premises from the owner might have become defunct in a business sense before the rent accrued, or apart from business default of the average type a person may find himself unable to pay. There are a considerable number of situations clear to anybody who considers the vicissitudes of business life which might bring it about that the owner of the premises might not receive the rent payable and "payable" is the word used. I want to get that point raised and I want to see if some amendment cannot be phrased to meet the point.
Comment on this
It is not sufficient at all. Amendment No. 9 is not sufficient but that can be discussed when the amendment is moved. I want the Bill to say precisely in all these cases not the rent payable but the rent paid. In other words where this new income tax has been put upon the owners of business premises I want to see that they should be assessed upon the actual money which they receive as rent for these premises and not upon what they might receive. It might be said that this might lead to fraud and that there would be collusion between the occupier and the owner and that something less than the rent fixed might be paid and that the owner would get off something; that there could be an arrangement between himself and the occupier which would make it profitable for both. The ordinary law would meet that situation. The question of fraud would clearly arise. In the two points referred to, I am moving that the word "payable" should be substituted by "paid" or "actually paid." Amendment No. 8 is where I want to get the phrase to read "the person receiving such rent." That is slightly a different point from the others, but it has afforded an apprehension of the same inadequate situation arising. The person actually in receipt of the rent may not be the person entitled to the rent. If there is going to be in the peculiar circumstances that might arise any differentiation then the assessment might be made upon the person actually entitled to receive the rent.
Comment on this
Will the Deputy who puts the amendment tell the House how he reconciles the principle which it proposes to introduce here with the general basis which has hitherto been adopted for income-tax purposes, which has always had regard to the income earned or receivable in a particular year, irrespective of whether it was received in that year or not? That is one of the problems which the Deputy's amendment raises. I should like him to state how he reconciles the new principle which he proposes to introduce in this amendment with the general basis upon which the Income Tax Acts and law has hitherto rested.
Comment on this
I would answer, if I had the quotation handy, by referring to what the Minister said was the revenue practice. The revenue practice departed from what was the actual rigid terminology used in the Act and, in fact, where rent was not received because of default of a business type that was taken into consideration. If that is the practice I do not see where we are departing from it very much in making the law fit the practice which has grown up contrary to the law because of the very inequities which have occurred.
Comment on this
The Deputy said that amendment 9, which was proposed to meet the particular case to which he has referred, did not satisfy him, that he is casting his net wider. I should like him to say how wide he is casting it, and how the attitude which he takes up in that regard can be reconciled with the existing practice, which was always the practice under his Government.
Comment on this
I have been asked how I reconcile this with a certain principle. My reconciliation is that the principle was not observed in practice; that my amendment is nearer the practice than the law. I want to bring them into consonance. The Minister refers me to his amendment. All I can say about his amendment is that it clearly shows that he is not disposed to stick to the principle he has attempted to put me up against. He is going to make certain exceptions. Why? Because the practice has shown that the rigidity of the law was impossible. The Minister is, to a certain extent, proposing to make the law fit the practice. I object that it does not go far enough.
Comment on this
Possibly Deputy Thrift might have something to say in support of Deputy McGilligan in the matter.
Comment on this
Really, I would prefer to accept the Minister's suggestion. I should like Deputy McGilligan to show his reason for not thinking amendment 9 is acceptable. I drafted an amendment on the same lines from a totally different angle. It was to enable the recovery of tax which failed under the previous Act, because the collection of this was passed from Schedule A to Schedule D. I am inclined to think that the amendment I have drafted is the best way of meeting the situation, but I am not going to move it in view of the Minister's amendment.
Comment on this
My amendment has been drafted to meet the point raised by Deputy Thrift—to make it quite clear, so that there will be no doubt in the matter.
Comment on this
I think it is up to Deputy McGilligan to show us why he thinks this amendment goes further than the amendment suggested by the Minister?
Comment on this
I want to be clear-cut and definite on this. We were told by the Minister who left the principle in the early stages that, in fact, the points made from this side of the House, and by some Independent Deputies, were to a certain extent covered by the practice.
Comment on this
We are discussing Deputy McGilligan's amendment and not what I said; at least, I hope we are.
Comment on this
I can discuss whatever I please as long as it is relevant, and I am not going to have the Minister as the ruler of order in the House, by any means. The Minister has himself asked me to say why his amendment is insufficient. I thought that was the point. Now he asks me to discuss my own amendment. If the Minister has to carry on on certain financial injections from time to time he ought to get them more frequently in order not to have confusion of thought. If the dope does not carry him far enough, let him get them stronger, or take them more frequently. I said previously that the Minister answered certain points made by saying that the principles upon which we were founding certain objections were being observed in practice by the Revenue Commissioners.
Comment on this
To this extent, that if the debt were a bad debt, and the rents were not collectable, of course the Revenue Commissioners would make the usual allowance for bad debts, as they do in all businesses.
Comment on this
We were told the Commissioners have a certain practice, but just how far it went was not explained by the Minister for a very obvious reason, because he did not know. I decided to put down an amendment which would make it clear in one respect that there could be no attempt to get from a man payments in regard to rent except in regard to rent which he actually received, and, as I said, if there were a more satisfactory way of meeting that case—there might be collusion, and that argument might be made against it—I am prepared to get phraseology for it. We were told that the practice was in accordance with the law. I want to have the law changed so that people will not be depending upon the practice of the Revenue Commissioners, but will have legal rights to assert embodied in certain phraseology. The Minister proposed to add certain exceptions, to add at a particular point that deductions shall be made "for any portion of such rent wholly and irrecoverably lost, for any portion of such rent voluntarily forgone by agreement with the occupier,"—and then the thing follows as before. I think there is still a certain amount of leaning against the man being assessed. We are going to have the assessment made. The procedure under the Minister's amendment will be that there is a rent payable out of business premises as defined and an assessment will be made. Certain correspondence or an interview will take place after that, and then the Revenue Commissioners may make deductions or make allowances in respect of certain things. I think it is a more clear-cut thing to have the word "paid" used. Let it be the word "paid" or the word suggested in the course of the debate previously, "received." I should say that nine-tenths of the annoyance caused, particularly by income tax collections, arises not so much in the end from the amount collected as from the annoyance, trouble, correspondence and interviews that have to be gone through to get to the point of what truly has to be paid.
Anything that is going to alleviate the lot of the taxpayer in getting something clearly before him as to what he is to pay in the end is a thing that ought to be sympathetically considered. When you say "rent paid" it seems to me that the evidence that a man has to produce on that is an easily produced thing. There is a receipt for rent; there is clear evidence to be given of moneys received. I want to found the whole thing on that. My intention was, not so much to get reduced payments, although that is at the back of the amendment, as to get rid of all this terrific trouble that one has to go through with regard to proof of evidence and all the rest in connection with payments of this type. Again to get back to what the Minister said: Why introduce a new item away from the principle of the income-tax code? The Minister himself is going away from it.
Comment on this
The practice has gone away from it and the amendment that has been suggested shows the inclination to go away from it. I think it is quite right to go away from it when you are putting on a new tax. If this were simply continuing the old system which people had got inured to by years of experience, then a case might be made against it. I think that the equities of the situation, with this new tax, a thing not previously considered, are that the man will pay and should only be asked to pay upon the rent paid to him, the rent received by him. We can leave out the smaller points at the moment as to whether he is the person entitled to receive or the person actually in receipt of the money. The point is that we should get him to pay on the money received.
Comment on this
My sole objection to the Minister's amendment is connected with the use of the words "wholly or irrecoverably lost." I can envisage a taxpayer upon whom an assessment is made and who has received no rent at all in that year. The rent is not coming in. He has got nothing from it at all, but still it might be quite in the air as to whether he might be able to recover some portion of the rent in future or not. He would be undoubtedly liable under the Minister's amendment for tax and he would have to pay it. Events might prove that the rent was completely lost and I do not see how he could recover from the income tax authorities the income tax he had to pay. In principle I would accept the Minister's amendment, though as I said I do not think it is the right way of going about it. I do see that difficulty of working it, that at the time of making the assessment on the taxpayer it might be impossible to say whether the rent is wholly or irrecoverably lost or to what extent it is wholly or irrecoverably lost.
Comment on this
I regret that Deputy McGilligan was not more precise. I do wish he had told us what gap was left uncovered by the amendment down in my name. The amendment provides that no assessment will be made "for any portion of such rent wholly and irrecoverably lost, for any portion of such rent voluntarily forgone by agreement with the occupier." I am sorry that Deputy McGilligan did not state explicitly what was the gap left uncovered by that. I am sorry that he did not address himself in greater detail to the matter and state how he reconciled the new principle that his amendment would introduce into the income tax law and the existing practice. The existing practice and the general principles adopted for income tax purposes is to take the income receivable in a particular year irrespective of whether the income is actually received in that year or not. It is the only fair way, because if we were to take into consideration the actual income received in a year, we might find that, owing to the fact that debtors delay in settling their accounts, whereas in one year a person might possibly pay income tax at a low rate, in the next year when trade was good and times were better and the debtors floated in to settle, the taxpayer might possibly be assessed for surtax. It is that principle which Deputy McGilligan proposes to introduce in this amendment.
It is because in certain circumstances Deputy McGilligan's amendment might make an income tax payer be assessed at a greater rate of tax than is provided that I am going to suggest to you, a Leas-Chinn Comhairle, that the amendment is out of order. We will take the case of a taxpayer who enjoys a rental of £1,200 a year from business premises and £200 per annum from other sources, his total income being £1,400 per annum. Under Deputy McGilligan's amendment it might possibly happen that a taxpayer who hitherto had promptly received his rents quarterly in advance, in a certain year would only receive £900 per annum. The taxpayer continued to enjoy the £200 which he had from other sources. In that particular year that taxpayer would be assessed under Deputy McGilligan's amendment on an income of £1,100, but his tenant was an honest tenant and in the succeeding year he paid up his five quarters' rent. He paid up the quarter which was in arrears and paid the other four quarters in advance. That is to say he paid in that year £1,500 and the taxpayer still continued to enjoy his £200 per annum from other sources. He is in that year assessed not merely for income tax, but under Sections 1 and 2 of the Bill which have been adopted by the House he is liable, as his income is over £1,500, for surtax. Therefore this amendment of Deputy McGilligan, prepared with so much care and with so much consideration, would impose an additional burden upon that taxpayer and can therefore only be moved from the Government Benches. I suggest, a Leas-Chinn Comhairle, that that is out of order.
Comment on this
Is the Minister putting forward that suggestion seriously at this stage of the discussion after the House has been discussing the amendment for something like 20 minutes?
Comment on this
Even so I am entitled to make the point that in certain circumstances, in the circumstances which I have outlined, the amendment imposes an additional burden on the taxpayer and is therefore out of order.
Comment on this
I was hoping that Deputy McGilligan would accept amendment No. 9. I asked him to state precisely what was uncovered by amendment Number 9. If he had shown that there was any reasonable way to meet him in regard to the difficulties which he alleged were present in amendment No. 9 I would have endeavoured to meet him but he did not do that. I was anxious to give him that opportunity.
Comment on this
Although Deputy McGilligan did what he did in regard to amendment 9 it would not affect the amendment being moved.
Comment on this
Whether I raised my objection at the beginning, or now, I contend I am entitled, at any stage of the debate, to make the point that the amendment is out of order. I do make it in view of the fact that no additional burden such as the amendment imposes can be imposed upon the people except moved by a member of the Government.
Comment on this
On the point of its imposing an additional burden we have no definite proof. The Minister used the word "may." He was very explicit. I took a note of the figures and I say we have no definite proof that it would raise the burden.
Comment on this
I understand that. But there is no proof before the House that it will increase the burden and the Minister has said definitely that it may.
Comment on this
Is the Minister to be allowed to pile up one ludicrous hypothesis upon another and deduce from that that the tax may increase the burden upon the taxpayer?
Comment on this
The ingenuity of the Minister is naturally directed to weaving these impossible hypotheses so that he can come along and ask to have matters ruled out of order.
Comment on this
I have no option whatever but to rule the amendment in order. It is merely hypothesis that the Minister has put forward. This matter should have been raised before the amendment came on for discussion. The point is pure hypothesis and nothing further. I rule the amendment in order.
Comment on this
I suggest I am in order in contending that the amendment would, in certain circumstances, impose a tax upon the people.
Comment on this
I want to ask the Minister if he would refer to the point about the words "irrecoverably lost." At the time when the tax is levied it might be impossible to say that.
Comment on this
I do not know what exactly the Deputy is getting at. If it seems clear to the Revenue Commissioners that the money is lost beyond reasonable hope of recovery the tax will be allowed to stand over in that case, but there would be no question of remitting the tax. In the circumstances I have related to the House, the better thing would be that the tax should be allowed to stand over rather than that a new assessment should be made, when the taxpayer would recover money that seemed irrecoverable.
Comment on this
Supposing for the sake of argument the matter was dependent upon the result of an action at law. The owner of the property may say: "I have no hope of winning this action; I may lose it." Would the Revenue Commissioners have power in that case?
Comment on this
They could allow the tax to stand over. They would not attempt to collect. They always have power to afford time where the collection would impose hardship.
Comment on this
We had a discussion upon the matter raised in my amendment in the Financial Resolutions that were before us. Clearly it is a difficult matter to settle, in the case of a premises partially used for professional purposes, such as the consulting room for a doctor or a barrister, what value should be put on the part of the house used for that purpose, as distinct from the dwelling-house. It seems to me the best plan would be to insert the words "or solely for the purpose." That is to say you would avoid having to decide what valuation should be put upon one room if that room is used for a professional purpose as against the rest of the premises used as a dwelling house.
Comment on this
I am afraid I could not accept this amendment. I think it is of much wider implication than the Deputy has in mind. It would, for instance, have the effect of taking outside the operation of the section each office building, a small portion of which is sublet and used residentially, and it would naturally encourage such sub-letting because it would have that effect——
Comment on this
There is the fear. Also, as the amendment is phrased, the courts would hold that the section did not operate in the case of office buildings or blocks of offices occupied by several professional men, on the ground that the section as amended applied only to premises used solely for the purpose of one profession or vocation. Apart altogether from that, the adoption of the amendment in my opinion would lead to a considerable loss of duty proportionately. Any office building of which any portion was sublet for residential purposes, so far as I can see, would come under the terms of this amendment, and would be exempt from the operations of the section, and the courts might conceivably hold that even if there were no sub-letting for residential purposes the office should be used solely for one profession or vocation.
Comment on this
I think the Minister has misunderstood my suggestion because my words do not touch trade at all. Office buildings would be in exactly the same position as in the Bill if my amendment were accepted. I think any premises let for trade purposes as premises would still be liable. The words I propose to introduce are "solely for the purpose of any profession or vocation." I do not think there is much revenue involved at all, but the difficulty is very real. Take the case of a house in which one room is let as a doctor's consulting room. The doctor is interested as to the amount of the estimated value of the room, the landlord is interested, and the Revenue Commissioners are concerned because of the revenue. I do not see how you can at all get an agreement between these two parties as to what value should be put upon that particular room. There certainly will be a great deal of inconvenience, discussion and correspondence in arriving at the value. That seems to be the end to which the section leads. I do not think it is worth while, for the sake of the small amount of revenue that would arise, to introduce that very complicated matter to arrive at the valuation.
Comment on this
Would it be possible to have amendment 7 discussed at the same time? They are very much the same. I think it would shorten the whole procedure.
Comment on this
I take objection to the amendment moved by Deputy Thrift because of the answer he has given to the Minister, who misunderstood the object of his amendment. This whole thing would be very much more easily debated if we understood what is in the mind of the Minister on the scope of this. What does he intend to catch? Further we have the answer that he made, in rather a hesitating way, on a previous day. In answer to Deputy Good he said he understood there was a provision under the valuation law to assess the valuation of a shop separately from the residential portion of a premises and he said that might come into force here. If there was an assurance that it would come into force here a lot of this objection might be met.
Comment on this
In one of the Greater Dublin Bills there is a proviso whereby offices were separately valued for the purpose of the franchise.
Comment on this
I am only quoting the Minister—that there is a provision under the valuation law which may come into force here to assess the shops separately from the residential portion of premises. If that was meant to be established somewhere or other under this Bill as the practice and procedure, then the matter is very simple, but the matter is only simple if we get an answer from the Minister previously as to what he intends to catch. He founded his arguments almost entirely on premises used for the purpose of trade, and on the contention that in the case of premises used for trade purposes a man should pay not upon valuation, but upon the actual amount received. There would be considerable agreement as to that, but when he goes into the wider field of profession or vocation, the Minister takes as an objection to Deputy Thrift's amendment, that if you imagine a big building used for offices, and if one portion were sub-let for residential purposes, then the whole building might be deemed to be excluded for this tax. Surely that does not arise under Deputy Thrift's amendment because he leaves out the phrase "occupied for the purpose of any trade." Whatever was the force originally intended Deputy Thrift's amendment does not interfere with it.
Comment on this
Yes, for professional purposes. So far as the trade side is concerned Deputy Thrift's point has no interaction on the particular point of view. Surely that must be agreed to? So far as the use of buildings for the purpose of trade is concerned the full meaning is still there, and is not affected by Deputy Thrift's amendment. He has proposed to put in these phrases after the word "trade," and he does not say "a profession or trade" but "any profession or trade." Take a suite of offices and say that one is let for the purpose of a profession, and that that might get the whole premises excluded. I do not know that it would. I do not know what he is founding his argument upon when the phrase used by the Deputy is "solely for the purpose of any" profession or vocation. Surely, if you had a different number of businesses of the trade type in an office, the trade phase would override every other phase, and the building still stands for tax as long as there is a trade being carried on in it. If not, then we are getting back to the business of different valuations for different portions of premises and, of course, if so, it is very equitable—it is very definitely to be regarded as equitable in that case. I never proposed to remove the provision that a building occupied for the purpose of any trade, or profession, should be liable, but we should clearly understand what is meant. I do not know what the definition of "profession" or "vocation" is likely to be extended to cover. "Profession" may have a fairly well defined meaning as far as law is concerned, but with regard to "vocation" I doubt very much, and I do not know if there is anywhere in the income tax code any real definition of these two words. I think in the end it comes to whatever the Commissioners like.
That is my first difficulty. The second difficulty I have in the matter is with regard to the mixed premises. It is becoming the practice in this town that, instead of as under the old custom both medical men and lawyers lived near the centre of the city, nowadays they have a room, or rooms, in premises in or near the heart of the city, and they live somewhat more often than previously outside the city boundary. I want to know whether if a doctor has a room in a house in one of the main centres of the city, and the remainder of the house is being used for a residence,—I want to know whether the fact that a couple of rooms are being used for a profession overrides the general quality of the house, and whether the whole house will be assessed. Supposing a doctor rents a whole house, as he may have to in some cases, and pays the rent on the whole house to the owner, and uses a room or two rooms for consulting purposes, is the owner going to be made pay on the whole rent received or is there going to be a division or an apportionment as between the rooms used for the purpose of a profession and the upstairs portion which may be regarded as residential? I think it is quite a common feature at present that the upper rooms in such cases are let in flats, and that the rest of the premises, the two rooms on the ground floor, are used for consulting purposes. Supposing the house is in possession of one man and the doctor is paying rent for the whole premises, is he going to be assessed on the whole lot? If not, I would find it easy enough to accept the phrase, if we could have the word "vocation" defined. The scope should not be too far flung. The Minister, during the early stage, said that he did not think that any of these peculiar cases would arise in the course of the present year, because he said there would be practical difficulty in getting the new proposals into operation. I suggest that it would be a good thing to leave the simple form for this year to premises used for the purpose of any trade, and if he can see arising out of the experience of the operation of this tax this year, any easy way of extending it to the mixed premises, then it might be made a proposal next year. But particularly as he says there are practical difficulties in the way will it not be much simpler to have the tax simplified—to have it applied only to trade and let the other things arise later?
Comment on this
If the Deputy will, at this stage, accept No. 9, I shall consider what he and Deputy Thrift have said in relation to amendments 6 and 7.
Comment on this
If he will agree to withdraw these amendments now, he can put them down for Report Stage if he is not satisfied with the amendment which I shall consider, but which I am not promising to introduce.
Comment on this
I believe that Deputy McGilligan's suggestion is better than my own. I was specially concerned with those premises used for mixed purposes—mainly as a private residence but partially for professional purposes by a doctor or somebody else.
Comment on this
I move amendment 9:—
9. In sub-section (1), line 30, after the word "made" to insert the words "for any portion of such rent wholly and irrecoverably lost, for any portion of such rent voluntarily forgone by agreement with the occupier, and"
Comment on this
I move amendment 10:—
In sub-section (1), line 37, after the word "rent" to add the words "For the purposes of this rule the term ‘maintenance' shall include replacement of the whole or any part of the premises where the replacement is reasonably necessary to maintain the existing rent or letting value of the premises; and shall also include additions or improvements to the premises if no increased rent is payable in respect of the additions and improvements; and shall also include all additions and improvements made in order to comply with the provisions of any statute or the regulations, byelaws or requirements of a local or sanitary authority.
For the purposes of this rule the term ‘insurance' shall include in addition to insurance against fire, insurance against storm, tempest, riot and civil commotion and insurance of any life or lives upon the duration of which the tenure of the premises by or the estate or interest therein of the person chargeable depends."
We had some discussion about this matter before. It may be quite true that the term "maintenance" is pretty well understood by the Revenue Commissioners, but I have been making inquiries and I find that there is a good deal of diversity of opinion amongst inspectors as to what is covered by it. I have, therefore, proposed an amendment which embodies several things about which there might be doubt as to whether they should be regarded as ordinary repairs, deductions being allowed in respect of them. The amendment covers, for instance, the replacement of whole or part of premises where the replacement is reasonably necessary to maintain the existing rent or letting value of the premises. That does not mean that any extension or capital outlay will be covered but merely outlay which is necessary to maintain the property at its present value. It is, I think, reasonable to contend that that should be allowed as a maintenance expense. The amendment also includes "additions or improvements to the premises if no increased rent is payable in respect of the additions or improvements." Again, the same point arises. This does not cover capital outlay which will enhance the value of the property. The amendment also covers "all additions and improvements made in order to comply with the provisions of any statute or the regulations, byelaws or requirements of a local or sanitary authority." If a property-owner has to expend money to meet statutory requirements, I think he ought to be allowed to deduct the amount of his outlay from his receipts from the property before he is assessed to income tax on the property. Finally, the amendment provides that "for the purpose of this rule the term ‘insurance' shall include, in addition to insurance against fire, insurance against storm, tempest, riot and civil commotion, and insurance of any life or lives upon the duration of which the tenure of the premises by or the estate or interest therein of the person chargeable depends." I think all the items I have mentioned represent reasonable deductions before the actual income-producing value of the property is arrived at. If they are agreed upon as reasonable deductions, it is much better to have them set out as such in our law than rely on individual interpretation as to what the term "maintenance and repair" means.
Comment on this
I am unable to accept this amendment. The words "maintenance, repair, insurance and management" have a perfectly well understood significance in connection with the assessment of property and provision is made for such an allowance as the Deputy seeks in the case of ordinary Schedule A assessments in rule 8 (5) under the Income Tax Act, of 1918, and other enactments. The allowance there is a fairly generous one. I cannot see how, in this particular case, there is any justification for interpreting the words "maintenance, repair, insurance and management" in a different way from the manner in which they are at present interpreted or how the proposition, that persons in receipt of a particular kind of income which this section seeks to charge, should be given the benefit of a new principle, can be defended. I cannot see that there is, in all the circumstances, a good case made for this amendment, particularly in view of the rule I referred to, which states that if the owner of any land or house to which the rule applies shows that the cost to him of maintenance, repair, insurance and management, according to the average of the preceding five years, has exceeded in the case of a house, one-sixth part of the valuation, he shall be entitled, in addition to any reduction of the assessment for the purpose of the collection, to the repayment of the amount of the tax in excess.
Comment on this
Does the Minister object to the amendment because it claims that certain things ought reasonably to be regarded as repairs or maintenance or because it is unnecessary to specify these things?
Comment on this
Surely the whole basis has been changed and it is not fair to quote what has been done in the past when you are changing the basis and making it dependent on actual profits.
Comment on this
Owing to the fact that in this country the valuation, in a great mass of cases, is lower than it is elsewhere and owing to the fact that the same system does not exist here that exists elsewhere, whereby the valuation is determined at five-year intervals by the actual letting value of the premises, a large number of people have been escaping tax here in respect of income derived from property which they would have had to pay if that income had been derived from any other source. This allowance was considered to be reasonable when income tax came to be imposed and it is a reasonable allowance now. If the owner shows that the cost of maintenance, repairs, insurance and management exceeded in the case of a house one-sixth part of the valuation, he is entitled, in addition to any reduction of the assessment for the purpose of the collection, on making a claim, to a repayment of the amount of the tax in excess. If he shows that the actual amount which he expends exceeds one-sixth of the rateable value of the property, he can come forward and claim the excess. In fact, in present circumstances he has got an allowance for the actual amount he expended on maintenance, repairs, insurance and management. There is not from that point of view very much purpose in the amendment. I think there is not, in any event, any justification for the particular purpose of this amendment, in giving a quite different interpretation to the words "maintenance, repairs, insurance and management" than has been generally adopted hitherto in relation to this question.
Comment on this
One would think from what the Minister has said that I was proposing by the amendment that the property owner should be allowed to deduct the cost of maintenance. That is not so. It is the Minister who is proposing that in the Bill. He proposes that the property owner shall be allowed to deduct the actual cost of maintenance. All I am trying is to show in law what we mean by "maintenance," and to make the meaning in the Minister's Bill clear to the ordinary person, so as to enable him to put in a proper legal claim for such expenditure. I am taking the Minister's own section and explaining what I would regard as a fair interpretation of the word "maintenance." If the Minister suggests any of the things I quoted are not reasonably entitled to be considered "maintenance and repairs" let him argue that, but let him not say that I propose to change the basis.
Comment on this
If the Minister had any experience of maintenance he would know that the claim is always put up.
Comment on this
I move: In sub-section (2), line 25, to delete the words "after the passing of this Act." This amendment introduces a new principle. The object of the amendment is to make the section apply to all stocks and shares that otherwise fall within the conditions set out in the Bill. It seems to me, if we are going to introduce this principle of differentiation in favour of investment in business and in industry in Saorstát Eireann, there is no reason at all for confining the concession to business started, or to investments made after the passing of this Bill. In fact there is a much better case if we are going to differentiate between two classes of investments by reference to time, for giving the concession to investments made before the introduction of the Bill, because in investments made before the introduction of this and other Bills coming before the House people had to take risks that they are not obviously going to take now. I cannot imagine any justification for the section as it stands, in the circumstances in which we find ourselves. We have high tariffs, in fact, prohibitive tariffs, imposed, and we have proposals in the Control of Manufactures Bill which are so extensive in industries that could not be called manufactures, that they are going to cut out competition. Therefore, the person investing hereafter, so far as the Government can do it, invests with the certainty of being able to make exorbitant profits from the consumer, and on these exorbitant profits he is going to pay less income tax than the man who invested money when the risks were greater, and who was not in the same position to fleece the taxpayer. If the principle is introduced at all it should be introduced in a general way. It should be possible for residents here, not residents elsewhere, who have incomes from investments in a business carried on only or mainly in the Saorstát, to have this particular relief. I can see no argument that the Minister could possibly put up against that. The argument that he mentioned in certain other cases was that of the cost. I do not know what the cost would be, but I am satisfied, without quoting the document that has been quoted already, that it would be possible in some way to make good the loss occasioned by the adoption of the amendment. In any case the loss in the present year, whatever it would be in subsequent years, would be by no means the loss of the full revenue. I hope the Minister will meet it. It is an unfair provision. I think the passage of the proposal in its present form would have a deleterious effect in certain directions. It is poor recompense to those who took risks. It will possibly lead to a further demand. It may even lead to people in certain directions making claims for greater concessions. I can quite well imagine people in certain cases holding off from investing in the hope that agitation for bigger concessions will be successful.
Comment on this
Is it permissible to refer to the general principle of the section on this amendment?
Comment on this
I join with Deputy Blythe in asking the Minister to consider the amendment, and I would like to draw his attention to one aspect that has not been presented. This section proposes to give preference to persons who invest in certain Irish securities. I suggest to the Minister that that exclusive benefit to enterprise floated after the passing of this Budget will have this effect. There will be a great many people—Nationals of this State— who, in the ordinary course of commercial affairs, will feel a certain reluctance to holding themselves out before the public as looking for favours of this character. The average man who is going to stake his capital in Ireland in business enterprise is not going to be greatly influenced by this concession. If a man is going to run a successful business he is not going to be induced to do so by the concessions that are offered but, to the fraud, and to the fellow who is a failure, this is the very kind of inducement that will draw him into the promotion market. I think the only result of this preference will be to induce persons, who, in their very nature have not got the material for success, into commercial ventures. I think the Minister should reconsider the matter. Already I know of certain persons actually engaged in making preparations for the floating of a company, and far from being encouraged to do so by this section, they find themselves in a certain predicament, because, regarding their proposition as commercially sound, they feel that they require no inducement of this character.
I do ask the Minister to consider whether he does not think that this kind of concession will be more a temptation to a company promoter than it will to the businessman who really means business and who has confidence in his ability to carry on successfully. The other matter has been mentioned, and I think it should not be lost sight of, that it does seem rather odd that companies which have overcome the various difficulties that they encountered when the State was being founded and set on its way should now be penalised in favour of those who were not prepared to take the risks they did. I do not want to labour that question. It has been already dwelt on in the early stages of the Bill and Deputy Blythe has referred to it now, but we cannot shut our eyes to the fact that this section calls on those who staked their money on the success of this State to shoulder a burden in order to relieve others who preferred to wait and who required inducements to come into the commercial life of this country, and, without which inducements, they preferred to keep their money invested abroad when they knew perfectly well that the State was badly in need of its assistance. I think that is a regrettable procedure altogether, but if that does not affect the Minister, I do seriously ask him to consider whether he believes that this procedure will influence anybody whom he would wish to see in the commercial life of this country into making a venture he would not otherwise make.
Comment on this
I will support this amendment. To a large extent, the original intention behind this concession was to encourage and to invite capital into this country. I presume that those who are in the position to make use of this concession or who would be influenced to bring money into the Free State by reason of this concession are, at this time, watching very carefully the industrial conditions in the countries in which they have their money invested, and when their investments to a very large extent have sunk so low, this concession in itself would be very little attraction indeed. What the majority of these investors are waiting for is a revival in the shares in which they have their money, a revival which they are hoping will come about sooner or later. Hence, if capital is not only to be retained but attracted here, it would seem to me that Deputy Blythe's amendment is one which should receive consideration, as obviously, if a revival does take place in shares or investments outside this country, people who have stood by and are willing to stand by the State will take advantage of that revival, if they have not got some good counter investment to interest them at home.
Comment on this
The acceptance of this amendment is impossible. It would cost us in its present form £500,000 per annum.
Comment on this
The greater part of this year. It would cost a very large sum and, taking that in conjunction with the amendment which Deputy Mulcahy has down, it would cost us a very large sum and a sum much larger than we could contemplate. I am not going to say that the Government are forever ruling out the possibility of giving effect to the principle contained in Deputy Blythe's amendment, but we are making a start, because our purpose is, so far as we can, to make new Irish investments more attractive than they have hitherto been. Deputy Blythe is aware that, on former occasions, perfectly sound propositions were put before the Irish public and they could not attract the necessary capital. We are hoping that sound propositions will be put before them in the near future by men of business initiative, of capacity and enthusiasm. Because it happens to be the case in this country that the man without capital will have to raise capital from the public, we have introduced this amendment with the idea of making these new capital issues more attractive. It does not represent the ultimate aim of the Government in any way. The aim of this Government will be to make Irish investments henceforward, as soon as resources permit, definitely more attractive from the investor's point of view. We can only make a beginning and we are making it in this way, the most economical way possible and the way in which the cost to the Exchequer will be measured by the success of the inducements which are offered. If we were to try any other way, we would find it, at the present stage, much too expensive, and, as I have said, we feel in addition to the other inducements we are giving to Irish manufacturers now, we must also make it easier for them to secure the capital necessary to finance new undertakings. The history of the country has been hitherto that quite a number of what were sound undertakings were not financed by our own people, and the only reason is that they did not think the returns likely to be offered were sufficient. We are putting in this inducement—it may not be very much, but it is, at any rate, something and it is the best the Government in its present circumstances can do.
Comment on this
The Minister has just said that he is making a start. I would like to point out that what he is making a start at doing is to help one set of business men at the expense of another set of business men. There is a man in business for a number of years which could legitimately be described by the Minister as one of these sound propositions put before the public, for which money was not refused, but in which money was invested. That business has been in operation for a number of years, and now a rival business may be set up and the existing business in that way damaged. That is the encouragement that is given, or, at least, that is an example of governmental action, so far as business in this country is concerned. There has been in the course of these debates a great deal of talk about competition, and we have been told that the imposition of tariffs and the various measures taken by the Government will not diminish healthy competition within the country, but here we have the Government stepping in and deliberately loading the dice, so to speak, in favour of one set of competitors and against another set of competitors. That is really what the Government is making a beginning at doing—damaging firms already in existence, firms that were, as the Minister might describe them, sound propositions and into which Irish money has been put. These are to be put at a disadvantage so far as their Irish competitors are concerned. That may, with some other inducement— whether it will or not remains to be seen—induce people to invest capital, but there is involved in that a lightheartedness in dealing with investments and making discrimination between different people, even in the same industry, that will probably frighten more people off than the concession itself will induce to come in and put money into enterprise of this kind. For that reason, the Minister has it open to him either to drop the section or accept an amendment of this kind. I suggest it is not merely almost immoral, but it is certainly economically unsound in principle, to make discrimination of this kind between competitors in the same market, all of them Irish competitors.
Comment on this
There has been no reasoned answer given to this amendment. I want to get this thrown into a slightly different setting from that in which it has been presented up to date. The whole aim of Section 7 is to give relief to investors in Saorstát Eireann securities. In a sense this is a complement to the Control of Manufactures Bill. I suggest it should entirely take the place of that Bill. When we were discussing that piece of legislation I asked the Minister if he had any examples of legislation successfully operating in any country under which the discretion as to whether a business firm should be allowed to come into a country or not is left entirely with one Minister. I got no answer to that. I did get a reference in a rather offhand and diffident way to countries where certain other types of legislation prevail. I suggested that the Minister would find in other countries, particularly in Europe, that there was a certain discrimination made by way of taxes; that certain foreign companies had to buy their admission—that there was something in the way of an admission fee, so to speak—and quite a number of countries had adopted the scheme of a tax on sales or turnover.
Having heard the few vague examples the Minister was able to indicate to us as analogous to his proposals, I can say without hesitation that where there has been discrimination against any foreigners it was made by way of increased taxation on the dividends arising from foreign-owned businesses in any country. This is something of an equivalent. If you remit taxation on home-owned securities, clearly it is the same as if the other thing were done. The section introduces a very vicious principle of discrimination which does not pay attention to the conditions under which any man opened a business. The point that is emphasised is the time after the passing of this Act. What renders the investment of securities in this country more virtuous after the passing of the Act than before the passing of the Act? Does the Minister apprehend any great danger in the future that he seeks to counter by this proposal? Does he feel that the tariffs are not sufficient and that he has to hold out some assurance to investors after the passing of this Act?
Let us take the case Deputy Professor O'Sullivan hinted at. Let us say there are two people in the same line of business. One man has been running the business for many years. It was founded in the 'eighties, and it has been carried on, creating an industrial tradition at a time when it was very much harder to create that tradition than even at the moment. Let us assume that man gave employment right up to date and has complied with all the conditions laid down here. To my mind that man is a much more virtuous business man than the man who has waited to invest until he has got all this supposed security by way of tariffs and remissions. I feel that point of security can be overdone and that this may be regarded as a moral from another angle. It is seeking to draw into this country people whom one expects it would be impossible to draw into the country if they had a realisation of the true conditions or the conditions that are likely to operate here before the autumn is over.
What is the point of making this discrimination with regard to the matter of time? The assumption is that before the passing of the Act a business is to be regarded in one way and after the passing of the Act it will be regarded in quite another light. What happens during the period prior to and after the passing of the Act that makes the difference worth a remission of 20 per cent. in the dividends payable? I cannot see it and no point has been made of it. If there is to be any discrimination as between a foreigner and a national in this country the only proper way is by way of taxation. It is the only way in regard to which any number of examples will be found in the countries of the world. It is an easily worked type of discrimination. It is not subject to the whims or fancies of a particular Minister or Government. It is there and the remission is for all to see. They can avail of it if they please or stay away. It is not subject to conditions that the Minister may put in, such as in the matter of controlling manufacturers' licences. It is a thing that advertises itself and cannot be used in a partial way. People come in under it or they do not. Those conditions and terms are open to all comers. If there is to be any inducement to Irish people to invest in Irish businesses or companies it ought to be by way of remission, and it ought to apply to all Irish business no matter when founded.
There is one subsidiary point. The inducement for the future is going to be very strong upon existing companies to close down in order to reopen after a year or two. There is a clause which is supposed to prevent that and to prevent the ordinary buying over of an existing business. A business may go out of operation. It may be worth a big firm's while to close down for a year or two, to save wages and bank moneys in order to restart under new auspices. Quite a number of firms have come to the point where they must readjust their machinery and get in better plant; where they may have to get additions to their buildings. This offers a very definite inducement to them to close down, to come in again with additional plant and to claim the 20 per cent. remission. There is no reason why that dislocation of business should be caused.
This is the only amendment that operates equally as between national and national and as between national and non-citizen. We have had the usual argument that it cannot be afforded. I promised every time that argument was raised I would have to counter it in a particular way. The Minister sits where he is because he promised to reduce taxation here by two millions. That fact cannot be denied. The Minister was a party to the slogan upon which his Party's enthusiasm was raised: "Here is what a Fianna Fáil Government can and will do for you." Two million pounds were to be saved. I am glad that the Minister for Industry and Commerce is here because he was not content with the £2,000,000. He said that £3,000,000 could be saved. Give us the extra million that the Minister for Industry and Commerce is able to get over and beyond what the advertisement was able to do.
Comment on this
It has been said that it cannot be afforded. It can surely be afforded out of the £3,000,000.
Comment on this
It was going to cost half a million, so there is only half a million asked from the people who told us they could save £3,000,000. The matter is relevant for Deputy Little, because he was one of the enthusiasts who believed that £2,000,000 could be saved. He was one of the people who were fooled. He sits there a fooled and deluded man, who backed the Front Bench because they were giving a £2,000,000 reduction in taxation for his people.
Comment on this
I am glad the point of time was raised by Deputy Little, because the point of time was not raised in the advertisement.
Comment on this
I was often wondering what was going to be the answer made on the point about this promised reduction. Was it to be a matter of time because the matter of time was ruled out altogether? "The Estimates for the current year have been examined." That is not referring to next year or the year after. "The Estimates for the current year have been examined and the Fianna Fáil Party was satisfied that economies were feasible to the extent of many hundreds of thousands of pounds," and then went up to £2,000,000. That £2,000,000 did not satisfy the Minister for Industry and Commerce. When he went to Baltinglass he added a million extra. That was promised on the Estimates for the current year and it was promised "without involving hardship upon certain people," and "without taking into account payments that were made and that should not be made under the Treaty." Let the Minister get one-quarter of those economies that were promised and we can get permissions for Irish industries, which are not of the type of discrimination which the Minister has been proposing for them.
Comment on this
I would like to describe, if I could, the pleasure which I feel in listening to Deputy McGilligan explaining why his Party lost the election. For ten years I had the obligation of explaining why the Party to which I belong lost the election and I know how the Deputy feels about it. I hope the Deputy feels——
Comment on this
I hope the Minister feels gracious about this concession. This concession will not cost the Government £500 this year and nobody knows that better than the Minister for Industry and Commerce.
Comment on this
Question:—"That the words proposed to be deleted stand part of the Bill"—put.
Do you agree with this result?
On behalf of Deputy Mulcahy I move amendment 14. Amendments 14 to 18 are nearly all covering one point. The point that these amendments are directed to is found clearly set out in sub-section (2) where it says that the remission which is proposed by the section shall only apply to stocks and shares in respect of which the Minister for Finance certifies that he is satisfied, after consultation with the Minister for Industry and Commerce, that the conditions are complied with. There is really no reason why a Minister should be brought into this matter at all, except the reasons that are to be found in paragraphs (a), (b), (c) where it states that “the capital raised by the issue of such stock, share or security is or is intended to be.” Every other condition that is mentioned in the section can easily be decided by the Revenue Commissioners or by the Special Commissioners in the ordinary way by methods in which such matters have to be decided even already. For instance, there is no reason why the Minister should be required to certify that the company “is incorporated by or under the laws of Saorstát Eireann,” or “is a company limited by shares within the meaning of the Companies (Consolidation) Act, 1908,” or “is managed and controlled in Saorstát Eireann.” For other purposes in connection with income tax the Revenue authorities have to decide in many cases. For instance, for the purpose of determining the residence of a company they have to determine where it is managed and controlled. It seems to me that the Revenue authorities are the proper authorities to determine that. The Revenue authorities can determine it by the examination of books and the Minister should not be brought into the examination of these books. The Revenue authorities could determine whether a business is wholly or mainly carried on in Saorstát Eireann. The Revenue authorities could determine whether the capital raised by the issue of the stock “was devoted to the establishment or extension in Saorstát Eireann of one or more industries as defined by this section” and that it was not used for the purpose of an existing business.
First there is the question of political disagreement between the Ministers and the people who might be carrying on business. There is the fact that a Minister is not permanently in office and cannot be bound by any oath of secrecy, as the Revenue authorities are bound. For these reasons, it is undesirable, where it is avoidable, that any Minister should be brought into an examination of the books and the affairs of a particular firm. I admit it may be difficult for the Revenue authorities, and outside the ordinary scope of their work, to determine what is intended to be done with capital, but there seems to me to be no reason for giving a concession to a company that has not started business, that perhaps has raised capital and has capital invested in some way, or on deposit on some special terms in the bank, or something like that. There is no reason in that case why any concession should be given. There is no reason, therefore, why we should give a concession to any capital that is merely intended to be used in a particular sort of business. This series of amendments proposes to strike out any concession in respect of capital that is intended to be used in Irish industry, and that having been done, to strike out the Ministers in sub-section (2), and allow these allowances to be determined the same as any other allowances in the income tax code by the Revenue authorities in the ordinary way of administration.
Comment on this
The point raised in amendment 14 was discussed at considerable length on the Second Reading and it is not necessary to repeat the arguments which were then advanced. It is thought that there is good reason for the inclusion of the provision contained in the sub-section at present and the amendment could not be accepted on that account. On the other point made by the Deputy concerning the giving of a concession to a company which intends to start or carry on business in the Saorstát, the purpose behind that provision is to facilitate a company proposing to engage in business here in getting capital subscribed. I think the Minister should have power to give a certificate in such a case. If, in fact, the required conditions are not complied with, the certificate can be withdrawn again under sub-section (4) and that I think is adequate safeguard against any evasion.
Comment on this
The Minister has entirely declined to reply to the point raised. There is good reason for not enabling a politician to poke his nose into the affairs of any business carried on in this country. The giving of that power to a politician leaves the way open to corruption and political blackmail of various sorts. There may be cases in which the business that is required to be done cannot be done without the intervention of the Minister but there is this factor to be taken into account that if the work can well be done with the existing machinery, such as the Revenue machinery, which deals with that sort of thing there is every reason why the Minister should be excluded. If you once take the question of intention out of this section, there is nothing at all that will create any difficulty for the Revenue Commissioners in administering the whole scheme.
The whole excuse for bringing in the Minister is that it is proposed in this section to deal with intention. Surely in connection with the whole scheme of relief here the question of the capital intended to be used is a very small thing. I cannot imagine that a case would arise where there would be any greater ease in getting capital for the carrying on of some sort of business by reason merely of the fact that there was going to be any relief earned on that capital before the business was started. Surely everybody who subscribes capital will look to the business and the carrying on of the business. They will know that no income can be earned pending the start of the business. It is quite an uncommon thing for a company to make calls on its shares before it has any intention of placing its contract or doing whatever may be necessary for the start of the business. That particular provision will be practically of no use. It will have practically no effect. It is unnecessary because after all there is no need at all to deal with the small interval that sometimes may elapse between the raising of the capital and the starting of the business. You could put the argument that way. You could argue that nothing can be done until the business is actually started and that no relief should be given, or with something like equal force you could argue that it is reasonable that if capital is raised for this specific purpose it should be used for this purpose. It is certainly a line ball case. That being so it seems to me absolutely clear that we should take intention out of the section and having done that and having removed the only reason for bringing in Ministerial intervention in a business concern, in a matter of income tax administration, I think interference by the Minister should be removed.
Comment on this
I do not want to delay the House but I think that this is a matter of some importance. I think it is a matter in which some reason should be given by the Minister for Ministerial intervention.
Comment on this
The Deputy knows quite well that in practice neither Minister will positively interfere at all, that the matters will be brought to the final stage by the officers of the Department. The Deputy knows that after his ten years' experience.
Comment on this
If there is abuse there is always an opportunity for any member of the Dáil to have the matter ventilated by Parliamentary question, by a question on the adjournment, or by motion in Private Members' time. It is desirable that the powers to certify in respect of a company formed with the intention of carrying on business should be preserved in order to facilitate the company in raising capital for that particular concern.
Comment on this
It is obvious, whether the Minister understands it or does not understand it, that there is no force in his argument. It is perfectly clear that that sort of certificate would be of no value whatever in raising capital. It will all depend on the permanent certificate, the permanent relief that is going to be obtained in using capital in this way for the carrying on of the business. It is true that a thing like this would have to be investigated by officials of the Department of Finance and the Department of Industry and Commerce. The Minister concerned could not afford the time, if nothing else was involved, to investigate each case. There is a great difference, however, in having a matter investigated by the Revenue officers and having the matter investigated by officials of the Department of Finance or of the Department of Industry and Commerce. If it is investigated by the Revenue authorities it is investigated by a body which has semi-judicial functions, which operates under the law and which does not report to the Minister. From their decision an appeal can be taken to the Special Commissioners and from the Special Commissioners to the Circuit Judge, and if there is a question of law involved, to the High Court and Supreme Court.
Where, however, it is investigated by an official of the Department of Finance it comes up before the Minister. He may look at the file or he may put his initials to the certificate without looking at the file at all.
It is open to him to examine the file and it is open to him to disregard the advice on the file. As a matter of fact every Minister from time to time does for reasons of his own take a line that is counter to the advice given to him. In many cases the Minister may not decide but there will be some cases in which the Minister will decide. There is no reason why this matter like all questions of relief in income tax, should not be decided by the Inspector of Taxes with appeal to the Special Commissioners and so on. It is a question of law. There are certain conditions which are set down for relief, apart from the question of intention, and there should be no difficulty in coming to a decision. There is no reason why the inspectors of taxes or the Special Commissioners should not decide and why the privacy that prevails in regard to income tax matters should not exist. The Revenue official is bound not to make any disclosure to the Minister and there is privacy in regard to the business of any firm whose affairs he investigates. An official of the Department of Finance on the other hand is not bound to privacy. In fact he is bound to make a report to the Minister. The Revenue practice of privacy in dealing with the ordinary business of firms should not be departed from without some reasons being adduced. The Minister has failed to adduce any reason because it must be obvious to him that the question of a certificate dealing with money before it is applied to a business would have no effect on the raising of capital.
Comment on this
Question: "That the words proposed to be deleted stand."
Do you agree with this result?
I move amendment 19: Before sub-section (5) to insert a new sub-section, as follows:
"(5) Where an individual who is resident in Saorstát Eireann and is not resident elsewhere claims and proves to the satisfaction of the Special Commissioners that—
(a) he is carrying on either alone or in partnership with any other person or persons a trade or business wholly or mainly in Saorstát Eireann, and
(b) he is beneficially entitled to or to a share in the profits of such trade or business, and
(c) such trade or business is managed and controlled in Saorstát Eireann, and
(d) the capital of such trade or business is or has been devoted to the establishment or extension in Saorstát Eireann of one or more industries as defined by this section, and
(e) no part of the capital of such trade or business has subsequent to the passing of this Act been used for the purpose of acquiring (directly or indirectly) an existing business or any share or interest in an existing business or of purchasing investments, or of paying off existing loans or debentures,
the following provisions shall have effect, that is to say:—
(i) such individual shall be entitled to repayment of twenty per cent. of the income tax applicable to any profits received by him in respect of such trade or business save in so far as relief or repayment in respect of such tax has been or is granted under any other provision of the Income Tax Acts;
(ii) in estimating the total income from all sources of such individual for the purposes of income tax and sur-tax the amount of any profits in respect of such trade or business shall be deemed to be diminished by twenty per cent."
This amendment if adopted might be found reasonably to require some drafting in view of the fate of amendment No. 13. The purpose of the amendment is to give the same advantage to private persons carrying on their extended business as to a firm. It is difficult to see on what principle the Government resolved to give a concession in respect to business carried on by a limited liability company and refuse to give any concession in respect to business carried on by a family or a partnership of individual industrialists.
Comment on this
A good case might be made for the amendment, and in other circumstances it might be quite possible to consider it, but it is quite obvious that the cost would be very considerable and that must be taken into account. Deputy O'Sullivan can now, if he likes, make Deputy McGilligan's speech as the subject of cost is mentioned. It is obvious if this concession were given it could not be confined to a business income alone. It would have to be extended to professional incomes and to incomes from other employment. The Deputy is aware that a business man trading upon his own account, or as one of a partnership, gets earned income relief upon his business income. I do not want to convey the impression that the Government would not be glad to try and do something on the lines suggested by this amendment, but it is not possible.
Comment on this
Amendment 21 refers to line 27; amendment 20 refers to line 28. Perhaps the Deputy would move both together?
Comment on this
I move amendment 21. The object is to confine the concession to manufacturers. I think that that is possibly what the Government most desires by this—the encouragement of manufacture— and there is certainly, in view of the undeveloped state of manufacture, less force, for instance, if this amendment 21 is adopted, in the argument used earlier by Deputy Dillon. We have plenty of distributors in the country, and it seems to me to be unfair to give a concession to somebody who starts a new distributing business, whereas, as there is not a sufficiency of manufacturing businesses, there is not that argument at all against them. There would not be the same argument against the scheme of the section if this amendment were adopted. I do not know whether the Government in proposing this scheme is anxious that new money should be put into distribution, and that we should try to encourage a host of new distributive enterprises to start. I would have thought that the object of the section was to encourage investment in manufacturing industry, and the amendment in the name of Deputy Mulcahy is to put that in the section.
Comment on this
There is a strong case for confining the section to firms engaged in manufacturing enterprises, but it is practically impossible to do so. To limit it to manufacturing enterprises only would involve very elaborate administrative procedure which would be very difficult of administration. If these amendments were carried, a firm employing one hundred hands in, say, a drapery store engaged purely in the retail trade need only employ one girl sewing on buttons or, say, darning stockings, in order to comply with the conditions required for the concession. To be logical we would have to differentiate, in the case of a firm engaged partly in manufacturing enterprise and partly in retailing, between that portion of its income which came from the manufacturing end and that which came from the retailing enterprise. Taking all things into account it is well that the concession should be given in the form here proposed.
Comment on this
That there would be, if the amendment were accepted and incorporated in the Bill necessarily as set down here, difficulties arising, I can quite see. But if the Minister feels any sympathy with the principle, would he not consider introducing in the next stage an amendment himself along somewhat different lines confining the concession to firms whose main business was, shall we say, manufacturing and the alteration of an article in such a way—that is, to confine it to firms whose business was mainly manufacture rather than distribution?
Comment on this
The Deputy may take it that that was considered, but very elaborate provisions would have to be made to carry out the intention and avoid evasion. If on reconsideration a simpler method could have been devised, it would have been employed, but it did not seem possible when exemption was being given in the first instance.
Comment on this
I move amendment 22:
In sub-section (5), lines 28 and 29, to delete the words "the purchase and sale of imported coal."
I would ask the Minister if he would give us some explanation of the reasons for excepting certain of these businesses set out here. For instance, as the section is very wide already, as the term "industry" in the section includes nearly every sort of business— as the Minister has admitted—why is, say, the business of the purchase and sale of coal excepted and the business of the purchase and sale of imported drapery, for instance, not excepted?
Comment on this
I do not think there are any companies formed for the purchase and sale of imported drapery, only, but on the other hand, companies are formed in this country particularly for the purpose of importing and selling coal, and in view of the special circumstances existing now in the coal business here, we thought that this concession should not be extended to firms engaged in it. These exceptions were considered in detail and in each case some justification arose to justify the extension of the concession to certain types of firm. It may be argued that certain other firms should be included but we tried to keep the limit as narrow as possible, and not give a concession where there was not some clearly defined reason for giving it.
Comment on this
I do not want to press the coal matter particularly, which I think is the weakest place, but there is a logical line which could be drawn demonstratively between the distributing and the manufacturing business. It is difficult to see why one particular distributing business—because that is what it amounts to— a particular business which happens to deal mainly in imported goods—should be shut out, and all other businesses—and there are many other businesses that deal entirely with imported goods, such as tea (that is an imported commodity just as much as coal is)—included in the relief. And while, as I say, I do not think that the coal item is the strongest of these series of amendments and I do not want to take too much time on it, I suggest that it is not a desirable thing more or less arbitrarily to exclude one particular sort of business from the relief that is being given generally and to refuse to include it.
Comment on this
The Deputy said that firms engaged in the importation of coal were being treated exceptionally. Those are there in pursuance of a sort of general principle. The other exclusions are public utility companies, such as companies engaged in the sale of gas for lighting, heating, or power, transport organisations of various kinds and companies engaged in dealing with stocks and shares. These classes are excluded. In addition, those engaged in the business of selling imported coal are also excluded because of the special conditions that exist in the coal trade, of which the Deputy is aware, as they were discussed in the Dáil from time to time during the last three years.
Comment on this
I move amendment 25: In sub-section (5), line 31, to delete the word "inland" and substitute the word "road."
If this amendment were accepted, I do not know to what extent it would operate in practice. Since amendment 13 was rejected and since we are confined to capital raised subsequent to the passing of this Act, I do not think that the practical effect of this amendment will be very great. If it be effective at all, I think it is completely defensible. We know that the railways are experiencing great difficulties. Their very continuance is, perhaps, imperilled. I do not know that they are likely to close down, because the economic circumstances of the country require their continuance. I suppose some means will have to be found to enable the railways to continue. If special steps are not taken, the difficulties of the railways seem to be destined to increase. In these circumstances, if a concession is given to any sort of enterprise, it should, above all, be given to the railways. It is possible to argue that the road policy which has been pursued and the new road policy which is going to be pursued by the Government have tended and will tend to increase the difficulties of the railways, to draw traffic away from them, to make it difficult for them to meet their overheads and keep going, not to speak of providing the modest dividend which, if the service is to continue to be made use of by the public, ought to be paid to those whose enterprise initiated the undertaking and carried it on so far. I think there is a case for giving this concession to a railway company if it is possible to give it to any company. It is possible that the development of the Drumm battery may make it necessary and possible for the railway companies to raise new capital. They might, if permitted, qualify for the advantage proposed by this section. If that should happen, the railway companies' enterprise ought to get the benefit of this section. If it is not going to be necessary for the railways to raise new capital for any purpose, then there will be no harm done. The Exchequer will lose nothing. I would urge the Minister strongly, at least to indicate his willingness to allow the railway companies to benefit under this section if circumstances should arise which would enable them to fulfil the conditions set out.
Comment on this
I gathered from the Deputy's remarks that this amendment is another solution of the railway problem.
Comment on this
If it is put forward in that spirit, I am afraid it is not acceptable as such. The question of transport services generally is under consideration and definite proposals will have to be submitted to the Dáil at some date in the near future. I think we can leave the question of what action is to be taken in relation to the railways over until then and the putting in of an amendment of this kind at this stage is of no value whatsoever. It is unlikely that there will be any new issue of stock or shares by the railway companies between now and the date on which some positive decision as to railway policy will be made by this House. The amendment should not be pressed at this stage as a solution of that problem.
Comment on this
It is obvious that nobody suggested this as a solution of the problem. We do not know what steps are going to be taken and we do not know how adequate any steps it is possible to take will be. Everybody recognises that the problem is one of very great difficulty and that even, with the greatest enthusiasm in the world, the Government might have quite enough trouble in devising measures that would be adequate and that would make the situation of the railways at all easy. I do not profess to be able to foresee circumstances in which the railway companies would issue new capital but, if anything makes capital expenditure necessary, the funds will surely have to be got by new issues. They are not going to be got out of earnings, in the present circumstances, or in any circumstances likely to arise. The Minister mentioned that certain things were excluded because they were public utility companies. There is nothing particularly evil in an enterprise being a public utility. The Minister simply said that they were not including public utility societies in the section. He did not elaborate that or state any grounds for so doing. I do not see what grounds he could have other than wanting to narrow the section somewhat or being unwilling to give a concession to a gas company which might be held to be competing with the Shannon Scheme or something of that kind. This is a permanent provision and circumstances may arise—though I do not profess to foresee them—in which railway companies will have to raise new capital. We do not know to what extent the Drumm battery will be used. If it were widely used by the railway companies, it would involve a considerable amount of capital expenditure. That capital would have to be raised by a public issue. I think the amendment ought to be accepted. The Minister did not put forward any arguments which were very convincing against it. He talked about a solution of the railway problem. That is quite another matter. Is the Minister sure that the railway companies will be placed in a position of affluence by the new measure? I do not think he can be. If he is not, why should he decline to encourage investment in railway companies in any new circumstances which may arise and thus ease their position under this section whatever may happen otherwise?
Comment on this
I have discussed the matter with the Minister for Finance. We are impressed by the Deputy's arguments and we agree to accept the amendment.
Comment on this
Whatever may be the purposes of the section, and however much it is likely to achieve its purpose as it stands, I think those who have listened to the debate, and in view of the refusal of the Government to put up any arguments against some rather important amendments that were suggested from this side of the House, will agree that the section enshrines some very vicious principles. In the course of the debates efforts were made to get rid of these principles and in answer to arguments put forward from this side, and from other quarters in the House, we were met with silence, practically, from the Government Benches, and on other occasions with the non possumus attitude that they could not afford it. Leaving out of account the statement that they could not afford it, with the immense taxation it will put on, and which, to a large extent is due to the extravagant policy the Government is adopting, what they do not seem to realise is that they aimed at one particular thing in the section apparently, namely, the setting up of new businesses and new industries, but at the same time as the section now stands, there are in it certain principles which must have the opposite effect. We had an example in connection with the Control of Manufactures Bill which shows an extraordinary naive view of what can be done with business; that it can be juggled with, and that there is no delicacy about business organisation because you are laying down certain principles and violating other long-established principles. A Government prepared to violate them unnecessarily I suggest is damaging the sense of security that any investor must feel.
No real argument was put up, and no attempt was made to answer Deputy Blythe when he was arguing against the substitution of the Revenue Commissioners for the Minister in connection with one particular section. He pointed out the danger involved in bringing in the political head to make a decision. He is there not merely as a matter of principle, and sometimes undoubtedly will be there as a matter of practice. That which many people regard as one of the few attractions in connection with the income tax raising is its secrecy, and that is now to go unnecessarily. No argument was put forward to show why that work could not be carried out by those accustomed to look after the ordinary income tax affairs of the people. What is disturbing is that here is the beginning of a tendency to throw aside long-established principles; principles in which confidence is based. No arguments were put forward and no reasons adduced for that. That is one reason why we must object to this section. With the intention, if I may say so, on the part of the Government to pry into the private affairs of individuals, which could be done as Deputy Blythe pointed out probably better by the Revenue Commissioners, to set aside the veil of secrecy, to violate a principle long established, that will probably do a great deal more to make people uneasy about investments than the section itself will do to induce people to invest in this country. In the same way with the discrimination to which I have referred owing to the failure to accept amendment 19 in the name of Deputy Mulcahy, there is further discrimination between a private company and a private individual, between a family and a company which issues shares. There is discrimination between men long established in business, men who had to struggle to keep the business in existence. They see business established in competition getting favours from the Government and having more money to put into business owing to the fact that they are charged less income tax. A business man sees himself discriminated against in that way. If all these principles are taken into account I think they violate the ordinary canons for the carrying on of business. There is Government interference with business to such an extent that the section will do a great deal more damage than any real positive good in the way of inducing people to put their money into investments in this country. Not merely for what the section indicates, but for the evidence of light-heartedness that it displays because the Government without any sufficient reason will violate longstanding fundamental principles, and because it is vicious and contains principles distinctly bad, principles which the House ought to consider carefully, I hope the House will object to this section as it stands.
Comment on this
The Minister was not present when I was arguing that this section ought to be amended by removing the Minister for Finance and the Minister for Industry and Commerce out of the scope of the section dealing with investments which had not yet been applied to the carrying on of business in the Saorstát. I do not know whether or not the Minister for Industry and Commerce had given any consideration to the section before he came into the House to take the place of the Minister for Finance during his temporary absence this evening. Certainly he adduced no argument that could have any force for maintaining the section as it stands. Every regulation to determine whether or not a company should be eligible for the relief given in the section could be made by the Revenue officials if we are to confine it to the relief of companies and businesses actually in operation. I think the Minister for Finance should further consider the matter, that income tax relief should be administered as every other income tax is administered by the Revenue staffs and that the Minister for Finance should not be required to go into details of particular businesses in connection with income tax, and that the officials of the Department of Finance who are under no seal of secrecy, but on the contrary are pledged to disclose the results of inquiries to the political head, should not deal with this matter.
The objects can be achieved quite well if the section is altered as I suggest it should be altered, and there certainly would be no good done, in the way of raising capital, by making provision to relieve any earnings that may be made by that capital before it is applied to the business for which it has been raised. The cases in which that particular provision in the section could apply will be very few, and, even if they were numerous, they will not influence the subscriptions to the stock being issued. What will influence them is the prospects of the business and the possible prospect of tax relief when the business is in operation and dividends are being paid.
Comment on this
While this section is vicious in the way described by Deputy O'Sullivan, I would like to deal also, and, perhaps, at a little more length, with the point raised by Deputy Blythe.
I think that the taking of power by the Minister to impose liability on particular citizens in the State is a power which should be very slowly given. I know under existing legislation very few examples of the head of a Government Department determining the actual liability on particular individuals. The only one which comes to my mind at the moment is the power given to the Minister for Local Government with regard to surcharges on members of local authorities, but I do not think that any analogy whatever can be drawn between that power and the power which this section purports to give the Minister for Finance and the Minister for Industry and Commerce. This section as it stands undoubtedly gives them power to impose liability for income tax on particular people. A power with regard to income tax generally under the income tax code is given to the Revenue Commissioners, and, as has been pointed out here, there is nothing whatever in the section, save the particular question of the intention to expend moneys on industries in this country, which could not very well be determined by the Revenue Commissioners, and, in fact, I think that even the question of intention could be quite as well determined by the Revenue Commissioners as by the Minister for Finance or the Minister for Industry and Commerce. Presumably, if the Minister for Industry and Commerce is to give any certificate as to intention, some form of evidence or declaration by the persons interested must be placed before them of intention to expend the capital of the company in this particular way, and, if it is thought necessary to retain this exemption in this section where any intention exists to expend money, the same evidence could be placed before the Revenue Commissioners and would satisfy them just in the same way as it might satisfy the Minister for Finance or the Minister for Industry and Commerce, but, in any event, the question of intention can be a mere temporary matter.
No certificate given in respect of intention can be any way permanent and the Minister for Industry and Commerce, in the few remarks he did make on the section, pointed out that it would be a mere temporary measure, and that if a person who displayed at one moment an intention to expend moneys in this particular way did not carry out his intention, under sub-section (4) of the section power was given to remove the certificate that had already been given. I have not heard in this House yet any case made for an inroad on the general finance code in respect of this matter, but the Revenue Commissioners are quite competent to determine any question that arises under the section. What case can be made, or has been made, to the House for depriving the ordinary taxpayer in this particular matter of the ordinary remedy, the ordinary relief he has against any particular decision which is adverse to him? If this matter were determined by the Revenue Commissioners, the taxpayer has his appeal to the Circuit Judge, and if a question of law is involved, he can go either to the High Court or the Supreme Court, but he has no remedy whatever, and no right of appeal when this matter is to be determined by the Minister for Finance and the Minister for Industry and Commerce. The Minister for Industry and Commerce says that grievances, if any, can be ventilated in this House, but that is very little good to the taxpayer, if there is a cut and dried machine to vote him out of any grievance he may want ventilated. Furthermore, I do certainly think that if the only remedy open to the taxpayer is to have his grievances ventilated in the House, it is not in the interest of industry or of people engaged in industry in this country, if, in any particular respects, they have to come and bring before the whole country, through this House, particular matters dealing with their business before they can get relief from any grievance, and I would press on the Minister that no justification exists, and no justification can be made for taking this matter outside the scope of the general income tax code, and for making the Minister for Finance and the Minister for Industry and Commerce the final arbiters in the matter, rather than letting it go through the ordinary channel of the Revenue Commissioners and to the courts, if necessary.
Comment on this
This section has been described as an example of the vicious principle which permeates the whole of this Bill. What is the vicious principle? Deputy J.M. O'Sullivan knows what words mean and can use them more precisely than I can, but what is the vicious principle? I will assume that he had carefully considered the matter and that before he used such language, he had weighed up what it meant and what the section proposed to do. What does it propose to do? It proposes, in this period, when every effort must be made to establish new industries in order to absorb our unemployed, to provide livelihood and bread——
Comment on this
I made it quite clear that whatever might be said about the general aim of the section, namely, to promote industries, it contained vicious principles, and these I mentioned—discrimination and violation of secrecy. That is all.
Comment on this
It aims, he said, at setting up new business in this country. That is the aim of the general section.
Comment on this
For this reason, that it is going to make that aim easier of accomplishment. It is going to make new ventures more attractive.
Comment on this
And yet, because we are trying to do that, Deputy O'Sullivan says that we are giving effect to vicious principles. I am glad that he is ashamed of the words he has used. And it is just what I would expect from Deputy O'Sullivan in his better moments, that he should be ashamed of his words. We are told that we are violating long-established principles. Quite obviously, there is confusion of thought in this matter. That is quite clear. What the Minister for Finance, in consultation with the Minister for Industry and Commerce, has to determine is something that the Revenue Commissioners have never had to determine before. There can be no long-established principle in this matter, because the case never arose before, but it arises now on the simple determination of certain facts, first of all, as to whether a company is or is not a public company. Whether it is or is not a public company is a fact which can be quite easily ascertained by any member of the public if he goes to the trouble of doing it—
Comment on this
And with regard to that, there can be no violation of any secrecy. The whole of Deputy Blythe's speech was based on this fact, that it would be necessary for the Minister to probe into the intimate affairs of any particular undertaking which came before him. It is not necessary for the Minister to do more than look at the style and title of a company and look at the company's register in order to assure himself that it is a public company, incorporated under the laws of Saorstát Eireann.
The next provision in the section is that it is a company limited by shares within the meaning of the Companies (Consolidation) Act, 1908, and that it is managed and controlled in Saorstát Eireann. It is not necessary for the Revenue Commissioners to be brought in to determine any one of these facts. Any one of these facts can be ascertained by any member of the general public. The section further provides that the company carries on its business wholly or mainly in Saorstát Eireann. Who is more competent to determine that fact than the Minister for Industry and Commerce, whose business it is, within certain limits, to keep all industries under survey, to be aware of what they are doing? I submit the Minister for Industry and Commerce is more competent to do that, and will do it in the ordinary everyday discharge of his functions, than the Revenue Commissioners could do it, because he has the machinery and the information at his hands.
Again, the section sets out: "The capital raised by the issue of such stock, share or security is or is intended to be or has been devoted to the establishment or extension in Saorstát Eireann of one or more industries as defined by this section." The person most appropriate to do that is the Minister for Industry and Commerce. Paragraph (c) of sub-section (2) states: "No part of the said capital so raised is intended or is being or has been used for the purpose of acquiring... an existing business or any share or interest in an existing business or of purchasing investments or of paying off existing loans or debentures." If any man goes for a loan under the Trade Loans (Guarantee) Act, before that loan will be granted has he not, in certain circumstances, to furnish to the Minister exactly the same information as is asked for here?
We are told we are violating long-established principles. Paragraph (d) says: "Such issue of stock, shares or security is so described and designated that it is readily distinguishable from all other (if any) issues of such company." What harm could there possibly be in the Minister for Industry and Commerce ascertaining that fact for himself? The manner in which the capital of any company is obtained is perfectly well known to the Minister and all he has to satisfy himself upon is that the new issue will be readily distinguishable from existing issues. I put it to Deputy Blythe, where is there any probing into the intimate affairs of any concern which seeks to benefit under this section? I think that what I have said applies equally to what Deputy Finlay said. There is no possibility of the confidence of any firm being violated, no possibility of any information of their affairs being conveyed to any competitor. I repudiate the suggestion made here in relation to the Civil Service. I am ashamed that the Deputy who was the former Minister for Finance, who was responsible for the Civil Service and who defended the honour and probity of the Civil Service in this House, just as I am doing now, would listen to any suggestion that one branch of the Civil Service any more than another would be guilty of any violation of secrecy in a matter of this sort.
Comment on this
The Minister is deliberately misrepresenting me. What I pointed out was that it was the civil servant's duty to report to his Minister, who was not a civil servant but a political head. The Minister is deliberately misrepresenting me.
Comment on this
The statement was made that the Revenue Commissioners and their staff are used to keeping confidences.
Comment on this
Yes; but there is no reason why anything should be withheld from the Minister in this particular matter, nor is there any reason for it to be withheld in most other matters unless, as I said on the Second Reading debate, the Minister is unfit to sit on the Government Benches and unless he and his Party—the whole Government—are corrupt and that he could possibly, for some political reasons or under political pressure, divulge any information or do anything that would prejudice the interests of any commercial concern in this country. The Deputy cannot get away from that. He has either got to accept it that those charged with the Government of the country are honest men or else he has to say in certain circumstances that the people of the Free State are so demoralised that they would elect to be governed by dishonest persons.
Comment on this
The Minister obviously has nothing to say in defence of the section. He delivered to us a farrago of nonsense.
Comment on this
Let us take one of the earlier paragraphs. Is it not utterly ridiculous to require a Minister to certify a company is incorporated by or under the laws of Saorstát Eireann? Is it not utterly ridiculous to certify that a company is limited by shares within the meaning of the Companies (Consolidation) Act? Should not the section be so drawn that companies complying with those regulations will get the benefits of the section? Why should a company go to the Minister to get a certificate that these things are so? So far as other matters are concerned, there must be probing into a company's affairs. In many cases there would have to be quite an amount of probing in order to determine whether a company was managed and controlled in accordance with the law here, and the Minister should know that quite well. There are cases in which there would be no difficulty, but there are other cases in which there would be considerable difficulty in determining where a company was managed or controlled from. It would be necessary to know a good deal about a company in order to determine that with certainty.
It would be necessary to know a lot about a company and to have the figures which would indicate the extent of its business in order to determine whether it is wholly or mainly in Saorstát Eireann. It would be necessary, for instance, to determine whether capital was being used for the establishment of a business in Saorstát Eireann and to make sure it was not being used to purchase existing businesses. The Minister would have to probe deeply into the affairs of the company. There has not been the slightest argument advanced to show why the Minister should make these inquiries and come to conclusions in regard to them. There has been no such relief as this in the income tax code heretofore, but there have been other reliefs and charges. The matters to be determined here are precisely the kind of matters the Revenue Commissioners are continually determining. There is no reason why, in relation to this particular relief, the Minister should be brought in when he is not brought into other reliefs.
It is most undesireable that a Minister should be allowed unnecessarily to probe into the private affairs of a business firm. It is quite conceivable that a Minister who is in business might have the affairs of a trade rival coming before him; he might have their books and accounts exposed to him—they might have to be exposed to him—and I think that is a most undesirable course. The Minister will himself realise that the ordinary law in regard to income tax and the secrecy in regard to income tax is thoroughly sound and thoroughly desirable, and that it would be a most disagreeable thing both to the Minister and to those in business if the matters that come before the Revenue Commissioners were such as would have to be reported to the Minister. The same thing applies with regard to the particulars mentioned in the Schedule. There is no reason why the Minister should come into them or that one set of civil servants should come into them when another set of civil servants should have to come into them. I am not going to suggest that there are frequently going to be Ministers who would abuse their knowledge or disclose in any way the information that would come to their disposal. It is quite possible that the firm concerned may be political enemies of the Minister and there would be in the minds of such a firm if the matter were done by the Minister a suspicion much more so than if the thing were done by officials who have been trained in the Revenue Service. That is a factor that possibly would not be absent from the mind of the citizen if the citizen is a political opponent of the Minister. It is unfair that such man should be asked to give private details of his business to any Department if that is at all avoidable. There may be cases where it is unavoidable that this information should be given and we have to bear with such cases. But when there is another, a better and more efficient way, a way that will prevent duplication of work, then we should not force a business man or firm to show his books to a politician who for the time being occupies a ministerial position.
Comment on this
It is a most extraordinary thing that the Deputy should in any way desire not to make obligatory the authority of this House. What is proposed is the only way in which this House maintains its authority. The Deputy would by his suggestion make it impossible for the Minister to answer to this House in any matter.
Comment on this
So that the full secrecy of the citizen's business can be fully discussed in this House?
Comment on this
I am with Deputy Blythe in this amendment. I think the principle enunciated by the Deputy is entirely a sound one. I do not think that the Minister can in justice take the other way. All sides in this House have the gratification of being proud of our civil servants and I do not think that there is any section in this House who would suggest that we should wish anything off them that they do not already give. As Deputy Blythe has said, it is entirely unfair that a person who is possibly violently politically opposed to the Minister in charge should be obliged to lay open his private confidential affairs before that Minister. Consequently it is the least desirable thing that could possibly be allowed. Deputy Little has suggested that the matter should be raised in this House. The most vital element in this House is publicity. That would be a most unsatisfactory proposition to formulate—that the confidential affairs of a firm could be discussed here by a Minister with cross-examination into certain matters connected with the firm.
I would remind the Minister for Finance that his colleague the Minister for Industry and Commerce employed the same language a few nights ago on another subject when that Minister struck the desk, as he often does, and told us that the very best check we could have was reference to Dáil Eireann and the accounting of the Minister to Dáil Eireann. But to-day the Minister told us that he had to refuse certain licences and when we asked him to render this account to Dáil Eireann he said certainly not, that it was not in the public interest to do it and that he was not prepared to do it. Then it occurs to me that this very important check on his operations about which we heard so much previously was not functioning. I hold it would be very unfortunate if the check did function in this connection because it would be an intolerable imposition on business firms. On this question as to whether this check by Dáil Eireann calling on the Minister to account for what he does is a desirable or effective check, I venture to suggest that it is open to the Minister always to say that it is contrary to public policy and injurious to the persons whose affairs are concerned to have such matters raised in the House. But leaving that out of the question it is obviously clear (1) that a matter of this kind should not come up before Dáil Eireann except of course in case of grave national emergency as Dáil Eireann is not the public forum in which to discuss such questions; (2) as Deputy Blythe has said where you have trustworthy civil servants habitually handling matters of this kind, having the requisite information, ready to undertake the work, and the individual citizen has a well-established right of appeal from their decision to the courts, you have obviously there a more desirable machine available. Why the Minister should try to burden himself and his Department with this work is more than I can understand. They have already quite enough to do without adding on functions of this kind. I cannot imagine why the Minister should want to add these functions to his Department or that it should be necessary to add them instead of allowing these matters to fall on the longsuffering shoulders of the Revenue officials.
Comment on this
There was one argument which the Minister adduced in favour of this section. He apparently admitted, not expressly, that there was something in the nature of recognition of the principle in dealing with the income tax code. He said we should not employ that existing principle because new facts arose. I think that is a weak argument now. It could be pleaded when the excess profit duties were imposed. It is an argument that could be pleaded when the corporation profits tax was imposed, and it could be pleaded when the super-tax was imposed. These were not new sets of facts, but the general principle of the income tax was recognised, and the Minister and the Treasury did not take upon themselves the assessment of corporation tax or super-tax. They allowed these matters to go through the ordinary channels. I have not heard from the Minister yet any sufficient reason why the ordinary channels should not be pursued in this respect, and why what are admittedly new facts should not be allowed to go to the Revenue Commissioners for their determination in the ordinary course.
Comment on this
I will deal with a couple of points which have emerged, and will not deal with the others. It seems to me that if the Opposition are in good faith, and I am accepting that the Opposition are in good faith, they completely misunderstand this matter. We have been talking about probing into the private affairs of individual concerns, and the affairs of private individuals—persons who might be compelled to lay open all their business affairs. But there is nothing new involved in this. At least nothing is involved so far as the Minister for Finance or the Minister for Industry and Commerce is concerned. Where the personal element and the individual enters he is able to show to the Special Commissioners that he is in financial ownership of certain stocks and shares. That is provided for in Section 1, and it is only there that any probing into private affairs would be undertaken. Section 2 applies only to public companies, and there can be no fresh probing into the affairs of public companies; there can be no imposition to ascertain from them any more information than they are compelled by the existing law to disclose in their balance sheets.
Comment on this
Mainly. That would be a known fact within the ordinary everyday knowledge of most people in the business, or at any rate the information would be within the knowledge of the Minister for Industry and Commerce.
Comment on this
Is the Minister going to go on common repute? There you have the question where abuse would arise, and a firm that would be politically acceptable would have a better chance. It is not on common repute, but by an examination of the books.
Comment on this
We can have these books examined if one likes by the Revenue Commissioners. That is a particular aspect. Is there any other? Every public company in its balance sheet discloses whether it is or is not incorporated under the laws of Saorstát Eireann. I come back to the whole point again. Where is there any violation of the intimate and confidential affairs of a public company? Of course, if the Deputy and the Opposition generally have misunderstood the section and if, notwithstanding everything that has been said, they believe that it is concerns in the ownership of private individuals that are going to benefit, then I think that they certainly ought to make amends and allow this to go through without further discussion.
Comment on this
For two reasons. We heard from Deputy Finlay that if the Revenue Commissioners were to have access, and if this were carried on under the ordinary income tax law, there would be an appeal from the Revenue Commissioners to the Special Commissioners and probably from the Special Commissioners to the courts on points of law and fact. The whole case against this section has been that there might be publication of the intimate concerns of a company. Is there any better way to secure that publication than by a process of law which will mean that the affairs of that company——
Comment on this
The Minister is apparently unaware that income tax appeals are heard in private by the Circuit Court Judge.
Comment on this
It is only a question of law comes before the High Court. No facts come before the High Court.
Comment on this
The law would not be dissociated from the facts in these cases. You could not possibly discuss whether under the law a company was entitled to this without having advertence to the facts, and the facts will be found to be divulged in the High Court. Suppose a company went to the High Court and lost its case there, even though the case were held in camera, that very fact would be an intimation to the public that they were not entitled——
Comment on this
I am perfectly certain that no case will arise which will have to come to the Dáil, that the companies that are refused a licence will be quite clearly companies which have absolutely no chance of securing a licence on any view of the facts. There is no possibility of any violation of secrecy. Most of the relevant facts will be disclosed by the company in its own balance sheet. If the question is as to whether a company carries on business wholly or partly in Saorstát Eireann, I say that that fact will already be within the knowledge of the Minister for Industry and Commerce.
Comment on this
In relation to the facts that could possibly require certification and they really fall under (a), (b) and (c) there will, in many cases, if not in all cases, be a need for examination and for probing into the affairs of the company. The Minister opened up a new line of horror in connection with the matter when he indicated that the thing was going to be done on common repute, on a sort of general notion that the Minister for Industry and Commerce would already have about the business of a firm. Nothing could be worse than doing it in that way, because if things are to be done along that line you cannot avoid favouritism and abuse. The particular privileges given under this section should only be given to a firm which certainly is entitled to them, and should not be given on the basis of common repute.
Comment on this
I move amendment 25a:—
Before Section 8 to insert a new section as follows:—
(1) Every allowance granted under Section 8 of the Army Pensions Act, 1923 (No. 26 of 1923), as amended by the Army Pensions Act, 1927 (No. 12 of 1927), to the widow or to any child or dependent of a person who was killed during the rising of April and May, 1916, shall be exempt from income tax (including super-tax and surtax), and shall not be reckoned in computing income for the purposes of the Income Tax Acts.
(2) In this section, the word "killed" has the same meaning as it has in the said Section 8 of the Army Pensions Act, 1923.
The purpose of this amendment is to enable the pensions payable to widows or children of persons killed during the rising in April and May, 1916, to be paid clear of income-tax and surtax. In the amendment, as printed, there is a slight misprint and I move the amendment with the omission of the words "super-tax and."
Comment on this
I move amendment 26: "To delete sub-section (8)." This amendment is merely consequential upon the introduction of a new section under amendment 73, which confers the same power in a separate section.