We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

Finance Bill, 1932—Committee (Resumed).

Contributions 1–208 of 875. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 4 parts.

Bill Finance Bill, 1932
Enacted

No. 11 of 1932 ›

Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Amendments 54, 54 (a), 55, 56 and 59 will I presume be debated together.

Comment on this

If you are taking amendment 55 would it not be necessary also to take amendment 211?

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Amendment 211 is consequential on number 55.

Comment on this

It seems to me that unless amendments 55 and 211 are taken together it would not be possible to discuss amendment 55.

Comment on this

Amendment 211 could not be moved later on?

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

It could not.

Comment on this

I submit that amendment 54 should be taken by itself.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Very well, there will be separate divisions.

Comment on this

We are simply dealing then with balls and dances not sports?

Comment on this

Sports and dances, and even the Dáil as a place of entertainment, were discussed by Deputy McGilligan on the last night.

Comment on this

Do not prolong the entertainment.

Comment on this

Will the Minister say whether ceilidhthe are included?

Comment on this

They are cultural.

Comment on this

I take it the Minister is not serious when he says that if I take part in the "Waves of Tory" I pay no tax, but if I take part in a foxtrot I do pay tax?

Comment on this

If you take part in the "Waves of Tory" and speak in English you are not, but if you take part in a fox-trot and speak in Irish you are. I have done both.

Comment on this

I agree that the Schedule may be full of anomalies but, at the same time, in its present form it is going to be productive of revenue, therefore I am defending it.

Comment on this
Mr. Hayes

Are we to assume that the Minister's position on the question of the tax on dances is that he wants revenue and is getting it this way?

Comment on this

Precisely. I have no desire to reform the world in this Bill.

Comment on this
Mr. Hayes

It would be difficult. Will the Minister say how precisely it is that ceilidhthe are exempt?

Comment on this

I should like to correct a possible misapprehension. Only ceilidhthe held under the auspices of the Gaelic League are exempt.

Comment on this

Again a distinction.

Comment on this

The Gaelic League is not mentioned in the Schedule, so far as I can see, and I would like to know exactly on what basis ceilidhthe or certain sorts of dances are being exempted.

Comment on this

This particular exemption enshrines the wisdom of our predecessors. Ceilidhthes were always exempted under their administration.

Comment on this

Is it on the basis of the object of the association? It is the point that they get exemption if they are engaged in education work?

Comment on this

First and foremost, I think it would be wrong to ride away with an imposition on indoor amusements, such as dances, under cover of a row in regard to the position of sports, and sub-section (2) might very well be amended and decided by itself. The Minister, apparently, does not know what exactly he proposes to do under this tax. He first tells us that ceilidhthes are exempt and now he tells us that, if they are exempt, they are exempt because they were exempt under the previous Government.

Comment on this

I presume that Gaelic League concerts and ceilidhthe are exempt?

Comment on this

This is a proposal, I understand, to tax balls or dances, no matter what kind of dances are danced at them. The Minister says he is not out for reforming things and, apparently, he ignores completely the reaction of this particular tax on anything like social conditions. He is simply considering his revenue and I would ask if he can give us any figures which will show what this would bring in in revenue, and whether it is not going to drive the normal type of dance in the City of Dublin, for which the ticket is about 5/- or so, from the hotels where they keep up a rather expensive equipment for providing people with places for social reunions, and which have considerable overhead charges and which are used only during a particular time of the year, into more or less private places, where they can be run under the guise of private social functions, rather than public dances. I understand that, in connection with this particular type of dance in the city, there is a floating staff of about 200 waiters kept continually employed during the winter period, when they would not otherwise have employment, as a result of the advantage taken by the public of the facilities provided by hotels and such places for social reunions of this kind. The percentage of dances run entirely for charity in the City of Dublin is very big, and I take it that, even if this tax is maintained, in order to get revenue, at whatever cost, these dances will still be immune and that exemption certificates can be got for them? But I would like the Minister to give us some idea as to how much money he expects to get from this particular tax and what he thinks the reaction is going to be in respect of the reduction of the number of dances held in institutions properly and fully equipped and under proper supervision, and with plenty of publicity. What percentage of these are going to be driven from these public places into less public places, where dances will be conducted as private parties, as it were, and without any of the supervision or proper equipment that these dances require.

Comment on this

I would like to shorten the debate on this. The Minister mentioned in regard to the exemption of certain types of dances, dances held under the auspices of the Gaelic League, but that is not mentioned here. It it the idea that they are to be exempt because they are run by an educational association?

Comment on this

Yes.

Comment on this
Mr. Hayes

Dances were not taxed before. What happened before was that concerts under the Gaelic League, for example, were exempt. I will give the Minister a simple example that occurs to me. If the University Gaelic Society runs a ceilidhe, would it be defined as an educational association? Supposing Trinity Gaelic Society wanted to run a ceilidhe, would the Minister regard the society as an educational association and exempt it? If he wants to exempt Irish dances, as such, and places where nothing is danced but Irish dances, it would be better to put in a section to that effect.

Comment on this

I think I see a way out of all the difficulty. We will get a lot of branches of the Gaelic League formed and we can have any sort of dances at them.

Comment on this

I find it very difficult to understand exactly what we are discussing at the moment.

Comment on this

So does the Minister.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Amendment 54.

Comment on this

You, Sir, were not in the Chair on the last night when we were discussing amendments 54 to 59, dealing with dances and football. What are we discussing at present?

Comment on this

You are in a scrum now.

Comment on this

May I suggest that a good deal of the confusion arises because some members of the Opposition think that the Committee Stage of a Bill is not for discussion but for cross-examination?

Comment on this

I would ask the Minister to divest himself altogether of his materialistic ideas and look on all these things as recreations and sports and relaxations from the every-day grind. I am afraid the Minister is becoming a bit too miserly in his hunt for revenue, and that, in that hunt, he is not going to be very careful what is going to suffer. I would make one appeal to the Minister on this matter, and particularly with regard to games of every kind. It will be remembered that when the raid was made on the Sweepstakes money, we were told that people were to be so educated in healthy practices, that there would not be so much necessity for the expenditure of money on hospitals. The Minister is nullifying that, to a terrible extent, by putting a tax on the people's amusements and recreations. I am not going to draw any distinction between football played under one code or another. They are all healthy amusements, and native to the soil, no matter what the shape of the football is——

Comment on this

Question!

Comment on this

What is the question?

Comment on this

All the classes of football played here are not native to the soil.

Comment on this

The Deputy only dances Gaelic dances.

Comment on this

I do not dance at all, no matter what kind of dances they are.

Comment on this

I will admit that there is only one national game, and that is hurling, but I am not going into any further controversy. I would make one appeal to the Minister. I would ask him to be a sport. We are a sporting people and we pride ourselves on our prowess on the athletic field at home and internationally, and I think that anything that will interfere with our development in that respect should not appeal to the Minister. I would sum up all the appeals I can make in that one phrase "Be a sport."

Comment on this

Let the Minister try. He may convert it into a goal.

Comment on this

I will appeal to the Minister to remit this tax, and, especially, the tax on Soccer football. The levy of this tax on Soccer football is (1) a vindictive levy, (2) a discriminatory levy, and (3) a levy on the healthy outdoor amusements of the people. I think this tax has been deliberately framed for one object, and one object only—to wipe out the playing of Soccer football in the Irish Free State. I noticed, some time ago, that Deputy Norton was particularly successful in obtaining a remission of taxation on horse racing, and I wonder will Deputy Norton intervene in this debate, and use the undoubted influence that he alone in this House possesses, to ensure that the amusements of the poor man, and these are poor men's amusements, are freed from the tax as the amusements of the rich man are freed. There can be no mistake about it. This tax is imposed against Soccer football particularly.

Deputy Curran intervenes with some remark with regard to shareholders or something of that sort. With regard to the shareholders, I should like to tell the House this and I hope it will impress the Minister for Finance in coming to whatever conclusion he finally comes to in this matter, that as far as the Soccer football associations are concerned, all of them, with possibly one or two exceptions, are in a serious financial position. They are not able to pay any dividend or to bring forward any balance from year to year on their balance sheets. That shows that Soccer football is not a dividend-paying concern. In justice to those who have put their money into it I would like to say that they have not done so with any hope of gain but absolutely in the interests of sport. I want to remind the House that there are some 60,000 people who go to witness Soccer football matches every week and that they come from the masses of the people, the ordinary every-day working people who manage to scrape up 6d. each with the necessary few extra pence to pay their bus or tram fares to get to a football match. They spend a few hours out in the open air, a thing which I think the Minister will admit is very desirable and beneficial. I will go further and say that the playing of Soccer has a very healthy effect in keeping men from spending money on Saturday afternoons in licensed premises, money which they cannot afford to spend. That is a moral aspect of the question that should not be forgotten.

Comment on this

You did not say that last week when they were extending the hours for licensed premises.

Comment on this
Mr. Byrne

I think if anybody in this House should look after the interests of the working class it is Deputy Curran. I know that the people of County Dublin are a sport-loving people, and I know that a great many of them go to attend Soccer football matches when they have the opportunity. The leader of the Labour Party on a previous occasion brought his whole party into the Division Lobby when there was a question of the imposition of similar taxation.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan Mr. Hogan (Clare) Labour Party

He did not.

Comment on this
Mr. Byrne

He brought his men into the Division Lobby on the question of the remission of taxation of some kind.

Comment on this
Mr. Hogan

Not his whole Party.

Comment on this

You said his whole Party.

Comment on this
Mr. Byrne

Well, I suppose Deputy Hogan was the one notable exception.

Comment on this

No, there was another one too.

Comment on this
Mr. Byrne

There were two exceptions.

Comment on this

And they were not expelled.

Comment on this

Because they did not deserve it.

Comment on this
Mr. Byrne

Well let us hope that Deputy Norton will exercise his influence on his Party now and bring as many as he possibly can without applying the whip too drastically in supporting an amendment that undoubtedly is in the interests of the working man. I somehow or other never feel so sympathetic when it comes to Rugger football, for I always think that people who play Rugger football are people with means at their disposal, and that a half-crown or two shillings admission fee makes no difference whatever.

Comment on this

Nonsense.

Comment on this

Nonsense.

Comment on this
Mr. Byrne

Perhaps those followers of Rugby in the House will not agree with me, but I am sure they will admit that followers of that game are the wealthier section of the community.

Comment on this
Mr. Byrne

I have been on both football pitches.

Comment on this

Pitches?

Comment on this
Mr. Byrne

And from my observation I can say this, that the men who go to Rugby football, as far as external appearances are concerned, motorcars being parked outside the enclosure and all that sort of thing, appear to be a much more prosperous section of the community than the ordinary workingman, who can just afford to pay 6d. to attend a Soccer match. I want to draw the attention of the Minister to the fact that if this tax is imposed there is no doubt that you are going to put out of action five or six clubs under the Soccer code. You have two very fine provincial clubs—Dundalk and Cork. Both of these are in an extremely precarious condition financially. We have three clubs in Dublin in a similar position— Dolphin, Drumcondra and Jacobs. The gates that these clubs are getting under existing circumstances are not sufficient to pay working expenses. How will these gates be affected if the tax is imposed? I want to say that in my opinion there can be no possibility or hope of carrying on Soccer football if the tax is imposed. I do not see why there should be discrimination against one form of outdoor sport in preference to another.

I think it has been admitted generally by the House that the Gaelic code, which a large proportion of Deputies claim to be the true national pastime, is in a very flourishing position. I think that the code which is merely struggling for existence should be encouraged in the interests of its followers and in the interests of sport. I think there will be a tremendous blank in the lives of many working people if they are unable to witness a game of soccer at each week-end. If three or four clubs disappear from the present list Soccer football will not be worth witnessing. I think the Minister should also take into consideration that there will be serious financial loss arising in other ways. Tramway companies, bus companies, and trains all draw a fairly lucrative revenue from the playing of football. If Soccer football is put out of existence, as I believe this tax will put it out of existence, all these pecuniary losses will arise. I would like further to tell the Minister that this money is spent reproductively in giving employment, and every penny of it is spent locally, in players' wages and fees for referees, linesmen and groundsmen.

I would ask the Minister to say what amount he hopes to gain by the imposition of this tax. I see sitting behind the Minister an ardent follower of Soccer who might join his voice with mine in this appeal before the debate closes. I think everybody in the House will admit the vital necessity for an improvement in the physique of our people. If there is one thing that conduces to that very beneficial result it is outdoor sports, especially an outdoor sport like Soccer football. I need not remind the House that outdoor sports generally receive the support of several Governments. The Governments of France, Germany, England and many other countries not alone associate themselves very intimately with the development of outdoor games but do everything possible to encourage them. I do not know why we, a sport-loving people, should impose a tax of this kind. I know that we have in our midst a certain small, bigoted, narrow-minded section who believe that we can only play one game without violating our national feelings. I do believe that the bulk of the people are not behind that outlook. I do believe that the Gaelic players themselves do not want to see Soccer football penalised nor have they any hope of gaining anything by it. I want to remind the Minister that there is not a single manager in a Soccer club who does not say—most of the Deputies have received the circular as well as I have —that they see no hope of carrying on if this taxation is imposed. I want to repeat that no profit has been derived from the running of Association football. It is run, as I have already said, purely for the love of the sport, and the working bodies in clubs believe that if this tax is imposed it will have such serious effects on the gates that they cannot possibly hope to continue in existence. On the last occasion, there was a somewhat similar Vote in the House and the Deputies on these benches who were then the Government of the country left the matter to an open vote. I want to ask the Minister for Finance is it his intention to leave this question to an open vote to-day? If he does not, I suppose it is pure futility appealing to the opposite benches and the only hope that now remains to me is again to appeal to Deputy Norton, the man who can crack the whip if he likes.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Discussion on the last day ranged over amendments 54, 54a, 55 and 56. A similar procedure is being followed to-day. Amendment 54 might be disposed of now.

Comment on this

I suggest that the Independent Deputies might have something to say on the subject. They will not take long.

Comment on this

They have an opportunity of saying anything they like now.

Comment on this

I know time is precious, and I do not want to obstruct the Minister. I would ask that he should remove this tariff altogether. I know his heart is not in it. I have sympathy with him in the necessity that he has to find revenue, but I hope he will find it in some other direction. I would like to have a few spots left in our life where we will not be harassed by tariffs, and I suggest that we should have our games at any rate without tariffs. I beg of the Minister to think of that, and also, in the interests of fair play, I would appeal to the Gaelic football players, who are sportsmen, too.

Comment on this

What appeal did you make to the British military in 1920, when Gaelic games were banned?

Comment on this

The Deputy is frequently off-side. There is one game that is a national game, and that is hurley, but I do contend that Gaelic football is not a bit more of a national game than is Rugby, especially Irish Rugby, and it has not as long a history in this country. That may seem a strange thing to say, but it is none the less true. However, I do appeal to the Gaelic players as sportsmen themselves to give us their support and get behind us in this, just as I would take off my coat for them if I thought they were being treated unfairly. I will not stress the educational or moral aspects, as that would mean delay, but I would stress again that these games which are now penalised are games upon which we as Irishmen and sportsmen should realise we may build very important structures in view of the common interests involved. It is a pity to break or destroy these ties and these smaller points of community with people all over Ireland, and I do suggest to the Minister that if he will think about it he will see the value of the suggestion. Let us say that the President had to meet Lord Craigavon to-morrow. There might be a little difficulty in breaking the ice at first, but after indulging in a little of their Rugby reminiscences a friendly atmosphere could be created. I appeal to the Minister to treat the matter in a sporting spirit, and I also appeal to the Gaelic footballers in this House as well as the Rugby footballers. Rugby football, at any rate, has one strong point that ought to appeal to Gaelic players—it is absolutely amateur; it is a fine, clean, sporting game. I do not want to make any comparisons, which are odious and invidious, but I think that that will be agreed to.

Comment on this

I would like that the House would approach this measure in a generous spirit, and not perhaps in the selfish spirit in which some Deputies have spoken during the debate. We all ought to recognise that engaging in any kind of sport is for the welfare of the country in general and for the welfare of the people who engage in them. Other countries offer pecuniary help to various forms of sport, and in my opinion we ought not to inflict a pecuniary disadvantage on them. We ought not to discriminate in sport. What we give to one sport we should give to another. There are sports which some members might not regard as being as national as others, but which have become international in character and which permit Irishmen in various parts of the world to show their prowess and to defeat the foreigner. It should be our object to help rather than to diminish the objects of our people for engaging in such sports.

Many years ago, various of the older Deputies here engaged in various sports which members on the opposite side now deride. The President of the Executive Council and myself included, and probably other Deputies, did so, and I do not believe it made either him or me or any other Deputy engaging in these sports less of an Irishman. I would appeal, if not to the Minister, to the Deputies in the House, as Deputy Alton pointed out, not to look on this in a selfish spirit but in a generous spirit, and to say that they are glad that the people of this State play any game and that the young men, and the young women, too, are good enough to play and excel over other nations in the various games, and particularly to take part in those games of an international character that have enabled Irishmen to show their prowess all over the world.

Comment on this

In amendment 56, in the name of Deputy Patrick McGilligan, amongst other associations he proposes to exempt from tax is the Irish Amateur Rowing Union. As one who has been actively identified with Irish rowing for a very long period— some 20 years—and who is still identified with rowing, and one who has been a captain of a rowing club for some years, I want to tell the Minister that if there is one sport more than another, in this country, which is known as a pure form of sport, it is rowing. It is a sport in which we get a lot of team-work. Now, we have roughly, say, about a dozen regattas in the year in Ireland—and in the world "Ireland" I include what has come to be regarded as Northern Ireland, but I do not recognise any boundary in sport and no sportsman recognises any boundary. We have regattas on the Bann and on the Lee—the most famous regattas in the world, of course are held on the Lee. I suggest that the reward of several months training to the oarsmen in this country is frequently expressed in a gold medal or in a replica of a cup. Anyone who is conversant with the training and equipment of rowing clubs in this country can appreciate what that means. There are two or three months of strenuous training and at the end of all that, where you have one or two clubs dominating the others, in other words where you have a senior rowing four and a senior eight, a junior rowing four or a junior rowing eight, which leads the others and it is a matter of a procession, and at the end of it all there is very little reward. The reward, as I have suggested, is very little at the end of it all. These twelve, sixteen, eighteen or twenty men go into training; and I suggest there is a great deal to be said in favour of that kind of training. It builds up character and discipline and above all it develops what I consider a most important factor in relation to things in this country, that glorious thing known as team work. If we had a little more team work, in the political life of this country, it would be a good job. There is no form of athletics that I know of, and I have gone in for most of them, that has a greater tendency to build up character than rowing. It is known as the purest form of athletics because, unless you are carrying a passenger, in a four, or an eight, every man is doing his best, there can be no such thing as doping, or selling a race.

In addition to exempting Rugby and Association football the other sports mentioned—lawn tennis, the Irish Amateur Swimming Association, the Golfing Union, the Ladies Golfing Union, Irish Amateur Rowing—should be exempted. If that were done it would be a decent gesture to people who want to lead pure lives. It would be a good job for the country if we had a larger number of athletic clubs, and young people devoting themselves to sport, instead of to other activities dangerous to the country as well as to themselves.

Comment on this

I would ask the Minister to consider well before he puts a tax on Rugby. I am connected with Rugby in Munster, and indeed in every part of Ireland. There is no better or more purely amateur game. The young boys who play procure everything for themselves, buy their own athletic outfits, etc. For the last couple of years the gates are very bad so that the clubs cannot stand this extra tax. That is the case in connection with amateur matches whatever may happen in connection with international matches here in Dublin. They of course bring a bix influx of visitors. We in Cork can hold our own with any Rugby club in Ireland. We win two out of every three matches we play, and we are known all over the world. I ask the Minister to think well before he puts a tax on these amateur games.

Comment on this

I would like to make an appeal on behalf of swimming, but although I talk particularly about swimming, I wish to associate myself with all other forms of outdoor sports. I do not wish to go into the question whether swimming is a rich man's game or a poor man's game; at any rate, it requires less equipment than any other form of sport. The Minister has said that this is a revenue tax. I would like to take him at his word and ask him to consider whether, on balance, the country will gain or lose by the imposition of this tax. Some other sports are in a different category from this. The governing body in the case of swimming, and there are other sports in the same position, has jurisdiction over the whole of Ireland. I do not know what the proposed tax would work out at, but I suppose at something like 20 per cent. on the gate receipts. Then you come to this position: that an entertainment, or whatever you might call it—we call it a gala—held in Northern Ireland would be held at a 20 per cent. less expenditure than one run in the Free State, so that a very serious position will have arisen. You would find that a whole lot of matches, normally played in the Free State, will automatically go to Ulster. I would like the Minister to consider that aspect of the question.

There are a couple of other considerations that arise out of that as well. Other speakers have stressed the fact that all the money collected goes back into the promoting of the sport. All the services are voluntary—handicapping, judging, stewards, etc. I would like to point out that teams leave this country at various times of the year and go to England, Scotland and Wales and at other times teams come back here. If their entertainments cannot be held here, in the same way as in the past, we will be doing away with our amenities. I am sure the Minister will recognise that the social amenities of every district have a profound influence upon tourists when visiting a particular place. We all hear people remarking from time to time: "Oh, we would not go to such and such a place. There is no entertainment, no amusement, nothing to do." I would urge upon the Minister, even from a purely materialistic point of view, considering all the aspects and all the ramifications of this class, to ask himself is it worth it?

Comment on this

The Minister, since the introduction of his Budget, made some remissions in regard to the national games. I desire to say I very much appreciate his action in that particular direction, but on this particular amendment I desire to join with other Deputies in protesting against the imposition of this tax. I think it is a monstrous course to take, having regard to the amount of hardship which will undoubtedly be inflicted upon the working and artisan classes who partake in this form of recreation during their week ends. I do not want to occupy time in referring to the number of games, indoor and outdoor, covered by the amendment we are now discussing. Neither do I want to enter into a discussion that might arouse some kind of acrimonious feeling in regard to the different football codes. As I said already, I appreciate what the Minister has done in regard to the national game of hurling, but I think he should give further thought and consideration to all these taxes on outdoor sports. Outdoor sports comprise a number of games that it takes a good deal of money to keep going. It takes good sport, and sportsmanlike effort, on the part of those who are engaged in them, to provide healthy recreation for themselves and for those who witness them. I would like to refer briefly to one or two points. Football, I think, has already been fully dealt with by other speakers. Rowing is one of the pastimes which will come under this tax, because of the takings at the gates. All kinds of outdoor games are subject to weather conditions if they are to be a success. Even under the best conditions, it is not possible for those running these fixtures to recoup themselves for the expense they incur. Prizes and other equipment are very expensive items. When rowing clubs require a new boat it costs between £100 and £150, and there is no means of meeting that expense except by voluntary subscriptions. I think that sport in place of being hindered, as it undoubtedly will be by this tax should get every encouragement. I do not suggest a subsidy, but I think it is not right that this form of sport should be hindered by a tax such as this. I join with other Deputies in offering a protest against entertainments tax being imposed on outdoor sports.

Comment on this

I join in the appeal to the Minister to remove the tax. I have been teaching students for many years, and my experience has been that the best in the class rooms are, generally speaking, the best in the playing fields. I have told them over and over again that I have no use for any fellow who sits in on Saturday afternoons and smokes in preference to going out on the playing fields. The reason for that is that sport engenders the spirit of fair play; it engenders something that we cannot provide in other ways, a spirit of discipline, a spirit of recognition, a spirit of keeping one's temper. There are certain Deputies here who would be very much better if they had played some game, as they would have learned how to control themselves, which is really one of the essences of outdoor sports. I would like to relate one instance that comes to my memory. I was playing a game of golf some years ago, in a fourball match, and when coming down the first green one of my opponents said to me "That is an extraordinary thing I heard.""What is it?" I asked. He said "I understand you are a Professor in Trinity College and that your partner is a Professor in the National University.""He is," I replied, "what of that?" My friend then remarked "I thought you would not speak to one another." My reply was: "That is what sport means." Sport has no limitations. It brings us together and in that way we see the best in one another. For that reason I appeal to the Minister to do nothing that will in any way lessen the encouragement of outdoor sports. There is no doubt whatever about the improvement to the general health and to the physical well-being of people who engage in outdoor sports. I did not like the attitude that certain Deputies took when they advocated that one form of sport should be taken account of more than another. I do not see why one should make an appeal on behalf of Soccer football more than Rugby football or rowing. All these have their good points and that fact should be recognised. My last word on this question is that I do not think it is a good thing to make discrimination between outdoor sports. I have no objection to people playing hurling. I have gone to hurling matches and enjoyed them. I would encourage hurling, Gaelic football and every sport that would bring young men and women into the playing fields, in order that they should learn to conduct themselves, because sport engenders a spirit of fair play on all sides.

Comment on this

I think the idea of taxing sport of any kind is bad, and I am glad that the Minister, having come to that decision, has decided not to tax hurling and Gaelic football. But I think a tax upon Soccer football is, as far as I know the City of Dublin, a tax on the amusement of the working classes. I will deal with it from that point of view. I cannot be taken as a partisan of foreign games. Very few people can say what I can say. I have never seen a Soccer match, I have never seen a Rugby match, a cricket match or a hockey match. I am really one hundred per cent. Gaelic from that point of view. The only games I saw were hurling and Gaelic football. I live at present near a place at Harold's Cross where they play Soccer football, and the question that I often ask when I see the crowds coming out is: "Are they not Irish? Are they not full citizens? Are they not one hundred per cent. Irish? Are they not voters? Are they not nationalists? Are some of them not supporters of Fianna Fáil Party?" I think they are. I know a number of them who did extremely good national work of various kinds who follow up Soccer football and who will not go to any other kind of football. It seems to me that it is not the particular business of this Government or of any Government to coerce people because the differentiation in this section contains that element of coercion. It is not any part of our business to coerce people and tell them what kind of game they are going to play and what kind of game they are going to look at. When joining the Volunteers a man was not asked if he played Soccer football, or if he played hurling. If that question was asked some very notable figures in that organisation would never have come before the public. When joining the Fianna Fáil Party the question is not asked: "Are you a player of Soccer football?" because some of those in that Party do so and got votes on that basis. Even when joining the Government that question is not asked. If my recollection serves me right one of the best known Soccer football players in University College when I was a student was Con Ward, and surely there could be nothing wrong with his nationality. Surely there was no one more national than he was or ever will be. On that basis, and without making any discrimination between games, I do not think this particular tax on Soccer football, which is the game that the working classes in Dublin go to see, and want to go to see, will help Gaelic football. It strikes me that those who go to see other games cannot be so anti-national. I have some friends who speak Irish, where Irish is used in the households, who rear their children to speak Irish—a very difficult process—and they go to Rugby games and talk Irish to their children there. I wonder are they anti-national. Why should they be taxed? Surely it is more Irish to go to Lansdowne Road and talk Irish than to go to Croke Park and talk English. While giving every assistance to Irish games, particularly hurling, I think such a wide differentiation is a wrong idea. But that is the basis of a good deal of the Fianna Fáil policy. This tax shows differentiation between sections of the community just as the Party opposite differentiates between the morning and the evening. You can wear evening dress but cannot wear a tall hat. Are not those who play Soccer football full citizens, one hundred per cent. Irishmen, good nationalists, people who, in various ways, made sacrifices for the Irish national cause and certainly should not be taxed?

Comment on this

I would like to echo the remarks of Deputy Anthony in connection with the various rowing clubs, not only on the River Lee, but in Cork Harbour. I think there must be, from the outset, a public spirit in connection with rowing. We can look back with pride on the work done by our various rowing clubs and the spirit it engendered amongst Irishmen generally. I would like to call the attention of the House to the fact that the Minister has deliberately taxed the amusements of some of the poorest people in country districts. Football and other games are their sole amusement. Those who are playing Gaelic football and hurling also play Rugby. Young men in country towns play Rugby, and if that game is taxed they certainly will cut out the expense. I would appeal very strongly indeed to the Minister to withdraw the imposition he is placing upon this amusement. It is the only amusement of many people in the remote country districts, and I feel this tax is seriously striking at a national spirit amongst the people.

Comment on this

I rise to deal with this question from a different angle from most of the Deputies who have spoken. I consider that a tax on sport is a tax on health and physical development. I think that this is a tax on fresh air and national health. We cannot get away from the fact that the economic position of the people who support these games is very low and is going to be lower. For that, neither this Government nor any other Government is responsible. If we are to have games, we must have a certain amount of revenue to keep them going. I refer particularly to the games played by the young people, especially the games played by ladies. When one contrasts the period about 1922, when I came to Dublin—I had been, of course, in Dublin in connection with Gaelic matters before—with 1932, one is struck by the improvement in the appearance and physique of the young ladies of the city. That is apparent to anybody coming up from the country, while it may not be so apparent to those living here permanently. I have heard everybody comment on it—the robust health, the physique and the excellent physical development of the young ladies of the city. Anything which puts a tax on national health, physical development and fresh air is not sound. The cheapest way to preserve national health is by the practice of outdoor games. That does more than all your schools of medicine. It builds up the physique, and when people have contracted disease or are suffering from weaknesses is not the time to tackle the problem of health. The physical health of the children should be built up from the ground. Every medical man in the State will agree that outdoor exercise is essential to the development of our race. I am not one of those people who believe that any special brand of patriotism attaches to any game. The Minister has thought well to exempt a particular form of sport from this entertainments tax. I might perhaps take that as a tribute to myself and the people with whom I was associated in building up Gaelic games. I was at the second or third convention held in connection with Gaelic games when I was a boy of eighteen, and there was not a convention held to formulate rules up to the time I was 34 or 35 years of age at which I was not present. Having said that, this exemption might be taken as a tribute to me and to the people I was associated with, but I do think it is too narrow. At one time, we deliberately went out and made restrictions with regard to games and to the people who played them. We knew why we were doing that, and nobody did more than I did to break up every other class of game in my area. I went out deliberately at one time to break up all games except Gaelic games. We knew why we were doing that, and we achieved our object. I spent night and day endeavouring to prevent the playing of any other games than Gaelic games in my own area. Nevertheless, I think that this tax is altogether wrong.

I want to get down to more detail than did the other speakers. I want to know how much the Minister expects from the tax on all the games and how much he expects from the tax upon any particular game. If we had the figures before us, we would be better able to strike a balance as between the gain to the national revenue, on the one hand, and the gain to national health, on the other hand. Could the Minister tell us what he hopes to get in revenue from this tax?

Comment on this

The total amount which the entertainment tax, in its present form, is expected to yield this year is £59,000.

Comment on this

That sum is very small when placed in the balance against national health and physical development. I do not believe that the receipts will reach anything like that figure, because there will be evasion. The Minister may be right but, in my opinion, the "gates" in the future will not be anything like what they were in the past. The war days are gone and the money of the war days is gone. The "gates" of the war days are also gone.

Comment on this

Does the Minister's figure cover all entertainment tax?

Comment on this

It represents the additional amount which we expect to receive from the withdrawal of exemptions and the reconstruction of the scale.

Comment on this

How much of that will come from dances?

Comment on this

Not less than £25,000 this year.

Comment on this

My question referred only to outdoor sports. I did not intend to include any other entertainment. What will be the yield from the tax on outdoor sports?

Comment on this

About £25,000.

Comment on this

That is a very small amount. I should be very much surprised if people who are advocates of Gaelic games in this country were small-minded enough to make a claim for themselves and to oppose exemption of other games. Hurling is out on its own. There is no doubt about its traditions. It is as Gaelic here as shinty is Gaelic in Scotland. The same claim can be made, in my opinion, for the game known at present as Rugby. I did not see a Rugby match until 1922, when I happened to be here, and I never saw a Soccer match.

Comment on this

You have missed a lot.

Comment on this

Perhaps I have. I have nothing to say against any of the games. I talk only about the things I know. I am not going to make a case for Rugby or any other game against other games. I am arguing the same case for all of them. I was amazed, when I saw a Rugby match at Lansdowne Road in 1922, to notice that it was the same game which I saw as a boy of nine played in my own county between the two sides of the King's River. Tipperary and Kilkenny were interested in that match.

A few years ago I saw an announcement made that a game known as Rugby was introduced into the college of Rugby by a Tipperary student and I was not surprised because that is the game I saw played in my youth. If I have any regrets in this matter of games it is a regret that Gaelic football went away from its original lines in the direction more approaching Soccer. Soccer is a good game, but I am sorry that when we went away from what was the old Gaelic football we made an approach to Soccer. If the game of Rugby were called Rockwell instead of Rugby it would be more appropriate. In addition it would have a better title to that name than it has to Rugby and there would not now be any question at all about its being a foreign game. People who want to lead a healthy life want to play outdoor games. I never, in the old G.A.A. days, had any use for the fellow who is only the hurler on the ditch. He was the greatest nuisance we had. The man who played the game was always the best man, but the hurler on the ditch was only a nuisance.

Comment on this

He was often carrying the bag.

Comment on this

I think that is a very improper remark for Deputy Coburn. He suggests something that is quite unworthy of any Deputy in this House.

Comment on this

I do not know what has been said.

Comment on this

Deputy Gorey did not lose much.

Comment on this

I have not much sympathy either with the man who speaks about a particular way in which you hit the football or the particular shape of the football. I do not see how these things make any difference at all. In the old days the insides of the ball were not made of rubber. The inside was got from the local butcher or from the local horse-knacker. I remember the time when we got rubber insides first. (Deputies: Oh!) I mean rubber insides for the footballs. The shape of the ball has nothing to do with the game. To my mind there is no doubt at all where the shape of the football came from. It came from the shape of the bladder of two useful animals. It makes no difference at all whether a man hits the ball with his foot or his hands or his head. Rules about these things are just a joke, and nothing else but a joke to my mind. I have no use for the Pharisee in connection with the playing of a certain game. The man who sees a difference in these matters is really only a joke and a Pharisee.

Gaelic hurling is able to stand on its own. There is no other game in the world like it. I have never seen its equal anywhere. Gaelic hurling will live without any assistance. In this matter of outdoor sports, I would appeal to the Minister to consider the relatively small amount of money involved. Outdoor sports are a great factor in national health and in fact the State should aid in the development of outdoor sports instead of putting a tax on them. What the Minister and the Government are now asked to do is the cheapest thing that could be done for the preservation of the race. The Minister should aid these games instead of taxing the intelligence and health of the people as he is doing when he is putting on this tax. I would appeal to the Minister in the interests of outdoor games and considering the relatively small amount this tax will bring in to do the big thing and to do the right thing about it and to remit this tax.

Comment on this

I agree with the last speaker that the two best games in the world are hurling and Rugby football. I would like to make this appeal for Rugby football if it has not been made before in my absence from the House and that is that there is no game that brings this country more prestige in England, Wales and Scotland than Rugby football does and this despite the very limited number in this country who play that game. That is the surprising thing about it, that we produce great teams of Rugby players in this country even though the number who play it is not large. I think everything about the game of Rugby football goes to show that it is a game that consorts well with Irish genius and that it is native to this country. There is something in the game that appeals to the Irishman. Everything should be done to encourage the game instead of discouraging it.

I should like to join in the appeal to the Minister to drop this tax on outdoor sports and if he wants to make up the money he can do it very effectively by putting a higher tax on indoor entertainments. It is to my mind deliberately shocking to see the rubbish that is served up at indoor entertainments. People rot their minds while spending their time watching such stuff as is given at these variety entertainments that have been introduced into the cinemas. I invite the Minister to put larger taxes on the things that rot the intellect of this country and on the things that really fight against our Gaelic civilisation, and to take off the tax on outdoor sports.

Comment on this

I, too, join with the Deputies who have already spoken in making a very earnest appeal to the Minister to remove the tax on outdoor sports. I rather think that the Minister must himself feel that in putting on this tax on outdoor sports he is not playing the game. At the moment I do not see that wellsatisfied smile on the Minister's face. He is holding down his head. Is it in shame because of his putting a tax on open air entertainment? While Deputy Gorey spoke of his admiration for the beauty and physique of the ladies of Dublin, he did not say a single word in support of the games they play. The Minister has a great many admirers amongst the young ladies of Dublin.

Perhaps I may be permitted to tell a little story of something that happened at an international hockey match about the time of the General Election. There were certain advertisements appearing on the hoardings at the time, not the advertisements that Deputy McGilligan has been reading for us here lately. These advertisements carried photographs of a certain group of candidates. These photographs were distributed amongst some of the ladies who attended the international hockey match. Whether this is now casting a reflection on their standard of intelligence may be another matter, but some of these young ladies on being shown the photographs of this particular group said: "We will vote for Deputy MacEntee because he is the best looking of the lot." And now this is how Deputy MacEntee rewards his admirers by putting on taxes on lawn tennis and hockey. I am glad to know that he has excluded hurling, because several of the young ladies of Dublin play hurling.

If the Minister for Finance lived where I do, on the north side, near the Dalymount Soccer grounds, he would at once realise that in putting a tax on Soccer football he is penalising tens of thousands of the working people of Dublin. There are as many as three or four matches there each month. Sometimes when one sees the spectators coming away from the Dalymount grounds one really wonders where they have all come from, the crowd is so large. I would appeal to the Minister, if he does not see his way to remove the tax on the higher-priced seats, that he would at least take the tax off the sixpenny seats. The same thing applies to Rugby. We have to look at things as they are and not as some of us would like them to be. We might wish everybody in the country to play Gaelic football, but everyone who sees the very large attendances at the Soccer and Rugby matches will see how large is the hold these games have amongst the people.

I might mention that the Christian Brothers, who might be regarded by some people as real die-hards in the matter of Gaelic games and who at one time would not touch anything but Gaelic games, have now some of the best Rugby football teams in the country. The Minister will be doing the big thing, the decent and the generous thing, and he will be playing the game if he remits this tax on outdoor sports.

I am not going to enter now into a dissertation on games and the talk about the great advantage of developing a sound mind in a sound body, but if the Minister wishes to fall into line with the general feelings of everybody in the House as well as the general feelings of the people outside, he will remit this tax and forego the relatively small amount that he will get from it in the end.

Comment on this

I am quite sure if some of the games are not safe those that are played by ladies are now safe after Deputy Mrs. Collins-O'Driscoll's appeal to the pretty Minister.

Comment on this

I said the good-looking Minister.

Comment on this

Very well, good-looking. I am very glad that we are discussing only portion of the tax that was originally imposed. Very important concessions have been given to a large number of people in this country, both people who indulge in games and people who content themselves by looking on at games. I wish the Government could see their way to make further concessions so far as the other games that still remain under the tax are concerned. If they did make concessions they would at least have it to their credit that on one occasion, at any rate, they gave way to arguments put up by different portions of the House and did not succumb merely to the pressure of big battalions organised from outside. The concessions given by the Government, possibly after a considerable amount of pressure, are important concessions. With the other Deputies who have spoken on this matter I would like to make an appeal to the Government to make further concessions so far as all classes of outside amusements are concerned.

I thoroughly agree with what Deputy Sir James Craig and Deputy Hayes said. You are really doing damage to the country by raising money in this way. I remember the relief it was to a good many people, myself included, when, after certain, very troubled and disturbed times in Europe and in this country we saw for the first time on the placards of the evening papers, not such and such a disaster or outrage, but references to the results of certain sports and games. It was a tremendous relief, because it at least meant that the country was interesting itself in matters other than mere politics. Of course, the question of politics is very important, and no one can deny it; but it is equally important that the people should interest themselves in ordinary health matters.

I know of a number of countries in which, during recent years, they have made very determined efforts—and it did require a great deal of organisation—to organise sports. I daresay they had such a thing as gymnastic instruction in schools to the full, perhaps too much of it. It was evident, however, that they were beginning to realise the value of outdoor sports from a national point of view. They realised the value, not alone to the people who indulged in these sports, but to those people who desired to look on. They made every effort to promote outdoor games. In those countries they had not the tradition that exists here, and it did require a great effort on their part to establish outdoor games.

I think the Minister should seriously consider whether it would not be advisable to grant the concessions asked for in the various amendments that have been submitted. I know pretty well that discrimination is now almost the life-blood of the present Ministry. They can hardly breathe in the purer air of fair treatment for everybody. I think they should make an effort on this occasion, because there is no question of politics involved, to show that they do not want discrimination in the matter of outdoor games.

Deputy Hayes has pointed out the extraordinary subtleties in which the Ministry can indulge where fundamental principles are concerned. We have had evidence that at the most solemn morning functions certain fundamental principles stood in the way of Ministers in order to prevent them donning normal European dress. In the darkness of the night, however, there appears to be no objection, and no one can be more resplendent than the Minister for Finance and other Ministers.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

What relation has this splendour to playing football of any type?

Comment on this

At the moment I am dealing with the principle of discrimination which is so engraved in the minds of the Ministry that it comes in almost everywhere; it comes in even in all those amendments we are now discussing. I quite admit I have not seen the Minister for Finance playing football, or any other game; I doubt if he ever did play. The matter, however, is a serious one. Concessions have already been made in the case of Gaelic football. That was a tremendous relief to those interested in that particular game all over the country. Everybody was delighted that the Ministry made that concession. Similarly, everyone was glad when the concession on horse-racing was granted. Again, that was granted after considerable pressure organised from the outside. It amazed a good many people that such a tax should have been put on in the first instance. Even when the Ministry did give way, for some subtle reason which was never made quite clear, they put the tax on again in order to take it off. If you examine the Bill and the Schedule you will observe that is the method in which they did do it.

References have been made to ancient games in this country. Deputy Gorey was very reticent in one particular respect. He did not refer to a sport for which he pleaded earnestly on other occasions. I refer to coursing. That certainly can claim to be as ancient a sport as any in this country. The value of outdoor sports from the point of view of health cannot be over-estimated. There are many reasons why the Ministry should make a generous concession. They should remember that if they penalise those who look on at outdoor sports, they really penalise the sports. They will penalise them to the extent of depriving them of the public interest, which, to a certain extent, forms their very breath of life. A tax on the attendance would be quite as injurious as a direct tax on the people who indulge in sport.

I will appeal to the Ministry to give way on this one occasion, and leave aside the policy of discrimination. From various portions of the House, from this side, at all events, and from the Independent Benches, appeals have been made on the grounds of the creation of a good, sound, public spirit, and on the grounds of public health. I believe that by the imposition of any tax of this sort the Government are indirectly doing a great deal more damage to public health than can be counterbalanced by even double or treble the contributions they may make to hospitals and various other things.

Comment on this

I want to add only one remark to what I said on another occasion. I want to get part of the Minister to appeal to himself. I fancy the idea that will appeal to him most is the idea of a united, national Ireland. I do not know whether he has ever been to Lansdowne Road when Ireland has been beating a visiting team. If he has not I wish he would go on some such occasion and hear 50,000 people shout for Ireland when Ireland scores a try. If he could experience that I do not think he would put this tax on outdoor games.

Comment on this

A few evenings ago in the Dáil, in discussing the Finance Bill generally, Deputy Dillon elicited an interjection from me to the effect that the tax on outdoor amusements would be properly before the Dáil on the Committee Stage, I should try to convince him that the G.A.A. was really a national movement, an absolutely national organisation, and that consequently it was exempted from taxation by the Minister for Finance. It was exempted on national and cultural grounds. The Dáil will pardon me, I hope, if I refer in detail to some of the activities of the G.A.A. It must have been a great revelation to the Soccer and Rugby people who visited Croke Park on the occasion of the last all-Ireland final, when they saw revealed to them the heart of Ireland for the first time. They must have been delighted and I hope converted. The G.A.A. is a national movement inas-much as it promotes those games which preserve a continuing sense of integral national existence; and cultural because it actually supports the language and the liberation of the Gael. It is really in terms of athleticism an expression of our distinctive nationality. On these grounds, thus broadly stated, the G.A.A. has hitherto succeeded in making good its claim for exemption from the provisions of taxation on outdoor games and amusements. In a debate in the Dáil, which was somewhat differently constituted, I think last July— the Official Reports may be referred to —there was a Vote taken here in which a discrimination was made in favour of Gaelic games by a majority of the House. If discrimination was justifiable then, surely it is justifiable now. Deputy Blythe who took a prominent part in the debate on that occasion. and who justified the preferential treatment for the G.A.A., is certainly unconvincing and inconsistent when he states now that the discrimination of the present Minister for Finance is excessive. The G.A.A. resisted attempted impositions of similar taxation in the days of the British regime and they were not enforced during the term of office of the last Government. Surely it is not expected that a Fianna Fáil Government is now going to tax the principle of Irish nationality that is embodied in the work of the G.A.A.

Comment on this

Nobody said a word against it.

Comment on this

Therefore the Minister is justified in exempting it on national and cultural grounds.

Comment on this

Certainly.

Comment on this

There are other considerations which single out the G.A.A. from other athletic-promoting bodies in the country. It should be clearly understood that whilst being absolutely and essentially national, it is a purely amateur athletic organisation. Professionalism, it cannot be denied, is a feature of Soccer football in Ireland and the superiority complex is very much associated with Rugby.

Comment on this

That is absolutely untrue.

Comment on this

I believe it is, and I have as much experience as the Deputy. That is the general feeling of the plain people. Otherwise why do you not associate yourselves with the plain people and play the national games? Are they not as good intrinsically as imported games?

Comment on this

They will not be let.

Comment on this

They will be let. There is nothing to prevent them.

Comment on this

Members of the Gaelic Athletic Association are not allowed to play foreign games.

Comment on this

What is preventing them?

Comment on this

The ban.

Comment on this

Membership of the G.A.A. is open to every Irish national, exclusive of class, creed or political affiliations.

Comment on this

It is known to everybody.

Comment on this

Is it not a fact that if a Gaelic player plays Soccer he is expelled?

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

We are not now discussing the rules of any organisation.

Comment on this

The G.A.A. is open to any Irishman. We have no divided allegiance in the G.A.A. They accept wholeheartedly loyalty to the ideal of Irish nationality when they enter there. As you mentioned bans, I know places where Irish games are not promoted in any circumstances. Why do not the devotees of Rugby, who say that hurling, being a traditional national game, is one of the finest games in the world, go in for hurling? There are a sufficiently large number of clubs to have a good competition. If they are sincere in their statement regarding the worth of hurling as a game, why do they not promote hurling bodies amongst themselves? Let them ask themselves that question. Professionalism or snobbery may be a good lure for the boy or man who can dexterously kick or head a ball, but the G.A.A. has to rely on the national appeal and the innate value of Gaelic games for the purpose of attracting patronage. The revenue of the G.A.A. is derived from those who patronise the games. So as to ensure that the games for which the G.A.A. caters shall be free from contamination, it prohibits all forms of gambling. The rules in respect of gambling are rigidly enforced.

Comment on this

Does the Deputy believe that?

Comment on this

I do.

Comment on this

That is nonsense.

Comment on this

At every Gaelic match the bookmaker is conspicuous by his absence.

Comment on this

Even so, the money is on.

Comment on this

No foreign dances are permitted, so that the dangerous or demoralising influences which Deputy MacDermot has referred to are absent from the G.A.A. No foreign dances are permitted on penalty of automatic suspension, thereby forbidding re-course to a generally recognised source of revenue associated with the activity of other athletic bodies. On the contrary, all G.A.A. clubs are exhorted and encouraged to promote and popularise the Ceilidhe and other distinctively Irish forms of entertainment, and its efforts in this direction are gratifyingly successful. The G.A.A. also shows its practical patriotism by supporting native manufactures. All paper officially used must bear the Irish watermark and all official "toggery" must, too, be of home manufacture. I should like to know how the promoters of non-native games stand in this regard. There is nothing compulsory about Irish goods in their programme. Some of them even import their players and referees and pay them handsomely. The G.A.A. also finances a monthly paper devoted to the propagation of Irish-Ireland ideas. This is now being converted into a weekly organ, absorbing amongst other organs "An Claidheam Soluis," the official organ of the Gaelic League. This national enterprise was guaranteed financially by the G.A.A., and its members are amongst the foremost contributors to its columns, showing the widespread activity of the association in its national work.

The Association is also preparing a scheme of scholarships, tenable at a well-known Irish-Ireland college, which will involve very large financial commitments. It also promotes the Irish language by having it mandatory that all its correspondence shall be addressed in Irish. No communication receives official recognition unless it is addressed in Irish, and an increasing amount of Irish is used at all its congresses and conventions, and on the playing fields, particularly in the schools' and colleges' minor and juvenile competitions. In many of these competitions, Irish is the language entirely used, and I am glad to say that that is progressively so. All the moneys received by the Association are utilised for the promotion and development of the games and in purchasing clothing and playing fields, and financing first-class teams to give exhibitions outside the country annually. The visits of our teams to Great Britain and to America are known to all the members of the Dáil. They are sent outside the country, at the expense of the Association here, to give first-class exhibitions of the game, in order to sustain and encourage our exiled kith and kin, who show magnificent loyalty to the games and to the ideals of the motherland.

We have had references made here to the international aspect of foreign games in this country. Anyone who was present at Croke Park last Sunday saw four countries competing in the national game of hurling. There were representative teams there from South Africa, America, Great Britain and Ireland, and, on the opening day of the Tailteann Games, there was the Scottish shinty team, playing the old traditional game of hurling. There are new lines of advance about to be embarked upon by the G.A.A. which will give an international character to these games, which will, perhaps, be of much greater value to the country than that which Rugby enjoys at the moment.

Reference was also made by Deputy J.J. Byrne to the huge crowds that patronise our finals at Croke Park, but that gives an exaggerated idea of our financial position. Until this year, we were working against a very heavy bank overdraft, but two draws in the all-Ireland hurling final this year strengthened our finances, so that we got out of debt. We have commitments, at the moment, that have placed us on the wrong side of the account, and the earlier matches in the championship, and particularly those in the junior and minor competitions, are usually run at a loss and have to be recouped later on when the semi-finals and finals are reached.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The House is at present discussing the exemption of certain games from a tax and the Deputy should cut short the history of the G.A.A. and deal with the matter before the House.

Comment on this

The G.A.A. has been mentioned here by several speakers, who said that there should not have been discrimination in favour of Gaelic games as against other forms of outdoor sports in the country. The Minister has exempted Gaelic games on national and cultural grounds and I was countering, perhaps somewhat negatively, the statements made from the other side against the inclusion of the other games in the provisions for taxation.

Comment on this

The Deputy was arguing that other games should be taxed as against Gaelic games.

Comment on this

Might I put this question to the Deputy?

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

With the Deputy's permission.

Comment on this

With the Deputy's permission, I would like to ask him is it really necessary to the success of the G.A.A. that it should be a tyrannical monopoly? Is it necessary that other games should be crushed out? May I also put this question to him? Does he seriously argue that there is more cultural value in the playing of one particular kind of football than in the playing of another?

Comment on this

We are playing Irish games from the point of view of nationality and Irish culture.

Comment on this

I was rather amused when I heard Deputy Hayes make a most extraordinary statement, coming from the Party he represents. He said it was no business of any Government to coerce. I hope it will sink in. Deputy Brasier told us about the country boys who played Rugby. I never saw any of them.

Comment on this

I did.

Comment on this

It must have been across the water the Deputy saw them. I asked Deputy Alton a question, and I repeat the question to Deputy MacDermot. I would like to know what protest they made in 1920 and 1921 when Gaelic games were banned?

Comment on this

I am afraid that I was in America at the time.

Comment on this

A lot of people like the Deputy are coming along now. I would like to know what action Deputy Alton took?

Comment on this

An t-uan agus an mac-tire.

Comment on this

Is it in order for a Deputy to go back to before 1922?

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

No, it is not in order, nor is the history of 1922.

Comment on this

We will have some order when we hear something about Irish culture.

Comment on this

We will hear that from you, surely. The Deputy talks a lot about playing the game. I wonder what kind of game he played when he threw the wooden gun over the bridge?

Comment on this

This is Gaelic culture with a "K" in it.

Comment on this

I would also like to know, when we hear so much about this national game of Rugby, why they refused to fly the national flag at Lansdowne Road this year. It is good enough for those who claim exemption on the ground of nationality or on the ground of sport. These are a few little matters we would like to have some information about. Deputy the Lord Mayor of Dublin, when speaking here last evening, told us that some 60,000 people attend Soccer matches every week. With a sixpenny gate, that would mean £1,500 and I do not think they can be so badly off as we are told they are. If there are 60,000 attending them, and I am sure they charge more than 6d., but with a sixpenny admission fee, it would amount to £1,500 a week. I do not think there is any occasion for Fianna Fáil to make any apology whatever for exempting Gaelic games and for making an exception in favour of the G.A.A. as against the games which flourished when the G.A.A. was banned—the only games that were allowed to be played in 1920 and 1921 when it was illegal to carry a hurley.

Comment on this

That is not so.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Deputy has been told that references to 1920 and 1921 on this issue are out of order. If he cannot keep within the rules of order, he will sit down.

Comment on this

Quite all right. I would like to know, in reference to the statement made by the Lord Mayor of Dublin, that 60,000 people attend Soccer matches and pay £1,500 a week at 6d. a head admission fee, how that particular Soccer club can be so badly off?

Comment on this

On a point of order, surely the Deputy must be aware that Soccer, like every other football game, is a seasonal game and that that number of persons do not attend every week but during the season.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

That is not a point of order.

Comment on this

Well, a point of explanation.

Comment on this

I said that 60,000 people a week attended Soccer matches. There are twelve clubs, some of them being in Cork, Waterford and Dundalk, and that number of 60,000 was divided over the whole twelve clubs. Surely the Deputy knows that no 60,000 people paid the sum he mentioned to one club.

Comment on this

And only for a period of the year.

Comment on this

At 6d. a head, even for the six or eight weeks they are playing, they pay £1,500 a week.

Comment on this
Mr. Byrne

Divided between twelve clubs.

Comment on this

Divided anyway you like, but the money is there. If those people want to claim exemption on any special grounds, surely they should not have any particular objection to flying the flag which is recognised as the national flag, and if the Rugby Association in this country refuse to fly the national flag of this country, they cannot very well growl if they pay a little for the particular brand of nationality they possess.

Comment on this

Deputy Gibbons has run away from the challenge by Deputy MacDermot as to whether the culture and the athleticism of the Gaelic Athletic Association would be wiped off the map if other games were not discriminated against. He has made no answer to that and I would like the Deputy, who is apparently the spokesman of the Gaelic Athletic Association here, to say on behalf of any man who ever swung a hurley in Tipperary that it would not and the Deputy can throw in the Mooncoin and Tullaroan men as well. The Gaelic games do not depend for their existence on the penalisation of other outdoor sports.

Comment on this

Let the Deputy not be under the impression that I was afraid or shirked a reply to Deputy MacDermot in the form which he wished that reply should take. The Gaelic Athletic Association is quite well able to look after itself. Irish nationality waxes as strong at the moment as ever it did and will continue to do so.

Comment on this

The Deputy was leaving the Gaelic Athletic Association under this stigma, that it was asking for the penalisation of other outdoor games in order that it might live but the Gaelic Athletic Association does not want that.

Comment on this

The conciliatory spirit of the last two speeches, I think, will have demonstrated to the Minister the danger which I have mentioned at an earlier stage in the Bill. The speech which I made on an earlier stage of the Bill was referred to to-day as a challenge to someone. So far as I intended, or so far as I am aware, I have not challenged anybody about anything at any juncture of this Bill. What I did say to the Minister earlier was this: I asked him to remember that wounds inflicted by weapons heal and wounds of another character often remain to fester. It was the original intention of the Minister when he introduced this Bill to tax all meetings of this character, dances and other amusements. Deputy Murphy in his speech at an earlier stage said he would support the Minister in that course, that he would be no party to an agitation to relieve amusements or sports from taxation so long as social services were still required and not yet available. I think Deputy Murphy's view is a short-sighted view. It is very easy to allow one's sentimentality to run away with one and to take the view that until all social services are available for the public you should tax everything that is not at first glance of vital necessity, but I think this debate will have impressed upon the Minister that on mature reflection sports or athletics of any kind are eminently desirable. I do not think I exaggerate when I say that those who organise healthy sports of any kind are engaged in a most valuable social service and far from withholding money from social services as a whole by remitting taxation on sport, I would submit to the Minister that by remitting taxation on sports he is by that remission assisting most valuable social services that the people of the country are prepared to promote without any Government assistance at all.

I join most cordially with some Deputies who have deprecated spoon-feeding for one game in particular. I do earnestly submit to the Minister that any decent athletic occupation for young boys or girls is desirable and that any athletic amusement which engages the interest and the enthusiasm of young people in friendly rivalry is invaluable and provides a training which I must say I think is evidently lacking in some members of this House on occasions. I think sports are the very occupation which trains one to join in games, in a debate or anything else, to allow one's opponent to do his best and to do the best one's self without having any ill-feeling afterwards. It avoids that deplorable tendency to feel injury and insult that is sometimes manifest amongst some members of this House. As I have said, the observations I made at an earlier stage of the debate brought Deputy Curran to his feet. He felt that I was saying something calculated to disparage one particular branch of sport in this country. Another Deputy on my right felt that I was challenging him to demonstrate that one particular branch of sport in this country was a good branch of sport and in keeping with the best national traditions of the country. Nothing I said could be reasonably so interpreted. Nothing I said was intended in any way to produce that reaction.

I think if my friends on my right had engaged in all sports they might realise that I had no desire to engage in a discussion into which any acrimony had to be imported at all. I pointed out to the Minister that the very touch of acrimony that has entered into the debate is a warning of the very deep feeling that will inevitably be stirred up if the public at large believe that the Minister is discriminating between different sections of the community who are only divided by their allegiance to a particular game. As has been emphasised again and again, the President has played Rugby in his day and played it well. My experience is that I played Rugby and Gaelic football, and when I was playing both I do not think it ever occurred to me that there was any particularly vital or desperate difference between the two, and I do not think whatever aptitude I had for either was impaired by my engaging in the other.

I should like to say in conclusion that the suggestion has been made that some of these sports are rolling in money and are well able to pay the tax. I wonder is the Minister aware of the fact that at least one branch of sport, which staged a particular event in the Tailteann Games, where the very best talent was displayed and where everything was done by way of producing good talent to make it an attractive event, lost £100 on a three days' display. They lost it because people did not turn out and people would not pay the entrance fee. I can only assume they did not pay the entrance fee because they found it was a tax on their pockets. I submit to the Minister that it is very undesirable to proceed in this way. I appreciate fully the difficulty in which the Minister finds himself when it becomes a question of abandoning one item of taxation altogether, but I believe that the Minister should take our view that differentiation between one form of sport and another in principle is undesirable. If with generosity he could meet that view and withdraw this tax I believe the withdrawal would be accepted in the spirit in which he would offer it. I think the withdrawal or the remission of this amusement tax would be accepted in the spirit in which he offered it, and, if I might say so with great respect, if he took up that attitude it would raise him still further, if that were possible, in the esteem of all of us.

Comment on this

I should like to echo the remarks of the last speaker. The Minister should remember that he is not merely a Minister for Finance for Fianna Fáil. He is a Minister for Finance for all of us, and his Government is the Government of various sections of the people. We have had here for two days a discussion similar to those which we had in previous years. In these discussions there has been a continuous improvement in the broadmindedness and in the intelligence displayed by the representatives of the people. It has shown a continuous improvement on the broadmindedness and the intelligence of the representatives of the people. It is quite true that last year, when a similar motion was put down by Deputy Dr. Myles Keogh, it was defeated by an unholy combination of the Fianna Fáil Party and the Executive Council of the Cumann na nGaedheal Party, all of whom voted with Fianna Fáil, I think, with the honourable exception of the then Minister for Agriculture. Deputy Gibbons is quite correct when he says that this principle of differentiation is not new and has not been invented by the present Minister. It was invented by his predecessor, if I may say so. The fact is that, as far as Soccer football is concerned, we have to fight not only against the misrepresentation of our country abroad by the Northeners, but also against the differentiation of various Northern Ministers of Finance in this part of the country.

Is it any wonder, then, that members of the Association come to believe that this is the result of some hidden hand, of some hidden red and bloody hand acting against this country. This debate, until the last half-hour or so, was conducted solely by the members on this side of the House, and it was the same also on the last occasion when the matter was discussed, and there has been a remarkable absence of comment from the Labour Party. I think it was Deputy Byrne who mentioned the fact that the first motion put down for equality amongst citizens in this matter of the taxing of sports was put down by Deputy O'Connell, who was then leader of the Labour Party. Now, however, the Labour Party, in the words of Dionysius the Areopagite, has shown itself to be "in the superluminous obscurity of sweet-sounding silence." We cannot, I suppose, hope that they will break away from their apparent subservience to what they think is the official opinion.

Comment on this

We are ourselves alone.

Comment on this
A Deputy

Be yourself.

Comment on this

In the old days when the Labour Party was a free Party, it was a different matter, but now, when they have reached the bellboy or the bell-hop stage, they are not in a position to give their opinion until they hear first from their masters.

Comment on this

We are our own masters.

Comment on this

I am afraid that they have become a football in Party politics. I am glad that the Gaelic Athletic Association has been relieved of any taxation by this Bill. I say so, not because of the fact that the County Wexford has made a sensational recovery in the ranks of Gaelic football in the last season, but it is certainly one commendation for the Bill.

Last year, the Minister for Finance was then Deputy MacEntee, and his remarks on the debate, which was similar to this, were reasonable. They were the kind of remarks which you would expect Deputy Blythe to make this year. He said that he would like every Irishman to play the game that most appeals to him. He had no sympathy with the policy of exclusion of the Gaelic Athletic Association. The President, on the same occasion, made perhaps the most sensible speech in the debate. He said: "If I had my way I would not tax any game. But there is a case for giving special encouragement to hurling, for example. I would prefer to see encouragement given in a positive way, rather than by exclusion from tax. I dislike very much taxing outdoor sports as we have not enough of them." The President said: "If I had my way I would not tax any game." Apparently, not even Presidents have their way when they have to deal with the Department of Finance. Not only in this House was that the case, but representative opinion of the Government Party outside has not been hostile to sports which are condemned here as being foreign in the sense that they were of foreign origin. On the contrary, the Government organ has given very excellent accounts of these sports, and, in fact, the sports section of the Government organ compares favourably with that of other papers.

Comment on this

Especially the tips.

Comment on this

For instance, last December, when there were two representative teams here representing South Africa and Spain, the leading article of "The Irish Press" said that "Ireland welcomes these foreign teams—that it was good for Ireland to renew its contact with the Continent and other countries in the field of sports." If the international influences of sport are to be discouraged and taxed out of existence by the action of the Government, it will make it almost impossible for Ireland to be adequately and properly represented in international contests. I think the Minister was misinformed in the actual figures put before him by his subordinate as to the possibilities of taxation from sports. He has mentioned the sum of, I think, £29,000 out of outdoor sports —or perhaps it was £24,000. As far as I know, the amount he would get from Association football would be at the very most £6,000, and very probably less than £4,000, this year, on the present basis, because we cannot expect that people will be in the position to attend matches with the same regularity as formerly in face of the ordinary depression which is upon us, and in face of the extraordinary depression which is almost bound to come upon us now. I think the Minister will find that he has made a gross over-estimate as regards the money he will receive from this tax, so that if he agreed to forego it the sacrifice will not be so great as he thinks it will be. I hope the Minister will give consideration to the arguments laid before him from all parts of the House, and that he will realise that by making this concession to so widespread a demand, he will be winding up the session in a sportsman like manner, and will be sending Deputies home in a pleasant frame of mind.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan Mr. Hogan (Clare) Labour Party

I shall be very brief in what I have to say, and I am not driven to speak because of the invitation given by Deputy Esmonde. I am expressing my own point of view, and not that of anybody else, in this matter. There has been a good deal of talk in this debate about discrimination. We are told that it is discrimination against; everyone used that phrase. But surely it is generally accepted that the genius of a nation finds expression in many ways, in music, sport, games, etc. It cannot be said that we are discriminating against the cultural value of French or German because we discriminate in favour of Irish. If the genius of our people has found expression in a particular kind of game we are entitled to support it. But to state that we are discriminating against other forms of sport by discriminating in favour of another, is not right. We are not discriminating, against any other form of game. We are discriminating in favour of our own. It may be a negative form of discrimination, but we are not in a position to adopt a positive form of discrimination. If people argued the other way it would be that they wanted to put every game on the same level, and, therefore, they are arguing that this is a discrimination against, when it is a discrimination in favour of the Irish game. How are you to discriminate in favour of Irish games? You must either say you have no Irish games or you have. Other people can play what games they like and are quite entitled to do so. They have a cultural value, a physical value and an athletic value, but how discriminate with regard to the peculiar Irish form of sport?

Comment on this

It is not a peculiarly Irish form of sport. Hurling is, but football is not.

Comment on this
Mr. Hogan

I am not qualified to go back so far as Deputy Gorey is, but certain games are accepted as a peculiar kind of Irish sport for a long time. There is no use trying to argue the matter on the Deputy's basis. The point I make is: This is a discrimination against no form of sport; it is a discrimination in favour of the kind of sport peculiar to ourselves, and that is the reason I am in favour of supporting this tax.

Comment on this

I must confess, at the start, that I could not follow the particular line of argument advanced by Deputy Hogan that a tax on games or commodities is not discrimination against a particular game or commodity. We have a tax imposed on imports into this country and these taxes have been defended here for many weeks, and the defence was that they are a discriminating tax against particular imports——

Comment on this
Mr. Hogan

In favour of the home products.

Comment on this

I do not know what they are in favour of, but what I am pointing out is that no one would argue that there is not a discrimination against certain games in this section. It is quite inaccurate for anyone to assume that because an individual stands up here and advocates that certain forms of athletics should not be penalised that that individual is necessarily against any other form of athletics. I heartily welcome the Minister's exemption of the G.A.A. in all its branches. I think it would be a shame if such a tax were imposed, and I think that followers of Rugby and Soccer, and other games, would equally welcome G.A.A. pastimes being exempt, because they are pastimes that the majority of the people regard as healthy. And why not view other games as healthy in the natural life of the country, as unifying things that go to the training of both body and mind and withdraw them altogether from the operations of these clauses of the Budget?

As Deputy the Lord Mayor of Dublin pointed out, the game that is followed with great interest by the poor in this city is the game of Soccer. To have to pay an extra penny for admission will mean a very great deal to these very poor people. It will interfere with their enjoyment of an evening's pleasure. Does the Minister for Finance, or anybody else, argue that the boys of Ringsend or Sandymount are any worse Irishmen than those living in other parts of the country, because they usually attend Soccer football matches? Down in Ringsend and Sandymount the Minister may have plenty of friends and supporters, and during the recent elections he would never have thrown it in their teeth that they were worse Irishmen because they were Soccer supporters.

I fought an election in the city and I was opposed by a very distinguished Soccer player, perhaps one of the best Dublin ever produced. The Fianna Fáil Party did not imply that he was any less patriotic because he was a Soccer player. On the contrary, a handbill was issued by his supporters with the motto, "Give it to So-and-So." He sits in this House now and is, I am sure, a friend of the Soccer players.

Comment on this

Yet not a word did we hear from him.

Comment on this

Perhaps he will now put in a word of defence of those poor deluded Soccer players. Candidly, I cannot understand this discrimination. I could understand the Government taking such an intense interest in sport that they decided to subsidise some particular form of sport. If there was a vote taken here to subsidise any sport I would be in favour of it, no matter who advanced the suggestion. But if it is impossible for the Government to subsidise sport, at any rate, they need not penalise it. There is a lot of confusion in the minds of some people as to what is Irish sport and what is non-Irish sport. Personally I think as good a Committee as could possibly decide that question is the Committee of the Tailteann Games. During the past two weeks you had very many of the sports that are penalised here recognised by the Tailteann Games. You had sports that some narrow-minded people might regard as "foreign games" played as part of the Tailteann Games. I do not want to get into the historical argument. I am not well posted in history, and I do not think it would serve a very useful purpose to go back and find out exactly whether it was a round ball or an oblong ball was kicked from village to village a couple of centuries ago. I think we might waste a considerable amount of time trying to ascertain the shape or the name of that particular ball, and having wasted all that time every one would still cling to the opinion he had before he opened a book to look it up. I think we should be big enough to do this. We should be generous enough to do so, and to recognise that, although it is a painful necessity to tax any commodity, the last things we should tax are the pleasures of the people, which lead to development of character, the development of health and a spirit of discipline inside the person.

Comment on this
Mr. Lynch

I am assuming that amendment 58 is not being discussed with this group.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Minister suggests that it should be. I understood that has not been discussed so far, and I prevented Deputy Gorey from referring to coursing on that understanding. However, the Minister says that all the amendments to Section 22 are being discussed.

Comment on this

Surely that is a matter for the Chair and not for the Minister.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

I am leaving it to the House to decide whether it should be dealt with now.

Comment on this

Before Deputy Morrissey intervenes I would like to say that I understand the debate on this section, which began on Tuesday night, ranged over the whole thing, that everything was being discussed in the general discussion, and that we were to have separate divisions afterwards.

Comment on this

You will remember, sir, that, not having been in the House for the debate previously, I thought it unfair that the discussion was as wide as it was, and that dancing should be dragged across what was a discussion on sports. You rule, sir, on amendments 54, 54a, 55, 56, and 59.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

And amendment 211.

Comment on this

That is consequential. I think it would shorten the debate if we finished this, and if the discussion were more vocal.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Will the House take a decision on these amendments now?

Comment on this

Leaving out amendment 58.

Comment on this

May I remind the House that there was an agreement between all sections to complete the Committee Stage to-day and to allow the Second Reading Stage of the Housing Bill to commence to-morrow. In most of the speeches we have heard, no regard whatever has been paid to that agreement, because they ranged from the robust appearance of Dublin ladies on the one hand to silk hats on the other hand.

Comment on this

And pretty Ministers.

Comment on this

Surely the Deputy will believe me when I say that I was too modest to refer to that, even though I admit that Deputy Mrs. Collins-O'Driscoll, who mentioned it, showed that she knew how to appeal to the vanity of man. I do not know what the silk hat has to do with the debate, except that possibly more than half a century ago it was regarded as the correct form of headgear for those who wanted to play cricket. It has been dragged in by the Cumann na nGaedheal Opposition, as it was dragged in in other sections of this Bill. I do not see why it should be dragged in except that they wish to erect the silk hat here as a sort of religious symbol in endeavouring to re-establish possibly the oval cult long ago vanished.

Comment on this

I submit that the Minister has spent more time talking about tall hats since he came here than was spent during the last three hours.

Comment on this

I have listened to inconsequent talk for three hours.

Comment on this

That is what you are doing.

Comment on this

If it has nothing to do with the debate, why was it brought in, except to waste time? Why mention tall hats at all except to waste time. I admit that possibly I am optimistic but the silk hat has become an obsession with Cumann na nGaedheal. It shows how flimsy the whole criticism of the Budget has been when in a debate on the Budget Resolutions they have to bring in as an argument the silk hat.

Comment on this

Do not mind the shape of the hat.

Comment on this

Most of the speeches that were made on this section seemed to me to have been made through silk hats.

Comment on this

In order to dispose of the matter for the last time will the Minister say what is the most recent decision of the Executive Council on the matter?

Comment on this

I must ask the Deputy to refrain from interrupting. He has become almost as impossible as Deputy Gorey. The whole of this debate proceeded on two misapprehensions, the first being that there was a tax on players—a tax on games—and the second was that the Exchequer had money to give away. I am not approaching this matter as the advocate of one particular game as against another. I am remembering what Deputy Esmonde reminded me of, that I am not merely the Minister for Finance for a Party. If I were Minister for Finance for a Party I would possibly concede everything that the Opposition is asking for, in order that I might get out of that concession the political capital which the Opposition are seeking to secure by making what they know to be impossible requests. I am here as Minister for Finance for the people of this State, to secure, if I can, the revenue which will permit me to finance the public services which the people of this State require. In order to do that, I have had to put a tax on entertainments, as I have had to continue the tax which the preceding Government put on the food and the clothing of the people. As I could not remit the tax on food I am not remitting the tax on entertainments. I would like to correct Deputies who do not seem to have examined this case before they put up impossible demands. I repeat again that this is not a tax upon games. It is a tax upon those who go to see games as entertainment. There is nothing in this section which will prevent Deputy Sir James Craig from going out and playing again that four-some with the professor from University College, and there is nothing which will prevent those robust young ladies to whom Deputy Gorey referred, from going out with their tennis racquets and playing their games of tennis. There is nothing which will prevent the rowing crew to whom Deputy Anthony referred—and judging from the Deputy's speech he seems to be the beau ideal of sportsmen—going out and rowing again. We are not interfering with, and we are not taxing individuals playing games. We are taxing those who go to see games as entertainment, just as we are taxing workers who go to see cinema pictures as entertainment.

Comment on this

It is taxing games.

Comment on this

Discrimination with a difference.

Comment on this

We have to tax them because we have to provide money to carry on the public services. To yield to the demands made by the Opposition would cost us this year not less than £59,000. If I yielded to them I should have to give up some essential services. For instance, I would have to withdraw the Vote for Forestry for which service we have to provide £66,000. I would have to withdraw the item for the Development of Marine Industries in Vote 54, amounting to £60,000. I would have to withdraw the item of £56,000 which appears against the railway Vote. I would like to direct the attention of the former Minister for Defence, and I believe a former Chief-of-Staff, to the fact that I would have to withdraw from Vote 65, subheads A and B, which provide for wound and disability pensions for ex-members of the forces, and allowances and gratuities to deceased members' relatives and to the dependents of ex-members of the forces. I should have to do one of these things if I yielded to the demands which have been put up by the Opposition. Now, they can choose. Do they want me to withdraw subheads A and B of Vote 65? Do they want me to discontinue paying wound and disability pensions or allowances to dependents of their old comrades? We have got to look at the matter on that basis and on no other. I have given away on this section every possible concession I can and I have got to stand fast for the rest of the money. There is no answer to that and there can be no answer to it. I have got to stand fast, not because I am Minister for Finance for a Fianna Fáil Party only, but because I am Minister for Finance charged to serve the whole people of this country and to procure on their behalf the moneys to carry on the public services which they deem necessary.

Comment on this

I should like to say a few words on this question——

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The understanding was that the Minister rose to conclude the debate on some six amendments.

Comment on this

I do not think so.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Chair thinks so. The House is with me in that opinion.

Comment on this

Do I understand that all the other amendments are being dealt with now?

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

A division is about to be taken to cover amendments 54, 54a, 55, 56, 59 and 211.

Comment on this

I should like to put a question to the Minister. Is it not a fact that when he introduced his Budget he had incorporated in it proposals for the taxation of all games? I feel that the Minister is not acting fairly in putting a tax on certain games and not putting a tax on other games. It is not a question of losing £60,000 or giving pensions to wounded soldiers. It is a question of differentiation.

Comment on this