We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

Finance Bill, 1932—Committee (Resumed).

Contributions 209–431 of 875. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 4 parts.

Bill Finance Bill, 1932
Enacted

No. 11 of 1932 ›

I move amendment 55:—

To delete sub-section (3) and substitute the following—

(3) On and after the 30th day of May, 1932, entertainments duty shall not be charged or levied on any entertainment as respects which it is proved to the satisfaction of the Revenue Commissioners that the entertainment consists solely of an exhibition of all or any of the following games or sports, that is to say:—

(a) games of football;

(b) games of badminton;

(c) gymnastic displays not involving the use or participation of horses, dogs, or other animals or the use of mechanically propelled vehicles;

(d) boxing contests at or in connection with which no money is awarded or paid to any of the contestants whether as prizes, remuneration or otherwise;

(e) any games or sports which are ordinarily played or contested out-of-doors by two or more persons or by two or more groups of persons and do not involve the use or participation of horses, dogs, or other animals or the use of mechanically propelled vehicles.

Comment on this
Division

Question put: "That the words proposed to be deleted stand part of the Bill."

Tá 63
·
Níl 58
Result Carried The question put was agreed to.

Do you agree with this result?

I move amendment 57:—

To delete sub-section (4) of Section 22.—(Earnán de Blaghd).

This is a drafting amendment, and I think the Minister might accept it.

Comment on this

Yes, it is a drafting amendment.

Comment on this
Mr. Lynch

This is in addition to the sub-sections which have been deleted. The subject can be raised on my amendment 212 on the Schedule. It is really not so much a matter of entertainment. It is a commercial matter.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Does the Deputy desire to have the amendment postponed?

Comment on this
Mr. Lynch

I think it would be more advisable. If you like we will take it now.

Comment on this

There is one advantage in the suggestion which Deputy Lynch made at the beginning. It was agreed that it would be desirable to discuss the Schedules in as great detail as possible to-day in the presence of the Minister for Industry and Commerce and his advisers most of whom will be away to-morrow.

Comment on this

I think the amendment can be raised on the Schedule.

Comment on this

Do I understand the Minister to say that he will take amendments in the Schedule?

Comment on this

Yes.

Comment on this

At what hour?

Comment on this

Immediately.

Comment on this

I move amendment 62:—

To add at the end of the section, line 29, the words "but not in any case exceeding the sum of five pounds.

Comment on this

If it would meet the case in regard to Section 23, there is an amendment down by Deputy Mulcahy, and I would be prepared to accept that amendment in part. That is to say, if the Deputy would agree to make the limit £10 instead of £5 I would agree.

Comment on this

Very good; I am satisfied.

Comment on this

Does that mean then that this section is agreed to?

Comment on this

Yes, with that amendment. The Minister is accepting the amendment as amended?

Comment on this

Yes.

Comment on this

Deputy Wolfe asked me to move amendment 63, which stands in his name:

To add at the end of the section a new sub-section as follows:—

"(2) This section shall not apply to any premises wherein no tobacco is sold save only through the medium of automatic machines."

Comment on this

I will bring in an amendment on the Report Stage that will enable that matter to be discussed.

Comment on this

Thank you.

Comment on this

I move amendments 61 and 61a:—

61. In page 19, line 24, to delete the figures "1826" and substitute the figures "1825."

61a. In page 19, in line 25, to delete the words "equals or," and in line 28, before the word "poor" to insert the words "amount by which the," and in line 29, after the word "premises" to add the words "exceed ten pounds."

These are drafting amendments and I am moving them both.

Comment on this

I am moving to insert before Section 24 a new section:—

Before Section 24 to insert a new section as follows:—

(1) There shall be charged, levied, and paid for and upon every licence (in this section referred to as a moneylender's licence) to act and carry on business as a moneylender issued under any Act passed or to be passed during the financial year beginning on the 1st day of April, 1932, an excise duty at the following rates, that is to say:—

(a) on a moneylender's licence expiring on the 31st day of July, 1933—ten pounds;

(b) on a moneylender's licence expiring on the 31st day of July in any year, other than the year 1933, and taken out within six months before such expiry—ten pounds.

(c) on any other moneylender's licence—fifteen pounds.

(2) Where it is proved to the satisfaction of the Revenue Commissioners that there is in force an excise licence to carry on the business of a pawnbroker at any premises in respect of which one or more moneylenders' licences is or are taken out by the individual or individuals carrying on such business the Revenue Commissioners shall—

(a) where only one such moneylender's licence is so taken out remit or, if the duty has been paid, repay one-half of the duty on such licence, and

(b) where two or more such moneylenders' licences are so taken out, remit or, if the duty has been paid, repay one-half of the duty on such one of such licences as is first taken out.

This is a new section designed to make provision for the Moneylenders Bill which will be introduced after the Adjournment. We will possibly have to amend the section on Report but we are getting the principle in now.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Does not amendment 103 meet amendment 104?

Comment on this

I do not think it does.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

They both deal with slate.

Comment on this

Very good.

Comment on this

May I ask if a small statue or a large statue is included under the heading of monumental stone?

Comment on this

No. Monumental stone comes under Reference No. 1. That deals only with stone for building purposes.

Comment on this

Statues are not included, even though they may form part of the building?

Comment on this

They would be an ornamentation on a building.

Comment on this

And they will not be included.

Comment on this

I move amendment 105 which is as follows:—

At Ref. No. 1, page 27, in the second column after the word "sawing" to add words "or crushing."

This is an amendment which I referred to on the Second Reading of the Bill. It is intended to permit the importation of certain crushed marble for mosaic work and other work of that kind.

Comment on this

I beg to move amendment 106:—

At Ref. No. 1, second column, after the word "sawing" to add the words "excluding polished black and purple Aberdeen granite."

This has reference to a species of black or—whatever you may like to call it— purple granite that is used extensively in shop fittings. There is no other substitute for it in this country. I understand it cannot be brought in and worked here. There is no machinery available for it and apparently the stone people do not wish to undertake the working of it. This is a class of stone that is very ornamental in appearance; it adds very much to the appearance of the streets. I would like to point out to the Minister that any tax imposed on this granite increases the cost of the very best class of shop front. In that way it adds to the cost of the owner of the building and it will in the long run increase his valuation. Therefore, he is more or less paying for beautifying the appearance of the streets and also he has to pay a permanent additional amount on his valuation. I appeal to the Minister to accept this amendment.

Comment on this

I am afraid it is not possible to accept the amendment. Following representations made by the Deputy and others on the Second Reading debate, officials of my Department consulted the firms engaged in the stone-cutting and working industries and they were very strongly opposed to any modification on the lines now suggested by the Deputy. It is true the polishing of granite is not done here now. It was done some years ago and I have no doubt it will be done again if this duty is maintained in its present form. Marble suitable for shop fronts and similar decorative work is available here in considerable quantities. Limestone almost like marble is being used for that purpose at the moment. It is available in large quantities and, when polished, gives a very fine appearance. The process of working can be done here. The imposition of the duty is to ensure that the process of working will be done here.

Comment on this

Can the Minister indicate any firm that is prepared to polish that granite at the present time? Can he give me the name of any firm prepared to undertake the work? I understand they have been approached and they are not willing to do it.

Comment on this

I do not know what approach the Deputy is referring to. Officials of the Department of Industry and Commerce approached firms and found them opposed to this line. A number of them stated they did polish granite in this country at one time and they would do so again although they were not actually engaged in that process at the moment.

Comment on this

Can the Minister give me the name of a firm prepared to do it?

Comment on this

I cannot mention the name.

Comment on this

Will the Minister give it at a later stage if this amendment is withdrawn? My point is that there is no firm willing to undertake this commercially.

Comment on this

Even if that were so, that no firm intended to engage in this business of polishing granite, my attitude would be unchanged. There is an abundance of marble and limestone available and it can be polished for any purpose for which granite can be used.

Comment on this

They are not sold in commercial quantities.

Comment on this

I may say that in County Cork there is a most beautiful marble—Midleton marble—which is used in many religious buildings. Then there are splendid quarries at Fermoy and, as to Connemara marble, what can surpass it? I have every sympathy with this tariff and I hope the Minister will stand firm on it.

Comment on this

Can the Minister get some information for Deputy Dockrell about marble polishers?

Comment on this

Certainly.

Comment on this

The Minister has indicated that Irish firms were formerly engaged polishing granite. Can he say if there are any firms engaged on that work at the moment?

Comment on this

Yes, there are.

Comment on this

Where are they?

Comment on this

I will supply the Deputy with a list.

Comment on this

I am aware that Connemara marble has been extensively used.

Comment on this

I beg to move amendment 107:—

At Ref. No. 1, page 27, to insert in the fifth column the following provision:—

Where it appears to the satisfaction of the Revenue Commissioners that an article chargeable with this duty is imported for use in the construction of a building which was in course of construction on the 12th day of May, 1932, the Revenue Commissioners may, subject to compliance with such conditions as they think fit to impose, permit such article to be imported without payment of this duty or repay any such duty paid on such article.

This amendment is submitted to meet the case put forward by Deputy Coburn, and one or two similar cases. This deals with cases where cut stone had been ordered for a building that was in course of construction when the Budget was introduced. Duty would have to be paid upon that stone if this amendment were not inserted. The purpose of the amendment is to enable the Revenue Commissioners to permit the importation of such stone; that is, stone intended for a building in course of construction on 12th May. That stone will be imported free of duty in order to enable the building to be completed.

Comment on this

I am very glad the Minister has introduced this amendment. It will be a great boon to contractors who are at the moment engaged completing buildings for which they contracted previous to the imposition of this tariff.

Comment on this

I beg to move amendment 108. This is one of the matters for which a very weak case was made. There has been no indication of any substantial employment being given as a result of this tariff. I think it is going to add to the cost of these articles in an unreasonable way.

Comment on this

The Deputy's information is not altogether correct. It is true that the total employment given in the industry of galvanised domestic hollow-ware and the like is not very large, but it is not inconsiderable. That employment is now being given and the firms are engaged in this industry. It seems to me to be a type of industry eminently suitable to the country and which should be fostered in every way, and the imposition of the duty has already had the effect of resulting in considerable development of it.

Comment on this

Could the Minister give a rough idea of the employment he anticipates?

Comment on this

I cannot say what the actual employment being given is, but I know that one firm has intimated their intention to take on additional hands each week for a considerable period to come.

Comment on this

Is it 50 or 250?

Comment on this

It would be in or about 50, I think, at the moment.

Comment on this

I move amendment 110:—

At Ref. No. 3, page 27, in the second column, after the word "ridgings" to insert the words "which, in the opinion of the Revenue Commissioners, are primarily intended for carrying off rain-water."

That amendment is necessary for the purpose of clarification. It was intended that the "ridgings" referred to should be rain-water ridgings. There is some doubt as to the interpretation that might be attached to the word, and so we are inserting the amendment.

Comment on this

The Minister adverts there to galvanised ridgings primarily intended for carrying off rain-water. Ridgings for barns could be used interchangeably for gutter ridgings.

Comment on this

If the Revenue Commissioners are of opinion that the ridgings are intended for carrying off rain-water they are subject to duty.

Comment on this

I move amendment 111:—

At Ref. No. 3, second column, after the word "ridgings" to add the words "excluding galvanised wrought steel and wrought iron tubes and fittings made by the buttwelded, lapwelded or solid drawn process."

I should like to ask the Minister to tell us what exactly he does want to cover in Reference No. 3. For instance, I rather imagine, but it is for him to say, that by galvanised gutters, pipes and ridgings he meant downpipes and ridgings. Perhaps he will tell us whether that is true, and whether he intends to tax galvanised tubes.

Comment on this

No. It is intended that the tax will apply only to goods primarily intended for the carrying of rain-water.

Comment on this

You accept the principle of my amendment that galvanised tubes are not included?

Comment on this

Rainwater goods only.

Comment on this

I move amendment 112:

At Ref. No. 3, second column, after the word "ridgings" to add the words "excluding galvanized steel riveted tanks, cisterns and cylinders."

I should like to ask the Minister does he wish to tax galvanised steel riveted tanks, cisterns and cylinders?

Comment on this

Who is going to make them?

Comment on this

There is a firm which specialises in the manufacture of these.

Comment on this

Would the Minister mind giving the name?

Comment on this

Messrs. Held.

Comment on this

They certainly galvanise.

Comment on this

There is another firm which is at present installing the necessary equipment to do the same class of goods—it is not a case of one firm—the Hammond Lane Foundry.

Comment on this

My information is that that is not correct.

Comment on this

They must have supplied different information then.

Comment on this

I do not wish to put my information against the Minister's. I should like the Minister to make further inquiries, and in the meantime I shall withdraw the amendment, because if the Hammond Lane Foundry is going to make steel riveted tanks it is a different matter entirely.

Comment on this

It has been intimated to us that the firm hoped to be in a position to meet the demand for all these classes of things in the very near future.

Comment on this

If the Minister will make sure of that I am prepared to withdraw the amendment.

Comment on this

I move amendment 113:

At Ref. No. 3, second column, to add at the end the words "but excepting buckets of galvanized iron or steel."

I am asking the Minister and the Dáil in this amendment to except buckets of galvanised iron or steel. I indicated to the Minister that I would ask him to do that at a later stage. Buckets are a commodity that the agricultural community habitually use, that they must use, and that they use every day. My information is—I cannot give this first-hand, because I have not been in the market for these commodities since the tariff was put on— but my information from other people, who have been in the market since the tariff was put on, is that 10 per cent. has been put on the price of galvanised buckets since the tariffs went on. I submit to the Minister that buckets are a commodity without which country people cannot get on. They are used for every branch of agriculture. The price has already advanced as a result of the tariff. If the Minister will meet me this far, and give a preferential rate of nil, and exclude the continental buckets, he will preserve competition adequate to control prices.

Comment on this

I could not agree to that. The removal of buckets from the scope of the duty would be, in fact, to nullify the duty altogether, because they are one of the main items which are manufactured in the country. I will undertake to investigate the statement that an increase of 10 per cent. has taken place. If such an increase has taken place, and if there is no justification for it, then the matter could be considered. I will undertake to make sure of what justification there is for any increase in price which has taken place, but the intention is definitely that buckets should be subject to this duty.

Comment on this

The information is secondhand as far as I am concerned. I cannot tell him of my own knowledge, but I have been told that by a person who has experience of the trade, and whose judgment I trust. If he finds out that it has increased——

Comment on this

Without justification.

Comment on this

Without justification other than the imposition of the tariff.

Comment on this

There will be ample justification.

Comment on this

When the price of goods goes down, Deputies opposite talk about the price of raw materials and everything else.

Comment on this

When I say justification I mean justification. We will raise it here, if needs be, on the Report Stage. In the meantime, the Minister will give me the undertaking.

Comment on this

I will look into it.

Comment on this

I move amendment 114. There seem to have been several difficulties raised when this particular Reference was under discussion previously. A number of alternative amendments have been put down in the hope that the Minister might consider some modification of the duty. Deputy Good, who is unfortunately not here, and who has some knowledge of the matter, asked the Minister certain questions that the Minister was not able to answer in full. He asked him, for instance, if merely cutting steel joists or beams would bring them under the tariff. The words used here are "beyond hammering, rolling, or casting." Deputy Good asked, for instance, if a person would have to bring in a beam longer than he required and have it cut here. There was also some doubt as to what exactly constitutes fabrication, and I would move the amendments here, with the suggestion that the Minister should consider them, or, alternatively, that he should let us know, more clearly, exactly what type of article will come under it and whether any minor change, such as cutting, will render an article liable to the tariff.

Comment on this

On the point raised by Deputy Blythe, as to whether the mere cutting would be regarded as fabrication, and bring the article under the duty, the answer is that it would not. It would be impossible for the Revenue Commissioners to say whether a particular length of steel bar was cut in the process of manufacture or not, so that definitely it would not be subject to duty. It is quite possible clearly is, that where steel has been subjected to working of any kind, has been adapted for erection in a particular building, drilled or shaped, or anything of that kind, it should be subject to duty. It is quite possible to have all that class of work done here. There are many competent firms in the business and the entire requirements of the Saorstát in work of that kind can be met at home. We are proposing to insert two amendments in connection with this reference, one, to make a similar provision as in the case of cut stone, namely, that where steel has been imported for a building in course of construction on the 12th May, the Revenue Commissioners may remit the duty, and secondly, a general licence provision, which would permit of the importation of articles required by a manufacturer in the process of manufacture, and where it is demonstrated that it is impossible, under the circumstances, for the manufacturer to have his requirements met within the country. That is the particular licensing provision that we inserted in relation to a number of the duties and we propose to insert it in the Schedule at this point also.

The position in respect of the duty as a whole is that it is quite justifiable. There is no reason whatever why fabricated steel should be imported here. I have explained that constructional engineers here are labouring under a disadvantage at the moment, in so far as a rebate is given by steel manufacturers in England to English engineering firms on condition that they use only British steel. That rebate is a very substantial one and has permitted the English engineering firms to beat Irish firms practically in all public contracts, because British steel has been specified heretofore in all contracts. Irish engineers have found Continental steel very much cheaper, and they have declined to give the undertaking which would entitle them to a rebate, and the position is that in order to redress the balance against Irish firms, this import duty is imposed. A considerable amount of employment will be given as a result of it and employment to skilled adult men, which is an important consideration, in view of the fact that a considerable number of the duties we have imposed are resulting in the employment of women or young people. We are anxious to encourage those industries which acquire adult men, and particularly those with technical skill, and this is one, and, consequently, I would be very loath to see any modification of this duty agreed to by the Dáil.

Comment on this

The Minister, in the course of his speech, has pointed out that his main object is to increase employment in the Free State. With regard to item 4 "manufactured articles of iron and steel for use in building construction" I want to say from information given to me that instead of increasing employment in the Free State, the Minister is going the right way for reducing employmen considerably. There are firms engaged in this trade, especially in the City of Dublin which have been established for over a quarter of a century. I want to be perfectly frank with the Minister and to add that these firms are English firms with headquarters in England, but with a branch in existence in Dublin City for very long periods. The particular firm I refer to is engaged in the manufacture of agricultural buildings, hay barns, cowsheds and things of that kind, and, as I have pointed out, this firm has headquarters in Britain, but for all practical purposes, it is a self-contained unit in Dublin City. They have to draw their raw materials in the shape of girders, beams and columns, upon which the Minister is now imposing this duty, for the purpose, as he said, of increasing employment, from across the Channel.

Comment on this
Mr. Byrne

Because they cannot get them here.

Comment on this

Why can they not get them here?

Comment on this
Mr. Byrne

Because they are not made here.

Comment on this

Of course, they are.

Comment on this
Mr. Byrne

The Minister knows that girders are not made here and everybody in the trade knows they are not made here.

Comment on this

No, but they are fabricated for use here.

Comment on this
Mr. Byrne

What does that mean?— drilling and putting together.

Comment on this

If they are not drilled and put together, there is no duty on them.

Comment on this
Mr. Byrne

That is the point. This drilling and putting together requires machinery and special plant, and, no matter how good the Minister's intentions are, I say that he has been overhasty in the carrying out of his intentions, and he is bringing about a reduction in employment instead of an increase. This particular firm I refer to has for the past 50 years obtained what is to it its raw material for its industry from across the Channel. They have no machinery for drilling, adjusting and putting the girder together. The tariff has been put on without a moment's notice, and, having no plant, they cannot do this necessary work. They have neither the time nor the opportunity to obtain the necessary plant, owing to the fact that no notice was given that the tariff was about to be imposed. This firm employs a staff of about 100 hands, and in that I include clerical, commercial and travelling staffs, and I am informed that notices have been served by the firm to terminate the employment of these 100 employees by the end of August, as the firm found it quite impossible to carry on, not having notice that the tariff was coming on, having no plant to deal with the necessary drilling and putting together of this girder work, which they use in the construction of hay sheds and barns. They have now definitely decided to close down their workshops and dispense with these 100 employees. This firm has headquarters in England, and I presume that the Minister will regard it as an English firm but, for the past half century, the firm has given employment to 100 hands, and if the Minister persists in the imposition of this tariff, these 100 hands will be disemployed.

Does the Minister expect that he is going to get employment for these hands if they are thrown on the labour market? How are they going to be employed? Who is going to employ them? Has the Minister any estimate as to the number of hands that will be put into employment by the imposition of this tariff? Has he inquired into that aspect of the question and can he give the House the number? I state, on reliable information, that these 100 employees will be disemployed by the end of August, if this tariff is persisted in. I want to point out an important aspect of the question and it is, that this drilling and putting together, or fabricating as the Minister termed it, will give employment only to an infinitesimal number of hands, because it is all done by machinery. Is the Minister wise in imposing the tariff and is he open to reconsider the tariff in the light of these circumstances?

I have asked the Minister what number of hands he hopes to get employed by this work. What does it really amount to? I want further to point out to the Minister that hay barns, cattle sheds and things of that kind are absolute requirements of the agricultural community. I presume that the Minister is not so blind or so prejudiced in the imposition of a tariff that if it can be shown that it involves a national loss instead of a national gain he will persist in its imposition. That is the position with regard to one particular firm. I know another Irish firm which has ten employees walking about without any work for them to do. How is the Minister going to get over these facts?

Comment on this

By allowing the stuff to come in free of duty?

Comment on this
Mr. Byrne

Yes. Allowing the stuff to come in free of duty, and allowing the work to go on in its usual normal way, or postponing the imposition of the duty for such reasonable time as will enable this firm to get the necessary plant to deal with it. There is another matter to be considered. This company would, I presume be what the Minister would call an English firm. What would be the effect on this firm of the Control of Manufactures Bill? There are so many complications facing employers of labour in the Free State at present that they do not know what their position actually is. Let me ask this question, if this firm is willing to import the necessary machinery to deal with this production and to deal with the necessary forming, moulding and putting together of this fabricated work, will it then be free from further imposts and duties? Will it be free to carry on in the same way as a firm which the Minister would term national, or will it be subject to further impositions?

I want the Minister to get into his head that we are as anxious as he is to get fresh employment for the unemployed in the Free State. When we put forward criticisms from this side, pointing out that a tariff fails in its object, we want to assure the Minister that we are looking for no political gain or kudos. All we are seeking is the betterment of the nationals of this country, the same object that he professes to have at heart. Will the Minister tell the House, and it is reasonable that the House should be informed, how many extra hands will be employed if the tariff is imposed? Tell us whether it will be a dozen, twenty or thirty. Has the Minister any information to warrant him imposing a tariff that in the city alone is throwing 100 hands out of employment, and which is placing a very severe burden on the agricultural community which is carrying practically the whole of this country on its back?

I want to ask the Minister whether he would reconsider this tariff or consider postponing it for a reasonable period in order to enable these firms to make the necessary preparations to deal with this branch of the trade which is imposed on them by the Minister without any notice. Is the Minister satisfied that it is going to give fresh employment or that more men are not going to lose their employment as a result of the tariff? I want to suggest to the Minister in all sincerity, without looking for any Party gain, that if this tariff is imposed it means disemployment in the City of Dublin for some 100 men. Whether he wants these to be some of the casualties or some of the shock troops for his economic policy I do not know, but I think it is right that the Minister should be informed of these things. I think that the Minister ought to make these inquiries as to the repercussions that will arise from this particular tariff. I do ask him to reconsider the tariff. I am not in this trade, but I am in a trade that is more or less allied to it, and I suggest to him that he will not get fresh employment for Irish nationals by the imposition of this tariff but that, on the contrary, he will increase unemployment and increase the charges on the staple industry of the country, agriculture.

Comment on this

The Deputy's contention is because some firm with headquarters in England, and a distributing centre here, declines to draw its supplies from an Irish firm and prefers to close down, we should abandon the duty or postpone the duty.

Comment on this
Mr. Byrne

Will the Minister tell me where these supplies can be drawn from in the Irish Free State?

Comment on this

There are at least half a dozen firms in the Irish Free State capable of supplying the requirements of the country.

Comment on this
Mr. Byrne

Would the Minister say where there is one firm capable of supplying steel girders and columns?

Comment on this

One very important firm in the Deputy's own constituency is capable of supplying all the requirements of the Free State in steel girders.

Comment on this
Mr. Byrne

They do not make one in the world.

Comment on this

Go down and ask them. Another firm in the Deputy's constituency, the Dublin Dockyard Company, is at the moment installing plant to make steel girders and other articles of this type.

Comment on this
Mr. Byrne

Does not the Minister know that there is not a steel girder rolled in the Free State?

Comment on this

This duty only applies to manufactured articles of iron or steel which are fabricated for use or otherwise advanced beyond hammering, rolling or casting. It does not apply to rolled girders. If it is only rolled or cast there is no duty on it. The position is that if that external firm wanted to establish works here we would have to consider it very carefully, because this is one of the industries that can be described as having reached the saturation point. There are sufficient firms already engaged in it. Not merely will all the requirements of the country be supplied, but there is going to be very intensive competition between the existing firms. It is difficult to say what amount of employment will be given, because the requirements of the country in fabricated steel vary considerably from year to year. It might be £150,000 in one year, £200,000 in another year, and £250,000 in a third year. Consequently the amount of employment given by the industry fluctuates according to the business which is being done. The figure might be altered by the amount of work done in one year against another, but a considerable amount of a very useful type of employment will be given which has been heretofore lost to the country because of the fact that not merely was the fabricated steel imported here, but the arrangement so worked that the engineering contracts were given to a foreign firm who brought in foreign engineers to do the erection here.

Comment on this
Mr. Byrne

What firm is the Minister referring to?

Comment on this

I am not talking about the English firm in which the Deputy is interested.

Comment on this
Mr. Byrne

I am not interested in an English firm. I am interested in the employment of 100 workers.

Comment on this

We have half a dozen firms which are quite capable of supplying all these requirements in fabricated steel. There is no need to import a single ton of this class of stuff.

Comment on this
Mr. Byrne

I say the Minister is misinformed. There is no raw material for fabricated steel in the city.

Comment on this

We are not discussing a duty on the raw material of fabricated steel. If the Deputy will read the Resolution he will see that the duty does not apply to the raw material, to rolled steel or cast steel.

Comment on this
Mr. Byrne

It applies to manufactured articles of iron or steel for use in building construction which are fabricated for use.

Comment on this

Read on.

Comment on this
Mr. Byrne

"Which are fabricated for use or otherwise advanced beyond hammering, rolling or casting." I think the Minister should consider the important aspect of the question that it needs only a machine to do all the extra work to which the Minister refers, and that in the case of this particular firm employing 100 hands, it does not mean the employment of more than two or three men or at the outside three or four men. If the Minister persists in the tariff it is going to disemploy 100 men.

Comment on this

Another aspect of this tariff, whether it is going to employ extra hands or disemploy those at present engaged, is that the agricultural community have been the principal users of steel posts and girders for hay sheds, cow sheds and so forth. Owing to the tariff policy of the Minister and the conditions down the country where a man cannot sell a beast or an article except at prices that are a long way under the cost of production, there are very many unemployed. There will not be a hay shed or a cow shed put up.

Comment on this

Or a stone left upon a stone!

Comment on this

The tradesmen will also be left idle as a result of the tariff.

Comment on this

The Deputy said the tariff would interfere with the price of cattle.

Comment on this

It is our only good customer who is making these prices yet.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

Deputy Corry will have either to make a speech or cease interrupting in the fashion in which he is.

Comment on this

I move amendment 117:

At Ref. No. 4, page 27, to insert in the fifth column the following provision—

Where it appears to the satisfaction of the Revenue Commissioners that an article chargeable with this duty is imported for use in the construction of a building which was in course of construction on the 12th day of May, 1932, the Revenue Commissioners may, subject to compliance with such conditions as they may think fit to impose, permit such article to be imported without payment of this duty or repay any such duty paid on such article.

Comment on this

As a kind of commentary on this, would the Minister take into consideration that possibly contracts might be signed before 12th May, 1932, though actually the work of construction had not commenced, and there might be cases of hardship as a result? I think that the Revenue Commissioners reviewing the case should have some powers given to them here to deal with such a case.

Comment on this

We considered that but decided that it would be obviously open to evasions. Representations could be made to say that the stuff was imported. If the construction has not been started—that is to say, the sod not turned or the foundations cleared, it is most unlikely that any of the fabrication could have been proceeded with and it would therefore be quite possible for those concerned to import the materials.

Comment on this

It brings a very sharp line of division. There are circumstances in which a contract might have been signed, say, a fortnight before 12th May, and the orders given and the work begun, say, by the present date. I suggest that this would be a case in which there would be serious hardship.

Comment on this

I can quite see what is in the Deputy's mind and his point of view, but we went into that matter with the greatest care and decided that this was the farthest we could go. We decided that if the work had been begun then there was a case, but the contract might be made many years ahead and the aim is to get the work done here, and consequently a remission of that kind, apart from the evasions which could be resorted to, would definitely defeat the idea behind the duty, namely, that this particular class of work should be done in the works here.

Comment on this

The principle of making exceptions of this character is very dangerous. After all, the Dáil is not charged with improving a man's bargain, and any man can put in a clause that the contract is subject to tariff. If you once give in to the principle that we ought to improve a bargain, it might lead to all sorts of difficulties.

Comment on this

The law is that if a person has entered into a contract, and a tariff is imposed upon any goods to be imported pursuant to the contract, the seller can add to the price of the goods the amount of the duty paid by him. That was the law enacted in 1910, I think, and we are clarifying it by this Bill in order to make it cover building and constructional work. The intention is that it should cover such work and we are doing this in order to remove the doubt and to make sure that it does cover building and constructional work and that in the case of any goods imported on which duties are paid, the contractor is entitled to add to the price the amount of the duty paid by him.

Comment on this

The consumer?

Comment on this

Undoubtedly. As far as I know, there were only one or two cases in which goods were in transit or were required in the course of a contract, and it was the fact that there was a very limited number of cases that made it possible.

Comment on this

Is the Minister prepared to say that a very liberal interpretation will be given to it?

Comment on this

I move amendment 118:

At Ref. No. 4, page 27, to insert in the fifth column the following provision—

Whenever the Minister for Finance, after consultation with the Minister for Industry and Commerce, is satisfied that any articles chargeable with this duty are essential raw materials of a process of manufacture carried on or intended to be carried on in Saorstát Eireann and are not obtainable or likely to be obtainable in Saorstát Eireann and are required to be imported by a manufacturer for use in Saorstát Eireann in such process, the Revenue Commissioners may by licence authorise such manufacturer, subject to compliance with such conditions as they may think fit to impose, to import without payment of this duty the said articles either, as the Revenue Commissioners shall think proper, without limit as to time or quantity or either of them or within a specified time or in a specified quantity.

It is a general licence provision which we are inserting in relation to a number of duties, where the goods were procured in the process of manufacture, and we are satisfied that the manufacturer cannot get all his goods in this country. By this, he may be authorised to get such goods as are not or cannot be manufactured here without the payment of the duty.

Comment on this

I am interested in two items which I do not see included. By amendments 118, 126, 142, 151, 165, 192, 198 and 200, it is intended to insert a paragraph in the fifth column of the First Schedule in the case of several duties. If the Minister will look at page 14, amendment 118, he will see in lines 118 and 119 the words "essential raw materials of a process of manufacture." Under that heading of "raw materials of a process of manufacture" will printers' requisites, such as brass rules, be included? I also want to know whether the words "process of manufacture" cover printing? And are these things considered essential raw materials of that industry, because I happen to know that they are?

Comment on this

Brass printers' blocks are excluded.

Comment on this

The materials to which I refer are known as brass rules.

Comment on this

Perhaps the Deputy will raise it under the brass section.

Comment on this

I would also like to know, does the Minister intend to exclude the material known as telegraphic slip, because I do not see it mentioned in the items to be excluded?

Comment on this

The question obviously arises under the duty on telegraphic steel.

Comment on this

The Minister must be aware that a telegraph slip is now considered an essential portion of the process of manufacture that would apply to the production of a news-paper.

Comment on this

I submit that the Deputy will get more satisfaction if he raises this matter on the relevant duty. It does not arise here at all.

Comment on this

I move amendment 119:

At Ref. No. 5, page 27, in the second column, after the word "casements" to add the words "excluding frames, sashes, and casements, which, in the opinion of the Revenue Commissioners, are designed, constructed, and intended for use as containers for stained glass."

This amendment is introduced to meet the case made by certain Deputies, for an industry in the South of Ireland and in Dublin in connection with stained glass. It is intended to exclude from duty the containers.

Comment on this

I am not in any sense objecting to this, but when the Minister talks about stained glass, does he include lead lights?

Comment on this

How does he distinguish whether these containers are prepared for stained glass or not, because it seems to me the ordinary frames would be suitable?

Comment on this

The Revenue Commissioners must be satisfied that these containers are intended for stained glass.

Comment on this

There should be some clarification as to how they are to assume that. It seems to me that you could make a statement that they were for stained glass.

Comment on this

The usual phrase that is used in connection with these matters is used here.

Comment on this

What is the distinction between the authorities mentioned in amendments 118 and 119? In the latter amendment it is the Revenue Commissioners who are to determine, while in amendment 118, it is the Minister for Finance after consultation with the Minister for Industry and Commerce?

Comment on this

It is a different matter. In the one case it is a question of fact whether these containers are intended for stained glass, and if they are there is no duty. In the other case the determination is as to whether a particular class of article is required, by a manufacturer, in process of manufacture, and, secondly, if it is not possible for that manufacturer to meet his requirements in the Saorstát. These are things in the determination of which the Departments of Industry and Commerce and Finance can assist. If they decide in favour of the application for the licence it is the Revenue Commissioners who issue the licence and fix the terms.

Comment on this

I move amendment 120:—

At Ref. No. 6, second column, before the word "paper" to insert the word "brown," and in columns (3) and (4) to substitute "25%" and "15%" respectively for the percentages mentioned.

As we understand it, it is only brown paper that is referred to.

Comment on this

That is not correct. Bags can be made from all sorts of paper imported for the purpose. Brown paper is made into bags. There are firms that make the paper, and make it into bags. There are other firms that import white paper and paper of all kinds and make it into bags. It would be a mistake to press this amendment; there are a number of people engaged in making bags from imported paper.

Comment on this

I move amendment 121:—

At Ref. No. 6, page 28, in the second column, after the word "paper" to insert the words "and not exceeding eight ounces in weight."

It is necessary to insert here this provision exempting from duty bags that exceed eight ounces in weight. In certain industrial processes very large and heavy bags are used, particularly in the flour milling industry and some other industries, and it is not intended that these should be subject to duty. They are strong, heavy bags, described as paper bags.

Comment on this

I move amendment 122:—

At Ref. No. 7, columns (3) and (4), to delete the percentages mentioned and substitute "25%" and "15%" respectively.

I submit that the percentage rates of duty against blankets are not really so much protective rates as a price raising. The manufacture of blankets and rugs is an industry that is very well established in this country, and they are competing, more than favourably, with any blankets or rugs made elsewhere. The rate of duty proposed in the Schedule is 30 per cent. and a 20 per cent. preference rate. I submit these are entirely too high in respect of an industry so well established as the blanket and rug-making industry in this country. The figures I propose in my amendment are 25 per cent. as against 30 per cent. and 15 per cent. as against the 20 per cent. preferential rate. The figures proposed in the Schedule would be simply price-raising in their effect. They will limit the return from the trade much more than the price-raising would increase it.

Comment on this

I entirely agree with Deputy Mulcahy. The Minister himself, I think, has experience of this. He knows the Irish blanket manufactures and he knows that the English manufacturers are quite unable to touch them with the existing rate of duty. I believe the Irish manufacturers supply 90 per cent. of the woollen blanket trade in Ireland.

Comment on this

About 75 per cent.

Comment on this

Whatever the reason is, they are superior; but, as Deputy Mulcahy says, this additional tariff will only operate as price raising. All the Irish manufacturers have to do, if they want to capture the remaining quarter per cent. of the trade, is to take their coats off, put their shoulders to the wheel, and it is theirs. All they have to do to capture the whole market is to put their backs into the business.

Comment on this

It is quite correct to say that the tariff imposed in 1925 resulted in a very considerable development of the trade, and that about 75 per cent. of our requirements are now supplied from Irish mills, and the remaining 25 per cent. is imported. Following on the imposition of the duty the English manufacturers cut their prices very much, and tried to beat the duty, for a time more or less successfully. They then relinquished their effort, but from time to time they have made sporadic raids upon the market here, cutting their prices and endeavouring to damage the trade of the Irish mills. One of these pricecutting raids is at present in progress, and has been maintained for some longer period, and with greater intensity than some of the others. An increase in duty, therefore, is necessary in order to prevent tactics of that kind being used and to secure for the market the 25 per cent. additional, which is available, and which is now supplied from outside the country. The tariff may result in an increase in price, but only to the extent in which we would get the benefit of the special cut price from the English manufacturer for a brief period. However, there are a large number of firms engaged in the business, well over a dozen, of making blankets here, and between them the competition for the limited market, which is valued at about £120,000 a year, is very severe.

Comment on this

Does the Minister know that there is a close, rigid ring in blankets, and that any merchant who departs by ½d. from the price brings the others down on top of him? There is no tighter ring in Ireland than in blankets.

Comment on this

I have no reason to believe that there is not severe competition between one mill and another in order to extend business.

Comment on this

There is none whatever, to my personal experience. There is a very rigid ring by which blankets are sold on the same terms, except Fox-ford, which are always a little dearer.

Comment on this

The capacity of the factories is much larger than the requirements of the country would justify, and in order that they may work up to the greatest extent of capacity, each mill is only anxious to try to extend its market. In fact, competition between them has kept prices down to the minimum, kept them so low that for a period the mills complained that they were selling at prices that were wholly uneconomic and were not realising an adequate profit. The firms engaged indicated to the late Government and to this that the increased duty was necessary in order to hold the position, and to capture the rest of the market. We think there is no necessity for the importation of blankets when mills here can more than supply requirements. As I pointed out that does not apply to allcotton blankets.

Comment on this

Did they tell the Minister that they are in a ring?

Comment on this

There is an association.

Comment on this

Did they inform the Minister that they are in a ring?

Comment on this

They certainly did not.

Comment on this

I submit that the Minister should be wary when manufacturers come to him to urge their claims, and that they should make full disclosures and should not hide any of the facts upon which his judgment would depend. I ask that the matter be investigated, and that the Minister should look carefully into information given by gentlemen who allege that they are fully informing him, when, at the same time, they are suppressing some of the facts.

Comment on this

I am not taking it that they suppressed any facts.

Comment on this

Will the Minister see that any of the tariffs that are being imposed will reach those selling the wool?

Comment on this

I am afraid there is too much wool in the world.

Comment on this

Has any information reached the Minister about the quality of the Irish blankets that are being sent out since the tariff was imposed? Has he any information why "muck" should be sent out, considering the price at which the blankets are sold?

Comment on this

That is not so.

Comment on this

My information is that it is.

Comment on this

The Minister has been asked if he insists upon this proposal.

Comment on this

I think it is absolutely necessary. There is no reason why we should import blankets.

Comment on this

I agree, but there is no reason why firms should be assisted in this way to raise prices.

Amendment negatived.

Comment on this

I move amendment 103:—

At Ref. No. 8, column 2, to delete all after the words "Putty in any form."

The proposal is to have a tariff of 30 per cent. and a preferential tariff of 20 per cent. on paints and distempers. I submit to the Minister that there is an amount of unnecessary destruction going on in this country through the non-use of paints. Probably a lot of people are using aspirin for bad heads for the want of cheerful surroundings. Recently the people in different parts were driven to use some paint, which had some effect. I hope one of the effects will be to preserve property. Here we are putting a tax of 20 per cent. on paint. I think the Minister might consider what exactly he hopes this tax is going to do in the way of developing the paint industry, as compared with the damping down there will be on the part of people who use paint to improve their property.

Comment on this

The Deputy need not fear that the gay appearance to which he refers will be diminished in any way by the imposition of this duty. In fact, if developments which are contemplated take place, certain firms, since the imposition of this duty, have not merely extended their capacity to supply the requirements of the Saorstát but are beginning to undertake trade with other countries in paints, distempers, and varnishes of various kinds. One firm in Cork has put in a considerably increased plant and proposes to supply paints to certain Eastern markets. Another well-known firm proposes to erect, in association with an existing Irish firm, a factory in Dublin which will, to the extent of 50 per cent. of its output, engage in export trade. The other firms engaged in the industry have extended their capacity recently, and generally there has been considerable all-round development. There is no fear that the full requirements of the country cannot be met by these firms. In fact, there is likely to be considerable competition, as the extensions which have taken place, plus new firms coming into the industry, will increase the capacity of these firms and extend it very much beyond what is required for the home market. I think this duty was one of the most successful.

Comment on this

Are there only three firms in the industry.

Comment on this
Mr. Hayes

How many?

Comment on this

There were five when the duty was imposed but other firms are coming in since. Certain firms which in recent years had ceased to engage in the industry have come back and certain existing firms have extended their capacity.

Comment on this
Mr. Hayes

I remember that when there was some discussion recently about using Irish paint on this building, my information was that there was a firm in Cork, a firm in Dublin, and a Dublin branch of an English firm whose paint was used. This tax is prohibitive. There is no chance of outside firms competing here now, and the question of quality is a very important one, particularly in varnishes. I understand from people who got tenders for varnishes at a certain figure from one firm and got another tender at a lower figure, that the firm who quoted the lower figure used varnish of an inferior quality. When you have a prohibitive tax you have no competition, and no means of ensuring the quality of varnish, where quality is all-important. The Minister may have more information on the matter than I have.

Comment on this

I know definitely that five firms are engaged in the industry, and not merely that, but practically every firm supplying the market also brought forward proposals of one kind or another to come into the industry here, some in conjunction with existing firms, or separately. The competition between them was so keen that, in fact, those that felt that they wanted to come in, came along with proposals to limit the output of the proposed factories and to use the rest for export only. We are likely to have, and it is an interesting development, an export trade in these goods. One foreign firm which came to investigate found that they could supply certain foreign markets cheaper from here than from outside because some essentials which are required and which are subject to duty in England are not subject to it here, so that there has been a considerable development in the industry.

Comment on this

Does the Minister think that the development here will ensure that there will be such competition at home as will secure an article of good quality?

Comment on this

I move amendment 124:—

At Ref. No. 8, page 28, in the second column, to delete the words "form or paste" and substitute the words "or paste form."

This is a verbal amendment.

Comment on this

I move amendment 125:

At Ref. No. 8, second column, after the word "colours" where it secondly occurs to add the words "and excluding distempers in paste form containing 30 per cent. Irish carrageen moss."

I should like to bring to the Minister's notice that there are many formulas for making distemper. Some firms use Irish carrageen moss. Others use French carrageen moss, and others have an entirely different formula. I suggest that it would encourage the use of Irish carrageen moss if distempers in which it is used were allowed in free. The export of carrageen moss would be encouraged in that way and more manufacturers would be induced to use Irish carrageen moss.

Comment on this

Leaving aside the question of the desirability of an amendment of this kind, it can be ruled out on the ground that it is impracticable. Insertion of this amendment would necessitate analysis of every consignment of distemper imported with a view to discovering if it contained carrageen moss and also to ascertain if it contained Irish as distinguished from French carrageen moss. It would be impossible to administer the Schedule if it were amended in this way.

Comment on this

Surely you would only analyse distempers where the manufacturers had made a statement that they contained Irish carrageen moss. I do not think it would be impossible for the Minister to find out if a particular firm did purchase Irish carrageen moss. I should like to ask the Minister if he has impressed upon the Irish firms the desirability of using carrageen moss in their distempers.

Comment on this

That would be considered, undoubtedly. In any event, there is no need to import distemper no matter what it is made of.

Comment on this

Indeed there is.

Comment on this

Will the Minister say if the Irish firms use carrageen moss in their distemper?

Comment on this

I don't know what they use.

Comment on this

Surely a preference should be given to firms coming to do business here which produce carrageen distemper.

Comment on this

There is a special department of Government whose job it is to see that that is done.

Comment on this

Perhaps the Minister would consider between now and the Report Stage whether it would be feasible, without making the extensive tests he mentions, to discover whether distemper imported was carrageen distemper or not.

Comment on this

Apart from the desirability of doing this, there are practical difficulties. We do not want to import distemper.

Comment on this

But we do want to encourage the use of carrageen moss.

Comment on this

We do want to induce people to use carrageen moss. I have no doubt that people are using it because they consider it suitable. No doubt, we might make a bargain with certain firms coming to do business in this country that they should use specified quantities of carrageen moss.

Comment on this

How many firms are manufacturing distemper in the Free State?

Comment on this

Two or three. I do not remember the exact number.

Comment on this

And they are able to supply the home market?

Comment on this

They are able to supply the home market.

Comment on this

Are there foreign firms coming in?

Comment on this

Can the Minister state that definitely?

Comment on this

Yes, including the firm the Deputy has in mind.

Comment on this

I move amendment 126:—

At Ref. No. 8, page 28, in the fifth column, to insert a further provision as follows:—

Whenever the Minister for Finance, after consultation with the Minister for Industry and Commerce, is satisfied that any articles chargeable with this duty are essential raw materials of a process of manufacture carried on or intended to be carried on in Saorstát Eireann and are not obtainable or likely to be obtainable in Saorstát Eireann and are required to be imported by a manufacturer for use in Saorstát Eireann in such process, the Revenue Commissioners may by licence authorise such manufacturer, subject to compliance with such conditions as they may think fit to impose, to import without payment of this duty the said articles either, as the Revenue Commissioners shall think proper, without limit as to time or quantity or either of them or within a specified time or in a specified quantity.

This is a licensing provision. There is a certain form of cellulose required by motor body builders which is not capable of definition. Any definition which we might give would cover a number of other things which we do not desire to include. There may be other special articles required by the manufacturers, to be used in the process of manufacture, and consequently we require this licensing provision.

Comment on this

On behalf of Deputy McGilligan, I move amendment 127:—

At Ref. No. 9; second column, to add at the end the words "but excluding bedspreads or counterpanes."

The Minister has been already finessing with Deputy McGilligan as to the difference between quilts, bedspreads and counterpanes. I cannot add anything to the discussion.

Comment on this

I am afraid I cannot add anything either. I cannot understand the amendment.

Comment on this

We will leave it over for Report.

Comment on this

The difference is perfectly manifest. However, I do not want to add to the discussion.

Comment on this

I move amendment 129:—

At Ref. No. 12, page 29, in the fifth column, to delete the words "which may be" and also to delete the words "the article" and substitute the words "or used in the manufacture or preparation of the article, but in lieu of any duty chargeable in respect of any other ingredient contained in or used in the manufacture or preparation of the article."

This is a technical amendment required for revenue purposes. It does not alter, in any way, the effect of the duty.

Comment on this

I move amendment 130:—

At Ref. No. 13, second column, to add at the end the words "but excluding preparations intended for staining boots, shoes or other like articles."

I hope the Minister will accept this amendment. There is a tariff on boots, designed to promote their manufacture here. The staining of them is one of the essential processes of the manufacture. In so, far as there would be any tariff imposed on this raw material for the manufacture of boots, it would be only taking away from the value of the tariff on boots.

Comment on this

The duty does not cover staining preparations. Mistakes may have arisen in the earlier stages as to the interpretation of the provision. The articles the Deputy has in mind are not intended to be covered by the duty.

Comment on this

I move amendment 131:—

At Ref. No. 13, page 29, in the fifth column, to delete the words "or saccharin."

This is a verbal amendment.

Comment on this

I move amendment 132. I should like to see this tax going entirely, but I suppose we may discuss amendment 132 and the Minister's amendment No. 137, together, because the Minister is making a very substantial alteration in the tax. If the Minister would begin by explaining the exact position now of taking the new paragraph (b) in amendment 137 in conjunction with Ref. No. 6 in the Second Schedule—that is, in regard to paper-bound books—it might shorten the discussion.

Comment on this