Finance Bill, 1932—Committee (Resumed).
Contributions 432–654 of 875. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 4 parts.
No. 11 of 1932 ›
If these amendments are inserted, the position will be that on novels there will be a flat rate duty of 1½d., preferential rate 1d.
Comment on this
A flat rate duty of 1½d. with a preferential rate of 1d. and a duty of 30 per cent., preferential rate 20 per cent., upon books other than novels which are bound in leather and printed in the English language, subject all the time to the exclusion of books which "are of an educational character ordinarily required for use in schools, colleges and universities or of a scientific character," as set out in amendment 144.
Comment on this
Surely the Minister will see that under paragraph (b) there are included books of all kinds "bound in leather or any material which is an imitation of leather." Are novels bound in leather exempted by that duty?
Comment on this
No, but amendment 208 is an amendment which changes the relevant part of the Schedule which imposes the duty upon "books which are, in the opinion of the Revenue Commissioners, novels and are printed in the English language and bound in any material."
Comment on this
Trade unions which are united with trade unions in England of which the Minister does not disapprove get over books in order to have complete records. They send over these registered. Will such books be subject to tax?
Comment on this
In the case of these trade union books, they would be taxable if they were bound in leather? Is it only when the complete cover is leather or imitation leather?
Comment on this
The amendment here is to delete the whole reference. Why is the Minister putting a penny tax on novels?
Comment on this
Does the Minister say that that will mean the starting of new printing businesses here?
Comment on this
I am prepared to stand aside on these leather books but the Minister knows as well as I do that the penny on novels is a farce and it will only mean that every bookseller in the country will be cursing him. It is not a question of the penny but the nuisance that will be caused in the filling up of documents. I do not know if the Minister has ever sent anything himself through the Customs. It would do the Minister a world of good if he entered practical business again and reconsigned something, sent in error, back to the original consignor. The unfortunate bookseller who has to reconsign these books is put to considerable trouble and annoyance for the sake of this penny which will achieve nothing in the way of revenue but boundless trouble. As for books bound in leather it is different. I do suggest that before the Report Stage the Minister will reconsider this.
Comment on this
The Minister has gone very far. This penny duty on novels which are printed here in considerable quantities will give considerable annoyance. I can understand the duty of ten per cent. on novels. That has now been amalgamated with the original duty and made a flat rate upon all novels.
Comment on this
Certain English publishing firms get novels printed here in paper covers and these are sold cheaply. The novels produced that way have an enormous sale, a sale of hundreds of thousands of copies. But the sale of them in this country does not amount to anything as far as these publishers are concerned. The people of this country do not read books in sufficient numbers. Is it the idea that big English publishers of cheap novels would, in order to get the little extra sale that is here and to save this penny tax on their books sold here, give the order for printing to a Dublin firm and have them printed here? Does the Minister think that any big English firm is going to say "we will send for estimates to Glasgow, Edinburgh and various other places in England and to Cahill's of Dublin, and while in other circumstances we would send the work to Edinburgh we are going to give it to Cahill's of Dublin because of the saving of one penny tax on the few dozen books we are likely to sell in Ireland"?
Does the Minister think that any English firm is going because of that tax to divert their printing to Dublin? It is not going to make a scrap of difference to an English firm and it is not going to induce them to divert their printing here because the Minister puts a tax of one penny on the cheap novels coming into this country. When the Minister is putting this penny tax on he is achieving nothing but merely irritation, a very virulent irritation of the whole business of the booksellers. Every 7/6 or 10/6 novel is going to have this penny tax put on and a great amount of trouble will be caused in the collection. What the Minister is trying to do by this tax has not a dog's chance of diverting one novel from being printed in Edinburgh or Glasgow to being printed in Dublin because no big English publisher would trouble his head about the few dozen copies of the novels that may be sold here. This tax will achieve nothing beyond making the life of the bookseller a burden to him and it will cause endless trouble and inconvenience to librarians; because in connection with this tax there is a whole formula to be gone through on the part of the librarian in order to make sure that the novel is really for the library. The implication of the tariff is that you are protecting an industry inside the country. The fact is that you have here a case of English booksellers distributing their printing amongst cheap printers. They send a certain number of their orders to Messrs. Cahill's here. They do not care about circulation here in Ireland because it is small. The Minister is putting all this inconvenience on the booksellers in this country because of the fatuous belief that he is going to coerce English booksellers to send their books over here.
Comment on this
Does the Minister think that this tax will cause additional novels to be printed here? I submit it will have the contrary effect, because it will add to the difficulty of doing business in the two countries. Does the Minister think that the latest sixpenny thriller, say, the last Edgar Wallace novel, is more likely to be printed in this country in a 200,000 or 400,000 edition because of that penny tax on each novel? The Minister knows as well as I do that it is not. Messrs. Cahill's are going to compete with the English and Scotch houses when their quotations can beat the English and Scotch houses. They will get the order then when it pays the publisher. This tax is going to make the life of the bookseller a misery to him and anyone who is going to order a book will be put to a lot of irritation and trouble. When you go into a bookseller's to ask for a book you will be told that it is not in stock, that he will order it, and then there is at least a week's delay before you will get the book.
Comment on this
Is the Minister aware that the Revenue Commissioners have the fascinating habit of charging a sixpenny tax for collection and that they have another fascinating habit of informing you bluntly that the lowest duty which will be collected is 2/6?
Comment on this
He would have to pay that in any case whether there was a duty on it or not. That 6d. tax is a delivery charge collected by the postal authorities.
Comment on this
It is a most damnable tax. The irritation of it is indescribable. I hope the Minister will goout of his way to meet some of the objections put up against this tariff. I hope the Minister will exterminate that tax. Perhaps he will patch this measure up a little more and remove these irritations. I do not think his heart is in this amendment, but, of course, he would not tell me about that. If I understand it rightly, the amendment moved by the Minister for Finance is to the effect that the only books to be taxed are books in English, other than novels, and bound in leather. Is that correct?
Comment on this
I will leave that aside for the moment; I think the Minister has suffered enough. I would like to point out that he is going to hurt probably a very small proportion of the population who are interested in scholarship and research work if he imposes this tax on leather-bound books, even in English. Books from the 15th to the 18th centuries, certainly from the 15th to the 17th centuries, were bound exclusively in leather. Most of the 18th century books were also bound in leather. I think that most of them are out of print. They are hard to get, but they are necessary for scholars. We generally borrow them or pick them up second-hand. They are expensive. As it is, we have to pay postage and now we are faced with this tax of 30 per cent.
Comment on this
Any books which are of a scientific or educational character are excluded in any case.
Comment on this
Take, for instance, the books produced during the Elizabethan period. Some of them are distinctly non-scientific. Are you going to turn your Revenue Commissioners into pedagogues, people belonging to the ignoble profession which I do not adorn but represent? I would like the Minister to put down some date in regard to these leather-bound books. He might, for instance, specify leather-bound books published since 1900. The Minister must realise that there are lots of books out of print and they are essential and very valuable. Most of us cannot afford to pay an additional 20 or 30 per cent. on their value.
Comment on this
The Deputy has been referring to a matter touched upon by an amendment of mine which will be reached later on. Perhaps we might be permitted to deal with the whole matter at this stage. I notice the Minister has completely abandoned his cultural aim. I think what happened in the case of the book tax was that Ministers looked around to see what they could tax and then they decided to tax books. They found, on further consideration, that certain things were impossible arising out of the book tax. They reached the point when they decided that a tax would have to be imposed for revenue purposes or to increase employment. With regard to the penny tax, I do not see how it can increase employment. There is at least one Irish firm which is able to print cheap novels in competition, not only with English, but American firms. That firm is enabled to do that as a result of a business organisation which permits submitting a lower tender than outside competitors. Perhaps the Minister will explain how a penny tax on novels coming in will help that kind of a firm? I cannot see how it will. The firm, as I said, prints a great deal of very cheap stuff in competition with outside firms.
Why is a tax to the extent of 20 per cent. put on leather-bound books? Why are leather-bound books chosen? Is it to give a fillip to the Irish bookbinding industry? If it is, is it contended there is a sufficient market for leather-bound books in this State to induce a publishing firm to publish a book bound in leather at a fairly substantial price? Is it contended that there will be, in our limited market, a sufficient circulation to enable outside firms to send in unbound books and get them bound here? I may say that that is not the experience of people who understand the situation. Those who are interested in the book trade say there is a very small market for that kind of book. New books bound in leather would, no doubt, do some little good to the Irish bookbinding industry. Let us take the type of book that Deputy Alton spoke about, the second-hand book. There are a great many second-hand books bound in leather, but they would not come within the category indicated in the Minister's amendment; they would not be ordinarily required for use in schools, colleges or universities. I think the Minister will find that the interpretation in this connection will be a very difficult matter.
With the franc as it is, if one went to Paris one would be able to buy a leather-bound set of any of the French dramatists, such as Carré or Racine, at a fairly cheap rate. Most professors going to Paris, even with the franc as it is, would find it profitable up to this to buy second-hand books bound in leather. With this tariff imposed the expense entailed in taking such books into this country would be very considerable. The persons who usually buy those books and bring them into the country increase our assets from a national point of view, and they should be encouraged. Looking at the matter from a national point of view, we must realise that such people bring into our possession something extremely valuable as distinct from something that is cultural.
The tariff imposed on such books can give no conceivable employment here. What we are doing by imposing such a tariff is that we are taxing the individual who seeks to bring valuable works into the country. Let us say that you tax six volumes printed in France in the 18th century, or, for that matter, the 19th century. There is no chance of getting those books bound in Dublin. It has no connection with employment here. It is merely putting a tax on persons who are, I submit, not too numerous. I suggest that those persons are a deserving class, because they add to our book population, which in itself is a good thing. If the Minister persists in keeping on this kind of remnant of his book tax he really ought to exclude second-hand books bound in leather.
If there were any evidence at all that the bookbinding trade would be helped by a tax I would be in favour of it, because that is a form of work for which Dublin was once famous. I would be anxious to see that work revived, but I contend you cannot revive it by imposing a duty on second-hand books. I am aware that people travelling abroad have purchased secondhand books and brought them to this country. The books were not of any value, but the binding was, and that binding was utilised for other books. People buy a lot of secondhand books bound in leather, and they get the covers put on other books in this country. I would like the Minister to examine carefully whether a tax on leather-bound books will improve the book-binding industry here. He should consider especially whether it is advisable to put a tax on secondhand books, many of which are very valuable. If, for instance, a valuable leather book were put up for auction in London, an Irish purchaser would be at a great disadvantage. A person who will pay a high price for a rare book will be bringing into this country something which is of very great value. If this tax remains, not only will that person have to face competition in an outside market, but he will also have to pay a very considerable duty before he can take the book into the Free State.
Comment on this
I am prepared to accept that amendment in principle. I take it, however, that it will require certain alterations in view of the alteration in the wording of the section. I assume that meets Deputy Alton's point.
Comment on this
Perhaps it would be better not to move the amendment at all and to leave it to the Minister to introduce the necessary amendment.
Comment on this
I should like to suggest another point. The Minister is trying to meet us on this. I think he really believes that the words of his amendment 144 go further than I believe they do go. I think he has omitted to notice one matter which is of a good deal of importance. I referred before to the proceedings of learned and scientific societies. I do not think they would come under the wording of amendment 144, yet I believe the Minister means to exclude them from duty. It is quite a common thing for different learned societies, which could not be called scientific, classical and foreign language societies, and various kinds of societies, to reciprocate by sending to one another their publications. As a rule, these are either bound in leather or imitation leather. I should like to ask the Minister to consider the insertion of the words "learned or scientific societies" as well as schools, colleges and universities.
Comment on this
I think the case referred to is met by amendment 143 or amendment 144. These would be books intended for use in universities, else they would come under the term "of a scientific character"; or else they are imported for use in libraries, other than proprietary libraries.
Comment on this
I should like to ask the Minister is vellum leather? Deputy Thrift said that books from the 15th to the 18th century were bound in leather. It struck me that he counted vellum as leather. I do not know whether it is technically leather or not. But the books at that time were mostly bound in vellum. The Minister has agreed to meet Deputy Hayes about second-hand books. Deputy Hayes spoke about books in French. As we all know, this definition about leather is only the Minister's way of trying to get after prayer books, missals and works of piety. He did not like to put it in that form, so he tried to get this other form. Take a missal with the Latin text for the Mass on various days and the English translation. What is the position with regard to that?
Comment on this
So far as missals are concerned, some of them are in Latin and contain no English. In others there is a certain amount of Latin, but the bulk of the material would be in English.
Comment on this
I do not think the Minister need try to cover his tracks. We know that this really is an attempt to get at prayer books and books of piety. Nobody thinks there is going to be any business brought about except in that line. Most prayer books have a certain amount of Latin. All sorts of missals also have a certain amount of Latin with an English text. You can say they are printed in English if you like, or in Latin. What is the position with regard to them? In these books you have one column Latin and one column English.
Comment on this
You can buy a missal here for 15/-. The wholesale price would be very much lower than that. To get that bound in this country as it is bound would cost you more than the whole book will cost you now. It seems ridiculous that for the mere binding, the sole purpose of which is to keep the printed paper together, the Minister is creating a position whereby, in order to have the thing bound as it is bound at present, you will first of all have to buy the book at its value, and then pay considerably more for the binding of it than you would have to pay for the whole book bound if the Minister did not put a tax on it. As far as the binding of these books is concerned, the Minister's tariff of 20 or 30 per cent. is no good, it is no protection. He will have to put on a tariff of 100 per cent. to force us to buy things bound in this country, if we want things well bound. Personally, I would rather pay 20 or 30 or even 70 percent. more to get decent value. It is true that the one type of book normally circulated in this country is the prayer book, the book of piety. Deputy Hayes talked about leather-bound books being only bought by well-to-do people. Nothing of the sort. These books are bought by every poor parent whose child is making his or her First Communion. They are given as presents to the children. This is a tax to make the unfortunate poor pay more for their piety in order to give employment to book-binders. I wonder how many people are going to be employed by this and what value are they going to give the poor people as compared with firms in Bruges and other places? This tax hits the unfortunate poor. Because they are pious, they will have to pay for it and that is the Minister's policy.
Comment on this
My amendment 137a reads: In amendment 137 after the words "other than" to insert the words "bibles and." That is to exclude bibles. The position with regard to them is peculiar. You cannot get employment in that respect at all. Bibles printed in the English language, whether in the authorised or revised version, are copyright and cannot be printed except by certain firms. These firms will not print and issue editions unbound. There is no chance of getting one of these bound in this country. There is no chance whatever of giving employment in that way.
Comment on this
The Deputy's amendment is not necessary. They will be admitted free of duty as educational.
Comment on this
The Minister gave an answer which he seemed to have some doubt about, and I want to be certain. He said that in order to be counted as bound in leather or imitation leather it had to be all leather, not merely the back. Is that the position?
Comment on this
There are one or two other points I wish to raise. I still hope that the Minister will, on consideration, insert the words I have suggested, "scientific or learned societies," in amendment 144. I ask him to consider that, anyway, but there is still one other point in order to make water-tight the concessions he has granted in relation to the proprietary libraries. The amendment he introduces applies only to Reference No. 15 on page 30, as stated by the Minister, but books again come in under the Minister's own amendment 208 in the second sheet.
Comment on this
I withdraw amendment 132. I would like to say that I was quite wrong in referring to French books as being taxed, but it is quite applicable to English books with leather binding.
Comment on this
The Minister said the purchase of these books would be a very desirable addition to the library wealth of this country, but a friend of mine recently bought a copy, a very well-known copy, of the Scriptorum Rerum Hiberniarum for a big sum, and did a benefit to the country in bringing it in here. He had, however, to pay the tariff on it. I cannot understand it, and I hope the Minister will see that similar blunders do not occur.
Comment on this
I move amendment 133:
At Ref. No. 15, page 30, in paragraph (a), in the second column, to delete the word "cardboard" and substitute the words "to any other article or substance."
This is a minor amendment. Printed paper, which is affixed to cardboard, is excluded from duty and it is intended to extend the exclusion to printed paper which is affixed to any other article or substance.
Comment on this
There is a considerable amount of stuff of this kind coming into the country for trade purposes from firms outside the Saorstát. Does the Minister intend to tax them?
Comment on this
Definitely so. The duty is 10 per cent. in any case, and if the firms persist in bringing in this sort of stuff, I see no reason why we should not get revenue from them. Generally speaking, the practice is that these catalogues are imported, with a blank space at the bottom, in which the trader gets his own name and address printed, and the intention is to induce him to get the printing done here, where it can be done quite well.
Comment on this
Take the case of the wholesale firm which sends in stuff which is not made here at all, and which sends in its own catalogue, which is not to be used by the trader at all, but which is to be kept by the trader and shown to customers when they are choosing stuff.
Comment on this
The duty only applies tc material imported in bulk. An individual catalogue for the information of a trader is not dutiable and in so far as these catalogues come in, I see no reason why we should not get our 10 per cent. revenue.
Comment on this
If you go into a shop, you may find 20 or 30 catalogues of articles in the shop which are not made here. Are we to get the printing of these catalogues done here?
Comment on this
Why not? If a firm wants to send in an article here, there is no reason why they should not get the catalogue printed here.
Comment on this
I move amendment 135:
At Ref. No. 15, page 30, in paragraph (a), in the second column, after the words "wall paper" to insert the words "maps, patterns for the manufacture of other articles, ornamental greetings, foreign government publications, forms officially prescribed by foreign governments."
This is designed to exclude the articles mentioned from this duty.
Comment on this
May I ask the Minister another question? What is the position with regard to such books coming through the post? It is frequently the case that books are sent through the post to subscribers to libraries. Are those books liable to duty?
Comment on this
It is quite the practice to import dutiable goods by parcel post and there is a regular recognised procedure by which the duty is collected.
Comment on this
Does the Minister really recognise the additional amount of inconvenience that is put on the ordinary public who subscribe to libraries, either in England or elsewhere, and who get books weekly from these libraries? It means a visit to the Custom House every time in order to get a book out. That may be simple for the person resident in Dublin, but it will mean a good deal of trouble.
Comment on this
The Deputy does not understand. The book will be delivered to the consignee in the ordinary way and the duty collected, then, on the book.
Comment on this
The Minister is, of course, aware of the present practice. If a package is made up, there is some doubt as to whether it contains a book or not, and notice is given that the packet is in the Custom House and the consignee will have to go and see it opened. Will that apply to every book received?
Comment on this
That is what I would expect the Minister to say, but what I am getting at is, what is the amount of inconvenience that is going to be caused to the public because of this wretched tax? It is incalculable.
Comment on this
A non-dutiable book, I am informed, can be sent by book post. The dutiable book must be sent by parcel post, and that will considerably reduce the amount of inconvenience caused, arising out of a dispute as to whether a book is dutiable or not.
Comment on this
That, I think, now makes matters worse, if I understand the Minister correctly. I order a book from a London firm—it may be a book on science or a novel—and the London firm does not know our regulations about novels——
Comment on this
It may or may not, but a firm often does not know, and it transmits the book to me by ordinary post——
Comment on this
Am I or the firm liable to a penalty for receiving through parcel post a novel liable to Customs duty, whereas it would be all right if it was a book on science and could not be called a novel? What would it be if it was a scientific novel?
Comment on this
There is an organisation here, the Carnegie Students' Central Library, from which one can get almost any book free. Their procedure is that when a particular book is asked for, they get it, from London, perhaps, and have it sent on to your address. You only keep it a certain time and then send it back. The position there seems to be very difficult. It is really coming into a library, but it is for the use of A.B., and is not coming in for sale.
Comment on this
The library will have to alter its procedure. That is all it means. Books intended for non-pro-prietary libraries are free, and, consequently, libraries will just have to alter their procedure.
Comment on this
Yes, if it is a novel. If it is a book on science, it may come by book post. It is an extraordinarily anomalous position, and because the person who sends the book is a private person, who may, as the Minister said, be somebody connected with the firm, who ought to know his business, but more likely to be somebody who does not know that aspect of the matter, a position is going to be caused——
Comment on this
Amendment 141:—
At Ref. No. 15, column 2, paragraph (b), at the end of sub-paragraph (iii), to add the words "excluding all second-hand books bound in leather or imitations of leather."
I am not moving this amendment because the Minister is accepting the principle of it.
Comment on this
I move amendment 142:—
At Ref. No. 15, page 30, in the fifth column, to insert a further provision as follows:—
Whenever the Minister for Finance, after consultation with the Minister for Industry and Commerce, is satisfied that any articles mentioned in paragraph (a) in the second column and chargeable with this duty are essential raw materials of a process of manufacture carried on or intended to be carried on in Saorstát Eireann and are not obtainable or likely to be obtainable in Saorstát Eireann and are required to be imported by a manufacturer for use in Saorstát Eireann in such process, the Revenue Commissioners may by licence authorise such manufacturer, subject to compliance with such conditions as they may think fit to impose, to import without payment of this duty the said articles either, as the Revenue Commissioners shall think proper, without limit as to time or quantity or either of them or within a specified time or in a specified quantity.
This amendment provides for the insertion of the licence provision in relation to the printed matter duty.
Comment on this
I move amendment 143:—
At Ref. No. 15, page 30, in the fifth column, to insert a further provision as follows:—
Where the Revenue Commissioners are satisfied that any books chargeable with this duty are imported for the use of a library which is not a proprietary library conducted mainly for profit, the Revenue Commissioners may, subject to compliance with such conditions as they may think fit to impose, permit such books to be imported without payment of this duty.
This amendment provides for the case of the proprietary library.
Comment on this
I move amendment 144:—
At Ref. No. 15, page 30, in the fifth column, to insert a further provision as follows:—
This duty shall not be charged or levied on any books which, in the opinion of the Revenue Commissioners, are of an educational character ordinarily required for use in schools, colleges, and universities, or of a scientific character.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 145:—
At Ref. 16, second column, to delete paragraph (d).
There was some discussion about this and I do not know whether the Minister undertook to consider it or not. I think the case was made that certain classes of these goods were almost bound to be imported, certain classes that could be made so much more cheaply abroad that no tariff that could be imposed would be of any use unless it was over 100 per cent.
Comment on this
The case was made that this was a one-firm trade and that Dennison's is a firm with enormous international ramifications. They supply unprinted tags of this character all over the world. I think it would meet the situation if the word "printed" were inserted before the word "tag" and if the tags were allowed to be imported in blank and printed here which I think is the common practice at present. I think the one firm have complete control of the trade all over the world.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 149:—
At Ref. No. 16, second column, paragraph (f) before the word "ticket" to insert the word "printed."
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 151:—
At Ref. No. 16, page 30, to insert in the fifth column the following provision:—
Whenever the Minister for Finance, after consultation with the Minister for Industry and Commerce, is satisfied that any articles chargeable with this duty are essential raw materials of a process of manufacture carried on or intended to be carried on in Saorstát Eireann and are not obtainable or likely to be obtainable in Saorstát Eireann and are required to be imported by a manufacturer for use in Saorstát Eireann in such process, the Revenue Commissioners may by licence authorise such manufacturer, subject to compliance with such conditions as they may think fit to impose, to import without payment of this duty the said articles either, as the Revenue Commissioners shall think proper, without limit as to time or quantity or either of them, or within a specified time or in a specified quantity.
This is the licensing provision. It is desirable to have that power.
Comment on this
I move amendment 152:—
To delete Ref. No. 17, including relevant references in columns 2, 3 and 4.
This is a case something like the book tax. It has been very substantially altered from the beginning. I do not know whether the original proposal was due to a misprint or some error in drafting, but all this wire was being taxed. Now it is manufactures of wire. A number of these manufactures seem to be excluded and we have only got what remains of the tax. I do not know that anything will now be chargeable with the duty except bird cages and rat traps and I suggest to the Minister that they should be allowed in free.
Comment on this
The exclusion of the word "manufactures" in the first instance was a misprint. The duty is intended to apply to wire manufactures. I agree that the majority of wire manufactures are excluded but still a large number of wire manufactures remain subject to the duty, wire fences and things of that sort which can be manufactured here. A fair amount of additional employment will be given as a result of it. I might mention that manufacturers are pressing very hard that barbed wire should be made subject to duty, but we are not prepared to do that.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 153:—
At Ref. No. 17, page 31, in the second column, after the word "iron" to insert the word "wire." This is only a drafting amendment.
Comment on this
I understand that if amendment 154, which proposes at Ref. No. 17, second column, to insert after the words "barbed wire" the words "fencing wire," were accepted it would leave only bird cages and rat traps subject to the duty. I shall withdraw the amendment.
Comment on this
I move amendment 157:—
At Ref. No. 17, page 31, in the second column, after the word "descriptions" where it lastly occurs to add the words "springs, and screwed wire."
Comment on this
I move amendment 158:—
At Ref. No. 17, page 31, to insert in the fifth column the following provision:—
Whenever the Minister for Finance, after consultation with the Minister for Industry and Commerce, is satisfied that any articles chargeable with this duty are essential raw materials of a process of manufacture carried on or intended to be carried on in Saorstát Eireann and are not obtainable or likely to be obtainable in Saorstát Eireann and are required to be imported by a manufacturer for use in Saorstát Eireann in such process, the Revenue Commissioners may by licence authorise such manufacturer, subject to compliance with such conditions as they may think fit to impose, to import without payment of this duty the said articles either, as the Revenue Commissioners shall think proper, without limit as to time or quantity or either of them or within a specified time or in a specified quantity.
Comment on this
I move amendment 159:—
At Ref. No. 18, second column, to insert after the words "telephone poles," the words "hayrakes or hay forks."
The Minister for Agriculture has doubtless informed the Minister for Industry and Commerce that there is a certain variety of American hayrake which is not made in this country. It is of light quality which, I believe, in certain parts of the country is largely used by women who are engaged in harvesting operations. I am not trying to make a false case to the Minister. I believe that is so. I do not believe that this amendment is absolutely essential or that it would work any grave hardship on women as a class if this class of rake were subject to the duty. However, I think it is a rake that does not compete seriously with the home product and I think it would be a great advantage to the agricultural community if the Minister accepted the amendment. I think the vast bulk of hayrakes would be manufactured here, with the exception of the light hayrake used for the particular purpose I have described. I do not press the amendment on the Minister but I suggest that he should look into the matter. I do not see how he can if he is going to Ottawa.
Comment on this
My position is that there is a number of exclusions from manufactured woodworks and it is the one class in which least exclusions should be made because if there is one thing that we can manufacture here it is worked wood. I have no doubt that we can make hayrakes here which would meet all the needs of the country. There is a certain type of American hayrake which is used here but it is not essential. I shall have the matter looked into but I do not think there is much likelihood of my being able to agree to the amendment.
Comment on this
I move amendment 160:—...
At Ref. No. 18, page 31. before paragraph (b), in the second column and the entries opposite it in the third and fourth, to insert in the second, third and fourth columns the following paragraph and figures:—
(b) the following tools when fitted with wooden handles and imported as complete tools, that is to say, hammers, hatchets, adzes, axes, pickaxes, mattocks, hoes, rakes and forks, and also wooden handles imported separately and, in the opinion of the Revenue Commissioners, designed, constructed, and intended for use as handles for one or more of the said tools: 50% ; 33?%.
The purpose of this amendment is to extend the customs duty and to remove an anomaly that arises. As matters stood a person who imported the head of a tool and the handle of a tool separately paid a duty on the handle, but if he imported the two together he paid no duty at all and the intention is that the handles will be charged with duty whether imported separately or not but there will be no extra duty if they are imported with the head.
Comment on this
I move amendment 161:—
At Ref. No. 18, page 31, in paragraph (b) in the second column to delete all from the bracket and words "(other than" to the end of the paragraph and substitute the following brackets and words "(except articles exempted by the provision contained in the fifth column) and component parts of such manufacturers (except as aforesaid)."
This is a drafting amendment.
Comment on this
I move amendment 162:—
At Ref. No. 18, second column, paragraph (b), after the word "furniture" to insert the words "toys, religious articles."
Comment on this
Even in the case of crucifixes I have some doubts in my mind. A number of these things are manufactured here.
Comment on this
I know that some come in from Belgium at prices which make it practically impossible to compete with them, but articles made of wood are made here and can be made here.
Comment on this
Well, at reasonable prices. There are some very cheap articles of this nature imported from Continental countries, but there are a number of firm engaged in the manufacture here, and although prices are a consideration, we should not allow the question of price to determine whether or not we should protect the industry.
Comment on this
We should take into account the poverty of the people who are forced to buy that type of article.
Comment on this
Because there is no reason. The term "religious article" is altogether too wide. For instance, all types of church furniture and things of that type could come under the heading of religious articles, and are made here and can be made here.
Comment on this
The Minister surely does not suggest that the amendment intends to cover such things as church furniture?
Comment on this
The Minister said at the earlier stage that he would investigate the conduct of a certain manufacturer of rosary beads of whom I had informed the Minister that he had advanced his price. Did the Minister look into that?
Comment on this
I did. I got a report, but I cannot recollect, at the moment, what the exact purport of it was, but as far as I can recollect it was not quite as the Deputy stated.
Comment on this
I got a list which said, in effect, "the increased cost compels us reluctantly to increase our prices in accordance with the schedule." I put it in my pocket at the time and said that, at least, Mr. Lemass will see this. What I want to know is will the Minister look into that?
Comment on this
I move amendment 163:—
At Ref. No. 18, second column, paragraph (b), after the word "kegs" to insert the words "extension ladders."
Is the Minister accepting that?
Comment on this
I do not know that anybody in the country is engaged in the manufacture of these extension ladders at the moment, because they have not got the opportunity, but any competent saw miller should be able to make an extension ladder.
Comment on this
With the greatest respect to the Minister, I differ from him. It is a highly specialised industry.
Comment on this
I quite agree with the Deputy. I do not wish it, of course, but I would much rather that the Minister was up on the 60-foot extension ladder, made by a saw miller who has had no experience, than that I was up on it. It is no good talking about somebody or some firm going to take up the manufacture of these ladders.
Comment on this
We approached persons interested in this business and asked them did they make, or was it their intention to make them. They said they had not made them because they had no orders, but that they could make them, and were prepared to make them. They said "If anybody wants them, refer them to us."
Comment on this
What I want to know is who is going to make them in this country? The Minister says "I will put a duty on them and the manufacturers of the ladders will automatically appear." Who are they?
Comment on this
I differ from you. You can cart an order around the whole city of Dublin for extension ladders, and you will not find anyone to undertake it as a commercial proposition. You might tell a man that you would bet him £150 if he would build such a ladder, and he might be able to build it for you. The same thing applies to other matters in this schedule. There is no manufacturer in the country making these ladders, or, as far as I know, willing to make them. Switch ladders are an entirely different thing. but extension ladders, with the development of modern transport and various other things, have practically become a necessity to contractors, and there is no one in this country making them or, so far as I know, purporting to make them.
Comment on this
Workmen's lives depend on the proper making of these ladders and from the point of view of anyone who knows a man who goes up these ladders, the point of view of a man who says that he will make them if he gets an order is not enough. I know a considerable number of people who have to go up on these ladders, and they say that they must know first who made the ladder before they will go up, and they will not go up on any ladder made by an amateur. It must be remembered that the people who have to go up on them are generally trade unionists, with a strong trade union behind them, and they will not go up.
Comment on this
There is as much difference between an extension ladder and an ordinary ladder as there is, say, between a vacuum cleaner and a swab. Is the Minister aware that an extension ladder is quite a complicated piece of machinery? I can make any ordinary ladder myself, and, I am sure, so could the Minister, if he had a few pieces of wood, some nails and a hammer; and so could any carpenter. An extension ladder, however, is a highly specialised article and one on which men's lives depend.
Comment on this
I would like to protest in the strongest manner possible that here is an important matter affecting all the contracting firms in this country, and the Minister meets us by saying "Are there not excellent wood-working firms in this country?" There are; but it is like a lot of other things, —this is a highly specialised kind of manufacture. The grain of the timber has to be very carefully selected, and I think, in the case of a firm starting to-morrow, it would be a couple of years before they would have selected the timber and left it to season. And here we are now with a tariff going to be put on, and there is no one to supply the demand. I suppose the Minister will dispute the fact that the price of extension ladders is going to go up to 33? per cent. I should like the Minister to look into this again.
Comment on this
The issue raised has not been taken seriously by the Minister. He assumed that an ordinary carpenter, in an ordinary firm accustomed to making ordinary ladders, could make these extension ladders just as if they were the same thing. He ignores the fact that these ladders are entirely different. He ignores the fact that men's lives may be depending upon them. The job being done by persons not accustomed to doing it may have serious consequences. I suggest that the Deputy should not withdraw his amendment.
Comment on this
No. I had the matter investigated and no case was made out for exclusion. An extension ladder is in the main two ladders held together with metal fittings.
Comment on this
The lives of workers may be depending upon this. Trade unionists will not risk their lives on these ladders.
Comment on this
I really think this is important. If these ladders could be produced here I would be perfectly satisfied.
Comment on this
Would the Minister get one of them made and submit it to a contractor and let us have his opinion on it? He tells us here that it is all right because somebody has told him that somebody else could make these ladders.
Comment on this
Probably there are firms here competent to make them, but does the Minister realise that the special timber for their manufacture is not to be had in the State? It has to be very carefully selected. I do not know how many Deputies here have had experience of the making of aeroplane parts and the laws of cross grains and so on. There are certain things that an ordinary person could see are not fit to go into a ladder. I am perfectly satisfied the Minister has in his mind switch ladders that merely involve split poles, bars and holes for rungs, which can be made by any carpenter in the country. The other is a highly specialised matter and you are merely, by this tax, going to increase the cost to the trade to the extent of the duty.
Comment on this
Surely the Minister realises that there is a difference between an extension ladder and the kind of ladder he has in mind.
Comment on this
I will undertake to look into the question to see whether my idea of an extension ladder and the Department's idea, differ, in any way, from Deputy Dockrell's idea. If Deputy Dockrell has in mind something that in our opinion is not an extension ladder we will exclude it.
Comment on this
It is not the wood that is in question at all. It is whether the wood used is matured and suitable.
Comment on this
If the Deputy does not move this amendment now and brings it up on Report Stage we can argue it again.
Comment on this
I move amendment 165:
At Ref. No. 18, page 31, in the fifth column, to insert a further provision as follows:—
Whenever the Minister for Finance, after consultation with the Minister for Industry and Commerce, is satisfied that any articles chargeable with this duty are essential raw materials of a process of manufacture carried on or intended to be carried on in Saorstát Eireann, and are not obtainable or likely to be obtainable in Saorstát Eireann and are required to be imported by a manufacturer for use in Saorstát Eireann in such process, the Revenue Commissioners may by licence authorise such manufacturer, subject to compliance with such conditions as they may think fit to impose, to import without payment of this duty the said articles either, as the Revenue Commissioners shall think proper, without limit as to time or quantity or either of them, or within a specified time or in a specified quantity.
This is a licensing provision.
Comment on this
I move amendment 166:—
At Ref. No. 18, page 31, in the fifth column, in insert a further provision as follows:—
This duty shall not be charged or levied on vehicles designed, constructed, and intended for use on roads or for use on rails, nor on any of the following articles nor on any component parts of such of the following articles as are complete articles, that is to say:—
(a) machinery,
(b) power lifts,
(c) furniture (not including picture frames imported without a picture),
(d) harness and saddlery,
(e) articles for use in sport, (f) scientific and medical instruments and apparatus,
(g) component parts of boxes which, in the opinion of the Revenue Commissioners, are margarine boxes,
(h) butter-boxes, egg-boxes, barrels, casks, and kegs,
(i) tools, excluding tools and component parts thereof specifically mentioned in the second column,
(j) spools,
(k) churns,
(l) incubators,
(m) component parts of umbrellas,
(n) unfinished covers for loose leaf ledgers,
(o) musical instruments,
(p) containers which at importation are filled with other goods,
(p) empty containers which are shown to the satisfaction of the Revenue Commissioners to be imported for use as containers of goods to be exported,
(r) punnets, chip boxes and baskets,
(s) articles constructed, designed, and intended for use for educational purposes in schools, colleges, or other educational establishments,
(t) crucifixes,
(u) any toy the value of which does not exceed one shilling.
This specifies the list of articles excluded from duty, following upon the various representations made here and otherwise. Considerable doubt exists as to the advisability of excluding some of the articles enumerated, and very strong representations against exclusion have been received, but I decided to move the amendment on this occasion, noting, however, that in relation to some of the articles it may be desirable to modify the provisions later by bringing them subject to the duty.
Comment on this
Does the Minister intend to include the component parts of sections of beehives? They come in in sheets.
Comment on this
I shall look into that. I received certain representations. The bee is a manufacturer of course in that case.
Comment on this
This could not have reference to No. 18 of the Schedule. We are dealing now with amendment 166 and that has reference to No. 18 which deals with wooden articles. Do these refer to machinery?
Comment on this
I shall accept that in principle and introduce an amendment on Report Stage. We will exclude three-masted sailing ships and motor boats and other boats of that kind. I think row boats of various descriptions are made here. I undertake to bring in an amendment on Report Stage to deal with the matter.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 168 standing in the name of Deputy Gorey: "At Ref. No. 19, second column, to add at the end the words. ‘excluding non-poisonous sheep dip.'"
I move this amendment because I am not satisfied, despite the representations made here, that a non-poisonous sheep dip prepared by Cooper for the prevention of sheep scab is available in this country of Irish manufacture. Is the Minister satisfied that there is a non-poisonous sheep dipused which will be regarded as discharging the obligation?
Comment on this
I do not know its composition, but I know that it is approved by the Department of Agriculture.
Comment on this
That is the whole problem. If there is such a difference let there be no warm feelings about it, as I will withdraw my opposition if it is available and can be had at a reasonable price. I do not think the Minister should put on this duty until he is satisfied there is such a difference. A number of people are obliged to use sheep dip of some kind for their stock. The Minister knows how intensely dangerous it is to introduce arsenic into farmers' houses, where there are young children running about, who may poison themselves or scatter it about. the yard where it will get into a pool of water and perhaps poison cattle. The thing is a very real danger, especially where there are children, not only to human life but to farm stock. Unless the Minister is certain that a non-poisonous dip is available I would not be satisfied. If a man uses dip that is not efficacious the country may be faced with an epidemic of sheep scab and any farmer can tell what a disaster that would be. If the Minister is satisfied, after consultation with the Department, I will not press the amendment, but I think he should take elaborate precautions.
Comment on this
Perhaps I could enlighten Deputy Dillon. In the town from which I come a sheep dip is made which is non-poisonous. It is a nicotine sheep dip.
Comment on this
It is non-poisonous and is used extensively in the Colonies. The gentleman who makes it sells practically the whole output abroad. It is highly recommended by agricultural experts in Canada, Australia and South Africa. The extraordinary thing is that in the town in which it is made it is hardly known. A poisonous arsenic dip is preferred. The sheep dip to which I refer is well known to officials of the Department of Agriculture and is highly recommended by them. If its manufacture were encouraged the owner could easily supply the wants of the Free State and, incidentally, give a considerable amount of employment. The dip is highly efficacious and non-poisonous.
Comment on this
With the leave of the House I will withdraw the amendment, providing the Minister will look into the matter.
Comment on this
There are a number of sheep dips manufactured in this country, which are approved of by the Department of Agriculture, the body responsible in this matter. I am almost certain that non-poisonous sheep dip is included in the list but I would like to be definite before saying so. As far as I know there are satisfactory sheep dips made here which are very strongly recommended by the Department.
Comment on this
As far as I know they are all poisonous dips. I asked the Minister to make sure when he stated previously that they were non-poisonous. I regret that the Minister has not the information now. I blame myself for not making enquiries. I venture to say, with very little short of absolute confidence, that they are not. Non-poisonous sheep dips are necessary for dogs and fowl as well as for sheep. A winter dip to be any way effective must contain carbolic which is non-poisonous. In the summer you must have arsenic or sulphur in the dip. I do not believe there is an effective non-poisonous waterproof sheep dip. We had an excessive amount of rain during the past few winters, and there was a necessity for a non-poisonous dip. Carbolic is waterproof and in that lies its greatest value.