Finance Bill, 1932—Committee (Resumed).
Contributions 655–875 of 875. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 4 parts.
No. 11 of 1932 ›
I would like to reassure the House on this matter. Cork County Council accepted tenders for sheep dip last week. It is made in Cork-Burke's non-poisonous dip— and is recommended by the Department of Agriculture. The advantages of that dip are that it is non-poisonous, it is recommended by the Department, the price was the lowest, and in addition it is made in Cork.
Comment on this
The dip I mentioned is a very suitable one, because it does not destroy the natural oil in the wool as arsenic does.
Comment on this
At Lismore, County Waterford. It is used by Cavan County Council and by other bodies and is recommended by the Department. It is non-poisonous.
Comment on this
I had experience of the dip to which Deputy Corry refers. Cooper's dip has to be used through it.
Comment on this
I move amendment 170:—
At Ref. No. 20, page 32, in the second column paragraph (v), before the word "pumps" to insert the word "water."
Comment on this
I move:—
At Ref. No. 20, second column, page 32, to add at the end the words : "No duty shall be charged on any goods that on importation are found to be damaged and are returned for replacement."
I would like to know if the Minister accepts the principle of this amendment or some form of it. In this trade the breakages are very heavy, and the desire is to have some machinery by which damaged castings may be returned for replacements without being subject to duty.
Comment on this
If the fact that goods on importation were damaged was brought to the notice of the Revenue Commissioners before the goods were cleared, no duty would be charged. Obviously the Revenue Commissioners could not be responsible after goods had been cleared and left their control.
Comment on this
I quite agree. The simplest and the easiest case is where they are found to be defective on the quays, but, if the Minister can supply machinery where on delivery goods are found to be defective, some arrangement might be made that would be acceptable to the trade.
Comment on this
I move amendment 173:
At Ref. No. 21, second column, to delete the word "superphosphates."
Here I think we come to the proposition which I asked the Minister to consider. On the last occasion on which I referred to the Finance Bill I told the House of my experience, and I gave the Minister, not prognostications, but facts that have occurred in connection with this trade.
For the information of the House, I propose now to repeat what I said. In the spring of every year during the last five years the English and Irish manure manufacturers have been accustomed to approach distributors. I propose to speak in round figures for the purpose of illustrating what I have to say. When they approach distributors, they inform them that they will be prepared to supply superphosphate of lime at say, £4 5s. per ton. On each occasion when such an approach was made to me, I bade the representative "good morning" and told him I was not interested, in his proposition. Usually after these representatives have called, the representatives of the Continental manufacturers arrive. Their price is usually from 12/6d. to 15/6d. per ton under the other price. That is to say, it runs from £3 10s. to £3 12s. 6d. In every single year, when the Continental price became current property to distributors, the English manufacturers came down to the Continental price—delivered superphosphate of lime at that price. That has happened one year after another.
The Minister will observe that although I was inclined to move the deletion of the whole section, I have sought to appreciate his difficulty in abandoning the principle of a tax of that kind. I am satisfied that if he removes superphosphate of lime from the Schedule, we will be able to control the price of compound fertilisers, because we will be able to offer farmers the alternative of mixing their own compound fertilisers if the manure manufacturers try to push the price up too high. Take the 8¼ per cent. general fertiliser. If the manufacturers try to push the price of that up too high, the people can easily prepare an adequate substitute by mixing muriate of potash, sulphate of ammonia and superphosphate of lime. Another mixture, would include superphosphate of lime, kainit and nitrate of soda. I could go through all the compound manures and prepare formulae that the farmer could mix in his own home if the manufacturer sought to mulct him in high prices. If you exclude the import of Continental superphosphate of lime by a tariff, you will not succeed in increasing the production of the Irish manufacturers of artificial manures by any substantial amount, because the Minister admits that a very large percentage—I think he said as high as 90 per cent.—of artificial manures are already supplied from sources other than Continental. Therefore, you are not going to increase Irish production. But you are going to withdraw the one safe brake on prices that has operated efficiently in the eyes of everybody for the last five years. There is no doubt about that. The facts are there and any person who honestly informs the Minister must inform him of those facts. The Minister has frequently replied to representations of that kind that if we are going to make price the only criterion he is not interested. All I say in answer to that is "Look at the thriving condition of Goulding's manures." Let him remember that Gouldings control the whole manure industry in this country. Let him watch the stock exchange and, if he does that, I think he will satisfy himself beyond doubt that Gouldings is not in any danger and never was in any danger. On the contrary, I believe it is very good for the Irish manure factories to have that competition, because it gives them just that impetus to keep their business efficient and just that justification for saying to their workers, supervisors and employees: "You must keep on the job if you are going to keep our trade." If that stimulus is withdrawn, the net result will be that the price of superphosphate of lime will be increased from 6d. to 1s. per cwt. to every farmer. That will mean that every small farmer who is trying to operate his farm intelligently will have laid upon him a tax of from 5/- to 10/- per annum at a minimum. Every farmer of any substance will be fined in a sum anywhere between £2 and £5 per annum, and this, so far as I can see, to achieve practically nothing, because the Minister admits that at present the Irish manure trade is holding its own and is well able to hold its own, as is evidenced by the fact that it is supplying the bulk of the demand at the present time. I ask the Minister to note that I have not applied for the removal from the Schedule of all compound manures and only ask for the removal of superphosphate of lime. If he will meet us on that and give us superphosphate of lime, we will be able to control the market and keep prices down to a reasonable level. If the Minister does not do that, it is well to understand—Farmer Deputies know it as well as I know it—that Deputies will be voting for an annual tax of from 10/- to £5 on every farmer, or else they will be voting for the farmers to stop using artificial manures, to the grave detriment of the land and in direct opposition to the advice promulgated by the Department of Agriculture when they published the exceptionally strong-worded poster declaring that the land of this country is "starving for phosphates."
Comment on this
This matter was well argued on a previous stage and anything that one could say now would be repetition. If the Minister is in the same frame of mind as he was, it is useless debating the question. If the Minister has made some of the inquiries I suggested, he will have discovered that his attitude should not be as it was before. Deputy Dillon has said that this will mean an increase of from 5/- to 10/- a ton in the cost of "artificials" to the consumer. That is putting it very low indeed. That is based on last year's experience when the other stuff was free to come in. What is it going to be now that it is not to come in? Is there any forecast made of that? I cannot see the cost being less than £1 per ton additional when the coast is clear of all foreign competition. The case is being made to you by the Minister that some of the employees were not retained as long last year as the year before. That may be his information. I do not believe it. I do not believe it is a fact because the same amount of artificial manure was used in the country last year as during the previous year, and no additional amount of foreign manure replaced it. The figures for the last few years vary from 200,000 tons to 168,000 tons of Irish manures. About 32,000 tons come from outside. These embrace raw mineral phosphates and compound manures. Now that it is reduced in the amendment to phosphate of lime, a different figure altogether would be arrived at as to imports. But it would be sufficient to regulate the prices, it would be sufficient to bring in that necessary competition that will prevent the consumer from being mulcted.
I cannot understand the Minister making a plea for a company whose shares on the market form some of the best investments in the State, the most favoured of the investments amongst the investing public. What then is the Minister's justification for boosting up a combine that is already at the top of the industry? We know as Deputy Dillon has said that the Irish combine is in the hands of one man and in addition to that that combine has affiliations with England, with the result that there is no competition from that quarter. Not alone is there a combination here but there is a combination across the water. Why the consumer in his present opulent or the reverse position, whichever you like to call it, should be asked to do a thing that the artificial manure business does not demand, something that the shareholders or traders in that business do not demand, is a thing I cannot understand.
The story about the drop in the sales of the Irish manure firms last year is a thing I do not accept, because the farmers sowed as much last year as the year before and the workers in the industry were employed as long as the year before. The effect of this tax will be that a very small amount of money will be brought into the Exchequer, but it will take a whole lot of money out of the pockets of the consumers. That is a thing that we here on these benches representing the farmers protest against and resent.
Comment on this
I do not wish to prolong the discussion on this amendment nor at this stage will I repeat the arguments set forth on the two previous occasions, but I do appeal to the Minister to reconsider this tariff. I would point out to him that the use of superphosphate of lime is now absolutely indispensable to the farmers of this country. I wonder if the Minister before he proceeded to impose this tariff on superphosphates and the tariffs on the other things used by the farmer, discussed these tariffs with any class of farmer or with the traders who have been in the habit of supplying the farmers of the country?
Did the Minister discuss it with traders of the type of Deputy Dillon and men like him through the country? if he had discussed these tariffs with a representative body of farmers and with the traders who are accustomed to supply these farmers he would have been advised that tariffs of this character, no matter how small they may be, are bound to do a tremendous amount of harm to the farming industry. This is one of the indispensable manures to the land of this country. There was never more need of phosphate of lime on the land than at present. That statement will be confirmed by his own officials. For years and years the officials of the Department of Agriculture have been advising the farmers of the country to use more phosphate of lime and some of those officials have actually assisted the small farmers to obtain adequate supplies of phosphate of lime. I do not want to prolong the discussion on this amendment but I would appeal to the Minister to reconsider the whole question and to remove the tariff altogether. In that way he will be doing something that will be not only in the interest of the Government but very much in the interest of the small farmers of the country.
Comment on this
There is no product so essential for the carrying out of a successful tillage policy as a plentiful supply of superphosphates. Everybody who has had anything to do with tillage must realise how very essential it is for those who are carrying on agricultural pursuits in this country to be able to obtain superphosphates at the lowest price possible. In putting on this tariff I feel that the Minister will be taking away the means by which the farmer will he enabled to increase the volume of production in the country. The imposing of restrictions on the importation of manures is taking away one of the means whereby prices can be kept within bounds. Artificial manures are provided to a very large degree by one particular firm in this country operating as they are on certain lines. They will only supply the trade. They will not supply direct a co-operative society or a body of farmers and therefore the farmer has absolutely no means of countering that combine except by the competition which has hitherto been available to him by the imports of foreign manure. I have realised that myself in the past.
We have been able to bring down prices of manures only in one way and that was by combining amongst ourselves to import foreign manures. If one takes into consideration that the Government are really in favour of increased tillage in this country, they are working against that policy by taking away from the farmer the means of carrying out tillage successfully. As Deputy Dillon has pointed out, one of the means whereby the farmer can counter any likely increase in the price of compound manures is by mixing the manures himself. That has been carried out by the farmers in the past. But this absolutely essential product, superphosphate, the farmer will not be able to obtain unless foreign manures are allowed in free. By this tariff on manures the Minister is striking a blow at agriculture and a blow at the farming industry. I would appeal to him to remit this tariff on imported superphosphates.
Comment on this
This matter was debated here at great length on another occasion and the arguments then put up were the self-same arguments as we have heard to-day. Apparently there is a certain brand of farmer in this country who want the unemployed labourers to buy their products but do not themselves want to buy anything in this country that would provide employment for those labourers. That is the whole case in a nutshell. This matter was all right until Great Britain put a tariff on imported artificial manures. The moment that was done the flow of artificial manures into Great Britain was changed to this country. We were made the dumping ground for the Continental stuff. That is the actual situation at present. I know very well there was a ring in operation in the artificial manure industry. I do not think there is any farmer who has had to buy manures who does not know that some years ago there was a ring in operation in this matter.
But we are taking steps to deal with rings and to deal with profiteering whether that is done in Indian meal by Cumann na nGaedheal Deputies or in artificial manures by Messrs. Goulding. That sort of thing is going to be dealt with and I am perfectly confident that the moment Messrs. Gouldings, or any other firm manufacturing manures here, look for a higher profit than they are getting at present, they will be dealt with and dealt with in a manner that will give satisfaction to everybody. We have no doubt about that. We will be using three times as much artificial manures next spring as were used last year. I believe that with our tillage policy in full operation we will need three times as much artificial manure as we required last year. It will take a good deal of artificial manure to get 150,000 extra acres under the plough and we expect to have 150,000 extra acres under the plough next Spring. That will mean that there will undoubtedly be more competition and that there will be more employment for our people in this country. I would like to hear Deputy Kiersey on that matter. That is the Deputy who told us some days ago that there were eight bright spots in the Cumann na nGaedheal Party. I would like to see those eight bright spots coming forward now in order to help in abolishing unemployment here. I hope those eight bright spots will still remain bright and that the fertilisers will not be too much for them.
Comment on this
I made a suggestion to the Deputy a while ago, but he did not take it up. I see no reason to be afraid of protecting our own industries. I know what happened during the last three months as a result of the extraordinary dumping of foreign manures.
Comment on this
There were 6,000 or 7,000 tons of fertilisers left on people's hands. That amount was changed over from the English market the moment England put on a tariff. Many of our people were left walking the streets of Cork unemployed. We have no room for foreign manures, either from across Channel or from the Continent, while there is an unemployed man in this country. There is no occasion for this howl on the part of farmers who want to sell their produce to the Irish people and who complain, at the same time, because they are asked to give employment to Irish people.
Comment on this
When this matter of superphosphates was debated in the first instance there was no case made for it on the Government Benches. As a matter of fact, occupants of the Government Benches were unable to agree in any particular. In the first place, the Minister for Industry and Commerce assured the House that the tariff would mean no increase in price to the farmer. Then came the Minister for Agriculture who said that of course it would mean an extra cost, and although it would mean an extra cost it would be well for the farmer to bear it as the money was going to be spent on a home product. Deputy Allen said this tariff should be borne because it was for the good of the community. Deputy Corry said it was not for the good of the community but for the benefit of 1,000 men employed in the artificial manure trade. He added that if this tariff were not carried we would have to support 1,000 men by way of home assistance.
Comment on this
We are told by one of the Labour members that even if the tariff were put on it would not mean any increase in employment, because the men at present employed in the artificial manure trade were not working up to 25 per cent. of what they were capable of producing. That is the way the case was put to us. Now Deputy Corry says there is a howl. I did not hear anybody howling. If one brings commonsense to bear on this question it will be found that it cannot stand examination. With regard to the consumption of artificial manures, the Irish farmer deserves great credit for his patriotism in purchasing home products, notwithstanding the difference in the price of the Irish article above the imported article. Four-fifths of the total quantity of artificial manures purchased by farmers were of Irish manufacture.
Comment on this
The fact is that Irish farmers purchased at least four-fifths of their requirements from Irish manufacturers notwithstanding that foreign manures were from 10/- to 14/- a ton cheaper. Whatever motive may be attributed, that is the fact. That was particularly the case in County Cork, where the farmers will not buy foreign manures on any account. If this tariff is imposed I fear the general tendency will be for the price of the home product to go up. At the present time the home manufacturer is able to sell his product notwithstanding a difference of from 10/-to 14/- a ton, as compared with foreign manures. If there is no outside competition there will be a tendency to increase the price of the home product, and that will be a distinct disadvantage to the farmer.
There was a very poor case made for the tariff. It must be understood that the control of this trade, in Ireland, is in the hands practically of one firm. There are seven firms engaged in the trade, but they are more or less under one central control. The firm has been doing extraordinarily well and I do not think it is opportune at the present time to encourage an increase in price by the putting on of the tariff. There is no case for it, and farmers ought to be allowed to take advantage of cheap manures if they want to purchase them. It will not affect the great bulk of the trade which is being done from the Irish manufacturers' point of view.
Comment on this
This duty was discussed at considerable length in the Dáil on two previous occasions, and I do not think we are going to become any wiser as a result of another long debate. The various representations made by Deputies were carefully examined. All the matters mentioned were gone into, and the more examination we gave them the more convinced we became that this duty was one that should be imposed and maintained. We are told there is a danger of the farmer being exploited. I do not think I said there would be no increase in price. In so far as superphosphates are being imported at uneconomic prices, the exclusion of imports may mean some increase in price, but the danger we must avoid is any undue profit-making at the farmers' expense. We are told there is some danger of that. The position is that we have seven factories working here. Between them they are quite capable of supplying all the country's requirements. In open competition here in the past they succeeded in supplying 80 per cent. of the country's requirements.
Comment on this
No clear evidence has been produced to show they were not in open competition. I have no evidence to show that they had an arrangement between themselves. That was emphatically denied to me by those concerned. The position is that they did succeed in securing 80 per cent. of the market here. We are told we are going to have a monopoly by excluding Continental superphosphates. Deputies are omitting the fact that there is no duty on superphosphates imported from Great Britain or any other member of the British Commonwealth. It is not a confined market. The duty is imposed upon the Continental superphosphates which have been excluded from England in recent months, by reason of the English duty, and which are coming in here at prices with which the Irish factories could not be expected to compete. The fact is that even the 20 per cent. duty we have imposed if paid in full upon the Continental superphosphate, at the present price of that superphosphate, does not bring it up to the price at which Irish superphosphate was bought by farmers last year in preference to the Continental stuff.
Comment on this
The fact is that if the Deputy wants to get Continental superphosphate he can get it and pay the duty and have it cheaper than the Irish superphosphate but it will not be as good. The Deputy knows that the reason Irish superphosphate was sold in four times the quantity that the Continental stuff was imported was because it was better and the farmers were prepared to pay more for it.
Comment on this
Whatever the circumstances are, the farmers prefer to pay more for Irish superphosphate. That is the position. There is no question about the ability of the factories to supply the requirements of the country. That is not contested. There is no question about the quality of their product. That is demonstrated by the fact that it commands consistently a higher price, and has been purchased in much greater quantities than any imported stuff. Doubt has been expressed as to whether or not an attempt will be made to exploit the farmers subject to the duty. I say that such exploitation cannot take place, firstly, because there is not a reservation of the market. There is a complete absence of any duty upon superphosphate imported from Great Britain. Secondly, because the rate of duty imposed upon the Continental stuff, in relation to the present range of prices, does not bring the price of the Continental stuff up to the price at which Irish superphosphate is being bought. I say further that if these safeguards are inadequate, if we should find that, in fact, an attempt to exploit the farmer is being made, then we are proposing, in a Bill which has been circulated to take power to deal with that situation. That situation will be dealt with if necessary, but we do not anticipate that it will arise. That Bill, in any case, will have been enacted here before the next season comes round or before there is an additional demand for superphosphate.
I think the Deputies opposite have been backing the wrong horse in their opposition to this duty. Those who have examined the position, including the persons who can be justly described as experts in agriculture with whom it was discussed, are satisfied that this is a duty which should be imposed. Its imposition, as I pointed out, means preserving the livelihood of the 1,000 people engaged in the compound manure industry. That industry was badly hit this year. The number of men employed were facing a long period of unemployment this Summer. A number of factories are at present temporarily shut down. It is true that they do normally restrict the output at this period of the year, but there is in the country an abnormal stock of the Continental stuff and, because of the abnormal supplies which came in, an abnormal stock of Irish stuff, and consequently a definite diminution in the employment given. In view of the restrictions which are being imposed on the Continental stuff, and other possibilities, there is some reason to anticipate, not that the number of persons employed in the industry will be increased, but that these people are going to get more employment and more regular employment. That is why we recommend the duty.
Comment on this
Question put: "That the words proposed to be deleted stand."
Do you agree with this result?
No. The tax is to get, first of all, bicycles and tricycles assembled here, and it has succeeded in that; also, to get children's carriages manufactured here, and it has succeeded in that.
Comment on this
So far as children's carriages are concerned in the discussions that are taking place between the firms and the Department, the firms are urging that certain other parts, which we propose to allow in duty free, should also be brought subject to duty.
Comment on this
Can the Minister give any idea as to what Border arrangements with regard to bicycles are going to be made?
Comment on this
I move amendment 177:—
At Ref. No. 24, page 32, in the second column, after the word "plate" to add the words "excluding photographic prints which in the opinion of the Revenue Commissioners are of a technical or scientific nature."
So far as photographic prints for exhibition purposes are concerned, there is a drawback arrangement, which, I think, meets the point Deputy Dockrell has in mind.
Comment on this
I move amendment 181:—
To delete Ref. No. 27, including relevant references in columns 2, 3 and 4.
This is definitely a tax by which it is proposed to obtain revenue, by taxing the import of knives, forks, spoons, tongs, razors and component parts.
Comment on this
The duty, as the Deputy has said, is mainly a revenue duty, but we are investigating, at the moment, the possibility of having some industry started for the manufacture of certain of these articles here. I do not know whether we will be successful in that, but, in the meantime, we will be glad of the revenue.
Comment on this
Will it not be better to make certain of the prospects of giving employment in manufacture here, and to postpone the imposition of this revenue tax until these prospects arrive?
Comment on this
Surely the Minister has put enough burdens on the backs of the people, without adding an unnecessary burden on them.
Comment on this
I move amendment 182:—
To delete Ref. No. 28, including relevant references in columns 2, 3 and 4.
I move this amendment because this tax is also a purely revenue tax.
Comment on this
I move amendment 183:—
At Ref. No. 28, page 33, in the second column, after the word "work" to add the words "and also excluding unexposed sensitized films, plates, paper, and cards."
This is an amendment I undertook to bring in on Second Reading.
Comment on this
I move amendment 183a:—
At Ref. No. 28, page 33, second column, after the word "work" to add the words "or in any educational institution."
I am glad the Minister has brought in amendment 183 and I think 183a is only in accord with principles he has adapted to other matters.
Comment on this
I am afraid that the wording of this amendment would make the exclusion altogether too wide. It would be impossible to distinguish a photographic apparatus intended for use in an educational establishment, from one intended for use, say, for pleasure. It is possible, definitely, to ascertain whether apparatus is intended for use in hospital or surgical work, and, if so, it is excluded, but the exclusion the Deputy suggests is altogether too wide.
Comment on this
It is very important for many research institutions that these articles should not be liable to duty. Would the Minister accept the principle that such things consigned to Universities or educational institutions should not be taxed? That would prevent any abuse.
Comment on this
I would have no objection to excluding from the duty apparatus which was designed for use in scientific work and which would be unsuitable for any other class of use, but I could not exclude from the duty apparatus similar to the apparatus which might be used for pleasure merely because it is intended for use in the University.
Comment on this
Still it is of considerable importance. Would the Minister produce some phrase for the Report Stage which would meet this point?
Comment on this
I should like to impress upon him that a great deal of scientific work particularly in laboratories, medical laboratories and scientific institutions, involves, nowadays the use of photographic apparatus which is generally of a very expensive type. This would be a very substantial tax on the limited resources of these very valuable centres of work and research.
Comment on this
In connection with these amendments has the Minister any hope or prospect of any firm coming in here for the corrugation of iron?
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 186:—
At Ref. No. 30, second column, before the word "iron" where it first occurs, to insert the word "curved," and to delete the word "flat" and substitute the word "straight."
I understand the Minister's mind on this question but the section as originally drafted does not convey his intention. It leaves a great element of doubt, so much so that an instruction was sent out I believe from his Department in connection with cases where people had been paying on straight sheets of corrugated iron. I have a billhead here showing that an amount of £11 17s. 8d. was charged to a trader in Bagenalstown on such sheet. The section says: "galvanised corrugated iron or steel excluding flat sheets of such iron." A flat sheet of galvanised iron is a straight flat sheet similar to the table. A corrugated sheet is known as a straight sheet, not a flat sheet and the whole confusion arose out of that. There may not be much necessity for putting in the word "curved" but there is certainly necessity for replacing the word "flat" by "straight." Flat has a certain meaning and there is no such thing as galvanised corrugated iron in flat sheets. There are galvanised iron straight sheets and there are curved sheets. If this amendment is inserted it carries out in my opinion the Minister's intention. This is a Resolution that has caused a whole lot of confusion and it will likely result in considerably more unless it is amended. It has already resulted as I have pointed out in one trader being wrongly charged £ll. I think it would be very much better if there was no doubt either in the people's minds or in the minds of the Revenue Commissioners as to what it means. The traders of the country want some information and the wording as drafted does not give that information. If you put in the word "flat" instead of "straight" it puts the matter right and carries out the Minister's intention and it is preferable to a word that causes confusion. In fact I should like also to put in the word "curved" because it removes all doubt both for the trader and the Revenue Commissioners.
Comment on this
It is clear that Deputy Gorey and myself have the same thing in mind but we are not agreed as to what we should call it. I submit the wording in the section meets the Deputy's point. It does not really matter so long as it is administered in accordance with the Deputy's view. What is happening is that the straight sheet and the flat sheet are not being subjected to duty.
Comment on this
The flat sheet of corrugated iron is not subject to duty, nor is the straight sheet of corrugated iron subject to duty.
Comment on this
Will the Minister say whether corrugated iron that is curved is subject to duty?
Comment on this
A galvanised corrugated sheet that is subjected to any other process of working is subject to duty.
Comment on this
Does the Minister know what a corrugated sheet of iron is?
Comment on this
I should like to urge one point upon the Minister. I am not in any doubt, unfortunately, as to what the paragraph means, but I should like to put in one last word against subjecting curved sheets to duty for the following reasons. The people engaged in the trade are small, medium and large. It does not pay anybody but a very large importer of corrugated sheets to have a bending machine. There is not a whole lot of labour involved. It merely means that any merchant who gets an inquiry for curved sheets, even if it is accompanied by an inquiry for flat sheets is practically left out of the market, if he has not got a bending machine. The Minister may say: "Well, let them go and get bending machines." But some people have not the room, others have not the capital and others have not the trade for it. It is really putting the trade into the hands of a very small number of people whom it pays to instal this bending machine, and it means a very small amount of labour.
Comment on this
I could not agree to that. The intention of the duty is to get the bending and working process done here.
Comment on this
To professional benders or twisters. The process is so simple that it would not mean any employment.
Comment on this
To illustrate the confusion that this will cause I might point out that Deputy Byrne connot still understand that straight sheets of corrugated iron are not meant to be tariffed. You can multiply Deputy Byrne, until you get 100 per cent. of the people of the country.
Comment on this
That is a fact. I never saw such confusion among people in the trade. The people of the country are anxious that the Minister and the draftsman should make clear what the duty means.
Comment on this
The intention is clear. A flat sheet or a straight sheet of corrugated iron is not subject to duty, but if the straight sheet or the flat sheet is subjected to any other process of working, including the process of bending, then it becomes subject to duty.
Comment on this
If a flat sheet or a straight sheet is curved is it subject to duty?
Comment on this
Does the Minister know that the result of the discussion here has been to clear the minds of many people as to what the Minister meant? Would the Minister accept that as true?
Comment on this
In any case the definition has been amended on the Report Stage of the Resolution to exclude thin, flat sheets from duty. The definition now is quite clear, I submit, and it is plain that flat sheets of galvanised corrugated iron are not subject to duty.
Comment on this
Perhaps the Minister would explain it better if he said the only sheet subject to duty is the bent one.
Comment on this
I move amendment 187:—
At Ref. No. 30, page 33, in the second column, after the word "iron" where it lastly occurs, to add the words "or steel."
Comment on this
I move amendment 189:—
At Ref. No. 33, page 33, in the second column, after the word "linoleum" where it lastly occurs to add the words "and also excluding floor covers made wholly or mainly of rubber."
Comment on this
I move amendment 190:—
At Ref. No. 34, page 33, in the second column, to delete all from the word "manufactured" to the word "machines" where it lastly occurs and substitute the words "Sheet lead, lead piping, and manufactured articles which are made wholly or mainly of brass or tin (including tinplate) or a combination of brass and tin (including tinplate), but excluding the articles exempted by the provision contained in the fifth column."
It is intended to alter to a considerable extent the description of the articles liable to duty in Ref. 33 in the manner I announced in the Second Reading, and amendments 190, 191 and 192 effect these alterations. The duty will now be payable only upon sheet lead and lead piping and manufactured articles which are made wholly or mainly of brass or tin (including tinplate) or a combination of brass and tin (including tinplate) but excluding the articles exempted by the provisions contained in the fifth column. That will operate to exclude electrical and gas fittings, apparatus, instruments, and appliances and surgical and scientific instruments and appliances, and all the other articles mentioned there. Amendment 192 introduces into this section the licence provision which will enable us to permit the importation, free of duty, of articles required in the process of manufacture.
Comment on this
I move amendment 191:—
At Ref. No. 34, page 33, in the fifth column to delete all from the word "article" to the word "business" and substitute the words "of the following articles nor on any component parts of such of the following articles as are complete articles, that is to say:—
(a) electrical and gas fittings, apparatus, instruments, and appliances,
(b) surgical, scientific, and optical apparatus, instruments, and appliances,
(c) apparatus, instruments, and appliances which; in the opinion of the Revenue Commissioners, are designed, constructed, and intended for use for educational purposes in schools, colleges, or other educational establishments,
(d) tinfoil, capsules, crown corks,
(e) brass wire (whether screwed or not screwed), brass pins, brass rivets, brass screws, brass tubing, and unworked brass rods,
(f) syringes, sprayers and combined syringes and sprayers, whether of brass or tin, (including tinplate) or a combination of brass and tin (including tinplate),
(g) toys,
(h) printers' blocks,
(i) filled containers,
(j) component parts of type-setting machines or of type composing machines,
(k) component parts of agricultural machinery other than dairy machinery,
(l) any religious object made of brass or tin (including tinplate) of which the value does not exceed one shilling,
(m) machines (other than pumps) which are made wholly or mainly of brass and, in the opinion of the Revenue Commissioners, are specially manufactured and designed for use by the proprietors of dairies and creameries in the processes of their business,
(n) containers which are made wholly or mainly of tinplate and have a capacity of not less than ten gallons and, in the opinion of the Revenue Commissioners, are specially manufactured and designed for use by the proprietors of dairies and creameries in the processes of their business."
Comment on this
I would like to talk on amendment 191. First of all, I would like to ask the Minister if he would accept as a substitution for (j) "component parts of type-setting machines or of type composing machines and brass rules"—that is, the printer's rules for those machines? Would the Minister consider that? It might be held that they were in under it already, but perhaps the insertion here would make it abundantly clear. I would compliment the Minister on the way he has dealt with sheet lead in amendment 190. I want to ask him also how he proposes to deal with my amendment 191a on the Order Paper? Many of these articles are not manufactured in this country and there does not seem to be any prospect of their manufacture at the moment.
Comment on this
As far as brass rules are concerned I will look into that point. It is possible that they are covered by the term "component parts," but I will have it examined.
In connection with the amendment moved by the Deputy on the Order Paper, 191a, I do not feel that it is possible to accept it. The history of this tariff is briefly as follows: We were anxious to take some action to develop the brass industry here. We endeavoured to get a clear list of articles which were made or could be made here with the intention of subjecting them to duty. We found almost insuperable difficulties in preparing such a list and we decided therefore to reduce the duty we had in amount to the lowest imposed by the Bill, that is, ten per cent., and to impose it upon all articles of brass, subject to certain exclusions. We appreciate the fact that certain articles will be subject to that duty which are not being made here, but I think we have taken the necessary steps to secure that no considerable hardship will be imposed upon any producer or upon any section. It is true that certain people will have to import brass articles and pay a duty upon them, but the duty will be ten per cent. and in the majority of cases will be of little consequence. The general licence provision will ensure that no manufacturer will be impeded in his operations by this duty. It is hoped as a result of its operations to be able to do what we have not succeeded in doing up to the present, and that is to get a clear segregation of those articles which can be made here in quantity or which are likely to be made here. It is felt that this small duty will attract attention to the possibilities of the industry and that we may be able to get development and later on definitely exclude from duty some of the articles which are not being made or will not be made, and possibly increase the duties upon some others and definitely secure a greater measure of protection. For the moment, it is felt that it is best to leave the duty as it is and leave the articles subject to the duty contained in amendment 191 and it is not intended to add to that list except under very exceptional circumstances for the duration of the present year. At the end of the year, the position can be reviewed and another attempt made to get that segregation.
Comment on this
I would like to ask the Minister has he considered that this amendment purports to leave out any things that can be manufactured here. This is a list of highly specialised articles, every one of which, in my humble opinion, cannot and are not likely to be manufactured here. Those articles which the brass trade here have made some attempt to manufacture have been deliberately excluded. And, of course, no doubt, the Minister is aware that he has expressly excluded from duty under this heading one of the largest lines of goods at present manufactured in this country.
Comment on this
I refer to the creamery business. The original in column 5, Ref. No. 34, definitely did exclude dairy and creamery machinery. That is not the position as it stands now. We have excluded from that definition pumps and "machines (other than pumps) which are made wholly or mainly of brass, and, in the opinion of the Revenue Commissioners, are specially manufactured and designed for use by the proprietors of dairies and creameries" in the Irish Free State. It is, I understand, mainly in the manufacture of pumps the local firms are engaged and they are now subject to the duty and it is intended they should be.
Comment on this
I move amendment 192:
At Ref. No. 34, page 33, in the fifth column, to insert a further provision as follows:—
Whenever the Minister for Finance, after consultation with the Minister for Industry and Commerce, is satisfied that any articles chargeable with this duty are essential raw materials of a process of manufacture carried on or intended to be carried on in Saorstát Eireann and are not obtainable or likely to be ob-able in Saorstát Eireann and are required to be imported by a manufacturer for use in Saorstát Eireann in such process, the Revenue Commissioners may by licence authorise such manufacturer, subject to compliance with such conditions as they may think fit to impose, to import without payment of this duty the said articles either, as the Revenue Commissioners shall think proper, without limit as to time or quantity or either of them or within a specified time or in a specified quantity.
Agreed.
Comment on this
I move amendment 193 on behalf of Deputy McGilligan:—
To delete Ref. No. 35, including relevant references in columns 2, 3 and 4.
That tariff again is a revenue tariff.
Comment on this
No, definitely not. We excluded from these duties the component parts of those articles partially manufactured, such as golf clubs and the like. They are, in fact, manufactured by the golf professionals and in some of the shops.
Comment on this
Has the Minister any prospect of having any of those athletic articles referred to in this Schedule made in this country?
Comment on this
The intention is to get them assembled here. Let me say the duty is partially a revenue duty. There is a definite revenue intention behind it but by the exclusion of component parts it will encourage the assembly of these articles here.
Comment on this
I take it that would include rowing gear, and I am informed there is already a 10 per cent. tax on that set out in this Schedule; but the customs authorities are demanding a 33? per cent. tax because it is partly of finished wood. Rowing gear, out-rigging and the like are not made in this country.
Comment on this
I think in amendment 166 the Minister has already conceded that wooden articles in sports material are not subject to the duty— golf clubs and so on.
Comment on this
As far as they are concerned it is a revenue duty. In reply to Deputy Doyle I would say it is possible that there may be a misunder-standing with regard to rowing gear which is now subject to a 10 per cent. duty.
Comment on this
Has the Minister any information that 33? per cent. is being charged upon these articles because of the finished wood?
Comment on this
It is possible that an error may have been made, but these articles are subject to the 10 per cent.
Comment on this
So we find the Minister is intending to get revenue by not only taxing the people going to the sports but also by taxing sport appliances.
Comment on this
I move amendment 195:—
To delete Ref. No. 36, including relevant references in columns 2, 3 and 4.
This is a revenue tax also.
Comment on this
I move amendment 196:—
At Ref. No. 36, page 33, in the second column, after the word "materials" to add the words "excluding binder twine and coir yarn, and also excluding any article which at importation forms part of another article."
I promised to exclude binder twine and coir yarn and any article which at importation forms part of another article.
Comment on this
I move amendment 197:
At Ref. No. 36, second column, to add at the end the words "excluding plaited and cable laid sash cords."
Comment on this
I am not quite sure as to what is intended there. We have a licensing provision in respect of this. The intention is in every case to exclude articles required in the process of manufacture. My belief is that that would cover the items mentioned by the Deputy.
Comment on this
I move amendment 198:—
At Ref. No. 36, page 33, to insert in the fifth column the following provision:—
Whenever the Minister for Finance, after consultation with the Minister for Industry and Commerce is satisfied that any articles chargeable with this duty are essential raw materials of a process of manufacture carried on or intended to be carried on in Saorstát Eireann and are not obtainable or likely to be obtainable in Saorstát Eireann, and are required to be imported by a manufacturer for use in Saorstát Eireann in such process, the Revenue Commissioners may by licence authorise such manufacturer subject to compliance with such conditions as they may think fit to impose, to import without payment of this duty the said articles either, as the Revenue Commissioners shall think proper, without limit as to time or quantity, or either of them, or within a specified time, or in a specified quantity.
Comment on this
I move amendment 199:—
At Ref. No. 37, to delete in the third and fourth columns, "45%" and "30%" and substitute "25%" and "15%" respectively.
This again is an excessive duty. In the case of knitted fabric the proposed duty is 45 per cent. and 30 per cent. respectively.
Comment on this
The intention of the duty is definitely to exclude knitted fabric except in so far as we permit its importation under licence arrangement. The duty could not be too high. The intention is to permit such importation as is necessary to encourage the knitting of fabric here. There was a real danger that our hosiery industry might develop along wrong lines, and instead of a hosiery industry become a sewing industry and a finishing industry. The intention is to prevent wrong development.
Comment on this
I move amendment 200:—
At Ref. No. 37, pages 33 and 34, in the fifth column, to delete all from the word "Whenever" to the words "foregoing provision" and substitute the following provision:—
Whenever the Minister for Finance, after consultation with the Minister for Industry and Commerce, is satisfied that any articles chargeable with this duty are essential raw materials of a process of manufacture carried on or intended to be carried on in Saorstát Eireann and are not obtainable or likely to be obtainable in Saorstát Eireann and are required to be imported by a manufacturer for use in Saorstát Eireann in such process, the Revenue Commissioners may by licence authorise such manufacturer, subject to compliance with such conditions as they may think fit to impose, to import without payment of this duty the said articles either, as the Revenue Commissioners shall think proper, without limit as to time or quantity or either of them within a specified time or in a specified quantity.
The intention is to have the form common to the other amendments.
Comment on this
I move amendment 201:—
To delete Ref. No. 1, including relevant references in columns 2, 3 4 and 5.
The Minister is imposing a terrible duty. I wonder has the Minister anything to say why it should be 7/6 and 5/- a gallon.
Comment on this
I would like to get it from the Minister that it is his intention to have absolute exclusion.
Comment on this
May I ask if the Minister will meet the demand of firms like Jacobs, who require special brands for foreign countries?
Comment on this
That position was examined before, and it was found that a supply of special varnish could be got here. That firm is getting it here.
Comment on this
I move amendment 202:—
To delete Ref. No. 3, including relevant references in columns 2, 3, 4 and 5.
This is the remains of the periodical tax.
Comment on this
I think "the remains" are better words than "best part." This is a tax that was imposed without thought and which in its effects is simply vexatious. If the intention is cultural there should be some inquiry to discover what kind of periodical we want to have excluded and have that defined by statutory definition. I agree with the Minister that there is coming to this country a type of periodical whose general tendency is such that people who have particular ideals, like we have ourselves, do not like. I have seen such periodicals and I have also tried as an experiment to frame a statutory definition to deal with them. I found great difficulty in doing so. In any event I would like to submit that the question of keeping out periodicals on cultural or moral grounds should be dealt with by the Committee dividing. What the Minister has done is to clap a tax on all kinds of periodicals. He proceeded to do what has produced great vexation amongst wholesale newsagents and newsvendors. He made certain amendments but even with the amendments there are still a number of periodicals which should not be excluded whose price has been arbitrarily raised for the getting of revenue. These periodicals are read by average citizens and the simplest thing for the Minister to do would be to abolish them altogether. The tax involves great difficulty for newsagents getting their supplies, because the packets have to be opened to see whether they are subject to duty or not. I would suggest to the Minister that he took the attitude that he is going to exclude certain publications, unless he is working on cultural or moral grounds. I would like to know what he expects to get by this tax in the way of employment.
Comment on this
I hope to get certain Irish periodicals launched in order to take the place of those excluded.
Comment on this
The Minister hopes that certain editions will be printed here, that certain periodicals will be kept out, and that writers will be employed here. He hopes that that will come about as a result of this tax.
[An Ceann Comhairle resumed the Chair.]
Comment on this
This is a part of the Bill that should be divided upon because there can be no doubt the Minister put on the tax without thought and then amended it. He worked up all kinds of arguments for it none of which he could sustain.
Comment on this
Question—"That the words proposed to be deleted, stand part of the Bill"—put.
Do you agree with this result?
Perhaps the Minister would accept this amendment.
Comment on this
I am afraid not. We have gone a long way to meet the point of view expressed in the amendment.
Comment on this
The point of view expressed in the amendment obviously is one that ought to be met. If it has not been met before it ought to be met now.
Comment on this
The term "informative" is altogether too wide. I take it that a paper that would inform the Deputy of the winner of the next race would come under that definition.
Comment on this
Supposing in deference to the Minister we dropped the word "informative," would he exclude technical, financial, or economic"? After all as long as we are next door to England and can read the English language we should not be prevented from getting a good type of journal which is produced for a country with a population of 40,000,000.
Comment on this
Why should people who want a technical, economic or financial journal be taxed? There is no possibility of any employment coming here through it.
Comment on this
You have the exclusion of trade and craft journals. I take it that should cover technical and scientific journals. I take it that the journals which the Deputy has in mind as economic journals are covered by the terms "scientific or educational."
Comment on this
That is the difficulty. It is hard to know what is meant by the term "educational." Economic papers are useful and instructive, and I do not think that they ought to be taxed.
Comment on this
I think there are, for instance, papers like The Economist or The Statist. Then there are papers like The Spectator or The New Statesman.
Comment on this
I would ask the Minister at this stage to accept the words "financial" or "economic."
Comment on this
Perhaps the word "informative" is too wide a word. I wonder would the Minister not consider whether it would not be possible, not merely, say, taking these papers as samples, that papers like The Economist and The Statist but also papers like The New Statesman would be included?
Comment on this
It would be almost impossible to get a definition. Deputy Hayes admitted he tried to get a definition, but did not succeed.
Comment on this
I said no such thing. I said I knew the journals that I would like to keep out, but that I could not frame a definition under the Censorship Act that would exclude them. I do not know how the Minister can manage to get this administered. He must make a very large addition to the staff of the Revenue Commissioners and that addition must be University men who could be expected to decide this. The only kind of employment this tariff will give will be employment to the staff of the Revenue Commissioners, who will require a very high standard of education in order to interpret what kind of journal should be excluded or should be admitted and what kind of book should be taxed and should not be taxed.
Comment on this
The Statist and The Economist are included but papers like The New Statesman and The Spectator are not.
Comment on this
Would the Minister say what would be the interpretation of the word "religious" in this definition? That is a very serious thing.
Comment on this
Would such periodicals as The Tablet and The Month be tabulated religious journals? Would the Minister include these as “religious”?
Comment on this
Would the people for whom the Minister is taking responsibility here tabulate these as "religious"?
Comment on this
I would like to say this: that some people claim that The Free Thinker is a religious journal. These people are supporters of Cumann na nGaedheal.
Comment on this
The Free Thinker is a negation of religion. But would a journal like America be included?
Comment on this
The Minister has said that some people have claimed exemption for The Free Thinker and he says that they are supporters of our Party. I would say they are far more likely to be supporters of his Party.
Comment on this
Will the Minister give his reasons for his refusal to exclude financial or economic?
Comment on this
The terms are too wide. The papers the Deputy has in mind are probably included already.
Comment on this
I do not know whether The Tablet or The Month or America would come in under the term “religious journals.” I do not know if The Commonweal counts as a “religious journal” and here we are asked to vote to apply a tariff to certain journals and not to other journals. I should like to have some guidance as to whether we might take The Commonweal, America, The Month or The Tablet as being journals that would come in under the definition of “religious.”
Comment on this
I suggest that it is we, legislating here, who should decide that matter and not the Revenue Commissioners.
Comment on this
The legislature is deciding as to whether journals which are religious, educational, trade or craft are to be excluded. The legislature is deciding that journals devoted mainly to these matters are excluded from the tariff but we will leave the actual administration to the Revenue Commissioners.
Comment on this
The Minister apparently cannot give a definition of the term "religious." I suggest that when the Minister cannot give a definition of these terms how can the legislature? I take these four journals that have come into my mind?
Comment on this
Surely, a Chinn Comhairle, this House is not going to take the authority of Deputy Fitzgerald as to what is or is not "religious."
Comment on this
I suggest that this is a very serious matter and the Minister is imposing on the Revenue Commissioners a burden which the Revenue Commissioners will not be able to carry. Deputy Briscoe was quite wrong in suggesting that the Revenue Commissioners are the proper people to solve this matter. Take a paper like The Commonweal. You may find one week in which you would not have in that paper one single article that any of us would say was a “religious” article.
Comment on this
I do not accept the Minister's interpretation. There are papers which are written from the Catholic point of view but which have articles on polities and finance and which sometimes have articles on Catholic Apologetics, but it would baffle any one to say that a particular issue of such a paper was religious. Everybody would say that they were good, sound Catholic journals but that they were religious is quite another matter. The difficulty about the Minister's own amendment simply proves that the whole thing is unworkable.
Comment on this
If I have used an expression that is offensive to a member opposite I wish to express my regret and I beg to withdraw it.
Amendment put and negatived.
Amendment 206:—
At Ref. No. 3, in the fifth column, to add on page 35, a further provision as follows:—
Where the Revenue Commissioners are satisfied that any article chargeable with this duty is imported for the use of a library which is not a proprietary library conducted mainly for profit, the Revenue Commissioners may, subject to compliance with such conditions as they may think fit to impose, permit such article to be imported without payment of this duty— (Aire Airgid).
Agreed to.
Comment on this
Does the Minister exempt a paper known as The Mind? It is devoted to philosophy.
Amendment 208:—
At Ref. No. 6, page 35, in the second column, to delete all from the word "Books" to the word "covers" and substitute the words. "Books which are, in the opinion of the Revenue Commissioners, novels and are printed in the Engglish language and bound in any material"—(Aire Airgid).