Finance Bill, 1932—Report Stage.
Contributions 1–163 of 327. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
No. 11 of 1932 ›
I beg to move amendment 1:
In page 6, Section 6 (1), after line 25 to insert the following paragraph:—
"Premises shall not be deemed to be occupied for the purposes of any trade, profession, or vocation within the meaning of this rule where the premises are mainly occupied for residential purposes and no part thereof is occupied for the purposes of trade but a part thereof is occupied for the purposes of a profession or vocation."
This amendment is designed to meet some of the points raised by Deputy Thrift and also by Deputy McGilligan. I think in the section as originally drafted they raised the objection that residential premises used by a doctor would become chargeable under Schedule D. I think Deputy Thrift has seen the amendment and I believe he will agree with me that, in so far as we can do it, it meets his point.
Comment on this
It will meet it very considerably. I think it is quite a satisfactory amendment, but I think it will still leave a large amount of difficulty in the case of a doctor—the determination as to whether his residence is used for private purposes or for the purposes of his professional qualifications. I am accepting the amendment and I thank the Minister for it. It goes a considerable way.
Comment on this
I beg to move amendment 2:
In page 9, Section 11 (2) (a), line 27, to delete the words "such article were included in" and also to delete all from the word "in" in line 28 to the word "rate" in line 30, and substitute the words "contained a list of goods to which duty of an amount equal to the said percentage of the value of the goods is made applicable as a preferential rate and such article were included in that list."
This amendment is a drafting amendment. I think in the Schedule in Item 14 the percentage preferential rate of duty is less than two-thirds of the full rate and accordingly this amendment is necessary.
Comment on this
I beg to move amendment 2a:
In page 13, Section 16 (1), in the first column of the scale of rates of duty, after the word "films" where it first occurs in that column, and before the bracket, to insert the words "of a width exceeding seven-tenths of an inch."
This amendment is designed to some extent to meet the case raised by Deputy Thrift in regard to small private films. These films are not suitable for exhibition in ordinary cinema theatres. It appears that a machine has been developed for use principally in educational institutions and also by salesmen and others for the purpose of displaying their wares. A narrow film with a sound strip attached is used in these machines and it would be obviously unfair to make a full charge in the case of these machines which are not designed primarily for entertainment purposes; it would be unfair to charge them the full rate of duty.
Comment on this
I beg to move amendment 2b:
In page 15, Section 19 (2) lines 25 and 26 to delete the words "in the year 1932 or any subsequent year."
The object of this is to release for the purpose of manufacture only Irish tobacco which is at present in bond and a large part of which has to be destroyed.
Comment on this
It is a strange thing to have these amendments coming in at this moment. Surely, with all the facilities that are at the Minister's hands in connection with his Department, those amendments could have been circulated at least at 3 o'clock? Surely it would have been as easy to turn off six or eight of them as two or three? It is certainly very bad treatment for the House to have amendments brought in like this at the last moment. In the hands of anybody else it would have been known that these would have been necessary, unless the concession to the home tobacco growers were a joke.
Comment on this
I understand there is a large quantity of tobacco involved which is unusable. A large part of it will have to be destroyed in any event.
Comment on this
About 40,000 lbs. There is a comparatively small portion which may be used. The question is whether we will release that for manufacture or not. It would, at any rate, give employment to someone. If it has to be destroyed it will be an absolute waste.
Comment on this
I beg to move amendment 3:—
In page 15 to delete Section 19 (3) and substitute a new sub-section as follows:—
"(3) If it is shown to the satisfaction of the Revenue Commissioners in respect of the business of a licensed manufacturer of tobacco that such business is either—
(a) in the beneficial ownership of an individual who is an Irish-born resident; or
(b) in the beneficial ownership of two or more individuals the majority of whom are Irish-born residents owning between them more than one-half of the capital invested in such business; or
(c) owned by an Irish-owned company and managed and controlled by persons the majority of whom are Irish-born residents;
the person licensed to carry on such business shall be entitled to receive a rebate of sevenpence in respect of every pound of unmanufactured tobacco received by such person upon which the duty imposed by this section has been paid and in respect of which no rebate under this section had been previously paid.
In this sub-section—
(i) the expression ‘Irish-born resident' means a person who ordinarily resides in Saorstát Eireann and either was born in Ireland or is the child of parents both of whom were born in Ireland; and
(ii) the expression ‘Irish-owned company' means a company of which the majority of the shareholders are Irish-born residents holding between them shares which, in the aggregate, are more than one-half in nominal value of the issued share capital of such company and carry at ordinary general meetings of such company more than one-half of the total voting power of all such shares in such company carrying votes at such meetings."
This amendment is designed to meet the objection raised by Deputy Norton.
Comment on this
On behalf of Deputy Lynch, I beg to move amendment 4:—
Amendment to amendment 3.
In the proposed amendment 3 to insert after paragraph (c) a new paragraph as follows:—
"(d) owned at the date of the passing of this Act by a company whose shares or stocks are quoted on any Stock Exchange in Saorstát Eireann and has established a share register in Saorstát Eireann."
The amendment sets out that under this new proposed section companies should come in whose shares or stocks are quoted on any Stock Exchange in Saorstát Eireann and who have established a share register in Saorstát Eireann.
That enables the companies to have quotations on the Stock Exchange, which, of course, makes the stamp duty on transfers here come to the Exchequer of this State, and if they have a register in the Saorstát then the death duties will come into the State on the death of persons who are shareholders in the company here. Therefore, these particular companies who would come under the section are companies whose existence here is of advantage and benefit to this State. In addition to that I put it—and I want to put it very shortly because this matter has been threshed out in previous discussions here and I do not wish to say very much more upon the matter—that it is taking away the preference which is being given to one set of manufacturers at the expense of another set; that certain persons or companies came into this State and set up business in this State; and that those persons are behaving as ideal employers. It is unfair now that after they have been established here for years, after they have built up their factory and everything else here, it is unfair to start discriminating against them in favour of any other person and I may add too that the company in question is a company in which there is an enormous quantity of Irish-owned capital involved.
Comment on this
This matter has been threshed out in the Dáil on four previous occasions and the principle contained in the Bill has been approved of by the Dáil on each of those occasions. The proposal now put forward in the amendment would be to rescind the previous decisions of the Dáil in regard to this particular section. We could not do that for one reason—which may possibly lead to a repetition of the previous speeches in this House—which I venture to make again and that is that it would cost the Exchequer at least £160,000.
Comment on this
The loss to the Exchequer could be got over if there was no discrimination against this company.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 5:—
In page 15, Section 19, before sub-section (4), to insert a new sub-section as follows:—
Any licensed manufacturer of tobacco who was on the 1st day of April, 1932, and has been continuously since that date a licensed manufacturer of tobacco carrying on business as such manufacturer in Saorstát Eireann but who at the date of the passing of this Act would not be entitled to receive the rebate contemplated in the last preceding sub-section shall nevertheless be entitled to receive such rebate as from the 12th day of May, 1932, provided that within twelve months after the passing of this Act such licensed manufacturer becomes qualified to receive the rebate contemplated in the last preceding sub-section.
Is the Minister accepting amendment No. 5?
Comment on this
The Minister in moving No. 3 suggested he was moving that amendment to meet certain representations made by Deputy Norton. As I understand it, the Minister's amendment No. 3 means that those firms at the present moment who are licensed manufacturers of tobacco and who are not Irish companies within the terms of his amendment, and perhaps within the terms of the Control of Manufactures Bill, ought to be deprived of a particular preference but that as soon as the taxation that is here or the restrictions in connection with the Control of Manufactures Bill operate sufficiently heavily on them to make them form themselves into Irish companies, they must get a rebate of the 7d. Now the particular tobacco manufacturers whose case was specially mentioned here and on which this question originally arose, made, I think, representations to the Minister that they were only waiting until following the very great expenditure of money on their part here in the setting up of their firm and following on the necessary loss that would fall on the first three years of their working —they would settle down and establish themselves and turn themselves into an Irish company here —to turn into an Irish company this company that has satisfactorily carried on its business under the laws of the country up to the present and has given a considerable amount of employment here both in the setting up of the new factory and its working. This company has told the Minister that it is anxious at the earliest possible opportunity to become an Irish company. If it takes it four, five or six months and carried its intentions in that way and becomes an Irish company, the Minister is going deliberately, and I suggest, unnecessarily, to deprive it of the rebate as between the 12th of May, the date of the coming into effect of this taxation and the date on which it becomes an Irish company. I submit that that company is in a bona fide way going to carry out the intentions which they have and I suggest that the company should not be mulcted for this particular taxation, for four, five or six months that must necessarily elapse before the coming into effect of additional taxation and the time by which they are able to carry out their intentions.
Comment on this
I cannot accept this amendment. The whole principle of it is illogical and I need not go into it.
Comment on this
Why should a person get a rebate before he becomes entitled to it? And why should he become entitled to it in respect of a period in which he was not entitled to it? That is the proposition that Deputy Mulcahy is putting before the House.
Comment on this
Does that apply in the other way? Will it apply to the Government getting retrospective taxation? That is the rebate to the Government to which they are not entitled.
Comment on this
The Deputy possibly has a poorer sense of the significance of words than I have. By his own showing here he has a very much poorer sense of the use of words and he can very easily see that things are not identical and that there is no analogy between them at all. Here is a case where a person is not entitled to any particular privileges. Possibly in eleven months' time he converts himself into an Irish company and he is entitled to reap, under this amendment, all the benefits and advantages which he would have had if he had been an Irish company during the preceding eleven months. I think the Deputy himself will see why no Government could accept a proposition like that.
Comment on this
The position we have then is this, that when an Irish company, coming back in changed circumstances here from Belfast and establishing itself here three or four years ago at a time when building costs were very high and spending £250,000 in establishing a sound tobacco factory here and giving a very big and considerable amount of employment, finds itself after three years working just as they anticipated, beginning to have their business properly established and to be making a profit. On the eve of being able to put their shares into the market in such a way as to secure that their company would be an Irish company, they find themselves, on 12th May last, faced with a completely new policy of discrimination. That discrimination as regards certain types of companies in contrast with others was enshrined in this Finance Bill and subsequently enshrined in the Control of Manufactures Bill. The Minister has brought in an amendment to his Finance Bill so that any company which is a non-Irish company, on becoming an Irish company, or any new company establishing itself as an Irish company, will get this rebate. This company is going to be caught in the discrimination contained in this Finance Bill. It is going to be forced to sell itself at a time when there is an unnecessary deduction from its capital arising out of the discrimination involved here. That is all I want to say on the matter. The Minister suggests that this is Deputy Norton's contribution to the saving of Gallaher's. After the Labour Party's performance on the Housing Bill last night, I am prepared to believe it is.
Comment on this
If the Deputy had put some of his points when I could answer them, I should be glad to answer them and the first answer I would make would be that Gallaher's is not an Irish company.
Comment on this
I am sure you, a Chinn Comhairle, will give the Minister latitude to answer the points I have raised in view of the latitude I have taken.
Comment on this
And in view, further, of the latitude that I am going to take. There is an amendment on the Paper which provides that any licensed manufacturer of tobacco who was on 1st April, 1932, and has been continuously since a licensed manufacturer of tobacco but who, at the date of the passing of the Act, would not be entitled to receive the rebate "shall nevertheless be entitled to receive such rebate as from 12th day of May, 1932, provided that within twelve months after the passing of this Act such licensed manufacturer becomes qualified to receive the rebate ...." Might I ask in connection with this, does the whole question of rebate operate within the financial year? I assume it does. Might I ask what is to prevent Deputy Mulcahy's amendment taking effect under the terms of the Minister's amendment which we have just carried—Amendment 3? Supposing Gallaher's do transform themselves into an Irish company, taking lettered paragraph (c) in the Minister's own amendment, we are told that "the person licensed to carry on such business shall be entitled to receive a rebate of sevenpence in respect of every pound of unmanufactured tobacco received by such person upon which the duty imposed by this section has been paid." Supposing Gallaher's transform themselves into an Irish company within the twelve months, will they not be entitled to demand a rebate, because the tobacco referred to is clearly tobacco upon which the tax imposed by the section has been paid? Are there any limiting words which prevent a rebate being claimed at any time within the financial year? I think it is necessary to know that before we can discuss the other amendments.
Comment on this
I should like to direct the Deputy's attention to the words "receive a rebate of sevenpence in respect of every pound of unmanufactured tobacco received by such person upon which the duty imposed by this section has been paid and in respect of which no rebate under this section has been previously paid." If the company changes its ownership, then the new owners will not have received the tobacco which was received and upon which duty was paid by the former owners.
Comment on this
That will depend on whether they can get themselves into the new position of beneficial ownership without changing the company. If they can do that without changing the old statutory company, they will be entitled to the rebate within the financial year.
Comment on this
If that be possible —I am only putting it as a hypothesis —then sevenpence per pound during the whole of the financial year can be claimed upon all the tobacco upon which they have paid the full rate inside the financial year. Is not that right?
Comment on this
The Minister says that the company would not be the same entity. Why not? If I am legal owner of an article or of property and if, within twelve months, I institute proceedings and am declared the beneficial owner as well, am I not the same entity?
Comment on this
It is a question of getting the reason why, because on the answer to the question will depend the argument that is to proceed on amendment No. 5. May I again put the point? A company is in existence at this moment. It might transfer its ownership without ceasing to be the same company. If it becomes a company beneficially owned in the Saorstát and if it has inside the financial year paid duty at the full rate, is it not entitled to a rebate under the terms of the Minister's amendment, which I shall read: "The person licensed to carry on such business shall be entitled to receive a rebate of sevenpence in respect of every pound of unmanufactured tobacco received by such person upon which the duty imposed by this section has been paid"? The "person" is the licensed manufacturer.
Comment on this
Is it possible for that to happen under the hypothesis I mentioned—that the company changes its ownership without ceasing to be the same company?
Comment on this
The Deputy can get an answer to that elsewhere. I thought the debate on amendment No. 5 had been concluded. However, I think I ought to point out to the Deputy the definition of the expression "Irish owned company" which is contained at the bottom of the amendment. "The expression ‘Irish-owned company' means a company of which the majority of the shareholders are Irish-born residents holding between them shares which, in the aggregate, are more than one-half in nominal value of the issued share capital of such company and carry at ordinary general meetings of such company more than one-half of the total voting-power of all shares in such company carrying votes at such meetings." I think the Deputy himself has missed the point.
Comment on this
In order to become qualified to receive the rebate under paragraph (c), the business must be owned by an Irish-owned company and the duty must have been paid by an Irish-owned company.
Comment on this
".... receive a rebate of sevenpence in respect of every pound of unmanufactured tobacco received by such person."
Comment on this
Is it the company? May I read the Minister's own amendment—"If it is shown to the satisfaction of the Revenue Commissioners in respect of the business of a licensed manufacturer of tobacco that such business" is owned in various ways, then, "the person licensed"—not the company—"to carry on such business shall be entitled to receive a rebate of sevenpence in respect of every pound of unmanufactured tobacco received by such person.""Person" is the word used, not "company."
Comment on this
Where is the use of fiddling with this matter? Is it not the same company. Assuming they are the legal owners, if they transform the company and become beneficial owners as well as legal owners, is it not the same entity?
Comment on this
If they are an Irish-owned company all the time, they receive the rebate. If, before a certain date, they are not an Irish-owned company, then, under the terms of the amendment, they do not receive the rebate.
Comment on this
Will the Minister read me the phrase dealing with the company and referring to the rebate?
Comment on this
Will the Minister read us the section which refers to the person receiving the rebate?
Comment on this
The Deputy knows that the word "person" includes persons or corporations in this context.
Comment on this
I want to have this amendment negatived definitely in this House by Deputy Norton and the Minister for Finance.
Comment on this
Question put.
Do you agree with this result?
I move amendment 6:—
In page 17, before Section 21 (6) to insert a new sub-section as follows:—
"(6) Notwithstanding anything contained in this section, a portion of cheese wrapped only in tinfoil and not exceeding two ounces in weight shall not be a package for the purposes of this section."
In the debate on the Committee Stage of the Bill, Deputy Blythe raised a point about small portions of cheese wrapped in tinfoil which were contained and sold in a larger packet, and I promised to see if I could not meet him. This amendment is to meet the point.
Comment on this
Will these words here employed be vitiated by the addition of a label on the tinfoil?
Comment on this
I want to ask a question on 6 (b) "all drinks not excluded by the next following sub-section of this section." I understand that at present wines and liqueurs that have been in merchants' bonding warehouses for years are being charged the packet tax on being taken out. If the Minister could consider that, I would feel very much obliged to him.
Comment on this
I am afraid the liqueurs and wines will be covered and will come within the scope of the duty, and I do not think we could possibly exclude them. In any event, there is sufficient profit on wines and liqueurs, I assure the Deputy, to pay the package tax.
Comment on this
As to the amendment, what is the necessity for having the word "only" in after the word "wrapped"? The amendment can secure what the Minister wants if he leaves out the word "only"—"wrapped in tinfoil."
Comment on this
No. There may be a subsidiary wrapping. I have in mind the case where there are six or eight sections separately wrapped in tinfoil and packed in one container.
Comment on this
"Not exceeding two ounces in weight." If there is any further wrapping then they clearly come within the terms of the package duty because the additional wrapping could be applied here. The statement is that the tinfoil must be applied at the moment they are packed in the first container, at the moment, as a matter of fact, when the pieces are made up.
Comment on this
Amendments 7 and 8 can be taken together. Will Deputy Sir James Craig state whether he considers amendment 8 meets the purpose of his amendment No. 7?
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 7. I am not satisfied that it is included in amendment No. 8. I understand that the Minister is going to accept my amendment. In that case I shall not occupy the time of the House by going into any description of it, but will merely formally move the amendment.
Comment on this
I am willing to accept amendment No. 7 in the name of Deputy Sir James Craig, and I am putting before the House amendment No. 8, which is designed to meet the point made by Deputy Mrs. Collins-O'Driscoll, on the one hand, and Deputy McGilligan, on the other, in regard to invalid foods.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 9:
In page 18, before Section 23 (2), to insert a new sub-section as follows:—
"(2) The duty imposed by this section shall not be charged or levied on any articles which are shown to the satisfaction of the Revenue Commissioners to consist only of frozen boneless veal produced in a country within the British Commonwealth of Nations and consigned from that or any other such country and imported solely for use for manufacturing purposes in Saorstát Eireann."
This amendment is introduced to facilitate an existing Saorstát industry for the manufacture of meat paste. The products of this industry are mainly exported, so that even if this provision were not made, a drawback would be payable as regards the part which would be imported. The duty-free admission is a much simpler and much more satisfactory procedure from the point of view of the Revenue Commissioners and the manufacturers.
Comment on this
I welcome the remission of course, but why confine it to "frozen boneless veal"? Supposing the people engaged in this meat-paste industry want to go into some other form of the meat-paste business, for which they will have to get raw material from outside, would it not be the proper thing to leave in some general word instead of the particular frozen boneless veal, say "meat" simply, or "meat or animal products produced in a country within the British Commonwealth of Nations"? The whole thing is covered by the later phrase "imported solely for use for manufacturing purposes in Saorstát Eireann." I think that guards everything that the Minister may want.
Comment on this
The manufacturers who, presumably, have a certain amount of foresight, and know what their business requirements are likely to be, have not suggested that the scope of the amendment should be any wider than appears on the Order Paper. In view of that, I presume there is no necessity for such a wider scope, and I do not propose to enlarge the amendment.
Comment on this
I suppose this is a sort of following up the procedure adopted, namely, put on a tax and wait until somebody squeals under the impact and then remit. Supposing people have not realised it and squeal too late, what is going to happen?
Comment on this
I move amendment 10.
In page 19, before Section 24 (4), to insert a new sub-section as follows:—
"(4) Entertainments duty shall not be charged or levied on any entertainment as respects which it is proved to the satisfaction of the Revenue Commissioners that the entertainment consists solely of a number of courses between greyhounds in each of which two greyhounds are released from slips in pursuit of a live hare."
On the Committee Stage I promised to introduce an amendment which would exempt from the scope of the entertainments duty greyhound coursing, and amendment 10 is designed to give effect to that.
Comment on this
Amendments were to be accepted in the House and I want to move the omission of the word "live" from in front of the word "hare" for an obvious reason.
Comment on this
To let in coursing which is not competitive greyhound racing and which is not in pursuit of a live hare.
Comment on this
I understood the Minister to say that he accepted the amendment in the name of Deputies Lynch, Morrissey and myself.
Comment on this
No. I made the point there that any exemption which I was disposed to concede in this matter would apply to greyhound coursing only, and not to greyhound racing.
Comment on this
When I heard Deputy McGilligan get up and say that he desired to leave out the word "live," I certainly thought I had discovered in his incisive personality a soft spot. I discovered subsequently that I had not and I think it is rather regrettable —if the Deputy does not say it, I will— that the Irish Treasury should have made a special exception in favour of the cruellest and most savage sport practised in this country. I can well understand that the dog men will become eloquent. Maybe I have started a debate that will go on for I do not know how long. I cannot, however, let this occasion pass without saying that coursing in many parts of this country is nothing better than savagery. The men who engage in it will not advert to that aspect of it; the gentlemen who hunt foxes will not advert to that aspect of it. To see unfortunate hares let loose one after another in order to be torn to pieces by hounds, and all for the edification of onlookers, is to me a most disgusting business. If the coursing of dogs has to be carried on, greyhound racing is the better of a very undesirable pair. For a different reason from that mentioned by Deputy McGilligan I wish that the word "live" would be removed from this resolution.
Comment on this
I quite agree with the statements made by Deputy Dillon regarding park coursing. It is most cruel and I appeal to the Minister to take out the word "live." We have in this country the electric hare and I think that the people who attend those places are as well entitled to do so as those who attend the park coursing meetings. As Deputy Dillon said, park coursing is absolute cruelty. I dare say in the open coursing it may be good and fair sport, but, in the case of park coursing, it is downright slaughter. I appeal to the Minister to take out the word "live."
Comment on this
The statements made by the last two Deputies with regard to park coursing are absolutely without any foundation.
Comment on this
All I can say is that those Deputies must not be accustomed to attending coursing meetings. In all the park coursing meetings I have attended there always has been an escape for the hares. Not alone that, but in case a faulty hare is let out the dogs are not slipped to her.
Comment on this
The hare that does not escape is killed and a good many animals do not get as decent a death as that. I am quite certain that the hares get a fair hunt. I am sure that at least 75 per cent. of the hares escape at the majority of park coursing meetings. At the Waterloo Cup and at other places the hares get as good a chance as any other animals get.
Comment on this
I would like to add my voice to the appeal made to the Minister to exempt the word "live." In the country districts, while they are not able to rise to such a luxury, if I may so call it, as an electric hare, they nevertheless have mechanical means of carrying on greyhound racing. They adopt a much simpler method when they cannot avail of an electric hare. I must say that this affords a very considerable amount of amusement in country districts and it eliminates the effects alluded to by Deputy Dillon and Deputy Curran. Of course everybody is entitled to his own opinion on this matter. Deputy Dillon and Deputy Curran are entitled to have their views with regard to the cruelty or otherwise of coursing. I certainly think that if the House agrees to Deputy McGilligan's suggestion, it will eliminate any effects of the sort described.
Comment on this
I think the Minister will remember that the case made out for the original amendment was in connection with the training and export of greyhounds. I am sure if he thinks over it he will realise that the amendment he now offers goes only a very small way to meet that particular case. The case was strong before, but I am sure that the Minister will now realise that, with the extra 20 per cent. that is being put on live animals of this kind exported to England, the case is still stronger than it was when the Minister promised to meet the arguments put up from these benches.
Comment on this
If the amendment in its present form is not acceptable, it seems to me the only thing I can do is to withdraw it. The deletion of the word "live," as suggested by Deputy McGilligan, would not, I think, meet the points raised by Deputies Dillon and Curran.
Comment on this
No. Let us put the amendment on a proper footing. The whole purpose of the section is to procure revenue. I am satisfied, so far as greyhound coursing is concerned— and I am not considering any other aspect of it except the revenue producing aspect—that there is going to be no revenue derived from it and the attempt to collect revenue is only going to cause most unprofitable labour for the officers of the Revenue Commissioners. For that reason I am exempting coursing primarily, but the situation is quite different in regard to greyhound racing. I know the attendance at meetings at which mechanical hares are used is substantial. I know that the profits of the greyhound racing companies have been very large indeed. Therefore, I say that this is an entertainment which can be made to yield something to the Exchequer. For that reason I am giving the House the option of either accepting the amendment as it stands or consenting to its withdrawal.
Comment on this
And neither of these amendments can be withdrawn without the permission of the House.
Comment on this
A peculiar situation has arisen here. There was an amendment moved the other day by Deputy Lynch from the front Opposition Bench. I rather approved of that amendment and was prepared to support it, but I understood that the amendment was being withdrawn by the Opposition on an undertaking given by the Minister for Finance that he would introduce the amendment which he has now introduced. Why are the Deputies opposite now objecting to this amendment? Why did they not press their amendment the other day? Why did they agree two or three days ago to have an amendment of this kind introduced? Why are they so anxious now to go back on their attitude of the other day? I was somewhat sorry the other day that Deputy Lynch did not press his amendment because I was particularly anxious that the tax on greyhound racing should be taken off. I thought it would be in the best interests of those people who breed greyhounds for sale. I thought it would be a little advantage to them and to that trade that the tax should be on the coursing meetings. For that reason I am satisfied with this amendment. I understand the Minister for Finance could not give way on the whole lot. The attitude of the Opposition now rather puzzles me.
With regard to the remarks of Deputy O'Sullivan, I cannot say that there is the same amount of jubilation on this side of the House or in the country at the idea of the British imposing a 20 per cent. tax on Irish cattle and Irish produce as appears to exist amongst the Cumann na nGaedheal Deputies in this House.
Comment on this
It was expressed by Professor O'Sullivan. It is a thing that should not be dragged at all into this discussion. Professor O'Sullivan is talking for a particular purpose to advertise certain things. The fact that the Irish export trade is going to suffer makes him talk about the export of greyhounds. I think he should look upon the matter from a different standpoint. We here think that the matter should be looked upon from a different standpoint than that of the people on the opposite benches I was going to appeal to the Minister now to extend his generosity to greyhound racing tracks seeing that this greyhound racing enhances the price of greyhounds, but the Deputy says there is no use now in doing that at this stage. The Minister is removing the tax upon open coursing and we have to be satisfied with that or nothing at all. I would not like that the House would press the Minister to withdraw that concession.
Comment on this
I suggest that Deputy McGilligan should withdraw his amendment and allow the section to go through.
Comment on this
I do not want to start another hare but I think the Minister's amendment is liable to misinterpretation. "A live hare" in the opinion of a great many people would include an electric hare. I suggest that the Minister would substitute the words "a living hare." It would be less subject to misinterpretation.
Comment on this
The Revenue Commissioners will not take it like that. They will not misinterpret the section.
Comment on this
Deputy Cleary might have his memory refreshed if I read what he said on this matter on a previous discussion here. Speaking on the 8th July, column 563-564 of the Official Debates, the Deputy said: "My impression is that coursing is of very little use to people who sell greyhounds and gain by the selling of them. Coursing as I know it, is only a sport— a very expensive sport to those who engage in it. In my county, it is usually a sport for people who can afford to spend money on it. It is track racing that makes whatever market there is for greyhounds. Since greyhound track racing came into prominence the value of our export trade in greyhounds has increased. Were it not for that greyhound breeding as a profitable proposition would not be worth while." The Deputy now goes back on his advocacy of the freedom of the greyhound racing track from taxation.
Comment on this
I ask the Deputy why did he allow his colleagues to withdraw the amendment the last day.
Comment on this
The Deputy now unfortunately acquiesces in the attitude of the Minister on this matter because the export of greyhounds has been killed.
Comment on this
I suggest that the Deputy should withdraw his amendment and allow the sub-section to go through.
Comment on this
It is clear to me that if the Minister does not exempt both the greyhound coursing and the track racing, he has done the next best thing.
Comment on this
Greyhound coursing in the country brings out the best qualities in the dogs and it brings forward the best dogs for the coursing track. That is very necessary from the point of view of the export of dogs for greyhound racing. Deputy Mulcahy has pointed out that the export of greyhounds is dead. The importers of greyhounds on the other side will pay the tariff.
Comment on this
The Dáil divided; Tá,
Do you agree with this result?
I move amendment 10a.
On page 19, Section 25, to delete lines 41 and 42 and substitute the following:—
"Duty calculated in accordance with the following provisions, that is to say,"
(a) where the premises to which such licence applies are of a residential character and no part thereof is used as a factory or a shop and the sale of tobacco or snuff on such premises under such licence is effected solely by means of one and only one automatic machine or other mechanical contrivance, such excise duty shall (subject to the limitation hereinafter mentioned) be of an amount equal to one-half of the 1 per cent., of the amount by which the poor law valuation of such premises exceeds £10;
(b) In every other case, such excise duty shall (subject to the limitation hereinafter mentioned) be of an amount equal to 1 per cent., of the amount by which the poor law valuation of such premises exceeds £10;
(c) The total amount of the excise duty now payable and the additional excise duty imposed by this section chargeable in respect of any one such licence shall not exceed £10.
Paragraph (a) of this amendment is designed to meet, in part, the amendment put down by Deputy Wolfe, completely exempting automatic machines from duty, to the extent that they will be only charged, so far as the valuation of the premises in which they are situate exceeds £10, at the rate of ½ per cent. of such excess. Paragraph (b) of the amendment is in fulfilment of the undertaking which I gave Deputy Mulcahy that, if he would withdraw his amendment on Committee Stage, I would accept the principle but increase the limit of duty from £5 to £10.
Comment on this
This amendment was only put into my hands a moment ago. Am I right in assuming that lettered paragraph (a) means that a private house which has an automatic machine on the premises will pay a tobacco dealer's licence fee? Is that what is intended?
Comment on this
Yes. The tobacco dealer's licence duty is payable in respect of such machines as the law stands at present.
Comment on this
The Minister has made the astounding statement that houses which have machines on the premises have paid—
Comment on this
That is entire rubbish. How many have paid? Would the Minister get figures from the Revenue Commissioners showing how much money has been received in such payments?
Comment on this
How many machines have been in use, say, in residential houses? What percentage, in other words, is the 400 of all the machines that have been in use?