We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

Finance Bill, 1932—Report Stage.

Contributions 164–327 of 327. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

Bill Finance Bill, 1932
Enacted

No. 11 of 1932 ›

Yes, but the point about it is that only one duty will be charged in respect of the premises. In respect of hotels, they fall under (b), in any event, and they will pay under (b), because I presume they would sell cigarettes otherwise than through automatic machines.

Comment on this

Sometimes not.

Comment on this

Will this apply to offices and any places that have automatic machines?

Comment on this

Yes.

Comment on this

I move amendment 10b.

In page 20, before Section 26 (2) to insert a new sub-section as follows—

(2) Where two or more individuals carry on business as moneylenders in partnership and such individuals take out moneylenders' licences in respect of the premises or all the premises in which they so carry on business in partnership, the Revenue Commissioners shall remit or, if the duty has been paid, repay to such partnership—

(a) where such business is so carried on in one premises only, a sum equal to the total duty on all except one of the moneylender's licences as taken out by such individuals in respect of such premises, or

(b) where such business is so carried on in two or more premises a sum equal to the total duty on all moneylender's licences so taken out by such individuals in respect of any such premises in excess of one such licence for each such premises.

This amendment has become necessary because the relevant clauses of the Moneylenders Bill of 1932 are not identical with the clauses in the Moneylenders Bill of 1929 upon which the original section was based. The amendment will grant the concessions to partners in so far as it limits the duty to what it would have been in the case of a single individual. The whole principle of the amendment will arise for discussion on the Moneylenders Bill.

Comment on this

And there will be no charge until that principle comes to be discussed?

Comment on this

No.

Comment on this

I move amendment 11:

In page 20, Section 29 (3), line 51, after the word "day" to insert the words and figures "or is taken out before the passing of this Act for a period commencing on or after the 1st day of July, 1932."

This amendment to Section 29 is designed to cover the case of a licence taken out after the 1st of July, 1932, but before the passing of the Finance Act. The case was not covered by the section as originally drafted.

Comment on this

I move amendments 12 and 13:

In page 20, Section 29 (3), line 55, to delete all from the word "at" to the end of the sub-section and substitute the words "be repaid to such person."

13. In page 21, Section 29 (4) (b), line 9 to delete the words "the allowing as a credit or" and in lines 10 and 11 to delete the words "to be so allowed or".

Amendments 12 and 13, I think, should be considered together, as they are more or less in the nature of drafting amendments. It is proposed to permit the refund to take the form of a credit on payment under the new licence. Power is, in fact, taken, under the regulations to be made under this section, to repay by way of credit but it is not usual to provide for credit in specific terms in the Act.

Comment on this

May I refer to Section 42 before we go to amendment 14?

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Yes.

Comment on this

It was up for discussion the other evening and Deputy Finlay raised a most important point about a sub-contractor. I do not wish to argue the law with the Minister, but I understood him to say that he would consider Deputy Finlay's point. Has the Minister considered it in this section as amended?

Comment on this

I have very carefully considered that point and I am advised that it is not necessary to make any special provision to cover the point made by Deputy Finlay. I am advised that it is, in fact, already covered by the section.

Comment on this

I move amendment 14:

In page 26, line 20, Section 46 (1) to delete the figures "1930" and substitute the figures "1931."

I do not want to take up the time of the House with this, but I believe that the dates in the Bill will cause hardship in certain cases, because profits will already have been distributed, in certain cases, without provision being made for payment of this tax.

Comment on this

I regret that it is not possible for me to accept this amendment in the form in which it is put down, or to accept the amendment at all.

Comment on this

Because it would mean that in this year we would have all the odium of increasing the Corporation Profits Duty and none of the rewards. In fact, we would get none of the increased Corporation Profits Duty in this year, and it would cost the Exchequer — at the risk, again, of rousing the Deputy — £200,000.

Comment on this

That is nothing to £2,000,000, and do you not expect to be in next year?

Comment on this
Frank Aiken Minister for Defence (Mr. Aiken) Fianna Fáil

No.

Comment on this

Deputy Aiken has different views but he is not able to express them.

Comment on this

Gather ye rose-buds while ye may!

Comment on this

Does the Minister not think that it is a very regrettable way of putting this matter? Am I wrong in thinking that it simply means that, according to the accidental period at which a corporation's year ends, it may or may not be liable for this duty for the preceding year? Supposing its financial year ends, say, on the 1st January or the 1st February. It becomes then, according to this, apparently, liable to tax for the whole of the preceding year.

Comment on this

It is quite true that it takes effect as from the 1st January.

Comment on this

Would the Minister say if there is any precedent for imposing a tax of that character retrospectively?

Comment on this

The point I want to make is that this is retrospective legislation of the most discriminatory character — discrimination depending on mere accident.

Comment on this

Not at all.

Comment on this

Is there any precedent?

Comment on this

Is it not a fact that there is no precedent?

Comment on this

At this moment, I cannot recall that there is any precedent, but is there any precedent for any fresh taxation? And is there any precedent for the situation in which we find ourselves?

Comment on this

Hear, hear, none.

Comment on this

But the Minister will admit that there is a special principle underlying this and he is now, with one fell stroke, introducing a principle that may turn up in a very awkward form in the future. However, I suppose the answer as to the £200,000 will serve.

Comment on this

Instead of the £2,000,000.

Comment on this

Is this duress, sir?

Comment on this

It is the duress under which I have been compelled to put this section in the Bill.

Comment on this

But surely the Minister does not justify, or has not, so far, attempted to justify, the fact that, under this, as worded, one firm's profits, during the year 1930, will be made liable to this tax because it happened to end its accounts on the 1st January, whereas another will not be liable to this tax at all because it happened to end its accounts on the 30th December?

Comment on this

I move amendment 17:

In page 27, Section 47, line 57, after the word "person" to insert the words "not being a member of the Oireachtas of Saorstát Eireann."

This is a most amazing section. The purpose of the section is to allow the Revenue Commissioners to remit all interest payable in respect of a certain year and to grant such remission of such duty as is considered just. The terms of instructions to the Revenue Commissioners are, that, where they are satisfied that a person who is liable to Excess Profits Duty (a) has voluntarily furnished to the Revenue Commissioners all such information in his possession or procurement as is requisite for the due computation of the amount of such duty—which, incidentally, he is bound to do — or (b) if he is in such financial circumstances that he cannot without undue hardship pay the whole amount of such duty or (c) has so furnished such information and is in such financial circumstances, then, the remission may take place. It is to be noticed that the first condition on which the Revenue Commissioners may remit is if a man does what he is bound to do, and the second condition — and it is not a junction but an alternative — if he is in such a financial condition, whether he furnishes the information or not, the Revenue Commissioners may make certain remissions. I propose to put in, after the word "person," the words "not being a member of the Oireachtas of Saorstát Eireann," so that the section will read: "Where the Revenue Commissioners are satisfied that a person, not being a member of the Oireachtas of Saorstát Eireann, has done these two things, etc."

I do that for this reason, that it seems to me that when we are making this peculiar remission of duty, we should not allow it to be said outside that members of the Oireachtas are looking for something in the way of remission, where that remission is really founded, in the main, or going to be founded upon their doing something, which, in fact, they were bound to do. Notwithstanding the opinion that may be held, inside the House, of members of the House, there are people outside who have expressed the view that this is specially designed for the safe-guarding of individuals, being members of the Oireachtas, who are put in conjunction with people who occupy Government posts, and who are close to them and who have got this particular remission to allow them to escape certain taxation which ought to be imposed on them. Whether that is right or wrong, and I do not believe it is right, I think that we should have a standard set, at any rate, for members of the Oireachtas, that they are not going to claim these peculiar remissions. If a man is elected here to do his duty as a public man, that ought to include his doing his duty as a private citizen in the matter of taxation, because a man's public duties rest to a great extent upon such matters as taxation and the imposition of taxation. We should not allow it to go forth that a member of the Oireachtas can gain a remission of taxation because, after the event, and after he has voted for something of this sort, he can do something which he was bound to do before, and so obtain a remission of taxation which had been justly and equitably assessed upon him. I move the amendment.

Comment on this

I do not know whether it is the intention of the members of the House to turn this into a Committee Stage debate. If it is, I should like the Ceann Comhairle to give such members an opportunity of making their points before I close.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The House is not in Committee. Every Deputy may speak once of course.

Comment on this

I cannot understand the rather peculiar reasons that have been given for moving this amendment. Deputy McGilligan has advanced arguments in support of the amendment which he has moved which he himself admits are untenable and without foundation. He asks the House to accept the amendment for reasons which he thinks cannot be substantiated. Quite obviously, this is a concession given, as I pointed out in the Budget speech, to the general body of taxpayers, and as members of the Dáil do not enjoy any benefit or advantage which the general body of taxpayers do not have——

Comment on this

Some of them do.

Comment on this

—— I do not see why they should be excluded from this concession. I give the House the fullest assurance that there will be no interference by the Government with the discretion of the Revenue Commissioners in administering this section. I think that members of the Opposition must accept this, that we will not interfere any more than they did with the Revenue Commissioners in their administration of the Revenue law, and if that were not a sufficient assurance to the House that no undue pressure will be brought upon the Revenue Commissioners to give any concession under this section to which people are not properly entitled, I would remind them that all settlements made by the Revenue Commissioners under it will be subject to review and examination by the Comptroller and Auditor-General. If he notes any irregularity in the administration of this section, or considers any concession given by the Revenue Commissioners under it not to have been warranted, he will draw attention to that in his report, and the Public Accounts Committee will have an opportunity of considering that and of subsequently reporting to the House on it. Therefore, I think the section as it stands is fully safeguarded against abuse and that there is no justification for the amendment proposed by Deputy McGilligan.

Comment on this

Is the Minister satisfied that what he said about the Public Accounts Committee is borne out by the facts?

Comment on this

Yes.

Comment on this

I suggest that he consult the present Chairman of the Public Accounts Committee.

Comment on this
Mr. Hayes

Upon what?

Comment on this

What does the Deputy mean?

Comment on this
Mr. Hayes

I did not catch the point as to the present Chairman of the Public Accounts Committee. Will the Deputy repeat it?

Comment on this

The Minister said that if the Revenue Commissioners made any concession under this section the matter would be adverted to by the Comptroller and Auditor-General, would be discussed at the Public Accounts Committee and then subsequently discussed in this House, if thought desirable. I asked the Minister if he was satisfied that what he stated reproduced the actual practice in that matter. He said he was satisfied. I said I would esteem it a favour if he would consult the authority, and I suggested the Chairman of the Public Accounts Committee, to ascertain if that is the procedure of the Public Accounts Committee.

Comment on this

First of all, I should like to emphasise that I said "any unjustifiable concession."

Comment on this
Mr. Hayes

Any impropriety?

Comment on this

Any impropriety. As to the Chairman of the Public Accounts Committee, I am perfectly satisfied——

Comment on this

Any impropriety?

Comment on this

This is not a question of impropriety. This is a question of not giving a remission to members of the Oireachtas as such.

Comment on this

Because the Deputy stated an undue concession might be given.

Comment on this

No, that is not the argument, because it seemed wrong to have members voting for the imposition of taxation and getting a remission of taxation in a case where they should have paid already.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Amendments 18, 19 and 21 go together.

Comment on this

Deputy Sir James Craig asked me to say that he does not intend to move amendment 19.

Comment on this

Amendments 18 and 21 go together. They are on very much the same points as Deputy Sir James Craig's was on. I should like to have some explanation from the Minister as to why he is going outside the financial year on which the Budget generally acts.

Comment on this

As I explained in the Budget speech, it was originally my intention to approach this matter in another way. When some information of this kind reached the Associated Hospitals Sweepstakes Committee, or, at least, the members of the Executive Committee of that Committee, I received a deputation and discussed the matter with them and they expressed the view to me very strongly that the course which I proposed to take, was in their view undesirable, and they submitted to me an alternative proposition which after prolonged discussion I agreed to accept as the basis of the new tax provided that they would put the matter to me in writing. In consequence of that I received this letter, dated 9th May:

Dear Sir,

In view of the declaration by the Minister for Finance not to tax the gross receipts obtained from the Hospitals Sweepstakes, the Executive Committee of the General Committee of the participating hospitals hereby agrees to the ordinary income-tax being levied on the total amount allocated to the hospitals (i.e., 25 per cent. of the gross receipts as ascertained under the Act).

This is the paragraph which answers Deputy McGilligan's points:

The Committee further agrees that the income-tax should be levied on the amount received from the Grand National Sweepstake of 1932, notwithstanding anything to the contrary in the Finance Act of 1931.

The Committee pointed out that in their opinion a larger amount should be allocated to the voluntary hospitals and that 33? per cent. was too much for County Homes and Nursing Institutions.

The Minister on his part undertook to recommend an inquiry into the present allotment of 33? per cent. assigned to the County Homes.

Yours faithfully,

Powerscourt,

Chairman, Associated Hospitals Sweepstake Committee.

Comment on this

Is that all the Minister intends to read?

Comment on this

That is the whole of it.

Comment on this

That is all that happened? Surely not.

Comment on this

The Deputy asked me why I proposed to bring in the Grand National Sweepstake.

Comment on this

Yes, and, in answer, we got a letter read and the preliminaries to it are merely a statement of the Minister that he saw a Committee — just saw a Committee.

Comment on this

And I told them what I proposed to do.

Comment on this

Yes, the Minister told them what he proposed to get from them.

Comment on this

Yes.

Comment on this

I should like to point out to the Minister that the statement he made when introducing the Budget has been characterised by a professional person, who has described himself as a friend of his, as one of the most brazen utterances ever heard in Ireland since Hamar Green-wood left the country.

Comment on this

Did the Deputy inspire it?

Comment on this

That is what a doctor friend of the Minister said. It shows the casuistry which is employed. What does it all amount to? We have the Minister giving his own reason for going back to the Grand National, outside the financial year. It is almost tantamount to going up to a person and saying to him: "Pay me so much or I will blow out your brains," and he writes back saying: "I will pay you so much." It does not answer the question: Why are they paying? to say "They will pay." You have to get the previous threat.

Comment on this

Do not forget the threats to-night.

Comment on this

The what?

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

It has nothing to do with the matter before the House.

Comment on this

That remark would almost always apply, I suppose, to what Deputy Corry says. The Minister has not explained why he must get from the hospitals a certain amount of money which necessitates going beyond the financial year. He has not explained it now. He did explain it before. He is a purist in finance, but he is going to go outside the financial year. He is building up Budgets in the normal way, but yet he is going to rob the hospitals. He complained to-day of an amendment which would give a rebate to people outside the period in which they would be entitled to receive it, but he can turn round and do exactly the opposite when it comes to the turn of the State. The State, according to the Minister, can claim outside the financial year. I merely wanted to get the Minister on record again with this brazen statement of his so that his doctor friend can again comment on it and other people can, later on, comment upon his attitude. The robbing of the hospitals must be contrasted with the promised £2,000,000 remission in taxation.

Comment on this

I beg to move amendment 20:

In page 29, Section 49 (1), line 21, to delete the words "stamp duty" and substitute the words "Public Charitable Hospitals Tax."

This is an important item. The Minister, when he was introducing this whole business in his Budget speech, said:

I have had to consider many proposals in this regard. They were all rejected in favour of one which was submitted by the Emergency Committee of the Hospitals and which outshone all others in its attractive simplicity.

We can now judge for ourselves as to the frankness and accuracy of this statement:

They were all rejected in favour of one which was submitted by the Emergency Committee of the Hospitals and which outshone all others in its attractive simplicity.

Here is the proposal:

I propose to levy 25 per cent. on the hospitals' share of the proceeds of all sweepstakes drawn after the 1st March, 1932.

The phrase was "to levy 25 per cent. on the hospitals' share of the proceeds." A few days afterwards the Minister produced a table explanatory of the Budget. On the receipt side there appeared an item "Income tax on hospitals' receipts from sweepstakes." The letter signed by Lord Powerscourt stated that the Committee was now willing to have the ordinary income tax levied. Later on Deputy Sir James Craig raised the point as to whether this was income tax or not. He saw a new phrase creeping into a Financial Resolution about stamp duty. He was told the two things were very much the same. Later on I was told the Minister had not had the question of income tax discussed in relation to this matter at all.

As will be seen in col. 1603 of the Parliamentary Debates, Deputy Sir James Craig asked a question in regard to this matter of stamp duty and he got the statement that the two things, income tax and stamp duty, were absolutely the same; there was no difference there. "One and the same tax" was the Minister's statement. They may be both one and the same tax, but they are both equally wrong in their application to what is being done here. I want to put the matter right. I want to have this tax called what it really is, a Public Charitable Hospitals Tax. Hence it is that in page 29 I am moving to omit the words "stamp duty." In connection with this phrase that has been used, how will the stamp duty be leviable if there is no stamp struck or affixed? What is the necessity for the subterfuge about stamp duty when the Minister previously said it was to be a charge upon the proceeds? He said afterwards that stamp duty and income tax are exactly the same.

Comment on this

Will the Deputy kindly indicate where I said they were exactly the same?

Comment on this

I have given the quotation.

Comment on this

The real point there was, were there two taxes?

Comment on this

Before the Minister starts to explain I think he had better listen to what he said.

Comment on this

Read the whole thing.

Comment on this

I will read all that is relevant because there is a terrible amount of stuff.

Comment on this

The Deputy likes to read what suits him.

Comment on this

I only read things which the Minister says and which are foolish—and that is saying a lot. I will read the following debate which took place on 12th May:

Sir J. Craig:... In the paper handed to us this afternoon under the heading of Emergency Budget Receipts there is an item of Income Tax from Hospitals Receipts from Sweepstakes. I want to know is the Stamp Duty the same as the Income Tax.

Mr. MacEntee: Yes.

Apparently Deputy Sir James Craig was not satisfied with that. He obviously knew what the Minister's "yes" might mean and the debate goes on:

Sir J. Craig: There is no difference.

Mr. MacEntee: No difference. They are one and the same tax.

That is the Minister's statement—"They are one and the same tax."

Comment on this

I did not say "one and the same thing," which was what the Deputy stated.

Comment on this

If there is any point in that, let it be made. I will come down to what the Minister said —"They are one and the same tax." I say they are both equally wrong in their relation to this. This should be called what it actually is, a Public Charitable Hospitals Tax. Apparently the only reason the Minister will not put that in is because he does not want to have himself associated with a tax which has "Public Charitable Hospitals" attached to it. He should get that monument to his memory, and I suggest it should be called a Public Charitable Hospitals Tax because it is nothing else. Why should the Minister be ashamed of it? He is actually raiding the hospitals, and some Deputies of his Party have declared that that is a grand thing. Some of them are even of the opinion that there is going to be more good got out of this than the hospitals themselves could do. One Deputy, a supporter of the Minister's and of the Government's interests, said the hospitals did not spend any more money in work and did not give any more employment since they got the benefit of the Sweepstakes. The matter is not of terrific importance, but it is of some importance. The Minister himself did not know what the levy in proceeds meant as he said in the Budget speech when he described this tax as income tax or stamp tax. In the explanatory statement issued afterwards, Lord Powers-court is quoted as saying that he would be agreeable to the ordinary income tax, and then the Minister said that income tax and stamp duty were one and the same tax. Why should not the Minister call the thing what it is—a Public Charitable Hospitals Tax?

Comment on this

Deputy McGilligan is thinking of the Public Safety Act.

Comment on this

I suppose Deputy Corry knows what the words "Public Charitable" mean. Why should he show his annoyance at the phrase used by me when it is a correct phrase? Deputy Corry is a purist in the matter of the English language, and I am sure he had straight speaking to himself over and over and he knows what the calling of things by their proper names is.

Comment on this

Do not make us do that.

Comment on this

Calling Deputy Corry what he is would be outside the limits of the forbearance of the Chair. But to put the proper word on this tax it should be called a Tax on Public Charitable Hospitals. That is what it really is.

Comment on this

I want just to say one or two words. I was asked not to press my amendment and I consented with very great reluctance indeed not to press it. And now there is no use in my going into all the severe things that I intended to say and that I had hoped to say. I will say this, however, that the Minister for Finance's name will go down to posterity as being the first man who is responsible for placing a tax on charitable institutions. He cannot get away from that. I want just to say another word. I have here a sheet containing those pictures already referred to here and Deputy MacEntee only takes second place in this particular competition. Deputy Robert Briscoe is first. What I want to draw particular attention to in this sheet containing these photographs are these statements: "What the policy of Fianna Fáil is and what they are going to do." The last sentence is this: "It will make for the welfare of the sick, the poor and the aged," and one of the things they are going to do is to rob the hospitals of the sums of money that were going to be used for the care of the sick, the poor and the aged.

Comment on this

If the Minister is not prepared to accept the amendment would he alter the term of the tax and call it "Death Duty"?

Comment on this

The Minister, when speaking on the Budget, referred to a particular Deputy on these benches and said that he used a meeting of the Associated Hospitals for political propaganda against the Government Party. Has the Minister learned since then that he was misinformed?

Comment on this

If Deputy Myles Keogh thinks that anything I said was a reflection on him, I unreservedly withdraw it.

Comment on this
Division

Question put: "That the words proposed to be deleted"—stand.

Tá 72
·
Níl 56
Result Carried The question put was agreed to.

Do you agree with this result?

I move amendment 22:

In page 34, First Schedule, Ref. No. 15 (a), second column after the word "government" to insert the words "and league of nations."

Comment on this

I move amendment 23:

In page 35, First Schedule, Ref. No. 15, in the fifth column, to add a further provision as follows:—

"This duty shall not be charged or levied on any books which, in the opinion of the Revenue Commissioners, have before importation been substantially used or have before importation been in private ownership for a substantial period."

This amendment is intended to cover the point raised, I think, by Deputy Alton or Deputy Thrift as regards books other than new books.

Comment on this

And raised by me on an amendment. I think the Minister has covered the second-hand books very handsomely indeed.

Comment on this

I move amendment 24:

In page 35, First Schedule, Ref. No. 16, in the second column, after the word "tags" in paragraph (d) to insert in brackets the words "(other than labels and tags of woven materials)."

On the Committee Stage of the Bill, the Minister for Industry and Commerce promised that he would consider the advisability of excluding labels and tags of woven material from the scope of the duty. The use of labels and tags of this description is extremely limited. There is, consequently, very little possibility of having them produced here. The quantities imported are small and the cost of the concession will be very slight.

Comment on this

I want to raise a point on amendment 24, item 16, with regard to trade catalogues. I do not think that the position with regard to trade catalogues is sufficiently appreciated. If you impose a duty on catalogues imported in bulk you are going to place the wholesale traders in a very unfair position with regard to their rivals who do their business from across the water. In my opinion, all catalogues ought to be allowed in free or all catalogues ought to be subject to duty. I understand that the Minister is considering the matter and if he merely mentions that I shall be satisfied.

Comment on this

I am very sorry this matter was not brought earlier to the notice of the Minister for Industry and Commerce. At this late stage, I am afraid we have not very much time to consider the matter further. I do not know whether we could improvise an amendment which would exclude wall paper pattern books if imported in bulk.

Comment on this

There was an amendment down to the Finance Bill, so that I cannot be accused of not raising the matter at the earliest possible moment. My position is that I cannot see why one set of catalogues should be allowed in free and catalogues in bulk should be subject to duty. That is the attitude I take up.

Comment on this

If the Minister were disposed to meet the Deputy, I am sure he could arrange for a recommendation to be made to the Seanad.

Comment on this

Would not that mean re-summoning the Dáil to consider the recommendation?

Comment on this

Does the Minister mean to suggest that there will be no recommendations?

Comment on this

There nearly always are.

Comment on this

Deputy McGilligan could answer his own question better than I could.

Comment on this

Every year there have been recommendations.

Comment on this

If we have to come back, we will consider Deputy Dockrell's suggestion.

Comment on this

Might I ask the Minister to consider it from this point of view? There seems to be an anomaly, in this way, that a local wholesaler who would import his pattern books in bulk would have to pay the duty on them, whereas a wholesaler or factory, outside the Saorstát, can distribute pattern books singly to local people here, free of duty, which would give an advantage over the Saorstát trader. I have discussed this point with Deputy Dockrell and I have made inquiries since and I find that there are wholesale distributors of wall papers in the City of Dublin alone. I would ask the Minister to meet the situation one way or the other. These people are not asking to have the duty taken off or put on, but they are asking that they should be put at no disadvantage as compared with outsiders. I think that is the point that Deputy Dockrell has in mind.

Comment on this

That is my point.

Comment on this

I move amendment 25:—

In page 37, First Schedule, Ref. No. 18, in the fifth column, to add a paragraph as follows:—

"(v) vessels and boats which, in the opinion of the Revenue Commissioners, are primarily constructed and designed for propulsion by sails, or for propulsion by mechanical means, or for the carriage of goods, or are intended for use in the fishing industry or for the purpose of the lifeboat service."

This arises out of the suggestion, which, I think, was made by Deputy Good, that possibly ships might be described as "articles manufactured wholly or partly of wood." The duty, as originally drafted, was extremely wide in its scope, and the possibilities are, that, if you could get ships on to dry land, they might be liable to duty. The amendment now proposed on behalf of the Minister for Industry and Commerce, exempts all vessels, except rowing boats, not intended for use in the fishing industry or for the purpose of the lifeboat service, and I think it will fully meet the point which was made by Deputy Good.

Comment on this

I understand that it meets his view.

Comment on this

I would like to know if the Minister has been given any substantial reason why rowing boats should be excluded.

Comment on this

Make the case against it.

Comment on this

There are rowing clubs throughout Ireland, who buy racing gigs, for instance. The racing gig may be an ordinary tub outrigger boat or what is known as a fine boat, and neither of these is made in the country. They are usually imported from Oxford, from boat builders on the Isis or the Thames, where a large number of wherries come from. In the case of some of these boats, the prices run anything from £60 to £80, and with the tariff it will be very difficult for rowing clubs to get a decent fine "four" or a fine "eight," under say, £100 or £120. That is a very big consideration to numbers of University students, for instance, and to the young men who take part in this sport of rowing in this country. As a matter of fact, I could prove to the Minister's satisfaction that very few of these clubs are solvent, and they cannot afford to undertake the great expense that will be involved now in paying extra for their boats. If we had in this country boat builders who were building these racing gigs, I would certainly encourage this, but, when we are not building these things, I do not see why we should discourage the sport of rowing in the manner proposed by the Minister.

Comment on this

I wish to support Deputy Anthony. I think the matter of the money involved is very small, but it is a very serious item for these clubs. Rowing clubs in Ireland, as Deputy Anthony has said, are not in a very affluent position—the one I am acquainted with certainly, is in debt— and they can only be run by subscriptions from outsiders. I would press on the Minister that, as he is interfering with sport in other directions—

Comment on this

Be very careful of what you say, now.

Comment on this

—he might make this concession.

Comment on this

Thirty or fifty pounds is a very small thing to the Revenue, but it is a very big item for a University rowing club. I can assure the Minister that rowing clubs have to be financed in order to be got to work at all. There is another aspect of this. There are many rowing pleasure boats used in this country, which afford working men with their means of livelihood, and, so far as I know, they are not likely to be made here at all. Yet it is proposed to put a tax on them.

Comment on this

I support the views of the last speaker, but I should like to draw the Minister's attention also to the fact that rowing boats are necessary for the recreation of visitors in our various summer health resorts. The Minister will be striking a blow at the livelihood of a deserving section of the community, and I would ask him, in view of the very small amount of revenue he is likely to gain from this tax, to withdraw it.

Comment on this

I do not want to place the Minister in any false position. Rowing boats are made in this country and the very boats referred to by the last speaker are made in the City of Cork, Dublin, Baltimore and other places in West Cork. They are made in this country and very good ones are made here. Very good yachts are also made in this country, and if the Minister came down to my part of the country, I could show him a £10,000 yacht built, quite recently, in Baltimore. The boats to which I refer are not made in this country and I do not see any prospect of their being made here, for some years, at any rate.

Comment on this

This discussion has been a case of much ado about nothing. I am awfully sorry that Deputy Anthony, who was so concerned about racing requisites, did not take the trouble, before he assumed that racing boats would be taxed under this, to read item 18, because he would have seen there that articles for use in sport would be exempted, and that, therefore, racing boats are definitely not covered by the duty. As to the point raised by Deputy Brasier, in regard to ordinary rowing boats for pleasure purposes, I think that Deputy Anthony has given him what I consider to be a conclusive answer.

Comment on this

Can I get the Minister's assurance that the racing boats to which I referred—

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

This is the third speech that Deputy Anthony has made.

Comment on this

This is a question. Can I get an assurance that a racing boat, with a sliding seat, will be exempt, and that there will be no confusion at the ports?

Comment on this

They are covered, of course, by the ordinary duty on sporting goods of 10 per cent. but they are definitely exempt from the heavy duty of 33? per cent., and it is on Item 18 that the discussion took place.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

Is amendment 25 agreed?

Comment on this

Why should it be agreed?

Comment on this

I protest. I have given the House every opportunity of making points on this matter. We are on Report Stage and Deputy McGilligan had an opportunity of speaking before this.

Comment on this

And, under the agreement, he is still within his rights in moving, simpliciter, an amendment to the amendment before us.

Comment on this

He ought to have moved it before the discussion concluded.

Comment on this

I take no direction from the Minister as to what I ought to have done. The Chair alone rules me.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

Is the Deputy moving an amendment?

Comment on this

I was suggesting that I might be allowed to move one.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

I do not think that, at this stage, the Deputy is entitled to do so.

Comment on this

I move amendment 26:

In page 37, First Schedule, Ref. No. 18, in the fifth column, to add a paragraph as follows:—

"(v) sections for beehive use."

The Minister for Industry and Commerce announced during the Committee Stage of the Bill that he would exclude sections for bee-hive use and this amendment is designed to give effect to that.

Comment on this

I think it was at my instance that the Minister made the concession. I asked him if he would also exclude the component parts thereof, because I believe they are sometimes imported in shooks and they come under the timber tax.

Comment on this

I think it is covered by this because this says "sections for bee-hive use."

Comment on this

The sections are small square boxes. They sometimes come in shooks and they stick them together. They will come under the timber tax. Will that tax be remitted?

Comment on this

They are covered by this.

Comment on this

I should like to draw attention to a matter under No. 18. The Minister for Industry and Commerce gave an undertaking that printer's blocks would be exempt. He has carried out that undertaking so far as lead blocks are concerned, but they can be taxed under the heading of "wood"—blocks mounted on wood. I ask the Minister to insert printer's blocks and type. Wooden type would also come under it.

Comment on this

I am advised that printer's wooden blocks and wooden type would be exempted as tools under Item 8.

Comment on this

I move amendment 27:—

In page 39, First Schedule, Ref. No. 28, to insert in the fifth column the following provision:—

"This duty shall not be charged or levied on any articles or component parts of articles which, in the opinion of the Revenue Commissioners, are of a type designed and intended primarily for laboratory use."

This, I think, gives partial effect to amendment 183a put down by Deputy Thrift on the Committee Stage. It is not proposed to accept the amendment in the form originally proposed, that is to say, excluding photographic apparatus, etc., for use in any educational institution, as it is not clear that cameras and photographic apparatus of a normal type are in fact used in schools and colleges to any great extent. If they were so used, it is possible that they would be frequently availed of by private individuals for purposes other than those of an educational nature. The Minister for Industry and Commerce, however, is convinced that there is a case for exempting photographic apparatus of a specialised or laboratory type. It is proposed to accept the principle of the amendment, and this gives effect to it.

Comment on this

I am obliged. It goes a considerable way.

Comment on this

I move amendment 28:—

In page 40, First Schedule, Ref. No. 34, in the fifth column, after paragraph (n) to insert a paragraph as follows:—

(o) brass rules for printers' use.

I think Deputy O'Hanlon raised this matter on the Committee Stage. It refers to printers' brass rules.

Comment on this

I move amendment 29:—

In page 41, First Schedule, Ref. No. 36, in the second column, before the word "coir" to delete the word "and," and after the word "yarn" to insert the words "and plaited or cable-laid sash cords."

Comment on this

Will it be possible to secure that the cordage which forms part of fishermen's nets will be let in, as the nets are at present, free of duty?

Comment on this

I should like to ask the Minister to accede to that. In salmon fishing a special quality of cord is required which is not manufactured in this country. I think that the Minister will be administering a very serious set back to the industry if he does not agree to that. I am speaking from personal experience. We have to import cordage for that purpose.

Comment on this

It is rather unfortunate that these points were not raised earlier.

Comment on this

I raised the point about cordage when the Minister for Industry and Commerce was here.

Comment on this

Did he give any undertaking with regard to it?

Comment on this

He did not give any more specific undertaking than to say that the matter would be favourably considered. Cases have been reported to me. First, nets were held up. Then directions were given that nets were to be admitted and duty not collected on them as cordage. Then I was informed that nets were admitted, but that the cordage attached to the nets was assessed for duty.

Comment on this

If the cordage is attached to the nets it is free, because it forms part of the nets.

Comment on this

Then if such a case arises again I shall mention the matter to the Revenue Commissioners and they will deal with it.

Comment on this

I also raised this point about cordage in the case of salmon fishing, where they require the nets to be renewed every year and cordage has to be imported. It would be a serious blow to that industry, which is already suffering enough, and I appeal to the Minister to let the cordage in free. The special class of cordage is not manufactured in this country and the tax would be likely to hit them very hard.

Comment on this

I will consider that matter between now and the time the Bill gets to the Seanad. It is a new matter.

Comment on this

I move amendment 30:

In page 43, Second Schedule, fifth column, to add a further provision as follows:—

Where the Revenue Commissioners are satisfied that any article chargeable with this duty is imported for the use of a library which is not a proprietary library conducted mainly for profit, the Revenue Commissioners may, subject to compliance with such conditions as they may think fit to impose, permit such article to be imported without payment of this duty."

The Minister for Industry and Commerce agreed to accept this suggestion. It makes a similar proviso with reference to libraries in the Second Schedule that had been made already in the First Schedule. I think the Minister will admit it is necessary.

Comment on this

I am accepting the amendment.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

When will the Fifth Stage be taken?

Comment on this

It can be taken now.

Comment on this

By no means—tomorrow.

Comment on this

Why not now?

Comment on this

Because it was not so agreed.

Comment on this

I should like to draw the attention of the Minister to the fact that I discussed with the Minister for Industry and Commerce the advisability of letting in free of duty a commodity known as telegraphic slips. There is no mention of it here. I understood the Minister was to put down an amendment to that effect. I also discussed the matter with the President.

Comment on this

I am advised that we can let it in free.

Comment on this