In Committee on Finance. - Vote 52—Agriculture.
Contributions 1–128 of 240. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
I move:—
Go ndeontar suim bhreise ná faghaidh thar £400 chun íoctha an Mhuirir a thiocfaidh chun bheith iníoctha i rith na bliana dar críoch an 31 adh lá de Mhárta, 1933, chun Tuarastail agus Costaisí Oifig an Aire Talmhaíochta agus seirbhísí áirithe atá fé riara na hOifige sin, maraon le hIdeontaisí i gCabhair.
That a supplementary sum not exceeding £400 be granted to defray the charge which will come in course of payment during the year ending on the 31st day of March, 1933, for the Salaries and Expenses of the Office of the Minister for Agriculture and of certain services administered by that Office, including sundry Grants-in-Aid.
This Estimate has been circulated.
It arises out of the Dairy Produce Bill which has been passed. It is estimated that about £100,000 will be required to meet deficiencies in the Butter Fund that will arise up to about August next. After that, the receipts will begin to come in in sufficient quantities to meet the total outlay and the Fund will be balanced again about March. The Bill was discussed here at length and I do not think there is any necessity to allude to it in any detail.
Comment on this
Before proceeding with the discussion of this Estimate, it may be just as well to state, so that there will be no misunderstanding later, that this is a Supplementary Estimate, in which the actual sum asked for is £400 and the purpose for which the sum is required is the administration of the Dairy Produce Act, 1932. Normally, discussion should be confined to the object for which the money is required but, in view of present circumstances, a wider debate on the agricultural position seems inevitable. As the Vote on Account and the Central Fund Bill will, to-morrow, give two further opportunities for such debate, it seems, from the point of view of the Chair, to be desirable that there should be some arrangement as to the item on which that wider discussion should be taken and concluded. If that agreement is forthcoming and this Vote for Agriculture is the item selected, the Chair is agreeable, under the circumstances, to allow a debate wider than should normally take place on Supplementary Estimates. It is thought desirable that the Chair should make that statement, so that there would be no misunderstanding, later, as to what may be discussed.
Comment on this
I would like to know if the Chair has full information of all the circumstances. I understand that another measure will probably be introduced to-night or to-morrow, which has probably some relation to the subject matter that might be raised on this Vote.
Comment on this
In that case, is it proposed to confine the discussion on this Estimate definitely to the matters raised in it?
Comment on this
We have not got the information quite clearly yet as to what the position is. We understand that an Emergency Bill is being introduced, and, in so far as we have been able to understand it, without seeing the Bill, and merely from conversations, it would appear that consideration of that Bill would enable the widest discussion possible to take place on the present situation with regard to our whole agricultural industry, and the recent developments on the other side of the water, but as to when that discussion is going to take place, we are not quite clear. We have not sufficient information and I do not know whether the Minister himself could give us any information on it.
Comment on this
I have been in the House and I understood that conversations were going on as to what was going to be done.
Comment on this
There is no doubt about the Bill being introduced and there is no doubt, either, that the Bill will give an opportunity for very full discussion. In the meantime, the position with regard to the butter industry, in the widest way, is certainly relevant to this Estimate.
Comment on this
Might I ask, in order to get clear on your ruling, if it is agreed and you approve of the discussion on this Estimate going somewhat wider than the Estimate would normally warrant, the subject that will be given that wider discussion on this Estimate will not be allowed to be discussed to-morrow on the Appropriation Bill or the Vote on Account?
Comment on this
The Chair stated that it was desirable that one item should be selected, and that all the discussion should be concluded on that one item, so that it would not drag over several items.
Comment on this
So, if you do make a ruling on this matter, and, without referring to the new legislation, if we do discuss the wider matter on this Estimate, it will then be ruled by you, or by the Ceann Comhairle, to-morrow, that that matter cannot be further discussed on the Vote on Account or on the Appropriation Bill?
Comment on this
I suggest that, if you are going to discuss the wider question at all, it should be discussed either on this or on some other item. If you discuss, for instance, the new position as it affects butter on this, the same arguments will be used again to-morrow under other heads. It would be a wiser course to allow discussion on this to embrace the whole lot, or, alternatively to confine the discussion to the narrow point of the matter concerned, and have the other discussion to-morrow. Otherwise you will have two discussions somewhat similar.
Comment on this
I would suggest that your suggestion should be accepted, Sir—that if the discussion takes place on the wide basis, it will be allowed by the Chair, and no claim will be made on the Appropriation Bill for a discussion on the same subject. That will leave the question of the new Bill, on which the Chair, of course, would not be in a position to rule, completely out.
Comment on this
Before you answer that, Sir, I would like to ask, whether, if you do rule that, it will really be possible to keep out what is likely to be discussed on this measure from any measure in which we are dealing with finance?
Comment on this
The Chair thought it desirable that the broader topic should be discussed on one item, and, of course, the House understands that, unless there is agreement on it, the Chair cannot have a discussion on this Estimate in which the broader topic would be discussed. The Chair must confine the discussion to the particular subject for which the Estimate is asked, unless there is agreement to discuss the broader topic.
Comment on this
The only question which strikes me as being of importance in connection with this is that I understand that most of those Deputies representing agricultural constituencies, or being themselves agriculturists, would probably question whether three hours and twenty minutes is enough for the consideration of this very important subject. Normally, the Appropriation Bill and the final stage of the Finance Bill would be rather shortly debated in a day, having regard to the special circumstances of this Session. I would say, in that connection, that it is possible that the House might be more agreeable to allow the larger discussion on this Vote and the smaller discussion on the other two measures. But there is the further measure which I have indicated to you, and which, I believe, is in course of preparation.
Comment on this
I got in touch with the Opposition about an hour ago, and told them that there was a new measure to be introduced, and it was suggested then that there might be agreement— I am speaking subject to correction now— to take the remaining stage of the Finance Bill to-night, and to debate the broad question of these tariffs on this new measure. I was to get in touch with Deputy Hayes, but I have not been able to assure him yet that the Bill will be circulated to-morrow. There is still something remaining to be done with it before I could say, definitely, that it will be circulated. Up to the present, I have not been able to say definitely that we will have it, but I believe we will. If it would be possible to take the Finance Bill, I am almost certain that the Bill would be ready for circulation to-morrow.
Comment on this
Yes, now, and the Old Age Pensions Bill. I understand that there is not very much time to be taken on that. Then there is the Vote on Account. That has to be passed to-morrow, too, or maybe on Friday. There is the other Bill, the second Appropriation Bill, to be considered. The Central Fund Bill and the Vote on Account have to go through before the 15th.
Comment on this
I do not know whether it is in print at the moment, but I believe it is ready. The other Bill is ready, but a certain official has to see it before it can be printed. I understand it is practically ready. If we could get the remaining stages of the Finance Bill and the Old Age Pensions Bill, and postpone this debate, if you like, until to-morrow, I am almost certain it would be ready.
Comment on this
There are a variety of topics which certainly call for discussion before the House rises. There is the situation which concerns us as a result of what happened yesterday in England. Secondly, there is, apart from that, and a different question from that entirely, the position which faces this country through the delegation at Ottawa. It is an entirely different thing and must be discussed differently, I suggest. Thirdly, there is the matter which has been ventilated so much in the Press for the last few days and as to which an attempt was made to prevent publication. These three big matters must be discussed. I doubt if they can be discussed on any single measure—the Butter Resolution, the Finance Bill, or the Appropriation Bill. They have to have their own setting.
Comment on this
We can sit on Friday if necessary. There is no reason why we should not sit on Friday, or even next week, to discuss these matters.
Comment on this
There is no doubt that an agreement was made to give the Finance Bill, the Vote on Account, the Appropriation Bill, the Central Fund Bill, and all the finance business of that particular kind to-morrow. There is no desire to do anything which will prevent us from carrying out that agreement. The suggestion made from the Chair, which is a very familiar one to me, that if a big topic is going to be discussed it should be discussed on one item, is one with which I am in agreement. But with regard to the announced new Bill, it makes it difficult to make any suitable suggestion, and making suggestions across the floor of the House is not of very great value. Deputy McGilligan has indicated certain matters which must be discussed. What, for example, is the suggestion about the new Bill and when it should be passed? I do not know whether the Parliamentary Secretary has any suggestion to make as to when that must be passed into law.
Comment on this
If there is no agreement we will have to proceed to discuss the Estimate within the narrow limits within which Estimates are discussed.
Comment on this
I submit, with great respect, that that is not a very sound line. Obviously, a fairly long discussion is going to take place. I propose that we take that discussion now and see if it can be concluded to-night, and that the other part of that discussion take place on the new Bill when introduced.
Comment on this
Let us go on with the Estimate now, on the basis that we conclude to-night and say more or less what people desire to say, even in a general way, and make no claim on any of the financial measures for further the discussion on the Estimate to the your point, I think.
Comment on this
Deputy Hayes knows as well as I do that unless there is agreement I must confine the discussion on the Estimate to the items for which this money is provided.
Comment on this
I am advocating agreement on that basis, that this Estimate be now discussed and passed to-night, and that no claim be made on any financial measure now before us for any further discussion on that matter. Of course, the new Bill will alter the situation.
Comment on this
The Deputy said that no claim will be made on any financial measure now before us. Does that include the principal Finance Bill?
Comment on this
You propose to discuss the Supplementary Estimate for the Department of Agriculture to-night?
Comment on this
Am I to infer from that, that the Opposition would be prepared to give the Fifth Stage of the Finance Bill now without any prolonged discussion?
Comment on this
How can we do that? The Government are anxious to submit proposals to the House arising out of the action of the British Government in relation to our produce. Do I understand that the Opposition will give us all the day to-morrow to discuss that Bill, as well as the Finance Bill?
Comment on this
I understood Deputy Hayes to say that he was prepared to facilitate the Government to this extent, that he would make no further demands in regard to the Finance Bills before the House, that he wished to discuss the Supplementary Estimates and the new Bill which the Government propose to submit.
Comment on this
Perhaps the Minister did not hear the original point. The Chair does not desire that there should be a wide discussion on this Supplementary Estimate and a further wide discussion on the Appropriation Bill or on the Finance Bill of the situation with regard to the tariffs imposed by the British. The suggestion has been made that that point of view put forward by the Chair should be accepted by agreement; that if we could get a particular liberty on this Estimate to-night we will not make any claim on the financial business for discussion on this matter, and then, in the interval between this and 10.30 p.m. we will presumably have some information about the Bill and either come to an agreement about it, or come to no agreement. In any event, we will keep the agreement about giving the Finance Bill to-morrow.
Comment on this
Could not that arise more properly on the Bill that is proposed to be submitted to the House?
Comment on this
We can conclude the Fifth Stage of the Finance Bill now and the Fourth and Fifth Stages of the Old Age Pensions Bill, if that is more acceptable.
Comment on this
You mean the printing of the Bill? That is a mechanical difficulty. For that reason I suggest that we take the Old Age Pensions Bill, Fourth and Fifth Stages.
Comment on this
Is not the position with regard to the Old Age Pensions Bill this: that the Government have put their foot down and said, "We are going to have this Bill"? What is the use of talking any more about it?
Comment on this
The Minister's suggestion would mean holding over until to-morrow the Fifth Stage of the Finance Bill, the New Bill and this Estimate.
Comment on this
I do not know whether the House can do it without having the print of the Bill, as reported, before it, but it seems to me that, apart from the mechanical difficulty of not having the Bill printed, there is no practical difficulty in discussing the question "That the Bill do now pass", the House being already familiar with the amendments which have been made in the Bill on the Committee and Report Stages. Therefore, if the Opposition intend to discuss that question, they might take up the discussion to-night and leave to-morrow free for the new Bill, the Vote on Account and the Central Fund Bill.
Comment on this
I suggest that the Vote be discussed in its wider aspect to-night. I do not expect that all the Deputies who wish to take part in the discussion will be able to do it to-night. Time might be found to-morrow, on the other Bill which is being introduced, to permit those Deputies who cannot speak to-night to address themselves to the subject.
Comment on this
Are Deputies prepared to allot a definite time for its consideration, and also for the new Bill, the Vote on Account and the Central Fund Bill?
Comment on this
It would be impossible to come to an understanding by discussing the matter across the House like this. The Minister need not worry about the Finance Bill. He will get it through to-morrow together with the Vote on Account and the other business.
Comment on this
Could we suggest, even provisionally, a period for the discussion of the three matters?
Comment on this
Let us have a discussion outside as to what we will do to-morrow.
Comment on this
Nothing of this sort was ever settled in the House.
Comment on this
The Minister is well aware that nobody was ever treated with such leniency as he has been. Nobody was ever treated like him before.
Comment on this
The Minister should be praying for Cumann na nGaedheal every night before he goes to bed.
Comment on this
When the Butter Bounty Bill was introduced some time ago the Minister gave an elaborate statement regarding its importance to the dairying industry, which, he said, was our basic industry. At that time the situation which confronted those engaged in the industry was that they were in a favourable position in the main market outside this country with regard to the marketing of their produce. We had the advantage over non-Commonwealth countries of a 10 per cent. tariff, which those non-Commonwealth countries had to bear. The basis of the Minister's recommendations was that the Butter Bounty Bill, which had relation to all butter manufactured in this country, in creameries and other places, was necessary by reason of the economic condition of the dairying industry at the time.
We are faced to-day with an entirely different situation. We are in the position of being 20 per cent. worse off than Australia and New Zealand, which are our principal Commonwealth competitors in the British market, and we are in a 10 per cent. worse position than our very powerful competitor, Denmark. That is the result of the new duties which the British Government have recently imposed. The position with regard to the whole agricultural industry is very, very serious. Properly speaking, those engaged in the industry are subject now to liability for Land Commission annuities in two countries; each of them is levying or collecting—whatever one wishes to term it. This produces a very complex situation. The industry cannot possibly bear this impost of 20 per cent. on its goods going into the British market. It is entirely unequal to that burden and no possible arrangement that I can think of could be introduced to remedy the terrible effects of that imposition on agricultural produce in our principal market.
There are complexities outside the immediate imposition which will be apparent to any observer. There are, let us say, three different payers of Land Commission annuities in the country. There is A who has paid, B who has paid all except the last gale and C who owes, perhaps, two or three gales. There is the further complexity that A may possibly have cattle to sell which will be subject to this imposition of 20 per cent. Then there is B who will probably have cattle for sale in a couple of weeks' time, and C who was fortunate enough to have disposed of them before this tax was put on. I can see no possible means of equating or compensating or doing anything to prevent the various anomalies that are bound to arise out of the situation with which we are confronted.
It is a situation which is truly appalling, having regard to the general condition of agriculture all over the world. The Minister for Agriculture, when talking on this subject some months ago, mentioned that we had some equation in respect of the Imperial preference which we were receiving. That has now gone. If the case then put up had substance in it, if this were a basic industry and if this industry required a tax to be placed on our own consumers in order that an extra price might be got for our sales abroad, then how much more serious is it now when we are confronted with this new imposition in our principal market? It is a matter on which I find the greatest possible pain in addressing the House. It is a situation in which I never expected to see this country placed. It is a serious situation which affects, not alone the agricultural industry, but practically every business that there is in the country. It requires careful consideration to see how far it will be possible to alleviate any of the terrible sufferings that are bound to ensue from the position in which we are now placed.
I suppose it would be out of order to consider even for a moment the Bill that is to be introduced to-morrow. These disputes between nations are very much the same as disputes between employers and employees. Disputes between nations which deal with one another and disputes between employers and employees are disputes which affect what gives both a living and they are not in the best interests of either of the parties. Their solution in the course of a fight limits, interferes with, impedes the progress of those engaged in them. In these days when one hears so much about following Christian principles, some principles ought to be adopted which will solve problems rather than intensify them. The people of this country are not in a position, nor are the people in the neighbouring country in a position, to undertake an economic war one upon the other. It is because of those considerations that I move, so that the matter may be discussed, that this Vote be referred back for reconsideration.
Comment on this
I want to second that proposal. I want to give in some more detail the points at which Deputy Cosgrave merely glanced when he was dealing with this particular Estimate and his proposal in regard to it. It is well at this moment to recall the statements made by the Minister for Agriculture when he was introducing his scheme for the stabilisation of the price of butter and when he was replying to criticisms, and I will quote certain comments in order to show how peculiar, in the light of present circumstances, was the statement made by the Minister for Defence, who thought well to intervene in that critical debate. The Minister for Agriculture in introducing the Estimate in Committee on Finance relating to the butter tariff pointed out that: "It has been the experience of this country for the last seven or eight years that the price of Free State butter on the British market has been invariably lower than the price paid for Danish butter. Some years the difference has reached as much as 21/- or 22/- per cwt., and even in the most favourable year the difference was 13/- per cwt., so that we may take it the Free State butter this year will not at its best reach the price of Danish butter. Danish butter is now quoted on the British market at 116/-. That is after duty has been paid and after freight has been paid." Note the premises. Then he goes on: "If we take it that the Imperial preference that may be given to our butter is equated by the consumers' preference for Danish butter, we cannot, if we had butter to export at the present time expect to get more than 115/- or 116/- per cwt. for it." The Minister for Agriculture proposed that the consumers' preference was to be equated by the Imperial preference which he assumed was to be given to us.
Later on in that speech the Minister for Agriculture indicated the necessity for the Resolution when he said: "We must remember that dairying is the basic industry in agriculture, that we get not only our butter and milk supplies through it, but also the cattle that are reared in this country. To a great extent pigs and poultry depend on the success of the dairying industry. If these are all taken together—butter, milk, cattle, pigs and poultry—they must form more than one-half of the total production both agricultural and industrial of this country." And then there was this sapient observation:—"While we are endeavouring to get new industries going, we should be careful to protect the industries we have." The success of the dairying industry, according to the figures of the census production amount to more than one-half of what was produced in the country both agricultural and industrial. And the Minister made the point that the success of the dairying industry depended upon the measure he was introducing so as to secure a certain price for that butter.
He said immediately after that:—"The position at present is, taking the creameries first, that they export half the butter they produce and the other half is consumed at home." And then this statement followed and it is very relevant at the present moment:—"We cannot get any more for the half we export as we must take the best price we can get in competition with the rest of the world." And that is in the British market. Then he went on to say:—"The only alternative left us is to turn to the other half which is consumed at home and to ask the home consumer to pay more." I want to relate those remarks: that the dairying industry is to this country more than half of the entire production of the country agricultural and industrial; that on the success of his Butter Price Stabilisation Proposal depended the success of the dairying industry and through that depended the success of half of our production, agricultural and industrial.
We have unfortunately to face the position that the British consumer on whom we had to rely preferred Danish butter. But we hoped that Imperial preference would continue and so we equated the consumer's preference for Danish over Irish butter. We were told that we could not increase the price in the outside market because there we were in competition with the rest of the world. Therefore, we had to increase it to the home consumer. I spoke later and asked what was going to happen if our butter should lose the preferential position under the Imperial preference and there was a remark later by the Minister for Defence about the imperial tang and he thought that that was a sufficient answer. The Minister for Defence referring to the question I had asked as to what should happen if we lost the ten per cent. preference said:—"He (Deputy McGilligan) asked what would happen us if we lost the ten per cent., if England ceased to love us. Then she might get to love us as much as she loves Denmark and import from us from 30 to 40 per cent. instead of from some other country."
That is a prediction that has not been verified. Later on the Minister for Agriculture had to make a more reasoned statement than that. He said that two Deputies were very much concerned that we should lose the ten per cent. preference and he added:—"I do not know why that question should be raised now." A Deputy in an interruption asked "Why not?" And the Minister then said:—"We had not anticipated that this ten per cent. would be lost. If and when it is lost it will be time enough to face the question." That is the question we have to face now and we have to face it under the circumstances described by the Minister for Agriculture. On the price of butter depends the dairying industry which is more than half the entire production of this country. We cannot increase the price of butter abroad. We have got to have relation between the price of the exported butter and we have to put a levy on the people who eat our own butter at home in order to keep up the price in the British market. That was the position when there was a ten per cent. preference in favour of our butter. But now instead of a ten per cent. in our favour there has been a ten per cent. preference against us. We have gone back 20 per cent. That is why I ask that the Vote should be referred back for reconsideration.
What is the opinion of the Government as to the amount of the levy that will have to be met by those who buy the butter for consumption at home if we are to keep the British market against the Danish competition now fortified by a preference in her favour? When we were making a levy of something between a quarter of a million and a million when we wanted our butter sold against a Danish competitor who suffered a ten per cent. disadvantage what levy will now be required when the Danish butter has ten per cent. in its favour against us? That is a question that will have to be answered. What will the new levy be? Or are we going to go on selling butter in the British market at all? If so what is to happen to the 350,000 cwts. of exportable butter which the Minister had to sell somewhere? And it must be remembered this is only one item of the big number of items that will be subject to the additional duties imposed in England yesterday. We have got to keep dairying going. We have got, therefore, to assist the producers and sellers of butter. We can only sell in England. We cannot increase the price that we are asking over there. We want stabilisation and a certain price. What is the new change to be put upon the consumer at home, or are we going out of the butter business? That is a situation that has got to be faced on this item alone, though it is an important item in the Minister for Agriculture's own phrasing. The reactions of this are going to spread in other directions. On this item so much depends, and if it were only on this that the 20 per cent. were put on, we certainly at this moment would be in a bad way.
The Government all along told us in varying tones that there would be no attempt to discriminate against us by taxation. We were told that that could not be done because England only bought from us what she could not buy elsewhere; that we could call the bluff. The Minister for Agriculture was asked in the debate from which I am quoting, what percentage of the total imports into England of butter did she import from the Free State and he admitted that it was something less than seven per cent. Yet despite that we were told that in this special item of butter there could be no possible discrimination against us because it was going to damage the English consumer more than the Irish consumer. But whatever was to happen we received the assurance that the Irish producer was not going to suffer and the Government would insist on that.
Therefore, there must be a plan. We were promised a plan about unemployment; we had a scheme about reducing taxation. The bluff of both of these has been called. Could we have some indication early of what has been done to save butter producers in this country from the injury that looks likely to be done by what happened yesterday, and from the injury which looks to be inevitable, if we are to believe what the Minister for Agriculture said when introducing the Financial Resolution which gave him power to impose a levy for certain purposes? If the people of this country are given satisfaction on one item, they will probably be spurred to greater effort with regard to the other items dealt with by the people on the other side. But, if they can get no indication that there was a plan to meet such contingency—a contingency that could easily be foreseen —then they will know where they are, and they can only be in despair. It is necessary to have this discussion as an urgent matter to-night, and it would be fitting that the President should intervene at the earliest possible moment, to see how apprehended injury is going to be avoided to the butter industry alone, so that we can get either confidence or lose hope from whatever indication he gives as to how he proposes to meet what is ahead. That is why I think it is important to have this segregated in its own setting, and not discussed with what might happen, or fails to happen, at Ottawa, or that may happen as a result of the impositions in the Finance Bill, and how the whole finances of the country may be affected by the Finance Bill. As the Minister for Agriculture stated, this is the biggest item in our production, and it is threatened with destruction by what has happened. People will anxiously wait to know how the destruction is going to be averted or the injury minimised.
Comment on this
It is surprising the turn this debate has taken. I am not surprised that Deputy Cosgrave was anxious that the debate should not be confined to the terms that would in the ordinary way take place on this Estimate. Cumann na nGaedheal Deputies want to have their innings to-night. The last Deputy announced that very forcibly, and told us that the contingency that has arisen with England was easily foreseen for a long time. I thoroughly agree with him in that. Anyone who followed the attitude and the actions of those on the front benches opposite, for the past 3, 4, 5 or 6 weeks could easily foresee that such a contingency would arise. We could easily foresee that they were preparing the ground, and that they were interested in nothing else but preparing the ground for such a contingency as has been created by the British. We easily foresaw the attitude of the men who now speak with great concern for the butter industry, the dairying industry and the cattle trade. We foresaw that their concern for these industries was to give the British hints how to destroy them. The contingency that has now arisen was easily foreseen. It was suggested in the tone of the Deputies' speeches and is contained in the regulations that the British have introduced.
A few meetings were held in my county recently, secret meetings— which were attended by Cumann na nGaedheal Deputies. I got a complete report of a few things that happened. The whole discussions at these meetings, which were held within the past two months, centred round statements made by these Deputies that this contingency was bound to arise, and that there was no doubt that England was going to take up this attitude. The attitude at these meetings was: "We will avail of this opportunity to down the Government. We will keep silent in public, as much as we can, but, at the first available opportunity we will step in and divide the forces here. Instead of following the British attitude, and being united in this crisis, we will divide the people as they were never divided before. We will break the Government and, at the same time, break the Irish case." That was the attitude taken by Cumann na nGaedheal Deputies at these secret meetings. The only interest in the butter industry, and in the farming industry, was to allow this contingency to arise, to allow British Ministers to see that there was division here, and that they could be strong in demanding their pound of flesh. The Cumann na nGaedheal Party and Deputy Cosgrave's proposal to refer this Estimate back for reconsideration was made on account of this contingency.
If the Deputy was as anxious about the industries as his Party pretends, was he not informed that a measure would be introduced by the Government to-morrow—possibly a measure to undo the wrongs that may be done by the British measure; possibly a measure to recoup Irish farmers; possibly a measure to meet losses sustained in the dairying industry? If the Deputy was in earnest, and was not interested in propaganda, as he is, but was interested in these industries, would he not have said that the decent thing was to let the Estimate go through and not to confine it to the ordinary terms? Instead of doing that he comes here and decides "to go" for the Government. Was not the other one the decent attitude for Deputy Cosgrave to take? Could he not have his innings to-morrow? Is it to his interest—and he was followed by Deputy McGilligan—to have scare headlines about, so as to stampede the State and the people? He took the opportunity of having his innings to-night, at a moment when there should be only one voice in this country when, if discussions are to take place—as inevitably they must—the Irish people would be, at least, as united as the English people are in their own interests? That is not the interest Cumann na nGaedheal has. There has been criticism by Deputy McGilligan of the Bill dealing with a bounty on butter that was introduced. What was the criticism from the Cumann na nGaedheal Benches when that Bill was introduced? The ex-Minister for Agriculture, Deputy Hogan, very conveniently remained away from the House when that Bill was introduced.
Comment on this
On a point of explanation, I may as well correct the Deputy's statement straight away. I made a considerably long speech on the Second Reading of that Bill and made my attitude quite clear.
Comment on this
Every part of the Bill went through without a division, and without an opposing vote against any section from the opposite benches.
Comment on this
One cannot take anything Deputy Bennett says as being for or against. The Bill went through without a single vote against it.
Comment on this
What happened was that the majority of the Cumann na nGaedheal Deputies interested in farming, the majority who know something about the butter industry, voted solidly for the measure and praised the measure in all its aspects. Now, however, when you have a different state of affairs existing and when you have this panicky legislation by the British coming along, you have Deputy McGilligan pointing out what he should have pointed out then if he was the great statesman he pretends he is to-night.
Another thing happened this morning in the Lobby of this House which will give an impression of the type of mind behind the discussion started here to-night for propaganda purposes. Two Cumann na nGaedheal Deputies— and I will say that the type of mind represented by these Deputies is in the minority on the opposite side, because I know there are some of them on the opposite side who are taking the national view of this matter—but two, anyhow—the exceptions, if you like; there are a few, including practically every member of the Front Bench—two of them met in the Lobby here to-day. One of them said: "Did you see the news in to-day's paper about the 20 per cent. against Irish produce in England?""Isn't it great!" said the other; "now we have them." And the two of them were quite jubilant about the great news that the British were going to destroy the agricultural industry here. That was their attitude. I admit that it is not the attitude of quite a number of the Cumann na nGaedheal Deputies, but it is a rotten attitude and an anti-national attitude, and it is the attitude for which the British are looking here, and it is an attitude which will defeat the Irish people if it is allowed to go on. I say that instead of attacking they should strengthen the hands of the Government and not allow any of their members to go out and make scare speeches and defeat the people. They should realise that the fate of the people is more or less at stake.
Comment on this
And I will not make it after the fashion of the Cumann na nGaedheal Deputies, who can make any amount of insinuations and get away with it. What I wanted to say——
Comment on this
——about this Estimate before us, was this, that as to the attitude of mind displayed by these members it shows that there is a determined attempt, at least by the Front Bench—and I believe it is not approved by many members of Cumann na nGaedheal—before action is taken by the Government to try to create a scare amongst our people while this crisis is on. We all know what Deputy McGilligan has emphasised again and again—that there is a ten per cent. tariff against us in the British market. He need not emphasise that. We are painfully aware of it, but our interest in facing up to this crisis is that the Irish people should win out in this question, that they should not be defeated or thwarted by having disheartened views on this matter. The people who are interested in this industry, the dairy farmers, know very well that a united voice is the best weapon they could have and that the united voice of the whole people behind the Government in this matter is the proper attitude. They know that the scare scheme organised by the Front Bench of the Opposition is organised with a view, not to refer the Estimate back for discussion, but to try, before the Government introduces measures, to give the people of this country a down-and-out feeling, to drive them into despair instead of rallying them as they would rally and as they are prepared to be rallied to stand in defence of their own interests.
Comment on this
Deputy Cleary referred to speeches made in this discussion as being out of order. An agreement was made that a wide latitude should be given for discussion on this Vote, and the speeches so far have consequently been quite in order.
Comment on this
I would like to explain, Sir, that what I said was speeches which in the ordinary course of events would be out of order.
Comment on this
May I intervene for one moment? In view of what Deputy Cleary has said about taking a national attitude, I suggest that he is wholly misinformed in saying that the British people are united on this subject. How he can say that after reading the daily papers I cannot understand, because I am glad to say that a large section of the English people feel as I do on this question that an economic war is a disaster and an unnecessary disaster. I would suggest that we should rally to prevent this economic war and that we should drive the two Governments into arbitration. Goodness knows, it ought to be possible to have arbitration. Why should we break our necks about the principle of having a tribunal composed either inside or outside the Commonwealth? Let us have, if necessary, an Anglo-Irish tribunal and let us make sure that it is not feasible to have such a tribunal before we ruin the country.
Comment on this
I want to draw your attention, Sir, to a statement made by Deputy Cleary just at this stage before it becomes stale. He stated that he overheard two Deputies conversing in the Lobby and that one of them said to the other, "Did you hear about the 20 per cent. tax against Irish produce in England—isn't it great?" and so on. He made that statement here in the House and in view of the fact that he thought it necessary to make such a statement and in view of its seriousness, I think he should name the Deputies.
Comment on this
I am aware of that, Sir. I am putting it through you to him in view of the seriousness of the statement.
Comment on this
I asked the Deputy to name them and since he refuses to give the names, I say now that I do not believe him and that it is a scandalous statement to make and one that should not be made.
Comment on this
We cannot at this stage go back to what was said last week on a very different motion.
Comment on this
Deputy Cleary made other statements contrary to the fact. He said that, in the passage of the Butter Bill through this House, Cumann na nGaedheal members on this side acquiesced in the Bill, or let it pass through without discussion. If he was in the House during the passage of that Bill he must have known that the statement is contrary to the fact. I do not suppose that the farming members on this side of the House ever spoke as much on any one measure as on that particular Bill. And if the Bill emerged from the House in the condition in which it did emerge it was not the fault of the members on this side of the House. Attempt after attempt was made to amend the Bill in its various sections and while the principle of the Bill may have been all right, we all felt it might be improved. Deputy Cleary went out of his way to make that false statement. He said to-night: "We are getting our innings." We were appealed to by various members on the Government Benches, and by people outside, to give the Government a chance. Those who represent country constituencies have given the Government a chance. The Deputy opposite may laugh but this is no laughing matter. There are no laughing farmers in the country to-night. We were asked to give the Government a chance, and we gave them that chance. They have only to refer to the daily editions of the newspapers to see what speeches were made down the country. I can speak for my own, and neighbouring counties, as to the number of speeches we made in opposition to the present Government in the last three months. They might very well be contrasted with the speeches the Government Party made when they were in opposition with regard to the then Government. We have not hindered the Government. There has been no Government in the past ten years less hindered than the present Government was. Deputy Cleary says that they were hindered but we know that they were not.
We are at the moment considering a supplementary estimate for £100,000 on the Butter Bill. The Butter Bill, in its original form, was, as some of us expressed it, and as I now repeat, possibly of very little use to the farmer. I said that when I spoke upon the Bill originally, and I repeat it now. I said that the benefits the farmers could get out of the Bill would be very small and would be less than half what the Minister for Agriculture said they would be. In the light of the events of the last twenty-four hours, with a certainty of an imposition of 20 per cent. tariff on butter, and all other agricultural produce, it is apparent, to the most childlike farmer, that the Butter Bill is now useless and is scarcely worth considering.
None of us knows what proposals the President intends to make to the House to-morrow, or to-night, to relieve the situation. Thousands of farmers who are badly hit are looking to some one for assistance and guidance, and crying out: "Is there any balm in Gilead?" and it is for the President to answer "Never more" or some time. The President does not answer. Before this debate goes much further, and before this motion can be carried, we are entitled to look for some line of policy, for some announcement from the leader of the Government. Rightly or wrongly, it looks as if we were to be engaged in an economic war. Deputy Cleary said in his speech that some of us anticipated evil from some proposal brought forward in the House in the last three months. Perhaps we did. I was one who did, and perhaps forecasted what the results would be.
Comment on this
In the last five years, and what we said in the last five years has been justified. We never said the Government had a very easy task; none of us said that. We recognise that the Government has a difficult task, but the late Government had, especially in its later stages, a very difficult task. It has never been admitted, in any period in the existence of the Party opposite, that there was depression, until they came into power. They denied it while we preached it from every platform in the country. Deputy Corry laughs. Deputy Corry would laugh if the farmers were going to the guillotine.
Comment on this
Any Deputy who laughs to-night at the plight of the farmers, the less said about him the better. I think we should have an intimation of the line of policy that is to be pursued to repair the damage done to the farmer, and to put some hope into his heart, so that he can look forward to something, and can have some hope of finding a way out of the morass into which he has been led by the Party opposite. We are looking to the President to give us some line of policy that can be adopted for the better guidance of the House. Until something like that occurs it is useless to be considering this Estimate. I agree with the proposal of Deputy Cosgrave to refer this Vote back because, in its present form and in the light of the conditions prevailing in the last twenty-four hours, this bounty and this Supplementary Estimate are useless.
Comment on this
When Deputy Cosgrave moved that this Estimate be referred back I, for one, expected something of that kind. We heard all about the reasons why Deputy MacDermot was anxious to approach the two Governments. We never looked for war. We did not look for this. This is the result of an action taken by the British Government when the money in dispute is being held in a suspense account and both parties have agreed to arbitration. England has agreed to arbitration. She says: "All right, arbitrate and anything you like, but I am fit to judge." We know all about that. We were not frightened by the big stick before, and the farmers of this country are not frightened by the big stick. Deputy Bennett said that I laughed at the trouble the farmers were in. I never did. I am a farmer myself and have done more to help the farmers, inside and outside this House, than any Deputy on the benches opposite.