We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

In Committee on Finance. - Vote 52—Agriculture.

Contributions 129–240 of 240. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

You would want to go back twenty years.

Comment on this

I saw Deputy Bennett go into the Lobby in favour of every Bill that was brought in here by the late Government. What did they deal with? First, they secured that the landlords should get the landlord's interest; secondly, that he should get the tenant's interest out of the place; and thirdly, compensation for disturbance.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Deputy is not in order in reviewing the legislation of the past five years.

Comment on this

I am endeavouring to answer a few charges made by Deputy Bennett, which undoubtedly are tending at the present moment and have tended to put the farmers into such a state of depression that they are very badly able to meet their liabilities. The farmers know that every year out of their sweat and out of the sweat of their unfortunate children so much loot has to be handed over under Acts of Parliament brought in here by the Opposition when they were in power—so much loot handed over to landlords to be spent in Monte Carlo or elsewhere. We all know very well that these unfortunate farmers are put in a practically impossible position to face the present situation or any other situation. How has the present situation arisen? These people over there went to England and made secret agreements, or agreements that were never brought before the Dáil for ratification. Under these agreements this money has been handed over year after year, money provided out of the sweat and the blood of the unfortunate farmers. These were agreements that they did not dare bring before the representatives of the people for ratification, agreements that were found in the pigeon holes of the Department out of which they were kicked. Their existence was not known of until they were found in the pigeon holes of the Departments out of which these gentlemen were kicked.

We are now trying to face up to that position, trying to retrieve the money that has been robbed, I cannot call it anything else, out of the pocket of the unfortunate farmer and we have an attempt made to stampede the people of the country. We had inquiries here for the last fortnight from Deputy McGilligan and others —information on this and information on that. What information was given to the people of the country when that secret agreement was signed in 1923 handing over the annuities? When was that agreement placed before the people of the country? When did the people learn about the agreement? They learned about it when it was found in the pigeon holes of the Department, when the late Executive Council moved out. They left this legacy after them. It is on that secret agreement that Thomas is basing his claim to the annuities, an agreement never brought for ratification before the Dáil. I can assure Deputies opposite that they have not succeeded in stampeding the people as they succeeded in stampeding the people into accepting the Treaty in 1921. They are not going to succeed now. We hear any amount of talk about this imposition, this tariff and that tariff. The people of this country are well able to stand up to any big stick that will be used. I saw creameries burned down and closed in 1919, 1920 and 1921.

Comment on this

Tipperary.

Comment on this

And the people existed, carried on and recovered. England did not succeed, nor did the Tans succeed in stampeding the people. They will not succeed this time in stampeding the people. If England chooses to put on a tariff on our agricultural produce going into that country, it is not going to be an unmixed evil, not by any manner of means. If it changes the farmers of this country or the whole people of the country from being totally dependent on Britain for their economic existence, it will be a good day's work. If it teaches the people of this country that, that they are not going to place their whole reliance on a country that has kept them for the last 700 or 800 years as the hewers of wood and the drawers of water, keeping a kitchen garden for the British people—if it changes that policy, it will not be an unmixed evil. The Executive Council will meet that position as it should be met. We have decided that we are not going to hand over the money, the money dragged out of the sweat and the labour of the underpaid labourers and the farmers' sons and daughters. If we have decided that that money is not going to be handed over any longer to Britain, well, then, a good day's work has been done.

This matter has been offered for arbitration to any fair court, but what was the result of that offer? "You can arbitrate; we will send over another Feetham. You can arbitrate and we will pick the judge." I remember reading a statement made on one occasion by Deputy Blythe when he told us that the sentence which was to be imposed upon him by a certain judge was decided upon a fortnight before he was brought before the judge for sentence. I suppose this matter has been already decided. If we had fallen into the trap and agreed to let John Bull appoint a judge he would decide the case, but, thank God, we have an Executive Council in office now who are men enough to stand up to it, who are not going to adopt the policy of saying that England is a big country. We are no longer going to crawl. I am very glad that the day has come when the people of this country elected an Executive Council and a Government that will not crawl. We are sick of all this thing. I am not at all surprised, I actually expected, that this would be the first move, and I had every right to expect it. It would be disgraceful of Thomas to let down his advisers. It would be a disgraceful act on his part if he did not take the advice so freely tendered to him during the last twelve months by those on the Front Benches of the Opposition. It would be a shabby thing if he did not at least try the bluff that they advised him to try. Every single speech that came from that Front Bench on the annuity question was: "Oh, John Bull will put on a tariff on cattle." Surely to goodness it would be a mean and shabby thing for John Bull if he had not taken the advice.

I can assure the House that that bluff will be called. I have the utmost confidence that the Executive Council will meet the case. I must say that I did not expect much from the Front Bench opposite. They have gone too far to be brought back, but I did expect something from the few bright spots Deputy Kiersey alluded to some time ago when I challenged the Opposion that they did not give us any help in relieving unemployment. Deputy Kiersey then told us: "A few of us did. A few of us went into the Lobby with the Government on the Butter Bill. A few helped to relieve unemployment, a few of us were anxious to assist the Government." Is there any one of these bright spots left to-night? If so, I hope that they will be a little vocal. I hope that when this Vote comes up for decision they will take the national side and the Irish side, for there are only two sides in this fight to-day—those who are for Ireland and those who are against her. We hear a lot of talk about the British market. I challenge any single farmer listening to me to say that he can produce cattle for the price he was getting in the market for the last five or six months or even for the past twelve months for that matter. The bad prices paid during the last three or four months in particular are being definitely used by the scaremongers of Cumann na nGaedheal down the country. "That is a de Valera fair," they say, "look at the prices." Compare the prices here during the last three months with the prices the Ulster farmers got. Our prices compare very favourably with the price that the Ulster farmers got. When we come to consider the position now, the first thing we have got to realise is that the farmers could not continue to hand over the annuities each year to Britain and produce the cattle for the price Britain was prepared to pay. I, for one, would as soon go down, straight off the reel, as be starved to death by slow degrees. That is what was happening the farmers during the last three years of Cumann na nGaedheal rule. Each year you had bigger difficulty in collecting the rates and in getting in the annuities, because each year the farmers are getting poorer and poorer. This total dependence on the English market had to end somewhere, sometime. Difficult and all as the situation may be, I, for one, am glad the crisis has come and that it will be ended once and for all. I am glad that we have at the helm a man who steered us through difficult positions before when there was a crisis in this country. When the might of England was being used before, we had Eamon de Valera chosen by the people to lead them in that fight. I am glad he is in the position to-day to see that fight to a successful conclusion. If England wants to fight, then England can have a fight. So far as this tariff is concerned, I challenge Farmer Deputies opposite to say that they can produce a fat lamb at £1 or at 15/- or 16/- and pay annuities and rates. Let us have this thing out.

Comment on this
A Deputy

What was the price this time twelvemonths?

Comment on this

You know nothing about it anyway. What was the price of frozen New Zealand mutton? That is the position we are faced with. The Irish farmer can no longer produce at the price England is paying for cattle. I for one would as soon go "wallop" to-day straight off the reel as starve by slow degrees.

Comment on this

Would the Deputy tell me how a farmer can produce cattle, sheep and lambs at 20 per cent. less than the present price?

Comment on this

Is that a question?

Comment on this

Yes. You are a farmer and will you say if a farmer can produce at 20 per cent. less than the present prices?

Comment on this

He cannot.

Comment on this

What is the alternative?

Mr. O'Leary rose.

Comment on this

One at a time and I will answer you all. The farmer cannot produce at 20 per cent. less than at present any more than he can produce at the present price and pay rates and annuities. I challenge you to say that he can produce at the present prices.

Comment on this

Which is £80 or £100 more valuable to the farmer to-day?

Comment on this

The farmer's position is that he has to find so much for rates and annuities before he has anything for himself. No farmer or manufacturer can produce and sell under the cost of manufacture or production. We have been producing under the cost of production. That cannot be denied.

Comment on this

If I might intervene, I suggest that Deputy Keating is begging the question. There has been a drop in the price of cattle during the past twelve months of more than 20 per cent. Will he explain that?

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Deputy Corry.

Comment on this

I think I have answered the Deputy fairly well. I think he will agree with me that the farmers could not produce cattle at the prices they were getting.

Comment on this

No, and they cannot afford to pay tariffs.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

This is not a cross-examination. It is a debate.

Comment on this

It is very seldom I get up, but the Deputy is going too far.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Deputy knows that he should not interrupt.

Comment on this

It is all very fine——

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Deputy will please sit down. Deputy Corry is entitled to a hearing. Deputy Keating will have an opportunity to reply, if he so desires, but he must not interrupt.

Comment on this

I appeal to the Ceann Comhairle to let them all ask questions. The more questions that are asked the clearer the matter will become. I have got a statement from Deputy Keating that farmers could not produce cattle at the prices they have been receiving.

Comment on this

Certainly not.

Comment on this

That clears the air. If that is the position, then it would only be a matter of time until the farmer went "wallop" anyway. I suggest that the first thing the Government responsible should do is to hold these annuities at home, since the farmer cannot afford to pay them, and see that those annuities are transferred to the farmers' pockets as quickly as possible.

We have other means and other ways of meeting this question. What is the position of John Bull at the moment? We buy from John Bull about five million pounds worth more than he buys from us. If I was sending my butter and eggs every week into a grocer and getting 30s. for them and if I were buying £2 worth of goods from the grocer, which of the two of us could afford to fall out? That is the present position. John Bull says: "You can keep your butter and eggs at home." We will tell him that he can keep his groceries at home. I have put the situation as clearly and fairly as I can. There are only two sides to this quarrel. On one side, are those who are for Ireland and on the other are those who are against her. Ireland should have first claim on us. When we realise that, it is our bounden duty to stand by Ireland in this quarrel. The quarrel has not been of our seeking. We have offered to put this case to arbitration because we know we will win before any fair tribunal in the world. If we get a fair and impartial tribunal, we will win out with flying colours in spite of all that has been done by the Front Bench opposite. If England is sure of her case or if she has any case, what objection can she have to bringing that case before any man for judgment? Why confine the tribunal within certain limits? But England says, "Yes, you can have a court to try it, but I will pick the judge." Is there any Deputy on the Opposition Benches who is going to stand for that, who is going to stand for a packed jury or a packed court, for that is what this amounts to? I am making a fair appeal to them, and, as I said, this is a fight as between those who are for Ireland and those who are against Ireland, and this is a time when every man who is for Ireland should support the Government elected by the Irish people to see this fight through.

Comment on this

I rise principally to suggest that this is a debate in which we should hear from the President or from a member of the Front Bench. The Vote before the House is not a Vote that, in the circumstances, could be expected to go through as a matter of course. The appearance of the situation is, and I think it must be so to everybody, that the scheme for which the Vote is now taken is useless. If there is something that we do not know that would make the Vote still of some value, I think we should hear it. Perhaps the Government have some plans, and if they have plans that have any bearing on this situation, even though we may not hear them in detail, we should have some outline of them now. There is going, unless something is happening about which we do not know, to be a 20 per cent. tariff on butter. With that 20 per cent. tariff, the position is going to be worse than the position which the scheme was designed to remedy, and it would seem to any person that it is absurd for the Government which has brought that position into being, and which has brought about the imposition of that 20 per cent. tariff, to go on with this scheme for improving the price of butter.

It would seem to me that the first thing for them to do was to take steps to see that there was not an imposition of 20 per cent. There has been a great deal of talk here about the national view and about the two sides, and so on, but there is no question of national principle involved here. At most, this whole question of the annuities is a question of accountancy on a large scale. It is the question of the lending and paying back of money, of the transfer of various liabilities and the cancelling of certain liabilities. There is no question of principle whatever involved in it, and if a man believes that the money is payable to Great Britain, he is not being a bad Irishman in saying it, no more than a man is being a bad Englishman if he says the money is not payable to Great Britain. This is a matter on which everybody is fully entitled to look at the facts, and to say what he thinks, and not have his patriotism called into question. I do not need to go into it now, but I have frequently said that, in my opinion, these annuities are legally and morally due to the funds to which they have been going, but that is not the view taken by the Government. I think it is wrong for Deputy Corry, or whatever Deputy it was, to say that the Free State, acting through the present Government has not provoked the present position. I think it is perfectly clear that the Free State has provoked the present position, because, while negotiations in respect of arbitration were still going on, they have departed from the status quo. They have withheld the payments always being made under previous agreements and under legislation. They have forced the British Government, for the first time to draw on its own Exchequer to pay the interest on money loaned to the Irish farmer, and to meet a liability that it never heretofore had to meet, and therefore, it seems to me perfectly clear that the provocation is on our side, and that, even on the Government's own thesis, there was no justification, up to the present for the withholding of these land annuities and for the putting of them into a Suspense Account.

Holding the Government's view, a situation and time might have come when the action they have taken would have been justified. Holding their view, I say that if they had said to the British Government: "We do not believe that we ought to pay these liabilities, and we want to discuss the matter," and if the British Government had said: "We will not discuss it; we will not go into it at all. It is closed"; if, after efforts to get them to negotiate, the British Government had refused, then, as I say, the Government would have been justified in this step. If, when the question of arbitration had been raised, after negotiation, the British Government had declined any arbitration, and had declined after repeated pressure, the Government would have been justified, or if arbitration had been agreed to, and a long period of negotiation had passed, without any possibility of arriving at agreement, in regard to terms of reference or personnel, then a position would have been reached in which the Government, taking their own ground, would have been justified in withholding the annuities; but things being as they are, very little time having passed and very little negotiation having taken place, with very little attempt to reach accommodation, and having regard to the fact that the agreement was made a long time ago, and that legislation was passed making it operative, it certainly was a provocative act, and, in my opinion, an unjustified act, on the part of this Government, instead of paying these annuities, which they had collected for the purpose of paying the interest on the land stock, to put them into a Suspense Account.

I do not know if the Government have plans, but, if I am to judge from the speeches of back benchers, I gather that the Government have plans for making the position worse—for having an economic war along the whole front, and for having a campaign of attrition, with some idea of trying to damage the British more than they have damaged us, and without any regard to the further ill effects that that campaign on our part will have on our own people. Instead of having that policy, if that is their policy, I think they ought to adopt the policy of preventing our goods from being shut out of the British market, and of preventing the loss of goodwill and custom, and the changing of habit, and of preventing all the damage to our economic future that will happen. As I say, there is no matter of national principle here. It is all a matter of pounds, shillings and pence, and it is absurd to look on it in any other way. When the national right to rule here was challenged, when it was a question of getting rid of the British troops, we were up against two things that could not be weighed one against the other. The economic loss in those circumstances did not matter. There was a great national principle that had to be vindicated, but here it is only a question of pounds, shillings and pence, and the question of whether this policy will be more economically beneficial to the country than the other policy. I certainly think that whatever may be the ultimate fate of the land annuities, whatever may be the ultimate decision in regard to them, it is bad policy for the Government here to provoke an economic war, as they have provoked it if it takes place, and to take no steps, even at this stage, to avert it. I think their duty is to take these steps and not to plunge the country further into a struggle, in which, at any rate, we can less afford to bear the loss than the other side.

There was a great deal of talk about whether or not the farmer could afford to pay the annuities and that is quite a separate and distinct question. All along the Government has been saying, not that they cannot pay, but "We will collect"—which seemed to indicate that they believed the farmer could pay—and "we will not transmit." If it is a question of making an ad misericordiam appeal, as many countries in difficulty have had to make, it is quite a different matter, but we are not dealing with that now, and if an ad misericordiam appeal should become necessary, we are prejudicing, by this particular policy that has been adopted, the prospects of getting any results in any negotiations that might take place along that line. It would be better, instead of having these irresponsible and foolish speeches from the Back Benches in this matter, that members of the Government should speak and that we should have the real issues dealt with; that we should have the matter, which I say is a matter of accountancy, dealt with on the economic plane, and none of this flagwagging and attempts to get up some sort of a war spirit and lead the country into evils into which there is no need to lead it. I would ask that members of the Government should address the House. They should not be prepared to go on, apparently, as if nothing had happened, and to expect the House to go on as if nothing had happened. What has happened is a very big thing. There may be negotiations going on that I know nothing about but, on the assumption that no negotiations are going on, what has happened is a very big thing, and may be a much bigger thing very soon, and a thing that will lead the country into complete bankruptcy and into a sort of chaos.

I do hope the Government do not want to shatter this world to bits in order to mould it nearer to their heart's desire, that they do not want to bring about chaos in order to put some of their theories into practice. I hope they want to cause the least possible suffering to the people of the country, and if they do want to cause the least possible suffering to the country, then they ought to begin here and now by facing the issue as it presents itself on this Estimate. They should continue to face it in some sort of a realistic spirit, and we should not have any talk about "Black and Tan" sufferings, or the "big stick," or anything like that. Let us face the exact facts. What has happened is that we have held back money that the British regard as owing to them; that up to this this country has always regarded as owing to them, and the British Government have simply taken steps to recoup themselves. There is no more in it than that so far. It is the first exchange of blows if you like. It might become very much bigger, and I think that the Government certainly ought not to allow it to become very much bigger.

I do not want to go into details on the question of a tribunal. I think there is no difference in the tribunal. I think a Commonwealth tribunal would probably, in all the circumstances, and in view of the sort of argument that Fianna Fáil as a Government have put up, be a more favourable tribunal, because as anybody knows that sort of argument would be much more likely to appeal to a British jurist, or a jurist trained in British law, than to an international jurist. I think the Commonwealth tribunal would be more satisfactory, but, at any rate, if the Government are not going to agree to that tribunal, they ought to take steps to see that this economic war is not started until negotiations have gone a bit further. Mention has been made of Mr. Justice Feetham. Mr. Justice Feetham was the appointee of the British Government. As far as I know, there has been no proposal in this case that the British Government should appoint the chairman. Of course, anybody knows that the fortunes of litigation, like the fortunes of war, are very uncertain, and that no matter where the judge may come from you may get an unfavourable result. The analogy of the Boundary Tribunal is of no value. I do not believe the present Government think that. I believe, in fact, that they have other reasons for making difficulties about the personnel. These are face-saving difficulties. I believe they want, if they agree to a tribunal, to have a grievance, so that they may be able to do something else afterwards.

Comment on this

Both Deputy McGilligan and Deputy Blythe are very anxious to hear a statement from the President. I wonder what difference it will really make to get that statement of the case, and how far it is going to alter the situation to-night. What I consider is of real importance is that a statement of the case should be made by the President to-night, not to satisfy Deputies opposite, but to satisfy the public generally.

Comment on this

"Hear, hear."

Comment on this

Any statement made will. I am confident have that effect. The farmers have had bitter experience during the last ten years of the problem of how to make ends meet. Dairy farming has practically gone into bankruptey. Nobody knows that better than the Deputies opposite. Deputies and farmers know what sum of public money was spent by the late Minister for Agriculture in endeavouring to foster that industry, depending at the same time upon the English markets for the sale of the produce. We know what sum of money was spent in that endeavour, and we know with what results. The farmers realise that the Fianna Fáil Government have honestly endeavoured to meet the problem as it confronted them. The farmers are not whining, as a Deputy opposite said, or calling out like a voice in the wilderness for some hope from this Dáil. I have received letters within the last few days, and to-day I received wires, from farmers keenly interested in the dairying industry and in the other ends of farming. These men supported the Cumann na nGaedheal at the last election. The purport of the messages sent to me was "Let the Government hold firm in their present attitude; we are with them."

Comment on this

Read some of them.

Comment on this

I appreciate the attempt to throw that indignity on the farmers when Deputies opposite want to create a scare. The farmers are not appealing in that whining voice, calling upon the Government to make a surrender at the threat of reprisals by an outside country. They are prepared to do now what they did on many occasions before, they are prepared, if needs be, to make sacrifices in the fight that is being made, and the farmers know that the present fight will be ultimately in their interests. I want to vindicate the character of the farmers and to stand up for them against Deputies opposite who are endeavouring to vilify them. Deputy Blythe said the Government had brought about this new tariff of 20 per cent. I refuse to believe that. I assert that the tariff is directly the result of the action of the Cumann na nGaedheal Party when it was the Government. That 20 per cent. tariff is the result of the secret agreement made by the representatives of the Cumann na nGaedheal Government, as was pointed out by Mr. Thomas when he was asked on what basis he made his claim for payment of the land annuities. We are endeavouring to rectify that secret contract. Deputy McGilligan quoted a statement made by the Minister for Agriculture in speaking upon the Butter Bill in this House, that he refused to believe that a tax would be put by England on the butter going into that country. What was Deputy McGilligan's prophecy then? What was the prophecy of other Deputies opposite? Are they satisfied now that their prophecy has been fulfilled? Most men are satisfied when they can point to their prophecy being fulfilled.

Comment on this

What was the prophecy?

Comment on this
Mr. Maguire

The prophecy was that once we held the land annuities, once we stood for these things, a tariff would be put on our products in England.

Comment on this

Deputy Cleary said, on the Butter Bill, that Deputy McGilligan gave no warning at all of that. Of course it was untrue.

Comment on this
Mr. Maguire

What was behind the attitude of Deputies opposite when Deputy McGilligan quoted the Minister for Agriculture saying on the Butter Bill that he did not believe a tax would be put upon butter? What are we to infer from that? What was the general purport of statements made by Deputies opposite when they were Ministers and since? It was to the effect that a tariff would be imposed by England upon these products. As prophets, they are justified. Are Deputies over there proud of that fact? Do you approve of those statements now? I presume some of you will run away from them and say you do not, but, mind you, it is frequently in human nature for men at the end of two or three years to say: "Two or three years ago I told you so." What is your policy on the present situation?

Comment on this

Is that what the Party opposite would like to get?

Comment on this

It is the duty of the Government to formulate a policy.

Comment on this
Mr. Maguire

You want an authoritative statement as to what we propose to do. I may tell you the farmers are satisfied to leave this matter in the hands of a Government which has already shown itself to be the friend of the farmers. What is your policy? Is it merely the policy "I told you so"? So far as I have heard from any Deputy opposite, that is the only policy that has been advocated. They are the proud men in the proud position of being able to say, "We are justified. Three years back we told you this would happen and to-night is our triumph." Could England have done other than she has done in this matter? Could any popularly elected Government in any country, in view of the attitude taken up by the Opposition here, who form a substantial number of the representatives in this House, say to their people: "We will refuse to collect those three millions a year"? It is well known that nearly half of the representatives in this House have been strongly advocating that the money should be paid?

No Government, no matter what their views are, could, in face of the position that exists here, have done other than the British Government have done unless they desired to court absolute defeat at the hands of the electors. I hope the Deputies on the Opposition Benches are satisfied with their victory to-night. They are in the extraordinary position that, having brought themselves to the point when they might flatter themselves on their triumph, in order to save themselves from their own act they dare not do it publicly. Supposing that we accepted the alternative as we know it, supposing you succeeded in your effort, your immediate effort, to unseat the present Government, and supposing you come back to office, what have we to face? We have to face the payment of the land annuities regularly to England, the payment of other debts, and the withdrawal of the tariffs that have created employment in this country.

Comment on this

We have not seen any of it yet.

Comment on this
Mr. Maguire

Probably you do not want it. We know there are people who were for years unemployed and they are now enjoying the benefits resulting from our policy.

Comment on this

There are not many enjoying it.

Comment on this
Mr. Maguire

Do you think the country will accept that alternative? You are living in a fool's paradise if you think the people are so ignorant as not to see further than your limited line of vision. Deputy Blythe said we were creating a scare; that our speakers were endeavouring to create a war atmosphere. We are not. We want no war. We want our rights and we are going to get them. If I or the farmers of the country had to make a choice between the creation of a war spirit and the creation of a surrender spirit, which is the spirit of the Opposition here, the choice would be with the war spirit.

Comment on this

I certainly cannot join with Deputy Corry in rejoicing at the fact that this crisis has come on our people. I think we are meeting here to-night under rather tragic circumstances, particularly from the point of view of the Irish farmer. I think we are meeting possibly on a day when the outlook is as black as ever it was.

Comment on this

Thanks to you.

Comment on this

I cannot bring myself to rejoice with Deputy Corry that such a crisis has come on our people. We have heard in the course of this debate back bench speeches from Deputies of the Government Party and we have had absolute silence on the part of the men whose duty it is to give a lead in such a crisis. We have seen a clear exhibition of a shirking of responsibilities, of trying to draw without giving the lead. In that they are consistent. As long as this House has been in existence, on every question that came before the House for discussion, be it great or small, a member of the Government has always been one of the first of his Party to express the policy of his Government on the situation that existed, such as it was. We have seen to-night back benchers put up one by one, their speeches calculated not to assist this crisis towards solution in one way or another but calculated deliberately to try and make this an issue between the Government and Cumann na nGaedheal. When each one of them in a laborious way attempted to make this a Party issue, he did it to the cry "This is a question between England and Ireland."

Comment on this

And is it not?

Comment on this

If ever I listened to three speeches calculated to stir up dissension and controversy amongst people of the same country they were the three speeches I listened to from that side to-night. I think it is regrettable, when our farmers are faced with a situation that may mean the absolute extermination of their trade, certainly the total extermination of their export trade if this situation is prolonged, that we should have such speeches delivered here. I think at least we should get something better than violent and heated Party provocative speeches. Such speeches might have been excused when the Deputies opposite were in opposition, but I think it is unseemly, and I think it shows a total disregard of their responsibilities as belonging to the Government Party, for any Deputies to make the despicable type of speeches that we have listened to to-night.

Phrases were slung across the House about secret agreements, about the events of 1920 and 1921, about a secret agreement in the year 1923 which was so secret that it was discussed in this House in April, 1923, when these same Deputies who are now talking were referring to this House as being the home of national apostates. If we are going to have that kind of thing, let us have it to and fro. Let us have the truth. If Deputies opposite are the least bit interested in the matter, will they look up the Dáil Debates for the year 1923? If they do they will see there that a full and adequate discussion took place in reference to that particular agreement.

We have a situation brought about in our country that has been provoked by absolute bundling and mishandling of a rather delicate situation; and when such a situation comes to its natural and logical end we have the complete failure of the Government Ministers even to take a lead in discussing it. We have a complete running away from the situation. We have a promise from back bench supporters of the Government that a Bill will be introduced to deal with the situation. Presumably a case of attempting to feed the dog with a bit of its own tail; presumably attempting to try to subsidise for the loss of exports. This is the situation for the unfortunate Irish farmer, who is expected to pay his annuities to two Governments and, when, in addition to paying these annuities twice he is supposed to pay the cost of administering an Act of that kind on this side and to pay for the cost of collection on the other side.

Is it not time that we began to grapple with the realities of the situation? It is rather unfortunate that the Minister for Agriculture is abroad, because I really think that the Minister for Agriculture was genuinely concerned for the interests of the farmer and I feel that if the Minister for Agriculture were present here to-night whether in the Dáil or behind the scenes, he would be man enough to put down his foot and to say that this threatened situation must be averted, even at the cost of political complications. I think if we sit down either inactive or if we pass a Bill that is to become another retaliation Bill, if we launch out on an intensive economic war in which the farmers of Ireland will be the casualties so glibly referred to by the Minister for Industry and Commerce a few weeks ago, we are embarking on a futile and suicidal policy, a policy which if we lend ourselves to it we will deserve every hard thing that will be said about us by posterity in this country. Are we to go on attempting to make into a national issue a mere squabble about finance as to whether agreements are to be maintained, or if this agreement shall be interpreted as a previous agreement, where one side is put in a position to defy the other and merely settle the point by saying "what we have we hold?" This is the situation that has come about.

We on these benches have been jibed at because we had a certain amount of foresight and because we had a certain amount of vision. I venture to say that there is no intelligent man interested in this question for years back that did not, in his own mind, foresee that such a situation would arise if we insisted, in the absence of agreement, in closing down on the payment of those annuities. I pay this compliment to the members of the Front Bench opposite that there was not one of them then that did not from time to time think of the possibility of such a step being taken. I certainly know that the Minister for Industry and Commerce on various occasions admitted that such a situation as this was before the country. But he dealt with it along the lines of telling his poor deluded audience that the British Government would never tax the Englishman's dinner table. He said: "Put that out of your minds; such steps would never be taken by any British Government."

Comment on this

Only for Cumann na nGaedheal.

Comment on this

Deputy Cooney flatters us. That in itself was evidence that such a situation did receive consideration from the members of the Fianna Fáil Party. Now a situation has arisen, and it is purely a case of what is best to be done in the new circumstances that have arisen. We are asked by the Fianna Fáil back benchers what is our policy in the matter. For ten years we were in the position of being obliged to frame and state a policy on every crisis that arose in the country. That responsibility was never shirked even for an hour. Some man, some one of the Government Front Bench at all times stood up and gave a lead in the debate. Never were the whole Government Front Bench seen to shirk that issue. They were always prepared to lead the House. Never did they refuse to give a lead. This is the first time of a real crisis in this country where we have back-sliding from an Irish Government, where there has been no attempt to announce policy. We are asked what our policy is. Our policy when we were the Government of the country was this: that obligations entered into had got to be honoured, and if there was a difference between the interpretation of agreements then that difference should be cleared up by frank discussion, frank, manly and open discussions between the parties, and if that failed by arbitration.

Comment on this

As in the Boundary Commission.

Comment on this

The personnel of an arbitration court may be important, but I do not think that the geographical address of any of the members of the court is worth jeopardising the trade of the Irish farmer about. I do not think that the particular town or village or country that an honest man comes from is worth jeopardising the whole butter and cattle trade of this country for. We heard some talk about ambiguity last evening. It is about time that ambiguity and phrase-coining and hair-splitting were removed out of the national life of the country and that where so distressingly serious a situation has arisen that we should be men enough to think of the human beings depending on us. We should be able to do that even at the sacrifice of a little bit of prestige. We should be able to get down to facts, to get to work, to cease quibbling about geographical places and to get this matter settled according to the judgment and honesty of the members of the tribunal.

Even in the next 24 hours every effort should be made by the Government of this country to bring the arbitration up to a point and to endeavour to get this Order suspended; and not have it put into operation pending the decision of that court. Every one of us knows that it is easy enough to lose a market. You can lose a market in one night by one false step, and having lost it, it will take you ten long years to win it back again. If we let the Dane and the Dutch and the Norwegian poach on our market for one month, a long decade will not oust them out of that market again. Those are the things that matter. It is not a case of one party trying to score off another party. There are twenty-four hours to go and during those twenty-four hours every effort of the Government and of those who maintain the Government in power must be directed towards trying to get an agreed tribunal, as against the suspension of the operation of this Order, until a decision of that court is arrived at.

Comment on this

I deplore the events which have led up to this action on the part of the British Government, because it is a stroke at this country at a time when it is least able to bear it. It would be an unheard of thing if a responsible Government did not warn the people against the consequences of hostile action, such as retaining the land annuities would be, towards the British people. We know what an effect it would have on the minds of these people when carrying on their commercial relations, upon which the very life of this country depends. What are the consequences of the action of the British Government in imposing duties amounting to twenty per cent.? It means that in our cattle trade alone two millions of money, at least, is going to be taken out of the pockets of Irish farmers. It means a loss to the trade which is most vital to us, and upon which this country depends. Farmers will hold their cattle, if they possibly can, when they know that people in the cattle trade will deduct the twenty per cent. from the price paid for them. Every other commodity which we export to the British market is taxed to a like extent. It means that when we sell our exportable surplus we will lose the same percentage. No matter what we say, the percentage will be deducted on our exports to the British market. The full amount of this tax will be deducted from every item which is purchased from Irish farmers, and that will mean a consequent reduction in their incomes. What action is the Government of this country capable of taking? They have taken action already in taxing every commodity which we buy from England. Therefore the British are not in a position to fear retaliation from us. I feel that there is a very serious time in front of the Irish farmers. If our markets were reduced by international competition to a very low level, however low the level, we must sell there. With the twenty per cent. tax we will lose a further sum.

Having regard to the serious position with which this country is faced, and with which our markets are faced, it is up to the Government to endeavour to secure arbitration on the issue involved by every means in its power. Surely it is not impossible in countries such as South Africa, India and other nations in the Commonwealth to find three representatives to do justice to this country on an issue that is so vital to its welfare. As the matter stands now, with the deduction of the tax, and the loss of the English markets, it means so much more of an opening for the nations in the Commonwealth that export to the British market. That will completely undo our position so far as that market is concerned. I do not see any alternative markets. We will be reduced to the position of endeavouring to consume our own products. There is not here a population large enough to do so. What will be the inevitable result? It means that prices will slump far below the cost of production. It has been put up to us that we cannot produce cattle at the present market prices. What will be the consequences now? Must the losses not inevitably be greater when farmers have to sell in order to pay, not alone their land annuities and rates but the various outgoings which are incidental to the economic working of a farm? They must sell, and must sell at the figure which the buyer will give. I think there is at any rate a mandate for arbitration. I would ask the government to exercise their powers in that respect, and to submit this dispute to a tribunal which they believe will be fair. Before a jury is empanelled an opportunity is given to challenge a particular member of it. Surely a jury can be agreed upon which will settle this dispute to the advantage of two countries which naturally should be friendly towards each other. Our interests depend entirely upon friendly negotiations and upon a friendly settlement of any dispute. I think the Government will not be serving the best interests of the people if they do not explore every avenue in order to secure arbitration in this matter.

The President rose.

Comment on this

I gladly give way to the President at this stage.

Comment on this

It is a rather interesting thing to be taunted with sitting silent while Deputies on the opposite benches are speaking. We had that experience for many years. We had to speak on very important questions, and generally one Minister was sitting here paying no attention whatever to what was being said. Apparently the Deputies on the opposite benches were very glad to stand up. There was no hesitation about it. They wanted this debate to-night. They would not wait until to-morrow, when there would be the ordinary opportunity when the measure that the Government is bringing in, in relation to the present crisis, will be before the House. Why then should we not give them an opportunity of saying the things they want to say? They wanted to give a lead; to tell the country we were down and out, and in a miserable position; to tell the people that they were misled, and to ask the people to despair, because a nation near-by wishes to bully them, to take away their rights, and to dictate the court by which they are to take away these rights. Some of the Deputies opposite said that this is a mere petty matter, merely a matter of pounds, shillings and pence. It is rather unfortunate that human beings have somehow to work out their material existence on an economic basis of one kind or another in pounds, shillings and pence. Yet we are told that pounds, shillings and pence are mere matters. I think it was a Deputy on the opposite benches who spoke of the Deputies there as being realists all the time, while we were the people who were talking about airy sentiment. It would be all very well, said Deputy Blythe, if this were a national question. Is it of no importance to the people to be robbed every year of £5,000,000 which they have to find? Is is of no importance to the people to be robbed every year of £5,000,000 that they think is theirs? £5,000,000 a year means something to our people, and the people who should best appreciate it are the gentlemen on the opposite benches if there is anything like realism or truth in their pretences that they are the realists. Of course, they are trying to put the Government in the wrong and pretend that it has led the people blindly into this position. We have done nothing of the kind. This position, as was admitted, was bound to occur, or something like it was bound to occur, if we were really determined to stand by our rights. Was it to be thought that Britain which is getting quite easily five and three quarter or five and a third million pounds directly from us would give it up, if they thought that by bullying us a little we would abandon our rights and continue to pay without demurring as we have paid in the past?

Let us see what exactly has happened. For years sums have been paid to the British Government, which, in our opinion, and in the opinion of those who have examined it, were not legally or morally due to Britain. The various sums we have paid for the period of years since the Free State was established have amounted to over £51,000,000. This is not a new measure. We debated it throughout the election time, and showed what that drain of money meant to our people. We pointed out to them that the total cost of the Shannon Works scheme—great as that enterprise was—that the construction part of it did not cost us more than we are paying every year on the head of these payments. We are handing over, therefore, to Britain, as the result of the policy of the present Opposition, sums every year the amount of which is equal to the sum that was paid for the construction works of the Shannon scheme. Is that a light matter? Is it something we ought to continue to put up with when there is a remedy for it and when that money, we feel, is not due? I have frequently pointed out during the debate on this matter in the country that, as the relative capacity of Britain to ourselves for bearing burdens was estimated by the British Treasury, as being 66 to 1 our total payments during the period of ten years to Britain have been equivalent to a payment by Britain of the colossal sum of £3,400,000,000. If Great Britain had paid £3,400,000,000, and if they felt that that sum was not legally due by them, do you think that there would be any party in Britain who would act as the present Opposition here is acting? £3,400,000,000 is the equivalent that Britain would have had to pay if she were to pay the sum that we have to pay. Take it the other way—per year. Britain's capacity again is 66 to 1. That is their own estimate of it. A payment of £5,000,000 by us is equivalent to an annual payment of £330,000,000. If Britain were annually paying away to another country the sum of £330,000,000 would there be any party in Britain to stand up and say: "This is not a national question. It is a mere matter of pounds shillings and pence" if you please? When there was a question of £2,000,000 for Britain itself— £2,000,000 for the country whose annual revenue is £770,000,000—Mr. Snowden went over to France, or rather I think it was to Belgium, and fought there for that £2,000,000, and was acclaimed a national hero when he came back. If he had gone over and tried to fight for £330,000,000 instead of £2,000,000, would there have been some party in the British House of Commons to stand up and say that he was not fighting for a national principle, that he should not make a national fight of it, and that it was a matter of mere pounds, shillings and pence?

I have said at the start that there was no person in this country who did not realise that, if we were serious in this matter, we would have to face a situation such as we are facing. I certainly realised it. And in order that there might be no doubt whatever about it, we put it down in our election programme in very definite terms as one of the things we intended to do. We said that we intended to remove the Oath—and the Oath is gone—Seanad or no Seanad. We said we were going to hold the land annuities until Britain proved in a fair court her right to them. And we are going to hold the land annuities. Who has acted provocatively in this matter? We are accused on the opposite benches of acting provocatively because we did not continue the work, which they had initiated, of making payments which we did not think were due from us. The Irish people are under no misapprehension about our attitude on that matter. We told them at the election time that if they wanted seriously to hold these annuities, they would have, as a nation, to do what a private individual would do under similar circumstances. What would a private individual would do under that he was paying sums which were not legally due from him? Would he continue paying them or would he bring the matter to a crisis, and in what way would he bring it to a crisis? He would bring it to a crisis by saying: "I will not pay until you prove your case to receive these moneys." And we have said that. Of course, the gentlemen on the opposite benches, who have no objection to paying it, do not understand an attitude like that. We should pay, I suppose they would say, "without prejudice." Well, I would say this. There are £51,000,000 gone—gone, in my opinion, without any just reason for paying them. Britain has received it. I would like to see us in the position of trying to get that £51,000,000 paid back, and I for one am not going to add to that bill to be got back. The proper and the right thing to do is to hold these moneys. We are holding them, and, to show our bona fides, we are putting them in a suspense account. Despite the efforts of some of the gentlemen on the opposite benches, who are asking the farmers not to pay, we have faced the disagreeable course of demanding payments of these moneys and putting them into the suspense account in order that, if it should be found by any chance that these moneys were due from us, then the money would be there to pay our debt. We are keeping the money there. Why do we collect it? Because the money is due to the community as a whole. It is due to the State. We have always explained that it was due to the State. Gentlemen on the opposite benches want to make it appear that if it was not due to Britain then it was due to nobody. That is not the position and it never was the position. It is due by the individual farmers to the State, to the community as a whole, on whose credit partly the moneys were originally advanced. We have not acted provocatively in this. We have said to the British, "We do not believe this money is due from us; we are prepared to have the matter settled by arbitration; but we are not, in going to arbitration, to be told that we must make our selection from a particular set that may be arranged by another Government—the other party to the dispute."

As I said, in the last despatch to Mr. Thomas, the very essence of arbitration is freedom of choice of nominees by the separate parties. Our choice, it does not matter how nominated, must be a free choice. Somebody on the benches opposite said that geographical address does not matter. Is it not extraordinary how we find Irishmen who always think a thing does not matter if it refers to themselves, and never ask: Why should it matter to the British? Why should a geographical address matter so much to the British? If it should not matter to us, it should not matter to them. We simply say: "Let the court be of the general character indicated in the 1930 Conference Report." The only thing we want is that we shall not be restricted in the choice of our nominees. It would be hard enough to get them outside the countries. As Deputies know well, we have not the power abroad that the British Government have. We have not the influence abroad that they have. We have not the various ways, directly and indirectly, of securing bias in our favour. We are relatively a small country, which British propaganda has misrepresented. We are a country that has been particularly misrepresented in this matter, and even with the whole world to choose from, if we are to get people of the character indicated there, it will be hard enough to get people who will be able to resist such influence as may well be brought to bear upon them. We have, then, in these circumstances, insisted that we must have freedom of choice.

The Feetham Commission was spoken about. I think there is no Irishman who will ever forget that Commission or who will ever again have any confidence in a court of that character. With that experience before us, we are not, in a matter of such importance to our people, going to restrict our field of choice. It has been suggested: "Oh, if you only went on the plea that you could not pay, then it would be a different matter." If you engineered a scheme by which the annuities were not collected, if you went about and suggested to the farmers not to pay, then you could go over, it is suggested, to the British, and make an ad misericordiam appeal.

The truth is, it is difficult, almost impossible, for our farmers to pay. We have seen the position with regard to arrears. We know the several processes and appeals that have had to be resorted to to compel them to pay. We know they paid only after they had tightened their belts, on many occasions, and deprived themselves and their families, very often, of the necessaries of life. They have struggled under exceptionally trying circumstances to meet these payments. Because they did that and made these sacrifices, and because the community as a whole has insisted upon these sacrifices being made, they are told they should not make them at all by the very people who say that this money must be paid. It is suggested to them that they should not make that payment at all and that we should make an ad misericordiam appeal to the British to relieve us of these debts. If they were proved to be legally due, there might be something to be said for that, but why resort to an ad misericordiam appeal if we have a moral right to retain them? Why should we do that? It would probably be true to say we would have a better foundation in this country for making such an appeal than countries who are to-day looking for relief of their debts. We are not making it, simply because there is a ground for getting it as a matter of right and not as a matter of grace.

The British suggest that they would listen to us and that their attitude would be sympathetic if we made an ad misericordiam appeal. We are not asking them to show any sympathy whatever, but simply to give us our rights in this matter. We are asking for a fair court. We are asking to get the same choice as we are willing to give the other side. If they say to us that geographical addresses do not matter, we say back to them: “It ought not to matter for you either.” Let us have fair play. The moneys are there. We collected them; they will be there if the matter is to go to arbitration. It is suggested that the farmers or the community will have to pay both ways. The community will not have to pay both ways. Under the policy of the previous administration the farmers were paying. The community were paying five-and-three-quarter millions, all told, of which five-and-one-third went directly to Great Britain. They were paying that sum out. The community, as a whole, will not have to pay that twice, because if Britain collects it one way she will not get it the other. We are not going to pay twice.

It is suggested that we are trying to work up an economic war. We are not, but we realise, and our people, who elected us by a majority, and the people who are behind us, the people who would again elect us by a ma-jority——

Comment on this

We will do the work that we got a mandate to do, and, after we have done it, we will go back to the people.

Comment on this

I was thinking as much.

Comment on this

As long as this Government has a majority in this House it will carry out the mandate it fairly got from the people. Do not forget that. If the gentlemen across the water think they are going to use this method to beat us, they are making a big mistake. The Irish people put us in the saddle and we are not going to get out of it, no matter what the gentlemen across the water think. If they think they can put us out by these methods, they will find that they have mistaken the temper of the Irish people. They are not going to get the chance. The Irish people will not be asked, in times like these, to make a choice. We were given a certain work to do, to defend the interests of the people, and so long as we have a majority in this House, then by every means available to the people, we will defend them. I have said we are not looking for war in this matter. We are simply out to maintain our rights by the only way that we have to maintain our rights. If we surrender now, so sure as we do, whenever an occasion arises again when the British will want to get anything from us, they will use the same methods. We are going to get out of economic slavery this time. We may have trouble in doing it. There will be hardships, no doubt, but there was many an Irishman before who wished to Heaven that an opportunity was given him to end the sort of economic policy that existed in this country in the past.

One of the Deputies here stated that in the past we were hewers of wood and drawers of water for the British. Our present economic system was the result of their deliberate policy. It would have taken us many years to change that policy possibly by acts of our own, by deliberate action on our own part. They are going to do it for us. If they force us to it, looking to the future and its possibilities, then my prediction is that many a generation of Irishmen will bless the day when the English tried to do this. Then we will be driven back to what economics should be. We will be driven back to have our people fed as the first duty of agriculture. Our own people will be fed. The hungry people who, in a land of plenty, are unable to get food, with the proper system that may result from this will be able to get food. In the past we were producing at a loss. Because there was no other direction to turn to we had to continue to produce at a loss until finally whatever little reserves of capital were left to our people were wasted and they were in the position to which they are reduced at present, almost in despair. Our own market was forgotten. We got from the foreigner the things we could produce ourselves. If we have to get things from outside the people who want to sell them will be very glad to take our produce in return. We will be getting back a rational system of economy. It will take some change from the present system and there is no doubt whatever that it will be difficult.

Quick changes are difficult. If we were choosing it, we would choose it by slower methods. I do not say that the sum total of the slower methods and the inconveniences and distress that might be caused by them would not be greater than it will be by this violent change but we have got to face it. There is no alternative. The only alternative is to pay away, and to continue to pay away quietly and without protest, these huge sums the amounts of which I have tried to get you to recognise by multiplying them by the factor 66 so that you might realise what they would be in the case of Britain. Do not think that we are alone in this struggle. Do not think that we are the only people, if they do try this economic war, who are going to be hurt. The British people are going to feel it just as much as we are and every day of distress that there is here at the start will mean a day of prosperity for our people in future. It will mean a proper national economy in future. It will mean getting more quickly to the point that has been the object of this Party all the time—to help to get a national system of economy.

Britain is looking to get her debts cancelled. There will be many voices raised in the place where she wants to get them cancelled. There will be many voices raised if she tries this method of extracting unfairly from this people these enormous sums every year. As I have said, we are not anxious to provoke this war. We have told the people what their rights were and what they must do if they want to secure their rights. We are doing that. The people knew it and, if I know the Irish people, they are going to stand by it. They know perfectly well what is involved. They know perfectly well what these payments have meant to them in the past. We are now, as in the beginning, quite prepared to let this matter go to arbitration, but if other people want to have the choice of court, to have it their own way, then the Irish people are not such fools as to ask us to give way. I appeal to-night to the Irish people to stand firm. Messages have come to us asking us, whatever we do, to stand firm. That is the attitude of the Irish people to-night, and I say to them that is the attitude in which the Government will not fail. Wherever there is an Irishman throughout the world to-night I appeal to him to stand up for the rights of his motherland.

Our offer stands as before. We are prepared to take a fair court, a court in which the British choose two and we choose two, the fifth to be agreed upon. It will be hard enough to get such a court. We are not going to admit the principle that that court must be chosen from the part of the world that the British care to prescribe for us and we see no principle that should attach to it. They say we are members of one family. Be it so. Suppose we are. Are there not family quarrel that have to be resolved by submitting them to outside arbitration? Are there not occasions when families, so to speak, are so divided by members taking parts, that whatever might be said for settling the quarrel in the family might have to give way to the higher consideration that as all the members of the family were involved, it were much better to get, and there would be much more likelihood of getting, a fair decision from outside? I see no principle in the thing. I see no reason why the British should demand it. I see no reason why any member on the Opposition Benches should suggest that there is any principle in it that we should accept.

I know that members on the Opposition Benches on other occasions when such a court was proposed by the British would not have it. They would not have it in their case. Why do they want us to have it? One would think that there was agreement in the 1930 report and that these reports were something binding as if they had been a signed agreement. They have never been accepted even by members on the opposite benches as anything of that character. All the report said was that it was desirable in certain cases, even in certain classes of cases, that such should be the case but because a thing may in general be desirable, is there any reason why, when there are special circumstances, what might be desirable in general should not be departed from? I see no matter of principle in it, trying to look at it even from the British point of view of the thing. Assuming that we were members of one family, if there was a family quarrel, it might be said that it would be better not to bring the thing out in public and, whatever might be said, that it should be decided within the family circle. In general, that would be a good rule. I have no doubt that in general it would be a good rule, but I do not see that there is any principle in it in considering that there are certain cases, and this is one, in which it is desirable to go outside the circle. That is our decision and, as I said before, it is irrevocable. There is no use in raising false hopes about a matter of this kind. That decision— that we will not be restricted in choice of personnel—so far as this Government is concerned, is irrevocable. Our offer remains—a fair tribunal. If it is accepted, there need be no economic war. We do not desire an economic war. We do not want to stir up any of this bitterness. Bitterness is bound to result from any of these measures. I admit that. It is inevitable. We do not want to stir that up. But the alternative is to pay over that money and, believing that that money is not due by us, we do not intend to pay it. We will pay it when, and only when, a court that can be regarded as a fair court has decided that that money is due.

Comment on this

The President probably thinks that he has made something in the nature of a historic or, at least, a courageous speech. I regard the speech as hysterical and I genuinely regard the speech as cowardly. We could adopt that attitude, too. Apparently, patriotism in this country consists in always delivering ultimatums, taking up a fixed attitude, talking big and getting popular applause instead of settling down and trying to solve the details of government, which is much harder, much more humdrum but much more patriotic. Deputies on the opposite benches said that probably we were delighted that our prophecies had come true. Well, we are not delighted. If there is any man in this country at present who is delighted, that man is a fool. If there is any man belonging to any Party at this moment who is delighted or pleased for any reason, that man is a fool. We are not justified by what has happened. I shall put it in another way. I am afraid that the position that we are in now goes a very long way towards disgracing the country. I am afraid that the position we are in now goes a considerable distance to furnish evidence—I say "evidence"—for the view that used to be held, that this country is incapable of solving the complex, difficult, ordinary day-to-day problems that self-government involves. That is the position as I see it. I do not feel justified by the situation. No farmer feels justified by the situation. As I see the situation, I believe that if there was an average standard of patriotism, an average standard of understanding and common sense amongst the citizens of the country, of whatever brand of politics, this situation—the most dangerous situation that has occurred in this country since 1922—would never have arisen. That is my view on this question and I have no other.

I am not the smallest bit impressed with the President's histrionics to-night. I had suspected for some time that the President did not want any settlement. If that is so, it is a damnable thing. I am afraid that he is in the position of a man who walks into a hardware shop in a country town and asks for a tractor. He knows he will not get it. He knows that if he takes a spade he will have to dig, so he does not ask for that. I am afraid that the President is not without knowing that there is one slogan that is useful in the country. That is, "Unite behind me and fight the British." I ask the President is it the consciousness of that that is animating him to-night, or is it the real interests of the country? That is the big problem. I do not regard fighting the British without good and sufficient reason as good patriotism. I think this country is in much the same position as are most countries. Its economic position is getting worse. I think that position was far better three months ago. I doubt if the country is able to stand any serious quarrel at the moment. I am perfectly certain it cannot stand a big political fight and an economic fight at the same time. That is exactly what the President is heading for. He is trying to bring about two revolutions. He is doing that with his eyes open and he calls it patriotism. He is trying to bring about a political revolution, on the one hand, and an economic revolution, on the other hand. Does he not know that that cannot be done in present circumstances without the most terrible suffering, the most terrible dislocation and the most terrible loss to the people?

When the President appealed to the people to-night to stand firm, he reminded me very much of what used to be said in England during the Great War: "We will fight to the last Frenchman." Who is going to pay for all these histrionics? The honest man working down the country will pay. And I want to tell the President that that working man in the country is just as capable of making sacrifices as he ever was, or any member of his Party was. He is not going to talk to us on these benches, he is not going to talk to me about patriotism. I have, and we on these benches have, just as good a tradition of patriotism as he has. And we have no better tradition than the farmers and the rank and file throughout the country, who are going to pay for this and who will receive very little sympathy from President de Valera's histrionics.

I appeal to President de Valera to face up to this like a man and to start with the intention of coming to some settlement and making some agreement. Let him start from that point of view and take the chance afterwards that he will be able to do the ordinary, humdrum work of government. Let him give up the old view, "When in domestic difficulties make a foreign quarrel"—when you want to avoid difficulties at home about humdrum matters of government, when you want to avoid dealing with the ordinary requirements of the people, make a foreign quarrel and ask the country to unite behind you. That is a cowardly attitude, and no amount of histrionics will make it anything else than a cowardly attitude. I say that President de Valera has a chance at present that very few leaders had. He could settle the whole thing, and settle it on good terms. We are not in a position to settle it. He knows that. We did our work in our time. We got a certain distance. We took the consequences of our actions and we brought this country a long distance economically. You are in a position—if you are the man to take advantage of it—to make a great settlement for this country. You are in a stronger and in a better position to make a great settlement for this country than we are, if you couch your terms to enable you to do that. I tell you that the real patriotism is to drop your histrionics and get down to that.

We were told that the farmer is unable to pay. The point of view was also put forward that, after all, this may be a blessing in disguise? What may be a blessing in disguise? Am I listening to responsible men? The abandonment of a market which is worth £30,000,000 may be a blessing in disguise! On what basis or on what principle, could that be a blessing in disguise? I can understand the President of the Government wishing to change the economy of this country. While I do not agree with that policy in some respects, I ask: Why not do that and hold your market as well? It can be done. When, in times like these, a responsible member of the Government gets up and lightly says that the abandonment of a market worth £30,000,000 may be a blessing in disguise, I begin to despair of the country. I say that this man should not be in the Government, and I say that, with this attitude of the Government, there is a very poor look-out for the country. I cannot believe— there ought to be some business men in the Government, men who have some experience of dealing with affairs —that that is a settled, convinced conviction of the present Government. Look around at statesmen all over the world seeking markets everywhere. What would America give for a market which to her would be so big? What would England give for a market which to England would be so big? What would France, or any country that is trying to keep things going, trying to keep the social structure going, give for such a market, and here we are in this country alone adopting a totally different attitude and lightly talking in these times of being able to afford to drop a market worth £30,000,000, and saying that it is a blessing in disguise. I know the President suggested at one time "We will hold on and change the economy," but now that is all changed. "This may be a blessing in disguise"—I do not mind that from Deputy Corry, who half suggested it, but imagine that coming from the President of the country in this year and in these conditions.

Now we are told that they are going to make no ad misericordiam appeal to the English Government. They were not asked. We were told that it was stated from these benches that this financial matter is of no importance. Nothing of the kind was ever stated. It is an important question, of course. The payment of £5,000,000 is an important question. Of course, it is, but what was stated was that we declined to accept that the patriotism is all on one side. We entirely declined to accept it and it is a waste of time trying to put it up. We will not be put in that position. It may be, the President said, that the farmers are not able to pay. Other people went so far as to say that cattle are not paying now, but they did not know what they were talking about, because the one thing that is paying is a certain type of cattle. “Pigs are not paying, bacon, eggs, butter, nothing pays”— supposing I admitted that for the sake of argument. Will Deputies in this House face up to it properly? Supposing that was so in the year 1932, has not every country in Europe experience of the same thing? What is the experience of farmers in any ten years of history, or any fifteen years of history—any fifteen years you like to pick out, not to speak of fifteen years following a tremendous war? There are one, two or three years during which things do not pay, but the reaction comes, and the whole problem of good farming is to try to create a little reserve to carry you over and to take advantage of the come-up again. But these are the humdrum details that Deputies will not face up to and out of which they seek only to make political capital. There was no country in the world in such a good position—I say this quite honestly, believing it honestly—to weather the storm as the Irish Free State, and we were weathering the storm fairly well up to 1930, and the reactions of the world situation in Ireland up to 1930 were less even than these reactions were in any other country in the world because of our very economy, because of our production of live-stock and live-stock products and, more important still, because the economy of the country was based on the comparatively small farmer who had his own labour. They were able to pay the whole time, and some of them came out line-ball, and some, with hard work, were able to make a bit of money.

A whole lot of them did and I know it well. I know that there are solicitors, farmers and politicians, and a lot of these small farmers saved a bit of money, and, up to 1930, and into the early part of 1931, they were even, some of them, making a bit, and there were a lot with reserves. When did the rot set in?—the day the first manifesto was issued by President de Valera on the land annuities. That was a black day for this country. It is no use now for the President to say—this does not arise as between ourselves and the British—that he, unlike members of the Cumann na nGaedheal Party, told the farmers that they would have to pay. He did, officially, but, beyond yea or nay, every one of your back benchers, every one of your organisers and your agents, and you know it, went around the country telling the farmers in 1926, and from that on, "Vote for us and you need not pay your land annuities."

Comment on this
Fianna Fáil Deputies

No, no.

Comment on this
Mr. Hogan

Every one of them. What happened? There is a big percentage of these farmers bankrupt, or nearly bankrupt, now. Why? If a a man pays each year as his demand becomes due, he is all right, but let him get into two or three years' arrears, and, in bad times, he will never get out of them. That was the position you brought about by that campaign. That campaign was badly got in the beginning and it had terrible reactions upon the people. In my opinion, that end of it was even more demoralising than the Civil War. But, anyway, we have it now, and there are a great many farmers, as a result, who are not able to pay and who must get time. Deputy Maguire wanted to know what is our policy and have we got any. We know perfectly well that this in-changed the whole situation for us. We know perfectly well that this in-security and these moratoriums and this debate about land annuities, if it goes on for a considerable period, more and more farmers will be getting into the position where they cannot pay and, of course, we will have to face up to that, and, some day or another, it may very well be that President de Valera's patriotic policy may drive some Irish leader who has more courage and more patriotism and less vanity to make an ad misericordiam appeal somewhere.

Comment on this
Frank Aiken Minister for Defence (Mr. Aiken) Fianna Fáil

Deputy Hogan, in the course of his usual speech, said that the President was seeking to create a foreign war in order to save himself from getting down to humdrum, everyday affairs. Deputy Hogan has gone back to humdrum affairs for the last few months.

Comment on this
Mr. Hogan

He was always there.

Comment on this

And, seeing that there was not so much money in the small farmers' pocket as he used to talk about, and that prosperity was not down the country, he has been trying to create a situation here in which there will be a foreign war.

Comment on this
Mr. Hogan

Who is?

Comment on this

The only reason the British are doing this is because they think they see a set of Irishmen in this country who will oust Fianna Fáil and do the British work. If the Irish people were standing solidly behind the national Government in this instance, there would be no talk about the British putting on taxes or anything else. The British know perfectly well—those of them who are sensible —that if this policy goes on, it is not going to pay them. It may not pay us, but it certainly will not pay them. Deputy Hogan talks about the £30,000,000 market we have in England. What market has England here? If Deputy Hogan is an Irishman, why does he not talk as an Irishman? Where is this Irish Opposition we were to have? We have had nothing here, for the past couple of months, but a pro-British Opposition.

Comment on this
Mr. Hogan

Bunkum, cant!

Comment on this

And it is not going to work.

Comment on this
Mr. Hogan

That stunt will not work, either. That cock will not fight.

Comment on this

Cumann na nGaedheal will see that, if they are going to remain in the political life of this country, it will pay them, in future, to be an Irish Opposition. Deputy Cosgrave showed that in his speech, because he was a little bit more Irish in his opposition to-night than he has been for the last couple of months. He said that if this economic warfare goes on, it is not going to pay either country.

Comment on this
Mr. Hogan

Of course, it is not.

Comment on this

And I was delighted to hear that from him.

Comment on this
Mr. Hogan

Did the Minister not know that already?

Comment on this

I am delighted to hear that they are coming to be some little bit more Irish in their opposition.

Comment on this

Oh, dear! Thanks for nothing.

Comment on this

This may be a blessing in disguise. Deputy Hogan and everybody else who has been watching the British market year after year, can see that it is becoming the dumping ground for the agricultural produce of the nations of the earth and that as year follows year, we were finding it increasingly difficult to obtain, in the British market, a price that would enable us to cover the cost of production in this country. We were finding it increasingly difficult to sell, in the British market, goods which would enable us to pay for what we were importing, and, if this goes on, it will force us to produce here in the country a lot of the things that we have been importing, and that is going to hit England. It will force us to get alternative markets and that, again, will hit England.

Comment on this

Where are they?

Comment on this

It will force us to find them out. The administration that was in office for the last ten years was doing nothing but praising the one market and neglecting all the others in the world. The Opposition here talk about these tariffs that the British are going to impose. What are they going to amount to? The British say that they are going to amount to the £5,000,000 we are keeping and we are keeping the £5,000,000, so that we will be no worse off. As I say, it may be a blessing in disguise, but certainly the British will be the worse off. If we can get all parties in the Dáil and in the country to back the Government and to stand up to the British this country will be very much better off.

Comment on this

We have heard the Minister for Defence and the President. Such two speeches no Parliament has been ever called upon to listen to. It is time, at any rate, that some of those on the Front Bench got up to speak, as they can speak with authority. Previous to that they put up Deputies who knew nothing about the question and had no responsibility. I do not believe that this House, or any other House, was treated with such disrespect until the President interposed. It shows in what a light the Front Bench view the position of the people for the future. The Minister for Defence said that perhaps this may be a blessing in disguise. He has admitted anyway that the disguise is there and no one can see the blessing. He talked about being forced to find an alternative market. It is the Government's duty to find an alternative market, if such a thing exists in the world. They need not apologise to the House, or anybody else, for finding an alternative market. If there is such a thing, it is their duty to find it. Let them not make any apologies about it, if there is such a thing in the world. It is their duty to find it. This is not a babies' debating society.

Comment on this

It sounds like it.

Comment on this

Nobody but a fool or a baby would make such a suggestion. We are as Irish and as patriotic as you are. We have better names behind us than you have. We have names going back two or three thousand years in Ireland, while some of you cannot talk about more than ten years. We are prepared to make more real sacrifices than you are, and we have more to lose than most of you. The President said one thing that perhaps gives a ray of hope. He likened this position to a dispute amongst a family. Twice, I think, he used that phrase in describing the present crisis with our neighbours—that this was like a dispute amongst a family. Would it not be a good thing if they could settle it amongst themselves, he said, but if they could not, leave it to arbitration? I wish the President thought we were a family. I wish the President thought that the British Commonwealth of Nations was a family, and I wish he would try to behave as one of the family, and encourage his Ministers to behave as members of the family. He or his Ministers did not give much indication in recent months that they thought the Commonwealth of Nations was one family. Every opportunity they got they used it to show how contemptibly mean they could be to other members of the family. Running out of the French Legation was not bravery. Tearing down flags during the Congress was not bravery, and it was done under the President. The flags of every nation can fly here, but one of the family that he is talking about could not fly its flag here. We have seen to-night what I can only describe as the heroics of the mule. I want to deal with this annuity question alone. I shall not go into the question of police pensions or local loans. The President has put the matter in such a light that even at the risk of being called a traitor to my country and the national interest I am going as far as I can to take the lid off.

Comment on this

It is off.

Comment on this

I should think it is off. It has been said here to-night that the British are doing the thing we suggested—that everything we suggested or hinted at is being done. It is only two or three months since Deputy Kissane assured the people in Kerry that it was the English farmer who will have to bear the whole brunt of this. We refrained from mentioning this question of the annuities all the time.

Comment on this

Deputy Kissane still holds that view.

Comment on this

The Deputy and other Fianna Fáil Deputies thought it well to explain that it was the British farmers would bear this and that it would not hurt the Irish agricultural industry. We have been silent on the matter so as not to prejudice the position. If we said anything at all it was only a mere reference. What is the position? The President talks about the farmers not being able to pay. Who does he mean is not able to pay? There have been more Land Acts than one for this country. Land has been purchased under three or four British Land Acts and under two or three Irish Land Acts. Does he mean that only those farmers who purchased under the British Acts cannot pay? Has he any word to say about the people who purchased under the Irish Acts? Can they pay? Has he any idea of lightening their load? Not a bit in the world. The people who bought under the 1923 Act have to pay and the people who bought under later Acts have to pay. Some of them got untenanted land and have to pay a price for it that, considering the way markets have gone, is not at all justified, nor was it even justified when they got the land. It certainly is not justified now. They have to pay. How does the President make the case that only people who bought under British Acts cannot pay? Does he also make the case that people who bought under other Acts cannot pay? The President nods affirmation. He makes the same case for them. Very well. Let us get to another point. We assumed responsibility to the stockholders under the 1923 and subsequent Acts. Does the President accept that as a national liability? I am asking the President a plain question. The President nods affirmation. He does. He does not accept the operation of the previous Acts as a national liability. Why? Is it because another Government chose to operate Land Acts that are really a national matter?

Comment on this

Read up the case.

Comment on this

I will read it up before I am finished with you. Let us get on with it.

Comment on this

Talk first and read afterwards.

Comment on this

It may be good business for the President to interrupt and try to get me off the line, but he will not get me off. The President admits his liability for the Acts passed by this Dáil, but he accepts no liability otherwise. Where does the British liability come in? This is the thing I said I might be called a traitor for. Where does the British liability come in? If the British never introduced a Land Purchase Act, would you have refused to do it? No, of course you would not. You would have done as was done in 1923 and as was done in subsequent Acts and the whole liability would be yours. Because the previous Government here, urged on by the Party that represented the country, did something of that nature, you call it a British liability. I say it is your liability the same as the 1923 Act is your liability. They did your work; they acted as your book-keepers and guaranteed your stock. Their claim to pay is nil and your claim to pay is 100 per cent. They have no right to pay in any court; morally or otherwise they have no right. If I could get out of it, even though it is a just and moral debt, I would get out of it as quickly as you would get out of it. I have no more morality than you have and I have no more honesty than you have and the only thing preventing me from being as big a rogue as you are is that it is not good business.

Comment on this

Is not the Deputy supposed to address the Chair?

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Deputy should address the Chair.

Comment on this

Is it in order for the Deputy to describe the President as a rogue?

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

It is not.

Comment on this

I apologise, but I am afraid the idea is in the back of my mind all the time.

Comment on this

What about the lead pipes?

Comment on this

I have stated that if nothing had been done by our predecessors here the whole problem would be our problem and we would have to face it; either that or we would have confiscation—it would be either one or the other. If it were only a question of making a choice, I know there are some people who would have preferred confiscation and who would not have favoured purchase. I believe the majority of the people, if the question were put to them in 1920, would certainly have favoured purchase. I believe no statesman would have stood for anything but purchase. If the whole problem was left for us to deal with in our time this would be regarded as a national debt and the British would have nothing to say to it. The only shred of a claim that the President has in connection with this whole matter is the position of the Six Counties with regard to the annuities. I admit that there might be some arguing done from that point of view were it not for the financial settlement. Under the 1920 Act a present of the annuities was made to the Six County Parliament. If we had accepted the 1920 Act I daresay the same present would be made to this State by the British Treasury and it would be ours. That is the only shred of a claim on which the President can make a case. The financial settlement was made. The North of Ireland Parliament have assumed certain financial responsibilities. They were put on a different footing.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

I wonder whether the agreement to conclude this debate to-night stands?

Comment on this

I think so.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

There may possibly be two divisions and it is now 10.25 p.m.

Comment on this

The House generally understood, in view of the business before us to-morrow, that this debate would conclude to-night.

Comment on this

Is the debate to be concluded before 10.30?

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The question must be put before 10.30.

Comment on this

I have dealt with only one-third of the matter I intended to deal with.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Chair has no power to enforce the agreement. That matter will be left to the parties to the agreement.

Comment on this

Deputy Gorey will have another opportunity of speaking.

Comment on this

If the President says I will have another opportunity, I am prepared to sit down now.

Comment on this

Deputy Gorey can safely leave to the British the case he was making.

Comment on this

I am a damn sight more Irish than you are, Mr. Aiken.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Votes 49 and 56 were agreed to, and they will be reported. In regard to Vote 52, there is an amendment by Deputy Cosgrave proposing that the Estimate be referred back for reconsideration.

Comment on this
Division

Amendment put.

Tá 58
·
Níl 71
Result Lost The question put was not agreed to.

Do you agree with this result?