We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

Supplementary and Additional Estimates. - Vote No. 73—Emergency Fund Grant-in-Aid (Resumed).

Contributions 1–185 of 381. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

I think it was Deputy Cosgrave that referred to Communism yesterday. He made a statement that this was an effort at Communism and Deputy Fitzgerald said that we were being pushed and that the I.R.A. and other bodies in this country were pushing us. In so far as the communistic business is concerned I think that Deputy Cosgrave, when President, found that that argument was a failure. I do not think there is any progress to be made along those lines. There is nothing at all communistic in what is being done in the introduction of this Estimate. It is purely a precautionary measure. As far as being pushed by the I.R.A., or any other organisation here, the policy of the Government is not at all pushed by any organisation, but it is definitely being pushed by this nation. Ninety-five per cent. of the nation are definitely pushing this Government to do what we are doing now for them. They feel they have been deceived, and that, really, now is not the time that this should have been done, but that it should have been done previously.

We have to-day some pronouncements from, I think, Sir Thomas Inskip. He seems to have taken the place of others. He has made various pronouncements but much akin to the little whisperings you hear round about this country. Great men evidently think alike in these matters. He declared that President de Valera has rattled the sword; that the £5,000,000 was nothing and that if it was only a question of £5,000,000 he would settle immediately. Money is nothing at all to him. We know things are not as they were long ago. These statements made by that gentleman are not going to be accepted in this country in the way the British Government thinks they will be accepted, and in the way a number of people in England want them to be accepted. That means that, latterly, the English people are beginning to open their eyes to the facts, that they are now accepting the situation, and that they believe the steps which Sir Thomas and others took are not the steps that they would like to have been taken. As far as rattling the sword is concerned I honestly can see no indication whatever of any sword rattling.

This question of land annuities has been before the country since 1926. It has been reported in the newspapers. The big English newspapers had it. I take it that the intelligence department of the British Government would have been notified of the fact. This is not a question that cropped up yesterday. It is a question of long standing. In fact, I daresay the source of it was what took place previous to the Land Act, 1923. It is this sort of agreement that Mr. Thomas bases all his calculations on, which undoubtedly influenced the 1923 Land Act and all land measures since, and which, further than that, influenced our capacity to hold our own, as I said last night, in the British market. What took place after all that we heard here so many times? The ex-Minister for Industry and Commerce on many occasions explained to us the co-equality which we had, all the power which we had and all that sort of thing. Certainly we had all that sort of power until we tested it. The very moment that any attempt was made to take advantage of that power you found that you could not go on. Mr. Thomas may be right or he may be wrong, but certainly he is a responsible Minister of State and the official statements which he made in the British House of Commons do not indicate at all that the treatment which we are supposed to get is the same treatment as any of the rest of the colonies get. In fact, as far as his official statement is concerned we are not at all in the same position. We have no co-equality and he would not at all give us the same treatment as he gives the other colonies. What does he want? Has he made a mistake?

Now the question is that these five million pounds, according to another speaker, are nothing at all—that there is something else behind it. I believe that there ought to be something else behind it. I believe that there is something else behind it and I hope that there is, because there is one thing that I am satisfied about, and so is everybody in this House, and that is that the system that has been carried on in this country since 1922 is a system under which we could not continue to exist here. If we cannot get some way out of the difficulties, and if we cannot get some way out of the impossible marketing conditions under which we have had to live and to get our living, there is not any use in going on. There is not a bit of use in a man reading all these big figures about £30,000,000 or £35,000,000, the volume of our exports, and so on. The question is how do the individuals fare who made that sum. They fared extremely badly. They got no opportunity. In other words, they did not get a fair deal and they could not continue. The position to-day is that 85 per cent of them are practically out of action.

The policy of the British Government economically towards us is to a large extent the same policy which she adopts towards her other colonies as far as her economic policy is concerned. She has a teeming population, a great deal more than she will ever be capable of holding or feeding under the present conditions. Her policy towards the colonies is "you may grow cattle and produce fats and feeding stuffs for us and we will return you all the manufactures which you require." At any rate, that is a perfectly reasonable proposal until it comes to be examined, but there are people in those colonies who cannot be all engaged in agriculture. If there are, there are quite a number of them like the people here who do not care to be engaged in that industry without getting something for it. I think that nobody here will deny that we, as producers of agricultural products in this country have suffered loss—that no person practically in this country in the last nine years got paid for their work.

Comment on this

Bunkum!

Comment on this

There is no bunkum whatsoever about it. What have they been getting? Have the farmers' sons been getting wages?

Comment on this

How do they live?

Comment on this

You would not work for their wages.

Comment on this

I often did for less.

Comment on this

The result is, if the thing is examined, that we can come to the conclusion, I think, that as far as our agricultural industry is concerned, as far as paying wages is concerned, we employed more people in England and in Scotland in the distribution of our agricultural produce there than we employed or paid wages to people in this country to produce those products. That is the position. We could not continue, and I believe that in this country we must have an opportunity here, and that we must seize on the opportunity, of developing our industries and getting a proper balance. We must seize and develop the market that exists here for agricultural produce and, furthermore, I believe that we ought to try to find out what our markets are outside and develop them. To do that, we must buy from those markets. To do that, we must get, as far as possible, ships to come from those countries. If we get ships to come from those countries here, they will not always go away idle.

Comment on this

They will bring sand away!

Comment on this

Who will take our cattle?

Comment on this

They would be taken, until you stopped them three or four years ago.

Comment on this

There was a trade developed with France a few years ago, as Deputy Hogan well knows.

Comment on this

For strippers, say.

Comment on this

It does not matter a jot. It is the strippers that count, and you know it quite well. As far as that matter is concerned, that trade was developed, and what took place was that they could not ship the cattle because the Board of Trade said that the boat was not right and it must be re-modelled.

Comment on this

They could not ship the cattle because they could not get the right prices.

Comment on this

You would not make the agreement. I can produce proof.

Comment on this

At any cost, as far as the price being right is concerned, is the price in the British market right? Has it been right for the past number of years? We are exporting the cattle at a loss.

Comment on this

I would like the price to be twice as much.

Comment on this

You would have to get it if you were to continue.

Comment on this

This is the great cattle trade of Meath talking nonsense of that sort!

Comment on this

There is no nonsense about it. The cattle trade could not continue at a loss, and it has been going on at a loss. There was a good deal of contribution towards that loss. It was not all the fault of the English.

Comment on this

The Sassenach, I suppose!

Comment on this

It was not all the fault of the English market or their attitude there.

Comment on this

This is interesting!

Comment on this

Does Deputy Anthony want to say anything?

Comment on this

Merely that it is a very interesting conversation!

Comment on this

I am sorry to interrupt him. I thought the Deputy might want to say something. As far as that is concerned, it was not the British market that caused all the damage. Quite a number of restrictions, and rules and regulations, imposed by the Department of Agriculture, caused a lot of the dislocation here. Is not that right?

The Government in power at the time told the British people: "Look here, you know nothing at all about what you want. We know all about it. We will see that you will get the right article and this is the right article for you." The farmers here were told: "You know nothing at all about this business of cattle breeding but we know all about it. We will put restrictions on you and we will do away with these scrub bulls." What is the result? We are supposed to have improved the breed of cattle going to the British market and for the last nine years in Dublin market—it may be through hunger—there are more cattle tied to the rails at 12 o'clock, 1 o'clock and 2 o'clock in the day unfit for anything than there have been in any period in the past. Nobody will deny that. Those were the developments. The same thing occurred with butter and every time that we obeyed the legislation passed here, all we got was a lower price. Every effort that was made to improve the quality of the article resulted in a loss. That is the record, and the fundamental part of it, taking production into account, is that under the 1923 Land Act we were paying at least three times more in rent than could possibly be met.

That is a good deal off the question at issue. To return to the question at issue, Mr. Baldwin talking on the Free State and what she paid out, on more than one occasion, gave it as his opinion that this country paid more out of its income to other countries than any country he knew of. How did he arrive at that? He knew perfectly well that we could not continue to pay these five millions that we were paying. It is quite true that, when this agreement was signed, monetary conditions were quite different from what they are to-day. It is quite true that, in 1926, the gold standard had been adopted in England and hopes were high that the world would have changed completely and that economic conditions would have been different. I admit that that is one excuse that could reasonably be put forward for the signing of such an agreement as was signed at that time. But what happened? It was found that the gold standard was unsuitable and there was another change. We got on to what they now call the sterling or paper standard. All the time markets were dropping. The value of produce was dropping, as it had to drop. I do not think that at any time we could agree that meat should be kept up at 1/- or 1/2 a lb. to the consumer. I do not think that that was possible and most people knew that the fall would take place and that it was inevitable that the price of meat would come down to what it was pre-war. There was no thought of anything like this so far as the then Executive Council was concerned. They signed a fixed, hard and fast agreement which, to-day, everybody, I think, no matter what the moral or legal obligation is, agrees should not have been made. We are not making this case because we know that we have a definite legal case to make and because we know that there is a moral case to make and because we are absolutely satisfied that that sum of money cannot be met, just as they are satisfied across the water.

Deputy Gorey yesterday spoke about 500,000 cattle having to be sold between this and November. That is the case. The figure would be in or about 400,000 or 500,000 but it would certainly be less than last year. These cattle, or a great portion of them, at least, have to be marketed— whatever portion of them is fat cattle undoubtedly have to be marketed—and that is one of the reasons why this measure was introduced so that we would have it to assist marketing that quantity of cattle. It may, however, be that it will not be necessary to market that quantity of cattle. We have, as I said last night, an enormous amount of hay in this country that will have no market——

Comment on this

Keep them fat.

Comment on this
Mr. O'Reilly

They are not all fat.

Comment on this

The ones that are fat —keep them fat.

Comment on this
Mr. O'Reilly

It takes quite a long time to fatten these cattle, and, if we are taught a lesson now, and, by some means or another, keep the cattle long enough to fatten them, we will find that there is benefit in it, and the Scotsman will find to his loss that we have discovered that fact and found a way of doing what he does otherwise. We have very few fat cattle in this country. The Dublin market would not have 100 such cattle at its best market. The rest are common stores, and I do not suppose that I ever saw 100 fat cattle in the Dublin market at any time.

Comment on this

And the Deputy is going to finish them.

Comment on this

May I ask the Deputy a question. Are fat cattle not unsaleable at the present time? The people want lean meat. Deputies may laugh but it is the truth. I speak from experience.

Comment on this
Mr. O'Reilly

I quite agree with the Deputy. He is perfectly right. There is a trade and always was in Lancashire for them. The cotton spinners and others were not able to eat fat meat and they had to get lean meat and there was a big trade around there for that purpose.

Comment on this

Deputy Gorey can sleep in peace.

Comment on this

I am not sleeping in peace on the Deputy's hay for the winter.

Comment on this
Mr. O'Reilly

Deputy Fitzgerald, I understand, yesterday, in addition to talking about the I.R.A., spoke about certain steps the farmers were taking not to pay bank debts. He said that some organisation was developed here with that avowed object. I have not read of any organisation of that description nor have I heard of any such one. I did hear of an organisation, which does not intend to repudiate debts, but which holds that it will pay the debts it can pay and that these debts should be reduced—I understand this is what they state—to the point at which they can be met. That point brings us down to the whole situation that we have here. We have not been able, for the last nine years, to meet any of the liabilities that were imposed on us, so far as land annuities or other payments were concerned.

We have not been able to pay for goods purchased abroad. Anyone who goes to the country and speaks to shopkeepers will be told quite plainly that they have enormous debts outstanding, and they have very little hope of recovering them, certainly not in the near future. These people are being forced into the position that they cannot meet their debts to distributors here, or, perhaps, in England. That indicates definitely that we are not able, out of our agricultural production and out of our exports, to pay for what we are buying. I hope that, as a result of the position we are in, we will be able to rectify that state of affairs. If so, it will have brought salvation to this country. I think Deputy Hogan stated that we could get a really good settlement now—a damn good settlement.

Comment on this
Mr. Hogan

I did not say even "a really good one."

Comment on this
Mr. O'Reilly

What was wrong that you did not have a try before?

Comment on this
Mr. Hogan

I will tell you if you give me a chance.

Comment on this
Mr. O'Reilly

There must be something very seriously wrong when you did not get the opportunity. There was a good opportunity of making a bargain but the Party opposite did not make an attempt. Any attempt that was made was a fiasco. The attempts that were made have been the cause of all the misfortune and of the supposed crisis that exists now. We have Lord Inskip and others trying to take all the advantage they can out of it. This is not an economic question! It is a political question purely! As far as we are concerned the question is an economic one. We must be able to get a living in this country, but the debts we pay must be debts that we are definitely satisfied we owe, and not debts about which there is any doubt. That is the question at issue and the sooner the British nation and the British Government realise that position properly the better by taking the necessary steps to see that those debts are properly proved. If they satisfy us in any suitable court that those debts are due they will be paid. If they do not take such steps then, as far as I am concerned, I certainly would not agree that these debts should be paid.

Comment on this

Deputy Gorey has handed me a note which in view of Deputy O'Reilly's speech I will read to the Dáil. "The farmers—ninety per cent. of them— are behind the Government, and are ready to pay tariffs, annuities, debts, subsidies, twenty-nine million pounds odd, plus two million pounds in the present Vote, plus British imposts, plus loss of goodwill, plus loss of preference and to fatten their cattle on O'Reilly's hay and get nothing back." I think that is a fair statement of the Deputy's speech. I did not intend to refer to Deputy O'Reilly. I must say that he talked with the authentic pose of the weakling, of the variety that you find in this country. When I listened to him, the amiable old gentleman, and the junior grade economics of Senator Connolly, I realised that that is the sort of information behind President de Valera. They are his advisers. I read Who's Who recently, and I found that Deputy O'Reilly was supposed to be an expert on agriculture, that he had a certain amount of expert knowledge of agriculture. When one realises that President de Valera—who knows nothing about the cattle trade, and literally nothing about any other business in the country—has to listen to Deputy O'Reilly on agriculture and to Senator Connolly's junior grade economics on the general economy of the country, I do not wonder we are in the present position. I do not propose to follow that very far, nor do I propose to follow Deputy Flinn, who made an attempt to make a case for the Government last night. I only want to say about Deputy Flinn that he is a humbug, he is a windbag, he is a cheap-jack who would sell any goods, Cumann na nGaedheal, Fianna Fail or Labour, provided he got into position. I have more respect for Deputy Corry, far more respect.

Comment on this

I can assure the Deputy I must examine my conscience.

Comment on this
Mr. Hogan

Would the President address himself to a few simple points which emerged from the debate and which are very relevant. We were told by the President, and certainly by Senator Connolly, that the game of the British is clear. He said that they want to put out the present Government and that they will then be able to make a settlement with some other Government, the other Government obviously being a Government from the Cumann na nGaedheal Party. Personally I do not think that is so with the British. I will tell you why. It would suit the British better to make a settlement with the present Government. I am not going to make any political point of this. The Cumann na nGaedheal Party speaks for a certain section in the country and always did speak for it. The present Government speaks for another section. We have said our say. We have made agreements. We have delivered the goods so far as the British are concerned. It would suit the British Government better to make an agreement with the present Government. I am not saying now whether they are right or wrong but, clearly in their opinion a settlement now would be more lasting in the sense that they would have got a new body of people here to make a settlement with. The present Government would be speaking for a different class. If I were in the inside counsels of the British Government, which, strange to say, I am not—but I can look on and I can use my commonsense—I say in my opinion it is perfectly obvious that it would suit the British Government better to make a settlement now than with another Government. I have no doubt the British would like to see this Government out unless it makes an agreement, because to realise this, it is really in a crisis like this you talk truth to the country.

It is not in the interests of the British Government that this quarrel should go on, and for that reason the British Government are anxious to make a settlement. Equally for that reason, if you are unwilling to make any settlement, naturally the British Government wants to see you out. I want the President to get down to the point—and the country should be told this—that in a great many matters the interests of the British and our interests are the same. In this matter the interests of the British and our interests are the same. It is the interests of the British to trade with us. It is even of greater interest to us to trade with them and, at this stage, when we are entering into a quarrel that is going to have such serious effects, the country should be told that. All the silly pseudo patriotic platitudes should be dropped, on the lines that anything that the British do not like is good business for us. Their interests and our interests more or less mean the same thing. Is that right— perfectly right?

Of course it is right and perfectly right. Why does not the President get his back-Benchers down to the country to tell the people that? Then if that is right why raise up the green flag to fight England, leaving the people to the assumption that a fight with England is always good business for Ireland? The question for this country is not whether this economic war would injure England. The question is what are our best interests in this doubtedly our best interests in this matter are to end this quarrel. Put it in that way and it does not matter what the British think. Everyone knows without being in the pay of the British Government that the British Government wants to trade with this country. That is the very thing that the President should appreciate in this matter. There was a reference to Sir Thomas Inskip, the British Attorney-General. His pronouncements are important because he is a member of the British Government and the British Government are used to negotiate. The British Government could buy and sell the best of us. They have been a long time in the job.

Comment on this

They bought you.

Comment on this
Mr. Hogan

Is the President losing his temper? They did not buy us in the sense that he means. He knows what I mean. The British Government are efficient and disciplined, which, unfortunately, we are not. They know how to get things done, and when Sir Thomas Inskip speaks he is to be taken seriously. Sir Thomas Inskip has made a statement which, if the President likes to make use of, as a basis of business, he can make good use of. I am not one of those who think that you are going to make any use of that statement to get £5,000,000. I am not one of those who think that you are going to get anything like £5,000,000 under any circumstances. I am not one of those who think that there is anything soft for any country in the present situation.

I think we are in the same position as individuals in each country. There is no soft living, there is no soft money anywhere. I do not think at all myself that there is anything like £5,000,000 going to be got. I do not think Sir Thomas Inskip said there was. I think we would be foolish to count too far in that direction, but I do think that a settlement of this dispute could be made if you drop political humbug. Perhaps I should not say political humbug. Perhaps the President thinks it is not political humbug. Perhaps he thinks it is a fight. Very well, if he does let him tell the country that. Let him tell the country "I will not settle this question of the land annuities on the basis of this money. I must have a settlement of the Oath question. I must have my views of the Treaty accepted by the British. We have to gain concessions." Let him tell the country that. Let the country face up to that issue knowing what it is they are facing up to. If the country is willing to face up to that issue; if it is willing to look to France for markets for its butter, for its eggs, its bacon and its strippers let it do it. That is not what he is doing.

The country is asked to go into this quarrel on the basis that it is purely a quarrel about money, whereas everybody knows that the quarrel is on a totally different issue and on a totally different basis. That is what I complain of. The country is being deceived and I want to tell the President then whether he agrees with our point of view or not, the mere fact that it is in the English interest to settle this quarrel does not preclude the truth of what I have to say now, and that it is that it is in our interests also. I say that whether he agrees with it or not. We say that in the present situation it is perfectly clear from the attitude of the other side, namely, the British, that if the President confines himself to the financial side he can get a settlement, but if he insists on introducing political matters which the British regard as very much higher political issues he cannot get a settlement. Let him deny that if he wishes. Let him say that he represents people in this country who must have concessions; that it is absolutely essential to establish a republic here; but if he wants to do that he should let the country know that that is the issue and that that is what he is doing.

We are told that in any event at the present moment the farmers of the country are unable to pay this money and that for the last nine years they have made no money. We are told that the British markets are worthless to them. We are told that there were no profits in selling cattle or in selling any agricultural produce on that market. We are told that this economic war is a blessing in disguise. We are asked why if a settlement can be made now did not the Cumann na nGaedheal Government make it? I will tell the President why. What settlement were we supposed to make? A settlement under which we meant to hold the annuities? We made an exact opposite settlement. We made an agreement under which we were to pay the annuities. That was the agreement we made. Start with that. We made that agreement in consideration of this country being relieved from a share in the British war debt, in the United Kingdom war debt. That is the settlement we made. We put this country in 1926 in a position in which no European country was put. This country had been committed to the Great War by at least as good an Irishman as the man who now leads the majority Party in this State. He was at least as good a man as that. This country in 1926 was relieved of all liability for the war debt and all liability in respect of the British National Debt. In consideration of that we agreed to pay the annuities. It was a first-class bargain and there is no question of doubt whatever about it. If it was not a first-class bargain, then what have we to say of the position of every other country in the world? Every country in Europe, and not only France, Germany and England, but all the countries that kept their territorial integrity after the Great War, have their war debts. All the countries such as Czecho-Slovaki, Jugo-Slavia, and all the new countries that emerged after the Great War, had every single one of them to take over a share of the national debt which was owing by the countries of which they came.

We put this country in a different position. If there is any tendency to smile at that proposition now and it is countenanced to-day in any way, I want to tell the President that so far as that is genuine it is due to the belief in this country that we are a soft people and incapable of standing up to the strain and the stress that other people have to stand up to. We could never make a bargain like first-class countries; we can never be a first-class country unless we are prepared in open competition in the world to shoulder the burdens of independence and liberty. We must be prepared to do that and if there is any tendency now to smile at that, that tendency is decadent. But why go back on it? We got so much; and now it is clear that the present Government are in a position to get a bit more. They are in a position to get a little bit more because there is no doubt about it in order to gain the goodwill of the electorate for whom the Deputies on the opposite side speak, the British Government would be prepared to give certain concessions. The whole question is now whether the President is willing to accept that genuinely and to try to obtain these concessions or whether he tries to make it impossible to obtain these concessions by raising other difficulties apart altogether from the issues which have any interest for the farmer, the labourer, or for the trade of this country. We are told that at the moment the farmers are unable to pay. Deputy O'Reilly stated that the farmers were unable to make a profit out of their agricultural exports for the last ten years. I think it was Deputy Cleary who said that the present Government took over a legacy of arrears of land purchase annuities.

We are told that the present situation is the fault of the last Government. I am exactly of the same opinion to-day as I was before the election with regard to the land annuities. I am entirely convinced that there is no legal case; that whether or not there is a legal case is a consideration that does not enter into British calculations. That there is no legal case, I am quite convinced. Further, I am entirely convinced that if the President persists on his present line of keeping up the pretence that there is a legal case, he is in the position of a client who might come to me as a solicitor and who might say: "I got a certain sum of money and I agreed to repay it. I signed an agreement to that effect. There is no question that the agreement was signed to that effect, but I believe the agreement is faulty in law and I want to get out of it." His position is exactly similar to that if he pursues his present line of policy. My answer to a client who would make that case to me would be the answer of any honest man or any Britisher. My answer would be: "If there is a legal flaw in the agreement, far from it being your right to take advantage of it, it is your duty to mend it."

If the Government adopt that basis there is no hope. On that basis, this country will be put in the position of endeavouring to bring off a piece of sharp practice. I do not care what the President says. I believe the lawyers have done their job. They have confused the electorate and that was what they were meant to do. I believe the President knows very well there is no legal case. I believe that is the reason he tacks on to this legal case what he calls a moral case. He refers to the way the landlords got their land. The history of British confiscation in this country has nothing whatever to do with the legalities or the moralities so far as they exist at the present day. The farmers are in arrears now. The big percentage of the farmers are in arrears and are in a very bad position financially. Who is to blame?

Comment on this
Mr. Hogan

I say this is a campaign that is deliberately organised. First of all, we had Peadar O'Donnell. Everyone knows the man or heard of him. What he said was taken up by President de Valera in 1926. I say it is nothing short of the most arrant humbug, cant, and hypocrisy for Deputies on the opposite benches to deny what everybody knows—that at every cross-roads in the country they told the farmers: "Vote for us and you will not have to pay your annuities." I heard that half-a-dozen times and there is not a Deputy on these benches who did not hear it.

Comment on this

Never.

Comment on this
Mr. Hogan

Denials after the event will not save the situation. In the face of that it is nothing short of sancti-monious and almost nauseating cant for the President to advise us the other day to practise the simple virtues and pay our way. Our policy for the last ten years could be summed up in the one sentence: "Work hard and pay your way." So far as the Fianna Fáil propaganda got—it is the most damnable propaganda and it will take centuries for the country to recover from it—to the electorate, it ended up in one thing—"Do not work and do not pay". The election took place last March and immediately after the election a very significant thing occurred in my constituency. I am a solicitor and a farmer. I was Minister for Agriculture and I knew what was happening in the country. In my constituency, after the election, Civil Bills were issued wholesale for arrears of land purchase annuities. Out of every 100 Civil Bills issued, at least 99 of them went to the people who supported this Government.

Comment on this

Nonsense.

Comment on this
Mr. Hogan

Was that an accident? That is the state to which you have reduced this country. Deputies went round to the country cross-roads and said to the people "Vote for us and it will end up in this way—you will not have to pay the annuities." President de Valera allowed that to go on.

Comment on this

That same statement was made here three times yesterday and it is repeated to-day.

Comment on this
Mr. Hogan

You said it a thousand times publicly and privately.

Comment on this

The statement is untrue.

Comment on this
Mr. Hogan

Sit down.

Comment on this

What did Deputy Corry tell the Cork County Council?

Comment on this
Mr. Hogan

I would expect a lot from the Party opposite in the way of denial, but to deny a thing at this stage is simply preposterous.

Comment on this

The Deputy made a definite statement.

Comment on this
Mr. Hogan

I will not withdraw it.

Comment on this

The Deputy said I made that statement down the country. That is untrue and I call for the withdrawal of that remark.

Comment on this
Mr. Hogan

I will not withdraw it.

Comment on this

Then all I can say is that the Deputy is a damned liar.

Comment on this
Mr. Hogan

Sit down. Personally, I would prefer the attitude adopted by the Deputies who told the farmers that at the cross-roads than I would the attitude adopted by President de Valera. I much prefer the man who throws the balls than the man who makes them. The President makes the balls. That is his line since 1922 and I am a close observer of his career. President de Valera knew perfectly well that even his own statements could be interpreted in no other way than that the farmers need not pay. He is a fair judge of politics and a fair judge of psychology—he has proved that—and he knew perfectly well when he told the people "We will not transfer the annuities to the British; we will give them back to you in the shape of relief of rates, etc.," that the hard-headed farmers interpreted it only in this way:—Once you withhold these annuities from the British there is absolutely no case for collecting them from us. He knew his own statement would be interpreted in that way, but in order to make it absolutely certain he allowed practically every member of his Party to declare expressly to the farmers that they need not pay the annuities. That is the difficulty we are in.

We have no case on the land annuities. Every time I addressed myself to this question before the election I always made the point that we could make a case—it is the case he is making now, so far as he can make any case, and that is the case with which the British will deal—that there has been over-taxation of this country. The case could be made that the country is unable to pay and that there has been over-taxation of the country. If you can get the British to agree on that—and it looks as if they would agree on that—there is no difficulty in getting them to agree to liquidate whatever debt there may be by taking over a liability for a certain share of the land purchase annuities. That would be an honest course and it would be consistent with the high national tradition of this country. But that course was not adopted. They very discreditable course was taken that has landed us in our present difficulties. The course was taken that will probably land a big proportion of the farmers in financial difficulties. Already it has landed some of them in financial difficulties. It is untrue to say that farming did not pay during the last nine years.

Farming, of course, did not pay as well after the war as during the war. Farming did not pay as well in 1926 as in 1924. It did not pay as well in 1930 as in 1926. It paid worse in 1931 than in 1930. But if there was a fall in prices here, there was a similar, or even greater fall in other countries. Some farmers had built up a certain amount of reserves during the war. There were many small farmers with their own labour making a bit of money up to 1929 and 1930 who were in a position to face the really bad years that looked like coming in 1930 and 1931, but they were to a certain extent demoralised. In other countries, such as England and France, which are the two notable countries, you had all parties trying to keep the people honest and at work; trying to get the people to pay their debts as they accrued due, knowing perfectly well that it was a bad policy to put them off; that money would become more scarce and more valuable later on. You had all parties in these countries endeavouring to do that. The one notable exception was this country. The attitude of the Party opposite was undoubtedly a wrecking attitude. Their attitude was to demoralise the country, to endeavour to prevent the people from paying their debts, to endeavour to prevent them from working. If there is at present the very serious financial situation in this country, it is a legacy not of the last Government, but of the damnable propaganda that was carried on by Fianna Fáil under the patronage, and with the consent of President de Valera during the last four or five years.

Let us leave that behind us, however. Let us come back to the present quarrel and face up to it. Is it not perfectly clear that you can make a settlement? I think it is. I think there is nothing more clear in the situation. For the moment, blame us, say we are traitors and failed to make it the last time. Take that line. We will accept that rôle. Brand us in that way and finish with it. You are the Government now. It is perfectly clear you can make a settlement. Why not make it? Why should the country be asked to suffer all these sacrifices. For what? The country should know it. Here we are now with an Estimate for two millions to meet the present emergency and we are not told how it is to be spent. When we ask how it is going to be spent we can get no answer. We are told it is to find new markets. Even Deputy O'Reilly realises that no new markets can be found that will absorb like one-tenth of our agricultural produce. We are told it is to be used to build up new industries. Is it not perfectly clear that the Executive Council have no plans? They have rushed us into what they call this economic war without any plans. Has the President any prospect of finding any alternative markets? Do not get away with the line that it is a shocking state of affairs that there are no alternative markets. Will he tell the country that there is any prospect whatever of any other alternative market, either here or abroad, during the next five or six years? If there is not, what are we going to do with the £30,000,000 export able surplus? He ought to address himself to that.

The Minister for Posts and Telegraphs tells us that we will win the fight if the people do not let the Government down. What does that mean? This is an economic war. Who are the soldiers? The farmers, traders, shopkeepers and labourers. They are in the front line trenches. They are doing the fighting this time. If they do not let the politicians down we are going to win the fight. What is the meaning of that? They are thrown into this fight without any plans, without any ammunition, without any help, without any prospect of success. This two millions is not ammunition. The loss to the country will run into twenty, thirty, forty, or fifty millions. They are thrown into the fight in that way, without any plans; into a fight that, if it continues, is absolutely hopeless from their point of view. Then, they are told that if they do not stand the massacre they will be letting down the Minister for Posts and Telegraphs. What is the meaning of the whole thing? Does the President want to settle? I put this to him: Even assuming he has a legal case—he will agree that it is doubtful—there are two sides to it. Suppose any business man consults a solicitor on a case which is doubtful. If the solicitor knows that while the litigation is going on the man is going to suffer tremendous financial loss on a very doubtful issue, what advice should he give him? I want to put this straight to the President. If he is the sort of man who wants to shelter behind the verdict of some judge and come back to his client afterwards and say: "What more could I do? The judgment went against us," he will tell him to go on. If he has the real interests of his client at heart he will tell him to settle if he can get a fair settlement. Is not that the present position?

If the President forgets his own reputation, forgets the impossible commitments he has made; if he thinks of the real interests of the country at this moment; a country that is bound to suffer, and that cannot win this war in the long run, even if he gets all the annuities, because the loss would be too great; if he thinks of the nation as made up of farmers, labourers and people of one kind or another, all trying to carry on and pay their way— if he thinks in that way there can be no doubt whatever that his duty is quite clear. Let him forget all the decadents and neurotics, all the work-shys, who cheer him at Dun Laoghaire because he has not settled, who do not want a settlement, who believe in failure, who want the political and economic agitation to go on for ever until this unfortunate country is bled white. There are many of them in this country, though they would not admit it. Let him forget them. Let him remember the example we gave them when we negotiated with the British. We could have thought also of who would meet us at Dun Laoghaire. We could have thought of your propaganda outside. We could have thought that we would be put in the wrong by every organisation which was hostile to us; that it would be pointed out that we surrendered to the British; that we made an agreement; that we were seduced by hospitality or by rubbing shoulders with people in silk hats. We could have thought of all that. We could have earned the plaudits of the neurotics who travel from Dun Laoghaire to the gallery of this House occasionally. We could have done all that. We could have funked it but we did not do it. We got good solid advantages for the country. We took responsibility for getting them and stood up to the criticism. We brought the country forward and we made not only a State of it, but we made a nation of it by what we did—for the first time a homogeneous nation. You quote Tone. I do not think an awful lot about Tone. I often heard the quotation "Not Protestant or Catholic but Irishmen." That is what we did in this country, and we were the first to do it. We went very nearly making —I was going to say a nation of the country. Do not undo all that work. You can make a settlement now. If you think more of your duty to the people who work hard, and less of your own reputation, less of your commitments, if you forget the idea that English interests are always opposed to Irish interests and vice versa, if you take advantage of the fact that the English are anxious to settle, a good settlement can be made. I do not say that five millions can be obtained, but the possibility is there and it should be explored. Then you can go to the country with added prestige. You will get a big prestige and a big satisfaction in the country for making such a settlement, for saving the country a big sum of money in bad times. Do not mind who are responsible for them or what is causing them. You can go to the country after that. If you do that this country can progress in the only way in which any country can progress. It can progress in peace and harmony towards whatever goal the majority of the people want it to proceed to.

Comment on this

I do not suppose that any member of the House is going to vote against this Emergency Fund grant but we are all anxious to hear from the President what he is going to do with this £2,000,000. Deputy Hogan spoke of the President making balls for his back benches to fire. I want to suggest that in the making and the firing of the balls it is the common people of the country who are going to suffer. It would appear to any casual observer in this country that the ordinary working class people have not been taken into consideration in what I can only look upon as a war of attrition between the two countries. Has the President got a mandate from the ordinary working class people? I do not refer to the work-shys although I do know they form the vast majority of his followers in the cities and the country. The work-shys and the ne'er-do-wells form the vast majority of his followers, particularly in the cities. I recollect in my school days reading of Pandora's box, from which, when it flew open, everything flew out except hope. To-day I think in President de Valera's box even hope has nearly gone. What are we going to offer the people of this country in this war of attrition between this country and England? I again put the question: who are to suffer in this war of attrition but the common people of the country and many of these people are not making themselves vocal to-day. I do hope they will make themselves vocal to-day. The people never gave the President a mandate to make the people endure, to endure more than what they have already suffered.

I ask is it the function only of our people to suffer and endure? Enduring and suffering have been the lot of the Irish people for many years. I, representing a city which gave birth to Terence MacSwiney, have regard for endurance and suffering when it is done in a good cause but I do feel that this generation of Irishmen and women have suffered quite enough and that they should not be called upon to endure and suffer further. I listened carefully to the rather laboured address of Deputy O'Reilly here to-day for over an hour, and if his arguments are the arguments of his Party, if this is the policy which his Government proposes to adopt and which it is adopting, then I say in all sincerity, "May God save Ireland." I look upon this vote as a war chest if you like and I am wondering how long it will be before the President comes back to the House again and asks us to give him another two million on account. Again, I would ask the President where is all this money to come from. The ordinary working class people will be taxed on their tea, their sugar and everything that enters into the life of the working class. Almost every commodity will be taxed in order to gratify the ambitions and to satisfy the spites and the malice of some important, if rather malignant, people in this country. I am personally aware that it is because of the spite and the malice of some people who wield a very definite interest in this country and are the strongest supporters of President de Valera to-day. Is that the lesson we have been taught during the Eucharistic week? Is that the true Christian spirit which we are all taught to regard as something to be aimed at?

I state here very specifically and openly that much of this agitation is the product of the malice and spite of certain individuals in this country, who wield a very bad and insidious influence in the Councils of State at the present moment. I have no hesitation in making that statement. Some of them were conscripted by Britain and because of that this country is going to be thrown into the maelstrom of an economic war with Great Britain. Are we going to be sacrificed because of the hatred and malice of these people? Is it because there are people on the Front Bench who have a grudge against the late Minister for Finance because, forsooth, he did not treat them courteously when they went to visit him? Is it because of this the honest working class of this country are going to be made suffer? I would ask the President to give us some information as to how he proposes to wage this economic war with England.

It might, perhaps, be illuminating if I related just one incident that occurred to me within the last two or three weeks. In speaking of the present economic position brought about by the breakdown in the negotiations. I heard a gentleman say that now we would have plenty of cheap food for the people. That doctrine has been preached by members of Fianna Fáil at all the crossroads of the country. I am told that potatoes can be bought at 4d. per 28lbs., fat hoggets at 20/-each, young pigs at 10/- or 12/- each. And we are going to have plenty of good food cheaply! I put myself in the position of John Farmer, or to be quite up-to-date, Seán Farmer. I ask myself how long do these people think that I, Seán Farmer, am going to produce pigs, sheep and cows and give it to them well under the cost of production? I ask any Deputy here is it not his experience that that mentality is abroad in the country, fostered by Fianna Fáil Deputies at the crossroads? I want to ask them to be honest with the people, if it would not be asking too much, and to let the people know where they stand in this matter. Is Seán Farmer going to continue to produce for Seán Citizen bacon, beef, pork, eggs, etc., under the cost of production? I want to know what the reaction of Seán Farmer will be, unless, of course, we use compulsion, or that blessed word coercion, which was so much abhorred by the present Government when they were in Opposition? Unless Sean Farmer is coerced to produce foodstuffs for our people and to give them foodstuffs under the cost of production, what is going to happen the people of the country?

We are told that we have plenty of beef, mutton, pork and so on. But is not the natural reaction to the state of affairs I have related that Seán Farmer is going to go into business for himself and himself only. He will produce what will satisfy his own wants and needs and no more. In this war of attrition, I ask President de Valera to weigh up seriously all the consequences and not have so much regard for the cheering, thoughtless multitude. The farmer was told that he need not pay any annuities. Then he was told that he should pay the annuities but that they would be kept in this country and used for the purpose of full de-rating. I feel that the doctrines preached in this regard will have a very bad, lasting effect on political morality here. They will make it impossible for any future Government to govern or to recover these annuities. I suggest, more ironically than seriously, that Fianna Fáil instead of having as its motto "Do not pay the land annuities" should choose the motto "Do not pay anybody." There is more morality behind that than there is behind the cry of "Do not pay the land annuities." The ordinary citizen can make just as good a case as the farmer for not paying his rent. It must be the experience of many Deputies that their incomes have decreased within the last ten or fifteen years. I know that that is so in my own case. I could make a very good case for the non-payment of my rent and the non-payment of my debts—the same case as can be made for the farmer. Many other people could show that their revenue has been decreasing within the last few years and they could urge that that connotes bad times, reduced purchasing power and all the other things that have been mentioned. That argument could be used in favour of Seán Citizen. I suggest very seriously—not ironically this time—to Fianna Fáil that they should go the whole hog for a wiping out of debts all round. I believe that would be a very good thing. Let us have a clean slate all round. I should like to go back with a message of hope— perhaps it would be suggested that it comes out of Pandora's box—to those citizens of Cork who owe a few pounds and to tell them that we have a new morality, that they have as good a case for not paying their ground rents, their butcher or their baker or their candlestick maker as can be made for the farmers. I stated before in this House that there is no man in this country who cannot claim, through blood ties or otherwise, relationship with the farmer. We are all sprung from the farming stock. It is only human to accept the line of least resistance. It is a very attractive doctrine, especially at a time of economic stress, to place before the farmer, that he need not pay the moiety of his land annuities. That moiety may be represented by a sum of £10, £20 or £30. Any of us who has even a slight acquaintance with farm life knows that that sum can be put to very practical use. It is only human to be attracted by the doctrine that one should put £20 or £30 in his pocket and devote it to some other use than the discharge of what is, after all, an honourable debt. I do not like to misquote the President, but I remember reading, before the 1926 negotiations were opened, where President de Valera stated that this country would not get out of its commitments to Britain under £19,000,000 per year.

Comment on this

That is all wrong.

Comment on this

If it is, it should have been contradicted in the Press. The plenipotentiaries or ambassadors from this country settled for a sum of £5,000,000. Somebody said it was a damn good bargain. Personally I believe it was a good bargain. We cannot have it both ways. Our people rejected the 1920 Act, under which we were to be relieved of the land annuities and placed in the same position as Northern Ireland. President de Valera wants to get all the fat out of the 1920 Act, and, at the same time, to get the advantage of the ultimate financial agreement. I think that that is not playing the game with the people of this country. The ordinary working class people who will be the greatest sufferers in this war of attrition should be told plainly what they are up against. They are told, in rather vague and general terms, that they will have to tighten their belts and adopt the policy of the hair shirt. The policy of the hair shirt is already in operation amongst our unemployed, but the number of people who will have to wear hair shirts in the near future will be multiplied very considerably.

Comment on this

A new industry.

Comment on this

I have suggested, on more than one occasion, that it would be well for all of us to get down to the realities of the situation. This vote of £2,000,000 means £2,000,000 of extra taxation on the country. I am not opposing it. The thing has gone so far now that we will have to give the Government plenty of rein. If I were to oppose this, I believe I would not be acting in the best interests of my constituents, or in the best interests of the State. But I ask the President to take the people into his confidence. Let us know how he proposes to spend this £2,000,000. Does he propose to build up institutions for the housing of our people on a huge, communal scale? Does he propose to imitate the systems that are in operation in Russia? These are things which are agitating the people. There is considerable unrest and anxiety, and the President and his Party have done nothing to allay that unrest and anxiety. Who suffers as a result of this condition of affairs? The ordinary working class people of the State. The people are patient. We all admire the patience and endurance of the poor of this country. The one thing that keeps our people in subjection to-day is their faith. It cannot be denied that if any other people were faced with the misery and poverty that our people are told from the Government Benches they will have to face, they would not accept the position with such patience and with such humility as the Irish people are accepting it.

How long does the President think our people will continue to endure and suffer? The breaking point may be reached at any minute. And there are signs and indications all over the country that the breaking point is very near. We are aware that we have a growing population in Ireland for the last few years, not because of any great patriotism, or love for Ireland, as some people would like to translate it, but because Uncle Sam has cut the quota of emigration allowed into his own country. That is what has caused the increased population in this country. We will have, possibly, at the next general election 90,000 or 100,000 extra people in this country for whom little or no employment can be found. We will have an extra 100,000 people, in this economy programme outlined by President de Valera, to be dealt with. You have in addition the number of people who have been referred to as "work shys."

It is the practice in this country, nowadays, to be misquoted. We are misquoted in the Press. We are being told that we are acting an anti-Irish part in this crisis. If one does not go all the way with this Government he is told he is anti-Irish. Not only are you told you are anti-Irish but you are told you are other things much worse. The Government should take notice of the fact that snowball resolutions are published in the Press, passing from public bodies in one county to another, suggesting, that not only should we support the Government in their economic proposals, but that we will be shot if we do not, because that is what it means. Were it not for the fact that there is in this country more moral cowardice than in any other country in the world these statements would not be allowed to appear by the Minister for Justice. I charge the Minister for Justice with not doing his duty because he is afraid to do it. We know that the power behind President de Valera is not represented by the most influential men and women in this country, but that it is made up of the potential robber and bank robber and everything that is bad and evil in our people, constantly playing up to the cupidity of our people, making speeches inflaming the passions of some of our young men and some of our old men as well. I want to suggest, very seriously, to this House, and I am not afraid to say it here or in Cork City which I have the honour to represent, that there is more moral cowardice in this country than in any other country in the world.

It may be President de Valera's ambition to make a second Mexico of this country, but if he does he will reap the whirlwind. I charge the President that he is not exercising the influence that he should exercise. He has a Bench of Ministers some of whom are as irresponsible people as ever sat on any Front Bench in any Parliament in the world. We have the Minister for Defence, who, instead of telling the Army that they are the servants of the people tells them that they are being kept for one purpose only—to achieve the full freedom of Ireland. I want to tell the Minister for Defence, and every other Minister on the Government Bench—and especially those, at any rate, who come from the North and frequently express the hope that there should be unity between North and South—that the people who most accentuate that dividing line between North and South are the people sitting on the Government Front Bench. These people, who, as I have said, are actuated by spite and by malice, are now not satisfied with having a border between Northern and Southern Ireland, but they are actually attempting to estrange from us our best customer, next door to us. Does anyone think for a moment that, in this war of attrition, we are going to come out on top? Some people say it is patriotic to shout—but I never understood their mentality—"My country, right or wrong." Up to a point it is good, but I tell my fellow-countrymen that public men and others are fully satisfied that the danger that besets the path of the present Government and of our people is the absence of the higher tradition of Irish nationality and patriotism.

I have asked the President to give some indication of the way he proposes to spend this money. We have no information whatever on that point. He has not told us that he wants to erect large institutions in which the people may live, with communal kitchens, and other things, that exist in a Communist State like Russia. It may be that he is going to raise a third army. A third army, I think, has been evisaged by the present Minister for Defence. A third army, in this small country, must be wanted to act as a kind of buffer between our National Army and an army outside. If the President told us we were going to spend this £2,000,000 in a way such as providing food for our people and accommodation for those thrown out of work because they cannot pay their way, I would be very pleased to support this Estimate. I am supporting this Estimate, but I would have more confidence in the President, and in some of his Ministers, if he told us what he proposed to do with it. That is the position in the cities and in the towns. It is a position of uncertainty and unrest and I ask the President, in his reply, to show the manner in which he proposes to allay that unrest and uncertainty.

Comment on this

During a previous debate in this House Deputy Desmond Fitzgerald insinuated that on the question of our right to retain the land annuities it was my view that we had no legal case. Last Sunday in the country he made a much more definite statement when he said that it definitely was my view that we had no legal right to retain the land annuities. I have not had any personal conversation with Deputy Fitzgerald or any communication with him for the past six years. How, in view of that fact, he purports to be able to get my views, on a matter of this kind, passes my comprehension, except, of course, that Deputy Fitzgerald adds the faculty of telepathy to the many other extraordinary qualifications for which he imagines he holds certificates. I want to say very definitely—and Deputy Fitzgerald can read this in the Official Report—that I believe we have a strong case and legal ground for the retention of the land annuities. I believe we have a strong case also for the retention of many other of those payments that we make to Britain. When I say on legal grounds I believe that on moral grounds, historical grounds and grounds of equity there is no answer to our claim to retain all these disputed moneys. I go further than that. Deputy Gorey last night talked about the plight of the farmer and the bad condition in which he is placed not merely in connection with this crisis but the position in which the farmer found himself for some time past.

As a matter of political faith I claim that just as I believe the first charge on industry is the maintenance of a standard of decent livelihood for the people engaged in industry, so I say also that the first charge on the land in this country is the right of the farmer to maintain a decent standard of living for himself and his children.

No State and no bondholder has any right to extract from the farmers annuities which can only be paid at the price of the farmer sacrificing his standard of life and at the price of seeing his family starve. The State should recognise the fact that it has no moral right to squeeze out of the farmer annuities which, in existing circumstances, he is unable to pay. He can only pay these annuities at the price of sacrificing his standard of living.

Under this Estimate, the Government seeks power to spend £2,000,000 for the purpose of dealing with the present emergency. With me, the problem is not so much one of giving them power to spend the £2,000,000. My only doubt is, will they use that power adequately and will they, with that sum of money, be able to defend the nation in the existing crisis? Yesterday, President de Valera and the other Ministers who spoke after him, and the other members of the Fianna Fáil Party who spoke, talked rather vaguely and rather airily about what it is necessary to do in this crisis. But there was a complete absence of detail. There was a complete absence of decisive policy. There was a complete absence of any kind of a concrete plan for dealing with the present emergency. What I want to ask is this:—What are they going to do in this crisis? What are they doing in this crisis? What do they propose to do in order to organise the nation to meet this crisis?

Comment on this
A Deputy

Nothing.

Comment on this

I will concede that this Government has done things since it came into office which, if Cumann na nGaedheal were in office for 100 years, it would never have done. I will concede that this Government has done many things that have given a ray of hope to the people, but I want to ask some member of the Government Front Bench where exactly the Government stands in this crisis? Is it going to give the road to the bolstering up of capitalism? Is it its policy to repair this rent or that rent in the fabric of the system of capitalism which may break down during this crisis? Or is it going to evolve some kind of a new social policy which will give to all our people that decent standard of life which is the God-given heritage of all our people? If it is going to give the road to trying to patch the rents in the capitalist system, then the future of the people of this country is going to be a bleak one indeed. The capitalist system will never stand the shock of this crisis or the rocks that are bound to confront it in this crisis. Does the Government realise the havoc which capitalism in every country in the world is wreaking upon the peoples of these countries to-day? According to Deputy Good, the champion of capitalism, it is the only method by which the people can pass to prosperity. In the world to-day we have 25,000,000 white men and women unemployed under a capitalist system of Government. That is the same kind of system which, I am afraid, the Executive Council are going to rely on to save the nation in this crisis. This nation will never be saved by reliance upon capitalism. During the past ten years, capitalism, plus the blunders of Cumann na nGaedheal, have given us an unemployment problem of 80,000 unemployed in this State. Capitalism, plus Cumann na nGaedheal has resulted in the export of a quarter of a million of the cream of our manhood and womanhood to other lands. Capitalism, even plus Fianna Fáil, will yield the same miserable and disappointing results.

Comment on this

What did Labour do for us in England?

Comment on this

Look at what capitalism has done all over the world to-day. An unemployment problem confronts the world of such a magnitude as has never been known in living memory. Look on every country in the world to-day rocking under the capitalist system. Roumania is unable to pay its civil servants or to feed its lepers, who broke out of a leper institution recently because of the lack of food with which to feed them. In Jugo-Slavia the cattle were turned out on the roads to fend for themselves. Across in America, a country that can produce all that is necessary for decent human existence every five months of the year, there is an unemployment problem which is described by the American Federation of Labour as extending to 10,500,000. That is the kind of evil that capitalism has wrought in the world in this generation. Is that the kind of system which the President is relying on to save the country in this crisis?

Deputy Gorey talked last night, and in many respects he talked quite sensibly, on the necessity for doing something in this crisis. I agree that something must be done in this crisis, not merely for the working class people in the cities and towns and villages of the country, but also for the farmers and especially for the small farmers, in order to assist them to meet and defeat this menace. This is not merely a temporary crisis. It has existed for the past ten years and will continue to exist under capitalism—this permanent crisis of involuntary idleness. This is no mere temporary crisis in this country. We have the permanent crisis of the continuous poverty of the poor people— the crisis of 80,000 unemployed men and women. If the Government are serious in their attempt to defend the nation and to equip it to defend itself, they must look upon this not merely as a temporary crisis but as another flaw in a social structure which has brought about the present crisis and which has given us the permanent crisis of 80,000 unemployed men and women. What is to be the hope for these people in this crisis? I am greatly afraid that in the attempt to grapple with this temporary crisis the permanent crisis is being overlooked. I am greatly afraid that the Executive Council have not envisaged in any big and comprehensive way the necessity for dealing, not merely with the existing crisis, but with the big problem of keeping our people on the land and putting them into productive employment. That must be done, no matter what the cost, because there is nothing more costly than keeping in involuntary idleness 80,000 people drawing from the pool of productivity while they are contributing nothing themselves to that pool. What is the hope for these people in this crisis? I see too much in the recent tariff orders of a mentality which is dealing with an existing problem, but not dealing with a bigger problem and a wider one. This crisis is only part of the bigger and the wider problem.

What the Executive Council has got to do to-day is to face up to the necessity of giving every man and woman in this country the opportunity to earn a decent livelihood in their own land. Our country is capable of giving all our people a decent standard of livelihood. The capacity of the Government will be judged by their ability to use this crisis as an opportunity to provide our people with a decent standard of living, and to use it to create, in this country, an economic and social system which will recognise that our chief assets are our human beings, our men and women, and that, no matter what else suffers, a decent standard of livelihood must be provided, as a matter of national guarantee, to every man, woman and child who is prepared to enrich the nation by operating on the resources of the nation.

Comment on this

We have listened to a very bombastic and very empty speech from Deputy Norton, but there were certain phrases in that speech which would be very significant indeed, if Deputy Norton and his Party counted in any way in the councils of this nation. The Labour Party, however, has been reduced, under its present leadership, to such a state of complete impotence that really what Deputy Norton says, or thinks, does not seem to me to be of very much account. In consequence, I do not intend to deal with his speech at any length, but I will just point out, that even from Deputy Norton, the doctrine which he promulgated, that there was no moral right in this Government, the British Government or any other Government to demand the payment of the land annuities, is a very dangerous doctrine. It is a doctrine which, if it is preached in this country— preached by somebody who counts— will have very serious results. I might point out to Deputy Norton that the doctrine which he is preaching, that the Government have no moral right to collect the land annuities, is a doctrine which, at any rate, up to this, the leaders of the Fianna Fáil Party have not preached. We have heard, in this discussion, a considerable amount of talk about this crisis in which the country is now involved. We have heard a great deal of discussion about the payment of land annuities, and how they should go, but I would like to point out what is the issue now between the British Government and the Government here. Certainly from the Government benches, we have heard nothing which would lead us to believe that the Government or their followers, at least, were, in any way, aware of what is the point at issue now between this Government and the British Government or what this fighting is about, why this tax had been placed on our cattle and on our other agricultural produce going into England or why these extraordinary and unprecedented powers are sought by the administration of this country.

There is no question at issue now as to whether the land annuities are to be retained permanently in this country or whether they are to be paid into the Land Purchase Fund to discharge the interest on the land stock. That is not the question at issue at all and it has nothing to do with the question at issue. The question at issue is not who has a right to the land annuities; into which Exchequer, or in what fashion, they should be paid. It is simply this, where one particular half-yearly payment of the annuities is to be placed temporarily, and before what tribunal is the question of the ultimate destination of the money collected in the form of land annuities to be decided. That is the sole question at issue. There is no question now as to who owns the land annuities, or whether they should be paid into the Land Purchase Fund or into the Central Fund here. That has not been reached. The whole of this fight is about a preliminary and let us deal, for a moment, with that preliminary. Members of the Executive Council very seldom speak, and, therefore, when we had a speech yesterday from the Minister for Posts and Telegraphs on this question, I sincerely hoped that we would get some little enlightenment. However, we got none. We got a discussion on such things as currency and we were given a re-hash of the old thing of how very unfortunate it was for us that we had to go off the gold standard when England went off the gold standard. That is an argument that has been answered half a dozen times. It has already been demonstrated that Denmark and other countries that have large gold reserves had to go off the gold standard, so that they could retain their markets for their produce, but, instead of dealing, as one would have expected, with the problem with which this Estimate is connected, we had nothing at all from the Minister for Posts and Telegraphs and we are still left in a very considerable state of doubt and darkness.

As I have already stated, we are fighting about preliminaries, and the Minister for Posts and Telegraphs informed us that there was one preliminary which, he said, was absolutely hopeless. He said that the present half-year's instalment of the annuities could not be handed over to be placed in the Land Purchase Fund as had heretofore been done. I would like to know why not? What is to prevent it? What loss of dignity or position will be caused, or how is your case in the slightest way weakened by dealing with this last half-year's instalment in precisely the same way as the half-yearly instalments of annuities have been dealt with for the past ten years? How could it be weakened in any way? That is what has heretofore been done and you can pay it over now without prejudice, and make it perfectly clear that you are handing these over, without prejudice, to be returned again, provided any tribunal which is agreed upon decides that that instalment should be reimbursed to the Central Fund here. What is the difficulty about that? As a matter of fact, as the President is perfectly aware, if he adopted that course, he would not prejudice himself in the slightest, and, at the same time, he would be acting strictly legally. As the President is perfectly aware, the setting up of this Suspense Account is illegal and contrary to section 12 of the Land Act of 1923. Taking the other course, he will be acting perfectly properly and perfectly legally, and he will be making a gesture which would show that he was bona fide anxious to have a determination on this question.

What I cannot see is why the first step cannot be taken by the Administration here. It does not prejudice their case in the slightest and they can then go on to discuss what tribunal they will leave this question to be finally decided by. I have not the slightest doubt in my mind that if the President said: "We will pay over this half-yearly instalment of the annuities without prejudice, and therefore, you have got no justification in keeping on your tax on Irish cattle," that tax would be instantaneously raised. I have no doubt in my mind that that would follow. It is because the half year's instalment has not been paid that this tax has been put on Irish cattle. That is the sole reason which is keeping this tax upon Irish farm produce in England, and which, according to the Government, has necessitated the introduction of this very special legislation, conferring upon the Government these very extraordinary powers. It is simply a case of what appears to me to be mere obstinacy, because I have no reason to think the contrary, on the part of the Executive Council not to hand over without prejudice this half-year's instalment of the annuities. That is what the fight is about. That is what this country is called to endure suffering for; that is what the farming community here is going to be broken for, simply because the Government are unwilling to pay over without prejudice the half yearly instalment of the annuities. That is a terrible responsibility for the Executive Council to take upon itself. I would like now if I can to bring home to the minds of the President and his fellow-members of the Executive Council, that they are not playing with children. They are playing with the destinies of a people, they are playing with human lives, they are playing with the happiness, the prosperity, the well-being, and possibly with the very lives of the people of this country at present. It is no light responsibility that rests upon their shoulders. Our people are being driven into most terrible poverty. That will come and worse than that. Possibly starvation and death will ensue and the responsibility rests upon the shoulders of the members of the Executive Council and upon their conscience. For that reason I appeal to the President, and to the members of the Executive Council, to recognise the position in which they are placed, to recognise how they are playing fast and loose with the destinies of the people of this State, and, as I said, almost with the lives of this people.

The one main issue, the one thing which makes this economic warfare go on, is that you are not willing to hand over without prejudice the half-yearly instalment of the annuities. I am not now going to deal with the question of the land annuities in general. But I will say this much in response to a statement made here by Deputy Clery the other day, that we contend, and must contend, that it is as clear as daylight that there is no legal right in this State to maintain these annuities. I go further and say that nobody who has gone into the question can honestly and conscientiously state that any legal case can be put forward. That is the perfectly plain attitude which we have taken up and maintained. However, as has been pointed out, there is another way out. Admit that there is and that there can be no legal claim, but simply go and say: "Our farmers are unable to pay. There is a legal obligation on us to pay, but do not insist upon that obligation." You can do that, and if you do, you may succeed in that attitude. As long as you take up the hopeless position that you have a legal case, when everyone knows perfectly well that you have not a case, there is no use in endeavouring to cheat your own mind. Let us come to the issue. It is the end of democratic rule in this country. After all, the one control which any legislative assembly can have is control of the purse. Recently there was given to the Executive Council unlimited power to raise taxation. They can raise any amount of money they like by any method they like. They can declare any single act a man does an act upon which excise duty can be placed. They can demand that a licence be had for the doing of that act, and for that licence they can demand payment of any amount they like. They can go to a railway company and say "pay over half a million." If the company does not do so they can carry out Deputy Norton's idea—they can nationalise it. They can do the same with a bank, saying: "Pay us over so many millions. If you do not, we are going to seize your bank. We will nationalise it." They have all these unlimited powers. They can take the last farthing from every citizen. They have been given such power. Up to this they only had power to expend money which had to be appropriated by this House. Here they are given a grant of two million pounds which for practical purposes is to be expended in any single way the Minister for Finance likes. What is here is so general, so indefinite, so vague, that there is no control upon any Minister at all.

There is another thing which is very significant. That is that this two millions is to be voted before the Government puts up their scheme. Why not think first and ask for the money afterwards? Why not, when coming to the House, be able to tell it what the money is wanted for; what they have in their heads, and what are their plans. They cannot do that because they have not thought them out. They come here in complete ignorance of what they want the money for or how much they want. They come in in absolute ignorance. They tell the House that they must have two million pounds to spend before the Dáil meets again, obviously to spend before October. What is the reason for that? They are going to pour down into some channel—which channel they do not know—the national capital at the rate of one million a month. As it is this country is in a very bad way. The Government has reduced it to terrible straits. What of the nonsense that was preached in the very long, elaborate and dull speech that was made by the Deputy from Meath, who told us that the people there were so demoralised, evidently by the present Government, that they would not even cut the meadows. It is certainly a very terrible criticism of this administration, when Deputy O'Reilly feels that his constituents are so demoralised, and have become so lazy, that they would rather let the meadows rot than cut them. If that is the moral condition to which the Fianna Fáil Party has reduced this State it is certainly not a thing to boast of.

The moral fibre of the people of every State must be built up, and if they are so demoralised that they do not consider it worth while to work, an amount of harm has been done to the moral fibre of the people that it will be impossible to make good. Deputy O'Reilly boasts about that. He stated that other things were due to the acts of the previous Government. The last administration can look back upon its ten years of office with justifiable pride. The last administration can point out that in one of the worst crises the world has ever experienced this State suffered less than any other State. They can point out that under their administration this State was the envy of foreign critics, some of whom were very hostile critics. From the accession of the present administration to power there has been such a change in the financial outlook of this State that instead of being the envy we must be, at present, the despised of the whole world.

Comment on this

We are asked to give unlimited powers. The Dáil is to give up all control over money. You have the Government asking for complete trust. Are they worthy of complete trust? What have this Government done to deserve the trust which was never given in any country in which there is a Parliamentary Government and an Executive Council? What has this Government done? It has piled failure upon failure; it has muddled every single thing it has taken up and now it asks for unlimited confidence. And I will point out, too, that this is not a Government that at the last General Election got the confidence of the Irish people. It did not get a majority at the last General Election and it only has a majority now because a Party which was elected as a proTreaty Party has become an Anti-Treaty Party and has flung in its lot with the present administration. That is the only reason why the President has got charge of the administration at the present moment.

Comment on this

What has the Treaty issue to do with the motion now under discussion?

Comment on this

What about your Free-mason supporters?

Comment on this

I have not the slightest intention of being drawn into any side-track by Deputy Davin. I have already stated that I consider the Labour Party are most insignificant. But to return to the matter. I will say that it is a Government only by the mere accident of getting a majority of those of this House behind it. That is the Executive Council which is asking now to be entrusted with powers which no Executive Council has ever before asked to be entrusted with.

Comment on this

Who changed your seat in this House?

Comment on this

The Deputy will soon change his.

Comment on this

We at the present moment are in as bad a position as we could be. So bad is the position that one would not have thought possible six months ago that the country would be reduced to the position in which it now is. But it is perfectly obvious that the position in which we now are is but the mere forerunner and the foretaste of what is to come in the immediate future. I say that is obvious. I agree with Deputy Norton that we are heading for a revolution. We are heading for a revolution as fast as we can head for it. Nobody who has studied the signs of revolution, the principles put forward and the causes from which it proceeds in any State can hesitate to draw the conclusion that we are heading fast for a revolution. We have got, as we know to-day, a strong body in this State who have been preaching the establishment of a Republic upon the Russian lines here. It was stated by Deputy Cosgrave that similar views have permeated the Executive Council. We were told yesterday that this body could not have been in existence before. It was in existence before. It was, of course, these principles that were being preached before, but they were not being preached or adopted or helped by the Government in office. On the contrary, they were being kept down, kept in check and kept back by the Government in office. The very opposite is now taking place and this Government is heading the country for revolution. Out of that revolution can come one thing and one thing only, and that is a Republic upon your Russian lines. That is where this country is drifting fast. We are going in for a revolution. I agree with Deputy Norton. Deputy Davin, of course, does not know the meaning of the word "Socialism."

Comment on this

Not your Socialism.

Comment on this

The Deputy talks about socialistic reforms and when he talks about socialistic reforms he thinks he has finished. He does not know what Socialism and Bolshevism mean. We are heading this State as fast as a State can be dragged towards something in the nature of a Bolshevic Republic. We are heading for a State where private property will be non-existent and not only are we going towards that revolution but we are being brought to such a state of poverty in this State by the action of the Executive Council and their friends that you may take it for granted that when the revolution comes it will be more than simply a quite harmless revolution. It will be a revolution accompanied by violence and I fear accompanied by bloodshed. I do say to the Executive Council, to those who follow, support and keep them in office and back them up in the wide course which they are now following, that when the fruits of their sowing are reaped, when the country has suffered as it is going to suffer, that for each bit of suffering which the country endures, for every act of bloodshed, and for every piece of political wrong-doing which takes place in this State engandered by the condition of poverty which the Government have brought about, the moral responsibility will rest upon the shoulders of President de Valera, his Executive Council and upon their followers and friends.

Comment on this

There is one Minister who should have intervened in this debate but so far he has not done so. I refer to the Acting-Minister for Agriculture, who for the time being at all events is the official head of the agricultural community in this country. In the present unfortunate circumstances of the country it was his duty to indicate to the people what steps he proposes to take to relieve them in the existing situation. The farmers have been advised by members of the Executive Council to hold on to their cattle and to hold on to their stock. The farmers, or a certain number of them at all events, acting on that advice, are holding on to their stock. What provision does the Acting-Minister for Agriculture propose to make out of this Vote of £2,000,000 to the farmers who are holding on to their stock and who will possibly sell these cattle at a loss perhaps during the months of September and October? It surely was the duty of the Acting-Minister for Agriculture in the present circumstances of this country to have intervened in this debate and to have indicated to the farmers of the country the steps he proposes to take in order to relieve them of the losses which they are undoubtedly incurring at the moment and of the greater losses which they will certainly incur during the coming weeks.

There is another reason why the Minister should have intervened. During the last ten days there was a very brief outline of a butter scheme given to the Press. The outline was so brief that it was difficult even for men engaged for years in the butter business to understand its terms. The people who are interested in the butter trade and in the creameries are naturally anxious to know the actual steps the Minister proposes to take for the purpose of enabling them to dispose of their butter. It was stated in that resumé of his proposal that there should be a guaranteed price in the home market of 117/-. Is it proposed to continue the export of butter? There is not sufficient cold storage here to accommodate the stocks of butter for the next two or three months. If it is proposed to continue the export, who is going to pay the duty? Has the duty to be paid by the creameries or will it be paid by the State? These are important matters bearing on the whole agricultural situation. In my opinion, it was undoubtedly the duty of the Minister to make some statement for the purpose of enlightening farmers as to their actual position under the new conditions.

This estimate has been severely criticised, and rightly so. There was a totally inadequate explanation of its scope and intention given by the President when introducing it. If the people are to be called upon to make sacrifices it is the duty of the President to take the country into his confidence and to tell the people what steps he proposes to take in order to tide them over the emergency period. It is grossly unfair to ask the Dáil for this large sum of money in the absence of any statement of policy from the President. The taxpayers, the farmers, the business people and the workers will have to pay for the luxury of the warfare we are engaged in. As the representatives of the people, we are entitled to know how the President proposes to spend this money.

It appears to me that if this warfare continues for any lengthy period he will have to approach the Dáil for a number of Votes similar to this. I believe this is the first of a series of such Votes. This condition of things, I assume, will continue until almost every citizen will be brought to the position that he must look to the State for some form of relief. I believe we will have a reversion to the conditions that prevailed here during the famine years. If the farmers' losses were to be assessed to-day—and these losses did not actually commence with the imposition of duties on our exports by the British, because some of the losses were incurred during the period when the negotiations between this country and Great Britain were in suspense—they would be found to be very considerable. I believe they would far exceed the figure which we are asked to vote in this Estimate to-day. If a rough approximation were made, I think it would be somewhere in the neighbourhood of £6,000,000. I doubt very much that even that figure would recoup the farmers for the losses they have incurred up to the present moment.

There are certain casualties in the ranks of the farmers already. Their numbers will be added to day by day, week by week, and the number of casualties will continue to increase as long as this unfortunate warfare lasts. One is entitled to ask, in such circumstances, what about the country? If we could look at the country quite independently of political considerations, political prejudices or political parties, if we took a completely detached view and asked ourselves the question: What of the country and its future? we certainly would be driven to the conclusion, no matter in what favourable light we might be inclined to view it, that even under existing circumstances there is no possibility of surviving if this warfare which the President and the Government have embarked upon is to continue for any length of time. Is it to be assumed, when he gets this money from the Dáil, that it is his intention to pursue this warfare to the bitter end, utterly regardless of the terrible consequences involved?

If one is to judge by the President's speeches down the country during recent weeks, it would appear that he has absolutely bolted and barred the door against the possibility of any further negotiations with the British Government. No matter from what aspect we view the present position of things, we cannot possibly see any ray of hope. In view of the sacrifices which have been made by the people during the last seventeen years, particularly during the last decade, and in view of the efforts made by Ministers in the previous Government and by the people who co-operated so whole-heartedly with them, it is certainly tragic to see the country brought to the condition in which it is. Speaking here recently I said that if this situation had been handled in the way in which such a situation would have been handled in any normal country, we would not find ourselves in our present unfortunate position. If the elements of statemanship existed amongst members of the Fianna Fáil Government, then surely they would have found some way out of the difficulty—some way to relieve the country of the onerous burden it has now to bear. I submit that even yet it is the duty of the Government to find a solution. The indications even at the moment are perhaps more favourable than they were yesterday or the day before in view of the speech made by the British Attorney-General. I say it is the duty of the Government to explore the situation as much as possible and find a solution for the present difficulties. The prolongation of this suicidal strife can only lead to a renewal of bitterness between the two countries. It can only lead to a renewal of racial hatreds and the longer this warfare goes on the more difficult it will be to bring about an understanding between the two peoples.

If the Government fail in these circumstances to achieve a solution of the difficulty between the two countries, then I submit that they are utterly lacking in any qualities of statesmanship, and history will adjudge them at their proper and true value. If this warfare continues, no one can possibly visualise the financial consequences to the people. Every individual will suffer. The workman and the farmer will suffer; the shopkeeper and the manufacturer will suffer; all will be involved in the common suffering. These duties imposed by the British Government, as I said, are directed mainly against the farmer. He is the one individual who will suffer most as a consequence of the operation of the duties. I ask the President to realise what the position may be in the months of September and October when the farmer will be compelled to send his stock into the fairs and to sell them at any price he can possibly get. If the farmer continues to act on the advice given to him by the members of the Government, he will hold up his stock, with the result that towards the end of September, and particularly during October, the markets will be glutted to such an extent that cattle will be procurable at any price offered by the buyers.

In this Estimate it is stated that disbursements will be made from this fund for various purposes—to promote the continuance of trade industry and business, to open new markets for agricultural and manufactured produce, to establish or assist in establishing new industries. I wonder what kind of industries the President or the members of the Government have in mind. Are they industries subsidiary to agriculture or new industries that require a great deal of experience and technical skill for the starting and running of them? Surely if industries are to be started under State supervision, the President should take to heart the lesson of other countries. State-aided industries of that kind have not succeeded in other countries; in countries that have a far wider and greater experience of the management of business than we have; in countries where there is available a great amount of technical skill. If they have failed in countries like these, how can the President hope, in any circumstances, to make new industries succeed in this country?

The question of alternative markets is also mentioned in the Estimate. We have heard a great deal about alternative markets, not alone in the Dáil, but in speeches delivered by Ministers and members of the Fianna Fáil Party throughout the country for the last few years. I understand that the President and certain members of the Government have been exploring the possibility of finding alternative markets during the last three or four months. I, for one, would be interested to hear the results of the President's investigations. If it is possible to find an alternative and a better market than the market we have already got, then by all means secure that market. But I offer this advice to the President: that he should hold on to the market he has got. He should hold on to the old market before he transfers his allegiance to the new. He should make quite certain, if that new market is available—and I do not believe there is a new market available—that before transferring the products of this country to that new market, the new market will receive them on as favourable and good terms as the old market. I do not believe it is possible to obtain an alternative market. If it were possible to obtain an alternative market for our products, he can rest assured that we have business men in this country sufficiently energetic and enterprising to have explored during past years the possibility of securing a foothold in these markets. We do know that certain business men did attempt to find alternative markets for certain lines of our products, and, after some little experience, these men discovered that, instead of these new markets being an advantage to them, they were a considerable disadvantage. They, themselves, as a matter of fact, lost quite a substantial sum of money in the effort to secure a foothold in these particular markets.

I think the sooner this nonsense about alternative markets is dropped the better. That sort of nonsense does not deceive any farmer. Every farmer recognises that there is only one market for his products and that is the English market. It is the only market where there is a demand for his products; where his products suit the peculiar tastes and the peculiar habits of the people. There is no use in talking about alternative markets. Under the Estimate I assume it will be possible for the Government to send ornamental deputations or delegations to various other countries for the purpose of finding out if alternative markets can be opened. It is possible that a great deal of money will be squandered in that direction. It is quite possible also, in fact it is certain, that no result will be achieved as a result of the visits of these delegations. Similarly, a lot of this money may be spent quite foolishly in the attempt to establish industries here. A great deal of State money has been spent already in an effort to subsidise industries in this country, after careful and minute investigation, and that money, as Ministers of the late Government can inform him, might as well have been thrown into the tide.

If this struggle is prolonged, if the President still takes up an adamantine attitude and insists upon pursuing this quarrel to the bitter end and refuses, under any circumstances or any set of circumstances, to reopen negotiations with the British Government, then I ask him to try and visualise the conditions that will be created amongst the farming community. The President knows perhaps as well as I do the struggles farmers have had during the past few years to make ends meet, the struggles they have had to pay their debts, to pay their annuities, to pay their rates, and the other expenses incidental to the carrying on of farming. These new duties will drive the farmers under the surface. There is a danger that if this warfare is prolonged farmers may lose all hope and all courage, and it will be almost an impossibility for any subsequent Government, taking over control of the destinies of the country, to restore initiative, character and enterprise in them again. There is that possibility. The farmer in this country has a peculiar psychology. The small farmer, particularly, when he finds things going against him, is inclined to abandon hope and just sink. Can the President calmly visualise the existence of conditions such as those amongst the farming community? So far as I can see, these conditions are bound to arise if this economic warfare is continued for any length of time. Farmers are asked to pay their land annuities, their rates, their shopkeepers' debts, and all other debts. I ask the President where are the farmers going to get the money to pay these debts at present?

Where are the farmers to get money to pay those debts? Everything the farmer is selling at present he is selling at a loss, under the cost of production. I do not care what it is, let it be an animal, let it be potatoes, any crop produced on the land, he is selling it under the cost of production. Prices, as the President knows, or ought to know, have dropped considerably during the last three or four weeks, and prices are still dropping. In circumstances such as these, I ask the President to explain how it is possible for the farmer to meet the debts which he advises them so jauntily to pay? There is scarcely a point that could be made on this Estimate that has not already been made by some other speaker. I do not propose to say anything more, but in conclusion, I would ask the President to bear in mind the existing conditions in this country. If he does bear clearly in mind the existing economic conditions and the existing circumstances of the country, I am sure if he is prepared to face up to the issue involved in this struggle quite straightforwardly and honestly, he will use every effort to secure a settlement of the difficulty between this country and Great Britain at the earliest possible moment.

Comment on this

I only intervene to remind the Opposition Front Bench of an implied promise made here about a fortnight ago by the former Minister for Agriculture and to ask why that promise has not been kept. Speaking here on the 22nd July, Deputy Hogan of Galway, referring to the secret agreement of 1923, said:

That agreement contains many clauses. I am not going into the reason why it was marked "secret." That can be explained at a later stage. I do not want to confuse the issue by dealing with it now.

I look upon that as an implied promise that the reason for marking the agreement secret was to be explained at some later stage by some other responsible speaker. No such explanation has been given. In my opinion it is very important that, if there be an explanation, it should be given because so far as I can see those who are following the debates here, who are reading of this secret agreement and reading further the statement that has been made by Ministers, that not only was the agreement marked secret but that an appeal was made to the British Government not to publish it, are almost a threat to the peace of the country. They are not only angry but they are furiously angry and it is natural that they should be so looking upon it as they do, that the Ministers whom they had elected to power made an agreement throwing a very serious burden on their backs, that they made that agreement without disclosing the terms of it to them, that the agreement was actually marked secret and that the Government they trusted appealed to the British Government not to tell anybody about that agreement or publish it. That is of course as it looks to them. I do not want to be reminded of the argument that the agreement was not secret from the Irish people.

Comment on this

The Deputy would not be reminded of it.

Comment on this

What about the letters?

Comment on this

I am not speaking from the Party point of view. Every speaker on the opposite side has spoken of the desire to make reason prevail in this fight, but there is one thing that will counter reason in this fight and that is the view prevailing as to this secret agreement—a view which I have myself found amongst a number of farmers to whom I have spoken.

Comment on this

That agreement was explained. Is that not accepted? Is Deputy Cosgrave's statement not accepted?

Comment on this

My question is not why was the agreement secret and not disclosed to the people. My question is why the implied promise given by Deputy Hogan is not being kept, that is as to the reason for marking the agreement secret and the reason for appealing to the British Government not to publish it? Surely we are entitled to know the reasons for that.

Comment on this

And for all other agreements.

Comment on this

We can deal with them another time.

Comment on this

I just want to say that we cannot deal with this agreement without bringing in all agreements. I would appeal to the President before the adjournment to give us an opportunity to debate all these agreements between any Government and the British and between any Government and the I.R.A. Let us know where we are to-day.

Comment on this

That agreement imposes a big burden on our people. Surely there must be an explanation as to why it was marked "secret" and why an appeal was made to the British Government not to publish it. I think that now, 10 years after the agreement was made, the members of the Dáil, especially in this crisis, are entitled to be told what is the reason for that. I think that those who profess an anxiety for peace on the Cumann na nGaedheal Benches ought to insist that that explanation be given, because in my opinion until it is given and until it is accepted we are going to have a very angry people.

I have very little to say in regard to the general subject. The only thing I would say is that I am sorry that this meeting of the Dáil ever took place, and that some of the speeches that have been delivered have been in very bad taste in relation to the present crisis in the country. Up to yesterday morning I believed that the Opposition was genuinely anxious to be helpful and I for one did not encourage the phrase "playing England's game". As a matter of fact I discouraged it, but after listening to several of the speeches made from the Cumann na nGaedheal Benches within the last two days, I think the accusation can now be made with a great deal more truth and a great deal more justification. Listening to the speeches of Deputy Hayes, Deputy Hogan and another Deputy I could not help thinking what on earth is the reason for such speeches at the present juncture. We may be sure that the British Government is watching every word uttered here.

We have it stated that the present Government got its majority by immoral methods and that the great bulk of its supporters, to quote a particular Deputy, are people of dishonest instincts, that they are work-shy people who do not want to pay their debts or to fulfil any useful function in the State. What is the reason for telling Sir Thomas Inskip and all those other gentlemen over there that this Government is the expression of the dishonesty and the immorality which prevail in this country, that the half million voters who voted the Government into power are people of immoral inclinations, and that it was by appealing to their dishonest and immoral instincts that the present Government was able to get into power? Is that helpful in the present crisis? Surely Deputy Hogan would be better employed in explaining what he promised to explain in the quotation I have just given than in repeating that statement here to-day. How does it help for him to repeat that he heard it stated or that it was repeated at various cross-roads by every Fianna Fáil T.D., "If you vote for us you will never have to pay annuities."? Whom does it help? As a matter of fact during the last election it was reported in the "Irish Independent" that Deputy Hogan made a speech in one of the towns in Galway, I forget which, in which he said that he had been for the first time in his life attending a Fianna Fáil meeting. To-day he said he heard half a dozen Fianna Fáil candidates, and at present presumably Deputies, telling the people that, if they gave these candidates their votes, they would not have to pay their annuities. I was in half a dozen counties during the last General Election and I never heard a suggestion of that kind. If there is any criticism that could be levelled at the Fianna Fáil meetings it is that there was too much of a rather absurd type of idealism. I felt sorry for the belief that prevailed amongst younger members of Fianna Fáil that by a very liberal use of Government action they could transform this country into a paradise in a few years.

Listening to Fianna Fáil speakers, I have always felt that they were rather hoping for too much in that respect. That, however, is a thing that is apt to prevail in every country. I must say that I never attended a Fianna Fáil meeting at which any suggestion was made that the annuities should not be paid. Again, practically every Deputy here took part in the Kildare by-election. That was the by-election which really brought this matter of the annuities to an issue. We were listening to one another at every cross-roads and at every church door. Why does not some Deputy mention a cross-roads or church door at which this statement was made? There was no truth in it.

Comment on this

It was stated in this House.

Comment on this

Deputies said here that it was stated at every church door and at every cross-roads.

Comment on this

It was stated here and I have the statement.

Comment on this

The Cumann na nGaedheal Party are wonderful for documentation. Every time they want a document, they are able to produce it. They seem to have rooms full of newspaper cuttings and they are wonderfully served by their Secretariat in regard to the production of quotations at the right time. Neither Deputy Hayes nor Deputy Hogan, of Galway, quoted from any newspaper report to show that this statement was made at any particular cross-roads or church door. I think it is deplorable that these statements should be made now.

Comment on this

I have the statement here.

Comment on this

I think it is deplorable that this should go on at this time. I think it is regrettable, on that account, that this meeting of the Dáil has been held at all. It has done no good. It has only served to spread abroad the curious description of the majority of this country as people who are watching for an opportunity to escape paying their debts, as people who answer to the good, old English description of being too lazy to work and who want to do nothing to fulfil their duties to the State. That is the achievement of Cumann na nGaedheal during the last two days. If they are proud of that achievement, I do not envy them.

Comment on this

In view of the probability that this House will not meet for another two months and that this special meeting has devoted almost twenty hours to discussion of the land annuities, I venture to say a few words.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

On the motion before the House?

Comment on this
Mr. Byrne

Yes. The President asked for £2,000,000. Members of the House from the country districts pleaded for consideration for the farmer. They pleaded justly and not an hour too much has been devoted to the consideration of the agricultural industry in connection with this proposal. I venture to ask whether any of that £2,000,000 will be devoted to the relief or assistance of the 8,000 people in the City of Dublin who are living on a small food ticket, provided not from taxation but through the rates of the city. We have, in Dublin, iron workers, painters, builders and unskilled men living in the tenements and receiving a food ticket valued 10/-per week to support themselves, a wife and two children. These men have the landlord clamouring at the door for his rent. The Dublin landlord has been very reasonable and very tolerant in granting time to his tenants but even landlords must get paid. After two or three months arrears, these people, in receipt of 10/-for themselves, a wife and two children, must pack up their belongings in a perambulator and go out to search for a basement dwelling. When all this talk is going on about the farmers, I ask the President if he will give some consideration to these unfortunate people. Our shipyards are at a standstill. Our docks have slackened down. There is little or no building going on. With a great feeling of insecurity present, those who have a little money will not spend it, with the result that there is continued unemployment and grave hardship for the people for whom I speak. I believe that if the political history of the last 12 or 14 years could be forgotten and if our President would go to England and negotiate, there would be a considerable change. Deputy Norton said to-day—very few, I think, noticed his words—that the bond holders in England or elsewhere have no right to take from the struggling farmers the annuities that they are unable to pay. I ask Deputy Norton, if that is so, what about the suspense account? If we all admit that they are unable to pay, would it not be better to go over to the other side, meet the people there, drop any idea of getting a political victory over those at home and ask the people on the other side, in equity, to forgive the debt? Negotiate with them on that basis. At all events, give it a trial and see what the result will be. If you could settle the land annuities question on these lines, employment would improve and the hardships our people are now suffering would be relieved. Would that not be a splendid day's work for the President and his Executive? Deputy Norton says that the farmers are unable to pay. Why not make that the issue with the people on the other side and ask their consideration of it? I believe some good would come of such a suggestion. Instead of that, we are faced with giving our money to other countries for their goods, while they will buy nothing from us. Deputy Norton referred to the conditions in other countries and he especially mentioned Belgium. Do we hope to get a market there? Do we hope to get any trade with them in exchange for the goods we may buy from them during this crisis? With other speakers I ask where is it all going to end? There ought to be no more talk of casualties. Something ought to be done to relieve the people. Food prices are going up.

Comment on this

Where?

Comment on this

They are going up, taxation is getting heavier and heavier —taxation equivalent to a substantial reduction in income.

Comment on this

Is income from the Royal Liver going down?

Comment on this
Mr. Byrne

The Deputy asks is income from the Royal Liver going down. The Royal Liver Society gives employment to 2,000 good Irishmen, some of whom fought with, and were in goal with, Deputies on the Government Benches. The Royal Liver pays good wages and gives good pensions. If the Deputy opposite refers to my association with the Royal Liver I may tell him that I am very proud of being associated with that society and with the workers in it. I do not intend to be put out by these interruptions. I ask Deputies from country constituencies to remember that there is such a place as tenement Dublin. I ask them to remember the conditions I have just described to them, and I ask is there any farmer in the country suffering in the same way? A man with a wife and two children gets 10/- a week in food tickets. He has to find his rent wherever he can. These are the conditions that exist. Eight thousand people on that kind of relief; 3,000 on indoor relief, and thousands not eligible for any kind of relief because they travel up from the country, and they come to Dublin and are not entitled to any kind of relief. Is that a proper condition of things for a country like ours? When may we hope to reap the fruits of the great week that is past? When may we hope for the fruits of the greatest of all weeks, the week of the Eucharistic Congress? As a result of that, one would hope for something good. Is it too late to hope for something good and that the political issues will be dropped—political abuse, and all the talk about who is a traitor and who is not. There are threats to people to keep their tongues quiet and so on. Who cares for threats? "Keep your tongue quiet or else." Is there a man in the House who cares, remembering the last fifteen years in Dublin?—"Or else." I appeal to the President to give consideration to the poor and the unemployed, to men who are in precarious employment and who may lose it after another week or two; and for God's sake, let us have no more.

Comment on this

Deputy Byrne has spoken and again in the usual play-acting way he indulges in——

Comment on this
Mr. Byrne

I will not be accused of play-acting by a man who has run away from his own people in Palestine. Let him go back to Palestine and work for his own people.

Comment on this

Remember the Eucharistic Week you talked about. Be consistent.

Comment on this

There is plenty of room for Jews and Gentiles in this country.

Comment on this

I welcome that from Deputy Gorey; it being the first time I heard such from him.

Comment on this

I will not be accused of play-acting.

Comment on this

You never did anything else.

Comment on this

Deputy Byrne spoke of 8,000 people in this City of Dublin as if these 8,000 families were brought into destitution in the past few months. He knows better than I do, if he goes back over the records, that he has indulged in the past ten years the same chronic complaint that he indulged in to-day.

Comment on this

I have not indulged in any personalities and I hope the Deputy will not be allowed to indulge in personalities.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

I cannot see that there are any personalities in the remarks Deputy Briscoe has just made.

Comment on this

I did not realise that I was in any way personal when I suggested that Deputy Byrne had great experience in this city of raising questions on the destitution that confronted the people of this country.

Comment on this
Mr. Byrne

Not by way of play-acting.

Comment on this

You never did anything else. You are going about here shaking your chain.

Comment on this

The suggestion has gone round, we are told, that anyone who takes up a position in opposition to the Government is dubbed anti-Irish. One Deputy complained that it was put about the country that anyone who took up such an attitude should be shot. I want to say that I am quite satisfied that the efforts the present Government are making are being made in the best interests of the majority of the people of this country. Other methods have been tried in the past. The 8,000 destitute people of whom Deputy Byrne spoke, in the City of Dublin, are the result of the methods tried by the predecessors of this Government. Whatever point of view one may have about them individually or collectively, even if it were admitted that they did their best, nevertheless, their position from the point of view they held brought no results of which the people in Dublin or in any part of the Twenty-Six Counties can be proud. Deputy Byrne spoke about threats. I have experience of threats and threats by Deputy Byrne when I raised a question in the Dublin Corporation——

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

We are not discussing the Dublin Corporation.

Comment on this

When I raised, elsewhere, a protest against legislation introduced in this House—the Public Safety Bill—Deputy Byrne arrived with armed men, made a scurrilous statement in regard to myself and left the place.

Comment on this
Mr. Byrne

That is not true.

Comment on this

It is true.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Deputies should leave the discussion of these matters to their proper sphere.

Comment on this

We have had very recently the experience of being seriously misled. When the Safety Bill was passed we had the spectacle, in this House, of every Deputy of the Cumann na nGaedheal Party, and every member of their Party in the Seanad, and every member amongst the Independents who was expected to vote for the support of the Government in the passage of their legislation, arriving here in this House under an armed bodyguard.

Comment on this

For very obvious reasons.

Comment on this

The obvious reason according to some was that they might have stayed away instead of coming here but for that.

Comment on this

I want to get to the point that if anybody really wants to examine the facts, as they confront us, it must be admitted that the cause insisted upon, for armed persons guarding other people, is becoming less than was the experience of our people in recent years before the election.

Comment on this

Creamery managers have to be guarded now.

Comment on this

I am saying it is a lot less. We had the spectacle of every member of the former Government being guarded at one time. Now there are some and I think they will be guarded and protected in that way until we can be sure their lives are safe. We want to see every section of the people, from every point of view, giving expression to their views, without fear of intimidation. We are heading in that direction and I say that the present Executive Council are doing their level best to bring about a situation where all shades of opinion can be expressed in public or in the House without any fear of intimidation one way or the other.

As regards the Deputy's suggestion that I should go to a certain place, I will leave that to himself, or, as a colleague of mine here beside me has said, I will leave it as an outburst as a result of the benefits he has derived here in the last few months where a little more charity is evinced than ever he expressed here.

The situation which the Deputy put before us has been his experience and my experience in the City of Dublin for a great number of years. We have hopes now, through a tariff policy and through the attitude adopted by the Executive Council, to try to bring about first consideration for the people of this country. I do not want to see or hear about farmers suffering unnecessarily. Nor do I want to see a constitution of the situation which we have and have had for many years in Dublin, but I do believe and I am quite happy and satisfied in thinking that an honest effort has been made and is being made by the Executive Council to grapple with these problems. What this sum of £2,000,000 will be used for remains to be seen. It will be seen as it arises. but I am not at all afraid, as some of the Deputies on the opposite side have suggested, that it may be given away to some pals or to some friends. I say this—that we will have in the very near future a change. We will have industries springing up in the Twenty-Six Counties and employment given to greater numbers than before. We will have a situation where the people will be able to earn the money to buy enough to eat. Deputy Hogan has asked what are we going to do with our surplus £30,000,000 worth of food if we lose our British market. We want to see that the population will be enabled to earn sufficient to eat and subsist on the food we produce and that it will not be a surplus product because nobody is able to buy it. If there were a good and a decent standard of living, so that the people could afford to purchase all they needed, and if the amount of food which they could consume were to be deducted from the amount we have at present, our exportable surplus would be a great deal less than the £30,000,000 worth referred to by Deputy Hogan.

A lot of heat has been engendered in this discussion. Deputy Anthony made ridiculous charges against the Minister for Justice and the Minister for Defence and, in fact, against the whole Executive Council. He said that the Minister for Justice was cowardly and that he was afraid to deal with a section of the Press that was advocating the shooting of individuals. I do not know of any section of the Press in this country that has been advocating the shooting of individuals among our people. I think, Sir, that when Deputy Anthony makes a statement of that kind he should be asked to substantiate what he says by a production of the documents in question. Deputy Anthony also says that county councils all over the country are passing and sending snowball resolutions of the same kind. I have not seen any snowball resolutions, or any other kind of resolution, of that nature. I certainly have seen resolutions by county councils pledging support to the Government and asking all Irishmen, now that it is a fight between England and the Free State and a case of standing together unitedly for the purpose of getting the best we can for the country—I have seen such resolutions asking Irishmen to sink their political differences without sinking their political identities for the purpose of getting the best we can in this matter. It was admitted by Deputy Hogan to-day that we will get a settlement of some kind. He even says that it will be a good settlement. His statement means that through the change of Government a situation has come whereby we are going to have this country some millions of pounds better off than it was when this Government was here.

What have the Opposition done in this matter? Instead of keeping quiet while the difficulty is on and criticising afterwards, they are criticising before-hand, and saying to England that the people are against us in this matter, trying to make out that 50 per cent. of the country—and, of course, the only honest, decent section is the 50 per cent. which they represent—are with them. If they do believe that the 8,000 destitute families in Dublin, referred to by Deputy Byrne, are there, if they want to see a change from the existence that these poor people have had for the past ten years, let them give this Executive Council a chance of doing something. If I found that the policy of this Executive Council would not bring twice as good results as was brought by our predecessors I admit that some other method would have to be tried and that neither Cumann na nGaedheal nor Fianna Fáil could solve the problem. At the present time, as I see it, we are heading for a better system entirely than the system under which we lived before, namely, that depression in England meant lower prices for our goods here and that if accidental prosperity came to England we got better prices and more prosperity here. It is up to us to keep our own house in order according to our own needs and according to our own requirements. We should not be considered hostile to any country because we feel that we can establish an industry here and that, in order to establish it and guarantee its continuity, we have to protect it. I do not see any hostility to any country in doing that. Some Deputies have said: "No wonder England has struck back. You put on tariffs." We put on tariffs to protect goods that we believe can be manufactured here and should be manufactured here. It is time enough for these Deputies to kick up a fuss if we are facing disaster and failing in the administration of our own country. Deputy Byrne said that prices of foodstuffs are going up. They are not going up. They are falling. They are getting cheaper. I do not believe that the Deputy could quote an instance where they are increasing. It may be argued that they are falling because of the present situation. I am satisfied to leave it to the Executive Council to settle this difference. It is a matter that concerns this country and another country. The Executive Council have the support of the majority of the people of the country and it is up to us to give them that support, and if they fail to make a good bargain it will then be time for Deputies opposite and here to reconsider their views regarding their allegiance to the Government. As regards the internal affairs of the country, which concern me intimately at the moment—because I am not a bit worried about what will happen in this matter between us and England—as regards affairs at home I believe there is going to be a better future for the people of this country and for the 8,000 people in the City of Dublin who are at present living on outdoor relief provided by the rate-payers of the city.

Comment on this

Deputy Seamus Moore, I think, gave us, to some extent at all events, a cue to the Fianna Fáil policy when he said that as far as he could make out it consisted of an absurd idealism. The matter before us—this matter of trying to find the £2,000,000—is certainly one not of a very ideal nature under the present circumstances, but it compels us to face the facts of the situation.

Comment on this
Séamus Moore Mr. Seamus Moore Fianna Fáil

I said no such thing. I said if there was any fault to be found it was in the amount of idealism to be found in Fianna Fáil.

Comment on this

And the Deputy added that that fault was being found in certain of the younger members of Fianna Fáil.

Comment on this

I accept anything the Deputy says, but, at all events, there is nothing of absurd idealism in asking the House to find £2,000,000. It is a very real fact and one that we have got to consider. What I am very much concerned about is where this £2,000,000 is to come from. We are told there is no Minister for Finance was not able to remit even a penny of the tax on the sixpenny Soccer ticket. Yet, a day or two afterwards, we are asked to find £2,000,000 to fight England in this economic war upon which we are engaged. I cannot see how this country is going to find this £2,000,000. In his introductory speech on the Budget, the Minister for Finance told us that trade last year was something more than 30 per cent. below the trade of the previous year, and, in face of that, he puts taxation to the extent of an extra 25 per cent. on the country this year. What the trade returns for the first half of this year are it is difficult to say at the moment, but, so far as we can make them out, trade is, at least, more than 40 per cent. less than last year. On top of the unfortunate people of this country, with a declining trade, with declining resources and with the black outlook at present before them, an imposition of £2,000,000 to fight this war is being put. In other words, we are going to arm them for war by taxing them still further.

What is this war we are engaged upon? It is a money fight with England and this is the fight behind which we are asked to range ourselves. We were told here that this Government had a majority mandate. I would like to remind the President, and the members of the Fianna Fáil Party, that they do not form even a majority in this House. They could not even form a Government without depending on Kipling's "Seven men from all the world," who swallowed every Trade Union principle and every election pledge——

Comment on this

Since when?

Comment on this

Since the election and since they came in here to maintain the Fianna Fáil Party in power as a Government.

Comment on this

It is the Deputy's imagination. We seem to be a great obstacle to you.

Comment on this

I am simply stating what is the truth. In spite of this, Deputy Matthew O'Reilly tells us that 95 per cent. of the nation is behind them in this economic fight, and the House knows what proportion the farmers form of the population of this country. Deputy O'Reilly tells us—he is very fond of the 90 per cent—that 90 per cent. of the farmers are down and out, and these 90 per cent. of down-and-outs are going to be the soldiers in your first line trenches. How are you going to fight a war when 90 per cent. of your shock troops, your first line trench men, are already casualties in the fight? Is the thing not absurd? Why does the House not try to get away from this absurd idealism, to which I refer again, and try to face up to the realities of this situation? We are going to fight England with money and we are going to buy foreign goods to kill England. Let us take the realities of this situation. Here we are, a small island. The Free State contains something less than 3,000,000 people. Our resources are small, while across the water, three hours from us, is a big and strong nation of 60,000,000 of people, with boundless resources of wealth. We speak a common language—I am very sorry to say that—and our intercourse naturally flows between our agricultural interests and their industrial interests. There is a natural flow of trade between the two. That is the real situation and is it not most unnatural that that relationship should be disturbed? I quite agree that, owing to past causes, political and otherwise, our economic policies have run on parallel lines. That has not been, as we know, to the advantage of this country.

We have been accused here of not developing the real economic policy of Arthur Griffith, but, unfortunately, since the change over, and since we got our own political and civil freedom, we have been unable, by reason of circumstances, to carry out the development of that policy. It must be understood that the late Government took this country out of the ashes to which it had been reduced through the refusal of the men on the opposite side to obey majority rule. That is a fact. I will agree that I, as one with a strong national outlook, am sorry to say that we are bound up too much with England, but I certainly say that a time of economic crisis is not the time to break down our present economic structure and to try to raise a new one. It is too critical a time, and it must also be understood that this thing has not been forced upon us by England. We have been told that Mr. Thomas has done this and that. Mr. Thomas did some very clownish things, I admit, but the House must understand that the policy that has been built up here, from the very manner in which it originated, in its protestations of hatred against England, or against anybody who showed any desire for friendship with England, was bound, some time or another, to eventuate in the present impasse. We had all this talk and we adopted the policy from Mr. Ghandi of non-co-operation with England. We have had the little pin-prickings of the tariffs here, and this was bound to eventuate in some sort of impasse. I do not, for a moment, wish to take England's side in this, and I certainly object to, and protest against, being called pro-English, but I will not, even if I have to do so alone, stand behind any of these resolutions that are going around the country asking me to support a policy which I know to be suicidal, criminal and foolish for this country to adopt.

I do not want to speak at very great length because most of the ideas I express have been expressed better, perhaps, by others, but I say that the outlook is very dangerous. Deputy Norton's speech, a while ago, put it to the Government whether they were going to continue with this £2,000,000 to buttress up the soulless capitalism that was destroying and has destroyed this country. Take that speech with the other pronouncements that have appeared in the public Press recently and see where we find ourselves. Three or four weeks ago, in one of the papers in Dublin, Deputy Norton was asked how long would it be before the workers of Gallaher's and Jacobs take possession of these factories. I saw placards in the streets of Dublin, a fortnight ago, urging to "Get a grip on the banks." Put all those together and what are you making for? The country is making for a very dangerous form of Sovietism here, which will not have behind it the positive plan of Russian Sovietism, but which will have all its vicious elements emphasised and aggravated. Then, when all this is over, when we have fought England with this money at a time when even our pound is guaranteed at this very moment in London, what is going to happen? There can be only one end to this unfortunate fight. In fact, it is over before it is begun, and the misery is already beginning to rise up in our country places and in the by-ways of our cities and towns where workers already find themselves out of work. It is practically over and yet we are deliberately told that we are going in to fight. I do not mind any of the men on the opposite benches going into fight, but I do not think that we ought to drag the helpless and workless people of this country, the women and children, into a ridiculous fight where they are going to meet with nothing but hunger, starvation and ruination.

I think the issue is very clear. We have taken up a position that is untenable and I do not think it would be wrong in our general, or our leader, or whatever he may call himself, to retire from that position so that, later on, when the clouds have cleared away, and when we may have strength in our own resources, we may advance on a new form of social order more akin to our national outlook and instincts. I think that is the policy that the President has before him, because he says that we are being forced to do, in a short time, what would take us years to do. I said in the begining that I think this is not the time to try to start a new social order. We are bound to fail, because, in addition to our own weakness, we have the strength of the forces of Sovietism and Bolshevism all around us in the country. There is no use disguising that fact. When all this has passed away the question of the annuities and the financial settlement with England will still remain to be settled. They have to be settled some time. In the history of the world a war never settled anything. If we go away without doing something now, perhaps in two months' time it will be too late to retract from the untenable position we have taken up. I appeal not only to the President but to every Deputy to come to the assistance of our common country. The President went over to London twice and on each occasion his visit did not extend beyond twelve hours. That period did not give a fair chance to make a settlement on a question like this. Deputies on the opposite benches represents one interest, Deputies on these benches represent another interest, but we all represent our common country—the Free State—and all of us would make any sacrifice to help our country. There was never a time when sacrifice on Party lines was so necessary. Would it not be possible to get together a committee representative of all Parties to meet during the Recess to consider the situation? Let us forget Party bitterness and Party points, while not forgetting Party principles, and little time would elapse before we could get an understanding with England that would be a durable one.

Comment on this

Deputy the Lord Mayor of Dublin struck a very appropriate note when he referred to the difficulties under which tenement dwellers in Dublin Labour. That condition of affairs is peculiar to every large town and to many country districts, so that we must try to visualise what will be the effect on those who helped their weaker brethren, when they are unable to realise the surplus production of the farming industry. Deputy Anthony clearly indicated in his speech the view that the man in the street is likely to take of the position as it affects the agricultural community. It must be very plain that when a market is not available for our surplus agricultural production there is a tendency on the part of those who take a part in that industry to lessen their efforts to increase production to any material extent. The income of the country is absolutely dependent upon that industry. Reference has been made to the £30,000,000 of agricultural exports. Instead of having the value of that produce reduced we should try to increase it in order to add to our wealth and to explore every avenue to find more markets. The President is now asking for two millions of money. If sufficient reasons are given to the House I believe that it should not refuse that demand. Members of the Dáil had always shown their readiness to attend when summoned. Although the attendance in the House is sparse at the moment, the divisions have shown that there is practically a full representation available. To hide from the people the means whereby that money is to be expended is, I think, a negation and a flouting of the democratic principles upon which the Government of any country is based. Is the money for the purpose of compensating farmers for the twenty per cent. duty that they are losing through no fault of their own? Perhaps the only fault is that they have given a majority to a Government which has brought about this state of affairs. Is the money for the purpose of supplying capital to farmers whose income has been very materially reduced by the reduction of the twenty per cent. from every form of live stock that they produce? If so, the President is certainly doing something which will perhaps help farmers to keep on producing, and will compensate them in some measure for the losses they have incurred. Practically speaking it is like feeding the dog on a bit of his own tail, because the agricultural community have to bear it in future taxation.

[An Leas-Cheann Comhairle took the Chair.]

The President in the course of his speech referred to the intention of exploring new markets to take the place of the English market, which we have for many years been accustomed to supply, and to exchange our products for products that we do not produce. It is very questionable if new markets can be found. At any rate it has to be taken into consideration that no new market will be got unless we take the products of these countries for our produce. That is the principle which governs trade between countries, that imports are paid for more or less by exports. Unless an agreement of that particular description can be made with other producing countries, I do not see how the President is going to get alternative markets. Supposing we exchange our livestock for the products of other countries, will we be able to get them on the same terms as we were getting them from the great country with which we had an export trade? I question if we will. If we do, these products must take the place of some industry that the President desired to establish by the large volume of protective tariffs imposed here. It must be clear to the dullest intellect that if such action is taken by the President then we must suffer the loss and he will fail in his policy of protective tariffs.

A stop has been placed on imports of British coal. I heard from manufacturers that they will not be able to use German coal. In fact it would be a positive injury to the boilers that some of them use. It also means more expense in carrying on manufactures, and that is certainly a set-back to the volume of production here. The House should seriously take into consideration the fact that the manufacturers will have to continue using British coal and to pay the tax, because, however we may feel about it, it is what conduces to efficiency in production that we will have to look to.

Comment on this

Name the manufacturers.

Comment on this

I will answer the Deputy afterwards.

Comment on this

How do the Germans get along?

Comment on this

By having a different type of furnace—the obvious reason.

Comment on this

We would have to alter a good deal of our machinery and to adopt the type of machine suitable for German coal. With regard to the land annuities I am sorry there has been an exchange of bitterness over this controversy, because, unquestionably we ought to preserve friendly relations between the two countries. In that way I believe we would get substantial concessions with regard to the annuities. I for one will not feel at all hurt if the President gets completely away with his policy of retaining the annuities. It will be £3,000,000 to the benefit of this country and I sincerely hope that negotiations will be resumed. I sincerely trust in the interests of the country that the President will endeavour to resume negotiations and that he will succeed either in getting a portion of this money or else carrying the whole hog in his negotiations with the British Government.

Comment on this

Did not Deputy Brasier vote in favour of handing over the land annuities?

Comment on this

I will be very glad if the President succeeds in getting them retained; but in view of the consequences which we are experiencing at the present moment when the Irish farmer is not able to pay his land annuities and the consequence of the tariffs imposed on our imports, I think I was perfectly justified in my action in voting for handing them over. The fact is that at the recent election I did not support the principle of retaining them. I pointed out to the farmers the consequences. I think the fact that I am here is a very clear indication that a large section in this country agrees with me. However, that does not change the fact that if the President succeeds by negotiations in retaining these land annuities without imposing on the country the very serious consequences that would be likely to ensue from the present economic war, then I will be very glad and the President will be conferring a great service on the country. But if the consequence of retaining them means that no farmer will be able to realise any portion of his produce or to pay any portion of his annuities, rates or shop debts, then all I have to say is that it does not require a very well-educated economist to realise the very serious waste that this will cause to the economic condition of this country and the injury that it will do to the workers and the unemployed and the chaos it will bring about.

Comment on this

Will Deputy Brasier answer a couple of questions? Will the Deputy tell the House whether he was prepared to continue the payment of these annuities? Will he say that on two occasions he stood as a candidate for this Dáil in the Farmers' Union interests? On the first occasion, he lost his deposit, and on the second occasion he barely saved it; but it was only when he repudiated the farmers and went on his own as a rag and bone merchant that he succeeded in getting in.

Comment on this

I think the very fact that I won on my own is the strongest indication of the soundness of the policy I unfolded to the electorate. I won, in spite of what Deputy Corry said, and in spite of the hordes of his friends who were out against me. I do not think there was a stronger barrage let loose on any candidate than that which Deputy Corry turned on me, and I am very glad of the fact that the electors of East Cork had the strength of mind to withstand the eloquence of the policy which the Fianna Fáil Party were able to bring on them. However, I am here and that does not prevent me from appealing to the President to use all the means in his power to open up negotiations again to bring about a settlement in this country. Otherwise, agricultural and commercial prosperity will be non-existent. I can only add that I would not like to call Deputy Corry any names.

Comment on this

Deputy Briscoe in the course of his speech—which added very little to this debate—queried the point made by Deputy Byrne as to the number of people destitute in this city Clearly that point of Deputy Byrne was that whatever the number of destitute now might be, the number of the unemployed and the destitutes is going to increase even while these £2,000,000 were in a blundering way being distributed. Deputy Briscoe's comment was that such destitution was there before and that Deputy Byrne's statement was nonsense. The facts however are that at this time last year there were 7,000 registered unemployed and there are now 14,000 registered unemployed in Dublin.

Comment on this

For what reason?

Comment on this

Because there is more unemployment.

Comment on this

Because they were asked to register and there was no useful purpose in registering before.

Comment on this

And though there is no more useful purpose in registering now still they are registering in greater numbers. No greater benefits are paid, but the numbers of unemployed are doubled——

Comment on this

No.

Comment on this

The numbers, so far as registration has shown, have doubled in the City of Dublin. The second point I have to deal with before I pass from Deputy Briscoe is his reference to the people who take their stand in opposition to this Vote. I have only to say that the Irish blood that runs purely in my veins did not make my heart beat one bit faster at the call of the blood that was sent out to me by Deputy Briscoe——

Comment on this

I did not send the call of the blood to the Deputy.

Comment on this

—or his call to Irish nationality and to Irish nationalism. As I said before, this country will soon come to realise the correct situation when they find the MacEoins, the Cosgraves, and the Fitzgeralds on this side of the House being accused of lack of patriotism by the Briscoes, the de Valeras, the Flinns and the Johnsons on the other side of the House.

Comment on this

Did the Deputy ever hear of James Carey and did he ever hear of Pearse and Childers?

Comment on this

I did, and I say that it is no little arrogance on Deputy Briscoe's part to associate himself with men who proved themselves to be patriots and who proved themselves to be unselfish in their patriotism.

Comment on this

I nearly proved it. It was not the Deputy's fault that I did not.

Comment on this

Just luck, I suppose, that you escaped.

Comment on this

I did.

Comment on this

The Deputy imputes to Deputy Hogan the saying that because Fianna Fáil has got into office they can get a settlement which will retain millions of money in this country. I did not hear anyone argue that because of Fianna Fáil being in office a good settlement could be got. It has certainly been stated here that by reason of the new circumstances that have quite recently arisen in Europe, the Fianna Fáil Government found itself in a position to make a settlement by which something of value could be secured. I have never heard it admitted that Fianna Fáil was in fact going to get any good out of these favourable circumstances, because I have not yet found anyone to admit, viewing their recent performances, that that Party of blunderers is likely to reap advantage from anything.

Comment on this

Does the Deputy agree with Deputy Hogan?

Comment on this

Deputy Hogan agrees with me that that Party is unlikely to make a good settlement.

Comment on this

That you will get a settlement.

Comment on this

Someone has phrased this Vote of £2,000,000 the sinews of war. It is not that so much as slugs for the blunderbusses. That is what these histrionics about piling up a war chest amount to—a war chest of which the President does not yet know the purposes or uses, although in the last debate he said that everybody must have recognised and that he personally had foreseen that this situation was bound to develop. Whether everybody recognised that or not he was clear about himself; he certainly understood that this situation was developing. Deputy Flinn knows what the money is to be used for. He said so last night but added that he would not give away the secrets to the enemy. Deputy Flinn knows; the President does not know. The Parliamentary Secretary knows the use that is to be made of these £2,000,000. Leave purposes and uses aside, we have as yet heard no statements as to where the £2,000,000 are to come from. Has any Deputy, willing to vote this money, cleared up that point for himself?

Deputy Davin in this debate made the criticism that this Vote was on a parallel with a Vote of £2,000,000 moved by me without explanation for the Electricity Supply Board. Deputy Davin has an errant memory. So well was the application of that sum of money explained in this House that his leader said he was not prepared to vote for certain amendments which had been put down enormously reducing the sum. When that same Vote went to the Seanad one of the most prominent Senators of the Labour Party said that after the explanation given by me in the Dáil it would be criminal folly for the Seanad to refuse one shilling of the money asked for. There were many divisions made of the money in that Vote and lengthy explanations as to how soon it was to be paid out and on what it was to be expended, and the divisions corresponded to subheads ordinarily introduced into an Estimate. But here and now we are asked for this £2,000,000 and this simple paragraph is all the explanation we get:

Disbursements will be made from this Fund, subject to terms and conditions to be approved by the Minister for Finance, to promote the continuance of trade, industry and business, to open new markets for agricultural and manufactured produce, to establish or assist in establishing new industries and generally for all expenses arising out of or in the course of the present emergency.

That is lucidity indeed and that is, in the main, the content of the speech that the President delivered in moving for this sum of money. Let us fit this into its proper perspective. The Government came into power, in the main, because they promised to reduce taxation this year by £2,000,000. So far from doing that, the Minister for Finance boasted on July 14th that the Government took the responsibility of imposing on the country for this year an additional burden of taxation amounting to £4,250,000. We are therefore £6,250,000 down on the Election promise. The promised reduction of £2,000,000 has gone and we have had the Government taking the responsibility of adding on an extra £4,250,000. We are now asked for £2,000,000 more and it is to be presumed—and I am going on this presumption until it is contradicted and shown to be false — that this £2,000,000 is new money. We have therefore, so far, failed to get the £2,000,000 reduction we were promised. We had £4,250,000 extra imposed by the Budget and now we have a new sum of £2,000,000 being looked for. We are really £8,250,000 down on the promises which got this Government the possession of Government. And all we are permitted to know about this new money is that it is to be used for expenses arising out of the present emergency.

If one can believe any of the statements made, the only hope that out of this emergency will come something good rests on the statement made in the Seanad by Senator Connolly that "if England does not give us this money England will not get the exemption from debt that she is seeking from America." That was the statement made by a responsible Minister of this Government, speaking in a most important debate. I assume he has the authority of the American Minister in this country for making that statement—that the United States Government has taken up our case and that England will not get the remission of debts for which she is requesting remission until she has left in our hands and in our safe keeping these disputed moneys. That statement was made by a man who should at least be responsible. It was made under circumstances that might induce responsibility, even from an irresponsible person, and it was made in a House and on a debate where he must have realised his responsibility.

So the big stick of America is being wagged now. I presume, when it is being wielded in this open way we may gather that America is really going to act on our behalf. It would be a good thing to know that precisely. Or is it to emerge again and slowly to be driven home that another diplomatic blunder has been committed and that, on top of Governmental rudeness to the French, there has been piled Governmental incapacity for proper behaviour towards the Americans? The statement, however, stands, for contradiction or confirmation, that we are in the happy position that England will not get that remission from debt for which she is looking unless we are satisfied on this question. We have an American Minister in this State and there was, possibly, contact with him, and it is to be presumed that he stands for that statement. Perhaps Senator Connolly will give us some explanation of what it means. If it is not true it can be repudiated. If it only means that we are trying to inject our little politics into American politics, I do not think that attempt is going to be successful.

Comment on this

It was successful in 1921.

Comment on this

It might be as big a blunder as the victory at Mytilene.

Comment on this

Is Thomas waiting for that answer?

Comment on this

It is to be noted that Senator Connolly was chosen to publish that statement, as it was he who in an earlier debate about 1929 said, in relation to the Nicaraguan situation, that the American people had been guilty of more atrocities in Nicaragua than the Black and Tans were in this country. There must have been definitely a burying of the hatchet between Senator Connolly and the Americans if he is now in the position to tell us that the Americans are on our side and that those whom he dubbed Black and Tan may meet the original Black and Tans if it comes eventually to a contest over this money.

Deputy Flinn made a point last night which he thought was of substance. If, he says, it is true that England is collecting these annuities by means of the duties, then the annuities are, in fact, being paid. In that case, he continued, we should not pay the annuities as a lump sum. He argued that in that case we are absolved from payment. One answer to that is that if you owe a debt which, if you do not pay, your creditor proceeds to take in some other way, that does not relieve you of your moral responsibility in regard to the debt.

But there is another and a better counter to Deputy Flinn's argument. If, in fact, the country is being bled to the extent of £3,000,000 or £5,000,000 by the new duties, and if the annuities at the same time are being collected direct from the farmer, then the farmer is, according to Deputy Flinn, paying twice. And it is true that the farmer is paying twice and he will probably pay a third time when we proceed to exact, by our emergency duties, what the Government represent as a payment from the British, but what is clearly going to be a payment from ourselves. The arguments in connection with all this have shifted from time to time, and as they have shifted it seems to me that certain of the earlier and more nonsensical protestations made by Fianna Fáil have also been abandoned. It is good, however, to recall them at this time. It is useful to ponder on what was promised to us, to wonder whether those promises are still being maintained or whether there is any hope of their fulfilment.

But before I deal with these promises, I shall clear away one smaller point. Deputy Moore is anxious to know if anyone can give absolute documentation as to whether or not the Fianna Fáil policy at one time was not to collect the annuities. I do not want to go to chapel meetings for proof of this. I will content myself with the debates in this House. A statement was made here on the 2nd May, 1929, by the then Minister for Agriculture. He alluded to Deputy Fogarty who, I think, still adorns the Fianna Fáil ranks. The then Minister, Deputy Hogan, said that "he preferred Deputy Fogarty, Deputy Mullins and Deputy Corry. Their attitude, he thought, was much more honest. There is not," he said,"the same amount of pettifogging about it." I am quoting from Mr. Hogan's statement in Col. 1347 of the Debate for 2nd May, 1929. Mr. Hogan went on:—

"Here is what Deputy Fogarty said:—

When Mr. Hogan, the Minister for Agriculture, was in Clonmel recently, he did not give much heart to Mr. Morris's motion. The motion we will put forward is to pay no land annuities."

That drew from Deputy Fogarty the interruption: "And only right, too." Then Deputy Fogarty, apparently, disappeared from the House while numerous columns were spoken. He made his reappearance later, having probably been coached that his statement was an unwise statement. He intervened to explain, and the explanation ought to be attended to. On col. 1434 Deputy Fogarty, in reply to Deputy Rice, said:—

My view upon this is that until such time as the annuities are retained in the Irish Exchequer the farmers ought not to pay the annuities.

Apply that to the present situation. What is the policy of Fianna Fáil as understood and announced by Deputy Fogarty? No payment by the farmer.

Comment on this

That is not relevant to the point raised.

Comment on this

I was asked whether or not it could be evidenced that any Deputy had stated that the policy was that the farmer should not pay. There it is.

Comment on this

Not at all.

Comment on this

"Pay no land annuities" and "the farmers ought not to pay the annuities."

Comment on this

I referred to the statement made by Deputy Hogan, in the hearing of half a dozen Deputies, that it was stated at every cross-roads and Church-door meeting.

Comment on this

Here it is on record.

Comment on this

That is not every Deputy.

Comment on this

I will absolve Deputy Moore. He believes the farmers ought to pay. He will not be so popular in Wicklow if he announces that in the teeth of his colleagues' advice.

Comment on this

I did say it and I further said I could not understand whether it was a legal case or not, and I do not believe there are half a dozen members on either side who can understand it, with half a dozen lawyers on either side on such a big issue.

Comment on this

But there is what Deputy Fogarty said the policy was.

Comment on this
A Deputy

Every one of them said it.

Comment on this