We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

Financial Resolutions. - Financial Resolution No. 7—General.

Contributions 1–192 of 382. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

Seán F. Lemass Minister for Industry and Commerce (Mr. Lemass) Fianna Fáil

When the various tariffs which were introduced in the Budget were under consideration we found ourselves up against applications for protection from various industries on which it was impossible to arrive at a decision in the time then available. All such applications were postponed and examined in detail later, when more time was available. It is as a result of that detailed examination of applications which offered elements of particular difficulty that these Resolutions are being submitted to the House. Most of the duties imposed are of minor importance in so far as the articles to which they relate are not articles consumed in very great quantities in the country. Some of them, however, can be considered of considerable importance, in so far as they are likely to afford considerably increased employment in the industries affected. In addition to the duties imposed in consequence of that detailed examination of the difficult applications to which I refer, it is also proposed under these Resolutions to effect some minor changes in the duties which were imposed in the Finance Act in consequence of our experience of the working of that Act during the intervening period.

It will, perhaps, be information for Deputies if I indicate the particular category under which the various duties arise. I presume they will desire to have an opportunity of examining them in greater detail and ascertaining information relating to the industries affected before discussing them at length. Any particular point of information desired will be supplied as far as it is possible to do so. The first Resolution contains the Schedule. The duties imposed by it are on coloured knitting yarns, 22½ per cent. with a Preference of 15 per cent. The second is upon any metal which is subject to another duty, and which is imported with an inscription engraved. It is subject to an additional 15 per cent. and 10 per cent., the purpose of the duty being to have increased engraving done in this country. The third relates to date stamps and marking stamps made wholly or partly of rubber or containing parts of such the duty being 50 per cent. with a preference rate of 10 per cent. Resolution 4 concerns springs for mattresses, cushions, settees, and light articles of furniture. The duty applies only to single springs. Assembled springs are already subject to duty. Number 5 deals with spectacles, monocles and other eye-glasses, the duty being 50 per cent. with a preference rate of 33? per cent. Number 6 refers to cuff-links, studs, hinge pins and ear-rings and component parts thereof made wholly or mainly of brass, bronze, or gun-metal, or a combination of any of those metals the duty being 30 per cent. with a preference rate of 20 per cent. Number 7 deals with certain specified articles of gold, silver and electro plate. Number 8 relates to glue and size, the duty being 50 per cent. with a preference of 33? per cent. with a licence clause. The necessity for the licence clause is on a certain type of size not produced here, and which it is necessary to allow to come in. It is not possible to get a definition of that particular size which will permit of its being distinguished from other classes of size which it is desired to make subject to duty. Number 9 relates to fillers and flats for egg boxes imported separately, the duty being 30 per cent. with a preference of 20 per cent. Number 10 deals with pipes made wholly or mainly of clay. Number 11 relates to picture frames wholly or mainly of wood, and pictures in frames made wholly or mainly of wood, excluding pictures which are imported temporarily for exhibition or which are imported for a public picture gallery. Picture frames were heretofore subject to duty as furniture. It is necessary to have this Resolution because certain difficulties arose out of pictures being imported as such, the frames being imported with the pictures and consequently evading duty as picture frames. Number 12 relates to coffin plates of metal.

Comment on this

Let the dead rest.

Comment on this

At least let them be buried in Irish coffins.

Comment on this

With plates of metal.

Comment on this

Number 13 deals with sheet lead and lead piping. It is proposed to delete the relevant reference in the Finance Act and to substitute the reference here, 15 per cent. and 10 per cent. Similarly it is proposed to delete from the Finance Act the reference by which a duty was imposed on certain articles of brass and tin. I mentioned when the section was being discussed that we had considerable difficulty in procuring what we desired to have, a specific list of brass articles which it was desirable to make subject to duty. Consequently we went the other way; we imposed a general duty at a low rate exempting articles which should be exempted. That did not work satisfactorily. In any case, during the adjournment we have had an opportunity of going into the question with much greater care, and, as a result, we are able to produce a specific list of brass articles which are and can be made here, and which it is desired to protect. It is intended to increase the duty on these articles in the case of church brasswork to 75 per cent with a preference of 50 per cent., and in the case of other articles to 50 per cent. with a preference rate of 33? per cent., and to remove the duty from other articles of brass.

Comment on this

What are milk pumps?

Comment on this

Part of the machinery used in creameries.

Comment on this

Does this refer to milking machines?

Comment on this

Milk pumps made of brass.

Comment on this

Does it refer to milking machines?

Comment on this

No. Number 15 is inserted in consequence of what I have said. The relevant reference in the Finance Act will be deleted, but it is necessary to re-enact in the Resolution the part of the Bill dealing with articles made of tin or tin plate. Number 16 is a duty on articles of manufactured woodwork which was imposed in the Finance Act. With certain changes, the entire reference in the Finance Act will cease to operate, and the new section will operate instead. This duty will apply to all plain and dressed timber. It will also apply to mouldings and to margarine boxes, egg boxes and in fact to all types of boxes except pyramid butter boxes. It will also apply to butter kegs and casks, and, in addition, one or two minor exceptions have been made. These are specified in the list in the fifth column, but are of no particular importance.

Comment on this

Is it to apply to component parts of egg boxes?

Comment on this

Yes. No. 17 imposes a duty upon the component parts (excluding road springs) of all wheeled vehicles which, in the opinion of the Revenue Commissioners, are designed, constructed and primarily intended to be drawn by an animal or by two or more animals, and to be used for the carriage of persons or for the carriage of goods or for the carriage of both persons and goods. Under the Finance (No. 2) Act we imposed a duty on unassembled parts. It is now decided to bring unassembled parts under the duty.

No. 18 imposes a similar duty on unassembled iron and steel parts for bodies of motor omnibuses, motor charabancs and commercial motor vehicles. These were exempted under the Finance (No. 2) Act and it is now decided to make them subject to duty.

No. 19 doubles the duty on worked stone. That has been made necessary for a few reasons, the principal of which is that information has reached the Department that exporters of worked marble, who also control to a large extent the supplies of unworked marble, have countered the duties imposed by us by increasing the price of the unworked marble. This duty will operate as a protective measure.

No. 20 imposes 50 per cent. full and 33? per cent. preferential on flock.

Comment on this

Will the Minister explain what is meant by flock?

Comment on this

Flock is a substance used for filling mattresses. No. 21 increases the duty on roof felting and similar substitutes. The small duties imposed by the Finance Act were countered by the importers reducing their prices and it has been decided consequently to increase the amount of the duty.

No. 22 similarly increases the duty on cordage, cables, ropes and twines, which industry has been making considerable progress.

No. 23 imposes 22½ per cent. full, and 15 per cent preferential duty on undyed jute yarns.

No. 24 imposes a duty of 37½ per cent. full and 25 per cent. preferential upon jute piece goods exceeding 4½ ounces in weight per square yard, but excluding jute piece goods of the following descriptions:—bleached jute piece goods, dyed jute piece goods, carpets, and jute piece goods imported with goods of which they form packing.

No. 25 imposes a duty of 50 per cent. full and 33? per cent. preference on heel plates, of horseshoe shape, made of iron or steel or of both iron and steel for boots and shoes. The necessity for that duty arises out of the fact that a factory for the manufacture of these heel plates is about to commence, but as we have good reason to believe that the announcement of the establishment of this factory would result in very substantial importations of these goods into the country to such an extent as would be sufficient for three or four years' supply and that consequently the factory project would fall through, it has been decided to impose this duty with a licence provision. Under this licence provision, we will permit the normal quantity of these goods to come in until the factory starts production and is able to supply the needs, when the duty will come up for reconsideration.

No. 2 Resolution differs only in so far as the duties imposed are specific and not ad valorem. On vinegar there is a duty of 2/- per gallon full and 1/6d. per gallon preferential. The duty on custard powders of 60/-per cwt. full and 45/- per cwt. preferential is not a new duty but a transforming of an emergency duty into a permanent duty. On filled Christmas stockings, snowballs, Easter eggs, and similar articles there is a duty of 3d. each full, and 2d. each preferential, in addition to any other duty that may be chargeable.

Comment on this

The Minister is putting a tariff on snowballs and Easter eggs. Does he propose to put anything on election eggs?

Comment on this

Is the Deputy applying for a tariff on election eggs? We are willing to afford all reasonable protection.

There is a duty on sausage meal of 1½d. per lb. full and 1d. per lb. preferential. The duty on compositions made of plaster of paris in sheets or slabs is doubled. There is a duty upon sparking plugs of 1/6d. each full and 1/- each preferential rate. There is also a duty on empty sacks and bags made of jute. The full duty is an amount equal to 37½ per cent. of the value of the article or 1½d. on each sack or bag whichever is the greater. The preferential rate is an amount equal to 25 per cent. of the value of the article or 1d. on each sack or bag whichever is the greater. It is intended to permit the importation of unconditioned secondhand sacks where such importation is done by a conditioning firm in the Saorstát. It was found impossible to provide for that in specific words because of drafting difficulties, and consequently the licensing provision is here. It is also intended to exercise that licensing provision to ensure that no firm utilising sacks and bags will be left without supplies. There is in this country one very large and highly efficient jute factory but it is not at the moment fully equipped to supply the whole requirements of the country. A type of machinery is being installed there to produce goods which in the past and at present are mainly imported. Arrangements to supply the full requirements of the country are at present being made. In the meantime there might be a shortage in which case the licence provision will be operated to meet the shortage.

Section 3 increases the duty upon shirts and collars and the component parts and accessories of same, on silk embroidered handkerchiefs and the component parts and accessories of such handkerchiefs, on all underclothing of silk including crêpe de chine, spun silk and Japanese silk intended for use by women, girls or children.

The Fourth Resolution deals with harness, and leather manufactured into harness.

Resolution Five deals with the imposition of duties which were announced in July last on bread, biscuits, buns and cakes imported into Saorstát Eireann. When the announcement of the intention of imposing those duties was made reference was made to the fact that there was some possibility of the supply of bread in Donegal by the bakers existing there proving inadequate. We satisfied ourselves that in every other part of the Saorstát a supply of bread was available, but there was considerable doubt as to the position in Donegal. The position in Donegal has not substantially altered in the meantime, A new bakery is being constructed and some extensions are being made in others in respect of existing bakeries, but there is a deficiency in the productive capacity. Consequently to put a duty or an imposition on bread immediately in Donegal might mean that there would be a shortage of bakers' bread. That might not be a serious thing in itself unless it came suddenly because in Donegal a large part of the bread is home baked, and, more than likely, the people would be able to supply their needs from home baked bread. It is proposed to impose the duty there as from next Wednesday, and in operating it to take power to issue licensing provisions to enable importers in Donegal to secure whatever quantity of bread may be necessary, while arrangements are being made to meet the requirements of the county from other parts of the county or from other parts of the Saorstát.

These are all the main changes that are being effected. I explained the circumstances and the necessity for changing the words. If Deputies desire any additional information or to discuss the proposal at greater length the opportunity will arise upon the General Resolution which can be postponed to a date which may be considered convenient to the main Resolutions when they come before us on Report Stage.

Comment on this

Would the Minister consider, in order to assist Deputies and people in the country, the necessity of issuing a list of goods that are not being tariffed if there are any such?

Comment on this

There are quite a sufficient number. If you take the goods imported into this country free last year you would find a very large list in relation to goods upon which tariffs were imposed since this Government came into office. The Deputy would find that, apart from tariffed articles, three-fifths of the goods of the country are not subject to any tariff percentage.

Comment on this

That is not my point. I am asking for the information of the House, and for getting nearer to the exact position, whether the Minister will consider issuing a list of goods imported into the country which are not subjected to tariffs.

Comment on this

Would the Minister say whether these series of Resolutions generally represent remission more than imposition of duty? There is a balance between the two.

Comment on this

There is a balance, but on the whole there is imposition of duty.

Comment on this

The balance is more in relation to the imposition. With regard to sausage meal I would like to know if it is a fact that a certificate is given to certain people to introduce into the country, free, a cheap type of casing?

Comment on this

Not that I am aware of, but I have no jurisdiction in that matter.

Comment on this

Why not? Surely a licence cannot be issued without the Minister giving his permission. That is the duty of the Minister.

Comment on this

I am afraid I do not get the Deputy's point.

Comment on this

My point is that if there is anything liable for duty under the Resolution it can only be exempted by a certificate from the Minister.

Comment on this

If the Minister wishes to license remissions it is his duty to do so.

Comment on this

I would not like to say that.

Comment on this

Supposing the Finance Bill contained power to the Minister to grant remissions in certain cases may I take it that where a duty is imposed by the Statute the Department carries out that duty and not the Minister himself?

Comment on this

The licensing powers we have secured under the Finance Act have been very freely used, but in particular cases where either we find that items are being brought in subject to a duty but which it was not intended to make subject to a duty, or where a license provision was inserted because it was not possible to get a definition of the article we wanted to exempt, then the Department were given general jurisdiction in regard to the matter. That applied particularly in the case of cellulose, which is a paint used in manufacture. It is impossible to get a definition that will include every object. We have a duty on paints. We desire to protect those made here. If restrictions had to be set out on all such cases the thing would be impossible.

Comment on this

The Minister decided on categories more or less and leaves specific examples to his Department, but the Statute imposed duties on the Minister which he should have carried out under the Statute.

Comment on this

Would it be possible for the Minister to compile a memorandum of duties, setting forth some explanation for the reason of the retention of the taxes where they are made and for the imposition of the taxes where further impositions are made? There is an item, for instance I think it is in No. 15 or at the end of No. 14, where it says that a duty of 1/- shall be charged or levied on the following articles:—"Any religious objects of which the value does not exceed one shilling." Is that retail or wholesale?

Comment on this

Wholesale, I take it. There is no change operated by that particular reference. It is necessary because we are dealing with the general duty on brass and tin articles.

Comment on this

Later on the Minister has some remission in 15 (t). It is stated that the duty shall not be charged upon crucifixes. If these crucifixes are gold or silver are they to be subject to a charge? There is a tax on gold or silver.

Comment on this

Unless it is laid on wood. Number 16 only deals with articles of wood.

Comment on this

No matter what the value would be? I have seen a crucifix lately which was worth £2. Would that be free of charge?

Comment on this

If it was of gold or silver.

Comment on this

But it was of wood pure and simple.

Comment on this

If it was on wood it would be subject to a duty.

Comment on this

But Resolution 16 contains an exemption in (t).

Comment on this

Of the duty on crucifixes.

Comment on this

But if of gold or silver they would be subject to a tax.

Comment on this

What about the previous one in which there is a reference to any articles of gold or silver—manufactured articles?

Comment on this

Oh, no. There is a specific list.

Comment on this

"Articles made of gold, silver, electro-plate, brass" and all these things, "and which articles are liable to duty under any other enactment and having engraved thereon at the time of importation lettering of the nature of inscriptions."

Comment on this

I think the Deputy is referring to No. 7.

Comment on this

I am referring to No. 2.

Comment on this

No 2 only refers to engravings and the value of the engraved work.

Comment on this

If there is an engraving on a gold crucifix it would be subject to duty?

Comment on this

How then is it worked out as free of duty on another page?

Comment on this

Perhaps I am misleading the Deputy. Where an article is subject to duty and is imported with an inscription engraved on it, then in addition to the duty which has to be paid on itself, a duty has also to be paid on the inscription. The additional duty goes on the inscription. If there is an article imported that is not liable to duty it can be engraved all over and there is no additional duty.

Comment on this

Are we to assume all that from Reference No. 2? I should like the Minister to read that reference. It says:—

Articles made of gold, silver, electro-plate, platinum, copper, brass, bronze or gunmetal, which articles are liable to duty under any other enactment and have engraved thereon at the time of importation lettering of the nature of inscriptions.

It does not say "if liable to duty."

Comment on this

That is the meaning of it.

Comment on this

That is what is intended?

Comment on this

The Minister said that the duty imposed would be the value of the engraving, but it is an additional duty, by reason of the engraving, on the value of the article itself that is meant?

Comment on this

It is on the value of the article.

Comment on this

The engraving is not assessed for duty itself?

Comment on this

Quite so.

Comment on this

Did I understand the Minister to say that the duty applied to the component parts of cubicle egg-boxes?

Comment on this

Quite.

Comment on this

Is the Minister aware that the Department of Agriculture recommends the use of foreign timber for egg boxes?

Comment on this

There is nothing in that particular duty which would prevent the use of foreign timber. That only applies to manufactured boxes or the cut parts.

Comment on this

Provided the unfortunate egg exporter who is already half strangled by Government interference is prepared to pay a further duty on the component parts of 50 per cent. Perhaps the farmers of the country will have something to say about that.

Comment on this

Is the Minister saying that while the Department of Agriculture recommends the use of these articles made outside he is going to impose a duty on these people?

Comment on this

I am not aware that the Department is doing anything of the kind.

Comment on this

The Minister is not aware; perhaps he would ask his colleague, the Minister for Agriculture.

Comment on this

Deputy McGilligan should be quite clear that he is quoting Deputy Dillon correctly.

Comment on this

I asked the Minister if he would inquire if that is so.

Comment on this

The Deputy was talking about foreign timber. I am talking about egg boxes.

Comment on this

I am talking about the component parts of egg boxes.

Comment on this

I am quite certain the Department of Agriculture is not recommending the use of foreign-made articles when they can be made here.

Comment on this

The timber cannot be obtained in Ireland.

Comment on this

They were made here before the Deputy or I was born, and will be made 100 years after he is dead.

Comment on this

There were thousands of things made here before I was born, such as rush candles, that will never be made again.

Comment on this

The Minister mentioned under Reference No. 16 planed flooring boards and mouldings. I take it sawn timber is free.

Comment on this

Sawn timber is free. Timber that is merely sawn is free.

Comment on this

No matter how it is shaped by sawing, it is free; but when it comes to be planed it is dutiable. That is the acid test.

Comment on this

Yes, planed and dressed.

Comment on this

Are you quite sure of that?

Comment on this

Would the Minister consider the preparation of a memorandum explaining these various alterations? We have here about 40 pages of Resolutions.

Comment on this

Most of them are only verbiage.

Comment on this

The bulk of them deal with the various alterations, and it might possibly shorten the debate if some explanation of the alterations that have been made—something more explicit than what is contained here—and as regards the exemptions or impositions were given. For instance, on the particular page to which I refer it is not quite clear what the actual intention is. The Minister said in answer to Deputy McGilligan that the word "if" should have been inserted but it is not.

Comment on this

That is what he meant.

Comment on this

If the Deputy means that we should issue a statement as to the precise nature of the changes achieved by each particular reference then I would consider having that done, but if he means a memorandum setting out precisely the articles subject to duty, the state of the industry and so on, that would involve very considerable labour. I would consider the preparation of a memorandum setting out in relation to Reference No. 16, which re-enacts the duty on the woodwork, the various changes and what exactly these changes are.

Comment on this

There must have been a case made out in each Department in respect of each tax and there is no reason why it should not be given to the House.

Comment on this

These are reasons which could be given here orally.

Comment on this

Am I to understand that under Reference No. 16 brooms, brushes, churns and toys, are all exempt from duty?

Comment on this

They are exempt from this duty but each one of them, with the exception of toys, is subject to duty under other Acts.

Comment on this

That is where a memorandum would be useful. Machinery is subject to duty under other Acts but we have also parts of machinery which are subject to duty under this.

Comment on this

It would be very difficult to have a general definition of machinery.

Comment on this

Surely if it is difficult for the Minister with his staffs it is doubly difficult for people outside. Surely it would be possible to put a warning note opposite such articles "See such and such an Act."

Comment on this

I should like to ask on behalf of some people in Waterford whether there is a duty on apple barrels?

Comment on this

Not by this Resolution.

Comment on this

I should like the Minister to furnish some explanation of what woodwork is included and what is exempted under Reference No. 16. I have been reading through it and I am not quite sure whether scaffolding poles or telegraph poles are subject to duty or are exempted.

Comment on this

I would remind the Deputy that the schedule to the Finance Act reads as follows:

Articles manufactured wholly or partly of wood or timber (not including planed or dressed wood or timber, mouldings, staves, sleepers, scaffolding poles, telegraph and telephone poles, plywood and veneer, imported as such).

We have deleted the words "planed or dressed wood or timber, mouldings, staves," so that the schedule now reads: "articles manufactured wholly or partly of wood or timber (not including staves (other than staves for butter casks, kegs and barrels) sleepers, scaffolding poles ..." I stated specifically that they are not included.

Comment on this

The Minister surely can see that a person, in order to be in a position to know whether such an item as I have referred to is subject to duty or not, would need to have the two schedules before him.

Comment on this

No, it is to avoid that that we are doing it in this way. When the Act, giving effect to this Resolution comes into force, the particular part of the Act that I have referred to will go out of force. We are re-enacting the entire reference with the changes that we desire in it. The duty will apply to all manufactured articles of wood, of any kind, except the articles specifically excluded.

Comment on this

Whether sawn or planed?

Comment on this

All manufactured articles, "whether wholly or partly of wood."

Comment on this

Let us suppose, for argument's sake, that one got portion of a barrow. It would be sawn, but it might be held at the same time to be a manufactured article.

Comment on this

Portion of a barrel?

Comment on this

Portion of a barrow. I do not know whether it would be subject to duty or not, and I am not quite sure that the Minister knows.

Comment on this

I am certain it would be subject to duty.

Comment on this

If only sawn?

Comment on this

Wood that is merely sawn is not subject to duty.

Comment on this

That is the point.

Comment on this

I am quite prepared to meet the point raised by Deputy Cosgrave; that is, to try and have prepared some type of explanatory memorandum, the scope of which will be merely to indicate changes in the law which this Resolution purports to make.

Comment on this

Arising out of what the Minister has said with reference to the preparation of an explanatory memorandum, might I remind him that I asked him on the Budget whether cotton blankets were subject to a duty or not? He protested that they were not. They are a commodity used very much by the very poor. The Minister overlooked the fact that in the next section of the Budget he put a substantial duty on sheets. Having consciously removed the duty from blankets he popped it on to sheets, with the result that while cotton blankets are, as such, duty free, they are apparently subject to duty as cotton sheets.

Comment on this

They are certainly dutiable.

Comment on this

But I have it on the Minister's statement in the Official Report that they are not.

Comment on this

On that point——

Comment on this

It does not arise on this.

Comment on this

The Minister does not deny that he did state to Deputy Dillon that blankets of cotton were not dutiable?

Comment on this

What I said was that the duty on blankets did not apply to blankets of cotton. That was not my interpretation. The duty which was imposed by the Finance Act was more or less an increase of the duty which had been in operation for a number of years. We did not change the definition of the duty. The interpretation of the duty which excluded cotton blankets had been in operation.

Comment on this

Deputy Dillon made the point that these articles were used by the poor, and he asked if they were going to be dutiable. The Minister's answer was "No." The Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for Finance went to the Seanad and said "Yes." The Seanad moved an amendment excluding them, and quoted the statement made by the Minister for Industry and Commerce. Nevertheless, the exclusion proposed by the Seanad was refused and these articles are dutiable.

Comment on this

All this shows the necessity for a memorandum.

Comment on this

In connection with the duty of 2/- per gallon on vinegar, would the Minister say if vinegar is manufactured in this country?

Comment on this

Yes, excellently.

Comment on this
Hugh Victor Flinn Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for Finance (Mr. Flinn) Fianna Fáil

Any amount of it in this House.

Comment on this

I am quite aware of that.

Comment on this

We have quite a number of firms here engaged in the manufacture of vinegar and there is no question of their ability to be able to supply the requirements of the home market.

Comment on this

With reference to "yarns (other than white yarns) wholly of wool or worsted or of a combination of wool and worsted, which are imported otherwise than in bobbins, cheeses, cones, or cops," I have a few questions to ask. Are white yarns exempt and, if so, why? Secondly, in order to get an exclusion of coloured yarns in this tariff is it only necessary to have it on "bobbins, cheeses, cones or cops" and if so, why?

Comment on this

The difficulty in this case was to get an arrangement by which we could impose a duty on knitting yarn without imposing it on yarn used by the manufacturers of cloth. The definition which we are using seems to meet that. We are excluding from the scope of the duty yarn on bobbins because it is only imported in that form by woollen manufacturers. The net result is to confine the duty to yarn imported for knitting purposes.

Comment on this

So that if a person wants to engage in the manufacture of knitted goods and to get in the yarn free of duty, all he has to do is to get it wound round a bobbin? Is the position this that a person can evade the duty if he winds the yarn round a bobbin?

Comment on this

If he thinks it worth while.

Comment on this

I take it that the duty referred to here does not apply to jute sacks coming in filled with other commodities?

Comment on this

I would like to have some information in regard to paragraph (h) under Reference No. 15 to the First Resolution. This paragraph states that a duty "shall not be charged or levied on component parts of type setting machines or of type composing machines." I should like to know whether it is the Minister's intention that the tariff should be put on type and type metals?

Comment on this

They are not subject to duty at present.

Comment on this

But will they come under this, because the exemption seems to apply only to component parts of type setting machines or of type composing machines. Type metal is not a component part of a type setting machine or of type composing machines.

Comment on this

I would like to get this matter with regard to church articles of different types cleared up. They come under Reference Nos. 2, 7 and 16. Under Reference No. 2, articles made of certain named metals have a liability to duty. They also have imposed on them an additional duty if engraved, and that additional duty is on the value of the article. The question of a crucifix made of one of these valuable metals was raised. Can the Minister conceive of a crucifix which has not an inscription coming in?

Comment on this

A crucifix is not liable to duty.

Comment on this

If made of gold or silver and inscribed, surely it is. If I import into this country a crucifix made of gold, is it not "an article made of gold?"

Comment on this

Undoubtedly.

Comment on this

Where is it exempted from duty?

Comment on this

Where is it made liable to duty?

Comment on this

If engraved—I am putting that qualification all the time. A crucifix made of gold or silver is going to be landed with whatever the duty is here.

Comment on this

Surely not.

Comment on this

If engraved?

Comment on this

If engraved and liable to duty under any other enactment.

Comment on this

We are given in No. 7 a list of articles which are of these metals, gold, silver and electro-plate. At (e) we have "plaques of silver." Is a plaque, portion of which is a crucifix which is inscribed, liable to duty under 7 and 2? I think so.

Comment on this

A plaque which is not a crucifix but a plaque——

Comment on this

But which has a crucifix raised on it. Surely that is liable to duty under No. 7?

Comment on this

If there is an inscription—I cannot conceive any crucifix which has not an inscription—it is liable under No. 2 also?

Comment on this

The exemption later refers to articles which are made of wood, and does not affect these things. These things would be liable to duty in the manner I have described.

Comment on this

Crucifixes are not liable to duty.

Comment on this

Would the Minister be prepared to exempt rope and twine of a special kind which is not manufactured in this country and which is used in fishing?

Comment on this

I shall be glad to get the particulars.

Comment on this

Item No. 5 deals with "spectacles, monocles and other eye-glasses of which the lenses are under 43 millimetres in diameter or in the greater diameter, and lenses for above which are under 43 millimetres in diameter or in the greater diameter." Will the Minister explain what the limitations on these spectacles, monocles and other eye-glasses are in No. 5?

Comment on this

Spectacles, monocles and other eye-glasses of which the lenses are under 43 millimetres in diameter or in the greater diameter——

Comment on this

What does that mean?

Comment on this

If they are oval-shaped.

Comment on this

What is the phrase which means that?

Comment on this

"Greater diameter."

Comment on this

"In the greater diameter"?

Comment on this

Yes, "and lenses for above which are under 43 millimetres in diameter."

Comment on this

What is a lens "in the greater diameter?"

Comment on this

That is the measure— under 43 millimetres in the greater diameter.

Comment on this

Did the Minister consult the Department of Agriculture with regard to the tariff imposed on fillers and flats?

Comment on this

The Department of Agriculture recommended a tax on fillers and flats for egg boxes although the best type of these articles is not manufactured in this country?

Comment on this

The very best type is manufactured here by the most up-to-date machinery and in the most modern way.

Comment on this

Does the Minister know what the best type is?

Comment on this

Cardboard and straw.

Comment on this

The best type is the cup-shaped type. Does the Minister state that the cup-shaped type is manufactured in this country, or does he know?

Comment on this

I do not.

Comment on this

I think the Minister should know before he puts on a tariff.

Comment on this

It is going to be made here next week.

Comment on this

Item No. 1 refers to yarns wholly of wool or worsted or of a combination of wool and worsted, which are imported otherwise than on bobbins, cheeses, cones or cops. Does the Minister anticipate that as a result of this tariff the spinning and woollen industry will be further developed and give more employment?

Comment on this

It should operate in that way.

Comment on this

I should like to see it operate in the way the Minister desires, but does not the qualification he makes—"imported otherwise than on bobbins, cheeses, cones or cops"— negative the Minister's own object—to create further employment in the manufacture of these yarns into woollens?

Comment on this

That duty, placed on hand-knitting yarns, does not apply to yarns used in the manufacture of woollen cloths. It is not intended that such yarns should be subject to duty.

Comment on this

In what way does the Minister think that this will create further employment in the woollen industry?

Comment on this

There is quite a considerable trade in hand-knitting yarns.

Comment on this

I think it is infinitesimal.

Comment on this

It is by no means as large or as important as the trade in yarns imported by manufacturers for weaving into cloth. From the examination I have been able to give the matter, there is no case for the imposition of a duty on yarns imported for weaving into cloth.

Comment on this

Is not the Minister aware that the most important end of the work is the spinning of the yarns and that that would give more employment than all the other processes put together?

Comment on this

That has not been established.

Comment on this

Is that not one of the facts which emerge from the report of the Tariff Commission?

Comment on this

I am not denying the importance of getting the spinning of the yarns done here, and I had discussions with woollen manufacturers upon that point. I am quite satisfied that it would neither help that industry nor the yarn industry to impose a duty on these yarns under the present circumstances.

Comment on this

Would it not create further employment?

Comment on this

It might have the opposite effect.

Comment on this

As regards item 11 —picture frames wholly or mainly of wood and pictures in frames made wholly or mainly of wood—I should like to know what that is intended to catch that has not been caught heretofore?

Comment on this