We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

Financial Resolutions. - Financial Resolution No. 7—General.

Contributions 193–382 of 382. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

The position heretofore was that if a frame came in with a picture in it it would escape the duty.

Comment on this

Because it was not subject to duty.

Comment on this

Surely it was, as furniture.

Comment on this

It was not subject to duty.

Comment on this

Will the duty paid on pictures in frames be refunded?

Comment on this

If they were not subject to duty, the duty was illegally charged.

Comment on this

The frames could escape duty by putting in a penny picture of Robert Emmet.

Comment on this

I know Customs Officers who had a wholly different conception of the law and insisted on charging duty on pictures brought in with wooden frames around them. Duty was charged on the value of the picture and not on the value of the frame. The only way to evade duty was by taking out the picture, rolling it up and taking in the frame separately.

Comment on this

That Customs Officer certainly mixed up his instructions. The reverse is what should have happened. A framed picture was not subject to duty; duty was not payable on it, and any person who paid duty on it can take his case to the Revenue Commissioners.

Comment on this

Surely pictures were always counted as furniture?

Comment on this

Picture frames.

Comment on this

That was not the way the resolution ran. It ran: any article of furniture the component parts being of wood, then there was a duty upon it. I am astonished. I think there will be quite a number of claims made if what the Minister says is right. This, at any rate, sets up the position now that if a valuable painting is brought in with the ordinary exhibition frame around it, the fact that it is brought in with a frame around it will involve a payment of duty on the value of the picture.

Comment on this

Not if the picture was imported for exhibition purposes.

Comment on this

I am talking of a person who buys a picture abroad. If a person on the Continent sees a picture for sale which does not happen to have a frame around it, or the artist is not disposed to sell the frame, and it is put on the ordinary type of wooden stretcher and imported that way, as long as there is something wooden about it there is a duty to be payable hereafter on it.

Comment on this

I am not clear as to why——

Comment on this

It counts as a frame. What I am speaking about is a picture frame. That is going to be subject to 75 per cent. duty. On what value? Is it on the value of the frame or on the value of the entire article— the picture, plus the frame?

Comment on this

The entire article.

Comment on this

Do I understand from the Minister that type is exempt from duty?

Comment on this

I think it would be better to have it specified.

Comment on this

Type is not subject to duty now.

Comment on this

It will under this.

Comment on this

No. It is free, the same as under the original Act. There is no change effected by this resolution at all.

Comment on this

As to the question of toys, which arises under 15 and 16, I take it from a casual reading of both of these that any toys made of tin or tinplate or tinned plate are exempt entirely, and when one comes to the wooden article the wooden toy is exempt only if the value is a shilling or under. If the article is made of a combination of both and there is more of tin than of wood, it escapes duty altogether.

Comment on this

I would not say that. No. 16 says, "Articles manufactured wholly or partly of wood or timber."

Comment on this

No. 15 applies to "Manufactured articles made wholly or mainly of tin, tinplate or tinned plate, or a combination of them," and the exemption must apply to articles made wholly or mainly of tin. If it is made more of tin than of wood, then surely it is exempted under No. 15.

Comment on this

I would say so.

Comment on this

Would the Minister tell us whether under No. 10 it is intended to include sewer pipes and flue linings, which are manufactured of clay?

Comment on this

No. The pipes must be designed and intended for use in smoking tobacco and other substances.

Comment on this

It is not the intention, on account of their being manufactured of clay, that this will be applied to sewer pipes and flue linings?

Comment on this

I cannot imagine anybody smoking tobacco out of a sewer pipe.

Comment on this

It says pipes manufactured of clay.

Comment on this

Designed and intended for use in smoking tobacco. I think that definition is clear.

Comment on this

As to No. 18: "Unassembled iron and steel parts for bodies of motor omnibuses, motor charabancs and commercial motor vehicles," what are the prospects of having these manufactured?

Comment on this

They are being manufactured. They can be all manufactured.

Comment on this

Why the limitation by means of the word "unassembled"?

Comment on this

Because assembled parts are already liable to duty. The Finance (No. 2) Act imposed this duty upon the complete body, and upon the assembled parts of such body. It exempted from duty unassembled parts. Consequently, we are imposing it on the unassembled parts. The assembled part is already liable.

Comment on this

Why were unassembled parts previously exempt?

Comment on this

Because in the examination we were able to make at the time we were not satisfied that they could be all made and made satisfactorily here, and at that time we decided to exclude them until we had an opportunity of going into the question in greater detail. We have gone into the question, and we have come to the conclusion that all of them can be made here, and are made here.

Comment on this

As to No. 22: "Cordage, cables, ropes and twine of hemp or light material" with certain exclusions, under the Finance Act the Revenue Commissioners held that fishing nets were not caught. Will they be so held not to be caught still?

Comment on this

There is no change effected by this.

Comment on this

So that fishing nets are still exempt?

Comment on this

With regard to this 50 per cent. on pipes made wholly or mainly of clay, what extra employment does the Minister contemplate will be given by this tariff?

Comment on this

Very little.

Comment on this

The Minister should be aware that there is a tendency in this country to depart from the use of the clay pipe.

Comment on this

It has gone out of fashion altogether.

Comment on this

It has been found in practice to be unhygienic and deleterious in many cases, and the medical authorities have attributed the disease of cancer to the continued use of the clay pipe. It appears to me that the Minister is attempting to encourage the use of the clay pipe, but he must be aware that the tendency is to get away from the use of it. Even in the remotest country areas the use of the clay pipe is more the exception than the rule.

Comment on this

Deputy Dillon told us that it was used as a sign of mourning.

Comment on this

I do not agree with Deputy Anthony as to the clay pipe being unhygienic. That has not been proved at all. As a matter of fact, the manufacture of clay pipes is an old-es-tablished industry in the country.

Comment on this

Long before the Minister was born.

Comment on this

Long before any Deputy was born.

Comment on this

Fitzgerald, of Cork, was the first manufacturer of clay pipes.

Comment on this

The clay pipe was probably used many hundreds of years ago, before we had tobacco at all. Probably when it first came into use they were made and at present they are being bought. The making of clay pipes provides a considerable amount of employment, and the Minister is right in encouraging their manufacture.

Comment on this

What were they used for before tobacco was used in the country?

Comment on this

Blowing bubbles.

Comment on this

Was the recent deputation to London provided with clay pipes?

Comment on this

Will the Minister give an explanation as to the tariff?

Comment on this

It was demanded by all Parties in the House three months ago. It was the only question on which we were unanimous in connection with the Budget.

Comment on this

Deputy Morrissey and I objected very strongly against that imposition.

Comment on this

I do not think so.

Comment on this

The most important thing to remember is that the manufacture of clay pipes will give employment in the country.

Comment on this

The Minister suggested that the employment given would be infinitesimal. He suggested that there would be no extra employment at all.

Comment on this

I did not say that.

Comment on this

Probably there might be a couple of hundred extra pipes manufactured. With regard to No. 24, it is proposed that jute piece goods are to be taxed. I take it that would apply to jute sacks, either the sacking or the made-up bag?

Comment on this

It will apply, not merely to sacking, but much more so to the made-up bag?

Comment on this

There is a separate duty on the bag—No. 7 of Resolution 2—a minimum duty.

Comment on this

Have we not a considerable export trade in jute bags?

Comment on this

Is there any prospect of that trade being injured by the tariff now being imposed? Has that matter been considered?

Comment on this

I do not think there is any likelihood of that. The goods exported are of a different class to the ones imported. The point is that the factory might devote its attention in future to supplying the requirements at home rather than interest itself in exports. The volume of goods imported exceeds the volume exported in value. If you take second-hand bags into account, it will be found that the excess is considerable. If the factory decides to alter its organisation, its equipment and its method of business so as to supply the home trade with its requirements, it would have a much larger market under the new circumstances than it has at present.

Comment on this

Yes, for a different article which, in the ordinary course of their business, they did not decide to manufacture. Is it not a fact that the export trade is likely to be met with a 10 per cent. tariff on 15th November?

Comment on this

I am not sure that that is so. It must be remembered that the chief competition comes from India. The low priced goods coming from India really affect the trade, and it is not so much a question of competition from Britain.

Comment on this

There is an Import Act in England under which the goods from this country are exempted up to the 15th November, and that catches jute bags. If that exemption is not continued after the 15th November there will be a 10 per cent. tariff against jute bags coming from this country and entering England.

Comment on this

Quite so.

Comment on this

When dealing with No. 24 the Minister referred to Resolution No. 2. If he turns to No. 2 on this list he will observe in the notes that this duty is in addition to any other duty that may be chargeable on the articles. That note is made in certain specified cases. There are other notes that set out that the duty is in lieu of any duty that may be enforced. Is it safe to assume that if there is no such note the duty mentioned is the only duty applicable to the article?

Comment on this

Jute sacks cannot be described as jute piece goods.

Comment on this

That is not my point. Certain notes set out that this duty is in addition to any other duty that may be chargeable. Other notes indicate that the duty is in lieu of other duties. In respect of some duties there are no notes at all. Would it be safe to assume if there is no such note the article is not liable to any duty at all?

Comment on this

That would be a correct assumption in 90 per cent. of the cases, but in some cases there will be the possibility of two duties applying to the article, in which case the higher duty will operate.

Comment on this

It would seem to me to be rather dangerous to have certain notes setting out that the duties are in addition to other duties and other notes indicating that certain duties are in lieu of other duties and, following all that, other articles with no note whatever, where, in my opinion, a note is really wanted.

Comment on this

I will try to get these notes covered in the memorandum.

Comment on this

I have another remark to make with regard to No. 19. I am not yet satisfied that the effect of a duty like that in No. 19 will not tend very largely to increase the cost of the raw material.

Comment on this

I would not say so. This did operate in the case of marble. The price of marble was undoubtedly increased and the protection which we gave to the stone-cutting industry was seriously diminished. There is only one supplier of raw marble. I am quite prepared to admit that a further increase might follow, but if that further increase should take place, while it might diminish the protection we are giving to the stone-cutting industry, it will also operate as a non-legislative tariff in favour of the production of marble. It will, I believe, tend towards the development of the marble quarries in this country and the utilisation of this marble in preference to the imported article.

Comment on this

But this refers to marble which cannot be got in the country at all.

Comment on this

It is intended in all cases where stone is imported that it should be imported in the raw and worked up into shape in the stone-working places here.

Comment on this

But will it not mean that the buyer has to pay more for the raw unworked stone?

Comment on this

That may have operated to some extent, but only in the case of marble. I will admit that the marble quarries here have not been in production, but steps are being taken to bring some of them into production in the future. Some big buildings in course of contemplation will occasion that, because it is intended to use Irish marble.

Comment on this

I take it the Minister has in mind Italian marble. That sort of marble cannot be got in this country at all.

Comment on this

It is a different type of marble.

Comment on this

The effect of this is that the person who wants it for his own special purpose has to pay more for the raw material. That does not do anybody any good.

Comment on this

If he wants Italian marble he must pay for it.

Comment on this

Speaking on the Resolution generally, I must say that I regard this list as almost the height of insanity, but that does not mean that I do not welcome it. The whole tariff policy as it had been proceeding up to the end of last year was more or less balanced. We had, at any rate, got to the position in which there was no outcry in the country against tariffs by reason of high costs. Even some of the articles tariffed under the Finance (Customs Duties) (No. 2) Act might have been accepted with good grace and goodwill in the country—I believe they would certainly have been accepted—if there had been some limitation put upon particular charges there imposed upon the community. If there had been a recognition that the duty upon a dear class of goods, say on woollens, was being increased and a remission made in consequence on a type of cloth not likely to be made, and if there were indications that the necessary changes could apply to the boot and shoe tariff—if those things had been done, there might have been a chance that a tariff policy would not be made the subject of violent Party disputations and would not be made the subject hereafter of a compaign in the country which is bound to develop into anti-tariff and pro-tariff.

This means that we have actually crossed the line. The last Budget brought us across the line but this nonsense to-night definitely puts us across the line. It means the end of a tariff policy which would otherwise have operated with goodwill on everybody's part, with tariffs operating under some sort of supervision and in a selective way. That chance is gone and the country is going to be faced with a very bad situation. There is not going to be any appreciation of tariffs properly used. This ludicrous use of tariffs will put people entirely and definitely against them and it is only right it should. I do not believe that there is going to be any talk made by the Minister himself or any evidence produced other than his usual recital of assurances as to the employment to be given in the manufacture of these goods.

The truth is, and it has been stated by a Labour authority in this country, that there are more unemployed in this country to-day than ever before, and that there are more people in receipt of home assistance than ever before. A great deal of that is due to a tariff policy which ran amok. Even if the tariff policy had been kept within bounds, it would, owing to the time at which it was introduced, have had bad results for the country.

This is camouflage. We are to tighten up the whole thing. We are to have our own heels made in the country; we are to have our own pipes made in the country and we are having all these miscellaneous things flung at us. We have had things flung at us that look well on paper and which, repeated to people who are not very careful about the statements they hear, will convey the meaning to them that there will be more employment created in the country. We have a state of general camouflage. We are to have all these things tariffed here. We are to have a grand tariff policy proceeding industrially in a short space of time. And these statements are made at a time when we have the returns from the tariff policy announced by the Minister.

We were told that a sum of £910,000 was to be brought in from the tax on the new tariffed goods. We were told that it was not possible to have made any better estimate than that because the development of home manufacture was to be taken into consideration. That estimate of £910,000 was the considered estimate of the Minister as to the sum that the tariffed articles would bring in to the Treasury. But we have seen 80 per cent. of that sum collected in six months. Now the difference between the estimate and the assurance given by the Minister and the actual fact in the way of levies made on the people is exactly the difference between the Minister's assurance as to the industries that were to be started and the actual fact.

All this addition to the taxation of the people certainly means very little indeed in the way of employment. It means a little bit extra. We will find out how much by practical experience, but it means a great deal extra in the way of costs to the community. It certainly means this that a great many more people are getting sick and tired of the tariff policy. More people who were prepared to give tariffs a chance when properly applied are now turning away from them in disgust. We gain very little in these tariffs and we lose a great deal.

Of course there are bigger things toward, and this is one of the things that has to be weighed in front of the people who are gradually getting involved by what is happening. Here is a matter which, whether you are expending your energy either on being enthusiastic about it or vehemently opposed to it, will be found to be a preparation for the economic war that is going to be announced. We are going to be a much more self-contained nation making our own pipes and our own heels. It is put forward now and the House has been given an opportunity of discussing the tariff policy in the Finance Customs (No. 2) Act or the Budget that was introduced last April. Over 80 per cent. of the £910,000 has been levied in the first six months.

It will be found instead of that £910,000 levied under these tariffs that something in the region of one and a half million pounds will be levied. The fact is that instead of that £910,000, a sum of one and a half millions is to be taken from the community and that in spite of the assurances that had been given that factories would spring up and that home goods would be made to replace the articles excluded. All these things that were to come from the tariffs, the promises and hopes expressed by the Minister, have not materialised. The hopes have been disappointed.

For myself I always felt that this country could not get on without a tariff policy. Tariffs had to be tried. I also knew that the impositions caused by the tariffs would be very severe upon the community at this particular time, and therefore I believe that tariffs ought to be brought in with very great care and very slowly, and with some appreciation from time to time of the costs that were to be placed on our main producers in the country.

That policy was tried and it had been found successful, having got 15,000 additional people into employment. That placed a fairly heavy extra charge on the community at the beginning, but that charge was lessened year by year. You had a policy which was under your control, and one that could be closed down when the farming community found they could not bend their backs to any further burdens. It was proper and right that a chance should be given to a tariff policy. What is proper and right about the present tariff policy at this moment when farmers are ground down, when they cannot get any prices, when the Government attitude has landed them in difficulties and when the hopes that were held out of other markets have been falsified?

The farmers are put in the position that they must sell and cannot get any remunerative price. These tariffs mean large extra cost to them and to the townspeople as well, but particularly to the farmers. The impression that the people will get of this rather futile piece of work at this time is that they are not getting a right tariff policy or a policy on right lines. They have a policy that means nothing in the way of extra employment, but it is a policy that means a great deal in the way of extra cost to the community and a great deal in the way of people hardening their minds in the future against any tariff policy.

Comment on this

Before the Resolution is put I would like to make some reply to the remarks made by Deputy McGilligan. I assume that we will have some reply to matters arising out of this Resolution.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

I had intended to interrupt Deputy McGilligan only that he did not speak at any great length. The procedure when these Resolutions are before the House is to give the Resolutions on the day on which they are expressed to take effect; that is to-day. The procedure is to debate the policy on a general Resolution. It has taken one and a half hours to dispose of one Resolution, and we have six Resolutions to get through. Each Resolution must be put separately. I do not think that Deputies have dealt with them all at this rate of progress.

Comment on this

I would like to say, before you put the Resolution, in connection with a remark made by Deputy McGilligan that the tariff policy introduced by this Government on imported goods has been much more successful than we had hoped at the time. The suggestion that this tariff policy is a failure has no foundation whatsoever—

Comment on this

Except in the revenue returns.

Comment on this

If the amount imported in the first six months has been high is not that more satisfactory than that the amount in the second six months should be high?

Comment on this

But suppose it continues?

Comment on this

Is the Deputy sure when he is relating the figure that the figure given has any relation to the returns for the twelve months?

Comment on this

Will the Minister give us the proper ones?

Comment on this

I cannot give you the proper ones. The Deputy referred to the unemployment situation. He gloated over the fact that there is more unemployment in the country to-day than ever there was. To some extent, that may be said to be correct. There are 87,000 people registered as unemployed. I do not think there are 87,000 people actually without work but there are 87,000 people registered under our new system of registration at the Exchanges as being available for work. Let the Deputies get that figure straight into their heads— 87,000. That figure is justification for this policy, because if we are going to find work for those people we cannot find it by adopting a tariff policy which will please everyone, including the importers. If the unemployment situation is worse here than it was this time last year it is due to the fact that 24,000 young people who went out of this country in every single year of the ten years that the Deputy opposite was Minister did not go out this year. They stayed at home this year and are looking for work, and we cannot get them that work unless we revive the industries of the country. That is the purpose of this policy. That is the purpose of these tariffs. That is what we have been aiming to do, to exclude from this country every article that we can make for ourselves. All the articles which have been specified in this list are articles capable of being manufactured here, that were in the past manufactured here, and in the future we are determined that in the production of these articles Irish people are going to be employed in this country. The policy on which we embarked has been successful. It has been more successful than I dared hope at the time. I remember Deputy Hogan rising up and saying that in eight months this policy would be discredited. I took him on that, and I said that if at the end of eight months we could not show a substantial increase in industrial productivity and a substantial increase in the numbers of people engaged in industrial manufactures we would admit failure.

Comment on this

That was not the question put.

Comment on this

I am speaking with a hazy recollection of what the matter was about.

Comment on this

Would the Minister take the challenge as put—that there would be more people unemployed after eight months as a result of the Minister's policy?

Comment on this

If the Deputy will give me the figure with relation to the number unemployed in April last year which is capable of comparison with the figure now available I will accept the challenge. The Deputy knows quite well his Government has succeeded in building up a false feeling of security amongst the people, and succeeded in painting a false picture of the situation by deliberately restricting the number of people registered as unemployed. In the County of Galway there were two unemployment exchanges where people could register.

Comment on this

That is not so.

Comment on this

It is quite so.

Comment on this

Does the Minister deny that any person could register by sending his name in an envelope without a stamp on it through the post?

Comment on this

At the present time any person can register in a Civic Guard barracks.

Comment on this

If he does that what good will it do him? Was it going to get him any work? Was it even going to get him the price of the envelope?

Comment on this

The fact is this, that until we make the machinery of the labour exchanges machinery capable of securing that those who register for work get an opportunity to work, until we insisted that every job throughout this country made available as the result of any expenditure of Government funds was to be filled through the Labour Exchanges we could not secure what we wanted to secure, that we would have on our books the names of every man and woman seeking employment. We have that now. There is no figure in relation to the figure of six months ago capable of comparison with the figure we have now.

Any attempt to prove that the unemployment position is worsened as a result of comparison between the number of registered unemployed before and the registered number now is deliberately false and misleading. Let me say simply this. The tariff policy has been successful in every branch. In respect of every industry to which it has been applied there has been substantial development, increased productivity, and increased employment. We are going ahead with the policy. We are quite convinced as a result of our experience and as a result of any theories derived from text-books that it is by that policy we can deal with the very serious unemployment problem we have. I have no desire to diminish that problem in the mind of anybody. If we cannot get a clear realisation in all quarters of its magnitude, a clear realisation of the seriousness which attends it, we will not get behind this policy and the other measures the Government has adopted to deal with it the necessary enthusiasm. It is because the public are beginning to realise now that there is a problem of great magnitude, it is because they are getting now information deliberately kept from them before that we are getting behind this policy a growing measure of support from the people. The duties imposed by these Resolutions may not be of first class importance. Nevertheless they are capable of providing work for a number of people who are now without it and on that ground alone they are worthy of acceptance by this House.

Comment on this

Are we in Committee still?

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Yes.

Comment on this

Will I have an opportunity of replying to him again?

Comment on this

Certainly.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

I do not know if the House desires to get this through before 8 o'clock.

Comment on this

It is a question of whether we take the General Resolution or not. Will the General Resolution be held over until to-morrow?

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Yes. But not a repetition of the debate, we presume.

Comment on this

Oh no. That will be a different resolution, sir. Arising out of the statement that the tariff policy of the Government, which is now intensified, has been successful in every branch, it has been successful in one branch, namely the Revenue branch—£910,000 to be collected, 80 per cent. to be lifted in the first six months and no signs of it diminishing.

Comment on this

Well, that is something.

Comment on this

In June and July the Minister was certain of all the factories that were going to spring up by magic from the manufacture at home of these goods. He expressed himself at times as being doubtful if we would get £910,000, that we are going to get a million and a half. That is the test of the policy. The home manufacture of goods has not filled the bill to the extent of the difference between the £910,000 estimated and the million and a half that may come in. Taking unemployment and the challenge about eight months made here by Deputy Hogan, Deputy Hogan never made any statement so foolish as that it was not possible to get people into employment if you prohibited goods from coming in.

Comment on this

He made more foolish statements than that.

Comment on this

It is certain you will get people into employment. That is not the test of the tariff policy. The test is what price will the goods be sold at. Will they be sold at such a rate that people in other employment will lose that employment? Will you find at the end of eight months as a result of your tariff policy that there are more people in employment or more people out of employment? The Minister denies about his figures and what they mean. He will not go to any meeting, unless he goes like the great Sequah long ago, with two or three bands to hide the groans and the agony of the people who are suffering from him, and say there are less people out of employment at the moment than there were when he came in. Even his brazenness will not carry him to that.

Comment on this

I will say deliberately that the unemployment situation is not nearly as serious as it was this time last year.

Comment on this

The man capable of saying that need not say anything more. Is this a point of order?

Comment on this

The Deputy is afraid to hear facts. He is running away from facts.

Comment on this

The Deputy capable of saying that is capable of anything. Look at the bill for Home Assistance mounting up. Look at the hunger marches going on. Look at the invasion of places by unemployed, and yet the unemployment situation is better than when the Minister came in.

Comment on this

There is an attempt being made to deal with it now.

Comment on this

Nobody denies that an attempt is being made to deal with it.

Comment on this

That was not the case last year.

Comment on this

A blundering attempt.

Comment on this

Successful now.

Comment on this

Nobody denied that there was going to be an attempt made. The question that was at issue was this, was the attempt likely to be successful or not, and the result has proved that it was not.

Comment on this

What is the test?

Comment on this

The test is the number of people out of employment at this moment, the number of people on Home Assistance, the intensified feeling in the country about unemployment and the agitation that is rising in the country about the people who are losing employment day by day. The figures have been quoted, 86,000. I suppose what is quoted is 80,000. 80,000 did not represent people who were looking for work, who were available for work and who depended for their livelihood upon the wages they get for work. It represented people who answered the question were they or were they not working.

Comment on this

Exactly.

Comment on this

That 80,000 figure was definitely explained, and I doubt if the Minister would make any serious attempt to dispute the reductions that had to be made in this figure. The 87,000 figure is equally capable of explanation. It would be quite foolish for anybody to over-estimate or to estimate wrongly or inaccurately the 87,000 figure. Let nobody follow any mistaken belief in what the Minister has said that because there is a new system of registration the figure is swollen. At the moment the Minister says the great change is that anybody can walk into the nearest police station and register.

Comment on this

More than that.

Comment on this

That is one point. Let me deal with it point by point. He could always have done that.

Comment on this

He never did it before.

Comment on this

It would cost him nothing. He could have gone to the nearest Post Office, written his name on a sheet of paper, and folded that paper in such a way that it would go through the post—he did not need an envelope—and without any charge to himself, it would go to Headquarters. The difference is now he can go in and write his name. That made the difference between 80,000 and 87,000.

Comment on this

I did not say that.

Comment on this

There was more to be got out of registering now. There were 17,000 vacancies per annum filled by the other system.

Comment on this

We are filling 2,000 a week.

Comment on this

There were 17,000 to be filled. Was that enough incentive to make a man go into the nearest Post Office and sign up his name?

Comment on this

That 17,000 was a fictitious figure.

Comment on this

It was not. There were 17,000 vacancies filled per annum.

Comment on this

The vacancy was filled when the County Surveyor sent down a list of the names to the Manager and he sent back the same list of names.

Comment on this

We will deduce this by Parliamentary Question from the Minister afterwards. There were 17,000 vacancies filled through labour exchanges, and people who registered at these exchanges knew that, and yet we are told the difference is there are 2,000 vacancies per week being filled.

Comment on this

On the average.

Comment on this

And yet there are 87,000 unemployed still?

Comment on this

I did not say that either.

Comment on this

There are 87,000 registered although the Minister has been filling vacancies at the rate of 2,000 a week—for how long?

Comment on this

Quite a long time.

Comment on this

Quite a long time notwithstanding the fact that there are 87,000 still registered. There was something more to be got by way of examination—that is what we have got. Has the 2,000 a week—say 8,000 a month—has that been going on for four months? So there are 32,000 vacancies filled in four months and we have still 87,000 registered. I wonder have we anything more than 87,000 registered at this moment, and the home assistance bill is certainly higher than it ever was before—and our tariff policy is a success—and the people are being mulcted to the extent of 80 per cent. of the £910,000 in six months. They have been mulcted in six months to the extent of 80 per cent. of the £910,000 that was to be covered in a year—and the tariff policy is a success. That is the sort of success that breaks the Government. It is unfortunately going to break the tariff policy, and that is what I regret.

Comment on this

When I came into office I was faced with a figure of unemployment which had no significance. I said to myself if we are going to tackle the unemployment problem we must get a real picture of the size of it. We must get some figure which will indicate exactly the number of people available for work and get a list of names and addresses with their qualifications. I set out to get that. I knew quite well when setting out we would have little whipper-snappers coming deliberately and misrepresenting the result, saying that the increased figures we secured were representing a worsening of the situation instead of a bettering of the situation. We knew these misrepresentations would be made. We knew members of the late Government concealed the position for ten years by publishing faked figures, and continued to publish these faked figures as against the figures now available in order to pretend the situation had got worse. Has it got worse? It is not easy to say whether it has or not. If we had put into employment in protected industries or any other industries 16,000 people this year the situation would be still the same as last year. I want the Deputies to appreciate that this year the population of this country is going up and instead of having an annual drainage of 27,000 per annum as we had while the Deputies opposite were in office we have people coming back into this country seeking work, and we have got to find that work. We have not altogether been successful. We have not provided them all with work, but we have provided work for very large numbers directly on relief labour of one kind or another and indirectly through the operation of this policy. There were 87,000 people registered— that is a big number. It does not represent 87,000 people unemployed, because as the Deputies opposite know throughout this country the people available for work on the roads or other public works are men who are not labourers in the ordinary sense—they are small land-owners, not people who would be reported as unemployed. They are farmers in poorer districts who support the livelihood they get from their lands by doing occasional work on the roads or work of some other kind. Probably 50 per cent., certainly 40 per cent. of the total of our registered unemployed is represented by such people. The number of registered people unemployed in the County Mayo when the new system came into operation went up from about 200 to something over 12,000. Is any Deputy opposite pretending that 12,000 people became unemployed in that period? The number of unemployed in Donegal increased from a few hundred to something well over 12,000. The same situation applies in Galway and all the western counties, and in so far as the allocation of relief fund was based on the number of registered unemployed in the different districts there was a direct inducement in every district for every person who was seeking work to register for work. The larger the number of registered unemployed the greater the amount of the allocation of the relief fund made.

I am rising to make sure that no Deputy will misunderstand the position as a consequence of the statements made by Deputy McGilligan. We had a serious problem but the situation has not become worse as a result of the tariff policy. It has been considerably eased as a result of the tariff policy and any proof anybody wants of this can be produced. The figures of people in protected industries are being prepared and will be published. The total number of people engaged in insurable occupations are being prepared and will be published. Figures for the output of the protected industries are being prepared and will be published, the market statistics are available already up to the end of August.

Comment on this

Hear, hear.

Comment on this

As the Deputy says, hear, hear, and they show conclusively there has been a steady decline in the importation of all or nearly all the protected articles—a decline which in some cases was much more substantial than I thought would be effected within the period of three months, and Deputies should remember these tariffs and this protective policy had been in operation only for three months up to the end of August. Now as that policy has worked out in a period of great hardship, in a period of world depression, in a period when every country in the world has unemployment trouble as big if not bigger than ours, we can safely assume that we can deal with the unemployment situation best by continuing that policy, by continuing to afford to Irish industries the protection they deserve and by fostering the growth of new industries in the country. That is what these Resolutions are intended to do and we will not be prevented from doing that by any tactics of misrepresentation based upon faked figures as the Deputy opposite stated. I would not like the Minister to be misled by any figures supplied to him by his Departmental officers or from local exchanges in the towns and cities. I have been making inquiries as a result of continuous communications which I have been receiving from parts of my own constituency and, particularly, from one county, Leix. I was informed, on 26th September, by a Government Department, because I made inquiries arising out of the very small grant given to the county, that the number of registered unemployed was 950, and that in one registration area, Portlaoighise, there were 425 out of the 950 registered. I would like to point out to the Minister that if those who are really unemployed in rural areas saw any real hope of getting employment in or near their registration areas there would be a considerable increase in the number of registered unemployed over those actually looking for work.

Comment on this

Quite so.

Comment on this

So that we have not got at the whole yet?

Comment on this

It is quite possible.

Comment on this

The position in the rural areas, so far as I know it in my part of the country, is no better than it was last year, and I would like to know the number of people who registered in the Civic Guard stations and local post offices as a result of this particular facility which was provided by the present Ministry.

Comment on this

The number went up by 40,000 in the week in which the new system came into operation.

Comment on this

I intervened in this debate to say what I believe to be the truth, so far as portions of my constituency are concerned and, although I do not want to magnify the position, I assure the Minister that it is certainly worse in the rural areas in County Leix than it was twelve months ago.

Comment on this

And everywhere.

Comment on this

Might I put a question to the Minister before he stops? He told us when he came into office that the figures of the unemployed were quite wrong, and in order to find the right figures he tried a particular system. Am I to understand that he ridicules the figure he now has for Mayo and Donegal and that we have not the right figure? He said that we had not the right figure when he came in and he has adopted a particular scheme and the result of that scheme is to give a figure which he ridicules. Is that the position?

Comment on this

It gives a figure which represents with some degree of accuracy, not the number of unemployed, but the number of people who are available for work other than the work they are at.

Comment on this

It always did that.

Comment on this

We are trying to get additional information now, and to segregate that figure into those who are, for example, holders of land, people who are workers with no means of living other than by their work, and the people with other means of livelihood. If we do that we will probably have more accurate information as to the position.

Comment on this
Mr. Hayes

The Minister's scheme for finding the true figure of unemployed would need considerable amendments before it can give any figures over which he himself can stand.

Comment on this

Quite so.

Comment on this
Mr. Hayes

So that the Minister's improvement is not really of any great value in spite of all the talk.

Comment on this

The Minister asked for a figure and he has now to explain it away. That is what it comes to.

Comment on this

I will admit that I was somewhat disappointed. I thought that the new system would give a figure that would be a fairer reflex of the unemployment situation than the figure we got has been. We have to go a step further and analyse that figure before we can be satisfied that we have the information we require if we are to deal with the problem.

Comment on this

Does the Minister consider it possible to get a better analysis than the 80,000 not working people?

Comment on this

Quite.

Comment on this

Will it be done?

Comment on this

Is it in process of being done?

Comment on this

And you are likely to get a true figure?

Comment on this

The Minister had better hurry up because people are falling into the belief that he will not.

Comment on this

I am delighted to see the Deputy agitating on behalf of the unemployed. Time works great changes.

Comment on this

It has worked tremendous changes in the Minister when he finds that the unemployed are not under his control, and that he cannot get them into employment.

Comment on this
Division

Question put.

Tá 68
·
Níl 58
Result Carried The question put was agreed to.

Do you agree with this result?