We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

Agricultural Produce (Cereals) Bill, 1932. - Second Stage.

Contributions 1–130 of 270. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

Bill Agricultural Produce (Cereals) Bill, 1932
Enacted

No. 27 of 1932 ›

James Ryan Minister for Agriculture (Dr Ryan) Fianna Fáil

I move that the Bill be now read a second time. The object underlying it is to increase grain production in the country. An increased production of grain would mean a very big increase in the wealth of the country. We leave aside for the moment the question of whether it pays the farmer or whether it is difficult for the farmer to grow grain or not. We are faced with the huge figure that is paid each year for the import of cereals and cereal products into the country. In the year 1924, for instance, the figure was 13½ millions. The import of cereals and cereal products has been diminishing since that year, but the volume of imports has not diminished. As a matter of fact, last year, the volume had increased very considerably. Last year, the amount paid for our imports was about £7,696,000, and, for the first nine months of this year, the import had increased over what it was last year. The Minister for Industry and Commerce has just been speaking about getting an advantage from preventing imports, even if we get no other advantage, by having certain things produced within the country. Here again we have to take into account the position of our imports and exports, and we find that there is an adverse trade balance against this country for some years. The adverse trade balance, with regard to imports and exports of commodities, may have been made up by invisible exports in the way of interest on capital invested abroad.

As long as we can continue to balance our trade by drawing on the interest alone of these investments, things are not, perhaps, in a very bad way and we need not take very serious notice of them. It it is necessary to draw on some of the capital that we have invested abroad, it is quite obvious that at some time that capital will be exhausted and then, whether we like it or not, we must balance our trade in imports and exports. We know that we must import certain things in order to maintain a good standard of living. There are certain things we would all feel the loss of very much if we were prohibited from importing them. But if we could reduce certain of our imports by producing these cereals in our own country we would then be in a position to lessen our exports and allow our own people some of the meat, milk and butter that we are exporting. We could, on the other hand, enlarge our imports in other directions and import some luxuries that we cannot afford to import at present.

The most important cereal that we deal with in this Bill is wheat. We have had many discussions here about wheat. If we could produce the wheat that we require it would, at any rate, be a distinct national gain. We would save the importation of between £4,000,000 and £5,000,000 worth per year. We would also give the grower the advantage of a guaranteed cash crop. We would increase employment in the rural areas and we would be more secure in case food supplies were cut off for any reason, such as a shipping strike, a war, or anything of that sort. The subsidy which this Bill provides for the growing of wheat, because the only way we can get wheat grown is by offering an attractive price to the farmer, is in or about 3/6 per cwt. In order to offer an attractive price to the farmer we must provide a subsidy. The subsidy provided in the Bill is based on present prices which have, perhaps, reached rock bottom. The amount would be about 3/6 per cwt. or 56/- per acre, assuming that the grower will market on the average 16 cwts. to the acre.

The principle of subsidising the crop is not a new one. We have had the experience of six complete years of beet growing. During those six years the subsidy paid on beet amounted to £2,060,000. Out of that amount, which was contributed by the taxpayer, the beet growers got £1,872,000. The amount of the subsidy was, therefore, 110 per cent. of the amount received by the grower. Taking the present prices of wheat, the subsidy which we have provided in this Bill will amount to about 37 per cent. of what the grower would get. In other words, the average subsidy paid on beet for the six years—£343,000—if applied to beet would give the grower £312,000, but if applied to wheat would give the growers £927,000. We could for the same subsidy get one acre of beet returning £24 4s. od. per acre or eleven acres of wheat returning £8 7s. od. per acre.

There have been discussions on various occasions about the growing of wheat. The objections raised to any wheat growing scheme were mostly from the technical or agricultural point of view. For instance, it was objected that our soil and climate are not suitable for wheat growing. We were told wheat would be particularly exposed to the ravages of crows and other predatory birds; that land sown with wheat was prone to weeds; that it was a hard crop on the land; that it could not be sown in old lea; that it was an unsuitable nurse crop and interfered with the ordinary crop rotations of the farmer. I do not know whether, on examination, many of those objections would stand. At any rate, I do not mean to spend very much time in dealing with those points.

With regard to soil, if we examine the returns got out by the Department of Industry and Commerce on the subject of agricultural statistics covering the period between 1847 and 1926, we find some very interesting information. In 1847, the first year for which we have had a return in regard to wheat, 671,000 acres of wheat were grown and the average yield was 16½ cwts. per acre. We must remember that at that time there were no artificial manures such as we have now. In the circumstances, it was truly a remarkable crop. Considering the information we have at our disposal now, and our advanced knowledge in regard to agriculture, we should surely do much better than the people did in 1847; we certainly ought to do better than 16½ cwts. per acre. I am led to believe that we have better varieties of seed now, and in every way we are in a more favourable position to that occupied by the people in 1847.

With regard to climate, if any Deputy will examine the yield of wheat over a period of twenty years he will find that there were three years during which the rainfall was more than 46 inches. In those years, and with that particularly heavy rainfall, the yield of wheat was not less than in preceding or subsequent years. I think the objections with regard to weeds will not hold. I think it will be found that the bad farmer always has weeds, and the good farmer never has them. I heard two or three years ago in the Dáil that wheat could not be grown on old lea. I had the courage to go back to my place and plough up old lea in order to see if wheat would grow on it, and I had a very good crop, just as good as I would have on any other land.

Comment on this

Have you continued using that land since?

Comment on this

I am doing the same this year. There is no proof better than practical experience. When you do things for yourself you have a better appreciation of results. Listening to a lot of people in the Dáil, who know nothing about the question, does not tend to convince anybody. The only thing is to work things out for yourself. We had objections also about nurse crops which I mentioned on a previous occasion were tried, and tried with success. Other objections raised were that, even if we succeed in getting wheat grown, we can only do so at the expense of other cereal crops; that it would take the place of oats and barley; that we would never achieve our chief object, to have increased tillage, and that we would only get a replacement of crops. Of course, if we succeed in making the oat and the barley crops remunerative that objection will not hold. However, apart from any arguments used against the growing of wheat, perhaps the most telling argument we can make for it is that we have the experience of our eyes at the present time, when we see wheat being sown on a much larger scale than hitherto. The reports we have received go to show that the area under wheat in the coming year will be at least three times as much as it was last year.

Comment on this

Could the Minister give any figures?

Comment on this

I think the acreage last year was about 22,000.

Comment on this

And 66,000 is anticipated this year?

Comment on this

About that. The question that will decide the area under wheat is the standard price. The point is, whether the standard price is sufficient to induce farmers to engage on wheat-growing on a large scale. I quoted before a discussion that took place in this House in 1925, between my predecessor, Deputy Hogan, and Deputy Gorey on the merits of wheat-growing. At that time, Deputy Hogan was emphatic that wheat could be grown in this country at 30/- a barrel. To give him his due, Deputy Gorey was not convinced. In fact, Deputy Gorey stated that people would only grow wheat when they had nothing else to eat. Deputy Hogan knew what he was talking about then.

Comment on this

Will the Minister quote what I said?

Comment on this

I will. In the Official Debates for June 4th, 1925, column 353, the Deputy stated:

How is the typical farmer to meet competition? What has he to do to meet the competition of rivals in Denmark, the Baltic States and elsewhere? He has to pay 12/- for Indian meal. He is buying practically all his carbohydrate food in the shape of Indian meal. Any man in the Midlands can produce barley at 8/-per cwt. in the average year. I will give you some figures which may be of interest. He can produce barley at 8/-, yet he is giving 12/- for Indian meal. That man might have two or three sons who would not be working terribly hard. What has that man been giving for flour, for instance, for the last two or three years? He was paying £1 or £1 0s. 6d. for the bag. He could produce that for about 12/- off his own land if that land was in good heart. When I stated that before, Deputy Gorey said that very little land will produce wheat. Most of the land of this country has produced wheat.

Take flour, if milled from whole wheat, and taking one cwt. of wheat at 12/-, at which price Deputy Hogan said it could be grown, that would be 30/- a barrel.

Comment on this

How many cwt. of flour in a cwt. of wheat?

Comment on this

I am giving Deputy Hogan's description. He said that if you milled one cwt. of wheat as whole flour you got one cwt. from it without any extractions.

Comment on this

There was no allowance for moisture.

Comment on this

No. I give Deputy Hogan the benefit of that. There was no allowance for moisture or anything else. If Deputy Hogan was speaking for the farmers at that time, and if he was satisfied that wheat could be grown at 30/- a barrel, I think an average price of about 24/- a barrel at present would be very good. If the prices of all farm produce were down now only by 20 per cent., as compared with 1925 prices, there would be no great complaint. Therefore, I think 24/- a barrel for wheat would meet the case.

As Deputies know from the Bill the standard price has been fixed over three periods. During the first period, which lasts to the 15th December, the price is 23/6; the second period goes from the middle of January to the middle of April, when the price is 25/-; and the third period from the 1st May to the 31st July is 25/-. The object in making the two prices was to induce farmers, if possible, to keep their wheat in stacks in the haggards, and not to thresh until after Christmas, so as to prevent the rushing of the wheat into the mills during the month of October, thereby making it difficult for the flour millers to deal with storage, reception and kiln drying. Under the scheme provided in the Bill there is freedom to farmers to grow or not to grow wheat. I think I read in the newspapers some time ago that Deputy Gorey stated that we were going to compel farmers to grow wheat.

Comment on this

You did not.

Comment on this

I am sorry if I am wrong and I apologise to Deputy Gorey. I certainly saw where some Cumann na nGaedheal Deputy stated that that was so. There is freedom to farmers to grow or not to grow wheat. If they think the crop is going to pay they can grow it, and if they think otherwise they need not grow it. When he has wheat a farmer is free to go and sell it to any miller or wheat dealer he may choose, and he is free to make the best price he can. The miller is free to buy where he likes, except that he is compelled to get a certain quota. That is the only driving force proposed. It will compel the miller to pay a fair price for wheat when he knows he must get a quota. Therefore, he must pay a certain price to get it. On the other hand, farmers will know that millers are bound to get a quota, and they will be in a position to hold out for a fair price for millable wheat. The crop that is clean and in good condition will naturally get a better price than a crop of inferior wheat that is marketed. There will be an inducement to grow a good variety of wheat, to have it brought in, threshed, and sent to market in good condition, so that it will get top price.

At the end of the first period, say in the middle of December, all the sale transactions will have been sent to the Department of Agriculture by farmers who have supplied wheat, and the Department will be in a position to calculate the average price paid over the period. The difference between that average price and the standard price will be the amount of the bounty. The bounty will be sent direct to each farmer who supplied wheat in that time.

In that way, it is quite possible that the farmer who submits the best wheat to the miller will get 1/- or 1/6d. more than the standard price because he will get more from the miller before he gets his bounty and the man who has sold the inferior wheat—wheat which was, perhaps, on the border line of rejection by the miller—may get 1/-or 1/6d. per barrel less than the standard price. The Department has recently issued a circular to seed merchants explaining arrangements for enabling them to give credit to farmers who buy seed for the coming season. Under this scheme, a merchant, when supplying seed to the grower, may get the grower to sign a form authorising the Minister for Agriculture to pay the amount due for that seed to the merchant when the grower's subsidy becomes due next year. With the help of this scheme, we expect, as I have stated, that the acreage of wheat will be in or about three times what it was last year. It may reach 70,000 acres but I think that would be the maximum. The subsidy payable would be about £200,000.

The second item dealt with under this Bill will be feeding stuffs. Under this heading, we have a very large import every year——

Comment on this

Before the Minister passes on to that, would he say if there is any fixed price payable by the miller for this millable wheat?

Comment on this

No. There is a free market between the miller and the farmer, qualified by the provision that the miller must take a certain amount.

Comment on this

His quota?

Comment on this

Yes. To replace even portion of this import would be a distinct advantage to the country. It would give increased wealth to the producers and increased employment to our workers. Nobody will dispute our ability to grow barley and oats so that we need hardly enter into the argument about climate, soil and weeds that arose in the case of wheat. The question does arise, however—it is probably the question that will be most in dispute—as to whether imported cereals, principally maize, can be replaced by home-grown grain as a proper diet for animals.

Various experiments have been carried out by the Department of Agriculture over the last three or four years. The results of these experiments would go to show that in practically every case maize can be replaced by barley or oats. The first experiment dealt with the value of barley meal as against maize meal in a pig ration. This experiment was carried out by agricultural instructors in 15 counties. It was a uniform experiment carried out by all the agricultural instructors, and the results were afterwards published. Two lots of pigs were fed on rations of the following composition— No. 1 on barley meal (one part), potatoes (two and a half parts) and separated milk; No. 2 on maize meal (one part), potatoes (two-and-a-half parts) and separated milk. The experiment went to show that barley meal was equal to maize meal for pig fattening. The daily increase in weight and the consumption of food for each lb. of gain were the same in both lots, so that, weight for weight, barley meal was as good as maize meal in that ration for the fattening of pigs. Again, an experiment was carried out as between crushed oats and maize meal. I do not want to read out all the details of these experiments. I shall only give the results. The increase in weight and the food cost of every lb. of body increase was similar in both lots, showing that oats are as good as maize for pig fattening when the quantity of oats fed does not exceed one-third of the entire ration. Oats could replace maize up to one-third of the ration for pig-feeding. Following on that, an experiment was carried out as regards the replacing of pollard and some other feeding stuffs by oats. A similar result was got. Oats, in quantity up to 30 per cent. of the entire ration, may be used to replace other cereals in comparison with which it has similar feeding value.

Comment on this

What were the component parts besides oats?

Comment on this

Maize meal (two parts), pollard (one part) and separated milk or fish meal. In the second case, maize meal (one part), crushed oats (one part) and pollard (one part).

Comment on this

I thought you dropped the maize meal?

Comment on this

In the first lot, there were two parts of maize meal——

Comment on this

You did not omit maize meal from any of these rations?

Comment on this

No.

Comment on this

That is an important point.

Comment on this

It was, of course, omitted in the barley ration. The next experiment dealt with the feeding of fowl and was directed towards ascertaining the value of barley as against maize in the ration of laying fowl. The result was that egg production and food consumption were equal. In the case of calves, an experiment in crushed oats as against maize meal was conducted by agricultural instructors in ten counties. The result was that the increase in weight over three and a half months was similar in both lots, showing that, for calves, oats has a feeding value similar to maize. In that case, oats completely replaced maize. In the case of dairy cows, in an experiment between crushed oats and maize meal, the milk yield was similar in both groups. The only experiment in which the result might be described as disappointing, from the point of view of home-grown grain, was in the case of fattening cattle. It was found that where these cattle were fed on decorticated cotton cake and crushed oats, they did not do as well as cattle fed on decorticated cotton cake and maize meal. In a second experiment, where the proportion of oats only amounted to half the ration, it was quite as effective as the maize meal. The result of all the experiments was, however, that in the case of pigs and cattle—milch cows and fattening stock —all the maize in the ration may be replaced by barley without altering the results of the feeding.

Oats is as good as maize for pigs when it is fed up to the limit of 20 per cent. to young pigs and 30 per cent. to older animals, provided that no bulky foods are included in the food mixture. Oats is equally good with maize for dairy cows, but for fattening cattle, receiving a bulky ration of fodder and roots, the equality of oats with maize holds only when the proportion of oats in the meal mixture is limited to about 50 per cent. of the feed.

We find, therefore, that maize can be replaced with advantage either by barley or oats, as the case may be, and we shall be conferring a distinct advantage on the producers, both workers and farmers, and also on the country, if we can find a method of replacing maize by those home-grown cereals. The obvious question that anybody can ask has been asked before in this House and that is if it is an advantage why did not the farmers grow these cereals for themselves without Government intervention? To understand the difficulties underlying the growing of cereals by the farmers themselves, we have to remember that there are at least for this purpose three different classes of farmers to be dealt with: (1), you have the farmer who grows his own grain and feeds it to his own stock. We are not concerned with him at all in this case. He has always been admitted by everybody in this House to be the best man for the country and for himself. The man who grows his own grain and feeds it to his own stock is the best farmer. There are two other classes of farmers with whom we want to deal—the farmer who grows grain and has a surplus after feeding his own stock and who wants to sell that surplus. There is a third class and that is the man who has not enough grain for his own stock and wants to buy feeding stuffs. If we can effect an exchange between the person who has a surplus and the person who wants to buy we would solve the problem. To do that is the difficulty with which we are confronted.

The farmer who up to this has been feeding his own stock and wanted to buy feeding stuffs found maize a very convenient foodstuff with which to deal. First of all, he found it not only convenient for the last couple of years but he also found it certainly cheaper, if not very much cheaper, than native oats and barley. If he wished to buy home-grown grain it was difficult to do so. Last year, for instance, he might have been in the position of getting oats, barley or wheat at a cheap price; but it was unmilled or unmixed in any sort of the balanced ration, and he had to buy it perhaps in the large quantities that did not suit him. On the other hand, we had the difficulty of the farmer last year who had grown grain and wanted to sell it and he was not getting a sufficient price to keep him in production.

Apart from the intrinsic value of maize as compared with home-grown grain, the miller, the wholesaler and the retailer certainly gave a decided preference to maize because it was easier for them to deal with maize. Maize is less troublesome. It was a more uniform article; it supplied the needs of most of their customers. They had not to be troubled with supplying barley to one, oats to another and wheat to a third. As a result of the difficulty on the part of the seller and the general inferiority complex of the farmers amongst themselves in this country with regard to home products, maize came to be looked upon as the superior article.

We came to the conclusion at any rate, that it was rather a duty to encourage the production of grain at home. The first thing that might have struck a person perhaps in trying to achieve this object would be to find out what are the possibilities of compulsory tillage. But I think very little consideration would bring one to the conclusion that compulsory tillage would be impossible under present conditions. Many of our farmers throughout the country would not have the capital necessary to engage in the purchase of horses, implements, seeds and manures and so on, so as to go into tillage. So that compulsory tillage did not hold out much hope of solving the difficulty. The two things that are required in order to get grain grown on an enlarged scale in this country are a guaranteed market and a fair price. A fair price itself will not solve it. For instance, a person might say that if we were to put a tariff on maize we would raise the price of maize and thereby raise the price of the average supplies all round thereby solving the problem. But Deputies who are engaged in farming will remember that about four or five years ago maize was as high as 12/- a cwt. while barley was 8/- a cwt. and oats 6/-. Even so, there was not a great rush amongst the feeders of stock to buy barley or oats which could be got at a much less price than maize so that a guaranteed market would appear to be essential to any scheme that is drawn up to solve this problem. You must, whatever way you approach it, compel the maize-miller to purchase a certain amount of home-grown grain and you must in turn compel the stock feeders to use a certain amount of home-grown grain.

Then we arrive at what has been known in the country as the mixing scheme. Now, the mixing scheme means that maize millers must be registered so that we would know who they are and where they are working. They must mix a prescribed percentage of home-grown grain with the maize they mill. That percentage would be calculated to absorb the surplus grain in the country. The percentage can be altered from time to time to achieve that object. The scheme is, I think, familiar to most Deputies in the House, and it is hardly necessary to go very much into the details of the working of the scheme. There are, however, various objections which have been raised from time to time to this mixing scheme. The first is that pure maize is used in certain parts of the country as human food and that under our scheme it will be not possible for people in the farming parts of the country to get pure maize for human food. We have to provide for that at least to a certain extent by allowing pure maize to be sold in cartons or packages of a stone weight or less. If people of a household want pure maize to consume they can get it in that form.

The second, and, perhaps the most serious objection to the scheme is that feeding supplies would be increased in cost to the purchaser. If we take the present prices of barley and maize and even putting barley at as high as 8/- a cwt. to the miller, which is putting it at the extreme limit, and taking maize at 5/-, which is putting it as low as we possibly can to the miller, we will find that it works out in this way: There is a difference of 3/- a cwt. between the two. If the home-grown grain does not exceed 10 per cent. it would mean that the mixture should be not more than 6/- a ton dearer than before. Even taking into account the extra trouble and the storage of the home-grown grain it might go a little more than 6/-, but I do not see that there is any reason why it should go beyond 10/- a ton.

Comment on this
Mr. Hogan

What has it gone to already?

Comment on this

Say 10/-. An increase of 10/- a ton may be looked on as a hardship and it probably is a hardship. I want to draw the attention of Deputies to one thing when talking about this increase of 10/- a ton. Already there is as appears from the sheets issued by the Department of Agriculture from time to time, a difference of 10/- a ton between feeding stuffs in different parts of the country.

I find from this sheet, which was issued for August—that is before the mixture scheme came in—that the difference for maize meal in various centres amounted to 10/- per ton, and that the difference for pollard amounted to £2 per ton, so that if anybody says that the producer can no longer remain in production, because the cost of his feeding stuffs is put up by 10/- a ton, then all I can say is that in August last, at any rate, there were some people in production that should not be in it as the cost of their feeding stuffs was up by £2 a ton. The question arises, what does it come to?

Comment on this
Mr. Hogan

The Minister says it is gone up by 10/- a ton.

Comment on this

I suggest that would be the extra cost to the miller.

Comment on this
Mr. Hogan

What has the price gone up by? This has been in operation now for a month or two.

Comment on this

I will come to that. It is held, for instance, and this is one of Deputy Hogan's famous points, that the millers will not be satisfied with the 6/- or the 10/- that they are entitled to, but will take a whole lot more. It was reported to us that in certain cases in the South, in Cork and Kerry, that the millers did increase the price by 30/- a ton instead of the 6/- or the 10/-they are entitled to. On that, I would say to Deputy Hogan and others like him, who hope that the millers will charge 30/- or £2 a ton as a result of this mixing scheme, that if they do that they are profiteers and there is no reason why they should not have been profiteers in the past. There is no reason why they should not have put up prices by £2 last year or the year before.

Comment on this
Mr. Hogan

But have they? What is the figure?

Comment on this

As I have said, the report that I got was that in some cases in the South of Ireland they put up the price by as much as 30/- a ton. In most cases, according to the reports I got, the increase would amount to 10/-or 12/- a ton, but what was the force that kept those maize millers from putting up the prize £2 a ton last year and the year before? There must have been something. According to what we have heard already from Deputy Hogan, if traders can get £2 a ton more than what would be a legitimate profit they will take it. Perhaps they will, and they are entitled to take it. Again, I ask what was it that kept maize millers from putting up the price £2 a ton last year and the year before?

Comment on this
Mr. Hogan

Competition.

Comment on this

And the competition still remains.

Comment on this
Mr. Hogan

Is that all that is in it?

Comment on this

The cost of the raw material is 6/- at the outside.

Comment on this
Mr. Hogan

What does it cost the miller?

Comment on this

10/-.

Comment on this
Mr. Hogan

Would it not be nearer to 24/-?

Comment on this

No. At least some are doing it at 10/-. I do not believe they are doing it at a loss.

Comment on this
Mr. Hogan

They are using oat hurds.

Comment on this

No.

Comment on this

The Deputy should not be slandering everybody.

Comment on this

According to Deputy Hogan the Irishman is always dishonest.

Comment on this
Mr. Hogan

Not at all.

Comment on this

He is just as virtuous as anybody else?

Comment on this
Mr. Hogan

Of course.

Comment on this

Another objection to the scheme is that it will not have the making of a uniform mixture. A strange thing that I have noticed in connection with the samples sent up by maize millers is that the uniformity of the mixture depended upon the miller's politics. It will depend in future on their efficiency and on their desire to remain in business. They will have to drop polities.

Comment on this
Mr. Hogan

They would be bad politicians if they did not send you the best samples. That is what I would do and I am as anti-Fianna Fáil as anyone.

Comment on this

The next objection is that the millers cannot store the grain. The millers did appear to apprehend danger under this head in the beginning: that it was difficult for them to have to buy 10 per cent. of their complete output for the year, store it and keep it there for their ordinary requirements for the year. I do not think that this danger is as real as the millers thought in the beginning. After all, we have corn merchants in the country who have capacity in the way of storage and capital to keep corn throughout the winter if necessary. They would supply corn to those maize millers weekly or monthly, as required, for cash down and not cash in advance. Another objection was that the farmer could not get pure maize for his stock. Everyone will agree that the farmer looking for pure maize for his stock should not be allowed to continue in the business. We are told that we cannot find out by chemical analysis whether the mixture is a proper one or not. When this Bill becomes an Act, the regulations will lay down that the miller is bound by law to put a certain percentage of home grown grain into his grist. If he does not do that he is breaking the law. Of course there are many crimes under the law that cannot be detected by chemical analysis. If they could things would be easy. But we will have other ways of finding that out and of punishing offenders. We feel that we can detect evasions.

Comment on this
Mr. Hogan

So that they can put what they like into it.

Comment on this

No. The mixture will be prescribed by regulation, and if they do not put in what is prescribed they will be prosecuted and made subject to the penalties laid down in the Act.

Comment on this

But in the case of farmers who have their own mills, how is the Minister going to get at them?

Comment on this

I will come to that later. Objection is also raised to the danger of feeding more than 20 per cent. oats to young pigs. That is true according to the results of experiments which I have already quoted. There is no reason, even if our mixture reaches a higher percentage than 20 per cent, as I hope it will, and goes to 60 or 70 per cent, why a man with small pigs should buy a mixture of maize with 60 per cent oats. He can specify to the miller that he wants 60 per cent. barley and keep that for small pigs. There will be a provision in the Bill to allow oats that have been de-hulled to be mixed. A mixture of oats of that sort would be suitable for pigs. In the case of farmers who have their own mills, they will not be compelled to buy the mixture. We mean to issue special regulations to cover that. If we find that a farmer, over the last three or four years, was in the habit of buying so much feeding stuffs, then on that basis we will permit him to import into his own premises a certain amount of whole maize.

The only provision that we may have to put into the licence is that he must have a quantity of home-grown grain that would be at least sufficient for the mixture in case he was buying the whole maize from a commercial maize miller.

Comment on this

What is the farmer going to do who is buying the fine meal which is turned out to-day? The modern practice of feeding pigs with raw meal requires a very fine meal.

Comment on this

He can get fine meal.

Comment on this

Can he buy the meal under the same conditions as the maize?

Comment on this

He can buy the mixed meal.

Comment on this

But then he cannot use his own?

Comment on this

Why not? He can easily mix his own. Generally speaking, however, the scheme would be easier to administer if the tendency in the country were to increase the acreage under barley rather than under oats, because the mixtures containing barley are much more uniform than the mixtures containing oats.

There is also a section of the Bill dealing with compound feeding stuffs. Up to the present, farmers were unprotected against the dishonest manufacturer of feeding stuffs. It was due to such dishonest practices that the seller had to state on the invoice the analysis as to oils and proteins, but even if the proper analysis were given of the feeding stuffs, and if it were analysed by the person and it turned out that the proper analysis was given, still it did not matter what the manufacturer was charging for his product. We know that in some cases manufacturers of compound feeding stuffs were charging prices which were altogether exorbitant.

Comment on this

I thought you said that they were all honest.

Comment on this

The manufacturers to whom I am referring were foreign manufacturers.

Comment on this

That explains it.

Comment on this

There was one case of an imported feeding stuff which was sold here for 56/- per cwt. which was only worth 7/- or 8/- per cwt. We want to prevent such practices and to prevent these dishonest manufacturers coming in here and corrupting our own honest men.

Comment on this

What representative had these manufacturers in this country?

Comment on this

I would want to get notice of that question.

Comment on this

The names of these representatives should be given.

Comment on this

Why don't you tell me?

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

Please do not enter into that.

Comment on this

We mean to see that nobody, foreign or native, will be permitted to manufacture a compound feeding stuff unless we are satisfied that it is right from the point of view both of price and composition. That does not mean that we are going to pry into the secrets of the feeding stuff manufacturers or to try to find out any particular secret process. If it shows, on analysis, that it contains in or about the normal amount of fats, proteins, and carbo-hydrates, and if the price is all right, we will not go down and ask the manufacturer what is in it.

Having gone over these things that are dealt with to supply our full needs in wheat and feeding stuffs, we hope to reach eventually that point where we will have in tillage about one and a half million acres in addition to our present tillage. The advantage of that would be a saving of £9,500,000, and the payment in wages, whether to agricultural labourers or to working farmers, would be £3,000,000 per year—as good as the land annuities— with work, or the equivalent of work, for an additional 50,000 men. I am aware, of course, that if we take one and a half million acres for oats, rye, barley and so on, we would be taking that much from grass. However, that would be only taking 15 per cent. of our grass away and I think that 85 per cent. of grass, if properly manured, would give as much as the one hundred per cent. of grass is giving at present. Our aim in this Bill is to get the farmer to grow his own grain. We do not want so much to bolster up the farmer in order that he may be able to grow cash crops, but we want to get him to grow his own grain. If we achieve that, we can get them all growing enough of their own feeding stuff to feed their own stock and that is the ideal condition. If the price of the barley and oats sold in the country becomes very good and the price of the mixture is much lower, there is a danger that farmers would sell their oats and barley and buy back the mixture. If that should arise, the only way to deal with it would be to raise the price of the mixture by a tariff on maize or by some other method. The price of oats at the present time is certainly much more favourable in the Free State than in the North of Ireland or anywhere else. There is a very large amount of oats coming across the Border to be sold in Dundalk and other markets because of the better price obtainable here than in the North.

That deals with the portions of the Bill with which the Department of Agriculture is concerned. There are other parts of the Bill with which the Minister for Industry and Commerce is concerned. The regulations of imports of wheat and maize are necessary in order to control the movements of grain within the country. They are consequential on the other provisions. The regulations in maize milling are necessary to have our scheme carried out. Regulations in connection with flour milling and bread would be necessary under this Bill, to some extent at any rate, but they have also been found necessary by the Minister for Industry and Commerce in order to save the industry of flour milling in this country and he has already dealt with that matter in June and again in this House the other day to some extent.

These, I think, are the principal points underlying the Bill. If any other questions are asked, we can refer to them later.

Comment on this

As one with considerable experience of tillage, I should like to say that I find that the great difficulty here is the changed condition of the climate. The Minister has given us reports from the Department of Agriculture as to the value of the different rations, but I should like to ask the Minister has the Department of Agriculture reported on the difficulty that is experienced in tillage owing to the changed condition of the climate for a period of, say, ten years.

Comment on this

Everybody recognises that the Minister had an exceedingly difficult task before him, first in justifying the Bill, and secondly in expounding what is undoubtedly a very complicated Bill. After all the justification of the Bill should, in a way, have been the principal business of the Minister on Second Reading—to point out why this Bill is necessary, why it is desirable and to show that the policy which this Bill foreshadows is a sound policy for the country. I wonder whether Deputies who are not already convinced on the subject will be convinced by the speech they have just heard from the Minister. It cannot be said that he was unaware of the case that could have been made against this particular policy. The House and the Minister will be aware —he already referred to it—of a pretty extensive debate that took place in this House some years ago as regards the second portion of the Bill —that dealing with the wheat policy. I think the case, so far as the first portion of the Bill is concerned—that dealing with the "mixing policy"— was put very clearly and very definitely by the independent tribunal that was set up to investigate this particular problem. I refer to the Grain Inquiry Tribunal. Members of that tribunal were able to approach the problem possibly in a way that the Minister is not quite able to approach it because undoubtedly it is clear that this is a policy in which he believes very strongly. They were able to approach the consideration of this problem possibly, if I might say so, with a mind more unbiassed than that of the Minister. They also had the advantage, which this House has not had, of hearing on that particular occasion the case to be made in favour of this project.

The Grain Growers' Association put their case very clearly and strongly before this tribunal. The tribunal also had the opportunity, which this House has not had, of hearing the very strong case that was put up on the other side. Similarly, the House cannot now hope to get the very extended view of the difficulties that prevailed and the difficulties that must prevail, as far as the second object of the Bill is concerned —the promotion of extensive wheat growing. They can find it, however, in the records of the House and in the reports of the Economic Commission set up by the late Government, which issued both a majority and a minority report. I suggest to them, if they read the debate to which I refer and the minority report, they will be struck with one thing, that it was not on the basis of facts or on the basis of experience that the conclusions of the minority were based. It was wholly on the basis of a priori reasoning, starting, as the Minister started this evening, with some very general economic theories—more general in the case of the minority report than is usual even in these debates—and with the proposition that the main business of agriculture was to produce human food. Then they went on in beautiful geometrical order from that principle to reach the conclusion that we must grow more wheat. I wonder will those who have given thought to the subject be altogether convinced that the Minister has made a case for this particular policy. There is one thing, I think, on which the House might agree and that is, that in normal circumstances it might well be that possibly the only way in which it can be tested is to try it out. I think that was ultimately the conclusion to which the Minister himself came. I will show later why I put in the reservation about normal circumstances. I shall deal with that particular point afterwards when I come to the matter. One thing I must say I did not quite gather from the Minister's speech was the cost to the taxpayer of this particular measure. There are two kinds of costs. I am speaking of the cost involved in the bounty and the cost of administration, because by chemical analysis, unfortunately, it is not feasible to detect the malpractices that are possible under the first aim of the Bill, the encouragement of the mixing policy. In default of the chemical analysis doing that, I fear we shall have to have a rather elaborate bureaucracy in the matter.

I wonder has the Minister formed any idea as to the increased number of officials that will be necessary to deal with that? No estimate was given. I presume there will be some cost involved. Also, though the Minister gave us what he estimated as the cost in the way of bounty for the coming twelve months, under this Bill when it becomes law, I did not get from him what he considered the ultimate cost if his policy is as successful as he hopes, and if we ultimately produce the total quantity of wheat necessary for our needs. He mentioned only the cost of the bounty for wheat for the coming year, but supposing we produce the total amount of wheat necessary for this country—possibly I think 600,000 acres would be required, roughly speaking—what would be the ultimate cost in the way of bounty? There are considerable costs involved, much more costs than are indicated in the slight reference to the cost for the coming year which the Minister made in the course of his speech. I think we should have the cost, as the country is asked to embark on this policy, not merely for the coming year. The Minister could treat the coming year as a harbinger of what is to come, and the country should get some idea of what the ultimate cost will be of this Bill. The subject of costs reminds me of another matter—the Minister was being interrupted, I will admit, while he was on the subject—namely, the increased cost of the mixture to the ordinary farmer. He estimated it at 10/per ton. I ask him how that estimate compares with the estimate of cost which he will find in the report of the Grain Inquiry Tribunal? In arriving at that estimate of 10/- has he taken into account all the factors that have been taken into account there? Has he also taken into account—I wonder how far the report itself does it—the difficulty the millers and others will be involved in,—the difficulty under the particular factors that are detailed in the report, of knowing precisely or with any degree of commercial accuracy what must be their commitments for the coming year, or what will be the amount of grain food required? The report points out that that depends on a number of factors which cannot be judged until the beginning of the year, and it points out also that whereas that does not matter so much when you can import a sufficient amount of maize by telegram it may matter considerably when you have to make your arrangements for the purchase of the amount of grain that will be necessary to be milled for the current season, when the millers and the dealers will unfortunately not be in the same happy position.

What I was particularly anxious to know was how this estimate of 10/-compares with the estimate of increased cost that is given by the tribunal which reported on this particular matter. I wonder also whether the Minister has considered, in connection with wheat and with this mixing process, how the distance of mills and the distance of farmers from large grain growing areas will affect the situation. I can quite conceive that there are certain portions of Ireland where there might be a very strong demand in favour of this particular policy. I think it is equally obvious that there are other parts of Ireland in which there is strong objection to it. I have heard from farmers in my own portion of the country that there is a strong objection to this mixing process where they are concerned. They object to it on various grounds. First of all they have not the same confidence—I am sorry to say it—that the Minister has in the people who are going to market the stuff to them, nor the same confidence in the ability of the Government to see that there is a good mixture of good materials. I find a very great deal of scepticism on their part as to the value of the mixture they are getting. In the case of maize it is practically, I understand, of a uniform quality. I think so far as certain parts of the country are concerned the Minister just brushed a little too lightly aside the increased costs that there will be in the purchase of maize for human food. Under the Bill it has to be put in packets of one stone, that is each stone for human consumption will have to be packed separately. That must mean increased cost, and it must mean an increase in the living expenses of the ordinary farmer in the portion of the country I come from. I can only speak for that portion of the country from experience, and mixed bread is a bread that they largely consume at present. They used to consume a lot of it at one time, then they were dropping out of it, and I understand they are now going back again to that particular form of food. It seems to me there is considerable cost involved, and certainly the farmers believe that there will be cost involved which they should not be asked to bear.

The Minister referred in quite glowing terms to one particular class of the population, that is the farmer who produces his own grain, produces his own feeding stuff and feeds it to his own animals. He spoke highly, and deservedly so, of that particular class of farmer—"the class of man that is best for himself and best for the community"—and yet that class of farmer, unless we are altogether deceived by the purely impartial Body that investigated the matter, are strongly opposed to this particular scheme. They think it will damage their business very seriously. In fact what, in comparison to them, the Minister would call the not so well deserving class of people would gain at their expense. Because they are already doing what the Minister aims at—they may have been compelled by circumstances to do it— they are now to be penalised by the increased cost. It is quite clear that they hold very strong views on the matter. Apart altogether from the evidence that was quoted in this report, I know that there are farmers who do resent very strongly the fact that those who have gone in for that particular type of farming will be compelled now to meet extra expenses. The Minister may, of course, say that they are trivial. He may say that because they were able to stand £2 two years ago they can stand 10/- now, —or whatever the increased cost is. The Minister, as I have already pointed out, left us in a rather unsatisfactory position as to how he reached that estimate of an increased cost of 10/-, but anyhow they do object to this increased cost and I can well understand it. I can well understand, owing to certain policies that have been pursued, why the farmer who, two years ago, might be able to bear certain costs, is not able to do it to-day. There are two sides to the farmer's economy. There is what he pays for what he gets in, and there is also what he gets for what he sends out. It might, in the normal way, as I said, seem to be the only course, to give the experiment a chance and see what will happen. Whether it is wise or proper to use the national purse in order to promote a policy that may be unsound is another question. I suppose trial is one of the best ways of deciding it, but undoubtedly if you expend enough, and are in a position to continue that expenditure, you will induce people to go into any policy no matter how unsound—if they are paid enough by the State for doing so—and therefore that would not be a final answer.

There is another objection, and I am basing it on a remark made by the Minister for Industry and Commerce last evening. He is the Minister referred to in various parts of the Bill. He spoke of the necessity for getting out of the cattle trade. I may have an opportunity of dealing more fully with that policy afterwards, but it is quite relevant to the discussion that we are now engaged in, because, apparently, in the minds of some of the Ministers, this grain policy is not to be an addition to the cattle trade, it is to be a substitution for it. Well, I would prefer that, before we lose what we have got, we were much more firmly established in what is to take its place. What makes me uneasy about this particular business, and the arguments I have heard again and again in favour of it, is this. One of the arguments most frequently used— we have heard it in this House, we have heard it from the Minister, we have heard it again and again from his colleagues through the country—is that instead of wheat-growing diminishing the amount of cattle that you raise it ought to increase it. Those who gave evidence in favour of some of those proposals before the tribunal to which I have referred were very strong in putting that forward,—that there was really no rivalry whatever between the policy they advocated (and, as I will suggest in a moment, the same thing will hold good in regard to wheat), and the cattle trade. In connection with wheat, again and again it was pointed out that the growing of wheat in this country will mean the rotation of crops, that you must have root crops follow your wheat crops and so on. Wheat is grown in the same field, at most, once in every three years. Take the most optimistic view, once in three years is as much as you can do in some patches of land followed by root crops. What is to happen your root crops? Are they for human consumption or cattle consumption? Which? Surely the contention that was again and again put forward, and put forward as one of the arguments of the wheat policy was the way in which, if anything, it would increase the cattle trade. What is the present policy we are indulging in—not in this particular Bill—but what is more clearly every day the settled mind of the Government? What is to happen these cattle? We know the simple answer of that most simple-minded man—the Minister for Defence. His answer is quite easy. Will the ordinary farmer who has two years out of three to put in root crops and feed cattle or for the people who have cattle, would the ordinary farmer be satisfied with that cheery prospect which the Minister for Defence held out as being the proper way of disposing of our agricultural animal produce, i.e., beef, butter, poultry, eggs, and so on?

I wonder whether if here we have one of the first examples of a constructive policy on the part of the Government which completely cuts across the other policy—what I might call their political anti-economical policy—which they are indulging in. It is no good for a person like myself or for any members of the Dáil to discuss the suitability of the wheat crop. There are various views for and against, but listening to some of the previous debates in favour of this policy, what amazed me in listening to them was this, how the Government or any Government restrained the farmers from indulging in it. It was painted in such attractive colours on the last occasion we discussed it, that the thing to account for is, why the farmers did not practically put every acre they had under wheat—it was such an attractive policy. We also had the other point of view put forward, and the conduct of the farmers, unfortunately, did seem to lend colour to the contention that it was not such a suitable crop for this country. I can find very few people in my portion of the country, at all events, who have any belief that you can have an extensive wheat-growing policy in that county at the present time. The ordinary farmer does not believe in it. I believe that is so. Not merely are these the views of those who support us but also of those who support the Government. Not like the millers who prejudiced the Minister. Their views do not depend on their particular political persuasion. Men have told me they have tried several times in recent years to grow wheat, and undoubtedly it was an excellent crop up to about three weeks before it was fully ripe and then it proceeded to produce a second crop—it sprouted. That was by no means an uncommon occurrence in more than one year, and I think many a farmer who tried it as an experiment gave it up. Now, whether that can be overcome or not I do not know. I have a vague suspicion, or a vague fear, that experimenting on this line has largely been done in the direction of trying to produce a variety of wheat which is suitable to other countries that have not much rainfall. I am not denying that in certain plots in every county in Ireland you can get good results so far as wheat growing is concerned. I am dealing now with the question as to the possibility of the farmers producing it on a large scale—not merely growing 22,000 acres and increasing it to 66,000 acres this coming year—that is not the policy that is before the country or before the Dáil. That is only the beginning. The real policy is a much bigger policy. I doubt the possibility of getting the real policy adopted. I doubt also the propriety of getting it done, because a large number of the farmers do not believe that they can do so with profit or with safety.

As I am on that point of safety I may quote something from the Minister's colleague, the man who is in joint charge of this Bill with him, so far as the enactments go. I have already quoted from him—from last evening's speech. I must say he was sometimes extremely candid in opposition; he is almost indiscreet when he gets going, as when he told us last night we must get out of the cattle trade, the country must get out of it. A short couple of years ago he painted this very illuminating picture for the farmers of the country whom he was trying to persuade to adopt the policy of wheat growing. There was, he said, a partial failure of the crops in Canada this year—1929. "The Economist" for the 3rd August, 1929, says:—"The straw is unusually short and the wheat is ripening prematurely. In many districts the damage done is reported to be beyond repair, and thousands of struggling homesteaders will have to face a very difficult winter, as their crop returns will be negligible." This is in Canada, the wheat growing country. "From Sas-katchewan the reports are almost uniformly gloomy, and in southern and south-eastern districts many farmers have simply ploughed their wheat into the ground to make summer fallow land for the crop of 1930." I am quoting from the Dáil Debates, volume 32, columns 1588 to 1589. Then Deputy Lemass, the present Minister for Industry and Commerce, goes on, and he showed great admiration for the courage of these Canadian farmers, and would like to inculcate and inspire our farmers with the same courage. "The farmers of Canada are not going to run away from wheat growing. As I have said wheat growing, at the present price, is the most profitable crop to farmers," and later on he said, "what I say is that it is the most profitable crop to the community." And again he says, "that although the crop may occasionally fail"—not the failure, mark you, of the crop of one farmer, but a general failure—"although the crop may occasionally fail in consequence of bad weather that cannot be advanced as an argument against wheat growing. An occasional failure is not going to drive the farmers in Canada from wheat growing and out of tillage altogether and into the production of live stock. The wheat crop failed from time to time in Canada. But they simply plough the crop into the ground to prepare the land for the coming year." That is a very encouraging prospect to hold out to the farmers of this country. I wonder, when you compare the suitability of the land for the production of wheat, will public money be wisely spent if this bounty produces such results as the Minister supposes. Occasionally we do happen to have a wet season, and I wonder, when we happen to get the wet season, if the farmers are to adopt the very heroic policy mentioned by the Minister for Agriculture and his co-Minister as adopted by the farmers in Canada?

Unfortunately the experience of farmers who have tried this experiment is by no means favourable. It may be, in the future, that a particular type of wheat will be produced as the result of experiment that will be suitable to wet climates. The effort has been in the opposite direction in the past, and consequently if scientists concentrate upon that problem they may produce a more suitable kind of wheat for wet climates. I doubt if they have done so yet. Here, not for the first time, the Minister is proceeding to act on the old plan of putting the cart before the horse.

As regards the mixing process, I know there will be very great fear on the part of the ordinary farmer in my part of the country at all events. Perhaps the Minister would say that in his part of the country the farmers are more trusting. They may be. But in my portion of the country there will be very grave doubts in the minds of the farmers as to quality of mixture. I wonder if the very severe penalties envisaged by the Minister will have sufficient effect when there is no chemical means of deciding the quality of the grain by means of analysis. As I am on the question of penalties, there are a number of millers in this country at the moment and they are, without more ado, to get licences—I mean ordinary millers. If they offend there are various penalties prescribed in the Bill as set out in the Schedule. But there is a penalty not mentioned in the Schedule which is much more serious than any penalty mentioned in it; and that is the power of the Minister to withdraw the licence altogether. You may have a fine of £50 or three months in prison, and so on. But if you have the power given to the Minister, not a court, but the Minister himself, to withdraw a man's means of livelihood it is a very serious matter. I mention this because the Minister will have an opportunity of dealing with it now or in Committee Stage. There are a number of reasons given why the Minister, if satisfied, may withdraw a licence. "The Minister may at any time without any such application revoke a milling licence granted to any miller if (a) he is satisfied that such licence was procured by fraud or misrepresentation." Not that a court is satisfied but if he is satisfied: or (b) "the business of milling wheat has ceased to be carried on at such mill; or (c) the holder of such licence has been convicted of an offence under this Act." But in addition to the penalties already prescribed in the Bill, a man may be deprived of his livelihood altogether. I suggest if that has to be done it should be done in plain terms. The power is there and it is taken into the hands of the Minister to interfere with a person's ordinary livelihood. But in recent Bills such extraordinary powers over the livelihoods of thousands have been taken, and this penalty here affects so few that probably nothing will be done about the matter.

There is another matter that I am afraid the Minister did not make quite clear, in his opening statement, and the difficulty that confronts me here I think also confronts other Deputies, and that is the difference in price paid for different types of grain. I admit there may be differences. There is an average price struck, and it is the difference between the average price and the standard price that is to be got in the way of bounties. In that connection there are two things that might be taken into account. If the average falls all round the country it makes no difference what price the farmer gets. Will not that have the gradual but inevitable tendency of depressing the price all round the country that the farmer gets for his grain as distinct from the bounty? I think that will be the inevitable result, gradually, because it will make no difference what the farmer gets from the miller as distinct from the bounty, if the average price decreases. If the millers, gradually, therefore, reduce the average amount of money they give for the wheat, the bounty will make up the difference. That is bound to happen. The other thing I should like the Minister to keep in mind is the different qualities of grain offered to the millers. Why should the unfortunate farmer who lives in a portion of the country where the climatic conditions and the conditions of the land are not as suitable as they are in other places, be at a disadvantage in comparison, merely because his land and the climate produce worse grain than elsewhere? If it were an ordinary commercial transaction, I could see the justification, but here is a case where public money is being spent, and I suggest that that is a most unfair discrimination so far as the poorer classes of land are concerned. As I represent one of the poorer districts of the country, I suggest that that might be looked into. You are really asking him to take risks and, where the risks are greater, the rewards, I fear, will be less. That is the policy in the Bill so far as it stands. In that connection, I need only refer again to the beautiful, heroic passage I read out from the speech of the present Minister for Industry and Commerce showing the dangers that farmers run, dangers that are greater in some portions of the country than in other portions. That ought to be taken into account.

A thing that was not clear from the Minister's speech, as it is not clear from any of the specehes we have heard when dealing with economics in this House, is the balance that there will be in the increased labour. We heard a reference, if this policy succeeds, to the actual number of people that will be put into employment, but we did not, unfortunately, hear even a suggestion that there may be many ways in which, if this policy was being adopted—and after all we ought now to be familiar with that, and, apparently, the head of the Government is familiar with it, if the others are not—people will be indirectly put out of employment. Has that been sufficiently considered? I do not say, if the policy succeeds, that more people may not be put in, but I have grave fears, judging by the previous experience of the method by which the Government looks at things, as to whether they even thought there was a problem of that particular kind.

I should like, in connection with this matter, to ask a question of the Minister: why it is that a certain firm has been singled out for the special patronage of the Department for the supplying of seed; why an exception has been made in their favour? There are a couple of instances; I do not know how widespread they are through the country. On 15th October there was a lecture given by an Inspector of the Department, at Enniscorthy, in which he pointed out that arrangements had been made for the supply of grain from the I.A.W.S. Why were they singled out for that particular preferential advertisement? It was not any indiscretion on the part of the inspector—I want to make that clear— because in the Drogheda Independent of the same date, in the Farmers Gazette of the same date, and I do not know in how many other papers an advertisement to the same effect appeared. I do not know what policy there was, or whether there was any policy behind that.

One thing that rather amused me in the Minister's speech was his considering it necessary to stress the fact that no force was being employed, no compulsion. Then he stated that the reason he mentioned that was because some Cumann na nGaedheal Deputy had said it. He, unfortunately, mentioned the Deputy. I have also recollections of hearing that stated, but it was not by members of the Cumann na nGaedheal Party; it was by followers of the Government Party. Force, and very decided force, was to be used against the farmers who did not fall in with the economic policy of the Government. Very often these people, I may say, have a method, and a very awkward method, of anticipating, in speech at all events, what ultimately becomes the declared Government policy. They very often let out to the public, possibly in order to accustom the minds of the public to it, what the Government are thinking, and what, when the people get over the first shock, the Government immediately proceed to enforce on the people. It is quite clear, of course, that there is no force provided for in this Bill. Those, however, who are familiar with the way in which farmers have been dealt with in other places know perfectly well that you can manage subsidies, preferences, and various other things in a way to amount to strong compulsion. Ultimately, I wonder whether, if this policy does not succeed to the extent that the Minister hopes, and if the other policy outlined last night in the celebrated phrase: "That we would have to get out of that trade," does succeed to the extent that the Ministry hope, force will not be necessary in the economic interests of the country, or, to put it in another way, whether the Government will not be convinced that it is the national duty of the people to do this, and that if they are not willing to do it, they must be made to do their national duty. We had also a little interchange here this afternoon in the matter of planed wood in which the Minister pointed out the great advantages of amalgamation so far as certain things are concerned.

It seemed to a number of people that there were a number of draw-backs to the wheat crop so far as this country was concerned. One was the climate and the other the small size of the farms which, of course, meant that they had to be worked in a very different way from that in which they were worked in other countries. As I say, the Minister was keen on rationalisation. They may succeed in the policy so clearly enunciated last night of dragging us out of the cattle trade. They might pretend to do it, but I doubt if they will be able to change the climate—but there may be a temptation to change the size of the farms, and for the Government to go in for that policy of amalgamation referred to this afternoon by the Minister. That, of course, is far from their minds at present. I am wondering, however, whether the very logic of events, whether all the policies that they are indulging in in this respect, will not drive them there, though nothing could be further from their minds at present; when it is quite clear that this crop is being managed under uneconomic conditions, whether there is fear the Government or some future Government may feel bound to interfere to see that it is managed under more economic conditions. There are some detailed points in the Bill to which I have referred upon which I want some special information, but as regards the details of the Bill they can be more suitably dealt with in Committee. I have tried to confine myself to the general policy of the Bill as I see it—how it will affect the farmers, especially the farmers in that particular portion of the country which I represent.

Comment on this

This Bill, as I see it, is an attempt to interfere with the farmers' economics. It is not compulsory and we are perhaps grateful to the Minister for not having made it compulsory; but in other respects the Bill will cost the taxpayer a very considerable amount of money, while it officers doubtful prospects of advancement for the farmer. The Minister for Agriculture, in introducing the Bill, said that the object of it was to increase grain production. I suppose that is obvious and I should like to address myself to that. Will it eventually increase grain production? The Minister says that next year's crop is certain to be trebled and, possibly with a visionary hope and without understanding the position, a number of small farmers, or large farmers if you like, will be induced this year to grow grain. With the exceptional season we have had, a season that occurs possibly only once in a decade in this country, there may be an inducement to have more grain grown this year and a greater crop harvested next year. The Minister said also, I think, that the price of 23/- per bushel would give the farmer something about 50/- an acre over what he received this year. That may be right, with this proviso, that this year's price, whether it is good or bad, is an average price. Next year's price to the farmer is subject, so far as he is concerned, to the extent of his millable wheat and the proportion of his wheat that will be millable next year will depend to a great extent on the climate, which neither the Minister nor I can foresee, but which, if we take the average, is not odds on being a good year.

The Minister said that we had grown good wheat for many years since '47; that we had grown 16½ cwts. to the acre and that possibly we could now grow more and better wheat—I think he added the word "better." We could possibly grow as much as they grew in '47. I do not say that we could grow very much more and we could not grow it better nor as good, taking the years around '47 as examples. I think Deputy O'Shaughnessy referred to the matter of climate. The question of climate has a greater influence on wheat than either the Minister for Agriculture or the Minister for Industry and Commerce will admit, and a greater influence in this country, and though the Ministers will not admit it, anybody who can cast his mind back 25 or 30 years knows full well that the climate of this country has changed for the worse so far as the growing of cereals is concerned. Anybody with any recollection whatever of the period even as far back as 30 years ago—the great majority of the Deputies with the Minister, and the Minister himself, are young men, whose recollections cannot go back such a number of years—knows just as well as I know that the climate then was completely different from the climate we now have in the winter. We had then, almost invariably, and I think I am stating it correctly when I say invariably, a frost of two or three weeks during the winter. The middle-aged people in the country remember that we had an annual sport of skating. Most of the young fellows down the country now do not know what a skate is for and if they have even seen skates, they do not remember what they were used for. There is, as a matter of fact, a pair hanging up in my own house and many youngsters do not know what they are for. There has scarcely been any ice within my recollection that would bear a human being, and if ice does come, it remains only for a day or so and then thaws. In previous years, the deepest lakes were frozen over and I myself remember driving a horse and trap over a lake. Such a climate is necessary for the growing of wheat. It makes tilling conditions easier for the farmer, and in fact, it is impossible without a certain amount of dryness and frost, to till land for wheat properly. That is one of the difficulties in growing wheat, and the second difficulty is the season for harvesting—the percentage of moisture you get in a year and the likelihood of your crop not standing up if there is too much rain.

The statement I made, some two or three years ago, has not been refuted that the possible quality of the wheat we could grow, or that the Minister for Agriculture or the Minister for Industry and Commerce could induce us to grow, would not come within the category of the world's third quality. So far as I know, that has never been refuted by a miller, or anybody else, so that it comes to this, that the Minister for Industry and Commerce, who is responsible for the second protion of the Bill, is going to make provision for the giving of a bounty for millable wheat which certainly will not be up to the quality of, say, third-grade Canadian wheat. I would like to know what is the Minister's definition of "standard" in the sub-section:

"The Minister may, after consultation with the Minister for Industry and Commerce, make regulations prescribing the standard to which wheat must conform, etc."

I notice that the word "may" is used there, whereas, in other portions of the Bill, there is a very liberal use of the words "may" and "shall." The word "may" is always used when it is a question of the Minister dealing with quality, but when it is a question of quantity to be used, the word "must" or "shall" is generally used. In this particular case, the Minister may prescribe the standard, and I would like some information as to what it is likely to be. Is the standard going to be as high as No. 3 or No. 4 Canadian wheat? Is the Minister going to make that the minimum standard for wheat that may be used in milling, or, on the other hand, is the miller to use his own discretion as to the standard of the wheat he is likely to buy?

Again, touching on that, so far as the miller's quota is concerned—and this appertains more directly to the miller and it illustrates the different use of the words "may" and "shall" to which I have already referred—the Minister may prescribe the standard but he need not do it. He possibly will, but the miller must use whatever kind of crop we have got, whether it is moist, or whether we have smutty or rotten wheat, or bad barley, or something else, he must use a certain quota of the meal. The Minister shall make that order—he is left no discretion. So far as quality is concerned, the Minister has a free hand to do what he pleases, but as to quantity it is definitely laid down in the Bill that it must be such and such. The public are to be compelled to use a percentage of home-grown wheat in any one year, no matter whether that year happens to be one in which there was not one stone of millable wheat grown in this State.

Now we will come to the question of price. The Minister stated that the farmer would get, possibly, 56/- an acre more than this year's price. He might get that, and even then he would not be getting an economic price. The Minister mentioned the figure of 23/- a barrel for millable wheat, advancing in certain circumstances, provided the farmer could store it and escape the rats and mice, to 25/-. The Minister is holding out the figure of 23/- a barrel in order to induce the farmer to grow wheat. Certain farmers may be enticed to cultivate wheat, but I very much fear that with the experience they will gain they will not be induced later to repeat the experiment. Will 23/- a barrel be an economic figure for the grower? Has 23/- a barrel during the last ten years, in eight of which the average price of wheat has been more than 23/-, been an inducement to the farmer to grow the crop? Is it likely to be an inducement in the coming years with the disadvantage confronting the farmer that the guaranteed price is payable subject to the wheat being millable?

I believe that neither the Minister nor the farmers can foretell what amount of home-grown wheat could be considered millable. In those circumstances the farmer is not even certain of 23/- a barrel if he grows what for this country might be considered middling wheat, but at the same time would not be considered suitable for milling by any miller. The millers, if left to themselves, will certainly assume that a very small proportion of the wheat grown in this State is suitable for milling. If I were left to judge I would have to declare that a very small portion of the wheat grown in this country of late seasons is of good milling quality.

We have had evidence here that 23/-a barrel, or its equivalent in cwts., is not economic. In Canada it would not be considered an economic price. There was a serious agitation amongst the farmers in Canada at one period in regard to what became known as dollar wheat—a dollar a bushel, which is something equivalent to the proposed guaranteed price. Those of you who never visited Canada must have read about that agitation in the newspapers. The agitation spread over Canada and the Northern States. Farmers protested for years that anything under a dollar was not a paying proposition as far as wheat raising was concerned. That happened in a country where they were capable of raising, not the standard of wheat we can raise here, but the very best wheat in the world. That happened in a country where they can produce 40 acres of wheat with the same amount of labour that it takes to produce one acre here.

In that country at the time of the agitation, their taxes were about one-third of ours and their rent nil. Still they agitated strongly for dollar wheat. They believed the dollar was just the minimum figure which would permit them to cultivate the crop economically. Their costs are altogether out of proportion to ours. I admit that Canada has been producing wheat at a much lesser rate, but the Canadian farmer had reason to complain that the price offered him did not even meet the cost of production.

I should like to refer to the mixing process. Deputy O'Sullivan did not leave me much to say on this subject. I would like to reiterate his fears and the fears of the farmers generally that the quality of the mixture that people will be compelled to feed to their livestock in future will be very doubtful. The Minister for Agriculture went to great pains to defend the people who will make up this mixture. I will not condemn his attitude. I will not say that every manufacturer and trader in this country is dishonest. Some time ago on another Bill I declared that they were not. The Minister for Agriculture stoutly defended the traders. He upheld their interests so strongly that, if he is right in his viewpoint, the Minister for Industry and Commerce would be well advised to withdraw the Control of Prices Bill forthwith; that measure is scarcely necessary if the traders are all so honest and upright as the Minister for Agriculture has led us to believe. I admit that most of them are, but I do not think that the average farmer is of that mind.

The only people the Minister for Agriculture vilified are the farmers. He went out of his way to defend the traders; they were above suspicion everywhere. But according to the Minister the farmer has an inferiority complex; he has not a national spirit good enough for the Minister for Agriculture; he does not know his business and he should be driven to do it. According to the Minister, Irish farmers use maize, not because they consider it a better food but because they would prefer to use anything foreign before they would use the home product. I declare that that statement is a travesty on the wisdom and judgment of the farmers; it is a reflection on the character of the farmers of this State. I am surprised such a statement should be made by no less a person than the Minister for Agriculture.

Comment on this

The Minister did not make it.

Comment on this

He did, just half an hour ago. He said that the farmers were suffering from an inferiority complex and that they would use anything foreign in preference to the home produce. The farmers of this country have carried on during the last century under many difficulties. They have carried on their business without any interference from the Government, and I would like to emphasise that the less interference the Government have with the farmers the better will it be for the Government concerned, and for the farmers, too. We have no guarantee, except the Minister's word, that the traders are honest. I believe they are, but we have no safeguard that in this mixture of barley or oats or sawdust the farmer is going to get an article equal to the pure maize that he is now using. I do not know much about chemical research work. The Minister may carry his paraphernalia around with him, or he can send his inspectors to the millers' granaries, but he cannot do that in the case of every huckster or retailer in the country.

In such circumstances how is the farmer to know what amount of maize, oats or barley and what amount of dust is contained in the mixture? He will have his suspicions, and he will be right. Maize will possibly for a long time be at a much smaller price than barley, oats or wheat. I believe that in coming years there will be a lot more wheat mixed than either oats or barley. A great amount of the wheat that the Minister will induce farmers to grow will be fit for nothing else except to be included in this mixture or for hen food. The Minister is assuring the farmer that he will get a guaranteed price of 23/- but, in my opinion, the crop of wheat will be fit only for this mixture, and a very bad mixture some of it will make.

The Minister smiles. If the Minister was where I was growing grain for four or five years he would know something about the matter. I would like to induce the two Ministers responsible for this Bill to come down to an average farm in some southern county, wearing their city boots, and, if you like, their city clothes, take a pair of average middle-class horses in the "yallow" mud, and prepare the ground for the golden wheat. I was as full of enthusiasm for wheat-growing thirty years ago as the Minister for Agriculture is now. On coming back from Canada I was filled with the Minister's ideas, that we should grow wheat here, that the Irish farmers were damned lazy and should try to grow it.

Comment on this

It was a different climate then.

Comment on this

It was. My neighbouring farmers thought I had pishogues. They laughed at me, and they were right, because after trying it for two or three years I found it would not do. The most that farmers get in this Bill are promises. If there was no great profit at 30/- God help us with 23/-. In fixing the bounty of the national percentage in respect to any cereal, the Minister shall have regard to the estimated quantity of wheat grown annually. I would like to know if he has had any regard as to the estimated quality of the wheat. It is easy to estimate the quantity. Why does not the Bill, for which the Minister is responsible, have some estimate as to the quality of the wheat? That is what we want to get down to. The last word in wheat is quality, and on the quality of the wheat depend many things, the percentage of the bounty that will reach the farmer; the percentage of the wheat on which he will get the bounty, or, on which he will get anything. The farmer may have to sell it to a miller for mixing. Above all, there is the percentage of good wheat that will be milled and mixed with flour, which the poor people will be compelled to eat after paying an advanced price for it. All these things depend upon the quality of which very little is said in the Bill. We should like to see some safeguard in the Bill, as far as Section 2 is concerned, so that the quality of the article will be protected.

The Minister made some comparison, when talking of bounties, between beet and wheat. He stated that bounties in the case of wheat would be much better than in the case of beet. The question of quality again arises. We know that we can produce the best beet in the world, and that it is a crop worth subsidising. We know also that we cannot produce the fourth best wheat. There is a difference between offering a subsidy for the best class article and for the fourth class article. I think the Minister himself realises that. I do not think he should have raised that point. There is no comparison between the two cases. The Minister read some articles as to the use of this mixture, and the great advantage he was conferring on the Irish farmer in introducing into it oats and barley. He stated that weight for weight barley was as good as maize. I would like to ask him is it as cheap price for price. The Minister admitted that the other two cereals were not as good as maize for the ordinary animal, for the production of flesh or milk. Barley may be as cheap price for price. We know that maize is cheaper than barley, and that weight for weight it is as successful, price for price. The end that touches farmers will not be so successful, as the extra price paid for the barley in the mixture will raise the price. If farmers go into the matter carefully they will find, after all the mixing and twisting arrangements, that just as there were manipulations of the galvanized iron, there will be certain manipulations in the mixing process, and that they will be to the disadvantage of farmers, both in the price they pay for the quantity of maize in the mixture, and in the quality of the mixed article, as compared with maize in the mixture, and in the quality of the mixed article, as compared with maize. I do not think there will be very much enthusiasm, except perhaps in Deputy Davin's constituency and in one or two other counties, for this mixing process. There will certainly not be much enthusiasm in the rest of the country for it.

Comment on this

Robbing Peter to pay Paul.

Comment on this

Whose teaching?

Comment on this

There are other matters that I would like to refer to, but I can do so on the Fourth Stage. I am as firmly opposed to the principle of this Bill as ever I was in any of the debates on this question that took place here. I do not see any great hope for successful wheat growing in this State. I do not see any great advantage, even now, in the mixing process. Farmers should be left to use their produce in their own way and any interference by the Department is inadvisable. I should like to reiterate the hope of Deputy O'Sullivan that the best results will accrue from this trial. Perhaps they will. While I expect that they will not be successful, I hope, when this Bill is passed, that my fears will not be fulfilled and that the Minister's may. Time alone will prove that. I do not think I would be justifying either my constituency or myself if I did not state what I honestly believe to be true, with a large experience of wheat growing, that the Bill must fail and that the scheme must eventually fail.

Comment on this

The absence of farmer Deputies on the Fianna Fáil Benches has been noticeable since the beginning of this debate. I am sure they realise, as well as we do, that the proposals embodied in this Bill are unworkable; that instead of conferring any benefit on farmers it is going to do them a great deal of harm. I am surprised that some Deputies on the Fianna Fáil Benches who are farmers have not participated in the discussion. It was very noticeable that the Minister himself did not father this Bill with any degree of enthusiasm. In fact it was commented on very generally, not only on these benches but on other benches, that the Minister did not seem to be the least bit enthusiastic about proposals that, I assume, he was responsible for embodying in the Bill. I do not wonder at that, and I can quite understand why farming members of the Fianna Fáil Party are so noticeable by their absence. I am entirely opposed to the proposals embodied in the Bill. I consider that these proposals are unjustified and that, instead of helping the farming industry, they will inflict very great injury on it; that the Bill in itself is an attempt to impair business that was carried on efficiently in the past; that will retard the ordinary normal development of that business and that it will impose a burden on the community which it is unable to bear under existing conditions.

At the outset of his statement, the Minister said that one of his objects in introducing this Bill was to increase the production of grain. He went on to say that if the production of grain here could be increased it would inevitably lead to an increase of wealth. He seemed to be under the misapprehension that one was a natural corollary of the other. I wonder if this Bill is to be regarded as the first step in the direction of changing the economy of this country as it has existed for many years up to now—from the production of live stock and live stock products to grain growing. At the close of his speech, the Minister said that it was not alone the intention but that it was the ambition of the Fianna Fáil Government to increase tillage to, or by, 1½ million acres—I did not quite catch whether the word he used was "by" or "to." Quite obviously, it is the intention of the Government to increase the tillage area very considerably during the coming years. I thought that the Minister's concluding words implied a threat that if the farmers were not prepared voluntarily to comply with the present proposal, compulsory steps would be taken and they would be forced to increase the area of tillage so that the Minister's ambition and the ambition of his Government would be realised. As I said, I do not know whether or not the Bill is to be regarded as the first step in changing the economy of the country from the production of live stock and live stock products to grain growing. If it is to be regarded in that light, then the Bill should receive very serious consideration from the members of this House. This country has followed a certain economy for many years. That economy has succeeded in bringing a certain degree of prosperity to the people. Notwithstanding the views expressed by certain prominent members of the Fianna Fáil Government, I still hold that the production of live stock and live stock products is the only economy that suits this country, is the only economy that is likely to pay the farmers under normal conditions and that any change in that economy would be a very serious blunder on the part of any Government controlling the destinies of the country and would be productive of disaster.

If this Bill is to be regarded as the first step in the direction of that change, then it will have to be very seriously regarded by Deputies, who must face up to the possible consequences of such a change. At the outset, it must be recognised that you cannot have a grain growing policy here without being prepared to expend a large sum of State money on such a policy and, consequently, that the people must accept a very much lower standard of living than the standard they have enjoyed up to the present. These are two inevitable consequences of the adoption of a grain-growing policy. For these reasons we should examine this Bill very closely. I am not in a position to know what is in the minds of Ministers, and I do not know whether this Bill is to be regarded seriously in the sense I have mentioned or not. But if you compare the provisions of this Bill with the statements and speeches of Ministers throughout the country during the past three, four, or six months, there is the possibility that they may be serious in their intention to bring about that change. It is in the light of that possibility that this Bill should be discussed

The Minister mentioned that one of the primary objects of the measure was to increase tillage. An increase in tillage inevitably means the expenditure of capital. I think that every Deputy realises that the capital of farmers has been woefully diminished in recent months, and that the indications are that whatever little capital is left is likely to be swept away from them completely during the coming months. I do not think that the policy of grain-growing is going to lead to any increase in tillage. What will happen will be that wheat will be substituted for some other crop in the present rotation. I know that farmers are preparing to do that in certain districts and we may rest assured that it will be done very generally. I do not believe that the Minister's estimate of an increase in tillage of 60,000 or 70,000 acres will materialise. I do not believe for a moment that the farmers, in view of past experience, will increase the area under wheat to any appreciable extent. It is all very well for Ministers and officials to have fine theories as regards the possibilities of wheat growing and the wealth which a crop of wheat will produce as compared with any other crop. But the farmer has hard experience to guide him—experience which is far more useful and far more reliable than any theory or any number of theories. And the farmers are satisfied, in view of past experience, that wheat is, in the main, not suited to the land of this country and not suited to the climate of this country.

The Minister made a reference to the question of climate in his speech. He seemed to suggest, although he did not use the words expressly, that the climate of this country was just as suitable for the growing of wheat as the climate of certain other Northern European countries. I am perfectly certain that if the Minister had consulted some of his own higher officials —particularly officials with experience of tillage operations throughout the country—they would have told him, and told him quite truthfully, that even during the last ten years the climate of this country has changed a great deal. There is no use in the Minister referring to the fact that we grew so many hundreds of thousands of acres of wheat in the year 1847 or 1857. The Minister stated that in the year 1847 we grew about 600,000 acres of wheat. Deputies are aware that in the year 1847 we had one of the biggest famines in our history. If the Government pursue their policy of wheat growing and succeed in restoring the grain growing conditions that existed in 1847, they may bring about another famine just as big as that of 1846 or 1847.

The Minister went on to say that wheat growing was bound to lead to an increase in employment. I wonder on what factors he bases that statement. Accepting, for the moment, his own estimate, if there is an increase of 30,000 or 40,000 acres in the area under wheat, that will not lead to any appreciable increase in employment whatever.

In any event, the growing of wheat will not lead to any increase in employment, because wheat will be grown in substitution for other crops. In that way it will create a certain dislocation of the farmer's economy. The Minister also referred to the experiment carried out by the officials of the Department over a period of four or five years for the purpose of getting a suitable variety of winter wheat in this country. I was sorry the Minister did not elaborate a little more on that point, because, so far as I am aware, the officials of the Department have failed to provide any suitable variety of winter wheat that will stand up to the conditions in this country. I have seen experiments carried out in my own county during the past few years, and each of these experiments, from the standpoint of the Minister and from the standpoint of the Party behind this Bill, has been a complete and absolute failure.

There is one thing that rather puzzles me in connection with this proposal, and particularly in connection with the proposal relating to the figures given by the Minister. I think it was in 1929 that the Minister stated not alone in the Dáil but before the Economy Committee that wheat could not be grown in this country at a lesser price than 30/- a barrel. That was his statement, and that statement is embodied in the Minority Report of the Committee of which the Minister for Industry and Commerce was, I think, also a member.

Comment on this

Will the Deputy read the extract?

Comment on this

I will, later on. In 1929 it was agreed that wheat could not be grown at a lesser price than 30/- a barrel.

Comment on this

Who said that?

Comment on this

The Deputy will have an opportunity of making his own speech.

Comment on this

Deputy Roddy should not make false statements.

Comment on this

We now come to 1932, and the proposal in the Bill is that a subsidy of from 23/6 to 25/- a barrel shall be paid for wheat of a millable quality. There was no question of millable wheat in the original proposal before the Economy Committee.

Comment on this

There was no original proposal of 30/- and there is no proposal now of a subsidy of 25/- a barrel.

Comment on this

I am afraid the Minister is suffering from a lapse of memory, because that was the last proposal. The Deputy made a speech before the Committee and it was only within the last week or fortnight that I looked up the debate in that matter. At any rate, the figure of 30/- a barrel was certainly mentioned not alone in the Dáil by the Minister for Agriculture, but also before the Committee as the figure which would recoup the farmer for growing wheat in this country. That was the price that was supposed to pay the farmer for growing wheat in 1929.

Comment on this

As what it would cost to grow wheat then.

Comment on this

It is now proposed in this Bill to grant a subsidy of 23/- and 25/-

Comment on this

Not a subsidy, the whole price.

Comment on this

Yes. What has happened in the meantime to reduce the cost of wheat growing?

Comment on this

Does not the Deputy know?

Comment on this

Surely I thought the Minister would have dealt with that point when introducing the Bill. What is the explanation of it? The cost of growing wheat to-day is as great as it was in 1928, 1929 and 1930. In fact it is greater to-day and this is largely due to the action of the Minister for Industry and Commerce, because he has piled up such huge tariffs on the farmers and on everything relating to the farming industry that it will naturally cost a great deal more to grow an acre of wheat now than it did four or five years ago. How did the Minister arrive at the figure of 23/- or 25/-? I should like to hear from the Minister how he arrived at the figure in view of the fact that in 1929, 30/- a barrel was considered to be a fair price for wheat in order to pay the farmers the cost of production in this country? What has been responsible for the change? Is there anything that has happened in the farming conditions in this country that would justify the Minister to pay a lesser price to-day than the price which he was prepared to pay in 1929? The Fianna Fáil Party have got wheat on the brain. Certain figures were worked out before the Economy Committee for the purpose of showing what it was possible to make out of an acre of wheat as compared with any other crop. Does the Minister now rely on these figures? Certain figures were produced for the information of the members of the Economy Committee to show that wheat in any event was a more profitable crop than any other crop grown on the land. Does the Minister still stand by the figures which, I assume, he prepared for the information of the members of the Economy Committee on that occasion?

Wheat probably has fallen in price during the last two or three years more than any other crop produced on the land, and wheat prices are still falling. The price in the last two or three years has fallen approximately 45 per cent. to 50 per cent. I think the Minister will agree with that. It has fallen considerably more than any other crop produced on the land. Yet why is it that the Government should select to subsidise the growth of wheat in this country at a period when the price of wheat is falling and when it is likely to fall still more? As a matter of fact, there is a glut of wheat in the world and there is a possibility of new countries entering into competition with old-established countries for the supply of the wheat requirements of the world.

In 1929 the members who signed the Minority Report of the Economy Committee stated: "There is reason to believe also that the low price of the 1928 crop will lead to some reduction of the wheat areas of the wheat exporting countries." It was considered at that time that the price was low at 31/6 a barrel. The Minority Report goes on: "It is safe to assume, therefore, that the average world price here for a number of years will not be lower than the annual average for 1924 and 1928." The members who signed the Minority Report of that Committee were very bad prophets. I am sure that now they would hardly like to refer to the prophecy after the event. In any event, the fact remains that wheat is the one main crop in the world to-day that is falling more rapidly in price than any other crop, and yet it is in circumstances such as these that the Minister chooses to put such a burden on the taxpayers of this country for the purpose of subsidising the growth of a commodity of which there is a huge surplus in the world, and of which, apparently, there will be a greater surplus in the years to come.

So much for wheat. I am sure there are many Deputies who will have a great deal more to say on wheat than I have. The remaining portions of the Bill deal with a mixture of maize and other grain. I wonder did the Minister give any serious consideration at all to the extra price which the farmer will have to pay for this mixture? He said, I think, when challenged by Deputy Hogan, that the price had only increased by 10/-. The price may have increased only by 10/- in certain districts, but in a great many parts of the country the price of the mixture has increased by at least £1 per ton and, in some cases, 24/-. I wonder if the Minister considered seriously, before he embarked on this proposal for the admixture of barley and oats and rye with maize, what would be the increased price to the farmers of this country. Surely, before embodying a proposal of this kind in legislation, he should have carefully considered what will be the increase in price for the mixture that will fall on the farmers of the country when his legislation has been given effect.

The farmers in the West of Ireland particularly grow more grain, relatively speaking, than the farmers in the majority of the other counties of this State, but if those farmers grow grain extensively they feed it, in the main, to their live-stock. Under the proposals embodied in this Bill they will be forced, so far as I understand the terms of the Bill, to sell their grain to the millers and buy that grain back in the form of this mixture at a greatly increased price.

The Minister, I know, when questioned by a Deputy on these benches as to what arrangements he was going to make in the case of farmers who feed their own grain to their live-stock, said that they would get special consideration, but he did not indicate the nature of that special consideration. It appears to me, from the wording of the Bill, that these farmers will be treated in exactly the same way as the less industrious and less enterprising farmers in the other parts of the country: that they will be forced to sell their grain to the millers, in the first instance, and buy that grain back again in the form of this mixture at a greatly increased cost.

This question of the advisability of mixing maize and barley and oats and rye was examined very exhaustively by the Tariff Commission. I do not know what has transpired since the Report of the Tariff Commission was issued, but, in any event, up to that time there was no demand for an admixture of this kind from any farmers in this country except from a few farmers in certain midland counties engaged in the growing of barley who could not sell barley at that period at a profitable price. I am not aware that the agitation for an admixture of barley and oats and maize has increased since the question was examined so exhaustively by the Tariff Commission. I have not heard it, nor have I heard that the growers of oats or rye in the other parts of the country have made any demand on the Government to embark upon a proposal of this character.

It appears to me that the farmers, as a whole, will be forced to pay an increased price for this mixture in order to satisfy the whims of a certain small group of farmers in certain midland counties. It was clearly demonstrated in the evidence before the Tariff Commission that if the farmers in the midland counties, who were so loud in demanding that this mixture arrangement should be put into force, followed the same economy as the small farmers in the West and of certain farmers in Monaghan, Cavan and Louth, there would be no occasion for them to make a demand on any Government that their industry should be artificially supported by means of this kind.

It is inevitable, no matter what the Minister for Agriculture says, that the price of this mixture will be higher than the price of maize meal. It is also inevitable that the price will go up higher than it is to-day. A miller told me no later than last week that, probably in a fortnight or three weeks' time, the price will certainly be increased by another ten or fifteen shillings per ton. What justification, I ask, is there for a proposal of this kind which imposes, in circumstances such as these, an additional burden particularly on the small farmers, the most industrious members of the farming community in this country? Surely farmers should be free to select their own feeding stuffs. The farmer is the best judge of the mixtures that suit him for the particular purpose for which they are required.

Deputy Bennett has stated that it is quite possible that in the course of time adulteration may be resorted to in the preparation of these mixtures. There is nothing, apparently, to prevent that happening. I think it was stated by a miller in his evidence before the Tariff Commission which investigated this proposal that there was no possible means of preventing adulteration. That was stated not alone by a miller, but also, I think, by an official from the State laboratory, so that the farmer who hitherto was able to go into a shopkeeper in the nearest town and get the best animal food it was possible to obtain at the cheapest possible cost—to get any variety of food —will now be forced to pay an enhanced price for an inferior commodity, a commodity which may not have the same food value as the one he was using in the past.

There is another point which I should like to mention before I sit down. The farmer will have to buy the mixture, apparently, from day to day—from hand to mouth, so to speak. He will not be able to buy any big stocks of the mixture, because, if he does keep sufficient to last for more than a few days, there is the danger of the stocks becoming rancid and fermentation setting in. That is a serious handicap to the enterprising farmer—to the modern type of farmer in this country—the farmer, after all, who is more responsible for the wealth of this country than any other type in it, because the good farmer buys his feeding stuffs in big quantities. He has always done so in the past, because it is more economical to buy in large quantities than in small lots, but, apparently, under the arrangements embodied in this Bill, it will not be possible for him to buy big quantities in the future. He will have to buy in small lots, and, even then, he will have to run the risk of the mixture becoming rancid and fermenting. So that not alone does he lose by the increased price of the mixture, but he runs the risk of the mixture itself becoming useless to him if it is kept for a long period.

It appears to me the whole Bill is foolish. I cannot understand why the Minister allowed himself to be forced into the position that he had to accept proposals of this character and that he embodied them in the form of legislation. There is not a practical farmer in this country to-day who does not regard the Minister's policy of wheat growing as a foolish one, and as a policy that is bound to lead to serious increases in taxation and in loss to the people as a whole; but they regard his admixture proposals as even more foolish. The Bill, it seems to me, is not conceived in the best interests of the country, but it seems to me rather that it is conceived in the worst possible interests of the country. The Bill, apparently, is not even supported by the farmer members of his own Party, because even when the Minister was introducing his proposals to-day, there were only two farmer members of the Minister's own Party in the House to listen to his speech. It seems to me that the Minister himself is not enthusiastic about the Bill. The farmer members of his Party are certainly not enthusiastic about it, and the people in the country as a whole look upon it as a foolish experiment and as an attempt to interfere with their business. I sincerely hope that if the Bill passes through the Second Reading Stage the Minister will, at least, accept sensible amendments for the purpose of removing some of the hardships in the Bill.

Comment on this

I am glad that the Minister for Agriculture has come to the rescue of the tillage farmers of this country. We heard a lot of foolishness preached from the Opposition Benches to-day, but when we come to examine the position, what do we find? What was the position of the grain growing farmers whose land was valued under the Griffiths' Valuation as wheat growing land? What was the position under the last Ministry? They were paying, owing to the high valuation of the land they held, two-thirds of the rates of their county. The farmers of East Cork are paying two-thirds of the rate of the County Cork on the valuation basis. The ex-Minister for Agriculture took good care that they got no benefit whatever out of the fact that their land was wheat growing, or grain growing land of any description. His policy was "the land for the bullock and the road for the men." In 1927, when we came in here, knowing the position and the difficulties under which those farmers were working, and knowing the manner in which they were being treated by the then Minister for Agriculture, we tried by questions here to find out from the Minister for Finance whether he would have a revaluation of those lands, and whether, under the changed conditions of agriculture, under the policies the Minister for Agriculture was then adopting, he would have a revaluation so as to place these farmers on the same basis as the farmers whose land was not wheat growing at the time of the valuation. The reply was that it would cost £780,000 to revalue the land and that he was not going to do it. From 1927 to 1932, the farmers in my constituency had to lie under that disability of having to pay two-thirds of the rates of the county on account of their land being wheat growing land, and then they were not able to get a market for what they produced. That position is now being remedied, and it is being remedied in the only way in which it could be remedied, namely, by providing a home market for the grain growing farmer and by seeing that he does get the benefit of the home market.

We heard a lot about barley from Deputies opposite. For three years here, I was raising the matter by question, on the Adjournment, and in every other way, that some limitation should be put to the importation of foreign barley into this country. We were told that they were not going to interfere with Guinness. On one occasion, the then Minister for Finance replied to me by saying that he was not going to tax the raw material of an industry when I asked him about this matter of the importation of barley, and when I also asked him about foreign malt he said that it also was a raw material of the industry. That was the reply which I got, and we were told that Guinness would run away if we were to put a tax on foreign barley. There is a tax on barley to-day and Guinness is still going on, and going strong.

Comment on this

That is due to Roosevelt.

Comment on this

In my opinion that is the only policy that will pull the farmers of my constituency out of the unfortunate position in which they are owing to the comic-opera actions of the ex-Minister for Agriculture.

Deputy O'Sullivan told us all about compulsion and Deputy Roddy also told us about compulsion. The ex-Minister for Agriculture came along and told us that you could not keep a bull unless it had three black hairs in its tail, or something of that description, and if you dared to keep a bull which did not measure up to these specifications you were liable to prosecution and would go to jail. What is the result of that policy?

Comment on this

Is not the present Minister doing the same?

Comment on this

I think I should get a chance to speak.

Comment on this

Does the present Minister adhere to the same policy or does he not?

Comment on this

What about the three black hairs?

Comment on this

We all remember the protests that were made here year after year about the question of bulls and the way the regulation was carried out. We had the Minister for Agriculture insisting at the same time that the only thing for this country was to go into dairying and to get into cows. You all heard him say that. What is the result? Here is the statement made by the late Minister for Agriculture last week as to the results of this policy.

Comment on this

And the policy of the present Minister.

Comment on this

I am talking of the last one. The present man is doing his job all right. I can guarantee that.

Comment on this

In his own way.

Comment on this

There was a statement made by the late Minister for Agriculture, Deputy Hogan, last week. "I was coming to the conclusion," he said, "after at least seven years of the operation of the Live Stock Breeding Act and after seven years of compulsion on farmers to keep bulls they did not want...

Comment on this

Like the present Minister.

Comment on this

Let the Deputy mind Indian meal, the price of it and the profit on it.

Comment on this

He will not get much.

Comment on this

The Deputy need not stick in his nose. I am very apt to cut it off. "Just before I left office"—a deathbed repentance of Deputy Hogan—"however, I was coming to the conclusion, and my experience since then has strengthened that conclusion, that the Live Stock Breeding Act, as it is operating, is operating against the dairy cow and in favour of the beef animal. I think if it is operated as it is being operated at present"—and I might add as it was operated in the past—"without making some attempt to encourage milk as against beef, that in a comparatively short time you may find yourself with magnificent-looking cows, very fine cattle and pigs, but that it will be extremely hard to get a good milking dairy cow in this country. The Act is operated in this way: there are licensing shows in practically every parish twice a year—in spring and in autumn. The animals are inspected there entirely on view. That is to say, pedigree or other qualities are not to be taken into account, and they are inspected as they would be on their appearance, or, in other words, on beef. That is bound to give an advantage to the animal that is bred from beef animals and it is undoubtedly working out in that way." Now, that is compulsion.

Comment on this

And completely out of order.

Comment on this

It is completely in order. The Deputy is not now Leas-Cheann Comhairle.

Comment on this

I did not like to interrupt the Deputy while he was quoting, but I submit that quotation is completely out of order on the matter before the House.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

I understood the Deputy was quoting to show the contrast in policy as embodied in this Bill and the necessity for a change of policy. As such, the quotation is in order.

Comment on this

I want to submit, with the greatest possible respect, that the speech from which the Deputy was quoting was made on a matter far different from that now before the House, and has no relation, I respectfully submit, to the matter before the House at the moment. I did not wish to interrupt the Deputy while he was quoting. I allowed him to finish.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Deputy Corry.

Comment on this

As one who has very painful experience of Deputy Morrissey's ruling. I am glad he is no longer in the Chair.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

That remark is distinctly out of order.

Comment on this

It is in keeping with the whole speech.

Comment on this

My quotation was for the purpose of showing that while the late Ministers were accusing us of compelling the farmer to grow wheat whether he liked it or not—that is the accusation made by Deputy O'Sullivan —we are not using compulsion on the farmer to grow wheat, but they undoubtedly used compulsion on the farmer which ruined the farming community. I say further that side by side with that policy of abolishing the milk yielding cows of the country, we had the purchase of creameries and a compulsion on farmers to pay £3 per cow for these creameries. We are told that we cannot grow wheat—"You cannot grow wheat, the climate is against you." That is what they told us also. I find that when it paid the farmer to grow wheat he grew it.

Comment on this

Hear, hear. And without any Bill.

Comment on this

And the climate did not stop him from growing it. For instance in 1918 when there was a price for wheat, we grew 135,000 acres. That is not so long ago, and the climate has not completely turned upside-down since, though the Dáil has changed a lot. Every year since then we find a reflex of the price in the amount of grain grown in the country. In the year 1922 there were 38,000 acres grown, and in 1931 it was down to 28,000, while the unfortunate farmers who occupy the land on which that wheat could and would be grown were compelled to pay rates on enormous valuations—valuations of their land as grain growing land. Let us study the returns. The last statement which Deputy Hogan made on this matter was just before he left office. He came along then and put a tariff on foreign oats—another death-bed repentance on the part of Deputy Hogan. Now we have fierce complaints because our present Minister for Agriculture is leading the farmers back to the only production by which the farmer can and will make a livelihood.

Comment on this

"Sez you."

Comment on this

At the taxpayers' expense.

Comment on this

"Sez you" and the A.C.A. When we come to consider what would be the position to-day as evidenced by the actions of Deputies opposite, of the Irish farmer, the grain growing farmer in a particular area, in fact of the farmers as a whole, under the Cumann na nGaedheal policy, under the compulsion of the last Executive Council, we wonder where the farmers would find themselves with the beef for which all this money was paid being sold in Birkenhead at 4½d. per lb., in "our only market," the "only market" we are losing, with the price of barley in England at 10/6 per barrel and the price of oats in England at 4/9 per cwt. or £4 15/-per ton. Compare these prices with the prices the farmers to-day are receiving for their grain and you see where the farmers here are undoubtedly benefiting. The farmers here to-day can get from 15/- to 16/-per barrel for barley.

Comment on this