Agricultural Produce (Cereals) Bill, 1932. - Second Stage.
Contributions 131–270 of 270. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
No. 27 of 1932 ›
Put down the money and I am prepared to bet with you. I am saying that the price offered for barley in East Cork to-day is 16/- a barrel.
Comment on this
Deputy Jordan will hold the coin. If you are prepared to take me up I am prepared to bet. There is no use in shouting "nonsense" here at all. "Nonsense" will not make a lie of anything. I am prepared to put down the money to prove my words, if you are prepared to take me up.
Comment on this
Oh, now we have another lawyer. Come on! Deputy Morrissey has recollections of the last bet.
Comment on this
Is Deputy Briscoe prompting you? It would be in keeping with Deputy Briscoe if he were. I am not surprised.
Comment on this
I am sorry, a Chinn Comhairle, that the members of the Dáil are getting a bit contrary and making so much noise, but if they keep quiet for a little bit I will be very much amused to hear them later on as regards these things. I am saying that the price of barley to-day is 16/-per barrel and the price of oats is £6 10s. 0d. That is 6/- per barrel or 5/6 per barrel increase on the price of barley in this country over the price across the water, and at least £2 a ton of a better price for oats than there is across the water.
Comment on this
The Deputy need not answer any question if he does not so desire. If the Deputy would deal with the Bill before the House there would be less acrimony.
Comment on this
Now, the kicking cow, keep quiet. I am comparing the price here with the price in England as a result of this policy, and I hold I am quite in order in that. Down in my constituency in 1926 there were 12,400 agricultural labourers employed on the land. Owing to the grass policy of the late Ministry that number was reduced to something over 5,000, the remaining 6,000 being set down on the fences to look at the bul-locks growing. This policy will bring those agricultural labourers back again on to the land and give them employment on the land. Deputy Roddy was amazed to think that we should pay a subsidy on wheat. Deputy Roddy seems to forget that during the last nine or ten years we have been paying a subsidy on beet——
Comment on this
——and that subsidy on beet has amounted to £2,060,000. The amount received by the growers of the beet in the same period was only £1,890,000. In this case the farmer is going to get the money, anyway.
Comment on this
It is not going to the Belgians. The subsidy on beet is 110 per cent. of what the growers receive.
Comment on this
The subsidy on the present price would be only 37 per cent. of the price, and if that 37 per cent. makes the people of this country practically independent of foreign countries for their daily bread, I hold it is 37 per cent. well spent.
Comment on this
The money is not going to leave the country anyway, and since Deputy O'Leary alluded to "who pays the bounty?" at any rate every ton of oats and every ton of barley that is used up in this country in this manner displaces a ton of foreign stuff coming in—displaces it and saves that much money for this country.
Comment on this
On a point of order. I maintain that this price is being paid by people who are not in a position to grow those crops themselves, and I consider that is very unjust.
Comment on this
Since Deputy O'Leary talks of justice, in that particular case I would like Deputy O'Leary to know that two-thirds of the rates in Cork County were paid by the grain growing farmers, and only one-fifth was spent on roads for these grain growing farmers. For ten years that particular portion of the constituency that Deputy O'Leary represents had the benefit——
Comment on this
I would not have alluded to them only for Deputy O'Leary complaining of the injustice of this Bill to a certain section of farmers.
Comment on this
We question the poverty of them. I have seen as good cows out in your country as anywhere.
Comment on this
I maintain, a Chinn Comhairle, that this Bill has come barely in time—that the present Government got into office barely in time to save a very large section of the agricultural community, and a section of the agricultural community that were tilling their land and giving employment to their people. I maintain that if the Deputies opposite looked at the question from a national point of view they would cease their opposition to this Bill at once. The ex-Minister for Agriculture says we could not grow wheat. It is a regular catch cry with him that we could not grow wheat. I remember some months ago the ex-Minister for Agriculture came down to Cork to see the grounds of the agricultural exhibition there, and when he was shown the grounds there on which the agriculturists of Cork County intended growing wheat, he said: "Nonsense, you can never grow it." Still that land yielded 26 cwts. of millable wheat to the statute acre.
Comment on this
Deputy Morrissey is surprised. Deputy Morrissey would be rather surprised if I told him that as regards the agricultural plots in Cork County the average return of wheat grown on those agricultural plots throughout the length and breadth of Cork County was 21 cwts. per acre, and that is going back over a number of years. I grew wheat and grew it successfully every year from 1918 to 1926 until the policy of "buy cheap stuff in the foreign markets" drove us out am talking about when I say we can grow wheat here and it will pay us. I found it the best paying crop I had for a considerable number of years.
Comment on this
Ah, get a subsidy on tin buckets! I do not wish to delay the Dáil further, but I do not think the Deputies opposite have put up any kind of a reasonable case whatever— at any rate, it was not a good case. They howl about injustice. There is no injustice anyway you view this matter. You are, in the first place, keeping money in the country. Every ton of wheat grown here displaces a ton of foreign wheat coming in, and every ton of barley grown here, and every ton of oats, displaces foreign produce coming into this country. If it were taken on these grounds alone, I hold that the Minister's Bill is absolutely justifiable. I wish to thank the Minister, on behalf of the people of East Cork, for introducing that Bill here. It was a Bill that was badly needed, and will prove a blessing, as it has already proved a blessing to the unfortunates of our constituencies.
Comment on this
I do not know whether I should sympathise with the House as a whole, or sympathise with the Minister for Agriculture on the speech to which we have just listened. I am sure that that speech has given more uneasiness to the Government, and in particular to the Minister for Agriculture than the speech of any other member of the House. Deputy Corry has made a number of extraordinary statements. Of course, those of us who have been members of this House since the Deputy came here are not surprised. I am not going to characterise any of the statements made by the Deputy as lying statements—I think the Deputy was drawing upon his imagination.
Comment on this
I am not surprised, sir. The Deputy is, in my opinion, as one who has had the good fortune, or, if you like to be absolutely truthful, the misfortune of listening to him for five years, one of the members in this House who never bothers very much as to facts. He is better able than any member in the House to paint what is white, black, and what is black, white, as it suits his case. I have heard the Deputy, while in Opposition, talk and thunder forth in this House, as he said to-night in his own speech "a tremendous amount of nonsense," and fill this Chamber with his contentions that wheat could not possibly be grown in this country at less than 30/-a barrel. Does the Deputy deny that?
Comment on this
I am not surprised the Deputy denies it. The Deputy, and not only the Deputy, but the present Minister for Agriculture, stated in this House that wheat could not be grown and sold by the farmers in this country at less than 30/- a barrel.
Comment on this
Am I misinterpreting the Minister when I take it from that, that that was the minimum price?
Comment on this
I am sorry the Minister misled the House. Of course he was not Minister then, and we must allow for the change over from one side of the House to the other.
Comment on this
The Deputy is still in the Labour Party—the Deputy is the Labour Party—the Deputy and his colleague here. I refrain from any retort. The Deputy tells us in his speech that climate has nothing whatever to do with the growing of wheat. The Deputy told us he grew wheat profitably, and that it was the most profitable crop he grew or possibly could grow on his farm from 1918 to 1926. Will the Deputy tell us what happened in 1926?
Comment on this
Would the Deputy tell us what happened in the last six years which caused the most profitable crop he could grow to be the least profitable, and why he ceased to grow it?
Comment on this
Will the Deputy allow me answer? The price of wheat fell from £11 per ton to £7 per ton and if you count that you will know the difference.
Comment on this
I am prepared to accept that. But I submit that the price of wheat last year is very much lower than it was in any year between 1926 and 1930. And I think the Minister will agree with me when I say this, that the price of wheat last year and this year is probably fifty per cent. or at least forty per cent, lower than it was in 1926. But the fact remains that Deputy Corry out of his own mouth told us, and I am not prepared to accept the statement he made, that the most profitable crop he could grow from 1918 to 1926 was wheat.
Comment on this
I think that is enough said for wheat at the moment. So far as I am personally concerned, and I think I have as much interest in this country as Deputy Corry has, or any other Deputy in this House, if wheat can be grown here I would like to see it grown here. I doubt if there is any member of this House elected by any section in the country who would not like to see any crop grown in this country or any article produced in this country which could be produced successfully and to the benefit of the country. Deputy Corry asked me what I knew about these things. I submit, and Deputy Corry in his own speech admitted it—if the farmers of this country who know their own business better than Deputy Corry and I can tell them, found that it is possible and profitable to grow wheat they would grow it without any Bill such as this. The Deputy himself admitted that a while ago. If the Deputy reads his own speech, when it is in print, he will see that he made the statement that there was no necessity to coerce the farmers into growing wheat. I agree. If the farmers, who know their own business better than Deputy Corry, or I, or than the ex-Minister for Agriculture, or the present Minister, think they can grow any agricultural produce, either wheat or barley, to their advantage they will grow it.
Comment on this
The Deputy wants to impart the information to every member of the House, and through the Press to the people of the country, that barley will now fetch 16/- per barrel.
Comment on this
In my county there is more barley grown not only than in the Deputy's constituency but in the whole of Cork. There is only one other county in which they grow more barley, and that is Wexford. And there was 6d. per barrel more got for barley this year than last year. I agree there is a further difference, there is a better class of barley this year and a better return than last year, but that is not due to the Deputy's exertions nor to those of President de Valera. It is due to the fact that we had a better year. The general price throughout the Free State for barley is not 16/- per barrel but 14/6 per barrel.
Comment on this
I said that I did not want to make any statement that would mislead anybody. I tell the Deputy I am prepared to produce orders and receipts for barley sold at 16/- per barrel.
Comment on this
I could produce documents from a single buyer for any number of barrels of barley at 16/- per barrel, but I am talking of the price ruling in the whole country. It does not matter whether one man sold ten or 500 barrels at 16/- a barrel. I say the average price for barley grown in the eight or nine counties that grow barley, whether for grinding or for malting purposes, is 14/6 per barrel. The Deputy has been offering to make bets to-night. I will guarantee that if the Deputy will enter into a contract with me I will supply him with anything from five to 50,000 barrels of barley at 14/6 per barrel.
Comment on this
That is a different point. It might improve the Flaherty whiskey. That sort of talk does not improve the position. We ought to face up to facts, and if Deputy Corry faces the facts, as a practical farmer, he knows as well as any man what are the practical difficulties before growing wheat. The Deputy knows well the talk there was about the gamble of growing beet.. Big and all as the subsidy was in that case, I question very much if the growing of wheat, and the subsidy, is not going to be a bigger gamble, and is not going to cost the country more.
Comment on this
The Deputy talked at length, and without, if I may say so, apparently having gone to the trouble to get some information from his colleague the Minister for Agriculture on the question of beet. He talked of what the beet subsidy cost the country. I am inclined to agree with the Deputy that the return the people of this country got from beet was not at all in keeping with what we had to pay in the way of subsidy. I suggest to the Deputy that he might use the eloquence and vehemence and enthusiasm at the next meeting of the Fianna Fáil Party that he used here to-night against any more beet factories——
Comment on this
If there are to be more beet factories in this country, if in face of the united opposition of the Government Party, when they were in opposition, to the subsidy for the present beet factory, they are going to create according to their publicity people two or three other factories, then surely I am personally entitled to look for one in my constituency. If we are to be taxed in Tipperary as well as in every other part of the Free State to put up additional beet factories, on the basis similar to the one in Carlow, I am entitled, if not in duty bound, if possible, to get one of these for my own constituency. If I may say so plainly and bluntly I am entitled to get a share of the spoils, although in that matter I suppose I would find myself between the devil and the deep sea, between the Cumann na nGaedheal Party and the Fianna Fáil Party. I suppose I would not get anything out of one or the other.
I was rather interested to hear from Deputy Corry that for eight years he grew wheat and grew it very profitably. I understand that Deputy Corry is a very extensive farmer and that he tills a fairly good acreage on his farm, and keeps dairy cows in a most up-to-date way. In other words he is a first-class farmer. I am satisfied of that. If from 1919 to 1926 he found wheat a most profitable and paying crop, and that he, also, grew other crops which must have been very profitable, and that his dairy cows were profitable, then I would suggest to the Minister for Finance, who is anxious to secure all arrears of income tax, that the Deputy on his net profits must now owe a very substantial sum to the Minister who is badly in want of all he can get.
Comment on this
This is a debate to which the country was looking forward with a considerable amount of interest and anxiety. The country expected to hear this afternoon from the Minister for Agriculture an outline, or indeed something more than an outline, of the agricultural policy of the Fianna Fáil administration. We were told last night that farming as it had been carried on in this country heretofore must cease; that the cattle industry was completely dead and buried, and there was no hope of its resurrection. We were expecting, therefore, to hear this afternoon from the Minister what was the alternative which he and his administration were going to put before the farmers. We have been told that what has taken place within the last few months was a blessing in disguise. This afternoon we expected that the disguise was going to be torn off, and that we would see the blessing clearly shining before us. We wanted to hear a statement of the full agricultural policy of the Party opposite, if they have got an agricultural policy.
Instead of that we had the statement which the Minister for Agriculture made in this debate. A farming economy which affected the whole of the country is to cease to be. There is to be an alternative economy we are told again and again. To-night we were to hear it. What is this? This is a Bill, the Minister tells us, giving the most sanguine expectation of the success of his measure which he could, which deals at the very outside with 45,000 acres of land. He expects that 45,000 acres, some of which was in tillage before, some of which may have been in grass before, will be affected by this tillage scheme. In other words, this is a scheme which, as far as the real agricultural problem in this country is concerned, is absolutely negligible and of no account. It is not affecting any area of this State that is of any importance. It is a Bill, on the statement of the Minister himself, which is of trifling dimensions, and which can have no beneficial effect upon Irish farming conditions as a whole.
This is the very best that Fianna Fáil can do. This is now Fianna Fáil's full agricultural policy which is to take the place of the rearing and sale of cattle and other livestock and of live-stock products. Our market for them has gone—according to the Minister for Industry and Commerce gone and lost forever. We are having as a substitute this measure which affects, not the whole country, but a tiny portion of the country at the very outside. The Minister is bankrupt in his views; the whole Executive Council are bankrupt in their policy. They have nothing to put before the country of any importance to the country. Let us take the time at which this measure is being introduced, because, small as this measure is, little effect as this measure can have, I do, in the first place, think that the effects of the measure will not be beneficial, and, in the second place, even if the effects of the measure can at any time turn out to be beneficial, this is the very worst time in which it could possibly be introduced. What is this measure? In the first place, we are told it is to have 45,000 acres of wheat in the country. We are told that a subsidy of £200,000 is to be given, if this scheme works out as the Minister expects it will work out.
He tells us that larger sums have already been given to subsidise a beet factory. I should like to point out to the Minister that there is an enormous amount of difference between the growing of beet and the growing of wheat. Of all crops grown, I do not think I am exaggerating when I say that the growing of beet root gives the largest amount of employment. I can say with absolute confidence that the growing of wheat gives the very minimum amount of employment. The growing of wheat for practical purposes, or the growing of any class of corn for practical purposes, gives no employment. Suppose the Bill were to be a success; suppose wheat were to be grown in this country on anything like a large scale; suppose there was to be mechanised farming in this State directed to the growing of wheat, what would be the employment given? It is calculated now in other countries that the employment given by the growing of wheat under modern conditions is at the rate of one man to every 200 acres of wheat. That is to say, if your wages bill was, let me say, at the rate of £1 per week per man, that for every 200 acres of wheat you grow your labour bill would be £52 under modern mechanised farming conditions. If you farm in the very oldest form of farming, as may be carried on in this State on small farms, the employment given by corn growing is negligible. What does it consist of? One man does the ploughing, one man does the harrowing, one man, if it is anything like a large farm, does the seeding and then the rolling and then he leaves it; work for a short period of time for one man and his pair of horses.
Comment on this
I am not talking of one man with 200 acres. When I spoke of one man to 200 acres, of course I was talking of modern mechanised farming with tractors and completely up-to-date machinery. I am talking, as I think I made clear, of what employment will be given under old-fashioned, out-of-date methods. Dealing with that old-fashioned, out-of-date method for wheat growing which may and which will, as a matter of fact, be resorted to in this State, I say that the amount of employment given by wheat growing will be negligible, because one man can do all the processes of growing wheat. The ploughing, the harrowing and the sowing—one man with a pair of horses can do that. Then he simply leaves the wheat there until the harvest time comes. At the harvest time, if there is a reaper and binder, one man can do all the reaping and binding. All that you want then is simply casual labour for the stooking and gathering up and bringing to the thresher of the wheat. In other words, wheat gives no permanent employment, cannot give permanent employment. Wheat gives a very small amount of employment to a very small number of persons for a very short period of the year. At the time at which there is any considerable number of people required per acreage of wheat, casual labour merely will be employed.
Wheat or corn-growing is not going to cut down unemployment in this country. If it has any effect at all upon the labour market, it will have the effect of increasing unemployment. Beet, of course, is absolutely different. Beet gives employment the whole time —the supply and setting up and keeping of it clean and the tilling of it— and it is the same with all green crops. They give regular employment, but the growing of grain crops gives, for practical purposes, no employment, and when the Minister talks about extra employment by the rotation which he seems to visualise—a rotation of wheat followed by oats, followed by wheat again, and that seemed to be what he visualised to-day when he talked about the area of oats not being cut down, it means that he simply will drive persons out of employment and will certainly not increase employment at all.
Comment on this
Let me take some other provisions of the Bill. There is a provision in it which has been dealt with—in my judgment, a very foolish provision, about the putting in of other grains with meal. That has been rather fully dealt with, but I would like to know what areas are there in which the farmers or the consumers of yellow meal want to buy other people's corn when they have corn of their own. What class of farmers are getting subsidised by the farming community? The farmers who live in the vicinity of working mills are to get a price for their grain, and they are to get that price at the expense of all the other farmers, and they are to get it at the expense of the small farmer. Take my own constituency where there are practically no working mills. You are going to bring rye to County Mayo and make the Mayo farmer pay for the barley or oats or anything else which may be grown somewhere near a port in any other place. That is not fair. Let me take a matter with which the Minister did not deal at all. I am going to leave out this idea of socialism, which is brought in in the last part of the Bill, by which the Minister for Industry and Commerce is to set up his mills and mill away. I would like to point out that there is a Bill here which is preventing the importation of feeding stuffs into this country, and preventing the importation of hay and straw, and I believe that if the Minister really regarded the situation in this country at the moment, instead of preventing the importation of hay, as he is preventing it, he would buy up all the hay he could buy, and expend his £200,000 very much more profitably by letting the hay be cheap on the market everywhere through Ireland than spending it in this fashion.
Comment on this
What is our position now? We have in this country at present, and I am talking especially of my own constituency and especially of the part of the country I know fairly well, a number of cattle which have not been sold up to this and which could not be sold. The people there got advice from responsible members of the Executive Council not to sell and they did not sell, even at the prices that were going, and now their markets are absolutely full of cattle and the cattle cannot get buyers at any price. If you have got a particularly nice-looking lot of cattle you may be able to sell, but if you have just ordinary animals they come home again and must be kept for the winter. What is the ordinary small farmer in Mayo going to keep these extra cattle on for the winter? He has got a certain amount of hay and a certain amount of grass left over for the winter, but he has calculated on that amount as the amount he requires for his cows, for his horse, and for whatever young calves he was going to keep on. He has not got the feeding stuffs. He cannot keep, it is impossible for him to keep, these extra three or four bullocks that he intended to sell and which, owing to the state of the market, he cannot sell, and what you will find, certainly in the part of the country I know best, and I believe it will be the same all over the State, is that there will be no fodder for the cattle this winter and no price for them at all, and the cattle will actually die of hunger in the fields.
That must come, and it seems to me that it is one of the things which anybody, looking at the situation now, can prophesy with absolute certainty, and this in consequence is a period of time in which the Minister should do every single thing that lies in his power to make feeding stuffs for stock cheap, but, if you please, this is the very period in which the Minister for Agriculture thinks it right to increase the market price of feeding stuffs for cattle. It is a misconception of the whole situation. I wish that this Executive Council, and, especially, the Minister for Agriculture and the Minister for Industry and Commerce, who are here in the House, would give up their theories and come down to facts, would recognise that they are living, not in an imaginary world of their own, but living in Ireland in the year 1932, and that their policy should not be a policy suited to some Utopia somewhere or other, but should be a policy suited to the needs of Ireland in the year 1932 and that they should get down to hard facts, and that they should formulate, if they are fit to formulate, a policy which would deal with and be suited for the needs of this particular State at this particular hour.
We get, however, absolutely nothing of the kind. We get as the very best help the farmers of this State can get from the Executive Council this Bill, a Bill which, granted even that it is a success in its operation, can affect only a very small percentage of farmers in this State and only affect that percentage of farmers in the most negligible way. And this is the best thing that can be turned out. This Bill demonstrates that, so far as a farming policy fit to meet the needs of the present situation, a farming policy that can be of any assistance to the Irish farmer at the present time, is concerned, the Executive Council have none. In spite of the challenges which have come from this side of the House, I have noticed that not one single member of the Fianna Fáil Party has got up to welcome this Bill or to say a single word in favour of it, because I do not consider the grotesque exhibition we had a few moments ago—I would not wrong Fianna Fáil even by thinking that that grotesque exhibition was the best that Fianna Fáil could do or by suggesting that it was typical of Fianna Fáil—but there is not a single representative of Fianna Fáil, who could be considered to have any weight or authority of any kind in the councils of that Party, who has got on his feet to speak a single word in favour of this measure. I think they were perfectly wise, because this measure, coming as it comes at this particular period of time, must fill not merely the followers of other Parties with despair, but must fill with still greater despair the followers of Fianna Fáil, who thought that they could build with safety on the promises made to them by that Party and who have now found how worthless those promises were.
Comment on this
I understand that in the third Schedule there are a number of items that are prohibited from being imported into this country. Am I correct in that? I would like to ask, with reference to "peas in grain (not fresh)," if New Zealand and Tasmanian maple peas, which are food for racing pigeons, are included in the prohibition? I am merely asking the question because it is of interest to all the pigeon fanciers who have to buy a special class of food for these racing pigeons. Those people do not see why a duty should be placed upon this special food that they have to get.
Comment on this
This Bill should more properly be called a Wheat Bill. It is the outcome of the preachings of the Fianna Fáil Party for several years. Members of that Party would seem to have a surfeit of wheat on the brain. This Bill is going to revolutionise the whole economic life of this country. Its object is to get the farming community to produce wheat, a commodity in which the world can beat us. Fianna Fáil have killed the market for the commodities in which we could beat the world—bacon, butter, beef, poultry, eggs. They have killed that market and they think this Bill will be the panacea of all our ills. All our sufferings apparently will disappear if we grow wheat.
The Minister for Agriculture said that 671,000 acres of wheat were grown in this country in 1847. Does he know under what conditions the wheat was then produced? Is he aware that wheat was then cultivated under slavish conditions? The small farmers had no machinery and no artificial manures. All the cultivation was done by spade work. They took the land and made what any Irish speaker is well aware of—"graf." They burned the land and as a result of the burning they had soil on which they were able to produce wheat. Notwithstanding all the labour they had to utilise in order to produce that quantity of wheat in 1847, they died by the thousand, unfortunately. For a long time after 1847 the great wheat-producing countries of the world were undeveloped. Transport was undeveloped. We in this island are on the extreme end of the wheat-producing belt of Western Europe. Northern Ireland cannot produce wheat. We are just on the verge, the borderline.
I have been a wheat grower all my life and I know that it is only once in five years or probably once in six years that we can produce what the Minister calls millable wheat. Then again, in this little State of ours, we have only small areas capable of producing wheat. Fortunately for me, I am living in one of these wheat-producing areas. I live within four miles of a mill which produces excellent flour. I have it on the authority of the miller that under present conditions a Canadian farmer could have his wheat brought thousands of miles to this particular mill at a cheaper rate than that at which I, who live only four miles away, could bring my wheat. I am not looking at this matter from a parochial point of view as others have done; I am regarding it from the view-point of the State.
We have heard a lot about a bounty and a subsidy, but we should remember that all those come out of the producer's pocket. We have numbers of people in this State who cannot grow wheat, they have not the land to grow wheat, and you are asking those people to give a bounty and a subsidy to men who are much better off, and who are living in the wheat-growing districts. I think that is most unfair. If I were to speak for my own parish I would say this was a great thing, and I would welcome the subsidy, but viewing it from the wider angle I look upon it as a national disgrace to make poor people foot the bill. We talk a lot here about the Gaeltacht and the development of industries there, but you are putting another nail in their coffin when you ask the people there to subsidise the wheat-growing farmer.
Our agricultural system is not one of to-day or to-morrow. Our fathers, grandfathers and great-grandfathers were shrewd men. They developed a system of agriculture which they found suited their particular districts. I have travelled this country from Malin Head to Mizen Head, and I have seen different systems of farming practised. I believe that the farmer who breaks away from the established system of any district will go wallop. That is not quite a Parliamentary word, but it is nevertheless expressive. Our agricultural system is the result of the experience of generations, and wherever you find that system do not try to change it.
I would like to deal with the proposed admixture of grain. That is going to add to the already heavy costs the farmer has to bear. The Minister for Agriculture has admitted that it will cost the farmer at least 10/- a ton. I have it on reliable authority that it will cost him probably 15/- a ton. When that extra cost is added to the already heavy costs the farmer has to bear, the difficulty of his position will be more generally recognised. The farmers are now in the position that they can get no price for their pigs, beef, mutton, turkeys or chickens and still they have to pay 15/- a ton for this admixture. The Department of Agriculture set out to advise the farmers to mix their own feeding stuffs. They told the farmers not to buy mixed manures, but to buy the various articles and mix them themselves. The ordinary farmer is much better able to mix his own stuff than any miller, yet under this Bill the miller is going to do the mixing and the farmer will have to pay.
I thought we were going to have compulsory tillage but instead of that we have compulsory millage. The miller will be compelled to do it, thanks be to God. The Minister for Agriculture must be aware of the real conditions that exist in the country; if he is not, he must be blind. I say that if this Bill is passed in its present form it is going to put a further nail in the coffin of the small farmer; it will particularly hit the poor farmer and some day it will react on the Party that sponsors it.
Comment on this
I have listened with interest to the last two speeches. Deputy Fitzgerald-Kenney told us that his opposition to the Bill was based on the fact that the growing of wheat would not give employment; in fact that a number of people would be thrown out of employment if this measure was put into operation. He pictured for us the case of some superman who could plough, harrow, seed and roll 200 acres of land. It may be that there is such a man; certainly I have not met him. I think the Deputy should be well aware of the fact that wheat is grown on small farms of five, ten or fifteen acres, and that one man could not plough, harrow, seed and roll 200 acres of land for wheat. The Deputy looked at this Bill from one angle only. He looked at it, possibly, from the point of view that the economy which Cumann na nGaedheal practised during their term of office was going to be changed. He did not take into consideration all the harm that that economy had on the lives of the people, as far as the growing or non-growing of wheat is concerned. He did not consider the effect that the chemicals used in flour for the purpose of bleaching had upon our people. It is a well-known fact that these chemicals have a very injurious effect upon the health of young people. The Minister's policy for the growing of wheat is welcomed by the majority of the people in agricultural districts in the Twenty-Six Counties. This Bill will put into operation a policy whereby our people will be supplied with home grown wheat which will be milled into flour that will not get any of the chemical treatment that the imported flour gets. Home-produced flour need not be treated with chemicals that are injurious to health. This home-milled flour will be converted into bread which will be wholesome.
Deputy O'Donovan stated that the world can beat us in the production of wheat. The world can beat us in the production of other things. I think the House will agree that the world has beaten us in the production of beef. It has been demonstrated for some time past that the price of beef in the markets across the Channel is not an economic price; is not one that gives the farmer here an economic price, even if we never had tariffs. Are we to look upon this question merely in the light of seeing whether the world is able to beat us in the production of beef or not? Should we not look to the interests of our own people? Should we not consider the fact that we have a legacy of 80,000 unemployed that Cumann na nGaedheal left after them last February? Should we not consider that these people need employment, and remember that Canada, the Argentine and Russia can supply wheat at the ports here cheaper than our wheat? Is not that a reason why we should welcome the wheat growing policy put forward by the Minister? Can we not protect our wheat against foreign competition? Because Cumann na nGaedheal viewed the position in a wrong light they are in opposition now. Their policy has been turned down. We preached a tillage policy——
Comment on this
——and we are going to put our policy into operation. Deputy O'Donovan thought fit to mention that wheat was produced very extensively in this country in 1847. Yet we had a famine, and unfortunately numbers of our people died by the roadside from starvation. We grew wheat then. Our people died because of the same old economy, and because England took our wheat and oats away to feed her own people, while ours were left to starve. That is the reason our people died. I think no person can conscientiously say that the growing of wheat was responsible for the death of one person in this country. As to the production of a millable sample of wheat, I would like to mention that in the county I represent, the agricultural instructor has certain tests made each year. I remember reading where he stated, in a report two years ago, that some of the samples of wheat grown by him were equal, from the milling point of view, to the very best samples from Manitoba. These were practical tests by an expert, and I have no reason to suspect that, when proper facilities are placed at the disposal of farmers, they will not be able to produce wheat equal to the very best that we now import. If one believed all that the Opposition said about this Bill one would imagine that it was the last thing in the policy of the Government. They will tell you about depression and all that sort of thing. They have no intention of placing their confidence in the Government even for a short time. Let them give the Government a trial.
Comment on this
You have given us a trial but when we got into office we could not sow wheat. We were too late. The last Government left us a legacy of grass land. In the county I come from I know what grass land has done for the people. I know that it has left many an unfortunate man on the road, with no means of providing for his family. Those people who have been looking at the grass land for years welcome this Bill. I suppose it would be too much to expect that the Opposition would welcome the Bill because they know that this changed economy will eventually bring prosperity to the countryside. They know that, but they dare not say so. They are afraid that the results of this policy will be unfavourable from their point of view, because it will be successful. I think you should understand that this is merely the first instalment of a progressive tillage scheme on the part of the Government. Other portions of that scheme will follow. I think you should know by now that it is the intention of the Government to grow all the wheat, oats and barley that will be needed in this country, so that we will not be placed in the humiliating position of importing all our foodstuffs and paying the foreigner to grow those commodities which we should have our own people employed in producing at home.
Comment on this
The last Deputy did not tell us whether he had any experience of the growing of wheat or not. Perhaps he would tell me now whether he has had any experience of wheat growing.
Comment on this
I have had no experience of wheat growing but I have had experience of growing oats. I am prepared to make the Deputy an offer. I shall give him fifteen acres of tillage land within fifteen miles of Dublin free, gratis and for nothing for the coming year and let him experiment in wheat growing.
Comment on this
I have not had much experience of wheat growing, because it is not grown very much in my constituency. One man who tried it in my own parish had to give it up because it was a complete failure. I want to offer strong opposition to the proposal of the Minister as regards the admixture of maize and feeding stuffs. I come from a constituency where thousands of tons of feeding stuffs are consumed. Anything that would increase the cost of those feeding stuffs to the poor people who use them would, in my opinion, be a crime. We are told that the people are very much in favour of this scheme. If that is so, how is it that the Government supporters in my constituency rushed all the Indian meal they could into their stores before this regulation came into force? If the Minister wants evidence of that, I am in a position to give it to him. The unfortunate feature of this proposal is that the increased price, which it is claimed will be 10/-, is only one means by which the small farmer will be hit. He will also have to pay portion of the subsidy. I know small farmers in my own constituency who have valuations of less than £10, and they would use, on an average, 20 tons of feeding stuffs each year when things were in full swing. Taking the increase at 10/-, that would mean that an additional charge of £10 per year would be imposed upon them. If, as has been stated here, the increase were to be £1, that would mean an additional charge to them of £20 per year. I have been told of one farmer —not a very big farmer—who was accustomed to use 120 tons of feeding stuffs. It is easy to estimate what the additional cost to that man will be.
We have been told that we, on these benches, were opposed to tillage. The ex-Minister for Agriculture was never opposed to tillage. He said that he was always in favour of mixed farming —that the farmer should till as much as he could consume, but that he would not advise him to go in for tillage for cash-crop purposes. I have some experience of tillage myself and my experience is that tillage gives very little employment if the grain stands up. If the grain does not stand up, as has been my experience on a number of occasions, there is a lot of employment given. I had 33 acres of grain the year before last and it was flattened out the same as if it had been rolled. I had 16 acres of oats next year and I had to cut it with a scythe. Do the Deputies on the Government Benches think that that is a paying proposition? The climate is against us. I am as patriotic and as much inclined to till as any other farmer, but I have, unfortunately, to admit that the climate is dead against us.
Comment on this
The speeches so far from the Government Benches on this important subject have been more comical than anything else. I suppose the only way to treat this wheat proposal is to work it out and see what is the result. No arguments that we could put forward would have any weight with the occupants of the Government Benches. They have a majority and they are going on with this proposal. They are aware of our view-point. We have been told that we have wheat equal to the best Manitoba. There is no wheat in the country equal to the best Manitoba. We have been told about the effect upon public health. If there is any effect on public health, why let in flour at all? Get in wheat and grind it and you will have no bleaching. That is a simple process. What have all these doctors on the Fianna Fáil Benches to say on this matter? There are a lot of doctors on those benches. Why do they not stand up and make the statements which are being made by less responsible Deputies who know nothing about the subject?
Comment on this
The doctors would not make statements that other Deputies, owing to their want of knowledge, are making.
Comment on this
It would be no harm if some of your people died. The Minister talks about the price he is going to give for wheat. He is to give 24/- a barrel, and 25/- in some cases—roughly about 10/- per cwt. Ten shillings per cwt. for wheat and about 15/- per cwt. for beef in today's market—due to the good offices of Fianna Fáil and their President.
The President started out in April to antagonise every consumer that was consuming our produce. He lost all the goodwill we had in the English market. He brought it to the point which has been stressed by several speakers that Canterbury lamb was selling in London at 2d. per lb. more than the price of our lamb; to the point where Argentine beef was selling at a price higher than ours and then the culminating bombshell came in July when we had given over the market altogether. And when we started to get back in defiance of the President's statement, and in defiance of the VicePresident's encouragements in his message from Ottawa, the only way we could get back was by underselling the people already in possession. And we started underselling them. When we started to undersell them they had to follow, but we led them in the race of underselling. Instead of leading them in the race uphill we led them in the race down.
The Minister for Agriculture goes down to Wexford and tells the people there that the English people were not able to buy our beef and that that was the reason our beef was so cheap. The real reason why our beef was so cheap was because the Fianna Fáil Party deliberately set out on this race down-hill and they went ahead and led in every race supplying England with stuff and they are still leading them in the underselling. The Minister for Agriculture must know—there is no better informed Department with regard to agricultural statistics than the Department of Agriculture—that there are more foodstuffs, more beef, mutton, bacon, lamb and other foodstuffs going into England to-day than ever before. The Minister says that the people of England are not able to buy. The fact is that we set out to give them these products cheaper. The Minister has the statistics there and I challenge him to deny that more cwts. of foodstuffs have gone into England and have been consumed there in the last six months than ever before in a similar period. They have been sold there at a price. The fact is they are consumed.
As to this matter of the wheat guarantee, I would say now the only thing is to let it be tested out. Everybody in this country knows that taking an average—not an exceptional year— there is more bran, weight for weight, in the wheat grown in this country than flour. The Minister talks about the returns he is going to get in wheat per acre. I tell him that half of that wheat is to be bran and the people are to feed that bran to live-stock which they would be selling at 18/- per cwt.; they are going to feed it to their stock which they will have to sell at a price to compete with the old horses that are being sent on to Belgium— against the old horses that are being shipped by Mosey Lee and Johnny Lord.
Comment on this
I wonder how the people of this country allow you to sit there on the Government Benches. I wonder why they do not tear you limb from limb in the halls of this House and I hope to God they will. I would be the first myself to lead them. I hope the people of this country will waken up to-morrow, and to-morrow is time enough for me.
Then we have this mixture proposal. The people of East Cork are to be subsidised at the expense of the people of West Cork. The people of South Kilkenny are going to subsidise the people of Leix and Kildare who will not work, people whose work consists of a couple of days' seeding the field of barley and then shutting the gate, and whose only concern for the following six months is to see that the fences are good. These people are to be subsidised at the expense of the people who work the 365 days of the year, at the expense of the people who have to feed and milk their cows all the year round; the people who have to feed their pigs and their calves all the year round.
It is the people who soil their hands and who are not afraid to have their hands dirty who are to subsidise the people of Kildare and Laoighis. After all the work that these people have to do for the 365 days of the year they only get a bare subsistence out of it. Still they are asked to subsidise the people who work one week in the year, people who never feed cattle or pigs. Then these people who do not want to work come to the Minister for Industry and Commerce, led by Mr. Bergin, of Athy. They come to the Minister for Agriculture. Did the Minister ever insist that these people who preach the value of their foodstuffs should practise that on themselves? How much of their foodstuffs do they feed to their cattle or to their pigs? Come down to statistics, and let the Minister see what the bacon and cattle production is in Kildare and Laoighis. I take off my hat to Wexford. They feed their own foodstuffs to their cattle and pigs, and I take off my hat to them. The people there are not afraid to work. If they grow plenty of corn they use plenty of this corn themselves. Wexford is perhaps one of the poorest counties in Ireland. I mean that the land in Wexford is poor land. The proposition that the Government are coolly putting up to the people of South Kilkenny, Wexford and the other counties where the people work is that they are to put their hands down in their pockets and subsidise lousers who work only one or two weeks in the year——
Comment on this
I cannot allow the Deputy to use that word with reference to anybody in this country. It must be withdrawn.
Comment on this
I do not mean the people who do not wash their faces. I mean the people who will not work.
Comment on this
Then I absolutely withdraw. What is the position in regard to the land of Ireland that is unable to grow corn? Everybody knows that the best land for general purposes is the land that is able to grow corn. The land that is able to grow corn is the best land for growing anything. It is so in Kildare, Meath and Westmeath. But what about the people who are unable to grow their own corn? What about the people in Leitrim who have to subsidise the people in the best land in Ireland to make them grow corn? What about the people in every part of the County Kerry except perhaps Ballymacelligot and Ardfert? I do not think there is any other part of Kerry suitable for tillage. What is to be the position in this huge county of Kerry with its large population? What about the people in Waterford and several other counties in Ireland? These people are in a worse position than the people who want to get subsidies for growing corn—the people who will not work, I will not use an opprobrious term again; the people who will not feed the produce that they grow to their live-stock? If there is any good in that system one would think that the first people to demonstrate its excellence should be the people who are looking for these subsidies. The real facts are that these people who are looking for this subsidy feed less of what they grow than any other people in the country. These people will not work. They snapped their fingers at us down in Kildare at the election two years ago. Most of them were wearing kid gloves and they had lovely white hands—even the young men.
Comment on this
These should be the first people to demonstrate the value of corn growing. We are told this is to raise the price by 10/- a ton in the area where it is grown. How much is the price going to be raised in Donegal? I am told that with the cost of transport and so on it will make the corn 20/- to 22/6 a ton dearer in Donegal and Leitrim. The people of these counties find it difficult enough to get on as it is under present conditions. How are they going to feed this corn to their livestock when they will have to sell their stock at a price which has been driven down to 18/- a cwt? I say that instead of helping the agricultural industry the House is going a long way by this Bill to crush out whatever enterprise and industry is left in the country. I warn the Minister that where there are ten pigs being fed to-day under present conditions not as much as one pig will be fed when this Bill is in operation. Then Deputies will see the value of the proposition. I say this Bill will put people out of pig production; it will put people out of egg and butter production and it will put people out of beef production. There is one thing right about your beef proposition and that is the whole of the State is paying the subsidy, but because it is doing that the subsidy has one virtue, but the other proposition has no virtue.
I would not object if the Government subsidised the barley grower and perhaps the oat grower in the same way as they are subsidising the wheat grower. What I decidedly object to is the Government's action in penalising one section of the community who are really in worse circumstances than the other: subsidising people who will not work themselves. I say it is criminal for the Government and for the Party behind them to support what is contained in this mixture proposition. From the point of view of the State, I have no objection to the Government standing in and paying a subsidy in regard to wheat, but what I bitterly object to is a subsidy to be taken out of the pockets of one section of the community and paid to another section. If you subsidise the grower of barley, he will have to take his share in subsidising the wheat grower as a member of the community. That is understandable and probably could be argued. Take the case of men who feed 200 and 300 pigs, and there are such men in this country. I venture to say that there are more pigs reared in three parishes in South Kilkenny than in all Kildare and Leix put together. The same is true of the Enniscorthy district in North Wexford. The people who farm on those lines are content with a mere existence. They are not making money. They have to work 365 days in the year, Sundays as well as Mondays. I say it is a shame, it is criminal that these people who are only just existing should be taxed to subsidise people in South Kildare and Leix and elsewhere who only work a few days and are gentlemen all the rest of the year—people who will not work themselves. I do not care whom that pleases or displeases.
Feeding-stuff, if it has any value at all, has most value on the spot. If the farmers who grow barley believe in its value they can spare themselves the cost of freightage from their barns and feed it themselves. If it is of value, why do not these people feed it themselves? Why are they not their own best customers? Has the Minister or his Government made any effort to make these people carry their weight? Instead of that he puts them up on a pedestal and calls on the rest of the people to subsidise them. That is the position and neither the Minister nor his Government can deny it. If feeding stuff has any value, then it surely has most value for those who have either their own mills or their local mills. What is the idea of making people in Donegal buy from around Athy if it has equal value in Athy as it has? I am the last to deny that barley is of value, but when it raises the bill of the feeder to a point where its use becomes uneconomic for him then I say it is an injustice for the Government to put on the individual what the State should bear, if the State think it is good policy.
As long as I have been in politics we have had the same cry from these same people. When I was in the Farmers' Party we had the same people waiting on us to try and get somebody to give them a subsidy. They waited on the last Government to try to get somebody to subsidise them. They have waited on this Government and evidently they have got a response. I say it is not to the Gov- ernment's credit that they have taken this step. Although the Government may get some votes here and there as a result of their subsidy policy, and may try to buy other people with something else, they cannot at all events fool all the people all the time. I take far more exception to this part of their programme than I do to their wheat proposition. Those who have been farming for the last twenty or twenty-five years and who have eyes in their heads to observe the results know what happens in an average year in the case of wheat and other corn crops. The first thing you have to do with wheat after you cut it is either to cap the stooks or to make hand-stacks of it. Any farmer who neglected doing that during the last fifteen or twenty years was simply left with a butt of corn that was not worth twopence, it was of no value except to feed to fowl. People growing oats and barley suffered in the same way.
The Minister, before starting with this wheat policy, should have acted on the suggestion I often made here: that is, to start glass factories in this country so that a roof could be put over the parts of the country where he wanted his tillage policy to operate. I made that suggestion seriously a few years ago and I make it again now. There is a great lack of employment in the country. That is one way in which the Government could help to relieve it, to start glass factories so that we could cover that part of the country in which the Government want to carry out their tillage scheme. I submit that my proposition is no more ridiculous than the Government's. In fact the weight of commonsense is on the side of starting the glass factories so that this scheme could be carried out in glass houses all over the country. I am afraid that the Government's wheat scheme will never be a success until they act on my suggestion. At any rate. I repeat that my proposition is no more ridiculous than the one the Government is here putting forward.
Comment on this
In view of Deputy Gorey's speech I suppose it is up to me to say something. The farmers in Kildare with the white hands and the kid gloves are not the farmers who voted and worked for Fianna Fáil. The farmers who supported our Party were the working and tillage farmers of the county. I saw Deputy Gorey in Kildare during the time of the by-election. He was then associating with the farmers with the white hands and the kid gloves who according to him do not work at all. These are the people who supported him. Fortunately, the working farmers in Kildare are more numerous than the gentleman type that the Deputy talked of. A Deputy who spoke earlier referred to the fact that each county develops its own system of agriculture. He said that the farmers in each county knew best what suited them and adopted the system that suited them. If South Kildare is a tillage area and is devoted largely to the growing of barley and of grain, I know the reason for that. The land suited barley, and farmers of that district followed up the pursuit of growing barley for brewing and distilling and did not ask for anything from any Government or from anybody while the brewing and distilling industries were prosperous in the country. Personally, I never agreed with the system of devoting our land altogether to corn growing as the best system of farming, and the farmer himself did not follow that system. I myself, and a great number of the farmers in Kildare, grow our own corn and feed it to our cattle, and while I know that the mixed system is the best system, I also know the plight in which they found themselves when the brewing and distilling industries failed. We know how difficult it is to change over to that mixed system. The farmers did not have sufficient capital. A few years ago they were recommended by Deputy Hogan, when he was Minister for Agriculture, to keep one more sow and one more cow and till another acre of land. Anyone with experience knows that the change from growing crops for sale to the other system is difficult without capital, and if the farmers of Kildare did not become the industrious people that they should have become, according to Deputy Gorey, it is due entirely to lack of capital. There was no encouragement, nor any prospect held out, for them to change over. The Government are doing a wise thing and a good thing for the country in trying to save that type of farmer in the country and there are more counties in the Twenty-Six Counties than Kildare. Many of the grain-growing counties were counties where the people largely depended on growing grain for sale.
Deputy Gorey and some of the other Deputies talked about the difficulty of growing wheat and said that you cannot grow wheat. Deputy Gorey said that you would want a glass house to save it. To listen to all those arguments against the growing of wheat one would think it was impossible. Why not put up as many arguments against the keeping and rearing of livestock as the Deputy puts up against the growing of wheat? A few years ago, when the fluke epidemic in the country swept away all the sheep all over the grazing parts of the country and put many of the farmers into bank-ruptcy, the Government at that time did not shout "Give up keeping sheep." They tried to find remedies for the fluke and the Department of Agriculture was instructed to find remedies. We could as easily have said then "Get out of sheep rearing." The same applies with abortion in cows.
Comment on this
The Deputy sneers at wheat-growing, just as he sneers at everything the Government attempt. It is not honest of him. He knows very well that wheat can be grown. As I was saying, the same thing applies to abortion in cattle. When cows suffer from abortion, we do not advocate that we should get out of the keeping and breeding of cows. I know that agriculture is difficult and that a man engaging in it must mind his business and know all about it if he is to succeed at it. There are difficulties of course, but we have got to get over them. This may not be the most successful year for wheat because it is new to many of the farmers and I do not know if sufficient attention has been given to see that the best varieties of seed are to be sown. Nevertheless, I believe that we have got to get on to wheat growing. The cause of the failure of wheat growing in the past was not because of the change of climate but because English policy made cattle rearing a better paying proposition. Wheat was grown successfully, but to suit herself the British Government repealed the Corn Laws and made this country, and even England herself, a cattle country. I notice that England is sorry now for her neglect of agriculture in the past and they are trying to get their own people back on the land and to develop agriculture just as we are trying to do. They are giving subsidies and protection for their own agriculturists, and we must do the same here. Deputy Roddy, I think—and he should know better— said that in the famine time the people died here of hunger, even though there was plenty of wheat. If they had not had to send their wheat to England, they would not have died, and they would have kept their wheat if they could afford to keep it.
Comment on this
They had to give their wheat to the absentee landlords. If it was kept at home the people would not have died of hunger. The reason they did not grow wheat here in the past was that it was made more profitable for them to keep cattle. Now it is no longer profitable to keep cattle and the English themselves are getting on to the wheat. They cannot keep their agricultural economy in England and they have to get back to wheat growing. That is the policy of the Minister for Agriculture and it is the policy the people want.
Comment on this
People are asking why President de Valera does not settle this dispute with England. If they want an answer to that, all they have to do is to come here to the Dáil and listen to this debate. This is a major item of the Fianna Fáil agricultural policy. I know that Fianna Fáil and the present Government Party say that industry—that is, non-agricultural industry—is very important, but they agree that agricultural industry itself is very important and this is their major item. Yet it is clear to me that they do not agree with this item of policy. I will leave out the Minister—he is naive in these matters. It is plain to me that even Deputy Corry, who showed no enthusiasm, and Deputy Kelly from Meath and the Deputy who has just spoken know that this policy is going to fail. They know it perfectly well.
Comment on this
This whole debate on the major item of the agricultural policy of the present Government is an example of where that Party would be if they had not this quarrel with England. We would not have debate after debate of this sort, with a dispirited Party in the benches opposite, everyone knowing that their policy is unsound, that it would not last and that they would be found out in a very short time if they had to be judged by the merits of this policy. If there is any one in the country who has any doubts as to the quarrel, they ought to be brought to the galleries of this House to-night. By the way, there are no cheers from the gallery to-night. There is no enthusiasm there. There is no enthusiasm anywhere.
Get this. If we were in normal times, that this were a normal country, that the Dáil were seriously concerned with the real problems of life—poverty, unemployment, agricultural prices—all these problems which are real problems—this would have been the most important debate we had in the Dáil since the Dáil was elected. There is no enthusiasm, however, there are no cheers, no heroics, "no nothing," as some Deputy on my left says. Why? Because the war with England is not in it. A few Deputies, my friend, Deputy Jordan, who comes from the same county as I do, and Deputy Harris, tried to bring the unfortunate British into it.
Comment on this
By interruption. That is the only time you find any life in the debate. This is the Fianna Fáil agricultural policy, and Deputy Corry is put up to defend it. I do not know whether he is a good farmer or not. I will say that he knows a certain amount about farming, but he was the man chosen to defend this policy. There are a few farmers on the Government Benches, but very few tillage farmers as compared with the farmers sitting behind me here, farmers like Deputy O'Leary and other Deputies whom I could mention, who till big areas of land. There are a few farmers, I take it, on the Government Benches who know a little about tillage, but on this question, one of the most important questions from the Government point of view that could be put before the House, who was put up to defend the Government's policy? Deputy Corry—I will not say the clown of the Party, but Deputy Corry above all people in the world and Deputy Kelly, from Meath, who did grow wheat. He said he grew wheat. These are the men put up to defend it.
There is not a man of the bunch who does not know it is all eye-wash. I shall go as far as to say that the Minister himself knows it is all eye-wash, and I can tell you why. He is asking the country to grow 66,000 acres of wheat, that is 44,000 more than are at present cultivated, but that 44,000 acres will be substituted for some other crop. If he wanted to go in for wheat growing in a really sincere way, he would not start with a subsidy of 24/-, because if he knows anything at all about tillage, he knows that bad and all as cattle are at £1 per cwt., wheat at 24/- per barrel is worse. Yet in order to grow wheat at 24/- per barrel, we shall have to pay 9/- per barrel subsidy. That is assuming that the world price of wheat next year will be 15/- per barrel, and it is likely to be much less. If the Minister is serious, even if he wants any big area of substituted wheat, that is to say, wheat substituted for another crop, I will give him a tip. Even at the present price of wheat he should start at 30/- per barrel.
Three years ago the world price of wheat was 31/- and it was far higher the previous year. Yet in these two years the area of wheat grown fell. The Minister might answer that at that time the price of live-stock was at a higher level than now. That would be quite true but I can tell him that if he wants any area of substituted wheat, wheat substituted for another crop, any increase in area, or if he wants to prevent any decrease, he will have to give about 30/- per barrel for wheat. The fact that he started here with a price of 24/- per barrel when every farmer—and I am one; I till a lot of land—knows that 24/- per barrel is no better than £1 per cwt. for pigs or cattle, the mere fact that he starts with a guaranteed price of 24/- per barrel for wheat makes it perfectly clear that this policy as conceived by the Front Bench is not seriously meant. Anyway we can test it out now. We are getting this chance of testing it out. Remember it is not going to cost much. I used to be asked when I was Minister why I did not subsidise a small area. My answer was that I did not believe in it and that I would let somebody who did subsidise it. I believed that the policy was entirely unsound and hence I did not do it. The present Minister believes in that policy and he is entitled to subsidise it.
One satisfaction that the Minister for Finance and the taxpayers of the country have is that this policy is bound to fail. Remember I am not talking in the air. This Dáil will be in existence in a year or two years' time and we can test it out. The Minister for Finance need not be afraid. It will not cost in my opinion £40,000 to pay the subsidy. Perhaps I may be wrong in that because not only the new areas of wheat will be subsidised but the 22,000 acres grown already. This experiment, however, will not cost £100,000 at most and when I think of all the waste of money that has taken place for the last six months, I think that £100,000 spent in the education of politicians who believe in wheat growing will be money well spent. I do hope that this experiment will be carried to its logical conclusion. We will see in a year when this policy has got a chance, the increased tillage that this policy of subsidising wheat, of all crops, is going to bring about.
A Deputy told us that this subsidy will be much less expensive than the subsidy on beet. I agree. He also told us that for the subsidy on one acre of beet you can grow eight acres of wheat. In that he is wrong. It may be that at the rate of £3 per acre for wheat that is what it would come to. It may be that you can subsidise one acre of wheat at a rate of £3 whereas it would take £24 to subsidise one acre of beet, but what actually is happening is that in neither case are you getting any increased tillage. In both cases you will just get the one acreage substituted for the other. That is practically what happened entirely in regard to beet. I might be asked why then did we give a subsidy for beet? The answer is quite simple. Wheat is a crop about which every intelligent farmer, every tillage farmer, knows a considerable amount. The Department of Agriculture knows all that has got to be known about wheat growing. On the other hand beet was an entirely new crop in the country and there was some justification for subsidising a beet-growing experiment in order to see what were the possibilities on a commercial scale of beet-growing. It was quite legitimate to subsidise beet.
Here we are now, when everybody knows the conditions under which wheat may be grown, when every intelligent farmer is a fair judge of the costings, when generally the conditions, the possibilities, the potentialities of the crop are well known, asked to subsidise wheat growing. There is a big difference between subsidising the growing of wheat and the growing of beet, but there will be one thing in common whatever the subsidy in either case is. You can take it that the very same thing will happen in regard to wheat as happened in regard to beet. The subsidy will not encourage increased production. It will simply encourage substitution of one crop for another, and even that substitution will stop the very moment the subsidy stops. I am not going to waste the time of the House. I have done it too often——
Comment on this
I admit that I have done it too often, talking about the effects of wheat growing on land. At this hour of the day Deputies, at least farming Deputies, ought to know something about the subject. It really pains me to hear the Minister for Agriculture talking rubbish on questions such as whether wheat is hard on land, whether it encourages weeds, scutch grass, and so on. There are I hope a few farmers on the Fianna Fáil Benches, some on the middle benches, and many on our benches, who know all about that, and I am not going to take up the time of the House at this hour of the day telling them about it. But there is one point I want to make, and that is Deputy Gorey's point. This subsidy, so far as it is paid to the growers, will go to the farmers on the best land—will go in the main to the beet farmers, and in the main will be paid by the small farmers and the farmers on the poor land.
Now with regard to this mixture, there is one point I would like to refer to because the Minister took up a certain amount of time in discussing it. He told us that barley is almost as good feeding stuff as Indian meal. We all know that. He asked us why it was we should not use barley instead of Indian meal, and he went to great trouble to prove that a farmer could grow the equivalent of Indian meal if he tilled his land and grew barley or grew oats. Would the Minister get this into his head, that all that sort of pleading is completely beside the point? What does he mean? What is he trying to convey to the Dáil? That if the average farmer tilled enough he would have all the meals that he requires in the way of oats and barley? If he does not mean that I do not know what he means. That is what he is trying to convey, that there is nothing to prevent us, if we till sufficient land, from having all the oats and barley we require to take the place of Indian meal. That is, I take it, what the Minister is after. Every acre of land in Denmark is under tillage—either tillage of first or second growth. Practically every acre in France, leaving out forestry, is under tillage, and the same applies in a lot of the Continental countries. And how is it that Denmark imports three or four times as much feeding stuffs as we do? Would the Deputies who are wasting their time telling us that barley is a substitute for Indian meal consider that fact for one moment? Would the Deputies who are wasting their time advising farmers to till more and that they will not require Indian meal get this well into their heads, that in a country like Denmark, where mixed farming is done well, and where every acre of land is tilled, the farmer imports at least twice as much feeding stuffs as he grows. What is the reason for that— because that goes to the root of the whole situation?
Has the Minister for Agriculture yet realised that you must have a certain rotation, and that one year with another you cannot grow much more than twice as much grain as roots? Does he realise that if you grow an acre of roots and an acre of grain you have at least four times as many rations in the roots as you have in the grain? I put it to him in figures. It is extraordinary to be wasting time over this but it does not appear to have penetrated to the minds of farmers on the Fianna Fáil side. Take a statute acre of mangolds. You have 40 tons of mangolds—6,400 stones, that is, 1,600 rations, allowing four stones to a ration. How many meals will you have to feed with that if you want to feed them economically? Every one knows on the average about 7 lbs. would be fair, that is only 320 rations, so that for your two acres of corn you will have only about 600 to 700 rations, whereas from an acre of roots you would have about 1,600 rations. If Deputies would only think of that they would see the reason why you cannot grow all the meals you require. They would see that even if every perch of land in this country were tilled it would be impossible to grow all the meals you require. The ideal thought in this country seems to be that we must either grow all the meal we require ourselves or we must buy it from our neighbouring farmers. Whom are we to buy it from? Where are the farmers from Galway or Mayo or Donegal or West Cork, or any of the poorer areas of the country—the farmers that keep most pigs—to get their meals from? Where are they to get their barley? They are to get it from Leix and Offaly and Kildare, from farmers who have 120, 130, or 140 acres of land, and are in a much better condition than they are. They are to go up there and get it. They can get a certain amount of it, but at what price?
Remember when you are talking of price now you must talk in terms of wholesale price. When the farmer sells barley he really gets a wholesale price for it. What is the wholesale price of Indian meal? Between £4 and £5. Where is the farmer that can take 4/- to 5/- per cwt. for his barley, that is, 8/- to 9/- a barrel? Would the Kildare farmers think it a good proposition? It is a pity Deputy Kelly, who is a convert to tillage, is not here. I wonder would the Meath farmers or the East Cork farmers think it a good proposition. If they are going to get 8/- to 9/- for their barley as a substitute for Indian meal the small farmers in the West of Ireland must pay more for their barley than they can buy Indian meal at. That is all right if they have not to export their pigs. If they have to export their pigs and sell them in the English market against pigs fed on Indian meal bought at a world price how can they do it?
This policy can be carried out successfully I admit, but only on one condition, and that is that production is cut to half. If pig production were cut to half there would be no occasion to sell pigs in the English market. We would have just enough for ourselves. Then you could force the small farmer of the West, or the small farmer who produces pigs and feeds cattle, to buy his feeding stuffs from the Leix and Offaly and Kildare farmer, and you could force him to give a high price for it. You could also force the consumer of bacon and beef and other agricultural products to give a high price for them. That could be done on one condition only, and that is that we cut down agricultural production to half. If the Deputies opposite think that that is an ideal policy they are right. If they think that instead of cutting down production to half we should increase our production the policy enshrined in this Bill is just suicide—just sheer lunacy and nothing else.
There is a big lot of time spent in debating the question of whether this policy put up the price of the mixture by 10/-, 15/- or 30/-. That does not matter. In my opinion it has put up the price by about £1 a ton on the average, but that does not matter. What does matter is the quality of the food which is sold to the farmer. There is no doubt about it that what is going to happen in regard to this mixture is that second and third and fourth quality barley and oats will go into the mixture and be sold at the price of Indian meal. There is no doubt about that. The Minister as good as admitted it. There is no possible test which could detect the quality of the Irish grain once it is ground and put into that mixture, and there can be no doubt whatever that the stuff in the way of barley, wheat and oats that will go into that mixture will be second, third and fourth type of quality.
We were told, I think by Deputy Harris, that it was England forced us to produce live stock and live stock products, and that it is the present Government which proposes to reverse that, and produce grain. I think that is right up to a point. The present Government, undoubtedly, has co-operated in the whole scheme, because Deputy Harris's statement amounts to this, that the British Government made the production of live stock and live stock products pay, whereas it is to the credit of the present Government it made them lose. That is quite true. I am not so sure it was the British Government forced us to produce live stock and live stock products. I am quite sure their production was taken on one year with another, because they paid and paid fairly well. Whether it was the British Government forced us or not to do it is another question. If the brutal Saxon, with whom we are at war at the present moment, did force us to produce live stock and live stock products he did us a very good turn, but in fact you are paying the British Government a compliment that they do not deserve. It was not the Saxon that did that. It was world conditions generally—free trade, if you like.
Comment on this
It was free trade. It was after the farmer realised that producing cattle, sheep, pigs and livestock products paid him better than other methods of farming. But this Government can take the credit of turning that profit very definitely into a loss. There is no doubt whatever that if the present price of beef, mutton, butter, bacon and eggs is still further depressed, that even wheat at 23/- a barrel will pay. Two or three years ago when I was opposing suggestions made to me from the Fianna Fáil Benches that I should go into wheat and encourage the growing of wheat, that was one element in the situation that I did not anticipate. I did not think you would have a Government in power which would consider that the economic dislocation, existing at the present moment between this country and England, was a blessing in disguise; I did not think they would take a certain amount of pride in having shared in bringing the present price of cattle to something like 18/-a cwt., and the price of pigs to the same thing; I did not think the state of affairs which they brought about would result not only in these very low prices, but lower prices still. If I had known that I might have been able to agree with some of the Fianna Fáil Deputies, but that is the present position. But I believe this foolishness will pass. I do not know when. As I said in the beginning, I hope the Government will last long enough to carry this policy out to its logical conclusion. I do not think they will myself, because I have a shrewd suspicion, knowing them, that when the difficulties begin to accumulate they will clear out and let somebody else clear up the mess. The mess will not be a political mess alone, but an economic and financial mess—that will be the most cowardly of all policies if they do that. Even though the present condition of things has cost the country an enormous sum of money, and even though it will take generations to recover from it and lower the standard of living for two or three generations owing to what is lost up to the present, I am a great believer in logical conclusions, and I think there is no country in the world wants logic more than this country. We had to sit here for ten years carrying out our policy under normal conditions. During that time we were not in a position to accuse the Opposition of being traitors; during that time we had to justify ourselves on everything we did, and by every attempt we made to solve problems in every Department of State, and so we stood up to our responsibility in that way. We have a different policy now. The propaganda of three or four years succeeded and people were persuaded that that policy was wrong; people were persuaded the policy their fathers and grand-fathers carried out so well and made money on was completely wrong and that it should be changed. They were persuaded, that is the worst of it, by politicians who I honestly believe did not really believe what they were saying. Whether they did or not, they are in office now, and the one thing I would like to see is that this Government will be left in office until they carry out their policy—their economic policy especially. But I am very much afraid that will not happen and for two reasons. Since they got into office they are entirely on the political policy. We have heard more of that policy than of their economic policy. This is the first instalment of their economic policy—it is the major portion of it; it was the big feature of their agricultural policy. And while I believe there is hardly a fair-minded Deputy on the benches opposite who believes in that policy, nevertheless the country is entitled to see it tried out—the country should not be codded. I want to see this policy of wheat growing in operation on a two or three years' subsidy, and I want to see it compared with the policy of producing livestock and livestock products, and I want to see that policy also given a fair chance. Of course, I know perfectly well the Government in power do not want to give that policy a fair chance. They want to see that this dislocation shall go on and shall continue, so that they will have an opportunity of carrying out certain political designs of their own, but so far as we are concerned we are going to see to it that the country will be told the truth. The country changed because the Deputies opposite persuaded the country they had an economic policy which would bring about comfort, prosperity, and work for everybody. We are in no hurry. We want to give them a fair chance, but we want to see that the country is not tricked again. We want to see to it that these policies which they put in such glowing terms before the country are carried out. As far as I am concerned, I disbelieve in the policy; I know it will fail, but I know it has taken in a good many well-meaning people in the country, and I want to see its terms in operation for, at least, two or three years, until the country knows exactly what it is worth. I move the adjournment of the debate.