We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

Private Business. - Agricultural Produce (Cereals) Bill, 1932—Committee (Resumed).

Contributions 199–402 of 816. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 4 parts.

Bill Agricultural Produce (Cereals) Bill, 1932
Enacted

No. 27 of 1932 ›

What is fraud? I suggest that the Minister will not define that.

Comment on this

The Minister says that he is protecting himself, but the way to protect himself is to go in and get an order of the court and put it down on the bench, saying: "There is an order of the court in respect of a man who held a licence and who was found guilty by the court. There is my defence": and then sit down. That is all he has to do. I would ask him to arm himself with an order of the court for protection, and nothing else, because nothing else is a defence.

Comment on this

We have now got the point of view that apparently the Minister need not make up his mind as to whether it is fraud or misrepresentation. He can just leave it vague. It is not a question of what a man is guilty of. He will not decide whether he is guilty of fraud, and neither will he decide whether he is guilty of misrepresentation. He is satisfied if, in a vague way, he is guilty of one or the other, but the Minister will not go to the trouble, according to his interjection just now, of judging what he is guilty of. On this matter, I would like to point out to the Minister that one of his interjections was that a person has the remedy of going to the courts open to him. Where is it so far as this is concerned? He put an interjection of this kind in when the debate on the sub-section was going on, but where is that particular remedy as regards what we are now complaining of?

Comment on this

I did not say that.

Comment on this

I must have misunderstood the Minister. I thought he said——

Comment on this

I said that any citizen can go to the courts for a declaration at any time.

Comment on this

For a declaration?

Comment on this

About what?

Comment on this

About whether the Minister is right or wrong?

Comment on this

Not when the Act gives the Minister the right.

Comment on this

Is there an appeal, in other words? This is an important matter, and I would like to know what that means. The Minister convicts the holder of a licence of having procured the licence by fraud or misrepresentation. Is it the Minister's view that before there is revocation of the licence that person has a right to go to the court and get the Minister set aside?

Comment on this

I did not say that.

Comment on this

What did the Minister say?

Comment on this

I said that any person can go to the courts and get a declaration from the courts as to the Minister's powers under this section.

Comment on this

But they are there.

Comment on this

That is what we object to. They are too clear.

Comment on this

And observe that a person has no remedy, according to the Bill, in the court, because the sole criterion is that the Minister is satisfied. It is quite sufficient for the Minister to go into the court and say "I am satisfied," and no mandamus will lie against him. The Minister says that a person can go in and get the protection of the court. That is precisely what we are trying to get for him here. If you put that sub-section in the Bill, he has no protection, but if you put in a provision, such as that set out in the amendment, he has every protection the Minister envisages—the protection of the court against the Minister. The Minister cannot penalise him without the authority of the court.

Comment on this
Division

Question—"That the words proposed to be deleted stand"—put.

Tá 60
·
Níl 43
Result _

Do you agree with this result?

I move amendment 82:—

In sub-section (2) (b), line 21, after the word "mill" to insert the words "for an extended period (save where such business has ceased through circumstances outside the control of the holder of such licence)."

I think it would be asking too much to revoke a licence because a mill had ceased to operate for a very short period—days or weeks. There ought to be some protection for the miller. The words suggested in the amendment would provide for an extended period. As the sub-section stands it is rather drastic, as a mill might stop on a Friday evening and might not start again until some time in the following week.

Comment on this

The amendment is not necessary. Paragraph (b) does not state that the milling of wheat has ceased at the mill. It means where the business has ceased. A temporary stoppage of machinery would not mean the cessation of business. The wording means that the mill would have to be out of action for an extended period, due to the fact that the company operating it had gone out of business.

Comment on this

If that is the Minister's reading of the sub-section I am satisfied. It appeared to me, as it might appear to the ordinary layman, that the mere temporary cessation of milling would bring the owner under penalties.

Comment on this

Oh, no.

Comment on this

I move amendment 83:—

In sub-section (2) (c), line 22, to delete all words after the word "convicted" to the end of line 23, and substitute the words "twice of offences under this Part of this Act both of which convictions have resulted in penalties being imposed under Part I of the First Schedule to this Act.

I think it would be rather drastic to revoke a licence because there was a trivial offence.

I propose that the licence should not be revoked unless the holder of the licence shall have been convicted twice, and not for trivial offences either. The penalties are rather drastic—too drastic, in fact—and in this particular instance I think it offers a loop-hole to rather heavily penalise the individual miller.

Comment on this

The power to revoke the licence, if the licensee has been convicted, should be there. It is quite obvious that that power will not be exercised unless for sufficiently grave reasons. The shutting down of a flour mill would be a very serious thing for any Minister to contemplate, and he would need to have a good case to do that. The point made here is merely to get permission to withdraw the licence if the miller has been convicted. It is quite obvious that if it was for some trivial offence, or that there was going to be permanent damage done as a result of the fine, the Minister would hesitate to take such power, but the purport of the section is to give the Minister power to revoke the licence if, in his opinion, the conditions are sufficiently grave to justify such action.

Comment on this

In the various other parts of this Bill and in the First Schedule to the Bill, the Minister has detailed various maximum penalties but, in reality, here he has gone beyond all that and has a new maximum penalty so far as the miller is concerned. The amendment that the Minister refuses to have anything to do with allows him, on a second conviction of a person by a court, of the very many things under this Bill that are to be dealt with or which make a miller liable to incur the penalties mentioned under Part I— that is, the serious offences, as the Minister himself would call them— to take away that person's licence. He refuses to put that in or to give that particular safeguard in legislation, and again everything has to depend on the wisdom of the Minister; and the only remedies open to a person who thinks himself unfairly treated under this sub-section are that the matter can be questioned here in this House. That again, I think, is a most undesirable method of ventilating a grievance of that kind. It means that in order to remedy a matter of that kind the only thing to do is to bring about the defeat of the Executive Council. It is ludicrous from that point of view.

What is the Minister's objection, for instance, to limiting the penalties for offences incurred under Part I? The Minister himself must acknowledge that he has been pretty generous in the way he treated offenders under Part I. Surely the penalties prescribed in the Bill itself are heavy enough, but it does seem absurd that he should have power to inflict the loss of licence if the court thinks that the normal punishment is the punishment under Part II or Part III of the First Schedule. Furthermore, the court, from the evidence before it, would be in a position to judge of the merits or demerits of the case. I think that, if there is any objection to the amendment, it is that it does not give enough power. The Minister should not have power to give that maximum penalty, namely, the loss of livelihood of the miller, unless the court inflicts the maximum penalty. Having heard the case, and approaching it in judicial fashion, the court inflicts the maximum penalty under Part I of this Bill. That would seem a reasonable case for the withdrawal of the means of livelihood, but what the objection of the Minister can be to limiting his discretion to offences for which the penalties mentioned in Part I of the Schedule are prescribed, I do not know. Why he thinks that he must have the power to deprive of a licence those whom even the Bill itself normally would make liable only to the lesser penalties under Part I, Part II and Part III, I fail to see. In reality, the amendment is much better than the Bill as it stands, even to the ordinary person.

Comment on this

Again, I do not think that any useful purpose is to be served by going over again what has been already covered. This section is taken word for word from a number of similar sections. The considerations to which the Deputy has adverted were, I am sure, in the minds of the Executive in the past. The section is designed to give permission for the cancellation of the licence in certain circumstances. That power would only be exercised in extreme cases, but, nevertheless, it is a power that should be there, and the whole operation of the Bill might easily be negatived if that power were not there.

Comment on this

Does the Minister suggest that it would be an extreme case if the miller was guilty only of the offences punishable under Parts II and III?

Comment on this

It is impossible. A person might be charged with that offence and yet be deemed to be worthy of a fine of 5/-. Another person might be found guilty and, under Part II, be liable to six months' imprisonment. That is no criterion by which to judge of the two offences, the nature of which we do not know.

Comment on this

Has the Minister received any representations from the people concerned?

Comment on this

From whom?

Comment on this

The millers.

Comment on this

I have no doubt I have.

Comment on this

No grounds have previously been covered in relation to this amendment because it is an entirely new amendment. Any arguments used previously about fraud and misrepresentation were specially directed to that. This is where we have got away from the Minister's point with regard to who has power. All that he is asked to speak of is, where a man has been convicted "twice of offences under this Part of this Act, both of which convictions have resulted in penalties being imposed under Part I of the First Schedule to this Act." It is an entirely new proposal, and has not been debated before in the House, and no argument can apply to this, other than the arguments used previously under Sections 26 and 27 of this measure.

Under Section 26 of this measure a man who gets a licence is obliged to mill his quota. He is, under an amendment put down yesterday, obliged to mill 90 per cent. of the wheat that has been assigned to him under the quota. If he fails for two years or for one year to mill that ninety per cent. he can be charged, and can be convicted under Part III of the First Schedule. The moment that happens he can have his licence taken from him. The Minister's answer to that is that it is obvious it will not be. We want to translate "obvious" into "impossible"—that it will not be possible to take the licence from him. That is all that is aimed at. I should like to find out from the Minister how he proposes to square the policy set down here with the line of policy which I understand his Party have adopted with regard to endorsements on other licences, and the abolition of a licence on a certain number of endorsements being put on that licence. I understood that particular type of procedure did not meet with the approval of his Party. Yet here on one conviction, with the minimum penalties, under the least onerous section of the Schedule, the Minister has it in his power to destroy a man's livelihood. Surely it is much more serious to give that power to the Minister than to give to a judge the power, when it seems good to him, to record certain things on a publican's licence and to forfeit that licence after a certain number of endorsements.

Comment on this

If the Deputy knows as much as he pretends about law, he knows that there is no similarity between the two things. There is in one case the automatic cancellation of a licence, following three convictions.

Comment on this

Not automatic can cellation.

Comment on this

In this case there is no cancellation.

Comment on this

Does the Minister know that in the other case it is possible to sell the premises?

Comment on this

It is possible here too.

Comment on this

To sell premises under a threat of revocation of the licence? He would get no more for it than he would get for the millable wheat.

Comment on this

I move amendment 84:—

In sub-section (2) (d), line 24, to delete the words "if he is satisfied that".

The Minister may revoke a licence if he is satisfied under this section that there has been any breach of any condition of such licence. I think the words "if he is satisfied" are superfluous and that they should be deleted. It is quite sufficient to say that if there is a breach of the licence, a man's licence may be revoked. I do not think it needs the satisfaction of the Minister to emphasise the fact that there is a breach of the conditions.

Comment on this

The paragraph would be meaningless without these words.

Comment on this

No; a court would have to decide the matter. That is the proper place to have it decided.

Comment on this

We want to have the phrase merely "that there has been any breach of any condition of such licence". It is objectionable that the Minister should have it in his own power to decide that and hence it is suggested that these words be deleted.

Comment on this

It is quite clear so far as the legislation is concerned— that is all we are interested in—that we give power to the Minister not merely to inflict punishments off his own bat without reference to any court, not merely to inflict punishments under Schedule I, but much greater punishments——

Comment on this

What power is given to the Minister to inflict punishments under Schedule 1?

Comment on this

I say we are giving much greater power than that. In the Schedule certain penalties are put down. Now, to the Minister himself, without any court intervening, we are giving much greater powers merely because "he is satisfied" and there is no appeal from that. It is a sufficient answer of the Minister to anybody that the Minister will act. He will swear he has investigated it and that he has come to a decision. That is his answer, and there is no safeguard whatever. Though we may mention maximum penalties, we are giving the Minister, without the intervention of any court, power to inflict much greater penalties.

Comment on this

The amendment suggests that if there is a breach of the conditions, no matter how trivial the breach may be, the licence must be revoked.

Comment on this

No. The decision is left to a court.

Comment on this

Is this what Deputies want? If the court establishes a breach of the conditions, the licence will be revoked, if the court so decides?

Comment on this

Automatic revocation of the licence following the decision of the court?

Comment on this

No, the licence may be revoked.

Comment on this

And the Minister is going to decide that?

Comment on this

He is going to have what we have discussed so much here recently, a prerogative.

Comment on this

He is going to have the decision as to whether the breach of the conditions was so serious as to justify a revocation of the licence. The ultimate decision is made by the Minister.

Comment on this

The Minister has to give two decisions as the Bill stands. He will give only one in the other case.

Comment on this

I submit it is the final one that matters. The Minister has not merely to satisfy himself but to satisfy the House that not merely was there a breach of the conditions, but that it was so serious a breach as to justify the shutting down of the mill.

Comment on this

How can the Minister satisfy the House if the magistrate does not propose to fine the man a shilling bit?

Comment on this

It is a no more serious matter to take away the business of a miller than the business of an egg dealer, a butter factor or a fresh meat exporter.

Comment on this

I cordially agree with the Minister. I quite agree that penalties of that grave character should not be inflicted on the whim of any Minister. I cannot understand the mentality of a Minister of a Fianna Fáil Government who feels that he is bound by precedents created by a Cumann na nGaedheal Government. If the Minister is making that defence to me, I would respectfully assure him that I am not a member of the Cumann na nGaedheal Party and I do not think he is. Therefore, he is not in any way bound by the precedents set up by the Cumann na nGaedheal Party. Of course, the Minister may have such a high opinion of the prudence that characterised the Cumann na nGaedheal Administration that he is quite content to copy their methods, but I suggest that the Minister for Industry and Commerce should improve on the Cumann na nGaedheal policy when he has an opportunity. I make the suggestion to him now in this case that he could steer a more prudent course and set up a better precedent than this one now before him.

Comment on this

The Minister asked us to compare two discretions. There is, firstly, the discretion which now resides in the Minister under the Bill that he may revoke a milling licence if he is satisfied that such licence is procured by fraud or misrepresentation, or if he is satisfied that the holder of such licence has been convicted of an offence under this Act, or if he is satisfied that there has been any breach of the conditions. He asks us that that discretion should be compared with the discretion which would still reside in the Minister to revoke the licence but only after a court has decided that the licence was procured by fraud or misrepresentation or after the court had itself convicted and imposed penalties under Part I or after the court had decided that there was a breach of the licence. The Minister thinks there is no difference in these discretions. It is the Minister's contention as long as the discretion is still with him it does not matter, although there is a material difference in the conditions precedent to the exercise of the discretion.

The Minister is very fond of finding precedents. I have a measure here in which the Minister is given power to revoke a licence granted by him, but he is not allowed to revoke it except in accordance with the section, and the only two things that have any impact upon the licence through the section are (a) an application made to the court, or (b) that the holder of the licence has been convicted of a serious offence under the Act. That was the Control of Manufactures Act which the Minister passed. Why not apply it to this?

Comment on this

Perhaps, now that the Attorney-General is here upon the scene, he will be good enough to furnish the House, through the Minister, with precedents for the Minister taking on judicial functions, and with precedents for the attitude which the Minister is now defending.

Comment on this

I have got now the relevant section from the Agricultural Produce (Eggs) Act, 1924, and I must withdraw what I said that this section is similar to the one in that Act. It is not; it is much more moderate, because in the Eggs Act the Minister can withdraw a licence for a very much larger number of reasons, including this "(d) that there has been any contravention (whether by way of commission or of omission) of this Act or of any regulations made thereunder."

Comment on this

Does not the Minister realise a little difference between the two?

Comment on this

In this case a contravention of the Act must be established in court.

Comment on this

The Minister does not apparently realise any difference between the two. In one case certain necessary punitive steps had to be taken in order to establish a standard of quality for an exportable product. In this case there is no such thing, and the Minister knows it. Millers do not generally require any character from anyone here.

Comment on this
Mr. Ryan

Your Party held them to be inefficient.

Comment on this

That is the very thing we held they were not. We held they were able to do their business and to preserve their industry in the country. Apparently the opinion about the efficiency entirely relates to the Ministry, because it is there, amongst them, from one end to the other. In this case it is obvious that the Minister is called upon to come to a decision, so as to say there has been a breach of the conditions, and secondly that he is qualified by reason of that to annul a licence. It is all on a par with the usual theoretical business comprehension of Ministers over there. If there was a single business man amongst the Ministry this proposal would not be in the Bill.

Comment on this

I remember a time when the Minister for Industry and Commerce used to wrap the green flag round him, and that was the end of the argument. Now I understand his answer to every argument is to wrap the Cumann na nGaedheal flag round him.

Comment on this

I have withdrawn from that position.

Comment on this

I heard him defending himself on the ground that there was a little more stringent provision in the Eggs Act. If the Minister is going, tonight, to defend himself, not by reasoned arguments but by using Cumann na nGaedheal arguments, or Acts passed by them, I am prepared to leave it so. There is no use attacking this Bill if that is to be his defence but if he wishes to defend it, on its merits, some useful purpose might be served if he took up that attitude.

Comment on this

Again I emphasise that I am not concerned with previous Acts even if the Minister for Industry and Commerce is very much so. The Leader of the Opposition has shown that the Minister's analogy is false. The Eggs Act set up a standard of good eggs, as distinct from electioneering eggs. But the standard of quality in this Bill is conspicuous by its absence. It is the missing link in the Bill. What he tries to ensure in this Bill is to put excessive penalties on the millers and others—penalties which nobody could stand behind. The Minister, in his own person, is the court, and he judges beforehand. These are things that no one could stand over, and, I think, the Minister might reasonably accept some of the amendments that are being moved. I think at any rate he might accept this amendment.

Comment on this

I quoted the precedent of the Control of Manufactures Act, 1932. Section 10 of that Act says:

(1) The Minister may at any time alter or revoke a new manufacture licence upon the application of the holder of such licence.

(2) The Minister may at any time without any such application revoke a new manufacture licence if the holder of such licence has been convicted of a serious offence under any section of this Act.

(3) The Minister shall not revoke or alter a new manufacture licence save under and in accord with this section.

I quote that precedent for the Minister.

Comment on this

If I quote a Cumann na nGaedheal precedent in my defence, Deputy McGilligan quotes a Fianna Fáil precedent against me.

Comment on this
Conor Alexander Maguire Attorney-General (Mr. Conor Maguire) Fianna Fáil

It seems to me that the section repeats, almost exactly, the provisions of the Agricultural Produce (Eggs) Act, 1923, referred to by the Minister. If there was a case against this section it surely would be shown, in practice, that this Act had worked injustice and that the vesting of these powers in the Minister had worked unjustly.

Comment on this

It is a gross injustice.

Comment on this

I have heard no evidence of it.

Comment on this

Who was it administered it up to date?

Comment on this
Mr. Maguire

The Minister did, but the Minister is not incorporated in the Act. Is it the Deputy's contention that the Act of 1924 was merely to last during the tenure of office of the Deputy when he was Minister?

Comment on this

No; but that the precedent established might be followed.

Comment on this
Mr. Maguire

I have not heard any suggestion made against the Minister for Agriculture that it worked otherwise than fairly.

Comment on this

This means that the Minister can take it upon himself to withdraw the licence. If you were here you would have learned that from the debate.

Comment on this

The Attorney-General missed the point.

Comment on this

I understand the point to be that objection was made to the effect of the section and that it gives the Minister powers that ought to be vested in a court. While in theory I agree with that principle, it seems to me that unless evidence was given that where a similar section has been in operation for a long period of years injustice and hardship has been caused, the case against this particular section has not been made out.

Comment on this

I think the real opposition to this section comes from Deputy McGilligan. It is not so much that these powers are vested in the Minister for Industry and Commerce as that he objects to the particular Party that forms the Ministry. That is a matter that we can settle in the Division Lobby and nowhere else, and Deputy McGilligan knows the result.

Comment on this

Deputy Dillon quoted a precedent that is not quite correct. That precedent dealt only with foreigners, and as this section deals with our own people we must put more stringent powers into the hands of the Minister for Industry and Commerce when dealing with our own people.

Comment on this

The Attorney-General referred to the Eggs Act, and said unless there was thoroughgoing evidence that this worked injustice the case against this provision breaks down. I contend that the provision in the Eggs Act does work injustice. I want to make it clear—I do not know how far any persons had their licences withdrawn by the Department of Agriculture—occasions have repeatedly arisen in which one felt that one had absolutely no defence and could get no protection against the Department of Agriculture's inspectors. They come down, under the Eggs Act regulations, and state that they require such and such a thing done. You say you do not think it necessary that it should be done. They say it is necessary and if you do not comply you commit a breach of the regulations. Therefore you have no protection from the suspension of your licence if the Minister listens to his inspectors. They present a case to the Minister and they tell you the protection that is required. You have no protection and none of the securities you would have if you fought the case if you were prosecuted. I had this experience repeatedly. I know the inspectors of the Department of Agriculture are men representing a very high standard, and are by no means fractious or contentious men, but there was a time when they took one view and I took another. We differed. I know they are acting entirely from a sense of their duty. I do not say that they were unduly fault-finding or vexatious. They were what the Minister would describe as reasonable inspectors, but I think I am entitled before my licence is taken away to the protection of a court. If a verdict was there given against me I would not feel the slightest hardship in complying with the regulations under the Act. I did feel a sense of hardship when I had no appeal against the inspector. Naturally the Minister believes his inspectors, looks upon them as reasonable men with a great variety of experience, and he would say: "This complaint is laid by some crank in some back part of Mayo. The inspectors are reasonable men and that is good enough for me." But I feel I am entitled to challenge the Minister to prosecute me for a breach of the regulations if he thinks I have committed it, and, then, if the issue is tried before an impartial judge, I am quite prepared to accept the judgment. But I do not believe that the Minister himself should have power to inflict the penalty which would result in the taking away of my licence. That is the power that we are now asked to give the Minister and that is a power to which I object.

Comment on this

Under what paragraph?

Comment on this

Under the provision here by which the Minister may revoke a milling licence, granted to any mill, if he is satisfied that there has been any breach of the conditions of such licence.

Comment on this

He has no power to prescribe conditions in relation to this particular section.

Comment on this

He prescribes the powers attaching to the licence.

Comment on this

No power to prescribe new conditions apart from the powers attaching to the licence.

Comment on this

The Minister can put on any conditions when he issues the licence and he can decide whether they are broken or not.

Comment on this

But not to prescribe a variation of the regulations such as Deputy Dillon talks about.

Comment on this

The Minister is defending a principle, that if the Minister himself is satisfied there is a breach of regulations he can withdraw the licence.

Comment on this

A breach of the conditions attaching to the licence at the date of issue.

Comment on this

The Minister can decide to withdraw the licence. The contention here is that he has the right to act as a court. Is not that so? In defence of the Minister's position a paragraph in the Eggs Act was quoted and I pointed out to the Attorney-General that material injustice ensued by the mere fact that a person can be penalised under that paragraph and that there is no right of protection to appeal to a court of law against the Minister.

Comment on this

I move amendment 85:

In sub-section (3), line 28, to delete the word "fortnight's" and substitute therefor the word "month's."

Comment on this

I move amendment 86:

In sub-section (3), to delete all words after the word "holder," line 32 to the end of the sub-section.

I propose to delete practically the last two lines of the sub-section which are "and may if he thinks fit cause an inquiry to be held in relation to the matter." I do not think there is any necessity, if the Minister complies with the rest of the sub-section, to have any inquiry, and I think we might relieve him of that necessity by deleting these words.

Comment on this

Has the Deputy reconciled his view with that of Deputy McGilligan? I think we might take Deputy Bennett's amendment and Deputy McGilligan's amendment together.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

If amendment 86 falls, amendment 87 cannot be moved.

Comment on this

I would prefer my amendment 87, which reads: In sub-section (3), line 32, after the word "fit" to insert the words "and shall at the holder's request," taken as one method of improving what is here. I would like, also, to have amendment 88 properly considered. If the only inquiry is one to be held when the Minister thinks fit I do not want that. But if an inquiry is going to be held when the Minister thinks fit I think the other party should be able to demand an inquiry. The words we are discussing in the sub-section are that the Minister "may if he thinks fit cause an inquiry to be held in relation to the matter." If the only inquiry, as I have said, is one the Minister thinks fit, then, so far as I am concerned, I do not want it. If he is to have power to call for an inquiry, then I think the other party to the business should be entitled to demand an inquiry; hence, the words in my amendment No. 87 "and shall at the holder's request." If one has a right to demand an inquiry let both have that right. If the holder of the licence has no right to demand an inquiry neither should the Minister. I prefer the words in my amendment to those in Deputy Bennett's.

Comment on this

Between the two I would prefer the case made by Deputy McGilligan embodying the principle that the licensee should pay the cost.

Comment on this

Because if he demands an inquiry by judicial persons then if he is found guilty of fraud or misrepresentation he should bear the cost.

Comment on this

Why should a man have imposed on him the necessity for paying for an inquiry which is brought about by the Minister's action? If the Minister had accepted, instead of the section as it stands, that where a man had been convicted twice of a serious offence that revocation should take place there might be some possibility of having expense imposed upon him, but as the section stands there is no necessity whatever to have expense imposed upon anybody, and a man ought to have the right to demand an inquiry and get it.

Comment on this

I accept the amendment.

Comment on this

But I want it accepted on my argument.

Comment on this

I move amendment 88:—

At the end of sub-section (3) to add the words "and shall bring before and have passed by each House of the Oireachtas a motion revoking such licence."

There would be no necessity for this bringing of Orders before the two Houses and of laying them on the Table to be subject to annulment if the circumstances under which annulment takes place were possible as regards what is set out in the amendment. But since in the Bill before us the Minister is to be the judge of fraud and misrepresentation, that he is to decide whether there has been a breach of condition, then certainly the House ought to get some opportunity of revising the order. The amendment would not be necessary if the fraud or misrepresentation or the question of a breach of the licence were left to the courts.

Comment on this

This is an amendment that could not be accepted. The Minister is responsible to the House and it is open to any Deputy to put down a motion of censure on the Minister for revoking a licence. The Deputy argued earlier that that would be tantamount to a vote of censure on the Executive Council and consequently would be regarded as a matter in which the Party majority would operate. The same thing applies in this case. The bringing of a motion for the revocation of a licence before the House would be a purely automatic matter, as the Minister would have to be in a position to justify his action.

Comment on this

But the main thing is that it would bring him before the House.

Comment on this

I move amendment 89:—

In sub-section (4), line 35, after the word "by" to insert the words "a member of the Gárda Síochána."

There is no provision in the section as to how the delivery is to be made.

Comment on this

Delivered to the person to whom it is addressed.

Comment on this

By whom?

Comment on this

The Minister or his agent.

Comment on this

The section does not say that. So far as I can make out, this thing is to be delivered by not delivering it. It is vital in this case that the notice should be delivered by some one in authority. Otherwise, how is the miller to know but that some anonymous person is serving a notice upon him. This amendment is introduced for the protection of the miller and for the protection of the Minister, too. The portion of the sub-section dealing with the serving of the notice by registered post is all right, but the other is not. It does not say that the notice is to be served by a civil bill officer or by an inspector of the Minister. As I have said, there is neither protection for the Minister nor for the miller.

Comment on this

Does the Minister intend to have this done by an inspector or by registered post?

Comment on this

By an inspector. Circumstances may arise in which it would have to be done by registered post.

Comment on this

Is the Minister's idea of delivery delivery by an inspector?

Comment on this

Then why not say so in the section?

Comment on this

Circumstances may arise in which it would be delivered in the offices of the Department of Industry and Commerce following discussion upon various points. It seems to me that as long as the notice is the proper notice, and as long as it is delivered to the person to whom it should be delivered, it is not necessary to specify rigidly that it must be delivered by a certain individual. I would be against having it delivered by a Civic Guard.

Comment on this

Why not put in "delivery by an inspector?" As the section reads it might mean delivery by ordinary letter post.

Comment on this

It does not mean that.

Comment on this

It is meant to mean hand delivery by an agent of the Minister, but not necessarily an inspector under the Bill.

Comment on this

What other agent would the Minister have?

Comment on this

An officer of the Department.

Comment on this

Why not put that in?

Comment on this

It is not necessary.

Comment on this

When documents are being delivered under Act of Parliament you must prescribe the mode of service. That must be made clear. If the service is not by the mode prescribed then it is not a good service. That is the position with regard to the service of documents under the courts, of civil bills and ordinary processes. In addition there has to be an endorsement of the service. Otherwise a man can go to the court and say that he did not get delivery of the notice.

Comment on this

Will the Minister define the word "delivery" on the Report Stage?

Comment on this

I will examine the point to see if it is necessary.

Comment on this

Examine it to see if there is any necessity to have any limitation of words to carry out delivery either by registered letter or by hand by an authorised agent of the Minister. I think the Minister should look into both points.

Comment on this

This is exactly as it is in other Acts. It does not mention how it is to be delivered.

Comment on this

This is the flag again. The Minister for Industry and Commerce and the Attorney-General have now wrapped the Cumann na nGaedheal flag around them. Why will not the Minister for Agriculture do the same, and then we will have the trio?

Comment on this

In providing for the service of documents you do not specify who is to deliver.

Comment on this

If you want to limit it to certain people you have got to so limit it, and the Minister says that he wants it limited.

Comment on this

On Section 32 itself, I will ask the House to divide, and I am not sure that there is not something to be said on it before we divide.

Comment on this

I think the section has been already very fully discussed and enough has been said on it.

Comment on this

Yes. I think all the points have been covered.

Comment on this
Division

Question—"That Section 32, as amended stand part of the Bill"—put.

Tá 60
·
Níl 42
Result _

Do you agree with this result?

Amendments 91 and 92 are in my name:

In sub-section (1), line 13, to delete the words "if he so thinks fit" and substitute the words "in accordance with regulations to be prescribed."

In sub-section (2), (c), to delete all words after the word "conditions" where it first occurs in line 24 to the end of the sub-section and substitute the words "as may be prescribed and are inserted in such permit."

The amendments deal with the old points about getting these things prescribed and brought before the House.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Is the Deputy anxious to press the amendments, or would he prefer to withdraw them?

Comment on this

In the circumstances, I have no objection to withdrawing them.

Comment on this

As regards the section, why insert the words "(including conditions as to revocation)" in paragraph (c)? Does it mean that there can be special conditions with regard to revocation?

Comment on this

This has relation to the conditions prescribed in the circumstances under which the licence would be revoked.

Comment on this

I think it would be well to take all the amendments to this section together. I want to make a statement concerning this whole matter of subsidies for wheat in port and inland mills. When we were phrasing the Bill originally, it was intended that we would pay a small subsidy to inland mills for a limited period in order to redress what we considered to be the disadvantages which these mills laboured under as compared with port mills. That intention was based on the information then available. Since the Bill was framed I had an opportunity of going into this matter with much greater care and with much greater information than had previously been obtainable. I have come to the conclusion that, with the possible exception of certain peculiar cases, a subsidy for inland mills is not necessary.

I found it impossible to get from flour millers, as such, any precise statement as to what were the advantages or disadvantages, if any, of inland mills. I found some inland millers took the line that it would not be possible for them to complete successfully with the port mills without a subsidy, whereas other inland millers took a completely contrary view and, in fact, stated they did not want a subsidy under any circumstances. They said that they did not consider a subsidy was required to enable them to maintain their position, if certain disadvantages were overcome.

Comment on this

Did they know about Deputy Norton's amendment which the Minister accepted last night?

Comment on this

I do not think that alters the position in the slightest.

Comment on this

The millers do not think so.

Comment on this

Our proposal, therefore, is to amend this part of the Bill so as to make it clear that it will enable a subsidy to be provided if, in particular cases, the conditions would seem to warrant that. At one time I considered the deletion of this part of the Bill, but on examination it did appear that there might be cases where, because of natural disadvantages, it might be necessary for a period to provide some assistance from the Central Fund to enable mills to be carried on, and flour to be sold at a price comparable with the price at which flour would be sold in other parts of the country. That decision was easier to arrive at in view of the fact that there might be secured from the Bill certain revenues which would probably be sufficient to offset any subsidies which it might be decided to pay.

It is possible that in the case of some of the silent mills a subsidy for a short period might be necessary in order to get them reopened. In particular parts of the country, for example where the existence of a flour mill would be advantageous from the point of view of the cost of living in the district and from the point of view of those engaged in the bakery industry in the district, such a mill could be re-established, despite the fact that natural disadvantages, such as the absence of a port into which vessels of a reasonable size could go, might exist.

If the various amendments which I suggest are embodied in this part of the Bill it will enable subsidies to be paid after the Minister for Finance has made an order and subject to the necessary money being voted by the Oireachtas. In each case the proposal would have to come before the Dáil and be approved and then money would be provided for the purpose. I want it to be clearly understood that it is not intended generally to provide subsidies. There will be no general subsidy for inland mills. Any subsidy which will be provided for a mill will be limited in amount and strictly limited in point of time. It is in relation to this statement that I would like these amendments considered.

In amendment 93 I propose to delete the word "ten" and substitute the word "five." I do not know if there is any substantial difference made by that change, but it is conceivable that a mill may be established within the limit suggested, and the scheme of the Bill is merely to ensure that a subsidy cannot be provided, no matter what the circumstances are, in respect of a mill in Dublin, Cork or Limerick, and by far the greater part of the milling capacity of the country is situated in these three centres. I am not inclined to press this particular amendment if there is any very strong objection taken to it; but I think it is one which should be carried because the advantages or disadvantages which might exist within ten miles might also exist within eight miles of any of these ports. Consequently, I think that provision should be made for it. The other amendments I shall deal with when the time comes. They are all designed to effect that change in this part of the Bill to which I have referred.

Comment on this

Can the Minister tell us where, in the amendment or in the Bill, there is any provision which necessitates a special Vote being passed by the Dáil before a subsidy is granted to an inland mill?

Comment on this

There is no money provided in the Bill. There is another section which refers to that matter.

Comment on this

Section 38 says: "The Minister may... out of moneys provided by the Oireachtas pay... subsidies at the appropriate rate."

Comment on this

That is the section I was looking for.

Comment on this

Has not the Oireachtas provided moneys which covered all the purposes of the Bill in the Financial Resolution which preceded this?

Comment on this

To an extent that is so but money will have to be provided by annual Vote here. That is the intention.

Comment on this

There would be, in other words, a Vote appearing annually on the Estimates for moneys to carry out the Cereals Act. The Minister spoke as if there was a distinction being made between subsidies to be provided for inland mills and any other part of the Act. That is not so.

Comment on this

So far as I can understand these amendments, they come to this—that we want to have wheat milled rurally and the distinction we now have under the amendment to 36 (1) is that everything is considered rural except places which are within five miles of the main Post Office in Dublin, Cork or Limerick. Every other place is rural, or inland, for the purpose of this Act. Is not that so?

Comment on this

And that is the situation at present.

Comment on this

The situation at present is that every part of this country is inland except those parts within five miles of the principal Post Offices of Dublin, Cork or Limerick? I did not know that.

Comment on this

I did not say that.

Comment on this

Let me read the definition as it is going to be:—

"For the purposes of this Part of this Act, every mill (other than a mill which is situate within five miles from the principal Post Office in the county boroughs of Dublin, Cork or Limerick) shall be an inland mill."

That is what we start off with. Shall we not, in fact, have dropped the distinction between inland mills and port mills when we incorporate the amendment? Is not the distinction founded on something else—probably the capacity of the mills within five miles of the principal Post Offices of Dublin, Cork and Limerick? Why not say so? We shall have got this section considerably readjusted by amendments and why keep this old idea of the distinction between inland mills and port mills? We are in the peculiar position that even a mill on the water-edge at Galway, Wexford or Waterford is an inland mill, but a mill which is almost five miles away from the Post Office in Limerick is a port mill. That is not a very logical distinction and keeping the old phrase seems to me rather to cloud for the future the point of discrimination. What that is has not been explained to us yet.

I do not want to raise the question of the whole purpose of this section. It was, apparently, to have milling decentralised. Why should you ask for milling to be decentralised if a mill situate on the water-edge, say, in Limerick, can, nevertheless, in competition, collect wheat milled inland from the hinterland around the port of Limerick, and sell the product more cheaply than the others? Have we a sort of constituency idea and do we want to have a mill per constituency so that Deputies, other than University Deputies, can go down to their constituencies and tell the people what they did for them with regard to milling? But what is the point of discrimination? If it is to be the capacity of the mill, why not determine it here and say that a mill of less than a certain sackage capacity may get a subsidy and mills above that capacity cannot and so drive people to build—if they are going to build in the future—mills of the limited and smaller type that will be required if they are to be spread all over the country? The section was better as it stood in so far as it did allow for some better differentiation as between inland mills and port mills. It would have been difficult, I think, to have got a mill in the county borough of Waterford or in an urban district, town or village situate on the sea determined to be an inland mill. Under the new scheme, those are definitely declared to be inland mills for the purpose of receiving subsidies. The idea does not commend itself to me but it is in the Bill and I suppose it is going to be pushed through. I do not know that the amendments, other than the one I referred to—No. 93— make any great difference. I do not think that they improve the measure in the slightest. I did not gather from the Minister's explanation that any difference is made by the amendments on the point of finance.

Comment on this

Is there any difference made by the amendments—except that they may be better phrased —in the matter of the subsidy being a general rate or a special rate for special areas?

Comment on this

It is only a matter of re-phrasing the same idea?

Comment on this

The Bill, as it stands, would do but its form pre-supposed a general subsidy for inland mills. The purpose of the amendment is merely to alter the form. Certain of my advisers argued that it would be better to leave the section as it stands and not go to the trouble of amending it. In view of previous statements and the form of the Bill on Second Reading, I thought it better that I should make clear that no such supposition was to be drawn from the form of the Bill. It is definitely intended that only in very rare and extreme cases will subsidies be provided at all.

Comment on this

That is more satisfactory, even though it is only a presumption. On the Minister's statement, the presumption is against subsidies being granted. As a result of amendment 93, Deputies who are interested in inland mills and who thought that inland mills, under this provision, might get a subsidy as against what we used to hear described as "the more favourably situated port mills," must realise that differentiation at the moment is between mills situate at Dublin, Cork or Limerick and all other mills and it is pre-supposed that these "all other mills" will not get any subsidy whatever. The presumption is generally in favour of a general rate, so that, if there is any rate struck, all will get it or none will get it.

Comment on this

I should have no objection to including the Port of Waterford in this but, in fact, there is no milling at Waterford at present and something more than 80 per cent. of the milling capacity is concentrated in the three centres mentioned. Any subsidy given would be limited to mills of certain maximum capacity or mills situate in a certain area. It would be exceedingly limited in amount and limited in point of time.

Comment on this

I appeal to the Minister to withdraw the amendment. In my opinion, the men engaged in the port mills are receiving a higher wage than the men who would be employed in inland mills. The amendment would mean that certain benefits would be given to certain mills against the interest of the workers engaged in the port mills. It will have an effect on the workers because it may possibly reduce the rate of wages paid in the port mills to the rate paid in inland mills.

Comment on this

I would prefer to leave it as it is. I am explaining to the Deputy that what he anticipates is not going to arise as, in fact, in the circumstances which he describes, no subsidy will be payable. It is definitely our intention not to do so. It is conceivable, however, that circumstances may arise at some time in the future in relation to another mill adjacent, say, to Limerick or Cork to which this would apply.

Comment on this

What will be the position of men who are already receiving a high rate of wages, as the mill in which they are working may be in competition with another mill not paying near the same rate of wages?

Comment on this

I take it the amendment accepted from Deputy Norton will regulate that position.

Comment on this

It will not.

Comment on this

The men in the port mills are paid on a certain capacity and other mills may not have the same capacity. Therefore, it will have an effect on the high rate of wages paid in the port mills. I appeal to the Minister to withdraw this and the matter can be brought up on the Report Stage.

Comment on this

We have already inserted in the Bill an amendment moved by Deputy Norton which requires that the rate of wages paid in any mill will be the generally recognised rate for workers doing the same class of work in licensed mills. It seems to me that that meets the Deputy's contention. It is now part of the Bill and, consequently, there need be no such fear arising out of the acceptance of this amendment.

Comment on this

I do not want to interfere in this, because I was against Deputy Norton's amendment without the explanation that I requested, and I did not get the explanation. I should like to point out to Deputy Everett that I did ask whether the amendment down in Deputy's Norton name allowed for different rates of wages to be paid in different localities, and the only answer I could get was that the arrangements were those which have been made between the trade unions representing the men and the employers, and if these permitted of different rates for different localities, then they were there, but if they did not, then they could not come. I got no answer, either from the Minister or Deputy Norton, as to whether, in fact, the arrangements referred to did permit of a variation between locality and locality. That has still to be determined.

Comment on this

The position, as I understand it, under Deputy Norton's amendment is that we are to have in the mills what we have on the railways at present under which a railway porter in Dublin and a railway porter in Skibbereen get exactly the same rate of wages.

Comment on this

I do not think that is right.

Comment on this

I think the Minister will find that it is so. There may be a difference as regards years of service, but, as regards other factors, I think he will find it is so. I shall be glad if he will inquire. That is the intention.

Comment on this

That is not so. It is neither the case at present nor is it in the amendment.

Comment on this

Let the Minister read the amendment. It is the intention that it should be a flat rate. I was sorry last night that the Minister jumped at it so quickly before he had the explanation or the information he had later on in the debate. I think if he waited for a little while he would not have been so anxious to accept it. That is the intention, and Deputy Norton did not deny it. That is the position at the present moment. Of course, we may have this up for consideration on the Report Stage, but, as it stands at present, it is a flat rate, and the mill in Deputy Everett's constituency that may be some distance inland, or on the borders of it, will be called upon to pay the same wages as a port mill, and the result will be that the port mill will get all the business because it will be able to do it at a cheaper rate.

Comment on this

Deputy Everett is afraid that it will not happen.

Comment on this

There is no fear of it happening because the trade unions will always consider the rate of wages paid in an area. You cannot compel mills in other areas to pay the same rate as is paid in Dublin. I am dealing with mills in County Dublin that may get an unfair advantage over mills at the Port of Dublin by reason of paying low wages. If I am assured that mills in County Dublin will pay the same rate of wages, then I am prepared to accept the amendment. What I want is that workers who will be engaged in certain mills in County Dublin will not be paid less wages than the men are paid at present at the port mills in Dublin.

Comment on this

That cannot arise out of this amendment. It definitely cannot, and it is our intention that it will not arise in any event, because the general scheme has been altered and, as I said, subsidies will only be paid in relation particularly to small mills situated in particular districts where very abnormal and unusual circumstances are operating.

Comment on this

Then I will be looking for a subsidy for mills in my constituency.

Comment on this

So will every Deputy.

Comment on this

There is no fear of the high rate of wages spoken of by Deputy Good prevailing in that area. I want wages in Dublin to be all at the same rate. I do not want men working a few miles from the Port of Dublin to be paid the same rate of wages as is paid in country districts, because the mills there will have the advantage of being near the Port, although the mill I have in mind would only get a similar subsidy and might be a hundred miles from the Port of Dublin.

Comment on this

What the Deputy wants is a differential rate of wages and I am quite with him in that. I should like to have the Minister with us and I hope he will be with us, otherwise he will shut up half the mills in the country.

Comment on this

Is it only mills which are not now working and new mills which may be started in the future that will get the subsidy? I think any subsidy given should come before the Dáil for ratification.

Comment on this

I should like to be able to say that there will be no subsidy at all, and Deputies may take it that that is the general inclination and the motive which will be behind the policy. There may, however, be exceptional cases of mills so situated, or under such initial difficulty, that it is no harm to have power to pay a subsidy. As I said, the amount of the subsidy will require to be voted annually by the Dáil and the matter will be discussed here.

Comment on this

I move amendment 97:

To delete sub-sections (1), (2), and (3) and substitute the following three new sub-sections:—

(1) The Minister for Finance may, from time to time, after consultation with the Minister, by order (in this Part of this Act referred to as a subsidy (rate) order fix by reference to weight, subject to the provisions of this section, the rate of subsidy to be paid under this Part of this Act on wheat milled at any specified inland mill.

(2) A subsidy (rate) order may relate to several inland mills, and in such case such order may fix separate, or different rates of subsidy in relation to some or all of such mills.

(3) The Minister for Finance may, after consultation with the Minister, by order (in this Part of this Act referred to as a variation order) under this sub-section revoke or amend any subsidy (rate) order.

This has reference to the amendment we have been discussing and it affects changes in Section 37. In fact the changes are only in form, but they provide for the payment of subsidies under the special circumstances I have mentioned rather than generally.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Amendments 98, 99 and 100 relate to amendments 4, 5 and 8 which have been already debated.

Comment on this

No. Amendments 4, 5 and 8 had reference to the question of a standard for millable wheat. These deal with the question of standard or rate of subsidy for inland mills.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

How do they arise now?

Comment on this

They may not have the same reference to the sub-sections because others have replaced them.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

This section has been replaced by a new section.

Comment on this

Then it only means that I withdraw them and that I shall put them down on the Report Stage to the new section.

Comment on this

I move amendment 101.

In sub-section (1), line 41, after the word "may" to insert the words "by order."

This amendment, Sir, was my attempt to have these special subsidies brought before the House. The Minister said apparently that is going to be the procedure. If that is to be the procedure my amendment is not necessary. I wanted to have them brought in by order so that they will come before the House.

Comment on this

Of course an order fixing the rate of a subsidy, and Allocation Orders, must come before the House. That is done by order of the Minister for Finance, in amendment 97, which we have accepted. I take it, though, that the Deputy's amendment relates to the period during which the subsidies may be paid. Amendment 101 is to insert after the word "may" in line 41 the words "by order," so that the section would be "such period as the Minister may by order determine?"

Comment on this

If the Deputy attaches the same meaning to it as I do, I am accepting it.

Comment on this

Yes, but I understand that the fact of the subsidy and the amount of it is going to be brought before the House in a special order.

Comment on this