We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

Private Business. - Agricultural Produce (Cereals) Bill, 1932—Committee (Resumed).

Contributions 403–608 of 816. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 4 parts.

Bill Agricultural Produce (Cereals) Bill, 1932
Enacted

No. 27 of 1932 ›

I do not see where that is compulsory on the amendment. I intended to raise the point on Section 40: "The Minister may by order make regulations for all or any of the following purposes that is to say:—

(a) prescribing any matter or thing referred to in this Part of this Act as prescribed." Supposing he makes an order, and by the order does not make a regulation, and is not bound to make a regulation because it is not a matter that has to be prescribed, must that order come before the House?

Comment on this

Sub-section (5) of Section 37 says: "Every order under this section shall be laid before Dáil Eireann as soon as may be after it is made."

Comment on this

That is under Section 37. Does that apply to an order made under Section 38?

Comment on this

Of course at present there is no order made under Section 38. As Section 38 stands at present there is no order made under it.

Comment on this

And I want to have this enshrined in an order, so that caught up in Section 37, if it is possible to entangle it in Section 37, the order will come before the House.

Comment on this

That is the order regulating the period during which the subsidy should be paid?

Comment on this

Yes. At the moment, the only compulsion on the Minister with regard to an order coming before the House is the order referred to in Section 37?

Comment on this

Now I was in doubt as to whether any other matter that is going to be determined in a later section to this was going to be caught up by Section 40, and I do not see that it was. I would like to get most of the things caught up in the order, and I put in a specific amendment on one special point. If that is going to be accepted it would require the acceptance of the phrase, and the transfer of sub-section 5 of Section 37 down to that section as well as 37.

Comment on this

If the Deputy would leave it over there may be a simpler method of doing it.

Comment on this

Certainly, if that is done.

Comment on this

Could the Minister say as to whether it is his intention that the subsidy for inland mills if given should be equal in all cases—should be the same for all mills.

Comment on this

It would be intended that a subsidy would be fixed at a rate which would apply to, say, all mills in a particular area, or all mills of a particular size, or all mills of a particular size in a particular area, but it would have general application within these limits.

Comment on this

But it would be a varying subsidy?

Comment on this

It might vary as between area and area. I move amendment 102.

In sub-section (1), page 17, to delete all words from the word "at" in line 41 to the end of the sub-section, and substitute the following words "on all wheat (subject to the limitations (if any) imposed under the next following sub-section) milled at an inland mill, which is the subject of a milling licence and of a subsidy (rate) order for the time being in force, at the rate fixed in respect of such mill by such order or by such order as amended by a variation order.

This amendment is consequential on 97.

Comment on this

I move amendment 103:—

To insert before sub-section (2) two new sub-sections as follows:—

(2) Whenever a subsidy (rate) order is made in relation to an inland mill, the Minister for Finance, after consultation with the Minister, may from time to time by order under this sub-section declare that where in a cereal year the wheat milled at such mill exceeds in amount the amount (in this sub-section referred to as the maximum) fixed by such order, no subsidy shall be paid on any wheat milled at such mill in any cereal year which is in excess of the maximum, and whenever any such order in relation to an inland mill is in force and there is milled at such mill in any cereal year wheat in excess of the maximum fixed by such order, no subsidy shall be paid on any wheat milled at such mill in such cereal year in excess of the maximum fixed by such order in relation to such mill.

(3) The Minister for Finance may, after consultation with the Minister, revoke or amend an order under the immediately preceding sub-section.

The same applies to this amendment.

Comment on this

I move amendment 104:—

In sub-section (2), line 48, after the word "corporate" and within the bracket to insert the words "in liquidation."

Comment on this

I am advised that this is not necessary.

Comment on this

I wanted to raise the point. Sub-section (2) says that the subsidy shall be paid "to the person who was the holder of the milling licence in respect of such mill at the time such wheat was milled or the personal representative or (in the case of a body corporate) the liquidator of such person." You would not pay to the liquidator unless the body corporate were in liquidation. It seems to me there is something wanting.

Comment on this

Of course the word "person" includes body corporate. "Every subsidy paid under this Part of this Act in respect of any wheat milled at an inland mill shall be paid to the person," which includes body corporate, "who was the holder of the milling licence in respect of such mill at the time such wheat was milled or the personal representative or (in the case of a body corporate) the liquidator of such person." Of course the words in brackets are only put in there because "the liquidator" only applies in a case of a body corporate.

Comment on this

If "person" includes "body corporate" what is the necessity for putting in the words "body corporate," unless it was intended to put in the words "in liquidation"?

Comment on this

Obviously it only applies where the person is in liquidation.

Comment on this

Why not say so?

Comment on this

In that case the personal representative of such person, or the liquidator of such person, only applies of course in the case of a body corporate. It was merely for clarification that the words in brackets were inserted. So I am advised.

Comment on this

Certainly it reads very oddly to say that the subsidy shall be paid either to the individual or to his personal representative or to that company's liquidator, without mentioning the circumstances of liquidation. However, leave it alone.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

Amendment 105 is out of order. It would be a charge.

Comment on this

Not necessarily, sir.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

It is to change "no subsidy" into "subsidies." It would potentially do so.

Comment on this

Only potentially.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

It would still be out of order.

Comment on this

There is an overriding maximum put down in sub-section (4) of not more than 1/- for every 400 lbs. If the subsidies paid to the Minister would be subject to that limitation——

Comment on this

You say "subsidies shall be paid on any wheat milled by the Minister."

Comment on this

I do not say subsidies shall be paid. I put in the word "subsidies" and I continue so that the phrase reads "subsidies paid on any wheat milled by the Minister under Part VIII of this Act" shall not be subject to the overriding limitations of 1/- for every 400 lbs. My idea is if the Minister is going to mill wheat he will require all the subsidies we can give him.

Comment on this

Wait and see.

Comment on this

We will not see.

Comment on this

The Deputy has been disappointed before.

Comment on this

On Section 39 I just want to point out that there is the same objectionable phrase in paragraph 2 to which definite exception is taken when it occurs in other sections, namely, that a certificate signed by the Minister "stating that a person has obtained a payment of a specified amount by way of subsidy under this Part of this Act, and that such person was not entitled to such payment or to a specified part thereof" shall be conclusive evidence. I do not object to it here, because I think anything is good enough for anybody who is to get a subsidy under this particular section.

Comment on this

Section 41 is again very severe, but seeing it deals with persons who get subsidies I do not object.

Comment on this

I move amendment 106:—

106. In sub-section (3), line 8, to delete the words "required by" and substitute the words "prescribed in."—

Might I ask with reference to this amendment, what are the matters that are required under Section 3, sub-section (4)? Are they only the matters that are mentioned in Section 46? Is it only a question of the name and address of the applicant and particulars of the premises? Is that all that is required, because if it is the phrase might stand as it is. Is it clear that that is all, because it is not objectionable to have it if that is all, but if anything comes in——

Comment on this

Yes, that is all.

Comment on this

Very good—on that assumption.

Comment on this

I want to ask a question on Section 45. Is there good legal precedent for the use of the word "premises," as it is used in line 41 with regard to the sowing of wheat— that you have to sow wheat on premises? The word "premises" everywhere else has relation to buildings— buildings where a man is going to mill or store. Is there legal justification for the use of the word "premises" without any other phrase joined to it as meaning lands?

Comment on this

The Department of Agriculture raised that matter and we were advised that "premises" was the proper word to use, or at least that it would be a correct word.

Comment on this

It might be correct in certain circumstances. A lot of people hold you should grow wheat in this country under glass and premises would be a very good word there.

Comment on this

I move amendment 107:—

In sub-section (1), lines 18-19, to delete the words "subject to the provisions of the next following section."

This is a point I can argue better on the various amendments that are down to Section 47 if just I might anticipate Section 47. I do not know what is the necessity for the proviso to it. I have called attention in amendment 108 to the words "other than Great Britain or Northern Ireland," and there are various other points I called attention to by amendments. If these are to be kept as they are, then I would rather have the phrase "subject to the provisions of the next following section" left out. If they are innocuous—they were explained as being more or less innocuous—the phrase in Section 46 might stand. If we could hold it over until we see Section 47 it might be better.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Not moved?

Comment on this

Very well, I will put it down again if required.

Comment on this

I move amendment 108:—

In sub-section (2), line 50, to delete the words "other than Great Britain or Northern Ireland."

This is one of the points I was querying. In Section 47, sub-section (2), line 50, the phrase comes in "other than Great Britain or Northern Ireland" and I want to know what is the meaning of having it put in here. The whole sub-section has to be taken in the framework of the section. Sub-section (1) of the sections says "subject to the provisions the Minister may refuse to register an applicant if he thinks it is not desirable in the public interest having regard to the number of persons already registered in such register." Then when we come on to the sub-section it says "notwithstanding anything in the immediately preceding sub-section the Minister shall not refuse to register an applicant if such applicant is bona fide engaged either as an agent for the importation of flour milled in Great Britain or Northern Ireland or as a direct importer of flour from any country other than Great Britain or Northern Ireland." Why the limitation? Why not leave it from any country?

Comment on this

The Minister for Industry and Commerce has been acting on the assumption that there is a difference between those who are importing flour directly from Great Britain and Northern Ireland, and those who have been importing flour from other sources and in the allotment of the quotas for imported flour a difference has been made between the two classes. He was anxious to keep this distinction in the Bill.

Comment on this

What is the reason for the difference? For instance, a man must be registered "if he can show he is bona fide engaged either as an agent for the importation of flour milled in Great Britain or Northern Ireland" and he must get a licence if he can prove he is an importer of flour from any country other than Great Britain or Northern Ireland. Apparently he is not entitled to his place on the register if he can only prove that he was importing directly from Great Britain or Northern Ireland. Why? If he is an agent for British flour, you allow him to register if he is importing from any place other than Great Britain and you will not allow him to register if he has been importing directly from Great Britain. Why?

Comment on this

I would prefer if the Deputy would raise this matter later. I cannot give any further information other than what I have given.

Comment on this

Let us hold it over to the Report Stage.

Comment on this

I move amendments 109 and 110:—

In sub-section (2), to delete all after the word "period," line 52, to the end of the sub-section.

In sub-section (4), page 21, to delete all after the word "period," line 9, to and including the word "date" in line 11.

Previously, we had in regard to application for licences that the man who had previously been engaged in milling flour must make his application within three months. I want to know why he should not be allowed to get his licence to mill if he applied at any time, say, within a year. Now, we get this period cut down even more when it comes to the registration of premises; where a man is entitled to get his registration you put a very narrow limit of time upon him. He must make his application not later than a month after the appointed date. Why the provision of the month?

Comment on this

There must be some time limit with regard to these applications. After all, in those registers we have to have regard to the number of people registered in the different registers. If we had to keep in mind the fact that such people might come along to register within the next six months, we could hardly act unless we put some limit on the time within which they must come in.

Comment on this

Why a month as the time limit?

Comment on this

We must decide on something. I think a month is quite reasonable.

Comment on this

Let us decide on three months. I think a month is very unreasonable, and three months would be perfect.

Comment on this

No. 119 is a similar one. It is of the same character.

Comment on this

What is the necessity of rushing this to the point where only one month is allowed. It is quite clear the register must be made up, and the register with regard to the new applicants can only be made up after the register of those who must get their licences has been made up, because there is the consideration whether it is desirable in the public interest having regard to the number of persons already registered. You cannot consider the new people until you know about the other persons. In regard to milling licences, it has been decided, and I think the time is considerably short, but at any rate, three months is going to be given for that, although the Minister told us to-night every 1931 vintage miller of wheat has his application in, and yet three months is given there. Here, where we have not heard a statement, at any rate, that all these various people, the flour importers, distillers, wheat importers, wheat dealers, maize millers, maize importers and manufacturers of compound feeding stuffs, have all their applications already listed, it is only proposed to give a month after a particular date. I suggest that this might be held over with a view to getting the time extended.

Comment on this

The appointed date is, of course, when the Act comes into operation.

Comment on this

It may be any time; it may be a different point for this section alone.

Comment on this

For each part?

Comment on this

Oh, no. I hope it will apply to all indiscriminately.

Comment on this

Would there not come a time, if a miller did not apply for his licence, when, to continue his operations would be illegal. The Minister apparently apprehends that if he does not prescribe a very strong time limit, millers will go on milling without bothering to apply for a licence. Would not a time then arise when, if they did not apply for a licence, their operations would be illegal?

Comment on this

Not if this amendment were carried, so far as I can see.

Comment on this

Suppose there is no proviso about time at all. They must get a licence at some juncture in order to entitle them to continue their operations?

Comment on this

Yes.

Comment on this

Therefore, you have a double safeguard and you could afford to give them a little longer time. There is no serious danger of any miller getting mislaid and not seeking his permit in due course, but there is the possibility of inconvenience being caused by giving him so short a time. He may be a day or two over the time and it will involve the Minister and him in the inconvenience. I suggest that the Minister might give him three months or go half way and give him two months.

Comment on this

He might still be a day late.

Comment on this

He might still be a day late, but all reasonable men would say that he has been given every conceivable facility and that he is a sluggard. One month, however, seems to be rather too short a time and it has been suggested by those interested that, if the time were extended somewhat, it would greatly convenience them, and as no vital principle is at stake, I think the Minister might meet them.

Comment on this

I cannot see any hardship on any miller in having to apply within one month from the appointed date.

Comment on this

If the Minister was a busy miller or if he was striving to make both ends meet in spite of trade depression——

Comment on this

I am trying to be under this Bill.

Comment on this

The Minister is not a miller on this occasion and he is supported by a very brilliant collection of advisers but where a miller is standing alone, frantically trying to earn a living in times of great difficulty, it is wonderful how rapidly a month will pass by. It is perfectly true, as the Minister says, that if he got two months he might be a day late, or even if he got six months, but what we are asking the Minister to do is to show the miller every consideration consistent with the efficient administration of the Act.

Comment on this

I move amendment 111:

In sub-section (4) (b), page 21, to delete all words from and including the word "either" in line 13 to and including the word "or" in line 15.

The point there is that where a maize importer is also a maize miller, we think it advisable to put certain restrictions on him. The person who is a maize importer and not a maize miller would have the wider powers specified in the section.

Comment on this

I move amendments 112 and 113:

112. In sub-section (5), line 24, to delete the words "in his opinion" and substitute the words "in agreement with the Maize Milling Advisory Committee he is of opinion that".

113. In sub-section (5), to delete paragraphs (a) and (b).

When amendment 112 was put down I had expected that a maize milling advisory committee would have been constituted under this Bill. That has not been done, but I understand that the Minister has said that, under another Act, he intends to set up such an advisory committee.

Comment on this

I am taking power under another Act to do so.

Comment on this
Mr. Lynch

The Minister intends to set up a maize milling advisory committee?

Comment on this

Yes.

Comment on this
Mr. Lynch

If I got an assurance that, when that committee has been set up, it would be consulted in regard to matters of this kind, I would be prepared to withdraw my amendment.

Comment on this

I am not sure. I wonder would it be in the interest of the person who is applying to consult the advisory committee? I think they would be very much inclined to be against any more licences being granted.

Comment on this
Mr. Lynch

I imagine that, for the Minister's own protection, it would be advisable for him to take a step of that kind. There may be allegations that favouritism is shown or something of that nature and the Minister, I think, should take every possible step to prevent any such allegation being made. No such allegation could be made if he had consulted the maize milling advisory committee even though he might not necessarily act on their recommendation.

Comment on this

The Minister must consider this amendment in relation to the Bill as it is at present drawn and not as it is proposed to be amended by a later amendment. At the moment, the Minister has power to decide, not merely what is in (c), namely, that the registration of the applicant is undesirable in the public interest having regard to the number of persons already registered on such register—he might have passed a favourable judgment on that and said that it is not undesirable in the public interest to have new entrants into the milling business— but he can also decide to throw out the application on the ground that the premises are not suitable or that the premises or equipment are not in a state of good repair. Surely, these are two matters, apart from (c), on which the Minister might, with advantage, consult that committee he is going to set up under some other Act. I agree that it would be undesirable to consult them with regard to (c), because I think the tendency, under all the provisions of this Bill, is to associate these bodies into rings, and if they are to be asked whether new entrants will be allowed into their ring, clearly they will go against them, but certainly I think they should be consulted on the question as to whether the premises are suitable or the premises and equipment are in good repair.

Comment on this

It will be necessary for the working of this Bill to have milling experts on the staff of the Department of Agriculture and they would appear to be the best people to consult in regard to premises and so on.

Comment on this

We were told yesterday, on the financial resolution, that the staff that would be required this year would not entail a cost of more than £1,500, and in no year would it entail a cost of more than £4,000. Does it mean that the year this Bill is going to operate we are going to get experts, in addition to the staff required, and that the total cost will not be more than £4,000?

Comment on this

The experts we will require under this Bill will be two milling experts.

Comment on this

Two milling experts at £1,500 yearly. That is £750 each. I wonder what the Civil Service will say to the introduction of experts at these salaries?

Comment on this
Mr. Lynch

Having regard to the subsequent sub-section in regard to premises, as far as I see no matter how dilapidated the premises may be, or how inadequate the equipment, if the applicant has been milling during the required period he will have power.

Comment on this

That is true.

Comment on this
Mr. Lynch

There is really no point at all in having that provision there about premises and equipment in view of the next sub-section.

Comment on this

Sub-section 5 would apply to new applicants.

Comment on this

It will apply to new applicants where the Minister thinks the premises, in respect of which the application is made, are not in good order and repair.

Comment on this

It does not apply to those at present engaged in the milling industry. They are saved by sub-section 6.

Comment on this

I am speaking of new applicants. Still here we have power given the Minister with regard to new applicants. He is going to decide whether their premises are suitable and if their equipment is in repair. If a man proposes to establish maize milling he ought to be the best judge whether the premises are suitable and if they are in good order and repair. If not he will soon go out of business. Why not let business have a part some time?

Comment on this

I would be almost tempted again to go back and vary the Dairy Produce Act. People were put out of that business.

Comment on this

What business?

Comment on this

Exporters of eggs and the manufacture of dairy produce. If their premises were not suitable they were put out of business.

Comment on this

I am glad we have the Minister at last wrapping the Cumann na nGaedheal flag around him. He is the third to do so.

Comment on this

I am pointing out how we are merely adapting what Cumann na nGaedheal did. We could go a good deal further before we would be as bad as Cumann na nGaedheal.

Comment on this

The point is that we have not yet got any equation of the Eggs Act to this.

Comment on this

We know that eggs are different.

Comment on this

The exporting of eggs.

Comment on this

I quoted the manufacturers of dairy produce.

Comment on this

I do not accept that comparison.

Comment on this

I must say that I had the unpleasant duty of withdrawing a licence from a man under the Dairy Produce Act.

Comment on this

I imagine it could be unpleasant for the Minister, whose whole idea is to demoralise the country by subsidies and flapdoodle of every kind.

Comment on this

We are going to be stricter in this.

Comment on this
Mr. Lynch

I move amendments 114 and 115:—

In sub-section (5), (c), line 31, after the word "register" to insert the words "or likely to be registered."

In sub-section (5), (c), line 32, after the word "register" to insert the words "under the next subsequent sub-section."

The insertion of the amendments would improve and clarify the section.

Comment on this

I think the point is covered, but I am quite prepared to accept it.

Comment on this

Will the Minister say where it is covered?

Comment on this

In sub-section 6.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Amendment 117 seems superfluous, but I am prepared to hear the Deputy on it.

Comment on this

I move amendment 117:—

In sub-section (2), line 55, after the word "applicant" to insert the words "but subject to the provisions of that section."

We have regulations laid down for registration of premises and they run that certain people "must" get premises registered and that certain others "may" get them registered. Then we come to the registration of new premises. I want to have it that the registration of the new premises shall run exactly on the lines of Section 47. If a person has been already in business, and has occupied more than one premises he will be registered in respect of one or two premises and will not be limited to a single set of premises. I think that is the intention of the section, but it is not in it.

Comment on this

That is the intention of the section. I do not think the amendments are required.

Comment on this

Let me point out that sub-section (1) merely states that any person who is registered "may" apply to be registered in respect of additional premises, and the Minister "may," subject to the provisions of this section, register them. When we look at the provisions of the section they relate only to provisions which may nullify the application, because the next section only talks about refusing to register. Under the sub-section, a man may apply, and shall, subject to the provisions of the section, be registered, but we come later to a subsequent provision and find it only applies to refusal. The obligation is carried forward under Section 47. Is it not clear that there is under Section 47 an obligation on the Minister to register premises if a man had been in the business. Is there the same obligation to register other premises than the first lot, if a man had been using them in the business previously? That is what I want to achieve. I do not think that is in the section.

Comment on this

I am advised that the section, as it stands, would have that effect. That is to say, the registration of additional premises other than those on the register will have to be on the same conditions of registration as those in which he is now milling maize.

Comment on this

All I can say is that it is nowhere in the section. The first sub-section says that a person may apply, and that the Minister "may" register, subject to the provisions of the section. Under this section, there is nothing to oblige the Minister to register. Sub-section (2) deals entirely with refusal. Where is the obligation? However, leave it alone.

Comment on this

I move amendment 118:—

At the end of sub-section (2), line 57, to add the words "but shall not refuse to register an applicant for registration in respect of additional premises in any register kept by him if such additional premises had in fact been used by the applicant for the purposes of his business during any part of the appointed period as defined in the preceding section, or if such additional premises are required by the applicant in substitution for other premises used by the applicant for the purpose of his business during any part of the appointed period so defined, or as a necessary addition to premises previously so used."

My amendment is much on the same lines as the previous one, but I think it makes the point clearer. I do not think this matter is covered. The latter part of the amendment would not be covered by anything in the preceding section. If any miller or person in any other business was to carry on successfully it would be necessary, on occasions, to make additions, or to substitute new buildings for old ones, maybe in a different place. It is not asking too much of the Minister to take from him the powers of refusal of a licence for additional premises under such circumstances. I am of the opinion that they are not covered by anything in the section. They are not covered certainly by anything under Section 48.

Comment on this

Might I add to what Deputy Bennett said that amendment 118 might be divided into three sections. If Section 48 is so divided it would cover additional premises acquired in substitution for other premises used by the applicant for the purpose of his business during any part of the appointed period defined, or as a necessary addition to premises previously so used. Let me take the second of those—substituted premises. This runs in a series of pairs. Sub-section 6 of 47 is the one which obliges the Minister to register, or rather "that he shall not refuse to register an applicant for registration in the register of maize millers in respect of any premises." That seems to be wide enough, but the limitation occurs in the next phrase: "if such applicant was bona fide engaged in the business of milling maize at such premises." Is it not clear enough that the Minister has to give a licence in respect of particular premises used? Supposing the premises are burned down, does not Deputy Bennett's amendment cover that?

The other point is that a man may be carrying on a business and the business has outgrown his original intention, and he wants to add to it. He puts part of his machinery into the new development, but it is part of the same mill. Is that man bound to get a licence for this addition which he has made to his business? It is the same business but he wants to get additional machinery to carry on developments in that business. That position is not covered by the section.

Comment on this

With regard to the points raised by the Deputy as to a man's premises being burned down and his wanting to replace them by another building and also the point of a man carrying on the business of maize milling wanting to add to his business, he is entitled under Section 48 to register additional premises. That would appear to cover the first part of Deputy Bennett's amendment.

Comment on this

Section 48 does not empower the Minister to do that subject to the provision of this amendment. It does not give you the power of the preceding section, as Deputy McGilligan pointed out.

Comment on this

I think not.

Comment on this

I have been advised by the legal advisers at our disposal that Section 48 does give security to the people who want additional premises. If the man wants to get additional premises, he need not show that they are any addition. He can get them in any case. That would be covered by the term "additional premises" and this amendment would only mean adding what is unnecessary.

Comment on this

If it clarifies what is meant by the Section, there can be no great objection to it. Still, whatever the Minister is advised as to the first part of the amendment being covered. I am of opinion that the first section in Section 48 does not refer explicitly to Section 47. The Minister says that it does, but it is doubtful in my mind and in the minds of many members of this House whether that is so. If it does, all right, but if the only objection the Minister has to it is that it makes what is clear more clear I do not see why he should resist the amendment.

Comment on this

I do not think that it makes it more clear, subject to the draftsman changing it.

Comment on this

It does appear to us, subject to the draftsman changing it, that it is not covered by the Section. We are not satisfied that the Bill might be so interpreted by other authorities. Would the Minister re-consider putting the amendment in some other words?

Comment on this

All I can do is to consult the draftsman again, but I think it is all right.

Comment on this

I propose amendment 120 which means the adding of three new sub-sections to Section 51. We have no provision in the Bill for the return in case the registration was cancelled. This amendment is to provide that it would be returned.

At the end of the section to add three new sub-sections as follows:—

"(2) Whenever the appropriate Minister has issued to a person who is registered in any register kept by that Minister a certificate of such registration and such person ceases to be registered in such register, the person to whom such certificate was issued shall within three days or (where such person is dead) the personal representative of such person shall within one month after such death deliver to that Minister such certificate of registration.

(3) If any person who is required by the next preceding sub-section to deliver up a certificate of registration fails or neglects so to do in accordance with the said sub-section, such person shall be guilty of an offence under this section and shall be liable on summary conviction thereof to a fine not exceeding two pounds and to a further fine not exceeding five shillings for every day during which such offence is continued.

(4) An offence under this section in relation to a certificate issued under this section by the Minister for Industry and Commerce may be prosecuted by or at the suit of that Minister as prosecutor, and an offence under this section in relation to a certificate issued under this section by the Minister for Agriculture may be prosecuted by or at the suit of the Minister as prosecutor."

Comment on this

The following amendment (No. 121) is in the name of Deputy Dillon:—

In sub-section (3), line 61, to delete the figures "II" and substitute therefor the figures "III."

This is an amendment merely to change the penalties. That is to say, that for an offence under this section the defendant shall not be liable to the penalty of imprisonment that is scheduled in Part II of the section, but should be subject to a fine as set out in Part III of the Schedule. I think that an offence of this kind does not justify imprisonment.

Comment on this

I regard this section which has regard to the returns to be made by registered persons, as very important.

Comment on this

You must have imprisonment?

Comment on this

We must have powers of imprisonment.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 122.

Before sub-section (4) to insert a new sub-section as follows:—

An appeal shall lie in accordance with Section 18 of the Courts of Justice Act, 1928 (No. 15 of 1928), against any conviction under the next preceding sub-section.

I should like to get the Minister's view on that particular matter, as to whether there is to be an appeal to the High Court as provided by the Act of 1928.

Comment on this

I am advised that the right of appeal under the Act of 1928 applies to all criminal cases whether the offences come under an Act passed before or after that Act.

Comment on this

That is the Act of 1928 works forward and takes this in?

Comment on this

Yes. The amendment is unnecessary.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

This is the first of a number of similar amendments aiming at an appeal. I presume they all stand under this decision.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 123:—

In sub-section (2), line 21, after the word "be" to insert the words "prescribe and."

This is again offered to try to get some publicity for the arrangements the Minister is making. Has he any objection to consider that, as he has promised to consider various other suggestions?

Comment on this

You cannot prescribe a thing in a notice. The sub-section would read with the amendment "particulars in relation to any wheat sown by him as may be prescribed and specified in such notice." I do not know how that could be done.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 125:—

In sub-section (3), line 28, to delete the figure "II" and substitute the figure "III."

I rise merely on this amendment to ask the Minister to consider that he is dealing here with a body of people who have not been making returns of this nature. He is dealing with a somewhat different class of people from those he has been dealing with up to the present. In this particular section he is dealing with the ordinary farmer throughout the country. The maximum penalty may be imprisonment, and I doubt if the Minister should ask here for imprisonment, because it will undoubtedly be difficult for the ordinary farmer to make the prompt return required under this particular section. I think owing to the class of people referred to here the plea for the mitigation of the penalty stands on stronger grounds than the previous pleas which we put forward.

Comment on this

I am inclined to agree with the Deputy's statement.

Comment on this

Taking the circumstances of the ordinary farmer into account it is rather too hard.

Comment on this

The term "false or misleading" in sub-section (3) is rather severe.

Comment on this

If it were inadvertently false or misleading the court would not inflict any penalty.

Comment on this

Would you put in "careless" then?

Comment on this

I do not know whether we could go so far as that. There may be wanton carelessness.

Comment on this

The Minister should know that the answers he would get in some cases, while quite clear perhaps to the people who prepare them, might mislead his officials.

Comment on this

The Deputy knows that the Government Department would not be too hard on them then.

Comment on this

I suggest that the Minister should consider that matter when he is considering the mitigation of the penalty.

Comment on this

Might I call the Minister's attention to the date, the 30th April, and suggest that it might be changed to the 15th May? It is quite possible that all the wheat might not be sown on the 15th April.

Comment on this

The point about that is that sometimes you do not get returns at the proper date and you have to send out a second whip. In cases like that it would probably be later than the 15th May before you would get the return.

Comment on this

I move amendment 126:—

In sub-section (1), page 23, line 37, after the word "premises" to insert the words "or at such other associated premises owned by such person as shall have been designated by such person for a specified time for the keeping of the required records and notified to the Minister for Industry and Commerce."

Again, in a rather similar case dealing with the mills, the Minister agreed to consider the advisability of introducing an amendment in regard to where these registers should be kept. This deals with the importers, and I suggest that a similar provision should be made here, that so long as the place is designated, and so long as the Minister knows where he can get the registers and get at them, that should be sufficient.

Comment on this

I agreed to consider that, but I stated that there would be a condition that the offices would not be in point of distance too far away from the mills.

Comment on this

May I ask the Minister to consider it with quite an open mind, and that in this case, as in the case of the millers, he should not consider the convenience of the officials, but consider the running of the business itself? Whereas you may have three or four business premises or mills you may have only one central office. The inconvenience of the officials should not be allowed to weigh against the serious interference that may be caused to the business.

Comment on this

I move amendment 127:—

In sub-section (1), page 23, lines 43, 46 and 47, to delete the word "dispositions" where it occurs and substitute the word "sales."

I just want to get information on this as to what exactly besides sales the Minister means by the word "dispositions."

Comment on this

There might possibly be other things. A maize miller may have a shop, and he might be transferring to his own shop for sale there, or he might dispose of some stuff that would be inferior. He may have to destroy it. He may have to dispose of some stuff in compound stuffs. In any case, "dispositions" would include the whole lot. It is a wider term.

Comment on this

Would that mean for instance that the officials would have the right to pursue the stuff if it were mixed by some secret process and that the importer would be bound to reveal that secret process? Would it not be better to enumerate the different things which the Minister has in mind? The objection to the word "dispositions" is that it is too vague. What are precisely its merits in the Minister's eyes seems to make it objectionable from the point of view of a person who may have a secret mixing process and who is liable to be compelled to reveal that process.

Comment on this

The point in regard to inquiring into secret processes may come up on the section dealing with feeding stuffs.

Comment on this

Would the Minister consider such a man when he is dealing with the matter?

Comment on this

I move amendment 129:—

In sub-section (1), page 23, line 48, to delete the word "twelve" and substitute the word "twenty-four."

Comment on this

On behalf of Deputy O'Neill I move amendment 131:—

In sub-section (2), page 23, lines 56 and 57 to delete the words "in the form prescribed by the Minister for Agriculture."

We have been discussing for a long time this evening difficulties with regard to the keeping of registers, the situation of offices and other matters. To add to the difficulties of the millers they are now asked not only to keep records but to keep them on certain forms. We all know that departmental and Government forms are rather difficult to keep. One could easily make a little mistake and that might render one liable to be imprisoned by the Minister for Agriculture or the Minister for Industry and Commerce. The millers may be relied on to keep their records in a very good way and in a manner that will satisfy the Minister. The amendment asks for the deletion of the words set out.

Comment on this

The difficulty about this is that one would require to have some knowledge of accountancy in relation to the business of millers to appreciate the significance of this amendment. If the Deputy who moved the amendment got an assurance that whatever forms were prescribed would conform, as nearly as possible, to those the millers have been accustomed to keep it might satisfy him. Any alteration in the manner in which the information must be kept would be a matter of much concern to the millers. There are various Government forms which prescribe different methods for the making up of accounts and so on. These are objectionable to business people who have their own methods of keeping their accounts, the methods to which they have been accustomed for years. I take it the fear behind the amendment is that a whole new series of forms will be prescribed with which the millers will not be familiar.

Comment on this

This prescribed form will be drawn up in consultation with the Advisory Committee. Naturally we would call the Advisory Committee together and put our form before them.

Comment on this

On that undertaking I withdraw the amendment.

Comment on this

I move amendment 132:

In sub-section (2) (c), page 24, line 4, to insert after the word "cereals" the word "milled."

This is a drafting amendment.

Comment on this

On behalf of Deputy O'Neill I move amendment 135:

In sub-section (2) (e), page 24, to delete all after the word "stuffs," line 12, to the end of the paragraph and substitute the following:—"such records of the quantities of all raw materials brought on to the premises for the manufacture of compound feeding stuffs, of the quantities of all compound feeding stuffs manufactured on such premises, and of all disposals of such feeding stuffs as may be required for the purpose of supervising and enforcing the provisions of a licence granted under Part VI of this Act: provided that nothing hereby required shall be construed as obliging the production of any information relating to or disclosing the composition of any special mixture or any secret process used by the person registered."

The object of the amendment is to protect the secret processes and prescriptions which may be of great value to the owners of mills. These prescriptions relate principally to compound feeding stuffs. Some millers, I understand, have paid considerable sums of money for these secret processes, and naturally will not want to make the secrets available to inspectors of the Department when they visit their mills. The amendment seeks to ensure that the millowners will be safeguarded to the extent at all events that no inspector, acting under the authority of the Minister, will have the right to ask for these secret processes and prescriptions.

Comment on this

Perhaps it is just as well that I should make it clear now that inspectors will have the right to inquire into such matters. Otherwise we could not carry out the clause about compound feeding stuffs. We want to see that the compound feeding stuffs turned out will be good in every way as feeding stuffs and also fair value for the money paid for them. We could not do that unless we had this power. Apart from that we will need to be able to trace the maize and other cereals through their different stages in the mill. We will require to have power to trace where these go to. In addition we may have to examine the books of the miller to see in what mixtures they went. Of course these officials will be bound by the Official Secrets Act, and that should be sufficient protection for the manufacturer. I do not think myself that there is much in those secrets.

Comment on this

The question is, is it the secrets that you want?

Comment on this

No. We do not want them, but we may come on them inadvertently.

Comment on this

There is just one thing about the Official Secrets Act. If the Minister is correct in saying that he does not want the secrets, then the information that is given to the official does not matter. If, on the other hand, it were required for that purpose, then the Official Secrets Act will not be worth the paper it is written on.

Comment on this

I think the Minister was doubtful about the value of the Official Secrets Act because I think at first he was going to complete his sentence by saying "if that is of any use," but changed it and said that the Official Secrets Act ought to be sufficient protection. Possibly he had some doubt in his mind.

Comment on this

What I did doubt was the value of the secret.

Comment on this

Surely that is a matter for the people who have the secrets to produce these peculiar proprietary stuffs. I did not gather that from the Minister's statements on previous amendments in which reference was made to the word "dispositions." I thought he was quite willing to consider how this could be dealt with. I do not know how many officials in the way of inspectors the Minister will have to administer this Act. Has he any idea?

Comment on this

If necessary, we could confine the inspection of compound feeding stuffs to one inspector, if a case be made about these secret processes.

Comment on this

I would prefer if the work were divided, and not have all this information concentrated in one person.

Comment on this

So far as these proprietary feeding stuffs are concerned, the Minister may have his views as to their value as feeding stuffs in his capacity as Minister for Agriculture, but I suggest that the only persons who can have views of their commercial value are the public or the owners of those particular secrets. It would be a very serious thing if this Bill could be used so that these secrets could be made known to quite a number of people. I do not know what the rank of the inspectors to be appointed will be or what their salaries will be. These are matters that now become important if the inspectors are to be in a position to inquire into and to have full knowledge of these things. Certainly the position, rank and salary of the inspectors will then become a matter of importance. Could the Minister give us any idea as to the type of man he has in mind for the position of inspector dealing with this?

Comment on this

At the present time we have power to take a sample of feeding stuff, analyse it and get the amount of carbohydrates and proteins which it contains. I think as far as that goes if it proves satisfactory and if it is found that the price is not exorbitant we would not go any further into an inquiry, but if we felt that it was a case of a real fraud we would be entitled to go into it and find out if it was a fraud. Some few years ago the Department of Agriculture knew that there was a compound feeding stuff sold in this country for about eight times its real value. They exposed that, but all they could do was to publish the matter. They could not go any further. It was not very effective. We want to be effective, and to get the real contents of that stuff. Then we can warn the manufacturer that he cannot continue it, and if he does so we can refuse to give the licence.

Comment on this

These are two different methods of getting information. If you get information by analysis you can utilise this information in the same way as a person in the revenue service could get information about clients in a bank, but the information in the two cases would be different. The information you get by analysis is one thing, but the information by this backdoor method is another thing if you utilise it for another purpose altogether. It may not be the mere question of the actual proportion of the contents of the compound, but the actual way in which the process is carried out. You are using the information given in the Bill and not merely utilising it yourself, but the secret is no longer a secret of the owner. The secret is given to an official and we do not really know what his position is.

Comment on this

This matter will again come on under the feeding stuffs section, but still it was necessary to discuss it here on account of this amendment.

Comment on this

I quite agree. The suggestion that the Minister made earlier that it would come up under the section dealing with the feeding stuffs is not sufficient because it is here under this section that the right is given. It may have reference to the compound feeding stuffs, but an opportunity of getting the information is given here.

Comment on this

What we are dealing with is the composition of maize and the home-grown feeding stuffs. If there is poultry meal or pig meal for which the proprietor claims to have a secret —but which we are informed at the present time is only a myth—he certainly will not object to making known the amount of maize in the feeding stuff. He may object to the official knowing the amount of lime or iodine or any of the other things that work the miracle.

Comment on this

That is precisely where the difficulty is, the wording is so vague that you do not know what is to happen to it.

Comment on this

But we are only dealing with the amount of maize here.

Comment on this

We will go into this matter again when we see what is done under the other section.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

This amendment is governed by amendment 127. We had it twice already.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

These amendments are analagous to amendments 69 and 70. Amendment 137 is not moved and amendment 138 is agreed to.

The following amendments were on the Paper:

139. In sub-section (3), line 24, after the word "distillers" to insert the words "or premises associated therewith."—(Patrick McGilligan.)

140. In sub-section (3), line 25, to delete the word "such record is kept at premises" and substitute the words "the premises to which such record relates are."—(James M. Dillon.)

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

These are similar to amendment 68.

Comment on this

These will be reconsidered.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

We will take them as not moved.

Amendment 141:—

In sub-section (3), line 28, after the word "Agriculture" to insert the words "on production of his authorisation in writing as such inspector."—(James M. Dillon.).

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Amendment 141 is decided by amendment 79.

Comment on this

The Minister has already promised to deal with that point. I presume the same applies to this particular part of the Bill.

Comment on this

This amendment is really a further attempt to restrain the inquisitorial powers of the Minister and his officials. The section reads ... "and it shall be the duty of the person liable under this section to keep such record to produce for the inspection of such inspector on demand such record and also all invoices, consignment notes, receipts and other documents ... reasonably demanded by such inspector for the purpose of verifying any entry in or explaining any omission from such record." Now the verification of an entry might assume considerable proportions if free scope were given to the Minister and his officials. It may be that the official would insist on inquiring into the actual profits earned by the owner of the firm concerned; into the actual working costs of the concern and many other matters of a purely private nature which it appears to the owner are of no use and of no advantage to the official in the carrying out of his duties. But on account of the way in which the section is worded there is no doubt that under the Bill the Minister is given very wide authority and naturally the section has caused a great deal of uneasiness in the minds of millers because they do not know if this Bill is passed into law what sort of information the official may ask or demand. It appears that the section as worded gives the official a right to demand the actual working costs, the rate of wages paid to the men working on the premises and so on. It seems to me that that is an entirely unreasonable position and I hope the Minister will take some steps to amend the section so as to make it quite clear that when his officials do visit mills of that kind carrying on this business that they will be restricted to the information necessary for them.

Comment on this

This point was argued before on another question and I demonstrated on that occasion that it would not be possible to confine the section as the Deputy suggests. It is clear that the inspector would not have the power that the Deputy says he would have. The inspector is only entitled to "demand invoices consignment notes and so on for the purpose of verifying any entry in or explaining any omission from such record." If the owner of the premises felt that the inspector was exceeding his rights and was demanding some document that he could not reasonably require for the purpose of carrying on his duties, then he could reasonably refuse to give him the documents, and he has a good defence if he could establish that the document could not be reasonably required for the purpose of verifying the record. We must assume that the inspectors will be reasonable people, and that if they are not reasonable people the Minister will remove them.

Comment on this

What do they want "receipts" for?

Comment on this

For the purpose of verifying the record; they want the receipts for the sale.

Comment on this

Why for sale? I do not know that receipts are required for any sale.

Comment on this

The point is that these documents, ordinary business documents, should be made available for inspection. There might, for instance, be some suspicion of attempted fraud and the inspector might be anxious to verify certain matters by reference to the records. If the owner of the premises believes that the inspector is acting in excess of his authority and is demanding documents that are not necessary in the performance of his duty, then the owner can refuse to allow those documents to be inspected.

Comment on this

Has the Minister any objection to amendment 143?

Comment on this

That amendment is not necessary.

Comment on this

In my opinion, it will make the section clearer and more definite.

Comment on this

It is quite possible that there could be a misinterpretation in respect of this part of the section which might give an official the right to ask for certain private information which would not be quite necessary for the purpose of his investigations. Perhaps the Minister will consider between now and the Report Stage inserting a suitable amendment which will make it quite clear that the official will not be entitled to information relating, for example, to the working costs of a mill?

Comment on this

We asked the draftsman to frame the section so as to cover that possibility.

Comment on this

But the draftsman is not a business man. This thing of receipts appears to me to vitiate the whole measure. It would seem to me that an inspector might require to know the details of a man's entire affairs, as distinct altogether from whatever he might be engaged in manufacturing. Under this section the details of the private business of any person could be ascertained.

Comment on this

All the inspector will require will be documents to verify entries and things of that sort.

Comment on this

The sub-section states "all invoices, consignment notes, receipts and other documents ... reasonably demanded by such inspector." I cannot see how a man's private affairs will escape.

Comment on this

This section is so defined as to give the owner of the premises a good defence.

Comment on this