Private Business. - Agricultural Produce (Cereals) Bill, 1932—Committee (Resumed).
Contributions 609–816 of 816. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 4 parts.
No. 27 of 1932 ›
Has the Minister any objection to inserting the word "solely," as suggested in amendment 143?
Comment on this
There seems to be doubt expressed amongst the people concerned as to what this will leave them open to. If there is no harm in it, I do not see why the word should not go in. Surely, there can be no objection to finding out whether its insertion will upset the whole drafting of the section?
Comment on this
Do not give me any Act of Parliament as an example of good English, whatever else you do.
Comment on this
I will ask the draftsman about the word "solely" in order to see what limitation, if any, it will impose.
Comment on this
From what the Minister said a short time ago I think it would meet his wishes if the words "wilfully or negligently" were inserted before the word "fails" in the appropriate places in this sub-section. I believe that would remove the anomaly of finding a man guilty of an offence and sending him to prison for six months while all the time he would be absolutely innocent of moral guilt. Take the case of a director going away. Before he leaves he takes every precaution to have the necessary forms filled. When he comes back he finds that he has earned for himself an additional leave of absence of six months at the public expense although he would be entirely innocent of any crime. Take the man who always keeps his own records and who becomes ill. When he recovers he finds that he has secured a cheap rest for six months although he is absolutely innocent of criminal intent.
I agree that the section must be stringent, but I think it is going a little bit too far to have it so drawn that a man may, without his knowledge or consent, commit a criminal offence. The probabilities are that he might have done everything possible to avoid that. I wonder what would the Minister say if he found a similar section inserted in the Constitution (Amendment) Act? I am sure there would be a good deal of trouble about it. I think it is a mistake to strain the law. There is a well-known principle that a man ought not to be found guilty of an offence of which he is, at all events, morally innocent. If, as I suggest, the Minister inserts before the word "fails" in paragraphs (a), (b) and (c) the words "wilfully or negligently" I think it will meet the case.
Amendment 146 is in the following terms:—
In sub-section (4), line 51, to insert after the word "person" the words "unless such failure, or such false or misleading entry is due to a strike, to a lock-out, or to any circumstance outside the control of such persons."
This amendment deals with the same idea, but it strengthens and explains what I have said in respect of amendment 144. I suggest to the Minister that he might safely accept the suggestion I made in amendment 146. Somebody might raid the premises and take away the records. One can easily imagine dozens of instances where a man, without any negligence, might be in such a position that he would fail to produce the documents required by the inspector. To make that man liable to imprisonment would be straining the criminal law to breaking point.
Comment on this
I think that point is governed by amendment 50—"unless he satisfies the court that such failure was attributable to circumstances over which he had no control."
Comment on this
I agree that if the Minister would put into Section 55 a clause similar to that in amendment No. 50 it would meet the case. It would be well that the same idea should not be expressed in two different forms of words. That would completely cover it. If you put the same tag on to Section 55 that you have put on to Section 26, it would meet that portion of the case. But I would still press for the insertion of the words "wilfully or negligently.""Wilfully" alone might raise difficulties, judging by what the Minister for Agriculture said in connection with another section. "Wilfully" alone might not be strong enough here, because negligence might not be wilful, and it is quite right that a man who is guilty of negligence should be held to be guilty of an offence under this section.
Comment on this
It is clear that the section as it stands does not take away the licence-holder's right to plead in the court that the omission to keep the record, or the other offences under (a), (b) or (c), was not done wilfully or was occasioned by causes outside his control. The court would take that into account, but what the Deputy's amendment would require would be that the prosecutor should prove to the court that it was done wilfully.
Comment on this
That is so. It places the burden of proof on the prosecution and it would be impossible to prove wilfulness in the matter.
Comment on this
I do not think that the Minister is taking me up correctly. If what the Minister states were so, I should agree with the Minister. Though the burden of proof in criminal cases is cast on the prosecutor, all the prosecutor would have to prove in this case would be that the accounts were not, in fact, kept. Once that were done, it would be for the defendant to rebut the presumption of wilfulness and to show that the omission was not, in fact, wilful. In practice, the onus would be entirely on the defendant.
Comment on this
It is clear that it is essential for the proper carrying out of the Bill that these records should be kept. There must be a definite onus on the licence holder to keep the records. It is not a matter about which he can be careless. He is liable to severe penalties if he fails to keep the records. If he is prosecuted for failing to keep them or for failing to produce them when required by the inspector, he can plead, in mitigation of his offence, that his action was not done wilfully or that it was occasioned by causes outside his control. No doubt, the court will take that into account. It is essential that he should keep the records. In the case of (d), which deals with the deliberate falsifying of records or the putting in of a misleading entry in order to defraud the revenue or to defeat the purposes of the Bill in some way, the onus should, undoubtedly, be on the prosecution to show that it was done wilfully. But in the other case, the mere failure to keep records for any cause should be an offence, even though the court might say that the circumstances were such that no penalty should be inflicted. It is the duty of the person who gets a licence and who is responsible for keeping records to secure that staff shall be provided or other arrangements made to prevent any mishap arising which would mean that the records would not be available for inspection, if required.
Comment on this
I am sorry if I have not made myself clear. I quite agree with what the Minister has said, but everything he has said will apply equally well if the words "wilfully or negligently" are placed where I suggest they should be placed. I ask the Minister to consider that because, at present, the section creates a very dangerous precedent. If the Minister will consider the matter, he will find that the view he has expressed will not be in any way affected by inserting those words. On proof being given of the omission, the defendant will have to show (1) that he did not do it wilfully and (2) that he did not do it negligently. For instance, it might be said that he had completely forgotten it. That would not be wilful but it would be negligent. If the Minister decides to put in those words, he will find that they will not interfere with the view he has expressed, with which I am in agreement, as to the desirability of having ample power in the section for compelling the miller to keep these records.
Comment on this
I am advised that the insertion of the words would have the effect I mentioned and would create considerable difficulties in the operation of the Bill. I am prepared to have the significance of the insertion of the words examined, but if it would have the effect of making more difficult the punishment of people who fail to keep records, it will have to be turned down.
Comment on this
The amendment I suggest would eliminate carelessness, because carelessness or forgetfulness would not be wilful, but would come under "negligence." In lieu of amendment 146, the tag to Section 30 should, I think, be added to this also. It reads better than the amendment I have drafted and would be in conformity with the wording in another part of the Bill.
Comment on this
I am not going to intervene in the legal aspect of the case, as to where the onus of proof lies. I was, however, under the impression, as an ordinary layman, that murder must be wilful but that when the killing of the man is proven, the burden is not on the State to prove wilfulness but on the prisoner to prove that it was not wilful. I suggest that that is an analogous case to the case with which Deputy Wolfe has been dealing. Though, to constitute the crime of murder, there must be wilfulness and malice, if the killing has been brought home to the prisoner, the onus rests on him to establish that there was no wilfulness or malice. That is precisely the point that Deputy Wolfe was arguing.
Comment on this
There is also the point that this must be done within twenty-four hours. In the twenty-fifth hour a man is liable to prosecution if it is not done. The question of staff arrangements arises, and it is quite possible that a clerical staff would be kept only on certain days of the week. The writing up of a register or journal or any of those books ordinarily kept would not constitute a defence, because the records must be kept in a form prescribed by the Minister. It seems unreasonable to prosecute a man for not having this done in twenty-four hours.
Comment on this
"Wilfully or negligently" might meet my point, but I should like to consider the matter.
Comment on this
Subject to your approval, sir, these amendments might be conveniently taken together because the same idea runs through them. In sub-section (2) a peculiar provision is brought in which I agree is not entirely without precedent. There is, I think, one precedent where the same course was adopted in what was looked upon as emergency legislation during the Great War (sub-section read). There is a rather dangerous precedent for that sub-section which, I suggest should not be followed and that the words "purporting to be" in line 23 should be deleted. I am also suggesting that in line 24 and the following lines the words "by an officer" should be deleted and " under the seal of the appropriate Minister" should be substituted; and that all words after the words "appropriate Minister" should be deleted. These are the three alterations I suggest. I do not know whether reliance will be placed on the precedent, which is the only one I know of, and which is one that I think ought not to be followed, having regard to the exceptional circumstances in which it was adopted. Personally I think it is very drastic. If any one is prosecuting on behalf of the Minister all he has to do is to write out the necessary certificate on a piece of paper, sign it with any name he likes and hand it in, and it is evidence. I suggest that instead of that the old procedure, which existed before the Great War, and which is followed in another portion of this Bill, should be followed here. It is in Section 28 (2) of this Bill and it follows the procedure of the Land Commission Court, and the procedure of all courts, so far as I know, prior to this unusual and emergency legislation. It is as follows:—
In any proceedings by the Minister under this section to recover any sum from the holder of a milling licence the production of a certificate under the seal of the Minister certifying that such sum is due by such person shall be prima facie evidence of the facts so certified.
I suggest that there is no reason why in this Section 56 the procedure adopted in Section 28 should not be followed. I suggest that it is inconsistent, and that to have in Section 28 one method and one procedure and have that reversed as regards a somewhat similar undertaking in Section 56 would be wrong.
Again in sub-section (3) there is an extraordinary provision which is contrary, I think, to all precedent (sub-section read). The certificate produced might be absolutely false and the man prosecuted might have absolute evidence that it was false, but whether he was registered or not it would be said that the man had no right to make a defence although he had one, because the certificate was evidence. I never heard of such a thing before. Section 28 as drawn, was obviously taken from the Land Commission precedent which is a fairer one. I suggest as regards sub-section (3) to delete the word "conclusive" and substitute the words "prima facie." To have it otherwise would be absolutely unconstitutional and there could be no answer to it, I submit. In Section 28 the position is that it is under the seal of the Minister. It is there and it remains there as prima facie evidence and can only be dislodged by counter evidence, which cannot be given only in a very few cases. Even Ministerial books are sometimes wrong and Ministerial records sometimes get lost. In some Land Commission cases I have known the records to be wrong through no fault of the Land Commission officials. That might also be the case with the Minister's records, through no fault of his officials. This is very drastic, more drastic than any legislation that has ever come before the House. It is not a good precedent and is not one that should be followed. I suggest to the Minister that in this section he should adopt the procedure which he has adopted in Section 28. It will be doing the right and the wise thing and will really do no harm to the prosecution and will do no harm to the Department. With regard to the other amendments, they deal with Section 34. I have dealt with the first six— 162 to 167 inclusive.
Comment on this
We did not go back as far as the Emergency Bill that the Deputy refers to. As a matter of fact the clause is an exact copy out of the Agricultural Produce (Eggs) Act of 1924. However, that is no defence for it, I suppose. The same clause, I believe, is in the Dairy Produce (Fresh Meat) Act.
Comment on this
Yes. The Deputy should have been a little more active when the Agricultural Produce (Fresh Meat) Act was going through, because the same clause is there. A man might be hanged for having fresh meat on his premises just the same as under this.
Comment on this
Clause 2 of Section 28 is in a different form and after the very able case the Deputy has made I think it would be worth considering putting it the same as Section 28.
Comment on this
I move amendments 158 and 159:—
In sub-section (4) to delete paragraph (a).
In sub-section (4) to delete paragraph (b).
Amendment 158 deals with sub-section (4) and the amendment is to delete paragraph 4 (a). The paragraph reads:—
"Any person may—
(a) inspect any register on payment to the appropriate Minister of the fee of 1/-.
That is the clause which requires amendment. I suggest that it is a very tall order. There should be no objection to the Minister, for any purpose, granting leave to the parties interested to inspect the register, but the Minister has not yet issued his regulations, and there may be in his returns something that would be used by rival traders.
Comment on this
The name and address of the applicant and particulars of the premises, that is all would be on the register.
Comment on this
But under Section 46 you may make regulations. As I understand the position it is open—and properly open—to the Minister to make regulations, and from time to time he may find it necessary to get a considerable amount of information, for the proper working of the Act, which would be of assistance to rival traders. What useful purpose can be served by keeping Clause (a) of sub-section (4) in the Act?
Comment on this
We can only put in the name, address and particulars of the premises. That is all that can be put on the register.
Comment on this
There is something more. "In accordance with the immediately preceding section, the appropriate Minister shall, subject to the provisions of the next following section, enter in such register the name and address of the applicant and particulars of the premises specified in such application." There is some portion of the Act I suggest that gives the Minister power to make regulations.
Comment on this
There may be on that register, under the regulations to be made by the Minister, information that would be of advantage to another trader or to competitors or other persons, and it is not intended, I should think, that the register under this Act should be used for the assistance of creditors or rival traders. I do not want to say the Minister is likely to make such regulations, still I know there is a feeling amongst millers that this clause will lead to abuse. What I fail to see is why this clause is there at all. What purpose can it serve? Who wants to inspect the register? Is it to be open to the Press to go in, and on payment of 1/- inspect and publish a man's business.
Comment on this
If only the name and address are there, in the name of all that is wonderful, why would anyone want to look at that?
Comment on this
If the only information to be got from the register is information as to the nature of the premises, will not all that be met under section (c), under which a person can get a certificate that a certain specified person is not registered.
Comment on this
Let us consider the purpose of the clause. Can the Minister tell us how he envisages a person having that desire? What legitimate purpose is there for inspection of this register? That a person may want to see if an individual is on it? Is that right?
Comment on this
He can get that by asking the Minister to certify whether he is or is not registered.
Comment on this
If the Minister refuses to give the certificate that a person is not registered clearly he is registered.
Comment on this
A maize importer can only sell maize to a registered maize miller. A maize importer might like to have a list of the maize millers, so that he would know, every time he got an order from a miller, whether he is entitled to deal with him. He would be entitled to have the whole list.
Comment on this
Under Section 46, in addition to any further regulations the Minister may make, he shall enter on the register "the name and address of the applicant and particulars of the premises specified in such application in respect of which such registration is sought." What business has the public of knowing that? Is not that a matter between the Minister and the Miller?
Comment on this
What purpose could be served by publishing particulars of a man's mill, and the clause might be used for very malicious purposes. I suggest that clause (a) serves no useful purpose.
Comment on this
Could the Minister not consider it from the other angle? Let him leave out the fact that he has put a certain thing into the Bill and has got to stand over that for the moment. Why ought the register to be open for inspection? Why ought a person to be allowed to inspect it? I say you cannot have busybodies running around and inspecting the register and the only purpose that is legitimate is that a man would want to know is he entitled to deal with a certain person. That will always arise, I suggest, in relation to a particular person. A man would want to know "may I deal with Mr. X, of a particular place?" Under (c) he can get a certificate as to whether a man is on the register or not. What else is required? What information is a man entitled to get? I can see the difficulty that a person does not know whether he is entitled to deal with a certain man. He ought to be able to get a certificate that such man is registered and that he is entitled to deal with him. He could get that under (c). What more does he want?
Comment on this
Take the Eggs Acts, just to show the section was there. The fact that it was there perhaps induced the draftsman to put it in here. Even if it had not been in the Eggs Acts, there would be great necessity for it in this Act. A maize importer is not allowed to sell maize except to a registered maize miller. He must know whether the miller is registered or not before he will deal with him.
Comment on this
That is all he wants to know. Is a maize importer, under the Deputy's suggestion, to write up to the Minister every time he gets an order and say: "Is this man on your register or not?" It would be much more convenient for him to walk in and look at the register and get the whole list. In the same way with wheat dealers, and wheat importers, they can only deal with certain people.
Comment on this
Is not anyone of these people on the register entitled to get a certificate from the Minister stating that, under an earlier section?
Comment on this
I am going to deal with a certain man who wants to know if a person is registered. Could he not ask him to produce a certificate?
Comment on this
So the Deputy's way of settling the question would be for a maize importer to send his certificate every time to show he is registered.
Comment on this
What is the difficulty about this being in. The Deputy wants to raise all sorts of difficulties about anyone wanting to see the register of the list of names and address, and particulars. If anybody is curious enough, as Deputy McGilligan seems to think, and if there are a lot of curious people running around looking for information, why should we not take one shilling from them for their curiosity?
Comment on this
Then they are not covered. Amendments 160 and 161 stood in the name of Deputy Roddy:—
160. In sub-section (1), line 53, to delete the words "he may think fit" and substitute the words "is prescribed."
161. In sub-section (3), page 26, line 4, to delete the words "he may think fit" and substitute the words "is prescribed."
Comment on this
This is the same point as before—instead of leaving it to the Minister to publish in such manner as "he may think fit" that the Minister shall give notice to the House as to what he does think fit by having the matter covered by regulation. That regulation does not impose any limitation on the Minister. It only means he will notify the House of what he is doing.
Comment on this
They do not refer, exactly, to the same things. Number 161 is in regard to statistical returns. On Section 57, I did not understand amendment 161 had been dealt with at all.
Comment on this
Yes, because they have not by any means the same reference. Amendment 160 refers to the Minister publishing in such manner as he may think fit certain matters entered in the register. Then we come on to sub-section (3).
"The appropriate Minister may from time to time collect and publish such statistical information (including statistics derived from returns made to him pursuant to this Part of this Act) with respect to the extent of the businesses carried on by persons registered in any register kept by him as he may think fit."
Whatever is to be said for letting the minor matters of the manner in which these things are to be published be as the Minister thinks fit, surely there is a great point here—the collection of statistical material. If it were clear that this is governed by the secrecy which is imposed under the Statistical Act itself, then of course a certain amount of the anxiety would be cleared away, but I rather take it, that this is outside the Statistics Act, and that there is not the same secrecy imposed, and that the Minister might, therefore, err in his judgment and publish matters which would give away the extent of an individual's business—an event which of course we always guard against in the promulgation of any information so derived.
Comment on this
That is another point. It is not the point made by the Deputy's amendments. The mere prescribing of the form and manner in which information will be published will not safeguard the position, if, in fact, statistical information, which should not be published, will be published.
Comment on this
It will give the House an opportunity of seeking that if he so published it, it conflicts with the secrecy previously imposed. I would rather have the other situation brought about, that this is entirely governed by what was previously put in and definitely fought for in this House, the necessary secrecy with regard to statistical matters.
Comment on this
Amendment 162 is governed by the previous arrangement. I move amendment 163:—
In sub-section (1), line 5, after the word "times" to insert the words "during office hours."
No. 163 is "during office hours." Is it being taken that way? Am I to understand the Minister is accepting 163?
Comment on this
An inspector must be entitled at all reasonable times to enter a flour mill. Flour mills work three shifts a day, but office hours are defined from 10 to 5. An inspector must be entitled to enter flour mills any time the mill is working.
Comment on this
Why not say during either office hours or any other hours in which the mill is, in fact, working?
Comment on this
That is, amendment 151. That only relates to office hours. The phrase "all times" is indefensible.
Comment on this
If you were to enter at a time the mill was not working you could be accused of housebreaking.
Comment on this
I am getting quite a number of legal defences from the Minister for Agriculture.
Can we get any sort of authority for that—that any attempt to enter a mill when the mill is not working is to be regarded as housebreaking?
Comment on this
If an inspector tries to get into a mill when the doors and windows are locked he certainly would be accused of housebreaking.
Comment on this
And there would be no penalty on the person who has not been there to let him in during those hours? That is a better situation. It is not in the section.
Comment on this
I understood that the Minister for Industry and Commerce objected to the phrase "during office hours"?
Comment on this
Would the Minister agree to "during office hours" or, "alternatively, during working hours," the hours when, in fact, the mill is working?
Comment on this
I move amendment 164:—
In sub-section (1) (a), lines 14 and 19, to insert after the word "mixture" the words "raw materials for the manufacture of compound feeding stuffs."
Raw materials for the manufacture of compound feeding stuffs were omitted. They should be inserted.
Comment on this
Will amendment No. 165:—
In sub-section (2), line 25, after the word "times" to insert the words "during office hours"
be considered?
Comment on this
Does the Minister think so? I should think not, if consideration is given to it. This refers to wheat growing. What are the office hours or the reasonable time for growing wheat, except growing it in glass houses as before?
Comment on this
Would the Minister say if there are enough inspectors in the Department to carry out all the purposes of the Act or will there be some new jobs created?
Comment on this
I move amendments 170 and 171:
170. In sub-section (2), page 26, line 59, after the word "which" to insert the words "the person registered agrees that."
171. In sub-section (2), lines 59-60, to delete the words "appears to him to be" and substitute therefor the word "is."
The reason I move these amendments is that it seems to me that the person registered ought to have some say in the matter of the alteration of the registration. I do not think it is right that the Minister should have power to alter without reference to the persons concerned. I do not think there is any use in arguing it further but it appears to me that it is a desirable amendment.
Comment on this
I do not think these amendments are necessary. As the sub-section stands it sets out the common form that is used in all other Bills.
Comment on this
Is there any answer to them except tradition? We might as well debate them, if they are not going to be replied to. At the moment, the proposal is that the Minister may alter any registration and any register in any respect in which such registration appears to him to be erroneous and misleading. Deputy Bennett moves to change that and to prescribe that the Minister may alter it where there is agreement, after notice given to the person registered, that the entry is in fact erroneous and misleading. Why object to that? If it is a matter of fact that can be shown to the person, surely he will be as anxious as the Minister to get a correct entry made? Why not have it done with his approval? That is all that Deputy Bennett sets out to have.
Comment on this
For keeping it; but for supplying the information, it is the person who has asked to be registered.
Comment on this
The argument that the Minister must have the final word will apply whether the entry was erroneous or misleading or not.
Comment on this
I move amendment 173:—
In sub-section (3) (a), line 65, to delete the words "whether fraudulent or innocent".
I respectfully suggest to the House that the provision in this section is one which is absolutely without precedent, and that it is an innovation to put into a statute a declaration that "registration was procured through fraud or by misrepresentation whether fraudulent or innocent." I submit that if a man makes an estimate as to the height of a house, or as to its width, and if he makes a mistake, that would be an instance of misrepresentation, and in that case the Minister might cancel his registration. Such a provision is entirely without precedent and in the best interests of the State should not be allowed to stand.
Comment on this
In the first place, it is not without precedent, as we can refer to a decision in this case also. The fact is that this provision has been adopted word for word from the provisions of Acts passed by this House. I believe the sub-section is there in order to ensure the accuracy of the records. If, in fact, registration was secured by fraud or misrepresentation, whether such misrepresentation was fraudulent or innocent, the Minister should have power to revoke the registration. That is all that is implied.
Comment on this
The fact was merely referred to to show that the Deputy was wrong in saying that it was a precedent.
Comment on this
Surely not. I want to ask if the words apply to misdemeanours, or only to the last phrase. If the phrase is going to be kept it is better to have it drafted so as to be clear as to the meaning. How could you have an innocent fraud? If it is only to apply to misdemeanour or misrepresentation, is there any equity at all in taking power to cancel a registration, where the Minister is satisfied that the misrepresentation has been innocent?
Comment on this
Surely the Deputy considered that when he decided to support the Eggs and the Butter Acts?
Comment on this
Section 10 (3) of the Agricultural Produce (Eggs) Act says:
The Minister may ... cancel the registration of any premises ... if he is satisfied (a) that the registration of the premises was procured by fraud or by misrepresentation, whether fraudulent or innocent.
The Government of which the Deputy was a member passed that Act.
Comment on this
As no evidence is given, well and good, we will take it that way. What were the circumstances of the Eggs Act? Was the licence or the registration of the premises to be withdrawn? Were they the only premises a man had? Was it with regard to the export business in eggs or what? When we know these things we will know what the circumstances are. We will know further whether this particular phrase had the approval of the representatives of the industry. Then we will understand if there is equation, and the claim why it is there. It should not be there, if it is there under circumstances at all comparable to this, because a man's livelihood, and the premises he has got registered, may be broken on the definite statement of the Minister, that there has been innocent misrepresentation. That is beyond the bounds of all justice, and no check by the Government is going to have the slightest effect. That is not justice in this Bill.
Comment on this
They deal with quite different things. Because an amendment in similar language has been put down it by no means follows that they are the same kind.
Comment on this
They appear to be similar but there is power of appeal applicable to a different registration.
Comment on this
The object is the same, to remove an injustice, but it is not applicable to the particular section here related. If the amendment is not going to be moved I will speak on the section.
Comment on this
I move amendment 177.
The witnesses will be before the court, and the District Justice, or the Circuit Judge on appeal, will have an opportunity of judging on the facts, the guilt or the innocence of the defendant I think it would not be unreasonable to give the Justice power to make a recommendation. He has the sworn testimony and hears both sides, and all that can be urged on behalf of the appeal, so that a man will have a fair trial. If that is not done, and if a man is tried in Dublin behind his back he will not be satisfied. He cannot be blamed for that. I think the first amendment might be usefully accepted. As to amendment 178 I think the wording there provides an alternative. As a safety valve I suggest inserting the words in amendment 179. It would be manifestly unfair for a man who gets the right of appeal under Section 18 of the Courts of Justice Act, on the one hand, to have it taken away on the other hand, if pending the hearing of the appeal he loses his licence.
Comment on this
That is not the same. This is a matter which has been argued before with regard to the licence for flour millers, I think. It was pointed out by the Minister for Industry and Commerce that the Minister had power to alter, or cancel, registration in case the Minister is satisfied of certain things, amongst them that the registered person has been convicted of an offence under this Act. Deputy Wolfe wants us to give power to the court to decide whether it should be removed or not. The second amendment is similar and the third amendments asks us to hold off for an appeal in case there should be one. I do not think that the court would be the best tribunal to decide whether the person should be removed from the register or not, because that would be a matter for the Department concerned. Whether there was a considerable amount of laxity on the part of the person, or whether the offence was a serious one as far as the carrying out of the Act was concerned would be a matter for the Department, and I submit that a Judge would not be in the position to judge whether that person should be removed from the register. He would not be as well qualified to give an opinion on that matter as the officials working the Act. Therefore, I think that the Minister should have complete power to remove a person from the register or to cancel his registration or take whatever other action would seem to him fit and proper.
Comment on this
I intended to say that a person should be convicted twice, because as it stands the effect would be that the Minister should have power to remove a person off the register because of trivial offences. I think that amendment 177 would provide for that contingency better by adding the words "on an appeal." I think that that would meet the case, and I suggest that the Minister should accept Deputy Wolfe's amendment 179.
Comment on this
That would mean accepting amendment 177 with it. I would say that amendments 177 and 178 are alternatives. I think it is wrong to suggest, as has been suggested here, that an official of the Department is a better judge of the circumstances than the district justice who has heard all that has been said and has taken the testimony on oath of the accused and the other persons concerned. I suggest that it is a tall proposition to state that a clerk in a Dublin office is better able to decide the question than a district justice, or that a district justice would not be as competent or would be more likely to be swayed by certain circumstances. I, for one, will not believe that of any district justice. They are a very competent tribunal, and I think it is better for all of us, who wish that the law should not only be observed but that the people should have confidence in it, that such matters should be left for the district justices. I would respectfully press this amendment and ask the Minister to give the district justice the power of cancellation and not let the matter go without trial, because that is what it will mean for the man who is charged and who will not get proper facilities for defending himself.
Comment on this
It is not done without trial under that particular clause. Under that clause it says that the man "has been convicted of an offence." That means that the case has been tried.
Comment on this
That may be, but that might mean that he had been found guilty of some trivial offence and fined, perhaps, sixpence. Surely, the district justice is the better judge of the truth or falsehood of the testimony? He has the opportunity of seeing the witnesses examined and hearing their testimony, and he is in a much better position to judge all the facts of the case than any official of the Department. If the Minister adopts the amendments, this work will be taken off the officials of the Department and that could be brought about by the adoption of amendments 177, 178 and 179. I would, therefore, press for these amendments.
Comment on this
They would not come before the court without first being subjected to the Minister. If that is so he will have his own office and numerous inspectors, and any decision will be subject to, and influenced by, any ruling made by the Minister on the matter.
Comment on this
The Minister said, in answer to Deputy O'Neill, that all prosecutions would be under his supervision.
Comment on this
Is the Department of Agriculture the only person, or body, to prosecute? There is a clause here that any suit instituted under this may be prosecuted "by or at the suit of the Minister for Agriculture as prosecutor." Does that preclude anybody else from prosecuting?
Comment on this
The Minister may not be a lawyer, but there are plenty of lawyers whom he could consult— there are plenty of lawyers here—but that is not an answer. The Minister is responsible for the Bill, but the Minister is in the invidious position of putting through a technical Bill such as this which is imposing a number of new offences in law, and surely a Deputy is entitled to ask whether anybody else is precluded from setting a prosecution in motion under this Bill?
Comment on this
It arises in this way —that we have been told by the Minister that prosecutions in this connection will only be instituted by him.
Comment on this
I want to repeat that no inspector of mine will institute a prosecution without consulting me.
Comment on this
We do not know whether other people may prosecute but if other people may prosecute, then the Minister has nothing to do with it and therefore the supervision which the Minister can exercise over his Departmental inspectors will not be exercised over outsiders. Therefore he will have no control.
Comment on this
The other people may prosecute. At least we will have to assume that they can until we get a definite statement that they cannot until we get some clarification of the position. The Minister has made the point that there has to be a conviction. Deputy Wolfe has pointed out that any offence under the Act may have been marked by the particular district justice who tried it as a slight offence by the fact that he imposes a very slight penalty indeed. Nevertheless powers are given to the Minister to withdraw, alter or cancel registration.
Let me refer again to the Control of Manufactures Act, Section 10 of which states the conditions under which a new manufacture licence can be revoked. I think it will be recognised that a new manufacture licence is a licence given to people who up to, or prior to, a certain date have not been living in this country. Definitely a new manufacture licence under the Control of Manufactures Act will be in the hands of foreigners, non-nationals of this country. With regard to non-nationals in this country who have entered on a new manufacturing process after 1932, the Minister may on the application of the holder revoke. The Minister without such application may revoke if the holder of such licence —here is the phrase—"has been convicted of a serious offence under any section of this Act." The third sub-section winds up by saying "shall not revoke or alter a new manufacture licence save under and in accordance with this section." That is what we laid down in regard to, as I say, foreigners coming in to manufacture in this country for the first time after this Bill became an Act. Outside revocation on application made, there is only power given to revoke or alter if the holder has been convicted of a serious offence under the Act. Here we have "convicted of an offence."
Let us look at some of the offences. Section 53 ordains that the Minister for Agriculture may make regulations in regard to any of the returns to be made to him by registered wheat importers, registered maize millers, registered maize importers and registered manufacturers of compound feeding stuffs, the time at which such returns are to be made and the forms in which such returns are to be made. Then it goes on to say that:
Every person required by regulations made under this section to make any returns who fails or refuses to make such returns, in accordance in all respects with such regulations, shall be guilty of an offence under this section and shall be liable on summary conviction thereof to the penalties mentioned in Part II of the First Schedule to this Act.
We have it now that that is an offence that would be absolutely put out of consideration if the phrase used in this were a phrase corresponding to that used in the Control of Manufactures Act—"convicted of a serious offence." It would be in very exceptional circumstances that any court would hold, I think, that failure to make returns up to a certain time or in a certain form would be a serious offence. Consequently it would not be possible to have registration cancelled or altered because of a breach of the Act arising under sub-section (3) of Section 53. It is possible here. It is undoubtedly somewhat better than the phrase under this sub-section (a) because it is only the Minister's satisfaction that operates under sub-section (a)—the Minister's satisfaction with regard to such things as fraud or misrepresentation. Here we have it down that there has to be a conviction but it may be a slight conviction.
In that connection, I feel that right through the Bill the sections and the different parts were drawn up without there being any proper relationship between the parts. A section that, in what we might call its framework, compared with this was Section 32. Section 32 has the phrase "he is satisfied" as the governing phrase only with regard to fraud or misrepresentation but that phrase does not govern the phrase comparable with the one we are discussing—that the holder has been convicted of an offence under the Act. In this, the phrase "he is satisfied" has to govern everything. Is that deliberate? In other words, are we going, in regard to cancelling or altering the registration, to have the mind of the Minister operating on the point as to whether or not there has been a conviction? There is something to be explained in the peculiar position of the words.
I wonder is the Minister following the point I am making. In Section 32, sub-section (2), the phrase is clear and distinct "if the holder of such licence has been convicted." The phrase "he is satisfied" does not come in. That is, in this, the phrase "he is satisfied" is not applicable to the separate paragraphs but governs the whole lot of them. Has it any meaning more than what was intended to be given under Section 32? Unless it is a sort of mistake in the drafting—the fact that the point has not been appreciated and is going to be cleared up—it looks as if there is deliberation about this and the deliberation can only have the result of bringing in the mind of the Minister to operate on that very point—as to whether or not there is a conviction. What I mean can possibly be better understood if I put it this way, that previously under the circumstances to which Section 32 referred, the revocation of a milling licence, unless a court was satisfied that there was a conviction there would not be an offence and a conviction could only be proved by the production of the court order. In this it is for the Minister to say "I am satisfied there is a conviction." Again I ask the Minister to say whether there is any deliberateness in that and whether he is satisfied that the phrase is applicable only as it is in Section 32 to fraud or misrepresentation. Would the Minister answer that point?