Road Traffic Bill, 1933—Committee (Resumed).
Contributions 1–231 of 701. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 3 parts.
No. 3 of 1933 ›
A Chinn Comhairle, I should like to add to what has been said in favour of having notices prominently displayed about the weights of vehicles which can go over certain roads and bridges. I hope this idea that information need not be circulated to the public is not going to extend, because it would be a most unfortunate matter for our tourist traffic if, in various publications, tourists were advised that there were special regulations of which notices were not displayed, and that they would have to make themselves aware of them either by reading the public Press or consulting certain documents. I feel that this is an aspect of this matter which has not been brought to the Minister's notice and, therefore, I would like to impress upon him the desirability of accepting Deputy Haslett's amendment.
Comment on this
I wonder if the Deputy has had his attention called to Sections 155 and 156, which prescribe that in cases such as those mentioned here last night notices must be put up by local authorities. This particular section—Section 16—deals particularly with the county boroughs, and it is proposed to leave the law as it is. It is not proposed to alter it in any way. In so far as this law has been in existence no case has arisen where anybody has brought to the attention of the Government or the Department concerned any disability or any inconvenience arising out of the absence of any notices. The weight of vehicles is restricted, and if they are above the weight registration would be refused to them. At any rate, in practice, so far as the Department concerned is aware, no case has arisen in the last eight years where any owner of a heavy vehicle raised any point to the Department that a difficulty had arisen owing to the restrictions imposed on heavy vehicles. In view of that the law has been left as it is. We do not propose to alter it, and do not think there is any necessity for the amendment.
Comment on this
I take it this amendment is purely designed for the purpose of ensuring that conspicuous notices are to be erected. Did I understand the Minister to say that no transport company had admitted that they were using vehicles of a weight greater than that permitted over certain bridges in the country?
Comment on this
This, as I say, relates to the county borough, and vehicles of a weight beyond what is allowed would not be registered. Every vehicle which is in use is a registered vehicle or a licensed vehicle, and they would not be licensed or registered if they were above the weight.
Comment on this
Might there not be a case where a vehicle would go out of its ordinary route and come into a borough such as this? Whilst I can see the Minister's point of view, would it not make assurance doubly sure if the driver knew of the existence of the regulations?
Comment on this
All I can say with regard to that is that for eight years the law has been as it is now. Not one solitary case has been brought to the notice of the Department by anybody; not one solitary case has been brought to the notice of the police by any individual or user of the road or any vehicle owner that any inconvenience has been suffered by the local authorities or anybody else. We cannot discover that any case has been mentioned and the law has been as it is for the last eight years.
Comment on this
There is a sub-section, sub-section (4), which was not in the original Bill. I want to call attention to the reading of it: "Whenever a member of the Gárda Síochána observes a vehicle which he suspects of being then used in such manner as to constitute an offence." I thought there was a method of expressing that idea so that the Guard would have to justify his suspicions. I thought there was a phrase about "reasonably suspects" or "has reason to suspect." In this case the Guard will not be required to give any reason whatsoever for his suspicions. We all know that in a force numbering thousands of men and where they are so much in contact with the public that it is inevitable that there will be personal differences from time to time between members of the Gárda Síochána and members of the public. A member of the Gárda Síochána might take advantage of this to get his own back in respect of some little quarrel or another. I suggest it should not be left as it is at present and that the Guard, without giving any reason whatever for his suspicions either to a superior officer or anyone else, should not be entitled to say he suspects an offence has been committed, and thereupon order a vehicle owner to submit himself to considerable trouble as is described in that sub-section.
Comment on this
I move amendments 3, 4 and 5:—
In sub-section (2), line 49, to delete the word "employ" and substitute the word "engage".
In sub-section (2), line 49, to insert after the word "employ" the word "knowingly".
In sub-section (3), line 54, to delete the word "employs" and substitute the word "engages".
The object of my amendments is to take off the employer the onus of seeing that on a proper date the licence is renewed. I think it is quite right that if a person engages a driver he should satisfy himself that the person is entitled to drive and has got a proper licence. I do not think it is reasonable to expect the employer to be the person who is responsible for seeing that a proper date is observed, and that when the licence falls out of date it should be renewed. I think in this case the driver should be the person responsible and the driver only. I am not quite sure that the word I suggested will meet the object, but I put it down in order to have the matter discussed. I suggest that the word "engage" should be used instead of the word "employ", meaning by that to leave on the employer the responsibility of seeing that the driver is properly licensed, but taking off his shoulders the responsibility of seeing, when the time comes for renewal, that the proper date is not overlooked. In these circumstances I suggest the word "engage" instead of the word "employ".
Comment on this
Deputy Thrift wants to remove from the employer the responsibility of seeing that his driver must be licensed all the time while in his employment. Our view is that the responsibility ought to be on the employer and we would prefer to keep the word "employ" rather than "engage." If the amendment be accepted it would relieve the employer of that responsibility. We think at all times when an employer has a man in his employment he ought to make it his duty to see that the man is properly licensed.
Comment on this
The man engaged is not a child. It is his duty to look after himself. Speaking as the employer of a driver, I am bound to say that I find it exceedingly difficult to remember the exact date to renew a licence. I am quite sure I would not do it as I would forget. I do not agree with the Minister that it is reasonable to expect the employer to see after those kind of details. I think that is the driver's duty and the driver's duty only.
Comment on this
I do not know whether the Minister has any experience, but most companies pay the licence duty for the drivers, and these men know that they simply have to hand in their licences to the office, to be sent to the proper authorities for renewal. Sometimes, as a result of this, the men get very careless. The authorities in the office are not able at all times to get in touch with these men, and I think you are taking the onus off the driver unnecessarily. He certainly should be compelled to see that his licence is kept up-to-date and in good order. The employer has no objection to do it, but there is no use in putting an obligation of this kind on the employer. The driver should be compelled and forced to see that his licence is in good order. That is my own experience and I have to deal with a lot of drivers myself.
Comment on this
Would the Minister consider accepting amendment 4 in the names of Deputies Ernest Alton and William E. Thrift?
Comment on this
Would the Minister accept amendment 3, because I think it is very easy for an employee to mulct his employer and make him responsible for a penalty. It seems to me to be unreasonable to take this particular responsibility off the employee or driver. It is more likely that each man could look after his own licence better than that one should look after a group of licences.
Comment on this
If I might point out to the Minister, I really think he is more likely to secure his object by accepting my amendment than rejecting it. If the driver feels the responsibility is the employer's, and not his, he is very likely indeed not to take out any licence at all and let the matter slip, and amidst a lot of other things, the employer might very easily forget.
Comment on this
The law is there to look after the driver and he is also responsible. A driver must not drive without a licence, and he is personally liable in law. Certainly there is responsibility on the driver too—the responsibility is on both.
Comment on this
I do not think that follows at all. If a driver is held up and if he is in the employment of a firm, it does not follow that the employer is going to pay his fine for him. He is certainly liable in law.
Comment on this
If it works satisfactorily at the moment why change it? I have not heard any demand in connection with it.
Comment on this
As far as changing the wording from "employ" to "engage" the Bill as it stands, I think, leaves the responsibility on the employer.
Comment on this
I think I am right in saying that if the Bill goes through, even with my amendment, there will be some change in the present law. I prefer to accept it as satisfactory that an employer should satisfy himself when engaging a man that that man has a licence. Having done that I submit that in fairness his responsibility ought to end.
Comment on this
It would mean then that when a new man was being engaged by the employer he would ask him to produce his licence, and when that licence expired he would have no further responsibility. As far as this Bill is concerned, my position is that I would like to leave this matter to the House. We do not want to stand here and to have it thought that we have here something that we are defending against all comers. I want to get a consensus of the views of the House but, so far, I am strongly advised that it would be in the interests of everyone concerned that the word should be "employ." The legal side of my Department and those with practical experience of the working of the law advise me to stand by the word "employ" rather than "engage."
Comment on this
I am very pleased to have heard what the Minister has said. I am only speaking in a general way but my own feeling is that this is an important little change, if you like to put it that way. At the same time I am absolutely ready to fall in with the views of the majority and if these views are expressed I will not press the matter. I would like, however, to know the general feeling of the House.
Comment on this
There is evidently no demand to change the law as it stands at present or evidently the demand is not strong enough.
Comment on this
Adverting to sub-section (3) would that include cases where a taxi driver was employed?
Comment on this
I move amendment 6:—
In sub-section (2), line 25, to delete the word "either" and in line 26 before the word "granted" to insert the words "and a certificate of competency" and to delete all words after the word "application" line 27 to the end of the sub-section.
The amendment is to secure that persons applying for drivers licences for any class of mechanically propelled vehicles shall furnish certificates of competency similar to those required by drivers of public service vehicles under Section 101. The amendments standing in my name have been submitted by a committee of the Dublin Corporation which was appointed specially for the purpose. The amendments are officially put forward for the Corporation. I hope the Minister will see his way to accept them, because they received very careful consideration in the Legal Department and from the City Manager.
Comment on this
The Deputy has made a very strong appeal to me as an old member of the Corporation. I am afraid I am unable to accept the amendments. The statistics we have in the Department show that accidents are caused not by incompetent drivers but by competent drivers taking chances. As a rule incompetent drivers are very careful, but competent drivers will take chances and try to get through where the less competent and, perhaps, wiser persons would not. Another point is that this amendment would necessitate the immediate examination of over 60,000 persons for certificates. Apart from the difficulty about machinery I am afraid I cannot accept the amendment, as the Deputy, who is Lord Mayor of Dublin, knows I have very great respect for the body which sends them forward.
Comment on this
May I ask is it the Minister's intentions when this Bill is law that people who will have to apply for a licence will be refused because of physical disability, such as having one arm? If they are able to show that they have been careful drivers over a certain period will they be interfered with, or will they be able to get renewal licences?
Comment on this
The point raised by Deputy Moore is a very important one. There are numbers of people driving cars who, if they had to undergo an examination say for their eyesight or for other defects might not be passed by the medical authorities while at the same time they have a record of many years of careful and safe driving. The record of a person who has held a driving licence for a number of years, and who has had no mishap, of a serious nature, should be ipso facto taken as a certificate of fitness for a licence.
Comment on this
If that point is not attended to many very serious cases of hardship will arise. I happened to hear of one case of a man very seriously crippled who was only able to get to business from his home by driving his car. He is perfectly capable of driving but I am quite certain that no doctor will certify him. It is partially with the object of dealing with such a case that amendment 8 has been put down.
Comment on this
I had a letter this morning from a man who has been driving for a number of years and who, according to his employer, is a model driver. I understand the man's employer has appealed to the Minister directly that under the provisions of the Bill he should not be debarred from getting a renewal of his licence. I had two other letters within the past week dealing with the same subject.
Comment on this
Of course the question of fitness will be decided by the Gárda and I take it that the Gárda will take into consideration the fact that the man has been driving for a number of years. If a man has been driving for a number of years without accident that I think ought to be ample evidence of his fitness. That will not rest with the Minister but with the Gárda.
Comment on this
Are you not changing the law as regards vehicles? There are men with one arm driving motor cars. Take a man who wears glasses, technically he is unfit to drive a car. Take another case, a man with one leg, he cannot be granted a licence because the contrary is laid down in statutory form. It was different in the past.
Comment on this
If the Minister could transmit to the Gárda the spirit in which he has received the suggestions that have been made it would meet the point.
Comment on this
I appeal to the Minister to make sure that between this and the Report Stage such cases will be safeguarded.
Comment on this
You will find, in Section 24, that there is a declaration to be made by the individual seeking a licence, which runs as follows:—
"I hereby declare that to the best of my knowledge I am not suffering from any disease or physical or mental disability which would be likely to cause the driving of a mechanically propelled vehicle in a public place by me to be a source of danger to the public."
In case the individual applying for a licence cannot, in conscience, make that declaration, then he has to submit to the Gardaí.
Comment on this
How are the Gárdaí going to pass a man suffering from a disability such as that suggested by Deputy Moore—say, a man with only one arm?
Comment on this
As to that, I have two people of my own acquaintance, one with only one arm, who uses some kind of mechanical hand, who has driven not alone an ordinary motor car but even motor lorries and who, I believe, has done it successfully for a good many years; and another man, with one leg, has driven a motor for a number of years and has done it very successfully and without accident. I am quite sure that such people would be able to get a licence.
Comment on this
I submit that the Gárda is not called upon to say it. If a man makes the declaration, and if it is only when an officer of the Gárdaí under Section 32, suspects that a person is not fit to have a licence, the Gárda challenges his fitness and he has to challenge that before a District Court and if the case goes against the applicant, the applicant has an appeal to the Circuit Court. So that, once an applicant, from his own experience, finds himself in the position to be able to make the declaration, then he has to get the licence and his fitness can only be challenged under Section 32.
Comment on this
I beg to move amendment No. 7:—
In sub-section (1), page 16, line 6, after the word "business" to insert the words "or profession."
Comment on this
I am advised that the words are not necessary—that the word "business" includes "profession."
Comment on this
I beg to move amendment 8:—
Before sub-section (2) to insert the following new sub-section—
Notwithstanding the provisions of the foregoing sub-section, a person who has driven a particular type of vehicle for six months prior to the Act coming into operation and who is not otherwise debarred from driving, shall not be disqualified for the driving of that particular type of vehicle.
Personally, I am not in favour of letting people who are too young drive cars or even motor bicycles; but it has been put up to me very strongly that there are certain individuals, certain young people, engaged in driving cars, who drive them with skill and competence and discretion at the present moment, and that if this section of the Bill goes through it will mean possibly that some of these young people will be put out of employment. The amendment is one of a transitional nature and will tend probably to prevent such cases of hardship arising. I should like the Minister to consider this amendment sympathetically if he can. The object of it is to prevent a young man, say of 16 years of age, who has been driving a car and driving it well and carefully for six months prior to the carrying of the Bill, being put out of employment.
Comment on this
There is no intention to rule out the case of such a young person. If he has been driving for six months prior to the Act and is not debarred otherwise he can get a licence.
Comment on this
I thought that that might be so, but the matter was put up to me very strongly that it would not.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 9:—
In line 50 to insert the word "calendar" after the word "twelve."
This amendment is moved in order to clarify the situation. I do not know exactly whether the word "month" means a calendar month or not. If it does, the word "calendar" is unnecessary; but the amendment is put down to raise that question and I should be glad to know if the word "month" as used in the Bill means a calendar month.
Comment on this
There is one difficulty which I see here. Sub-section (1) says that "every person who drives or attempts to drive a mechanically propelled vehicle in a public place while he is drunk shall be guilty of an offence." I suggest that neither the Minister nor anybody else will be able to define when a person is drunk. I think we should get some sort of a legal definition of that word "drunk."
Comment on this
That is not very definite. This is a very serious matter. I have one case in my mind where a man has had six deaths to his credit and he is still driving a car. Of course, any man who is drunk and has a serious accident should not be allowed to drive again, but I suggest that the definition is very indefinite even in this sub-section (3).
Comment on this
If the Deputy would be good enough to send us in a suggestion as to how to define it I should be glad to consider it.
Comment on this
Would it not be sufficient to say: "When a person has been convicted more than once of being drunk in charge of a motor car?"
Comment on this
If he was convicted more than once how was it decided that he was drunk in the first case?
Comment on this
I feel that I ought to draw the attention of the Minister to sub-section (4). It seems to me that that sub-section puts a power into the hands of the Guards which might be easily misused. I quite recognise, that, as a force, the Guards are exceedingly efficient and do their work exceedingly well, but there are bound to be members occasionally whose opinions in such a connection would be worth very little. I think that under this sub-section the liberty of the subject is definitely placed at the mercy of a Guard's opinion. A Guard can just say in justification of his arrest: "Oh, I thought so; I thought I was entitled to do so," and so on. I think it puts a very serious power in the hands of every individual member of the Gárdaí, and that it ought to be considered very carefully before the House adopts it.
Comment on this
Deputy Thrift objects to the giving of this power to the Guards under this section, but on an earlier section he did not support me, and was quite content, apparently, to give power to the Guards, where they suspected an offence had been committed, to order a person to drive a vehicle a certain distance along the road and cause that person all kinds of trouble.
Comment on this
Surely Deputy Moore sees the difference between requiring a person to drive a motor car down a road a certain distance and incarcerating a person in Mountjoy or in the Bridewell. Citizens have the right to resent being made criminally liable for things they never did, but they have not the right to resent being asked to take reasonable precautions against the commission of an offence.
Comment on this
The emphasis is on "suspicion" in these cases. Deputy Professor Thrift objects to a Guard being allowed to suspect the man of being drunk.
Comment on this
He objects to a Guard having that power. In the other case, because it does not involve imprisonment, but involves a lot of trouble, loss of time and money, neither Deputy Dillon nor Deputy Professor Thrift sees anything unreasonable in the Guard having the power proposed in the section.
Comment on this
Is it being argued that if a man is considered to be drunk in charge of a vehicle that he should be allowed to continue to drive simply because he does not admit that he is drunk?
Comment on this
Might I point out that the Guards exercise what I might describe as a wise discretion? I have known cases where the Guards have prevented certain persons from continuing to drive a car when they considered that they were not in a fit condition to do so? It appears to me, however, that if the section is passed in its present form and if the Guards find people in a certain condition they will have no alternative but to arrest them. If a man adheres to the decision to drive his car, and the Guard thinks that he should not be allowed to do so, then I think that in order to protect the public the Guard will have no alternative but to arrest him.
Comment on this
I think it would be well if the section as it stands were reconsidered. It appears to give a power to the Guards that it is undesirable to give to every Guard. Some Guards exercise a wise discretion. Others of them do not seem to be able to do that. Possibly, if the section were redrafted it would meet the views of different Deputies.
Comment on this
Under the law as it stands a Guard may arrest a man whom he suspects of being drunk even if the man is only walking along the street. I think Deputies will agree that it is much more desirable that the Guards should have power to arrest a man suspected of being drunk in charge of a motor car.
Comment on this
Certainly, if when the matter came before the court the Guard was able to produce strong evidence to show that he was entitled to hold that opinion. What I object to is the laxity of the words in sub-section (4): "Whenever a member of the Gárda Síochána is of opinion." Under the section as it is it would be sufficient defence for the Guard to say in court: "Oh, I thought I was entitled to arrest under the section." I think the Minister should come to the conclusion that the words in the section are very lax.
Comment on this
I strongly disagree with the last Deputy. It seems to me that for the safety of the ordinary citizen the Guards should be protected in this way. It is always a matter of opinion whether a man is drunk or not. It has been found very difficult to define drunkenness. If the Guards were without this power and felt that they had absolutely to prove afterwards that a man really was drunk, then I am afraid they would often allow men to continue in charge of motor cars when they ought not to be in charge of them.
Comment on this
The Deputy entirely misses my point. I never suggested that a Guard should be able to prove that the man was drunk. What I did suggest was that he should have some evidence, at any rate, to justify his forming the opinion. It is there the difference is between the Deputy and myself.
Comment on this
I suggest that the Guard should be compelled to give some reason for his opinion in this case as in the section I referred to previously. Here, in this section, it is simply "I suspect; I am of opinion." The Guard has not even to give any explanation to his superior officer as to why he was of such an opinion. We can all have certain opinions, but it is another matter to give a reason for them. I suggest it is quite unreasonable not to ask the Guard to give some justification for an opinion that may lead to grave consequences for those concerned.
Comment on this
The Deputy seems to miss the point. The Guard has to charge this man subsequently, and has then to give reasons for his opinion. The Guard will not arrest a man with the intention of charging him with an offence under the section unless he has evidence which satisfies him that an offence has been committed. The Guard has to justify the charge in court.
Comment on this
Has it not happened on a score of occasions within the last three or four years that the Guards have accused men of being drunk, that when the cases came up in court they were not able to support the charges made and the court found them unjustified.
Comment on this
Would the Attorney-General say if he thinks it necessary to introduce this sectiton into the Bill at all? So far as I know, the Guards already have adequate powers to deal with people suspected of this class of offence.
Comment on this
One reason is that there is a special statutory definition of drunkenness in sub-section (3).
Comment on this
And this is simply, I take it, to bring an express statutory definition into the administration of the law, and adds nothing to the existing powers of the Guards?
Comment on this
I move amendment 10:
In sub-section (2), line 11, to delete the word "three" and substitute the word "five."
I think the period of three days is rather short. Circumstances may arise in which it may not be possible to deliver the licence to the district court clerk within three days. I think five days would be a reasonable period, and I hope the Minister will see his way to accept the amendment.
Comment on this
I was anxious to hear if there was anybody else of the same opinion as Deputy Haslett, that this amendment ought to be accepted.
Comment on this
Make it seven instead of five; it will not make much difference one way or the other.
Comment on this
If there is any strong opinion that it should be five instead of three I am satisfied. We would prefer three, but if the House likes to have five we are prepared to give way.
Comment on this
It is only an extension of two days and, in certain circumstances, that might be absolutely necessary. I agree with the Deputy who suggested that postal arrangements may sometimes fail, and, then, serious hardship might accrue. The extension of three to five cannot hurt anybody.
Comment on this
I move amendment 11.
In sub-section (2), line 35, to delete the word "five" and substitute therefor the word "three."
This is a case where a licence is being granted that had elapsed, or it may be a licence that had no previous existence. We are now dealing with the particular section on endorsed licences. A person who has had such a licence for three years is entitled to get a new licence provided the period has been a continuous one. If the period has not been a continuous one, then the whole of the calculated broken periods must be equivalent to five years. I think that is somewhat of a hardship because there are many of those drivers who have long periods of unemployment. I do not think it is desirable to harass them by reason of circumstances beyond their control. In this amendment we propose that where broken periods amount in the aggregate to three years they should be accepted. We, therefore, propose to substitute the figure "three" for the figure "five" in connection with the broken periods. If a man, with a continuous licence for a period of three years, is entitled to a renewal, we think that a man with broken periods aggregating three years should also be entitled to a licence.
Comment on this
We feel strongly that the section in the Bill, as it is, should be allowed to stand. Sub-section (2) makes a concession compared to what was in the original draft in the Bill. From inquiries and experience we feel that that section should now be allowed to stand as it is.
Comment on this
Will the Minister say why it is that a man who has broken periods should be compelled to have those periods make up five years, before he is granted a licence, and that a man with unbroken periods gets the same licence after three years. My point is that the man with broken periods is harassed. He has, unfortunately, through circumstances beyond his control, been unemployed. We should not burden him further than he is burdened already.
Comment on this
This does not necessarily apply to a man who has lost his licence through want of employment. Our view is that the section ought to stand as it is.
Comment on this
Would the Minister be good enough to consider the matter further, because the people who asked me to put forward this amendment laid considerable stress upon it. They consider the sub-section as it is is going to act unfairly and harshly against certain people.
Comment on this
I move amendments 12 and 13:—
12. In sub-section (1), line 17, to delete the word "three" and substitute therefor the word "seven."
13. In sub-section (1), line 17, to delete the word "three" and substitute the word "five."
The first of these amendments deals with the case where the driver of a motor car has been called upon to show his licence, and, for some reason or another, he has not the licence with him. There may be negligent people, and we must provide for these people. The case I have in mind is that of a tourist who, for some reason or another, has left his licence behind him. He may be going some considerable distance from the place where he is asked to produce his licence, and some time may elapse before he is able to get his licence and bring it back to the particular area where he is called upon to produce it. For that reason it is suggested that the period of three days might be reasonably extended to seven days. The next amendment deals with the case where the owner of the licence is called upon to produce it personally. That I think is unfair. I think, in the first place, it is desirable to give a person a little more time to produce his licence if he has to get to his destination for it and then come back again to produce it. I suggest that three days, in that case should be extended to seven; and, now, further we propose that the person should not be called upon personally to attend in producing the licence, and that if he could get some other person—his legal representative or somebody like that—to produce the licence for him, it should be sufficient.
Comment on this
I think the purpose which the Minister is out to achieve in this section would be accomplished if the person was allowed to produce his licence at the Gárda Síochána station nearest to his own home. If that were done I think it would be an improvement on what is outlined in the section.
Comment on this
With regard to the first of these amendments I think it is wiser that we should stand by the period of three days as mentioned in the sub-section. In practice, and where it is necessary, the Gárda do give an extension of the time. The Guards have never acted strictly on the letter of the law. They have allowed any extra time that would be necessary.
Comment on this
The court always has a discretion. They have exercised it whether they have it or not. I must say they are not always right in doing so. If Deputies would agree, I would be prepared to give five days instead of three. With regard to the points of the discretion that is exercised, if we gave seven days it is quite possible that the discretion that would be exercised might extend it to ten days. It has been the practice to allow a little longer in that way. We think it is unreasonable to allow it. In regard to the second point, the handing in of the licence by another person, I am advised that it would lead to very great difficulties in identification and to evasions of the law, if persons who could not be identified put in the licence. It would be very unwise to accept the amendment.
Comment on this
Would not there be some other way of dealing with the matter of identification? We are all anxious to encourage tourists to come and spend their time and money in this country. Take the case of a man who is in the West of Ireland and who is called upon to produce his licence. He is coming on to Dublin and his licence is in Dublin. Would it be fair to ask him to go back to the West of Ireland to produce his licence?
Comment on this
He can produce to the Gárda here in Dublin and they will accept it and convey word to the Gárda in the West.
Comment on this
Take the case of a man who has not his licence with him but who has left it at home. Surely the home station is in the best position to identify the man and the licence?
Comment on this
If a man who comes from Monaghan is held up in Galway and is found without a licence by the Gárdaí there, he can produce his licence at his home barracks inside five days or whatever number of days is considered sufficient. The Monaghan Gárdaí will advise the Galway Gárdaí that the man has produced his licence.
Comment on this
Is that the practice at the moment? Possibly the Minister could enlighten us on that matter, because it does seem a way out of the difficulty. As I read the clause, he would have to produce the licence at the point where he was held up.
Comment on this
No. "Unless within three days after the date on which such production was demanded he produces his licence in person to a member of the Gárda Síochána at a Gárda Síochána station to be named by such person at the time at which such production was so demanded."
Comment on this
Under the law as it stands he is bound at all times to have the licence with him. He has no option. He cannot say: "I will show it in three days." Now he is getting an option to show it in three days.
Comment on this
But is it not a fact that at the present time the Guards have a discretion? We are now making a definite provision and we are specifying a definite time and a definite way for the production of the licence. In regard to the poor Monaghan man referred to by Deputy Mulcahy who is found without a licence in Galway, it may happen that his business will not take him home in three days.
Comment on this
As one who has been numbered amongst those forgetful people recently, I think I can say that no person need be afraid if he has forgotten his licence. If he says that he will produce it at a certain place the Guards will accept his word. That has happened to me during the last week or ten days.
Comment on this
If you insist on having a place named, you will tie him down to producing it at a particular place.
Comment on this
I think the decision on these amendments might also govern amendments 27, 28 and 29, as they deal with the same point. However, we shall come to them later.
Section 39, as amended, ordered to stand part of the Bill.
SECTION 40.
Any member of the Gárda Síochána may request any person driving a mechanically propelled vehicle to sign his name in a book and with a pencil to be provided by such member and at the place in such book indicated by such member, and if such person on being so requested and on being provided with such book and pencil refuses or neglects to sign his name in such book or with such pencil or at the place in such book indicated by such member he shall be guilty of an offence under this section and shall be liable on summary conviction thereof to a fine not exceeding five pounds.
Comment on this
I move amendments Nos. 17 and 18:—
In lines 3 and 4 to delete all words from and including the words "in a book" line 3, to and including the words "such member" line 4, and in lines 5 and 6 to delete the words "and on being provided with such book and pencil" and in lines 6 to 8 to delete all words from and including the words "in such" line 6 to and including the words "such member" line 8.
In line 4, after the word "member" to insert the words "always provided that after due examination and verification the signature is forthwith destroyed or defaced in presence of such person."
The point involved in these amendments may be rather remote but still the section as it stands is capable of being abused. A person is called upon to leave his signature in a book or on a piece of paper. When the licence has been identified and the signature verified there is no point in keeping the signature and there may be a certain amount of risk in it as the signature may be used for another purpose.
Comment on this
This section has got very considerable consideration by the Department, by our legal advisers and the draftsmen and they are unanimous that it should stand as it is in the Bill. I do not know what use might be made of the autograph. Possibly if it were Deputy Haslett's, the Gárda would paste it into his autograph book but in most other cases he would tear it up. I doubt if any improper use would be made of the name of anybody when written in a book which belonged to the Gárdaí. I do not think it is likely to happen.
Comment on this
I move amendment 19:—
In sub-section (1), line 14, after the word "so" to insert the words "within a reasonable time."
I think that the suggestion I make should commend itself to the Minister —that reasonable time should be allowed for the production of the licence. The proposal does not weaken the section as it stands. The section as it stands at present suggests that the licence must be immediately produced and that seems unreasonable.
Comment on this
But, surely, if a man is going to court on a charge of any kind he ought to have his licence with him. That is the one particular occasion on which he should have his licence with him, and that is the time his licence is certainly going to be demanded. It is then that the justice would like to see the licence to enable him to make up his mind as to whether he will convict or not or, perhaps, after he has convicted, in order to see if there is any endorsement on the licence. I think it is the time when he ought to have his licence in his possession and be ready to present it there and then, and not several days or a week or a month after.
Comment on this
A reasonable time would, I think, be the time within which the licence could be obtained, say, by post. The licence might have been left at home.
Comment on this
But is it not reasonable to expect that on an occasion like that a man should have his licence with him?
Comment on this
But the fine here is rather heavy, and I suggest that the addition of these words does not weaken the force of the section in any way. It might be decided that a reasonable time was two or three hours or even a day.
Comment on this
I really think it would defeat the object of the section which is to enable the judge to determine the penalty after conviction. A driver should have his licence there so that the judge could see whether he has a clean sheet or not, because it would influence him.
Comment on this
Before we go on to Section 46, there is a point I should like to raise on the question of the issue of licences which appears to be fully dealt with in the clauses up to clause 45. One is tempted to ask whether it would not be necessary for a driver to have a licence to drive a trailer. Can any man with an ordinary licence drive a motor lorry with a trailer behind, carrying six or eight tons, and not under proper control, or are we now going to admit the principle that one driver can drive a heavy lorry and to have behind it what is equivalent to two or three cars with the one licence? Heavily laden lorries do considerable damage to our roadways and to our railways. They do not provide any compensatory employment when there is only one licence. Those of us who have travelled on the country roads have seen one man driving a heavily laden car with a trailer wobbling about behind with neither a man nor a boy in charge of it. Would it not be necessary in order to protect our railways to see that there shall not be this procession of heavily laden motor lorries? The second or third vehicle, as we all know, is not under proper control when it is heavily laden, and any of us who have travelled the roads recently have seen some of these cars driving along with the second vehicle more than half way over on the other side.
I have seen lorries with double decks of milk cans and double decks of sheep, and in one case, I saw double decks of cattle, and I say that, under the Bill that we have before us, those trailers cannot be considered as being under proper control. I hope the Minister will go into it at some later date. They do not give any compensatory employment for the work done or the damage done to the roads. I suggest to the Minister that he might be able to introduce a section to ensure that these trailers will not be allowed. I remember about twenty-five years ago our tram company here endeavouring to have trailers or second tramcars with only the one driver and conductor, but they were not allowed. They were forced to take the passenger-carrying trailers off and to put a driver and conductor on each car. I suggest that the pressure of unemployment would be somewhat relieved if the Minister would see to it that such conditions as I have described shall not continue.
Comment on this
I would refer the Deputy to Section 164 by which some of the points he mentioned are already dealt with.
Comment on this
I say that they are not fully covered, and I am drawing attention to the fact that they are not giving compensatory employment for the damage they are doing to the railways.
Comment on this
I move amendment 20:—
In sub-section (1), line 61, to delete the word "twenty-five" and substitute therefor the word "thirty-five."
This amendment I have down is a proposal to raise the speed limit under certain circumstances. This particular portion of this Section 46 deals with the light motor car or motor car drawing a light trailer. Those of us who use the roads and, especially, during the summer months, have been accustomed to see these trailers being more widely used. One sees light trailers behind some cars carrying, in addition to luggage, tent equipment for camping and one sees caravans and a variety of things drawn at the back of motor cars. The case I have in mind is that in which the luggage is in the light trailer with camping equipment and I think it would be exceedingly harsh to limit the speed of such a vehicle to twenty-five m.p.h. These vehicles, as we know, travel considerable distances and some of them I have seen coming across here and going out to camp in the West. If they are to be limited to a speed of twenty-five m.p.h., they will be some time getting to the West and, if they know of that particular speed limit, they may not come here at all.
While it would be quite safe to drive a motor car and trailer of the description I have just mentioned at 25 miles an hour, I quite agree there are other forms of trailers which it would be dangerous to drive at that speed. If we could in some way define light trailers of the character I have mentioned it would be absolutely safe to permit them to go at a higher rate of speed and it would be unfair to keep them to a speed of 25 miles an hour. As a matter of fact, it would be absolutely safe to drive them at 35 miles and hour. I am not in any sense an advocate of speed. I am not one of the community known as speed merchants; I am rather of the other type; but I think at the same time under certain circumstances we would not be doing anything that might be looked upon as unreasonable if we extended the speed limit from 25 to 35 miles an hour.
There are other amendments down expressing more limited views on this matter, but I think, all things considered, we might in this case give permission for particular vehicles to travel over this specified speed limit. The cars might, if one liked, be limited by weight. I know if the Minister saw the trailer I have in mind he would not hesitate to extend the speed limit in its favour. I will trust to his generosity to accede to my request.
Comment on this
I hope the Minister will not accept this amendment. My experience is that 35 miles an hour would be a dangerous speed for any form of trailer, even the lightest, particularly at road bends. I quite conceive that 30 miles an hour might be permissible for the lighter form of trailer, but it would be difficult to distinguish between trailers that would be dangerous and trailers that would be dangerous. I think the section ought to be allowed to stay as it is.
Comment on this
Would it be advisable to discuss the two amendments together? The amendment that follows mine suggests 30 miles an hour.
Comment on this
Our view is that the speed limit ought to stand as specified in the Bill. If Deputy Good wishes to induce British tourists to come here, this speed limit will be attractive. I am informed that in Britain the speed limit is 20 miles an hour for light private vehicles drawing trailers. That will mean an advantage of five miles an hour here; they can scorch the extra five miles here, and that might be an inducement to them. In other States in Europe, I am informed, the speed limit would more likely be 20 miles an hour.
I have seen some types of trailers. The Department has supplied me with quite a number of illustrations depicting different varieties of trailers that are used in connection with light and other motor vehicles. There are, for instance, caravans, trailers drawing cattle—I have not seen any drawing horses—trailers drawing vegetables and some things that appear to be like cottages, if not houses on wheels. I think we are doing very well with the speed limit we have specified and it would not be to the motorists' advantage or to their safety, any more than to the safety of the public, to do more than we are doing.
Comment on this
In view of the fact that the Minister has mentioned that the limit on the other side for this type of vehicle is 20 miles an hour, I do not think we can ask for any more than 25. I will withdraw the amendment.
Comment on this
I beg to move amendment 21:—
In sub-section (2) (a) (ii), line 10, to delete the word "thirty-five" and substitute the word "thirty."
I hope this will meet with the Minister's approval. It is a move in the direction of prudence and the Minister has been very prudent. Deputy Thrift could speak much better on this subject than I. I have been informed by a motoring expert that 30 miles an hour is quite enough if one is to observe safety in the case of these large public service vehicles. Such vehicles are very heavy and a speed of 35 miles an hour would be sufficiently dangerous for themselves, apart altogether from the danger to other road vehicles and to pedestrians. The question of damage to the road surface must also be considered.
Comment on this
I should like to support this amendment strongly. I am convinced from wide experience that 30 miles an hour is a quite high enough speed for buses.
Comment on this
Of course there are many countries where a speed limit still exists for ordinary motor cars. It so happens that in the State of New York, where I had a great deal of motoring experience, 30 miles an hour is the speed limit for an ordinary motor car, though it is not always strictly enforced. At any rate, the police have the power to enforce it whenever they feel called upon to do so, as frequently happens. I am absolutely confident, both from the point of view of damage to the roads and public safety, that buses ought not be allowed to go at more than 30 miles an hour. I have motored quite a lot in this country and I feel that buses go far too fast. I have seen many instances where buses travelling at a fast speed have narrowly missed being involved in serious accidents.
Comment on this
I think the House should be unanimous on this question of a speed limit for buses. Anyone who has had any experience of road traffic must feel that at the present moment there is really no speed limit observed by big buses. If this proposal is accepted by the Minister I hope that the authorities will see that a speed limit of 30 miles an hour will be observed and that it will not be merely a pious expression of opinion. I have seen buses travelling at very high speeds. I have chased them myself at a speed of 47 miles an hour and I could not catch up to them. We all recognise that a potential danger in the country at the present moment is the rate of speed at which buses travel. I hope the Minister will accept the amendment.
Comment on this
I do not feel like joining with other Deputies in asking the Minister to reduce this speed limit. I think some Deputies are influenced by what Deputy O'Neill speaks about; that is, the very excessive speeds at which buses in nearly every part of the country travel, and also the very great want of courtesy that very often is found on the part of drivers of buses and large trading cars. The want of courtesy is very marked on the part of drivers on quite a number of the big vehicles. I do not think, however, that the kind of unrestricted circumstances we have at present should make us introduce legislation here that will cramp a very necessary service. The Minister is taking power under Section 47 to vary the speeds that are being made statutory in this measure after a specific resolution has been passed by both Houses. My own instinct in the matter would be to raise the 15 miles in respect of the double-decker rather than to reduce the 35 miles in respect of ordinary buses. We did, I think, approach the double-deckers here with a certain amount of diffidence as regards the safety of travelling in them for the reason that we had no experience of them here and, perhaps, also for the reason that a number of double-deckers that came into the country were secondhand. I do not know what is the experience in the country of the double-decker, but I think 35 miles an hour as the maximum speed under the best possible conditions on the open road for the ordinary bus that is doing long route trips between one part of the country and another is not an excessive speed, and there is ample safeguard in respect of special areas for making orders with regard to speed limits.
I appeal to the House and the Minister not to be swept away by any feeling that there are serious irregularities in connection with the speed and the general management on the road of buses at the present time. Once you get this measure, and once you settle down to more detailed administration of the traffic on the roads, you will find that in the matter of the 35-mile limit with respect to buses there would be ample power to deal with a speed limit and to deal with it in a simple way by putting a resolution before the House here and having it passed. I think the general spirit in the matter here is to do the best and the most sensible thing. I would advise against touching the 35-mile limit.
Comment on this
I think there is a fairly strong case in support of the reduction in the maximum limit from 35 to 30 miles an hour. When making a comparison between the speed limits here and in Great Britain I think one must pay some regard to the difference in the type of road here and in Great Britain. I have travelled over a number of trunk roads in Great Britain and I know that anyone will have to admit that the trunk road running from London to Birmingham and up on to Scotland is about twice the width of any of our roads here. Let any Deputy picture to himself the road from Dublin to Limerick and picture to himself the number of dangerous corners on that road. I travelled over that road by bus on several occasions and I can quite see the danger to people in overcrowded buses when you have a speed limit of 35 miles. In travelling over the roads of the country I find that the engineers who originally constructed those roads must have had only one eye instead of two. When considering whether the maximum speed should be 30 or 35 miles an hour, I do not think that it is right for Deputy Mulcahy to suggest that in reducing the speed to 30 miles an hour we are cramping a necessary public service. We must consider the type of roads here compared to the roads in other countries, and I think that taking these circumstances into consideration there is a very strong case for reducing the speed limits for the buses.
Comment on this
Deputy Davin was, in 1931, one of a Committee who unanimously decided that a speed limit for private motor cars was absurd and that it ought to be done away with.
Comment on this
Yes, unanimously agreed. By that agreement it was decided to leave out of the Bill, as amended, that question of a speed limit for private motor-cars. Now we have the peculiar spectacle of Deputy Davin, ardent Labour man as he is, coming along here and saying that the rich people are quite responsible and that they are entitled to get where they want to go as quickly as they can, but when it comes to the bus, the poor man's motorcar, he is for strictly limiting the speed. He wants to prescribe the speed for the poor man and let the rich man go at any speed he likes. That is a curious attitude for a Labour man to take up. There is much more reason, in my opinion, for restoring the speed limit in the case of the private motorcar. Deputy Davin should remember that most of the accidents do not occur through the fault of one vehicle. There are generally two vehicles involved and the accident may be the fault of the private vehicle which may be unrestricted as to speed. It may be through the fault of the private car that the accident will happen. Accidents to one vehicle occur very rarely. Accidents generally arise through one vehicle coming into collision with another, when you have legislation whereby one vehicle can go at any speed it likes on the road, irrespective of what danger it may cause to the other vehicle which is to go at 30 miles an hour. I think Deputies will agree that that is an unsafe state of things. Deputies who urge that favour a line of reasoning that is not convincing.
Comment on this
I think Deputy Moore has overlooked the fact that a great many roads in this country are constructed in such a way that buses should not pass over them at all. There are roads in the West of Ireland where a bus looks as much out of place as a bull in a china shop; but buses are allowed to ply over them for the convenience of the travelling public. It is only on the understanding that they should be kept within a safe speed limit that cars should be allowed on these roads. A great many of these roads are not fit to stand anything like a higher rate of speed than 30 miles an hour if we are to have a safe limit for travelling.
Comment on this
I do not think that the House can accept the view of Deputy MacDermot and Deputy Davin that this Bill entitles any bus to go round the corner at the rate of 35 miles an hour. There are many corners on the trunk roads where it would be dangerous to the public to have a bus going round them at ten miles an hour. The very roads which Deputy MacDermot has mentioned are roads on which it would be dangerous to the public using the buses to travel at 20 miles an hour. But I take it that this Bill envisages other things. There are other roads on which it would be quite safe at 35 miles an hour. Take the road from Slane to Dublin which many Deputies here know. Are we going to pull down a bus to 30 miles an hour on that road? We are here enacting legislation, and we are supposed to make that legislation sensible so that there will be a reasonable hope of its being observed. On a road like that road from Slane to Dublin where you can see miles and miles ahead, it is foolish to impose speed restrictions at all. On the other hand, where there are dangerous corners on the road, you are not under this Bill entitled to travel through them at this speed. I agree with Deputy Mulcahy that in the case of the double-deckers, as they are called, we seem to have forgotten that in limiting them to 15 miles an hour we are making them a public nuisance on the roads. I have travelled on double-deckers several times and, in my opinion, they are perfectly safe vehicles. There is as little vibration as in a single decker. The speed limit of 15 miles an hour is not right in the case of double-deckers. On the other hand, I think it is foolish on the open road to reduce the speed limit on buses to what it is in the Bill. I would suggest that the Minister should allow the 35 miles' limit to stand.
Comment on this
I think the argument advanced by Deputy Haslett is one that has been overlooked by those advocating a reduction in the maximum speed for buses. That is, that travelling at the maximum speed permitted may, in various circumstances, be in itself an offence making the driver liable not only to a fine but to imprisonment. Section 51 prohibits dangerous driving, no matter what the actual speed is, having regard to all the circumstances of the occasion. It is specifically stated there that it is no defence for the person who has been charged with dangerous driving to plead that he was driving within the maximum speed permitted. It is not stated in the Bill that an omnibus driver may drive his omnibus at 35 miles an hour in all circumstances. What is stated is that, under the most favourable circumstances possible, on the widest road and on the finest day, with the least amount of traffic, that is the highest speed at which he can drive his omnibus. That is, in my opinion, a reasonable speed. It is certainly much less than the ordinary speed of omnibuses at the present time. If this section is passed and rigidly enforced, it will mean a substantial reduction on the speed at which omnibuses travel at the present time. People who have to use omnibuses are entitled to get to their destinations in the shortest possible time that considerations of the public safety will permit. I was astounded to hear that Deputy Davin travelled from Dublin to Limerick on a bus, side by side with the railway all the way.
Comment on this
Assuming that Deputy Davin was travelling on a bus because there was no train service available and that that bus could travel at 35 miles an hour without danger to the public, there is no reason why it should not be permitted to do so. That is particularly so when we remember that, as Deputy Moore pointed out, the wealthier person—the owner of the private car—is allowed to travel without any restriction as to the maximum speed whatever. He is, of course, required to drive with all due care and caution, but he is not liable to a fine because he exceeds a certain speed.
I was one of the members who, when this Bill was in Committee in a previous Dáil, were opposed to the idea of a maximum speed. I think there is a case for a maximum speed in relation to heavy vehicles like omnibuses and lorries, but my view is that the imposition of a maximum speed-limit attracts attention to the wrong idea— that the right idea is a speed which, having regard to all the circumstances of the occasion, is reasonable. The enforcement of a law of this kind should have as its first concern whether the public safety is being endangered by the speed under the circumstances. The introduction of a maximum speed introduces a wrong element into the situation. It is, I think, true that a maximum speed of more than 35 miles an hour for heavy omnibuses is dangerous not so much to the people travelling in the omnibuses as to other people using the road. The weight of the omnibus is such that it cannot be pulled up except over a considerable distance, and accidents cannot be so easily avoided as in the case of the lighter type of car.
I think that a speed of fifteen miles an hour for double-decker omnibuses is much too low as a maximum speed, and that it makes for something in the nature of a public nuisance. That was the speed suggested when this Bill was before the Dáil on the last occasion. As Deputy Mulcahy said, we had not at that time much experience of these double-decker omnibuses and they appeared to be somewhat unsafe. In the City of Cork they have had experience of double-decker omnibuses for a long time now. They have been in use for transport in and around the city, and they have been found quite safe at a speed in excess of fifteen miles an hour. I do not say that we should have the same speed for double-decker omnibuses as we have for single-decker omnibuses, but I think the Dáil should press the Minister for Local Government and Public Health to increase the maximum speed for double-decker omnibuses beyond fifteen miles an hour.
Comment on this
I join with the Minister for Industry and Commerce and other speakers in urging the Minister for Local Government not to reduce the speed limit of those heavier buses. One would think, listening to Deputy MacDermot and Deputy Davin, that the present Bill proposed to increase the speed of these vehicles. Actually, I think that the effect of this maximum speed limit will be very drastically to reduce the speed at which those buses travel through the country. I do not agree with Deputy MacDermot for one moment that if a maximum speed is allowed it is going to be the average or the normal speed. In this Bill, there is ample power and ample machinery to deal with the driver of a bus who drives in a manner dangerous to the public under certain conditions and certain circumstances even if his speed is considerably less than the maximum speed limit outlined in the Bill. From the point of view of public safety or public danger, I think that very heavy vehicles travelling along the road at a slow rate are often a greater menace to the public than if travelling at a faster rate. There is a temptation or a tendency to pass them out when they are going at a slow rate irrespective of whether one is at a corner or not. I think that the proposed speed limit hits off the happy medium.
Comment on this
I think that the amendment is unwise. Buses are generally run to schedules and drivers are inclined to take chances. If the driver is confined to a speed of thirty miles an hour on the open road, he will certainly take chances at corners. You cannot have Civic Guards at every corner along the Dublin-Limerick road. If a driver travelling to schedule is limited to thirty miles an hour, he will take chances at corners and you will make bus traffic more dangerous.
Comment on this
I should like to assure the Minister for Industry and Commerce that I have not—I am sure that Deputy Davin has not either— confused the maximum speed with the normal speed—not a bit of it. It is the maximum speed and not the normal speed to which I object. I think that thirty miles an hour is quite enough. You have got to remember that drivers of buses have a greater propensity than ordinary private drivers to hurry on to their journey's end.
Comment on this
The schedules are composed for them and if a certain maximum speed limit is fixed, they will get instructions. I suggest that it would be very much to the benefit of the public as a whole, that it would make for the safety of the people travelling in buses and that it would be to the advantage of the ratepayers who have to pay for the roads to have a maximum speed limit of thirty miles an hour fixed.
Comment on this
The question of a speed limit does not really arise. The question at issue really is that of dangerous driving. It may be dangerous to drive 5 miles an hour in one place, while it is quite safe to drive at fifty miles an hour in another place. That is the law irrespective of any other consideration. Owing to the strike on the Great Northern Railway, I am coerced—unlike Deputy Davin, who travelled to Limerick by bus—to travel by bus to Dublin. On those long journeys, I thought that the bus was not going half fast enough. Take the case of a bus travelling from here to Sligo and from Sligo to remote parts of Donegal. If that bus was confined to thirty miles an hour, how would I ever get to my constituency? It would be quite safe for that bus to travel at fifty miles an hour on certain portions of the road while it would be highly dangerous for it to travel at 10 miles an hour on other portions of the road. That is the law irrespective of anything else in this Bill. The provisions of a time table do not exempt drivers of omnibuses from their liability under the law. If the driver drives at a dangerous speed, he is liable irrespective of the contents of his time table. His time table is not going to protect him from the provisions of the law. We have to keep that in view. This thing of a time table does not count at all.
Comment on this
Deputy Moore has endeavoured to create the impression that I was a member of some Committee responsible for making a certain recommendation. That was a Committee of the whole House and I think it is ridiculous for any Deputy to suggest that every Deputy was responsible for what went through the Committee of the whole House when Deputy Mulcahy was Minister, and agreed with everything in the Bill. That is not so. I do not mind confessing frankly that if the law was rigidly applied and could be rigidly enforced, to the extent that the maximum limit in the Bill would be the real limit, I would be satisfied. Deputy Goulding, however, hit the nail on the head when he said that in order to do so it would be necessary to have a Civic Guard at every awkward corner from here to Limerick, Waterford, or Ballina, or wherever buses run for long distances. I recognise that provision is made in the Bill to deal with those found to be driving to the danger of the public. How is that going to be enforced in a country like this with a very scattered police force to deal with this and other matters for which the police are responsible? Deputy McMenamin spoke of the schedule provided for drivers. I invite the Minister to look up the existing time tables even of the big bus companies and he will find it would be impossible under the time tables for a driver to go from here to Ballina or any other long distance by bus without exceeding the speed limit in the Bill. I know of cases, and I think cases have been brought to the notice of the Minister for Local Government, and to the notice of the Minister for Industry and Commerce, where drivers found exceeding the speed limit through complying with the time tables were themselves made responsible for the fines although the owners were responsible for drafting the time tables which compelled the drivers, under penalty of dismissal, to get to certain places within a specified time. Deputy McMenamin knows that well.
Comment on this
Under the existing law, as far as I know, —I am subject to correction—the person responsible is the driver. I think it is a scandalous state of affairs for an employer to employ a man and under penalty of dismissal make him comply with a time table which compels him to arrive at a certain destination at a certain time.
Comment on this
I know, but under the existing law that is the position. I would be quite satisfied, if the law could be properly enforced and if the Minister could give an assurance that it will be enforced as soon as the Bill becomes law, to leave the maximum speed limit as it is in the Bill, although I believe, from the point of view of the roads available for the use of buses, compared with the roads available in Great Britain and elsewhere, there is a far better case for a higher speed limit outside this country.
Comment on this
I agree with Deputy Davin as to the speed limit. I consider that it is far too high. My only regret is that there is not some limitation to the speed at which private cars can go. From the few trips I had with the Minister for Industry and Commerce I must agree that he would not share my view in that. The point I should like to make clear is, as Deputy Goulding said, that the schedule will be fixed at the maximum speed limit. Buses will have to slow down at corners and take them at 10 or 12 miles an hour, but they will make it up on the open road by travelling at 40 or 45 miles per hour. We have to consider the farmer who is coming out of a boreen or a passage with a horse and cart on to a road when one of these buses is coming along at 45 miles an hour. Then there is the farmer who has to use the roads for the driving of cattle. Can a bus going at that rate be pulled up in time? One would think that the only thing required in this country is speed to take people who have nothing to do somewhere where they will have nothing to do either. Anybody who watches on Sundays private cars taking the new rich from one public house to another will see that they insist upon going at 60 miles per hour even for a distance of two miles. As I say, the speed limit is far too high. Even 30 miles per hour would be too high, in my opinion, because the schedule will be arranged at that rate. That will mean that if they have to go slow around corners or on bad stretches of road they will make up for it when they come to a clear stretch of road and the speed will be 60 miles per hour.
Comment on this
If the Minister does not feel like accepting the amendment will he be willing to leave it to a free vote of the House?
Comment on this
Personally, I would be quite willing to leave it to a free vote of the House. We might then get a fairly large majority for one figure as against another, but no matter what figure you arrive at, there will be a very large amount of disagreement, judging by the discussion in the House two years ago and judging by the discussion we had to-day. We have had speed limits ranging from 15 to 50 miles per hour suggested. I think that if we put it to a vote we will have amendment after amendment put up to reduce it by five miles every time. I really think that the figure of 35 miles as the maximum speed is as good a figure as you will get, judging from my experience of the discussions in the House. It is suggested that that figure will be more an average figure than a maximum figure, because bus companies will tie their employees to a schedule which will oblige them to travel at a much faster rate in certain places in order to keep to the schedule. But if Deputies turn to Section 54 they will see that that particular question of the schedule is dealt with. Section 54 provides:
Where the owner of an omnibus instructs the driver thereof to observe a time table and such time table is so framed that such driver could not observe it without driving such omnibus at a speed which would be a contravention of this Part of this Act, such owner shall be deemed to aid, abet, counsel or procure the commission of an offence punishable on summary conviction within the meaning of Section 22 of the Petty Sessions (Ireland) Act, 1851.
I think Deputy Davin may rest assured that it will be regarded as the maximum, and it certainly will be an improvement on the conditions as we know them at present.
Comment on this
Supposing the speed limit is 30 miles and the bus company schedule involves travelling at an average rate of 25 miles; a man could not do that, as a matter of fact, without exceeding the 30-mile limit. One knows that from practical experience. Is it not very hard to prove it?
Comment on this
Is the Minister not aware that normally every bus company has what are regarded as official stopping places; that the number of actual stopping places is double the number of official stopping places; that the bus driver who stops at different places to pick up passengers, which are not regarded as official stopping places, loses time and that he must make it up? Therefore, to ensure the operation of a maximum speed limit there must be some average speed limit for a bus driver covering a journey, say, from here to Limerick or from here to Ballina.
Comment on this
A couple of years ago I had experience of a motor bus that went 55 miles an hour. I know that does happen, but it cannot happen any more with the maximum speed at 35 miles. With the maximum speed fixed under the Act you will find there will be very much stricter observance of the speed limit, as it would be contravention of the law to exceed it. Those who make out time tables which encourage bus drivers to exceed the speed limit will be brought to book also.
Comment on this
Is the Minister satisfied that he will be able to administer the maximum speed limit that is now laid down in the Bill?
Comment on this
I think the House will be with the Minister in agreeing that 35 miles an hour is not excessive for a bus, but all of us who travel on the roads know that buses go very considerably in excess of 35 miles an hour. I am quite sure that in the future— notwithstanding the Minister's provision in this Act—if there is not a policeman in view they will still continue to go considerably in excess of 35 miles an hour. That is the objection which we have. I am old enough to remember the period when there were metres put on our trams to prevent their going beyond a certain speed. I do not know whether the Minister can recall that period, but I remember it very distinctly. I was just wondering whether some such metres could not be attached to the buses.
Comment on this
Some of those people do lightning tours for 24 hours running, but we ordinary individuals want to have a little comfort, even on the roads. I would be quite satisfied to agree to the provision of 35 miles an hour if I could get some guarantee in connection with it. I quite recognise the difficulty of the Minister, but it would be well if some provision were made whereby those buses could not, at any time, exceed 35 miles an hour. I know it is very trying on a person who wants to travel at a normal speed on the road to find a bus hooting behind and trying to urge you on at the same speed as it is going. Those things occur, and will occur in the future if some steps are not taken other than what are being taken at the moment. I would suggest to the Minister that inquiries might be made to see if some method could be contrived—some mechanical device— whereby those buses could be prevented, even when they are carrying Deputies anxious to cover long distances, from exceeding the limit laid down in the Bill.
Comment on this
I think the Minister is now persuaded that everybody in the House thinks 35 miles an hour a reasonable rate.
Comment on this
Deputy Davin particularly has made it clear that, in spite of all he has said about it, he does not object to 35 miles an hour.
Comment on this
I do not propose to detain the House very long. I have experience of motoring in practically all parts of the country, at a moderate speed on all occasions, notwithstanding any qualms of conscience people may have to the contrary. I have experience of bus drivers and lorry drivers, and there is a marked improvement in the courtesy extended by those drivers to practically everybody on the roads. I believe I was passed on one or two occasions by buses, but it is many years ago. It is not at all a question of speed; it is a question of the security of the vehicle which is being driven, and of the competency of the person driving it. It is nonsense to say you are going to make a regulation here for the amusement of making it; you are making it to preserve order on the road, but with good machines and good drivers, speed is a matter of secondary consideration. Ten years ago this 35 miles that we are mentioning here might reasonably be put down at 22 or 23 miles. The improvement in the road, the improvement in the machine, and the improvement in the competency of the driver, have advanced beyond ten miles an hour during that period. The damage that is done to the road at a speed of 35 or 37 miles an hour is negligible, no matter what the size or weight of the car, if it is a tarred macadam road. Driving at 35 miles an hour on a warm summer day or in normally mild weather in this country would be intolerable. The heat of the car would make it almost a penance to do so. If we are concerned with the order of the road there is no danger whatever in a speed of 35 miles an hour, even if it were an average rather than a maximum speed. There is danger with quite a number of cars at over that speed, but few cars that are capable of being on the road are dangerous at a speed of 35 miles an hour. I take it we do not want to put undue hardship on people who have to journey on omnibuses. As regards the competency of the drivers, one has only got to look at the list of accidents. There are very few head-on accidents with buses as compared with private cars. The damage to the road is negligible. The convenience of the persons on the vehicle ought to be considered. Steps should be taken, in connection with licences given to individuals to drive mechanically propelled vehicles, to see that they are competent. It would make a laughing-stock of the House if there were a lower speed than 35 miles an hour for buses.
Comment on this
On the section, might I ask the Minister if, having regard to some of the remarks that have been passed, he will reconsider the question of 15 miles an hour for the double-decker?
Comment on this
I would ask the Minister not to reconsider it. I have seen an accident with a double-decker which was caused simply by excessive speed.
Comment on this
I move amendment 22:—
In line 50, to delete the words "without exercising due care and attention or."
I put down this amendment for the purpose of drawing attention to the wide scope of this particular clause in this section, and also for the purpose of eliciting from the Minister some sort of official justification for the insertion in this section of these wide words. In the Second Reading speech of the Minister he merely stated that careless driving, as distinct from dangerous driving, is also dealt with. This section, I am of course aware, is almost a precise copy of a similar section in the English Road Traffic Bill. I do not know whether the Ministry consider that a sufficient justification for its insertion in this Bill. I do want to direct the attention of the House to the very wide scope that these words insert into the Road Traffic Bill. The words themselves are "without exercising due care and attention or" and those words constitute a separate offence in this section apart from the next part of the section which provides against anybody who does not exercise reasonable consideration.
With the second portion of the section I am in full agreement. I think it is an offence that anybody should drive on the public roads without exercising reasonable consideration for other people. But I do want to know what precise significance is to be given to the new terminology of "due care and attention." Those words "due care and attention" replace the words "recklessly and negligently" which were in Section 3 of the Motor Car Act of 1903, and everybody is conversant with the meaning of the word "negligent," and everybody, particularly District Justices and Circuit Court judges, knows the standard of care which the word "negligent" requires, but so far as I know nobody knows what standard of care is to be applied where the expression used is "due care and attention." What I am apprehensive of is this—that those words "due care and attention" will be used merely to harry motorists and also for the purpose, perhaps, of justifying a District Justice in prosecuting a motorist who is brought by a traffic Guard to the District Court in circumstances in which there should be really no conviction at all. That is borne out by the provision of the next section which provides that, if a person is prosecuted for driving to the danger of the public, and the evidence does not sustain a charge of that kind, he can still be convicted by the District Justice for not exercising "due care and attention." It appears to me, therefore, that this provision is merely inserted, as I said, for the purpose of enabling the District Justice to stand over the action of a Guard who brings a prosecution in circumstances where there really should be no prosecution at all. I should like to know what is the precise meaning, or what is the precise justification, for that particular offence.
In this connection, perhaps it would not be irrelevant if I urge on the present Ministry what I urged on their predecessors, namely, that provisions of this kind, and provisions such as are contained in the next section, are provisions for the protection of the public, and particularly those sections of the public who use the roads. And the provisions in this particular section "without exercising due care and attention or" are wide enough to enable a prosecution to be brought where no member of the public using the road is in any way endangered. It will be noticed also that while the words which these particular words replace, namely, "recklessly and negligently" had attached to them the qualification "having regard to all the circumstances" the words "without exercising due care and attention or" now in the present section have not that qualification attached to them. I do not know whether it would be possible to determine whether a person had or had not exercised due care and attention without having regard to all the circumstances of the case, but when you find in one section those words are omitted and in the next section they are inserted it is possible at least to construe the provision as excluding the words "having regard to all the circumstances of the case." I would suggest, as I said before, that in the administration of this Act traffic police should not have as their guiding motive merely bringing a considerable number of prosecutions under this Act. When the Act is passed there will be regulations, the breach of which will be an offence, and the sections all over this very long Bill provide for numerous offences, and it appears to me, having regard to those provisions, and for this particular provision, it will be almost impossible for even the most careful and law-abiding motorist to cross the city without running the risk of, at least, being liable to prosecution at the hands of the police.
What the administration of this Act should be directed to, in my submission, is this: That the really dangerous drivers should be concentrated upon, those who pass at corners, those who cut corners, those who stop without giving warning, and various other matters of that kind, and that merely technical offences such as would be comprised in the expression "due care and attention" should be overlooked or at least treated with considerable discretion.
Comment on this
The idea of putting those words which the Deputy has asked to be deleted—"without exercising due care and attention or"—in this section was to make it as wide and as all-embracing as possible. Everyone knows that the number of accidents— happening—very serious accidents— where loss of life is involved, is on the increase, and while in the Act already in force, there were laws making it an offence to drive recklessly and negligently, the law was not sufficiently strong or was not so administered as to make the penalties sufficiently severe on those who drove recklessly or negligently, even to reduce the number of reckless drivers and the dangerous accidents which took place. It is not the intention, I think, of the Bill, and I do not think it is the intention of the House here, that any Bill of this kind should pass which would enable the Gárdaí to harass motorists. I do not think anybody in the House wants that, but I think the whole House does want legislation to be such as will put the person who is not a careful driver off the road—that would be my own personal desire at any rate —that the person who is a habitually careless driver and does not drive with due care and attention should be put off the road. I would not want it to be proved always that the individual was a reckless driver, that he did not drive with due care and attention. I think that person ought not to be permitted to drive. However, I say if there is an opinion in the House here that these words in this section would be capable of being so interpreted or so used by anybody who was straight in administering the law, whether the District Justice or Gárda, if it would be that they would be interpreted or used merely to harass motorists and not achieve the purpose we have in view, and the purpose for which these words were put into the section originally, I would leave the matter entirely to the House to say whether these words ought to be allowed remain in or not. Speaking personally I think they ought to be.
Comment on this
Would the Minister not consider that the object he desires to achieve, and which I think everyone desires to achieve, is covered by Section 51, driving to the danger of the public? When I was moving the amendment I do not think I directed attention to the fact that the words "due care and attention" would be sufficient to enable a passenger in the car to prosecute the driver. That is not a reason for putting in this section. The old section of the Motor Car Act of 1903 was construed as not enabling any prosecution to be brought unless a member of the public using the highway was in danger. I think the object of the Bill was to preserve the lives, the limbs and the safety of users of the highway, and that there is no desire or necessity to preserve the life of, say, a young lady travelling in a car with a gentleman with his arm round her during the progress of the drive.
Comment on this
If there is any strong view in the House that the amendment ought to be accepted, I am quite prepared to consider it. No one has spoken but Deputy Cosgrave.
Comment on this
And informations are always refused in cases where life is lost through motor accidents.
Comment on this
Deputy Costello has not made it clear that there is the danger of people being brought to court and fined or imprisoned because of these words.
Comment on this
In reply to Deputy Moore I would like to say that there is no standard laid down in this particular section. It would appear to me that the measure of the "due care and attention" required by the Bill would be what a particular policeman at one point might consider it, while another policeman at another point might not consider it in that way. That is what I object to. It leaves the question whether due care or attention was exercised to the individual whim of a Guard.
Comment on this
He acts in a judicial capacity. Deputies will appreciate the fact that the District Justice very naturally—and I would like to add very properly—does not wish to let down the Guards. If a prosecution for dangerous driving is brought by a Guard, and if the evidence does not justify such conviction on the facts, then the tendency of the District Justice will be to use his powers in the "due care and attention" section in order not to let down the particular Guard who brought the prosecution.
Comment on this
This provision is not the one that is most likely to lead to abuse of that kind. I think a very good general case of that kind could be made against the Bill, particularly in view of the enormous number of regulations that the Minister is empowered to make, because in that way considerable scope is given to Guards who may be ambitious or who may wish to have cases every hour. Seeing that we have got on so long without practically any law with regard to road traffic, now when motor traffic is actually beginning to decline, such a vast amount of law should not be required in this matter. I think this is the least likely provision of the Bill to be abused. It would want to be much more definite in order to give an opportunity to busybodies in the Gárda to claim that due care had not been exercised. It is quite a necessary phrase to have in, because if a motorist is seen wobbling from one side of the road to the other, though he may not do it in circumstances that would be dangerous, or if he stops here and there suddenly, it should be open to the Guards to prosecute for such conduct, and particularly in the city.
Comment on this
The point that Deputy Moore has mentioned is covered by Section 50, dealing with due care and attention. What is mentioned here is a drag-net to get in another prosecution.
Comment on this
There was an interjection as to whether the object of this proposal was not to preserve life. There is no question of human life involved. If human life were in danger it is not a penalty of £10 would be mentioned. The interjection was like more of the nonsense that people interject about things of which they know nothing. The question is whether motorists are to be used, as far as this section goes, to prohibit careless driving. What is carelessness in driving? Is it not enough to see that they exercise reasonable consideration for other persons and vehicles? If a person drives a car and exercises reasonable care and consideration for other persons and vehicles, surely that is sufficient. If he is able to prove that he has exercised reasonable consideration he may be answered that he did not drive with due care. I do not see any necessity for this at all. There is only one possible case which might arise, and that is in the case of a person who drives a small car, the type which would catch in the rails of the tramways. If there was a skid that might possibly be regarded as lacking the exercise of due care and attention, although it was purely accidental. If a person is prosecuted in such a case I think it is really penalising motorists. There is enough in the section without this. It is like the case of a schoolboy explaining that he was not guilty, and being told by the schoolmaster that his past conduct was bad, but that he had been punished enough already.
Comment on this
All the comment I make is that this was in a Bill that was partly introduced two years ago.
Comment on this
We do not pin ourselves to this. We put it there because it was in a former Bill. I want to get the consensus of opinion in the House. Deputies have not been very vocal in the matter. If they feel strongly about it we will be glad to hear what they have to say.
Comment on this
I may tell the Minister that on many occasions when Bills were introduced, and when representations were made regarding clauses or points in them, they were given due consideration. I am quite sure that if the Minister in his capacity as a Deputy at that time called attention to a double-barrelled clause for prosecutions it would receive consideration.
Comment on this
It is perhaps fair to the House that it should be known that this was not a recommendation of the Traffic Committee on whose labours the Bill was founded. I think it was when the Advisory Committee was reviewing the Bill that they recommended it, no doubt based on the very strong consideration that the British Act had something like this. I find myself unable to make a case with my colleague for the retention of this section against the strong arguments that he has been able to put up.
Comment on this
If the Deputy is satisfied and agrees we will have it examined again and it can be brought up on the Report Stage.
Comment on this
I fail to see the necessity for it. I can see the danger of a cranky Civic Guard—and there are cranks even in the Civic Guards—pulling up motorists for what is really not an offence at all. Then the difficulty would arise as to what constituted want of reasonable care and attention. Eventually the case would go against the motorist.
Comment on this
I move amendment 23:—
In sub-section (1), lines 57-60, to delete the words and brackets "(including the nature, condition, and use of such place and the amount of traffic which then actually is or might reasonably be expected then to be in such place)."
This amendment, standing in my name, is rather of a verbal nature. Section 51 deals with dangerous driving. The section is worded as follows:—"Every person who drives a vehicle in a public place at a speed or in a manner which, having regard to all the circumstances of the case (including the nature, condition, and use of such place and the amount of traffic which then actually is or might reasonably be expected then to be in such place), is dangerous to the public shall be guilty of an offence under this section," and so on. The words "traffic... which might reasonably be expected to be" are very ambiguous. I suggest to the Minister that these words might lead to some misapprehension on both sides. The phrasing is very loose. It seems to me to be quite unnecessary. The words are, if anything, looser than the phrase they are supposed to exemplify—"the circumstances of the case." I suggest that the words which are in brackets are redundant and weaken the section. Indeed, there is hardly any necessity for the words, and it should be sufficient to say "who drives a vehicle in a public place at a speed or in a manner which, having regard to all the circumstances of the case, is dangerous to the public." Otherwise, there would be a tendency to limit one's attention to the specific points mentioned as exemplifying the circumstances of the case. I stress particularly the looseness of the phrase "traffic which might be expected to be." I suggest that it would be very hard to estimate that. Who would estimate it? Would it be the driver of the motor car, the policeman, or the judge? I suggest to the Minister that the wording should be reconsidered.
Comment on this
If I remember aright, there was a considerable amount of discussion on these words when the matter was before us the last time, and I think that the consensus of opinion then was that they should be allowed to remain. These words are part of the existing law and included in the law on which many cases have been decided. Since they have been in the law so long, and since decisions have been given under them, I do not think that there is any haziness or want of proper understanding about the words, and I think they ought to be allowed to remain.
Comment on this
If the Minister assures me that the words as they stand here will be found to be workable, I will withdraw my amendment; but they seem to me to be unhappily phrased.
Comment on this
The words "all the circumstances," undoubtedly, include these matters that are there specifically mentioned. But I submit that when you do mention certain specific points there is a danger that those are the only points that are covered and are meant to be covered by the preceding words.