We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

Road Traffic Bill, 1933—Committee (Resumed).

Contributions 232–463 of 701. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 3 parts.

Bill Road Traffic Bill, 1933
Enacted

No. 3 of 1933 ›

I am informed that that is not the practice in the courts.

Comment on this

Then, I have nothing to say.

Comment on this

What is meant by saying in sub-section (2) "in a prosecution for an offence under this section, it shall not be a defence to prove that the speed ... was not in excess of an ordinary speed limit," etc? Does it mean that it shall not be a complete defence, or does it mean that it will not be a legitimate plea? I think that surely there ought to be an adjective there of some kind to indicate what is really intended.

Comment on this

The intention there is that it should not be used as a defence of any kind.

Comment on this

Before Section 55 is passed, I should like to call attention to the use of the word "shall" on line 58 of the section. That gives the justice no option whatever but that the evidence of one witness "stating his opinion of the speed ... shall not be accepted as proof of such speed." Was it intended to make it absolutely obligatory?

Comment on this

I think that the word "shall" was put in deliberately.

Comment on this

I move amendment 24:

Before Section 58 to insert a new section as follows—

A person hiring a public service vehicle, a street service vehicle or a private hire vehicle shall not become liable to pay any sums by way of damages, costs, or otherwise on account of injury to person or property occasioned by the negligent driving of such vehicle.

I should like to point out that there seems to be some ambiguity as to whether a person who hires a taxi would be liable for any damages as the result of an accident. I cannot impress too strongly on the Minister that, if that is going to be the law, the amount of employment of taxi drivers will become even less than it is at present, and that in everybody's interest it is desirable that the law should be made perfectly plain. It is with that object in view that this amendment has been inserted. If the Minister approves of the position, I do not want to delay the House any further. Perhaps the Minister would give us his views on the question.

Comment on this

The law, as it exists, does not impose any obligation of that kind on the hirer, nor do we propose it in this Bill. We do not propose to alter the law in that way; but, of course, if a person, hiring a public service vehicle, such as a taxi, does offer an inducement of any kind to a driver, such as a few shillings, to catch a train at a certain station, and that necessarily, as a consequence, the driver has to exceed the speed limit, and an accident happens, I do not think that the hirer in that case should be free from responsibility. Other than in cases of that kind, however, the hirer has no responsibility at present, nor do we propose to put any further responsibility on him.

Comment on this

When this was under discussion before, there was a very grave doubt about the liability on this particular point, and it was then suggested that, if there were a doubt, it would be better to have it clarified.

Comment on this

I am informed that there is no doubt.

Comment on this

Well, our advice is that there is still a doubt about it. The Minister makes the plea that, supposing an inducement is offered by the hirer of a vehicle to the driver, that in that particular case the hirer accepts a liability. Supposing a single person hires a motor, an accident with liability accrues and the driver alleges that he was informed by the hirer it was necessary to take certain liabilities while the hirer says that is not the case—that there was no such inducement—who is to decide? Even in the case which I think the Minister put, it is very unfair that the liability should be cast on the hirer. The hirer, even assuming that he should make a request to the driver, may be wholly unaware that as a result of his request certain liabilities accrue. Surely it would not be fair to make him liable. I think the Minister ought certainly free the hirer under all circumstances. If he likes to offer an inducement to the driver, and that the latter accepts that inducement and the liability, then it should be the driver's liability and not the liability of the hirer. As Deputy Dockrell has pointed out this will certainly keep a number of people from using taxis. The people in this city are not apparently a taxi driving people. Some people hope that in the course of time we may become users of taxis to a larger extent than we are at the moment. Difficulties of this kind should not to my mind exist if the law was framed as it should be framed. I would press on the Minister that, in the circumstances, it is not desirable even in the particular case he mentioned that that particular liability should accrue.

Comment on this

We do not propose to put a liability on the hirer of a public service vehicle except in so far as that individual induces a person to commit a breach of the law. I am informed that there is no such liability at present.

Comment on this

Though that is done in ignorance: that is to say that the person doing it is quite unaware of the liability that would accrue from his action. As regards 99 out of every 100 hirers of taxis I think that would be the case. They would not be aware that, in offering an inducement to a driver to speed up in order to catch a train, they were incurring this additional liability.

Comment on this

I think that anybody who has been in the habit of using taxis will know the law relating to speed limits just as well as the users of ordinary private motor cars.

Comment on this

Supposing the other question is one which we may leave to lawyers to differ on, what is to happen to the poor hirer in the event of his being held liable?

Comment on this

I am not aware that lawyers do differ in this matter.

Comment on this

It is not the first time that we have had the lawyers differing. I had a case recently in which the adviser of the State and the adviser of a client did not agree. Eventually the adviser of the State agreed to adopt the advice of the adviser of the client. I think it would be no harm, in order to clarify the position and to free the hirer of liability, that this proposal should be incorporated in the Bill. It will do no harm.

Comment on this

It would do harm, I believe. We have had it examined very carefully since the last discussion, and we are definitely of opinion that the amendment could not be accepted.

Comment on this

I do not like to press the Minister unduly, because he has been very reasonable all through on this Bill. Would the Minister state what injury would accrue from the incorporation of this particular clause?

Comment on this

I would like to support the plea that Deputy Good has made. Suppose I hire a taxi in the morning, that I am a bit late, and I ask the driver to speed up a bit so that I may be in time for my appointment—suppose, too, that in consideration of his speeding up I, like most hirers of public vehicles, give the driver a gratuity—and that an accident happens, where does the hirer stand? The driver can say that the hirer asked him to get on a bit of speed and that he gave him a gratuity. How would I stand in that case as the hirer of the vehicle?

Comment on this

In that case if the Deputy encouraged, aided or abetted in a breach of the law, if he encouraged the driver to drive negligently or dangerously, then he would have to bear his share of the responsibility.

Comment on this

In connection with these insurance proposals, when the 1931 Bill was before the Dáil we had a discussion, I think, as to whether it would be practicable to cover, in the arrangements for compulsory third-party insurance, accidents arising from such a thing as a skid where negligent driving was not necessarily the cause of the accident. Since then I know that representations have been made to the Minister to consider whether something could not be done so that the relatives of victims of accidents arising in that way might have the benefit of insurance. Everyone will agree, I think, that it is a very regrettable thing that where an accident occurs and the victim is a poor person with perhaps big family responsibilities—cases of the kind have occurred again and again—that there is no compensation of any kind for the relatives simply because negligent driving was not proved. I think an attempt was made to deal with cases of the kind in a special Bill in England, but how far that measure got I am not able to say. Seeing that we are introducing this principle of compulsory third party insurance now for the first time, it would be very desirable indeed if we could so extend those compulsory insurance proposals that the relatives of people who meet their deaths in that way might be able to get compensation.

Since we last discussed this matter I, myself, was involved in an accident where a man was killed. The accident arose from a skid. It was described by the poor man himself before he died as an unavoidable accident. He had seen the car skid. Cases of the kind make one realise what a terrible thing it is when a family finds itself bereaved in that way—when the breadwinner, perhaps, loses his life—that it has no claim for compensation. I am sure the Minister has inquired into this since he took up the preparation of the Bill, and I would be glad to hear whether he has anything to say on it.

Comment on this

Might I ask the Minister another question? I put this case to the Minister as a possibility. Of course I know the driver would be breaking the law, but laws are broken. Supposing a taxi-driver were driving a taxi at a time when he was not insured and supposing an accident happened, would there be any possibility of taking an action—it could not be taken against the insurance company, and there would not be much use in taking it against the taxi-driver, because even if it were successful it would not be likely to produce anything—against the employer of the taxi, even though it could not be proved that he had urged the taxi-driver to drive at an excessive speed? There is nobody else, I presume, against whom the injured party could make a case. May I ask is there anybody else against whom they could make a case?

Comment on this

Would the Minister be good enough to reply as to whether there is any hope of embodying the principle about which I spoke in the Bill?

Comment on this

I am afraid not. We had the matter examined, and found that it would widen the scope of the Bill so largely and would have such effects upon insurance that it would make it impossible for us to consider it.

Comment on this

I move amendment 25—

In sub-section (1), line 54, after the word "thereof" to insert the words "to a fine not exceeding ten pounds or".

The object of this amendment is to put in an alternative. The section as it stands reads: "Every person who ... commits any fraud or makes any representation or statement (whether in writing or verbally or by conduct) which is to his knowledge false or misleading in any material respect ..." But there may be a technical offence committed. There may be, in filling up a proposal form for insurance against accident, for which a person could claim compensation, something omitted, and which was omitted with no intention of misleading. In that case the justice before whom the case might be tried would have no option but to imprison the offender. The object of the amendment is to provide another way, and to enable the justice to exercise his discretion. He is the judge of the case and if, in his opinion, it is a case in which there might be a nominal or a substantial fine, he should have the power to impose such fine. As the sub-section reads at present there would be no option but to imprison the offender.

Comment on this

It is quite true that there is no option given to the justice or judge in this case. That was the deliberate intention. The words of the section are "which is to his knowledge false." It is not something that would have slipped, unintentionally, into the form, but something put there deliberately, and, to the knowledge of the person putting it there, false. In that case of putting in deliberate and false or misleading information there should be no alternative. A fine would not meet the offence under that section. The justice, in that case as in every other, has the choice open to him of the First Offenders Act or something like that. If it was not a very serious matter the justice might allow the person out under the First Offenders Act, but if it happened a second time we all know there should be no alternative.

Comment on this

The point is not to take away any of the justice's powers. I would be the last to condone what, as the Minister put it, would be a deliberate fraud, but where there was some unintentional offence committed, in the filling up of the form, one would wish to give the justice an alternative power.

Comment on this

If it is unintentional there is no offence. It has to be to his knowledge false or misleading.

Comment on this

Would the Minister say what is the necessity for proceeding by indictment? Assuming that it is desirable that there should be imprisonment, without the option of a fine, why have this long drawn out expensive process of a first hearing before the District Justice followed by Circuit Court proceedings? Why not allow the matter to be tried by the District Justice or give him jurisdiction, in minor cases, to deal with such matters, under this section?

Comment on this

After what Deputy Costello has said, perhaps the Minister will consider this matter further. Surely it is altogether against the tradition of the administration of the law in this country to prescribe a penalty of the character set out here, withdrawing from the District Justice the option of imposing a fine. I quite recognise that a deliberate fraud means a very grave crime, but the Minister will realise that circumstances may arise in which any person may do something, and sometimes it may be carefully written, that should be marked with the severest censure. But the District Justice may consider, taking everything into consideration, the offender's family and all the circumstances in connection with the offence, that it would be quite excessive to impose a penalty that would make a jail bird of the offender when a fine might very well meet the case. The infliction of a heavy fine might suffice, and might save the offender's family from having a jail bird amongst them—that is a jail bird who had committed a criminal offence. There are, of course, few families that have not jail birds amongst them who were sent to jail for other purposes. I suggest to the Minister that we in this House are never able safely to withdraw from a judge the exercise of his discretion. Cases will arise in which a judge feels he is either bound to let down the administration of the law or do what he believes to be a substantial injustice to respectable people. There is no suggestion, as Deputy Haslett said, of reducing the penalty that may be imposed. The suggestion here is to give the judge discretion to do what he thinks is best.

Comment on this

Deputies will remember how many of them contended that insurance companies were going to be the arbiters whether persons were going to drive motor cars or not, and rather considered that there would be a considerable number of persons who are anxious to drive but who would be prevented from driving by reason of the fact that the insurance companies would be squeamish of covering them by insurance. That was the original idea that suggested imprisonment rather than a fine. I would ask the Minister whether the intention in sub-section (2) of the section does not cover the point raised by Deputy Costello; that is whether sub-section (2), at any rate, permits a minor case coming before the District Justice and being dealt with there subject to a term of imprisonment of six months.

Comment on this

Sub-section (2) does allow the accused to consent, and also gives the justice jurisdiction if he is of opinion that it is a minor offence. My point was why is there not machinery in this Act for small offences to be tried summarily as misdemeanours and to be brought under summary jurisdiction, leaving it in the hands of the District Justice to say whether or not it is a minor offence. Arising out of what Deputy Dillon said, from my experience extending over a considerable number of years of looking after the administration of criminal law in this country. I can say that it is utterly useless to provide minimum penalties in cases of this kind. The court simply ignored them and, in any case in which it thought fit, ruthlessly made use of the provisions of the Probation of Offenders Act. In fact the provisions of Acts providing for minimum penalties are simply set at nought by District Justices and Circuit Court judges.

Comment on this

We regard an offence under this section as being of a very serious nature. It is bound up intimately with the whole insurance section of the Act. After all the whole question of insurance will depend on the information that will go to form the declaration to be made to the insurance company. If the whole basis of insurance is to be falsified, if the information is to be false and misleading, and deliberately so, then the whole machinery breaks down. This only applies in a case where a person deliberately makes a false statement. It does not relate to a person who unknowingly misleads the insurance company. As Deputy Dillon has stated it is a great hardship on any family, respectable or otherwise, to have one of its members put in prison, but if we do not make the provisions of this Act very secure and if we do not make it a very grave offence for people to give false information of this kind, the consequences may be very serious. We are not here to press for any undue hardship on anybody in connection with this Bill. We want to try to get the views of the House. If the House considers this an unduly harsh penalty, I certainly would be prepared to consider the matter again but from what I know of the views of those who have been concerned with the drafting of the Bill, and who are concerned with the administration of it, I can say that they are strongly of opinion that it should remain as it is.

Comment on this

Would the Minister consider accepting the amendment on the clear understanding that if, after a year's experience of it or some period like that, it became apparent that this crime was prevalent he would approach the House again for powers to make the penalty imprisonment? I do not quite follow whether Deputy Costello agreed with me that to withdraw the discretion from the judge is a fundamentally bad principle. There is no necessity for me to recapitulate what I have already said. The thing is so dangerous and might work such hardship in particular cases, that unless a reasonable case can be made for it it should not be proceeded with. I suggest that if the Minister makes this concession now, no difficulty will be placed in his way if he decides to introduce an amending Bill to restore the original penalty if he finds that his leniency was making the administration of the Act impossible.

Comment on this

I should like to assure Deputy Dillon that I regard these provisions as bad in principle and useless in practice.

Comment on this

I quite appreciate the Minister's sympathy in this matter and I want to assure him that my support for the amendment is not called forth by any desire to leave a loophole, but I think this is a case that could be tried in the District Court if it is a minor offence. The District Court deals with much more serious offences than this. The Minister said that the punishment would be only inflicted in case false information was deliberately supplied. One might find a case where a person would find it difficult to disprove that it was false. Suppose one got compensation for an accident which escaped one's memory. You can imagine the prosecution saying: "Well, did you not get a cheque, was that not in your mind and should you not have remembered that?" As against what Deputy Mulcahy says, I would point out that this is a clause which has been in operation in Northern Ireland for some years and the experience has been that premiums have been reduced as a result of it. It has not been worked against insurance companies. They have not been compelled to raise premiums as a result of any statements made to them in applications for policies.

Comment on this

I quite see that a case has been made for reconsideration and if the Deputy will withdraw his amendment and hold it over to the Report Stage, we shall see whether we cannot meet him in the meantime.

Comment on this

I move amendment 26:—

In sub-section (1), line 28, to delete the word "five" and substitute therefor the word "seven."

We had the principle which is embodied in this amendment under discussion on Section 39, the only difference being that it then applied to the licence while in this particular case it applies to the certificate of insurance or of guarantee. The section allows five days for the production of a certificate if the owner has not it with him, and the amendment seeks to substitute "seven" for "five." The Minister originally gave two days more for the production of the certificate of insurance than he did for the production of the licence. He has already extended the time for the production of the licence by two days, so that I presume he will also extend the time by two days in this case.

Comment on this

In the original draft the time was the same in both cases, but when the Bill was discussed here before, the House agreed to allow five days for the production of the certificate of insurance. Now the Deputy wants to have it made seven. We do not agree to that.

Comment on this

I have two amendments down later on, one to delete the words "in person." I think we agreed in the previous case to leave these words in the section on the understanding that the licence could be produced at any Gárda station. I would suggest to the Minister that some similar provision should be embodied in the section, or that he might allow the authorised representative to hand in the certificate, so that if it causes considerable inconvenience for a person to attend in person, if I might put it that way, he might be allowed to attend through a representative, such as a legal representative, and, in that way, satisfy the Gárda as to the production of the certificate.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

I take it that the Deputy is not moving No. 27?

Comment on this

No, I am not moving No. 27.

Comment on this

I think that the Minister might accept the words "by a duly authorised representative" without any harm to the clause. It would be almost impossible on certain occasions for a person to be present and might cause very great inconvenience, and I do not see the slightest objection to allowing the matter to be dealt with by a duly authorised representative.

Comment on this

I am advised that it would be most inadvisable to allow that; that it would make administration very difficult and might leave the door open to fraud.

Comment on this

I would like the Minister to explain how fraud could come in in any case like that. If the duly authorised person is a legal representative with power of attorney to act for his client, I cannot see how any fraud could creep in.

Comment on this

I really contend that it is practically impossible for a mistake to arise, and that a duly authorised representative could make the presentation with absolute certainty. Photographs are always possible to ensure that the person aimed at is the correct person. The section, as it stands, leaves no loopholes. A man might be taken ill, and there is no possibility of escape under the section. I think the Minister should give us some indication of what he is afraid of.

Comment on this

Certificates in similar cases have been presented by people to whom they were not issued. Substitutes have been got and certificates with forged names have been got. This matter has been submitted to those having the administration of the law in similar cases, and they say it would be unwise to accept the amendment for the reason that the chances are that it would leave the door very widely open to fraud.

Comment on this

But are you not tightening up the conditions by means of photographs to make that kind of cheating impossible?

Comment on this

The Deputy means to have photographs on the certificate?

Comment on this

Yes.

Comment on this

Is the certificate not issued and identified by the car number, the engine number and the chassis number?

Comment on this

But the car might not be at hand when the certificate is being presented.

Comment on this

Whether the person attended in person or through a representative, would not the natural thing be to check it and make sure that it was the proper policy of insurance covering that particular car?

Comment on this

That is just the point. The certificate might be presented in some place where the car was not available.

Comment on this

Then it would be no use at all.

Comment on this

If the individual responsible was not available, the car may not be available either.

Comment on this

Will the Minister consider whether it is not possible to take such precautions with reference to the certificates as to make fraud impossible, and will he consider also the possibility of illness which I have raised? I do not think that the section as it stands leaves any loophole for inability to attend.

Comment on this

It does not leave much, I admit.

Comment on this

Surely that is an unfair hardship to impose.

Comment on this

As it stands, it is enforced in that way in Great Britain, I am told.

Comment on this

And that is why I am raising the point here. It is not working well.

Comment on this

Is it not?

Comment on this

So I am informed.

Comment on this

We will look into it again.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

Amendment 30 is out of order.

Comment on this

That is one of the sections proposed by the Dublin Corporation.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

There is an amendment in the name of Deputy Byrne which is out of order, because it proposes something outside the scope of the Bill altogether—State insurance.

Comment on this

I move amendment 31:—

At the end of sub-section (3), Section 79, to add a new paragraph as follows:—

(d) any person who is refused a licence by reason of his failure to pass any test of competency or fitness carried out in accordance with the provisions of this Part of the Act, shall be entitled to appeal to the District Justice Court against such refusal, after giving previous notice to the Commissioner.

I do not want to waste any time over this. This amendment is in the same form as one I proposed on the previous Bill, of which the then Minister said, I believe, that he admitted the justice of it and was prepared to try to embody it at a later stage. I would ask the present Minister to consider whether this right of appeal is not a thing which should be permitted.

Comment on this

The question was considered and, while there is no right of appeal there is, in fact, always an appeal to the Department. There are at present appeals under the Motor Law to the Department, and every case that comes up gets very patient and careful hearing and consideration. It might also go to the senior officer of the Gárda, and if an individual failed there it would probably go to some Deputy, who would take it up perhaps with the officials of the Department, and while in law there is no appeal, there are, in fact, several appeals, and it is very unlikely that any case of hardship would arise.

Comment on this

May I put it to the Minister that that does not seem to be an altogether satisfactory procedure? I do not think that the Department ought to be bothered with that kind of appeal. I think that a legal justice is a much better kind of appeal than the Department, and I think it is putting trouble on the Department from which the Department ought to be free.

Comment on this

What about the Deputies?

Comment on this

To say nothing of the Deputies.

Comment on this

I think the experience of Deputies is that, in any visit of that kind to any Department, the officials concerned are a very favourable court to go to.

Comment on this

I quite agree, and therefore I would rather have the justice. Is the Minister adamant on the point?

Comment on this

I am afraid so.

Comment on this

I beg to move amendment 32:—

In sub-section (1), line 36, after the words "Gárda Síochána" to insert the words "or inspector appointed for the purpose."

An amendment on similar lines was brought forward here on a previous occasion. It was then suggested, as I now suggest, that normally the Gárda Síochána does not include a person or persons properly qualified to carry out the work intended to be carried out by this section. The Irish Trade Union Congress, at its annual meetings for some years past, has been making a demand along the lines contained in this amendment. I understood it was the intention of certain unions to make direct representations to the Minister in connection with this matter. I am not in a position to say what happened. I believe it is only right and proper that the Minister, when carrying out this section, should have at his disposal a person or persons skilled in the body-building industry who would, as a result of their skill and experience, be considered the most proper and suitable persons for a duty of this kind. I hope the Minister will accept an amendment along the lines suggested here.

Comment on this

I do not agree that there are not people at present in the Gárda Síochána qualified to carry out certain examinations relating to mechanical and other aspects. There are at the moment in the force some men who have had long experience of that work and have considerable technical knowledge. They are qualified to carry out the examinations that are required; they are competent to deal with the mechanical and other aspects of vehicles. While that is so, I quite admit that it is necessary to have expert knowledge and I am ready to accept the amendment, but not exactly in the form in which it is here. We will have an amendment embodying that principle drafted for the Report Stage.

Comment on this

In view of what the Minister says, I will withdraw the amendment.

Comment on this

Is the Minister accepting the position that the person appointed shall be a properly trained and equipped person; in other words, a person engaged in motor body or coach body building? There is a precedent for that in Cork City where the inspector, when appointing inspectors of hackney carriages, selected a properly trained and qualified man.

Comment on this

We want properly qualified men. I know what the conditions are in Cork and I would like to have the same conditions obtaining elsewhere.

Comment on this

The Minister, I hope, will make provision, so far as the wording is concerned, for the employment of a skilled civilian.

Comment on this

We will make provision for the appointment of qualified persons.

Comment on this

A civilian—someone other than members of the Gárda Síochána?

Comment on this

They may or may not be members of the Gárda Síochána.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

That disposes of amendments 32, 36, 37, 38, 39, 40, 41, 42 and 43.

Comment on this

I beg to move amendment 33:—

Before Section 90 to insert a new section as follows:—

Any person who is the driver of a mechanically propelled vehicle in respect of which no public service vehicle licence is in force and who takes up and carries passengers whether for reward or otherwise (save as excepted by Section 90 of this Act) on such vehicle, shall be guilty of an offence under this Act and shall be liable on summary conviction thereof to a fine not exceeding ten pounds for a first offence, or in the case of a second or subsequent offence to a fine not exceeding twenty pounds.

(2) This section shall not apply in the case of a driver of a mechanically propelled vehicle who is the owner of such vehicle and who takes up and carries as passengers on such vehicle members of his family or his employees or where an employee of such owner is the driver of such vehicle such employee may take up and carry on such vehicle as passengers members of the family of his employer or other such employees: provided that in such cases not more than one person is allowed to occupy a seat beside the driver.

At first sight, this amendment may seem to be antagonistic to amendment 34, but the fact is that the amendments are dealing with two different matters. This amendment seeks to prevent the improper use of a commercial vehicle while being used for commercial work purely. The other amendment deals with a vehicle from the point of view that, when not used for commercial work, it may be used in order to carry parties to Gaelic matches. I want to provide that lorries, motor vans, and other commercial vehicles, when travelling on the public road, shall be prohibited from taking up unauthorised passengers and from giving people lifts from place to place.

Comment on this

For reward?

Comment on this

For or without reward. For instance, a lorry driver might engage in conversation with a man, whom he would then take for a lift. The result is that the driver of the vehicle does not properly mind his job. He will probably stop at the nearest public-house and the two of them will have a drink. That occurs several times in the course of the journey until finally, the passenger reaches his destination. The driver in that case is really neglecting his employer's work and he is using his employer's vehicle in an improper manner. He is putting on the employer a very serious liability which is not generally recognised. For instance, if there is an accident to the vehicle, and there are personal injuries, the person carried as an unauthorised passenger has a claim against the owner of the vehicle, and he may claim very serious damages.

If the person taken up happens to be a lady—and girls are frequently taken up in these lorries by the drivers —there is a serious temptation to waste the driver's time. One of the reasons why I am forced to bring forward an amendment of this sort is that in Cork last year we had a case where the driver of a motor vehicle had ladies as passengers. He wasted his employer's time. There were two cases where such parties went to the Cork Fair one evening; they were late going home, and one of these men killed two ladies on the way home. That man is still, I believe, in jail. That shows you the danger that exists in such cases.

I was very much impressed by the Minister's introductory remarks. He said it was his object to secure the safety of public life. Another case occurs to my mind. A little boy was taken up by a lorry driver in order to show him the way to a certain place. The boy fell off, was killed, and the owner was mulcted in very serious damages. It is on that account and because of the grievous waste of time on the part of drivers, that I am induced to bring this amendment forward. I think drivers should be forbidden to take unauthorised passengers on their lorries.

The second portion of the amendment is partly a corollary of the first. There would be an exception made where the driver would be carrying fellow employees, provided he would not carry more than three. Carrying more than two persons at the front of the lorry is also dangerous. Deputy Moore will understand the point I have in mind here. Several accidents last year were caused by over-crowding in the front of the lorry, the result being that the driver had not proper control of the gears.

Comment on this

I agree that the object of the Bill is to regulate road traffic so as to reduce the casualties that occur. I am strongly of opinion, however, that the Deputy's amendment is altogether too drastic, and could not be worked. It would make it impossible for example, for a person, a driver of a motor car, even to take up a person who would meet with an accident and who might need immediate hospital attention. It would make it illegal for that driver to take an injured person to hospital, even though the person might be dangerously ill. One portion of the amendment would make it impossible for the driver of a car to take up his own employer; he might take up some of his own family, but not his own employer. However, I know the Deputy did not intend it, but as it is drafted it certainly goes too far; it is too drastic, and it would be absolutely impossible to work.

Comment on this

The Minister is condemning it from extreme cases. The cases I mentioned were not extreme or exceptional. They are everyday cases. The cases which the Minister raises as objections where the driver could not take up his employer are cases that could be got over. I would ask the Minister to take into account the matters I have raised and to give them some attention. I would ask him to consider the evils and dangers I have pointed out. If he does that he will meet my case. With the implied promise of the Minister, I beg for leave to withdraw the amendment.

Comment on this

I want to ask if this practice were made illegal, would the liability that Deputy O'Neill speaks of as a grievance on the owner be removed, that is to say once the practice was declared illegal would the liability cease?

Comment on this

On the second part of the amendment, I want to ask whether it would prevent the man who is driving his own car from taking up his friends?

Comment on this

I have withdrawn the amendment. I will get the matter brought up another way. As to the point about a man not being allowed to take up his friends, we would be better off if we had not our friends with us sometimes in motor cars.

Comment on this

I move amendment 34:—

Before sub-section (3) to insert a new sub-section as follows:—

The Superintendent of the Gárda Síochána in any district may, where he is satisfied that such provision is necessary owing to lack of public service vehicles, grant to the owner of a mechanically propelled vehicle a licence for each occasion to use such vehicle for the conveyance of the members of a hurling or football team who do not exceed twenty in number and who are travelling to engage in an entertainment promoted by a club affiliated to or under the direct control of the Gaelic Athletic Association, which entertainment consists solely of games ordinarily contested out of doors, and the issue of such licence shall not be deemed to render such mechanically propelled vehicle a public service vehicle within the meaning of the Act merely by reason of its being used under and in accordance with such licence for the conveyance of such teams for reward.

I will not take up the time of the House beyond pointing out that it is a practice of the Gaelic clubs in this country to utilise lorries for the conveyance of teams. It is only the teams we have in view when we ask for the acceptance of this amendment and it is chiefly to facilitate teams in rural parts of this country getting to the different venues for football and hurling matches. I trust the Minister will accept the amendment and meet the wishes of the G.A.A. in the matter.

Comment on this

In supporting this amendment, I wish to stress, for the information of the Minister and the House, that it is intended to apply to districts where there are no regular bus or train services for the conveyance of teams to central matches. We have had resolutions adopted by more than one all-Ireland G.A.A. congress and applications sent to the Governments in office. But we found that the Government were statutorily prevented from meeting the wishes of the G.A.A. in this respect. The safeguards set forth in this amendment ought to satisfy the House and satisfy the Minister that there would be no abuse. I want again to point out that the concession we ask for is in respect of teams only, twenty members constituting the team. In respect of actual competitions there would be no abuses whatever with these safeguards. Our activities extend into every area in the country. Our members are drawn from the ordinary plain people whose financial resources are not unlimited. The amendment would help them in this respect also. As drafted, the amendment explains itself pretty well and I bespeak for it a favourable reception.

Comment on this

I would not vote for anything in this House which would in any way hamper the activities of the G.A.A. When proposals were before this House on previous occasions I think I gave evidence of that by my vote. I would like, however, to ask the movers of the amendment whether it would not be possible for them under existing legislation to hire vehicles at a reasonable rate, as is done by many clubs. I mean vehicles that are licensed for the purpose. I know it is possible to get special rates of charges from bus companies. Would that meet the situation that the amendment purposes to meet? I put that query to the movers as to whether they have endeavoured to meet the needs of the teams in that respect and to what extent they have been met by the people concerned. Deputy Gibbons has greater knowledge and experience of football and hurling in recent years I am sure than I have, but I am aware, and I am sure he is aware, that lorries are being used to carry passengers in places where trains and bus services are available. I think it is wrong that lorries that are not licensed for the purpose of carrying passengers should be allowed to carry these people for profit. I think that is pretty unfair in the case of lorries that are not licensed. I have raised that point because I am sure Deputy Gibbons realises that that has been going on, and has been going on to the disadvantage of people licensed and paying heavy duty for their buses and also to the considerable disadvantage of the railway companies in areas where hurling and football are played.

Comment on this

If this amendment be accepted by the Minister I intend, on Report Stage, to move a further amendment. I will do so for two reasons. The first reason has been mentioned by Deputy Davin. The second reason which, perhaps, I should have placed first, as it appears the more important, is that I cannot understand the insularity of mind behind the amendment. That is that the advantage must be passed on to only one association in this country, namely the G.A.A. I am a strong admirer of the G.A.A., but I am not so insularly minded as to suggest that the same kind of protection and the same kind of encouragement should not be given to the followers of other games. If Deputy Gibbons were to alter his amendment so that it would read in such a way as to embrace other athletic clubs, instead of confining it to clubs affiliated to or under the direct control of the G.A.A., I would be in favour of the amendment. In East Cork, at Cobh, for instance, an event comes off every year on the 15th day of August. This attracts very large numbers of people not only from Cork County but places beyond Cork County. I am aware that for that day the facilities which Deputy Davin suggests can easily be got for taking many thousands of people travelling to Cobh over the system run by the railway company to Cobh. But there are thousands of people who have no means of getting to this annual event except by the methods suggested in this amendment. I suggest that Deputy Gibbons and those associated with him in drafting this amendment should, at this hour of the day, have regard to the fact that there are other games played in the country and games to which the same facilities should be extended as are now extended to the G.A.A.

Comment on this

I support the amendment. I am sorry that Deputy Anthony is bringing the old, not exactly red herring, but the old vengeance he has always displayed in this House towards the Gaelic Athletic Association, into this matter. Practically 80 per cent. of the teams engaged in hurling and football come from country parishes. They have not the facilities of which Deputy Davin speaks. They cannot hire a bus for the day to take them from Cobh to Rathcormac or any other part of East Cork to play a hurling or football match. What usually happens is: a shopkeeper of the town or village lends them his lorry for the day. Unfortunately, this Bill finishes that kind of convenience. It will mean, if this amendment is not carried, that about 30 per cent. of the rural hurling and football clubs will be knocked out of existence. The members of these teams have not a great deal of money to spare and they cannot afford to hire special buses. They are working boys who have only one day in the week free—Sunday.

Comment on this

Does not the same thing apply to the players of Rugby and Association?

Comment on this

Rugby and hockey and these games are unknown in rural areas, however anxious Deputy Anthony may be.

Comment on this

I played all the games and I know that that is not so.

Comment on this

This amendment was specially framed—great credit is due to those who framed it—to benefit those boys who have very little amusement, who do not possess the facilities that townspeople and city people enjoy, who have only one day in the week free and who are good enough to devote that day to an Irish pastime. I think that this little concession should be granted by the Minister. I see no reason why it should not.

Comment on this

Why do you not ask the same concession for all other games?

Comment on this

What other games are there?

Comment on this

Rugby, Association and rowing, for instance.

Comment on this

As far as the regatta at Cobh is concerned, we know that full facilities are provided for people anxious to go there. Unfortunately, the facilities are greater than the number that go. I regret that. On that day there are very cheap services to Cobh afforded by all the bus lines and by the railway companies. I do not think that that red herring should be dragged in here.

Comment on this

I saw them come to the regatta in lorries.

Comment on this

It is an awful pity you were not put in a lorry. This is a small concession, and it is a concession to those who are, after all, the hardest workers. They are the producers in this country. The boys who engage in hurling and football are farmers' sons and farm labourers, and this is a very small concession to afford to those who have no other amusement than this game on Sunday, and who have no other means of travelling to the game than those afforded through the decency of a local tradesman who places his lorry at their disposal for the day.

Comment on this

In supporting Deputy Davin's attitude, I should like to ascertain from the Minister how this provision squares with the general line of legislation as regards the organisation of passenger-carrying services and goods-carrying services. If facilities like these are to be provided for the followers of a certain line of athletics could not similar facilities be more reasonably claimed by those who organise feiseanna and educational festivals of one kind or another? Could they not be claimed by bodies of that kind which are widespread in their organisation, and which engage in educational work? Could they not be claimed by dramatic societies and by pipers bands, apart from the claims that might reasonably be made by persons following other kinds of athletics or by hiking bodies who wanted to get over rather flat parts of the country and get away into the mountains? I should like to have an answer to these questions from the Minister. Before an amendment like this is accepted, the Minister, and particularly the Minister for Industry and Commerce, should give the House an idea as to how it cuts across the whole general policy with regard to the organisation of our transport.

Comment on this

I do not quite agree with Deputy Mulcahy in his alarm lest this should cut across general policy. As Deputy Jordan and Deputy Gibbons said, the circumstances governing these cases are peculiar. It usually happens that a team representing a parish or some such area wants to get to the scene of a football match. Unlike a feis or some gathering of that character, there would probably be no general traffic going. It would be out of the question for a small parish team to raise sufficient money to hire a bus. Very often, a local shopkeeper, or somebody with a local interest in the team, places a lorry at very reduced rates, or perhaps gratis, at their disposal.

Comment on this

Perhaps gratis!

Comment on this

Frequently, gratis. I should not at all approve of making this general or spreading it out to feiseanna or other activities, because it is up to organising committees of feiseanna to arrange for omnibuses and so forth if they want to bring a crowd together. What astonishes me about a very reasonable amendment of this character is the effect it has on Deputy Jordan and Deputy Gibbons. Deputy Jordan is a good-humoured man and so is Deputy Gibbons. But when they set their hands to a pen to prepare an amendment of this character, they immediately get cranky. Why? What evil effect has their association with the G.A.A. upon them? Most of these G.A.A. men up and down the country are good-humoured men and pleasant men to meet. But nobody seems to be able to draft an amendment which refers to the G.A.A. without hitting somebody else. What is the point of that? Surely, if you are making this little concession to promote athletics, you should not leave out the National Athletic and Cycling Association or the Association Football teams or any other legitimate athletic club which would desire to enjoy a similar privilege. If you are sending a team to a cycling competition or sending a team to represent a parish in a cross country race, why on earth should they be marked with the seal of the G.A.A.'s disapproval? What a much better feeling it would create if Deputy Gibbons and Deputy Jordan, who represent the G.A.A., would show themselves solicitous for the N.A.C.A. and every other athletic organisation, at the same time? Instead of having this rather regrettable note of acrimony and laurels laid upon their brow by Deputy Corry for their good national spirit, they would get pretty general support all over the House. I think it is regrettable the way in which this amendment is moved and I would be very much gratified to hear from the Minister that, if Deputy Jordan withdraws the amendment and redrafts it to include athletic teams to represent their parish or district, no matter whether they were G.A.A. or N.A.C.A. or any other athletic association, he would favourably consider an amendment on those lines on the Report Stage. I do not believe, and I really do not think Deputy Davin believes, that this is going to have any serious effect on the ordinary carrying companies. We all know in practice what this amounts to, and it is not going to interfere with the traffic of the railway companies or the authorised bus undertakings. If this concession is not made some of these people will not go and the rest will borrow bicycles.

Comment on this

If we accept the principle of this amendment I say the amendment is too narrow, for this reason, that there are other things in this country as well as sport. This year I had the pleasure of attending the national ploughing competition. If we accept the principle, why should it not be extended to the national ploughing competition or to a number of people in a locality who want to go to an agricultural show?

Comment on this

What about a coursing match?

Comment on this

We are bad enough, but do not take us to the dogs.

Comment on this

I say that if we grant this, part of the answer to Deputy Davin will be found in the first two lines: "Where he is satisfied that such provision is necessary owing to the lack of public service vehicles." I would be sorry to see this House passing this amendment for one particular thing and leaving the other national things out of the running altogether.

Comment on this

I should like to associate myself with this amendment. It seems to me that this is a specific section, and as regards the paucity or the lack of facilities for other organisations let the other organisations speak for themselves. This is a specific sub-section drafted for the G.A.A. If Deputies opposite are so anxious to know why Deputies on this side are so solicitous for the welfare of the G.A.A., let me tell them straight that but for the G.A.A. the bulk of them or of us would not be occupying these benches. That is the reason why the amendment is specifically devoted to the G.A.A. Let the other bodies speak for themselves. If the principle of this is right in so far as it is confined to the subject under discussion, that is all we have to deal with now. Other bodies are well able to speak for themselves. The facilities afforded to the members of the G.A.A. to travel to various centres through the country are sometimes extremely restricted and, as has been pointed out by members of the Centre Party and others, the local traders are sometimes compelled to run lorries gratis. This is not meant to cut across or in any way to be inimical to the bus companies or the railway companies. It is meant to apply only to specific instances. There are hosts of poor fellows who could not possibly club together to get a bus or pay the small fare necessary to travel on the train. They must, perforce, travel on a lorry. This is, therefore, a specific case. As regards other organisations, such as ploughing matches and Feiseanna, there is no analogy. I should like to explain that G.A.A. matches are carried on practically all the year round, while Feiseanna are confined to the fine weather and ploughing to half-a-dozen matches. The activities to which this sub-section refers are carried on all the year round. As regards other athletic organisations I think Deputy Anthony said the same conditions were applicable to Rugby Clubs, etc. I do not wish to allude to other associations, but my experience is that those associated with Rugby Clubs are very well able to pay for vehicles. Consequently, I have much pleasure in associating myself with the amendment.

Comment on this

It appears to me that it is a very vicious principle to put one association, whatever it is called, into a privileged position in our legislation. After all, who can tell what will happen to the G.A.A.? Perhaps one section of it some years hence may wish to break off from the parent body, may consider the parent body is not sufficiently patriotic, for heaven knows what reason. It is undesirable that we should be called upon here in the Legislature of this country to put the whole resources of the country at the back of one particular athletic association.

Comment on this

If the Minister is accepting the proposal I hope he will at least fix some standard of safety. It is a very big responsibility for the Dáil on an occasion when they are discussing a Bill to secure the safety of life on the roads and when there has been so much emphasis laid on that to declare at the same time with regard to Sunday traffic that they are prepared not to worry; that vehicles can be used regardless of their efficiency, regardless of the safety which they will provide. I am not speaking against the principle of the proposal, though I would certainly ask the Minister if he accepts it to extend it at least to bands. I may say that while I have had several applications from bands I have never received an application from the G.A.A. to get the privilege of travelling on a lorry on a Sunday to fulfil an engagement. If the Minister is accepting the proposal I hope he will see that there will be a certain standard of safety laid down and that the Superintendent of the Gárda Síochana or somebody like that will be responsible for ensuring that the vehicle used will be up to a certain standard of safety. It is known that last year there were two serious accidents to vehicles which should never have been put on the road but were used to convey parties, one to Dublin during Congress Week—I think everyone will recall the serious accident near Maynooth—and another travelling to a G.A.A. match in Kildare. I do not think the Dáil should take the responsibility of saying with regard to traffic that may prevail in rural places on Sundays that they do not care what type of vehicle is used and that the people themselves will have to take the responsibility.

Comment on this

I should like to say that the remarks we have heard on this are a very curious commentary on the unanimity with which, say, the proposals in the Road Transport Bill are being gulped down on the far side. The proposal before us now is to enable a trader, who under the Road Transport Bill is going to be prevented from carrying a parcel for a neighbour from his own place to some place else, to bring an athletic team on a particular occasion from one place to another. I should like to know what the Minister for Industry and Commerce and the Minister for Local Government think of the proposal. I may say in reply to Deputy Dillon that teachers do bring groups of children from one school area to another school area to Feiseanna, and if facilities of this kind are to be made available for a hurling or a football team, I think that a group of children going to a Féis and taking part in educational competitions are entitled to get the same facilities as some of the Deputies on the far side would hold out so readily and invitingly to athletic clubs of a particular kind, and that the same thing ought to apply to a rural dramatic company going to give a performance in some neighbouring village or town. Those are only samples of the kind of demands that could readily arise once this principle is admitted, to say nothing of the demands that are going to arise from traders to be allowed to carry their neighbours' parcels, in, of course, very special circumstances.

Comment on this

I do not want to allow Deputy Mulcahy to misrepresent any view given expression to by me. I am, personally, quite prepared, as I have done on previous occasions in this House, to justify preferential treatment—by vote or in any other way— for games that are looked upon as national games in this country. I have endeavoured to do it before, and will do it again when the opportunity arises, irrespective of what Deputy Dillon or Deputy MacDermot or anybody else may think. I am quite sure that this amendment, limited in operation as it is in its wording here, is not going to do any serious harm to the transport industry. Deputy Gibbons and Deputy Jordan, who are leaders of the G.A.A. in this country at present, know that a very large percentage of men working in the transport industry have done more than one man's part for the G.A.A. What I want an assurance upon is this: I am personally aware of numerous cases where lorry owners have charged young men in the country so much per head for bringing them to hurling and football matches, and were not licensed for that particular purpose. I do not want any man who has not a licence for the carrying of passengers to make a profit out of this kind of thing. I think if that were accepted by the majority in this House it would certainly be very detrimental to the people engaged in the transport business. The people engaged in the transport business are there to make a living out of that particular business, the same as people engaged in farming or in any other occupation. It is not right that pirates should be allowed to come into the industry, and, under cover of an amendment of this kind, make money out of their lorries which are not licensed for the carrying of passengers. I want an assurance from Deputy Gibbons—I am sure he can give that assurance—that the G.A.A. are not going to put their hallmark upon the use of lorries not licensed for the carrying of passengers for the purpose of making profit out of them in connection with the running of hurling and football matches.

Comment on this

Deputy Gibbons cannot give that undertaking.

Comment on this

I can give that assurance, with a full sense of responsibility.

Comment on this

I believe I could justify, or any man could justify, giving preferential treatment to games treated as national pastimes.

Comment on this

I would be slow to accept any amendment that would cut across the transport policy that is, I might say, before the House at present —the Bill has been read the First Time—and if this principle set out here in this amendment were to be adopted in a widespread fashion, and lorries of that kind were used for profit-making purposes it would cut across the transport policy we had in view. If anything of that kind, therefore, were intended I would not accept the amendment, but I am prepared to accept it in principle and to apply it not alone for G.A.A. purposes, but all other purposes such as Deputy Mulcahy mentioned. We had a case brought to our notice where in one parish in Donegal people had something like seven miles to go to Mass, and had no way of getting there on a wet day except on a lorry lent by some friendly neighbour. Cases of that kind—but rare cases—I think might be provided for, but they can only be provided for under conditions such as laid down here.

Comment on this

I do not like to interrupt the Minister, but I want to ask would he extend the same facilities to Rugby and Association football?

Comment on this

You are not the Minister.

Comment on this

In cases such as I have outlined, where, in any area—I do not think there would be many areas, but cases may arise perhaps in, say, County Cork, County Mayo, County Kerry and County Donegal—there are no transport facilities available, and the Superintendent of the Gárda Síochána is in a position to give a certificate that such transport is not available, they would have to notify the Minister for Industry and Commerce in advance and get other treatment. In those conditions I am prepared to accept this amendment, and leave it to an authority of that kind to give us an assurance that there is no other transport facility available. It would, as I say, be used only in very restricted circumstances, and certainly would not in any way cut across the transport policy of the country.

Comment on this

But it would be used for all outdoor athletic occupations?

Comment on this

Perhaps the Deputy would not mind drafting an amendment and putting it up here.

Comment on this

I want again to ask the Minister a question which he was prevented from answering by one of his own back benchers. Would the Minister extend the same facilities to Rugby football and Association football?

Comment on this

Will the Deputy be satisfied when he sees the amendment we will bring in?

Comment on this

I will be quite satisfied.

Comment on this

Will Deputy Anthony inform this House where Rugby football or Association football teams exist in rural areas? In respect of Mr. Davin's request that he would like an assurance that there was no intention on the part of those who tabled this amendment to favour that particular type of person known as pirates in the traffic world, certainly that is not the intention. I can give that assurance with a full sense of responsibility. There seems to be a misconception in the minds of several Deputies. This amendment, as drafted, tightens up the giving of licences very considerably. It applies only to teams, not to followers or supporters of teams, and the number is set forth as 20. That is the official number which constitutes a team. It is restricted also to official legitimate competitions conducted under the auspices of the G.A.A. It is intended to meet cases that crop up very frequently, particularly in remote districts where there are no other facilities of transport for the teams. I think it is a very fair amendment, and one which I am sorry aroused so much opposition.

Comment on this

To show the genuineness of both of us who have moved this amendment, and of the associations on behalf of which we have moved it, we only ask for this concession on the production of an authorised certificate from the county secretaries in every part of the country that the lorry is being used for the team only, and not for followers. The county secretaries will be authorised to give that certificate.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

I take it the amendment is withdrawn?

Comment on this

What has the Minister to say about it?

Comment on this

I accept it in principle. I will bring in an amendment on the Report Stage.

Comment on this

On the section, I want to draw attention to sub-section (4):—

Whenever a mechanically propelled vehicle is used for the carriage of passengers for reward in contravention of this section the owner of such vehicle shall be guilty of an offence under this section and the driver of such vehicle shall, unless he proves that he did not know that no public service vehicle licence was then in force in respect of such vehicle, also be guilty of an offence under this section.

I want the Minister to explain why the driver has to take responsibility for an offence which is an offence solely of the owner of the vehicle. Why attempt to divide responsibility? What is gained by it? Surely it is a tremendous injustice to the driver. Employment is not such that a driver on a public service vehicle can feel so independent as to challenge his employer to show the licence and that he can argue for a moment on the question. If he has doubts as to whether he can argue the matter or not, his decision depends on whether the employer is an amiable person or whether he is inclined to be autocratic. If he is not an amiable person he can very quickly get rid of the driver and make him sorry that he dared question whether a licence was in existence. I ask the House is it fair to put a driver in this position? He has got to risk the displeasure which may result in his being dismissed from his position in order to comply with this provision when the responsibility should really rest solely on the owner of the vehicle. There must be some explanation for this curious provision.

Then again, in Section 93, it is even more absurd, but I suppose there is some explanation for it because it was discussed here before. At the same time, I cannot remember when discussing it before that there was one reason advanced in favour of the principle. I would expect a very satisfactory explanation indeed before we would vote for such a curious principle—on a principle which would mean that a number of people who have been a long time waiting for jobs and now having got them, may lose them within a week or even a day after getting them simply because they must challenge their masters, with regard to their masters' duties.

Comment on this

The principle of dual responsibility in this Bill is mainly to ensure that there would be no possibility of evading its provisions. If the driver is released from any responsibility in the matter it might be possible for an arrangement to be entered into between the driver and the employer to put the onus upon the driver in the event of a prosecution taking place, the owner pleading that the driver had been liable under the Act if it were amended, as the Deputy suggests. Under this section it is a good defence for the driver to prove that he considered the licence had been issued, but the obligation is upon him to prove that. If he does prove it, he has a good defence. If he cannot prove it, he is held to be equally liable for having broken the law.

Comment on this

I confess that that seems a hopelessly unsatisfactory defence of such an extraordinary provision. Further, taking it at its face value, is the Minister going to provide that the employee will be compensated in the event of his sacrificing a day's employment in order to prove his innocence. Will he provide that the employee can engage counsel, and if it is proved that the employee acted innocently that he will not be responsible for these legal expenses? In my opinion there is nothing to be said in support of the principle and I will certainly vote against it.

Comment on this

The difficulty I see, and which perhaps the Minister would see also, is that the owner may give orders, and knowing his action is in contravention of a section of this kind, to the driver to take out the lorry, and, if, in the circumstances, the driver refused, he is probably dismissed. If he takes out the lorry with the consent of the owner, and it is an offence, as he is likely to do under this particular section, then there is a dual prosecution and he is brought to court to give evidence against his employer. I see there is double danger there for the driver also. By bringing the driver into a position of dual responsibility, as suggested in this amendment, it looks as if he is going to lose his job one way or the other.

Comment on this

It is clear that this section does not really relate to lorries at all—only omnibuses. I cannot imagine a case where the driver would be likely to be required to engage in the driving of an omnibus for which a licence had not been issued without his knowing it. If such a situation did arise he has a good defence, and he is not liable to conviction under this section. But if he does know there is no licence for it and, nevertheless, takes it out for the conveyance of passengers, then he must share responsibility with the owner. In any event it is quite clear you open the door wide to evasion of the Act if you omit to place responsibility on the driver as well as on the employer.

Comment on this

I was informed in the House yesterday that there were two buses plying in a certain district not very far from Dublin to outlying areas and under this section the drivers would be held on the same basis of responsibility as the owner provided they are committing an offence.

Comment on this

Knowing it.

Comment on this

That is a very elastic word when it comes to the question of prosecution. In any case I think the owner is the person who should be held responsible.

Comment on this

And he is held responsible.

Comment on this

And the driver is also coupled with him.

Comment on this

Only if the driver, with full knowledge, facilitates the owner in that manner.

Comment on this

Has the Minister no pity at all for the unfortunate wretch who is out of employment for two years and goes into a job after waiting all that time? This happened within the last two months. I know a man who got into employment as the driver of a bus. Now he is a week or so in his employment and everyone knows that there is a certain nervousness for the first few weeks at all events, and very often much longer; he is afraid of his life something will happen which will deprive him of his employment again, and he knows the horrors of unemployment at this time only too well. He has got then to brave his master and tell him he does not believe his story; that there is no licence for this vehicle, and he must make his master produce the licence. Supposing the master admits there is no licence and says: "We will risk it, it is a very special occasion and the guards will not observe us," he must say: "No, I would rather be dismissed, because the law punishes me just as it punishes you." Surely, it would not be fair to put an unfortunate man in that position. Then he is offered no compensation. There is no provision by which he can recover any damages from his master. There is no attempt to pay his expenses in connection with the matter. I think it is outrageous.

Comment on this

I do not accept for a moment that the driver is an unfortunate wretch who is a long time out of employment and who only got a job within the last fortnight. I would like the Deputy to consider the ordinary case which would arise under this section and that is where the driver, with full knowledge, deliberately co-operates with his employer in the breaking of the law.

Comment on this

I asked for a written statement of the two cases given to me in the House yesterday. I was not going to make representations in the case unless I got the matter in writing, or any information which would enable the Minister to satisfy himself that these people were not operating under the 1932 Act. I suggest to the Minister if the driver of the lorry or owner of the bus comes along, and if under the terms of this Bill he wants to make a complaint in connection with the matter and was satisfied he was not carrying out all the condition of the Bill fear would prevent him lest he would lose his job. It is the fear of losing their jobs which prevents drivers from coming forward and giving information against the owners.

Comment on this

Surely one must have regard for the people using the omnibuses, and have consideration for the public safety. We cannot ignore these altogether merely to avoid the possibility of imposing a fine upon an omnibus driver who knowingly breaks the law for some reason, and is coerced into doing it by his employer.

Comment on this

I can see the difficulty in the case of an owner driver.

Comment on this

Does the Minister hold that the passengers would be safe by having the responsibility put upon the driver? It would be difficult to do that. I alluded to the same principle in Section 93 where, if a plate seems to have the serial numbers defaced, it is the drivers' duty to object and to tell his master that he will not take out the vehicle unless a better plate is put on. Does not the Minister admit that this case is almost certain to arise? The master may tell the driver: "You do not think that the Guards are looking for prosecutions. We are prepared to take the risk. We have no other plates." The driver is told to go ahead. Does not the Minister realise that that is likely to take place? Does he want the unfortunate driver to say "No" and lose his job? That is expecting too much.

Comment on this

I suggest that we will get on much better if we discuss one section at a time. This section relates to the driver of a public service vehicle which has not been licensed. If a driver knowingly co-operates with an employer in having such a vehicle utilised for the conveyance of passengers then he should not be exempted from responsibility or released from the punishment for such an offence. We are not putting the responsibility on the driver instead of the owner, as Deputy Moore suggests. We are putting it on the owner as well as the driver and the prime consideration must be the public safety.

Comment on this

I move amendment 35:—

In sub-section (2), page 45, line 27, to delete the words "by wear or injury."

The object of this amendment is to make the wording of the section less narrow.

Comment on this

Perhaps I might now get some hope from the Minister, having regard to the fact that he said that he preferred to have Sections 90 and 93 discussed separately. Has the Minister considered the injustice with regard to the very small offences indicated in Section 93, offences which certainly will not affect the safety of passengers and the public? The unfortunate driver, at all events, should not be asked to lose his job by opposing his employer's wishes and telling him that he is not prepared to take the risk of taking out the vehicle if the plates are defaced. Does the Minister hold that there is any reason whatever for such a situation?

Comment on this

I would like the Deputy to consider the case from the other point of view. He is assuming that the owner would be entirely responsible for the fact that the plate was obscured or defaced, and that consequently the driver should not be held to be blameworthy. But the reverse might be the case. The driver might have removed, obscured or defaced the plate, and surely in such case the driver, and not the owner, should be held responsible. The purpose of the section is to hold both responsible and to ensure that the plate is not defaced or obscured.

Comment on this

I certainly disagree there. I think the driver would be responsible to the employer. Why hold the driver responsible to the public? I think that would be an outrageous thing when the employer knows that he is responsible for the vehicle and for its safety. We are not making the driver responsible for negligent driving where the damages recovered are recovered from the owner. Why make the driver responsible when the owner may refuse to supply a new plate, having said that he is prepared to take the risk? No matter how it may happen the driver has as much responsibility as the employer. I think that is a new principle, and a shocking principle.

Comment on this

May I draw the attention of the Deputy to the fact that this Bill does not deprive the individual of his remedy for negligent driving. It gives a statutory remedy to the injured person against the proprietor of the vehicle. Surely the Deputy will consider the question from the point of view of the owner of a vehicle who takes every precaution to see that the plate is as it should be. For the purposes of illustration, let me take an extreme case—that of a driver who deliberately desires to drive recklessly, to break the law, and who, for his own purpose, deliberately obscures the plate. Why make the proprietor liable for that, and discharge the driver from all trouble? Surely that would not be equitable or prudent. Would it not be a licence to the driver to obscure the plate, to do anything he liked, and to leave him free of all responsibility? The sensible thing is to make both parties liable and to leave it to the court to decide the burden of punishment. Leave it to the discretion of the court to deal with the driver and the owner fairly and equitably, after taking into consideration the respective guilt of the parties. If the driver makes the case that his employer told him to go out and to break the law, or that otherwise he would sack him, no judge is going to penalise that man heavily or to make his position intolerable. On the contrary, discretion would be used and the penalty would be placed on the owner. If a respectable owner tells the court that he saw the plate, that it was in perfect condition when the omnibus went out, and that the driver deliberately spread oil on it, surely the judge would measure the penalty in accordance with the guilt by penalising the driver, and excusing the owner? That would be justice. Unless judges are fools they are not going to penalise savagely the unfortunate drivers.

Comment on this

The Deputy has missed the point entirely.

Comment on this

I think the Minister should reconsider this matter because, as far as I can judge from the section, the driver is almost bound to be fined. Some other words might be included.

Comment on this

The experience has been that, in the vast majority of cases where there were complaints of obscuration or of defacing of plates, it was found that the drivers and not the owners were responsible.

Comment on this

In this case, if it is seen that the trouble was caused by usage, age, or anything of that sort, surely the driver is not responsible.

Comment on this

We deleted some words.

Comment on this

Notwithstanding that, if a plate is illegible or defaced, unless it was the fault of the driver, I do not see why he should be liable. If it was defaced by him there is every reason why he should be liable to punishment for the offence. In the ordinary way of wear or injury the driver is held responsible here.

Comment on this

Do I gather from the Deputy's suggestion that the owner should be responsible if the plate is obliterated or illegible, and that the driver should be liable if he is responsible for having defaced or obscured it.

Comment on this

I will have that suggestion brought to the attention of the Minister.

Comment on this

Why are offences of that kind picked out for special treatment? Cases dealing with the handling of vehicles generally by the driver will not come before the courts. They are matters between the employee and the owner. When doing up a vehicle before he takes it out, a man who is expected to deface a plate, if he is so inclined, can cause injury to the engine so that it will break down—if we are supposing him to have that criminal intention with regard to his master's vehicle. Deputy Dillon missed the point entirely. He thought that my principal aim was to prevent the man being brought into court. My principal aim is to prevent him from losing his employment. My point is that, if the employer is prepared to take the risk, the driver should not be expected to say to his master: "No, I will not take out the car even though my refusal may involve my dismissal."

Comment on this

Surely, it is not the intention that it should cover the case of a man endeavouring to escape detection by obliterating the plate. Very often we have cases of men driving off after an accident and getting down and smearing the plate with mud or oil so that the guard could not detect it. Should not the driver be responsible in that case?

Comment on this

Cannot his master bring him into court for it if he is responsible to his master?

Comment on this

The law states that the plate must be affixed to a vehicle in a prescribed place and manner so that it can be read in certain circumstances and that it must not be obliterated. If the law is broken in that way, the person who broke it should be liable to a penalty. That is the purpose of that section.

Comment on this

Will the Minister look into that point?

Comment on this

On Section 95, I should like to draw the attention of the Minister to the fact that on an earlier section representations were made that the Civic Guards should be restricted —indeed, I think it was Deputy Moore—from requiring a person to accompany him to a weighbridge if the Guard suspected that the weight of the vehicle was too great. Deputy Moore suggested that that ought to be "reasonably suspected." It was suggested by the Minister for Local Government and Public Health that the insertion of that word was not necessary, as it was implied. Perhaps the Minister will explain why, if the word "reasonably" was not necessary in that part of the Bill, it has been deemed necessary to insert it in Section 95. It will be observed that the words are:—"any member of the Gárda Síochána may, at any time and in any place, inspect and examine any public service vehicle (including the fittings and equipment thereof) which he reasonably suspects to be so defective as to be unfit" and so on.

Comment on this

Is the Deputy objecting to this section?

Comment on this

I am asking why it is necessary to insert the word "reasonably" in Section 95 when it was not found necessary to insert it previously.

Comment on this

The Deputy has no objection to this section?

Comment on this

The Deputy has the objection that the form of this section creates doubt in the mind of the conscientious legislator.

Comment on this

I take it that tyres are included in the phrase "fittings and equipment." There have been cases, in other countries at any rate, of accidents where tyres were included.

Comment on this

Yes, the definition "fittings and equipment" would include tyres. Presumably it would include all things with which a bus is equipped.

Comment on this

Will the Minister explain why in Section 16, sub-section (4)——

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

We are past Section 16.

Comment on this

I am not going back, sir, and I must ask your indulgence to allow me to continue with the sentence. Will the Minister explain why, if the form used in Section 16, which says "whenever a member of the Gárda Síochána observes a vehicle which he suspects of being then used in such a manner," is adequate in that part of the Bill, it ceases to be adequate in Section 95? Section 95 says: "which he reasonably suspects to be so defective as to be unfit for the carriage of passengers." If it was deemed necessary to omit that word "reasonably" in an earlier section, surely its introduction here limits the Guard's discretion in a much more important relation. Why is it deemed necessary or desirable to limit the Guard's discretion here when it was not so limited in other parts of the Bill?

Comment on this

It is deemed advisable here because of the circumstances of the section. I could give a very lucid explanation of Section 16 to the Deputy, but its discussion is out of order.

Comment on this

I move amendments 44 and 45:—

In sub-section (1) to insert at the beginning of the sub-section the following words:—

Subject to the provisions of this section.

Before sub-section (2) to insert a new sub-section as follows:—

(2) The Commissioner may certify that in his opinion a conductor is not required for a specified passenger road service in respect of which a licence is in force under the Road Transport Act, 1932, and may at any time withdraw such certificate and while such certificate is in force the provisions of this section shall not apply to any public service vehicle while it is being used on such passenger road service and accordingly it shall not be necessary to carry a conductor on such vehicle while it is being so used.

Comment on this

I am prepared to accept amendments 44 and 45 in principle, if the Deputy will withdraw them at this stage.

Comment on this

On the section, the only point I want to raise is that if those vehicles are not licensed, and if they are in possession of certain persons, there is a certain confiscation taking place of public property. Can there be any consideration given to that matter? I understand that some of those people are not people of very considerable means and, in certain cases, it may be that it is their entire livelihood, and it might not possibly pay to have a conductor on a small vehicle of that kind. Could there be any arrangement made whereby the life of a car would be allowed to be worked out and no future licence given in respect of another vehicle?

Comment on this

I am not aware that it is not the practice to carry conductors on buses larger than 14 seaters. It is undoubtedly correct that on the 14 seater buses the driver acts in the double capacity of driver and conductor. That will still be the case. This only applies to vehicles of larger size —22 and 32 seater buses. It would not be easy for the driver on these to act also as conductor. For one thing, they carry a larger number of passengers than the smaller buses, and as a rule, they are entered from the back.

Comment on this

Are there vehicles at the present time with more than 14 seats not carrying conductors?

Comment on this

I do not think there are very many.

Comment on this

Would the Minister look into that point?

Comment on this

Certainly. Apart from the fact whether there are or not, I feel that for the larger type of vehicle a conductor is essential. For one thing, on the larger buses a conductor is required to look after the passengers. The door is usually at the back of the vehicle, while on the smaller buses it is at the front. On the larger buses a conductor is necessary to give the driver signals when to start and to stop as well as to signal to traffic coming behind when the bus proposes to turn. On these larger buses a conductor is essential not merely for the safety of those using the road but also for the safety of the passengers.

Comment on this

I agree with the principle. I am a child in these matters as I have never travelled on a bus. I accept what the Minister says, but, having regard to what I have pointed out, I think some consideration ought to be given for the life of the bus.

Comment on this

The Deputy will remember that since the Road Transport Act came into operation licences for public service vehicles have only been given to those who have undertaken not merely to preserve the service with the degree of efficiency that existed at the time the licence was given, but to improve it and also the efficiency of the vehicles on the service. If they allow their buses to deteriorate, become old or unsafe, then, apart from whatever penalties may be imposed under this measure, they are liable to suffer the withdrawal of their licence under the Road Transport Act.

Comment on this

Would the Minister say whether it is the practice in areas outside the Saorstát to have buses larger than the 14 seaters controlled by a single man?

Comment on this

I am afraid I cannot give the Deputy any information on that.

Comment on this

I agree with the Minister that in crowded areas such as cities it is not advisable to have buses under the control of only one man, but in rural areas where the conditions would not be at all as exacting it might be advisable to relax the regulations in that connection somewhat.

Comment on this

The position in the rural areas is that apart from one or two omnibus services which operate in isolated districts all the omnibuses are now railway-owned over the greater part of the country. Apart from a few services running into Cork and one in Galway the Great Southern system— the I.O.C. buses—is really the only one operating at the moment. These are all large omnibuses and the company should be able to supply the staff provided here.

Comment on this

The Minister will understand that in areas where the population is small and the distances covered not very great, while it would not pay to run a large bus it might pay to run a smaller one, and just because the larger bus does not pay there is no bus run at all, with the result that the people do not get the convenience to which they are entitled.

Comment on this

The 14-seater bus is the ordinary small bus that one sees running in the city. There is no obligation to carry a conductor on it. The next size of bus is generally the 20 to 22 seater. That is a substantially larger vehicle, and usually has the door at the back. It would certainly require a conductor, both for the safety of the passengers and the public generally. Then there is the 32-seater bus on which a conductor is essential.

Comment on this

I travelled on a bus not many weeks ago on the other side— a 20 seater—which was controlled by one man. He controlled the door, which was almost opposite him, by a lever in his box. I think the Minister ought to consider taking powers in order to deal with cases such as I have mentioned—a case, say, where a larger bus would not pay and where it might be advisable to instal a small bus. He should take power to deal with the 14 to 20-seater vehicle.

Comment on this

I will convey the Deputy's suggestion to the Minister for Local Government.

Comment on this

I move amendment 46:-

In sub-section (1), line 47, to insert after the word "concerned" the words "and the motoring organisations."

As Deputies know we have in this State motoring organisations which serve a very useful purpose. They erect signs on our roads and they give a lot of useful advice. I suggest that it would be a very useful thing to make provision in this section that motoring organisations such as the A.A. should be consulted in the making of by-laws.

Comment on this

In the ordinary course motor organisations of the kind the Deputy has in mind would be consulted in the preparation of by-laws of this kind, but it is obviously highly undesirable that such consultation should be made a matter of statutory obligation. If that were the case it might, in fact, be necessary to prove consultation before the by-law could be admitted as valid. Apart from that the term which the Deputy uses in his amendment is a rather wide one. It might cover a lot more than the particular organisation to which he referred. It is a very wide phrase indeed. If we were to include it we might find an organisation in some part of the country that no one ever heard of before coming forward and objecting to the validity of certain bye-laws on the ground that it was not consulted. As I have said, it would be the practice to consult these organisations in the preparation of the bye-laws. It is very advisable to leave it at that and not to attempt to make it a matter of statutory obligation.

Comment on this

With the Minister's assurance, I ask leave to withdraw the amendment.

Comment on this

I move amendment 47:—

To add at the end of the section a new sub-section as follows:—

(7) For the purposes of this section, the expression "public service vehicles" shall include tramcars.

The object of the amendment is to empower the Commissioner to regulate the movement and stopping place of trams by the police. From the by-laws that the Commissioner is empowered to make, tramcars are omitted, and, I think, the Minister will see the desirability of giving such power as is suggested in the amendment to the Commissioner.

Comment on this

I would like to support this amendment. It has been moved as a result of consultation between the members of the Dublin Corporation and the officials of the Corporation, who have some responsibility for the stopping places of public vehicles. This amendment, and others of a similar nature, are the result of such consideration, and I hope the Minister will see his way to meet the borough representatives upon this point.

Comment on this

In the first place, I would refer to Section 145, which purports that the Commissioner may, with the consent of the Minister, make in respect of any tramway system by-laws for all or any of the following purposes, that is to say: (a) regulating the management of other vehicles in relation to tramway cars on such tramway system and in particular the conduct of such vehicles when overtaking a tramway car; (b) the places at which tramcars on such tramway system may stop to pick up or set down passengers; (c) the places at which intending passengers in such tramcars may congregate to await transport in such tramway cars. I would ask the Deputies if that does not meet their point.

Comment on this

In that section the county council or the municipality is not consulted. The amendment that I am asking the Minister to accept gives power to consult the Commissioner as to the particular stopping places.

Comment on this

The matter is complicated by the fact that the tramways company has powers, under various private Acts and Statutes, all of which are administered by the Department of Industry and Commerce, and are not under the Department of Local Government. To bring it in now, in the manner suggested, would complicate things very considerably, and would involve very substantial amendment of this Bill. The Deputy may take it as reasonably certain that the Commissioner, in exercising his power under Section 145, will take into consideration any views that the local councils may submit in connection with the matter.

Comment on this

Is the Minister satisfied that the section to which he has referred does cover the matter, and that it would be desirable for the municipal representatives to have some consultation with the Commissioner?

Comment on this

I do not think the Minister really sees the point which the municipal authorities have in mind. Apart from the ordinary facilities that will be accorded in regulating traffic, the municipal council is engaged, almost continuously, on building operations, and so forth. They have to consider, in the clearing up of certain areas, that they may have to remove facilities in connection with public vehicles. Bearing that in mind, they want to be consulted so that they might have some right, one way or the other, when occasion arises. I assure the Minister these amendments are not put down except from the point of view of absolute necessity from the municipal side. All sections of the municipal authority are satisfied that these amendments are essential in the public interest, and from the municipal point of view. They are not merely asking for rights because they are a public authority, but they are asking for them for the purpose of being able to work in with the police authorities in regulating traffic, so that it will be for the benefit or the State as a whole and the public in general.

Comment on this

I suggest that possibly the difficulties the Minister mentioned might be avoided if he undertook in Section 145 to put in the words "the Commissioner may, with the consent of the Minister, and after consultation with the local authorities, make, in respect of any tramway system, the following Order, etc." That is the point I think Deputy Byrne wishes to have. If the Minister would amend Section 145 in the way I suggest I think he will get over the difficulty he mentioned.

Comment on this

I shall have the suggestion brought to the notice of the Minister for Local Government. But the tramways are regulated under a system of private Acts that could not be amended here.

Comment on this

I am not familiar with their private Acts, but if the Commissioner, in consultation with the Minister, can make regulations under Section 145, as obviously he can, because I am sure the section was carefully considered by the Department and the draftsman, surely he can do so after consulting the Department, and with the consent of that Minister.

Comment on this

Is the Minister making the point that the tramway stopping places cannot be altered or amended?

Comment on this

I am not making such points at all. It is clear that there is power to regulate where people may stop to get their trams; and as there is power to interfere in these matters, and as it is proposed to give the Commissioner power to make by-laws in connection with them, there is no reason why the Commissioner could not be forced to consult with the local authorities before making the by-laws. I shall bring that to the notice of the Minister for Local Government in connection with Section 145.

Comment on this

Would the Minister agree that these amendments be withdrawn in order that the Minister may consider the points of view, and, equally, that the members of the municipality may consider them with a view to finding out whether amendments could not be framed to meet the point?

Comment on this

I am not suggesting an amendment, but making suggestions to the Minister for Local Government.

Comment on this

Deputy Fitzgerald-Kenney suggested an amendment that he thought might meet our point. We would like to consult the municipal authorities upon the matter.

Comment on this

I merely suggested a point that might be helpful.

Comment on this

On the assurance of the Minister that he will give the matter further consideration I ask leave to withdraw the amendment.

Comment on this

Section 146 does not govern Section 145, does it?

Comment on this

I move amendment 48:—

In sub-section (2), line 58, to delete the words "County Surveyor" and substitute the words "County Council."

The object of the amendment is to make the county councils, instead of the borough surveyors, the authority to be consulted by the Minister before approving of a road in the county for the purpose of an omnibus route. As the sub-section provides for consultation between the Commissioner and the county surveyor in every urban district and county borough through which the road passes, the suggestion is that the council should similarly be the authority in the county to be consulted. Sub-section (2) definitely makes reference to the county surveyor as the authority to be consulted, and not the council, which is the employer of the county surveyor. I think it will be agreed by everybody in this House that the council should have some right to be consulted as to a bus route which it is proposed to make and which may possibly entail a road being made through some new housing estate of theirs. I think that the council should be consulted.

Comment on this