We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

Road Traffic Bill, 1933—Committee (Resumed).

Contributions 464–701 of 701. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 3 parts.

Bill Road Traffic Bill, 1933
Enacted

No. 3 of 1933 ›

I do not know why in this particular section the surveyor in Dublin should be picked out as distinct from the council, whereas the council is the authority in other areas. As Deputy Byrne has pointed out, the municipal authority after all is the ultimate authority. It may have a surveyor or certain surveyors in its employment from time to time, but I think the Minister should indicate that this was not done with any intention of singling out the City of Dublin to deprive the council of its authority. Apart from the distinction which the Bill makes, the municipal council may appoint a second surveyor. Which surveyor then is the Minister to consult? I think the Minister should leave us this authority in our own area.

Comment on this

If the Deputy reads the section he will see that his council is the authority. The sub-section says:—

Before approving of a particular road under the foregoing sub-section, the Minister shall consult the Commissioner and also the county surveyor of every county through which such road passes, the council of every county borough, borough and urban district through which such road passes...

In the case of a county borough, it is the council of the county borough that will be consulted. In the case of the county council, it is the surveyor who is consulted, and none of the county councils have asked that they should be consulted.

Comment on this

The point we make is that the county councils are not interested in maintaining or preserving the roads as we are. We are interested in preserving the roads in our area.

Comment on this

The section says that the council of the borough shall be consulted.

Comment on this

Then it is not the borough surveyor the Minister will consult in the city borough?

Comment on this

"The Minister shall consult ... the council of every county borough."

Comment on this

But the city borough is not a county borough. Our law agent has guided us as members of the municipal authority——

Comment on this

I am afraid he is getting a bad advertisement.

Comment on this

Hé assures us that this amendment is necessary to clarify the position as far as we are concerned.

Comment on this

I am quite sure he did not say that the City of Dublin was not a county borough.

Comment on this

I did not say it was not a county borough. It is a borough within the county, but it is a city borough in itself.

Comment on this

I strongly object to the county surveyor telling the council of a borough what road within their area should be used. As far as I can see, the county surveyor can go into a town in any county and decide whether a road there shall be used. The borough surveyor is not mentioned at all.

Comment on this

The section distinctly states that before approving of a particular road the Minister "shall consult the council of every county borough, borough and urban district through which such road passes." In the case of a county borough, borough or urban council, it is the council that is consulted.

Comment on this

And in the case of town commissioners?

Comment on this

Yes. It is only in the case of a county council that the county surveyor is consulted.

Comment on this

And in most cases the county surveyor will consult with the county council.

Comment on this

And if the reverse were there, the county council would consult with the county surveyor.

Comment on this

It is the reverse we want.

Comment on this

You have it.

Comment on this

Is the Minister going to give us what we want?

Comment on this

It is in the Bill already.

Comment on this

Having regard to the Minister's assurance that what we want is in the Bill, although a legal man appeared to have some doubt about it, we are satisfied. Once the Minister's assurance appears in the Official Report, we will take that as the official decision on the matter. I therefore ask for permission to withdraw the amendment.

Comment on this

Nach leor na fógrai agus na ticéidi do chur amach i nGaedhilg amhain sa nGaeltacht? Iarraim ar an Aire alt mar san do chur sa mBille.

Comment on this
Seán T. O'Kelly Seán T. O Ceallaigh Fianna Fáil

Táim sásta é sin do dheanamh.

Comment on this

I should like to know from the Minister whether the words "for which passenger accommodation is available in such vehicle" as contained in sub-section (1) of this section, mean that the vehicle cannot carry any larger number of passengers than it has accommodation for. Is the word "seating" implied before the word "accommodation"? It might have accommodation but still not have seating accommodation.

Comment on this

If the Deputy refers back to Section 20 he will find that that point is covered.

Comment on this

I take it from the Minister that passenger accommodation may mean either sitting or standing accommodation. Section 20 only gives power to the Minister to make regulations and in such regulations to distinguish between sitting and standing accommodation.

Comment on this

What does the word "accommodation" mean?

Comment on this

It may mean either.

Comment on this

Would it not be advisable to make it clear?

Comment on this

There are certain hours in the day at present during which a certain amount of standing accommodation is allowed. That will be continued under the regulations. There are certain hours during which not more than three passengers might be allowed to stand. That is the custom at present and I think the intention is to allow that to continue, but of course to limit standing accommodation.

Comment on this

I move amendments 49 and 50:—

In sub-section (3), paragraph (d), page 60, line 46, after the word "inspector" to insert the words "or an ex-officio inspector".

In sub-section (3) (e), page 60, line 52, after the word "inspector" to insert the words "or an ex-officio inspector".

Comment on this

I should like an explanation of what precisely is an ex-officio inspector.

Comment on this

The present ex-officio inspectors are members of the Gárda Síochána.

Comment on this

They are ex-officio inspectors of weights and measures, I know, but what members of the Guards are there who are ex-officio inspectors for the purpose of inspecting motor buses?

Comment on this

We want to make them such.

Comment on this

You say they are already existing.

Comment on this

We want to empower them to be inspectors under this Bill.

Comment on this

You put in the words "or ex-officio inspector," which seems to suggest that there are already existing ex-officio inspectors, and I want to know who they are.

Comment on this

There are inspectors of weights and measures at present and we want to empower these to be inspectors under this Bill. They have measuring instruments available.

Comment on this

I move amendment 51:—

In sub-section (4), page, 61, line 20, after the word "may" to insert the words "after consultation with the Minister and."

Comment on this

I move amendment 52:—

Before sub-section (5), page 61, to insert a new sub-section as follows:—

(5) The power of making general regulations vested in the Minister for Industry and Commerce by virtue of Section 5 of the Weights and Measures Act, 1904, shall include power to make, after consultation with the Minister, general regulations with respect to the provision and maintenance of standards and equipment by the Commissioner under this section and the verification of such standards and equipment and with respect to the guidance of special inspectors in the execution and performance of their duties under this section, and the said Section 5 shall be construed and have effect accordingly.

The Minister for Industry and Commerce considers it advisable that this amendment should be put in so as to safeguard the interests that are looked after by that Department in regard to traffic.

Comment on this

I move amendment 54:—

In sub-section (1), line 3, after the word "may" to insert the words "after consultation with the road authority".

This amendment is intended to provide that the Commissioner, in making by-laws for the control of traffic generally, should consult the road authority. The suggestion of the Corporation that such consultation should take place has already been adopted by the Minister in Sections 115, 124, 146, 147 and 148 and the amendments in my name have had the consideration and approval of a committee of the municipal council.

Comment on this

When the Bill was before the House on the previous occasion, similar amendments which were put up to many of these sections were suggested by the Corporation and wherever it was possible to secure that that consultation should be held with the local authorities in reference to regulations to be made, the necessary amendments were made in the Bill. This section, however, deals with a type of regulations that would be made to govern the whole Saorstát and it would mean, therefore, that, in the case of every regulation, every road authority should be consulted. We do not think that that would be possible, but in all other cases in which regulations are being made concerning a particular district, Dublin, Cork, Galway, or wherever it may be, the road authority will be consulted.

Comment on this

I move amendment 55:—

At the end of sub-section (3) to add the words "and the cost to the council of erecting or providing such notices, instructions directions and instruments shall be paid from contributions to be made to the council from the Road Fund."

I hope that this amendment will be acceptable to the Minister. The object of it is to secure that the cost of providing notices, instructions, directions and instruments for giving signals by mechanical means for the regulation of traffic shall not be paid by the ratepayers of the district but shall be borne by contributions to be made to the local authority from the Road Fund. Such expenses are properly payable from that fund rather than from the local rates. We all see the day coming when mechanical signals for the direction of traffic will be used to a great extent in Dublin City. These electrical robots will be asked for. Personally, I am against too much machinery being used in anything and I would prefer, if it were possible, that man labour would be employed everywhere possible for the direction of traffic. But, if in various outlying districts in which it might not be considered necessary to have a traffic constable, these electrical or mechanical devices are erected for directing traffic, the cost should not be borne by the ordinary ratepayer.

As you have a Road Fund being subscribed to by those using the mechanical devices to be erected under the Bill, we think that the Road Fund should bear the cost. My own opinion is that we are getting too fond of machinery and I see the possibility of machinery displacing men, which is regrettable, but, when I raised that point in another place, I was informed that in big areas where traffic constables had to be employed, they will continue to be employed and that these signals might go up in districts where traffic constables are not already in employment. I feel that I am appealing to a sympathetic Minister in this matter because he knows how heavy the burden of rates is on the city and, having regard to the fact that there is a substantial Road Fund in existence, I think it should bear the cost of those instruments.

Comment on this

Sub-section (5) of this section enables a contribution to be made out of the Road Fund towards the cost of erecting signs, particularly for roads that are maintained out of any part of the Road Fund. I think that will cover the point the Deputy has in mind.

Comment on this

If the Minister is satisfied it gives us power to demand the erection of these instruments we, too, will be quite satisfied.

Comment on this

I would like to know from the Minister whether it is the intention forthwith to put up mechanical signs for the control of traffic in parts of Dublin. I am anxious to know if that matter has been thought out. Of course, if it has not received full consideration, I recognise it would be unfair to ask the Minister to make a statement now. I suggest it should be given a trial in Dublin. I have been in cities where it has worked admirably.

Comment on this

That matter is one very largely for the local authorities. I refer now to mechanical or other signs. The local authority is the body primarily responsible in that case. We will certainly be prepared to consider any recommendations that they make with regard to the necessity for putting up mechanical signs. The matter has not received very serious consideration so far.

Comment on this

So far as I understand the section, the Commissioner makes the order and it must be carried out by the local authority.

Comment on this

After consultation with the local authority.

Comment on this

No, not after consultation with the local authority. This is one of the sections in which the Minister said consultation with the local authority should not be put in as of right.

Comment on this

That is so. Perhaps the Deputy is quite right. If the local authority are against it, of course the Commissioner would not insist on putting up mechanical signs as against other ways of directing traffic.

Comment on this

I have an amendment down to Section 145—to insert after the word "passengers" the words "and after consultation with the local authority the selection of terminal points on tramway routes"—but I recollect that this is the section the Minister referred to when we were dealing with a previous amendment. I am satisfied with the statement he then made, that he will give this matter further consideration, and I do not intend to move the amendment.

Comment on this

I have an amendment down to Section 147, but it is closely related with the subject-matter of my amendment to Section 148 and, in the circumstances, I am not moving it.

Comment on this

I beg to move amendment 58:—

To delete sub-section (1) (e).

Briefly, the amendment means that exception is taken to the payment of a fixed fee. It is held by many that the fee payable to the attendant at these parking places should be a voluntary and not a fixed fee. Under the proposal in the Bill the Minister will prepare a schedule of fixed fees to be paid to the attendants in parking places. My intention is to leave it entirely optional with motor owners as to what their contribution will be.

Comment on this

If I remember correctly, I think this subject was discussed at considerable length on another occasion. My recollection is that the consensus of opinion seemed to be that there should be a fee laid down. That is our view. The fee may not be a very large one, but there ought to be something definitely fixed and it should not be purely a voluntary matter. We think there ought to be something in the way of a definite fixed fee.

Comment on this

I quite agree we discussed this matter at considerable length when the Bill was before us on a previous occasion. There was a considerable variation of opinion on the subject. I must admit that the consensus of opinion was with the Minister. If he is still of the same opinion, there is scarcely any use in pressing the matter further.

Comment on this

How have the existing regulations worked? At the present moment these parking attendants get entirely voluntary contributions. No doubt they are very generously paid by some people, and, I think, on the other hand, it is highly probable that there are persons who do not pay at all, who avail themselves of the attendants' services and do not contribute anything. It seems to me there will be difficulties. I submit for the consideration of the Minister that there may be great difficulties about fixing a fee. If you fix a fee you must fix a very low one. If a car stands in a place for five minutes, nobody would give anything except a comparatively small tip. If a car were standing in a place for a couple of hours, I expect the ordinary person would give a reasonable tip.

If you fix a scale you will have to fix it at the very minimum and, in consequence, a person whose car stands for ten minutes or for an hour will be charged the sum of twopence or threepence and the result might be that the attendants would finally lose heavily, because the motorist would give the fixed fee which might very often not be one quarter of what he would give if it were left to his own generosity. I would rather like if the Guards ascertained the views of the parking attendants on this matter. This proposal in the Bill may have the effect of cutting down the tips which are being received by the attendants—making them very much lower than they are at the moment. Except in some places, I know the attendants are not doing extraordinarily well.

Comment on this

It is the Commissioner who will make the regulations and I am sure he will take the opportunity of reading over carefully the debates that have taken place on this matter. He will note the suggestions made as to how these fees should be regulated and as to whom he shall consult. I am sure all these things will be carefully weighed by him before he comes to a decision.

Comment on this

If this becomes law he will have to fix a scale and I am afraid it will be very difficult to fix a suitable scale.

Comment on this

What is done in other places?

Comment on this

I am afraid I do not know anything at all about that. I have never known of any regulations of this kind in any other place except, perhaps, privately owned places in America, where parking places are owned by private individuals and they charge a very stiff fee, sometimes a dollar an hour and sometimes 50 cents an hour, according to the locality. These are the only places of which I have any personal knowledge.

Comment on this

I was interested in the matter of these parking attendants when the idea was first introduced into Dublin. I am aware that they were in existence in parts of England at the time. It was not a new idea here at all. At that time they were worked by voluntary contributions in England and they were started here on the basis of voluntary contributions. I suggest that the Minister would have a consultation with the Department of Justice on this question and ascertain the views of the Guards on the matter. I do not want to press the thing any further. I only want just to point out that one danger.

Comment on this

I am afraid the Minister will find that the attendants will be opposed to this idea.

Comment on this

Possibly.

Comment on this

I am afraid they will suffer.

Comment on this

Quite possibly.

Comment on this

I beg to move a new sub-section:—

At the end of sub-section (2), page 70, to add the words—

The expenses of the local authority of acquiring, appropriating and adapting any such land for use as a vehicle station shall be paid from contributions to be made to the local authority from the Road Fund.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

This amendment is somewhat similar to amendment 55.

Comment on this

Yes, as there is some difference about adapting the land for a vehicle station I think I might be satisfied with an assurance given by the Minister that he does not intend this expense to fall upon the ratepayers of a particular area where the public generally will benefit. This is somewhat on the same lines as my amendment to Section 144 that any expenses in connection with the matter should be paid from contributions to be made to the council from the Road Fund. This will benefit the public generally and the expense should be borne out of the contributions to be made to the local authority from the Road Fund. I would like to have an assurance from the Minister on that matter.

Comment on this

I am afraid I cannot give any assurance to the Deputy with regard to this particular amendment. The idea of my Department is that all these various stations should pay for themselves. The local authority will decide whether it is wise to have such stations put up and whether they will undertake the expense of keeping them in order. If they do they should make them bear their own costs. I am afraid that I could not promise the Deputy it would be borne out of the rates.

Comment on this

Suppose a case like this: A number of motor car owners make up their minds to go out to Howth on Sundays—and we know that the ratepayers of Howth are doing their very best to make the place attractive—I suggest it would be rather unfair on the ratepayers of Howth to have to provide accommodation for people who go there on Sunday from Dublin. The same would apply to a number of areas in and around the city. These people would come from Dublin and places around it, and it would certainly be a hardship on the ratepayers of Howth and small areas like that to have to provide these conveniences. If they do not provide them see what is likely to happen. I would ask the Minister to give the matter consideration between now and the time when the Bill comes next before the House on Report Stage. Otherwise the necessary conveniences suggested might not be put up.

Comment on this

I am quite willing to give and carry out a promise to consider the matter. I will ask the Department to consider it again. I am not holding out any hope that there will be any contribution from the Road Fund for this purpose.

Comment on this

Having regard to the fact that we are asking for contributions from the Road Fund for other matters, I think this should also have a claim. I was making applications that an inroad should be made on the Road Fund for the purpose of providing that where roads are not properly lighted a contribution should be given for that purpose.

Comment on this

Would the Minister say if this section applies to bus or tramway stations in addition to parking places? I read it as applying to bus terminal stations?

Comment on this

Do you mean this particular section?

Comment on this

Yes, Section 150. Will it apply to bus terminals?

Comment on this

It will.

Comment on this

Railways which are in competition with the buses have to provide their own terminal stations, and if the railways have to provide their own terminal stations it is only fair that those in competition with the railways should have to carry similar obligations. I agree with Deputy Byrne that it would be most unfair that citizens would have the obligation of providing accommodation for these bus companies. I think some means ought to be provided whereby the burden of that expense would be taken off the city and thrown on to the bus users. What I have in my mind at the moment is that in Scotland a number of people travel by steamer to different places. Before they can get on to the steamer they have to pass through a gate at the pier, and at the gate at the pier there is a charge levied. A somewhat similar arrangement might be made in this case so that the burden of maintaining and providing stations would fall on those using the stations. I think it is only fair that the obligation should be cast on them and not on the ordinary ratepayers of the city.

Comment on this

The Deputy would not suggest that the Road Fund should be raided in order to provide these stations?

Comment on this

I do not think so, but the Road Fund may be used for many other purposes. I am only looking at the bus as a competing service with the railways. You cast on the railways the burden of providing stations and station equipment and the same obligation should be cast on their competitors.

Comment on this

That is my idea. If the obligation is cast on the local authorities to provide these stations they should have to ask the bus owners to pay a small fee. It is purely obligatory on the local authorities to provide these stations.

Comment on this

Supposing a number of small bus owners started using the place I have referred to, and, as a result of a big number of these small buses using the place, it is found necessary to erect lavatory accommodation for the people stopping there, even if it is only for half a minute, is it fair that the small township should be forced to build these stations rendered necessary by the motor traffic? This would really be for the convenience of motorists who are subscribing and paying towards the Road Fund?

Comment on this

Is it fair that Dublin City that gets within its bounds every day in the week many thousands of visitors from all parts of the country should provide accommodation for these visitors to the city and for whom accommodation of that kind must be provided in some way?

Comment on this

Does not Dublin City welcome its visitors?

Comment on this

Yes, certainly, Dublin City welcomes its visitors and is delighted to have them.

Comment on this

But it is entirely a different matter in a small seaside town where people are passing through and perhaps only stop for half-an-hour and where the township gets no benefit.

Comment on this

If the bus makes any delay somebody usually profits

Comment on this

Particularly if the weather is warm.

Comment on this

Or cold.

Comment on this

I move amendment 60:—

Before Section 152 to insert a new section as follows—

It shall not be lawful for any person to ride or drive a pedal bicycle or tricycle in a public place unless there is attached to same in a position appointed by regulations to be made by the Commissioner with the consent of the Minister a plate of the description required by such regulations bearing a registration number issued to him by the licensing authority as defined by Section 21 of this Act.

This amendment appears in my name although it is one of those suggested by and agreed to by the Municipal Council. I received a communication on the 15th March from the City Manager's Office saying he was directed by the Housing and General Purposes Committee of Dublin City Council to enclose me a series of amendments which the Committee at its meeting the previous night decided to request members of the Council to support. I looked through the amendments and, in my ignorance of the rules of the House, I left them in my pocket, thinking it would be just the time to move them when considering the Bill. Afterwards, I thought that, having regard to the very severe forms of this institution of which I am a member at present, I had better make some inquiry. I called at the office below and the clerk in charge told me that Deputy Byrne, whom you all know as the Lord Mayor of Dublin, had been in there and had lodged all the amendments. I said "Very well" and put them back in my pocket. I was not long out of the office when a messenger was sent after me to say that Deputy Byrne would not lodge the amendment relating to bicycles as he did not agree with it. I submit that when the Municipal Council make representations they ought to be heard in full. Consequently, I put down in my name the amendment approved of by the Municipal Council's Housing and General Purposes Committee. I have no feeling whatever regarding cyclists. If you accept this amendment, it is all right; if you reject it it is all right, so far as I am concerned. The case made in the memorandum submitted to me on behalf of the Municipal Council is as follows:—

The amendment, which is clear in its terms, speaks for itself and represents the opinion of the Corporation of Dublin on the necessity for the registration of pedal bicycles and tricycles and for imposing on the riders the obligation of the provisions of the Bill with regard to third party insurance. It is hardly necessary to point out the number of accidents caused by pedal bicycles and tricycles in which the victims had no redress owing to the fact that the riders of the machines were people of little or no means——

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

There are two amendments on the paper in the name of the Deputy—Nos. 60 and 60a. Amendment 60a is out of order and cannot be discussed. The Bill as read a Second Time provided for third party insurance for mechanically propelled vehicles. To extend the scope of the Bill to include pedal bicycles, would be to go too far. The Deputy must confine himself to amendment 60.

Comment on this
Mr. Kelly

You will understand that the Municipal Council of Dublin is speaking and not I. You have knocked out one half and I expect the Deputies present will knock out the other half on the same principle as obtained long ago in a locality in which I lived in Dublin. There was in the neighbourhood a small monarch who governed all he surveyed. He usually paid his rent to his landlord by saying to him: "You knock off one half and I will knock off the other." In order to retain the friendship of the tenant, the landlord always agreed to do so, as his tenant's enmity was particularly dangerous having regard to his fistic accomplishments. I have no feeling against cyclists at all—quite the opposite. I suppose I have much the same experience as other citizens who use Shanks' Mare. Some of the cyclists are gentlemen. If they get into your way or cause you either inconvenience or alarm, they express their sorrow for it. Others sometimes become rude and angry. Others call you names. "You old blind bat" was the expression used to me in a very busy thoroughfare in Dublin. An adjective was used also which is not pronounceable here. "Waken up, four eyes" was another expression used to me. I dare say if I was in a hurry and had very little experience I might use much heavier expressions. Regarding the ladies on bicycles, I have not the smallest possible complaint to make. I always admire them whether they go on two wheels or four wheels or whether they keep their feet near the ground, as I do myself. In my whole experience of Dublin, I have never yet seen a cyclist run away from an accident of which he or she was the cause. They always held their ground. I must say that for them. I do not think that I have made any case at all for the amendment standing in my name but I am not going to let the Corporation down. The Corporation was let down some years ago and we shall have a word to say about that piece of history some time or other. I submit the amendment to the consideration of the House.

Comment on this

I do not propose to accept the amendment——

Comment on this
Mr. Kelly

I was thinking you would knock off the other half.

Comment on this

For the very good reasons given by the Deputy.

Comment on this

I move amendment 61:—

In sub-section (5), line 43, to insert after the word "vehicle" the words "other than a mechanically-propelled vehicle." (Sub-section quoted).

It is thought, and I think the House will agree, that the obligations with regard to lights on mechanically-propelled vehicles are sufficiently heavy at present, and that there is no necessity whatever for applying this excellent provision to motor vehicles.

Comment on this

It is our view that the fitting of a reflector on a mechanically-propelled or other vehicle could not be any hardship. As we all know, tail lights sometimes go out, lamps fail, or something else happens, and the lights disappear. In that case it would be a wise precaution for the motorist himself to have a reflector.

Comment on this

Has the Minister considered what effect that will have, for example, on tourists? I do not know whether the obligation exists in any other country to carry a reflector in addition to a tail light. If it does not, anyone coming here would have to get a reflector specially put on. I must say it seems to me entirely unnecessary.

Comment on this

I would ask the Minister to look into the matter before the Report Stage, because there are, as he knows, large numbers of tourists visiting this country, and it would be rather a serious obligation to place upon them. The Minister may say that it is not a very heavy penalty, but it is not a very easy thing to affix to a motor. I think that he will get all the benefits which he hopes to derive from this provision from the attachment of this to other vehicles. I think everybody will agree that motor vehicles are sufficiently well-lighted at present. Of course, lights are liable to go out, but if the Minister argues that it is necessary to put a reflector on the back of a vehicle, so that when the light goes out there will be something to show, he might argue just as strongly that it would be desirable to put white reflectors in the front of all vehicles. I would ask him to consider the matter before the next stage.

Comment on this

If the headlights or other lights go out when travelling at night, a wise motorist will not go very far.

Comment on this

I saw one last night doing 50 miles an hour not very far from here without any lights.

Comment on this

I agree that there are difficulties, and that there is a difficulty about an attachment to a motor car. My advisers, however, are very strong on the matter. They think it is necessary. When the lights fail, something of the kind would be advisable. However, I shall look into the matter again.

Comment on this

I move amendment 51:

In sub-section (1) (a), page 74, line 38, after the word "to" to insert the words "the lamps and reflectors (if any) which are required by or under this Part of this Act to be carried lit or to be carried."

These words were dropped out of the print of the Bill by the printer. In fact in this draft of the amendment they dropped another word the word "on". These words that are here with the word "on" at the end should go in before the words "such vehicle".

Amendment amended by the addition of the word "on" at the end.

Comment on this

Is this the way the Minister proposes to deal with what I think is an abuse very largely, that is having dazzling head lights inside areas that are well lit?

Comment on this

Sub-section (c) covers it.

Comment on this

I move amendment 52.

In sub-section (1), lines 31-32, to delete the words "such lamp reflector or other instrument as" and substitute the words "a lamp duly lit and in efficient condition and so constructed and carried as to be visible at a reasonable distance in all horizontal directions which".

We had considerable discussion on this matter when the Bill was previously before the House. The section deals with the driving of cattle on roadways after dark and provides that the drivers of such cattle should carry "such lamp, reflector or other instrument as will enable him therewith to give to the drivers of vehicles approaching from any direction reasonable visible warning." I do not know what other instrument means in this and it does not say where the drover will carry the reflector.

Comment on this

At the back of the cattle.

Comment on this

It is the drover who is to carry it. How he is to carry it, or to make himself visible to an approaching motorist is not clear. The way I propose to clarify the situation is to delete the words "such lamp, reflector or other instrument" and to substitute the words in the amendment. If we had that regulation in, I do not think it would add very much to the troubles of those driving cattle at night and it would ensure their safety from approaching motorists. One of the greatest difficulties that a motorist has is when on a dark night he comes round a bend and before he has time to pull up is into a drove of cattle. That is the risk to the motorist and to those driving the cattle and it is a danger to the cattle. If such a lamp as is proposed in the amendment were carried the reflection of that lamp would appear for some distance and warning would be given to the approaching motorist. I think, with all respect, that it is an amendment which is desirable in the interests of all concerned.

Comment on this

As Deputy Good said, there was considerable discussion on this section when it was before the House the last time. The revised section is drafted to meet, as far as we could, the view of the House as expressed when we were discussing the matter before. It was felt that it would be too much of a hardship to ask drovers of cattle to carry a lamp, and it was pointed out to us in relation to one particular locality—there may be others—that the area was specially well lighted. Take the North Wall. It is very well lighted there when cattle are being shipped, but, although it is almost as lightsome there at those times as it would be in daylight, if the amendment were insisted on every drover of cattle would have to carry a lamp. We know the difficulties of the farming community——

Comment on this

It need not apply except in prescribed areas.

Comment on this

It is very difficult to prescribe those areas.

Comment on this

I think the Minister has quite a different situation in mind to what the framers of this resolution had. I quite agree that no motorist would run into cattle at the North Wall in driving down to the boat. The motorist who would do that under the present lighting conditions in this city ought to be very severely dealt with. What Deputy Good has mentioned and what I certainly had in my mind were country roads at night, which are practically unlit, and where in the summer time the road is grey— almost the colour of sheep. I would say that sheep are practically invisible on an ill-lit road in summer time. That is the precise situation which we had in our minds—where sheep or cattle are being driven from one farm to another in the country. It has been mentioned here in this Bill that the drover has to carry a reflector. I do not know whether he would carry the reflector before, or behind, or in his pocket. Certainly if he carried it in front it would be quite invisible to a motorist coming behind.

The Minister has displayed such solicitude for the safety of everybody that one would like to examine the class of accidents which do happen. As far as I know, the accidents resulting from one motor car running into the back of another motor car in motion are few and far between. I am afraid the accidents to motorists, such as Deputy Good has described—coming around the corner on a dark road and running into cattle or sheep—are fairly frequent. The drover is usually on one side of the road, and even if he sees an approaching motorist, he has no method of warning him. I would like to impress on the Minister that this is a very common cause of accident and a great danger to motorists. I think it is not very much to ask a drover to carry a lamp with some sort of reflector that will be visible and give some sort of warning.

Comment on this

A Chinn Comhairle, I am opposed to the amendment. I think it is rather ridiculous to ask a drover or whoever is in charge of cattle to carry a lamp. I think the accidents resulting from driving into cattle are so rare as to make such a section as this undesirable. I can only recall one accident of this kind in my own lifetime. Everybody knows that cattle coming towards you provide by their eyes the greatest reflector that can be produced. Anybody who on a dark night could not see the eyes of a flock of sheep or cattle coming towards him does not deserve to be allowed to drive a motor car. As regards cattle going away from you, they are generally followed by one or two persons. If you are to provide that every person walking after a flock of cattle has to be provided with a light, it follows logically that every man walking on the road ordinarily must be provided with a light or reflector. One suggestion is just as logical as the other.

I cannot conceive of any motorist driving carefully, at whatever speed, running into a flock of cattle numbering anything more than one or two. I notice that in the case of the lesser number this regulation does not particularly apply. Although if there is any danger it would be occasioned by a single beast or two beasts. As regards any man in his ordinary senses, driving carefully, irrespective of speed, it seems to me impossible that he could drive into a flock of cattle. Only once in my long experience of motorists have I seen a man driving into a flock of cattle, and on that particular occasion the man was not in a condition to drive a motor car. There is danger, as Deputy Good says, of a motorist coming around a bend driving into a flock of cattle. There is danger of driving into anything, and it is because of the negligence of people driving around bends that accidents of any kind happen. I fail to see the necessity for the lamp, or, for that matter, any light at all.

Comment on this

We should like to hear the Minister on this horny problem.

Comment on this

I certainly feel I cannot accept the amendment. I think what is provided for in the section as re-drafted will meet the situation. In my opinion, it would be too much to expect that every individual on the road should carry a lamp as suggested by Deputy Good and Deputy Dockrell.

Comment on this

Will the Minister prescribe regulations as to how these reflectors or other instruments are to be carried or worn by drovers?

Comment on this

Are they to be carried in front or behind?

Comment on this

Both!

Comment on this

Will you insert "both"?

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Is amendment No. 63 withdrawn?

Comment on this

I am afraid I will have to withdraw it. It goes against my will, though.

Comment on this

I move amendment 53:—

In sub-section (1), line 10, after the word "section" to insert in brackets the words "(the drivers of privately or professionally owned cars excepted i.e. those cars not plying for hire)".

What I ask in this section is that drivers of privately or professionally owned cars be excepted. A person may be considered to be on duty even if he has made a stoppage and is waiting for whoever he is driving. In the case of a medical man the car may be stopped for a considerable time. Under this section a man might be construed to be on duty even though sitting in the car and not actually driving. For that reason I would ask that the driver of the private car should be excepted. I can see the force of the section in providing that a man shall not be in a bus and driving for longer hours than we prescribe, but in the other case where his actual driving would not be so very long, he might be considered to be on duty even though he was not actually moving the car.

Comment on this

The Deputy's speech has, in fact, very little relation to his amendment. His amendment proposes to exclude entirely from the operation of this section employed drivers of private cars. I can see no justification for that whatsoever. If, in the interests of public safety, we prescribe maximum driving hours for the professionally skilled drivers of omnibuses and lorries there is, in my opinion, a much stronger case for prescribing similar hours in respect of drivers of privately-owned cars who are as a rule less skilled than the drivers of the public service cars or the commercial cars. In any event the same considerations of public safety apply. I think most Deputies will admit that the greatest danger on the road is the man who is half asleep, and who has been driving for a long period and has not got the full control of his wits, so that he is unable to think rapidly in case of an emergency. If that is a danger to be avoided the provisions to deal with it should apply just as rigidly to the driver of the private car as the driver of the public service car or the commercial car. In fact, I was expecting that we would get an amendment to this section to extend it to the owner driver. We have not included the owner driver in the section because of the difficulty of administering it, the difficulty of securing evidence that the owner driver had, in fact, exceeded the hours prescribed. If there was any substantial demand by the House for the inclusion of the owner driver, I would not be disposed to resist it. It seems to me that in every case where the driver is an employed man and subject to orders these maximum hours which are quite reasonable should be insisted upon in the interests of public safety. I think any man who has been driving for 11 hours in a day, even with half hour intervals, is so tired that he is not in a fit condition to take full control of a high-powered car. The Commissioner of the Gárda Síochána, and other parties, interested are repeatedly issuing notices to drivers to remember that when they are in charge of a car they are in charge of an instrument capable of considerable destruction, and it is absolutely necessary that such persons should be wide awake and not apt to be in a somnolent condition. That is why we think these conditions should be inserted. They are, in our view, essential conditions for securing the public safety.

Comment on this

I am sorry I did not make myself sufficiently intelligible to the Minister. I was asking for a definition of what he considered was driving continuously. Does he mean that to be the actual driving, or supposing there are hours at intervals when he is not actually driving, does he consider him on duty then?

Comment on this

Where a person is in charge of a car, apart from the time in which he is free to take rest and refreshment, he is regarded as being continuously driving.

Comment on this

That would certainly be an argument against including the owner driver.

Comment on this

I think another thing that should be taken into consideration is the owner driver. Certainly in the case of public vehicle services you have the driver continuing day in and day out, whereas it should be quite reasonable for the owner driver to do a very long day, and perhaps then to rest for several days afterwards. I have done 12 hours myself and I imagine myself quite as capable to drive at the end of 12 hours as at the beginning.

Comment on this

I take it, it is quite clear that the section does not apply to the owner driver.

Comment on this

No, it does not.

Comment on this

Would that be looked into because many reading the section would read it as applying to the owner driver as well as to others. I would be glad if the Minister looked into that matter.

Comment on this

Certainly.

Comment on this

I move amendment 65:—

In sub-section (1) (b), line 14, to delete the word "eleven" and substitute the word "eight."

I would like to make it clear to the House that I fulfilled all my promises to the Municipal Council. I could tell at the beginning that there was one amendment which I could not see my way to move. The Corporation suggested that Section 110 of the 1931 Bill, which has been repeated in Section 119 of the present Bill, should contain regulations governing hours of labour not less favourable than those contained in Section 19 of the English Road Traffic Act, 1930. This Section 167, which is a new section, is an improvement in the matter of hours and goes far to meet the Corporation's suggestion. The Corporation are of opinion that it does not go far enough. They consider the seriousness of continuous periods of driving, and that in one period of 24 hours it should be limited to eight hours instead of 11 hours as suggested in the measure. Now, if I want to make a speech to support that amendment I would just try and repeat word for word the Minister's speech a few moments ago on the last amendment when he said men working for long periods are a danger to the public. This eight hours suggestion instead of 11 hours was unanimously agreed upon by members of every party in Committee. This amendment had the hearty support of every member of the Corporation representing Labour, members of the Minister's Party and others. I am asking the Minister to accept it in view of the speech he made a few moments ago. I think men driving for a long period, without a break, have to sleep on the return journey, and are a danger to the community.

Comment on this

I gathered from Deputy Byrne that the consideration that weighed with the Council for the inclusion of the amendment, was that it would prescribe hours of driving not less favourable than that of the British Act. This section prescribes hours of driving not less favourable.

Comment on this

We tried to get this suggestion put through in a previous Bill, but did not succeed. The Council agreed that the new section goes further, but not far enough, and they asked me to press the amendment.

Comment on this

The first point arising out of this is that the section in this Bill is not less favourable than the corresponding section in the British Transport Act. In fact, it goes a little further than the British Act. The second point is that the section does not permit eight hours continuous driving. It permits a maximum of five and a half hours, and it provides that in any period of 24 hours there may be a succession of periods not amounting, however, to more than 11 hours. I think if Deputies consider the circumstances under which certain omnibus services are conducted, the period in which private cars—not owner driven —but driven by hired employees—are utilised, and the circumstances under which certain commercial cars have on occasions to be used, they will come to the conclusion that the provisions here are not unreasonable and that any lesser provisions would be a considerable restriction on trade. This section does not set out to prescribe what should be regarded as maximum hours of work for persons employed in the transport industry. It sets out to prescribe in the interests of public safety the maximum number of hours any person can drive in 24 hours. If an omnibus driver takes a bus to Ballina in the morning and has a rest in the afternoon, and comes back later, he would be entitled to do so under this Bill, subject to the total driving hours not exceeding 11 hours. That is what it is intended to provide for. It seems that if we were to prescribe that in any circumstances no one could drive an omnibus, a lorry or a car for a greater number of hours than eight in 24, the restriction upon a number of commercial enterprises would be very considerable. This is not a restriction that is essential to the public safety. I think we have taken our cue from the British Act and got the periods least likely to impose hardship on commercial enterprise, and at the same time we secure the maximum of public safety which is what we were aiming to do.

Comment on this

Would the Minister say where there is a check on the number of hours worked by a driver?

Comment on this

The Bill provides that the period shall not be more than 5½, and in successive periods not more than 11 hours in the 24 hours.

Comment on this

I follow that, but where is the check on the actual number of hours worked?

Comment on this

It is made an illegal offence.

Comment on this

There is a complaint.

Comment on this

The ordinary law will operate then.

Comment on this

I know that if an employee of a company makes a complaint to the Gárda Síochána, automatically, if he can prove that the hours laid down have been exceeded, a charge can be made against the owner of the vehicle. Failing a complaint by an employee where is there a check in the section on the actual number of hours worked? I was reading to-day evidence that was tendered before a British Tribunal dealing with this matter. The Minister is after admitting that he has copied the working hours from a British Act. According to the evidence before the British Tribunal the Act there is so loosely worded that it has been possible for employers to impose intolerable conditions on employees so far as working hours are concerned. If an employee makes a complaint and a prosecution follows I know what would happen to him shortly afterwards, if the employer was convicted.

Comment on this

What does the Deputy suggest?

Comment on this

Is the Gárda Síochána to bolster up a trade union?

Comment on this

I am not going to accept the Deputy's view on that. Naturally the Deputy would like to evade the issue involved in an amendment of this kind. I suggest that if the Minister wishes the section to be effective there must be some arrangement for a log book which could be produced when asked for by the Gárda Síochána or by any one administering the Act.

Comment on this

I do not know if Deputy Davin can reconcile his view of this amendment with what his Party proposes in the next Bill which deals not with the carriage of passengers but with the carriage of merchandise. As far as I can make out under this Bill an employee can drive for 5½ hours, they stop for half an hour's rest and go on again for another 5½ hours. That is the limitation put upon him in the 24 hours, a half an hour's rest during each period. But he can be made to work 77 hours in the week. That is the situation with regard to the carriage of passengers in public service vehicles. In the other Bill to which we are coming, Deputy Norton wants to have an amendment inserted providing that the maximum hours of work by persons employed in the carriage of merchandise shall not be in excess of 44 hours a week.

Comment on this

The Deputy is confusing the two things. This section has nothing to do with the maximum hours a week. It has to do with the maximum number of hours worked in 24 in the interests of public safety. The Deputy is only trying to cause a little confusion. The fact is that this section has relation only to one consideration—the public safety. The Road Transport Act of 1922 and 1923 was designed to give effect to certain general principles affecting employment in this country. That is entirely different to what is under consideration here. May I remind the Deputy that an attempt was made to introduce a section similar to this, prescribing the maximum number of hours per week in the Road Traffic Bill introduced by his Government and that he strongly opposed it? He wanted no limitation.

Comment on this

I have not declared my attitude yet on the merits of the rest of this Bill. I want Deputy Davin to reconcile the two things—a 77-hour week being possible as far as this section is concerned. I did not go further than that.

Comment on this

As far as the Traffic Law is concerned.

Comment on this

In the next Bill which deals with merchandise Deputy Norton desires to have a maximum of 44 hours a week. How does he reconcile the two?

Comment on this

The Deputy was listening on the Second Reading to the principle of the Bill and under a certain section when considering applications for licences, the Minister must consider the condition of the workers employed by carriers. A question was put to the Minister from these Benches and he indicated the lines of the proposed Bill, which are the lines in this section. It was then understood that the matter would come up for consideration long before the Transport Bill. Everyone admits that Deputy McGilligan can make good debating points but anyone who understands the Bill knows that he is misrepresenting the position of the employees, as laid down in the Road Traffic Bill. All I am concerned about is that the Minister should ensure that it is possible to detect any owners of vehicles who may be abusing the conditions laid down in the section. How can they be detected if they force employees to work hours other than those laid down? They can only be detected by an employee making a complaint, and if the owner is convicted, and the employee loses his position, I want to have some method devised under this section so that the responsibility should not be laid on the employee who made the charge.

The Minister knows perfectly well what would happen to any employee who would make a charge against his employer. I want some system to be devised to deal with this. I want an assurance from the Minister that something in the nature of a log-book, or some other scheme of the kind, will be devised which will enable the people responsible for administering this Act to detect those owners who are trying to evade its provisions.

Comment on this

That suggestion might be practicable in relation to a limited number of operators, such as bus owners and so on, but this section relates not alone to those but to everybody in the country who is employed in the driving of a car, whether a private or a commercial car. Obviously, it would be quite impossible to arrange for a log-book in all these cases. As I have said, it might be possible to devise some such system in relation to omnibuses, licensed bus services, or public service vehicles generally; but I do not think that it would be practicable in relation to every single commercial or private car in the county for which there is an employed driver. Undoubtedly, the position is that action could not be taken under this section except the information came to the Guards in some way. That information need not necessarily come from an employee. As we all know, such information sometimes comes from an employee who has been dismissed and who has a grievance against his employer. In addition to that, there are other means, obviously, by which information can also come. For instance, an investigation into an accident might reveal the fact that the driver charged with responsibility for the accident had been working for an excessive period, in which case, his employer would become liable to a penalty under this section. In such cases, and many others, information might come to the Guards that this section had been contravened and, following on that information, action would be taken. Apart from that, I do not think that there are any practicable means of devising a system. We might devise one to cover those who get licences under the Bill now before the Dáil. In relation to this particular section, however, I think that the enforcement of it must be left to the ordinary course of things as in the case of every other section in the Bill.

Comment on this

One could not fail to notice that when the Minister said that it is impossible to devise a scheme to cover this matter, Deputy McGilligan said "Hear, hear." Deputy McGilligan made that comment when the Minister said that it was impossible to devise any scheme to detect owners of vehicles who might be inclined to ignore the provisions of this section. With regard to what the Minister has said as to the impossibility of devising such a scheme, I suggest that the very same argument would apply in the case of the licensed traders of the country in so far as there is no proper inspection on Sundays or during the various prohibited hours in a week all over the country. Obviously, it is impossible for the Guards in every case to go into the houses of licensed traders during all the prohibited hours, whether during the prohibited hours on Sundays or any other part of the day or week. But in ordinary business concerns there is some record kept of the time worked by the employees. Take the case of the factories coming under the Trade Boards Act. The Minister has some way of finding out what are the hours of work in these factories if a complaint is made to him.

Comment on this

—A complaint made by whom?

Comment on this

Surely, it is not beyond the bounds of possibility for the Minister, with all the resources of his Department to help him and with all the advice which is at his disposal, to find some ways and means of having this Bill administered in the interests of the employees.

Comment on this

I will admit that my arguments were weakened, perhaps, by the remarks of Deputy McGilligan, but they have not been necessarily invalidated.

Comment on this

What I want to emphasise is that in this section now before the House, this democratic House is asked to give recognition to a possible 77 hour working week.

Comment on this

No. This has nothing whatever to do do with the number of hours per week.

Comment on this

I say that it is possible under the terms of this section for a man to have to work 77 hours per week.

Comment on this

This section has only to do with the number of hours which a driver may drive having regard to the public safety. If under some other Bill the drivers of omnibus or road vehicles are confined to ten hours— well, I suppose it would have to be 11 hours—it would not conflict with this. That is an entirely different proposition. What would be regarded as proper working conditions have nothing to do with this Bill. This is simply a Road Traffic Bill, and its aim is the public safety merely. The object of this section is to prescribe a certain number of hours per day for driving consistent with the public safety, and it is to prescribe the number of hours per day that this section is concerned with. No question of the number of hours per week arises.

Comment on this

There are a number of employers who keep their men out for many hours. They can be seen by anybody around O'Connell Bridge at all hours.

Comment on this

If the Deputy knows of the case of any small bus owner who is working his men for 77 hours a week and paying small wages, I suggest that the Deputy should not keep that information to himself. If the Deputy will give me that information, I can assure him that the owner will lose his licence.

Comment on this

I say that this section gives power to sanction a 77 hour week. I have been asked by my colleagues of every Party affiliation to press this point home. Eight hours is what is asked for instead of the 11 hours named in the Bill. I have already stated that the Corporation were satisfied that the Minister might go a long way to meet them, but not far enough. I can satisfy the Minister that there are employers who do work their men for 77 hours a week.

Comment on this

On omnibuses?

Comment on this

Yes. I had complaints to that effect from men themselves— conductors who are working at a wage of 30/- a week from early morning to late at night, until they almost collapsed. I asked these men to put it in writing. They did not do so, but I will make it my business to find out the names of these employers who are working these men and who will avail of this Act to work the 77 hours.

Comment on this

The first condition of an omnibus licence being given is that reasonable hours are worked and satisfactory rates of wages paid. When all these licences came up for renewal on 31st October last year we publicly notified, in the Press and otherwise, that anybody who had any reason to object to the renewal of licences on the ground that that first condition was not observed, could do so. We did get objections and in each case, as soon as the objections came to the Department, we were able to force the owners to improve the workers' hours and to increase the rate of wages. I have received no complaint since then, but if there is the possibility of making a complaint on that ground and if the information is supplied to my Department, then it will lead to the result I have stated. There is adequate machinery for dealing with that, but all that has nothing whatever to do with this Bill which only prescribes the maximum hours per day that may be worked by persons driving all sorts of cars.

Comment on this

Would there be any administrative difficulty in the way of having periodical surprise tests carried out as to the number of hours worked particularly by people employed in the carrying trade? I know one fairly large lorry owner operating in my constituency who pays his men a minimum wage of £1 a week with commission on the tonnage carried. The result is that his workers are influenced to work unduly long hours. They have to do so to earn a reasonable weekly wage.

Comment on this

So far as lorries are concerned we have no power at the moment to deal with them, but when we get our road transport legislation through we shall then have in relation to persons operating merchandise road services the same powers that we now have in relation to omnibus services. All that, however, has nothing whatever to do with this particular section. What is prescribed here is the maximum driving hours per day. That is done in the interests of public safety. The working conditions that should operate on an omnibus or a merchandise service will arise on the other measure.

Comment on this

Would the Minister consider the question of devising some additional wording for this section so as to make it effective in law?

Comment on this

I think Deputy Davin ought to be encouraged to let the House know a little more about this method of test that he in some vague way envisages. The Deputy talked about a log book system. I applaud the Minister's answer to that, that it is impossible to administer it: that it would be very complicated and cause an awful amount of expense and trouble.

Comment on this

The Deputy does not want it.

Comment on this

I am not concerned with it, looking at it impartially. I do not see how it could be administered. The Deputy now proposes a surprise test, but how is this test to be carried out? A surprise test means that an inspector authorised for the purpose pays a surprise visit and asks somebody—is it to be the employee?—what number of hours he has been on duty. I presume that is what the Deputy means.

Comment on this

Ask for the production of the log book.

Comment on this

The Deputy is back again to the log book system, but that has already been ruled out. The Minister said that it would be too cumbersome, that you could not impose it on every employer, and that it would be troublesome and expensive. The only other thing then is to ask the employee and Deputy Davin has already answered himself on that. He said that the employee could not answer because if he did so he is going to be victimised. Therefore, the Deputy himself has set up an insuperable obstacle to any method of inspection, because if employers are going to be heartless enough, as he suggests, to get rid of employees who give information, they are certainly going to be heartless enough to do that if they make log book entries of unreasonable hours worked. The Deputy cannot have it both ways.

Comment on this

There are three trade unions catering for workers engaged in road transport. I can assure Deputy Davin that they are very active organisations. At any time anything comes to their notice in which it is possible for the Department to interfere in support of their contention I have deputations coming to me, one from each union, generally within twenty-four hours of the complaint being made. The Deputy can rely that the trade unions will ensure that adequate information will be supplied if anything occurs that warrants a complaint being made.

Comment on this

I am aware there are some people who will be concerned in the proper administration of this section and they are not in any trade union at all. I know of one employer in my constituency and when his employee joined a union he was immediately dismissed.

Comment on this

The Minister has denied that under the section a man could be employed for over seventy-seven hours a week.

Comment on this

He cannot deny that.

Comment on this

Would the Minister not admit that under the section as drafted a bus owner would be entitled to infer that his men could work seventy-seven hours a week and that there was nothing to prevent that?

Comment on this

There are the conditions of the licence.

Comment on this

But they are not laid down.

Comment on this

I understand the Minister has laid it down that, for the purposes of paragraph (b) of sub-section (1) of the section, so long as a man is in charge of a lorry he shall be deemed for the purposes of the section to be driving the lorry. I want to put this case to the Minister. Supposing a merchant has a man driving a lorry and the man is sent out to deliver stuff here and there through the country, are the intervals during which he is engaged unloading the stuff—these may extend to half an hour or forty-five minutes in a particular place—to be considered part of the time during which the man is driving the lorry?

Comment on this

If the man is not free to take rest and refreshment, yes. If he is free to take rest and refreshment, no.

Comment on this

But suppose the man is driving on the road and has a breakdown?

Comment on this

That is provided for.

Comment on this

The Minister has not satisfied many members of the House on the point that has been raised by Deputy Byrne. I want to know from the Minister if the meaning of sub-section (1) is this, that an employer may keep an employee engaged on seven days a week for eleven hours per day.

Comment on this

I have already explained that six times, and I am not going to do it a seventh time.

Comment on this

I am not going to say anything about this seventy-seven hours a week that has caused so much discussion. I believe it is too ridiculons, and at any rate I am certain the trade unions will look after that. Having regard to the strain imposed on men driving these road transport vehicles is the Minister satisfied that with a short interval, say, of half an hour for lunch they are competent or that it is safe in the public interest, to drive for an eleven-hour period? Take the case of men driving these heavy vehicles from Dublin to Limerick. Is the Minister satisfied that a man would be competent to carry on at the wheel for eleven hours with the little break that is provided for in the section? I suggest to the Minister that he should define the period that must elapse between the two working periods of five-and-a-half hours each.

Comment on this

We have fixed eleven hours as the maximum total of all the periods that a man may work in twenty-four hours. That is the utmost limit. If a man was driving for more than eleven hours he would be a danger to the public. Some men might be a danger after driving 10½ hours, while others like Deputy MacDermot might go on for twelve hours.

Comment on this

He could have his 11½ hours.

Comment on this

No, not more than 11 out of 24.

Comment on this

It is possible to have 11 hours instead of 11½ out of the 24.

Comment on this

Yes. It might be necessary, in certain circumstances in a particular trade, that a man might make that journey in a day. It has nothing to do with the hours he works per week. He might work 11 hours one day and none the next and none the next and 11 hours the next day. It is the maximum. As the law stands at present, he might drive 24 hours; there is nothing against it. The idea here is to try and get a period which is reasonable, having regard to the convenience of particular trades, and, also, to public safety. We are considering the matter and, it seems to us, that the periods specified in the British Act seem suitable. We are following that idea as the period was fixed following a very exhaustive inquiry. They all arrived at the same conclusion that 11 hours should be the period. I am prepared to adopt that as the maximum. A man may drive 11 hours who is not fit to drive any more.

Comment on this

Could not the Minister stipulate that the interval ought not to be less than an hour?

Comment on this

I am prepared to consider that.

Comment on this

I think it would be a great improvement to the Bill if the Minister would consider a separate section for buses. I think the weakness of the whole section is to try to cover too many different sets of things. The Minister must insist on the real principle that ought to be considered, that is when a vehicle becomes a danger to the public. It is particularly wrong in principle to tell a man, at one kind of work, say a man driving a lorry delivering goods, that after a time he becomes a danger to the public if he works the same number of hours that a man driving a bus does. If there was a separate section for bus drivers I think we might get a section —one that would satisfy all parts of the House.

Comment on this

We have powers at present under the Transport Bill. These powers are general powers and I explained the manner in which they were administered. We tried to get each licensee to give the same conditions of work and wages which a good employer would do. We were trying that and gave licences generally for a period of three months. Then we got an inspector to procure the information required as to the wages paid and hours worked. Once that was established we began to cut off at the bottom. We were assisted by the trade unions, who laid objections on the ground that the hours of work were too long and the wages too low. In each case where that happened notice of objection was sent to the licensee, and conditions and wages were improved, so as to bring them up to the general level. This worked very satisfactorily, indeed, and I do not think that in relation to the omnibus service there is any complaint at the moment. There may be particular instances that I cannot call to mind, but, as far as I am aware, the trade unions expressed themselves satisfied in relation to the omnibus services at the moment. If they were satisfied that the position was not satisfactory, and if any particular licensee tried to increase the hours of work, or decrease the standard of remuneration to the extent that would draw forth a protest in that direction, we would consider the protest in relation to our information as to the general conditions, and, if we considered the protest justified, we would give notice to withdraw the licence if the conditions were not improved. So in relation to omnibuses we have powers, not all set out here, but in another Act, to ensure what are reasonable and satisfactory conditions.

Comment on this

I understand that and I am not confusing that at all with when a driver of a vehicle is likely to become a danger to the public. My point is that a man driving a public bus will get tired very much quicker than a man doing ordinary work. I think there ought to be a separate section dealing with bus drivers and, likewise, chauffeurs, but to mix them all together is not satisfactory.

Comment on this

I want to try to return to the point at which I started. The Minister tried to fog the discussion by referring to the complete hold he has upon licensees. He has not explained so clearly that he has power to impose what he calls reasonable conditions. But while he has that power to introduce reasonable conditions, he now introduces a section to say that notwithstanding what he thinks reasonable a maximum 77 hours a week may be worked.

Comment on this

No. Why not calculate it per month or per year?

Comment on this

It would only be worse. Deputy Norton, on behalf of the Labour Party, gets a Bill dealing with passenger services to be carried on. He gets the hours reduced and then he finds a section whereby the Minister can attach reasonable conditions on the person getting the licence. He is not satisfied with that. He will have a new section saying the maximum number of hours shall not be more than forty-four in any one week. I would like to have that standard more definitely established.

Comment on this

It will be established with or without your consent.

Comment on this

Not at forty-four hours?

Comment on this

We now know where you stand.

Comment on this

I do not think the Deputy ever had any doubts on that. Why is that a reasonable condition that must attach both to the licences for passengers and goods services? They are almost identical. Deputy Norton wants an overriding condition. He wants forty-four hours maximum for goods and he is prepared to allow seventy-seven for passengers.

Comment on this

No, no. Wait until the division is over.

Comment on this

I want to know what is the Labour Party's view. Do they take their stand on forty-four hours in regard to the carriage of goods and what is their attitude in regard to the overriding provision of seventy-seven hours for passengers?

Comment on this

When this Bill was before the House in 1931 it was sought to insert a section similar to this amendment. Deputy McGilligan stood for twenty-four hours a day or 168 hours a week.

Comment on this

I give the Minister a month to produce a quotation from any statement of mine in support of that.

Comment on this

The Deputy stood for twenty-four hours a day.

Comment on this

I did not.

Comment on this
Division

Question—"That the word, proposed to be deleted, stand"—put.

Tá 76
·
Níl 32
Result Carried The question put was agreed to.

Do you agree with this result?

I move amendment 66:—

In sub-section (3), line 48, to delete the words "or permits."

I think that the Minister ought to be satisfied with the word "causes." The addition of the two words "or permits" introduces a great deal of ambiguity into the working of the section and it will lead to all sorts of disputes between masters and men and as to the interpretation of the section. The Minister should be quite satisfied if an employer does actually cause his employee to work over hours.

Comment on this

The Deputy appreciates that that would make it almost impossible to get a clear case in any single instance. The section definitely makes it an offence for an employer to cause or permit an employee to work for more than 11 hours in the day and that responsibility is definitely placed on the employer because, otherwise, we would always have a conflict of evidence as between employer and employee in any case that might arise. It seems to me that, if the section is to have any value at all, these words "or permits" must remain in it and I think it is right that they should remain. It is, of course, desirable, in the first case, to ensure that there would be no possibility of misunderstanding as to the obligations and no possibility of a conviction falling through because of inability to prove what would otherwise be capable of proof under the section, but, in any case, I think that the employer of men engaged in any transport business should clearly understand that it is against the law for him to allow, much less to insist, on one of his employees driving a bus for more than 11 hours a day in view of the public safety being involved.

Comment on this

That is exactly why I urge the omission of the words. It will be practically impossible for an employer to prove that he did not permit. His only remedy will be dismissal and he will have to turn out his employee if he has done wrong. It will be nearly impossible for him to prove in court that the thing was not done with his permission.

Comment on this

I want the Deputy to keep in mind that the main consideration behind this Bill is the public safety and I want him to consider the section from the point of view of the person on the road whose life or health is being endangered by the fact that a person is driving a bus or lorry for more than eleven hours a day. It is not a matter entirely of the relations between employer and employee or the effect of the section on such relations. The main consideration must be the public safety and, as we make it illegal for an employer to require his employee to drive for more than eleven hours, it is illegal for an employee in fact to drive for more than eleven hours, and, consequently, it should be illegal for an employer to permit his employee seeing that he controls the vehicle, to work more than eleven hours.

Comment on this

That is an illustration of what I was saying a few minutes ago. The Minister is trying to make the same clause apply to different things altogether. The Minister has in mind one group to whom this section applies—the bus or lorry driver—and I am thinking solely of the chauffeur.

Comment on this

I am thinking of him, too.

Comment on this

In that case, it will be impossible for an employer to clear himself, if you leave these words in.

Comment on this

Would the Minister say, if an employer gives a general instruction to a driver that he was not to break the law in this respect, whether that would discharge the employer from liability or will it be held if, despite the employer's instructions, the man does break the law by driving for twelve hours or by not taking a rest in the middle of the day when he should take it that the employer permits that because he cannot prevent it? How can he? Take the man with a lorry in the country who sends a driver out to do eight hours' delivering of merchandise. He tells him "at one o'clock, you must stop driving until a quarter to two." It transpires that the man does not do so but stops only for a quarter of an hour or twenty minutes—part of his earnings may be commission and he wants to cover as much ground as he can— but, although the employer expressly warned him that he must not do so, is the employer still to be liable for something he cannot control and, no matter what he does, cannot control, beyond cautioning the employee not to do it?

Comment on this

The only argument I can advance against the Deputy is that, on the whole, our judges and justices are reasonable people.

Comment on this

I quite agree. If the Minister tells me that if an employer can prove to the satisfaction of the court that he expressly forbade it, that acquits him, I am quite content, but does the word "permit" mean that if the misdemeanour or irregularity has occurred, it places a liability on the employer from which he cannot escape by any explanation? What more can an employer do than say to a driver, "Do not do this." He cannot follow him.

Comment on this

In my opinion, it would be a good defence for the employer if he satisfied the court that the driver had exceeded the hours against his express orders.

Comment on this

I have the profoundest respect for the opinion of the Minister for Industry and Commerce on almost everything but, on points of law, I am afraid——

Comment on this

The Deputy asked for it.

Comment on this

What I want to ask the Minister is whether he has considered that question and consulted his legal advisers and, if he has not, will he do so?

Comment on this

Does Deputy Dillon know the existing law?

Comment on this

Deputy Dillon knows an extraordinary deal.

Comment on this

There is more in it than Deputy Dillon has said because express forbidding may not occur and yet the employer may not intend or, in fact, have permitted, the breach of the law which has taken place. Yet, it will be impossible for him to prove it. It may be said that he ought to have expressly forbidden but he could not expressly forbid such a thing on every occasion.

Comment on this

I will look into it and see if it is possible to get any phrase to convey the same idea.

Comment on this

Would it be possible to get the Committee Stage accepted as completed now and have these amendments that remain—there are very few —brought on on Report Stage?

Comment on this

It is after hours. There is a section that might be debated then.

Comment on this

Would the Minister say what business will be taken to-morrow?

Comment on this

We start with this Bill to-morrow and we hope to complete it to-morrow morning.

Comment on this

The Road (Transport) Bill will remain over until next week?

Comment on this

No. If the Road (Traffic) Bill is completed to-morrow, we will start on the Road (Transport) Bill until twelve o'clock when Private Members' time comes on.

The House adjourned at 10.30 p.m. until Friday, 24th March, at 10.30 a.m.

Comment on this