We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

Private Deputies' Business. - Public Services (Temporary Economies) Bill, 1933—Second Stage (Resumed).

Contributions 1–182 of 361. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

Bill Public Services (Temporary Economies) Bill, 1933
Enacted

No. 12 of 1933 ›

Seán MacEntee Minister for Finance (Mr. MacEntee) Fianna Fáil

I was showing the effect on the various Services of the respective scales which are set out in the Schedule of the Bill. I was showing how equitably they would apply to the various branches of the public service, taking all the circumstances into consideration. I think I had dealt with the position of those who are at a point on the various scales of salaries up to £1,000 per annum. At the point of £1,00 per annum a civil servant would, under the provisions of the Bill and due to the operation of the cost-of-living figure, suffer a deduction of £84 4s. per annum; an officer in the Army enjoying the same pay would suffer a deduction of £85 per annum, and an officer of the Gárda Síochána would suffer a deduction of £77 18s. per annum. Up to the point of £1,200 a civil servant would suffer, due to the Bill and the fall in the cost-of-living bonus, a deduction of £99 13s.; an officer in the Army would suffer a deduction of £100; an officer in the Gárda Síochána, £91 13s. At the point of £1,300 in the scale, a civil servant would suffer a loss of £117 5s., and an officer in the Gárda £107 14s. Up to the point of £1,400 per annum the civil servant would suffer a reduction of £136 19s., and the Gárda officer £125 1s. A civil servant whose total remuneration was £1,500 will suffer a reduction of £158 19s. per annum. There is no civil servant in the State with a salary of £1,600 per annum, but if there was such a civil servant he would suffer a reduction of £180 12s.

The figures which I have read will give the House and the country some idea of the economies which we are enforcing on the public service. These figures will give an idea of the magnitude of these economies. They will also I think serve another purpose. They will indicate that so far as possible the burden has been imposed equitably upon all branches of the service. I do not know whether it would be necessary at this stage to discuss the question whether that in fact is true or not. All I know is that it has been the purpose of the Government to realise such an equitable distribution. I would suggest that, possibly, it is a matter which does not arise immediately for debate at this stage of the Bill; that in the Committee Stage the Schedules can be discussed in detail and, as I think I have indicated, it is not proposed to take the Committee Stage of the Bill until after Easter. So that the various sections of the House will have time to formulate any criticisms they may have to make as to the manner in which the sacrifices are being exacted from the various classes of public servants.

As to the amount which we hope to gain from this Bill, I want to say that speaking last year I indicated that we hoped to secure by a reduction in the salaries and allowances in the various public services a sum of £250,000 per annum. Of course at that time already almost six weeks of the financial year had elapsed. It would be necessary, then, if we were to secure that sum in the remaining portion of the year to have imposed burdens possibly at a heavier rate than they are imposed in this Bill. Leaving that fact out of consideration, and remembering that the scope of this Bill is somewhat wider than was in my mind at any rate when I made that statement in May last year, the total amount which I hope to secure by the particular operation of this Bill as distinct from and excluding any savings we may secure in the cost-of-living bonus, will be about £280,000 for the year as contrasted with the figure of £250,000 which I mentioned last year as the saving in something less than 12 months.

This year we hope to make the saving effective for the whole 12 months. The burden may, if possible, be increased in some cases, in other cases our experience was that it would be desirable not to impose our original intentions in their full rigour but to ameliorate them in some way. I do wish to say, speaking personally, that I feel that these are heavy sacrifices. I do not want to disguise that from the community at all. I do not want to lead any section of the public service to feel that we are indifferent to the sacrifices which we ask them to accept now.

Comment on this

They are only for one year?

Comment on this

Yes, only for one year. Our need is very much greater this year than last year. The need everywhere of all Governments to secure economies is greater than it was last year. If we have to cast our net a little wider, and if in some instances we have to ask for increased sacrifices, it is merely, as I have said, because our need is greater, and that more drastic measures must be taken to meet that need. The year which is closing, I am happy to say, as far as present indications go, will be much less unfavourable, and will turn out to be much more satisfactory than some of the dismal prophecies which we were hearing during the last three months would have foreshadowed. The revenue has been in all circumstances fairly elastic. I believe that our Estimates in that regard are going to be realised if not exceeded, but the preliminary estimates of the revenue for next year which we have prepared, indicate that we may expect a substantial decline.

On the other hand, there has not been a corresponding decline in expenditure. Such a decline in expenditure could only have been secured at the cost of the social services and it is not the policy of the Government to secure economies in that way. On the other hand, if revenue is going to decline, and if expenditure cannot be reduced, there is only a choice of two ways in which the deficiency may be met, either by imposing additional taxation or meeting it to some extent, as the Government propose to meet it, by reducing, not expenditure on the social services, but by reducing the remuneration paid to public servants. I do not want to be taken as, in general, favouring that as a principle. I feel that the community ought to pay as much to its public servants as it can afford to pay, but the time comes when the ability of the community to continue to pay salaries at rates which were fixed in more prosperous times comes to be one for consideration and one for doubt. I believe that in our case it has gone past the stage for doubt, and it is now a certain and an assured fact that, for the coming year at any rate, public salaries and remuneration could not be maintained at the rates and the standards which have hitherto obtained here. Consequently we are in this position: We cannot, and we do not wish to impose any additional taxation. We have got to balance our Budget; we have to pay our way. Therefore, in all the circumstances, we have got to ask these public servants, who, taking every factor into consideration, can best afford to make the sacrifice, to make a sacrifice which will enable this State to maintain its good reputation and its good credit.

Comment on this

I move:—

To delete all words after the word "That" and substitute the words "the Dáil declines to give a Second Reading to the Public Services (Temporary Economies) Bill, 1933 until provision is included therein for the reduction of allowances payable to Deputies and Senators."

The position that we on these Benches have taken up in this matter has been on certain occasions deliberately misrepresented and, therefore, I propose to preface my remarks by saying that we fully recognise that it is essential to secure the truly democratic character of this Assembly, and to do that it is the duty of the State to make it possible for people, no matter what their resources may be, to come here and represent their fellow-citizens if their fellow-citizens desire to send them. Therefore, every Deputy is entitled to an adequate allowance to make it possible for him to do that. I personally recognise that in arriving at an estimate of what an adequate allowance is we must have in mind the position of a wage earner who is obliged to absent himself from his work, possibly to leave his position, in order to discharge his public duties in this House. I certainly fully recognise that an allowance, sufficient to make it possible for such a person to exercise his democratic rights is essential.

The Minister for Finance suggested in the course of his observations that he would have preferred me to have taken a different course from that of putting down an amendment at this stage. I would have preferred to have proposed an amendment to introduce a new section, but the structure of the Bill did not permit of that. I would remind the Minister that the reason I have taken this occasion to bring this question to issue is that 12 months ago in introducing his Budget it was suggested to him that before he asked for further sacrifices from different sections of the community he should take steps to see that the members of the Oireachtas made their contribution on a fair and equitable basis. In the last 12 months we have heard nothing from the Minister as to his intentions on that matter, nor, so far as I am able to see, has he in this Bill, or in any of his public speeches, given any sign that it was his intention to examine this matter from the point of view from which we wish to have it examined.

I move the amendment in order to extract from the Government a Bill designed to effect economy in public services which we can support. Personally, I should much prefer to see the Government pursuing economy at the expense of the public services along the lines of reducing personnel and as and when they have reduced personnel as low as they can, consistent with an efficient public service, then and only then should they proceed to bring salaries down, if the public purse demands it. It seems to me, however, to be a strange form of economy to make a great public démarche of reducing salaries and, at the same time, increasing the junior staff in certain Departments to the tune of £60,000 or £70,000 as the Government are doing by the tariff policy in which they are at present engaged. To my mind it is going to serve the public purse very little to reduce the salaries heavily all along the line and, at the same time, to introduce a horde of new officials under the Wheat Bill, under the Tariff Bill, under the Prices Control Bill, and the hundred and one other measures that the Government have brought in, so that what we save to the public purse at the one end we are going to scatter at the other end in the creation of new officials. To my mind that line of economy is all wrong. The object of the Government should be to reduce the personnel so far as it is consistent with efficient public administration, and then, and only then, if public economy required it, to call upon that personnel to make such sacrifices as are just and equitable in the common good. We feel that to call upon that personnel to make these sacrifices without showing ourselves to be prepared to share the sacrifices is to give them reasonable grounds for resentment. If there are to be sacrifices—and the President did not put a tooth in it, because he said on a historic occasion, “We cannot have omelettes if we do not break eggs”—if we are to have sacrifices in order to prosecute this economic war, then our position is that the sacrifices should be equally and fairly divided amongst all sections of the community. The Government should not look to the agricultural community to bear the whole share of the burden, and they should not look to civil servants to bear the whole share of the burden.

The burden should be distributed evenly between professional classes, the Civil Service; the members of this House, the agricultural community and the labouring man; all should bear a fair and equal share. I know it may be said in certain quarters that it is comparatively easy for somebody who is not dependent exclusively on his Parliamentary salary to advocate deductions. I am not suggesting, nor will I at any other time suggest, that we should reduce the allowance of members of this House below the figure which we have laid down as sufficient for a civil servant or a public servant to rear a family on. I am of opinion that if we equate the Parliamentary allowance to the salary which was given by the State to a civil servant in 1922, when our allowance was fixed, we cannot feel that we are doing the poorest man in this House an injustice by bringing his Parliamentary allowance down to the same level as we are prepared to bring a civil servant's salary.

Comment on this

What about the two homes—a home in the country and a home in Dublin?

Comment on this

Deputy the Lord Mayor makes a most pertinent interjection— what about the two homes? Might I remind the Lord Mayor that members of the Seanad sat in the Seanad for 36 days in the year on an average, and have accordingly received salary at the rate of £10 per day in attendance.

Comment on this

I am talking about members here.

Comment on this

I am talking about members of the Oireachtas who attend the Dáil on an average of 72 days a year, and are accordingly remunerated on a basis of £5 per day. I am fully aware that a conscientious Deputy has expenses in going about his constituency at home, and that he has expenses in looking after the true interests of his own people, but it should be borne in mind always that he has free 1st class railway expenses to and from his constituency. I do not want anyone to imagine that we are going to advocate the cutting of Deputies' salaries down to some preposterous figure. I am prepared to defend the principle that if the true democratic character of this House is to be preserved an adequate allowance must be made, but what I say is that if a certain sum was adequate in 1922 for a member of this Dáil, and for a civil servant or public servant of any kind, then the same sum is adequate to-day for a member of the Dáil or a member of the Civil Service. I feel that when we put our hands to the task of reducing our neighbours' income we ought to be sure that we are not ready to ask any man to bear a burden which we ourselves are not prepared to bear. It is very easy for Deputies to get up and say "so-and-so has plenty, and it does not matter to him what allowance he gets." There are very few people in this country, after the last 12 months, who have plenty. I might remind some Deputies that those of us who are trying to do our best to prevent the growth of unemployment, and who are trying to keep on our pay-rolls men who served us well in the past, and who now, as a result of the policy to which this country has been committed, have no work to do, find it hard enough to make ends meet. There are many people, though perhaps they had enjoyed the reputation of being persons of substance, who, in consequence of the burdens that are being put upon them—unless they turn their employees out into the street—are left with a very little margin.

No one wants to drag his own affairs before the public notice on an occasion of this kind. I merely wish to discuss this question on its merits, without reference to the personal affairs of any individual Deputy. I admit the principle that once we have a flat rate we must resolve that the poorest man who is called upon to discharge public duties will be adequately provided for, otherwise he would be at a disadvantage, and there should be no question of advantage or disadvantage as between any two men coming into this House. I quite admit that. I also hold that we should not ask public servants or other persons over whose income we have control, to make sacrifices we are not prepared to share in the same proportion. It is for that reason, and in order to secure an undertaking from the Minister now, or a Bill, drafted in different form, which will spread financial sacrifices evenly between us—the members of this Oireachtas—and the people whose salaries we propose to reduce, that I introduce this amendment. If the Minister will introduce a Bill giving effect to these proposals, then we will support his Bill. We believe in the reduction of public expenditure, and we believe that it is the duty of the Minister to effect a substantial reduction in public expenditure. We will co-operate with him and assist him in any way we can, but we ask that he should proceed on a fair and equitable basis. If and when he signifies his intention to do so, he is assured of our support, but until he is prepared to give that undertaking this amendment stands, and I move it.

Comment on this

There is a prevarication and an untruth stamped on the whole speech and on the whole attitude of the Minister for Finance in introducing this Bill here. He puts the Bill before us in circumstances of which all Deputies in the House are aware, and he tells us that this is only for a year. The Minister is to start off on a pilgrimage to Rome; I would like to ram that untruth down his throat on his way, because the Minister in apologising for his position this morning, pleaded illness. The Minister is on the horns of a dilemma.

Comment on this

I beg your pardon. I did not introduce into this debate any question of my personal position. I asked, and I still ask, that the Second Reading of this Bill be taken, in order that the principle which is set out in sub-section (5) of Section 7 may be accepted, that is:—

"Every deduction made before the passing of this Act from salary paid to a person to whom this part of this Act applies which would have been a lawful deduction under this section if this section had been then in force shall be deemed to have been made under this section and to be and always to have been lawful accordingly."

I want that principle accepted; that is why I am asking that the Second Stage be taken, and not because I have any personal interest in having the Second Stage of this Bill taken to-day or any other day.

Comment on this

I say the Minister finds himself in a dilemma. He does not know whether or not he can afford to appear before the Civil Service as leavening the spirit of a holiday abroad with the feeling that his duty has been done by fixing in some way or another the cuts in the Civil Service salaries. In fact, the decision has been taken to-day in order to relieve the mind of the Minister, when he is away on holidays, from the anxiety that might hang over it if this decision were not taken now. We oppose this measure. We oppose it because it is introduced by the most uneconomic and the most spendthrift, as well as the most destructive, Government this country could have.

The Minister yesterday evening at 7.30 took a breathing space in the middle of a Second Reading speech on the Damage to Property Bill. That is a Bill under which, in the circumstances of the bad financial conditions that the Minister implies but does not describe in his speech, he proposes that the taxpayers of this country would contribute money for its payment over to persons who had suffered injury in property or in goods in circumstances in which they were associated together for the purpose of destroying property and goods— persons who, according to Section 9 of the Damage to Property Act, 1923, were "associated or combined or in league with the person or persons by whom the injury was committed for the committal of that injury or for the committal of other similar injuries to property." Those persons combined together to destroy property, their own amongst others. They gave their own property for the purposes of an organisation that carried out the destruction of property, and they are to be compensated in this very bad financial year for damage that they themselves did to their own property, if necessary.

When the Budget was introduced last year, a Budget and a general policy which, as Deputy Dillon has indicated, has left very few people in this country in the position in which they can boast of any great riches after 12 months experience of it, it was described from the benches on this side as the economic counterpart of the civil war. This Bill is a continuance of the attack on the administrative machinery of this State that was begun in 1922 and that has continued ever since, an attack not only continued on the lines proposed in this Bill, but continued in many other ways. The Government that is so careful to cut down the expenses of the machinery of administration in this country sent to the courts within the last few days not only its Attorney-General but Senior Counsel and Junior Counsel, for what? To prosecute individual units in the machinery of the administration of this country, individuals in that machinery that they have been after since 1922. No expense was to be spared, not for the prosecution of communists caught on the roofs of houses in Dublin with revolvers, but for the prosecution of responsible officers who were, if you like, part of the machinery that carried on the administration of this country against the attacks of the party now in power.

It is because of the general policy of the Executive Council and the general losses that they have brought on the country that we are opposed to this measure. They tell us that they are going to save £280,000 by this Bill. They say it is only for this year. That is untrue. That is not their intention. Yesterday the Government were convenienced by getting through all its stages a Bill dealing with the dairying industry. I do not know what information was given to the House as to what that Bill is going to cost the country. The Irish Independent states, following its examination of the situation created by it, that it is going to cost the consumers of this country £1,200,000.

Comment on this

Was that figure got in the Cumann na nGaedheal offices?

Comment on this

At any rate that figure is quoted. Part of the figure is made up of 21/- per cwt. as being caused by the economic war. Roughly, from the figures available in the Irish Independent——

Comment on this

Might I ask the Deputy did he vote against the Bill?

Comment on this

I did not, because the Minister came in, as he has come so often to the Dáil, with the child in his arms, stating that he wanted all stages of it if the State was not to collapse.

Comment on this

Voting against it would not have relieved them of the cost. I suppose the Minister does not know that.

Comment on this

The figures in connection with that measure are such as to suggest that for the butter alone that is exported out of the country £480,000 approximately is to fall on the people of this country, or nearly twice the amount of money that is to be saved under the Bill we are discussing. The farming community know that that is a very small figure in their total losses.

It is at this time when a policy is being pursued which is costing our farmers millions of pounds, and is going to throw on the consumers of butter a charge of £480,000, that it is proposed to save this sum of £280,000 and from whom? From the men who, in my opinion, are standing between the people of this country and the destruction of the State. I suggest that the Minister for Finance could not get another Minister to take this Bill and pilot it through the House because, as politicians at the cross-roads, they had told the mob that they were going to go and cut off the big salaries in Dublin. As administrators in office they met civil servants, big and small, and realised something of the work that falls on the civil servant, realised how very futile and very often misdirected will be the effort of a political head if he has not the preparatory work done for him and if he has not the guidance and the experience that is enshrined in our Departments of State. They find it difficult, coming from the cross-roads and having addressed the mob there as to what they were going to do with the big salaries—after spending a couple of months working in co-operation with the heads of the Civil Service, or the middle and lower classes in the Civil Service, to stand up in public and say: "These men are not worth their money."

It has been suggested in many ways that this country is over-officialed. When I think of the incompetence of some officials in various parts of the country that members on the opposite benches stand over in the administration of local government work and the salaries they pay them, and then think of the work that is done up here, I find it very difficult to have any respect for many persons on the far side or to have any belief in their sincerity that they want this country administered in a sound or economic way. I say to members of this House that this country in its Civil Service is not over-officialed. In 1922 we took over the Civil Service of this country such as it was then. It was a Civil Service that fed straight into the head Departments in London. Over that Civil Service we put a top: we put the necessary keystone that made the Civil Service here a self-contained unit and linked it up with the Oireachtas. We did that with an economy of numbers and an economy of salaries. I personally take exception to statements made by persons in responsible political positions in the country, such as Deputy MacDermot, who from time to time seems to make it as one of the foundation stones upon which he will build up a farmers' organisation in this country that "Mr. Cosgrave introduced a horde of officials into this country." Mr. Cosgrave did nothing of the kind.

Comment on this

Deputy MacDermot is not long in the country.

Comment on this

Any responsible section of people in this country that takes up the attitude that there is a horde of officials around the Government here in Dublin who are overpaid and underworked is doing as big a disservice, as a class, to themselves as they could possibly do, and is doing a very big disservice to the country as a whole. I do not think that there is a single Deputy in this House, whatever may be his politics on this measure, who has attempted to do any serious work for his constituents, who does not realise the excellence and the merits of the civil servants generally and the absolute necessity to this country to have a good Civil Service, and to have it so well paid that you will relieve the heads of the Civil Service from anxieties that might otherwise be theirs. It must be remembered that, while a Minister can leave his office at any time, the man who is at the top of the Civil Service has, night and day, the responsibilities and the worries of everything that is a matter of policy and of administration in the country here. I say that this Bill before us is nothing but low politics on the one side, and, on the other side, a continuance of the attack on this State that has gone on since 1922.

I, personally, do not approve of the amendment that Deputy Dillon has put down to this Bill. I think that the proposal in the Bill should be discussed on its merits, and on its merits alone. I think, in the circumstances in which we find ourselves here, and with this measure coming from the hands of those from whom it is coming, that the country or the representatives who can in any way stand for any scrap of the policy with which it is associated—the present economic war that is completely undermining our whole economic conditions in this country—are only reducing themselves to a very absurd and a silly position. What Deputies are paid or what they are not paid does not matter twopence in a country in which policies are being pursued such as those being pursued here. So far as proposals like it are concerned, they are as a smoke-screen drawn across the situation here and designed to feed further the stirring up of feeling among the mob and the unemployed that there are big people at the top with money, including Deputies, who can be stripped in order to provide them with the things they want. In so far as things of that kind are concerned, it is designed to help the Fianna Fáil policy of developing a very strong, very active, and well-mobilised left wing in this country. We are asked in this Bill to cut the salaries of members of the Civil Service, who are doing hard, solid and necessary work, men who, by the very fact of their existence—notwithstanding the policies that are being pursued on the opposite side, and which are actually being put into force—by their very existence and their work saved this country from some of the dangers and from some of the losses that would otherwise have fallen on this country. These people are going to be cut in their salaries. Their standard of living is going to be reduced. The domestic anxieties under which they labour, and under which they labour increasingly with the rise in income tax and the increasing difficulties that they are finding in placing their children into employment in this country, and with the hope of doing that receding in so many homes are to be increased— and these are the people whose salaries you are being asked to cut. You are being asked to cut the salaries of these men by people who, while individually digging themselves in pretty well, are destroying the economic foundations of this country—for that is what is happening.

We have been told that this Bill is urgent and that this Bill is necessary. We got it yesterday. We were told voluntarily from the opposite side that it was going to be discussed to-day. I suggest that it was deliberately left in that position in order that in a short session of the House—in a Friday House—there might not be the critical examination of this measure that it deserves. From the first letter to the last full stop we are opposed to this measure.

Comment on this

I want to say at the outset that the Labour Party is opposed to this Bill, and equally opposed to Deputy Dillon's amendment. Before I deal with the Bill, I should like to say a few words about Deputy Dillon's amendment. In my opinion, Deputy Dillon's amendment is so much eye-wash and so much claptrap, and nobody knows it better than Deputy Dillon, who, I am sure, is capable of working out a simple sum in arithmetic in order to see how much money would be saved to the taxpayer if the allowances to Deputies were halved. Deputy Dillon says that the present scale of salaries for Deputies was fixed in 1922; but he says that since then reductions were made in the allowances to civil servants and that, consequently, there should be a reduction in the allowances to Deputies. Everybody knows that the civil servants very vigorously opposed the reductions. In face of the protest by the civil servants, Deputy Dillon wants to offer them some consolation, or rather pretends to deceive them into believing that he is offering consolation, by an amendment of this character. Deputy Dillon took 1922 as the starting point for the purpose of his comparison. I am sure that Deputy Dillon is not unfamiliar personally with the fact that in 1909, 1910, 1911, 1912, 1913 and 1914, members of the old Irish Parliamentary Party were paid a salary of £400 per annum. If that was a fair and adequate remuneration for a member of Parliament from 1908 to 1914, and no protest, on the ground of extravagance against that remuneration was made, surely an allowance of £360 per annum in 1933 is not extravagant, when we remember that some members of the old Irish Parliamentary Party, admired then and admired now by Deputy Dillon, received at that time the sum of £400 per annum.

I believe what the Deputy said to-day was just part of the supercilious, superior nonsense that emanates from people who talk about doing things with a high public spirit, but who make sure that they themselves are well fortified with this world's goods, behind all their protestations of public spirit. There is not a member on these benches—and I make the offer now to the Leader of the Centre Party; and I do not mind if a Commonwealth chairman arbitrates — who would not exchange this world's goods with the leader and the deputy leader of the Centre Party. Deputy Dillon knows perfectly well, and so does Deputy MacDermot, that even if the amendment is carried, and even if there is a substantial reduction in the allowances paid to Deputies, so far as the leader and the deputy-leader of the Centre Party are concerned, there will be no sacrifice. Yet, apparently well endowed with this world's goods, they propose to set a standard for other people. I suggest that that kind of supercilious patronising outlook ought to be dropped. If Deputy Dillon feels that he has more salary or allowance than he can use, there are abundant ways to put it to some useful purpose, instead of coming to this House, fortified, presumably, with a good bank balance, and purporting to prescribe an economic existence for other people. I suggest to Deputy MacDermot that ordinary good taste should induce him to persuade the deputy-leader of the Party to withdraw the amendment.

I want now to deal with the Bill. I did not catch what the Minister said, but I understand from Deputy Mulcahy that he hoped to save approximately £280,000 in connection with this scheme of economy.

Comment on this

Inclusive of bonus.

Comment on this

I did not say bonus.

Comment on this

Presumably it is necessary to save £280,000 this year. On the Second Reading of the Railways Bill I stated that the Government definitely and deliberately decided to hand over £280,000 to the railway companies, which it is admitted by the Government and the railways is actually owing to the State to-day. I said to the Minister for Industry and Commerce, who was in charge of the measure in this House, that I hoped that as there was an economy crisis or when furrowed brows were endeavouring to balance the Budget, that someone would remember the generous gift which the State gave to the railways, because under the Railways Bill they are given £280,000. Apparently that £280,000, handed over to the railways by the State, is now to be got out of the pockets of the public servants who are attacked in this Bill. Does the Government want to act the part of Brewster with the railway companies and, in many cases, act the part of Lazarus with its own underpaid servants? The Minister said it was necessary to have the cuts, and this Bill is introduced to attack public servants, whose remuneration is threatened in the Bill.

Take the case of a doctor who is carrying on his practice and receives an income up to £1,000 yearly. Is it fair that a doctor in the Civil Service, receiving £1,000 per annum, should be asked to make this sacrifice when the doctor outside is not going to be asked to make a similar sacrifice, even though the outside doctor's remuneration may be twice as great as the remuneration of the doctor in the Civil Service. Of course this Bill is not confined to the cutting of the remuneration of civil servants in receipt of substantial salaries. The Bill is an attack not merely on salaries which are fairly substantial but on low salaries, because whole groups of wage earners will be assailed by the wage slashing policy enshrined in it. The Bill is endowed with the title "Public Services (Temporary Economics) Bill." That title is a masquerade. It is a wage-slashing Bill, and the Minister knows perfectly well that those in receipt of £2 10s. a week will be cut. I put it to the Minister, to Deputy Cooney, and to Deputy Cormac Breathnach, who have trade union connections, are they going to stand for trade unions or for an attack on the wages of people with £2 10s. a week? If that principle is announced, as Deputy Cooney and Deputy Breathnach know, there is a definite incitement to private employers to follow the example. If Deputy Good or Deputy Dockrell were here, I am sure they would have no hesitation in saying that the mentality postulated in this Bill will be noted with considerable glee in the Chamber of Commerce, and will be noted with care by employers' organisations in the city and elsewhere throughout the country. One can imagine the statement of the Minister for Finance being read carefully and analysed by some wage-cutting employers, in order that they may obtain from him the requisite amount of philosophy to "put over" wage cuts on their employees.

Call this Bill what you will, it makes a definite attack on the remuneration of people in the wage-earning category. Because it does that, and seeks to cut wages as a remedy and as a recipe for the existing crisis, which, in fact, will not be found to be either a remedy or a recipe, I am completely opposed to this Bill. The mentality behind it is the old capitalist philosopy; cut wages and everything will be all right. I could understand the Minister desiring to effect certain kinds of economies in the form of eliminating waste, but this is not a Bill to eliminate waste. It is not a Bill to cut out unnecessary or redundant services. This is not a Bill to get rid of trimmings which are unnecessary in this country.

This is a Bill steeped in the philosophy of cutting wages and that then everything would be all right. What is the economic problem the Minister is attempting to deal with? What is the economic crisis to which the Minister refers? If there is any crisis in this country it is the problem of poverty—chronic poverty with a large section of the people. That is the real and indeed the only problem. The economic crisis which confronts the country is due to the fact that our own people are unable to purchase what we produce here. The economic problem in this country and in the world to-day is due to the inability of consumers to purchase the products of industry. The gap to-day between production and consumption is widening and widening. That is the problem confronting this country. The Minister imagines that by cutting wages and salaries and by reducing purchasing power he is going to provide a remedy in a country where the purchasing power is already too low. Cutting purchasing power is not a remedy for an economic problem brought about by inability to purchase the goods and services that are produced here.

If cutting wages could ever have made the world prosperous, the world of the last ten years should have been a very prosperous world indeed. Wage slashing has been recommended here and elsewhere as a remedy for almost all industrial and economic ills. Has the wage slashing that took place in this country for the last ten years produced the remedy that some people claimed in 1922 that policy would produce? Has the wage slashing that we have seen indulged in in other countries in the world produced the remedies that those who sponsored such a policy prophesied it would produce? Everybody knows that the attack on the purchasing power of the community, in the form of cutting wages and salaries, practised for the last ten years, has not made the world better or more prosperous; it has made the world poorer and it has brought about the economic crises through which these countries are passing to-day.

If there is anything to be learned or any significance to be attached to the speech of the Minister for Finance, it is an indication that the Minister, at all events—and perhaps in this matter he is speaking for the Government—has got cold feet on his own economic and industrial policy. The speech of the Minister clearly indicates that he has no faith whatever in his own industrial and economic policy because if the Minister had any faith in the policy of his Government to bring about that economic and social regeneration, which is spoken of so glibly at election times, he has no case whatever for cutting purchasing power and attacking wage standards such as are being attacked in this Bill. This is just an attempt to apply a cut plaster to a disease which is not an external disease but which is a disease affecting the whole organism of society in this country. Merely to apply an external lotion, in the form of a wage cut, is not going to cure all the diseases from which the organism of society is suffering to-day. The Minister imagines, in the old capitalist way, that all you have got to do is to cut salaries and wages and that then everything will be all right.

Instead of the Government facing up to their responsibility, by implementing the Christian social policy we hear spoken of so often outside the House but which is never implemented in this House, we find the Government patching up to-day a system of society in this country which is neither Christian nor Irish nor moral. Instead of dealing with the matter by way of implementing the Christian social policy, about which the Minister speaks so eloquently at times, we find no attempt made to implement that social policy. Instead, we find the Minister following figuratively and literally in the philosophy of "cut purchasing power, cut wages and salaries and everything will be all right." Instead of bolstering up the foreign and unnatural social system, for which the Minister is standing in this matter, the Minister might well tell the House that he does not propose to deal with the economic crisis by wage cuts, but that rather he intends to build up a Christian social system without which we must have always wage cuts, always unemployment and all these social evils and sores which follow in the wake of an unnatural foreign social system.

Other Government, says the Minister, have found it necessary in other countries to cut wages and salaries. Is that any reason why we should do the same? Surely the Minister for Finance is not going to say that we will make up our own minds as to what is good for our country, so far as our governmental institutions are concerned, but, that in the matter of wage cutting we will follow the example of Chinamen or Japs. Governmental institutions, hall-marked 22 carat Irish, are the only kind of governmental institutions that satisfy the brand of patriotism that the Minister vaunts. We must have genuine 22 carat Irish political institutions, but when it comes to wages and salary cutting, let us look around the world for any example. No matter what country it comes from it will be good enough so long as it means a wage cut. That is the extraordinary omelette I find in the Minister's speech to-day. He wants to take his political institutions from Ireland and his examples for wage attacks from any part of the world. Surely the Minister will hardly contend that the economic conditions and the unemployment that exist in other countries are such as to justify him in following the examples of these countries in their economic or social policies? Wage cuts in these other countries have not brought the prosperity that those who stood sponsor for the cuts, maintained they would. Wage cuts there have brought what wage cuts here will bring, namely, a reduction in the purchasing power of the people and the enforcement, on those affected by the cuts, of a standard of living which in many cases cannot be reconciled with the vaunted Christian social policy for which the Minister claims to stand. In my opinion, there is neither vision nor remedy, as there is certainly no statesmanship, in this Bill so far as an economic and social policy is concerned.

The Minister wants to have wage cutting. He wants to reduce wages. He might make some slight show if he were only cutting the remuneration of those in receipt of salaries approximating to £600, £700, £800, £900 or £1,000, but let the Minister and every member of his Party remember that every vote given for this Bill is a vote for cutting the remuneration of people with approximately £2 10s. a week. It is a definite incitement to private employers to do the same thing. Now that Deputy Good has returned I am sure he will have no hesitation in saying that the speech and action of the Minister for Finance will be a very potent argument in the hands of employers when they come to endeavour to enforce wages reductions on their employees. This mentality displayed by the Minister will be welcomed, as one would expect, in the Chamber of Commerce, another institution which, with a few exceptions, believes in wage cutting, more wage cutting and still more wage cutting.

The Minister is making it perfectly clear in this Bill that, for his part, he is not concerned with what standards of living he breaks or what standards of life he invades. The Minister is only concerned with one thing in this Bill, and that is to cut the remuneration of wage earning groups. I challenge the Minister to go out into his own constituency or into the City of Dublin and defend there cutting the remuneration of people with £2 10s. per week. If the Minister tries to do that, I think it will not be long until he is sadly disillusioned because every working man and every trade unionist in this city and throughout the country knows the significance of this Bill. It is an attack on wage standards; it is telling private employers that wages of £2 10s. per week can be reduced. That philosophy is good enough for certain sections of society in this country, but one would expect that, after the radical and almost revolutionary declamations of the Minister in other days, he would not be the one to come into this House to claim the doubtful honour of setting a headline to private employers by cutting the wages of Civic Guards and teachers —setting a headline for private employers to invade and attack the wage standards of their own workers. It is because it is an attack upon wage standards, because I believe it will not cure the existing depression but aggravate it, that I am opposed to this Bill and to the whole philosophy of the Bill. Not merely is it an unwise departure for the Government, but, judging by the Minister's speech, it seems to me to be the first step along an economic and social road which will bring this Government to the same end to which the last Government came— a road which means low wages and a low social standard, the bringing down the level of our people until this country is just another Balkan State in Western Europe.

Comment on this

I have to complain, as other Deputies have done, regarding the manner in which this Bill has been introduced. It is a Bill which introduces a very big principle and a very big change in the social and economic life of a very important section of our people. It was circulated yesterday morning. Other Parties not having been told until late last night, time is taken to-day for the purpose of passing this revolutionary measure with a single day's discussion. Deputies have not been given a reasonable or proper opportunity to examine the provisions of this Bill. While I reserve the right and intend to criticise this Bill, section by section at a later stage, I wish to make some observations on it now.

The Bill is described as a Temporary Economies Bill. I adopt the expression used by the Leader of the Labour Party in another connection in his speech just now as a proper description of that title, and I say it is only "eye-wash." The Minister knows perfectly well that this is not a temporary reduction of the remuneration of public servants. He knows that, having regard to the economic policy his Government are pursuing, it is a permanent reduction in the remuneration of the public service. I take the view that the reduction of the pay of the Civil Service is a step to the detriment of the country. We have in this country a public service surpassed by none. This measure is calculated to introduce discontent and to interfere with the efficiency of the service rendered to the State. One section of the public service is the police. The police of this country have always had a high reputation for the cleanness of their work. The policemen of this country do not, as happens in other countries, put out their hands for tips. There have been very few instances in this country of police officers having been accused of receiving bribes from persons with whom they had to deal. The police here should be kept above all forms of temptation, and they ought to be given reasonable remuneration such as is given to a workman for his week's work. Our police are a very important body in the carrying on of the work of this country, and it is in the interests of the country that there should be clean administration and decent work done. I say it is a retrograde step for the Minister to propose to reduce the remuneration of the police below what is a decent living wage.

I complain, as I have said, of the manner in which this Bill was introduced without giving Deputies any reasonable opportunity of studying its terms. Perhaps I, with a certain amount of training in construing documents of this kind, have less right to complain than the ordinary Deputy who is without that training, but I do say that I, and Deputies like me, have a right to complain of the Bill being introduced in this way. There are sections in this Bill the construction of which might occupy a court for days, and Deputies are asked to discuss the terms of the measure without any such consideration. The manner in which the Minister introduced the Bill is on a par with the manner in which the President introduced this morning the first motion on the Paper. As the Leader of the Opposition pointed out, the first item on the Order Paper this morning was a proposal to effect a trade agreement with another country under which we were giving eight concessions in return for three concessions. If the President had had his way, we should not have been given an opportunity of discussing the relative advantages of these concessions. The Minister for Finance, in introducing this Bill, adopted a similar line. He took up what appears to me to be a novel attitude. He suggested to the House the lines on which the Bill should be discussed, and that we should only discuss the principle that he introduced. My view as to the rights of the House in discussing any Bill that comes before it is that it is entitled to discuss every aspect and every implication of the Bill, subject to the rules of order and the authority of the Chair. I am very glad to say that Deputies have refused to be led by the nose by the Minister for Finance as to what they should discuss. The Minister referred to what he said on 11th May last. The Minister said many things on 11th May last. We shall have a more appropriate opportunity of discussing what he said on 11th May last on the day on which he introduces his Budget for the coming year. I do not intend to be tempted now into comparing what the Minister said on 11th May last with what he said before he sat in his present position. But we do know that immediately before he took up that position he told us our taxation would be reduced by £2,000,000. We know now our taxation has been increased by about three times that amount. I am very glad to see that the Labour Party are at last wakening up to the implications of the alliance in which they have been engaged for the past 12 months. The President laughs. I am pleased to see him laugh. It is a pleasure and a novelty to see the President laugh.

Comment on this

Deputy Rice should know all about making alliances.

Comment on this

And about alliances that go astray.

Comment on this
Mr. Rice

I am very glad to see the Labour Party wakening up to the implications of the alliance they formed with President de Valera's Party. It is a good thing to see that the representatives of Labour have awakened to the fact that what is behind this Bill is not really a proposal to save £280,000 a year out of the pockets of the Civil Service. We know, as a matter of fact, on a rough calculation; that the Government, by their present policy of what is called an economic war, are wasting just about that amount per week in carrying on a controversy and a dispute which they can settle any day they like on fair and reasonable terms. They are wasting each week they carry on this economic war the amount they propose to save in a year by reducing the remuneration of the public service. If this Bill had been introduced by the late Government, everything could be said in its favour from the point of view that they were economising and husbanding the resources of this country but, if a person spends half his income in buying dope and drugs, it is foolish economy to save a halfpenny on the price of his tea. That is what this Government are doing in introducing this Bill.

Comment on this

What about the Rice housing scheme?

Comment on this
Mr. Rice

I am glad to see that all the principles of the Rice housing scheme have been adopted by the present Ministry. I read, with great pleasure, the statement of the Minister for Local Government in which he adopted the proposal which I put before a conference of which I was Chairman for a ten years' house building scheme. I am glad also to see that he has adopted the scheme that was accepted by President Cosgrave, as he then was, and the then Minister for Finance for the financing of that scheme—for raising a loan and spreading the building of houses in Dublin over a ten years' period. Deputy Cooney's interruption reminds me—and it might have been irrelevant otherwise—that even this Government is capable of learning something.

Comment on this

But would you not like to see some of the houses sometime?

Comment on this
Mr. Rice

Yes, we would like to see some of the houses.

Comment on this

It took Fianna Fáil to produce the houses.

Comment on this
Mr. Rice

It might be better to get a scheme of that kind from a Government which had the confidence of the people in the matter of the raising of the money rather than from the present Government. As I have said, I am glad to see that Deputy Norton and his Party have at last awakened to the implications of the alliance they have formed with Fianna Fáil, because Deputy Norton is right. The purpose of this Bill is not the purpose shown on the face of it at all. Its purpose is to carry out the policy announced by the President to reduce the standard of living in this country all round. We are living too well, he says, and we are all going to wear hair shirts. If the Minister for Finance could only remember the speeches he made immediately before he took office, he would not come into this House in a hair shirt but in sackcloth and ashes, having regard to what he has done since he took office.

I am glad that Deputy Norton has awakened to these implications, and I may say, with regard to what he has said here, that this is the foundation of a policy to cut the remuneration of working people all round. That is true. I said to a large employer of labour, as soon as the terms of this Bill were indicated: "I suppose the big employers will be in favour of this Bill, because it will give them a headline to cut wages?" He did not answer me, and I said to him: "What do you say to that?" and his reply was: "I am deaf on that side." Deputy Norton is right. This is a headline deliberately laid down by the Government for the purpose of introducing a system of wage-cutting all round.

Comment on this

To which you were always opposed?

Comment on this
Mr. Rice

Compare the remuneration under the late Government with the remuneration now. Personally, if I had the misfortune to have to work for a weekly wage as a labourer, I would much prefer 29/- or 30/- a week to 24/- a week, and I have not yet found any of the people to whom Deputy Flinn referred when he said that, if it was suggested that they did not want that wage, the people who suggested it would be torn limb from limb. I have not met them and, when Deputies come to consider how they will vote on this Bill, I ask them not to be misled by the talk of Deputy Norton about the wage-cutting policy of the late Government. Where was the wage-cutting policy of the late Government? How does their policy as regards wages compare with the policy of the present Government? Compare the standards that this Government have set up with the standards maintained by the late Government.

Comment on this

Do not spoil your case.

Comment on this
Mr. Rice

I would rather spoil a case than be like the Deputy who interrupts who could not make a case on anything at all. This Bill is, as Deputy Norton said, an incitement to private employers to cut wages all round. I say that the whole principle of the Bill is vicious and, apart from that, it is a direct breach of the undertaking—I will call it an undertaking—given by the President in a speech he made immediately prior to the General Election of 1932. The Leader of the Opposition referred to that speech this morning and I am going to refer to it again.

Comment on this

Quote it now, please.

Comment on this
Mr. Rice

The President's statement in that speech was that there was no case to be made—I do not purport to quote the actual words but, if necessary, and later on, I will quote the actual words as reported in the Irish Press; perhaps that will satisfy the President and, perhaps, he will admit that the report is accurate——

Comment on this

Not at all.

Comment on this
Mr. Rice

Well, he controls the paper so he ought to know.

Comment on this

That does not make for accuracy.

Comment on this
Mr. Rice

I will give the actual words later on but I do commit myself to this now that the substance of the speech made by the President on that occasion was a promise to civil servants that the remuneration of those who had £400 a year or less would not be cut. He pointed out that, owing to the burdens on people who were rearing families, it would not be fair to cut the salaries of persons earning under £400 a year. I definitely say that the President made that speech in Rathmines, either in the month of January or the month of February preceding the February 1932 General Election and it was a very important speech.

Comment on this

He did not say anything about £300, did he?

Comment on this
Mr. Rice

He mentioned £300 or £400, yes.

Comment on this

But you are giving the substance of the speech?

Comment on this
Mr. Rice

I am giving the substance of the speech and now I will read the report of the speech as published in the Dublin daily Press.

Comment on this

The Irish Press?

Comment on this
Mr. Rice

No, not the Irish Press, but perhaps a newspaper with a much higher reputation for accuracy and fair dealing—the Irish Independent.

Comment on this

But the Deputy promised us the Irish Press a few minutes ago.

Comment on this
Mr. Rice

I said that I would produce it later on, but I am giving you this now as a slight consolation in the meantime. President de Valera himself, before the election, admitted the justice of the claims made by the lower grades. He spoke on the subject at Rathmines on 29th January and, so far as I remember, the general election took place on 8th February. I want to say now that I lost my seat in the general election, but I got it back since, and I want to say further—I am delighted to see the President laugh again; twice to-day I have made him laugh, and it must be a tonic to his supporters to see a smile on his face——

Comment on this
A Deputy

The Court Jester!

Comment on this
Mr. Rice

I lost my seat in that election, and one big element in causing the loss of my seat was the promise made by the President——

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

There have been repeated interruptions during the past ten minutes. They will have to cease now.

Comment on this
Mr. Rice

May I respectfully say that I am delighted with them?

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Chair is not.

Comment on this
Mr. Rice

I said that I lost my seat in that election, and the one main element in causing me to lose my seat was the illusory promise made by the now President of this State to the Civil Service, because in the constituency I then represented and now represent again a very big element of the voters belong to the second and third grade of the Civil Service. They were deluded by the promises made to them and which have been broken by the introduction of this Bill.

Deputies opposite want to hear what the President said at that time when he was Leader of the Opposition. Ten days before the election he told the civil servants of the city, and the rest of the country, before they went to the polls to register their votes: "It is not our idea to start to cut the lower salaries. With regard to the salaries of £300 or £400 a year, I hold that those in receipt of them are getting nothing excessive. These are not the salaries I had in mind for a cut."

On the eve of the general election he went further. In this article—the article, I may mention incidentally to the President, is headed "Broken Promises"—he promised immunity not only to the lower grades but to the middle grades. "We do not," he said, "propose to seek economies by restricting the social services or cutting the salaries of the middle or lower grades of the Civil Service."

Do Deputies any longer suggest that the summary I gave from recollection—I had good reason to recollect it —was inaccurate?

Comment on this

On a point of order. If the Deputy is quoting from a document, is it not usual to state what document he is quoting from?

Comment on this
Mr. Rice

If the Deputy had intelligence enough to follow me he would have heard me stating what I was quoting from.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Deputy did not state what newspaper he was quoting from, but a newspaper is not a public document.

Comment on this
Mr. Rice

I prefaced my quotation by stating what it was, and if Deputy Briscoe had intelligence, and followed the debates he would have known and should have remained silent.

Comment on this

I understood the Deputy to say that he was quoting from the daily Press. There is no such organ in Dublin.

Comment on this
Mr. Rice

I leave it to the House to judge as between the Deputy and myself. The President secured at least one seat by the promises he made in the general election of 1932. The Minister for Finance made a point in his speech that was worthy of him. He said that the President did not say £300 a year. I read the quotation which referred to smaller salaries of £300 or £400. Is not that a really pettifogging point of the Minister for Finance? Now what are the conditions that produced the change of attitude of the President of the Executive Council? Why, having given that promise and secured a very considerable number of votes in the City and County of Dublin, the change? What is the reason for the change of his attitude? Why should he propose now to cut down a miserable wage of £2 10s. a week which a man receives as his remuneration? I suggest the explanation is that the promises were made for the purpose of securing votes in that general election. It was on a par with a promise made by the Minister for Finance and published in posters by the Fianna Fáil Party before the election that the taxation in this country would be reduced by the Fianna Fáil Party by £2,000,000 a year if they were returned to office. I do not propose to go in detail into the different sections of the Bill, because there will be an opportunity of examining them later. But there is one section that I wish to say a word of comment about now. I refer to Section 8. That section provides:—

Every doubt, question, and dispute which shall arise as to whether a person is or is not a person to whom this Part of this Act applies, or as to the amount of the salary for the purposes of this Part of this Act of any person or the amount of the deduction to be made under this Part of this Act from any such salary shall be determined by the Minister whose determination thereof shall be final.

What is the purpose of that? Here you have the whole Civil Service of this country robbed under the terms of this Bill of their rights if their remuneration is curtailed. This section reintroduces the old futile system that the King is supreme and that there can be no appeal. King MacEntee ought to recognise that in this country there are courts of justice who have the right, in law, to determine the rights of individuals, to decide impartially and fairly as between individual and individual and between the Government and individuals, as to whether a grievance exists or not. No individual who is aggrieved by the position under this Bill, if it becomes law, will rashly or inadvisedly rush to the courts to have his rights determined. But what is the object of this section? Its object is to oust the jurisdiction of the courts as between the Minister and the subject. It introduces a most reactionary principle, and one that this House should not stand for, because we have courts of justice to decide these matters. No Minister should be in a position to say: "I am the great I am, and that is an end of it." It is a wholly undemocratic thing to introduce. The rights of the courts to determine as between the State and the individual were built up after a long struggle by democratic forces. These rights were settled, and were recognised in the Constitution of this country, and they were recognised by the Government that operated here up to 1932.

Comment on this

Were they recognised in the Constitution Amendment Act No. 19?

Comment on this
Mr. Rice

They were recognised. The Minister is going off on a false trail and trying to draw a weak red herring across the track of my argument. I am pointing out that the humble subject is entitled to protection and that the right of the subject was recognised by the late Government. Here is a measure introduced to prevent determination by the courts of the people of this country as to whether an individual has a grievance or not. The Minister can sit down in his office and determine the rights of any individual and there is to be no appeal to the courts as against his decision. I say that is the introduction of an undemocratic and retrograde principle. I ask Deputies, when they come to consider this measure, whatever they may do with the measure in general, if they have any regard for the preservation of democratic rights, to vote against that section.

I would like to say a word or two on the subject of Deputy Dillon's amendment. The subject-matter of the amendment was discussed in this House some years ago and I think the view the House took at the time was that, while a case could be made for the reduction of the allowances to Deputies like myself who represent metropolitan constituencies, no case could be made for such reduction as regards Deputies who represent rural constituencies. That distinction, if it is worth making, is sound. We are supposed to be working under a democratic system and all classes of the community in this State are entitled to be represented in this House. If the people want to be represented by Labour Deputies, they are entitled to have that right and we cannot expect the working men to finance Deputies who represent them here, to pay the expenses of these Deputies.

I think it is wholly false to suggest that the allowance made to Deputies is a salary. It is really an allowance to cover expenses and on that principle it is wholly justifiable. There are many other classes besides those who return Labour Deputies who are not in a position to finance their representatives in this House. I will refer to what happened in another House in another country on this very subject as a headline to Deputies like Deputy Dillon, who has made this proposal. There is a simple method for every Deputy who feels that he can do without this allowance. He can return the money to the Treasury or he can apply it to charitable work.

In another House on a certain occasion not very long ago a taunt was thrown from the Government Benches at a Deputy in the form of saying to him: "Well, you take your allowance, anyway." It did not transpire on that occasion that the Deputy in question did not, in fact, take one penny of his allowance. It transpired at a later meeting when the Minister who threw the taunt apologised and said he had learned that the Deputy had applied every penny of his Parliamentary allowance to charitable purposes. I suggest to Deputy Dillon and Deputy MacDermot that every member of their Party who favours the policy of cutting down or even abolishing the allowance to Deputies has that simple course open to him. He can hand his allowance to the St. Vincent de Paul Society or to other charitable societies in Dublin and that money will be certainly as well applied as if it is left in the Treasury.

Comment on this

Buying sweep tickets.

Comment on this
Mr. Rice

I did not catch the Deputy's remark.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

It had nothing to do with the motion before the House.

Comment on this
Mr. Rice

I suggest that is a simple course and it is one that I will commend to the mover of the amendment. The foundation of this system of an allowance for Deputies is in order to procure representation in the Dáil for all classes of the people. That is the reason and the justification for the allowance to Deputies. I propose at a later stage, when I have had a chance of considering its implications, to ask the Minister what he means to carry out by Section 5, a section that prima facie may be the section which is designed entirely in relief of civil servants. I do not propose to deal with that to-day, but at a later stage I hope to have an opportunity of asking the Minister to elucidate what is intended by the section.

Comment on this

When the Government were announcing their economic policy to the country they represented that they could make tremendous savings without hardship to anybody. I suppose this Bill represents their attempt at the fulfilment of that assurance. Looked at from that point of view, it is not possible to congratulate them upon it. They seem to have overlooked a fact that they are rather fond of repeating, that they cannot make an omelette without breaking eggs. There is no doubt this particular omelette involves the breaking of a good many eggs. In the present serious condition of the country's trade and finances, we of this Party feel it is our duty to give support to the Government's economy proposals. No matter how much their own policy has been responsible for the necessity of them, we feel it is our duty to give support to the Government's economy proposals, leaving on them the onus of the equities as between different classes of public service, but supporting the general principle, provided that we are put in a moral position to do so. That is the point of Deputy Dillon's amendment. All the criticism I have heard of it to-day is absolutely beside the point. If we were recommending the reduction of Deputies' allowances for the mere sake of reduction there would be some meaning in the attacks made on Deputy Dillon's amendment, but we are not. What we feel is that it is absolutely indecent for the Oireachtas to be imposing cuts on other people and refusing to submit to any cuts themselves. When we hear about the sacrosanctness of this particular figure, £360, we must realise that if it is unjust to call for any reduction of that figure then it was unjust not to consent to a considerably higher salary in 1922, because you have reduced the salaries of civil servants since and the cost of living has gone down.

Deputy Mulcahy has entered an objection to the type of controversy that he says we are addicted to on these benches, which consists in saying that there are too many officials in the country, and blaming the Cumann na nGaedheal Government, in part at any rate, for the extent of public expenditure and the multitude of officials that exists. I am unrepentant on that point. I consider the public expenditure in this country is definitely too high. Deputy Norton speaks as if there was absolutely no limit to which a nation could go in the matter of public expenditure. One would gather from his speeches that he thinks the country can spend and spend and spend, and that nothing but good can come of it. When the Deputy says that the economic troubles the world over are due to the insensate policy of Governments in cutting down salaries and effecting economies, he is merely flying in the face of facts. Everybody knows that is not true.

You might take, perhaps, as a supreme example the United States of America, where you had unreasonable expansion, optimism and the rising of salaries of every sort. And ever since the great crash in 1929, the Congress has been ineffectually struggling to deal with the situation. One of the main reasons why they have been so completely ineffectual in dealing with it is that they refused to get down to economy. They committed the same mistake, I am sorry to say, that is shown in the Government attitude here to-day. Such proposals for economies as were introduced into Congress were never allowed to contain any sacrifice for the members of Congress themselves. It is only when the country is going to crash over the precipice, when President Roosevelt comes in and gets semi-dictatorial powers to enable them to make economies to save the country from financial ruin, that economies in the remuneration of the members of the Congress at Washington are introduced.

I say, in reference to the general question of public expenditure, that I consider public expenditure in this country is too high. I admit I was not living in this country at the time and my evidence is not first hand, but I have the impression that the Sinn Féin movement as a whole was not alive to the true financial situation in this country. I do not believe that very many of them realised that under the old regime a great deal more was being expended in Ireland than was being drawn from it in the way of revenue. Ever since the Old Age Pensions Act was introduced in the British Parliament that has been the position. I do not believe that the Sinn Féin Movement realised that under the 1912 Home Rule Bill we were going to get substantial subsidies from the British Parliament in order to enable us to carry on the services which were then established and which otherwise we would not have been able to carry on without an enormous increase in taxation the moment Home Rule came into operation. I think they had an idea that by simply cutting adrift from Great Britain this country was going to come into a fortune, and I think they were under the impression after the Treaty, that in the negotiations that went on they had done extremely well for this country and that they had made "a damn good bargain." That is, as may be but this much is certain that if our cutting adrift in the way we did and in the circumstances we did from Great Britain, led to a great improvement in the financial position of this country, that improvement was not passed on at all to the unfortunate taxpayers and ratepayers. We find to-day that even taking into account the change in the value of money, and the expansion of the social services that the figure of public expenditure for the Free State alone is grossly out of proportion to what used to be to the expenditure for the whole of Ireland under the British regime.

That being so and the times being as bad as they are the world over, and especially bad in Ireland in consequence of this so-called economic war, this wasting disease which the Government has inflicted on the country, I feel we have no choice but to give general support to the economy proposals, much as we dislike them provided they put us in the moral position to do it. Are we in that moral position? I say we are not. Take first the most flagrant case, because the case of the Seanad is the most flagrant. I want to know is there any Deputy in this House who could justify the salaries paid to Senators? Senators have no constituents to meet. They have not the same kind of work to do between the sittings as the members of this House have. They meet 35 times or perhaps 36 times in the year. Suppose we take it that they meet 36 times, the position remains that they get, as Deputy Dillon has pointed out, £10 for each sitting.

Is that a thing that can be defended? I say it is not. I think it is specially difficult to defend in view of the desire of the Government that the Seanad should be somewhat different in character from this House. I suggest that the Seanad should not be regarded in any way as a whole-time job and that the people who go to the Seanad, poor as well as rich— if there are any rich still left in this country—should be paid on the basis of their attendance, and that it should be something like £2 a day, plus first-class travelling fare, instead of £10 for each session as at present. I have yet to hear of any sort of reasonable defence put up for the salaries paid to the Senators. The result of the present salary or allowance is to make it a laughing stock and to turn it into what it has become, that is, as a place for providing for persons for one reason or another that people wish to provide for, rather than in sending people there who would make the best possible Senators.

As regards this House itself it is quite clear that the member who does his work honestly as a Deputy will earn the £360 to the full. I admit that quite readily. But this proposal of a reduction last year as well as this year—for I was the one to make it last year—was not made as something desirable for its own sake, but only in relation to the proposals for economies to be imposed on others. I make my proposal in that situation—a situation where it is proposed that economies shall be imposed on others, shall be imposed upon men who have no other means of livelihood. The civil servant has no other means of living. He is not like the Deputy who has got a chance to earn something outside his work here, as a great many of them do. I say it is a perfectly impossible situation—it is impossible for a Deputy here to be put in the situation of being called on to support cuts that will cause so much resentment and hardship unless he is prepared to lead the way himself. Deputy Norton has talked of the bad taste of Deputy Dillon in proposing a sacrifice in the case of an individual civil servant. He said it was bad taste for Deputy Dillon to suggest it. I call it much worse taste and very bad taste to enforce cuts on unfortunate State servants and not impose cuts on themselves.

Comment on this
A Deputy

Why not vote against them?

Comment on this

What about the bad taste of the action of the Labour Party here? The Labour Party do not feel there is any sort of bad taste when they get up and make all sorts of proposals that would destroy other people's income by causing a high income tax to be imposed, or when they destroy people's income by voting for the economic war and when they propose that unfortunate railway shareholders should have their interests disregarded. That is not bad taste at all. It is only when one gets up and makes a proposition that should appeal to the most moderate sense of decency and good taste that Deputy Norton gets up and talks about the old Irish Party and say they were not ashamed to take £400 a year. That is an entirely different matter, because that £400 did not come directly out of the pockets of the Irish taxpayers. It came out of the pockets of the British taxpayers, who supplied the largest portion of it. Besides that, for years and years the old Irish Party did their duty at Westminster without any payments whatever from the public purse. There are a few unfortunate remnants of the old Irish Party alive to-day and in a state of almost destitution after all the years in the service of the country. All that service is now forgotten. We are ready to ladle out money for the new heroes at any time on any pretext.

Deputies of this House have very little cause to sneer at the old Irish Party, least of all on financial grounds, no matter on whatever other grounds they may sneer at them. At any rate that question of £400 a year was beside the point. It is not because we think £360 a year too high for a Deputy that we introduced this amendment at all. It is because we really feel it is asking us to do something that we should not in decency be asked to do when the Government calls on us to support their economy proposals, unless something was first done on our part to show that we ourselves are ready to make sacrifices as well. I think that the amendment moved by Deputy Dillon is, perhaps, as reasonable a one as could be moved; that we should be linked up with the civil servants to about the same scale of salary. Taking into account the time when this salary was fixed the deduction to be made from it should correspond to the deduction made from the salaries of civil servants. I appeal to the Minister to give us some satisfaction on this point, to declare that the Government will definitely introduce proposals for the substantial reduction of the Seanad salaries and that they will, at least, institute an inquiry, if nothing more, although I would like them to go a bit further and say definitely that they would make some reduction in the salaries of the Dáil in order to make our moral position stronger. We must not forget, although I do not wish to raise unnecessarily contentious points, that a number of Deputies during the last election were going around the country hounding the people on into the economic war, calling on them to put Ireland before their purse, to strike a blow for the good old country, to destroy the brutal British and discomfort John Bull. How they can have had the face to do it, or how they can have the face to do it again, while they take up the attitude that they will not sacrifice one penny themselves, is something beyond my conception.

Comment on this
Mr. Kelly

I did not intend to interfere in this debate. My policy, as long as I will be here, is to speak as little as possible. I felt, however, that some comment is necessary on the part of back benchers having regard to what I have heard to-day. With reference to the amendment proposed by a Deputy belonging to the Centre Party, I humbly submit to him that he is illogical. Either Deputies should be paid or they should not be paid. If he proposes that they should not be paid, I am with him. I have always held that men or women who wish earnestly to serve their country ought to do it without fee or reward. I am probably the oldest member who can speak with any authority on the Sinn Féin movement that has been alluded to more than once to-day. Probably I would not have spoken only when it was mentioned it came into my head that an opportunity might arise for me to say something concerning it. I will tell you about the Sinn Féin movement. If you lived nearly 30 years ago you might have rambled into a house in Fownes Street, and if your curiosity led you to go upstairs you would have found a man in a back room sitting at a broken desk on a three-legged chair engaged in writing. That man at the end of his week, having spent nearly all the six days and some of the nights there, would draw about 30/-. He had the greatest and the most subtle pen wielded in the cause of Ireland since the days of Swift. That was the beginning of the Sinn Féin movement. You know to whom I allude—the late Arthur Griffith.

Comment on this

And the end of it was that you said he sold his country.

Comment on this

He was called a traitor.

Comment on this
Mr. Kelly

If you are going to introduce these things you are going to be replied to very swiftly. More than he sold their country and all that can be said of them is that they sold it for a price.

Comment on this

And the others came back to pick up the price.

Comment on this
Mr. Kelly

I advise you to keep quiet. I do not want to introduce an angry note.

Comment on this

Tell us the whole story.

Comment on this
Mr. Kelly

I will not tell you the whole story now. I may tell it some other time. I am only concerned with the Sinn Féin movement because it was referred to in connection with money. Arthur Griffith and those who assisted him worked without fee or reward. We had often to go from door to door, begging almost for subscriptions to maintain the Sinn Féin paper.

Comment on this

If it would shorten the proceedings, I would like to say, in case the Deputy misunderstood me, that I did not wish to imply that the Sinn Fein movement had been a mercenary or unpatriotic movement.

Comment on this

You said they had no knowledge of financial matters and other things.

Comment on this

I was speaking about public finances.

Comment on this

You cast a slur on the Sinn Féin movement.

Comment on this
Mr. Kelly

You must understand that you raised a very delicate question to-day, and one that must be considered very carefully. You insinuated, so to speak, that we were very well remunerated here for our services. That was the insinuation.

Comment on this

I said I did not consider the remuneration a bit too high.

Comment on this
Mr. Kelly

If it is not a bit too high, why reduce it?

Comment on this

I explained clearly that the reason was because you are proposing to reduce other people's salaries, and if you reduce other people's you should reduce your own.

Comment on this
Mr. Kelly

Not necessarily. Why try to reduce your income, which I think is a very considerable one?

Comment on this

Why do you think so?

Comment on this
Mr. Kelly

And also that of the gentleman who sits beside you.

Comment on this

I wish it was.

Comment on this
Mr. Kelly

You can very conveniently speak about a reduction of other people's salaries or allowances because you are on fairly safe ground. As I was saying before being interrupted, in connection with this matter of money and the Sinn Fein movement in its earlier days, the efforts of the late Arthur Griffith and those associated with him to keep up the Sinn Fein paper were almost superhuman. We went from door to door almost begging for money to keep it going. When the Sinn Fein daily paper was started the same thing happened. It only lasted six months, but during that six months the salaries paid were almost laughable they were so small. Towards the end—this has never been told before—two Irishmen undertook a mission to America to collect money for its continuance—the late Mr. Bulfin and the late O'Rahilly. Both of them spent three months in America and came back without even the price of a box of matches. Mr. Bulfin died a short time afterwards, and we know that the O'Rahilly was found with bullets in his heart during the fight in Easter Week. These things do not suggest in any shape or form that the Sinn Fein movement was founded by money grubbers. When other men and other methods prevailed, and the Sinn Fein movement, so to speak, almost passed away, and when, as a result of the work of these men and their methods the Easter Week insurrection was possible, and the events which followed it, you know very well the intense enthusiasm which was created amongst the Irish people, and you know that millions of money flowed into the Exchequer of the then young Irish Republic that these men brought about. When the first Dáil was elected I was one of a committee appointed to arrange the salaries for the President and Ministers of the Irish Republic, so that I know thoroughly well what I am speaking of. The salary arranged for the Ministers was £300 a year, and that for the President was £600 a year. He declined to take £600; he said £500 would be sufficient. That will give those gentlemen of the Centre Party, who were speaking to-day in connection with the Sinn Fein movements and things national in a spirit I do not like, to understand the self-sacrificing spirit of the men who founded those movements, who carried them on, and who, I think, brought them to success. I have nothing further to say on that point.

I thought, in my knowledge of debate, that the amendment only would be before the House, but I understand that both the Bill and the amendment can be discussed. My connection with the Bill will be very brief. It was my job, on the opening of the first Dáil in 1919, to read the democratic programme of Dáil Eireann. That programme set out what was proposed to be done for the workers and for the poor people of this country. I read it with pleasure. I believed it was going to be carried out. I give general credit to many of those associated with that movement that they had an honest intention of carrying those things out, but I fearlessly say here now that, until President de Valera and his men got together this year, no effort was made to carry out the democratic programme of Dáil Eireann. That was the reason I came in here to give them my little support in their effort to do so. When I heard just the last word of Deputy Norton's statement, to the effect that the men here on these benches were going to meet the fate of the men over there, because of their wage-cutting and because of their depressing the conditions of the poor and the workers of this country, I came to the conclusion that I am afraid Deputy Norton is not strictly speaking the truth. I do not think he was justified in saying such things, and I should remind him, and the members of the Labour Party generally, that there are other men here on these benches as closely associated with the Labour movement and as much in sympathy with it as they are. I should like them to understand that perfectly. If there was anything in the shape of interference with an honest living, with good wages, with good housing accommodation, or with good general support for the working classes of this country, we would have nothing to do with it. I honestly believe that President de Valera and his men are now engaged in carrying out the programme laid down 13 or 14 years ago. I believe they are honestly engaged in carrying it out. For that reason I support them, and will continue to support them as long as I am here. Whether that will be long or short I cannot say.

As regards my own position, I intend to keep an exact account of the £330 a year or whatever it is that we get for our services here. I intend to keep an exact account of it, just to see how it will pan out at the end of the year. At the present moment I have to shut up my shop for three days a week. I calculate that at a loss of about £80 or £90 a year, to begin with. I do not know what other losses I may sustain, but to think that we are here for the purpose of the £360 or £330 a year is wrong. There are men behind me on these benches—more vigorous and ardent, and probably more national than I am—who may be losing a good deal more than I am. I did not want to interfere in this matter at all, but having regard to the insinuations which I believe were made concerning men on these benches, I had to make a protest against them, and make it with all the vigour I possess at present.

Comment on this

A Leas Chinn Comhairle, I think the insinuations made by the mover of the amendment reflect not only on the members of the other side of the House but also on those at this side of the House. I believe this amendment is altogether insincere. There are some people in this House to whom this payment—whether you call it an allowance or a salary—is of very small account. There are others——

Comment on this

Perhaps the Deputy would give way for a moment, to allow me to state that in all I said there was no insinuation. There was no desire to have any covert implication read into my words in any conceivable way. I said plainly and straightly everything I had in my mind, and I do not desire to reflect on any individual in this House in any way—good, bad or indifferent. I want the Deputy to know that there is no insinuation, and I should be glad if he would draw his deductions from what I said, and permit me to contradict them. There was no hidden meaning in my statement.

Comment on this

Hear, hear!

Comment on this

I have no doubt about the subjective honesty of the Deputy. His objective honesty is a matter of interpretation. The other side of the House is being interpreted in a manner which could be applied to this side of the House as well.

Comment on this

Without shadow of foundation!

Comment on this

It may be without shadow of foundation, but I am entitled to my opinion and I am entitled to express it. I accept the Deputy's assertion. As I said, there are many persons in this House to whom that payment is of very small account. There are others to whom it means very much, and there are some here who, by accepting it and by coming here, lose by interference with their business or private profession a sum perhaps more than twice the amount involved. In introducing this amendment the proposer said that we were to be equated in a sense with the Civil Service. I think that is altogether wrong. Civil servants are an educated body of persons.

Comment on this

Now who is making insinuations?

Comment on this

They are men who have had specialised training for the position they have. There is no educational or physical standard of fitness required for a Deputy. It is possible for a man to be a member of this House who may be semi-illiterate, and who would not be worth 5/- a week in any commercial occupation in the world. That is the fact. Even to join the Civic Guard it is necessary to have a high standard of physical and intellectual fitness. I think in fixing this allowance some regard was paid to the low standard of personality that might possible enter this House. I am sure that there are many persons here in this House who are not worth £360 a year to the State. It is not proper to look on this amount as a salary. It is stated to be an allowance. If the proposer of this amendment had put it in a form which would take it out of this ambiguous category—whether it is an allowance or a salary—I would be very pleased to support it. In other words, if a man were to be compensated for the time lost in his business, for the actual time he spends in this House, and for his travelling expenses to and from this House, it should be in another form. But there is no doubt that at present it is by some regarded as a salary, and by some even as their sole means of living. In that connection it has helped to rear up in this State a very low peculiar form of professional politician. I would have been very glad to support the amendment if put in another form because I believe that this £360 a year is a lure to membership of this House. If it had been eliminated I believe we would have had a better class of man coming forward to serve the country here. That, of course, is a matter of opinion.

With regard to the general principles of the Bill before us the Minister was very apologetic for its introduction. In fact, he nearly wept over the necessity that has arisen for paring down the salaries of some of the highly placed civil servants. When the Minister and his Party came into power last year they promised the country an immediate reduction of £2,000,000 in taxation without making any inroads whatever on the public services.

Comment on this

The Deputy ought to prepare a speech for himself. That is Deputy McGilligan's copyright.

Comment on this

It is a public fact. I have a Fianna Fáil poster here that was issued to the public and I will read it for the Minister if he likes. At any rate, we are all familiar with that poster. The country was told that £2,000,000 a year were going to be saved in taxation, and that without any sacrifice whatever in the public services or in the cost of administration. Immediately the present Government came into office, not only was there no attempt whatever made to show the country how this economy in administration was going to come about but we were immediately in the new Budget taxed to a further extent, over and above what we had been already paying, to the tune of £4,000,000 a year. It is quite possible that this year there will be a further increase in taxation. All this time, it is freely admitted that taxation has reached a breaking point in this country. It has now gone to a point where it is beyond the capacity of the people to pay. We see this all through the country where it is impossible to collect the local rates. We see it in the general depression of trade. In the financial year that ended in March, 1932, the trade of this country was £86,000,000. In the year ending March, 1933, it was £64,000,000, a drop of £22,000,000 in the turnover of the trade of the country. More than £8,000,000 of that was accounted for by the foolish economic war which was not brought about by England because, as the President admitted, we fired the first shot. It is at this time, when the Minister sees that the capacity of the people to bear less and less taxation is becoming very evident, he grasps at this straw to save this one-quarter of a million of money, a comparatively miserable sum.

Comment on this

It is one of the wealthy Deputies who is talking now.

Comment on this

I am talking in relation to the extravagance of the Minister and of his policy of trying to save £250,000 by taking it out of the pockets of the true and tried servants of this State, while launching into extravagances in other directions where more than that sum could be saved. Mention was made to-day that, while the Minister was trying to save this money by taking it out of the pockets of civil servants, there had been a remarkable increase in the personnel of some departments. In the Vote for the Revenue Commissioners, there is an increase in salaries alone of £20,000. I can only attribute that increase to the pitch-forking of men into the Customs —men who, I am informed, did not pass in through the ordinary avenue of a Civil Service examination.

There is one thing in the Schedule to the Bill that I strongly object to, and that is the proposed interference with the salaries of the Civic Guards. The ordinary Civic Guard has not a salary or wage anything like that which an ordinary semi-skilled man is paid. Yet to become a Civic Guard he has to pass a very stiff examination. He has to be a man of more than ordinary education, and in the moral sphere must be above suspicion. His salary is going to be cut and, comparatively speaking, cut in a very drastic way. I protest against the reductions in Civic Guard pay. The Civic Guard is not confined to a 44 hour week about which we had all the trouble last night or to a 48 hour week. He is supposed to be on duty night and day as he may be required. His duties and responsibilities are increasing every day. Practically every Bill that is passed through this House means an addition to his work. The Traffic Bill that we discussed last week throws additional responsibilities on him for the safety of the public. I have not studied the Bill very carefully in so far as it affects the Army, and therefore, I do not propose to say anything on that aspect of it. As to the national teachers, they are coming out best of all so far as the proposed cuts are concerned. The reason alleged for that, is that they are great friends of Fianna Fáil. I do not know whether that is so or not. In certain parts of the country which I know well they are not, but in other parts I am told that they did wonderful election work for Fianna Fáil. I have been told too, that in many schools one of the first things that lisping children are taught is "Up Dev." That may be the reason why, comparatively speaking the national teachers are not being so severely cut as other civil servants. I think they would have done just as well if they had agreed to the reduction which was come to between themselves and Cumann na nGaedheal Government had it been put into effect.

Comment on this

They would have been enjoying those reductions for two years now.

Comment on this

This whole thing is a weak grasping at a straw on the part of the Minister to save himself from the financial chaos in which his policy has plunged him. The meanest and most contemptible thing of all in connection with the Bill is to be found in Part VI of the Schedule. I refer to the proposed reduction of the capitation grant to Industrial Schools. This whole Bill is mean and miserable, but I think this proposal is the meanest thing of all; this attempt of the Minister to try and save himself from the consequences of his own financial folly by cutting down the grants for the most unfortunate and weakest section in the community, the children and the orphans in the industrial schools of the country.

Comment on this

I want to be very brief, and with great respect to Deputy Dillon I do not propose really to discuss his amendment at all, because I think it raises questions that are quite unimportant compared with the general principles raised by the Bill. Taking the Bill itself, if the principle were simply that stated by the Minister, namely, the desirability for economy, I should not be rising to protest against the Bill, but I think, even from that angle the question in the Bill is much more than that. It is a question whether the economy that is necessary should be carried out in the kind of way suggested in the Bill. From that angle I find myself very much nearer to the point of view of Deputy Norton, namely, that the economy to be effected in the way suggested is much more like additional taxation of a certain section of the people than a real economy.

However, I do not rise, really to discuss the matter from that point of view. I may leave that to others. Neither do I rise to discuss it from the point of view, very important as that point of view is, of why such economies are necessary at all. That is a big question, and many others have pointed out that it is due, as I believe it is due, to very official economic policy. What I do want to discuss is the Bill from the point of view of what change it envisages in our Parliamentary methods. I envisage it from that angle in a most serious way. It seems to me to be, on the part of the Minister, a cynical recognition and admission of the fact that our Government—democratic Government by Parliament—is becoming from day to day more and more a simple stamping of the acts of the Cabinet by the Dáil, acting merely as a registering authority. If it were not for that, I do not think we should be discussing a Bill of such vital importance as this Bill at a late session on a Friday afternoon.

Comment on this
A Deputy

You did not object to discussing the Public Safety Act.

Comment on this

The attitude seems to be that they must get the final vote of the Dáil on any particular matter, but that no matter what is said by the Dáil they must get that vote in the way they propose. That is the only reason we are doing it, evidently, and we are only wasting time in discussing the matter before a comparatively small House. But there is much more than that in it. When I look through this Bill I see much more in it. We see it in the section to which Deputy Rice has drawn attention to-day. The Minister's say is to be final. The Minister is to decide. Further on through the Bill you will see such principles as these—that whatever is decided by statute or otherwise the Minister can revoke, annul or repeal and that he can act as he thinks proper —he alone! The Minister can consult with whomever he thinks right, be they outside bodies or other Ministers. It is the Minister that is to be the final dictator in all these matters. He is to have the final say as to what local authorities he will consult with, and he alone. I see, outstanding in this Bill, simply an incarnation of dictatorial government. It shines in it from first to last. We are dispensing with the functions of the Dáil beyond merely registering powers. We are dispensing with democratic government. We are electing a junta in charge of the State which is to be final and practically dictatorial in its methods. I think that we have brought out in this Bill in a very clear, vital and important way, the goal to which our democratic government is rapidly tending. For that reason, and for that reason alone, I shall oppose this Bill and protest against it as strongly as I possibly can.

Comment on this

With regard to the Bill, I want to say that I am absolutely opposed to it.

Comment on this

Hear, hear!

Comment on this

Deputy Cleary says "Hear, hear." I do not know whether he will say "Hear, hear" to my next sentence or not. I have an idea that he will not. I am also opposed to the amendment and I am going to vote against that amendment. I am also going to vote against the Bill itself. I assume that Deputy Cleary will vote against the amendment, because it would mean the cutting of his own salary.

Comment on this

It is not a salary. It is an allowance. The Deputy thinks that he is still Vice-Chairman.

Comment on this

I cannot see the sense of that remark.

Comment on this

The Deputy had a salary then.

Comment on this

Well, of course, not having two jobs like the Deputy, the allowance is to me a salary, and I am not ashamed to admit it. I consider that, like every other Deputy in this House, on all sides of the House, I am giving fairly good service for that salary or allowance. I consider, and I think it will be agreed, that I am not making any profit out of it. Before 1927, when the Fianna Fáil Deputies came in here, they advocated a reduction of the £360. According to them then it was altogether too much. We were supposed to be living on the fat of the land. Is there one of these Deputies now who is prepared to vote for a reduction of the £360? Is there one of them who has made any money out of the £360 per annum for the last five years? I put it to any member of the Government Benches that those of them who have done their duty here in this House—and I admit that most of them have done their duty—when they receive their constituents here in Dublin, that amount would not cover their expenses in any one year. Would they admit that?

Deputy Dillon's amendment is mere hypocrisy. It is absolute hypocrisy.

Comment on this

On a point of order—is that a legitimate observation?

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

It is.

Comment on this

It implies deliberate dishonesty. If the Chair rules that it is legitimate abuse, then I am going to treat it as abuse.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

I think that Deputy Morrissey said that the amendment was sheer hypocrisy.

Comment on this

If the Chair holds it to be merely vulgar abuse——

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

The Chair does not hold it to be abuse. The Chair would not allow abuse. The Deputy has characterised the amendment as hypocrisy. That is the Deputy's understanding. He has not said anything about Deputy Dillon.

Comment on this

It is his insinuation.

Comment on this

It is not an insinuation. It is a pure statement of fact and I can assure Deputy Dillon that I am going to say much more than that. Deputy Dillon is not fair to the Chair.

Comment on this

He does not occupy the position which Deputy Morrissey did.

Deputy Cooney interjected a remark.

Comment on this

I suggest that Deputy Cleary ought to keep silent. Deputy Cooney knows something about silence and about speaking also. On many occasions the Deputy spoke when he should have remained silent, and remained silent when he should have spoken. However, I am not going to be taken away by Fianna Fáil members who are against the amendment, from saying what I want to say, and I repeat that it is absolute humbug and hypocrisy, and the only reason it was put before this House was because the Deputies—and I do not want to put all the blame on Deputy Dillon; I am sure that his leader is really responsible for it, and I am quite satisfied that if we could have been present at the Party meeting when the division took place as to whether this amendment should be put forward or not the vote must have been pretty tight—but if Deputy MacDermot or Deputy Dillon thought for a moment that the amendment should be carried——

Comment on this

If I might be allowed to intervene, I should like to say that the decision was unanimous.

Comment on this

The Deputy has no right to intervene. Is Deputy Cooney coming to the assistance of the Centre Party?

Comment on this

Is the Deputy looking for another split?

Comment on this

If the Deputy wants to come to their assistance I am satisfied. I want to suggest that if the Centre Party thought that there was the slightest possibility of the amendment being carried it would never have been introduced. May I say to Deputy Dillon that another member of this House first thought of this proposal and thought it would be good political propaganda. This is not the first time it was suggested that the allowances for Deputies and Senators should be reduced. It was suggested by the Cumann na nGaedheal Party as far back as 1923. I hope that what happened previously will not happen to Deputy Dillon, as at an election three months after the suggestion was made, that the allowances to Deputies should be reduced, the proposer when he went to his constituency was defeated and was never since heard of in public life. If Deputy Dillon and Deputy MacDermot, who I think is more behind the amendment than Deputy Dillon, think they are going to fool the farmers into thinking that the economic circumstances will be affected in any way by a reduction in the allowances made to members of either House they are very foolish. No farmer, labourer or shopkeeper in Donegal would believe for one moment that Deputy Dillon was sincere when he proposed to cut his own allowance. Of course Deputy MacDermot does not want to reduce the allowances, he wants them abolished.

Comment on this

That is untrue.

Comment on this

Shall I put it in another way? Deputy MacDermot wants his own allowance abolished. Deputy MacDermot made a great show —I do not know if it was through himself or through some other channel —in the Press, that he was not going to accept the £30 per month. I want to say deliberately that that is a good exhibition of snobbery. Either this State can or cannot afford to pay allowances to those who are doing the work of the State. It does not matter which side of the House Deputies are on. I class as snobbery of the worst type the action of a Deputy who comes in here and says he is not prepared to accept the allowance fixed by Statute, and with the consent of all Parties, to meet the ordinary expenses that are incurred in carrying on the work of the country. I go further and say that if that were carried into effect it would mean that representation in this House would be confined to men of independent means. If that is Deputy MacDermot's policy, or if he were speaking for himself in having it carried into effect, it would mean that representation would be confined absolutely to people of independent means. There would then not be real and proper representation.

Comment on this

Is it not obligatory for a Deputy to accept a statement disproving what he has said? I have stated that I am not in favour of abolishing the allowances.

Comment on this

With all due respect I corrected myself and I accepted the Deputy's statement that he was not in favour of the abolition of allowances. I am now talking of the fact that the Deputy did not want to receive his own allowance.

Comment on this

I would like to suggest to the Deputy that he is not at all acquainted with the facts surrounding the statement with regard to my allowance, and that it is a matter on which I would be pleased to enlighten him privately. Before the Deputy knew the facts he had no right to use the word "snobbery".

Comment on this

May I put through you, sir, a question to Deputy MacDermot: Did he or did he not state that he did not want to receive the allowance voted to him by this House?

Comment on this

I do not like intruding on the time of the House on a personal matter, but when the question is put to me, I must answer it. I told my constituents a year ago when I came back after living for a good many years abroad, and when I was an unknown personality, that in order to prove that I had not come into Irish politics to make money out of them, and to show that I had a real interest in the country, I would not take any allowance. That was the sole reason. There was no question of snobbery.

Comment on this

If the Deputy had not been away in foreign countries so many years, and if he had been in political life in this country for the last ten years, there would be no necessity for him to prove to his constituents that he could not make any money out of £360 a year. I join to this extent with Deputy Thrift in saying that I think it is a pity this footling amendment was introduced to cut across a very important Bill. In my opinion this is one of the most important Bills we have had for a number of years. There are sections in it which are going to create great hardship. These sections will, in my opinion, bring about a position both in national and local public services which will not be good for this country. I want to say, and I am sure it will be agreed to by most Deputies, that the saving which will be made in actual cash is a very small thing in the national finances. I am afraid the Bill is going to reduce the standard of ability that we will have in national and local services. I wonder how the new C.E.C. of the I.N.T.O. will look upon this Bill. The I.N.T.O. drove out of office a couple of years ago the then Executive because they were supposed to have been intimidated into accepting a cut much less than the cut proposed in the Bill. They put into office an Executive sworn to resist any cut, no matter how small. I hope that we shall hear much more than we have heard so far from the C.E.C. of the I.N.T.O. I notice that there is one section put in apparently as an afterthought, and in brackets—I do not know if the Minister for Education is responsible for it—by which the secondary teachers are excluded. I am glad of that. Up to a couple of years ago the secondary teachers were very badly paid. I think they are not overpaid yet by any means. Why are they excluded? I would like the Minister for Education to give the reasons for reducing the primary teachers and excluding the secondary teachers.

Comment on this
Thomas Derrig Minister for Education (Mr. Derrig) Fianna Fáil

The reason is that the secondary teachers' grants were cut last year.

Comment on this

I am open to get information on that point. There are many other points upon which one could touch, such as cutting the pay of the Civic Guards and of the Army. There is one section in the Bill and we do not know whether it is going to lead to a cut in the salaries of the employees of local authorities or not. Personally, I think that under the section as now framed, only the salaries of employees or officials of agricultural committees and vocational committees can be cut. I am sure the Department will make quite clear very soon what their intentions are. Deputy Tom Kelly has gone from the House and I am rather sorry. The Deputy dwelt for a long time on the democratic programme of the first Dáil. He told us the reason he came into the House, and the reason he was voting with the present Government was that they had attempted to carry out the democratic programme of the first Dáil, so far as it affected the workers of the country. I would be the very last to question the absolute sincerity of Deputy Tom Kelly, but I question whether he is wise in the statement he made. One of the articles in the democratic programme of the first Dáil was that the State should be responsible for the maintenance and the feeding of workers and their children and should see that no child in this State went hungry. Deputy Tom Kelly said that President de Valera was giving effect to the democratic programme of the first Dáil. How? After 12 months of Government by those on the opposite benches there are over 40,000 persons, according to their own figures, more on outdoor relief to-day than there were before they came into office. Is that giving effect to the democratic programme of the first Dáil?

On the 26th of June last a motion was passed in this House—I want to remind my late colleagues in the Labour Party of this—and accepted by the Government that it was the responsibility of the State to provide either work or maintenance for the unemployed in this country. What steps have been taken since then to give effect to that resolution? None whatever, and because no steps have been taken the responsibility was thrown over on the local authorities. The Government accepted the motion but they did not give effect to it and because of their failure to give effect to it, as Deputy Curran can state, in the South Riding of Tipperary this year for outdoor relief alone there is an increase of 2/3 in the £1 plus an increase of 1/4 owing to the reduction in the agricultural grant, making a total increase of 3/7 in the £1. Is that giving effect to the democratic programme of the first Dáil? As I say, I am absolutely satisfied that Deputy Tom Kelly, perhaps more than any other member of the House, would like to see full and absolute effect given to that programme. I am absolutely convinced of his sincerity in the matter, but I do respectfully suggest to him that the policy pursued by the present Government during the last 12 months, far from making it possible to put the democratic programme of the first Dáil into operation, has made it absolutely impossible for the present Government, and will make it very hard for any Government that succeeds them to do so.

Comment on this

I should like to say a word or two in connection with the point raised by Deputy Morrissey, and I intend to be very brief. He more or less misrepresented the attitude of the Centre Party to this Bill and the amendment put forward by Deputy Dillon. He has misrepresented our attitude and said that there has been a division in this Party, and that it must have been a close one. I say there has been no division in the Party. We are absolutely unanimous in our attitude to the Bill. The amendment has not emanated from either Deputy Dillon or Deputy MacDermot, but it represents the desire of farmers, who are in such a condition at the present time and for a number of years past, that they cannot understand how the country can carry on if the scale of salaries paid to public officials is to be continued. As a matter of fact farmers have absolutely no income at present. They are running their business at a loss. I think the time is certainly coming when drastic reductions must be made in all salaries, reductions even more drastic than are proposed for the present year. There will have to be very drastic reductions during the continuance of the present economic war. The principle of equality of sacrifice should be accepted and the farmers, who have been described as the soldiers in the front line trenches, should not be expected to bear all the sacrifices. Otherwise this war cannot be regarded as a war carried on by other countries would be regarded. It would be a war confined to one particular class in the country. I am entirely in favour of the principles of the Bill, but as Deputy MacDermot said we want to be in a moral position to support it. We are in the position at present of a Party in a glass house, who are beginning to throw stones. That is what the Fianna Fáil Party decided to do, to start throwing stones in a glass house. They might at least have given the Centre Party a chance to get out. As regards the Labour Party they, like Cumann na nGaedheal, do not want to get out and they do not want the stones to be thrown. They pretend to have great sympathy for poor men who are unemployed; yet they believe it would be much better to spend money in paying salaries from £400 to £1,000 and perhaps up to £1,500 without any cuts and to leave thousands of the unemployed living on a few shillings a week. Small as are the cuts that are being made, they should have a great effect on unemployment down the country. I, as a Deputy representing small farmers in Co. Cavan, can tell the Dáil that the average farmer in Co. Cavan, if he got 50/-, £2 or even £1 per week would leave his little farm and be very glad to get the money. I do not want to delay the House further than to put these facts before it and to clear up a misunderstanding that seems to exist amongst the members of the Labour Party, with regard to the attitude of the Centre Party towards this Bill. It is absolutely necessary that cuts should be made and, on the other hand, it is necessary, if we are to be in a moral position to impose these cuts, that we can say we are not asking anybody to do what we are not prepared to do ourselves.

Comment on this

I am sorry that I had not the advantage of hearing the debate which has taken place upon this Bill. Unfortunately I am under the necessity of earning my own living, and I was unable to be here during the progress of the debate.

Comment on this

We are under the same necessity.

Comment on this

Because of that necessity, I am all the more vigorously opposed to the fundamentally immoral principles enshrined in this Bill. I do not propose to make any comment on the amendment proposed by Deputy Dillon except to say that I am in full agreement with what Deputy Morrissey has said. It was unfair for a Deputy in Deputy Dillon's position to put Deputies into the position before the country of appearing to defend their own £360 a year. That is a separate matter that could be debated separately—as to whether £360 a year is a proper allowance for public representatives not only for the work they do in this House but for the heavy demands made upon their charitable inclinations and the other demands from the public which they have to meet out of their meagre stipends. I do not know whether Deputy MacDermot or Deputy Dillon makes any profit out of their £360 a year. If they do, they have not much company amongst the Deputies of this House. Every Deputy knows the demands made upon him by his constituents and by others all over the country in respect of donations to charitable purposes and subscriptions to different objects. When he has discharged these, when he has paid his own election expenses and the expenses of going around his constituency looking after the interests of his constituents, I should like to know whether he has a profit out of the £360 a year paid to him. How does Deputy Dillon or anybody who supports his view expect to get people to come here and give their time and labour to the work of the Dáil if they do not, at least, get some indemnity against the heavy demands made upon them? I am against the principle enshrined in this Bill for three reasons. I am against it because this Bill is politics and not economics. I am against it because the principle is immoral and unjust. I am against it because of the effect it will have on the purity and efficiency of the public service. I say that this Bill was introduced not for the purpose of saving money or for the purpose of enabling the Minister for Finance to balance his Budget in difficult times, but for the purpose of pretending to the people in the country, whom he has duped by his political advertisements extending over six or seven years, that he has fulfilled his promise of economies in public administration. He has introduced this Bill for the purpose of pretending to those dupes that he has fulfilled his promise and the title of this Bill instead of being the Public Services (Temporary Economies) Bill, should be the Public Services (Pretended Economies) Bill. As a result of this Bill, there will be little, if any, effective economy in the administration of this State. I am sure that previous speakers have pointed out that there are a multitude of ways in which far better economies could be effected and far greater sums saved than can be saved at the expense of civic guards, army officers and civil servants.

At the very outset, I want to say that I, personally, have been, as long as I have been connected with the Government of this country, against this principle of cuts in salaries of civic guards, teachers or anybody else. I say that the principle of cuts enshrined in this Bill is an immoral and an unjust principle. I am willing to admit that the Government with which I was associated for ten years made mistakes in effecting cuts in old age pensions and the salaries of civic guards and national teachers. I make a present of that point to anybody who wishes to make political capital out of it. It was a profound error to cut the pay of the guards, and I rejoice to say that the last Government came to a definite decision that they would not cut the pay of civil servants. They made inquiries among civil servants at that time as to whether they would voluntarily submit to a temporary cut in their salaries. The reply was such as you would expect from a body of men who have given such service to the people of this country and to the building up of this State. They were prepared, they said, if there was a state of national emergency, to make their contribution, provided every other section in the State made a similar contribution. They were prepared, as the last speaker said, to accept the principle of equality of sacrifice for all. The cuts that were proposed—if they were proposed—at that time were proposed in entirely different circumstances from those of the present time. They were proposed at a time when income tax was only 3/6 in the £. These cuts are made when income tax is 5/- in the £. Deputies in the Centre Party pay no income tax, and Ministers pay no income tax. The Centre Party is in favour of the principle enshrined in this Bill. They pay no income tax and Ministers pay no income tax. If the Government were really alive to their duty in connection with economy in public administration, they could save any paltry sum which they expect to save at the expense of efficient and loyal public servants by holding a tighter hand on the purse strings and not be indulging in profligate finance and expenditure for nothing but political purposes and political victimisation.

I take the position of the Department with which I am myself most familiar, the Attorney-General's Department. It would be invidious for me to select individuals for the purpose of showing the hardships that will accrue as a result of the political manoeuvre enshrined in this Bill. There were a Parliamentary draftsman and four assistant draftsmen when the Government with which I was associated left office. There were no more efficient servants of the State and no more efficient draftsmen connected with any Parliament in the world. The Government propose to cut the salaries of the Parliamentary draftsman and his assistants. At the same time, they have brought in an additional Parliamentary draftsman, and the salary of that additional Parliamentary draftsman would, I think, equate the amount they will save by the cuts they propose to make in the other salaries. There was no necessity to bring that additional draftsman into the Attorney - General's Department. They bring that man in without necessity, and, at the same time, they propose to cut the salaries of men who have worked harder than any Deputy in the Centre Party or any other Party in this House has ever worked in his life, or ever will work. I feel that it is a definite injustice to those men, with whom I have been associated for so many years, that their salaries should be cut. I am prevented from selecting individuals, but the Parliamentary draftsman has been mentioned so often in this House and in the Seanad for his efficiency that I may be permitted to say this: in the year 1922 he offered his long and wide experience in business and in law to the State and came into the service of the State. He worked for twelve solid months without knowing what salary he was going to get, or whether he was going to get any salary. I do say this, that, while I am against the principle of cuts in any direction, whether for guards, for national teachers, for civil servants or for army officers, I am also against the principle of cuts for labourers, because I think that this whole principle of cuts is eating into the economic life of this country and causing strife that should never be permitted to take place. The principle of cutting salaries or wages is nothing but taking the line of least resistance. It is easy to cut people's salaries, and it is easy to cut people's wages, because it enables the people who do that sort of thing to dodge the real issue and to avoid facing up to the facts and finding the real way in which economies can be effected, not at the expense of individuals whose lives are ordered and regulated for years on the basis that a certain salary would be given to them or that a certain wage would come in each week.

So far as civil servants are concerned, I think this Bill is a more profound injustice than to any other section which it is intended to hit by the Bill. They came into the Service on the basis that they would have a smaller salary than they could earn outside. They came in on the basis of security of tenure and security from interference with their salaries and it takes a civil servant many long and weary years to reach any sort of position in which he can even get married or maintain himself in a proper situation in life. Every penny of the civil servant's salary is mortgaged and regulated on the basis that it is going to continue over a period of years without interference. Numbers of them have bought their houses and mortgaged their salaries to pay for those houses on the principle of payment by instalments and they now find their whole family economy uprooted by this Bill, brought in by this Ministry for political purposes and to enable them to dodge the real issue of economy in public administration. These private individuals, who had regulated and ordered their family economy on the basis that their salaries were going to continue for a long period of years, with every penny regulated by their wives on the basis that the salaries would continue indefinitely, will find themselves in a position in which, in many cases, they will not be able to pay for their houses or keep up their policies of insurance on which their wives and families depend in the event of their death.

This is the policy that is sponsored by the big farmers in the Centre Party and, for political purposes, by the members of the Fianna Fáil Ministry. I have mentioned one so-called economy in the Department with which I was associated—the addition of an unnecessary draftsman. I want to mention another so-called economy. Army Officers' salaries are to be reduced. What was the necessity for the comic opera performance of busbies on St. Patrick's Day and the banquet or reception, or whatever it was, in St. Patrick's Hall on St. Patrick's Day? The amount of money that was put into those busbies and that comic opera uniform for the Army and the amount of money spent on lobster sandwiches in St. Patrick's Hall would probably go very far to save the amount of money that will be saved by cutting junior Army officers' pay under the proposals contained in this Bill?

We are told that Ministers' salaries are reduced, and we find that they are down to £1,000, so-called. They said and undertook in advertisements and political propaganda that Ministers' salaries would be reduced to £1,000. What are they in fact? They are £1,000 free of income tax, and it matters not to those Ministers whether income tax is £1 in the £1 or a penny in the £1. They can go on increasing other people's income tax and cutting other people's salaries but they give themselves £1,000 free of tax, and, in addition, give themselves a free motor car for the use of themselves and their families, free petrol and a free driver. The man who holds the position that I held as Attorney-General has these perquisites in addition to £1,500 a year, free of tax, and liberty to get as much money as he can by private practice. He has what I never had even when I was supposed to be protected—a free motor car, a free driver and free petrol.

Where is the economy? Is it not all a sham and hypocrisy, as Deputy Morrissey has said? What I regard as my greatest achievement as Attorney-General was when I was enabled to come to an agreement with Deputy Norton and others representing the Civil Service on an agreed Bill on the dispute that arose out of the Wigg-Cochrane question. Mr. Blythe, who was then Minister for Finance, announced to this House that he was glad that agreement had been come to in order that civil servants might feel secure in the service of this State and, if civil servants are to be in a position in which they are to have what is now called a temporary Act brought in to cut their salaries this year, they can have no feeling of security that next year this Government, or any Government that may succeed them, whatever it is, may not double the cuts in another temporary Bill next year. There is brought into these proposals that element of uncertainty which is the predominant note in every branch of Fianna Fáil policy. We have uncertainty in every department of life in this country at the present moment as a result of Fianna Fáil Party policy—uncertainty in the country and uncertainty in lives and liberty and property—and this Bill enshrines again the dominant principle of the Fianna Fáil Ministry— to produce political and economic uncertainty.

What will the effect of these proposals be on the efficiency and loyalty of the servants of the State? I have no doubt, from my knowledge of these men, that they will be as loyal to that Government opposite, and, perhaps, even more loyal, than they were to the Government presided over by ex-President Cosgrave. Whatever happens I have no doubt that, although they take almost their means of livelihood away from them, they will continue still loyal in their services to the State because they will, I am sure, from my knowledge of them, put their interests in the State above their own private interests and their own feelings against the Party who has taken the bread out of their mouths. But what will its effect on their efficiency be? They are only human, and they can be efficient and can do a day's work—a better day's work than any Minister on the Front Bench opposite does or is capable of doing— within the strict letter of their regulations, but anybody who has associated with these men during the last ten years knows that time is no consideration to them, hard work is no consideration to them, and even their pay was very little consideration to them. They gave the best that was in them for the service of this country during ten years, and they were not into their office at 9.30 a.m. and away at 5 p.m., with the usual lunch interval, which could be expanded by a quarter of an hour washing their hands before and subsequently.

They gave unstinted effort and the best they had in them, and we have, I am glad to say, in the service of this State the best brains in any of the islands that were formerly known as the British Isles. The sooner the farmers realise that these men are working for them the better. If you take the Civil Service of this State and examine it, it will be found that a large percentage of that Civil Service is rendered necessary by the demands of the farmers, and if the farmers would cease their unceasing demands there would be more opportunity for economy. The Land Commission, the Department of Agriculture and the rest—they are all there for the farmers, and this proposal put forward by the Centre Party is merely the result of envy and, perhaps, of greed.

Comment on this

We have listened to a most amazing speech from, what I consider, a most amazing type of man. I think it is well for him that he has been elected a member of the Dáil because he may learn things here he never would have an opportunity of learning elsewhere even about the Cumann na nGaedheal Party. He taunts the Ministers of this Government for having free motor cars, free petrol and free drivers, at their disposal and he has the brazen cheek to make that insinuation while there is sitting beside him Deputy Fitzgerald-Kenney, who though he is not a Minister at all has a free motor car.

Comment on this

May I say that Deputies who were former Ministers were only supplied with motor cars to protect them from attacks by people who had threatened to take their lives? The present Ministers have repudiated any such state of things as existing.

Comment on this

Is that the explanation? It is almost as good as the argument which the Deputy made for the belief he holds that General O'Duffy is still chief of the Civic Guards. It is almost in line with that argument.

Comment on this

I am glad because it is quite right.

Comment on this

That is the argument he makes use of. He says that General O'Duffy is still Commissioner of the Gárda Síochána, and he went on to describe the uniform of the Army, as worn at the Eucharistic Congress, as comic opera uniform. I think that is not fit language to use, and I think the Deputy should take the first opportunity of withdrawing that statement and apologising for such insinuations.

Comment on this

What insinuations?

Comment on this

The insinuation that uniforms that were made in order to pay respect to the Eucharistic Congress should be described as fit for comic opera.

Comment on this

On a point of order. Deputy Cleary has now said that Deputy Costello described the Eucharistic Congress as comic opera.

Comment on this
Deputies

No! No!

Comment on this

He says that people will be surprised to hear that the Deputy described the Congress as comic opera.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

I did not hear Deputy Cleary describe the Eucharistic Congress as comic opera.

Comment on this

He did not say any such thing at all.

Comment on this

Deputy Dillon was so anxious that such a description should be used, and so wished it said that he thought it was said. He acted to-day as he has in many other of the unctuous things that he has done in this House which shows that having thought things out for himself he thinks everybody is going to say the same thing as he thinks. He will get out of that habit in time just as the ex-Attorney-General will get out of many of the habits and customs peculiar to him now. Deputy Costello talked about Ministers now getting huge salaries of £1,000 a year.

Comment on this

I never said that they were drawing huge salaries. I never said anything of the kind

Comment on this

But he did not complain that members of the late Government were drawing £1,700 a year, and he did not complain that the President of the late Government drew £2,500 a year. But he wants to make capital out of the fact that our Ministers, having considerably reduced their salaries, have not made further reduction by paying income-tax. As I said, the Deputy's argument does not surprise me. I have only one regret as regards Deputy Costello's career when he was Attorney-General, and that is that his Government took the advice he gave them in regard to the land annuities and refused the advice he gave them with regard to salaries reductions and old age pensions allowances. He is entitled to speak on a Bill of this kind, because he told us candidly that when he was Attorney-General to the late Government he opposed reductions of any kind either in old age pensions or in salaries. Therefore, he is the first man on the benches opposite who has a right to speak on this motion. He has been consistent throughout the years. Again, I regret that the late Government did not accept his advice with the same foolhardiness that they did on the question of the land annuities.

I regret that the Minister for Finance, in introducing this measure, did not go further than he has done. I am prepared to say here—and Deputies opposite can make what capital they like out of it—that I hope this is only the thin end of the wedge in making reductions in certain people's salaries. I have more respect for members of the Civil Service than Deputies opposite, because I did not set out to make political capital out of the Civil Service position, as Deputies opposite have done. Therefore, I hold that I have more genuine respect for the Civil Service than the Deputies opposite who prate and prattle about it. But I hold that while this country is in a crisis, as it is, it is necessary that certain official people in this State, who are guaranteed their future, not like people who do not know what to-morrow will bring them, should bear some of the burden of this crisis. We are assured by the Minister that as far as certain salaries are concerned, the lower grades particularly, this is only a temporary measure, and I trust that when this crisis is got over certain reductions that had to be made in the lower grades will be discontinued. I have no doubt about the country getting over this crisis. I am at one with the Leader of the Opposition who, speaking at the Ard-Chomhairle of Cumann na nGaedheal, held the view that the country will wear down this crisis. And I hope when the crisis is worn down the lower grades of pay will be advanced again to their former figure.

One other remark, and that is with regard to the salaries of teachers. I regret that the Minister, before he made further reductions in their incomes, did not go first to the higher Civil Service salaries and reduce their salaries by an amount equivalent to the amount the teachers were reduced by the Cumanna na nGaedheal Government. Then if further reduction were necessary the whole service would suffer an all-round reduction. Since things have happened as they have and a reduction is necessary, I hope this Bill will be extended to employees of local councils if necessary. They have fixity of tenure and a guarantee for the future, and in times of crisis they, too, should suffer some reduction. I am quite sure that the efficiency of the Civil Service will not be impaired in the least, that they will respond to this call and give as good a return in their work and service as they have given heretofore.

Deputy Costello talked about the foolishness of the Government expenditure on certain St. Patrick's Day celebrations. The Deputy, when he mentions that, would appear to have a very short memory. He should realise that this Government will be a very long time in office and will be carrying out celebrations on St. Patrick's Day for a considerable number of years before they spend as much as Deputy Cosgrave did when he was President on garden parties. Both functions are not to be compared at all. Except in so far as Deputy Costello is concerned, all the opposition to this Bill is simply a smoke-screen. I am convinced that, with the exception of the Labour Party, three members of the Centre Party, and four members of the Cumann na nGaedheal Party, if Deputies were of the belief that their opposition to this measure would defeat the Government and force them to go to the country they would abstain from voting. It is quite all right to make speeches and to vote when Deputies know there will be no direct consequence to themselves. It is all right for them to create a certain sort of atmosphere for political purposes when they know very well that the Government is going to succeed with this measure. Members of Cumann na nGaedheal and the Centre Party know they are quite safe in voting and they create all the political propaganda that they can. In those circumstances we cannot take as serious their attitude in this matter.

I am glad that the Minister, when he sets out to economise, does not touch the lower grades of the Civil Service or the citizens to whom Deputy Cosgrave used to go when he wanted to effect economies. I am glad the Minister is not interfering with old age pensioners or with certain members of the Gárda Síochána. I think it is right that the slicing of salaries should begin at the top. What would be the position if Cumann na nGaedheal were in office? The ex-Minister for Agriculture, during and prior to the last election, said that Cumann na nGaedheal were going to go out for a very clear-cut system of economy by reducing salaries at the top, in the middle and at the bottom. I dare say they, too, would be forced to reduce salaries. I wonder if they were in power where they would start to reduce. I expect they would go, as they did before, to the old age pensioners. I expect they would interfere with public services and also appropriate money that would otherwise be voted for social services.

We have now before us a policy the very opposite of the Cumann na nGaedheal policy and I commend it very strongly to the House. I express the hope that so far as the incomes of certain people in this country are concerned it is only the starting point and that we will have later on an advance from this position. Let us hope that when the Budget comes up for discussion we will have a definite reduction in certain very highly paid offices.

Comment on this

If I answer the last speaker it is not out of any particular respect for him. Let me emphasise that whoever was a guest at my house was a guest at my own expense, and not at the expense of the State. It could be inferred from the Deputy's statement that my guests were there at State expense, but that was not so. Let me add that there was a greater percentage of Irish Irelanders than there would be in the company of the Deputy or of anybody belonging to the Fianna Fáil Party. It is quite apparent from what we have just heard from the Deputy that he has not read this Bill. In consequence of that I would like to point out that the protest I made this morning has more substance now. It is obvious from the last few remarks the Deputy made that he has not read the Bill at all.

The first consideration is the amendment. I was disposed, on reading the amendment the first time, to support it. I then examined it in all its implications, and also the standing of the two Deputies proposing it. To my mind they are not the best judges of the means of the ordinary Deputy of this House, nor are they the best judges of the expenses or other commitments which fall to a Deputy here. From the information I have had, not alone during the last few years, but in the beginning, when this proposal was taken up, as to how unfair it would be to Deputies to cut the allowances that they are being given, I am not supporting the amendment. I firmly believe, notwithstanding the fact that we have heard it was a unanimous decision of the Party, that those members of the Party who have longer experience than Deputies Dillon or MacDermot will admit that the allowances are just reasonable.

Comment on this

We admitted it.

Comment on this

If they are reasonable, then judge them on that basis. I take a different line on this Bill from that taken by Deputy MacDermot. There is, to my mind, for a person like Deputy Dillon or Deputy MacDermot, a case for the proposal they have made—I will admit that—but although I am opposed to the measure and to the whole proceeding in connection with it, I cannot support the amendment. The Minister told us to-day that he had set up a Committee to deal with this matter and had got three reports. If my recollection is correct, the reports differed. He wound up by saying that the Committee did not take into consideration the Government's need. I inferred from that that this independent committee, examining the question in all its bearings, brought in a report which would not satisfy the Minister in respect of the amount of money that was going to be saved and the allocations, in consequence, are being made solely by the Government. I am quite sure it is one of a great many drafts that they had before them of one sort or another.

Deputy Rice neglected the opportunity of directing attention to the fact that when the Leader of the Government was speaking in Rathmines in 1932, before the general election—he was then in the position of being Leader of the Opposition—he practically admitted that persons in receipt of £300 or £400 a year were not to be called upon to make a contribution by way of a reduction of their salaries. What is the situation? The Minister told us he was going to save £250,000 a year by reductions in salaries. It was not done during the year. There was no question of this Bill. The Committee apparently had reported or had not reported, but no decision was taken. A general election was fought and the people throughout the country were not impressed with the Minister's statement that they were going to save £250,000 a year by reductions in salaries. The civil servants, the guards, the army and various other people concerned, each and every one of them could have drawn no other conclusion from the circumstances that no Bill had been introduced and that no cuts had been imposed, than that the policy of the Government had been departed from in that connection. We were not told that there was any departure from the statement made by the President.

I find in the publication which was circulated by the Government to the Press that there is mention there of a salary of even £350 a year. This statement points to a super-deduction of £7 and a super-deduction, plus loss in bonus on 1st January last, of £23 5/-. That is the first point I have to make. When the second general election came the President gave no information whatever that it was the intention of the Government to make reductions on salaries of £300 to £400. There was no intimation given by the Government that the salaries of the Guards were to be cut and as well as I remember there was no intimation given that the salaries of the teachers were to be cut. There had been some talk about it.

Comment on this

May I say that possibly the Deputy's knowledge is imperfect or his memory is at fault?

Comment on this

Would the Minister correct me and show me where I am wrong?

Comment on this

The President interviewed a deputation of teachers and he refused to give them any undertaking with regard to the matter whatsoever.

Comment on this

That is a very different thing to telling them they were going to be cut. I interviewed a deputation also and I gave no under taking, but it was not my intention to cut them.

Comment on this

Did the Deputy say that they were not to be cut?

Comment on this

Certainly not. I said that I knew the position and I was prepared to say this, that for 12 months no interference would be made until we had seen what the actual situation was. On February 4th, 1932, Deputy de Valera, as he then was, said: "The President of the Executive Council had a salary of £2,500 a year and Ministers £1,700 each. These salaries would have to come down by half. A salary of £1,000 should be sufficient for any Minister to meet his expenses and rear his family. He was, however, against the cutting down of the smaller Civil Service salaries by reason of the fact that these moneys were being usefully spent in the community, whilst the larger salaries were being largely spent on luxuries." That is very fine. The President has one of the larger ones now himself. I wonder is he following out the example? We had one Vote here, one Estimate here before us yesterday or the day before. It was an Estimate for the Army Vote, and the salary that is down for the Minister for Defence is £1,000. The estimated income tax liability in respect of this £1,000 was £150. The only conclusion that I will draw from that is that the salary of the Minister is free from income tax. I presume I may be entitled to draw that conclusion having regard to the way it is set out. The very hasty calculation that I have made would show that the actual salary which would produce £150 to a person in the position of the Minister for Defence is £1,300 odd, £1,323. When we were told that a salary of £1,000 a year was enough for a Minister the income tax was at 3/6 in the £. We were not told then that they were to be free of income tax, and I am not by any means to be taken as arguing in favour of reduction in Ministerial salaries. I believe that if a Minister serves the State well the State ought to be rich enough to afford him a sufficient salary. £1,323 per annum is the salary of the Minister for Defence as far as I can make out what the real salary now is.

Comment on this

May I ask Deputy Cosgrave a question? Would he explain to the House how he arrives at the conclusion that the present Minister for Defence is enjoying a salary of £1,323 as Minister for Defence?

Comment on this

Let the Minister take his pencil in hand and a piece of paper and I will show him.

Comment on this

Is the Minister for Defence enjoying a salary of £1,323?

Comment on this

As I have made it out here it is over £1,300.

Comment on this

Will the Deputy show the House how any Minister in this Government enjoys a salary of £1,000 as Minister?

Comment on this

If the Minister will not write it down will he get a blackboard and Deputy Cosgrave will make the calculation?

Comment on this

I said I have made a hasty calculation and I propose to give the Minister the figures. There is a reduction in the first place of £360 as an allowance. There is the further deduction which an unmarried person is entitled to. There is £100 at the half rate. That totals £595 off the £1,323. That would leave £728. There is one-sixth off the first £450 or something of that sort and a deduction of 10 per cent. on the remainder. The balance is at 5/-. Will the Minister correct me if I am wrong in these figures?

Comment on this

It is all wrong, absolute rubbish and the Deputy knows it.

Comment on this

Will the Minister give the correct figures?

Comment on this

The salary of the Minister for Defence is £1,000.

Comment on this

What will it be with the £150?

Comment on this

I am dealing with the person who is subject to income tax and there is no ordinance in this State to discharge Ministers from income tax any more than anyone else. No matter how the Minister cooks his figures or how they are arranged these are the facts as I said earlier. You have the figure £725 levied on, and off the £450 there is allowed one-sixth, the deduction of 10 per cent., and the balance then is at 5/-.

Comment on this