We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

Private Deputies' Business. - Public Services (Temporary Economies) Bill, 1933—Second Stage (Resumed).

Contributions 183–361 of 361. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

Bill Public Services (Temporary Economies) Bill, 1933
Enacted

No. 12 of 1933 ›

How does the Deputy get £725?

Comment on this

I deducted £360, £135 and £100 from the £1,323.

Comment on this

The Deputy's figures are all wrong.

Comment on this

Let the Minister get one of his officials to make it up. They know it. If I am wrong I wish to be corrected here and now. Any one of the Minister's officials can do it. Why I am mentioning that figure is this:—I am taking up the position of a civil servant in receipt of £1,300, and I find that according to the memo issued by the Department of Finance the civil servant has a deduction of £117 per annum off his income. I say it is bad form and bad administration, and it is not just to deal with civil servants who enter into a contract with the State to interrupt that contract and not to make some disposition with regard to any emoluments that the Ministers are in receipt of themselves. I do not subscribe to the proposal that the Minister should not be paid a good salary, but I am asking what did the Ministers state, and pointing out what they put before the people, namely, that £1,000 is enough. There was then no intimation when they said that £1,000 was enough that it was to be free of income tax. I say that no person in this State under statute is entitled to regard his salary as free of income tax.

Comment on this

Who is?

Comment on this

The form in which the Army Vote has been presented shows that. Will the Minister contradict me in the calculation I have made and point out where I am wrong in my figures? I admit I made the calculation hastily, but I want him to show me where the mistake is.

Comment on this

I will not waste time doing it.

Comment on this

The ordinary civil servant in receipt of £1,300 a year previous to the general election this year, and that is after he had received a cut, or perhaps two cuts, was in exactly the same position as the Minister with £1,000 salary free from income tax. In the one Vote that has been taken by this House there is shown in the form in which it is presented that the civil servant in comparison with the Minister would be paying £117 off that salary. When the Bill passes into law the Minister for Finance says that he expects to save £280,000 by reason of this measure. He has already saved £125,000 by reason of the fall in the cost-of-living bonus. Is this £280,000 in addition, and, if so, does it mean a saving of £405,000 as compared with last year? The Minister has not given us that information. I do not know whether he has the information. Then we do not know what is the position with regard to Sections 3, 4 and 5 in this measure. The most important part of the Bill is to be found in the Schedule, Parts I, II, III and IV.

So far as civil servants are concerned—although they are last in the list I shall take them first—one might divide them roughly into three classes. There are the old British civil servants who have a contract of service and whose position is safeguarded to some extent by Article 10 of the Treaty, and subsequent agreements. There is the second class, the recruited class, who have come into the service during the last ten years and they extend, I suppose, over all grades. Then there are those who were attracted to the service. I was responsible for persuading one of them, if I may say so, to come into the Civil Service some years ago. There is nothing wrong about it. I invite the Minister to say whether or not the Government made any attempt to attract any person to the service of the State who might be in the employment of another State. The first class have certain safeguards. The second class came in on the honour of the State, of the electorate and the elected representatives of the people, and the Government subsequently elected in the Dáil. The third class is composed of those attracted to the service of the State such as the case mentioned by the ex-Attorney-General, of a man who could have left the service six or seven years ago and earned £800 more a year than he was getting from the State, but whose conception of his responsibility and of his civic duty was such that he would not leave the infant State at that time. As the ex-Attorney-General said, the marks of the excellence of his work are to be found in the statutes passed by the Oireachtas. What is the position of those who have been recruited? There are people of a certain mentality in this and other countries who think that any salary beyond a particular sum should not be paid. I would hesitate for a long time before recommending the adoption of that policy to any person of experience in administration or business or who knows anything about public matters. What a State ought to do is to attract to its service the most brilliant intellects, the ablest men, the most capable persons, that can possibly be got and pay them properly. They would be much cheaper than inferior material however poorly paid.

Deputy O'Kelly missed the point altogether of a statement made by Deputy MacDermot who said that those in the Sinn Féin movement had been ignorant of the fact that this country had been run by the British Government during the two or three years before the Great War at a loss, and that the Home Rule Bill of 1912 was framed on the basis that the revenue derived here was less than the expenditure. We were not unaware of that fact—we knew all about it, and a lot more besides. That economic situation was changed to our advantage during the Great War, and, at one period, I think in 1920, the amount received by the British Government from tax revenue over expenditure was somewhere in the neighbourhood of £20,000,000.

I do not know whether Deputy MacDermot will persevere in his statement about hordes of officials. I have already drawn his attention privately to the fact that in the first year of the administration here there was a loss of £1,000,000 on the Post Office. Last year I think the loss was down to £40,000, and if we had been in office during that period it would have been nil. Hordes of officials! We had one Estimate discussed already this week and Deputy MacDermot was in his place, but no attention was drawn to any saving that could be made in that estimate. It is one thing to make a flowery or rhetorical statement; it is another thing to come down to business and show where economies can be effected. I am tired listening to the Party over there, who have had to swallow practically all they said when on these benches about extravagance and so on. They told the people 12 or 18 months ago that £2,000,000 would be saved without interfering in the slightest with the efficiency of the services and they are now sitting late this evening to save £280,000! They have had over 12 months to do it and they could not make up their minds how it was to be saved. After trying to persuade a Committee to take them out of the mess the Committee handed back the baby and now they come forward and say that it is absolutely necessary to have this passed this evening. For what reason? None of the reasons given would hold water. This is not an estimate. This Bill is passed already. All is wanted is the mobilisation of the silent members to make sure that it is law inside a month or two months, or whatever the time is. The fact of its passing this evening does not count in the least. We have had no information regarding the hordes of officials and I hope we shall get it. I should like to learn, notwithstanding the fact that I am getting aged, something about where these economies can be effected. I am quite sure the Minister would like to know more.

Comment on this

He is putting in new officials.

Comment on this

Deputy O'Kelly said he was attracted to the support of this particular measure by the fact that this Government was the first to adopt the democratic programme.

Comment on this
Mr. Kelly

I am plain Kelly not O'Kelly.

Comment on this

Deputy is your title here and you will have to take it.

Comment on this
Mr. Kelly

Not "O."

Comment on this

We will put the "O" on to you. It will do you a lot of good. The only Administration that put the democratic programme into practice was the one over which I presided for nine years. It is one thing to tell the people that a thing is not done; it is another thing to prove that it is not done. What is the Deputy's position? Is he a representative of the City of Dublin? On March 30th, 1933, what did the increase in the cost of relief in Dublin amount to? £489 over the corresponding week of last year, and the democratic programme has been in operation for 12 months!

Comment on this
Mr. Kelly

You were ten years in office.

Comment on this

I never had a record such as that. During my term of office the number of people in receipt of home assistance did not go up by 40,000 in 12 months. Now the Deputy says it is because the democratic programme is in operation. That is more of the nonsense that is leading towards the destitution, the degradation and the impoverishment of our people.

Comment on this

That is your legacy.

Comment on this

It is a legacy you would want, and more than a legacy, to keep you going. Then we come to the cut in the salaries of teachers in national schools. As to that, I shall only say that the statement published by the secretary of the teachers' organisation this morning throws doubt upon the statement made by the Minister this evening that it was more favourable than what had been agreed to. Then there is to be a deduction from the sums made available for universities. There the same thing applies that I have referred to with regard to public servants. We want good professors, lecturers and assistant lecturers. It so happens in the world in which we are moving that talent goes where it gets remunerated in most cases, and if by reason of these deductions universities are not going to get the best material it is not to-day or to-morow or next week or next year that this country will lose by reason of this ridiculous economy. Any proposals that were made in connection with a reduction in the cost of the public services when I had responsibility for administration were based upon the acceptance by or the agreement of the people concerned.

Comment on this
A Deputy

Old age pensions.

Comment on this

These people would, I believe, give consideration to an economic crisis. After the old age pensions had passed we won a general election—two, you might say—and that settled that.

Comment on this

That settled you.

Comment on this

It settled that, anyhow. I had a long time there, and I did not take over a machine such as was left to my successors. I did not get the headlines that were left of efficiency, competency, and general statesmanship, in connection with the public state of affairs of the State. The high cost of public services at the present moment is a serious consideration. We are told that there is a crisis on. What do you do when there is a crisis? Do you save money or do you spend it lavishly? This Government is responsible for every increased cost put on the people of this country. We had the Minister admitting this evening that the revenue is falling—that the incidence of taxation is such that the various impositions are reducing in amount. I would like to say that there is a limit beyond which if taxation and rates are pushed the result is chaotic. In connection with local administration, I would like to say that the principle regarding local authorities enshrined in the Bill is bad on the face of it. What are you doing? You are proposing to reduce certain salaries, and you are proposing not to give the local authorities the benefit of that. The saving is to come into the Exchequer. Certain minor cases have been referred to by the Minister, in respect of which, if there be a saving, it will be devoted to the particular service in question, but as far as the local authorities are concerned, whatever saving is effected is going to go into the general Exchequer, and at the same time they are being reduced £448,000 a year in the agricultural grant.

This Bill is presented to us by reason of the fact that an outside jury mobilised by the Minister could not give him what he wanted. Not having got what he wanted, he puts up to us what the Executive Council decide. It is unfair; it is unjust; and it is going to shake the confidence of the public servants of this State. It is possibly going to result in less efficient legislation, and in connection with the whole administration of the State it is going to affect that heart which men should have in their work, and would have in it if the Minister were to take them into his confidence and tell them that the crisis is such that he asks them to give some assistance in solving it. It is not being done in that way. It has been botched, one might almost say, from the very beginning. Nobody has more admiration for the efficiency of the Service than I have. I have long experience of it. I know enough about the Service—and about the ordinary people in the street, in business or elsewhere—to realise that if you make the position such for them in connection with their income that they cannot put the heart they would like to put into their work the consequence will be a loss of efficiency in the Service, perhaps much more costly than what is involved here. The Minister would be very well advised to withdraw this measure, and to take those public bodies which are affected here —all the persons, from one end to the other—into council. Some fifteen or sixteen months ago, when a question of this sort arose before, civil servants through their secretary informed the Secretary to the Ministry or some other official that if a national crisis were in existence...

Comment on this

Fifteen months ago?

Comment on this

Somewhere about October, 1931,—they were prepared to consider the case. It may be that the mistrust which will be occasioned by this measure will wipe away a lot of the profit there is in it. If that happens the situation will certainly not be improved; it will be disimproved. To my mind if the Ministry were in earnest, honest and sincere in this matter, they would accept the amendment which has been proposed by Deputy MacDermot. I agree with neither the Bill nor the amendment, and I propose to vote against both.

Comment on this

I just want to make a few remarks with reference to Deputy Dillon's amendment to this Bill. Deputy Dillon calculates a Deputy's work for his constituency by the number of days he attends in this House. Any Deputy who lives in his constituency is all the time, Sunday and Monday, working for that constituency, and his expenses do not cease when he goes back to it. A Deputy living in Dublin perhaps, or living away from his constituency, may be under less expense, but the general body of Deputies who live in their constituencies have to travel from place to place in those constituencies. When Deputy Dillon refers to their having 1st class travelling allowances to and from their constituencies he forgets that the least part of their travelling is the travelling they do to and from the Dáil. The heaviest portion of their travelling is up and down within their constituency, the areas of which are very big in many cases. Deputies are not confined to coming to Dublin during the sitting of the Dáil. If they do their duty by their constituents they have to be up here in Dublin practically every week visiting various Departments. Neither is their time in Dublin confined to Wednesday, Thursday and Friday. If they want to do any work in the various Departments they find that they have to be here on Monday, or at least early on Tuesday.

I think that this amendment is actuated, no matter what Deputy Dillon says, by a desire to make this House undemocratic, and to have nobody representing the constituents but people like himself, with large incomes outside their Parliamentary allowance. Perhaps the activities of those opposed to Deputy MacDermot politically are too much for him, and he sees a way of curbing those activities by bringing about a reduction in the Parliamentary allowance. Deputies who do their duty in dealing with their correspondence often find a bill averaging 5/- a day for postage alone. Six days out of seven the cost of postage alone reaches 5/- per day, out of their Parliamentary allowance of 19/8 per day. I would not speak on this motion or on this Bill were it not for the mean references made by the ex-Attorney-General, in his speech, to the present Ministry and to the national celebration on St. Patrick's Day. It comes very well from the ex-Attorney-General who, with the other Ministers of the late Cabinet, had all the facilities of free transport, free petrol and a free driver, to put up such allegations against the present Government.

Comment on this

They had these only to carry a Thompson gun, a .45 revolver themselves, and a guard.

Comment on this

They had the other car to do that.

Comment on this

They had no such thing. They never had official transport of any kind except to carry their guard, and they never had a guard until Fianna Fáil were coming back into the political arena.

Comment on this

I had the pleasure of opposing Deputy Mulcahy as a speaker in my constituency when by-elections were fought there, and on all those occasions the Deputy and every other ex-Minister had a free army car and a free driver.

Comment on this

Again I deny that I had official transport for any other purpose except to carry the guard that the police authorities considered it was necessary for some of us to have when the Fianna Fáil Party decided in 1927 to come back into competitive politics. But from 1923 down to 1927—until that came about—I like every other Minister and ex-Minister was able to go to any part of the country that I wanted to go to unarmed and unattended without any official transport.

Comment on this

Deputy Costello——.

Comment on this

That is right. Get away from the point.

Comment on this

I will not get away from the point. Deputy Costello stated this evening, in his mean fashion, that the cars used by the Ministers in carrying on their duties as Ministers of State were also being used by their families. I could make an equally mean insinuation and, perhaps, would have more proof for it than Deputy Costello has for his. I can state and prove that an ex-Minister uses the army car at his disposal for conveying his children to and from school every day of the week since we became a Government.

Comment on this

Make it.

Comment on this

I will prove it if I am challenged to do so. That does not come very well from the ex-Attorney-General when we remember that when their dead colleague was buried they made the State put up the cost of the wreaths that went on his grave, and made the State pay for the lunch they had after the funeral in the Gresham Hotel. It comes well from such a Deputy to make little of the attempt to raise the dignity and the prestige of this nation by honouring the national holiday with a banquet in St. Patrick's Hall, as well as his talk about the lobster salad and all the other mean talk that we heard from him.

Comment on this

Ask them how they used the secret service money?

Comment on this

Is the Minister not prepared to ask it himself?

Comment on this

I will deal with that.

Comment on this

I hope when the principles of this Bill are being put into operation that the Minister will see that they also apply to the inflated salaries paid to certain local and municipal officials up and down the country. If an amendment to the Bill is necessary to do that, I hope the Minister will see that it is introduced. The cost of living in the country is not as high as in Dublin, and I trust the Minister will see if the suggestion I have made cannot be included in this Bill. I again protest against the mean spirit that has been introduced into the debate by the ex-Attorney-General.

Comment on this

As representing the people of Kerry, I welcome this measure, particularly in so far as it relates to the local authorities. If there is not power under the Bill to deal with highly superannuated officials, I hope the Minister will amend it in that direction and make it more drastic than it is. As Deputies are aware, the amalgamation scheme that was carried out was one of the greatest curses ever inflicted on the country so far as local authorities are concerned. In almost all cases it led to a duplication of services. There are many glaring instances of that in the County Kerry, of officials drawing salaries at the present time under local authorities who are entitled under the amalgamation scheme to superannuation allowances as high as £700 and £800 per annum. There has been too much overlapping, so much of it indeed that very drastic action is called for so far as the local authorities are concerned. The secretary of the principal local body in County Kerry has admitted that he is in receipt of £1,450 per annum. That includes salary and emoluments. I hold that this measure is merely a gesture in so far as economies are concerned, and that the real drastic reductions must take place later. We welcome it so far as it goes, but power should be taken to deal with salaries paid by local bodies. As regards the £1,000 salaries, I think the Bill should be more drastic than it is. In the case of the lower ranks I think the grades of allowances are very fair, but the reductions in the case of people with £1,000 a year should be greater than what is proposed.

With regard to Deputy Dillon's amendment I would like the Deputy to know that I and other members of this House worked for years on local bodies and were not worried about salaries or allowances. We did that work free, and we are still prepared to work for the people without any remuneration with the exception of a subsistence allowance. It was simply camouflage on the part of Deputy Dillon to bring in this amendment and it will be taken as such by the people throughout the country. The people know quite well that many of us are prepared to work for them and that we are not out for this allowance. They know that we are prepared to carry on as we did in the past—that the working Deputies of this House are prepared to do their utmost for the people they represent. I think Deputy Dillon when bringing forward his amendment must have had in mind the old-time politicians, who went down the country, made glorious promises to the people, and then returned to live in Dublin. We are not of that type. I welcome the Bill, but as I have said I hope it is only a gesture as to what the Government propose to do in making drastic reductions in salaries.

Comment on this

This measure is a national calamity from one point of view. It is a national necessity from another point of view. I am afraid that the Centre Party, who attempt to represent the farming community of this country in this amendment, will find that they do not represent them— that they do not represent them even to the percentage extent that their numbers as Deputies represent the electorate of the country. Eye-wash of this kind will not deceive anybody. I was sorry that Deputy Dillon put his name to this amendment for a number of reasons. I was sorry because he is an educated man of 21 years of age and upwards and that he is James Dillon, the son of John Dillon, and the grandson of John Blake Dillon, that he should put his name to a proposal of this kind that, in the words of Deputy Morrissey, is pure hypocrisy. It is pure hypocrisy from my point of view. I do not accuse the Deputy of using it in a hypocritical way, but it appears to me to be nothing else.

Comment on this

The distinction is very fine.

Comment on this

Yes; well, I hope it will be appreciated. One thing which Deputy MacDermot said I want to contradict now. As far as I could observe, he made a reference to the effect that people—Deputies—he looked around the House when he said it— sneered at a reference to the old Irish Parliamentary Party. I did not see anybody sneering at any reference to the old Irish Parliamentary Party, and I think that it should go on record that that statement of his was not true. It certainly was not true as far as I could observe. Whether we differ with the policy of the old Irish Parliamentary Party or not, I do not believe that there is a single Deputy in this House that does not recognise the signal services which, under different conditions from the conditions under which we live now, that Party gave to this country.

Another matter about which Deputies opposite grew very eloquent—almost hysterical—was the reference made by Deputy Costello to the saving that might be effected if busbies on the gallant hussars were not used at the sumptuous banquet which the Army, in all its glitter, dominated on St. Patrick's Day. We were asked by Deputies why should it not be done. We here agree that it should be done, we have no objection; but I would ask the House to remember the hypocrisy of that Party over there who would not co-operate even to the extent of walking in the funeral procession of the greatest patriot of our time, the greatest Fenian of our time, whose remains had been sent over here from America to be buried in Glasnevin—the late John Devoy. The Fianna Fáil Party refused to march in that funeral, and a Deputy opposite was in the room in the City Hall on the night that three representatives of Fianna Fáil marched out when they asked the Executive Council whether the National Army were taking part, and were informed that it was.

Comment on this

The Fianna Fáil Party did take part in the funeral.

Comment on this

The Deputy can take up the matter later. The question was put as to whether the National Army was going to participate in the funeral procession, and the Secretary of the Executive Council said that he was empowered to state that it was, that John Devoy's remains were entitled to the honour of a public funeral, and that no funeral could be public here if the State did not co-operate in it, and the Army did not also co-operate. "Very well," said the three representatives of Fianna Fáil, "if the National Army is going to co-operate in this funeral, we cannot co-operate." One of those representatives was a Senator, drawing a salary from the Free State. Another had been a Deputy Speaker of this House for five years and drew £1,000 a year. The other was a Senator in receipt of a pension from the British Army, who had been decorated on the field of battle for cutting the throats of the Boer farmers. Deputy Rice can contradict me now if I am wrong.

Comment on this

My recollection of the proceedings of that Committee is that Mr. Dermot O'Hegarty came down and told us that whether we liked it or not the Executive Council would take charge of that funeral and make the arrangements as they thought fit. It was then, and not till then, that some of the Fianna Fáil Party withdrew from the Committee.

Comment on this

As the matter has been raised, I wish to say that there is only a shadow of truth in that.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The arrangements for a particular funeral have nothing to do with this Bill, and more than enough has been said about the matter.

Comment on this

Very well, sir, I will not pursue the matter further. The proposal in this Bill has become inevitable from the policy adopted by the Government and by the Labour Party. It is their economic policy that is responsible —and I want it to be clearly understood what I mean by economic policy; I do not mean the policy that the people opposite tried to put over on the people as the beginning and ending of their entire policy, the economic policy of Arthur Griffith. That policy has no opposition on this side. The policy to which I refer is the policy of the Government to deprive this country of its markets. That is the only policy, because the real economic policy of Arthur Griffith, a real national protective policy, is impossible unless you have a market for your surplus goods. None of the Ministers will face up to that position. That war was declared last year by President de Valera. I say President de Valera, advisedly, because President de Valera is the Government. He is the Minister for Finance, the Minister for Justice and the Minister for everything else down the line, and the Minister for Finance opposite knows that very well and I know it too, and the Minister for Finance knows how I know it.

Comment on this

The Official Secrets Act!

Comment on this

As to the Official Secrets Act, they came as badly out of my Official Secrets Act as out of the one in Green Street. These reductions as I say, are the inevitable consequence of the reduction in national income, represented in our trade returns, of £8,000,000 for a half year and the position we are up against now. Apologists over there need not say that this is only temporary. Everything is done now with the appearance and the genuineness of permanency. The annuities have been taken out of the Suspense Account, or at least there is a book-keeping entry to the effect that they have been taken out—whether there was anything there to be taken out or not I do not know; the Minister knows that better than I do—but, as I say, as a book-keeping transaction they have been taken out. War to the knife has been declared. Agriculture was described picturesquely to-day as being in the front line trenches for the last year. The farmers cannot remain forever in the front line trenches and this trouble with England has got to be settled or pass this Bill, and Deputies opposite can rest assured that this is only the thin end of the wedge. The civil servants and the teachers and all the other public officials mentioned in this Bill will be very lucky if there is anything to pay them in six months' time if this economic war is not settled.

We were told by a Deputy to-day that the previous Government cut the roots of the tree and that the tree was withering when the present Government came into office. We know who cut the roots of the tree, and we know who tried to stop the tree from being planted. It was not the people that the Minister for Finance hopes some day to see standing on the broken arch of Mallow Bridge, not to sketch the ruins of St. Paul's, but to sketch in the pages of Irish history, the men who set up this State in spite of him and his colleagues. If the civil war had not been fought we would have millions of money now. That was what rotted the root of the national tree. What do we find in the so-called economic war and in the Minister's proposals? They are co-related financially. As Minister for Finance he should know. Some of his colleagues told us about them on political platforms, of course, where they were all playing football the one way. They do not attempt to tell us here. He told us of the money he is going to get from the printing machine in the future. He should know that times of stress are not the times to contract currency but the times to increase it. I refer him to the Report of the Select Committee of the House of Lords and the House of Commons of 1832. He is going to restrict currency in times of stress. How is he going to restrict it? By reducing the wages and the salaries of State officials. In his comic turn a few days ago Deputy Hugo Flinn told us that the policy of his Government was to make this a self-supporting State. If this is to be a self-supporting State it must provide a market for itself within itself. What are the potentialities of a market within a State? The purchasing power of the workers within the State. This Bill proposes to cut by varying percentages the purchasing power of the people. They are only State officials, to start with. Remember that this means every wage earner and every employer ultimately.

Consider the position of thousands of thrifty civil servants in Dublin and around it, who, in the last ten years have bought houses on the hire purchase system. They have a fixed social scale and an ambition for themselves and their families commensurate with their remuneration, a remuneration that was guaranteed to them under Government contract. These civil servants have insured their lives. Some of them bought their houses through insurance companies and have to meet very high charges at the present time. Has the Minister considered what this might mean to them and what case in equity they might be able to put up? If they find themselves on reduced salaries unable to meet their obligations, and if they go to the Minister, to the banks or to the insurance companies saying "Our incomes have been cut down, even though we were under Government contract to get these incomes, and we want our contracts with you cut down," what will be the Minister's position? Perhaps he would refer the matter to the Farmers' Association of agricultural experts that works under the wing of the Fianna Fáil Party, but that contains no farmers. That Association always asks for the repudiation of bank debts. Perhaps it might become a semi-Government institution to deal with those house purchasers whose salaries will be reduced under the Bill and who will not be able to meet their obligations.

As regards the amendment it is a cheap way of getting publicity. It is cheap, political propaganda and nothing else. There are certain Deputies—I must use the plural although it would be the singular up to a few days ago—going around the country telling the farmers that salaries must be reduced. That is going to be the acid test. Supposing you abolish the £360 a year—call it what you like— or part of it——

Comment on this

I do not want it.

Comment on this

I will assume for the sake of my argument that the lot goes. Each Deputy represents a population of 20,000, which means 4d. per head to his constituents. If a Deputy goes to his constituents and gives them 4d. a head he would not enrich them. If a Deputy was not worth 4d. per head well he is not fit to be here and it is a poor valuation he is putting on himself. If a Deputy represents half that number, 10,000 electors, it would only mean 8d. per head. If constituents through the country are told that if this allowance is withdrawn from Deputies it will mean that each elector will gain 8d. in the year, will the electors be satisfied? Of course not. It is the service that a man gives his constituents and his ability and his knowledge to understand their peculiar requirements that count.

Comment on this

What about the civil servants who are going to be cut? Does not the same argument apply?

Comment on this

I might answer that question by asking another question. Why is the Deputy going to vote for it?

Comment on this

I will tell you later.

Comment on this

As far as I understand your leader, he is going to vote for the Bill. I am not. If he is going to vote for the Bill he must have some reason at the back of his head why civil servants should be cut. I cannot understand the mentality of some people. I can speak in this matter as a farmer, as an ex-civil servant, as a businessman, and as a manufacturer. I deplore the reduction of salaries of public servants. It means a lowering of the standard of living. You cannot stop; it will run down the line. Every grade will be reduced; the purchasing power of the community will be reduced, and it will have a cumulative effect. It will increase in momentum as it goes along. Before the year is out salaries will have to be revised again, all through one cause, and one cause only. That cause is the economic war that was precipitated by the Government opposite.

Members on the Front Bench are very careful in what they say about the causes of the economic war, but the back benchers come along and say in effect: "No surrender. We were attacked." They were not attacked. They say that the late Government paid the annuities to England. They all stand round the annuities, but what about the claim amounting to £400,000,000 that was put up to Mr. Thomas the last time this Government was in touch with the British Government? In that, and this comes home to the Minister for Finance, is a particular claim that we were entitled to the profits on the note issue from the signing of the Treaty onwards. The Minister ought to know, if he does not know, that we had then a note issue of about £20,000,000 making five per cent. for the British Government. It made that on a reduced currency running down to about £17,000,000 up to 1929. Whose fault was it? Was it the fault of the British Government? No, it was the fault of the people who set out to lay this country in ruins and who made it impossible for any Minister for Finance to establish a national currency and to save that money from going to the British Treasury. Every Treasury note that was in circulation here made that much of a free grant to the British Treasury. That was ruling here until 1929, and this country was losing about £1,000,000 per year on the profits of the note issue. Now that the Fianna Fáil Party have been responsible for England having control of our note issue up to 1929, and the British Treasury having profits on that note issue amounting, roughly, to about £1,000,000 per year, the Fianna Fáil Party come along and make a claim on the British Government that they must be refunded the profits on the note issue.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The control of the note issue up to 1929 is surely not relevant on the Public Services (Temporary Economies) Bill.

Comment on this

Let me explain, a Chinn Comhairle. The Bill before us is a direct consequence of the economic war. Part of the issue in the economic war is that we should be paid the profits on the note issue from 1922 up to 1929.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Deputy has said that this Bill is a result of the economic war. He may be quite right in so arguing, but all the items and details in that economic war cannot be argued on this Bill. It is quite in order to give reasons for and against the Bill but not the details of every matter which a Deputy considers to have affected or necessitated the Bill.

Comment on this

We have this as an alternative to a settlement of the economic war. How can a dispute be settled between two individuals or two nations if one party demands that the other must pay for losses for which that party is not responsible, but for which the party claiming is responsible? The Party that is the Government here to-day is responsible for certain losses. Our Government is claiming from the British Government compensation for losses for which the Fianna Fáil Party is directly responsible. We are told here that because we refuse to join in such a nonsensical claim as that, we are playing England's game. We must reduce the salaries of our public servants, we must shake up the whole fabric of the State, we must reduce the standard of living, simply because Fianna Fáil wants to save their faces. They knew the Ultimate Financial Settlement was in existence in 1927 but yet they allowed a vote to be taken in this House without declaring their policy on it. The President knows he was asked to declare his policy on it and he refused. He did nothing until this House had committed itself to the vote. That is true, and I was the member of the Party who asked him to declare his policy on it.

Comment on this

On what?

Comment on this

Your policy on the annuities.

Comment on this

Nonsense.

Comment on this

And on the Ultimate Financial Settlement.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Deputy is out of order in referring to these matters and the President would be equally out of order in replying to him.

Comment on this

The dispute between the two countries has deprived us of our markets, has reduced national income by eight millions in six months, and will reduce it by another eight millions during the remaining six months. While the national income has been so cut down, we cannot pay our public servants the scale of salaries they were formerly paid. While I clearly see that position, my attitude and my vote will be given for a policy that we should stop the economic war rather than reduce the standard of living of this country. We could settle it on the lines of mutual confidence. We have got either to settle it or to reduce our standard of living. That is sticking out. It is not the British Government that started it, but the members of the Front Bench opposite. It is not the Party that built up the Treaty and the National Army, that has been so highly complimented by back benchers on the Government side who started it. It is not those who supported the Treaty that are playing England's game, but those people who tried to break the State from outside, and who are now trying to break it from inside. It is time this breaking of the State was stopped, and that we who want to work for our country should be allowed to work for it and build up the State as it should be built under a friendly native Government and not be eternally squabbling over nothing. We have got very important work in our own country but we will not be let do it by our own Government. We are not playing England's game. If we dare to criticise our Government they say that we are playing England's game. What game were they playing when they were out in arms burning and looting?

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The civil war is not relevant to the matter under discussion.

Comment on this

It may not, directly.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Nor indirectly.

Comment on this

But we have to suffer as a consequence of that civil war.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Possibly, but it is not in order on this Bill to refer to it or to discuss it.

Comment on this

The national debt incurred by the civil war constitutes a large portion of the overhead charges of the nation to-day. With all deference to your ruling, a Chinn Comhairle, we cannot get away from the obligations incurred through the civil war, though I do not want to labour that point. I want to refute the allegation of this new patriotism, that the people who built up the Treaty are playing England's game, and that the people now working the Treaty, who did all they could to smash it, are the patriots. It is time that this mock patriotism was put aside. It is time that the mask was pulled off and the country saw who was playing England's game and who is playing England's game. The civil servants may thank the people who played England's game and who are playing England's game for this cut. I wonder will so many of them shout "Up de Valera" now. I have made clear the attitude that I propose to adopt on this Bill. I recognise that there is no alternative to this Bill, or even a more drastic Bill, but a settlement of the so-called economic war. It is time the Government did something for a settlement. We here stand for a revision of the Ultimate Financial Settlement.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Neither the settlement of the economic war nor the Ultimate Financial Settlement is in order in this debate.

Comment on this

I shall not go back to that any more. As regards the proposal to reduce the allowance of members of the Oireachtas, it is easy for a Deputy who lodges round the corner in the Shelbourne Hotel, and who can spend his time going round the country in a sumptuous motor car to support a proposal of that kind. He is not in the front-line trenches of agriculture, industry or commerce, and, if this country were smashed to-morrow, he could take his hand-bag and go off safely to Paris. It is easy for Deputies of that type to talk as they did, but those Deputies cannot speak for farmers or for the Agricultural League for which they pretend to speak, because they only came into that and captured it by stealth. Well the Deputy knows that. Well he knows that when he approached the organising committee of that organisation to be made president of the convention, he was told he was not a farmer and that he had lived for almost fifty years without realising that there was a country called Ireland and that farmers were not going to be represented by him. He knows that the next man selected by the organising committee was bought over by a caucus meeting held in Fitzwilliam Square by the Deputy and others.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Deputy has made a suggestion that certain people were "bought over."

Comment on this

I did not mean that they were bought over in money or kind. I withdraw that remark.

Comment on this

Nobody minds the Deputy's insinuations.

Comment on this

They are not insinuations; they are statements of fact. I am not going to test the patience of the Ceann Comhairle by putting down the relevant documents the Deputy in question circulated in order to get there. But I could do that. The present proposal is one which, at that convention, Deputy MacDermot opposed. It is time that all this hypocrisy was brushed aside. It is time that all this playing to the gallery by Deputy MacDermot and Company, as regards the reduction of the allowance, was ended. It will not wash. What the farmers want done by the Centre Party, the Fianna Fáil Party, the Cumann nGaedheal Party and every other Party is something to improve their condition. They do not grudge, any more than any other section of the community, compensation either by way of allowance or otherwise to Deputies who come here to work in their interests and in the interest of the nation. They will not be caught by bird-lime in this way. They have been pulled a long way but their eyes are opened now. I am satisfied conscientiously that I am doing the proper thing in voting against this Bill and against the amendment. Deputy MacDermot should be more sparing in his criticism when he tries to insinuate that Deputies are here for the salaries. Whatever differences there may be amongst Parties in this House, there are men in the two big parties facing each other here who have spent bullets in their bodies as a result of fighting for their country. When they went out to fight, they never thought that they would be rewarded for doing so. If the people who won us this freedom are prepared to work for the country for which they made sacrifices in their youth, why should they not be remunerated now or why should they not get their out-of-pocket expenses for coming here in their own time and working for their country? Their constituents will be the judges whether they are doing the work in the interest of public representation or not. It is exceedingly bad taste on the part of Deputy MacDermot, who spent his manhood working and fighting for other countries, to come here and castigate men who fought for their country and who worked for their country without fee or reward. Now, they only ask out-of-pocket expenses when they come here to the Dáil. They are making nothing out of it, and never will make anything out of it. I have no hesitation in voting against the Bill and against the amendment.

Comment on this

The principle enshrined in this Bill is that the salaries of persons in the service of the State should, for one year, be reduced. That would seem to be a very simple matter if we did not take it in conjunction with the fact that in this country and in every other country the political Party in charge of the Government changes from year to year or from decade to decade, as the case may be. I am sure that everybody will agree that there is nothing so important to any State as the existence in that state of a reliable Civil Service, military service and police force, with the other service which it is suggested in this case should be cut, the education service. There is a feeling—I say this as representing the County Dublin and the townships where the majority of the blows of the axe are likely to fall—that an attack is being made generally on the services whether it be the Civil Service, the Army, the Guards or the education services.

I do not want to refer to any irrelevant matters, but people have this feeling, even in the Civil Service, that, as a result of the change of Government, there has been withdrawn from this State service that feeling of security and that feeling that they have behind them the support of the Executive Council which they always felt and on which they could always rely. As yon know, sir, and as every Deputy knows, the civil servant and the member of the Army or the police forces of the State is in a very different position from that of the ordinary citizen. The Guards are not allowed to vote, although, personally, I believe that is wrong. The Civil Service and all these other services were not asked whether, if an economic or uneconomic war were started with another country, they were prepared to dole out to the extent of a quarter of a million pounds to meet the cost of the war. The civil servant cannot engage in other occupations. He cannot do the many things which persons in ordinary civil life can do. As a result, possibly, of his training and his experience, he proceeds to set out early in life to live in an ordered, regular fashion.

Other Deputies have referred here to the number of commitments that the civil servants undertook in the nature of purchase of houses, insurance and so on, but possibly one of the most important matters, namely, the education of his children, was not referred to. I think that it is a very serious matter for the civil servant to be faced to-morrow morning with the information that, having planned his budget for the year, he will receive from £50 to £150 less for the next year. That may be all right for the Minister for Finance who is dealing with national finances and really does not care whether or not his Budget will balance at the end of the year, but the civil servant is in a very different position because creditors and bank managers have an extraordinary habit of insisting on a civil servant paying his debts. It is very likely true that no body of persons gets less credit, or, perhaps, I should say, shorter credit, than civil servants, members of the Army, the Guards, and school teachers, all because they are State servants and "why should they not be made pay?" That should be considered. It is a very important item in this matter when, suddenly, without consultation or agreement, this attack is made on the income of these servants of the State.

As I said before, very likely in no other country in the world is it so important that there should be a loyal, satisfied Civil Service, military service, police force and educational body than in this country where we are inclined to go so much to the Left or to the Right in the matter of political thought. The people however Left or Right or red or green they think, should, at least, be unanimous in one matter—that they would have and should have a really satisfied Civil Service, military service, police force and educational body. The most serious objection to this Bill is the attack on these four important services in this most serious way. I take it that the most serious way in which anybody now could be attacked is financially, because, when we want to declare war on England, we do not throw up flags and fire shots, but we declare an economic war. An economic war has been declared on these four services which have been, and still are, the pillars and foundation of the State, but, in the Bill itself, there is a principle enshrined of a most objectionable character. Each member of these four services is a servant of the State and it would be well if Deputies, electors, farmers and others would, sometimes, realise that there is a difference between servants and slaves. They are servants of the State, but the State has no right to make them slaves. If any individual enters into a contract of service, either as an employer or an employee, that person has got the right, under the Constitution and under the laws of this country, to have the contract examined, enforced or qualified by the courts of the land.

What happens in this Bill? Section 8 says:

Every doubt, question, and dispute which shall arise as to whether a person is or is not a person to whom this Part of this Act applies, or as to the amount of the salary for the purposes of this Part of this Act of any person or the amount of the deduction to be made under this Part of this Act from any such salary shall be determined by the Minister whose determination thereof shall be final.

As I said, the civil servants, members of the Army and the Guards and the teachers are servants of the State. Let us cut their salaries, if you like, but let us not insist on making them slaves of the State. Why should not the civil servant, the Army officer, corporal, sergeant or other rank, the Guard or the teacher have the right against his employer, namely, the State, which every other employee in this country has—the right to go to the courts of the land to have determined his claim against his employer? I submit that there never was a more drastic section introduced into any Bill brought before this House. It makes these officials—the Civil Service, Army, Guards and teachers—not servants of the State but slaves of the State. It is likely a continuance of the policy which has shown itself in other ways but, as I said, I desire to keep from irrelevancies. I would like, however, to protest, as strongly and as loudly as I can, against that particular section and even the removal of that particular section will not alter the Bill.

To deal a little further with the section, it sets out that every case of doubt is to be decided by the Minister. The Minister says that the salary of Mr. X, a civil servant, is to be cut by £25. Mr. X thinks that it should be only £10 and who decides?—the Minister. The same set of officials who advise the Minister that the amount of the cut should be so much will again advise the Minister, and the ordinary rights of the citizen, as between employer and employee, are entirely removed from these members of the State services. They are being transformed from servants to slaves, not of the State but of Ministers. If there is any objection or doubt the Minister decides, and his decision and determination, whatever it may be, shall be final. The desirability that there should be satisfactory servants of the State and that these servants should bend their backs bravely to their jobs is very necessary. Any possibility of the servants of the State bravely bending their backs to their work is removed by a Bill like this. One would think that a Government composed of a Party that said for years that there were disloyal servants in the State, fighting England's battle, would take a big step to dislodge that theory instead of adding fuel to the flame of discontent which they allege already existed.

There are many other matters that might be mentioned. I only refer to general principles and general reasons why this Bill should not be supported. The teachers are a body of people, in this country, who render a very great service to the nation. I agree that they are a body well paid—the present Government said they were too well paid. Some speaker said that an agreement was come to with the previous Government for the acceptance of a reduction, during the period of economic depression. But what has happened in this instance? The present Government brings in this Bill. There is to be no separate discussion. Agreement between responsible officials of the Unions and the Government Departments is to come to an end. A tyranny has taken the place of government. Servants of the State are to be slaves of the Ministry, in order that an economic war may be waged. I am not discussing the merits or the demerits, the rights or the wrongs of that economic war. All I am asking is what is to be the end of all this. There is to be a saving of a quarter of a million. I ask the Minister seriously to consider the advisability of forcing this Bill. It will in the end mean no saving. It will bring discontent to the Civil Service, to the Army, to the Guards, to the teachers, and to their homes in the cities and the villages throughout the country, and in the end it will not mean a saving of even a quarter of a million. Especially unfortunate is the actual fact in the Schedule that the Guards are to be cut half-a-crown a week. It is very little satisfaction to the Guards, and very poor consolation to me, to be able to say that when the election promises were being made by the Party opposite I told them they would be cut. I said "Never mind the promises that are being made" but of course, it is little satisfaction now to be able to say to them "I told you so."

I would like to hear from Deputies on the Fianna Fáil Benches and, especially those who sit for the County Dublin, what explanation they will give for the promises they made that no Guard whose pay would be from £2 10s. to £2 15s. per week would be reduced by 2/6. I am glad to see Deputy Breathnach here. I should like to know what he will say, not to the Guards and the teachers, but to the workers in North Dublin, when these workers are faced by their employers with this consideration: "The Government consider it right to reduce the Guards by 2/6 or 5/- a week, and we propose to reduce your wages also." A headline is set to employers for a reduction of wages, a lowering of the standard of living, and not only that but in the outlook of civil servants, and the provision that they might have been able to make for their children. It is a pressing downwards. Instead of what we were promised, not only a few months ago, but fifteen months ago, that all would be rosy we are now being asked to consider reductions of 8 per cent. plus 4, plus 8½, plus 9, plus 12 per cent., plus 17½, and so on, going on through all these miserable figures, when in reality we were promised something a little short of the Garden of Eden.

Comment on this

I think there is a dangerous suggestion contained in the proposed amendment. It seems to me clearly to indicate a frame of mind which if developed in this country would prove very dangerous. As the mover of this amendment is a second lieutenant in the Centre Party there may be some explanation from his point of view and that I assume would fairly well indicate the point of view of his Party or at least that of his leader. Last year, we had the grand example of the leader of the Farmers' Party showing his generosity by refusing to accept his allowance as a T.D. That was a generous gift, and one would have thought that it would have been followed by others of his Party. Apparently his Party to-day are not with him in his notions that this allowance should not be accepted. Last year, after the leader of the Party gave the example that he did, I did not hear of any of his followers taking any step in that direction. To-day his entire Party is behind him for a substantial cut. If we work this to its logical conclusion we can see a very sinister motive in it. We see that a man who last year disposed of his entire allowance might calculate that a situation might arise that made the prospective leadership available only for those who, like himself, could make those gifts voluntarily without any crisis arising. That displays to me a type of imperialistic outlook that is certainly not in keeping with the traditions of this country. I do not think his gesture will appeal to many of the people.

The general trend of opposition to the Bill shows that not alone the Centre Party but, in conjunction with them, the Cumann na nGaedheal Party, are completely out of touch with the people. They have laboured here the question of the necessity for this cut, and they have endeavoured to make political capital out of the fact that the cut is the result of the economic war in which the country is engaged. They seek to add to the discontented amongst the farming and business community, the civil servants and other servants in the State who are called upon to accept a temporary reduction in their salaries. Of course, if it were not a consistent policy on the part of the Opposition, and if the country were not already well aware of the attitude all this might be regarded as a very dangerous thing, but because we have had experience of these tactics for at least twelve months we are not at all astonished.

Speaking a short time ago, Deputy Belton attributed the necessity for the Bill to the civil war. Was the claim made that it was the civil war that was responsible for the reduction in teachers' salaries some years ago, and also for the reduction in the pay of the Civic Guards a few years back? Was the civil war responsible for the reduction in the case of old age pensions six or seven years ago? Reductions took place for several years back; it was found necessary in the economy of the State to make those reductions. Why is the whole responsibility for these proposed reductions now attributed to the civil war? Deputies who speak in that strain are not seriously tackling the proposition. I suggest they are completely out of touch with the people down the country. I represent a country constituency, and I know perfectly well that the farmers and business people are in complete sympathy with this Bill.

There is no person interfered with by this measure who cannot reasonably afford to make a sacrifice in a time of crisis. There is no person affected by the proposed reductions whose children will go hungry. But that is not true of the conditions existing in the case of many families in the country where a salary of £300 represents a condition of opulence that it is very rare to find. This measure is needed in order to cater for the wants of poor people in the towns and villages throughout the country. We are making provision for them in the only way in which provision can be made— by taking it from those who can afford to give without inconvenience to themselves. We are endeavouring under this measure to meet the requirements of many thousands of needy people in the country.

That is the proposal that the Opposition are opposing here to-night. They have wasted practically all the day appealing for a class of the community whom they endeavour to hold up as men so sordid that they can only think during every moment of their working hours of the amount of salaries coming to them. They suggest that civil servants will become indifferent if this cut is put into operation. Is that not tantamount to saying that every civil servant has little or no interest in the State, has no human sympathies and only thinks of the amount of salary that he gets? If that is really the outlook of the civil servants you cannot have from them that generous type of service that can only come when men work not entirely for the consideration of a reward in money but because of an interest in the service they are giving to the community. I suggest that that does not truly depict the Civil Service. It is wrong to make that charge against civil servants. I know a good many of them, and I am quite satisfied they are good, conscientious people. Many of them to whom I have spoken have indicated their willingness in this crisis to make this sacrifice, and more if necessary. I repudiate the charge that our Civil Service is made up of men and women who have no souls, no sympathies, and no national outlook.

All this talk we have heard to-day is mere camouflage. It is an endeavour to dishearten the people in their struggle. Almost every Deputy who has spoken has suggested that the solution for all this is to end the economic war. Of course, this economic war could be ended at any moment if we desired to put up our hands and say to England "We are prepared to accept your terms." We have no mandate for that. We have a mandate to fight this war to a finish, and we are going to fight it out. There are people in this country to-day who are shouting: "We cannot stand the strain of this economic pressure. End the war." The people responsible for that are the people who are actually responsible for the existence of the economic war.

This amendment is a ridiculous one. It is not inspired by anything that one could conceive to be national or honest. It is insincere. It is without backing. I am very glad to find that the amount of support of a sincere sort behind it is limited to probably a few men in Deputy MacDermot's Party. Even Cumann na nGaedheal Deputies, hard cases that they are—hardened in many respects—are not so shamefaced and are not such hypocrites as that they would even sponsor the motion. The Bill is a good Bill, and it is framed in the interests of the people who are most deserving of support in this State. I am sure the Deputies who support it will receive from the country the reward of people satisfied with work well done.

Comment on this

This matter has been debated at some length to-day and my contribution to this debate will not be made at any great length. But I do not wish on this Bill, which I consider to be a Bill of some importance, to content myself with merely a silent vote. I was very glad to hear a good deal of the speech of Deputy Ben Maguire, who has just sat down. I was very glad to hear a great deal of what was contained in that speech. I was very glad to hear the clear and frank admission on his part that the people of this country were suffering, and suffering at the present moment. I was very glad to hear an admission on his part that in country districts there is very great poverty. I was glad to hear that because I heard the Minister for Agriculture in this House urging the very opposite and taking the very opposite stand. I do sincerely hope that Deputy B. Maguire will not cease his efforts with his speech in this House but that he will go to the Executive Council and that he will press upon them the condition to which the small working farmer in this country has already been reduced and the still worse prospect that there is in front of him. I hope that the Deputy will keep hammering at the door of the Executive Council chamber until he manages to get his voice heard by that heretofore deaf body.

Now I turn to the actual proposal made by Deputy Dillon. The proposal is that there should be a deduction in the allowances made to the members of this House just as there is a taking away from the salaries of other persons. That appears to me to be a completely logical attitude to take up. I could not, for instance, say with Deputy Maguire: "Let everybody else when there is this economic war going on, when this country is called upon to suffer, let everybody else suffer except the members of the Dáil and Seanad."

Comment on this

Hear, hear!

Comment on this

I would not take up that attitude at all, and if I were going to support this Bill, as most certainly I am not, I would also support Deputy Dillon's motion. I cannot understand the strange sort of logic which animates the Front Bench of Fianna Fáil when they will vote for the Bill brought in by the Minister for Finance and at the same time vote against Deputy Dillon's motion. I cannot see their logic. I would like to hear it explained and I would like to know what the difference is. If a fulltime officer of the Gárda Síochána whose pay amounts to £360 a year has got to have a reduction in his pay, I do not follow in the slightest the logic which would say that the part-time Deputy in the Dáil is not to have any reduction. If logic governs—but of course it does not govern—those who direct the minds of the Executive Council I do not see how they could have any hesitation in accepting Deputy Dillon's motion. But unfortunately logic, like a great number of other things, has been flung to the winds.

Now I come to the Bill itself. I am going to oppose this Bill, and I am going to oppose the amendment, put forward by Deputy Dillon. I do not see that the present time, and in the present circumstances bad as the condition of affairs is, you are going to help this condition of affairs by this Bill. You are going to do positive harm. There are times, of course, when economy in the shape of reductions may be justified—always undesirable as it may be, there are times when economy may be justified. If you come to the conclusion that your country is taxed as highly as it can be taxed; and if you are making real economies everywhere, undoubtedly you can then impose reductions in order to avoid imposing new taxation. If that can be done by the cutting down of salaries, by all means that is right. But when you are absolutely careless as to whether you have reached the peak point of taxation that the country can bear, it is quite a different thing when you are willing in one year to fling upon the shoulders of the country an extra burden of taxation, when you are willing to collect money and waste it in the fashion it is being wasted now by a spendthrift administration in all directions, that administration has no right to be economical in one direction and in one direction only—that direction being at the expense of the servants of the State, admirable servants of the State I would add. You can spend in every direction you like. You do not care how much you increase this tax, that tax and the other tax. You are regardless of money. You fling the money which is the State's money, to the wind, you waste it and then you come along and say "Oh, yes, we will put on another £4,000,000 or £6,000,000 extra taxation on the country. That does not matter the slightest bit." The Government then comes along, and not in any genuine spirit of economy, but simply as a mere political move they say "we can be wasteful spendthrifts in every direction but one, and that is, where the money is very well invested and well paid out and from which we get a very admirable return at the present moment." The State is getting no better return for the money it is spending than it is getting from the money which it is paying to the Civil Service, to the officers and men of the National Army, and, above all things, in my humble judgment, from the money that it pays to the officers and Guards of the Gárda Síochána.

I would like very much to know if the representative body of the Gárda Síochána have been consulted about this Bill? They are entitled to be consulted. They have a right to be heard before the Executive Council. They have a legal right to have their representations brought before the Executive Council and considered before any alteration in their pay or allowances is made. I would like very much to know if they have been asked what their views are; and if the representations made in consequence of their asking—if there has been such asking—have been considered? I would like to know what these representations are. I would like to know if the legal right of the Gárda Síochána to have their representative body consulted before any alteration is made in their rate of pay has been carried out in this case?

I think this is the worst possible time in which you should attack the pay of the Gárda Síochána. They have a very difficult task and their task is not being made more easy from day to day. They are a perfectly magnificent, loyal body, magnificently loyal to the State. The ex-Minister for Justice, Deputy Geoghegan, paid them the highest tribute for the way in which they saw the General Election conducted. And, this now is the time in which you come to them and say "We are to make these reductions, we will appoint any number of new persons; we will have these new offices, these new posts, and we will fill them up with highly paid persons; we do not care how many new posts we create and how many new jobs we give away; we can be as wasteful and spendthrift in that direction as we like, but you men, tried and trusted men, are men to whom we can say ‘you must bear a reduction'." I do not intend to go through this measure section by section. It has been very carefully analysed already. It has been pointed out again and again that it gives the most dictatorial powers to the Minister for Finance, that it makes him an autocrat and that questions that should be decided by an impartial tribunal are going to be partially decided by one person interested in the matter. I ask the House to reject the Bill as being a thoroughly bad, unsound measure.

Comment on this

I rise to oppose this Bill and the amendment to the Bill. My reasons for opposing both the Bill and the amendment are similar. My reason for opposing the amendment is, however, slightly dissimilar in one respect from my reason for opposing the Bill. The amendment comes from the Centre Party and for that reason, on looking at it for the first time, I was inclined to suspect the soundness of the proposition which that amendment contained. As a matter of fact I suspect that this amendment has nothing whatever to do with economy. The amendment comes in reality I suppose from two Deputies of the Centre Party who would, I am inclined to think, not alone forgo £360 a year for attending in this House, but who would gladly pay £1,000 to come here and take up this political hobby of speech-making in the House, because it is in that light, I think, that the business of the House is looked upon by the Deputies in the Centre Party to whom I have referred. It is nothing more than a pastime to these Deputies. A pittance of £360 a year is nothing to the plutocratic front ranks of the Centre Party. My reason for opposing the Bill is, in general, that I am opposed to cuts in any branch of life in this State. Cuts in general should on principle be opposed. In this case there is no doubt whatever that the cuts are necessary. The condition of this country has been brought so low by the policy of the Government that the cuts are absolutely necessary. The Exchequer is empty and the Government is looking around exploring every source from which revenue can be derived. But that seems to me to be no reason why I, at least, should lend my support to the Government in putting through this Bill. In other words, why should any Deputy of the Cumann na nGaedheal Party register a vote which would help the Government to get out of a difficulty into which they walked with their eyes wide open?

The principle which underlies the Bill, we are told by the Minister for Finance, is the principle of economy. There would have been no necessity for this particular type of economy if the Executive Council had not lost a trade which was worth £30,000,000 a year to this country. If that trade were at present operating in this country as it should be operating, if it were operating 100 per cent., this Bill would never have come before the House. For that reason, I refuse by my vote to do anything which would help to take the present Government out of a quandary into which they walked with their eyes wide open.

Comment on this

The task of the Minister for Finance in any country is not a pleasant one at present. At no time, in fact, is the task of the Minister for Finance a pleasant one. And yet, listening to some Deputies to-day, one would imagine that the Minister for Finance had gone out with his heart in his work, striving to lower the standard of living everywhere throughout the country. I had hoped for once—and during the time it was possible for me to be in the House my hope was not realised—that there would be some attempt made in dealing with this Bill to analyse the general position and to show how, other than by a measure of this sort, we could at present equalise the burden we must all admit is pressing heavily upon the producing part of this community, and upon the community as a whole. Deputy Norton spoke about wage-slashing. I was in the House during a part of his speech, at any rate, and I do not think the Deputy made good that charge that there was wage-slashing. I heard from the other side of the House that we were running away from our election pledges and promises. Anybody who looks at the Bill will see that it is scrupulously constructed with the idea of trying, as far as it is at all possible, to carry out those pledges in the same spirit as we have attempted to carry out every other pledge that we gave to the people before the elections. A statement which I made at Rathmines— I am not quite certain whether I made it in reply to a question asked in the hall, but I think I did—was to the effect that the general policy of our Party, if we were returned to power would not be to seek economies on the lines on which our predecessors had sought them, namely, by a reduction in the social services, cutting the old age pensioners, and then seeking substantial sums by cutting the lower grades of the Civil Service. I said that if we were returned to power our policy would be to seek reductions in the ranks that could best afford to stand these reductions. I spoke of the higher salaries and, when asked to mention a figure, said that to my mind salaries below £300 or £400 were such that every penny of them was needed, and every penny of them was spent in the support of families, and in the purchase of the necessaries of life. If anybody cares to look through the Bill and study it, he will find that we have kept to that promise. No civil servant whose salary is under £300 has been touched by our cut, and I think that most of you will admit that £300 now has a greater purchasing capacity than it had when I made that promise. I have kept within the letter of the promise, and I have kept within the spirit of it. The Executive Council has kept within the spirit of it as far as they possibly could, taking into account all the facts of the situation. The scheme therefore running through the Bill is that civil servants' salaries of £300 and under are not to suffer any cut, because, as the Minister for Finance has pointed out, there was an automatic cut which operated from the beginning of this year. That cut resulted in an automatic reduction of those salaries. I think every Deputy here will admit that in cases of this sort we have to deal equitably with all branches of the public service. If a civil servant under £300 can show that he has suffered an automatic cut, due to the bonus system, since 1st January— and a civil servant whose salary is over £300 has that added to the proposed existing cut—and that he has suffered since 1st January of the present year as compared with his previous remuneration a cut of £70 or £80, he will undoubtedly feel that other public servants should, if they are to be dealt with on the same basis as himself, suffer a similar cut.

There is a proposed cut in the Guards. We tried to discriminate, and not impose any cut on the married Guard. The reason for this in the case of the Guards was that there was a definite understanding that if the cost of living figure fell below a certain margin the rates that were being paid at the time were not to be regarded as fixed. We felt that it would be unfair if the cuts that were being imposed in fact on the Civil Service were not similarly imposed on the other branches of the public service. In the case of the teachers—it is not necessary for me to deal with it in full— there is another factor which operates. The Minister for Finance may postpone dealing with it until we come to deal with the particular schedule in the Bill. The truth is that we spent a very considerable time in trying to work out conscientiously the policy of not cutting the lower salaries, and of imposing an equal reduction in all the services. When you come to examine the scheme in detail on the Committee Stage of the Bill you will be able to see how closely that has been worked out. The Minister for Finance to-day gave you certain figures and certain stages in the scale, pointing out how it worked. I think it is an unfair charge to say with respect to the cuts proposed in this Bill that we have ignored our election promises. Deputy Norton says that this is not the way to deal with the economic situation. It is surely not suggested that this Bill is proposed as a Bill to deal with the economic situation as a whole? The only way in which it touches the general economic situation is this, that there has been a reduction already of purchasing power in the community; it is a question not of reducing it further, but of equalising the burden of that reduction. We are here imposing on the servants of the State certain reductions, because we believe that—when we compare the position of the primary producer to-day with his position some years ago—the reduction which the servants of the State will suffer in their salaries does not at all put them in a relatively worse position in relation to the primary producer than they were in some years ago.

It has been suggested by Deputies on the opposite benches—a most unfair suggestion—that this Bill has been prompted by some sort of animus against the servants of the State. There is no truth whatever in that suggestion. It is suggested that there is uneasiness and insecurity in the ranks of the public servants. I think that—in a year at the beginning of which there was perhaps a greater change than you could point to in any democratic assembly; a greater change, when you have regard to all the circumstances, than you would possibly be able to point to in history —the servants of the State have been dealt with fairly by the present Government. One of the Deputies went out of his way to drag in a case which has been in the courts recently. What was the Executive Council to do? Was the Government to stand by and see State files and secret documents handed out, even if it was for the purpose of writing a book? What right had any State servant to give out secret documents? Were we to sit idly by and allow it to be thought in the service that State servants could deal in that manner with confidential documents? There were two matters concerned. On the one hand there was a breach of Statute; that was tried in the courts. There was also a question of breach of regulations; that is a matter of discipline. Our attitude towards the Civil Service has been one of full recognition of their worth, but we are determined that there will be discipline. No servant who does his work honourably and loyally has anything to fear from this Executive Council, but we are not going to stand for indiscipline anywhere. If that is to be taken as indicative of any unfair attitude towards the Civil Service I want to know what is the proper attitude. There would have been those cuts in salaries—and on a very different system, I contend— if the previous Government were in office. The amount that is coming into the Treasury is no insignificant amount, and we hold that that sum is coming into the Treasury in the best way, and from the section which at the moment can best bear it. I have had experience during a year now of the work that is done by the higher servants of the State. I know how devoted they are to their work, and what long hours they spend at it, but I do want to say that if they do hard work and spend long hours at it, so also do the members of the Executive Council. I think it is most unfair to suggest that what Ministers do is lock up their offices at 5 o'clock, go away with easy minds, and leave all the business and all the worry to the permanent officials. There is no truth what ever in that, and the members on the opposite benches know there is no truth in it. The ultimate responsibility for decisions, and the ultimate responsibility for seeing that the work is done in his Department, rests with the Minister, and whilst it is true that he alone—any more than any man at the head of any organisation—could not do that work unless he had loyal and faithful assistants, it is, at the same time, true that it is not the assistants who do all the work.

It is the Ministers who have the final responsibility. They cannot divest themselves of it. Our experience has been that Ministers are certainly loyally and faithfully helped, and that every assistance which it is reasonable to expect from the permanent officials with whom they come in contact is given to them. I think it was Deputy Mulcahy who suggested that it was only the Minister for Finance who would be hard-hearted enough to stand up here and defend this Bill: that other members of the Executive Council had such experience of the chief civil servants who are working with them that they would not have the heart, so to speak, to stand up here and propose cuts in the salaries of those individual servants. I think it is true to say that the Minister for Finance is served as loyally in his Department as any other Minister and it can be no harder on any of us to propose a cut in the salaries of these officials whose work we know than it is on the Minister himself. I can say more, that the Minister for Finance has been the stoutest defender, when these matters were discussed in detail, of the branches of the service that he is legally the head of. Therefore, I think it is most unfair to suggest that his attitude towards the Civil Service is different from that of any other member of the Executive Council.

As I said this morning, I do not think there is much in the general principle if we keep really to the Bill and do not wander off to the civil war or to the present economic war. If we were to take these debates up again we could spend a considerable time at them. If we wanted to we could point out that while people talk of the loss the community is suffering at the present time, these same people did not talk of the loss to the country when it was paying out millions per annum, paid too by this same community. When the members on the opposite benches talk about cuts imposed they did not hesitate to impose more drastic cuts on a section of the community which was less able to afford it than the section which we are now proposing to cut.

With regard to the amendment, I think I can understand why it was proposed—from the point of view of putting the members of this House, if you like, in a moral position to impose cuts on others by accepting cuts themselves. Most of us, I think, will appreciate that there is something in that point of view. I do, at any rate. But when we come down and deal with it as a practical proposition we must remember that this matter has been dealt with in this House on several occasions already, when it was pointed out that this was the smallest sum—in fact that it was inadequate—which could be fixed. From such examination as I have made myself of the allowance, I think that better public service could be rendered by the Deputies if they had an increased allowance. If we were dealing with anything like normal conditions I would say that the allowance, considering the work that is expected from a Deputy, was not sufficient to enable him to do that work properly. I think it was the Lord Mayor of Dublin who interjected a remark the point of which should be obvious. He asked about the two homes that Deputies who come up from the country have to keep, and of the double expense. There is also a question of principle: that it should be possible for a Deputy to come here, to give up whatever business he has and to devote his whole time to his public work. It is not fair to say that a Deputy should be paid only for the time he is actually sitting here in the House.

Comment on this

Hear, hear.

Comment on this

That is not right, because if he is to do his work it means a good deal more than attending here when the Dáil is sitting. To be fair and to get good service you must make a sum available which will enable the representative of any section of the community to give his whole time—if he is to do it well—to the work to be done here. I think this allowance was fixed on, first of all, by a Joint Committee in 1922. Later, in 1923, there was a further examination of it, and again in 1927. In 1930, when Deputy Thrift made a proposal for the reduction of the allowance to Senators, there was a further examination. Reports were submitted to the House on the results of these examinations. After the most thorough examination it was found that the sum which was made available in allowances for the Deputies and Senators was not unreasonable at any rate, and any suggestion that was made for a reduction was rejected. That being so, why should the Government take upon itself, having had recent decisions on the matter, to reduce these allowances which all of us, from experience, believe are certainly not excessive but rather inadequate?

Comment on this

Does that remark of the President apply to the Seanad also?

Comment on this

With regard to reductions in the Oireachtas, I have always taken the point of view that the best way to get economies in the Oireachtas was to reduce the numbers to a reasonable amount. When in Opposition I suggested that about 120 members would give adequate representation in the Dáil. I saw there was no chance of a reduction in the other direction and suggested, therefore, that the reduction should be by numbers. In the case of the Seanad our view again is that if a representative of the people is to do his work and be available at all times, you cannot fix his remuneration by the length of time he is occupied in the Seanad. I am not going to pretend that the Senators do as much work as the members of the Dáil, not for one moment. Again, there is a minimum amount which would enable a representative of the people to give up his work, if necessary, and to devote himself to representing and working for the public interest. There is a certain minimum sum, and I for one would hesitate to cut that below the figure which I believe to be needful in the case of Deputies. I would hesitate to cut it down for anybody unless we were going by that fact to be prepared to see the representation fall into the hands of people who, out of their own private means, could take on the task of public representation.

With regard to the Seanad I have always held that, if we did have a second House here, we could reduce the number practically to one-half the number of the present House. During the elections, I indicated that it was our intention to abolish the Seanad as at present constituted. The question of whether or not we should have a second Chamber at all, to my mind, rests on this: whether a suitable second Chamber can be devised, a second Chamber that will have really valuable functions. I have an open mind on that matter myself. I have sought for solutions in various directions, and I have to confess that up to the present time I have not been able to get any form of second House that would warrant its being there, and warrant the expense that would be involved. If, however, we are able, within the course of a year or so, to devise a Constitution for a second Legislative Chamber which would warrant our proposing it instead of the present one, then, we may, instead of bringing in a Bill to abolish completely the second House, propose to bring in a Bill to establish such a second House with a constitution of the character which I have indicated, namely, which would give it some really useful functions. That being the position with regard to the Seanad, and it being our intention anyhow to bring in a Bill very soon to avoid the filling of about 20 vacancies which are due to come about, I think, next year or so—with that in mind, and also with the idea that there was a certain minimum limit beyond which we could not go, we felt we would not be justified in bringing in either the members of the Dáil or members of the Seanad under this Bill. However, I think the attitude of the Executive Council can be stated to be this—that if private members here in the Dáil bring forward a resolution or an amendment, when this Bill comes for the reduction of these amounts, we, as a Government, anyhow, will not oppose it. We will leave it here open to the private members to bring forward if they wish to put themselves in the position of which Deputy MacDermot speaks, that is, in the position of not appearing to cut others without suffering a cut themselves. We are prepared to consider such a proposal. We have no closed mind, at any rate, with regard to such a proposal. Personally, if it were an open vote, I would oppose it on the grounds I have indicated. But, for one, I can understand the attitude of mind which, possibly, could reasonably prompt such a proposal.

As I have said then, with regard to this Bill as a whole, we feel that the Exchequer needs this sum of money. We cannot have our social services; we cannot expand in the directions in which we need to expand unless we have money. We must economise where we can in order to expand. We are engaged deliberately in a process of expansion in certain directions, and we know that we cannot expand in these directions without employing further servants of the State. But we are anxious to see that no servant of the State will get a greater salary than the community can afford. We are anxious to see a certain levelling or equalising of the burdens if you wish. This money is necessary. The Minister for Finance finds it necessary. It has to come from somewhere. We are not going to save by restricting our social services. We cannot produce it that way. The question of increasing the burdens on the taxpayer is one on which everybody, who knows the effect that would have on further production and further employment, must hesitate. I put it to those Deputies who are inclined to disagree with this policy that, if they were in our position and had the task which the Minister for Finance has at the moment and had to find the money, the way we propose to find it is a better way than any that has been put forward in this House.

I do not think that the Executive Council need excuse itself in regard to this Bill. I have said that it is not intended to depress wages and I do not think that it will have that effect. It is not intended to depress the standard of living all round. It is intended to try to equalise the burdens which every section of the community must be prepared to bear if we are to deal properly with the present situation. If I would not be going too far, perhaps, outside the proper scope of a speech on this occasion, I should like to say that the present situation is a really serious one. It is recognised as being serious in other countries. It is particularly serious in our country from the point of view that so much of our production is from agriculture. We have unemployed in the streets. We have a duty to those unemployed. We have got to try to perform that duty by getting work for them.

I had a letter a short time ago from a friend who is a professional man and who was in receipt of a fixed salary of about £900 a year. He complained of the income-tax. He said that he was trying to rear a fairly large family, that he was now of a fairly matured or advanced age—50 or 60 years of age or over—that he could not afford a motor car, that he was not able to take any holidays. The only way he took any recreation was by working in his garden. He went on to say that in the past he had supported our Party but that he was doubtful, seeing the burden which was imposed on him by income-tax, if he could support us any longer.

I replied telling him that we were very sorry we had to tax earned incomes, that we were very sorry he could not have more out of life, more of the enjoyments, and more holidays than he appeared to be able to have. I told him also that there were people in the streets who have not got their daily bread. What about them? There are people whose homes are cheerless, who have not got fires. There are families living in single rooms for which they are paying exorbitant rents, and in which the ordinary decencies of life cannot be observed. I also said to him: "Do you not think their cases much harder than yours, and that the Government is justified in taking from you something which is not absolutely essential for you, but which is absolutely essential for them?"

That is the policy behind the whole of our administration. It is a difficult task. We have never made light of it. We believe that we are making headway with that policy. We believe that there would be a substantial reduction of unemployment to-day, if we had circumstances such as there were in the past, when the unemployment difficulty was relieved by emigration. Remember that we have now every year to provide for some 20,000 or 30,000 young people who are coming into employment. We relieve unemployment, so to speak, at one end of the scale, and make headway with it, but the problem is increased at the other end. Any reasonable Deputy who takes the position as a whole, if he wants to be fair, must put himself in the position of the Executive Council and of the Minister for Finance, who has got to make ends meet, and who has to consider where the necessary moneys which he deems absolutely necessary for certain services can be got, by imposing the least possible hardship. That is the spirit in which this measure is conceived. The idea is to get the necessary moneys from a section of the community with the least possible hardship.

I think Deputies on this side have been just as generous in their praise of the work being done by public servants as Deputies on the opposite side. It is a fact which civil servants themselves must recognise, that the purchasing power of their salaries is greater to-day than it was some years ago, and that they can afford at the present time, better than other sections of the community, to bear this part of the burden. No matter what may be said by others, I believe that there was a very proper idea behind the Deputy's amendment. At least, I think we ought to try to look for the best interpretation of what we find. Just as there was in my opinion a proper idea behind that, namely, that we should not be imposing upon others cuts that we do not impose upon ourselves, so I think that public servants who are paid by the producing part of the community ought not to be unwilling to bear a part of the burden which, willy nilly, the producing portion of the community are forced to bear in present conditions. The cuts are for one year only. The intention of the Minister was to show that we did not, in principle, regard the sums paid as in themselves extravagant, but that in present conditions, and in the circumstances in which we find ourselves, it was the duty of a section to bear that part. If we want to succeed and improve the standard of the community as a whole, we must be prepared to bear this burden. If we are to solve unemployment and other social problems we must be prepared to bear even greater burdens than these. If we do not, then we are going to have the position that certain sections of the community are to be, so to speak, outlawed; that they are not going to be allowed to exercise the God-given right to live. I hold that they have a right to live. I think it is necessary for the community as a whole to bear such a burden as will enable these people to be given the opportunity of living.

It is a big question. There is a big question of organisation behind it. I am not one of those who believe that it can be done by some sudden change in monetary policy. To my mind, there is a big question of organisation. You want the will on the part of the community as a whole, the part of the community that have to share with those who have not; in other words, to share the burden in order that those who have not may be enabled to live. In the first place, you want that will. After you have got that will then, in the second place, you want organisation of the community, so that the exchange of services between one section and another may be effected. It is fundamentally a question of organisation, and the attitude on the part of those who have in the community to part with a share of what is theirs, in order that those who have not may be enabled to live. Without these two things, I do not think there is any way of solving the problem. In this instance we are asking the public servants to do their part, just as when we tax income we ask the people to do their part. We are asking the public servants to do their part now. I, for one, believe they will. I believe that all the efforts that have been made on the opposite benches to urge them into unrest will be in vain. I do not think the higher members of the Civil Service have not the intelligence to realise that Bills like this are necessary, and that the sacrifices they are asked to bear are the type of sacrifices that every other section of the community will be compelled to bear if we are really going to solve this problem of unemployment. At any rate, we intend to do our best. We are prepared to be judged, even by this measure, in the direction in which we are going. We deny, as has been suggested, that this is a retrograde measure. We deny that we are departing from the path we have laid out for ourselves, or that we indicated to the electors we would take. We hold that this Bill is strictly in consonance with the whole idea, and the whole philosophy behind our policy, and it it as such that I support the Minister for Finance in asking the House to accept it.

Comment on this

This House is at the moment discussing an amendment in the name of Deputy Dillon in relation to the Public Services (Temporary Economies) Bill, 1933:

That the Dáil declines to give a Second Reading to the Public Services (Temporary Economies) Bill, 1933, until provision is included therein for the reduction of allowances payable to Deputies and Senators.

I speak on that amendment under the disadvantage of not having heard what case was made for it by the mover. I want to state here, irrespective of what case was made about it in this House, that when I first saw it I placed it in mind in the envelope of statements made by Deputy MacDermot, and more recently by Deputy Dillon, throughout the country. It may be that these statements have not been fully given, but as given they conveyed to me this idea, that one of these Deputies always, and the second Deputy more recently, held the opinion that the salaries or allowances paid to members of the House are more than adequate for the services rendered. May I say this with all respect to the Deputies, that if that were the idea coming from both, but more particularly from Deputy MacDermot, it would have to be criticised as not being merely snobbery but the height of vulgarity, because be it for good or ill, Deputy MacDermot has certainly appeared before this country as a man in the enjoyment of certain wealth. I have got to stress that, because if such an amendment as this, to reduce the salaries of Deputies, had come from a person who was notably the other way, then I think the same odium would not attach to that particular amendment. It may be that is a wrong interpretation of this amendment. I hope it is.

Secondly, if the amendment means— I have been trying to discover for myself what it does mean — that although these two Deputies do not believe that the salaries paid to members are more than adequate for the duties they fulfil, nevertheless they think that they should be cut and that after these cuts are made, the cuts in the salaries of members of the Civil Service should follow, then I am totally in disagreement and will oppose the amendment as I oppose the Bill. It may mean that the Deputy had these things in mind, or that he felt that before people in this House could talk with a clear conscience about cuts for others they would have to arrange for cuts for Deputies. There is something to be said for that. There is no doubt, as standing on the Order Paper, the amendment is subject to either of the misconceptions to which I have referred, and at any rate, it does convey conditional assent to the cutting of salaries on the case made here to-day.

What is the case made here to-day? Before I leave that, because of the misconceptions that may arise in regard to the amendment, because of the fact that I do not want to approve of what has been said in regard to cuts of salaries at all, even if the third explanation be correct.

Comment on this

Would Deputy McGilligan allow me to intervene just to say this definitely once and for all? It has come up many times in debate here. I have never said, and so far as I am aware Deputy Dillon has never said, and I had never intended to say to-day, or at any subsequent date that this subject might be discussed, that the allowances paid to Deputies in the Dáil were unreasonably high.

Comment on this

Very good, that is something gained in this debate. I want to accept fully what the Deputy has stated now though his remarks have been subject to the other reading. His speeches throughout the country have been subject to the other reading.

Comment on this

Not as delivered by me.

Comment on this

As reported. We have got to take what is reported. The President said to-night with regard to this measure that the Bill has been scrupulously drawn to carry out the promises made with regard to public service. I want to found anything I have got to say on that, that the Bill has been scrupulously drawn with regard to the promises made. What is it really? The old cliché is the best to describe it, the butchering of the public services to make a Roman holiday. It is distinctly that. There was the old Roman idea of bread and the games. The modern equivalent is seized upon by the acute political mind of the President—free milk and a round with England. But who is suffering from the round with England? At any rate, the Romans had that saving grace, that the games were the subject of edification to the mob and lulled them over their disappointment. At the moment the arena is packed with people who are suffering, who have been thrown to the lions, and the President displays very much the same amazement when even people in the front line trenches turn to him and complain, as the Emperor Nero might have shown if the people intended for the lions complained that they could not sleep because of the roaring of the lions nearby in the arena. This is butchering the public services for political purposes.

"Scrupulously upholding all our promises," says the President. I am going again to recount some of these. The President to-night went over a lot of ground and there is hardly a point he touched upon that I did not find in some cutting of a newspaper, containing a speech of some member of his Party, as if they foresaw all the excuses that might be made on an occasion like this and had previously countered them. Emigration was dealt with. Deputy Boland, now a Minister, was going to reduce the Army and the Civic Guard to such a point that while they could be given other means of employment, money was to be saved and the tide of emigration was to be stopped. Yet that is one of the excuses the President makes to-night. Apparently his Minister has succeeded in stopping the tide of emigration. I wonder is that the case, that he has got to deal with these large numbers now in this country? Let us take these promises as being meant in the old days. I do not think it is fair or proper for the political future of this country that these promises should be cynically thrown aside and laughed at now. Very distinct promises were made and there are some of the promises which would help Deputy Dillon's amendment.

One personal point has been introduced here to-night. I am glad it was introduced to get the matter cleared up. It is in relation to members of the late Executive Council and the present Government and the difference between the emoluments that both groups enjoy. There seems to be a certain amount of passion aroused by a statement of literal truth, that certain accommodation in the way of motor cars now provided is provided distinctly as a perquisite of office, when previously it was not. Why be angry when that is said? There was considerable anger in the House to-night when that was said. I personally never had a motor car supplied to me at the public expense until after the murder of Kevin O'Higgins and it was then forced on me. I objected that I thought I was in no danger and that I did not require this car. It seemed to me to be judicrous that when I went round the country in my own motor car I should be followed at the public expense by the guard that was put on me. I pointed that out but those who were responsible for the preservation of order in the country insisted and so the guard came on. May I say that since I have left office I have been subjected to an in-and-out treatment that I do not think capable of explanation? The same guard was left with me for some period and then I was asked did I think it should be removed, as if I were responsible or had the information to make the decision and then it was removed. Then I had a policeman put to guard me. A fortnight later I had two policemen put to guard me and about three weeks later I had a third policeman put on. A little later I was asked never to travel in my own car or the car of anybody else unless I took two of these people with me. Then, round about the time of the dissolution, I was given a car again. I think it was a police car for the first two or three days and then I was given a military car and the old military guard. About a week after the election was over I was returned again to my lonely policeman.

Comment on this
Mr. Kelly

They knew you were found of a change.

Comment on this

Apparently, but I had not the means of knowing whether the change was necessary or not.

Comment on this
Mr. Kelly

Perhaps it was wholesome.

Comment on this

From what I have seen recently of the people in charge of that branch of the Service, I should not rely too much upon their judgment as to whether that change is necessary or is a proper one to make. But let us face the fact that in the old days—between 1923 and 1924, which was the period of my first experience of Government—and up to the murder of Kevin O'Higgins, there was no car as a perquisite of office. It was never so regarded. It is now so regarded and if it is an addition to the salaries which the Ministers thought fit to grant themselves, I do not regard it as too much to give them. But I do not think it should be camouflaged. The President has said, with regard to the Civil Service salaries, that the purchasing power of the civil servant is now greater than it used to be. And he is scrupulously honest with regard to his promises. What was the promise with regard to those who were to be at the head of the State? A thousand pounds a year salary. There was no question of freedom from income tax, but let that pass. How about that £1,000 and its purchasing power in the days when it was talked of as the highest salary of which those at the head of the State were worthy. Has it increased? Deputy Dillon has his point there. Has the £360 which members get as an allowance increased in purchasing power? If the argument of increased purchasing power is applicable to the civil servant, why is it not applicable to all the members of this House, whether members of the Government or not?

Comment on this

Hear, hear! That is just what I said.

Comment on this

Speaking at Athy, in 1932, the President said that the then President of the Executive Council had a salary of £2,500 and Ministers a salary of £1,700 and that "these will have to come down by half." Have they? Deputy Lemass, as he was then, speaking at Dundalk, in 1927, said: "No person in the State would receive more than £1,000 a year." Have the Government recently given salaries of more than £1,000 a year? He said: "They might give that £1,000 to the President, if he would take it, on account of the dignity of his office." Why the change? The President said in 1926—and this is a point for Deputy Dillon, again: "£300 should be sufficient for a public representative. That amount would enable him to bring up his children in Dublin in a proper manner." That meant what £300 of purchasing power amounted to in 1926.

Comment on this

Blackrock.

Comment on this

It was said that we would not need to reduce our salaries; economies were to be possible in other ways. "Substantial economies are possible." This was a serious promise set out in a manifesto—"Fianna Fáil is satisfied that substantial economies are possible without reducing social services, inflicting hardship on any class of Government servants or impairing in the slightest degree the efficiency of the administrative machine." There followed then the famous comment—or, at least, the comment I hope I have made famous by repetition—that having examined with precise care the Estimates, they were convinced that a saving of not less than two million pounds was possible. Does the President think that anybody reading that sentence when it was placarded around the country in 1932 would have thought that the phrase about substantial economies being possible without inflicting hardship on any class of Government servants meant this Bill? Is there a quibble—that, of course, the civil servants and the other people mentioned can suffer these cuts without incurring hardship? Would the President have written in those days, if he had been asked to be quite honest and frank in the matter, "Fianna Fáil is satisfied we can impose cuts of the type mentioned here and they will not inflict hardship on the services mentioned." He might have wanted to do that, but his propagandists would not have allowed him in those days. That was the promise and it is not to be laughed at. That is one of the considerations on account of which the Government holds office. We were to be brought into a promised land where wasteful administration was to be cut off. A great deal was made of the "wasteful administration." It was all summed up in that statement that not less than two million a year could be saved. That other phrase I alluded to was put in because the President knew well that his campaign of a previous period about salaries was going to lead to the conclusion in certain minds that cuts were intended, cuts in the Civil Service and in the services of the local authorities. The phrase I mentioned was put in to prevent that idea spreading and it succeeded. There were specific means pointed out for economies. At Galway, the President said that "the police forces in the country, which cost one and a half million pounds, could be decreased by one-half." It costs at this moment £1,600,000 and this is the second year of the administration. At that time, it could be reduced by one-half. That was part of the way people were fooled. Deputy Cooney was even more precise. He said that "their administrative programme included a saving of two million pounds on the Army." I do not think that the Army cost that amount in those days, but let that pass. "The £500,000 saving on the Civic Guard, with other savings that could be effected on overpaid Departments, would be put into productive industries. They came to the conclusion that they could solve the unemployment problem in 12 months."

Comment on this

Six.

Comment on this

It was 12 at that time. The "ante" was raised later and they had to reduce it. Speaking at Rathmines, in May, 1932, the President said that they were not going to start on the lower salaries.

"With regard to the salaries between £300 and £400 I hold that those in receipt of them are getting nothing excessive."

Then, we have this leading article in the Independent of May 28th.

"The immunity was promised not merely to the lower grades, but to the middle grades of the Civil Service."

"We do not," said the President, "propose to seek economies by restricting the social services or cutting the salaries of the middle or lower grades of the Civil Service." Yet, we are told to-night that this Bill is scrupulously drawn with regard to these promises. There are other things that we were promised—increases in the social services. There was going to be a revision of the unemployment and national health insurance schemes so that the full benefits would go to those insured—the workers—but they are now cast aside in favour of cuts.

The President has paid a tribute to-night to these civil servants whose salaries he proposes to cut, amongst others. He pays that tribute to them in a peculiar way. "They are certainly hard working," and, then, as if anybody had commented on it in any serious way, he adds: "So do the Executive Council," and, then, we are told that the Executive Council do not lock up at six o'clock and go away with easy minds and come back at a certain hour in the morning. "The Ministers have the final responsibility"—that was the case in our time. It was definitely the case in our time. The President well knows that members of his Front Bench and of his back benches went about the country declaiming that Ministers were living on the fat of the land and not working. Now, the situation is changed. They work, while he admits the Civil Service do also. Then he says: "This is only for a year." The Minister for Finance has emphasised that the cuts proposed are only for a year in respect of salaries earned and paid in the coming financial year, but he did not say that, if the financial position did not improve, it would not be imperative to deal with these salaries in another year. The President, at the end thinks that "despite the attempts made"—I suppose from these quarters—"to cause discontent, the Civil Service will do their part," the Minister for Finance, in introducing this Bill, to-day, said that the proposal to reduce salaries had been referred to in the Budget statement last year. How? There was going to be an endeavour to get, by agreement during the year, certain cuts. Then, he said that he found this year it had not been possible to get that agreement, and hence these cuts were being imposed, and the President is optimistic that the Civil Service are going to bear these cuts with equanimity. His Finance Minister told him last year that he would try to get agreement about these cuts and confesses this year that he failed to get them.

What was the President's optimism based upon? They felt that the Civil Service would realise that their salaries could not continue when the country was in an impoverished state, and I think that was a good analysis of the Civil Service mind. We certainly felt in our time that it was being borne in on the Civil Service that, if a certain depression went on, they could not continue at a particular rate. I wonder why has the change occurred? Surely it is the same change of feeling that is in most people of the country who are suffering—that they do not believe that the suffering is necessary; that they are not convinced of the justice of the treatment that is being meted out to them and that they can see no hope, that after these imposed sacrifices have been made, there is any better prospect a year, three years or five years hence than there is now.

Civil servants are like most other people in this community. They do not deny what the President, in one of his attempts to cloud the position to-night, referred to as "the God-given right of the people of this country to live." Civil servants, in the main, spring from the small farming community in this country and they know as well as the President what the economic situation of that class of the community is and they know what they are suffering at the moment. Most of them have, near and around, in their family circle or their circle of relations, people who sometimes feel that the God-given right to live is being denied to them, and they are as easily able to be touched by that phrase as anybody else, but they are not going to be touched by that phrase as used by the President because they feel that whatever was the God-given right to live in this country, it has been somewhat jeopardised by the policy of the present Government.

"The economic war is not an issue," the President said, to-night. It is at the root of this Bill. We are going to save how much? Last year, it was said to be £250,000 and this year, because the scope has been somewhat widened, it is said to bring in a maximum of £280,000. It has been pointed out that that is only the equivalent of the loss of one week from the present economic war. Rate, with as much importance as can possibly be given to it, the world-wide depression and add to it the 20 per cent., 30 per cent. or 40 per cent. the folly with England has caused us, and you will get from that 20 per cent., 30 per cent. or 40 per cent. more than the £280,000 that this slaughtering of the public services is going to get you. I had thought that we were faced with a very bright prospect once the Government came into power and got their economic policy on foot. I have alluded to what the then Deputy Boland had said in relation to emigration. Does the President not remember Deputy Lemass's, as he then was, forecast of what was going to follow from their economic policy? There would not be enough idle hands in the country to do all the work that was to be done. We would have to call back some of those emigrating; not merely would we stop the tide from flowing out, but we would have to call back some of those who had gone out. The President, not to be outdone by that statement, responded with a statement that the country could support seventeen millions of people.

We have had a year of this policy in regard to unemployment. The President, on one occasion, stung by a certain comparison that was made with the unemployment that was elsewhere, said that it was forgotten by the people, who, as he said, made propagandist use of depression in other countries, that this country had in its hands a remedy against unemployment that no other country had, and we presume the remedy has been found and that we are getting the full benefits of it. We have this declaration—it is ludicrous to bring it into a debate of a serious nature—but it was promised; it was dangled before the eyes of the people and it was what misled certain people. It was part of the consideration for holding office:—

Protection of industries means more money in Ireland. Money in Ireland means more employment. Employment means more buyers. Buyers mean more buying of Irish goods. Buying Irish goods means more money in Ireland. More and more and more money—why should it ever stop?

We have had a year of that rolling around of money in this country, and we have had the full benefit of the retention in this country of the moneys that used to go to England, and we have had our protection policy going, and we have had bounties for the main agricultural industry and, at the end of it all, we hoist the white flag—cuts.

Cuts! And over what a range do the cuts extend! Everybody has got to feel what sacrifice means, but I think most people would agree to the sacrifice if they could see what was the end of the sacrifice. If there were people who were being denied the God-given right to live, and who are now being denied in increasing numbers that God-given right to live, surely common honesty demands that instead of continuing the impoverishment and spreading it more widely, there should be a halt to get the plan exposed which is in operation, but which nobody seems to know anything about —the plan which is guiding the fortunes of this country, the plan which is going to give us happiness some years ahead. If that could be proved, and if it could be shown that after some years of sacrifice there was a prospect of better times, this country would do willingly what people like the Russians are being forced to do under stern necessity and compulsion.

The reason why there is aggravation over these cuts and over the suffering that is being caused is because nobody believes that there is a principle at the back of the whole thing; nobody believes that there is any thought-out, deliberate plan; nobody believes that anybody has thought out what the old economy was and what the new economy is to be, what the steps for the change-over are, how long they are likely to take and what the new situation afterwards will be. It seems somewhat ludicrous to be introducing these things into a debate of this sort, but they were paraded to the people. There was something of the old idea of the fortunes told at the country fairs. Fortunes were told for everybody. These things are about as good as the prophecies that were made around these fairs. We did get these prophecies. We were told about all the unemployed who were to be gathered into employment, all the emigrants who were to be called back to get work in this country, all the taxes and all the rates that were to be lowered and the better security for everybody. There was a precise promise that whatever economy was decided on it would not be such as would either reduce social services or inflict any hardships on any class of Government servants.

I took it from the Minister for Finance's speech to-day that the two million promised saving has been definitely abandoned, but I want him to say that. He finds himself in the dilemma that he must either increase his revenue, and he says that is only possible by increasing taxation, or else he must reduce expenditure. He said that preliminary estimates of revenue which were being prepared indicated that they might anticipate a substantial decline of revenue, but on the other hand there would not be such a decline in expenditure. That comes from the man who had promised two millions of a decline. And then he gives as an excuse that such a decline in expenditure could only have been secured at the cost of social services. It could be achieved, he said, by reducing social services. What is the correct position? Are we going to have a definite confession that former declarations were all nonsense, a complete sham and humbug?

We are told now that the Minister, after being a year in office, is convinced that a decline in expenditure could only be secured at the cost of social services. He designed the policy of the Government to secure economies in that way. Then he found himself in this fearful dilemma. If revenue was going to decline and if expenditure could not be reduced he had only the choice of two ways in which the deficiency might be met—by additional taxation or by reducing the expenditure in the remuneration of public servants. Everybody else knew, except the people who deluded themselves into writing that and the fools who believed it when it was written, that you could not get a £2,000,000 reduction in expenditure. We must not forget the promise that they would not reduce social services or inflict hardships on any class of Government servants.

We have got the truth in a halting way now. The Minister for Finance makes a certain statement by reason of an office which he holds by false pretences. If he said previously that the saving could only be got by reducing social services would be have been able to stand the criticisms that such a statement would have evoked? Was it his policy to reduce the social services and, if not, will he indicate where the £2,000,000 saving was to come from? That was no mere promise held out, because we have it definitely that Fianna Fáil had examined with minute care the Estimates of supply services for the current year and they were convinced that a saving of many hundreds could be made, not including such items as a sum of £1,152,000 paid in respect of R.I.C. pensions, and other similar payments not required by the Treaty. Then there was the final flourish: "The burden of taxation could be lightened by not less than £2,000,000 per year." After a minute examination and after a still more minute examination, we are now told by the Minister for Finance, who was probably behind the advertisement and got office on the foot of it, that he is in the dilemma that he must reduce social services if he is going to get any decline in expenditure, and his only alternative is £280,000 through these widespread cuts on public services of different types.

The President bases the justice of the reduction on this—he compares the position of the civil servant with the position of the primary producer. Will he take the sum that is to be saved, will be take whatever the world depression is and its effect on this country, will be take the extra amount of loss caused by reason of the trouble with England and say to the civil servants: "We could have refrained from saving £280,000 in this way if it were not for the trouble with England; even an economic depression would not have made it necessary; but the economic depression, plus that other folly, has made this necessary, and then put it to the civil servants clearly and bluntly that they have got to pay because he has called a certain tune, called it, as he admitted in this House, with the knowledge that there is going to be trouble over it, and continues to call it with no statement to this House that is of any assurance to it that he thinks the trouble is going to end satisfactorily for this country?

We just have a statement from the Minister for Finance, a warning that, although the cuts amounting to £280,000 are phrased to be for this year only, there has got to be the definite apprehension that these salaries may fall to be dealt with next year if the situation does not improve. The President has an easy way out of his dilemma with regard to Deputy Dillon's amendment. If a Private Deputy's Bill is sent down to cut the salaries of some of those who want salaries cut—and I hope it would have the backing of some one person from the Fianna Fáil Benches —he will allow a free vote on it. He will vote against it himself. I suggest a better way. Let us take some critical division in this House, say on the Budget, and have agreement before that division is taken that anybody who votes in a particular lobby for the imposition of taxation on this community is taken as agreeing to a 5 per cent. cut in his salary. That will be something of a free vote. I wonder how the back bench opposite would face up to it.

Comment on this

Wait until it comes and then we will see.

Comment on this

It will never come and that is why you are so happy about it.

Comment on this

Why talk about it any more then, as you say it will not come?

Comment on this

Neither will the Private Deputy's Bill that the President talked about. Why did he talk about it? It is just for the same reason. Deputy Kelly would not welcome such a Bill, certainly. The Minister has told us with regard to the small item in this measure that the savings are not going to fall into the general Exchequer. In the case of the Agricultural Credit Corporation the savings are going to go towards the building up of a reserve for contingencies. Would the President say how much is to be saved by the cuts imposed on the officials of the Agricultural Credit Corporation and is it going to be a significant amount?

Comment on this

I could not say right off. In principle it is.

Comment on this

But the principle will not build up much of a saving for contingencies. In the case of the Electricity Supply Board it might be desirable that the deductions, in so far as it can be done, should be passed on to the general body of consumers. What deductions are we to get in the case of our bills by this saving? Is that a significant sum? Will the savings made in the salary cuts upon the officials of the Electricity Supply Board equate the extraordinary expenditure which they have been forced to incur by reason of the tariff on British coal alone? We were told by the Minister for Industry and Commerce that coal of equally good quality could be got elsewhere. We have two sets of evidence against the assumption of Ministers. The railway companies have told us that they tried one type of foreign coal and that, as it was useless, they abandoned it. I presume they abandoned it with the concurrence of the Minister for Industry and Commerce. The chairman of the company said that as a result of using that foreign coal some of their locomotives had to be laid up for repairs.

Comment on this

He was misinformed.

Comment on this

I am sure he was misinformed if he said anything contrary to the Minister's policy. But this thing the chairman of the company said—that the Government proposed to grant allowances to them and that they could import a certain amount of their coal duty free. In the last couple of days we had a meeting of the Alliance and Dublin Gas Consumers' Company. I presume they, too, were misinformed by their expert. They have also stated that they did not find that the substituted coal which they had been using was of any great value for their purposes.

Can we get at any stage what expense the E.S.B. had to incur by reason of this tax on coal? Have they also been allowed to import a certain amount of coal duty free? It is absurd to talk about sacrifices made by the Agricultural Credit Corporation officials being passed on in order to build up a reserve for contingencies. It is equally absurd to say that the cuts on the Electricity Supply Board's officials will be passed on to the general body of consumers. I doubt if these cuts will even enable them to balance their books as they were being balanced and enable them to keep to the old rates of charge. The extra expense they had to incur in the last year will certainly drive them to increase their charges, if they do not see some hope of that situation being mended in a favourable manner. At any rate, this was the Government that was to get us reductions in taxation; lower rates and more security, employment for everybody and the calling back of emigrants to take up the work that had to be done here. At the end of a year of that Government we find ourselves in the position that in order to enable the Minister for Finance to balance his Budget, we have got to get, as well as other things, this £280,000 from the persons here indicated.

The President based himself, in the end, on the primary producer. We have got a fairly good test recently of the condition to which the primary producer has been brought; and that despite the optimistic phrases that we so often hear from the Front Bench that agriculture is all right. Agriculture is all right according to the Minister for Industry and Commerce, who said it was never better, notwithstanding any evidence to the contrary. His unemployment figures are going down, so he tells us, though they appear to be going up. We have this admission, made in this House under very severe cross-examination, that there are certain rates of wages admitted to have been paid on certain schemes in this country. These rates, we are told are equated to the agricultural labourer's wage. The agricultural labourer's wage in Cavan is 21/- for a six-day week. That was the official answer given; these were the wages paid on Government schemes in Cavan. I wonder would this rate work out at 4½d. or 5d. an hour. We had a further statement made in reference to that admission with regard to the road wages paid in Cavan; we have this statement made by the man who was asked would he stand over them. The Parliamentary Secretary said here that if anybody went down to the County Cavan and tried to take from the men in receipt of it that 21/- for a six-day week that they would tear him limb from limb. That is the condition to which this country has been reduced. We are told, of course, that that is the same as the rate paid in President Cosgrave's time. I deny that to start with. But at that time we were told, and it was the theme of every crossroads orator, that these rates of wages were scandalous and that the people were refusing them. Now we are told that 21/- for a six-day week——

Comment on this

With broken time.

Comment on this

——is so acceptable and that the people are in such a state that if one went down to Cavan and tried to take it from them, he would be torn apart limb from limb. In these conditions it is almost impossible not to agree to a cut in the Civil Service salaries. What has brought us to that? What is the main point of Deputy Dillon's amendment? It is outrageously hypothetical for the people who have brought the country to that state to ask others to make sacrifices when they themselves did not make the sacrifices that they previously promised, and when they will not accept cuts in whatever they are receiving at the present time. That is the point of the amendment, and so far as it goes in that direction it is good. But the amendment is not a proper one in the face of this measure. It is absurd to be tinkering with it, and saying that this Bill should not be passed until provision is made to include therein a reduction of the allowances payable to Deputies and Senators. It should be until this whole situation has been examined and explained to the people; until they will have some clear knowledge where they are going; until they can have it demonstrated to them that eventually there will be prosperity, and demonstration does not mean mere declaration. But until some reason like that is given to us, then we have to say that, although the country has been reduced to a terrific state of impoverishment, we do not think it is necessary that it should stay there, and that it is a proper thing to have further impoverishment by reducing the salaries of those people indicated in the Bill. For that reason I, personally, am not going to accept either the amendment or the proposals in the Bill, and will resist any such measure until I am told what are the reasons for hoping eventually that we are going to be in a better position, or, alternatively, that that reason has been demonstrated to the people who are now going to be cut, and that they have agreed to it. I will take their word second-hand, but I am not going to take the word of the people who have brought the country to the position in which we now find it.

Comment on this
Seán F. Lemass Minister for Industry and Commerce (Mr. Lemass) Fianna Fáil

The attitude of the Deputy, in so far as I could understand it, is that he wants to get a reduction of taxation without reducing expenditure. He and his associates have been, from time to time, in this House and outside it, during the past six months, pressing the urgency of a reduction in the tax burden of the community. He thinks, apparently, that there are some means by which it is possible to reduce taxation without reducing expenditure. He is bringing to the consideration of the problem of the nation's finances exactly the same attitude he brought to bear upon other problems that faced him when he was Minister for Industry and Commerce. He wanted to get certain things done, but he did not want the job of doing them. It is because he and his associates for ten years faced up to their responsibilities in that way that this Government came into office to find the country with a declining population, declining agricultural production, declining industrial production, stripped of resources, stripped of wealth-producing capacity; in the position that, if a check had not been called to the continuous decline, recovery in our day might have been made entirely impossible. The Deputy is taking his responsibilities in opposition as lightly as he took his responsibilities in government. If he knows any way in which to reduce taxation without reducing expenditure, why does he not tell us about it? He did not speak about that. If he is opposed to a reduction of expenditure we must assume he is content to allow taxation to remain at its present level. We are aiming to reduce taxation.

The Deputy to-night as on other nights has been making play about an undertaking given on behalf of Fianna Fáil that taxation would be reduced. Let me look at the book of Estimates this year and compare it with the Estimates last year. Let him go through the Estimates and pick out of them the increased sums that are being made available for social services of one kind or another, and compare the figure that is left with the figure of expenditure on corresponding services in any one of the ten years the Cumann na nGaedheal Party were in office, and he will find that we have reached very close to the £2,000,000 we were talking about.

Comment on this

Do you think so?

Comment on this

I am certain of it. I am asking the Deputy to apply the test.

Comment on this

Without the payments mentioned?

Comment on this

In so far as the amount of £2,000,000 has not been reflected in a reduction of taxation, it is due entirely to the fact that increased provision has been made for social services of one kind or another. That does not represent a charge on the community. It represents a certain transfer of wealth from one class to another. It does not in any way increase the burden on the nation as a whole, even though it may increase the burden on individuals. There are several ways, of course, in which economies can be achieved. From time to time, between 1923 and 1931, the Cumann na nGaedheal conception of the right way to achieve economies was made plain. When the Minister for Finance of that Government was faced with budgetary difficulties, faced with the obligation of reducing expenditure, so as to permit of a reduction in taxation, we know the type of economies he thought of. The Deputy spoke about a promise given, or a proposal suggested that the rates of contribution to persons entitled to benefit under the Unemployment Insurance Acts should be increased. He reduced them.

Comment on this

The Deputy.

Comment on this

Reduced the benefits?

Comment on this

The whole purpose of the Unemployment Insurance Acts was used by the Deputy to achieve the peculiar type of economies he has in mind. Deputy Morrissey signalised his approval of what Deputy McGilligan said in relation to the Unemployment Insurance Acts in the course of the Deputy's speech. Deputy Morrissey would be well advised to read again the speeches which he delivered from time to time in the House upon the method of administration of these Acts for which Deputy McGilligan was responsible.

Comment on this

What about the point as to reducing the benefits to the unemployed?

Comment on this

And the old-age pensioners?

Comment on this

Keep to the unemployed.

Comment on this

I am going to speak about old-age pensioners.

Comment on this

You have left the unemployed.

Comment on this

I have for the moment. I want to speak about the old age pensioners. There was an economy achieved at their expense. It was always towards people of that class that the Cumann na nGaedheal Minister for Finance turned whenever his budgetary difficulties necessitated a reduction of expenditure of some kind. No doubt if this Bill was a proposal to reduce further the amounts payable to old age pensioners, to reduce further some social service which is operating now to alleviate hardship in parts of the country, it would have the enthusiastic approval of Deputies opposite, including the recent convert to that Party, Deputy Morrissey, who has, I notice, left the House. There is one fact I want Deputies opposite to bear in mind and that is that the remuneration of every class in the community has been reduced and it did not require an Act of the Legislature to reduce them. None of us likes to contemplate reducing the remuneration of any person or class of people, but we have to bear in mind that it would be unfair that any one class should be protected when every other class must suffer. Yesterday and to-day I have been in consultation with those who speak for the railwaymen of this State. It did not require any Act of the Legislature to achieve a reduction in remuneration for them. The farmers, who constitute one-half of the community, have had their remuneration reduced below the pre-war level, and it did not require the introduction of one of those green papers and a prolonged debate in this House to effect it.

Of course the Deputy had to insinuate that special circumstances exist in this country due entirely to the ill-conceived policy of the present Government. He conveniently forgot that the circumstances are nowise different elsewhere. Is this the only Legislature in the world in which national economy has been introduced in the past 12 months? Is there some peculiar reason why measures considered justifiable and necessary in almost every other civilised country in the world should not be introduced here or should be regarded as particularly obnoxious pieces of ill-advised Government policy when introduced here? The circumstances that exist here amongst the agricultural community and amongst other classes of people are paralleled elsewhere. They are due to causes which are worldwide; causes no doubt capable of remedy, but not yet remedied. It is because we contemplate being able, in our own way and in the near future, to take measures which will to some extent repair the damage done in this country by those world causes, and that by action abroad the world causes themselves may be removed or at any rate lessened in their effect, that this Bill operates for one year. We contemplate, at the end of that period, an improvement in our conditions which will obviate the necessity for reducing not merely the remuneration of civil servants, but, in part, the remuneration of railway workers and of every other class of worker. The Deputy chose to talk sarcastically about the consequences of the economic policy of this Government. We have been in office 12 months, and I am prepared to put side by side, in relation to any industrial activity, the record of the last 12 months with the record of the previous ten years. The Deputy quoted from an advertisement in which it was stated that the economic policy which we are now operating would tend to reduce unemployment, would be capable of providing employment for all those in the country who are seeking it, and might, in fact, operate to bring back and employ here those who, during the past ten years, were forced to emigrate and find abroad the livelihood they could not find at home. The Deputy asked a number of sarcastic questions. I do not know if he seriously meant them, but I intend to answer them. They are coming back from America. In last year, for the first time in half a century, we had a net immigration into this country. That situation came more rapidly than we anticipated, and came because of causes abroad as well as causes at home, but it is the fact.

Comment on this

Deportees!

Comment on this

Does the Deputy suggest that all those who returned from the United States of America last year were deportees?

Comment on this

One hundred and ninety-three landed in Cobh in one boat—all deportees.

Comment on this

I do not propose to follow that line. The facts are that they are coming back, that emigration has stopped, and that unemployment is decreasing. The Deputy said that he had been told unemployment is decreasing although the figures show it is increasing. The figures do not show anything of the kind. The 100,000 registered unemployed, which the Deputy talked about so eloquently at the general election, are only 20,000 to-day.

Comment on this

Will the Minister explain the Athlone and Longford situation, and the Dublin situation?

Comment on this

I say that every source of information open to me shows that employment is increasing, and that industrial productivity is increasing.

Comment on this

Pity they would not reveal it to us.

Comment on this

Traders of this State have told me that in this year they have a smaller percentage of bad debts than they ever had.

Comment on this

Because there is no purchasing.

Comment on this

They have told me that their cash returns are greater this year——

Comment on this

Because they will not give credit.

Comment on this

It is a fact that their production and sales are increasing rapidly and that this country is probably the only country in the world faced with this situation, that a number of our social problems are due to under-production.

Comment on this

Then away with the cuts!

Comment on this

And the cuts are going away as soon as that situation can be reflected in the public revenues. We have been in office for one year, and for a large part of that time we have been trying to put right the situation that we found on taking office—trying to repair some of the damage done by our predecessors. I say that in 12 months we have done more to increase industrial equipment, to increase employment, and to increase the production of wealth in this country than our predecessors contemplated doing, much less achieved, in their ten years. There is more money in Ireland, more money circulating, and the traders will tell you that business is good. A number of the leading traders stated in the Press that the Christmas trade of three months ago was the best they had for three years.

Comment on this

In Dublin.

Comment on this

They said that not merely in Dublin but in every town in the country.

Comment on this

Why the cuts?

Comment on this

Manufacturers are busier than ever they were. We have made progress in the development of industrial equipment much more rapidly than I contemplated. Take any industry you care to name. Take the flour-milling industry. Twelve months ago that industry was faced with extinction. A short time before that, in an attempt to ward off extinction, it had to enter into an arrangement which conceded to the importers one half of the whole market. A few days ago the flour millers came to my Department to make representations that there was a considerable danger of this country being over-milled, that the productive capacity was in excess of its requirements, and requesting that new entrants into the flour-milling industry should be restricted in consequence. We have doubled production and doubled employment in the boot and shoe industry. In the woollen industry there is not a factory in the country which has not substantially increased its production; some of them have multiplied it by three times. I was down in Cork recently and one woollen manufacturer came to me and said: "You recollect my telling you last October that I was doubling my plant. I have doubled it again since." In the hosiery industry employment has been more than doubled, and the rate of progress is so rapid that we contemplate its being doubled again before next December.

Comment on this

You should be giving a bonus to the civil servants.

Comment on this

In every industrial activity, as I have said, there has been that increase, and when that increase is reflected in the public revenues we will be able to avoid measures of this kind, and to give the benefit of the increased yield which existing taxes will produce in the form of reduced taxation. Deputies know quite well that the revenues earned by traders and industrialists in this year will not be reflected in the public revenues until next year.

Comment on this

The turnover in trade is £22,000,000.

Comment on this

The Deputy does not understand those figures. It has been one of the finest of our achievements that we have succeeded in releasing this country from its thraldom in connection with foreign trade. We do not export goods simply for the pleasure of giving them away; we export them to pay for the ones we import. We have released ourselves from the necessity of importing the bulk of our requirements. We have succeeded in getting produced here at home the whole range of manufactured goods which for ten years previously were bought abroad. We have succeeded in giving employment to Irishmen in Ireland where formerly the employment was given to Englishmen in England, to Germans in Germany——

Comment on this

You bought one million pounds' worth from Germany and sold them £100,000 worth.

Comment on this

And all that has been achieved despite the abnormal circumstances of last year, despite world causes, and despite the economic war. The Deputies opposite should be slow to talk about those matters. Some months ago they talked frequently, as Deputy McGilligan talked here to-night, about tricking the people. They told us that we had taken office under false pretences, and were operating in office a policy different to that which we placed before the electors. They talked about the will of the people; we gave them the opportunity of deciding. That is not two months ago. We gave them a general election with all the advantages on their side. Every political advantage that any party manager could ever dream about they had and, nevertheless, the country repudiated them. It endorsed the policy that we have been putting into operation for 12 months.

Comment on this

It endorsed those advertisements, not your policy.

Comment on this

The country had 12 months' experience of that policy in operation. They had experience of it probably in its worst aspect, because the fruits of it had not yet been reaped. When we came into office we had to clear the debris left by the previous administration before we could begin to put our policy into operation. That policy may have caused hardship in particular quarters, and yet in spite of that and the fact that the fruits of our policy had not yet been reaped, we gave in these conditions to the Deputies opposite the opportunity they pretended to want: of standing before the electors of the country and making their case. When they got the opportunity they were told in no undecisive manner what the country thought about them and what it thought about us. The policy that is enshrined in this Bill was endorsed by the people of the country. If there is an economic war in progress, then this Government was given a mandate to take whatever steps were necessary to secure victory in that war. If this Bill is one of the measures, as Deputy McGilligan alleged, then it is one that has the full endorsement of the majority of our people. We contemplate a speedy improvement in conditions. An improvement is taking place every day under our eyes. There has been a drop in the unemployment figures since last January. New industrial undertakings are reported every other day in the Press. An increase in tillage is taking place this year.

Comment on this

On paper.

Comment on this

The general development of economic activities of one kind or another is indicative of the improvement that is taking place. The whole of our people, with the exception of a small number in the Cumann na nGaedheal Party, are really optimistic as to the future.

Comment on this

What about the 151,000 people on home assistance?

Comment on this

Let the Deputy examine the causes for the increase in the amount expended on home assistance. It is due to the fact that increased provision is being made for the unfortunate people who are obliged to have recourse to that means of subsistence. Let the Deputy go back over the whole period the Cumann na nGaedheal Government was in office, take the number of people in receipt of home assistance each year, and note the percentage rate of increase until 1931. That will give him some idea of the problem that we were left to deal with. The Minister for Agriculture, speaking the other day about the agricultural position, said, in relation to that industry, that he found the country stripped of its wealth. Deputies opposite asked why the cattle exports had gone down. He told them the reason—because the number of cattle available for export had gone down.

Comment on this

That is not so.

Comment on this

In the year 1931, the last year in which the Deputies opposite were in control, the number of cattle in this country was 300,000 head less than in the year 1922. How can we export more cattle when the cattle are not there to export?

Comment on this

Does the Minister read the figures that are issued from his own Department?

Comment on this

I am quoting the figures issued.

Comment on this

Would the Minister refer to them again.

Comment on this

I have quoted the figures. Is the Deputy asserting that the number of cattle in this country in 1931 was higher than in 1922?

Comment on this

I am saying that the number of cattle in the country was absolutely maintained year after year, up to 1931, and that the number was greater, say, in 1931 than it was in 1929. I say that there was no diminution in the cattle stocks of the country worth talking about on the 1st June in those years, and neither the Minister for Agriculture nor the Minister for Industry and Commerce can quote a single figure to show that there was a diminution in the cattle stocks of the country in 1931 as against the preceding years.

Comment on this

I think the Deputy must have been following the example of his leader and reading the figures backwards.

Comment on this

I am reading from the introduction to the statistical figures issued for the year 1930, in which the whole period back to about 1922 is reviewed.

Comment on this

In the absence of the figures we cannot settle that argument now.

Comment on this

I can assure the Minister. The figures are available in the Minister's Department.

Comment on this

I repeat my statement that there was during that ten year's period a very substantial diminution in the cattle stocks of the country amounting to 300,000 head, and the reason why cattle exports were down during portion of last year was very largely due to that fact.

Comment on this

And not to the price?

Comment on this

The circumstances are changing. Last week, for example, we exported at least 3,000 head more than in the corresponding week of the previous year.

Comment on this

Is the bounty coming off?

Comment on this

I am speaking of numbers now—the number of cattle available. In every sphere of agricultural production there was the same decline during the ten years that the Party opposite were in power. The position in which we found ourselves when we came into office was that not merely had the wealth available in the country been decreased by the misgovernment of the Party opposite for ten years, but that the wealth producing capacity of the country had been definitely impaired. We have been repairing that position. Our anticipations in that respect have been exceeded, despite the economic war and the abnormal world conditions that prevail. At the rate of progress that is now being made we can contemplate a complete recovery in a very short period.

There are still many problems to be dealt with, many that require careful examination and very decisive action. No matter what methods are adopted for dealing with them, there is one that must be tried and that is to keep as low as possible the tax burden on the country. It is because that is necessary that this Bill is now before the Dáil. This Bill does not in fact impose any real hardship. There are many people in the country who have had to suffer much more substantial reductions in their remuneration than is proposed for any class of public servants under this Bill. We hope that these people as well as civil servants will benefit by any improvement that may result from the Government's policy in the next ten months or a year. If the Deputies opposite vote against this Bill and against the proposal to effect economies in the way proposed under it, then let them at least stop talking about a reduction of taxation, about the plight of the agricultural community and about the various measures that they would like to see adopted if they did not involve an increased cost to the public. A vote against the Bill, and against the achievement of economies in that way on the part of the Deputies opposite will stultify everything they have been saying during the past six months through the country. I expect them to vote against it, but at least let them do it avowedly because this Bill is a measure introduced by a Fianna Fáil Government. Let them admit candidly that that is the only reason they are opposing it. It is, I think, a pity that ex-Deputy Blythe is not available to-night to tell us exactly what economic excesses he was contemplating before the people got the opportunity of putting him where he now is.

Comment on this

I regret that it has not been possible for the Minister for Finance to remain and, therefore, I move that the question be now put.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The motion is that the Bill be now read a Second Time. To that an amendment is tabled in the name of Deputy Dillon to delete all the words after "that" and substitute certain words. I am putting the question—"That the words proposed to be deleted stand part."

Comment on this
Division

Question put.

Tá 79
·
Níl 8
Result _

Do you agree with this result?

Division

Question—"That the Bill be now read a Second Time"—put.

Tá 59
·
Níl 30
Result Carried The question put was agreed to.

Do you agree with this result?