We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

National Health Insurance Bill, 1933—Committee Stage.

Contributions 1–137 of 268. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

Bill National Health Insurance Bill, 1933
Enacted

No. 14 of 1933 ›

I beg to move amendment 1:—

In sub-section (1) lines 34-35 to delete the words "Saorstát Eireann Unified Health Insurance Society" and substitute the words "Cumann Aontuithe an Arachais Náisiúnta ar Shláinte."

I move this amendment so that the Unified Health Insurance Society may be known by its Gaelic title and by none other. I do not anticipate any opposition from the Minister. We are all aware of the fact that he has on all possible occasions urged and encouraged the use of our language. I assume that in developing the Bill and in devoting time to the details the Minister has overlooked the possibility of adorning the society with a Gaelic title. I do not anticipate opposition from any section of the House. No objection has been raised to the first two words of the title being in Irish. The two words I refer to are Saorstát Eireann. Consequently, I cannot presume that there will be any objection if the remaining two-thirds of the title of the society are in the native language.

It is but fitting that the title of a national institution should be in our native tongue. It may be argued that people will not be able to understand the title if it appears in Irish. Already they have learned to read and speak fluently one-third of the words of the title, and I think we can safely rely on the intelligence of our people, and we can rest assured that they will be able to pick out the remaining portions of the title without much difficulty. We must remember that there are numbers of people in the Gaeltacht who would be unable to read the title of the society if it were in the language of the foreigner. As it now stands, the title appears partly in one language and partly in another. I am sure Deputies will agree that there is no reason why that should be the case. I trust that if the Minister does not accept my amendment as it stands, he will accept the principle of it.

Comment on this
Seán T. O'Kelly Aire Rialtais Aitiúla agus Sláinte Puiblí (Seán T.O Ceallaigh) Fianna Fáil

Ma's maith leis na Teachtaí ainm Gaedhalach do bheith ar an gCumann, táim sásta glacadh leis an leas-rún.

Comment on this

I think I am right in assuming that every statute passed by this Oireachtas must be published in the English and in the Irish languages. In that case the name of this society will be recorded officially in the Irish language, and every provision of the measure when it is passed will be published both in the Irish and in the English languages. To my mind this amendment simply proposes to insert in the Bill words that are, in fact, already there. The Bill ought to be circulated in the Irish language. Is it not in accordance with the Standing Orders that Bills should be circulated in both languages?

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

That does not apply to Bills.

Comment on this

I am surprised that reform has not been introduced under the present Government. I have no doubt that tribute will be paid to the language before long. Anyhow, when the Act comes to be printed it will appear in both languages, and the Deputy's point will thereby be covered.

Comment on this

My anxiety is to have a purely Gaelic title for the society. Dáil Eireann is known as Dáil Eireann; you do not translate it. Similarly, Seanad Eireann is a Gaelic title, and you do not translate it—there is no need. There will be no need to translate the Gaelic title of the society either.

Comment on this

So far as I am concerned, I am prepared to welcome the naming of this society in Irish if it would in any way redound to the credit of the language; but I am not quite sure that it is consistent with the dignity of the national language that chips of it should be interspersed in an English text. If, however, the Deputy thinks that by taking that course it adds anything to the lustre of the national language, I would not object. I would prefer that the whole Act and the title of the society should appear in Irish. As the law stands it will appear in Irish and also in English. I should imagine that is the more dignified course.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

I take it that the Minister is adopting the principle of the amendment and will introduce it in another form later.

Comment on this

Yes, I am accepting it in principle.

Comment on this

I beg to move amendment 2:—

At the end of sub-section (3) (a) line 8 to add the words "and the Minister shall nominate one of such members to be chairman of such committee until the appointed day."

I think this amendment is a rather important amendment. The committee is usually entitled to appoint its own chairman, but in a case such as is suggested in the section it might not be possible to secure unanimity in the choice of a chairman, seeing that the committee would be composed of only three members. If the Minister would retain the right of the appointment of the chairman when installing the committee, I believe matters would be considerably simplified by such action. Most of the responsibility will rest upon the shoulders of the chairman, and therefore his appointment by the Minister is, to my mind, of considerable importance. I therefore move the amendment standing in my name.

Comment on this

I have no objection to accepting the amendment, but the words "until the appointed day" there are unnecessary; otherwise I am prepared to accept the amendment.

Comment on this

Is the Minister objecting to the words "until the appointed day"?

Comment on this

They are unnecessary. He will be for the period of the existence of the committee.

Comment on this

I move amendment 3:—

To add at the end of the section a new sub-section as follows:—

(6) The first secretary and first treasurer of the unified society shall be persons who were on the 30th day of June, 1932, holders of qualifying posts under an approved society.

I think this is a reasonable amendment. It is just and proper that these positions should be reserved for the existing officers of approved societies. There are in the various approved societies throughout the country experienced officers who know their work, and who have been engaged in the work of approved societies for many years. It would be unfair and unjust that they should be passed over for outsiders. In addition to that there is the other consideration that it will save compensation. If outsiders are brought in, it will mean that some officials of an approved society must ultimately be displaced. Consequently from both points of view—that is from the point of view of the existing staffs and from the point of view of economy —it is proper that this amendment should be accepted.

Comment on this

I think there is a good deal in what Deputy Costello says about taking over men who would have had probably long experience of approved societies. While I do not think that I ought to be bound in that matter, I think that the persons to be appointed will in all probability be persons who have acted in such capacity for one or other approved society. However, I would like to feel completely free to get the best persons I can in any way. I say that, while I do believe there is a good deal in the argument that Deputy Costello has used.

Comment on this

I should like to support Deputy Costello's amendment. The Minister has no case against the amendment, and admitted that a good deal was to be said for it. If there is a good deal to be said for it, there can be no objection on the part of the Minister to accepting it. In answer to a question asked here, the Minister stated that there were 360 whole time officers in the approved societies. Now, that being the case, the Minister has 360 whole time officers to select from in the filling of these posts. These people have experience, and I doubt if there is any person outside the existing societies who has such experience. Unless the Minister is contemplating importing some officials to fill these posts there is a large number to choose from. He has 360 full time officers. It is because I believe it is desirable to have officers of experience and officers who have justified their previous employment by their knowledge of the Insurance Acts and the various regulations issued under them that I urge the Minister to accept this amendment, which should commend itself to him. I hope on reconsideration he will accept it. It does not bind him except that it makes him choose from these 360 people. And that is a very wide choice. The Minister is bound by this amendment to do the right thing, and he ought to accept it.

Comment on this

I would suggest to the Minister to accept this amendment. For the reasons mentioned by Deputies Norton and Costello, I think the Minister will agree that in making appointments of this kind it would sometimes be of material advantage to him to have certain statutory limitations on his discretion. It does give him a means of readily disposing of wholly unsuitable candidates by simply pointing to the Statute and saying: "If I had the will I have not the power." Furthermore, it would make it obligatory on him to appoint somebody whose appointment would effect a small saving in the fund that is at his disposal for compensation. As the Minister has been good enough to say at an early stage of this Bill that the limit of his generosity in compensation will be only the limit of his capacity to pay, I am anxious to see every economy of this character made obligatory in order to make the compensation more liberal for those who will be compelled to retire. I suggest to the Minister for those two pretty cogent reasons he might consider this limitation on his discretion.

Comment on this

I just want to put one or two points, as I feel that the Minister if he is pressed a little further, in view of the fact that he recognises the equity of the case, may give way and accept this reasonable amendment which is put forward in the interest of those officials of approved societies who are really anxious to make the new unified society, no matter how they may dislike its formation, a success. I suggest to the Minister that one of the facts that he should take into consideration is that if an outsider is appointed it will cause very severe heart-burnings amongst the officials who are retained and a certain amount of natural discontent. I think the Minister might further take this matter into consideration having regard to the fact, as I am informed, that the Committee of Inquiry into Health Insurance in 1925 reported that the first officials of the new unified society should be chosen from the existing officers, so that he has valid and cogent reasons for accepting it, and apparently his own inclinations lie that way. In addition, there is very strong approval for this course in the Interim Report of the Committee in 1925.

Comment on this

There is one other reason that could be advanced, but that has not been advanced so far, in favour of the amendment. When the measure was originally introduced we were not in favour of it. and we have not altogether changed our opinions yet. We view it with some misgiving, because centralisation in one society here in Dublin would make for less sympathetic administration. The Minister knows, as some of us do, that occasionally cases come up for consideration which are borderline cases that can be decided favourably to the insured member when there is a proper appreciation of the position all round. In order to ensure the sympathetic administration of the Act that I am sure the Minister desires, it would be desirable that an experienced official of some society should be appointed to the position. The Minister has shown that he is not unfavourably disposed to the amendment, and with the point I have in mind, as well as other reasons that have been advanced, I ask him to give it favourable consideration.

Comment on this

As I say, my own view is that the Minister ought not to be tied in the matter. I quite agree that there is quite a considerable amount of force in the arguments used by Deputies recommending the acceptance of the amendment. No doubt there is a considerable choice, but there might be a much wider choice. I am not saying that one would get persons better fitted and more efficient and knowing more about health insurance outside people who have acted as secretary or assistant secretary or treasurer of one of those societies. The view that has been expressed here has been already suggested to me, but my own feeling was that I ought, as Minister, to be absolutely free to get anywhere I could the very best persons for these very important posts. However, if the Deputy will withdraw the amendment and put it down on Report Stage I will agree to reconsider it.

Comment on this

In Section 7 (2) it is provided that the treasurer of the unified society shall also be the assistant-secretary of the unified society. It is quite possible that one officer could combine the two positions, but is there any need to enshrine this in legislation, specifying that in the unified society the assistant-secretary may be required to discharge duties which would make it impossible for him effectively to supervise the financial side of the society? Yet, we are providing in legislation that the two offices shall be one and taking no cognisance of possible changes in the assistant-secretary's duty which may make it impossible for him effectively to supervise the financial side. I suggest that while, in fact, this combination might be possible as a matter of ordinary efficient office routine, it is undesirable to put it into legislation, because if you do you will always have an assistant-secretary who, no matter how burdensome his duties, will be required to look after the financial side. I think it would be well rather to leave it to the administrators of the society to combine the offices if possible, but I think it is wrong to do it in legislation.

Comment on this

I shall look into the point.

Comment on this

I move amendment 4:—

In page 5, line 2, to insert after the word "company" the words "except with the consent of the Minister."

This is an amendment to add to the section a discretionary clause. I might describe this as the obverse of the medal of the last amendment moved by Deputy Costello, because while it is a useful thing to restrict the Minister's discretion and his range of choice and say that he shall not go outside a certain class of highly-qualified men, it is quite another thing to say he may not enter another class of very highly-qualified men. The general principle that the Minister has in mind here is to prevent the appointment of agents or employees of insurance companies as a member of the committee of management in the unified society and I think the principle underlying that is fairly manifest. I would suggest, however, to the Minister that circumstances might arise where it would be greatly to the advantage of the committee of management to have amongst its members some person who was connected with the insurance business in this country. The case might not arise, but, on the other hand, it might. The Minister is quite free to refer to the principle underlying this section in the event of any pressure being brought to bear upon him to nominate any particular person to the committee of management. At the same time, if it were generally felt that it would be to the advantage of the parties concerned that such a person should be appointed, he would have the right to make an exception in that person's case and it would admittedly be an exception. This is one of those cases in which, I think, the Minister ought to have discretion to make an exception if the advice of one particular person is very necessary for the proper conduct of the unified society.

Comment on this

My feeling is that I would rather not have the freedom in this case; that I would rather have it definitely fixed that persons interested in other forms of insurance work should not be eligible. I know from experience since the Bill was introduced that considerable pressure from many sources would be exercised to get people appointed who may be enthusiasts in the matter, but it might be a type of enthusiasm which might be very embarrassing. I think it would be better for the Minister not to have the discretion the Deputy wishes to give.

Comment on this

Perhaps I should be content that this amendment has extracted from the Minister the admission of a certain principle which might prove very useful on the Report Stage in connection with another amendment which will reappear. It is regrettable, however, that the Minister and I should disagree on two occasions when the application of this principle arises. I do not agree with him. I think it would be better for him to have this discretion, but I do not propose to press the amendment.

Comment on this

I move amendment 5:—

To add at the end of the section a new paragraph as follows:—

(e) to submit before the appointed day for the consent of the Minister, with the approval of the Minister for Finance, a suitable superannuation scheme for the permanent officers and employees of the unified society.

This amendment is moved for the purpose of securing the establishment of a superannuation fund for the future employees of the unified society. So far as I am concerned, the fund suggested should be on a contributory basis, with the right, of course, of the employing side and the employees to have an equal share or voice in the management of the suggested fund. I understand that the average age of the 360 full-time employees is fairly low, and that would make it much easier for the fund to be established on a solvent basis. Personally, I do not believe it would be right to allow any very old employee of the unified society to go into such a superannuation fund without having to pay some surcharge as from a particular date or age. I have some knowledge of the existence of superannuation funds. I am myself a member of a fund which is supposed to be the biggest fund in the world for clerical employees, and I know that under no circumstances would the committee of management of that fund allow any person to come in late in age on the same conditions as those who came in after passing an examination at 18 or 20 years of age for service in the company concerned. I understand that a few men who are old and who might be given the option of coming over to the unified society as employees are likely to retire at whatever compensation the Minister would deem fit to give them. I understand that four years ago the association representing employees of the existing societies submitted a scheme for the superannuation of the then servants of the societies concerned. If I am correctly informed, I understand that the claim was sympathetically looked into, but that it was deferred until such time as the societies then in existence would agree to unify on a provincial or a national basis. However, that does not get away from the fact that any national organisation of this kind should have some kind of fund created which would enable provision to be made for them to retire at an age to be fixed, and to get a reasonable scale of pension. I hope it is possible, now that the unified society has been formed, that by the time the society comes into actual operation a fund such as that now contemplated in this amendment will be established with the consent and approval of the Minister.

Comment on this

I am afraid I cannot accept the amendment of Deputy Davin, although I think the idea of the superannuation fund a good one, especially a contributory fund. I think any large institution such as the one we are going to set up should have something of the kind. If we were to set up such a fund now there would be not a small number of men of 40 or 50 years of age who might have to be provided for, and in order to provide for them a large capital sum would be necessary. I am afraid our funds at present would not enable us to make that provision, and besides that the individuals concerned would be called upon to put up a considerable sum if there were—as I am told there are— a number who are of an age to have served in the national health insurance, and who are 40 to 50 or over 50 years of age. If the Deputy would be satisfied I would agree with an amendment of this kind: "To examine and report to the Minister as to the possibility of establishing a suitable superannuation scheme for the officers and employees of the unified society, having regard to the moneys available for the purpose under the financial provisions of the Act." I am quite sympathetic with the idea of a superannuation fund, but our funds at present would not enable us to provide the capital sum necessary, so far as I understand at the moment, to provide for the people whose service with the approved societies would have to be taken into account. If we were to take their service into account a large capital sum would have to be provided. If it were merely a question of starting a superannuation fund from now on, it would be a different proposition, but a lot of those men who have already served would not come in.

Comment on this

May I say to the Minister that any such fund which I would have in mind would be based upon actuarial considerations and recommendations. I would not admit, except that I have just casually referred to the conditions which should attach to it, that it should be on a contributory basis. Aged entrants, if they were allowed to come into the superannuation fund formed as a result of the acceptance of an amendment of this kind, should pay as say from 20 or 28 years of age. That surcharge, whatever it might be, may be enabled to be paid over three or four instalments. I would not suggest the formation of any fund except one that would be suggested after actuarial investigation and recommendation, and if there were employees of the unified society who, in the opinion of the management committee, and after the consideration that should be given to a matter of this kind by the actuary, should not be allowed to come into the society for some good reason, I would not endeavour to place any obligation upon the management committee of the unified society that would force them to take over a bad business proposition.

The whole idea is that the future employees of the society should have some such superannuation scheme. If it is possible on the basis of the actuary's report to bring in those who would be taken over from the other societies, and whose average age I am informed would not exceed 35 to 40 years of age, I do not think it would be a bad proposition to bring those in on certain defined conditions so far as surcharge is concerned. If the Minister cannot see his way to accept the amendment as now worded, and I admit it is not worded in a model manner, I should be glad if he would between now and the Report Stage give this matter further consideration. I would reserve the right to move the amendment on the Report Stage, and then see whether or not, after having heard the Minister on the matter and after the Minister had reconsidered the whole matter from the point of view I have just put forward, I would withdraw the amendment.

Comment on this

Of course any superannuation scheme anywhere would have to be actuarially examined before being set up. Since the amendment was put in we have not had an opportunity of having an actuarial examination. You would have to have a full investigation into the age and health of all the people concerned before any scheme could be set up. I think it would take even a longer time than between now and the Report Stage.

Comment on this

I did not suggest that at all. So long as before the appointed day the scheme would be considered by the management committee in consultation with the actuary, and that the principle of the amendment is accepted, I am satisfied.

Comment on this

Is the Deputy then accepting what I suggest—"to examine and report to the Minister the possibility of establishing a suitable superannuation scheme for the officers and servants of the unified society, having regard to the moneys available for the purpose under the financial provisions of the Act?" Speaking as a Minister, I am quite willing and anxious to have a superannuation scheme set up, but without actuarial examination and full consideration one could not bind oneself at this stage.

Comment on this

Will the Minister put in a date in his suggested amendment?

Comment on this

What would be a reasonable date? First of all I think there is only one actuary in this country so far as I know.

Comment on this

There are two or three.

Comment on this

There were two on this matter previously.

Comment on this

There is one in this Department.

Comment on this

I know that, and I do not know if there is another.

Comment on this

There is.

Comment on this

It is not easy to get actuaries. It would probably take months to get them to make their arrangements. You would have to give them months for the examination, and it is not easy to fix a date.

Comment on this

Make it "not longer than such a period."

Comment on this

Would a year be too long?

Comment on this

I would accept a year.

Comment on this

"To examine and report by this time 12 months."

Comment on this

The Minister is in agreement with the necessity for such a fund?

Comment on this

In principle, I am with you entirely.

Comment on this

Is the Minister saying within 12 months from the date the unified society is set up or within 12 months from the passing of the Bill?

Comment on this

This report would have to be made by the provisional committee. The provisional committee will go out of office in three years, and it would certainly have to be done long before they go out of office.

Comment on this

The Minister means 12 months from the date of the passing of the Bill?

Comment on this

Yes.

Comment on this

The Minister has accepted the principle? Let there be no misapprehension about what his intention is. He will have to constitute his entire unified society before he can have an actuarial investigation into the risks involved in the scheme for the employees. He will have to have his roster of employees.

Comment on this

That has nothing to do with compensation.

Comment on this

I am not talking of compensation. I say that he will have to have his roster for the purpose of a State superannuation scheme. He will have to have his list before him before he can float his scheme. At the present time he does not know who is to be taken over into the unified society. Let us suppose he takes over 350, and they form the nucleus of a new society. It is upon that he will have to lay the foundation of the new compensation scheme, and it is upon that he will have to rest his calculations, and he cannot start his calculations until he has his roster, so I suggest to the Minister that to make a promise to set a scheme on foot in the next 12 months is not safe.

Comment on this

I did not promise to set a scheme on foot. I said an examination would be made as to the possibilities, taking the officials as they are known to the Department, getting the numbers of the officials in the existing societies, and basing our scheme upon the information we get with regard to employees, and any other particulars we can get as well.

Comment on this

The position is this. If you make an actuarial calculation on the basis of 350 employees of the societies, you are taking into consideration the elderly men as well as the younger ones. The tendency of the Minister will be to pick a lot of the elderly men type and compensate them. You might get an actuarial compensation basis upon the number of 350 but that would be out of all proportion to the actual facts if the Minister sets up his society. If the Minister waited until he gets his roster in the unified society the possibility might be better. I would prefer that the Minister, before he proceeded actuarially to examine the scheme, would have the actual employees he is going to retain and on that basis make his calculation as to what the risk would be.

Comment on this

I do not think it is necessary to wait until such time as one gets the names, ages and history of all the individuals to be taken over, in order to ask the actuary to prepare a scheme which will contemplate the employment of a certain number of people and enable the Minister to say what percentage of salaries will be necessary for the employee he is dropping in order to bring the measure into operation.

Comment on this

You would require some idea of the ages.

Comment on this

All this requires is the numbers of the unified society taken after such a year. It is an enquiry based on maximum and minimum numbers.

Comment on this

Suppose we have 300 employees. The unified society has 100 over 50, 100 over 40, and 100 under 40. This consideration will be placed before the Minister as to the practicability of the superannuation fund. Supposing the Minister started and took five of the men over 50 and five over 40 and 150 under 40. I put both sides to the Minister. If he submitted five over 50, five over 40 and 160 under 40 it would make a more unified calculation for him in the setting up of the superannuation scheme than if he submitted to an actuary an average of 350 from whom he is going to make his decision.

Comment on this

I agree that not having exact facts and figures you would not have the exact actuarial position before you, but it would be possible to make a shot at it. But it runs the risk of not being as inviting as it otherwise would be with the full facts and figures. But I suggest that the amendment meets what the Deputy has said. The matter will be examined, I am sure sympathetically, by the committee, and certainly it will be examined sympathetically by the Minister.

Comment on this

But it might be held to represent three years from the appointed day. Would the Minister agree to have it expedited?

Comment on this

I will agree to have it examined at the earliest possible moment.

Comment on this

I move amendment 6:

In sub-section (2), line 52 to delete the words "passing of this Act" and substitute the words and figures "31st day of December, 1933."

The unified society will not have any machinery for dealing with new entrants into insurance until some time after the passing of the Act. It is considered desirable to allow existing societies to admit new members until such time as the unified society will be in working order.

Comment on this

There is no possibility of a situation arising in which the machinery for accepting persons into the unified society would be ready by 31st December, 1933?

Comment on this

I do not anticipate that.

Comment on this

I move amendment 7:—

Before Section 13 to insert a new section as follows:—

(1) It shall not be lawful for any approved society without the consent of the Minister to pay to any person, who, on the 5th day of April, 1933, was rendering service to such society in any capacity (whether as officer, member of the committee of management, employee or otherwise), remuneration in respect of any period subsequent to the passing of this Act at a rate greater than the rate of remuneration of such person on the 5th day of April, 1933.

(2) It shall not be lawful for any approved society without the consent of the Minister to pay to any person, who, after the 5th day of April, 1933, and before the passing of this Act, was appointed to render service to such society in any capacity (whether as an officer, member of the committee of management, employee or otherwise), remuneration in respect of any period subsequent to the passing of this Act at a rate greater than the rate of remuneration of a person employed by such society in a similar capacity on the 5th day of April, 1933.

(3) It shall not be lawful for any approved society without the consent of the Minister to fix or alter the remuneration of any person appointed after the passing of this Act to render service to such society in any capacity (whether as officer, member of the committee of management, employee or otherwise).

This new section has been found necessary by reason of the efforts made in some places to rush large increases of salaries to officials so as, I presume, to enhance their compensation. Efforts have been made already and we have heard of others likely to be made in this connection. We think it necessary that this new section should be inserted so as to prevent inflation of the salaries and emoluments of officials during this period.

Comment on this

It is only right that this amendment should be introduced for the purpose of forestalling any such attempt but is not the number of such cases very limited?

Comment on this

It is limited.

Comment on this

Possibly there is not more than one case where an advance was given to a county secretary and that was not with the full approval of the managing committee. It is only right that the Minister should make clear that this practice is not general.

Comment on this

It is not general.

Comment on this

Can we have an assurance that this section will not be used to prevent an official getting a normal increase in salary?

Comment on this

In some cases officials may be entitled to increments and those increments may become payable during the period mentioned.

Comment on this

Ordinary increments will certainly not be interfered with.

New section agreed to.

Comment on this

Can the Minister explain on Section 13 why there is a differentiation as regards the appointed day?

Comment on this

There is a later provision in connection with that. There are extras to be examined between this and 31st December.

Comment on this

Special provision had to be made in regard to these societies. Additional benefits were largely given out of the funds provided by the two institutions concerned. Special provision, therefore, had to be made in regard to them.

Comment on this

Is there any suggestion as to excluding either the St. James's Gate Health Insurance Society or the Dublin United Tramways and Omnibus Employees Health Insurance Society from the unifying provisions of the Act?

Comment on this

I move amendment 8 which stands in the name of Deputy Davin and myself. It is as follows:—

To add at the end of the section a new sub-section as follows:

The following amendment is hereby made in the Act of 1911, that is to say:—In Section 8, sub-section (1) there shall be inserted a new paragraph as follows:—"In the case of an insured person requiring dental treatment on and after the 5th day of July, 1936, payment in whole or in part of the cost of providing such treatment (including dentures) in accordance with regulations to be prescribed by the Minister."

At present, many of the societies, especially those in a financially sound position, provide dental treatment for their members. Indeed, dental treatment is now extensively provided by all societies, but specially generous provision is made in the case of those societies in a good financial position. In practice, dental treatment has become one of the statutory provisions so far as insured persons are concerned. Most of the societies provide such treatment. Under the unifying provisions of this Bill, all the societies will be thrown into one common pool. This amendment seeks to give the insured person a definite right to dental benefits in the same way as if they were provided in the Act of 1911. The amendment seeks to ensure that a provision now made available to insured contributors by practically all the societies will be made available to them as a matter of right in this Bill in the same way as if that provision were included in the Act of 1911.

Comment on this

I am afraid that I cannot accept this amendment. The contributions at present paid are all required to finance the present statutory benefits. There is no money and, so far as we can anticipate, there will be no money available for this purpose. It may be that the actuarial report at the end of this quinquennial period will be better than forecasted. If so, the money will be there for such additional benefits as may be thought advisable. At this stage, we do not see any likelihood of money being available for this admirable object.

Comment on this

If the Minister declares this proposal to be actuarially impossible, that finishes it, but the Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister might have drawn his attention to this aspect of the case—that probably one of the most prolific causes of permanent disablement in the later years is one or other form of rheumatism. The Parliamentary Secretary will, from his expert knowledge, tell the Minister that what is popularly styled "rheumatism" is, very often, some form of arthritis and that that largely results from dental infection of one kind or another. A large number of the cases which we call "chronic cases," which come on the funds for six or sometimes seven years towards the end of the insurable period by reason of permanent incapacity, could and would have been kept off the funds had the persons concerned received adequate dental treatment in middle age or when about 30 years of age. One of the great objections to this whole unification system is that certain people who are members of solvent societies are going to be deprived of benefits they used to have. We know from the Minister's speeches on the Second Stage that that is unavoidable under the circumstances, but when a proposal is made that may at first place an additional burden on the funds, but may reasonably be expected substantially to relieve the funds later on—I think the Parliamentary Secretary will bear me out in my contention that we could reasonably expect to relieve insurance funds when persons reach the ages of 60 and 70 if dental benefits were provided —the Minister might take a risk. I do not think that he has had advice that this proposal is actuarially out of the question. The actuary has said no more, I imagine, than that it would be dangerous to do this until they had found their feet. I suggest that there is as good argument for maintaining that this is an economy to the fund as there is for maintaining that it is an excessive burden. I suggest that on this occasion the Parliamentary Secretary might break loose and join with us in bringing judicious pressure to bear on the Minister to make a concession in respect of this important matter.

Comment on this

I did not know that Deputy Dillon had a knowledge of dentistry in addition to all the other knowledge he seems to possess. This treatment that is spoken about here— putting a man in a chair, hauling the teeth out of his head and leaving him, to use a vulgar word, "gummy" for the rest of his life—is not dental treatment, in my opinion. Some method should be taken to preserve the teeth rather than pull them out. As regards the dental treatment suggested by Deputies here, I would like to know what they mean by it. Preserve teeth by all means with dental or other treatment, but do not make poor people, men and women, victims of indigestion for the rest of their natural lives after a visit to a dentist's chair.

Comment on this

This amendment attempts to make certain that at the end of a particular period insured members who are to-day in a position to get this benefit will have it continued. It also makes provision for people not now in receipt of this benefit to receive such benefit as from the date set out. I am afraid that the Minister, when approaching the consideration of sections of the Bill dealing with the future financial position of the unified society, was altogether too nervous and moderate. So far as I know, the Minister, has not made the House fully aware of the resources that will be available for the unified society, when it comes into operation. I understand the contingency fund is in surplus to the extent of £65,000 and that there are reserves amounting to very large figures. I would like the Minister to indicate what the reserves amount to, so far as available information goes. The House will be interested to know what amount of reserves will be at the disposal of the unified society. I am now speaking of reserves as distinct from surpluses.

If my information is correct, I understand that the majority of societies in existence, although they are small, provide this benefit for their insured members, in addition to other valuable benefits; but only one-third of the members of national health insurance societies get that benefit. In other words, the insolvent societies, which appear to be the large societies, do not provide this benefit. I have sufficient knowledge of the administration of national health insurance on a nationwide scale to be able to prophesy that a great deal of the malingering which has been going on all over the country will be cut out by the unified society by reason of its stricter administration. By cutting out that malingering, you are going to bring the unified society to a solvent state much earlier than if it were to be committed to a continuance of payments on the present scale. I am sure there is no Deputy here who will not agree that malingering has been practised. Most Deputies know why and for what reason, and perhaps they could tell the House what all that has cost the large societies whose members have not, for a variety of reasons, been in a position to get this very valuable benefit. In any effort we make to secure that members of the unified society will obtain this benefit in the future, we should not interfere with the people who have been getting such benefit in the case of societies that are solvent. I believe we can look forward to the time when the unified society will be in a position, not alone to provide for the continuance of this benefit to those now in receipt of it, but also to make provision, because of its financially sound position, for this necessary benefit in the case of all its members.

Comment on this

I would like to see dental benefits extended to every member of the unified society. I hope when the society is put on the new basis its work will be so efficient and its financial security will be such that dental benefits will be added to the other statutory benefits. I hope the society will be in such a position that that benefit will be continued for those who have been lucky enough to have got it so far and will be extended to others. I am informed, however, that the finances are not in such a position that we could accept this amendment and insert it in the Bill, thus binding ourselves to grant these dental benefits. I am advised the money is not there and we are by no means sure that the money will be there by the date the Deputy suggests. If it is there, there is no reason why the committee of management that will be in existence should not do the same as other approved societies have done. When they had a surplus, they spent it on their members and I hope the unified society will be in a position to do the same. I hope they will be able to distribute the surplus amongst members in the way of increased dental, hospital and other benefits.

Comment on this

How many approved societies give these benefits now?

Comment on this

I am not certain. This afternoon I was told nine or ten and I was told later 16, but I have no opportunity of checking it up.

Comment on this

What is the amount of the reserve fund that is likely to be at the disposal of the unified society in addition to the surplus in the contingency fund?

Comment on this

There is only the reserve. I am aware of a reserve of £3,000,000 which will finance the whole scheme of national health insurance.

Comment on this

That figure has not been mentioned before.

Comment on this

It was mentioned.

Comment on this

What has that to do with the benefits?

Comment on this

It has nothing to do with the benefits. If it were not there the whole scheme of national health insurance would fall to the ground.

Comment on this

The Minister could borrow on the strength of that.

Comment on this

I think the Minister might well take a risk in this matter. The passage of this Bill will ensure to the contributor certain statutory benefits which were set out in the Act of 1911. How is it we can still pay these statutory benefits and yet not be in a position to give an extra statutory benefit in the way of dental treatment? If the Minister's speech is based on an actuarial examination of the position then, of course, we cannot argue, but I am not sure that it is. Has it been determined, for instance, that we can pay benefit for the full period of 26 weeks or, say, for 24 weeks? I am rather sceptical that there has been an actuarial examination of the position. I think it is desirable to have dental benefit provided as a statutory right.

We are building houses to-day on a very large scale. More and better houses ought to mean improved health. By reason of the huge allocations to hospitals from the proceeds of the sweepstakes we ought to have better methods of fighting disease. The Minister for Industry and Commerce talks of growing industrial development which will mean less unemployment. If we are going to have more and better houses, better methods of fighting disease and the industrial development that the Minister for Industry and Commerce tells us of, surely there is a good case for taking a risk in this matter. The provision of dental benefit would be a great boon to insured contributors. I implore the Minister to take a risk in this matter. The Bill ought to be amended so as to make it capable of providing the dental benefit which we all agree is so necessary. As it is contributors cannot make any financial provision for that treatment on their own.

Comment on this

Has the Minister examined this question with expert advisers, such as his Parliamentary Secretary or other physicians? Quite apart from conferring benefit on insured persons, I think it might be very good business to take the long view. What is the experience of the types of disease I have mentioned between the period from 60 to 70 years? I think the percentage would be remarkably high. I think the persons suffering from permanent incapacity between 60 and 70 years would represent at least 50 per cent. They would be suffering from some form of trouble that the Parliamentary Secretary might be inclined to trace to dental defects in their earlier years. When we are passing legislation which is going to deprive a large number of people of benefits they have been accustomed to receive, we ought to be careful that any economy we are making now will not prove to be an extravagance in the general administration of the scheme 20 years later. I would like the Minister to look into it. Apart from the benevolent aspect of the question, I would ask him to look at it from the point of view of good business and to see if it might not be to the advantage of the whole fund to take the precaution of giving dental benefit forthwith.

Comment on this

I cannot press the Minister on this point if he says he has not got the money to do it, but I think it is a most disastrous and backward step that we should deprive people who previously had these benefits from having them in the future. On this benefit of seeing to their teeth and to the teeth of the children I am not going into any medical matters. I will say nothing more than this, that I do not know of anything of more importance as far as the people are concerned than this particular benefit of keeping their teeth in order. I think it is a most disastrous thing that we should be faced to-day with the proposition that we cannot afford this treatment to people who had dental treatment before. I look upon this matter as of far greater importance even than hospital treatment. I do not consider the benefit of any other treatment equal at all to the benefit that can be derived from dental treatment. That is all I have to say, but I ask the Minister if it is at all possible for him to do so to make provision in the Bill for this dental treatment.

Comment on this

Has the Minister any estimate of the cost?

Comment on this

I have not got the figures of the whole cost yet.

Comment on this

Does the Minister admit that one-third of the present insurable people are in receipt of these dental benefits already?

Comment on this

I may say that it cost £1 to give dental treatment for every ten members. That would be a fair estimate. I think that is the case in some societies that are giving this benefit.

Comment on this

We ought to know this definitely and we should have the figures from the Minister. If a Deputy is able to stand up here and give us something like that why cannot we have the information from the Minister, why cannot we have something definite and not guesswork from a Deputy, the sort of guesswork that I might make myself. I have had the figures on this matter from time to time but I would not make any statement from these figures from memory. I would not fall back on my memory for that. I really think the Vice-President should have supplied us with some figures of that sort.

Comment on this

The whole finance of the scheme is based on an actuarial calculation on the basis of the present contributions. The present contributions are fully required to meet the present statutory benefits. We cannot increase the benefits without increasing the contributions. That is the financial basis of the scheme.

Comment on this

Is it not the position that some societies with a surplus have set aside some of that surplus for additional advantages and benefits for their members? Of all the benefits we are seeking to preserve this one of dental treatment is the vital one. We would take the risk on others.

Comment on this

If there was any hope from the figures I have got and the actuarial calculations made as to the money required to continue the present statutory benefits I would be agreeable to that. Certainly that is what I would consider a most desirable treatment, but some might argue in favour of dental treatment and some might argue in favour of optical benefit. Nobody will argue against it; everybody will want it. But the question is that the present contributions will not provide the funds to meet it.

Comment on this

That is the case in some of the societies.

Comment on this

The funds of the unified society would not meet it.

Comment on this

Does the Minister consider that there may be any possibility of giving these benefits?

Comment on this

We do not see that there is any possibility. We say that any surplus in the unified society will be dealt with as in the approved societies in the past. They will be used to provide additional benefits for the members and I do not see any possibility of our being able to do it.

Comment on this

We should have some estimate of the costs. The Minister may remember that on the Second Stage of the Bill he told us that in the unified society he would have a surplus of £55,000. In the answer he gave me to-day he dug up another £335,000.

Comment on this

That was mentioned on the last day.

Comment on this

I am not suggesting that the Minister concealed anything, but out of this surplus can he not see the possibility of a further benefit?

Comment on this

From which sums deficiencies on the other side will have to be deducted.

Comment on this

But that £55,000 does emerge. Then we do start with a surplus of at least £125,000.

Comment on this

That is so.

Comment on this

I take it then that the Minister is satisfied that the actuaries have borne that in mind when they advised him that they could not give other benefits.

Comment on this

I do not see the strength of the Minister's argument that people who do not require optical treatment would have some right to have a clause inserted that would guarantee benefits to them, but I do know this, that a number of people during the last five or ten years secured advantages and additional benefits from the approved societies. Some of them have had dental treatment. They have had their teeth extracted and new dentures have been given them. In some few cases they required optical or hospital treatment and got it. Therefore, I submit that they will have an equally good chance of getting the statutory benefit if the Minister is not assured that the actuarial figures will guarantee such benefits. Perhaps he would leave it to the discretion of the new Committee to formulate a scheme which would be suitable to cover all cases. This scheme would, perhaps, receive the sanction of the Minister.

Comment on this

Would the Minister be prepared to look into this matter and leave it over to the next stage of the Bill, when he could give us further information on it?

Comment on this

The information is that the matter has been closely examined from the financial point of view and there is no hope of including dental benefits.

Comment on this

Does the Minister not hope that if he went into the matter again with the actuaries it possibly would help matters? I say that because there is a feeling in the House that the different societies who have given their members dental treatment in the past are being denied something in the future. There is a strong feeling on that matter. If the Minister could do something to help both the members of the House and the members of these societies that have in the past initiated that treatment I think he would be meeting the matter.

Comment on this

There is nothing that would please me more than to be able to promise them.

Comment on this

Will the Minister look into it?

Comment on this

I will, of course. I would be very pleased to be able to promise dental, optical and any other benefits. We do not want to keep any of these from the people. There is only the measure of possibility. I am informed that it is out of the question to include any additional statutory benefit at this stage. There is no greater disposition on any side of the House than there is in the Ministry and in the Department dealing with this to increase the benefits as much as possible, but the money is not there.

Comment on this

Could the Minister even tell us on the next stage what the additional cost of the dental benefits would be?

Comment on this

I will try and get the figures.

Comment on this

The Minister said that he had the figures and that the actuary's report on the whole matter had been carefully and sympathetically considered. If so, could he give the House the figure by which the present sum would be increased by those who might receive this additional benefit after 5th July, 1936? He has not denied, I think, that one-third of the membership of insured societies are at present in receipt of this in addition to other valuable benefits.

Comment on this

I am not affirming or denying it, but I do not know what the proportion is. I doubt if it is one-third.

Comment on this

If the Minister could give us the figures of the additional cost, one could put that against his own estimated savings.

Comment on this

I will look up the figures and provide them on the Report Stage.

Comment on this

Will this amendment be reintroduced for the Report Stake?

Comment on this

That is for you to say.

Comment on this

It is quite definite that it will be.

Comment on this

Then it will be turned down.

Comment on this

Then we shall have a division on it now.

Comment on this

Very well, take it now. I do not want to mislead the House into thinking that there is any possibility of getting this statutory benefit. In case the House might be misled, I think you had better have the vote now.

Comment on this

Surely the Minister will agree that as a result of the unification some benefit ought to come to the insured people.

Comment on this

Yes.

Comment on this

Might I submit that there is not the least use getting impatient over this? It will not improve the situation to have the division taken now. If the Minister will examine the question and place the details that he has not at hand at present before the House on the Report Stage we can then take the division on the Report Stage and the matter can be dealt with. I know Deputy Davin and Deputy Norton want to do their "stuff."

Comment on this

We can do our "stuff" without asking you to help.

Comment on this