National Health Insurance Bill, 1933—Committee Stage.
Contributions 138–268 of 268. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
No. 14 of 1933 ›
I only got up in the interests of the people who might possibly get the benefit. I suggest that it might be to the advantage of these people if, before the House went to a division, there was an opportunity of considering the relevant facts. The Minister has not got these essential facts at his finger tips at present, but they can be got. They can be laid before the House and in the light of them the House can make up its mind. I suggest that it would be to the advantage of everybody if the matter were postponed to the Report Stage in order that we might have the essential information before we proceed to a vote. Deputy Davin can put down another amendment for the Report Stage.
Comment on this
Before a division is taken, I join with Deputy Dillon in asking that the division should be left over until the Report Stage. I concede that the Minister is sympathetic. He is just endeavouring to cut his cloth according to his measure. The plea that Deputy Dillon made is a very fair one. If the Minister further examines the question in the light of what has taken place during this discussion, perhaps he may be able to meet the suggestion made by Deputy Davin and also by Deputy Dillon. I ask the Minister if he does not consider that this is a case of plundering the well-managed and efficiently-run national health insurance societies? In view of the fact that many of these people, who have been insured in these societies for a considerable number of years, and have been receiving dental, optical and many other benefits which, according to the Minister, they will not continue to receive, does not the Minister consider that it is simply a raid on the funds of these efficiently-managed organisations? Will he not consult with the Parliamentary Secretary, who must have technical and professional knowledge of these matters, in view of what he has heard to-day and the fact that we take it for granted that he is sympathetic and that we all believe he is, which is a tribute rarely paid to any Minister? I suggest that Deputy Dillon is only asking him to reconsider the matter with a view to doing the merest justice to these persons who have been for many years contributing to national health organisations.
Comment on this
If we agree to postpone this division, will Deputy Anthony give an assurance to the Labour Party that he will have the other members of his Party here on the next stage when the division takes place?
Mr. Anthony rose.
Comment on this
I allowed Deputy Anthony to make a three-minute speech after I had risen to put the question.
Comment on this
I move amendment 9:—
In sub-section (1) to delete line 32 and substitute the following words: "such date vested in such society in its own name in relation to health insurance business or held by the trustees of such society."
This is merely a drafting amendment. A doubt arose in the mind of the draftsman as to whether line 32 is sufficiently clear to make it absolutely certain that the property of every society will be transferred to the unified society.
Comment on this
I move amendment 10:—
In sub-section (1) (d), line 52, after the word "society" to insert the words "on terms and conditions not less favourable on the whole than the terms and conditions on and under which such person was previously employed."
This section provides compensation, in the form of gratuities, to certain officers who lose their employment and are not offered employment in the unified society. Apparently the offer of employment in the unified society, under the Bill as it now stands, would preclude an officer seeking any compensation. Cases will occur, in connection with the transfer of staff from existing societies to the unified society, where a person who occupied the responsible position say of secretary of an existing society, with a certain scale of remuneration, might be transferred to a subordinate position in the unified society at a salary much less than in the existing society. But no matter what the conditions of transfer, under the Bill as it stands, he would be debarred from seeking compensation. My amendment seeks to preserve his right to compensation if transferred under conditions and terms that are less favourable than those that he now enjoys. I am sure the Minister does not intend that a person to be transferred should lose his right to compensation if he gets a subordinate position in the new society, not in any way comparable to that which he occupies in the existing society. I hope the Minister in the circumstances will accept my amendment.
Comment on this
I could not accept the amendment at all. I think the Deputy puts an exaggerated case when he suggests that a person holding a responsible position would be offered a subordinate post. If he is offered any post it will be a reasonable one in comparison with the post he held in the approved society in which he worked. I am satisfied that the offer of a reasonable post, taking into account the position occupied by the officials in the approved society, means that reasonable employment is offered to that person at remuneration as near as can be to his former position. I am not going to say, and we cannot bind ourselves, that the salary offered to any individual will be the same as he got in his approved society. I am told there are some approved societies that paid very generous salaries. I cannot hold out any hope that persons offered employment in the unified society will be paid the same salaries as they are now getting in their approved society. But I say that reasonable offers will be made to anyone selected for employment in comparison with the employment he previously held. That being so I think that if an individual turns down the offer made to him of permanent employment, in a unified society, he should abide the consequences. If there is no employment offered to such a person or if the managing committee were to offer him an unreasonable post that would bear no comparison to the post or the salary held in the approved society there would be some reason in turning it down, but so long as there is a reasonable offer made I think there is no cause for this amendment.
Comment on this
May I ask the Minister to advert to amendment No. 25, which enshrines a similar principle. The Minister should bear this in mind, that for the purpose of effecting savings we are going to vitally affect the livelihood of a number of people, many of whom have reached middle age, and some of them advanced middle age, in the public service. It should be borne in mind, when dealing with this problem, that these men did great service. They built up a great system for protecting the interests of defenceless people, and they built up machinery so effective that the Minister can now take over the whole thing in the certainty that it will go. I suggest to the Minister it is a hardship that departmental officials should have the right to transfer men from positions they at present occupy to others of inferior status. My knowledge of the Minister and his Department leads me to believe that the transfer would be done with every consideration, and that every endeavour would be made to do as ample justice as the circumstances would permit. But at the same time cases almost certainly will arise in which it is necessary to offer a man who held a position of high standing in his own society a position which is materially of lower status in the unified society. In such cases I press the Minister that some proviso should be made whereby those people would be consulted as to whether they wished to be taken over or not. I quite agree if a man is offered a position of equal status or advantage it is up to him to take it, or sacrifice his right to compensation; but where a person is offered a materially inferior position, I think the Minister should signify his readiness to accept Deputy Norton's amendment, or my amendment, No. 25, to protect these men. There will be very few such cases but, nevertheless, in individual cases it might mean real hardship. There is not a big sum involved. There is no possibility of embarrassing the fund or the Minister and I think he should signify his intention of accepting the one amendment or the other. I think mine is probably more moderate than that of Deputy Norton. If the Minister cannot accept Deputy Norton's, which I think is reasonable, he should make a promise that he will accept mine.
Comment on this
In refusing to accept the amendment moved by Deputy Norton the Minister has expressed his intention of doing something that will cause great alarm among the employees of approved societies. He has indicated that, in his opinion, they are generously treated in the way of remuneration and that we may visualise the slender staff that will be retained in the unified society to do the work of national health insurance being remunerated on a less generous scale than that which obtains in the case of the 65 societies throughout the country. That suggests that the policy of parsimony is going to be carried a little too far. The Minister has refused to accept what I believe is an eminently reasonable suggestion— that men who have given loyal service to national health insurance and who are to be transferred under this Bill to other positions ought to have a right to refuse such positions if they are not of a standard or status approximately equal or analogous to that of the positions that they have occupied in the local societies. Their refusal to accept the offer of such positions should not debar them from compensation if they are not satisfied that they are getting a fair crack of the whip from the unified society. The number of well-paid posts will be fewer and less generous remuneration is to be paid. These officials gave very valuable service in building up the local societies and they handed them over to the Minister in apple-pie order. The number of failures amongst the societies is a high tribute to the manner in which these men applied themselves to the interpretation of an intricate and complex Act. Notwithstanding the talk we hear of deficits, the societies have been very successful and it is due to these officials that they should be treated with the greatest possible generosity by the unified society. It is regrettable that the view should be expressed that these men will get less generous remuneration than, as officers in the local societies, they are getting. I think that the proposal in the amendment is the minimum that these employees can expect. They should have the right to decide for themselves whether or not they will accept the position offered. If a reasonable offer is made to them, they are not going to throw it away. But if the offer is such that they cannot accept it, they should be entitled to the compensation set out in the Act.
Comment on this
I think that there is considerable danger of hardship, such as is anticipated by the mover of the amendment, arising from the interpretation of the clause as it stands. While the Minister may say that it is not proper that a person who is offered a reasonable alternative post in the unified society should be entitled to insist that he get a better post, what really is desired by the amendment is that a person who is offered any sort of post should not be debarred from compensation because he refuses the offer. The effect of the section, as it stands, is that if one of these employees of an approved society refuses the offer of any sort of post he loses all possibility of getting compensation. In effect, the question of the reasonableness or unreasonableness of the offer of employment rests entirely with the provisional committee to be appointed pending the appointed day. There is no possibility of having that questioned in any way. The net effect of the section is that any offer of employment whatever will, if refused, debar the employee of the approved society entirely from compensation. He cannot question whether or not the offer was reasonable in the circumstances.
Comment on this
I should like to remind the Minister, before he speaks, that in previous legislation aiming at unification of essential public services and creating redundancy in these services the wording is on the same lines as the amendment moved by Deputy Norton. If the Minister looks up the Electricity Supply Act or the various Railways Acts passed by this House with the approval, in some cases, of some of the Minister's own Ministerial colleagues, he will find that we are merely asking to have a provision similar to that in those Acts inserted in this Bill. If the Minister believes that there was nothing unfair in the wording of these Acts, then there is nothing unfair in the working of this amendment. The man who occupies a position in an insurance society is entitled, at least, to the small amount of protection afforded by Deputy Norton's amendment. I am sure the Minister realises that this Act is not going to be interpreted, in respect of every section, in consultation with himself or with whomsoever occupies the position that he now holds. The Minister may have a fairly decent outlook on matters of this kind but he should make certain that what he looks upon as right, or what his Ministerial colleagues supported in this House, should not be watered down.
Comment on this
The question largely depends on the interpretation that will be put on the words "reasonable offer," or on the words in the amendment, "on terms and conditions not less favourable on the whole than the terms and conditions on and under which such person was previously employed."
Comment on this
Take the case of a person occupying a position worth £300 a year. If, instead of offering him £300 a year, we offered him £250, would that be a reasonable offer?
Comment on this
A person receiving £300 a year would, under the terms of the Bill, receive compensation to the amount of £900. If, instead of compensation, we offered that man a permanent position worth £250 a year, I think that would be a reasonable offer. If it went below that, probably it would not be a reasonable offer.
Comment on this
If the Minister's colleagues took that view on previous legislation of this kind, nobody would have got compensation under the Acts I have mentioned.
Comment on this
I am trying to get a near shot at what I think would be reasonable. I do not want to bind myself to offer exactly the same salary, because there are 65 secretaries of local societies and their salaries vary. There will be only one secretary and assistant secretary for the new society. There might be a dozen secretaries of approved societies getting to-day the same salary as will be offered to the secretary of the unified society, or they may be getting more. Only one of these secretaries can be made secretary of the new society. Only one can be appointed assistant secretary and we cannot give all the secretaries of approved societies the same salary as the secretary and assistant secretary of the unified society. If they accept employment, the salaries will have to be scaled down because there will be only one secretary and assistant secretary.
I do not know how many secretaries of approved societies are at present getting salaries, probably as high as, and maybe higher than will be offered to the new secretary. We cannot bind ourselves to give the same salaries. If a form of words could be found to cover this I would be willing to accept it. I cannot accept "on terms and conditions not less favourable" because that would be binding us to the salaries they are drawing.
Comment on this
Will the Minister look at amendment 25 on the Paper and at the words "then such person if he is dissatisfied with his employment."
Comment on this
Would not the Deputy agree that two years is a long time to take to make up a person's mind.
Comment on this
I think it is. The Minister has stated that if he offered a man £250 instead of £300, that that, in his opinion, would be a reasonable offer. The employee might think it a reasonable offer also. It would relieve his mind if he could go into the unified society and try to get along, with the security that if he found it would reduce his standard of living, or that the economies it entailed were too severe, he would be able to take his compensation and get out. The Minister might find that the vast majority of people would settle down in a good job, with perhaps a superannuation scheme and security ahead. Once they got going there would be no more trouble. Some people might think that a bird in the hand was worth two in the bush. They might take compensation plus a chance of getting outside employment, whereas if they had an assurance that within two years of going in, if they could make a reasonable case that the conditions they were employed under were not analogous to those they enjoyed before the transfer, they could withdraw. As many people might come in that difficulty would not arise. At the same time, it would secure them against the possibility of a severe degradation, without the option of retiring.
Comment on this
Here we have a Bill going through the Dáil without consulting the insured contributors, without consulting the employers or without consulting the committees of management of the societies. This House is definitely deciding that unification is necessary in the interests of the people and of the State. These people have no grievances whatever. They are quite satisfied to carry on, but the State steps in and says: "No, the whole course must be changed; you must have a unified society." If that is the position, surely the State ought to recognise that people whose whole mode of livelihood will be changed, whose economic conditions will probably be imperilled, should have a right to reasonable treatment as a result of the State deciding to embark on a unification scheme. The amendment, as Deputy Davin stated, is an eminently reasonable one. Similar provision has been made in the Railways Act, in the Shannon Power Acts, in the Civil Servants (Transferred Officers) Compensation Act and in the Greater Dublin Act. This House has already accepted the principle that if a man is transferred from one position to another he ought to be transferred on conditions not less favourable than he formerly enjoyed. That is all the amendment seeks to do, that a person who is not desirous of being transferred but that the State compels to transfer should be treated reasonably in the new conditions. The Minister said these persons will be offered reasonable employment but there is no obligation to offer reasonable employment. All the Minister has to do is to offer permanent employment. The Minister wants to import reasonable conditions into the agreement, but when we come to the Minister's definition of "reasonable" it means £300 less £50. He thinks that taking £1 off a person with £6 a week is a reasonable offer. I hope Deputy Cormae Breathnach will take a note of that and that he will be glad the teachers were not treated in a similar fashion. It is a most unreasonable attitude for the Minister to adopt. These people are entitled to expect that the State which is going to direct the course of their future will treat them fairly and reasonably.
The amendment seeks to ensure that they will not get less favourable terms than they enjoyed. The Minister says "we cannot do that." I began to wonder who "we" were. In this case, the compensation is provided by the unified society from the National Health Insurance Fund and is repayable to the fund. It is expected that amalgamation of societies will result in administration costs not being as high in the future as in the past. The compensation will be provided out of the administration funds. Seeing that it will be provided in that way, what is the difficulty in treating these people in the reasonable way—not in a generous way—that we seek to provide under this amendment? The State will not be asked to pay a halfpenny compensation, or to make any contribution whatever in respect of any compensation that they may be entitled to. The compensation will be provided by economies effected by unification. I think this amendment would be desirable in any circumstances, but is doubly desirable in view of the statement made by the Minister.
Comment on this
The Minister gave an instance of an employee with £6 a week being reduced to £5, and he considered that that employee ought to be very well satisfied. Apparently Deputy Norton thinks that he would not be satisfied. I find myself in agreement with Deputy Norton. Could the Minister pursue that illustration a little further, and tell the House at what point would a person with £6 a week have a right to make a case objecting to the reduction? Perhaps if the Minister could give us an idea of what the figure would be we would have an idea of what is in his mind.
Comment on this
The Deputy suggests 24/-. I will wait for the Minister to give us a guide as to what would be an unreasonable reduction in a salary of £6 a week.
Comment on this
Before the Minister replies I would like if he would give us his interpretation of the words in the section "the holder of a qualifying post under an approved society." Has he clearly defined what he means by persons holding a qualifying post? I want to ask the Minister if a person holding the position of a city parish secretary would be considered a person holding a qualifying post under the Bill?
The Minister must be aware that a number of very deserving persons have been engaged in building up the societies of the national health organisation for a considerable time. I think somebody in the House to-day referred to another class of men who have given their best years of service to the building up of these societies. The class of person to whom I refer is the parish secretary. His duties are multifarious. Amongst the number of things which he has to do are the collection and distribution of contribution cards, the issue of cards, the compilation of application forms for sickness and maternity benefits, the issue of forms of application for dental, surgical and hospital treatment, the completion of application forms in the case of new members, and so on. There is a number of other duties, but I do not want to take up the time of the House reading them out. These employees of the national health insurance societies have duties to perform from ten o'clock in the morning until six o'clock in the evening. The one with which I am best acquainted is the Diocesan Society of St. Finbarr in the City of Cork. They go on there in relays—one goes on from 10 a.m. to 12, another from 12 to 2 p.m. and so on, four of them operating from ten in the morning until six in the evening. That does not represent the full extent of their duties. When they have put in two hours in the office they have a good deal of other business to attend to. As indicating the importance of their duties, there is a case on record in the Diocesan Society of St. Finbarr in which one of these parish secretaries to whom I refer had to give up his position as it was considered so important and so onerous and he had to devote so much time to it that he had either to resign his position on the national health insurance society or resign his position in commercial employment which he held in the city. These positions, whilst looked upon as part-time positions, in reality are whole-time jobs. What I should like to know from the Minister is, does he consider these persons as coming within the terms of Section 21 of the Act and embraced in the words "the holder of a qualifying post?"
Comment on this
Deputy Anthony will find a definition of the persons holding qualifying posts in sub-section (3) of that section which he quoted—Section 21. Deputy Norton talks about the administration fund providing the money that is necessary. As a matter of fact, societies are exceeding at present the administration allowance, and I doubt if there are at present, without dipping further into the administration allowance to an extent which may be endangering the administration fund, money enough, without cheeseparing, to pay the compensation on the basis on which we propose to pay as things stand at present.
I did not say, and I do not say now, that it is reasonable to say to any individual: "We will take your post of £300 a year away from you and give you one back at £250 a year." What I did say, and what I say now, is that in the present circumstances, when we have to unify—even though, as Deputy Norton says, it was not asked for by the approved societies or by the committees—when we have to unify them, when circumstances force us to unify them and when it is certain that a number of people may be thrown out of employment, we have to offer them the alternative of an amount of £900, which is three years' salary at £300 a year, as compensation for the abolition of the post, or to accept a post at £250 a year for permanency. I think that it is a reasonable alternative. It would not be reasonable to say to the official: "We are going to dock you one-sixth of your pay" unless he was going to be thrown out of employment. But when the alternative is between £900 compensation or offering him a permanent post of £250 a year I regard the £250 a year as reasonable.
Comment on this
The Minister stated that he considered that if the man were offered £250 a year for a permanency as against the previous £300 a year, it would be a reasonable alternative to £900 compensation. Would the man have the option of taking the £900 or would he have to take the post at £250?
Comment on this
I certainly think that if a man who got an offer of a permanent post of £250 a year it would be unreasonable for him to refuse that offer.
Comment on this
People, as a matter of fact, expect progression in their salaries after working for so many years and they do not expect to be going back in their salaries.
Comment on this
I quite agree with the Minister that as between an official offered a sum of £900, or three years' salary at £300 a year and, alternatively, a permanent salary of £250 a year, there would be very little hardship. At the same time, it is as well to point out to the Minister that one could also put forward a case as regards an officer who was in receipt of a salary of £300 and who would be offered alternative employment at a rate of, say £150 a year. I do not think the Minister would regard that as equitable or fair.
Comment on this
Whilst that might be the viewpoint of the Minister, as far as I personally am concerned I more or less agree with him and trust that the Minister would act fairly and justify to the officials. Nevertheless, the Minister might not be in the position at all. There might be some other man in his place who would be less sympathetic to these officials and who would offer permanent employment at a very much lower figure. It is in order to have some safeguard in the Act that this amendment was suggested by Deputy Norton in order that it, or something of the kind that would put a proper interpretation on what was in the mind of the Minister in regard to the words "permanent employment," should be enshrined in the Act.
Comment on this
If it would meet the requirements of those who are insisting on this amendment to put in the word "reasonable," or some such word that would qualify it, such as "permanent employment at reasonable remuneration" or "reasonable terms"—if any phrase of that kind would cover it, well and good, but if not I cannot do any better.
Comment on this
Amendment put.
Do you agree with this result?
I move amendment No. 11:
To delete sub-section (2) and substitute three new sub-sections as follows:—
(2) (a) Every person entitled to compensation under this section who had less than five completed years of qualifying service shall be entitled to a gratuity calculated on the basis of one-sixth of his remuneration and emoluments for the year ended on the 30th day of June, 1932, for every completed year of his employment.
(b) Every person entitled to compensation under this section who had not less than five completed years of qualifying service and who by reason of the establishment of the unified society:—
(a) has suffered loss of employment; or
(b) has relinquished his employment in consequence of being required to perform duties such as were not similar or were an unreasonable addition to the duties which he was required to perform by such approved society at the date of transfer; or
(c) has suffered diminution of salary, wages or emoluments; or
(d) has been placed in any worse position in respect of the conditions of his employment than he was in that respect on the date of transfer; or
(e) has suffered any direct pecuniary loss in consequence of the establishment of the unified society including any loss of prospective superannuation or other retiring or death allowances and allowances to his widow or orphan children,
shall be entitled to receive compensation in accordance with and subject to the provisions of this section hereinafter contained.
(3) The compensation to be paid under paragraph (b) of sub-section 2 of this section to a person who either:—
(a) has suffered loss of employment; or
(b) has relinquished his employment in consequence of being required to perform duties such as were not similar or were an unreasonable addition to the duties which he was required to perform on the date of transfer;
shall be an annual sum not exceeding in any case two-thirds of the remuneration and emoluments payable to him for the year ended on the 30th day of June, 1932, and subject to that limitation to be calculated at the rate of one-sixtieth of the said remuneration and emoluments for every completed year of his service with the approved society with an addition thereto based on the number of completed years of his service and calculated according to the following scale:—
If he has twenty or more completed years of service an addition of ten-sixtieths of his remuneration and emoluments;
If he has less than twenty completed years of service then such addition shall abate proportionately and so that no person shall receive an addition of less than one-sixtieth of his remuneration and emoluments for every completed two years of his service.
(4) The compensation to be paid under paragraph (b) of sub-section (2) of this section to a person who either:—
(a) has suffered loss or diminution of salary, wages, emoluments; or
(b) has been placed in any worse position in respect of the conditions of his employment than he was in at the date of transfer; or
(c) has suffered any direct pecuniary loss in consequence of the establishment of the unified society, including any loss of prospective superannuation or other retiring or death allowances and allowances to his widow or orphan children;
shall be an annual sum not exceeding in any case two-thirds of the remuneration and emoluments payable to him for the year ended on the 30th day of June, 1932, and subject to that limitation as nearly as possible the equivalent in money of the annual diminution in remuneration and emoluments or of the worsening of the conditions of his employment (as the case may be) including any direct pecuniary loss suffered by him and shall be payable during the continuance of the employment in which such annual diminution in remuneration and emoluments or such worsening of the conditions of his employment (as the case may be) is so suffered by him as aforesaid.
In moving this amendment, my object is to provide for the persons affected some more reasonable measure of compensation than that provided by the Minister in the Bill. Under the Bill, the Minister provides compensation in certain circumstances, assessed at one-eight of the annual remuneration where the person has less than ten years' service, and one-sixth of the annual remuneration where he has ten or more completed years of service, but subject to an overriding maximum of three years' salary. Many of the arguments that could have been used on this section have been already used on the previous amendment. Here again, it is hardly necessary to point out in any detailed way, the State comes in, and creates a situation by this unification Bill, the effect of which is to prevent these people following the occupations which they formerly followed. The State in that way interferes with their livelihood and yet the compensation provided by the Minister under this section is a maximum of three years' salary. Many of these people will have given 22 years' service to the business of administering the national health insurance. Many of them are people highly skilled in the knowledge not merely of the Act but of the thousand and one regulations made under the Act. Many of them have reached an advanced age at the moment. Here the State steps in and interferes with their employment, jeopardises their livelihood and then offers to pay them three years' salary. We must add to that the fact that they are not likely to get any further employment having regard to their past avocations. That is, to say the least of it, treating these people in a most unreasonable way.
The amendment which I propose provides that these persons shall be paid as a gratuity one-sixth of the salary for each completed year's service. That is for persons having under five years' service. For those with a service of over five years, my amendment seeks to provide compensation in the form of an annual allowance calculated at one-sixteenth of the salary for each year's service, subject to an overriding maximum of two-thirds of the remuneration and emoluments in the year ending 30th June, 1932, with the addition, as already recognised in legislation, of certain added years in compensation for the abolition of the person's office. Under this amendment of mine, it would be possible for a person to get compensation if he is dismissed, or if he is compelled to relinquish his employment because the conditions are not similar, or are an unreasonable addition to the duties which he was formerly required to perform. The amendment provides also for the payment of compensation if a person suffers loss or diminution of salary, wages or emoluments, or if he is put in any worse position as a result of his transfer, or if he suffers any other kind of loss set out in sub-section 4 (c) of the amendment.
I think the House will agree that a person who suffers loss of employment is entitled to compensation and that a person whose salary or wages is reduced is likewise entitled to compensation. If the State seeks to transfer a person from a reasonably remunerated post to a post which is not remunerated so well it worsens that person's position. If he is put in a worse position than he occupied previously he is entitled to compensation. In assessing compensation the Minister is confining himself to a gratuity basis, giving people with 22 years' service in national health insurance work a gratuity of three years' salary. That method of remuneration or compensation is not the normal method or the method that the legislation passed through the House for the past ten years has recognised. In all cases it is recognised that persons with a certain service are entitled to an annual pension. That particular point has been already conceded in the case of the Electricity Supply Board, in the case of the Railways Act, in the case of the Greater Dublin Act, and in the case of the Civil Service (Transferred Officers) Compensation Act. Seeing that the State has adopted this principle of compensation in cases somewhat analogous to the cases with which we are now dealing I do not see any reason why the State should depart from that method of compensation now.
That is a reasonable piece of legislation which has been endorsed by this House, supported by all Parties in the House, and it seems utterly unreasonable to come along now and give to people who have 22 years' service in national health insurance, who were responsible for the smooth and satisfactory running of the National Health Insurance Acts for the past 20 years, such miserable compensation as is provided in the sections of the Bill introduced by the Minister. I hope the House will show irrespective of Party that they stand for a square deal for these officers who are being transferred to the unified society. These officers are quite willing to carry on with the unified society and give their services to that society, and if they lose their employment or if their conditions are in any way worsened they are entitled to compensation on not less generous terms than the State provides in the case of civil servants, in the case of railway employees under the Railways Act, and in the case of persons affected by the Greater Dublin Bill and the Electricity Supply Bill. There is a strong case for extending to these officers the same consideration as the legislature has already extended to other officers, and I hope that, irrespective of Party, the House will say definitely that it wants a square deal for these people whose interests and livelihood are jeopardised by the action the State is taking in the matter.
Comment on this
Will the Minister, in dealing with that, say what his intentions are in respect of amendment 15?
Comment on this
Deputy Norton suggests that we should deal with the officials in this case as generously as we would deal with civil servants. What he proposes is that they should be dealt with on a much more generous basis that civil servants in the cases in which the offices of civil servants were abolished, but, in the case of the abolition of their office, civil servants would not get the terms that Deputy Norton is suggesting that these officials of approved societies should get.
Comment on this
I am talking of the terms provided in the Civil Servants (Transferred Officers) Act.
Comment on this
They were, but under special conditions. They were being transferred from one country to another. There was quite a different set of conditions and circumstances in that case from what we are dealing with in this Bill. The civil servant who is dealt with in respect of abolition of office is, to start with, a pensionable officer while these officers of approved societies are not. The civil servant's salary scale is much lower because he is a pensionable officer, and, if his office is abolished, and if he has ten years' service, all he gets in the way of pension is based on one-eightieth for each year of service, plus a gratuity based on one-thirtieth.
Comment on this
The amendment that Deputy Norton proposes would give these non-pensionable employees of approved societies not only one-sixtieth calculated on service, but added years on the general scale. Our position is that anything that is done in the way of compensation or gratuity has to be paid out of the administration fund. The administration fund is limited and, at present, the societies are exceeding the administration allowance. At present, that allowance is about 4/9 instead of 4/5, and, in order to provide this compensation, we shall have to dip into the administration fund to a heavy extent and to take from the administration fund moneys which ordinarily should be required for administration. We will, of course, make some economies, because the various expenses of the approved societies, such as office expenses and salaries, are bound to be reduced. We will thus be able to make economies. Therefore, the whole of the sum now spent on administration will not be necessary. We shall have to use these economies plus further economies that we shall have to make in order to be able to pay the compensation on the scale we propose to pay.
Perhaps it is just as well that I should say, at this stage, that, while I cannot at all accept the amendment proposed by Deputy Norton—the fund will not allow it—I propose to accept, at any rate, in principle, amendments 12, 13, 14 and 15, in the name of Deputy Dillon. It is with a certain amount of trepidation that I am accepting these amendments. I will not say that it is against the advice of the Department, but the Department certainly has accepted them under pressure from me. I thought that the compensation ought to be increased even to the extent of taking a risk when we were putting these people out of employment and it was only under the very greatest pressure from me that the officials eventually decided that we might risk it. They do, however, impress upon me that it is taking a risk with the administration fund. That risk I am prepared to take and, if the fund would allow it, I should like to go further, but there is no earthly hope of that. There is no earthly hope of basing the compensation on the scale that Deputy Norton has set out in his amendment. In the case of the pension scheme, he mentioned the Railways Act and the Electricity Act, but they were dealing with affairs that were business affairs and supposed to be making a profit. The moneys came from the shareholders' pockets while, in this case, the money will come out of the fund of the national health insurance societies and we will be robbing them of the benefits to which they are entitled. It will be a case of robbing Peter to pay Paul. It is the people who would be sick and infirm and entitled to the statutory benefits who would be losing and we cannot afford to take any more from these people in the way of benefits.
Any further addition to my proposal would be taking money out of the fund provided for statutory benefits and that we cannot do. The only other alternative would be to tax the contributions to national health insurance by both employers and employees and that, I do not think, would meet with the approval of this House either. Therefore, we propose to go to the furthest limit and to take some risk in going that far with the administration fund. It will be going to the fund to an extent that some of my advisers say is not right, but, on the whole, we have decided to take the risk and to go as far as we can to meet these people because we are putting them out of employment. I should like to go further—it is my own personal attitude—and I must say that the officials feel the same way about officers being put out of employment but they want to safeguard the funds of national health insurance and that is our first concern. That being so, we cannot go any further and we cannot accept Deputy Norton's amendment.
Comment on this
When I first examined these proposals, I was inclined to the view that superannuation was the most equitable arrangement. I saw that there was a great deal to be said against superannuation, not the least being the difficulty of financing it, and I must say that I consider that the Minister has met this problem as generously and as fairly as his resources would permit. I am not authorised to speak for anybody on the matter but I have watched the business as it went forward with considerable anxiety to see that these men who would prove redundant as a result of this scheme of unification would be fairly dealt with.
Taking into consideration the fact that the Minister proposes to accept in principle amendments 12 to 15 inclusive, in my opinion and in the opinion of my colleagues he has done what is fair by these people. So far as we are concerned, we appreciate the spirit in which he has met the situation and the spirit in which he has provided compensation. We recognise that had it been possible financially he would have gone further. Having gone so far as he has is an indication of that. I am sure he feels with us that it would have been desirable to go further if such were possible without seriously embarrassing the administration. Taking everything into consideration, he has met the situation generously.
Comment on this
Deputy Dillon speaks in a tone of voice which makes those who do not know him feel that he speaks with the authority of a person who is infallible on every subject. He did not tell us, as he should have, the difference between the cost to the administration fund if the Minister accepts his amendments compared with the cost of £90,000 that would accrue as a result of the compensation clauses in the Bill as originally introduced. The Minister has assured us throughout this discussion that he has made a careful study of the consequences from the point of view of compensation and further concessions to insured members. Perhaps the Minister will tell us a little more of the information at his disposal. He told us the cost of compensation would be £90,000. Will he tell us—I am sure he can, after agreeing to accept Deputy Dillon's amendments—what would be the increased cost to the administration fund as a result of the acceptance of Deputy Dillon's suggestions? Will he also tell us what would be the cost arising out of the acceptance of the amendment moved by Deputy Norton?
There is no reason whatsoever, from the Labour Party point of view, at any rate, why the members of this Party or the Cumann na nGaedheal Party should vote for the insertion in this Bill of certain clauses in the Electricity Supply Act and the Railways Act, watering down the measure of compensation. The Minister says that the compensation in these cases is being paid by business companies supposed to be making a profit. I do not think that the Minister for Industry and Commerce, when putting the Electricity Supply Bill through the House or when pushing the Railways Bill through, could have at that time indicated what the cost was likely to be. He first approached the consideration of the whole question from the point as to what was likely to be fair to those going to lose their livelihood as a result of legislation passed here. If I wanted to, I could quote several passages from speeches made by the Minister's colleagues supporting the same principle in the case of previous legislation concerning people who did lose their livelihood as a result of the passage of legislation. What grounds can he give for reversing the policy adopted by himself and his colleagues when they were in Opposition, in relation to matters of the same kind?
I have been told that three-fourths of the existing servants of approved societies are likely to be taken over by the unified society. I do not know whether that figure is right or wrong. The Minister could give more figures than he has given in connection with this matter. On the Second Reading the Minister indicated that he had reached the limit—that the compensation section of the Bill was the limit to which he could agree to go so far as paying compensation to redundant officials were concerned. He said they were doing the best they could with the moneys available. Deputy Dillon, who apparently knows more than the Minister about every aspect of the Bill, without having any official figures at his disposal, says that the Minister has acted as generously as his resources would permit. Where did he get the information? Has he more information than the Minister on this matter? If he has, then it is due to the House that this person who recently posed as an expert should give us what information he has. Seeing that the Minister did not accept the water-tight amendment which Deputy Dillon proposed this evening in connection with those who will get the positions of secretary and treasurer, I suggest that the Minister might, in the light of the very valuable advice given him by Deputy Dillon on the question of national health insurance and in view of the financial limitations supposed to be involved in the acceptance of our amendment, seriously consider the absorption of Deputy Dillon as one of the principal officer of the unified society when it is established.
Comment on this
I want to correct one or two statements made by the Minister. The Minister stated that I was claiming more for the insurance official than for a civil servant. Either the Minister's brief is wrong, or the Minister has not had time to read it. If he looks at it again he will find that in the case of the civil servants there are two schemes of superannuation, one concerning one-sixtieth for each year of service and the other one-eightieth for each year of service, plus a lump sum.
Comment on this
Perhaps the Minister will recollect the legislation concerning the Dublin and Blessington steam tram which was recently passed by his own administration. His own Minister for Industry and Commerce justified the compensation. Now the Minister wants to justify this Bill which is, to my mind, most unsatisfactory.
Comment on this
This Bill provides inadequate compensation. The hair shirt is put right through this whole section. The Minister thinks this is generous compensation and Deputy Dillon congratulates him upon the generous attitude he has adopted. It would seem as if there were a new alliance between Deputy Dillon and the Centre Party and the Minister. Deputy Dillon is saying everything that is complimentary about the Minister so long as it is reactionary. I must congratulate the Minister on his new convert. I would go even further than Deputy Davin; I would suggest that Deputy Dillon might not merely be absorbed into the unified society but he should be absorbed into the Ministry. Apparently he will be found to be a very accommodating gentleman judging by the things he is prepared to say and do in the House. I again emphasise that this measure of compensation is thoroughly unsatisfactory. It is unfair for the Minister to tell Deputies that the measure of compensation we seek can only be provided either by increasing the rates of contribution or by taking benefits from sick people. The Minister knows that is not true. I do not accept that as the position and the Minister's advisers know perfectly well it is not the position. In any case, so far as we are concerned, we do not accept it as the position. It is true that the societies find a difficulty at the moment in carrying on under the administration grant but that is because there are 65 offices, 65 telephones, 65 separate secretaries and 65 separate sets of furniture. One would expect that with unification a very considerable economy would be effected there. The working of the Act will disclose what the economies will be.
Comment on this
Our attitude on this Bill has been dealt with at some length already. The difference between us and the Labour Party in relation to this Bill is this: That we have tried to amend the Bill to the best advantage and for the benefit of any person who might otherwise suffer under it. But the Labour Party is concerned to-night to "do its stuff" here, to edify the railwaymen and the post office workers and all the diverse persons from whom Deputies Norton and Davin cherish the hope of getting a vote in the future. They salute their flag and salute their staff.
Comment on this
I will discuss that with the Deputy on another occasion. Once this Bill was introduced my Party here took it to be their duty to do everything in their power to assist the Government to make it a more equitable and, possibly, a more generous measure. So far as we are concerned we are of opinion that the Government has made a genuine and generous attempt to meet the exigencies of the situation. Our position is that when they do that we deem it our duty to support them in that course. If they fail in that course we consider it our duty to vote against them. The jibes from Deputy Davin and Deputy Norton and from others on the Labour Benches are interpreted by us rather as compliments coming from the quarter they come. Praise or compliments from the Labour Benches would be received by us with very uneasy feelings and with heart searchings. The Labour Party only a short time ago pursued a very different course towards the Government. But they are now trimming their sails. We followed a different course all the time.
Comment on this
The question I have to put is: that the words:—"The compensation payable to a person entitled to this compensation under this section shall be a gratuity," stand part of the section. That matter is disposed of by the Minister in Section 21 (2).
Comment on this
If Deputy Dillon's amendments are defeated by the House they cannot be moved again on Report Stage.
Comment on this
If something is defeated in Committee Stage it cannot be accepted on Report Stage but the House as a whole can disagree with what it has done in Committee. The House as a whole can refuse to assent to what it has done in Committee.
Comment on this
You are not entitled to a clear division on an amendment of this kind. Conceivably we could defeat this amendment and Deputy Dillon's amendments and still stand by the Bill.
Comment on this
Seeing that the Minister has accepted the principle cannot Deputy Dillon's amendment remain over for Report Stage?
Comment on this
The question I have to put is: that the words "The compensation payable to a person entitled to compensation under this section shall be a gratuity," stand part of the Bill.
Comment on this
That means that our amendment though it was allowed to be discussed is not to be decided by the vote of the House.
Comment on this
I take it that if we vote for the question put from the Chair we are really voting against the amendment in Deputy Norton's name.
Comment on this
That is so. If Deputy Davin will read his own amendment he will find that it was to be the sum provided for pensions. The other would be a gratuity. I want the House to understand that before I put the question.
Comment on this
If I were putting the positive case I would cut out Deputy Dillon from moving his amendment because if the House decided that the amendment stands he could not move amendments 12, 13, 14 and 15.
Comment on this
I propose to accept in principle amendments 12, 13, 14 and 15. There may be some amendments that we cannot have discussed. The principle of these four amendments is accepted.
Comment on this
I heard the Minister say that no material alternation would be made in the amendments. I ask the leave of the House to withdraw them.
Comment on this
Might I say that the additional sum that would be put on the administration fund by these amendments would be round about £50,000 or £60,000. If we were to accept the amendment moved by Deputy Norton and Deputy Davin the total cost would be round about a quarter of a million pounds as against £140,000. That is a sum we could not face.
Comment on this
I move amendment 16:—
In sub-section (3) (a) (i), line 12, after the word "secretary" to insert the words "treasurer or other salaried officer."
This is an amendment designed to bring in principally the treasurer of an approved society. The Minister will note that there is mention specially of the secretary and whole-time employees and part-time employees who derive the greater part of their income from salaries as servants of an approved society. But it would seem, however, that a part-time treasurer who was an officer held in a society a status similar to that of the secretary. If he were only a part-time employee he would be entitled to no compensation at all. It seems to me, as the Minister has accepted the principle that the secretary, being an officer of the society, and, therefore, an employee, is entitled to compensation, that principle should be extended to include the treasurer as well. Very probably the sum involved here would be trivial. Where the treasurer was a part-time employee his work was largely formal and his remuneration was proportionate. There may, however, have been and, I think, there were certain cases where the treasurer's duties were more than formal and he occupied something in the nature of the position of general consultant to the secretary. Officially, of course, that could not be recorded; for official purposes he was treasurer of the society. But in these cases where he was acting in the nature of consultant to the secretary his remuneration was sometimes a material sum, perhaps £100 a year. These cases would be very few and the amount that would fall upon the administration fund for compensation in respect of treasurers would be very small. A real hardship, however, might accrue if they are not provided for and it is to provide for the possibility of such hardships that I have put down the amendment.
Comment on this
Amendment 17 is an alternative, because if you dealt with them under amendment 16 you gave them compensation whether they derive the major part of their income from employment or not. Amendment 17 is merely to ensure that there should be no doubt that a treasurer was an employee.
Comment on this
I do not think that there is any case where a treasurer, who was not a whole-time official of an approved society, was anything but a consultant such as Deputy Dillon suggests. I do not think there is any case for compensating a consultant, no matter how frequently he may have been consulted. If the treasurer occupied any position in the society, whole-time or mainly whole-time, and if he derived most of his income from that employment, of course he will be compensated. Otherwise I am afraid there is not any case for a treasurer.
Comment on this
The Minister perhaps throws undue emphasis on the case I described, where this individual might be employed in a consultative capacity. In these few cases these men would have received much larger salaries than treasurers normally receive. Treasurers are usually rather figureheads, simply for the purpose of singing cheques, and got £10, £15 or £20 a year for filling that job, but there were a few cases in which they got a more material sum. £100 a year, say, is a very material part of an income to a man, but we are proposing to wipe that out without any compensation. What I am putting is this: that compensating the vast majority of treasurers will cost practically nothing, because they were only in receipt of £10 a year or so. There may not be more than 60 treasurers and a great many of these are banks. Therefore, I doubt very much that there will be more than 30 or 40 men holding the position of treasurer. The burden it is going to place on the administration fund is trivial, but the burden that it might place on individuals, if a provision of this kind is not made, might be very severe indeed and might materially alter the whole standard of living. I do not wish to press this at present. If the Minister would look into the circumstances and ascertain if there were any such persons as I have described between this and the Report Stage, he might undertake to deal with it himself on the Report Stage, if it requires attention. I imagine that if he looks into it he will find there are going to be three or four hard cases if they get no compensation, whereas if he decides to compensate them, all individual treasurers, except the banks, who are corporate bodies, he will find that the burden will be the merest bagatelle and he will avoid doing serious harm.
Comment on this
I am afraid I have gone to the limit already with the administration fund. Any further encroachment upon the fund would put it in a state that I would hesitate to put it in.
Comment on this
I move amendment 17:—
In sub-section (3) (a) (iii) line 14 after the words "part-time employee" to insert the words "treasurer or other salaried officer."
Would the Minister not even consider taking the men as employees? He said that the only treasurer who can apply for compensation was a person who could satisfy the Minister that the larger part of his income was derived from his position as treasurer. Will the Minister allow them to come in under that category?
Comment on this
Certainly if the treasurer is able to satisfy the Minister that the larger part of his income comes from that employment he will be compensated.
Comment on this
It is clear then that the introduction of the word "treasurer" after the word "employee" is unnecessary—employee covers treasurer?
Comment on this
I move amendment 18:—
At the end of sub-section (3) (a) (iii) line 17, after the word "livelihood" to insert the words:—"or that he was performing work usually performed by wholetime employees."
The wording of the amendment explains its meaning.
Comment on this
If the amendment is meant to cover a person who, though free to do other work, is actually performing duties for a society which would normally occupy his whole time he would be regarded as entitled to compensation.
Comment on this
If that is the meaning of it, I will accept the amendment, but I think it will have to be redrafted. If the meaning of it is that the individual concerned gave so much time to it as would normally make it a whole-time position he would be entitled to compensation. I will put up an amendment on the Report Stage if the Deputy wishes.
Comment on this
I move amendment 19:—
In sub-section (3) (b), line 24, to delete the word "continuously."
If the sub-section is passed in its present form it might be found to operate unjustly in several cases. It would provide that employment should be continuous and that all voluntary or enforced absence would not be allowed for. The object I had in mind in putting down this amendment was to ensure that employees of approved societies who had their services broken by activities during the civil war, by strikes and so forth, would have that time allowed them, but I notice that Deputy Costello has put down amendment No. 20 which covers the point I have in mind. It probably makes the position clearer, with the exception of the word "strikes." He makes no provision here in amendment 20 to provide for those people who went on strike. Such cases have come to my notice, that people in approved societies have been on strike in the past. I would like to make provision for them. Perhaps I ought to pay a compliment to Deputy Costello for the drafting of this amendment No. 20—although it may be premature until he is allowed to move it—seeing that he has accepted the principle that both parties in the civil strife are entitled to recognition.
Comment on this
I cannot accept amendment No. 19 as moved by Deputy Kelly, but I would propose to accept the amendment by Deputy Costello which covers the same thing. I think Deputy Kelly is rather suggesting that he would accept that.
Comment on this
If it would cover those people who had been on strike.
Comment on this
I do not know whether there are any such cases or not. At any rate, I would not hold that being out on strike would break the continuity of the employee's service.
Comment on this
Before it is withdrawn I would like to feel that the Minister would give some consideration to it. There has been talk about armies. I am not interested in any army. I know cases where a man's service was broken; the son was asked by the father to carry on the position for a period so that the proceeds would be coming in to the family. If you put in the word "continuously" there you knock this man, whose main source of livelihood is that position, out of getting any compensation.
Comment on this
There may be various reasons why a man had to go away for a period of a year or two, and his son asked and got the approval of the society to carry on the position. When the father came back he resumed his own position. If he had let the position go to an outsider that source of income, which was very necessary to the family, would have gone out of the family altogether. Possibly there would be a very grave danger that it would never come back.
Comment on this
I think that in accepting Deputy Costello's amendment, which covers a wide variety of cases, and the principle of the one suggested by Deputy Kelly to include people who may have been on strike, if there are such cases, all that could be reasonably expected to be covered in the way of broken service will have been covered.
Comment on this
Might I ask the Minister if he can have included the word "strikes"? From former experience in this House I found that where the Minister's intentions were expressed in debates but not definitely put into the Bill, which subsequently became an Act, the fact of it having been stated that that was the intention meant nothing because it was not in the Bill. In that case I should like to know if the Minister would include the word.
Comment on this
We will put in this new section proposed by Deputy Costello, with some words to cover the position mentioned by Deputy Kelly. We will have it on the Report Stage.
Comment on this
I move amendment 21 on behalf of Deputy Good:—
In sub-section (3) (b) line 26, after the word "service" to insert the words "Provided that where such person was temporarily unemployed by reason of illness or in consequence of a vacancy not being available in an approved society when no interval shall be deemed to have elapsed if he resumed his employment with an approved society as soon as reasonably possible, but such period or periods of temporary unemployment shall not be reckoned in computing his total period of qualifying service.
Comment on this
I move amendment 22:—
In sub-section (3) (c), line 28, after the words "taken to be," to delete the words down to the word "remuneration," inclusive, in line 43 and to substitute the words "his annual remuneration for the year ended on the 30th day of June, 1932, and in calculating his annual remuneration any amount or amounts paid to such person for the provision of clerical assistance or other expenses shall not be treated as part of his remuneration.
This amendment has two objects. In the first place, it aims at calculating the remuneration as on the 30th June, 1932, and not, as in the Bill, for the previous five years. I can understand that there is a good case to be made for taking the average of five years; at the same time I do suggest to the Minister that people who have got say an increase of salary just before June, 1932, by reason of their special merits, ought to be entitled in the circumstances created by this Bill to have their compensation assessed on the basis of the actual salary they were in receipt of on the date in question. There can, I think, be no question that no approved society would have artificially increased the salary of any employee with a view to getting compensation, because I think that the provisions of this Bill were not generally expected. In any event, the bad case should not prejudice the good one. I would suggest that particular point for the consideration of the Minister.
The second point in the amendment aims at allowing the question of bonus to be considered in assessing the compensation, for the reason that as I understand it the amount available for administrative expenses depends upon the number of effective members each year. That cannot be ascertained until the end of the year; therefore, it was the practice in a number of approved societies to give a fixed salary to their officers, with the intention—when they knew what their proper financial position was at the end of the year—of increasing that salary by way of bonus. In effect then, the bonus was really part of the salary, but only ascertained when the facts were available for the society.
Comment on this
I cannot accept this amendment. The question of unification has been before the country for a considerable time. It has been discussed, I think, for years, and the fact that it would be necessary to unify was announced to the approved societies and to the public a considerable time ago. In at least one case there has been an effort to forestall the provisions of this Bill by rushing increases of salaries to officials. We think that it is necessary to average the period of salary over five years, and that is as fair a way as any of measuring the compensation. At any rate, the compensation we propose to give has been calculated on the average over five years, and we have stretched that out in accordance with the demands that were made here in the House, and the feeling that there should be a more generous scale of compensation. We have stretched it out and given out of the administration fund as much as we think that fund can afford. We cannot contemplate increasing the draw on that fund to any extent beyond what we have done.