We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

Public Services (Temporary Economies) Bill, 1933—Committee.

Contributions 1–214 of 622. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 3 parts.

Bill Public Services (Temporary Economies) Bill, 1933
Enacted

No. 12 of 1933 ›

Seán MacEntee Minister for Finance (Mr. MacEntee) Fianna Fáil

I move: "That Section 1 stand part of the Bill."

Comment on this

I move amendment 1:—

At the end of the section to add a new sub-section as follows:—

This Act shall continue in force until the 31st day of March, 1934, or, in the event of agreement between the Government of the United Kingdom of Great Britain and Northern Ireland and the Government of the Irish Free State on the matters in dispute between the aforesaid Governments, until the date of the coming into force of such agreement if such date occurs before the said 31st day of March, 1934, and shall then expire (as the case may be).

I intend to occupy as little time as I can, because the volume of adverse criticism of this Bill is reflected in the fact that there are 12 pages of amendments to it. The Bill is described as a temporary measure, and the House has been assured that it is proposed to impose these cuts in salaries only for the period of the current financial year. If my amendment is accepted these cuts will cease to operate as from the date when a settlement of the financial dispute with Great Britain is reached. I am moving the amendment for two reasons. The first is that the cuts set down in the Bill are necessitated—if they are necessary at all—by reason of the economic war, and the continuance of the economic war. There is no reason why they should continue during the whole of the current financial year, if the waste of the public resources of this country is brought to an end during that year by a settlement of the economic dispute with Great Britain. The second reason is that I accept, for the purpose of this discussion, the assurances that were given from every Fianna Fáil platform at the last general election, that if that Party were returned to power an immediate and successful settlement of the economic dispute would be reached. I say that these cuts are necessitated solely by the economic war, and by the continuance of that economic war, because we must, of course, accept as sincere the promises made to the public during the last general election and the one that preceded it, promises on which the Fianna Fáil Party were returned to power. I have here a manifesto that that Party published during the last general election, and the previous one, and the things which were promised show clearly that, instead of reducing the standard of living of civil servants, and the very large body of employees who, although technically not civil servants, are persons paid out of public moneys, civic guards, teachers and others, they were all promised a higher standard of living if that Party were returned to office. Here are the promises: "More employment, more houses, more factories, more tillage, less extravagance, end of destitution, stop emigration."

Comment on this

That one is correct.

Comment on this
Mr. Rice

Three days before the general election in February of last year we were told "Fianna Fáil has a Plan". We have all heard of this before, but it is good that we should hear it again. I wish the Minister for Finance would keep these posters, frame them, and hang them up in his office, and when he is considering a new attack on the capital and the resources of this country that he would read them every morning. In the poster issued three days before the general election of last year, the promise was made that there would be 80,000 odd new people put into employment. As a matter of fact, perfect details were given, because the figure was brought down not merely to thousands or hundreds, but that 84,605 new people were to be brought into employment. For the farmers there were to be increased profits and, of course, the shopkeepers were going to do splendidly, because they were going to sell more, and to have a larger number of customers. For all, it meant less taxation, lower rates and better times. I presume it was the financial expert, who now sits in this House in charge of the Bill, made the calculation, because these documents were prepared with great care. No doubt the Fianna Fáil Party in their election propaganda consulted their financial expert as to details, and he discovered that without reducing social services in any way, taxation in this country could be reduced by £2,000,000 a year. We have now made the unfortunate discovery, after 15 months' experience of this Government, that taxation has, in fact, been increased by £6,000,000 a year. These promises were swallowed not only by simpletons but by very clever people. Deputy Norton and his Party I think must have accepted them.

Comment on this

We accepted anything but Cumann na nGaedheal.

Comment on this

Does the Deputy accept 24/- a week?

Comment on this
Mr. Rice

The Deputy is learning every day, and the Deputy is still voting in favour of keeping in power a Government that fixes 24/- a week as a proper wage.

Comment on this

Where were all the absentees in the Deputy's Party?

Comment on this
Mr. Rice

Deputy Norton says he will accept anything but Cumann na nGaedheal. In spite of that statement, I do say that he is learning, because, in this House—and quite recently—on the Second Reading of this Bill, Deputy Norton gave indications that the cobwebs were being removed from his eyes. Deputy Norton, in his speech on the Second Reading of this Bill—it is in Vol. 46, page 1900—said:—

"If there is anything to be learned or any significance to be attached to the speech of the Minister for Finance, it is an indication that the Minister at all events—and perhaps in this matter he is speaking for the Government—has got cold feet——"

Comment on this

Hear, hear!

Comment on this
Mr. Rice

Imagine the wizards over there getting cold feet!

"——has got cold feet on his own economic and industrial policy. The speech of the Minister clearly indicates that he has no faith whatever in his own industrial and economic policy, because if the Minister had any faith in the policy of his Government to bring about that economic and social regeneration, which is spoken of so glibly at election times, he has no case whatever for cutting purchasing power and attacking wage standards such as are being attacked in this Bill."

Comment on this

Do you object to that?

Comment on this
Mr. Rice

No; on the contrary, I accept it as a sign of the gradual conversion of Deputy Norton.

Comment on this

You were converted out of another Party before, and you will not be long in this.

Comment on this
Mr. Rice

Those were the promises made to the people of this country at that time, and I say, therefore, that no case can be made for the continuance of these "cuts" in the remuneration of public servants except on the ground that the Party opposite—the Government—wish to continue indefinitely this economic war. Why were promises made to settle this question if this Government were returned to power, and why, when they were returned to power, has no effort been made to settle this economic war? Amongst these promises that were made the first was a promise of a higher standard of living for all the people of this country. Is it a step towards the higher standard of life of the people of this country that these essential services—the Civil Service, the Civic Guards and the teachers—should have their remuneration reduced during this year? What is the use of saving one week's salary in 12 months of "cuts" on these people, and causing discontent among them at the same time, if you are wasting that amount of money every week in carrying on an economic war which you promised the people you were going to bring to an end? There is no sense in it, and it is an absolute breach of faith.

Comment on this

If the Deputy would keep his mouth shut we might settle it.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

If the Deputy who has just spoken would follow his own advice, progress would be more rapid.

Comment on this
Mr. Rice

We have kept our mouths shut on this question for a very long time.

Comment on this

Question?

Comment on this
Mr. Rice

I should prefer the views of the President to those of Deputy Jordan. The President stated, on the occasion when he was going to London to have a conference prior to the last general election, that he appreciated highly the attitude of the leader of this Party. This Party follows the attitude of its leader in giving every opportunity to the President to bring about a settlement of this question. I do not intend to imitate the bad manners which we saw from the benches of the other Party when they were in Opposition. I appeal to this House and to Deputies on the other side to consider this amendment from the impartial point of view as to what is the justice and necessity of this thing. As I said before, I do not propose to imitate the bad manners exhibited by Deputies on the other side when President Cosgrave was the head of the Government and who, because people followed their leader, referred to the followers of President Cosgrave as "the dumb driven cattle of Cumann na nGaedheal." I am sorry that the Parliamentary Secretary, who devised that lovely expression, is not here. Apparently, appreciating his oratory, the present Government have promoted him to a Parliamentary Secretaryship.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Which has nothing to do with the matter before the House.

Comment on this
Mr. Rice

I submit, sir, that it arises from the interruption of Deputy Jordan.

Comment on this

And the Chair gives you all the satisfaction you deserve.

Comment on this
Mr. Rice

I shall wait until Deputy Flinn returns to the House and, by further misconduct in this House, gives me a further opportunity of saying what I wish to say about it. I say that no case has been made for the cutting of these salaries. Any other Government could have made a case for reducing expenditure in this country. This Government has no moral position from which it can tell the people of this country that the remuneration of its public servants ought to be reduced, because, in every week during which they remain in office, they are fruitlessly and foolishly wasting an amount of money, by a continuance of the economic war, that would be saved in 12 months by these reductions in the salaries of public servants. I ask Deputies to put pressure on the Government to end this economic war by voting for this amendment, and to bring home to the Government the fact that they promised to end the economic war as soon as they were returned to power. What efforts have they made, since they were returned to office in February last, to end this economic war? So far as the public know, they have made no effort. If we were to get any of the benefits promised to the people of this country by the Party opposite during the last general election, then there would be no necessity for these "cuts" and the House can only come to the conclusion that these "cuts" are being rendered necessary by the continuance of this economic war.

As to the increased markets which we heard about—I am sorry that the Minister for Industry and Commerce has left the House, because we heard here some time ago from the President that he did not see any prospect of procuring alternative markets. Of course, when we want to know the inner thoughts or views of Ministers as to what their hopes are we naturally have to go to the English Press to find out those views. I read recently in an English newspaper an interview with the Minister for Industry and Commerce, in which he said that he saw alternative markets in sight.

Comment on this
Seán MacEntee Minister for Finance (Mr. MacEntee) Fianna Fáil

I am sorry to interrupt the Deputy, but I would remind him that there are 120 amendments on the Order Paper and there is, I understand, an arrangement whereby the Committee Stage will be disposed of by to-morrow. It seems to me, from the rambling way in which the Deputy is speaking, that it will be impossible to finish it in the time.

Comment on this
Mr. Rice

As a matter of fact, when the Minister arose, I was about to make my last point. I should like to hear something from the Minister for Industry and Commerce as to where these alternative markets are to be found, because nobody in this country sees any sign of such markets, and I think that the Irish people in this country are entitled to be informed of such markets, if there are any, before the readers of English newspapers.

Comment on this

Would it be in order, a Chinn Comhairle, to discuss the question of alternative markets on this amendment?

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

It would not.

Comment on this

The interruption by the Minister for Finance, when Deputy Rice was speaking, appears to me to raise a most important issue. Is it to be taken that in future the practice of this House, when important measures of this character are under discussion, is to be that Deputies will be limited in their remarks? The issues raised by Deputy Rice in his amendment are certainly very important to this country. His amendment is one of great importance, for the reason that it enables him to deal with issues which will be raised in a subsequent amendment. In view of the importance of the amendment and what is involved in it I think the Deputy was cut unduly short. I would like a ruling from the Chair on that. When very grave issues are under discussion in the House surely to goodness a Deputy should not be interrupted, even by a Minister.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Deputy's speech was not cut short by the Ceann Comhairle.

Comment on this

I quite agree, sir, but the suggestion came from the Minister, and I feel that the Ceann Comhairle and the House would have some regard to what the Minister has to say. I do suggest that it is most unfair to the House that the Minister should have interrupted.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Surely a Minister is entitled to make a suggestion.

Comment on this

I accept that.

Comment on this

Is a Deputy entitled to reflect on the Chair in the way that Deputy Anthony has done?

Comment on this

I am not reflecting on the Chair, and have never done so. I leave that to the Minister.

Comment on this

He is an old hand at it.

Comment on this

This Party is opposed to this Bill, lock, stock and barrel. It is opposed to every line of the Bill, and will give its support to every amendment moved which will render the Bill inoperative. If that is not possible, then it will do all it can to minimise the hardships likely to be inflicted under the Bill and will vote for any amendment having that objective. But this particular amendment is steeped in the same kind of philosophy as the Bill itself is steeped in. This amendment, in its opening sentence, accepts the whole philosophy of the Bill.

Comment on this
Mr. Rice

No.

Comment on this

The opening sentence to the amendment reads: "This Act shall continue in force until 31st day of March, 1934." I do not believe that it should continue in operation for 24 hours. I submit that Deputy Rice, in his ill-framed amendment, is committing himself to the principle that "This Act shall continue in force until 31st day of March, 1934." Consequently though I am completely opposed to the Bill and perfectly prepared to support any reasonable amendment designed to render it ineffective, the suggestion of Deputy Rice and the phraseology of his amendment make it impossible for us to support the amendment——

Comment on this
Mr. Rice

That is very clever.

Comment on this

——because of the fact that the Deputy, apparently when drafting it, was more concerned with the making of a political speech than he was with introducing a sensible amendment.

Comment on this
Mr. Rice

That is very clever.

Comment on this

It bowls you over, anyway.

Comment on this

We have just heard from that non-political person, the Leader of the Labour Party, a condemnation of Deputy Rice for making a political speech. It is very interesting to hear this view of general public ethics which animates the leader of the Labour Party: that in this House political speeches should not be made. The Leader of the Labour Party evidently has not the remotest idea of what the amendment means. It does not mean that, of necessity, this Bill should be enforced. What it does mean is that, if the Bill is going to be passed by the House, it shall not be in force for one moment beyond the termination of the economic war. The Leader of the Labour Party and the members of that Party, if they vote against this amendment, will be voting against this: that if this Bill becomes law in its present form it shall be kept on longer than the termination of the economic war. For Deputy Norton to get up and say that he is opposed to the Bill, lock, stock and barrel, opposed to every line of the Bill, and then to turn around and say that he is opposed to an amendment which can have no effect except to shorten the duration of time which the Bill will be enforced if it becomes law is, I submit, an appallingly illogical proposition.

Comment on this

Because you support it.

Comment on this

What about the one and a tanner boot allowance that you took off the Civic Guards?

Comment on this

I support the amendment. My action in doing so does not mean that it is to be interpreted in the sense that Deputy Norton's action would be interpreted if he supported the amendment. Deputy Norton and his colleagues should not disown their own baby. They helped to bring the economic war on this country and have been directly responsible for this Bill.

Comment on this

You helped Jimmy Thomas.

Comment on this

In what way?

Comment on this

You backed him up and took his point of view in this House.

Comment on this

I never helped Jimmy Thomas or anybody else——

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

It would be desirable to be more respectful in referring to Ministers of another Government.

Comment on this

I would point out, a Chinn Comhairle, that it was Deputy Davin who first used that term.

Comment on this

I repeated unconsciously a remark put into my mouth by an interrupter, and I withdraw and apologise for mentioning in those terms the name of a Minister in another country. For my doing so, that Minister can blame his one-time Labour colleague, Deputy Davin.

Comment on this

Do not labour the point now, anyhow.

Comment on this

Deputy Norton says that he will not support this amendment, because he objects to the Bill altogether, but he did not object to the direct results and the direct consequences of his own actions when the wages of the men that sent him here, the agricultural labourers in the County Kildare, were reduced by one-half.

Comment on this

By your Party and by the Centre Party.

Comment on this

Not my Party.

Comment on this

Oh, yes, I will give you the names.

Comment on this

If I am to be in a Farmers' Party, then it is going to be led by a farmer.

Comment on this
A Deputy

Give him a chance.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

I want Deputies to realise that the Chair will take serious notice of repeated interruptions.

Comment on this

I wish to draw your attention, a Chinn Comhairle, to a statement made by Deputy Smith opposite. I am not afraid of wearing my sins on my forehead, but I do resent sins being put on my forehead that I never committed. Deputy Smith, if he represents the farmers and the electors of Cavan, should be man enough to get up and speak, and not be slinking around in the back seats interrupting, as he has been doing every day that I have been in this House. I know all about the plan of campaign. I know the names of the Deputies who have been told to carry out these interruptions. They can carry them out, but they will get back more than they give. Let them make up their minds on that. I never was in the Centre Party, and never would be in a class party.

Comment on this

The Deputy was the leader of the first Centre Party, but that Party never had a member in it as it was dead born.

Comment on this

I cannot understand what the Deputy has said. I do not mind interruptions but I cannot understand him when he speaks. The purpose of this amendment is quite clear. It is not going to continue in force for ever. It sets a limit and that limit is the termination of the economic war. Now Labour should stand up, as I have previously remarked, and acknowledge its own baby. It should also be able to face its Labour organisations when the cry will come from them: "You threw your weight in to win this economic war."

Labour cannot have it both ways. They cannot perpetuate the economic war and reduce the wage-earning capacity of the country, or to put it another way, allow the production of this country to be confiscated by another country through their actions. When that production is confiscated to the extent of £5,000,000 directly and about £20,000,000 indirectly the level of prices must be lowered in this country, the volume of employment must shrink, and the actual wages paid must diminish. If the Labour Party want to stand for the interests of Labour they should support this amendment. Then perhaps when they support this amendment and study, not the philosophy of this amendment but the philosophy of their own actions during the past 15 months, they might come to a truer realisation of the position and regulate their political conduct accordingly. They cannot do something, that must produce a certain result and then object to that result when it comes about.

Deputy Rice in introducing this amendment objected to the cuts. So did I. I object to the lowering of the standard of living, to the lowering of wages, because the moment you begin to lower wages that very moment you are lowering the standard of living. It does not matter how highly paid the wage-earner or the salaried official is, once you cut down his salary the effect goes down the whole line to the very humblest worker in the country, and by reducing those wages and salaries you cut the only market that the Government seems concerned to build up, the home market. What some of the Government Deputies are fond of referring to on platforms as the great Republic of the West is not cutting salaries. Their President has advised all employers throughout the State in this year of depression to increase wages. Our Government is going to cut them. That is a most vicious procedure. I do not want to develop the argument because if I attempted to develop it I would be making a speech more appropriate to the Second Reading than to the Committee Stage of the Bill.

Coming to this specific amendment that is before the House, the amendment is prompted by hostility to the principle of the Bill. For reasons which we need not enter into now, if the Bill is going to be forced on the House through the dead weight of Government votes, the proposal asks this House to limit the duration of the Bill and not to make it a permanent Bill, not to reduce the standard of living permanently. I fail to see the philosophy, the logic or the consistency of Labour Deputies if a single Labour Deputy goes into the Lobby to vote against the amendment. While against the cuts on general principle, I support the amendment, the object of which is to put a limitation to this lowering of the standard of living by the Government Party who told us at every cross-roads before the election: "Put us in and the whole country will flow with milk and honey." Now it seems it is to flow with vinegar and gall.

Comment on this

One wonders, reading through this amendment and studying the Bill, whether those who drafted it took the trouble to do either, because if they did and if their speeches are not mere expressions of the perfect and shameless hypocrisy it is difficult to see how they could have introduced the amendment at all. It is quite true, as Deputy Norton has said, that the amendment does specifically accept the principle of the Bill, which is, that in these times of stress, whether it be for the duration of the economic war or for this year only, certain temporary economies should be made in the public service. There is no use trying to get away from it. That is the principle which Deputy Belton has just advocated to the House.

Comment on this

The House accepted the principle on Second Stage.

Comment on this

Of course it did, and those who framed the amendment have accepted the principle.

Comment on this

Just as the House did.

Comment on this

Those who framed the amendment accept the principle, but they want to deprive civil servants of the safeguards which are contained in this Bill.

Comment on this

Where?

Comment on this

Deputy Rice asks where. Deputy Rice put his name to the amendment and he, presumably, knows what is in the Bill. Has he studied the effect this amendment would have on Section 4?

Comment on this
Mr. Rice

Yes.

Comment on this

Very well, it is quite obvious, if Deputy Rice has studied Section 4 of the Bill, that this amendment is designed to deprive public servants of one of the safeguards that are in the Bill.

Comment on this
Mr. Rice

If the Minister were not Minister I should say nonsense.

Comment on this

It would not matter what the Deputy said. The fact remains that what I have said is true. The Deputy's judgment is of very little importance in matters of this sort.

Comment on this
Mr. Rice

As the Minister's judgment is to me.

Comment on this

The Deputy said that this amendment is designed to ensure that the Bill will have a temporary application. He and all those who were associated with him in drafting the amendment would deprive civil servants of the protection which is afforded by Section 4, which provides that in computing pensions these deductions shall not be taken into account. In attempting to paint the lily or to gild the refined gold of the draftsmanship of this Bill——

Mr. V. Rice rose.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Minister is entitled to make a speech without interruption.

Comment on this
Mr. Rice

He has made a statement which I am entitled to query, that someone was associated with me in drafting the amendment.

Comment on this

There was not? Am I to understand from the Deputy that there was no member of his Party associated with him in drafting the amendment?

Comment on this

None, none whatever, but they are all going to support it.

Comment on this

This exhibition of utter folly and foolishness—that is what the members of the Party are going to support. The real effect of it, as I say, is to deprive civil servants of the protection afforded them in the Bill. If this Bill expires before April, 1934, Section 4 of the Bill expires also, and if Section 4 expires all pensions would be computed on the basis of the salary paid at the date of retirement, and not on the basis set out in Section 4 of the Bill. Therefore, Deputy Norton was perfectly right——

Comment on this

Hear, hear.

Comment on this

——when he said he was opposed to the principle of the Bill, and that the action of himself and his Party would be designed to minimise any hardships the Bill might impose. In view of that attitude which is quite logical, one which I believe is quite creditable, it would be impossible for Deputy Norton to vote for the amendment which, as I have already said, would deprive the civil servant of the status for pensions rights, which is guaranteed by the Bill.

Comment on this

I am supporting the amendment, and if I had to choose between Deputy Rice and the Minister for the interpretation to be put on Section 4, I should bank on the judgment of Deputy Rice. I will be very brief because I feel that the time of the House should not be taken up to too great an extent on one amendment, but this amendment seems to me to be of supreme importance. We were told by the Fianna Fáil Party before they came into office—I quote from their own statements—that:—

"Fianna Fáil is satisfied that substantial economies are feasible without reducing social services, inflicting hardship on any of the Government servants or impairing in the slightest degree the efficiency of the administrative machine."

I want to submit that we shall, to a very large extent, impair the efficiency of the administrative machine by imposing these cuts on the very large number of civil servants and others mentioned in the Bill. We shall have other opportunities of discussing these cuts in relation to certain officials in the Civil Service and in the other services enumerated in the measure. There may be, and I believe that there are—and this is possibly where I may differ from Cumann na nGaedheal and from official Labour—cases in which this Government, under the present circumstances, may be quite justified in reducing certain salaries and the reason I rose to support this amendment was the fact that I feel that, while these economies in the higher-paid posts in the Civil Service of the State may be necessary at the moment, we may and, certainly, should be, able to reach a point, if the economic war were ended and our markets thrown open to us, at which we could restore to those civil servants and, even the higher-paid civil servants, the salaries they enjoyed at the passing of the measure. I have always felt and I have stated, on more than one occasion in this House, that I did not consider that the Ministers of this House are over-paid and I also consider that many of the civil servants in the higher grades were barely adequately paid. Certainly none are over-paid in view of the importance of the duties they have to attend to. That argument may apply to the lower-paid grades and it possibly would have stronger force in its application to the lower-paid civil servants. I am going to oppose cuts in the salaries of national teachers in cases where the salaries are below a certain amount—the lower-paid national teachers and civil servants—and I will develop that at a later stage, indicating what I mean by the lower-paid civil servants. There appears to me to be some misconception with regard to this amendment. Deputy Norton, I think, must admit that already some of these cuts are in operation.

Comment on this

Illegally.

Comment on this

I agree, but they are in operation. This amendment of Deputy Rice is a carefully drafted and well-worded amendment. It simply suggests that this Bill, which we all know will become an Act on account of the steam-roller majority the Government are able to command——

Comment on this

On account of the will of the people.

Comment on this

On account of the dumb-driven cattle on the other side. The Deputy is one of those. I am not one of them. The amendment sets out that this Act will continue in force—with the assistance of one of the dumb-driven cattle behind me— until 31st March, 1934. That suggests that there must be some kind of finality to the hardship you are about to inflict on the civil servants and other persons enumerated in the Bill.

Comment on this

There seems to be a general impression amongst Deputies opposite that, no matter what the position of the people of this country, no matter whether the people are able to pay or not—and this applies to the last seven, eight or nine years and, in fact, since Cumann na nGaedheal came into office—a certain section of the community are to be set aside, surrounded by barbed wire entanglements and are to get their salaries and their pensions. I did not take very much notice of Deputy Rice or Deputy Fitzgerald-Kenney on this amendment, because one rather expects it from the particular class they represent, but I was rather surprised to hear Deputy Belton on it.

Comment on this

I was looking after my market then.

Comment on this

Ah, your market! The total amount in the Estimates this year is £22,000,000 odd. The amount of salaries paid out of that is £12,780,000, leaving £10,000,000 for the Services. From 1924 to 1931, when the income of the farming community —the baby whom everybody in the House is anxious to cuddle in his arms—was reduced by £13,000,000——

Comment on this

The Deputy admits that?

Comment on this

The Cumann na nGaedheal Party thought that the officials should still be paid the same salaries, no matter whether the people were able to pay or not——

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Deputy is making a Second Reading speech. He must get down to the amendment. On Committee Stage only, the amendment before the House can be discussed.

Comment on this

I am discussing——

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Deputy is making a Second Reading speech.

Comment on this

If the argument put up by Deputy Belton is correct, we ought to double all salaries.

Comment on this

Certainly, if we are able.

Comment on this

People would then have more to spend, and I presume that the farming community, with whom Deputy Belton always has sympathy, will be able to pay. We have heard a lot of this kind of thing, but I should like to warn Deputies, and not alone Deputies opposite, but all Deputies in the House, that if they are not prepared to reduce salaries to a point within the capacity of the people to bear, somebody else is prepared to do it for them.

Comment on this

I have only one or two words to say. May I point out to Deputy Norton that, unfortunately, so far as the principle of the Bill is concerned, it is accepted already, and all that amendments can do is, in individual cases, to weaken the effect of the Bill. One of the ways in which you can weaken the effect of the Bill is by shortening the time during which it will be in operation. His argument was purely a verbal one and suggested that this amendment accepted the principle. I would suggest that this amendment no more accepts the principle of the Bill than does amendment 106, in the names of Deputies Norton and Corish. That proposes, undoubtedly, to give certain concessions, but it also proposes to give certain cuts. This amendment stands on exactly the same footing. All we can hope to do in the Committee Stage is to make this Bill less harsh where we consider it should be less harsh. This amendment makes it possible to cut short the time during which the Bill will be in operation, and it, undoubtedly, makes the Bill less harsh on the people affected, in the same way that the Deputy's own amendment—amendment 106, and I think he has another—do.

Comment on this

There is the same acceptance of cuts there.

Comment on this

There is no such thing.

Comment on this

There is an acceptance of cuts. You are accepting cuts there.

Comment on this

I am not.

Comment on this

Just as this amendment proposes to cut short the time. That is the purpose of the amendment. Every amendment put forward by this side is open to exactly the same objection as Deputy Norton has brought forward. The members of one particular Party have not spoken in relation to this amendment. We do not know how they are going to vote. They may be anxious to leave it to the Government to continue the economic war. I suggest that it is possible they might vote for this amendment. Last week—I do not suggest it was through any arrangement—we observed a thing which seemed to work out admirably. When the Labour Party went into the Division Lobby against the Government, the Centre Party went into the Government Lobby. That, apparently, is going to happen throughout this Bill as well.

Comment on this

See-saw.

Comment on this

Deputy Davin and Deputy MacDermot may have had a consultation. I know they had an earnest conversation, but they may have been discussing another matter. We have heard many absurdities so far as this Bill is concerned, but the crowning absurdity was the passionate speech of the Minister when he was throwing a cloak over the Labour Party. I admit that they badly want that.

Comment on this

Not a bit.

Comment on this

Apparently the Minister thought they wanted it badly. Anyway, over them he threw the cloak. He told us that they were a consistent Party, and they stood for a definite principle. Now they have a chance in this amendment of showing——

Comment on this

Of depriving civil servants of their pension rights.

Comment on this

On a point of order, the Deputy should confine himself to the amendment.

Comment on this

He is endeavouring to throw a cloak over the amendment.

Comment on this

Then we had a most extraordinary statement from the Minister. It was the ipse dixit of our legal pundit as well as our financial expert. He said the effect of the amendment would be to do away with the rights granted under Section 4. That is one of the most absurd statements the Minister made, and he made quite a lot. The amendments suggested will have the effect of diminishing the amount of harm that would be done by the Bill. This amendment stands in the same position as every other amendment so far as that is concerned.

Comment on this

A couple of weeks ago this House, and indeed the whole country, was astounded when the President took the unprecedented step of silencing the Minister for Finance on the Budget. Whilst I do not always find myself in agreement with the President, I think anyone who listened to the Minister's speech on this amendment must come to the conclusion that the President was very wise. If the Minister was able to make so many blunders in the course of a seven minutes' speech on such a simple amendment, how many more blunders of a much more serious character would he be capable of making in connection with the Budget? I think Deputy Norton is mistaken in the view he has taken of this amendment. I am satisfied that Deputy Norton and the other members of the Labour Party want to weaken, as far as possible, the effect of the Bill. So far as I can judge from this amendment, I am satisfied it will weaken the effect of the Bill and for that reason I am going to vote for it.

I suggest that the members of the Labour Party might consider this amendment further. It seems to me that, if carried, the amendment will indicate a definite date when the Bill must cease to operate. That is something that is not in the Bill. We are told by the Minister and other Government speakers that this measure will operate for only one year. Anybody with commonsense, anybody outside the members of the Front Bench opposite, any person who goes to the country from week to week and any Fianna Fáil Deputy who is in touch with his constituents, is well aware that unless the economic war is settled within the next 12 months, not only will this Bill not cease to operate, but the cuts will be steeper and will have to be steeper. That is quite clear to everybody except the Minister and his colleagues.

Comment on this

And the members of the Labour Party.

Comment on this

The members of the Labour Party are as well aware as I am that unless the present situation is settled there will be greater cuts, not only in the salaries of public servants but in social services next year.

Comment on this

I would like to know if Deputy Belton is now the Leader of the Cumann na nGaedheal Party?

Comment on this

They do not want any leading, but the Fianna Fáil Party did when they were brought in here.

Comment on this

I do not see why I should be interrupted in order to permit Deputy Donnelly to ask such a question. Deputy O'Sullivan has mentioned that the Minister for Finance endeavoured to throw a cloak over the Labour Party. I say that it was rather an impertinence on the part of the Minister to give the impression to the House that he was coming to Deputy Norton's assistance. Deputy Norton is quite well able to look after himself and his Party; he is much better able to do it than the Minister. It seems to me that the Minister was anxious to talk about Deputy Norton and everything and anything except the amendment. The Minister did not want to face the facts. When he cannot answer definite arguments then, like the solicitor in court who has had a bad case, he endeavours to abuse everybody. That is an old habit on the part of the Minister, as those of us who have had to suffer for our sins listening to him for a couple of years know only too well.

Comment on this

This amendment implies the principle that even if the economic war is still in continuance on March 31st, 1934, those cuts should cease to operate and ought not to be continued. That is not a principle to which we can give adherence. We regard the Bill primarily as an attempt to distribute the sacrifies entailed by the economic war amongst other classes of the community than the farmers. From that point of view we have not considered it our duty to go into the Bill in very great detail. The main thing is to have the principle accepted and some attempt made to put it into practice. Our general view of the Bill is that it might have gone a good deal further. Had this amendment proposed merely that the whole matter should be reconsidered as soon as the economic war came to an end we might have been tempted to support it.

Comment on this

I rise to support this amendment and I do so because, of all the amendments to this Bill which I have seen, this seems to be the only one which brings to light the reason for the necessity of the measure. Everyone knows that it is because of the economic war this country is 40 per cent. worse off than it otherwise would be. It is for that reason that this Economies Bill becomes necessary. It is easy to understand the chagrin of the Minister and the anxiety of the Labour Party to get away from this amendment. The Labour Party, of course, supports the Government in what is the major point of its policy, namely, the continuance of the economic war with England. Without that economic war there was absolutely no necessity for this Bill. I, for my part, am grateful to Deputy Rice for this amendment, because it does bring to light the fact that the economic war with England is the true reason for the necessity of this Bill, and for that reason I have great pleasure in supporting the amendment.

Comment on this

Deputy McGuire, following Deputy Belton with the musical voice of their master, again repeats the unfounded allegation that the Labour Party are really the people responsible for the economic war. Now may I say this—and I think nobody can challenge it—if the Opposition Party in this House had taken the same view of this issue as the Opposition Parties had taken in the French Chamber, in the English Parliament and in the American Congress there would never have been an economic war. Were it not for the fact that the Cumann na nGaedheal Opposition gave such encouragement to the British when this issue was first raised we would not have this question of the economic war between the two countries now.

Comment on this

On a point of order, is this a speech on the amendment or is it a Second Reading speech on the economic war? If it is a Second Reading speech on the subject of the economic war I would be delighted to cross swords with Deputy Davin.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Deputy Davin's reply has been directed to criticism made. He should now get down to the amendment.

Comment on this

I would not have said a word about it were it not for the fact that the Cumann na nGaedheal Deputies have mentioned it in their speeches. Look at the attitude of Herriot in the French Parliament. Look at the attitude he adopted in the French Parliament on a similar issue when——

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Deputy has replied to criticisms made by Opposition Deputies. He cannot pursue that course any further. He must come to the amendment.

Comment on this

May I take the liberty of saying, whether justified or not that the people gave a mandate to this Party at the last election. The people did that whether right or wrong. I believe by the majority of votes——

Comment on this

And personations.

Comment on this

——they gave a mandate to them and it is a matter for the Government who have a majority in this House without considering twopenny halfpenny matters of this kind——

Comment on this

This is not a twopenny halfpenny matter.

Comment on this

It is a matter for the Government to secure a settlement of this economic war. The sooner the Opposition in this House take up an Irish attitude the sooner we will get an honourable settlement. At any rate the members of this Party are quite capable without any lectures from the members of the Cumann na nGaedheal Party to understand the meaning of an amendment of this kind.

Comment on this

Question.

Comment on this

We voted against the Second Reading of the Bill showing by doing so that we disapproved of the principle of the measure and in doing that we do not care a thraneen whether Deputy MacDermot and his Centre Party vote for it or not. We hold the view that whatever Party is in power there is a wage rate or a salary below which it is bad economy to cut. I pay one tribute to Deputy Belton—and he deserves it—and that is that he is a practical farmer and believes in paying a living wage to his employees. I wish the same could be said of those Deputies who sit around him.

Comment on this

Or the Deputies on the Fianna Fáil side.

Comment on this

This amendment by the first sentence commits us to the acceptance, for some time at any rate, of the principle of the measure. That is the real reason why we are going to vote against it. I hope in discussing matters of this kind we have heard the last of the economic war. The economic war should not be brought into this issue. It does not arise from it.

Comment on this

It is to me a most extraordinary state of affairs that the leader or the deputy-lieutenant of the Labour Party should stand up here and defend the attitude of the Government as regards its economic policy. As far as I can see no more pressing measure was ever brought into this House, at all events in recent times, than the Bill now before us. I say that because of the position to which the farmers have been brought by the economic war. We have been told by the Government Party that everybody in the country should tighten his belt and make sacrifices in this economic war now being waged. As far as I can see, least of all has the Labour Party made any effort whatsoever to tighten their belts or, in the alternative, done anything to bring to an end this economic war between the English Government and the Irish people. They have done nothing to tighten their belts.

Comment on this

You would want a pretty big belt.

Comment on this

Yes, but I will have to tighten my belt many a time, like the rest of the farmers. I hope Deputy Davin when asked by the Minister for Finance to make sacrifices in order to bring the economic war to a successful issue will make sacrifices. What is the necessity for the introduction of this Bill? To my mind it is that we have in the country at the present moment a Government returned by a majority of the Irish people; as to their having got a mandate, I say the mandate they got was to bring about a settlement of this issue and so bring the economic war to a successful issue. Who are the sufferers by this economic war? Are the Labour Party in the Dáil the sufferers? Have the Fianna Fáil Party in the Dáil suffered by this economic war? When that Party was asked within the last month to tighten their belts and reduce their allowances so as to be in a position to give a lead to the people of the country as regards nationality and patriotism, there was a howl from that Party, and especially from my colleague Deputy Martin Corry, who was supposed to be the exponent of the Farmers' Party and every other Party in this country.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Deputy is reverting to a debate which took place some weeks ago, and he has wandered very far from the amendment before the House.

Comment on this

I should be sorry to get away from the amendment. I want to tell the House that I am totally opposed to this amendment. What is the position in this matter of economy so far as the farmers are concerned? The farmers of the country have tightened their belts to such an extent that they can have no further tightening. I ask the Executive Council and all the members of the Fianna Fáil Party, from the President down, to make sacrifices in the same way as the farmers have to make them. I will have to vote against this amendment.

Comment on this

I should like to say just one word with reference to the point made by the Minister. He suggested that my amendment was detrimental to the interests of the Civil Service, having regard to Section 4, that is the Section dealing with "saving for pensions." That is the first lecture on law that I have ever received from the Minister for Finance. The section to which he refers is the one providing for saving for pensions, etc. That section simply provides that the position of the Civil Service as regards superannuation is not prejudiced by the passing of this Bill. One would have assumed that even a gentleman like the Minister, who had never attended one law lecture, would know that a saving clause of that kind is a saving clause, and that if you were only to apply the cuts for three months instead of 12 months, then the position of the Civil Service could not be adversely affected by the carrying out of that amendment for the shorter period. I suggest that in future the Minister, before he proceeds to lecture any Deputy on the construction of a section, should take the precaution of consulting the Attorney-General, who is in the House.

Comment on this
Division

Amendment put.

Tá 30
·
Níl 74
Result _

Do you agree with this result?

I move amendment No. 2:—

Between lines 32 and 33 to insert the words, "references to employment shall be construed as including engagement and retainer."

The purpose of this amendment is to put it beyond doubt that the word "employment" covers the type of service to the remuneration for which the Bill is intended to apply, especially where services are occasional only.

Comment on this

What does the word "retainer" apply to?

Comment on this

To senior counsel for instance.

Comment on this

Do senior counsel in fact receive retainers from the State? It is news to me if they do.

Comment on this

From the local authority.

Comment on this

Coming from a local authority they do not come under this Bill.

Comment on this

Of course they do.

Comment on this

If paid out of local funds?

Comment on this

Yes.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 5:—

In line 37, to delete the words, "and under the control of."

This is a drafting amendment only.

Comment on this

Would the Minister explain what that amendment means, and would he also mind explaining a thing I am particularly interested in—how the original mistake arose? It is a great deal more than a drafting amendment. The section as it stands asserts that the Government has control of those colleges. I admit that is in full keeping with the Government's whole policy. It is a great deal more than a drafting amendment, and I should like to know how the original mistake arose.

Comment on this

I am not in a position to say how the original mistake in drafting arose, but I am telling the Deputy it is a drafting amendment. In fact those colleges are not under the immediate control of the Minister, even though we pay for them.

Comment on this

Therefore it is a great deal more than a drafting amendment. The Bill asserts the principle which the Government is following, the principle of State control of private institutions. They forget that this is not a State institution.

Comment on this

What follows from what the Deputy has said?

Comment on this

That the Government's whole policy in this matter is wrong, and naturally it made the mistake in the Bill.

Comment on this

I beg to move amendments Nos. 6 and 7. May I ask what the Minister includes? Does he include house allowance and so on?

Comment on this

Yes: It is quite clear, as a matter of fact, from the section as it stands that it does include house allowance.

Comment on this

Why should that be reduced if it is an expense that the officer has? He does not enjoy it. He must live. What justification does the Minister give for a cut in that?

Comment on this

Because it is the equivalent of a cash allowance which the officer would receive——

Comment on this

No. There is this difference; if he had the cash allowance he would probably be able to get a cheaper dwelling. If there is any truth in the Government contention that there is a fall in prices he would get the benefit of it. Here the thing is fixed. He gets no benefit of any fall in price in the case of either dwelling or mess allowance.

Comment on this

The actual benefit in kind is, I think, greater than the cash allowance he would receive in lieu thereof. Exactly the reverse of what the Deputy has said is true.

Comment on this

Could the Minister give us any indication as to the class of officers employed in the Civil Service at this stage who are remunerated by way of commission?

Comment on this

Stock managers in the Land Commission, for instance. They collect grazing rents on commission.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Amendment No. 6 withdrawn.

Comment on this

I presume we are going to dispose of the principle of this.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

On amendment No. 6 the House might debate the principle of Nos. 6, 7, 9 and 10.

Comment on this

I think the words "or on any other basis" include all benefits whether paid in money or given otherwise than in money.

Comment on this

There are my amendments.

Comment on this

We will take these separately.

Comment on this

"House allowance" and such things come properly into my amendment No. 11.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

We shall take Nos. 11, 14 and 48 together.

Comment on this

I would like to have that made clear, because the Minister was dealing with amendment No. 11 when he was talking of "house allowance."

Comment on this

Amendment No. 6 is not moved then.

Comment on this

I hope this amendment is not withdrawn now in order to be moved on Report Stage. It was clearly understood that the Committee Stage was to be concluded in two days. In not moving the amendment now the Deputy is not to reserve to himself the right to move it on Report.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The amendment was definitely moved by Deputy O'Sullivan.

Comment on this

It is withdrawn now.

Comment on this

It cannot be withdrawn without the leave of the House.

Comment on this

The Minister is getting suspicious.

Comment on this

Where Deputy McGilligan is concerned every Minister must be suspicious.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Amendment No. 6 is negatived.

Comment on this

On amendment No. 7—"In sub-section (1), line 41, to delete the words "and other remuneration"—I would like some explanation as to what "other remuneration" means.

Comment on this

It means other remuneration. An official may turn up who thinks he has a claim and accordingly these words are to protect the Dáil and the country, and that is the effect of them.

Comment on this

I understand this is only a sort of shadow in the dark. There is no one who gets remuneration not already covered by duty salary and fee. Is that the case?

Comment on this

Remuneration may be in kind as well as in cash.

Comment on this

So may wages.

Comment on this

Precisely.

Comment on this

First we are told there is to be nobody of any kind who gets remuneration. Then we get something of a hint that it may be a payment in kind. If it is a payment in kind it is not covered by salary, pay, wages, commission or fees, is that so?

Comment on this

It is put in as a safeguarding clause to make the policy of the Government quite clear, if any case turned up hereafter of which we have no knowledge now.

Amendment No. 7 negatived.

Comment on this

I move amendment 8:—

In sub-section (1), line 41, after the word "remuneration" to insert the words "(but not including payment for overtime, Sunday duty or trip allowances paid to persons employed in traveling post office)".

The section in the Bill is as wide and comprehensive as ever I have come across. It is indeed so comprehensive that it would, in my opinion, inflict hardship on people whom it was not intended to come within the scope of the Bill. Part IV of the Schedule deals with salaries not exceeding £300 a year, and provides that persons whose salary does not exceed that sum should suffer no reduction in income. There are many people employed in the Post Office whose salaries would not exceed £300. As a matter of fact none of the manipulative grade would come in any way near that salary. But I understand it is proposed that there is to be reckoned with their income, and taken into consideration, such items as payment for compulsory Sunday duties and compulsory overtime and trip allowances. Now in the Post Office there is a very strong agitation for an increase in the trip allowances. The Minister will get some idea about the niggardly attitude of his Department when I tell him that if an officer in the Post Office goes to Wexford, leaving Dublin at 6 o'clock in the morning, responsible for all the mails arriving from Dublin to Wexford, and arriving back in Dublin at 8 o'clock in the evening he gets the sum of 5/7 for the whole of that day from 6 in the morning until 8 at night. It is hard enough for officers to exist on a trip allowance of that kind and they cannot do it. But under the Bill it is proposed to include this niggardly trip allowance in the men's income for the purpose of making them liable for the cut.

Many officials travelling regularly would, if the Bill is passed, be liable for a cut in their wages, if these trip allowances, which are greatly inadequate for the purpose of defraying the expenses of the officers, are to be taken into consideration. I do not know whether that was the intention. If I could get any assurance that it is not intended to take into consideration these allowances, and if I could get an indication that the Minister would reconsider these matters arising out of compulsory duties and overtime, as well as the question of these trip allowances paid by reason of the fact that an officer is travelling on his official duties, I should be glad to withdraw the amendment.

Comment on this

With regard to the question of trip allowances, and allowances covering expenses as well as remuneration it will be our duty to allocate the respective portions of the allowance to its own proper category. With regard to the case of overtime it is rather more difficult. If the Deputy will withdraw the amendment at this stage I will have the matter further examined in order to see what we can do.

Comment on this

The Minister will reconsider all three items of the amendment?

Comment on this

Yes, I shall see to the three items.

Comment on this

I take it that the Minister will indicate to me his decision before the Report Stage, so that I can repeat the amendment on Report Stage if necessary.

Comment on this

Yes.

Comment on this

The Minister is going to find out how far these things are divisible, so much into remuneration and allowances and so much for expenses.

Comment on this

No, I will consider whether it is proper to deduct from the salary, which only during a temporary period is earned at a rate subject to deduction, the deduction to which it would be thus subject for that period, in a case in which over the whole of the period for which the Act would operate the bulk salary earned would be less than would be subject to deduction.

Comment on this

Why should payment for overtime be paid to persons in one employment only, and not to other persons who have to travel?

Comment on this

I am afraid that is a question the Deputy should have put to the Minister for Finance in the last Government. It does not arise here.

Comment on this

I am putting the question to the Minister now. He says he will consider the amendment in reference to one class in receipt of an allowance. Why not broaden it so as to include persons who receive overtime and do not travel.

Comment on this

Probably I may not limit it to those who travel.

Comment on this

Neither does the amendment.

Comment on this

I understand the Minister's explanation to be given to quite a good point. He is going to consider remuneration paid to people in temporary capacity in the Civil Service.

Comment on this

No, I said remuneration paid for a temporary period.

Comment on this

To anybody, whether fully established or whether only temporary in the Civil Service.

Comment on this

To anybody.

Comment on this

I move amendment 9:—

In sub-section (1), line 42, to delete the words "or otherwise howsoever."

I want to find out what these phrases mean.

Comment on this

"Otherwise howsoever" means in any other way.

Comment on this

What is the meaning of the phrase "than paid under"?

Comment on this

I think that it is quite clear from the context what the words mean.

Comment on this

Is there any example of a payment which is not a fixed payment and which is not paid under statute, order or regulation?

Comment on this