We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

Public Services (Temporary Economies) Bill, 1933—Committee.

Contributions 215–428 of 622. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 3 parts.

Bill Public Services (Temporary Economies) Bill, 1933
Enacted

No. 12 of 1933 ›

Certainly. The fees paid to counsel are not paid under statute, order or regulation.

Comment on this

How are they fixed?

Comment on this

Sometimes by agreement.

Comment on this

Is it suggested, when they are fixed by agreement, that you should cut off a certain percentage?

Comment on this

Certainly.

Comment on this

It would be quite in keeping with your policy.

Comment on this

Make a bargain and break it the next day.

Comment on this

What is the meaning of "fixed" in that connection? I thought that the fees paid to counsel from time to time—since that example has been taken—were fixed. It was understood that they were fixed.

Comment on this

It seems to me that it will be necessary for Ministers——

Comment on this

To explain their Bills.

Comment on this

When they come with a Bill, to bring a copy of the "Universal Dictionary" for the use of Deputy McGilligan.

Comment on this

If there were a dictionary sufficiently universal for the needs of the Minister, I should not mind making him a present of it. What is the meaning of the word "fixed"?

Comment on this

The word "fixed" means "determined", in this case.

Comment on this

Have the fees paid to counsel, from time to time, not been determined? I understood they were. Therefore, they would be covered.

Comment on this

They are not covered by statute, order or regulation.

Comment on this

If they are fixed, they are determined.

Comment on this

They are not fixed or determined by statute, order or regulation. If the Deputy is not capable of reading or construing the phrase, I cannot help him.

Comment on this

Why put in "statute, order or regulation or otherwise howsoever" unless there is some variety of cases to be covered? I could understand a group of cases, which could not be caught by a precise phrase, being put into some sort of compendious phrase like this. But the Minister cannot give us an example.

Comment on this

Fees or remuneration determined by custom.

Comment on this

Is the only example under that head, fees paid to counsel?

Comment on this

Engineers' fees would be another example.

Comment on this

Professional fees?

Comment on this

Yes.

Comment on this

That could be put in a phrase which would enable us to understand where we were. In ordinary circumstances a phrase like this might serve a certain purpose but along the line that is being followed anything is understandable—

Comment on this

Except the Deputy.

Comment on this

In the Civil Service, special remuneration is paid from time to time to officers who act on commissions. It cannot be said that that is fixed though there is a normal rate depending on the amount of time put in. I doubt very much if that rate exceeded for any commission a sum of about £50. I do not know whether it is the idea of the Minister to get this idea of sacrifice and necessary suffering down through the Civil Service by reducing this remuneration say by £10. Is it intended to catch such things as that? There are payments made from time to time to members of the Civil Service in respect of commissions. Would they come under the sway of this provision? It is easy to fix the remuneration for the future. Every man who goes on a commission will know that in the present rigid circumstances he is not going to get as much as he previously might have expected but there are people serving on commissions at present—they have made a half-way passage—who went on with the knowledge—it is common knowledge in the Civil Service—of these special payments of a particular amount. Are these going to be affected?

Comment on this

Can the Deputy give me an instance of the type of commission he has in mind?

Comment on this

The Bankruptcy Commission. A civil servant from my own Department served on that.

Comment on this

The Deputy says there are commissions going on.

Comment on this

Any number.

Comment on this

Which of them does the Deputy think would come under this provision?

Comment on this

I refer the Minister to the commissions down in the Estimates. Will any of those come under the provision?

Comment on this

Possibly the members of these commissions will not be paid.

Comment on this

Then the civil servants will have to do this work, which was always considered an extra, as part of their ordinary duties?

Comment on this

Nobody knows better than the Deputy that it was not always considered an extra.

Comment on this

Are these things going to be caught by this phrase?

Comment on this

What is going to be caught is all salary, pay, wages, commission and fees paid otherwise than under statute, order or regulation.

Comment on this

Only otherwise?

Comment on this

In addition to payments made under statute, order, or regulation.

Comment on this

It is quite obvious that the Minister does not know whether or not there are cases to be covered by the clauses which it is proposed in this and other amendments to strike out. He is putting in those phrases on the off-chance that there will be a case or two cropping up. He wants to make the provision water-tight. Does he not consider that there is a lot of time wasted in trying to cover things of that kind?

Comment on this

There is no time wasted. We do not waste time. Times have changed.

Comment on this

I move amendment 10:—

In sub-section (1) line 44 to delete the words "or on any other basis."

Here we have a calculation by reference to a period of time and by reference to work done. What is the other basis?

Comment on this

Whatever is not included by reference to a period of time or by reference to work done.

Comment on this

Is there any example present to the Minister of a payment made which has not reference to the time or to the work done?

Comment on this

Yes, a visit. A person might be engaged to do something at so much per visit. The visit might be for an indefinite time.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

I suggest that amendments 11 to 14 be considered together.

Comment on this

15 might also be taken.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

And perhaps 16.

Comment on this

No. 16 is an enlargement.

Amendments:—

11. In sub-section (1), line 44, to delete the words "and also includes" and substitute the words "but does not include."—(James Fitzgerald-Kenney)

12. In sub-section (1), line 45, to delete the words "and benefits."— (Patrick McGilligan)

13. In sub-section (1), lines 45-46, to delete the words "whether paid in money or given otherwise than in money" and substitute the words "paid in money."—(Patrick McGilligan)

14. In sub-section (1), line 47, to delete the words "but does not include" and substitute the word "or."—(James Fitzgerald-Kenney)

15. In sub-section (1), line 50, to delete the words and brackets "(other than a uniform allowance)."— (James Fitzgerald-Kenney)

Comment on this

The object of these amendments is to ensure that allowances which are made to various persons, and which are affected by the provisions of this Bill, shall not be subject to any "cuts." In my opinion, as far as the Guards are concerned, the persons who will be detrimentally affected will be the officers. The Bill does not apply to the rank and file of the Guards at all, and their allowances will not be touched. I would point out to the Minister that officers of the Guards are going not only to have their actual salaries reduced, but also their allowances. If the Bill stands as it is at present, the allowance for uniforms and the plain clothes allowance to such officers as use plain clothes will be treated with gross injustice. As far as I understand, the basis of the Bill, as put forward by the Ministerial Party, is that all these officers are overpaid. That is not so. The officers of the Guards are not overpaid. It has been the experience of everybody connected with the administration of the service that during the last few years the State has been deprived of the service of very efficient and very excellent officers, owing to the fact that these officers were not able to make ends meet upon the salaries they were receiving. Consequently they got into debt. It is essential that no officer of the Civic Guards who is in debt could be retained, because a man in debt is in the power of another person. That is a position which could not be tolerated in the Civic Guards.

I will refer to another question which, I dare say, might be more on the general question, but might as well be dealt with now, because it is hard to segregate them. I know one particular superintendent of the Guards, a man of tremendous ability, who was more suited for the position which he occupied than any other man throughout the force. No one in the force was more capable of performing the duties of the particular post than the officer in question. He found he could not support his family in Dublin upon the pay he was receiving, and in consequence he applied to be transferred. He had to be transferred to a country station where his abilities had not at all the same scope for employment that they had in Dublin, which I say was a very serious loss for the State. I emphasise that in order that the Minister might understand it, having regard to the positions which Gárda officers must keep up, and the expenses thereby entailed. As it is very difficult for a Gárda officer to make ends meet, it is most desirable that they should be in an independent financial position. Now, not only is it proposed to cut down the ordinary salaries, but it is proposed to cut down the allowances, which it is very necessary for them to have.

The question of housing will show how very unjust these proposals are. Some officers are housed in barracks at the State expense. All rooms in barracks are occupied by members of the Guards and they receive no housing allowance. I cannot say at present what numbers receive housing allowances as I have not got the particulars, but a considerable number of superintendents and chief superintendents do not receive these allowances because they are provided with houses.

To take a specific example. The chief superintendent of Roscommon is provided with a Government house, but the chief superintendent in Sligo is not. By this Bill the housing allowance of the chief superintendent in Sligo is cut down very heavily because allowances are put in at the end, and when allowances are cut down to the maximum a man may be brought down from one scale to another. Supposing the deduction is 8 per cent., then the housing deduction must be at 8 per cent or it may possibly go to 8½ per cent. In itself that seems to me to be a specific injustice. There is an undertaking by the State to every member of the Civic Guard that he will receive accommodation. That accommodation is given as far as it can be provided in barracks, or in houses which are the property of the State. It is only when that accommodation falls short that a housing allowance is made. I would press upon the Minister, as far as uniform allowance is concerned, that it is absolutely essential, and that as far as plain clothes allowance—which the new section deals with—goes and the housing allowance, they should not be cut at all. The question whether the salaries should or should not be cut arises on a subsequent amendment. I would press the Minister to accept the view that the allowances should not be subject to reduction.

What I have said about the Guards could be repeated almost word for word about officers in the Army. They are to receive barrack accommodation and uniform allowance. Where there are not sufficient married quarters the officers find houses outside. Why are they not to be given the amount necessary for them to be housed? That is part of their contract with the State.

Comment on this

There must be a great deal of confusion about this Bill in the minds of those moving the amendments. I cannot understand, since the House has accepted that there are to be economies in the public services, why it is necessary to make a distinction between civil servants, national school teachers and persons employed in the uniformed forces. The civil servants and the national teachers have to provide houses out of their salaries. Surely it is part of the contract with officers of the Gárda that houses should be provided. The State recognises that, and when it does not, makes a cash allowance. It is part of the salary which in total provides for the housing and for the accommodation of a member of the Guards and his family, just as a civil servant's remuneration covers the provision of a house for himself and his family. Similarly, the State requires a Guard to wear a special garb and he wears it. If uniform is not provided, cash is provided. But a civil servant cannot turn up in the office clad only with a fig leaf. The State allows a civil servant to exercise his own personal taste in the choice of his garb, but insists that he shall be properly clothed. The State when it pays remuneration to the civil servant does not say that so much is for uniform and so much is for housing. But we all know, nevertheless, that the remuneration of the civil servant and the national teacher covers housing and clothing, and we propose to make that subject to reduction under the Bill. If there was anything logical in the Deputy's attitude he would approach the problem in this way: so much of the civil servant's remuneration, that part which covers the clothing and housing of his family is to be free of tax; and so much of the national teacher's housing and clothing for himself and his family is to be free of tax. The Deputy knows that in present circumstances he could not possibly defend that before the country, and therefore he makes the illogical reservations expressed in the amendment. The logical way, when considering public servants is to take into consideration everything they receive from the State, either directly in cash or by way of perquisites attaching to their offices. As it is necessary to make economies, we have to evaluate the remuneration of public servants at its true value in the terms of the cost of living. In view of that, we have to take into consideration the allowances paid to the officers of the Gárda and of the Army, and in any other uniformed and special sections of the public service and to make them subject to this Bill.

Comment on this

I think that when the Minister was speaking he should not have referred to logic. Logic is about the last word he should have used, for anything more illogical than his speech I myself could hardly imagine. I would urge upon the Minister that when he indulges in reasoning it is a great thing to get one's major premises right first and then start drawing one's conclusions; but before drawing conclusions it is necessary to get the major premises right. There is all the difference in the world between the allowance of an officer in the Civic Guards or an officer in the Army and the allowances of a civil servant. An officer in the Guards or in the Army has got to provide a uniform for himself over and above his ordinary clothes. An officer in the Guards or in the Army cannot wear his ordinary clothes whenever he likes. Officers in the Guards or in the Army have got to have this uniform ready to wear on certain occasions. Similarly, with regard to housing. No officer in the Guards or in the Army can really buy a house, whereas a civil servant can. The officer in the Army or in the Guards must always hire or rent his house. The civil servant knows, if he is in a position here in Dublin, that he can purchase his house because he will be here in Dublin for the rest of his life. In exactly the same way, the national school teacher can build his own house with money provided for that purpose by the State and it is not proposed that on moneys advanced to him for that purpose the amount of repayment he makes is going to be increased under this Bill at all. An officer in the Guards or in the Army must live not only in a certain place but in a place very close to his barracks and the difference between his case and that of the civil servant is a very broad and real distinction.

I certainly impress upon the Minister as strongly as I can that, if he wants to act fairly to the force— I have already pointed out to him how terribly illogically this thing will work out, how some will suffer and others will not suffer; I noticed that he entirely glossed over that part of my remarks—if he wants to have an efficient and contented force, the worst thing he can do is to take up this policy of pin-pricking and of looking out for every single place that he can find to say: "Where can I possibly take another whack at this force?"

I shall have something more to say, of course, upon this matter when dealing with the amendments specifically referring to the "cuts" in the Guards' pay, but there is one little remark, which I saw reported in the newspapers the other day, to which I should like to draw the attention of the Minister for Finance, because I am very anxious to see how the Minister for Justice is going to vote on this and subsequent amendments. The other day, I see, the Minister for Justice was giving decorations at the Depôt—the Scott medals—to the men who had earned them, and the Commissioner of the Civic Guards, Colonel Broy, in the presence of the Minister, made this remark:

"He could say that the Minister had spared no effort to eliminate the ‘cuts' and to minimise their effects as much as possible."

Well, of course, if the Commissioner, Colonel Broy, knows that the Minister for Justice spared no efforts to eliminate the "cuts," he can only have heard that from the Minister himself, and I take it, being a man of tact and judgment or he would not be in the position where he is, that Colonel Broy must have made these statements with the consent of the Minister.

Comment on this

I should like to know whether the Deputy is in order in making these statements.

Comment on this

I am merely drawing logical conclusions. I conclude from these remarks that Colonel Broy can only have got this information from the Minister for Justice— and the Minister for Justice was present at the time—and if he had got it confidentially he would be too terrified of the Attorney-General and the Official Secrets Acts to divulge it. I am interested to see how the Minister for Justice is going to vote in this particular instance—whether he will spare no effort to minimise the effect of these "cuts" upon the Guards and whether, later, he will spare no effort to eliminate the Guards from these "cuts" altogether. I will be very anxious to know how the Minister for Justice, who, in this discussion which affects his Department so vitally, is not in the House, will vote when the Division comes.

Comment on this

Do I understand that it is proposed, in computing the national teacher's salary, to take into account the value of his residence?

Comment on this

No.

Comment on this

Is that clear in the Bill? Is it clear that that is excluded?

Comment on this

The Deputy's understanding passes human comprehension.

Comment on this

I want to know is it definitely excluded in the Bill.

Comment on this

I do not know.

Comment on this

The Minister does not know! I thought not.

Comment on this
Division

Question put: "That the words proposed to be deleted stand."

Tá 70
·
Níl 36
Result _

Do you agree with this result?

Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

The decision on amendment 11 disposes of amendments 12, 13, 14 and 15.

Comment on this

How does it dispose of amendments 12 and 13, which deal specifically with the one point: benefits paid otherwise than in money.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

The decision on amendment 11 clearly disposes of amendments 12, 13, 14 and 15.

Comment on this

An amendment was moved to delete the words "and also includes," and to put in instead the words "but does not include." That is to say it would have ruled out allowances paid in money. How does the negativing of that, negative also an amendment which aims only at the ruling out of benefits paid otherwise than in money? I have put down the amendments to permit of the inclusion of certain things paid in money, and have specially directed my attention to the exclusion of benefits given otherwise than in money.

Comment on this

When the Ceann Comhairle was here it was definitely ruled that amendments Nos. 11, 12, and 13 would be taken with 14 and 15.

Comment on this

Who said that? I have no knowledge that the Ceann Comhairle said that.

Comment on this

I am putting it to the Leas-Cheann Comhairle now that the negativing of an amendment seeking to exclude an allowance, whether paid in money or otherwise, has nothing to do with the rejection of a much less wide amendment, which aims only at the exclusion of benefits paid otherwise than in money.

Comment on this

They are all interdependent.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

I think it has been intimated by the Ceann Comhairle that these amendments are interdependent. I think there is no doubt that the decision we have taken rules the other amendments.

Comment on this

In the discussion which we had it was clearly ruled by the Ceann Comhairle that my three amendments, Nos. 11, 14 and 15, and the Minister's amendment No. 16, should be taken together. They were the amendments which were voted upon a few moments ago. These other two amendments, Nos. 12 and 13, were not mentioned from the Chair.

Comment on this

I am certain the Ceann Comhairle mentioned only four amendments.

Comment on this

He mentioned Nos. 6, 7, 9 and 10 and then he went on to mention 11 to 14.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

What is Deputy McGilligan's point?

Comment on this

It was proposed under the Bill to include allowances or benefits, whether paid in money or otherwise than in money and then to exclude certain things. Deputy Fitzgerald-Kenney moved to exclude all these things. I am moving to exclude only benefits paid otherwise than in money. Surely that is much narrower than an amendment to exclude everything. It is a much less wide amendment.

Comment on this

I think the House will remember that the amendments specifically mentioned were 11, 14, 15 and 16. These were distinctly mentioned.

Comment on this

If we agree that No. 16 was carried——

Comment on this

It is negatived.

Comment on this

It has not been negatived.

Comment on this

What has been decided by the House is that the words stand part of the Bill and therefore amendment No. 16 has been negatived.

Comment on this

Amendment No. 16 could not have been negatived because it was not moved by me.

Comment on this

On that argument I would not move 12 or 13.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

I do not think there is any use in discussing amendments Nos. 12 and 13. I think a decision has already been taken on them. If the Deputy, however, presses the point I shall allow him to move them.

Comment on this

I think the amendments are quite distinct, but I am not going to argue it. I can say what I want to say on the section.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

Amendments Nos. 11, 12, 13, 14 and 15 go together.

Comment on this

Have we not already discussed amendment No. 16?

Comment on this

I do not think any Deputy on the Opposition Benches can move a Ministerial amendment unless that Deputy is convinced that it is a proper amendment to be accepted. I move amendment No. 16:—

In sub-section (1), line 50, after the word "uniform" to insert the words "allowance or a plain-clothes."

The House has already decided that where an allowance is paid for a garb of a particular kind, it is to be considered for the purposes of this Bill as remuneration. It is consequential on that, and merely as a logical extension of that principle, that I propose that where the kind of garb which the officer wears is one of his own election as to colour, shape and other characteristics, that it for the purpose of the Bill should be regarded as remuneration.

Comment on this

Would the Minister tell us how many officers and what class of officers this amendment applies to and whether it applies to the Army?

Comment on this

Does the Minister suggest that Army officers can appear in a blue shirt to-morrow?

Comment on this

I am not aware of the fact that any allowance is paid to an Army officer for the purpose of providing himself with a blue shirt.

Comment on this

Would the Minister answer my question: how many, if any, officers of the Guards receive a plain clothes allowance? I know there are some, but I want to know in what circumstances officers of the Guards receive a plain-clothes allowance, or if there are now any officers receiving a plain-clothes allowance.

Comment on this

I am not in a position to say, but if the Deputy would put down a Parliamentary question he would get the information.

Comment on this

Surely it is not necessary to put down a Parliamentary question on a point put to the Minister in the course of the conduct of debate. It is usually assumed that the Minister knows the Bill he is conducting through the House. The Minister now, according to himself, is moving an amendment which may be absolutely meaningless, an amendment, in other words, making the House ridiculous.

Comment on this

It is not.

Comment on this

Can he tell us if any officer, or what class of officers, gets a plain clothes allowance?

Comment on this

As the Deputy knows, there are inspectors who get a plain-clothes allowance.

Comment on this

The Minister said that inspectors received a plain-clothes allowance. I want to get that specifically. Does the Minister make that statement? I am afraid he does not know.

Comment on this

I should like the Deputy to know.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 17:—

In sub-section (2), page 3, line 3, after the word "offices" to add the words "and such aggregate amount shall be subject to such deduction as would be appropriate thereto if the whole of such aggregate amount were—

(c) where one only of the said offices is a whole-time office, the salary of such whole-time office, or

(b) in any other case, the salary of that one of the said offices the salary of which is the greater or greatest.

Section 3 of the Bill, as it stands, provides for the aggregation of salaries where there is more than one salary paid but it does not state specifically what scale of deduction is to be applied to the aggregate salary. The amendment, as will be seen, is intended to make this provision.

Comment on this

I move amendment 18:—

In page 3, to add at the end of the section a new sub-section as follows—

(3) Where the Minister is satisfied that the amount of the salary of an office has been fixed on the basis that an undefined part thereof is of the nature of an allowance for expenses necessarily incurred in the performance of the duties of such office, the Minister shall determine for the purpose of this Act the proportion of such salary which is attributable to such allowance and thereupon the proportion so determined shall not be included in or form part of the salary of such office for the purposes of this Act.

It happens that there are certain cases where remuneration covers more than personal service. It may include office expenses, rent and other expenditure of the sort, but it is not specifically indicated how much of the salary or remuneration is allocated for this purpose. The purpose of this new sub-section is to allow the Minister for Finance to determine for the purposes of this Act what proportion of such salary is attributable to such expenditure and to exclude it from the operation of the Act.

Comment on this

On Section 3, we have got it declared now that the word "salary" includes:

All salary, pay, wages, commission, fees and other remuneration:

and there have been cases where commission has been paid:

whether fixed or paid under statute, order or regulation or otherwise howsoever, and whether calculated by reference to a period of time or by reference to work done, or on any other basis, and also includes allowances and benefits (whether paid in money or given otherwise than in money).

There is then the exception that it is not to include:

any payment made by way of allowance for or reimbursement of specific expenses incurred nor any payment (whether separate or included in other remuneration) which is expressly made as an allowance (other than a uniform allowance).

I should like to find out from the Minister, as he did not mention it as one of the things that might come under these vague phrases of his, whether he does intend to bring under these additions such things as the fees paid to medical officers for vaccinations, for registering births and deaths and such matters. If so, does the Minister know that a deputation was received five years ago which urged that these registration fees which are paid nowadays to professional men should be increased? At the moment, a medical officer in charge of a dispensary gets one shilling for entering up in his register either a birth or a death. With regard to a birth, there has to be entered up the date of the birth, the child's name, the name of the parents, generally, the maiden name of the mother and the place of birth, and, in the case of a death, there are very much the same particulars to be entered up, and, thereafter, if a person wants to get a birth certificate or a dependent or anybody interested wants to get a death certificate a sum of 3/6, I think, has to be paid, one shilling for the filling in of the document and 2/6 to cover the medical officer's trouble in searching back through the years.

The medical officer gets one shilling for entering up these particulars in relation to a birth, and one shilling for very much the same particulars in relation to a death, and if these are queried after the event — at any time. I believe, and not only immediately on the occasion of the birth or death — there is a search fee of 2/6 given. That makes 3/6 in the case of either of those two things, when not taken immediately on the happening of the event or the registration, and, as I say, five years ago, there was a deputation which urged an increase in these fees, and the deputation got a judgment that it was believed that no first-class or second-class serivener could be got to do the work done by these medical officers for the rate at which they were paid. I am assuming that whatever emoluments a dispensary officer gets arising out of these things will suffer a cut to the same degree as his ordinary salary is being cut.

The vaccination system is even worse. A long process has to be gone through with regard to vaccination. The medical officer's duty is to compile an alphabetical index book from the register of births, and, with regard to each prospective vaccination, there have to be entered up, I think, ten separate items — the name, the date of birth, the date of registration, the names of the parents, the maiden name of the mother, I think, also — and then there has to be a statement made as to whether there has been vaccination carried out, whether it has been postponed, whether it has taken, and whether it is going to be tried again. Later — and I think the fee includes all this — there has to be a register of defaulters made out. This is handed to the relieving officer and it is his duty to notify the parents and to impose on them whatever coercion he can to have the child brought in, and, if the child is brought in these, the particulars I have mentioned have got to be entered up.

If the coercion is successful in the case of a defaulter, and, if the infant is brought in in the ordinary way, vaccination has to be performed, and there has to be a dressing put on. There has to be inspection, generally, inside a week, and the medical officer is responsible for the vaccination until it is healed. The average period of healing is, I think, about three weeks. There has to be a register of successful vaccinations brought up to date and handed to the registrar at the union at the end of the month when the medical officer draws his pay, which is at the magnificent rate of 2/- for every successful vaccination. That is included, I am assuming, in some of the vague phrases which the Minister has given us. I do not know whether that payment is calculated by reference to time or to work done, but I am assuming, at any rate, that it forms part of the remuneration and is, consequently, going to be cut down.

I think the Minister is very wise in doing what he proposes to do under amendment 18, just passed, that is, to have a determination as to the amount of salary that is in the nature of an allowance for expenses necessarily incurred and to have it segregated from the salary which is to be cut. I think he might go further and come to the conclusion that neither vaccination nor registration of births or deaths pays. It is actually going to be an encumbrance on a man because it will swell the amount of his emoluments and will thereby bring down the amount of salary he will get.

These wholetime payments were fixed very long ago and the movement there was with regard to them amongst medical men was rather towards getting them increased than getting them reduced. Now, they are going to suffer in a double way because these little things will be added in as part of a man's emoluments and will put the salary at a higher level than that at which it would be if he were not getting these things and, consequently, he will suffer a bigger reduction. I think that that might be attended to. I did put down amendments with a view to elucidating this paragraph and to find out exactly what was the number of people paid on commission, what people get other remuneration which is not salary, pay, wages, commission or fees, how these things are paid if they are not fixed or paid under a statute, order or regulation, and what is paid without reference to a period of time or to work done. In relation to that the only answer was a visit. Surely a visit is paid in relation to the work done? Surely the basis of the visit is work done?

Comment on this

No definite quantum of work is assigned to a visit.

Comment on this

Neither is there in relation to a civil servant's pay.

Comment on this

He is paid on a basis of time.

Comment on this

I also have my doubts about that. That means payment scaled according to hours. Surely not? We did get the example of the visit. That is not a payment by reference to work done. I do not know what the consideration of the payment is. In the absence of more explicit information, I am calling attention to a couple of outstanding things that have been brought to my notice. I think there is a great case to be made for having these small payments definitely segregated from emoluments.

Comment on this

I would like to point out how really vindictive the Minister is towards two services in the State. The House has just passed an amendment setting out that where an undefined part of the salary is in the nature of an allowance for expenses necessarily incurred in the performance of a duty the Minister may determine how much is applicable to expenses and that is to be deducted from the amount on which a reduction is to be made. Where there is a defined part of the salary necessarily incurred in the performance of the duty, that is not to be. In other words, the only people who come under this statute are the Guards and the Army. They are the people who get defined sums for necessary expenses such as the purchase of their uniforms. And because it is a necessary expense and a defined sum has to be paid for it, it is put upon a completely different footing. If an officer of the Guards is receiving a sum in salary which includes his uniform allowance he will come under the section, but because he is receiving a defined sum for this expense, he is not to come under the section. It seems to me to be ridiculous and it can only be a vindictive spirit which dictates this ridiculous attitude.

Comment on this

There is really no substance in what Deputy Fitzgerald-Kenney has said. With regard to the point raised by Deputy McGilligan, I would like to call attention to the fact that the amendment which I proposed relates only to the salaries payable under Part II of the Act. There will be no aggregation of the salaries where they are payable under two Parts. Therefore, while it is true that superintendent and district registrars would be subject to a deduction with the qualifications introduced by the new amendment No. 18, nevertheless, as the major portion of their salaries would be payable by local authorities the deduction, if they were to be subject to one, would fall under Part III of the Act. In their case there would be no aggregation of the salary payable by the local authority and the fees received from the central authority. Therefore, this amendment would not operate, as the Deputy said, to make their salaries liable to deduction at a higher rate.

Comment on this

The Minister says there is only aggregation where a person holds two or more offices from the salaries of which deductions are required by the same Part of the Act. Supposing a person is due for a deduction under Part II and under Part III, he is worse off; there will be no aggregation and he will have deductions from both. Is that so, or is it not so? It is a new situation. Supposing you have a person liable for a salary deduction under Part II and under Part III, does the Minister hold that in that case the person would be excluded from the deductions altogether.

Comment on this

It may happen.

Comment on this

It is not sufficient to say it may happen. What is the certainty of it?

Comment on this

If the salary were below the limit affected by any Part——

Comment on this

Then he is not liable to deduction?

Comment on this

Yes.

Comment on this

Let me take the person whose salary is above the point at which deduction is made. He is liable under Part II and also under Part III. Surely, so far from being safeguarded by this aggregation he is penalised?

Comment on this

He is not.

Comment on this

But there is a deduction under both Parts. If there is an aggregation he is subject to deduction under the higher of the salaries, but not under both. Supposing a man is above the level at which deduction is made under Part II or Part III, would he not suffer?

Comment on this

Not if he is under in one Part.

Comment on this

If he is above the level at which deduction is made under Part II, a deduction will be made?

Comment on this

Yes.

Comment on this

If he is above the level under Part III a deduction will also be made, so that he will suffer two deductions. Instead of being saved in the way the Minister indicated, he is liable to two deductions. In a proper case the Minister's answer about aggregation falls to the ground.

Comment on this

No, it does not.

Comment on this

It is obvious there will be two deductions.

Comment on this

Will the Deputy consider the case of a person receiving a Civil Service salary of £700 a year? He receives that under Part II. He receives from some other public source a salary of £200. If these salaries were aggregated and he was to be cut under Part II on a salary of £900, the Deputy will see that he would be cut at a much higher rate when the salaries are aggregated than if they were made separate.

Comment on this

I have not argued to the contrary. I say that in a proper case where a man is getting a salary above the level at which deduction is made by reason of payments from the local authorities he will suffer. If he also has a salary which, when added to this emolument, brings him above that level, he will also have a deduction made. I think that is a hardship. Does the Minister think that any man is paid at 2/- per vaccination or 1/- per registration of a birth or death in the manner I have described? Would it not be better to exempt these things altogether?

Comment on this

Of course the fact that he must act as superintendent-registrar of births, marriages and deaths is a condition attached to the office which he carries. He draws a salary as dispensary doctor on condition that he discharges the duties of superintendent-registrar.

Comment on this

That is not a condition in the appointment of a dispensary doctor.

Comment on this

Does the Deputy mean to tell me that in the case of a medical officer appointed to a dispensary it is not obligatory on him to accept and discharge the duties of superintendent-registrar?

Comment on this

Certainly. It is not obligatory.

Comment on this

Then he seeks the duty willingly?

Comment on this

The point I am making is that it is not a condition of his appointment.

Comment on this

May I say, then, that he does look for this office?

Comment on this

He does accept it, but it is not obligatory.

Comment on this

Then the case made by Deputy McGilligan falls to the ground.

Comment on this

Because the remuneration is adequate.

Comment on this

If my argument falls to the ground it is not because of anything that the Minister said in countering it.

Comment on this

The Minister spoke of men who enjoyed a salary of so much from the Civil Service and so much from another source. Would that mean any other source, or would it be a public source?

Comment on this

A source within the terms of the Bill.

Comment on this

Will the Minister refer us to the limiting part of this section? "Salary" includes salary from any source whatsoever, according to the definition in Section 3, whether fixed or paid under statute, order or regulation or otherwise. It is the meaning of the word "otherwise" that I ask the Minister to determine.

Comment on this

I am awfully sorry for the Deputy, but I do not see how this Bill covers anything else but salary from a public source.

Comment on this

It is on that I want to be quite clear. I want to be quite clear that it does not cover anything else, that the salary must come from a public source, and that no account can be taken of a man who is a part-time official, and receives a salary from another source. I want to see that he cannot come within this Bill except——

Comment on this

If the Deputy will look at the section——

Comment on this

Will the Minister shut up for a moment? The Minister is continually interrupting, and will not allow any Deputy to finish the sentence he is addressing to the Chair. It is a habit the Minister has. He has always acted in that way — it is not alone on this particular Bill, but——

Comment on this

I want to point out——

Comment on this

May I suggest that the Minister be asked to preserve some signs of listening. Again and again he has offended by interrupting Deputies, and again and again he has been asked to keep quiet, but he cannot possibly do so.

Comment on this

Neither can the Deputy.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

I called on Deputy O'Sullivan to speak; he is entitled to speak without interruption.

Comment on this

But the Deputy expects to be answered.

Comment on this

Order, order!

Comment on this

Evidently the Minister has not the remotest conception of order, or of how a debate should be conducted. He has again and again shown his want of knowledge of this Bill by not giving the information asked for on the ground that he did not know it. I suggest that another Minister be given charge of the Bill. I want to be quite clear that nothing in the Bill will enable the Minister, if he thinks fit, to take into account salaries received elsewhere, salaries got otherwise than fixed by statute or regulation. I want an answer to that question. The Minister could wait until I sit down, and then he could answer the question.

Comment on this

He cannot.

Comment on this

I cannot penetrate the dull, obtuse intellect of Deputy O'Sullivan. But I have already told him that nothing in this Bill will affect remuneration obtained from private sources.

Comment on this

That is the intention of the Bill but the question here is does the Bill limit it so that private sources will not be brought in. I think the definition of "salary" given in Section 3 of this Bill was intended to be tied down to salaries drawn from what we may call public offices. But in fact it is not so clearly tied down as the Minister seems to imagine because the word "salary" is defined as including "all salary, pay, wages, commission, fees, and other remuneration, whether fixed or paid under statute, order or regulation or otherwise..."; paid one may say in any way under the latter part of the section and whether calculated by work or time or any other thing. Now when we come on to the deduction it is quite clear that the deduction can only be made from salary which is paid to him as a public officer. But surely the amount of the deduction from that office might also be in regard to a salary earned otherwise than from a public office. I see no limiting phrase in the definition which makes the Minister's meaning clear. I am sure the intention of the Bill is what the Minister says, but we have a number of people pointed at in Section 6, people who are employed in any other civil capacity whether permanent or temporary in the public services of Saorstát Eireann. It is clear enough and it is possible that there are people who are temporarily employed in the public services and are in receipt of emoluments and who while in receipt of those emoluments are capable of getting emoluments from other sources. I am sure it is not the intention to have the deductions made in respect of anything except what he receives by way of salary from the public employment. But that is not clear. Perhaps if the Minister will give me a limiting phrase it will clear the matter. I do not see any limiting phrase in the Bill. I suggest the matter is worth looking into. We do get this very wide phrase and I suggest that the section can be read back to line 40 in the definition. If it is not possible to relate it back to the words in lines 40 and 42 in Section 3 then I think that there is that loophole. That deduction must be made from the amount of salary a person receives from his employment in the public service but the amount of it may be determined not by what he gets in the public service but what he gets outside the public service. Now if that is absolutely impossible where is the limiting phrase in regard to it?

Comment on this

I suppose Deputy O'Sullivan is the proud parent of this mare's nest. He seems an appropriate person to occupy such a role. If the Deputies had taken the trouble to read this Bill we would not have the time of the House wasted. In sub-section (2) of Section 6 there is quite clearly a limitation on the power of the Minister to make deductions in respect of salary. That section reads: "This part of this Act applies to a person whether his employment is a whole-time or part-time, or is for particular work or a particular occasion, and whether the amount of salary is fixed by statute or otherwise but this part of this Act applies to a person only so long and in so far as he is employed and remunerated in the manner mentioned in the foregoing sub-section of this section." That is to say: is employed as "a commissioned officer in or a chaplain to the defence forces of Saorstát Eireann or a member of the Gárda Síochána, teacher in a national school, or in any capacity in a preparatory school, or in any other civil capacity, whether permanent or temporary, in the public service of Saorstát Eireann and is remunerated wholly or partly (whether directly or indirectly) out of the Central Fund or moneys provided by the Oireachtas or a fund under the control of a Minister."

Comment on this

May I point out that the Minister has completely missed the point?

Comment on this

No, he has not.

Comment on this

I may be allowed to point out that he has. The point I raised was this: whether there was anything in the section to provide that "salary" did not include any salary that came other than from public funds. The Minister has not shown that. All he has said is that the deduction only applies in respect of State salary. But let us take it that a man is a whole-time officer at a salary of £150 a year. The man has from another source a salary of £400 a year. So far as this section is concerned, what I want to know is this: is it quite clear that that £400 is absolutely excluded and that it is not possible under the section to take into account, in making up the Minister's mind as to what may be deducted from the salary of £150? I suggest that Section 6, which the Minister read out as an answer to the point raised, has got absolutely nothing to do with it.

Comment on this

Is that the only answer the Minister has to the point raised? It clearly does not cover the ground.

Comment on this

It does. Only so long and in so far as the person is employed — in no other way.

Comment on this

Let us consider that: "Only so long and in so far as he is employed and remunerated in a manner mentioned in the foregoing sub-section of this section." How do you get away from the difficulty mentioned? Let us take a person remunerated partly out of the Central Fund or some other fund under the control of the Minister and receiving emoluments from some other source. The word "salary" as defined here includes everything he gets. It does not say everything he gets from that source.

Comment on this

From that source.

Comment on this

If that were there it would be correct, but it is not there.

Comment on this

It is not necessary.

Comment on this

That is what we are arguing. The fact that the Minister has suggested that phrase seems to me to indicate that he feels it is necessary. Certainly it is necessary, it is water-tight then. It is not intended to catch any other moneys. Is it capable of extension so as to catch them?

Comment on this

No.

Comment on this

Because it is not.

Comment on this

I am not so built that I shall accept the ipsissima verba of the Minister on a matter of interpretation of this Act, or of any Act, but in particular on the interpretation of this. In the short space we have been at it already it is clear that he has not considered, and could not have considered, points raised for the first time. If it was not for a peculiar type of vanity, the Minister would have no great hesitation in admitting it. Why could not this be brought up again on the Report Stage with the statement that it has been put before those better fitted to judge, without any derogation from the Minister's status, whether the phraseology is capable of extension to the case we have mentioned?

Comment on this

But it is not.

Comment on this

That is the difficulty.

Comment on this

If the Deputy will turn to the Schedule.

Comment on this

There is another argument. Every argument that is made shows the weakness of the case.

Comment on this

No, it does not.

Comment on this

What does the Schedule amount to? It simply says: "There are the salaries from which deductions are to be made."

Comment on this

And the salaries are drawn from the public service and nothing else.

Comment on this

I am not saying that a deduction is going to be made from any salary other than one paid to a man in the public service because it cannot be done; but the amount of the deduction the Minister will make from the salary is under his control is another thing. Is it one calculated in relation only to the money he gets from the public service?

Comment on this

Certainly. If the Deputy will turn to the Schedule he will see that.

Comment on this

Whatever strength there may be in any other argument made by the Minister, the Schedule has not any strength in it as an argument, because it merely says: "There is the source from which you are to get the deductions."

Comment on this

And there are the cuts.

Comment on this

And there is the amount. The amount is a percentage amount. There is the source from which this money is to be gathered in. Then you turn back to find out how the percentage deduction is to be calculated and it is calculated by taking in everything that a man earns.

Comment on this

In the public service.

Comment on this

If there were somewhere in Section 3, which defines this, something about the public service I would be satisfied, but it is not there. As long as it is not there, I think it is still open to that interpretation. Nobody wants it. All we want is merely a statement that that point will be considered.

Comment on this

Is that all the Deputy wants?

Comment on this

Absolutely.

Comment on this

There is no substance in it, but, if it pleases the Deputy, I will consider the point.

Comment on this

I will admit that the Minister thinks there is no substance in it. Honour is satisfied.

Comment on this
Conor Alexander Maguire The Attorney-General (Mr. Maguire) Fianna Fáil

This is a rather ingenious point raised by Deputy O'Sullivan, but I think that the Title can be looked to.

Comment on this

Does the Title ever rule a Bill? We have never had that ruled here.

Comment on this
The Attorney-General

Perhaps I may be wrong, as I have never come up against this point before. I am only suggesting to the Deputy that if the Bill is passed into an Act with this Title to it, the Title can be looked to to construe a particular section. The Title provides for the making of deductions from remuneration payable out of public moneys. Then as to Section 3 (1), I think Deputy McGilligan is wrong in saying that that can be construed as defining salary as anything other than remuneration attached to an office. If you go on to Section 7 (1), I think it is made clear. That sub-section states: "From all salary which, during the current financial year is earned by and payable to each person to whom this Part of this Act applies, there shall be made a deduction calculated at the rate stated and in accordance with the provisions contained in the Schedule to this Act which are applicable to such person." The deduction is only from the salary.

Comment on this

That is agreed, but how much?

Comment on this

Turn to the Schedule.

Comment on this
The Attorney-General

I admit that the point is an ingenious one, but I do not think it can possibly be interpreted in the way the Deputy stated. May I add this? If there is any doubt whatever about it, we will make it right.

Comment on this

I am quite willing to accept that. May I point out that the Title merely says that the deductions must be made from public moneys. That was never in dispute. In the whole argument that was common ground. What we want to know is whether, as the actual words of the Bill stand, other money can be taken into account in calculating what is going to be deducted.

Comment on this

It could not.

Comment on this

I am speaking, through the Chair, to the Attorney-General. I am asking whether other money could be taken into account in calculating the amount that might be deducted, as well as the amount coming from public funds. If the Attorney-General agrees to look into it, I am satisfied. If there is any doubt I want it removed.

Comment on this

It could not.

Comment on this
The Attorney-General

I think the Deputy has not read the Title, which provides for the making of deductions from remuneration payable out of public funds.

Comment on this

The governing word is "from."

Comment on this
The Attorney-General

The deductions are to be made out of public moneys. I think it is quite clear that the point could not arise. I do not think there is any substance in it.

Comment on this

In view of the discussion that has taken place, will the Attorney-General undertake to consider the matter and see if, in his considered judgment, the wording of the section carries out the intention? If so, we shall be satisfied.

Comment on this

Let us see what is the point raised by Deputy O'Sullivan — that is, if he still remembers it. It was this: that a person might be employed in the public service. He must either be employed whole-time or part-time. In addition to the remuneration which he drew from his employment in the public service he also had remuneration from another source, and I understood Deputy O'Sullivan to say from a private source. May I ask Deputy O'Sullivan if that is correct?

Comment on this

Possibly.

Comment on this

Is that the point the Deputy made?

Comment on this

Well then I ask the Deputy to turn to the Schedule of the Bill. I ask him to turn to Part IV, which is the only part which deals with part-time and whole-time service. Quite obviously remuneration which is covered by whole-time service must be the remuneration which the public servant draws when he serves whole-time as a public servant. That is the only remuneration which the Minister for Finance or any other person can take cognisance of. If he draws remuneration from a private source it must be for work done outside the ordinary hours of a public servant. Section (a) of Part IV covers that case, and covers it definitively. There can be no doubt as to what and how much remuneration is to be the subject of deduction.

On the other hand, a person may be employed in a part-time capacity. That is the only case I can conceive which would fulfil the conditions laid down by Deputy O'Sullivan, that is that the person would draw remuneration as an employee in the public service, and at the same time, out of some other work which he does in a private capacity elsewhere, would receive remuneration from some other source. If he is a part-time employee there can be no question at all as to how his salary is to be computed, because the deduction has to be a proportion of the full amount payable to him out of public funds, and from no other source.

Comment on this

That is the difficulty.

Comment on this

That does not satisfy the matter at all. I should like, since the Attorney-General is going to look into the matter, to draw his attention to two points which he made. They both converge on the same point, and not the point which has been discussed. What is the long Title of the Bill? I have never yet heard anybody announce that the long Title of a Bill should be taken to govern the measure. We have here, over and over again, found ourselves forced by necessity into enlarging the Title of a Bill when the content of the Bill was clearly outside the Title. The Attorney-General may have a case in mind, but I know no case where the Act was restricted by reason of the Title.

Comment on this
The Attorney-General

The Title of an Act may be looked at so as to gather the intention of a phrase.

Comment on this

Let us look at it. That is all we are bound to do. What does the long Title come to? I do not want to read it. The part to which the Attorney-General drew special attention is "provide for the making of deductions from remuneration payable." The governing words are "deductions from." We have always admitted that the only fund from which these deductions can be made is the moneys paid to a person while he is in the public service. Whether the amount deducted will have relation only to the moneys originally paid for service of a public type, or whether something else will be brought in, is the point we are arguing. The Attorney-General referred to Section 7. That section refers to this point again, and the source from which these deductions are to be drawn. Referring me to the Schedule I do not think carries me any further. When we get to Part III what does the Schedule stand as? A model. It is not down as a regular rule. It is not an absolute criterion. There are to be certain deductions made. I think the phrase runs through all those paragraphs 9, 10 and 11 —"having regard to the proportion of such grant ordinarily applied to the payment of such salaries, to the deductions from salaries to be made under Part II of this Act, and to the other circumstances of the case."

Comment on this

That has nothing to do with Section 3.

Comment on this

It is the whole point we are arguing. I only rose this last time to say that the Attorney-General seems to have fixed his mind too much on what is not in dispute. From what fund are these deductions to be made? Supposing our contention is right — I hope it is not — it does me no good to have it said to me: "You are in receipt of £900 from the public service, but you have another £600 outside, and we are going to make a deduction based on £1,500; we will only deduct it from the £900." We might say, in answer to you: "Sour grapes! You could not get at the other £600. You can get at the £900, and if you make a deduction on the basis of my getting £1,500, it is very little solace to say ‘we are tied down and can only take it out of the £900.'"

Comment on this

Might I ask the Minister whether, in fixing the proportion of the salary that he considers is a proper allowance for expenses necessarily incurred in the performance of duties of a position, he will take into account certain variable factors, and whether he will make provision for altering the proportion according as those factors change? For instance, in the case of an employment exchange manager I presume part of his salary will be considered as an allowance for expenses necessarily incurred in the provision of premises. That premises obviously pays rates and rent. If, two or three days after the Minister has fixed the proportion referred to in the amendment, these are raised through the falling in of the lease or something of that kind, the official would have a very big grievance if the Minister did not provide for such a contingency. Is it intended that the proportion will vary from time to time in order to make provision for such variable conditions as that?

Comment on this

Yes, according as the expenses vary.

Comment on this

I move amendment 19:—

In sub-section (2) to delete the word "full," line 18, and substitute the word "reduced," and in the same line to delete the word "not."

This amendment is put down to get some illumination on what exactly sub-paragraph (2) of Section 4 means, and, if it means what I fear, to guard against a particular happening. I want to take, first of all, the case of a person granted a pension. I may take a specific case. People have been granted pensions under what is called. I think, the Military Service Act. There were I.R.A. pensions granted, and there was a sliding scale with regard to payment. Those pensions have deductions made from them according to the amount of salary which a person is in receipt of from, say, occupation in public service. Do I read sub-paragraph (2) of Section 4 correctly in assuming that for the future although a cut is made in the salary which a person was getting he is deemed to continue at the old rate of salary, and that, therefore, his pension, which has been cut down because he is in actual receipt of certain moneys, will not be allowed to move up although in fact he is not in receipt of these moneys? That is what it amounts to. There will be some definite hardship on people whom it was never the intention should suffer under a measure of this sort, and if that is so I would press my amendment. It would add at the end that the deduction will be made in relation to the actual facts of the case, and not in relation to something that is deemed to have been the facts. The superannuation case is the one that bothers me most. I do not know whether the same consideration or arithmetical consideration would hold there, because I had not a concrete case before me. Again if there are people in receipt of what are described as superannuation allowances and also remuneration in some grade of the public service, and if that particular superannuation allowance is cut down under some sliding scale, according to what money they are in receipt of, then this paragraph means that the superannuation allowance will continue at the cut-down rate in relation to the moneys received by the person. If that is so, I think it is rather an unjust arrangement. Certainly I am on firm ground in regard to I.R.A. pensions. It was always regarded as a hardship to have pensions given under such conditions cut down, because the person was in receipt of other moneys for different services. And it was a deplorable practice that those persons should be condemned to be cut because of some others who were not cut. If the Minister can give me an example of people in receipt of superannuation allowances and getting remuneration from the public service I could argue that.

Comment on this