Public Services (Temporary Economies) Bill, 1933—Committee.
Contributions 429–622 of 622. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 3 parts.
No. 12 of 1933 ›
The Deputy may take the interpretation put upon the section as correct. If a person is in receipt of a military service pension, and subsequently gets employment in the public service, that re-employment is in the nature of a boon to him. If the salary attached to his present position is equivalent to the salary he enjoyed in his former office, his Civil Service pension is wholly suspended; if less his Civil Service pension operates to bring his emoluments consisting of salary and pension up to the emoluments enjoyed by him in his former office. In the case of a person in receipt of a military service pension the procedure is different. His military service pension is reduced by reason of his employment in the public service pro rata. If his salary as a public servant is £550 a year or more then it is wholly suspended. That is the position and we think it is a justifiable one. This deals with salaries. It deals with the salary of persons reduced by reason of their employment in the public service and takes no cognisance of the pension position whatever. If it happens, in present circumstances, that a person is employed in the public service and draws something as a pension as well, we leave the pension untouched. His salary is cut the same as that of any other employee in the service and that is the only just and equitable basis to go on.
Comment on this
Intention and actual facts are two things. I am contrasting. Would the Attorney-General let his mind turn on to this, as to whether pension could not possibly be included under such special definition as salary or as salary, pay, wages, commission fees, and other remuneration, leaving out the other vague phrases?
Comment on this
That may be. But the intention may be different; and, at any rate, if it does not effect the purpose, it would be wrong to have the phrase carried in here. I am against this whole scheme in regard to military pensions and I.R.A. pensions.
Comment on this
I am speaking definitely and clearly to my own amendment, and if not, I would be ruled out by the Chair. It is not beyond doubt whether pension is dragged in under the heading of salary.
Comment on this
Apart from that, and leaving out superannuation allowances, I am going to divide the House for the reason that military service pensions or I.R.A. pensions are to be kept at a particular rate, to which they were limited by reason of the fact that people were in receipt of certain service moneys, and are to be kept at that rate when people are not in receipt of those moneys. They are not a very numerous class, but the pensions grants were grants for a particular service and should not be played about with. If for nothing else than that, I shall have to divide the Committee.
Comment on this
I do not think there is the slightest doubt that the definition does not cover pensions. I fail to see what words the Deputy could suggest.
Comment on this
You cannot speak of superannuations and pensions.
Comment on this
No, not in my opinion. I do not know why the Deputy raises it unless he has got some reasonable suggestion. I see no cause for doubt.
Comment on this
Question put: "That the words proposed to be deleted stand part of the Bill."
Do you agree with this result?
I move amendment 20:—
In line 22 to delete the word "and" and substitute therefor the words "unless the person from whose salary paid under such contract of service a deduction under this Act is made or proposed to be made claims that the making of or proposing to make such deduction shall operate as his discharge and the termination of his contract of service, and in the absence of such claim."
I put down this amendment to get certain elucidation on the meaning of the section, and to guard against the danger which might possibly lurk, which I think decidedly does lurk, in it. (Section read). I can imagine there being a very innocent and, in fact, quite a praiseworthy idea behind the section. It might be regarded if there were salaries fixed by statute, by order, regulation or otherwise, and if the appropriate or fixed salary was not paid, that the moment it ceased to be paid, there was a breach of contract, whether persons wanted to have that contract broken or not. In that sense, this section must cover such a contingency as a good case, which would allow a contract to continue. There is also the possibility that it may go much further. It may go to the point that it prevents a contract being deemed even to have been broken, and so consequently would encroach on the rights of civil servants, and particularly on the rights of transferred officers of the Civil Service. I want to save one without permitting the other by putting in the phrase in my amendment. By my amendment I want to save that the contract would not be immediately broken because salaries were reduced. I do not want to allow that the salary can be reduced and that a breach of the contract can be effected — in fact, that a breach did not need to exist — on the will of one of the two parties to the contract. As the section with my amendment would read I am putting the onus on the person who says he regards the contract as broken and that he has been discharged, with whatever consequences may thereafter follow. “In the absence of such claim” the contract shall continue to subsist subject to the right to suffer such deduction. I would like to have a declaration on the section, whether or not it is intended to break contracts entered into with civil servants, and particularly State contracts enshrined in an international document, the phrase used by the President of the Executive Council when this matter was under discussion on another occasion. We ought to be definite. There is either an attempt to break through a contract of service with civil servants and other people. by the State, or else it is not so intended. If it is not so intended then why frame a phrase which would permit such a thing to be done? It should not be there. We should avoid it by some phrase, approximately such a phrase as I have in my amendment. At any rate, I set down the purpose of my amendment and I want to hear what is said on it.
Comment on this
The object of the section as it stands is to ensure that the present position remains in fact, as between employer and employee, and that the contract as it stands remains. The only change the Government proposes is in regard to a reduction in remuneration. There is no intention of interfering otherwise in the contract. As far as they are concerned the position will be exactly the same as before. What Deputy McGilligan wants is that a party to the contract should be enabled to take certain action and to determine a decision which in any event should be given by a tribunal after it had heard the merits of the case. It seems that Deputy McGilligan's amendment would tend to give to one party to the contract what it does not give to the other party—to with the Government. In any case, I think the section as it stands does not interfere with rights of civil servants. As regards transferred officers I am advised that under Section 10 of the Treaty whatever rights they had are still maintained to them. They can go to the Compensation Tribunal if they think they have a case. If they think this section entitles them to put up a case, and if they have been discharged and the contract terminated, they can go before the Compensation Tribunal. I think the Deputy should be satisfied with that. If the amendment were inserted it would mean that the issue would be prejudiced. The Compensation Tribunal is there and the civil servant, if he says that his position has been worsened or his contract terminated, can go there. As regards the civil servants who are not transferred civil servants, I am advised that the position, even with the amendment inserted, would not, in fact, strengthen their position. They would have no greater rights than they have at present. So that, if the main contention of the Deputy is that he is interested in the case of the transferred civil servants and fears that their rights have been prejudiced, I think the section preserves that. The section in fact preserves the rights of these servants and preserves the contract. The Deputy, in this amendment, proposes to hand over to one party to the contract the right to say whether in fact, the contract has been determined or not. The general attitude of the Government in this section is to ensure that matters will remain exactly as before and that no changes would be made between the State and its employees who are affected by the Bill.
Comment on this
I should like to know from the Minister whether he means by that that Section 5, if passed as at present, will not be used before the tribunal as a defence to any action or proceedings brought by a transferred officer claiming to retire under this Bill. I should like a specific answer from the Minister to that.
Comment on this
I could not give a definite assurance in advance as to what might happen in the hypothetical case which the Deputy has suggested.
Comment on this
Therefore, the Minister cannot say whether the intention is to impair the rights of transferred officers under Article 10 or the Act of 1929. I understand that the purpose of Deputy McGilligan's amendment is to extract from the Minister a statement of Government policy as to what is the meaning of this Section 5 in relation to the rights of transferred officers under Article 10 and the Act of 1929, and I suggest that the virtuous attitude taken up by the Minister in connection with this matter is quite untenable because the shoe is on the other foot. The Minister suggests that Deputy McGilligan, by his amendment, will bring about a position whereby one party to the contract will be entitled to repudiate it, so to speak. The inference from that statement of the Minister is that it will be the civil servants or other officials affected by this Bill who will be in that position; but the Minister overlooks this very important and vital consideration, that this section itself enables one party to the contract to say: "Away with your contract; we will break it; you can stick to your part of the bargain but we will not keep ours." That is what this means. We are under a contract, expressed or implied, with civil servants and other people employed by the State, to give them a certain remuneration. Notwithstanding that we are breaking our side of the contract we force them by law to undertake their part of the bargain. If that is not unilateral breaking of a contract I do not know what it means.
Comment on this
I do not think the Minister can have understood Deputy Costello's question. The Minister was asked by Deputy Costello for an assurance that this section, if passed as it stands, will not be used as a defence on the part of the State if any transferred officer takes a case before a tribunal, to which he is entitled to go, on the basis that his salary had been reduced. In reply to that, the Minister said that he could give no such assurance. The conclusion from that I think is that the Government either do intend and have definitely made up their minds in advance to use this section as a defence in an action brought under the Transferred Officers Act, or they have not yet made up their minds to use it as a defence. It either means that in such a case a statement will be made that this Act of Parliament overrides the earlier one, and that consequently there is a new situation, or it may mean that the Government have not yet made up their minds to do that but that they are certainly not going to prejudice their future by telling us that they will not so use it. I suggest that that is dangerous. It will not bring very much comfort to civil servants, particularly when they remember that we were told by the President on a former occasion that these transferred officers had their rights and that these rights were enshrined in an international agreement which this House could not change. Yet the Minister will not tell us here that he stands over that phrase and that the present Government do not intend to use this section, if passed in its present form, as something overriding the previous position or overriding the Act guaranteeing the present position to these officers. The Minister rather gives the impression that the Government have made up their minds so to use this section.
I do not, by my amendment, put it in the power of one party to this contract to break the contract by unilateral action. I put in the word "unless" and the force of it is merely to negative what the section wants to achieve, that is that the making of a deduction by the State, by unilateral action on the part of the State, shall not operate to terminate the contract "unless the person from whose salary a deduction under this Act is made or proposed to be made claims that the making or proposing to make such deduction shall operate as his discharge and the termination of his contract of service and in the absence of such claim." I say it shall operate only if the people affected do not claim something to the contrary, but I do not say that their claim is final and conclusive. I only say that I put a stop to this section from running against them. The matter would then have to be determined by the particular tribunal concerned. What I want to do is to get the balance back as it was previously — that there are two parties to the contract each with rights and there is a tribunal with judicial powers to determine the position. What we are faced with now is that the Government wants to have this position achieved by this section: they are going to make deductions from salaries and then can say that that is not a breach of the contract, that the House has passed it and if anybody is foolish enough to go to the Compensation Tribunal he will be met with this. He will be told that the State has decreed that that is not a breach of the contract. He will be told: "We are going to keep all our contracts as guaranteed to the civil servants except in this one particular, that we can shift your salary up and down as we please," and, of course, they know it will be down. We want to stop that. I thought we could have stopped it by getting a statement from the Minister that he did not intend to use the section in this way, but the Minister has refused to say that there was no intention to use this defence in any action that may be brought under the old transferred officers guarantees. We have to conclude that the Government are going to break their contract and to plead that this House has given them leave to do it and has given them the right to do it or else we must conclude that they do not know whether or not they will have to so use it in the future.
In any event, I want to hark back to what was said here in the Debates of the 19th May of last year where, in answer to a question of the late Deputy Finlay, the President said:—
"There is no intention whatever to interfere with the rights of civil servants in this legislation—none whatever. They are amply safeguarded."
and in answer to a further question the President said:—
"Article 10, as far as it gave them rights, is gone. This is a document, an agreement, which is completely setting aside Article 10, because it gives effect to the intention that is actually in the Bill itself —‘for the final determination in accordance with their will.' That is a final document, a new Treaty, if you like. It is an international document safeguarding their rights, and their rights are not dependent on Article 10. This is the document on which their rights depend, and there is no suggestion——"
At this point he was interrupted by Deputy Cosgrave, who said:
"Is it open to the Legislature at any time to repeal, alter, or amend that Act as it stands?"
and the President's answer to that was:
"It is not, because it embodied an international document. There was an international agreement."
Now the Minister for Education, in a casual moment, tells us that he cannot give an assurance that this is not intended to be used as a defence in the way the President said it could not be used because it would be an attempt to override an international document.
Comment on this
These casual moments which Deputy McGilligan speaks of are very trying. The Deputy proposes a particular amendment, but in the course of his disquisitions in the House he manages to depart clearly from it and to explain to the House what it means or what the implications of it are. If Deputies read the amendment they will appreciate the fact that Deputy McGilligan, in his effort to clarify matters, proposes to give to every transferred officer the right to say, when these cuts operate, that he is discharged from the service. By reason of that fact he can go to the Compensation Tribunal and get the specially favourable compensation terms that the 1929 Act lays down. If Deputies believe that the Government, when it is trying to effect economies, should not at least get a square deal but should be tied up by an amendment of this kind then they are simply proposing to lay down as the law that, what the civil servant affected by the cuts claims, shall, in fact, be the determining factor. If Deputies believe that economies can be effected in that way then they should certainly support Deputy McGilligan's amendment.
The Deputy has made no case whatever why the amendment should be inserted. He has a legal doubt in his own mind but what does it amount to? Surely the Deputy ought to be able to get over the doubt in the section, if there is a doubt, without proposing to hand over the entire determination of this question to the persons affected and without giving the State any right in the matter — to leave it to every civil servant to be entitled to say: "I claim that this action of the Government entitles me to compensation as a transferred officer under the special terms of the 1929 Act." If that course were adopted, then not alone would we have no economies but the State would have far bigger liabilities than it has — tenfold liabilities in proportion to the economies that we are seeking to bring about under the Bill. Under the amendment every single transferred officer, simply because he claimed that he was affected in a particular manner — that this action of the Government operated to his disfavour — could say that he was entitled to get that compensation. There is no mention at all of the State.
Comment on this
Deputy McGilligan has not answered the point that I made that the section, in fact, makes no difference whatever. It makes a difference in regard to the remuneration. A reduction is made in the remuneration, but as regards the legal contract it is unimpaired. If we were to accept the amendment we would simply be accepting the position that every one of the State servants affected by this Bill could declare themselves to be adversely affected, claim for compensation and leave the service. I do not think that, without further argument on the question, any serious Deputy could agree that Deputy McGilligan's point of view could possibly be accepted. In my opinion it would negative the whole force of the Bill and the economies it is proposed to make as well as add enormous liabilities to the State. As I said in the beginning, it is not even fair to Deputy McGilligan because presumably he wants to hold the balance evenly between the State and the employee, but that is just what he does not do.
Comment on this
Because "unless the person from whose salary paid under such contract of service a deduction under this Act is made or proposed to be made claims"— that is to say if he just claims——
Comment on this
——that his contract is determined by these cuts, then he will take the usual action and apply for compensation, I presume, under the Act Deputy Costello referred to.
Comment on this
He has the full right at present to make his application in the usual way to the Compensation Tribunal. Deputy McGilligan wants to give a decision in advance. He also wants the Minister for Finance to come forward in the House and give an assurance that he is not going to take certain action in the event of this case being triable at law; that he is not going to take action to defend the rights of the State as he sees them and as he is charged to look after them, but that he is going to let the whole question go by default and award compensation to the civil servant in advance. I do not think any Minister for Finance could possibly give any such assurance. I do not say that the Minister for Finance is not endeavouring, as I have said, to give the civil servant the ordinary fair play that he had. There is no proof, except the legal doubts that exist under Deputy McGilligan's amendment, that his contract is being interfered with. If it is being interfered with, let us remember that the civil servants in question have the ordinary rights to go before the Compensation Tribunal, and if they can substantiate their case there they will get compensation in the usual way.
Comment on this
I think the Minister has been more successful in attacking Deputy McGilligan's amendment than he has been in defending the section.
Comment on this
The position at the moment under the Civil Service (Transferred Officers) Compensation Act, 1929, is that an aggrieved civil servant whose salary has been reduced, whose conditions of employment have been materially altered to his detriment, or who feels that the contract with him has been broken can, of his own volition, go before the Civil Service Compensation Board and there make a claim in accordance with the provisions of the Act. Now this section prevents a civil servant pleading that his contract has been broken although his conditions of service have been materially altered to his detriment. The position, therefore, under the section is that from their being no obstacle in his way heretofore to go before the Compensation Board and plead that his contract has been varied to his detriment, he now finds himself in this position: that Section 5 will be used as an impediment against him when he goes before the Compensation Board.
Comment on this
It can have no other meaning, because the official side of the Board will be entitled to say: "Your contract is not broken. This is only a deduction and your contract is still preserved." I think this is a case of killing the cat with milk. The Government's attitude in the matter is not nearly as generous as the Minister for Education painted it, because the clear purpose of the section is to say to an officer: "Although your conditions of service have been altered to your detriment, notwithstanding, your contract is not broken." Why say that at all? Is it not clear that the contract is broken when a person's conditions of service have been materially altered to his detriment? While the Minister says he objects to Deputy McGilligan's amendment because he claims it gives power to an individual civil servant to operate a break in the contract, still the Minister is insisting in Section 5 that even if it is advantageous to a civil servant to plead that his contract has been broken the Minister will not permit him to do that. As between an individual civil servant on the one hand having, say, 60 per cent. of the case, with 40 per cent. being on the Government side all the time, I would be prepared to take a risk and give the individual civil servant more power in the matter, seeing that he has got to fight his case against the Executive Council all the time.
Comment on this
As Deputy McGilligan says, here is a new law grafted on to the other impediments that are against him. In the case of an individual civil servant who is fighting the law, I certainly would be on the side all the time of giving the individual civil servant the advantage, because fighting the law is an expensive pastime for the individual civil servant, as the President knows. I think there is much more to be said for Deputy McGilligan's amendment in the circumstances than for the section.
Comment on this
I want to press my amendment, but I want Deputy Norton thoroughly to understand it. As the situation is at the moment, there is a contract between certain transferred officers and the State. As this section goes, the Minister for Education has told us that, although the salary is going to be reduced, they want to have it that that does not break the contract. I want it otherwise, but I do not want to have it that there is a breach of contract simply because the civil servant says there is.
Comment on this
If the Minister would follow it a little more painstakingly he would discover. The section runs: "The making under this Act of a deduction from salary paid under a contract of service shall not operate to terminate such contract." I want to hit that. I want to stop the force of that phrase and to say "shall not operate to terminate such contract unless the person affected"— let us put in that phrase for the purpose of the legal argument that is to follow —"claims that the making of such deduction... shall operate as his discharge and the termination of his contract of service." That does not mean that it does so operate — that is a matter for determination by the Tribunal — but it does this, and it is what I want to achieve; it stops the overriding force of the clause which the Minister for Education is standing over. A civil servant can say: "I claim, I do no more than that, that that breaks my contract, and, therefore, I am in the same old position. I can go to the Transferred Officers' Board." I put the phrase in at one time which would definitely put an end to the contract—"whereupon the making of such deduction shall operate as his discharge"— but I cut it out. What the amendment provides at the moment and what I want to have is: the State can say to everybody: "This does not operate as a breach of your contract," and unless the person is vigilant in regard to his own rights and claims that it does, then his contract is not deemed to be broken. If he claims that it does, then it does not mean that his claim is satisfied. He has got to prove that before the proper Tribunal. I say that in the absence of such a claim the contract shall continue to subsist. In other words, if there are civil servants who will say: "We recognise that a certain situation exists; we will allow certain deductions to be made and we will not stand on our contractual rights," they can give that accord to the State in the matter, but if anybody has rights and wants to stand on them, I want to put them back to the old position. The Minister has read into my amendment a phrase which is not there. I do not suggest that once they claim, the contract can be terminated.
Comment on this
What is the meaning of the phrase then "claims that the making of or proposing to make such deduction shall operate as his discharge."
Comment on this
I do not say that. I say that unless the person claims, certain things shall operate. I do not say that on the claim being made the discharge shall operate. I say to a person who is making the most of the force of the section: "Notwithstanding what we do in regard to you, there is no breach of contract; the old contract still subsists." That is my amendment. There is, however, a serious situation revealed here. The Minister says: "We are going to keep our contract, but we are going to reduce their pay." What is there in the contract of service about which the transferred officers have been agitating for years except pay and pension, which depends upon pay? I want now the old position, the position which we were told by the President could not be dislodged by any domestic act of the State because it was enshrined in an international document. The Minister says now: "We are not changing that international document. We are only going to change it in a small particular." Let me say that I think Deputy Norton used a most inappropriate phrase in referring to this as killing the cat with milk. Unless he is referring to the free milk, that the civil servants might be killed by the free distribution of milk, the phrase was most inappropriate.
Comment on this
If the Deputy suggests that the Minister in dealing with the question was full of milk and honey, I agree. We are told now that if this is a breach of the transferred officers' rights, it is only a little bit of a breach — the usual excuse that is given. It is only an interruption of their pay. I wonder was that what President de Valera had in mind when he said in answer to Deputy Finlay last year that these men's rights could not be interfered with because they were enshrined in an international document? Are we now to be told that though they are enshrined in an international document we cannot interfere with these men except in the matter of remuneration? If that is what was meant it should have been more clearly stated. I shall certainly press the amendment.
Comment on this
Question put:—"That the words proposed to be deleted stand."
Do you agree with this result?
Amendment 21 is the first of a series of amendments which aim, in the first place, at limiting the persons to whom the cuts are to apply, and, later on, in reference to the schedules, aim at excluding certain categories completely. I suggest that the amendments dealing with the separate categories be taken together and on the one now before the House, dealing with commissioned officers and chaplains, amendments 21, 22 and 25, 26, 97 and 98 be debated together and that two questions on No. 25 should give a decision on the two classes included in that category. In other words, "that the words ‘commissioned officer' stand," will be the first question and the second question will be "that the words ‘or a chaplain' stand." The principle may be debated now.
Comment on this
I beg to move amendment 21:—
In sub-section (1), line 27, after the word "person" to insert the words "other than a commissioned officer in or a chaplain to the Defence Forces of Saorstát Eireann."
In putting down this amendment to exempt commissioned officers and Army chaplains from the operation of this measure, I was influenced by certain considerations. I put it down, in the first place, because Army officers and Army people generally are the most defenceless body in the country when it comes to legislative interference with the conditions of service. Every other body of public servants dealt with under this Bill, whether doctors, civil servants, school teachers or Civic Guards, have all some representative body which is in a position to put up a case, either to Deputies or to the general public, against the operation of the Bill, with the result that Deputies and the general public understand the position of each of the other services to which this Bill applies.
The Army people have no representative body, no council, such as other services have. They are prohibited by regulation from writing to the Press. They are prohibited by regulation from approaching members of the Oireachtas with regard to service conditions. In other words, they are entirely gagged and have no machinery for ventilating their views, or putting up their case to Deputies. I am not against that particular position. I think it would be very unwise if Army officers were free to write to the Press. But it may not be generally understood that no body of public servants has received so many reductions in increments in the last five or seven years as Army officers. It is true to say that the pay, according to rank, remains unchanged, but their increments have been very drastically reduced by a curtailment of allowances — a reduction in allowances — and, in particular, by reductions in rank.
There have been many Army reorganisation schemes and the result was, in the main, that officers, when being fitted into the new organisation, got a rather substantial reduction in rank. That meant a substantial reduction in pay. I think nobody will argue that the pay of the Free State Army is high. As a matter of fact, it is low compared with the pay of other armies. One must also take into account that the prospects of promotion in our Army are very slight, by reason of the fact that the higher posts are held by comparatively young men. There is no great difference in age between the highest officers in the army and the junior lieutenants, so the prospects of promotion are rather remote. I do not think there have been three promotions within the last three years. That being so, and taking into consideration the fairly low standard of pay, I do not really think their pay can bear any further reduction. Officers have various expenses which they cannot avoid. They have mess and general expenses common to mess life. They have to pay more for insurance premiums than any civil servant, or anybody else affected by this measure. I think they are in a peculiar position, a position that should receive very serious and sympathetic consideration.
Comment on this
What the Deputy has said would apply almost equally to all the other public servants with whom this Bill deals. I am not going to assert, for one moment, that the pay of officers in our Army is high, judged by any other standard than the capacity of our people to provide at this moment. If it were not for that fact this Bill would not be before the House. I do not question the sincerity of the Deputy's statement. I am glad some person has risen to put the point of view of the Army before the Dáil. What the Deputy has said is quite true — this is the one branch of the public service that is denied public expression. But it is not true to say that the Army has been defenceless. The Minister for Defence was himself a soldier and has a soldier's instincts and regard for the Army. He has pressed their cases as strenuously and as strongly as the Deputy would, I am sure, if he were in the Minister's position. There is no factor in favour of the Army that has not been before the Executive Council. There is no factor to which the utmost consideration has not been given, a consideration which has been depened and intensified by the appreciation which the Executive Council feel for the attitude which the Army has taken up during the past few years. If it were possible to extend to it undue consideration, that consideration would have been extended, but the position is, as I said at the beginning, that while we do not for a moment assert that the Army pay as compared with the rates that prevail elsewhere is high, nevertheless it is higher than our people can afford at the present moment.
Comment on this
I think the House will agree that the Minister has not met the case put forward by the mover of this amendment. In fact, I think the Minister's whole statement is a refusal, practically speaking, to meet the case and to discuss this or apparently any other amendment — I presume this will be the line taken up — on its merits. He did not suggest that the pay of the Army was unduly high. The fact is that the Army pay is low — I might say unduly low — in comparison with any ordinary standards. Take, for instance, a doctor or an officer — any rank in the service that you wish. Take a captain and take the pay paid here and compare it with the pay in England and you find there is a difference of £80 a year. That is to say he gets £80 a year less here. The Minister will reply that the two countries are different — that England is a rich country. I was always under the impression in the case of the English Army that those who got commissions had, generally speaking, private sources of income of their own. If you take that into account when one makes a comparison between the two sets of officers, the difference is more striking. In the case of a captain, leaving out the allowances, there is a reduction in the pay here of between £70 and £80 a year, roughly speaking.
In addition, we must realise the fact that precisely because this is a poor country most of those who get into either the Civil Service or the Army or the various teaching bodies are men who have no private source of income of their own. That is a fact, and I doubt if the Executive Council paid attention to it when making these cuts, though the Minister said that all relevant facts were taken into account. If all relevant facts were taken into account they seem to have exercised no influence whatever on the decision to which the Executive Council came.
If Deputies examine the Bill they will see right through it one thing that is particularly clear. That is that there is a great deal more desire for mathematical accuracy on the part of the Executive Council than there is for justice. The very figures for their justification that the Minister himself gave on the Second Reading — and the fact that it should appeal to the President was quite natural — were purely a mathematical justification.
Leaving out altogether the human element these cuts in the pay of the servants of the State are not merely unwise but unjustifiable. Undoubtedly one of the facts mentioned by Deputy O'Higgins applies particularly to the Army. The Minister said that the various considerations applied equally to the other services, but there is this one difference in the case of the Army in comparison with the other services. That is the impossibility of rapid promotion. All our men in the Army are young men. There has not been rapid promotion, and from the very circumstances of the case there could not have been rapid promotion. There has been, as Deputy O'Higgins pointed out, definite reductions already in salary.
The whole thing aimed at by the Minister in his defence of this Bill left out of sight altogether these concrete circumstances which colour the whole consideration of the case. The Minister was looking out for something in the way of mathematical accuracy in framing the Bill and left aside altogether considerations of justice. The Minister says this is as much as the country can bear. That is his one standard. How he arrives at that is beyond the power of the ordinary Deputy to understand. It is quite obvious that the Minister when imposing taxation thinks that there is nothing that this country cannot bear. It is only when cutting down salaries that he raises the point of the capacity of the country to bear. In the midst of all the extravagance in which the Government has indulged, this trying to save some thousands of pounds on a service like the Army has no justification whatsoever.
Comment on this
There is one matter I would like to put before the House. The Army is a new service in the country and the rates of pay were fixed rather arbitrarily at a certain period. The intention was that at a later period these rates would come under the review of the Minister. Remember that the actual gross cost of the Army had to be taken into consideration. We, for the purpose of Budget calculations and for the purpose of the Estimates, fixed the normal cost of the Army at £1,500,000. We attributed its higher cost to the fact that there has been a civil war during which there had been a very large number in the Army. The Minister himself at the time ridiculed our proposal that the normal cost of the Army would be £1,500,000. But for the purpose of borrowing money it was necessary to demonstrate that that was the correct figure. In 1927 the Army cost £2,300,000. The cost of the Army was since reduced by £1,200,000. Now, during that period when the Army had been reduced, if justice had been done, undoubtedly the pay of the officers would have been reviewed and it would have been increased. But at the time nothing could be done. I, personally, was responsible for this enormous reduction.
The cost of the Army was reduced during my time from, I think, £2,300,000 to £1,100,000. If I had been less drastic or less successful if you like, the Army would, when the present Government came in, have been costing considerably more. If I had not been engaged during that period in so drastically reducing the cost of the Army and concentrating on that, there is no doubt but the pay of the officers would have been increased. I think that the officers understood that once we got the position stabilised, their position would be considered in the light of justice rather than in the exigencies of the moment. If the pay had been increased as it should have been, there is no doubt but the same ratio of reduction would now be proposed, and these officers would be getting more than he proposes to give them. If the cost of the Army had not been reduced the Minister would have accepted it at a much higher figure. If it had only been reduced, say, to £2,000,000, the Minister would have accepted that figure and he would have proposed a reduction and would justify that by saying, irrespective of the merits of the case: "this is as much as the country can afford to pay." He is saying now, "this is as much as the country can afford to pay," and is fixing it at that figure, merely because the present Government's predecessors made drastic cuts in the cost of the Army. As I have already said, if normal circumstances prevailed at that time the officers' pay would have been increased. If it had not been necessary nationally to bring down the cost of the Army to the normal figure in that short time, the Army would not be reduced to the figure to which the Minister now proposes to reduce it.
With regard to the chaplains, I want to point out that chaplains are in a peculiar position in this way, that they are actually appointed by the bishops and can also be removed by the bishops. Consequently we have no graduated rate of pay. We have a fixed rate of pay for the chaplains. There are chaplains who have been ten years in the Army and they are getting paid exactly the same as if they had only one year's service. Their leaving the Army or their staying in it does not depend on the Government or on the Minister, but on the ecclesiastical superiors of the chaplains. Some of them have been there ten years. Still there is a fixed rate of pay and no chance of increase. It is certainly most unfair to a man who has been in that position for ten years that he is given no chance whatever of an increase. The increase in the period of service gives no increase in the rate of pay. In these circumstances it is most unfair in the case of chaplains to say to them that they are to have their salaries cut. On the other hand, if chaplains had been appointed and dismissed by the Government instead of being subject to their ecclesiastical superiors, this Government as well as the last Government would have taken into account the length of service and they would have provided as their years of service increased for increments in their pay. But now there are cases in the Army of chaplains who have given ten years' service without any chance of an increase of their emoluments, and the Minister arbitrarily comes along and says they must be reduced, presumably on the ground that that is as much as the country can pay. But if the predecessors of the present Government had not been so successful as they were in reducing the Army in about four years to less than half what it was previously, then the Government would have estimated what the country could afford to pay upon a much higher figure than they were paying when the Government took office.
Comment on this
Notwithstanding all that has been said with regard to the Army, the question is, can the country in the present economic condition of the farmers afford to maintain the Army we have at present? To my mind, every man in this State should be a member of an Army to defend the rights of the country. I avail of this opportunity to protest against maintaining such an Army in this country while the farmers are in a state bordering on economic ruin. It takes a large amount of money from the taxpayers to maintain this Army which we cannot at the present time afford to pay. As a member of the Centre Party, I say emphatically that we should abolish this Army which we cannot afford to maintain. What is the Army for?
Comment on this
I understood we were considering a big estimate for the huge Army we have at present.
Comment on this
We are not discussing estimates at present. We are discussing whether or not the pay of commissioned officers should be cut.
Comment on this
The pay of commissioned officers should be cut. In the present economic condition of the farmers, I maintain that we cannot afford to pay the salaries of commissioned officers. My opinion is that every man in Ireland should be prepared to defend his country. In the present conditions, I maintain that we cannot even afford to pay a recruit to the Army, not to say a commissioned officer. I maintain that in the event of an invasion it is the duty of every Irish citizen to be prepared to defend the country and to fight for Ireland's rights and an Irish Republic.
Comment on this
Question put —"That the words ‘commissioned officer' stand."
Do you agree with this result?
On the second question, is the Minister objecting to the elimination of the word "chaplain"?
Comment on this
As far as we can see from the Estimates there are, in all, 11 chaplains in the whole Army, and the sum in question is about £250. Does the Minister think the State is unable to afford that?
Comment on this
The Committee divided: Tá,
Do you agree with this result?
Amendments 21, 22, 26, 97 and 98 are not moved. With amendment 23 I shall take Nos. 27 and 102 and shall put the question on No. 27.
Amendments:—
23. In sub-section (1), line 27, after the word "person" to insert the words "other than a member of the Gárda Síochána."—(James Fitzgerald-Kenney.)
27. To delete sub-section (1) (a) (ii) —(William Norton, James Fitzgerald-Kenney, Richard Anthony.)
102. To delete Part II. —(William Norton, James Fitzgerald-Kenney.)
Comment on this
The whole principle may be debated on amendment 27 if that amendment is formally moved.
Comment on this
I move amendment 27. The reason why amendment 23 is necessary is that if you deleted merely the words "as a member of the Gárda Síochána or," which is amendment 27, the Guards might — indeed, I think, would — still be caught by the remaining words of the section. To make the matter perfectly clear, it seems to me to be necessary not alone to delete the words proposed to be deleted by amendment 27, but to insert the words contained in amendment 23. The effect of these amendments is that the Bill shall not apply to the Gárda at all. Earlier in the evening, I dealt with the question whether this Bill should be applicable to the officers of the Gárda or not. A great number of the arguments which apply in this case I have already used in relation to the officers of the Guards. I shall not go over them again. I shall content myself with the general statement that, in my opinion, the officers of the Guards are not overpaid, that it is very difficult for them to make ends meet and to keep up the social position they have to keep up and meet the requirements which they have to meet. I am perfectly satisfied that there are practically no officers of the Guards who have been able, out of their pay, to make those savings which they may require for a rainy day when they may have to meet extra expense for family sickness or something of that nature. I gave further specific instances earlier in the day and I shall not repeat them.
I now turn to the general question — whether these cuts should be made applicable to the inspectors, sergeants, and Guards. In my opinion, the pay of the Guards should not be touched at the present time. It is more important at present than it was in any period in the history of our country that the pay of the Guards should remain undiminished and that nothing should be done which might cause discontent in the Force. There is no use in our shutting our eyes to the present condition of affairs. There is no use in our shutting our eyes to the fact that in this State we are in a very serious position. I know that the argument of the Government is that the country is so reduced financially that it is unable to pay the Guards or to meet the expense of the other services in full. That is due to the way in which the Minister himself has maladministered the finances of the country. There is one primary necessity, one thing upon which public money must be expended, because it is the prime need of the State — that is, in securing the service of a proper, efficient and contented force of Civic Guards. That is more necessary at present than it ever was. We are facing an economic crisis and, in addition, nobody who knows anything about the internal affairs of this country can regard the present situation with anything except the greatest apprehension. We know that there is an armed force which is allowed to drill without check, let or hindrance——
Comment on this
The A.C.A. is not an armed force. The I.R.A. are allowed to drill without check or hindrance. They are allowed to spread any doctrine they may choose to spread. How these doctrines are being spread by that association and kindred associations anybody who has read the various weighty pronouncements by the Bishops during the last few days must realise. People who do that must know the position the country is in. This is a body which is standing between this country and——
Comment on this
On a point of order I would like to have a ruling from the Chair as to whether the Deputy's present observations are in order.
Comment on this
The Deputy is in order in giving reasons why the pay of the Gárda Síochána should not be reduced.
Comment on this
Deputy Smith evidently objects to the words of the Bishops. Possibly if Deputy Smith read the Bishops' Pastorals they would have a very excellent effect. I would suggest that he should do so.
Comment on this
No one who looks round the country can help seeing that there is a determined effort being made to impregnate this State with shocking doctrines, and to spread these doctrines, if need be by force, and that the people who are standing between that association and law-abiding citizens, the persons to whom the Farmers' Party, as well as any other Party, look for protection, are the Gárda Síochána. Of course we were told from the Centre Party Benches that the country cannot afford an Army. Possibly we will be told that the country cannot afford the Civic Guard force. If it cannot afford a Civic Guard force, then God help the farmers. The whole economic structure of this country rests upon this, that order will be preserved. Now you have got a force, owing to instructions coming down, as we see regularly, with one hand tied behind its back, maintaining order, or endeavouring to maintain order.
Comment on this
Unless this force is contented you will be asking too much if you ask it, or ask individual members of it, to risk themselves and things that are dear to them in carrying out the duty of preserving law and order. This is a time, above all times, when it is pre-eminently necessary that there should be a contented police force. Every person must be aware that these "cuts" are causing grave discontent in the force. I quoted earlier to-day words used by the Commissioner of the Guards in the presence of the Minister for Justice, as reported in the "Irish Press," in which he evidently gave utterance to these words which had been uttered to him by the Minister: "He could say that the Minister had spared no effort to minimise the cuts, and to minimise them as much as possible." I had not high hopes, but I thought that, possibly, the Minister in whose presence the remarks were made, and from whom Colonel Broy must have heard the facts — because I do not see how Colonel Broy could otherwise know Cabinet secrets — would explain, but the Minister did not by his voice make any endeavour earlier to minimise the effects of the "cuts," and I suppose now he will make no effort to eliminate the "cuts" by voting in favour of these amendments.
If the words uttered in the Minister's presence are correct — and the Minister did not deny them — then we have it that the Minister for Justice is of the opinion that there should be no "cuts" in the Guards at the present time. I am sure Colonel Broy did not make these remarks incautiously. He cannot be so completely tactless a person as to make them incautiously, and yet attain to his present position. Therefore it must be the deliberate wish of the Minister for Justice to let it be known that he was opposed root and branch to the "cuts," and that he wished to have the Guards eliminated. The House should bear in mind, and Fianna Fáil, Centre Party or other Deputies who wish to vote against this amendment should bear in mind that there is evidence that the responsible Minister was opposed to these "cuts." I do not know whether the Minister will have the courage of his convictions or not. I said a few moments ago that I thought he would not on this matter, but the House must bear in mind that it is a matter of prime importance to the State — more important now than ever before — that the Gárda Síochána should be a contented force. We know that the result of these "cuts," if they go through, will leave them discontented.
Comment on this
As I said on the Second Stage no matter how the Minister may try to gainsay it, and no matter what kind of apology may be made subsequently on platforms by the Fianna Fáil Ministers and spokesmen, the proposal to include the Gárda Síochána within the ambit of the "cuts" is a direct attack on wage standards. Deputy Cooney has trade union connections, and Deputy Cormac Breathnach is president of a trades union organisation. I put it to these two Deputies with trade union knowledge and experience, that the passing of a section of this kind, to cut the wages of the Gárda Síochána — wages which are as low as 50/- a week — will be an event the significance of which will not be overlooked by grasping, greedy employers in this country. This section, so far as it includes the Gárda Síochána, is an attack on wage standards, and is a direct incitement to private employers to invade wage standards. I think the Minister for Finance in Fianna Fáil, which claims at times that it is a working class Government, which is never slow to profess that it is standing for Christian, social principles, in this Bill is definitely setting a headline for every private employer to attack wage standards above 50/- a week. Gainsay what you will, try to apologise for, or to cloak it, that is the real significance of the section.
I put this question to the Minister, and to Fianna Fáil Deputies who stand for a working class policy, and who profess working class ideas: is this the kind of section which they ought to be supporting? At times you hear people claiming that they are following in the footsteps of the late James Connolly. People who desire to claim Connolly for their own should remember that it is not for slashing wages of 50/- Connolly would stand, if he were alive. I am not making a case for the exclusion of the Gárda Síochána in order to make them good policemen, in the sense that Deputy Fitzgerald-Kenney was concerned about. I am making a case for the Gárda Síochána because they are Irishmen, because they have got to lead decent Christian lives, and because they are entitled to lead decent Christian lives. I am not concerned merely with their physical prowess. I am concerned with their human needs, and it is on that basis I make a case for the Gárda Síochána. Everyone knows that in the last ten years, in a period of revolution, a police force was built up which, by its fairness, by its courtesy, by its integrity, and by its honour, commanded the respect of all sections. We do not desire that a force built up with care and patience should not be decently paid, much less too well paid. We do not desire to see the members of a force of that kind subject to wage cuts, and instead of being able to devote their energies to their particular duties, being compelled to balance these duties with the problem of how to pay their debts. It is because I believe that it is not good business and not good police business to slash the wages of the members of the Gárda Síochána that I am associated with this amendment. I cannot understand on what grounds it is sought to include the members of the Gárda Síochána in this section. I have here the Fianna Fáil election manifesto issued over the signature of the President on the 9th February last. In that manifesto — a manifesto which did service and got votes in the last election — we had this declaration by the President:
"We do not propose to seek economies by restricting the social services or by cutting the salaries of the middle and the lower grades of the civil servants. These salaries are, in most cases, barely sufficient to meet the costs of maintenance of a home and the support and education of children."
Here we have a definite admission by the President of the Executive Council that the salaries of the middle and lower grades of the Civil Service are barely sufficient to meet the cost of the maintenance of a home and the support and education of children. Members of the Gárda Síochána are in receipt of wages which do not compare favourably with the middle grades of the civil servants. If, therefore, members of the Gárda Síochána are in receipt of wages less than that level which is barely sufficient to provide for the maintenance of a home and for the support and education of children, how much worse off will they be when a Bill of this kind is passed to legalise cuts in their wages?
We do not need even to draw on our own imagination to find out what salary the President had in mind when he was writing that manifesto. Speaking in the Town Hall of Rathmines on the 1st February last year the President said:—
"It is not our idea to start cutting the lower salaries. I have often expressed the view that £1,000 was the limit, but with regard to the smaller salaries of £300 or £400, I hold that those in receipt of them are getting nothing execessive. These are not the salaries I had in mind for the cut. We could always feel certain that these smaller salaries were being spent inside the community and for necessaries, while much of the larger salaries were spent outside the community and often on luxuries."
Here we have a definite admission from the President, firstly, that people in receipt of salaries comparable to the middle and lower grades of the Civil Service, had an income only sufficient to maintain a home and support and educate children, and secondly, the President followed it up with figures in the Rathmines Town Hall and says: "I regard the smaller salaries of £300 or £400 as nothing excessive." If that was true in February of last year, what has happened to make it untrue to-day? If £300 or £400 were nothing excessive in February of 1932 what has happened to justify a cut in this Bill not on salaries of £300 or £400 — but on salaries of 50/- a week? I say to the Minister that the precedent he is setting to private employers is a dangerous one and will do serious harm. It will start a wage slashing campaign which will produce industrial strife and turmoil because the working class people of the country will defend the wage standards which have been built up after many years of struggle and many years of sacrifice.
This proposal to cut the pay of the members of the Gárda Síochána is bad business from a police point of view. It is bad business from an industrial point of view. It is setting a headline for private employers and it is part and parcel of the policy that you can feed a dog by feeding him on his own tail. It is not going to be any remedy for the situation which the Minister is endeavouring to deal with. It is not less purchasing power that the community wants, but more purchasing power, and if the Minister can pass this section with the aid of his majority there will come a day when he will be sorry for the groats that he is saving here to-day.
Comment on this
If there is one section in this Bill which deserves to be considered on its merits and not as a political issue it is that part of the Bill which relates to the Gárda Síochana because, when the definitive scales for the Gárda were fixed in 1924, they were fixed by a pay order promulgated by a colleague of Deputy Fitzgerald-Kenney. That pay order was accompanied by a memorandum which quite clearly related the scales of pay of the Gárda Síochána to the cost of living figures. It was laid down there, and it was accepted by the late Government and by the Oireachtas of the time and by the Gárda Síochána themselves without question, that as soon as the cost of living figure fell below 70 there should be a revision of these scales so as to make them conform to the principle upon which they were originally based. The cost of living figure is now not 70. It is far below 70. It is in the neighbourhood of 55, and, consequently, even if there were no financial crisis — if we were only to maintain the position which was settled and determined by our predecessors — we should have to consider the special case of the Gárda Síochána and apply to them the same principle as has been applied consistently, without any question or any opposition from Deputy Fitzgerald-Kenney, to the civil servants. So that, I say, the Gárda Síochána, at any rate, are in that special position that their pay, when it was definitely fixed in 1924, was fixed with reference to the cost of living figure at the time. Therefore, there cannot be any question of injustice in this matter if we propose now to consider revision of the scale.
Apart altogether from that, apart from this special circumstance which affects the Gárda, we have to take into consideration the general factors which apply now to the budgetary situation. Notwithstanding anything that has been said on the part of the Opposition, this Bill is not based upon a settled Government policy to reduce salaries or to reduce emoluments of any kind. If it were, it would not be a temporary measure. It would be made a permanent measure and there would be no provision fixed for the cessation of its operation. This Bill is designed to meet the present position and if we exclude the Gárda Síochána from it, then, on every ground of justice and equity, we are bound to exclude every other service, some branches of which, such as the Army — I do not want to make invidious comparisons — may have a stronger claim, on their merits, to reconsideration than the Gárda Síochána. If we once proceed to exclude the Gárda Síochána from the operation of this Bill then the Bill falls to the ground and every other service must be excluded. What is going to be the consequence of that?
I would recall to Deputies the situation with which we were faced here when I had to produce the annual financial statement to the House. I pointed out how, after borrowing so far as borrowing was justifiable, and after making a reasonable and proper allowance for over-estimation, we had to impose another £140,000 of taxation. Yet another £277,000 was wanted. Were we to go further. It is quite true that the taxes which were imposed by the Financial Resolutions passed by the House on the 10th May were primarily protective in their nature, bringing in little revenue, but we hope more than compensating for their tax burden by the extra and additional employment which they will ensure. After having taxed the products which could be produced or grown here at home were we to go further and find this £277,000 by putting additional taxation on tea, sugar or tobacco? You cannot, in a matter like this, play Mr. Facing Bothways. You either have to stand for this reduction or stand for additional taxation on the farmers and the workers: upon those who can least afford to bear it in this State. There is not another penny piece to be got out of Income Tax or Property Tax, and the only way in which the Budget could be balanced, if this Bill were not before the House, would be by taxing the food and clothing of the working classes, or by reducing the provision which we are making for unemployment relief.
Those who talk about depriving the people of purchasing power had better examine the position critically and carefully. We are not depriving anybody of purchasing power. The purchasing power will still remain in the pockets of the poorer people of this community. Those who are in the public service—let us face the facts— at the moment are very much better off than those who are out of it, at least than the majority of those who are out of it. Those who vote now — let me make this clear — for the exclusion of any one section of the public service from this Bill are voting against the Bill as a whole, because the economies which are proposed in the Bill can only be made operative if every section of public servants feels that it has been treated equitably and justly as compared with every other section. Therefore, I say this Bill must be considered on its merits. As I said a moment ago we are not depriving any person of purchasing power. We are simply refusing in this instance by imposing additional taxation, to transfer that purchasing power out of the hands of the taxpayers and putting it into the hands of public officials. In the hands of the taxpayers I believe that purchasing power will yield the biggest return in happiness and contentment to the community as a whole.
On the question of the reductions which we are making, in regard to the Gárda we have heard a lot of the 50/- a week. The average wage of a member of the Gárda is 75/- per week, or £195 per year. Will anybody tell me that a single man with £195 a year cannot stand a cut of 2/6 a week? That is the average wage of a young unmarried Guard. Is anybody going to tell me that he cannot stand a cut of £6 10s. 0d. a year in our present necessities?
Comment on this
For a single unmarried man. In addition, those who are married have an allowance of £20 a year, and they are not being cut. Those who read the Bill and look through the schedule will see that the married Guard is excluded altogether. That is why I say we have got to get away from claptrap in this case. We have got to consider the facts, to be honest about the facts, and that is why I say there is no person in this House who professes to have any regard for the taxpayers of the country, the farmers, labourers and workers, or the shopkeepers who can vote for the exclusion of the Gárda Síochána from the Bill.
Deputies Bennett and Anthony rose.
Comment on this
My name is associated with this motion and I have not spoken yet. Am I not entitled to speak?
Comment on this
Deputy Anthony is entitled to speak, but is not entitled to any preference. I did not notice the Deputy rise in his place. If I had I would have called on him as no member on that side of the House has yet spoken.
Comment on this
Notwithstanding the eloquence and the fury with which the Minister for Finance approached this question, I intend to vote for the amendment. Possibly the best case for excluding any section of public servants from this Bill could be made in the case of the Gárdai. That case was well made by Deputy Fitzgerald-Kenney and by the Leader of the Labour Party. For the reasons given by both of them — mainly because of the reduction in salary by one Deputy, and by the other because it affected the loyalty, efficiency and contentedness of the Gárdai, which I regard as indispensable to this State — I intend, as I have already said, to vote for the amendment. I am voting for this and other amendments for other reasons which, perhaps, it is just as well I should state now. Speaking as a member of the Cumann na nGaedheal Party, and mainly as a farmers' representative, I cannot say that I agree with the view put forward by the Leader of the Centre Party in supporting this Bill. If there is any section of the community which at the moment should be in opposition to this Bill it is the farmers. The economic war has put the farmers of this State in an almost impossible, yea, in a very impossible position.
Comment on this
May I interrupt the Deputy? I do not know if I heard him correctly, but I understood him to say that the Centre Party was opposing the Economies Bill. That, of course, is not the case.
Comment on this
I mean the "Cuts" Bill. You are supporting it. Whether you are supporting the amendment or not, I do not know, but you are supporting the Bill. As I was saying, the farmers have suffered more by the economic war than any other section of the people. They are reduced to the position in which they have to depend on doles and bounties to keep them in existence: doles and reliefs which they did not ask for or demand, doles and reliefs which must fall on other sections of the community and, perhaps, as heavy as any on the people it is proposed "to cut" under this Bill. The Minister has definitely stated that this Bill is only designed to remain in force while the present position continues. There has been no case made why any representative of the farmers should back this Bill. I intend to support amendments moved to exclude any section of officials from the Bill. I repeat that the farmers of the country have suffered more from the present position than any other class. They have to depend on reliefs and bounties to keep them going — reliefs and bounties the cost of which other sections of the community have to share in and must bear. Whatever might be said for a Bill of this kind in normal circumstances, when there was a general all round endeavour to economise, this Ministry, which history will never call an economic Ministry, cannot come before the House and say that a paltry sum of £277,000 is any setoff against the huge sums that they have themselves imposed on us by their actions. I did not intend to speak on the Bill at any great length. I do not think I shall speak on any other section, but I just want to emphasise what appeared to me the natural course for a farmers' representative to take on the Bill. That is to vote against the Bill, and I intend to do so.
Comment on this
I rise to support the amendment with which my name is associated. I want to say, by way of preface, that I threw my mind back while the Minister for Finance was speaking to a speech made by Mr. Blythe when Minister for Finance, and I recalled that he made almost the same kind of apologia for inflicting a cut on the Gárda Síochána that the present Minister does now. To me, and to many other persons who give any thought at all to public administration, and particularly to national administration, it must be very obvious that it is an absolute confession of failure, on the part of the present Ministry, of their economic policy, when they have to resort to the cuts suggested in this Bill, without taking any particular item in it. It has been contended with a good deal of sense, in one or two very logical speeches to-day to which I have listened, that the main reason, the dominating factor which has compelled the Minister for Finance to suggest that these drastic economies should be enforced in the various Departments under his control, was the failure of the present administration in its economic policy. That is the important fact that emerges from the debate so far as it has gone. We have heard a good deal to-night, and on other occasions, about the widespread industrial and economic depression that exists in other countries. We hear it frequently stated in this House, from the Government Benches, that people are suffering in Northern Ireland and in England, and yet the Governments there have not thought fit or wise to reduce wages or the emoluments of the police forces.
I do not want to read out a lot of figures, but I should like to give a brief comparative statement of the salaries and wages paid to the Guards in this country and the rates paid to police forces in other countries which I shall mention. We find that when a Guard entered the service in the year 1922 he started with a salary of 70/- weekly. He went on a certain scale of increments until he reached 78/- in his fourth year, 80/- in his fifth year, and so on. The rates were somewhat similar in Northern Ireland for the rank and file in that particular year. In 1924, following cuts in the Guards' salaries, we find that on appointment a Guard got 50/-. During this period there had been no change whatsoever in the rates paid in the other countries.
Comment on this
Deputy Anthony must be allowed to make his speech without interruption. That should be clear by this time.
Comment on this
In a statement made by the then Minister for Finance, Mr. Blythe, he said that under no circumstances would he contemplate, while he held office, any further reductions in the pay or emoluments of the Gárda Síochána. We had, again, the statement made by the President to which Deputy Norton has referred, the statement which he made in Rathmines. I do not want to advert to this, because it has been referred to already by more than one speaker, but it must be evident to everybody that increased discontent will follow on this constant nibbling at the pay of the police forces in this country. That is admitted even by the Minister himself. He contended that the police force spells a whole lot, particularly in present circumstances. We all know the advantages of having a contented police force, a sufficiently paid police force. Without introducing the name of any other country, I may say that it is common knowledge that there are in other countries corrupt police forces, and the view of many people of sound judgment in these countries is that the main cause of the corruption to which I refer is the relatively low wages paid to these policemen. It must not be forgotten that even across Channel at the present moment the Government authorities, or the heads of the police authorities, are considerably agitated about a practice which has grown up of allowing members of the police forces to attend various public functions as special stewards, and so on. Our police forces, I hope, will never be forced to seek employment of that character.
I should not like to see the police force here reduced to the necessity, as police forces in some other countries have been, of having to seek employment to make both ends meet. I want to suggest very seriously to the Minister that it is highly essential that a minimum standard should be established for the Gárda Síochána, below which any cuts should not be effected. There was no argument advanced so far by the Minister, or by anybody on the Government Benches, as to why the standard of the Gárda Síochána should be less than the standard set for any other of the State services. If we are to make any comparisons let us face up to the whole issue and not take it piecemeal. What do we find? The teachers, over a period, have been cut ten per cent. and remember I am going to vote against any reduction in the salaries of the lower paid teachers.
Army officers have not been cut. The Gárda officers are not cut. The basic salaries of civil servants were not cut or, at least, any reductions that did take place in what was known as the cost of living bonus, and we do know that the cost of living bonus fluctuated downwards, and we also know that the essence of this bonus is the fact that it does fluctuate. In the non-commissioned ranks of the Gárda Síochána, I include every man up to and including the rank of inspector. There appears to be some confusion of thought in this matter and the reason I refer to it is because I have another amendment on the Order Paper and because there is a further amendment in the names of Deputies Dillon and Wall. The inspector is not an officer in the full sense though he is graded as such. The officers will recover this cut in their ordinary increments, whereas the inspector will not be able to recover in increments, thus showing that there will be a grave injustice done to the inspector who is cut in salary without any chance of getting the basic rate back.
In these non-commissioned ranks to which I have alluded, we find that, if this cut becomes operative, they will be subjected to a cut of 17 per cent. and that, inclusive of pension, it will represent a cut of 19½ per cent. That means that the non-commissioned ranks of the Gárda Síochána will have lost practically 25 per cent. of their basic pay since they were subjected to the first cut in 1924. I am not going to go into the figures although I have collated some figures which would give the actual amount which accrues to the State in pounds, shillings and pence as a result of these various cuts. I do not want to labour that side of the question.
It might be information to many members of the House that, under this Bill, the ordinary Guard will have been subject — these are all, I should say, cumulative cuts—to a cut of £39 6s. 2d. per annum, the married sergeant to a cut of £48 12s. 2d., the unmarried sergeant to a cut of £53 6s. 9d., the married station sergeant to a cut of £49 19s., the unmarried station sergeant to a cut of £54 14s. 3d., and the inspector to a cut of £65. I am given to understand that the representative body of the Gárda Síochána, or some body acting on their behalf, made certain representations to the Minister, or to whatever other Minister may have been concerned, and they made to him certain suggestions by which the Minister might get almost as much revenue as he will be enabled to get under this sub-section when this Bill passes through the House. Amongst other things, they suggested that the total savings effected in the case of the commissioned ranks by these cuts would be £28,000——
Comment on this
I don't wish to interrupt the Deputy, but might I ask whether we are now discussing amendment No. 27?
Comment on this
No. I am given to understand that the representative body, or some body acting on their behalf, made some suggestions to the Minister as to how this amount of money could be got without inflicting much hardship on the Gárda Síochána. The cuts would bring in something like £28,000, but it was pointed out that the consequent decrease in income tax of, roughly, £3,000 would make the total saving, roughly, £25,000. The alternative method that the representative body submitted to the Minister was that there is something like £19,000 spent in officers' locomotion allowances, and they endeavoured to show that, as a means of effecting economy, the system applying to that particular branch of expenditure in the Department of Justice might be reviewed, and they pointed out that, with that, and a revision of the system of inspections by officers, a sum of £10,000 could be saved.
In addition, I understand that they proposed that £10,000 should be taken from the reward fund which is the property of the force and is governed by the Minister for Justice, the Chief Commissioner and the Minister for Finance. I should like to hear from the Minister when he is replying whether he gave any kind of sympathetic hearing to a representation of that kind, because one of the strongest arguments that can be put by a member of any Government to criticism of this kind by any Opposition Party is the very obvious one: "what do you propose as an alternative; how do you suggest I should find the money I am endeavouring to find here?"
Here is a case in which the men themselves offered to find a very substantial portion of the money and the Minister would have the satisfaction, if he gives way even on that point, of knowing that he had done his duty by the employees of the State. I could indicate to the Minister, but I think it is not the appropriate time, a way in which he could have found the revenue. I shall reserve that very valuable suggestion until a later opportunity presents itself on the Finance Bill. I will show the Minister three ways in which he might easily get the revenue without hurting any of the lower paid people in the Civil Service, and without inflicting any of the hardships that his Party suggested they would not inflict when going before the electors at the last general election. I was not going to read that document again because it has been read by several members of the House, at one time or another, but it is such a gem that it is worth even repeating. It says:
"Fianna Fáil is satisfied that substantial economies are feasible without reducing social services, inflicting hardship on any class of Government servants or impairing in the slightest degree the efficiency of the administrative machine."
Then, here is another gem: It must have been taken out of Malachy's Collar of Gold:
"The burden of taxation can be lightened by not less than £2,000,000 per year."
What does the Centre Party say to that?
Comment on this
I have pointed out some of the things that the Irish policeman cannot do because he is not allowed to do them. He is not allowed to do some of the things that are commonly practised on the other side of the Channel.
That makes my argument all the stronger that the salaries of Guards should not be reduced. I am not advocating that certain higher-paid officials should not suffer some reduction of salary, but I want to suggest that the Gárda Síochána at their present rates are down to bedrock, and any further cuts in wages or emoluments are bound to have serious repercussions unless human nature has terribly changed within the last 20 years. I am not going to refer to the state of the country. The police officers are there and they know and understand their duty, and are prepared to administer the law as they find it. But the Minister and Deputies must know that under the present circumstances — I am not saying it is so, but it may be — that many reports of a serious character are not reaching the Ministry because of a fear in certain parts of the country that if these reports reach the Chief Commissioner of Police other reports will come from the local Fianna Fáil clubs.
Comment on this
The Deputy will have to confine himself to the amendment. It has nothing to do with the duties of the Gárda Síochána, or whether they are carrying out their duties, which I think the Deputy is hinting at, and that should not be stated here.
Comment on this
In case there might be any misconception, I will say that I believe the Guards are carrying out their duties under the most difficult and trying circumstances. Whilst I agree that in some Departments there might be valid reasons why salaries should be reduced, I see no valid reason for reducing the wages paid to the Gárda Síochána, particularly in view of the fact that they have already suffered cut after cut and they have got promises both from Mr. Blythe and from President de Valera that they would not be cut further. The President in a memorable speech said that he considered salaries from £300 to £400 should not be reduced.
Comment on this
I would like to compliment the Minister for Finance on his speech. He made some disclosures which are, to my mind, most valuable. He stated that this Bill was designed to meet a financial crisis. That is very different from what we heard when the Budget was introduced. We were then told that the revenue was buoyant. He also cleared the air when he told us that this was designed definitely to meet the present situation. In other words, the Bill is designed to meet the situation created by the economic war. It is a temporary measure. We now know exactly where we are. The Deputies who are supporting this Bill should realise that if our resources continue to diminish for another year as they have diminished during the last 12 months a very serious situation will arise. Will they be prepared to meet the more serious economic situation created by diminishing resources by having another cut? If the economic war continues that is the situation you will have to face. If it continues for another year after that will Deputies still be prepared to have yet another cut and further diminish the purchasing power of the people?
Apparently what the Government are setting out to do is to bring everything down. Under normal circumstances there might be need for the revision of higher salaries, but, as the Minister says this is definitely designed to meet the present situation, that does not arise. This is all part and parcel of the economic war, and any savings made as a result of the cuts now proposed will be simply to assist the Government to continue the war. The people do not benefit in any shape or form. I will oppose the Economies Bill on that principle alone and I will support the amendments similarly on that principle. I maintain that support of this Bill——
Comment on this
The Deputy is making a Second Reading speech. Perhaps he will come to the point as to why the Gárda Síochána should not be included.
Comment on this
I did not intend to speak on the Bill at all until the Minister made those definite statements to the House. He also made a very important statement. Notwithstanding all we heard about the revenue being buoyant, the Minister intimated that not another penny piece could be got out of property taxation. I can quite believe that. But what about the £2,000,000 that we were to save? Apparently we cannot have that; all that was in the air, so to speak. With regard to the Guards, I think the case on their behalf has been very well put by Deputy Fitzgerald-Kenney and Deputy Norton. I do not want to say anything about any type of person who is mentioned in the Bill. I am supporting this amendment because I am altogether opposed to the principle of the Economies Bill.
Comment on this
We heard much talk in the House to-day of the disloyalty that would result because of the cuts. This appears to be the chief argument by Deputy Anthony against a saving of £250,000, and he suggests a minimum standard. I, for one, on principle am against the cutting of low salaries and against the payment of low wages. I would like to make that clear, but there are Deputies in this House who are against the cutting of the salary of any official whatsoever. Deputy Anthony is looking for a minimum standard. What minimum standard is he prepared to give the unemployed man with a wife and children? Is it not fair that a single man earning £3 15s. a week should lose 2/6 in order that that 2/6 should be devoted towards the providing of employment for a man with a wife and children and who has no 2/6 at all? That is the side of the question that Deputy Anthony does not bother with. Then we had Deputy Brennan, and Deputy Brennan, like all the Deputies on the opposite benches, has the economic war on the brain. It is Deputy Brennan and those with him who are responsible for the setting up of an inflated standard in this country, a standard that the people and the taxpayers cannot bear.
Comment on this
I am very easy about it! I tell the Deputy that if the present Government does not cut these salaries a Government will come in here that will do so. It will not be a cut of £250,000 they will make in officials' salaries but a cut of £4,000,000 or £5,000,000. It will come to that. If Deputies consult their constituents they will very quickly be told about it. It is all very well for Deputies opposite to speak about cuts. But Deputies opposite and their Executive Council did not trouble about those unemployed people. When they were in office they had no money for unemployment. They did not bother about providing it. The poor could starve, men could die of starvation in this country, and it was not the duty of the Government to look after them. Neither was it the duty of the Government apparently to provide houses for those who were living in condemned slums, nor——
Comment on this
The argument put up by the Opposition is that this cut is altogether owing to the economic war.
Comment on this
So the Minister for Finance told us in his own words. He made the present crisis the reason for the cuts.
Comment on this
There has been a crisis for the last five years. In this country with one section of the people living in poverty and hunger and the other section getting the fat of the land a crisis was being created. Of course, I would be told that there should be a minimum standard. Deputy Anthony will tell me I am a Communist and another Deputy will tell me I am approaching Russian politics but let us get down to bedrock——
Comment on this
Yes, let us get down to the amendment. I maintain as things stand and as things have been in this country for the past five years that these cuts and much more serious cuts should come. The case that has been made here to-night both by Deputy Bennett and Deputy Anthony reflects very little credit on those for whom they speak. I do not believe that the particular class for whom they speak have their feelings expressed here by these Deputies. When you have the case of a single man who was getting £3 15s. a week we are told that, if he is cut 2/6 in order to provide employment for others, he is going to become disloyal. If these officials are going to become disloyal because of 2/6 a week——
Comment on this
I do not want any reflection cast upon any set of officials who are not represented and cannot get their views heard here.
Comment on this
I have not the official records here but I know that the statements were made. I, for one, am not prepared to believe it. I consider it is time that these cuts were introduced. They are not enough but I am supporting the Bill as I consider a sop is better than nothing. That is the sole reason why I am supporting it, because a sop is better than nothing. If we are going to say that single men at a salary of £3/15/0 a week are not going to be interfered with, then we are to consider carefully the position here. Deputy Anthony made a special plea here for inspectors and other officials. As far as I can see we have made provision and we are making provision for those who have no sheltered position, for the unemployed. Those who have not any sheltered position are the people who require consideration. The sooner other Deputies in this House realise that position the better. The people of this country have been heavily taxed by a standard of salaries for which there is no reason. This portion of the country consisting of twenty-six counties is not in a position to bear these salaries and they cannot be justified. We have heard arguments here to-day as to what salary this position was worth, what that position was worth and what the brains of this gentleman and that gentleman were worth. They are just worth what this country can afford to pay and no more, and the sooner Deputies opposite get that into their heads the better. They may be worth these salaries to America, but as far as this country is concerned we cannot afford to pay a sum of £13,500,000 a year in salaries. The sooner all people get that into their minds the better.
Comment on this
I rise to support this amendment. I do so, first of all, for the general reason I have already stated when speaking on previous amendments, that is that there would be no need at all for these reductions in the wages of the Civic Guards except for the economic war policy of the Government. I find it rather hard to understand the attitude of two Parties in this House with regard to this whole Bill. One, the Labour Party——
Comment on this
——supports the policy of the Government in the continuance of the economic war, but it refuses to vote the supplies which are necessary for the continuance of that war. The Centre Party ardently oppose the Government's policy in the carrying on of the economic war, but they step into the breach, do what the Labour Party will not do, and vote the supplies for its continuance. The economic war policy of the Government is the whole meaning of this Bill. That is the reason why the Gárda Síochána salaries and wages are being cut—to enable the Government to carry on the economic war. But for that economic war there would be no necessity for this Bill at all. I support the amendments for the specific reason that the Gárda Síochána are in an altogether different class from the other classes which are affected by this Bill. They are a class, the members of which have no vote at Parliamentary elections. They have no voice in deciding what is to be the Government of the country. For that reason I think they should be the very last class to be affected by a Bill such as this. It cannot be said that a mandate for the carrying on of the economic war which necessitates this Bill came from the Gárda Síochána, as they have no votes. As I said, they should be the very last to be affected by a Bill such as this. The same cannot be said of other classes affected by the Bill, but we shall talk of them later. Of course the Bill in its entirety can be opposed on the general ground that the members of this Party are not going to do anything to help the Government out of the quandary into which they have walked with their eyes wide open.
Comment on this
I did not intend to reply, but I think the statement which has just fallen from Deputy McGuire deserves to be emphasised. Last year, in the maintenance of the rights of this people, the Government, with full consideration, came to a certain decision and determined that what belonged to the people of this country was going to remain here for the use and benefit of the people. Our right to do that was challenged in the House. We were told that we had not a mandate. We went to the people and the people gave us a mandate. Now the Deputy rises in his place and blares forth his treachery and his want of patriotism on a measure like this. That Party, he says, will do nothing to help the Government out of the quandary in which they have been placed; will do nothing to help the Government to fulfil the trust reposed in them by the people; will do nothing to fulfil the will of the people; the will of the people, for which members sitting on those benches over there hauled men to their death, some of them without the consolation of religion on one holyday on 8th December, 1922——
Comment on this
—— the will of the people for which the Civil War was fought and lost——
Chair, Order, order, and interruption.
Comment on this
Deputy MacDermot is raising a point of order and speakers must give way when a point of order is raised.
Comment on this
—— the will of the people of which we have been made the repositories on this issue is now to be flouted by Deputy McGuire and the members opposite. That explains the whole conduct of the Opposition towards this measure which we have brought before the Dáil—that they will not help the Government out of this quandary in which they have been placed; that they will not help the people of the country to make their will effective; that they will not help them to maintain their rights against every other power.
Comment on this
That explains their whole attitude to this Bill. This Bill is necessitated, not by the economic war, not by the dispute with England, but by the struggle which we are waging against want and unemployment in this country. We could have dispensed with these cuts, we could have forgone these cuts, if we had been willing to do what our predecessors did for ten years when in office— refused to make as adequate a provision as our means would permit to deal with the want and poverty that is widespread. If it had not been for that, we could have forgone every penny piece of the cuts which are necessary to secure these social services economies. When we first came into office in 1932 and saw the problem confronting us, when we realised that the true extent of unemployment had been concealed from the people for the preceding ten years, when we saw how an attempt had been made to fake the register, to keep men from registering——
Comment on this
On a point of order. I heard you, sir, from the Chair, reprove Deputy Brennan for making a Second Reading speech and spreading out into a discursive statement on general policy. If Deputy Brennan was out of order when you ruled in that way, the Minister is out of order now.
Comment on this
Deputies give the opportunity to each other. When one Deputy becomes irrelevant another Deputy becomes equally irrelevant when replying. I have given the Minister a good deal of latitude to reply to some of the statements made by Opposition members, but I think he has had scope enough and should now return and tell us why the Gárda Síochána should be included within the provisions of the Bill.
Comment on this
The Gárda Síochána should be included in the provisions of this Bill because certain moneys are necessary if we are to provide the relief, inadequate and all as I freely admit it is—the relief which we are going to provide to the utmost resources of the community for those who are in suffering amongst us. That is why the Gárda Síochána should be included. If they are not included, as I said, this Bill falls to the ground. In that connection I should like to say that this Bill is not introduced because of the economic war. It is true that that has added to our difficulties, but, before the economic dispute started last year, we clearly saw that some economies of this sort would be necessary if we were to be able to make that provision which we thought necessary to meet the public needs.
As to statements made here about 50/- per week, I should like every Deputy to get that figure out of his mind once and for all. The only person who could be in receipt of 50/- per week in the Gárda Síochána would be a recruit, and that only during the six months in which he was in training in the Depôt. Recruiting for the Gárda Síochána has been stopped for the past 15 months. Consequently, there is no person in the ranks of the Gárda Síochána receiving only 50/- per week. It is probable that the lowest paid man in the Gárda Síochána is receiving 64/- per week; that is £166 a year. Will any Deputy declare, if a man is receiving £166 per year, living in barracks if he is a single man, messing with his fellows, living as economically as possible, with uniform provided for him—there is no uniform allowance in question here—that we are going to interfere with his ordinary human needs if we reduce that man's pay by £6 10s. 0d. per year? He will still have £160 to provide himself with food and clothing, apart from uniform, and to put something by.
I want to make it clear that the average wage paid to the Gárda Síochána is over 75/- per week; over £195 a year. Most of the Gárda are men with long service and, if married men with family responsibilities, they get a housing allowance of £20 in addition to their ordinary pay. These men are not being cut at all. If there was any sincerity in the arguments advanced and the calls that have been made for retrenchment and economy; if Deputy Anthony's performance, when he read out that alleged pronouncement of the Fianna Fáil Party, had been anything else except an exhibition of slimy hypocrisy; if he had been merely concerned about the workers whom he represents, he would not be here clamouring that the force be excluded from the Bill. Here is a force which costs the State £1,635,000 a year, and we propose to save about 2 per cent. of that. He would have said it should be much more. We would not have acceded to his request because we prefer to be fair and just, and we do have consideration for the human needs of which Deputy Norton spoke. For that reason we have deliberately excluded 50 per cent. of the Gárda; the married men in the ranks of the Gárda are excluded from this cut. The non-commissioned officers of the Gárda we have met, I think, with very fair consideration.
Comment on this
That is just the mentality that guided our predecessors in all their operations, and that is what left them where they are. That is what left Deputy O'Leary sitting up there. This Government, no matter how unpopular it may be, and notwithstanding the fact that every member of the Gárda may have friends and relations with political influence, is not deterred by political considerations from doing its duty to the general mass of the people. We feel they cannot pay any more. We feel the cuts must be extended to every branch of the public service, and that is why the Gárda are included in this Bill. We must get from every man according to his resources, and those who are in the public service can afford to help the public out now.
Comment on this
I was not going to speak on this, but I got a little bit of news or information from the Minister, and I cannot resist looking for more information. He told us that the necessity for these cuts was there when he and his colleagues took up office. If that is so, this cut is not sufficient. It should be 40 per cent. more. If the necessity for the cuts was there when the Minister and his colleagues took office, why did they start the economic war? Was it to wipe us out altogether? Following the lines of Deputy Brennan's remarks, when we grow poorer and poorer every day we will want to have a sliding scale downwards to cut all public servants. I agree that there should be equality of sacrifice. That would be the logical line for the Government Party to take, and for the Labour Party, who were their natural allies in producing the conditions which necessitated the "cuts" in the salaries of public officials. The Centre Party's attitude I cannot understand at all. They are neither fish, flesh nor good red herring in this matter. They oppose the economic war, but, as some Deputy has said, they are voting supplies to keep it on. This Party here is the only Party consistent in connection with this economic war. We oppose it, and we oppose giving supplies to it.
Comment on this
I do not find the Party irksome, but if I were sitting with the Deputy there I would feel very irksome, and I think the Deputy must feel his seat very irksome to-day.
Comment on this
And you know how it was done. The Deputy was Republican that time; I think it was for the first time in his life.
Comment on this
We will get back to the Gárda Síochána when the interruptions cease and when the Ministers cease going back into history which they, of all people in this House or in this country, should try to forget. No case has been made for the reduction in the Guards' salaries or wages. The Minister for Finance told us he got a mandate. We know how the mandate was got. Deputy Anthony reminds him of how the mandate was got; he accuses Deputy Anthony of alleging something against Fianna Fáil. He did not reply to Deputy Anthony when Deputy Anthony asked him to deny the propaganda which Deputy Anthony had quoted. He gives the salary of the Gárda Síochána; he mentions £175 or £195 and asks could they not afford £6 a year of a cut. Perhaps the Ministers, when they have done with their little consultation will remember that tradesmen have more than the Guards; that there is not a tradesman —carpenter, bricklayer, plumber or plasterer in the City of Dublin to-day who is not earning £4 a week. If a married Gárda with less salary than that must contribute £6 or £7 a year, why not the plasterer? Why not the bricklayer? Why not the carpenter? Why should not their wages be cut?
Comment on this
I do not want to interrupt the Deputy, but did I understand him to say that married Gárdaí were suffering this cut?
Comment on this
Well then may I take it that if the single Gárda gets married the cut will be restored to him? I am giving way; I am waiting for the Minister's reply.
Comment on this
No, but I would anticipate a boom in matrimony. It is a very natural question. If a married Guard's wages are not going to be reduced, but a single Guard's wages are going to be reduced, then the natural, logical, and sensible way out for the single Gárda is to get married quickly. If he is not able to get married in time will the Minister undertake that, on his getting married and producing his marriage certificate, the cut will be restored to him?
Comment on this
Well then it does not rule out my question. I should like an answer to it. The Minister is not inclined to answer that. The Gárda who was not fortunate enough to be married before the Minister introduced this Bill, has now to bear a reduction in his pay as a contribution to the economic war.
Comment on this
He has to contribute £6 of his salary, which is small enough already, in order that we may give butter at 6d. per pound to John Bull, in order to carry on the economic war, and to help the rake's progress who, following the course of every other rake, becomes a robber when he finds his resources running out. He puts his hand into other men's pockets, while preaching the policy of self-sufficiency, trying to hold a market from which we have been turned out. Will Ministers face up to this? Before the last General Election they declared there was no need to cut the Guards in their pay. During the very election of last year, which gave the Minister for Finance his portfolio, he preached from every platform in Dublin the monstrosity of trying to reduce the Guards in their pay. He will not deny that. I am dealing with the Minister's policy, and his public statements. From every platform the Minister for Finance declared the necessity of protecting the Guards in their salary and wages. It was his constant theme; it was the subject matter he preached in every speech that he delivered from every platform in Dublin.
Comment on this
No, not at all of them, but I know the substance of the Minister's speeches and he has not attempted to deny my statement. I heard every one of the Ministers opposite at that time, and all their spokesmen in the City of Dublin, and it was the same theme they all spoke on. Yet the Minister for Finance has just informed us that when they took up office they saw, in one week, the wages of the Gárda would have to be cut although during the previous week they were preaching to the multitude that the wages would not be cut. Still the Minister for Finance has the audacity to tell us that the Government are carrying out the will of the people, while they are carrying out a policy opposed to that which they preached on every platform. If all the nonsense and lies and humbug, preached off Fianna Fáil platforms, were brushed aside, and the true facts put before the people the Fianna Fáil Party would not only be out of office now but would never again occupy office, and well the Deputy opposite, who laughs, knows that. He was in no way sparing in his promises when he got on the platform.
Comment on this
Only that we must have some regard for the matter that we are discussing I would tell the Deputy opposite something he would not like to hear. It was not upon a policy of economy that the Deputy was elected.
Comment on this
The Deputy will not deny that, or the 250 more that were in the Fianna Fáil Committee Room in O'Connell Street under Mick Price.
Comment on this
Too high for the Labour Party to pay. I hope, now, we have heard the last of the will of the people from Deputies opposite. If the will of the people were carried out, as preached by the Minister for Finance and his colleagues, salaries would be doubled and trebled instead of being reduced. A year ago the Minister told us that it would be necessary, in the light of the knowledge and experience he got when he took up office, to reduce the Gárdai though he and his colleagues were not out to reduce them. Does he know anything of the life a Gárda has to lead in Dublin? If he did he ought to be thinking of increasing their pay instead of reducing it.
I am not going to suggest that if you cut off a few shillings a week from the pay of the Gárda you are going to make him disloyal; neither am I going to suggest that by taking a few shillings off him you are going to make him more loyal. A member of the Gárdaí is not a stick or a stone; he is a human being. He is not a sheep to be driven. He has a "thinking box" which is as good as that of many people in higher stations, if not better. It is not human that by reducing his salary he should become more efficient or loyal. Just as would happen to us all he is likely to take less interest in his business, as we would be likely to take less interest in our business if we found that it was not paying, or if we found that we were not getting a return for our labour, and that we were not getting what we were entitled to. He will become indifferent and if the Guards become indifferent what sort of law will be administered in this country? It is no good having good solicitors, barristers and judges if you have not a loyal and efficient police force, for in the last analysis the police are the people on whom the law rests. If they do not do their duty, protecting the lives and property of the people, there will be very little security for life and property in the State.