Public Services (Temporary Economies) Bill, 1933—Report Stage.
Contributions 1–178 of 749. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 4 parts.
No. 12 of 1933 ›
The amendment seems to be outside the scope of the Bill. It would possibly, and indeed very probably, entail a State charge. The Bill deals with deductions from the salaries of serving officers. It has no reference to pensions, and to allow a condition of that sort to be put in might lead to discussions on many extraneous matters. You could, for instance, have a similar amendment in reference to the cuts in the pay of the Gárda. It might be argued that the cuts in the Gárda pay be not enforced until a boot allowance was restored. In the case of post office officials it might be suggested that the cuts should not take effect until something else was restored. Allowing an amendment of that kind might mean that every grievance conceivable might be discussed.
Comment on this
May I suggest for your consideration that the amendment is really relevant and, so far as the form goes, it does not impose a charge on the State? I speak now so far as the form goes. I suggest the amendment is relevant. First of all, the amendment deals specifically with the question of the cuts. I quite admit it makes that contingent on certain other things being done, but the principal purpose of the amendment is to deal with the cuts. Secondly, I suggest that in this particular connection there is a special reason why the amendment can be particularly regarded as relevant, because in connection with this pension fund that is mentioned in the amendment a deduction is already made from the salaries of the teachers.
I submit that in the present circumstances, the Bill is proposing a further reduction of six per cent. in reality, unless the Government does what the late Government proposed to do, take the two things in conjunction, namely, the question of the solvency of the pension fund and the question of cuts. The actual cut proposed is a great deal more than the six per cent., because as things stand no benefit can accrue from the pension fund to the large majority of the teachers. I submit the two things ought to be considered together, as they are closely allied. That was the view, if I may so incidentally remark, of the members of the late Government when they refused to consider them apart. They considered it was unjust to do so. Now the whole position is that a cut is being taken from the teachers at a time when in reality, owing to the refusal of the Government to consider the two questions together, they have a cut that is not being taken from any other branch of the service, namely, the cut of the pensions.
Comment on this
I know I cannot argue the merits of the case on a point of order, but I am putting to you the reason why this particular amendment is relevant and why the two should be taken together. I understood you to say that it was not relevant, but I am putting up an argument suggesting that it is relevant, and suggesting why the two amendments should be taken together. It is inevitable that they should hang together. It is from the teachers' moneys that the funds for this Teachers' Pension Fund are taken, and it is most unfair to the teachers that the two things are not taken together by the Government. I suggest that the amendment be considered by itself. As to whether other grievances should follow I do not know, but I suggest that they are not in the same position. What I understand is that this Teachers' Pension Fund stands in a different category from other pension funds. In the case of the civil servants there is no pension fund. In the other case it is not suggested, where you have pension funds, that they are insolvent. Here this fund is insolvent, and I suggest the House should be given an opportunity of expressing its view that this cut should not be imposed upon the teachers.
Comment on this
May I suggest that the amendment as it stands is really an interruption only in point of time in regard to the operation of the deductions in these cases? That point of time is related to a discovery which requires to be made by the Executive Council, and that the discovery is a solvent fund. It simply interrupts the operation of the measure until that discovery is made.
Comment on this
May I point out that the question of the pension fund has been carefully excluded from the scope of this Bill?
Comment on this
I should like to draw your mind to the fact that the first amendment in the name of Deputy Rice purported to determine the operation of the Bill if the Economic War ended between this and the 31st March next. That was allowing in something which, I think, was far less relevant to the proposals in the Bill than this amendment proposes to do.
Comment on this
It seems to me that the principal purpose of this amendment is to discuss the solvency of the pension fund and to try to establish a pension fund, whoever would be responsible. The Deputy states that there is no explicit reference to Government liability. The Ceann Comhairle, whilst giving due weight to that fact, cannot close his eyes to the facts of the case. As Deputy Lynch states, I did allow a certain amendment by Deputy Rice. The Bill is termed a Temporary Economies Bill; the purpose of Deputy Rice's amendment was to attempt to fix a period to that Bill. This amendment is moved not to the period of operation of the Bill, but to a section dealing with different categories affected. It is true that on many sections of this Bill the grievances of the classes concerned might be discussed, but it does not follow that amendments framed to redress those grievances would be relevant. To make the application of the reductions of salaries contingent on the remedying of grievances would not be in order, and on those grounds this amendment and amendment 10 are out of order.
Comment on this
The Deputy is aware that once the Ceann Comhairle has given a ruling the matter is ended.
Comment on this
I do not see how you could take these. Amendments 5, 6 and 7 must be definitely disposed of first.
Comment on this
May I point out that the Deputy in whose name the amendments stand had an opportunity of having them discussed in the House this day week?
Comment on this
They can be moved by Deputy Fitzgerald-Kenney with the consent of the Deputy in whose name they stand. I presume Deputy Fitzgerald-Kenney has the consent of his colleague, Deputy McGilligan.
Comment on this
I move amendments 5, 6 and 7:—
In page 4, Section 7 (1), line 5, to delete all words from the beginning of the sub-section down to and including the word "payable" line 6, and substitute the words "From that portion of the salary earned during the current financial year which is payable as from the date of the passing of this Act."—Patrick McGilligan.
In page 4, Section 7 (1), line 7, to insert before the word "deduction" the word "proportionate."—Patrick McGilligan.
In page 4, Section 7 (1), line 7, to delete the word "at" and substitute therefor the words "with reference to"—Patrick McGilligan.
Amendment 5 is consequential upon amendment 11. Amendment 5 is simply consequential. However, I am willing on this amendment, if it is taken now, to deal with the entire question. The question which is raised by this series of amendments here is a question of making legislation of this nature retrospective. I think retrospective legislation is never desirable. Retrospective legislation, when it is based on matters financial, is always wrong. And this not only is based on financial legislation dealing with a financial matter, but it has that other characteristic in a most aggravated form. This amendment purposes to take away a portion of a section by the terms of which persons who have already earned salaries from the State shall be deprived of those salaries. They have a right to those salaries. They have earned them. They are theirs. To take away these salaries is to defraud the labourers of their wages, to defraud servants of the State of the wages which they have earned.
I know that that is not without precedent. What the Government purposes to do by this section is not without precedent. I know by their Hospitals Bill which recently passed through Committee in this House, by retrospective legislation they robbed the voluntary hospitals. We see now that same principle following upon that precedent and enlarging it. The Bill before the House has for its object to rob the servants of the State, to rob the guards, to rob the Army, to rob the teachers and civil servants. It has for its object to rob everybody who has earned money from the first day of the financial year down to the present. Now you are coming along with an indemnifying Bill to justify that defrauding labourers of their wages. This Bill is unique amongst indemnity Bills. For indemnity Bills have been for things which have been passed and done and finished with, something which had to be done upon the spur of the moment. But this Bill is unique amongst indemnity Bills. This is an indemnity Bill indemnifying the Government for an act which is morally unjustifiable and morally unjust. At the same time this Bill is legalising the continuing of that immoral act. It is also legalising and regularising this illegal and I say immoral stoppage of payments. Until this Bill becomes law every servant of the State is entitled to every penny which he has earned from the State, whether under statute, or under contract, or by rules deriving their force from legislation. He has that legal right. He has got another right, a right built upon a higher and stronger foundation than any law passed by this Assembly could have; he has got the right based upon the immutable eternal principles of justice to what he has earned. It is that right based on principles of justice, that this House is asked by Section 7, as it stands, unamended, to take away.
This is an indemnity Bill. If this were not an indemnity Bill, if the State were not doing wrong, what is the need of this section? If they can legally deprive men of the wages they have earned, why are they coming in here with this section? The other day the Minister for Finance said that he had power after the Second Reading to pursue the course he has pursued. If my memory is not very much at fault, these cuts began before the Second Reading even. If I be wrong in that, even if he had legal power, which I entirely deny, and most certainly in the case of the Guards he had not, he has not purported by any act of his to exercise that legal power. He has simply, in defiance of the law, and against all the principles of justice, deprived State servants of their salaries and wages. Everybody is entitled to the money that he has earned. I wonder what would be thought of a private employer who was under contract to pay an individual, say, £2 per week and, at the end of 11 months, came to his employee and said to him, "I am going to cut you down to 30/- per week next year, and, because it is my intention to do that, I am going to cut you down to 30/- during this last month"? Is not that the very position which the State is in? The State is under contract to these people to pay them fully until that contract is legally terminated, just as a private employer would be if he had entered into a legal binding contract.
This money is now being kept away in defiance of the principles of justice. Every single penny of these salaries has been earned. To keep these salaries away from the persons who have earned them is to defraud labourers of their wages. That is what the House is asked to do. We know that defrauding labourers of their wages is one of the sins that cries to Heaven for vengeance, and that is the sin which every person who votes for this section to stand unamended is committing, because he is helping the Minister to commit it. "Behold the hire of labourers who have reaped down your fields, which by fraud has been kept back by you, and the cry of them has entered into the ears of the Lord of Hosts." Deputies may scoff at these words if they like, they may laugh their defiance in the face of Heaven if they wish, but here in this section, if it stands unamended, they will have defrauded men who have honestly earned wages from the State of these wages. I do not know how strong the ties of Party affiliation may be. I do not know how much Fianna Fáil Deputies may have deadened their consciences and determined, no matter how morally wrong legislation proposed to the House by the Executive Council may be, to put the wishes of the Executive Council before the laws of the Almighty. Let them. But, for goodness' sake, if you pass this section unamended, never have it paraded in this House again that you are a Catholic Party, and that you are not willing to act, when the occasion arises and when it suits you, directly in contradiction of Catholic doctrine.
Comment on this
I should like to know are we taking all the amendments which deal with Section 7 together?
Comment on this
May I suggest again—I had occasion to call attention to it already in another debate in this House—that hardly a week passes now that we have not an example of retrospective legislation on the part of the Government dealing with the rights of property of every kind? Either we are threatened with such legislation or have had such legislation passed through this House dealing with actual personal property, and now we have such legislation dealing with actual salaries. There may be certain occasions on which a procedure of that kind may be justified, but such procedure, I suggest, is justified only in times of crisis, or when very grave questions are in dispute. What I object to strongly is the renewed evidence, week after week, that it is the settled policy of the Government to ignore any principles in these matters, to throw them aside as if they were of no value. The open illegality of the action of the Government in this connection is confessed, I suggest, by the section as it stands. Otherwise, there are clauses in this section in connection with which it is impossible to understand why they are inserted. Surely that illegality is not condoned or made legal by the fact that one House of the Oireachtas passes a Second Reading? Nobody can condone that. The Government, without any excuse, deliberately and with its eyes open, determined to do what is illegal.
Does anybody suggest that the purposes served by this Bill, that the miserable savings that are effected here, in comparison with the spendthrift policy of the Government, are sufficient excuse for the Government with its eyes open deliberately doing what is illegal, and then trying to condone or cover over that illegality by subsequent legislation? It is admitted on the very face of the Bill that their action was illegal. I suggest that in a country that has never shown too great a respect for law such a barefaced action on the part of the Government cannot but have, from the point of view of example, deplorable effects. I suggest that the Government—this Government particularly, for obvious reasons—ought to show some respect for the law. Here, without any excuse, or only with the most paltry excuse, it sets about deliberately violating the law, and then it comes along to this House and asks this House to condone its conduct. I suggest that the House would be wanting in its duty to the ideal of respect for law if it did anything of the kind. As I say, we have had in this House too many examples of retrospective legislation, especially where property is concerned. The Government has shown that it is bound by no consideration and no principle. I suggest that the House should accept those amendments standing in Deputy McGilligan's name.
Comment on this
I move that if necessary the Dáil sits later than 2.30 p.m. and that the motion for the adjournment be taken not later than midnight to-night.
Comment on this
Would the Minister consider the alternative mentioned by Deputy Briscoe, that we should have the closure on every amendment, on this Report Stage. Then, perhaps, the Minister would find that he would not get through before midnight.
Comment on this
Considering that the House has sat every day since Tuesday, and that Private Members' time has been appropriated by the Government, and that the Government are now so flaitheamhaileach with its time that they promised a day for Private Members on Tuesday, and, also, that the House sat late last Friday afternoon, will he not reconsider this matter? Deputies have a considerable amount of business to attend to in the country. Some of them travelled on Monday last in order to be here on Tuesday, and most of them must get home to-night if they are to have any chance of doing any business at all. Why in these circumstances should it be necessary to sit late to-night?
Comment on this
Because this Bill must get through its Report Stage to-day. I heard Deputy Fitzgerald-Kenney recently saying that Heaven was weeping because we had been acting illegally. We propose to put ourselves right with everybody at the earliest possible moment.
Comment on this
I am pleased to hear the Minister admit that he had been robbing the Civil Service and that this robbery will now only last for a short time.
Comment on this
What is the necessity for getting the Bill through to-day? The Minister's reply is that it is necessary to clear up any illegality. But this day week he was clear there was no illegality. The Attorney-General was asked to intervene on that occasion and make a statement as to whether the cuts which had been made on the authority of a Second Reading were illegal or otherwise. He was asked whether a Second Reading defence would be sufficient to make in a court of law against the process of somebody who had been robbed in the meantime. The Minister could not answer that. His Attorney-General would not attempt to answer it, and now we are calmly told that it is necessary to get the Report Stage through. Getting the Report Stage does not help the Minister very much. The Minister could have got agreement to have the Fourth and Fifth Stages taken together provided that there was a legitimate debate allowed upon the Fifth Stage.
Comment on this
There is no suggestion of telescoping these two stages. We are simply told that it is necessary to get this Report Stage through; no excuse is made and no reason given to back up that; there is mere assertion simply that it is necessary to-day. have the Report Stage through to-day. There is nothing in this Bill that cannot wait so long as Section 7, sub-section (5) is in the Bill. So long as that is there, there is no reason for urgency, and no reason is given. When this same motion was made in Committee Stage last Friday I asked had the Minister any reason he could offer? I asked is there any class of people in whom he wants to put his claws and upon whom they are not already fastened, and does he think he is going to ease those people who feel they have been legally hacked about by having the Report Stage passed to-day although the Fifth Stage is still to be taken? Will it ease the conscience of the Government to have that Stage taken to-day without any statement as to when the Fifth Stage will be taken, instead of having the Fourth and Fifth Stages taken next week? In order to uphold any principle of procedure and order it is necessary that a Division be taken on this motion.
Comment on this
We consider this conduct of the Ministry absolutely disgraceful and unwarranted. I presume that the normal procedure in this House is that if the Minister cannot get through certain Bills they take the whole day and do not take any private business. I do not think there was any definite obstruction so far as this Bill was concerned, and our Party, certainly, will not be a party to voting for this motion. As Deputy Mulcahy pointed out, Deputies make certain arrangements in their constituencies, and if this is allowed to be carried on, no Deputy will be in a position to make an appointment in advance.
Comment on this
There is an old saying that when doctors differ, patients die, but when lawyers differ, lawyers prosper. With regard to the opposition to this motion here, Deputy Fitzgerald-Kenney holds that our procedure has been utterly illegal. On the other hand, Deputy McGilligan—a mere neophyte at the Bar—comes along and assures the House that we have no cause to be alarmed.
Comment on this
Deputy McGilligan comes along to reassure Deputy Fitzgerald-Kenney who, in a preceding speech, told us that Heaven was standing aghast at the attitude of the Government in this matter and that we were robbing the——
Comment on this
——Well, I suppose robbery does not appal Deputy McGilligan; but there are things that should appal a person with a conscience like his. As to what Deputy Corish said with regard to the necessity for this, I should like to remind the House that on Wednesday last a very definite argreement was arrived at with other Parties in this House to dispose of all the amendments on the Committee Stage by 10.30, and if they were not finished on Wednesday we would have to sit on Friday. Late in the evening, when it was found that some important amendments might not be properly discussed if the Government insisted on that, I rose and offered concessions and indicated that I should be prepared to allow amendments to be withdrawn and reintroduced on Report Stage if of vital importance. Later, the Leader of the Labour Party said that he would be no party to that arrangement. The Leader of the Opposition—or rather the real Leader of the Opposition—Deputy McGilligan said that since the Labour Party were not going to be bound by the agreement neither would his Party be bound by it.
Deputies either withdrew amendments or spoke on them for some length, and, in consequence, it was found necessary for the House to sit on Friday in order to dispose of the Committee Stage of the Bill. On Friday, amendments standing in the names of Cumann na nGaedheal Deputies, including a considerable number in the name of Deputy McGilligan, under the agreement which had been made with the Cumann na nGaedheal Whips at any rate, were not moved and are now down on the Report Stage. These amendments have got to be definitely disposed of to-day in order that, at any rate, once an agreement has been arrived at that agreement will be loyally observed by the parties to it, even though some others may disclaim it.
Comment on this
It is very easy for Whips to come to an agreement if they know what they want, but it is utterly impossible for any Whip to serve a front bench in which the Minister speaks in the way in which he speaks here, and who acts in the way he acts here.
Comment on this
Deputy Mulcahy has been careful not to deny that it was a part of the understanding that the amendments were to be disposed of within two days.
Comment on this
There was no explicit agreement as to what was going to happen to the amendments. It was agreed that there would be the fullest co-operation in disposing of them, and I think that the Minister was offered the fullest co-operation. I do not want to fight out Whips' disputes here. This is not the place for it. We can make agreements as to how the business ought to be done if the control or the conduct of business in the House is done in a businesslike and orderly way. The Minister cannot complain in any way at all of any want of co-operation in the House generally, and particularly in regard to this Party here. He got full co-operation in the Cement Bill and in the National Health Insurance Bill. He had all yesterday to discuss the "Cuts" Bill, but he put down Estimates yesterday, when the whole of yesterday was available for the discussion of the other Bill.
Comment on this
The Minister for Finance misunderstands, I am sure, the mentality of the Labour Party if he thinks that at any time we will be a party to any agreement to put a closure on discussions on a Bill of this kind.
Comment on this
I ask leave to counter one or two of the more audacious misrepresentations that the Minister has made. I will state my point very briefly.
Comment on this
Yes but I did not hear his motion being accepted. I have never said that the proceeding under Section 7 of this Bill is legal. I have asked the Attorney-General to get up and say that it is legal. That is the simple test for that. Will it be met? Of course not. As to this agreement on the necessity for getting this Bill through the Minister tried to establish, last Friday, that the agreement bound the Labour Party. He has now gone away from that. He has followed that up with the misrepresentation that Cumann na nGaedheal Deputies said that they were going to break the agreement. They said nothing of the kind.
Comment on this
We did not. Can the Minister understand this? Suppose there is an amendment down in the name of Deputy Norton; it is reached at a particular time; it is moved and let us say that it covers a very important measure such as the "cuts" in the Civil Service. It is clear that once that amendment was moved discussion had to go on and be concluded on that amendment and that no other amendment was possible; and has the Minister now got it into his head that, if and when that was moved, the only discussion that could take place was when Deputy Norton moved it and that no other Deputy had a chance of putting down a substitute amendment on the same point? What was the position of people who wanted to discuss that? Under the agreement it could have been put down for the Report Stage. I never heard that there was any agreement as to the Minister's being the judge of what was or was not a substantial amendment. I have never heard that there was any suggestion that the Minister was to be the judge; but even the Minister could not have denied that the question of "cuts" in the Civil Service was a fundamental matter. We met on Friday last and it was the meeting on Friday which broke the agreement.
What was the consideration supposed to be in all this matter—that in order to prevent Deputies having to appear again in this House after the holiday in the same week the measure would be got through if at all possible in the two days, and that amendments, if not disposed of, would be put down again. Is the Minister trying to assert that no amendment would appear again on Report Stage? Will his Whips say that that was the agreement? Because the Minister did not see fit to inform his Whip accurately as to what he wanted and because, misled by his instructions, the Whip did not see the Labour Party, and because the Leader of the Labour Party moved an amendment which he had in his name, we had got to meet last Friday and sit late and we have now got to meet again to-day and to sit late in order to get it through.
Comment on this
I would like to know where is the hypothesis? There can be no denying the fact with which I started, that once the amendment about the civil servant was moved it had to be concluded. It was a vital matter and could not be concluded in the period of 15 minutes which was left after Deputy Norton moved it. An open breach of the agreement was made on Friday. Will the Minister deny the other statement I made—that there was no agreement with regard to other amendments, that amendments which would appear on the Paper on the Committee Stage would not be seen again, that they would be disposed of finally to the point that they would not appear again on Report? This is an outrageous procedure and it is brought about by the Minister's own incapacity. The speech he made to-day shows he has not troubled to look over the matter. He should not take on in too active a way at the beginning; he should wear in on it.
Comment on this
Question put:—"That if necessary the Dáil sit later than 2.30 p.m. to-day and the order for the adjournment be taken not later than midnight to-night."
Do you agree with this result?
I move amendment 8:—
In page 4, before section 7 (2), to insert the following sub-section:—
The amount of such deduction as aforesaid shall in the case of an officer in the Civil Service of the Government of Saorstát Eireann be reduced by such sum not exceeding the total deduction as is equal to the difference between the two amounts following:—
(a) the annual amount of the cost-of-living bonus applicable to the substantive salary of such officer on the 31st December, 1932, calculated by reference to the cost-of-living index figure in force on January 1st, 1923, and
(b) the annual amount of the cost-of-living bonus applicable to the substantive salary of such officer on December 31st, 1932, calculated by reference to the cost-of-living index figure in force on that date.
The object of this amendment is to provide if possible that in making cuts from the salaries of civil servants some account should be taken of the fact that civil servants for the last 11 years have, through the operation of the bonus system, suffered a very severe reduction in their salaries. I drew the attention of the House to the fact that civil servants were the only State servants whose salaries were related to the rise in the cost-of-living figures and the fall in the purchasing power of money by means of the system of bonus. It has always been the contention of civil servants, and it has been practically admitted by the present Government that the bonus system as at present in operation did not really relate the salaries of civil servants to the present cost of living. In other words, that the bonus was only a fraction of the increase in the cost of living and it will be known that this fraction got less and less as the salary of the civil servant increased. So that the loss under the operation of the present Bill will be such that a point will be reached where the cut proposed to be imposed by this Bill will exceed the amount of the bonus given under the operation of the bonus system.
It has been suggested in many directions that there are far too many civil servants, that we have an over-staffed public service and a far too highly paid Civil Service. But it is not generally known to the public at all events that 65 per cent. of the civil servants receive £3 a week, or less; that nearly 80 per cent. receive not more than £4 a week, and that over 90 per cent. receive not more than £400 a year. About 5 per cent. receive salaries exceeding £500. The suggestion that there are hordes of public officials who are battening upon the unfortunate taxpayers and particularly upon the unfortunate farmer, is a suggestion utterly devoid of foundation. From the introduction of the bonus system in 1921 until January of this year there has been a steady and increased drop in the bonus, due to the drop in the cost of living. The result of that has been that the Exchequer of this State has benefited to the extent of over £2,000,000 at the expense of the civil servants. During the first three months of this year, from January to the 31st March, as a result of a further drop in the bonus, £40,000 was saved to the Exchequer. During the entire of this year, owing to the drop in the bonus, the Exchequer will be saved something like £125,000. I think it is due to the civil servants that some notice should be taken of these facts. They, more than any other section of the public service of this State, have suffered very severely and have been cut right along the line from 1922 down to the present moment. If I might be permitted to do something which I dislike doing, namely to quote figures, I could bring home to the members of this House and to the public the serious situation in which civil servants find themselves. From the 1st January, 1933, to the 30th of this month salaries will be reduced as follows:— On an inclusive salary and bonus of £161 19s. od. the civil servant will suffer a cut of £9 10s. 0d. Since the bonus in 1921 was put into operation that inclusive salary of £161 19s. 0d., which nobody can say is very excessive, has contributed to the Exchequer, in cuts from the operation of the bonus system, a sum of £95 5s. 0d. This year it will contribute a sum of £9 10s. 0d. under the present Bill. Take an inclusive salary of £414 9s. 0d. That will be reduced by £17 12s. 0d. under the present Bill. The particular person who is in receipt of that salary has suffered a total cut already of £176 16s. 0d. through the operation of the bonus system. A salary of £536 19s. 0d. will suffer a cut of £21 1s. 0d. That salary has already suffered a total cut of £206 13s. 0d. There is no necessity to go through any further figures.
The figures I have quoted are sufficient to show that a very serious inroad has been made into the remuneration of civil servants. There is really no relation between the remuneration of civil servants, even through the operation of the bonus system and the cost-of-living figure or the purchasing power of money. While in the case of other sections of the public service it might with some show of justification be said that their remuneration has no relation to the fact that the cost of living has in some respects fallen, it is perfectly clear that the civil servants' remuneration is related to pre-war salary and has no proper reference either to the drop in the purchasing powers of that salary or to the fall in the cost of living. I would appeal to the Minister to exercise his discretion, if I may put it that way. I would rather appeal to his sense of justice that he should take into account that civil servants are in an exceptional category in this connection, and that some consideration should be given to them, having regard to the facts which I have brought before the notice of the House.
Comment on this
I should like to say, in reply to Deputy Costello, that we had to take the position as we found it at the close of the last financial year and to seek the savings where they could be best found. But, in drafting that part of the Schedule which relates to civil servants we did take into consideration the fact that they had already suffered some reduction in remuneration, due to the change in the cost-of-living figure. It is quite true that we have not taken into consideration the total reductions which they have suffered since 1923. That is, however, rather because we were not going back to 1923. We dealt, as I said, with the position as we found it at the close of the last financial year, and had to consider that in relation to our requirements for this year.
Comment on this
I move amendment 9:—
In page 4, before Section 7 (2), to insert the following sub-section:—
Notwithstanding anything contained in this Act no deduction shall be made from the salary of any person in the Civil Service of the Government of Saorstát Eireann:—
(a) who was appointed with a special agreement as to the amount of his remuneration and who for the purpose of accepting such appointment gave up the practice of any profession or occupation in which he was actively engaged at the time of accepting such appointment, or
(b) who was appointed subsequent to the 6th December, 1922, with a special agreement as to his remuneration and who for the purpose of accepting such appointment gave up an appointment in the service of any other country, or
(c) who was appointed to any post, office or situation in the Civil Service of the Government of Saorstát Eireann with a special agreement or understanding as to the amount of his remuneration.
I would make a special appeal to the Minister to give his sympathetic consideration to the categories of people who are comprised in the classes mentioned in this amendment. The object of the amendment is really to secure the maintenance of contracts, not merely for the purpose of maintaining contracts, or preserving the principle of the sancity of agreements, but for the purpose of securing efficient service for the State, and securing that people who are applying for the sort of posts covered by this amendment will be efficient workers, and will give efficient and proper service. The amendment covers a number of classes of people. It covers professional men such as solicitors and barristers, who have become legal officers of the various Departments of this State, and it covers doctors who are employed in the service of the State, and also engineers. In addition, it covers, perhaps, a more important class of professional men or quasi-professional men, economists, financiers, people with specialised knowledge in one department or another in this State.
The State requires, as I said on another occasion, not merely for internal purposes, but for its external relations with the other countries of the world, that we should have the best legal brains, the best financial brains and experience, and the best economists we can secure; and no money that we will expand in securing first-class service from people in these categories will be money badly spent. It will be an economy in itself to pay proper legal men, proper medical men, proper financiers, proper economists. What I want to secure in this amendment, if it is at all possible, is that people of these classes who have given up the active practice of their profession for the purpose of giving their service to the State, and who entered into a special agreement with reference to their remuneration and other conditions of service, should not have that agreement interfered with by the Bill. As I said, that principle is not merely the principle of the sanctity of agreements, but it is one designed to secure the efficiency and the economy of the public service.
What I have said covers paragraph (a) of my amendment. There is, however, over and above that, if I may put it so, an extra special case in reference to the people comprised in paragraph (b). Paragraph (b) comprises a class of people who were appointed to the Civil Service subsequent to the setting up of the Saorstát, and they were of a kind who had very specialised experience and service, mostly in the British Civil Service. They were mostly people who were reluctant to come into the service of this State, not because they were not desirous of giving their service to the Irish people, but because they had to consider themselves in some degree. People in the British Civil Service have far more opportunity of advancement and promotion than they ever can hope to have in the Irish Civil Service. People who accepted the express invitation of Ministers of this State to come over and give their services to this State gave up considerable prospects of advancement in the British Civil Service. It would be invidious to mention names, and I do not propose to mention them, but there is notoriously one instance of a person who was in the Civil Service of this State on a temporary or loan basis and who returned, let us put it, to the British Civil Service, and who is now occupying a very high position in the biggest and most important department of the British Civil Service. We lost his experience, his specialised knowledge, and the gain that he would have been to this State. He personally gained, but he was prepared to stay on here.
Numbers of people of similar experience and first-class brains accepted the invitation of the Irish Government to come over and give their service to the Irish Free State and the Irish people. They did not ask for anything exceptional; they did not ask for any special promotion; they did not ask for any special terms. They did not say:"We are making considerable sacrifices in the way of our prospects of promotion in the British Civil Service and there is very little prospect of promotion or of kudos in the Irish Civil Service." All they said was: "Let us be secure in our positions and our salaries and that is all that we want." They got that undertaking when they came over with that agreement, given on behalf of the people of this country to secure highly specialised services and first-class brains, and I do appeal to the Minister to consider the word of the Irish people given on behalf of their elected Government in reference to these people.
Comment on this
Of course, I do feel that there is something in what Deputy Costello has argued on behalf of the people who are in the category of paragraph (b) of his amendment. I am not able at this stage to say whether I shall be in a position to do anything special in regard to them, but I shall give the matter consideration.
Comment on this
I am much obliged to the Minister for his undertaking. It is a topic on which I personally feel very keen indeed.
Comment on this
In regard to amendment No. 12, I must inquire what is the exact application of this section before I speak on it.
Comment on this
I do not know that it is necessary at this stage of the Bill to make any statement on it.
Comment on this
The Deputy had an amendment down on the Committee Stage which would have enabled us to speak on it. The Deputy did not move the amendment then.
Comment on this
Question put:—"That the words proposed to be deleted stand."
Do you agree with this result?
I move amendment 13:—
In page 4 to delete Section 7 (5).
It seems to me that this section, in itself, is the clearest possible admission that there is no authority, outside the section, for imposing any reduction such as is contemplated in this Bill. The only purpose of the section, it seems to me, is to enable the Minister to be in the position to impose cuts retrospectively. In my opinion this section is retrospective legislation of the worst and most reactionary character. If such a proposal was embodied in a Bill when the Minister was in Opposition it would call forth a torrent of his delightful oratorical denunciation upon any Minister who tried to stand up for such a proposition. In the last six years various acts have been passed providing for retrospective legislation. Every one of these was denounced by the Party of which the Minister is a member. The last of these Acts was the notorious Constitution (Amendment Section 2) Act. That was denounced by every member of the Fianna Fáil Party and especially the retrospective provisions of that Act were denounced by the Fianna Fáil Party. If retrospective legislation was bad on that occasion, it is no less bad to-day. This piece of retrospective legislation is as bad, if not worse, than the retrospective legislation contained in that Act to which I allude, and if that legislation merited the Minister's hostility and denunciation, then, I cannot understand, if he is still a democrat, which is highly doubtful, how he can stand for this section.
There is no reason or justification for this section. If the Minister is going to stand for its introduction into this Bill then he is following along the paths of reaction that have, in some respects, been originally marked out for him by his predecessors. I hope the Minister will not persist in standing over this section. It is unjustifiable and it is completely at variance with the previous protestations of the Minister.
Comment on this
I think there is some difference between amendment 13 standing in the name of Deputy Norton and Amendment 14 in my name. Deputy Norton's amendment if accepted and if the sub-section was taken out would not leave the Minister in any worse position, if the Minister feels that what he is doing is lawful, apart from any bolstering up of the section which cannot come into operation until the Bill is law. I wanted it declared that no deduction made should be lawful as long as the section which seeks to make the deduction lawful is not law. Deputy Norton criticises the section on the grounds of its being retrospective. It is worse, a great deal worse, than being retrospective; and it is exceptionally bad coming from a Minister who has the audacity to say that the passing of the Second Reading of a measure justifies action at once. If that were so why is there such a thing as "the Provisional Imposition of Taxes" Act giving force to taxes which ordinarily are taken up by the Finance Act. They immediately become law, when passed, but only because there is that special statute attached to them. If the Minister believes that the Second Reading is a justification, and that if brought into a court by civil servants or by a member of the Police Force he could plead the Bill as a justification then he does not want this section. Deputy Norton says rightly that the introduction of this section reveals conscience in this matter. Minister have a gift of giving themselves away in the phrasing of their measures, but that only reveals their conscience, it does not get over the difficulty.
Comment on this
I am not sure that that particular phrase has not been repudiated as well as the phrase about personation. The Minister put into the section that every deduction made —and there is this limiting phrase: "which would have been a lawful deduction under this section if this section had been in force, shall be deemed to have been made under this section and to be, and always to have been, lawful." If it was always lawful why say so? Why call attention to a practice, creating a suspicion in some minds, by saying every deduction which would be lawful if the section was in force? Why, then, the futility of going on to say every deduction which would be lawful, if done in a lawful way, would be lawful when this measure becomes law? When this measure becomes law it would be lawful but with retrospective effect. Here we have a new point of law—and this is now to be taken as having been advised upon by the legal advisers of the Government—to the effect that once the Second Reading of a measure is passed the measure becomes operative. In fact, this measure is operating either legally or illegally, and the only justification we have for it in this House is that the Second Reading must pass. That is not law yet—I do not care what the Minister says. How can anything, not previously lawful, be lawful under it until it becomes law? Why call attention to the payments which would have been lawful deductions if this had been in force? Two points emerge from that phrase: (1) that it is not in force at the moment; and (2) that until it is in force the deductions now being made are not lawful. Yet it is sought to justify this, not by the section, but by the Minister's excuse that the Second Reading has been passed and that therefore this is legal. I want to know specifically—I have asked the question a dozen times already—is there any belief that a person who, believing himself to be aggrieved and going into court at this moment and able to get an action to have his case decided immediately, would have pleaded, in defence against his action, a section of a Bill—not a section of an Act? If that is so, it is a new defence; and it is the first time that it has ever been urged that it is even to be considered as a defence.
There is a retrospective side to it apart from this attempt to bully and bulldoze people into accepting the illegality. The Minister knows perfectly well that what prevents action from being taken against them is not that, but the knowledge that they can dismiss civil servants and degrade and worsen them in their positions. Any individual who goes against them knows this, and it is that tyrannical use of power that is saving them at the moment. It is not any appreciation of the fact that that is legalising it now. There is not the slightest belief in that. But there is an attempt now to get away with this: that there are certain people whom we have chosen to hack because they are close to our hands and also because we have them under our control, and anybody who dares to go against us in court knows what is coming to him. That may be successful, but it is not morality and, certainly, it is not law. Look at the type of retrospection itself. There has been always a feeling in this House against retrospective legislation. That feeling is sound in the main. I have never yet found anything in the way of the retrospective validating of a thing that went beyond this: simply saying that "something has happened which was not properly effected and in which there was a flaw; a decision has been given which goes beyond the views of the Oireachtas that passed it; and we are now going to take cognizance of that defect and try to remedy it." But this measure says: "We are going to do something—not something that we have inadvertently slipped into doing—but we are going to do something which we recognise as being illegal but which, when passed, will justify us in what we have done." That is quite different to anything ever attempted in this House before. I want to get that definitely clear. If ever there has been retrospective legislation in the House it has had reference to something which has previously been done through inadvertence and the Oireachtas sets out to amend it or the Government of the day sets out to do so. This is entirely different. It does not look to something that was inadvertently done. It says: "We are going to do something; we recognise that it cannot be justified, as the Act is only going through, but we will take a phrase in the Act which, if the Act ever reaches the Statute Book, will justify us for what we have done." That is an amazing proposition. Here is something which is clearly not right. We are not going to wait in the ordinary way and to try to validate it in the ordinary way, but we say: "Here is an illegal act; we are going to do it; but we will pass a Bill and, if the Bill becomes law, it will have retrospective effect in that respect."
Let us take the justice of it, which is an entirely different thing. Proposals for cuts were made. They were made last year in the Budget speech. The Minister entered into negotiations with the various civil servants, the police and other bodies in order to get these deductions by agreement. He failed to get that agreement. He set up a Commission with regard to one of these bodies, and I think he told us that he got four different reports. The idea of that Commission was an attempt to get justification for what he had in mind. We have not seen the reports, but we can only judge, from the fact that the Minister kept the results to himself, that they were not favourable. When this failed, the proposal is made that there are going to be "cuts." We are supposed to be governed at the moment in a reasoned fashion, that is, that proposals are going to be submitted to the test of debate; points are going to be brought out for and against the measure; and the House makes up its mind as to the justification for, or the objection to, the particular proposals concerned. Ordinarily, people have this to look to that they can await the outcome of these deliberations. This is supposed to be a deliberative assembly, and it is usual to wait to see what case can be made for or against a proposal before any penalty can be imposed. Generally speaking, a person is preserved from having any attack made either upon his person or upon his property until such time as the Oireachtas, looking to the future, determines that such an attack should be made. But here, after years of fruitless negotiations, which means years of failure to persuade the people to accept cuts in the interests of the State and owing to economic necessity, after a Commission had sat and reported in a way which is no great use to the Minister he comes in here and, without any detailed discussion of this matter, gets a Second Reading passed and because of that, says that that is sufficient. He operates the Bill not merely on this principle of a "cut," but according to the Schedule which is a matter of the details involved. If there is any sense in having a Bill in this House go through certain stages and be examined in detail—if there is any sense in that, there is certainly no justification whatever for imposing, not what might be called the principle of the matter, but even the details of the measure upon people, prior to this House having had any chance of exercising what it was elected for, namely, deliberation and argument.
This Bill is brought forward, and an automatic majority is secured for it. That majority was secured for it on the Second Reading, not merely for the principle or lack of principle contained in the Bill, but for the details. The details are actually in force, and an attempt was made here on two occasions to prevent discussion on the details. The whole progress of the Bill is marked by everything that is most abhorrent to an assembly of this kind, elected for discussion and argument. The test of legislation is that it commends itself after discussion to a majority of the people. This Bill is abhorrent in every way to that, because the Minister proceeds to enforce the details of it without giving any chance for discussion. He takes up a completely illegal attitude in so far as justification is concerned, and he proceeds to act before there is the slightest chance in equity given to the people concerned to have their cases pleaded for them, as they cannot plead them themselves. The progress of the Bill is marked by a considerable number of other vicious points. It is a distinct slur cast upon the procedure under which this House usually operates in so far as no opportunity is given for adequate discussion and deliberation on a measure of this importance, and particularly on this section.
Comment on this
Deputy McGilligan is very much concerned about the slur which, he says, is cast upon the proceedings of this House by the inclusion of this section. I quite clearly indicated in my speech on the Second Reading that the Minister for Finance, in virtue of the Ministers and Secretaries Act, had power simply by regulation to make every one of the cuts proposed in this Bill. I said that in view of the extent to which that power was going to be exercised, and in the particular circumstances, I would be loath to exercise it until I had given the Dáil an opportunity of expressing its opinions on the whole general principle. The Deputy is, of course, a fruitful father of Aunt Sallies, and he creates an argument with no substance merely that he may give himself the somewhat doubtful pleasure of knocking it down. He said that I admitted we were acting illegally. I have denied that from the beginning. I made it quite clear that we had the power under the existing law to do everything we have done under this Bill.
The Deputy's colleague was somewhat maladroit in his characterisation of the law. According to a statement made yesterday, a letter was sent to his Department—he was then a Minister—stating the Government had decided to make a cut in the pay of the Gárda Síochána. The Deputy said he did not mean what was in that letter. One never knows what Deputy Fitzgerald-Kenney does mean when he talks in this House. I never said we were acting illegally. To make it quite clear what was the intention of the Government in regard to this matter, this section was printed in the Bill and, if Deputy McGilligan had any doubts as to what was going to be the result of the House giving a Second Reading to the measure, it was quite open to him, if he were concerned, to raise this particular detail and he could have put down a reasoned amendment asking the House not to give the Bill a Second Reading until this particular subsection to which he objects had been deleted. Any member of the House could have done that, but he did not do so. I am quite entitled, in view of the powers already conferred on me by the Ministers and Secretaries Act, to carry out what was my original intention, and that was to impose the deductions and fix the remuneration of all classes of public servants as from 1st April of this year.
Comment on this
I do not think the Minister's statement should be allowed to go, at least without some challenge. As I understand him, he claims that this section is above reproach, because he has power under the existing law to do what he proposes to do by this Bill by virtue of a regulation. I think I am correctly stating the Minister's contention when I say that. I agree with the Minister that he has power to reduce civil servants' salaries by means of regulations, but that power is not derived from the Ministers and Secretaries Act. So far as I recollect —I am speaking from recollection—that power is derived from the Civil Service Regulation Acts. The distinction that has to be borne in mind is this, that the British Civil Service is based on an old theory of Crown prerogative and the British civil servant receives his salary, not for the purpose of clothing himself and feeding himself and his family, but for the purpose of keeping up the dignity of the Crown. So that the King's servants may not be shabby and the King's lackeys may not be ill-fed, the British civil servant receives his salary.
The principle on which the cut would be operated without the authority of the Oireachtas would be based on the theory that when we took over the Civil Service from the British Government our civil servants were being remunerated for the purpose of keeping up the dignity of the Minister for Finance and for the purpose of seeing that the officers of the Service should not go into their various Departments badly clothed, badly fed or badly shod. Unfortunately, we did not allow that situation even to remain in theory because we passed the Civil Service Regulation Acts, which put the Civil Service on a statutory basis, and those very arbitrary rights which the civil servants are subjected to under the Civil Service theory in England no longer obtain here and it is a fallacy to think that they do, because they do not.
The Civil Service at the present moment is a statutory creation, it is governed by statute, and anything that has to be done by way of administration dealing with the civil servants and affecting their rights, and particularly affecting their salaries, must be done in pursuance of the Civil Service Regulations Acts. While I admit the Minister's contention that he can reduce Civil Service salaries by regulations, these regulations would have to be done and made under the Civil Service Acts and by the machinery in relation to those Acts. The real fallacy in the Minister's argument lies in this, that while he has power to reduce Civil Service salaries by regulations, he has not introduced those regulations but has instead proceeded in another way. In doing what he proposes to do he is acting illegally. That is my submission.
Comment on this
I would like to make it quite clear to the House that I never advised the Minister—and that the Minister never suggested that he had been so advised—that the Second Reading of a Bill in this House made the Bill law.
Comment on this
We had this question of retrospective legislation discussed on another Bill the other day. I understood that Deputy Fitzgerald-Kenney stated that when he introduced the Hospitals Bill, 1931, the legal position was then completely different, and that he endeavoured to act under that Bill while it remained a Bill. I challenged him on that. Deputy McGilligan made the point that no Bill is law until it is actually passed by the Oireachtas. I understood the Deputy to say that the legal position was quite different to the position under the section which we were then discussing. I think I can readily explain why this section finds its place in the Bill. I am sure it has already occurred to Deputy McGilligan and to Deputy Costello that the Bill had to make a reduction in the annual remuneration of the servants of the State for the coming year. If this section were not in the Bill and the Bill came into force without it, that would mean that the civil servants who up to the time of the passing of the Bill had been paid their salaries in full would, after the passing of the Bill have to face a contribution out of the moneys they already had received. Their salaries for the remaining part of the year would have to be further cut so as to make up for the money they have been overpaid in the previous months. But in order that the matter would be made more easy for the civil servants to meet the intention of the Bill, the collection of the money to be cut was made operative from the date of the passing of the Second Reading. As the Minister points out, the position is that the principle of this Bill has been accepted by this House.
Comment on this
I have already stated that no lawyer would contend otherwise than that.
Comment on this
A Bill has not the force of law until it becomes an Act. On that particular contention I was challenged by Deputy Fitzgerald-Kenney a few days ago, and I am quite sure that Deputy Norton will agree that it is much more reasonable that the deductions should be made as from the date when the Bill was introduced and got the Second Reading passed than that the civil servants should have all the deductions made from their salaries for the year in the months after the Bill had passed.
Comment on this
When the Labour Deputies have ceased their little dialogue I will continue. The Attorney-General after the very lame halting defence he put before the House just now started off with an entire misstatement of fact. He said that I had acted upon the Hospitals Bill before it was law. That is absolutely incorrect. I made that perfectly clear on the debate on the Hospitals Bill. It should be plain to the knowledge of the Attorney-General that the Hospitals Bill introduced a scheme but that scheme was not sanctioned until after the Bill became law. The persons who promoted that scheme knew that the Bill was under discussion in the House. They knew that if the Bill became law an amendment of the scheme would be made. That is a perfectly different thing, absolutely a different thing from what has happened in the present Bill. I do not care how much the Attorney-General may endeavour to prevent his own brain acting or how much he may stultify himself but I do not believe that he can drive himself into the belief that the facts are any way similar.
The Attorney-General gets up here and tells us that there are two forms of robbery, one form is a form in which you are to take the money at one stroke. He says it would be very unfair to the civil servants to rob them all in one piece. He says he would prefer the robbery day by day. "We are very charitable robbers, very mild robbers and we will make robbery as gentle as possible to the persons who are being robbed." That is really the attitude of the Government but the Attorney-General is not entitled to argue in this House that it was not a robbery.
Comment on this
Do I understand that Senior Counsel is now arguing that something done in the Dáil is robbery?
Comment on this
Is it in order to refer here to a Deputy as "Senior Counsel?" As I take it the Standing Orders lay down that a Deputy speaks here as a representative of the people. A Deputy, I submit, should not be referred to otherwise than as a representative of the people. In speaking in this House I could not for instance refer to the Minister for Finance as a very mediocre civil engineer.
Comment on this
I do not think there is anything objectionable in calling a Deputy "Senior Counsel".
Comment on this
It was always understood that a Deputy spoke in this House in a representative capacity. Of course if you rule otherwise I will have great pleasure in using other synonyms about the Minister for Finance.
Comment on this
I will not rule otherwise. I hope the rule will be observed in future that Deputies will be referred to as Deputies.
Comment on this
Is Deputy McGilligan entitled to make use of a point of order for the purpose of insulting a Minister?
Comment on this
He is not. No Deputy is entitled to make use of anything to insult anybody in this House.
Comment on this
Deputy McGilligan used a point of order to insult the Minister for Finance. I ask that he be asked to withdraw.
Comment on this
Is it orderly to refer to a Deputy in this House who is in fact a distinguished member of the Bar as "Senior Counsel"?
Comment on this
The Standing orders prescribe that members of this House shall be referred to as Deputy So-and-So.
Comment on this
I withdraw the words "distinguished" and "Senior Counsel" in reference to Deputy Fitzgerald-Kenney.
Comment on this
The Minister for Finance is, as usual, endeavouring to be insulting. I do not mind that. We know the Minister for Finance for some time. Now that the Attorney-General and the Minister for Finance have wasted a considerable amount of time I would like to get back to my speech. I said that the Attorney-General was very kind, and that the Executive Council were very kind to the civil servants, because when they wish to rob the civil servants they want to make the robbery as light as possible. They are to see that the victim is to be very lightly treated. Instead of taking all his money together he is being robbed gradually. Instead of taking all the money at one time from him they will take it bit by bit, so that the robbery may be a little bit less hard upon the victim. The Attorney-General has not got up in this House and has not said in this House that the withholding of these moneys was legally done, and if the withholding of these moneys was not legally done, then the persons who have not been receiving their moneys have been robbed.
Whether retrospective legislation deprives him of the money at once or whether it deprives him by a sum deducted weekly or monthly in instalments, it is exactly the same thing in law. The Attorney-General has not said that in this House because he could not say that the action had been legal. If the action is not legal and if these persons have been deprived of the moneys which they have earned, then those persons have been wronged. As I said before, you are defrauding labourers of their wages and committing a sin that cries to heaven for vengeance. The Minister tells us that he had full power. If he had, he certinly has not exercised that power, and I deny emphatically that he had any such power. Unless my memory is at fault, before any reduction can be made in the pay or allowances of the Civic Guards, it is necessary that the Representative Body should be consulted and their views considered by the Executive Council. Have any of these things been done? It is necessary that the order reducing their pay shall be laid on the Table of the House and voted upon. Am I correct in that?
Comment on this
The Minister, therefore, had no justification to cut the pay of the Civic Guards. It requires this Bill to do it. It is admitted that, as far as civil servants, and possibly teachers and some other people, he may have power, but he did not exercise it. Until that power is exercised according to the statute empowering him, those persons are entitled to their pay. As regards the Civic Guards, he certainly had no power. Now he comes along, plainly and openly, to rob that body of men. Surely that is the most dishonourable and most criminally wrong thing that any House has been asked to do with regard to persons in their employment. If there is any sense of Justice, any sense of honour, or of right doing, in the members of this House, they will not be guilty of this appalling act of dishonesty.
Comment on this
Apart from the friendly squabbles which have been going on between members of the two main Parties and, especially, between lawyer Deputies on both sides of the House, it is an extraordinary situation to find that the Attorney-General should get up in the House and admit that this section is merely put into the Bill for the purpose of regularising what he admitted was an illegal procedure. He laid great stress upon the fact, as also did the Minister, that the Government were empowered to do by regulation what they are now proposing to do in this Bill. Is it not correct to say that the regulation under which the Minister says he could carry out this administrative procedure would not be effective until laid upon the Table of the House and approved of within twenty-one days of being so laid? In other words, if a regulation was laid upon the Table of the House under any Act under which the Minister claimed to carry out this procedure, the regulation will not be effective, and the salaries will be illegally cut, if such regulation were annulled within 21 days from the date on which it was laid on the Table. I am sure the Attorney-General will admit that. I think it is an extraordinary thing for Deputies of the Fianna Fáil party, who claim to be the real democratic Party in this State, the first democratic Party that ever took charge of the Government, to have to go to the country and to admit, after having heard the Attorney-General, that they are merely being called to this House for the purpose of registering in a penny-in-the-slot-machine-like way decisions of the Executive Council which have been admitted by the Attorney-General to be illegal.
Comment on this
The issue boils down to this, that the Government have done something that is grossly illegal, and did it deliberately. Either that or the section is futile. Assuming from the arguments advanced that the Government did, with their eyes open, and confessed they were going to do something grossly illegal, they are now asking the House to condone it. There was no necessity for doing it. There was no crisis. There was none of the ordinary excuses that Governments sometimes have to go beyond the law and then afterwards seek idemnification by an idemnity Bill. What the Government have done is, without any excuse, deliberately to act illegally and then come to the House and say: "Condone our conduct." I do not think the House ought to do anything of the kind.
Comment on this
Question put:—"That the words proposed to be deleted stand."
Do you agree with this result?
I move amendment No. 18:—
In page 4, before Section 8, to insert a new section as follows:— Notwithstanding anything contained in this Act this Part of this Act shall not apply to any existing officer or servant referred to in Section 63 of the Court Officers Act, 1926 (No. 27 of 1926), who pursuant to the provisions of the said section of the said Act was offered and accepted employment in a situation under the said Act.
In moving this amendment I wish to emphasise that it covers a comparatively small number of men in the Civil Service. If the Minister could see his way to accede to the proposal contained in the amendment it would create no precedent whatever in connection with the principles contained in this Bill. I would make a very earnest appeal to the Minister for sympathetic consideration on this particular amendment, which is genuinely put forward by me in the interests of a certain class of State servants, who have a particular and unique case. The Court Officers Act, 1926, was passed in peculiar circumstances. It is the provisions of that Act that give those particular officers a very special case and enable me to make a very special appeal to the Minister on their behalf.
The Minister will probably be aware that in 1926 the courts were, so to speak, cleared out. The old courts of Justice were regarded in the days prior to the Treaty as being the happy hunting ground for sinecures, people who wanted soft jobs, easy money and nothing to do, and who had relatives to place. To a certain extent that criticism was justified. In 1926 the whole lot were cleared out, lock, stock and barrel, deserving cases, good cases, bad cases and indifferent cases, and a new beginning was made in the staffs of the courts of justice. Everybody was dismissed from his post under the provisions of the Act of 1926. Many of those people who were then employed, and who were dismissed under the Act of 1926, were entitled to a life tenure, were entitled to retain their posts, and not to be removed from them without cause being shown for their removal.
There they had conditions of tenure and service entirely distinct from any other branch of civil servants. However, the Government of that time, decided to take the bold course, and clear them out; but they were entitled to their rights, under Article 10 of the Treaty. It was not intended that the Courts of Justice should be entirely denuded of their staffs. What was intended was that a large measure of economy should be effected, and it was effected. A lot of duds were cleared out and a lot of furniture was dispossessed, and a new beginning was made. It was provided expressly in the statute that the offer of employment should be made to such of the court officials who was considered entitled to remain on by reason of their service and their efficiency. That statute under Section 63 provided that when officers were offered employment, they should be offered employment in a situation, under this Act, carrying with it not less salary than the situation held by them, as such officers, at the passing of that Act. What happened was that in accordance with the provisions of the Act, a written document offering a situation, at not less salary than that which he previously held was sent to each court officer. On certain terms he was offered to be employed in the new courts, and a written agreement was signed, coupled with that offer, accepting the terms proposed. In other words the persons covered by my amendment have a written contract with the State, made for valuable consideration, and it is expressed in a statutory provision that they are to have the same salaries.
Now, this Bill would operate upon that small class of officers to break that written agreement made for valuable valuable consideration. And valuable consideration did not emanate entirely from the Minister for Finance, as one would naturally expect. The Minister for Finance gives nothing for nothing. No Minister for Finance ever does. But in order to secure the services of proper individuals, the Minister, in that letter, waived the provisions of the statute which he is entitled to waive, which provides that a court officer when offered new employment, and when he acceptes that new employment, would, by that acceptance, waive his rights under Article 10 of the Treaty. In order to induce efficient officers to serve in the courts of justice the Minister for Justice agreed to waive that provision and said to these officers: "If you accept the offer we are now making the Minister for Finance will not consider that a waverer of your rights under the Treaty."
I suggest it was clear from that that the Department of Finance at the time considered it desirable to get these individuals and that it was worth their while to make that sacrifice to get them. And the men who accepted these positions, in their turn, accepted a tenure less beneficial than the previous tenure they had. They had left a tenure with a better prospect of promotion and I am quite sure that they did not get better salaries. But most of the men covered by this particular section are people who got into the service by open competitive examinations. There is no question of the people retained being made secure in sinecures. They are people who have given expert services, because they are expert servants of the State, in return for a written agreement securing them the same salary as before, and securing them that, not merely by a written agreement, but by statute; so that the proposition in this Bill proposes to cut right across both a written contract and a statutory agreement.
As I said before, there are very few people who will be affected by this amendment, if passed, and they will have a better case than any other case put forward. There is this further fact to be urged in their favour: that they are not paid entirely out of State funds. Litigants are contributing and contributing largely to the expenses of the upkeep of the courts of justice. They have to pay stamp duties on various documents and, of course, that is only one method of raising revenue for the discharge of the expenses of the upkeep of the courts of justice. I admit from litigants does not entirely cover the expenses of the courts of justice or the cost of the establishment in the courts of justice, but it goes some way towards them. It is a relevant fact to be taken into account by the Minister. If he wishes to make economies in the courts of justice administration, the way to make those economies was not, I suggest, at the expense of the people to whom a written contract and a statutory right was given by the Oireachtas, but by increasing the fees of litigants.
A very small increase to litigants would cover the economies that would be effected if the cut is put into operation under this Bill in respect of those people for whom I speak.
I appeal to the Minister on behalf of this small section of the public service on the ground of justice, on the ground that only a few people are employed under these conditions, on the ground that they have a written contract, and on the ground that this Bill will conflict with the sanctity of agreements. But I make the strongest appeal to the Minister on the ground of general principles. He may effect economies at the expense of these men who are thoroughly efficient, and who carry on very important and very essential technical services in the State. But if the principle is once admitted by this House that a written contract made for valuable consideration, made as a result of statutory provisions, can be set aside by this House by a subsequent Act of Parliament, that will have wider reactions and greater evil effects than this House can anticipate at the present moment. The great danger that exists in this State from the point of view of financial stability is an element of insecurity that exists as a result of statutory enactment by this House. If a decision is given against the Government in the courts of justice it is immediately followed by an Act of Parliament nullifying that. I make the Minister a present of the fact that the previous Government was not entirely blameless in that respect. If anything happens, or a situation arises, or exists, which is inconvenient in the march to be achieved by the Government's policy, it is swept aside, whether based on written contract or statute, by subsequent statutes of this House. I do think it is worth while to sacrifice the very small amount of money that could be got as a result of cutting the court officers' salaries, for the purposes of keeping the principle that written contracts are made to be kept, and that statutes of this House, when passed, will not be lightly or arbitrarily set aside. I make a very special appeal to the Minister on this ground to consider this matter. I am not making this appeal now, I can assure the Minister, personally, because there are men who are attached to my own profession. I scarcely know any of them except casually in the course of my professional occupation, but they can cause great havoc and expense to this State unless they are efficient in the carrying out of their duties, and they can cause a lot of trouble and expense if they are not efficient. I am making an appeal, not merely on the ground of justice, but on the broader ground that this House ought to be slow to set aside a written contract or a statutory contract, and I appeal to the Minister for his most earnest consideration of this matter.
Comment on this
From the point of view of the Government, it seems to me that Deputy Costello has not stated the issues fairly in this matter. These Courts of Justice officers were placed in the privileged position in which they are at the present time because our predecessors decided that they were going to reform the existing organisation in this country and decided that, in order to do that, it was necessary for them to dispense with the services of these officers. I do not think that Deputy Costello would be prepared to say, that, in taking that decision and in doing everything that was consequential upon it, our predecessors were doing something which they had not the right to do under Article X and that consequently they had the power under the Treaty and the power which was, of course, conferred upon them by legislation in this House to dismiss everyone of these officers and to say: "We are not going to have anything more to do with you and the only thing we will do is to concede without challenge, that you are entitled to Article X rights." There were certain of these officers whom they wished to retain in their service, and who possibly if they had been in any other situation than that in which they were could have been quite easily absorbed into the general body of the service and therefore, by virtue of that absorption, would not, under the Treaty have been entitled to these Article X rights at all.
They said to these officers:"We are reforming the courts and therefore, must abolish your office; we will allow you to remain in exactly the same position as you are in at present so far as your emoluments are concerned." They said:"No. That will not satisfy us. Under the bond we are entitled to our pound of flesh. We will not come back into the public service on the same terms and conditions as we have enjoyed heretofore. Instead of that, we are going to insist here and now that our Article X rights be conferred upon us. Once we have secured ourselves in those rights, if you offer us further employment upon terms and conditions that will be satisfactory to us, we will consider whether or not we will accept it, and if so, we will agree to the suspension of our rights under Article X during the term of that employment." That is the position they put themselves in.
Faced with demands of that sort, the Government, because they wanted to retain the services of these men at that time said: "Very well, we will concede you Article X rights; we will offer you this re-employment upon terms not less favourable than you enjoyed hitherto." That agreement, at any rate, was made between these officers and the Government. The position, as far as the agreement was concerned, is that these men have an option either to take the employment which is being offered to them and to continue in it or else to leave the service and to take their Article X rights. There is nothing in this Bill which deprives them of those Article X rights. They still have those rights. The only thing the Government proposes to do under this Bill is to reduce the salaries paid to these men and that reduction is being made as part of a reduction which is being applied to every person in the service. The rights of these officers is in no way infringed. If they are not satisfied with the salaries and conditions of employment which will exist after this Bill has become law they can still elect to leave the service and they still have their Article X rights, and that is all. That was provided for in the agreement of 1926. Therefore, I suggest that Deputy Costello is not fair in suggesting that there was a breach of contract. The terms of the contract are there and can still be fulfilled. These men have the right at any time to leave the Government service and to take their Article X rights. Of their own volition they could elect to take these rights and leave the service. Surely, if that is so, the Government also has the right to discharge these men at any time it wished to do so and to compel them to take their Article X rights. We do not propose to do that. We propose to treat them in the same way as every other class of public servant is being treated, and that is that during the period of financial stringency, their emoluments will be reduced by a definite fixed percentage. If they like to accept that, they can do so or, if they do not like it, they can still take their rights under Article X.
These people had so little regard for the position of the Government in 1926 and were so much concerned with their own position that they went to the Compensation Board and had their compensation assessed, and they insisted that this additional right would be reserved to them, that when they did cease to hold office under this Act they could elect whether they would take the compensation already awarded to them under Article X or such greater superannuation as might be awarded to them in 1926. So that, I do not think that any person could say that these men are being ill-treated. If the law were to be applied to them in all strictness, and if the deductions that are now being made were possibly to be taken off some people there would be no case, so far as I can see with regard to this class. This is one class of public servant, so far as I can see, for whom no plea for special consideration could be made properly in this House, because when the time came for them to drive a bargain, they certainly, so far as they could, drove the hardest bargain they could; and there was no consideration of patriotism or even a desire to treat our predecessors with fair play at that time even though they knew they were coming back into the service with the equivalent of what they had already. They went to the Compensation Board and only agreed to the suspension of the award so long as it pleased themselves to accept it. When they came back into the service they were careful to ensure that if they left of their own volition their full rights under Article X and the compensation awarded to them in 1926, possibly at a much higher rate than it would be awarded to them to-day, would not be affected and that they would carry that with them.
Accordingly, I do not think that the amendment has any special claims for consideration at all and, therefore, even on its merits it should be rejected by the House. I want to make it quite clear there has been no breach of contract, no breach of agreement, with these men. The agreement made in 1926 still exists, and they have the right if they wish to take the compensation awarded to them under Article X. We are not interfering with that in any way.
Comment on this
I beg to move amendment 19:—
In page 4, at the end of Section 8, line 42, to add the words:—
Provided however that an appeal from such determination shall lie to the Civil Service (Compensation) Board established in accordance with the Civil Service (Transferred Officers) Compensation Act, 1929 (No. 36 of 1929), and the said Board shall have jurisdiction to hear and determine any such appeal and the determination of the said Board shall be final and conclusive.
This amendment provides that the public servant affected by the provisions of this Bill and about whom a dispute may arise shall have the right to go to the Civil Service (Compensation) Tribunal for the purpose of having that dispute determined. I think the Minister will agree that that particular Tribunal has been found to have worked very satisfactorily, from the point of view of both parties, since its inception. I am not able to envisage very clearly what sort of disputes will be likely to arise under this Bill which will cause any very great degree of difficulty in determination or any acrimony between the staff and the Minister. But, if there be such disputes, it would be only proper that a Tribunal such as this, which has proved its impartiality and worth, should be resorted to rather than that civil servants should even feel a sense of grievance in that the person who is one of the parties to the litigation should also be the judge.
I have not gone to the extent reached by the amendment in Deputy Norton's name, suggesting an appeal to the court. The Civil Service (Compensation) Tribunal is a very expenditious, handy, impartial, effective and efficient Tribunal. There is not any great likelihood of serious disputes arising out of this Bill, but if there should be any such, it would be more conductive to the efficiency of the Civil Service that there should be a resort to this Tribunal. If such resort is permitted it will maintain the principle that a litigant should not be a judge in his own cause.
Comment on this
I wish to support the amendment. It is quite contrary to fundamental principle and justice that any person, a Minister or otherwise, should be put in a position to determine as between himself and another person whether he is right or wrong. He makes a decision as between himself and a civil servant and the person to whom the right of appeal is left is the Minister who has already decided. It is fundamentally unjust that such a principle should be acknowledged in this House. In a matter of the kind, where a dispute may arise between the Minister and the public servant, the obvious and fair course is to allow it to go to a body already proved to be a suitable and proper body to determine matters of the kind.
Comment on this
On behalf of Deputy Norton, I beg to move amendment 20:—
In page 4, line 41, Section 8, to delete all after the word "Minister" to and including the word "final", line 42, and substitute the words "but nothing in this Act shall operate to restrict the right of appeal by any person affected to a court of competent jurisdiction".
The argument advanced by Deputy Rice on the last amendment can be equally applied to this. This amendment merely asks that public servants, who consider they are affected adversely in their positions, should have the right granted to any ordinary citizen to have recourse to a court of competent jurisdiction. In the simplest matter affecting the lives of citizens the courts are considered to be fair arbiters between man and man. It is unfair for any Minister to arrogate to himself or his successors, whoever they may be, this right of final appeal. It is unfair to deny the civil servant the opportunity of appealing to the courts. No civil servant would dream of appealing to the courts if he did not feel he had a just case to present. Only the barest form of justice is being asked. The Minister is not, in our opinion, a suitable person for this job, and public servants should have courts of competent jurisdiction left available for an appeal, if an appeal is considered necessary.
Comment on this
It is not possible to accept this amendment. Apparently the Deputy who has spoken is under the impression that this is a novel principle. The Minister for Finance, virtually since the establishment of the Free State, has been the final authority in all matters relating to the Civil Service and, possibly with some exceptions, to public servants generally. It has been his office to determine all disputes of such a nature as, for instance, might arise out of the operation of this Bill. Of course if he were to exercise that function in relation to these matters he would have to determine issues in accordance with the terms of the Bill. Hitherto he has been the sole interpreter and final authority in these matters, and it is not proposed to depart from the existing practice in that regard.
Comment on this
A phrase of the Minister's which I caught is not a justification, in my opinion, for his attitude in this matter. Deputy Keyes has moved to insert a certain phrase in Section 8. The phrase is such as would give a right of appeal to a court of competent jurisdiction.
Comment on this
Any trifling talk about the situation heretofore is vain in view of what is contained in Section 8. Here is a Bill setting out a definite standard by which the Minister is to limit his cuts, indicating certain persons. Then there is brought into the Bill this tremendous and comprehensive phrase: "Every doubt, question and dispute which shall arise as to whether a person is or is not the person to whom this Part of the Act applies, or as to the amount of the salary for the purposes of this Part of this Act of any person or the amount of the deduction ...." On those three tremendous things now introduced for the first time into the ordinary life of these public servants the Minister is to be the man who determines, and his determination is to be final. Really with that clause in, one might as well take out the schedule and give the whole thing to the Minister. No matter how wide the scope of the Bill, the Minister may go outside it. The Bill is intended to be very comprehensive but no matter how comprehensive it is and no matter what scope is given to it, the Minister can come along and enlarge it. He can apply it to anybody about whose salary he has something in the way of a grip. He can decide on the amount of salary which calls for consideration by him and decide on the amount of reduction.
The Minister does not want schedules or anything else so long as that clause is there. The Minister argued against Deputy Norton's amendment on the basis of what operated in the case of public servants heretofore. He has not met this amendment fairly. The amendment is put down, because, recognising the tremendous extent of these terrible powers given to the Minister, we think there should be a right of appeal to a court of competent jurisdiction. What is the right of appeal if he would not be allowed to apply it to the person or to the salary of the person in the Bill? On these three points appeals could be taken, but the Minister will not have them. This is a new situation, and the Minister can only meet the new argument of the new section by referring to what has happened up to this. This is a tremendous enlargement of the Minister's powers. It is necessary that on these enlarged powers there should be some limitation. The limitation in the amendment is a limitation of appeal to a court of competent jurisdiction. I submit that it is a very sensible amendment.
Comment on this
I move amendment 21:—
In page 4 before Section 9 but in Part II of the Bill to insert a new section as follows:—
Nothing in this Act shall take away, prejudice or in any way affect any right of any transferred officer, as defined by the Civil Service (Transferred Officers) Compensation Act, 1929 (No. 36 of 1929), under Article 78 of the Constitution or under the said Civil Service (Transferred Officers) Compensation Act, 1929, or any powers or jurisdiction conferred by the said Act upon the Civil Service (Compensation) Board established in accordance with the said Act.
The Minister should have no difficulty in accepting the amendment, because throughout the debate he has iterated and reiterated his desire not in any way to interfere with the rights of people under Article X of the Treaty or under the Act of 1929. All this amendment does is to put down what the Minister has said dozens of times during the course of the debate; so that, if he is genuine, as I am sure he is, in saying that he has no desire, and the Government have no desire, by any of the provisions of this Bill to interfere with the Treaty rights, or the rights under the Act of 1929, he will immediately accept the amendment. There are certain provisions in this Bill which undoubtedly give grave reasons for misgivings. The Minister thinks that these misgivings are unfounded, proceeds to declare that opposite. The Minister, while he thinks that these misgivings are unfounded, proceeds to declare that he has no intention whatever of interfering with the rights under Article X or under the Act of 1929. If he has not, why not say so specifically? This amendment merely asks him to state specifically what he has repeatedly declared throughout the course of the debate.
Comment on this
It is quite clear from the Bill that it does not propose in any way to interfere with the rights of the transferred officers, and because there is nothing in the Bill which does, in fact, interfere with these rights, there is no necessity for this new section. As Deputy Costello is well aware, it is very bad, from the point of view of the draftsman, to encumber a Bill with sections drafted merely out of a superabundance of caution.
Comment on this
If the Minister read Section 5 again I think he would not talk with such buoyancy about this Bill doing nothing to affect the legal rights of transferred officers. In my opinion, Section 5 is taking away from a transferred officer the right to make a certain pleading before the Compensation Board, which he has until the Bill becomes an Act. The moment it becomes an Act, that pleading is withdrawn from the officer to some extent, in my opinion, under this section. The Minister for Education, when defending this section, said that this was an attempt by the Government to preserve the contract of the officer. Preserve it against the officer's will; preserve it, not for the sake of the officer's interest, but in order to give the Government a lever which might be used subsequently to defeat the officer's legitimate claim for compensation! If the section generally is not intended to be an infringement of the transferred rights of civil servants, the Minister ought to have no hesitation in accepting the amendment, in order to make sure that Section 5 is not to be construed in the sense of constituting an infraction of these rights. If the Minister, in reference to Section 5, declines to accept the amendment, then there is only one fair conclusion to be come to, viz., that the Minister, while affecting to believe that the Bill does not in any way invade the legal rights of transferred officers, knows very well that the Bill is an attempt to put impediments in the path of transferred civil servants.
Comment on this
I should like to supplement what Deputy Norton and Deputy Costello have said. This amendment would never have been put down, certainly would never have been put pressed, only for the attitude taken up by the Minister for Education on the night the Minister for Finance left him in charge of Section 5. On that occasion Deputy Costello asked for an assurance that in any cases coming before the Civil Service (Transferred Officers) Compensation Board, Section 5 would never be raised against the officers concerned. If it is clear that Section 5 does not affect these rights, that assurance can be readily given now by the Minister for Finance. The Minister for Education refused to give it as a start off. Later in the debate he said that, of course, it would be used. I am not sure that he said it specifically, but he certainly indicated it. When he was pressed, however, on the matter he refused to say that this Bill made no change prejudicial to these transferred officers. He said that they should be in the same position as every other officer in the State, and, secondly, that the change made in their position was only a small matter of getting their salaries cut. If the Minister for Finance believes that the position of the transferred officers is not in any way affected or prejudiced by anything in this measure, he can give that assurance, and the amendment can be withdrawn.
The Attorney-General is again in the House. He has previously taught the Minister a little law this morning. Would he agree that Section 5 in no way affects or prejudices the position of the transferred officers? If we can get a statement from him on that matter it might enlighten either the Minister or those who are putting forward this amendment. Could the Attorney-General back up the Minister in his statement that there is nothing in this Bill which in any way affects or prejudices the rights of the transferred officers? Could he say if there is any possibility, under this measure, of their rights being in any way prejudiced or affected, because even if there is only a bare possibility, without any intention to use it deliberately to prejudice their position, then the argument that the Minister for Finance has used falls to the ground. It is said that this is superabundant caution. There has to be caution if there is even the possibility that this measure will be used to prejudice their rights. I should like if the Attorney-General would give us the benefit of his advice as to whether Section 5 could be in any way used to prejudice the rights of the transferred officers, or whether they would be in exactly the same position after the passage of this measure as they were in before.
Comment on this
On the Second Reading of this Bill I expressed considerable doubt as to what was intended under Section 5. I expressed the hope that some information on that section would be given to the House by the Minister at a later stage. Apparently there is no desire to give any such information. We have the position here that under Section 8 the Minister is made the final judge as between civil servants and himself on the most material questions that affect the civil servants.
Comment on this
I am dealing with the amendment before the House, and I am pointing out that under Section 8, to which the Minister refused to accept any amendment, he is made the final judge as between himself and the civil servant, first of all as to whether the civil servant comes within this part of the Act or not; secondly, as to what his salary is; and thirdly, as to what reductions there may be. No court will be entitled to interfere, when this Bill goes through, as between the Minister and the civil servant on those matters.
Comment on this
No court can interfere and, having regard to the views that the Minister has already expressed here as to what is meant by any particular section, I am wondering what is going to happen when he is given those powers. He refuses here to accept an amendment which merely attempts to set out in express terms what the position of the civil servant is. Last week, when I moved the first amendment to this Bill, the Minister rose in his place and informed the House that if that amendment were accepted it would take away the rights of the civil servant under Section 4. I advised him, before he makes those wild statements in future, to consult the Attorney-General as to what the meaning of sections is. A more irresponsible statement I have never listened to in this House, from a Minister or anybody else, than that the effect of a saving section was in fact to take away rights. If that is the Minister's mentality, and if that is his mental equipment for the purpose of interpreting those people's rights, then I say, if the House gives him all those powers without limitation, God help the civil servants over whose rights this Minister presides. It is a Power that should not be given to any Minister, and particularly having regard to the present occupant of the position of Minister for Finance, it certainly should not be given now.
Comment on this
I beg to move amendment 22:—
In page 4, Section 9 (1) (b), lines 54-55, to delete the words "or in the form of dividends."
Comment on this
I can deal with amendments 22 and 23 and 28, 29 and 30 but possibly there may have to be separate divisions. Section 9 as drafted is applicable to any board, commission or company and other bodies as long as it falls under the description of paragraph (a) of the section. The section applies to every board, commission or company or other body (a) "which was established by or under a special statute or for the establishment of which express provision was made by a special statute or which, though incorporated under statutes of general application, is regulated in part by a special statute, and (b) the whole or part of the surplus revenue of which is payable to the Exchequer either specifically or in the form of dividends or of repayments of advances." I am assuming that this section by these phrases catches under it the Electricity Supply Board, the Currency Commission and the Agricultural Credit Corporation and I would like to have these three bodies removed from the scope of the measure. It shows the lengths the Ministers have been driven when they try every little bit of logic to bring in bodies only related to the State by the nature of some of their activities or by reason of repayment by them of advances made to them by the State. The Electricity Supply Board is an obvious example. That body when established, it was explained, was to be a body of a commercial type. The Act which gave it its origin and foundation set out to establish it clearly apart from the State. The phrase current in this House was that the body to be set up was to be flung, as far as possible, from the State and to be kept at the fullest arm's length, and as far as possible outside the scope of the authority of the State except in one thing, namely that the members of the Board were appointed only for a limited period, and could be removed under certain procedure and the reasons for the extraordinary powers given them were that there was to be publication of their activities and the result of their activities. But everything spoken, round about the time of the establishment of that Board, tended to this: that the Board was to be as far as possible regarded as an ordinary commercial enterprise flung far away from the controlling authority and State supervision.
We did give it money, and that money is being repaid. But we did say that, as long as there was any money owing by it to the State interest had to be paid on outstanding advances, and there was a period after which both interest and sinking fund had to be met by it. There had to be a modification of the scheme with regard to that Board in the sense of allowing it the remission of some of the payments which had previously been exacted from it, but the principle of the scheme has never yet been interfered with.
The Electricity Supply Board got the advantages of State credit being put at its disposal, but it had to pay for it. It had to pay the issue price of any loan out of which it got those moneys, some percentage of the money and the interest and the sinking fund bore a relation both to the life of the assets built out of State advances and to the period for which the State had to repay the moneys it had borrowed. The principles of that are still in existence. Payments are still being made. The accumulations reserved for these purposes are still there. There has been no change so far as the Board is concerned, or so far as this State is concerned except what was done under a regulation of the Oireachtas. But just because that Board is engaged in repaying advances then it is thought that the State should come down with its axe on the members of the Board and, through them, on the personnel of the Board, the Board's servants. It is bad enough to have, what I previously described as the immorality of segregating, for this type of attack, people just because they were in a certain position in relation to the Government. Their salaries were near enough at hand to be cut. It is an aggravation of that to have it extended to people who are not so close at hand, but on whom certain coercion can be brought to bear by reason of the fact that the Board is repaying advances—not that it is looking for money or that it has any need of funds at the moment or that they could not get those funds elsewhere by a public issue—but just because in the past they have been granted State credit and are now paying off a debt in accordance with the Act, the members of the Board first and the servants of the Board afterwards are going to have their emoluments reduced. I cannot see any reason in this. I cannot see why this Board should be picked out in this way.
Similarly, with the Currency Commission and the Agricultural Credit Corporation. In both these instances an attempt was made by the Oireachtas of the time to give these bodies something in the way of an autonomous position. It was not so clearly defined as in the case of the Electricity Supply Board, but certainly an attempt was made to give them considerable freedom and as near an approach to complete autonomy as possible. But, because in one case there has to be a repayment of advances made and in the other case payments by way of dividends this immorality is extended again to these two bodies and their autonomy is being interfered with in the same way as the autonomy of the Electricity Supply Board is being interfered with. There is a definite breach of the principle on which these bodies were established and of the way in which they were allowed to appoint their own servants. I cannot see the reason —I suppose I should call it the lack of reason—for picking out these bodies.
Let us take the justice of any attack on these salaries. It is very hard to get any line on the logic of the Minister in this at all. In the case of the police we were told that we must remember that their salaries do not fluctuate according to the cost of living and, therefore, are not subject to a bonus. Their salary is fixed, we are told, and does not fluctuate in the same way that the bonus type of salary fluctuates. When we come to the Civil Service, that is forgotten. In their case there is a more callous statement, which is to the effect that it is recognised that the civil servant's full pay has been decreased because of the decrease in the cost of living, but that in addition to that there is going to be an additional cut put upon him. When we come to the case of the teachers, we are just told simply that the State wants the money and that they are going to get it this way. In fact, we got a very definite statement from the Minister for Finance to-day that there is no other way in which these moneys can be got. So that we are definitely out in the open now so far as the old promise of the £2,000,000 economies is concerned. The most we can get, evidently is this £280,000 and we can only get that by hacking the salaries of the public servants.
However, the argument against the teachers was that their salaries were established in far off times relatively, and that therefore there was some room for adjustment in those salaries in consideration of the stringent times now upon us. None of these arguments have any application either to the Electricity Supply Board or the Agricultural Credit Corporation or the Currency Commission. These bodies are of very recent appointment, comparatively. In the case of one of these, the Electricity Supply Board—by far the largest of them as far as numbers of officials and employees are concerned—the salaries were not even put upon anything that could be called a firm basis until very recently. There is even a process of grading going on in that Department at the moment. But certainly anything in the way of grading was in an upward direction, because the Board realised when it started that it had no means of knowing what its financial position might be in the future and, because of that, it did pay low rates of wages and enticed people into its employment on these rates, but with the promise that, when their financial prospects improved and when they got into smoother water financially, there would be a stabilising of conditions, and something in the way of granting security of tenure and a better scale of salaries. These employees are all people of recent appointment. Even at the time they were appointed, as far as normal conditions are concerned, there is no reason to believe that things have got any easier for them, and there cannot be any argument used in relation to these people such as has been used with regard to the Civic Guards or to the teachers to the effect that the times are so vastly different from the normal times when the salaries were fixed, and that therefore there is room for adjustment at the moment. The salaries were not fixed in any firm way. People were got in under the promise of increased emoluments and better times. They were told they were in rather a provisional way, that the salaries were fixed at what was considered to be the minimum, and every hope was held out to those people that any movement in regard to their positions or status, or in relation to their employment, would be in an upward direction. Now, instead of that they are to be cut.
We even get further. I asked a Parliamentary question after this Bill made its appearance as to the savings estimated as likely to accure to the community generally from the cuts likely to be imposed under the Bill in the case of the Agricultural Credit Corporation, the Currency Commission and the Electricity Supply Board. I was told, in the usual evasive way, it was impossible to make any estimate because the schedule had not been fixed or determined. At that time the cuts were in operation in the case of certain groups. I was told, at any rate, that the whole thing would be an approximation at the best. I was also told by both the President and the Minister for Finance that the savings in the Agricultural Credit Corporation or the Currency Commission would be inconsiderable. The phrase was used by the Minister for Finance that the saving that would be made in this connection would accrue to the community generally and would not accrue directly to the Exchequer. We were told that any savings made in the case of these two Departments would be used to pile up reserves. Again, we were told that the savings would be inconsiderable.
The position is that in the case of the Currency Commission we are to have a reserve piled up as a result of the saving of a few miserable pounds. That reserve would be the direct result of getting after the salaries of the people employed there, salaries fixed not so very long ago. As regards the Electricity Supply Board, there might have been a better case made to the effect that the salary savings would be something considerable. But even that phrase was not used. There was rather a decrying of the amount that would be saved. We were told that whatever would come off the salaries will accrue to the community in the way of cheaper electricity. Not alone is that the greatest rubbish, but it is well known to those who spoke it that it is the greatest rubbish. There will not be any saving which will accrue to the community, by way of the cheapening of electricity. Anything that may be saved has been more than taken away from the Board and, therefore, from the community, by one item alone, the increased price of coal under the penal tariff. The Electricity Supply Board has got to have its supplies of coal and that coal is subject to a tariff and the Minister has had to admit that the coal required cannot be got elsewhere.
It is all part of the general idea that everybody in the community has to be humiliated because of the Government's incapacity. The people who are to be humiliated are those who have that thin line of affiliation with the Government in that they are actively engaged in repaying moneys that this Government did not give them. They are repaying moneys which, in more enlightened times, they got, and because of that they have to feel the whip like everybody else. This is a rather petty type of revenge, and it is an immoral extension of what is already immoral—the whole method by which these people have been picked out for these cuts.
Comment on this
I do not propose to reply at length, because there are so many questions of moral obliquity in this Bill that I do not feel competent to deal with the question from that point of view. I suggest to the Deputy that when he tells the House that because the late Government instituted the Electricity Supply Board and made certain arrangements in relation to it that that is going to bind future Ministers for Finance in whatever arrangements they have to make regarding economies, I think he will not get many people to agree with him. If promises have been made to the officials of certain bodies, I have no doubt those promises and the general position of those autonomous or semiautonomous bodies will be carefully considered by the Minister when he is inquiring into the question as to what reduction he proposes to effect in their remuneration. The Deputy has laid great stress on the principle of this matter. I see no principle. This is a Bill to effect economies. It is an essential feature of the Bill that the servants of all public bodies receiving grants from the Government will suffer. If differentiations were to be made we would never get to the end of it. There may be anomalies, and some cases may be harder than others, but all these matters will, I have no doubt, receive the careful consideration of the Minister before he comes to any decision.
Comment on this
There is a certain amount of pleasure in hearing the Minister. On the few occasions when he intervened in this Bill he gave the impression that he did not believe in it. There was no conviction in the manner in which he backed up the principles of the Bill; he certainly put forward no defence. The three bodies mentioned here are not receiving grants from the Government. The E.S.B. does not receive any grant. I suggest the effort of the Government to deal with those bodies and to interfere in the salaries they give to their employees, reveals the whole purpose of the Bill. I suggest that from the statements we have heard here about the amounts expected to be saved by this section from these three bodies, and also from the confession that the saving will not go into the Treasury at all, it is quite clear, more clear here than elsewhere in the Bill, that the purpose of the Government is simply to set the headline for everybody to be cut down all round.
That has been made clear in public by various members of the Government. The purpose is not to effect economies or to save money for the State. The purpose is to set a headline for all bodies, public or private, in the State. In no sense are those three bodies State institutions. They were set up by the State, but every effort was made to see that they were conducted as far as possible as private business institutions. Here we have an attempt to set a headline, for instance, to banks.
Comment on this
We have an attempt here to set a headline to scientific undertakings and big business undertakings as to how they are to deal with their employees. Is there any other purpose served by the effort to bring these bodies into this Bill? There is no necessity for bringing them in. They were brought in by force. Those officials were pulled, practically by the hair of the head, by main force, into this Bill in order that the Government could set a headline to other institutions in the country in furtherance of its policy to make everybody suffer.
By certain portions of this policy he has made some people suffer. The only comfort this gives is that he is able to say to other people: "Well, now, we will make everybody else suffer as well as you." The Minister's outlook is this. In effect he says: "Even though the State will get nothing out of the salaries we are saving so far as the Electricity Supply Board, the Agricultural Credit Corporation, and the Currency Commission are concerned, at least we are determined that if other people are suffering because of our policy, the people in these institutions will suffer as well."
It is absolutely clear and it was noticeable that the Minister when replying did not touch that point put up to him—as to why these people were brought in. There was no effort to show that these were State institutions. When they were being set up the House took the trouble to see that they would be independent of State control. It required a big effort to show how they could possibly be brought within the scope of this Bill. Logic required it that they would be kept out, but it was simply because the Government wanted to put into force their general policy of levelling, and levelling down the standard of living that these were brought in. You have here three ordinary businesses, commercial undertakings, and the only purpose the Government can achieve by bringing them in is that they propose here to set a headline to various other business institutions in the country.
Comment on this
They are related to 5, 6 and 7. I take it they are covered by 5. It is the same principle.
Comment on this
More or less.
Amendment 24.
In page 4, Section 9 (2), lines 56-57 to delete all words from the beginning of the sub-section down to and including the word "payable," line 57, and substitute the words "From that portion of the salary earned during the current financial year which is payable as from the date of the passing of this Act."— (Patrick McGilligan.)
Not moved.
Comment on this
I move amendments 25 and 27:—
25. In page 4, Section 9 (2), line 59, after the word "as" to insert the words "such body after consultatation with."
27. In page 5, Section 9 (4), line 7, to delete the word "Minister" and substitute the words "body concerned," and in line 8 to delete the words "body concerned" and substitute the word "Minister."
Comment on this
In speaking on amendments 25 and 27 it is necessary to consider not merely Section 9 but Sections 10, 11 and 12. Sections 9, 10 and 11 insist on certain deductions being made from certain salaries which are not under the control directly of the Minister or else from grants made in the case of certain bodies. Then Section 12 deals with deductions from salaries consequential on deductions from grants. This deals with cases where certain bodies get grants from the Minister. Then somebody is to make a reduction in the salary paid to the individual employed by that body. Under Section 12 it is the body itself that is to make the determination as to the deductions that should be made from the salary. In Sections 9, 10 and 11 it is the Minister who is to do certain things. I do not approve of letting the Minister wash his hands of these things and then throwing the odium of enforcing the individual reductions upon the body which gets these grants. You have it right down through the sections in the same way. Section 12 is the section in which the individual employee will find his emoluments reduced, and the onus in making the deduction is thrown upon the body concerned. I want the whole thing put into the hands of the body concerned so that the deductions that take place as well as all the odium will be met by the body. Alternatively, if the Minister wants to take upon himself the odium, let him do it clearly and openly instead of doing it in this secret fashion in which it is to be done under this Bill. I am moving that instead of the Minister directing the amount of deductions to be made under this section it shall be the body that shall determine it after consultation with the Minister. Having regard to the deductions to be made in Part 2 in the circumstances of the case, amendment 27 is really to the same point. I am moving both.
Comment on this
This amendment would take away responsibility for the decision from the Minister for Finance and would hand it over to the persons concerned, the persons who would suffer as a result of the decisions they have to make. That would be to hand over to them the question of deciding whether they would make a deduction in their own salary or not. That would be quite impracticable.
Comment on this
That is a different statement. What I say is that the Board is to say there is to be a deduction.
Comment on this
Apart from that altogether the Deputy wants to take official responsibility from the Minister for Finance.
Comment on this
I would like to take official responsibility for doing anything rash from the Minister for Education.
Comment on this
We would like to have the assistance of the Deputy in this matter but his action on the Bill has shown that he does not understand it.
Comment on this
I move amendment 28:—
In page 5, at the end of Section 9 to add a new sub-section as follows:—
"Notwithstanding anything contained in the foregoing sub-sections of this section this Part of this Act shall not apply to the Electricity Supply Board."
Comment on this
I move amendment 31:—
In page 5, line 13, Section 10, after the word "grant" to insert the words and brackets "(other than a grant to an approved society under the provisions of the National Health Insurance Acts, 1911-1933)".
It seems to me that so many bodies will be affected by the terms of this section that it is likely that national health insurance societies might likewise be affected. If there is any danger of that happening, my amendment seeks to exclude national health insurance societies from the provisions of this particular section. The State pays two-ninths of the cost of administration under the National Health Insurance Acts, and there seems to be a likelihood that, since a grant of that kind is made by the State, the national health insurance societies would presumably come within the scope of the section. At the present time if the Government proceeds with that intention it will mean that the employees of national health insurance societies will have to suffer a reduction in their already low salaries. Even part-time officers will be affected too, because if the Government cuts the administration costs of the national health insurance societies it will mean that inevitably the societies will be bound to cut the salaries.
The present administration costs are low, and will not bear any increase in salaries. If those costs are cut it inevitably means that the salaries and wages of the officials affected will also be cut. Any cut in the present administration costs would impose a considerable hardship on the societies. In 1912, I think, the administration costs per head per annum were 3/5. Now the cost is 4/5 per member per annum, an increase of 30 per cent in the interval between 1912 and 1933. When the Minister considers the increased cost of rent, stationery, labour, buildings and telephones; the increased complexity of the Act, due to the issue of so many new regulations, and the additional work which has been thrown on the societies by reason of the increased number of claims, I think he will realise that any reduction in the administration costs of the societies will not only cause hardship among them, but can only be met by substantial reductions in the already low rates of wages and salaries which are paid to the employees of approved societies. I hope the Minister will see his way to accept the amendment.
Comment on this
I regret that I cannot accept the amendment. It introduces again, like a great many other amendments, a principle of differentiation, and if accepted would vitiate the whole principle of the Bill. It would interfere with the discretion of the Minister for Finance. I have no doubt that in this particular case all the facts will be before him when making a final decision. There are not sufficient grounds for differentiation in any case.
Comment on this
Could the Minister say whether a member of the Ministry informed a deputation recently that it was not the Government's intention to apply the Economies Bill to national health insurance societies?