Public Services (Temporary Economies) Bill, 1933—Report Stage.
Contributions 179–373 of 749. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 4 parts.
No. 12 of 1933 ›
May I submit that we have been discussing this matter for the past half hour, and there were only six Deputies in the House?
Comment on this
The Minister is entitled to ask whether a sufficient number of members require a division.
Comment on this
The Dáil divided: Tá,
Do you agree with this result?
Very well. The principle I am aiming at is to permit the same thing in both these sections. I think there would be some slight difference in application. I shall first move amendment 32, which is:—
In page 5, line 18, Section 10, to delete the words "wholly or."
Later on I wish, in amendment 33, to delete the words "amount of such grant which falls to be made in the current financial year" and to substitute for them the words "portion of such grant made in the current financial year which is ordinarily applied otherwise than in the payment of such salaries." and then to delete certain verbiage in Section 10. I will take these three matters first. The effect of the section, as it stands, is that where a grant is made for certain objects and that that grant is wholly or partly available as payment of salaries there shall be deducted from the grant such sum as the Minister shall determine, after such consultation with the governing authority of such institution or body as he shall think proper. The effect of my amendment would be this: I must move to take out the words "wholly or" because my amendment would, I think, apply to the grant partially available for the payment of salaries. I want the deduction made from the part of the grant ordinarily expended otherwise than as salaries. I seek to have the salaries immune, so that the deduction would be made from the grant from the Government to the central body of money expended in other ways than the payment of salaries. I want to relate it to the upkeep of buildings, various types of apparatus and so on, but that it should have no relation to the payment of salaries. If it is necessary to have these economics I think the first stress should fall not upon the emoluments which certain people were given to believe would continue to them under the various contracts under which they got their employment and that only when the Minister had failed in that attempt and in the task of finding this £280,000 of economies should he approach the salaries of people fixed on a basis that encouraged certain expenditure, that induced them to lay out a programme for the education of their children, and that has some relation to the type of house they live in and certain other commitments made by them and which could not be readily or immediately changed.
Recently in England when the financial crisis came upon that country, and they began to consider grants made by the State they did follow the line of approach that I have indicated. They looked after different bodies and associations inside that grant, and tried to find whether there would be any great harm done by the non-recruitment of extra people or by the curtailing of expenditure on new buildings or by refraining from maintaining existing buildings in the ordinary fashion in which these buildings are maintained or by neglecting to purchase, say, apparatus of a particular type which might ordinarily be required but which, in critical times, might be done without. In relation to universities in particular—and they come under this section—even at the height of the critical period in which Great Britain found itself a couple of years ago, they decided that they would not make deductions, or that they would not recommend deductions to be made, in the salaries of their university personnel. They did distinctly say that they were going to stop building grants and, particularly, where the building grants were for extensions of buildings. With more reluctance, they said they would even stop the moneys going to the upkeep and repair of existing buildings but they certainly said they would prefer to have those set out as a matter to be cut and to save on rather than the salaries of their personnel.
In this country, where salaries are certainly not excessive and, in this debate, where there has been an abandoning by the Ministry of their old profession that salaries were excessive, it seems to me that every attempt should be made to scratch money from every other little pocket and from every other source from which moneys might be obtained rather than to cut moneys that are paid out as salaries to the people who will come under this. I do not know whether that line of approach was followed by the Ministry before they decided to cut salaries. I rather gather that it was not but, again, we have to get back to the spirit of something approaching vengeance that is running right through this, the spirit that people have got to be brought low, this idea of sacrifice, as it is euphemistically termed, without there being given to the people any explanation of what necessitates the sacrifice or whether it was unavoidable or not.
I am assuming that there has been no approach made to these savings, even if they are considered necessary at all, along the lines I have indicated, but that there has just been this blind wiping at individuals, as it is the easier, although the more unjust of the two types of operation. I hold that this House should have before it, and should get an opportunity of discussing and deliberating on, a suggestion that they should try to see if there is any other way of saving money through the grants made to local bodies of the types mentioned here, without touching the moneys that go to the upkeep of certain people and their families. That is why I move the amendment.
Comment on this
If this amendment were to be accepted, it would mean that, while greatly limiting the scope of the section, in fact no deductions might be made from the salaries and the purpose of the Bill is to effect, so far as possible, deductions from salaries.
Comment on this
In this case, the amendment and the other amendments would cut across the whole principle of the Bill. I do not think that any useful purpose can be served by discussing the matter.
Comment on this
I do not think any useful purpose would be served by adding anything to what the Minister has said.
Comment on this
Question put: "That the tabular statement in Part I of the Schedule stand part of the Bill."
Do you agree with this result?
I move amendment 34:—
In page 5, line 23, Section 10, to delete the word "such" where it first occurs in the line and in line 24 to delete the words "as he shall think proper".
There are to be deductions from grants to certain classes of bodies. The Minister has been given power on the vote taken to make the deductions. He is given power to make these deductions "after such consultation with the governing authority as he shall think proper". Why the words "as he shall think proper" rather than "after consultation with"? If there is going to be a cut made, the body whose grant is to be cut should be approached. It should be incumbent on the Minister to approach the authority concerned. That, of course, can be done through officials but the obligation should certainly be there.
Comment on this
The question which the Deputy has just put is one he could have put more effectively on the Committee Stage if he had chosen to move this amendment.
Comment on this
Question put:—"That the tabular statements immediately following the heading in Part II of the Schedule— stand part."
Do you agree with this result?
I move amendment 36:—
In page 5, at the end of Section 10 to add a sub-section as follows:—
Notwithstanding anything contained in the foregoing sub-section this Part of this Act shall not apply to the National University of Ireland or to any of the colleges of that university.
I know that an attempt has been made to delude the House into the belief that this section does not apply. If that is due to inadvertence I should like to point out the mistake that has been made. If, as I believe, it is due only to an attempt to get in in a more subtle way what the Ministry found they could not get in by a direct attack, I want to prevent that. When this Bill was introduced——
Comment on this
I presume that if a Minister does not give a reason as to why it is not a proper amendment, that is sufficient justification for speaking on it.
Comment on this
I ask the question because university colleges are definitely ruled out under this section.
Comment on this
I was just coming to that point. As the Bill was introduced the phrase ran "Where a grant is made annually, under statute or otherwise, out of the Central Fund or moneys provided by the Oireachtas to a university, college, or other educational institution (not being a secondary school)". That has now been changed so that the university does not come under that part of the section. The phrase we have now is "Where a grant is made annually, under statute or otherwise, out of the Central Fund or moneys provided by the Oireachtas to any educational institution (not being a university, a university college or a secondary school)": but it goes on to say still, "where a grant is made to a board, commission, company, association, or other body (whether corporate or unincorporated)." The university is certainly one of these. There was a University Commission which established the whole university system in the country. I am not going to take it, after the devious attempts which the Ministry made to get the universities to interrupt their whole autonomy, as if I recognised that they did not know what they were doing. I am moving, therefore—I have it absolutely clear-cut—that "Notwithstanding anything contained in the foregoing sub-section this Part of this Act shall not apply to the National University of Ireland or to any of the colleges of that university." I want to point out the danger that exists for educational institutions of the university type under the measure as it stands because, if their position is capable of being so interpreted as to bring them in as a commission or as a body corporate or unincorporated which receives a grant under statute or otherwise out of the Central Fund or moneys provided by the Oireachtas then, not merely this Section 10, with its deduction, falls on that university body but Section 12 also falls on it.
Section 12 is to be taken into the consideration of this amendment. On the basis on which I am arguing that it is still possible to include the university under the phrase which is in Section 10, it is possible to make the deduction from that university body where it receives a grant out of the Central Fund or out of moneys provided by the Oireachtas. When that fund is depleted, then you get Section 12. That body then has to make such deductions as, with the approval of the Minister, shall be thought proper, having regard to the amount of the deduction made, the proportion of the grant and other circumstances of the case. That is a definite and clear-cut attack upon a matter of very great importance to Catholic education in this country. One of the things that was fought for years was that there should be Catholic educational institutions of the university type founded in this country and founded without any possible interference from Government.
On two or three occasions when the Catholics were offered educational facilities of a type that might have suited them, they were refused under the authority of the members of the Hierarchy speaking at that time, because they were to be under the control of the Government of the time.
We are certainly not going to let throught in any slipshod fashion any phrase which might give certain powers to a Minister who knows nothing and cannot, from his position, know anything about university education. Even if he knew as much as the wisest head in the university could know, we are not going to allow a Minister to have anything to say to the internal arrangements of the university. One would have thought that, before blundering in this way, there might have been some consultation with people who are knowledgeable in this matter, people who have some touch with the history of affairs relating to Catholic education and some knowledge in particular of the fight made for university education in the country.
We know quite well the way this Bill was started off. The Minister for Education openly and rather clumsily announced to-day that it is a reduction of salaries Bill. There is nothing more or less in the minds of the people behind it than that. It is purely to be a hacking of salaries; salaries are to be reduced. We know it is directed, in the main, against the people whom the Government always directed their propoganda against at election times— members of the Civil Service, the Gárda Síochána, the Army and the teachers. The teachers, not being university teachers, were certainly the object of hostility in the beginning. Then there was an extension of the measure to bodies so very thinly tied on to the Government by reason of the fact that they are paying dividends to the Government out of moneys received by them or are making repayments of advances granted to them by a previous Government. Then there is the further extension to educational bodies. As the measure stood first, it was quite clear that it entered into the consciousness of someone connected with the drafting that the University College might have its grants reduced and, once its grants were reduced, then the man who would decide what salaries should be paid to individual professors would be the Minister for Finance.
That invasion of university rights had never been thought of here. There may be a provision in a particular Act which has a phrase which, loosely interpreted, might be regarded as giving this power; but it certainly was never intended in that way. I think any use of it in the way intended under this measure—and I think it is still intended under this measure—would have been quite indefensible and illegal. The idea of striking at the university did enter somebody's head. A certain amount of thought was apparently given to this matter and we had the decision of the Ministry as first put up. The Minister is going to determine salaries as between individual professors. That is all that Section 12 can mean. On another vote I tried to get certain people who, if not the originators of this attack on the university, are at any rate the people put up as the mouthpieces through which the Government policy would be announced to the electors, to indicate their point of view. I hope they will do it on this occasion. I find that the start of this matter about university salaries and of interfering in university autonomy and making discrimination—actually it was made in advance as between different professors—was first unfolded to the public in an election address promulgated on behalf of two of the Deputies allied with the National University.
Comment on this
I am going to show it is distinctly in this measure. We were told by two Deputies in this House, backing the Government, that the National University has a very special duty to the Irish nation. I have here the election address of Deputy Mrs. Concannon and Deputy Maguire. the Attorney-General.
Comment on this
Here is what the election address says:—
"The National University has a very special duty towards the Irish nation. From it come the majority of the scholars and administrators of the country. The University, as we envisage it, should be more closely associated with the life of the country, not only culturally but also economically. It is not a colourless or half-Anglicised education that our students require, but an education that is truly Gaelic in instruction and outlook."
Comment on this
On a point of order. There is nothing in this section and there is nothing in this amendment which proposes to bring in the universities for consideration at this stage. Therefore, I suggest the whole of the Deputy's speech so far, particularly in so far as it is based upon a document which is not before the House, which cannot be tabled in the House and which is not a public document, is out of order.
Comment on this
On the contention that the universities are not properly before the House, I have made my point that the universities are——
Comment on this
——included in the phrase "board, commission, company, association, or other body (whether corporate or unincorporated)." If that is not so, my amendment should be accepted.
Comment on this
In reply to that, and again on a point of order, the universities are definitely excluded from one part of the section—"(not being a university, a university college, or a secondary school)." Having been definitely excluded from the operation of the section in that way, they could not be brought in by any other phrase in that section.
Comment on this
I do not think there can be any doubt that the amendment has a certain relevancy and is in order. What I am not quite clear about is how the Deputy is relating what he is quoting now from an alleged election address—how that is related to the Bill before us.
Comment on this
Having the firm foundation to stand upon that the amendment has relevance, I hope to build up my argument, and I hope to show that what I have been reading is quite relevant also. If my amendment is not carried there is, at any rate, the possibility that the universities are brought in under Section 10. If they are brought in under Section 10, Section 12 is applicable to them. Section 12 is to fall by Section 10. Section 10 was always intended to have its application to the universities when the universities were clearly and definitely in the Bill. We have got to take Section 10. It states that deductions shall be made from grants to certain classes of bodies. I do not see how the argument can proceed in connection with any grant unless these two sections are taken together. There is a possibility of a cut being made in the university grant, and if that is possible then the authorities governing must make such deductions in the salaries as with the approval of the Minister they think proper. That is bringing in the Minister to decide what the salaries of university professors are to be. I have to return again to my little pamphlet.
Comment on this
Before the Deputy returns to the pamphlet I have a point of order. The amendment before the House says that "notwithstanding anything contained in the foregoing sub-section this part of this Act shall not apply to the National University of Ireland or to any of the colleges of that University." I submit that the Deputy is bound to confine his speech to showing that this amendment should be accepted and in doing that I submit that no matters anterior to the present Bill are in order.
Comment on this
I am endeavouring to keep Deputy McGilligan to the Bill and, to prove the relevancy of his argument, I have asked him to show how the amendment is related to the section. I am endeavouring to do that.
Comment on this
I submit that the amendment is in order. I will also show in dealing with this amendment that this election pamphlet is in order. I will show that there was a definite action taken by the Government in the way of attempting to make a deduction from university salaries and to take away university autonomy. If, as the Minister says, the university is so clearly cut out in another section, in Section 10 as amended, why not accept my amendment? My amendment puts the matter beyond all doubt; but it is not going to be accepted by the Minister for the reason that the Government have pretended to exempt the university. In reality they have not exempted it, other words bring it in. It is covered by the words "a body corporate receiving moneys." They still have a weapon there in their hands as given to them in Section 12 and they shall have in mind that they are going to interfere in the teaching of the university by reason of the hold they will have over the salaries of the individual professors. The public already got notice of this. They got notice of it in the election address of the Fianna Fáil candidates to the constituents of the university. They were told in that address that it was not "a colourless half-Anglicised education that our students require, but an education that is truly Gaelic in instruction and outlook." The University must be Gaelicised through and through. The University was a colourless, half-Anglicised university.
Comment on this
I submit that was the aim that the Government had. Their intention was revealed there. They are taking power over the professors' salaries.
Comment on this
I refer the Chair to the Long Title of this Bill. There is nothing in it about university education. The speech of Deputy McGilligan is dealing with a certain feature in university education.
Comment on this
There has been no change in the Long Title from what it was when the Bill was first brought in. The Long Title was then the same and you had university education in the Bill as it then stood.
Comment on this
I have to refer to a particular phrase used in this pamphlet "not only culturally but also economically." Let me get down to bedrock facts in relation to Sections 10 and 12. This means that the salary of the professor who teaches according to the mind of the Ministry is going to be cut partly or hardly at all and that the salary of the professors who teach according to their own ideals will be cut. That power is there. Is that what we mean by university autonomy? Is it desirable that the Minister should have that power now? Supposing you get a Ministry in office which is taking action of a particular type. I would ask the House to remember the sort of University Bill originally introduced which the Hierarchy of this country ordered the people of the country to refuse. The Minister with this power will have made the way clear so that those people who operate certain doctrines can and will hack at certain salaries. Once that principle is accepted and preached it is easy the second time to act on it and the whole university system can be swayed by people who hold certain views. They are doing that with the backing of the two people who represent the university here, the people who issued the address to the university constituents where they talked about cultural and economic teachings. With regard to the Attorney-General, we are told he was to make the university a seat of learning worthy of the nation and of its traditions. What has he done since he came here? Cutting professors' salaries. What have we here as a result of the efforts of these two people who were going to make the university "worthy of the nation and of its traditions"? The Minister expresses astonishment that anybody could find any possible interference with the university system and its regulations, or with the professors and the teaching they give their students. By degrees it was borne in on them that there was a tide of opposition arising against the proposals and then they had to make the half-hearted repentance that they have made, and they had to come along and try and fool us into believing that because the University is taken out from the one heading of educational institution that it is not possible to bring it in under any other heading, with the further bit of veil given in Section 13. One would have thought that the President, whose chief vanity, I suppose, is that he is Chancellor of the University, and who prides himself more on the multiplicity of the honorary degrees he received than any man I ever knew——
Comment on this
I am going to make it—would have thought fit to consult the university authorities before he ventured on such a scheme as was in the measure when introduced and which to my mind is still there. Why should there be any slackening of anxiety with regard to the university and its teachings and freedom from political interference nowadays from what there was before? Many attempts were made to found a university system of a type in the country. Among the matters that were for ever in dispute and under consideration by the old Irish Parliament, I suppose, the two things most often discussed were the question as to whether the judges were to be free and independent and their salaries beyond any chance of grabbing; and whether the university, if established, was to be on a basis of freedom or whether it was to be under control through the financial grip. In both cases the thing that was looked to was the control of finance. We know very well that heads of Bills were sent from the Irish Government long ago to England insisting on the freedom of the judges and putting forward proposals about universities, and any time they were sent forward they were turned down on the basis that the freedom of the judges might be one thing in England and university freedom——
Comment on this
——they are brought in as an analogy. They are the same in principle, but the Minister in his stupidity cannot see that they are relevant. There is exactly the same point at issue, whether you are making certain people free from interference. There were two things that were very definitely fought about—the control of law and order in the country and the control of education, or the absence of control of it. What is simply happening is that this Ministry, which pretends to be so keen on freedom, which pretends to be so national and so Gaelic in its outlook, which pretends to be so liberal in everything, has gone more reactionary than the people whose proposals brought about the condemnation of the hierarchy of the country. They did try to delude the university people who went on a deputation to them that there was no intention of operating against the university in this way. There was an appeal made —that no reasonable man could believe that there was any such attempt made. Nine reasonable men from the three colleges were sent up because, in their reason, they believed that the weapon was there to be used, and that there was evidently going to be use made of it.
As I say, we had this pretended weakening on the part of the Ministry, this giving-in, this delusion that the University was out of this, and that the Minister for Finance cannot come in and cannot operate there as against one professor whom he dislikes, and another professor whom he likes. The Minister for the future, I suppose, will regulate not merely the finances of the country, but the financial teachings that will come from the University. That will be a poor day indeed. Why should the Minister take power to discriminate as between the different men and women appointed to university posts? Why did he ever think of taking it?
Comment on this
I can analyse Section 12. It has been admitted that my amendment was relevant and it can only be relevant because there is still the possibility that the University can be brought in under Section 10. It is, therefore, possible to cut the grant made for the National University and its Colleges under Section 10. If that is so Section 12 says that whenever a deduction is made from a grant, any board, authority, committee or other body receiving such grant may make such deductions as such body, with the approval of the Minister, shall think proper, having regard to various things.
Comment on this
May I point out that there is nothing that empowers the Minister to make these deductions?
Comment on this
That is what made the nine people, who were described as unreasonable, think that the use could be made that I think may be made of it. If that use could not be made of it, why did the Ministry pretend to cut the University out of Section 10? Why were they driven to take the University out of Section 10? Was it because of the agitation which had arisen over the assault upon the economy of the University? Where else does that assault find its base except in Section 12, and the phrase I have referred to? Is that a delusion? Why could not the Minister, in the intimacy of his office, have converted the people, who visited him to discuss the matter, to his point of view? Why did he pretend to yield and say, as he said this morning, that he cut the University clean out of the business? He is still keeping in Section 13 power to cut the grant. The only thing he is pretending to change is his power to interfere with individual salaries.
Comment on this
The Minister never claimed that power. It is not in the Bill, and the speech is out of order.
Comment on this
Why the change? The Minister is no judge of order. He is as little a judge of order as a judge of the capacity of university professors and the necessity for cutting their salaries. That was the power he took to himself, and it was on that basis the whole argument has gone with these people.
Comment on this
I take it it is there. The Minister, if he replies, can tell us why he made the change which this Bill shows from the Committee Stage, and why he has still kept power to make the cut in the amount of the grant, and what has he excluded from himself which was previously in the measure.
Comment on this
I take it it is the governing body has the power to interfere with the salaries and only the governing body.
Comment on this
The Deputy might as well say that the Minister for Local Government has power to cut the salaries of public officials without any interference by the local bodies.
Comment on this
Might I again direct attention to the wording of Section 12 which states that "any board, authority, committee, or other body receiving (directly or indirectly) such grant or part thereof may make, from the salaries earned and payable in the current financial year by and to persons in the employment of such body, such deductions as such body shall, with the approval of the Minister, think proper ...". The only person who has power to make a deduction under this section is the grantee.
Comment on this
If all Deputies are like Deputy McGilligan they do not understand what approval means.
Comment on this
I am trying to keep Deputy McGilligan from suggesting that the Minister has direct power to initiate a cut in the salaries of the staff of the University.
Comment on this
On a point of order, may I submit that the Chair has ruled that Deputy McGilligan's amendment is in order? May I suggest that from the point of view of order Deputy McGilligan is entitled to put his interpretation of the particular section to the House, just as the Minister is? I want to submit that numerous points raised by the Minister were not points of order but of interruption.
Mr. MacEntee rose.
Comment on this
May I point out that Deputy McGilligan's amendment is to Section 10, and not to Section 12, which the Deputy is discussing at the moment?
Comment on this
I take it Deputy McGilligan is addressing himself to the power this Bill gives the Minister to interfere with the autonomy of the University. I take it that is the strong point Deputy McGilligan is endeavouring to establish. I cannot see how he has established that the Minister is entitled or empowered to deal directly with the salaries of the staff of the University, and to interfere with the autonomy of the University in that direction, that is to say that the Minister can discriminate as between certain professors on the University staff.
Comment on this
As the Minister is, in the end, the approver of the whole thing, surely the Minister has control over the University governing body. If there is a certain cut in salary, and the Minister refuses approval, surely he can beat down the governing authority to make the changes he requires.
Comment on this
The Deputy does not suggest that the Minister can pick out Professor A and cut him £50, while Professor B is not to be cut.
Comment on this
He certainly can. That is the argument which lies on the section, whether it is a correct argument or not. The Minister wants to get after Professor A. He refuses every scheme put up until Professor A is reduced to the level to which he thinks he ought to be reduced. What is simpler than that? The anxiety of the Minister to disabuse the public mind or rather to confuse the public mind about this is a matter to be noted. He is very anxious to pretend that this power never was there. I want him to face up to this point. Why has the change been made in this measure? Why have we the pretence that the University is cut out of Section 10, because if it disappears from Section 10 it is out of Section 12? Why the Minister's anxiety to cut the University out of Section 10? There are only two things can be done to the University under this measure as it was originally introduced; the gross amount of the grant payable to the University can be reduced; after that the Minister can see that that reduction is brought down through the salaries of the university professors in such a manner as he approves. He still keeps the power to make a deduction from the grant. That is under Section 13. What is he pretending to get rid of? The power to get at the individual salaries of the individual professors? What I want to know is why did he pretend to take the University out of Section 10, if it was not for the purpose of getting rid of the argument and the objection that this Bill, as originally introduced, and I hold still, gives him the power to break in on the scheme on which the University was founded, and to get at the salaries of the individual professors? That is for him to explain.
The University has been established on a particular scheme, and it was not one that met with entire approval. When the University Act of 1906 was introduced and passed there was considerable discussion as to whether it should be accepted. In the end it was accepted as a workable compromise. The main point upon which it commended itself to the people of this country who were interested in educational matters from a Catholic angle was that it established a rather rigid scheme with regard to the appointment of professors, and with regard to the salaries on which they should work. There is a whole scheme laid down. The University is made, to all intents and purposes, a legislative body. The Charter which established it allowed for the establishment of a governing authority. It gave that governing authority power to bring in statutes, which statutes had to lie on the Table of the House of Parliament. They might be rejected, but they could not be amended; at any rate the University could refuse an amendment. No amendment could be made that was outside the Charter. The University had its own legislative powers tied down to two things—the method of the appointment of professors, and the emoluments on which those professors would carry out their duties. This certainly breaks in on the second of these. It is a matter of somewhat doubtful legality as to whether, introduced incidentally in the way in which it has been, it over-rides the Statutes of the University, but there is an attempt made to do so. It is a scandalous thing for a Government which professes anxiety for the interests of Catholic education in the country to give a Minister, no matter who he may be, the power that there is under Section 12, the power that by operating the control of the purse he can, in the end, operate the whole fabric of the University institution. He can get at people through the particular matters they are teaching, in every branch of their teaching, languages—the Gaelic language in particular—economics, the moral sciences and everything else. The Minister has the grip over the future that by getting at certain professors, whose doctrines he does not like, he can finally reduce them to the point that they would either have to live as a class of martyrs, suffering under his persecution, or else get out.
An Ceann Comhairle resumed the Chair.
Comment on this
On a point of order. I would like to direct the attention of the Chair to the words of the amendment, which are are follows:—
"Notwithstanding anything contained in the foregoing sub-section this Part of this Act shall not apply to the National University of Ireland or to any of the Colleges of that University."
I should also like to direct attention to the following words of the section: "not being a university, a university college or a secondary school."
Comment on this
The universities are definitely excluded from the operation of the section. The argument upon which, I think, this amendment might be held to be in order is that because there is certain ambiguity in the words "or to a board, commission, company, association, or other body," it might be held that they would be brought within the ambit of the section. I am not holding that this is a sustainable argument, but I do say that the only ground upon which this amendment might be held to be in order is that it is necessary in order to clear up an ambiguity within the section which exists by reason of the fact that when a university is specifically and explicitly excluded by one phrase, it might be held to be implicit in the words "board, commission, company, association or other body." But I am putting this point: that any discussion we might have upon this amendment should be confined entirely to this question as to whether, in view of the ambiguity that might be held to exist within the section, it is necessary to have this amendment, so that it would be made quite clear that the University would be excluded. So far, the Deputy has utilised this amendment to discuss matters that I hold arise on Section 12.
Comment on this
May I point out, a Chinn Comhairle, that the Leas-Cheann Comhairle has already ruled upon that point. The Minister was in the House when he so ruled and I submit it is an abuse of the privileges of the House to ask the Ceann Comhairle, who has only just come into the Chair, to rule upon a matter that has already been ruled upon by the Leas-Cheann Comhairle.
Comment on this
The point the Minister has just raised was already made by him, and overruled by the Leas-Cheann Comhairle.
Comment on this
Deputies should not raise rulings given by the Leas-Cheann Comhairle to be commented on by the Ceann Comhairle.
Comment on this
Universities have been excluded, but the Minister says there is ambiguity. As far as I understand, Deputies are on the question of ambiguity and, if that is so, the Deputy is entitled to argue it.
Comment on this
I wonder, a Chinn Comhairle, did you misunderstand the point I raised. You have just said that Deputies should not raise the rulings of the Leas-Cheann Comhairle in order to be ruled upon by the Ceann Comhairle. Did you not mean that the Minister for Finance should not raise that point?
Comment on this
I am merely pointing out to you, sir, and to the House, that it was the Minister raised the point. He, previously, raised the point when the Leas-Cheann Comhairle was in the Chair and was ruled out of order.
Comment on this
I pointed out that the only ground upon which it would be in order was that there would be fear of ambiguity in the section.
Comment on this
The Minister did raise the question of the irrelevancies of my speech and each time he raised it he was rebuffed by the Chair. Will that tie him now any faster to his seat or is there any process that would keep him in his seat?
Comment on this
Has not a Deputy the privilege of asking the ruling of the Chair when he thinks that another Deputy is wandering outside the rules of order? When a Minister discharges his duty I think he should be protected from the insolence of an irrelevant Deputy.
Comment on this
Is the Minister entitled to indulge in disorderly interruptions?
Comment on this
Can he indulge in continuous interruptions by way of points of order and indulge in abuse?
Comment on this
You, sir, could not have any experience of what the Minister has been at during the last 15 minutes. Really there ought to be something in the way of a limit to the number of times the Minister can raise irrelevant points, and all the time be rebuffed by the occupant of the Chair.
There, again, the important point is ruled in order, that the universities are still in Section 10; there is still ambiguity about their being there, but they are in Section 12. Section 12 operates and operates to destroy the autonomy of the university system. That was a thing for which the Catholics in this country fought hard. It was a principle they would not abandon in the face of most attractive offers in other respects. And it is rather an amazing thing that when these other schemes had been rejected even when they were put in the most attractive way, we should now come to find the defects of the old scheme brought into a system that was accepted, as I said, more or less, as a compromise. This matter, which the Minister now pretends to be of no substance or importance, has got to a point that the University authorities themselves have got anxious about the matter. I think I am revealing no secret when I say that the authorities of Maynooth have got greatly disquieted over the matter and that we have the Hierarchy in line with the protest which the lay-folk of the University have decided to make against this Section 12 which is still in the Bill and may be brought in to operate against the University. After a great deal of consideration they put their thoughts in writing for the benefit of the Ministry and they circulated a memorandum which contains their doubts to quite a number of Deputies in this House. I propose to make a short quotation from that as showing what they thought of this measure and pointing out what it was that raised their apprehension.
Comment on this
The thoughts of the people who wrote the memorandum to which I am referring. It was prepared by the staffs of the three colleges of the National University, and lest there might be any misunderstanding, I understand that everything in this memorandum was approved by the authorities in the College of Maynooth and that this can be taken as having their approval, certainly in regard to all the points on which I am now going to touch. The memorandum referred to Section 10 of the Public Services (Temporary Economies) Bill in application to certain limitations of the Minister's powers and it goes on to say that:—
"Whereas until now the Minister for Finance and his officials have had no power to very the college endowments, Section 10 of this Bill gives him liberty to make such reductions in them as he shall determine ‘after such consultation with the governing authority of such institutes as he thinks proper... having regard (a) to the proportion of such grant ordinarily applied to the payment of such salaries; (b) to the deductions from salaries to be made under Part II of this Act, and (c) to the other circumstances of the case'. These apparent limitations to the Minister's power are in reality general indications concerning a decision which will, in fact, be arbitrary and final. In reading this section the ordinary member of the Oireachtas will probably have in mind such bodies as county councils and boards of assistance already subject to the Ministry. There is a danger that it may not be realised that in effect the section is supersending the colleges as autonomous corporate entities and undoing the settlement of the university question. The Dáil is not setting up a commission of educational experts, or even one of public representatives. It is being asked to institute an inquisition of civil servants and to approve beforehand of their unpredictable predictions."
Comment on this
What the Deputy is reading is a reference to Section 10. Are the universities not out of Section 10?
Comment on this
Oh, dear, has that to be explained again to a late comer who has not taken the trouble to read the section? Where are the universities out of the section?
Comment on this
I am asking the Ceann Comhairle, not the Deputy.
Comment on this
It is not for the Ceann Comhairle to interpret a section. Deputies are entitled to argue that certain interpretations may be given to the section.
Comment on this
I ask if it can be ruled that the universities are in the section when the words are qualified by the phrase "not being a university, a university college or a secondary school."
Comment on this
And, in opposition, I am asking the Ceann Comhairle if it can be argued that the universities are exempt from a section which goes on to say "...or a board, commission, company, association, or other body"? Excluding them as an educational institution does not exclude them from a commission or board. Maybe the Attorney-General would apply his mind to that?
Comment on this
I ask for the Ceann Comhairle's ruling. The section makes it plan, on the face of it, to any intelligent Deputy that university colleges are out of the section and the suggestion that they can come in under other words is absurd.
Comment on this
It is not the duty of the Chair to interpret Bills beyond saying what is in order. The Deputy is entitled to argue that university colleges do come in under certain terms of Section 10.
Comment on this
The Government has already intimated that it has no desire that universities should be included——
Comment on this
——within the ambit of this section and, as a matter of fact, on Committee Stage, it introduced an amendment which definitely, in the opinion of the Government, excluded universities from the operation of the section. In pursuance of that intention, a further new section in the Bill dealing specifically with universities was introduced. I suggest that the only ground on which the amendment can be in order before the House is if the Deputy had introduced it in order to clear up an ambiguity which he says exists within the section and the only thing he is entitled to discuss is whether that amendment is necessary to clear up that ambiguity. He is not entitled to go beyond that and to discuss all the questions which he holds arise under Section 12.
Comment on this
Can I make my point again? We are told that Section 10 has specifically excluded universities. I hold that it has not. You, sir, have refused to rule, even on the seductive appeal made by the Attorney-General that you should rule what an intelligent Deputy would think. I presume that you refrained from that because the repercussion on the intelligence of the Attorney-General might have been too severe. The universities are in the section——
Comment on this
I should like to ask whether it is in order to object to a Deputy being irrelevant. If it is so in order, how can it be declared whether he is relevant or not without ruling what the section deals with? I suggest that universities are excluded and, therefore, the Chair is in a position to rule that the Deputy is irrelevant and, for that purpose, to interpret the section.
Comment on this
Is it now open to every member of the Fianna Fáil Party, in turn, to put the same question to you, sir?
Comment on this
Deputies and Ministers and the Attorney-General are quite in order in asking for a ruling from the Ceann Comhairle on this section. I do not know whether the argument of the Deputy is based on the Bill as it originally stood——
Comment on this
The Deputy should take into account the fact that the universities have been ostensibly excluded, but he may argue that there is ambiguity or doubt about the intended exclusion.
Comment on this
I am entitled to argue that they are still in the Bill and that is what I am arguing.
Comment on this
On that, I put it to you, sir, that the Deputy is entitled only to deal with the ambiguity and to argue that this amendment is necessary to remove that ambiguity and that he is not entitled to discuss the amendment or any other point of view.
Comment on this
The Deputy is entitled to discuss the amendment before the House that "notwithstanding anything contained in the foregoing sub-section, this Part of the Act shall not apply to the National University or to any of the Colleges of that University."
Comment on this
The Government having already intimated its opinion that the section does not apply to universities, it being arguable from the words of the section itself that the section is not intended to apply to the universities, I submit, one again, that the Deputy must confine himself to the question of ambiguity.
Comment on this
I am not going to be ruled by the Minister. Let us get this clear, if it is possible. The Bill, as it was introduced, had a Section 10, which ran:—
Where a grant is made annually, under statute or otherwise out of the Central Fund or moneys provided by the Oireachtas to a university, college or other educational institution (not being a secondary school)....
That part of it is changed so that it now runs:—
where a grant is made annually, under statute or otherwise, out of the Central Fund or moneys provided by the Oireachtas to any educational institution....
and then it runs:—
not being a university, a university college or a secondary school.
There is the change that is made. Now, let me leave out that part—let us assume it is not there. The old measure ran:—
Where a grant is made annually, under statute or otherwise... to a board, commission, company, association or other body (whether corporated or unincorporated) and such grant is wholly or partly available in the hands of such institution or body for the payment of the salaries of persons employed by such institution or body, there shall be deducted from the amount of such grant which falls to be made in the current financial year such sum as the Minister... shall determine having regard to the proportion of such grant ordinarily applied to the payment of such salaries....
That is still there. There has not been the slightest change made in it. The words: "not being a university, a college, or a secondary school," have not been inserted after the words "or other body (whether corporate or unincorporated)," which might have put the matter beyond reasonable doubt. We have all that excluded but the universities brought in under the description of educational institution. Is it certain that they are excluded entirely from Section 10?
Comment on this
The Attorney-General is very alert in coming in at this time. We, some time previously, had a legal matter and I noticed that he left the House almost immediately —I do not know whether he was sent or whether he left it of his own accord. How can anybody argue that a university being a commission and, certainly, being a body corporate or unincorporated, receiving a grant——
Comment on this
And the section must be considered as a whole and you must not forget that you have in the phrase "Commission or body corporate or unincorporated." At any rate, if all this is as clear as the Minister and the Attorney-General say, why not accept my amendment? Does it not put an end to this once and for all? Does it impose any handicap on the Ministry in their activities against these other bodies if they accept the phrase: "notwithstanding anything contained in the foregoing sub-section, this Part of the Act shall not apply to the National University or to any of the Colleges of that University"?
Comment on this
Very good; that is the balance of consideration. It is clear beyond all doubt to both the Minister and the Attorney-General that universities are not in but there will be an embarrassment of words, there will be a surplus of words, if the phrase goes in. I hold, on the contrary, that it is still possible to bring the universities in as a commission or body, corporate or unincorporated, receiving a grant.
Comment on this
So long as this phrase can be so interpreted that the universities can come in under it, I hold that there are all the dangers that were in the original Bill, Section 12 being as it was and Section 10 still giving a loophole to shoot at the universities and I am entitled to argue this whole question of the university autonomy and the attack made on it.
Comment on this
I think the Deputy should confine himself to the possibilities of their being included and to the ambiguity which he says exists.
Comment on this
And to what will follow, if they are included. Surely, that is a matter for argument. If I am to get rid of the ambiguity, surely the strength of the case I can make is founded on what will flow if the ambiguity is discovered to be present? I cannot make any great case, otherwise.
Comment on this
The Government having definitely accepted the principle that the universities are to be excluded from the operation of this section, the universities are being excluded from Section 12 of the Bill.
Comment on this
It is not in order for the Deputy to go further and argue what is going to happen if they are included in Section 12, the Government having definitely made up its mind that they are not included. I submit that he must confine his speech to submitting to the House the reasons which, in his mind, make it essential that these words should be included in the section.
Comment on this
To a point of order, since you have come into the Chair, sir, the Minister for Finance repeatedly and the Attorney-General, on two occasions, have got up to discuss a matter on which you have definitely given your ruling. You have ruled that Deputy McGilligan is in order. Your ruling is now being challenged by the Minister for Finance and I respectfully submit to you that neither the Minister for Finance nor the Attorney-General nor any Deputy in this House is justified in questioning the rulings of the Chair.
Comment on this
The Chair does not take it that the ruling is being questioned. The Ministers responsible have given an assurance that, in their opinion and in the opinion of their advisers, the universities are not included in this section and they suggest, therefore, that the question of ambiguity alone arises. The only question that arises is whether or not the universities come under the operation of this section.
Comment on this
I must protest. Once the question of ambiguity arises at all, a Deputy is entitled to argue as to the evil consequences that will follow if the ambiguity is allowed to remain. What good are assurances from Ministers in respect of a statute? This Bill is on its way to the statute book and, when some other Minister is operating this measure, there will be no use in our telling him of the assurances given by those people. That is what may happen if, in fact, the universities are brought in under this provision. So far from their being any question of ambiguity, I cannot see that there is any doubt about it. There is certainty that the universities are brought under it and the proof is this: there is an amendment which clearly cuts them out. It adds three lines to this measure. Why not accept it?
Comment on this
Might I suggest—I put this as a point of order—that if the Deputy wished definitely to exclude the universities from the operation of Section 12—all his remarks on this amendment have, I think, been confined to the effects which would ensure if Section 12 were to be applied to the universities—his amendment should have been down to Section 12.
Comment on this
Since the Deputy has admitted that he has an amendment down to Section 12, I submit that his speech on this amendment must be confined to the question of ambiguity. The other issues which could be raised in regard to Section 12, if the universities were included, he will have an opportunity of discussing on his other amendments.
Comment on this
It is a pity that the Minister would not let his eye run down the list of amendments before rising to make a foolish point like that. I have down an amendment to Section 10 and I have down a similar amendment to Section 12. I thought that I had to put both down. Suppose I refrained from putting an amendment down to Section 10, clearly I should be met, when I came to discuss Section 12, with the statement that the universities are out of Section 10, and, therefore, that Section 12 has no application to them. I have, therefore, got to move, firstly, to exclude them from the operations of Section 10 and, secondly, to exclude Section 12 from having any application to these bodies.
Comment on this
I am not accepting any limitation in regard to ambiguity. I put it quite definitely for a ruling that I am entitled to say that the universities are within the scope of Section 10, as it now stands, and, being within Section 10, that they suffer from the repercussion of Section 12; that Section 12 gives the Minister final power to approve of the salaries and, that being so, that the whole scheme of university autonomy is gone. I have no argument to make merely on the question of ambiguity. The only strong argument I can make is to show what was definitely intended; what, I think, is still intended and what can still operate against the universities, Section 10 being amended to the point only to which it has been amended and Section 12 remaining without amendment. There is no freedom of discussion in this House under the campaign of continuous interruption to which I have been subjected this evening on a matter of great importance, a matter which so raised the anxiety of those interested in education that they made the protest they did to the Minister, which drew in the authorities of Maynooth College and which, I think, drew in the criticism of the Hierarchy.
Comment on this
I have always said "I think" in that connection. I do not make any alteration or reservation in regard to what I said respecting the staff of the College at Maynooth. If the universities can be brought in under Section 10—as I hold they can— and if the Minister can operate on them under Section 12—as I hold he can—then the arguments set out in this memorandum from which I was attempting to give a quotation are quite relevant to the discussion we are having at the moment. This represents the considered views of the staffs of the three colleges——
Comment on this
I presume that that memorandum was written before words purporting to exclude the universities were inserted in this section?
Comment on this
The Deputy is therefore quoting at length from a memorandum drawn up to meet a situation which has changed.
Comment on this
The transfer of what was written to the present circumstances is my responsibility but it is a responsibility I shall easily carry. These arguments were sound, in the opinion of the people who urged them, when the universities were clearly inside Section 10. They had no doubt as to what Section 12 meant in those circumstances. If it is still possible for the universities to be brought in under Section 10, or suppose we go beyond that and say it is extremely likely that the universities are still in under Section 10 or if we can go to the point of saying that the universities are still in under Section 10, is a very easy responsibility if I transfer the arguments they urged under the old circumstances to the present measure. Taking that as my responsibility, here is what they said:—
In reading this section. the ordinary member of the Oireachtas will probably have in mind such bodies as county councils and boards of assistance already subjected to the Ministry——
Comment on this
"There is a danger that it may not be realised that in effect the section is superseding the colleges as autonomous corporate entities——"
Comment on this
Whether the Deputy has authority to quote that memorandum is a matter for the Deputy himself. It has been explained that the document was written under certain circumstances. The circumstances have altered since and the Deputy is quoting the document on his own responsibility.
Comment on this
If I have not authority, I shall answer for it afterwards. I am not going to give the Minister any further satisfaction than that.
Again may I quote. Referring to Section 10, these people said:—
"In reading this section the ordinary member of the Oireachtas will probably have in mind such bodies as county councils and boards of assistance, already subjected to the Ministry. There is a danger that it may not be realised that in effect the section is superseding the colleges as autonomous corporate entities and undoing the settlement of the University question. The Dáil is not setting up a commission of educational experts or even one of public representatives; it is being asked to institute an inquisition of civil servants and to approve beforehand of their unpredictable decisions. If we advert to the extremely wide definition of "salary" in Section 3, it will be apparent that the Bill practically means handing our entire administration over to the Ministry of Finance, for every transaction except the purchase of material, rents, maintenance and the like, can be regarded as salary. The mere fact that the declared purpose of the reduction of endowment is a cut in the salaries of the staffs is itself a most definite infringement of the autonomy guaranteed by Parliament and Charter. An enforcement of economies in general by an Act reducing the total grant, is quite within the powers of the Oireachtas. But it is not open to it, without raising very fundamental questions of principle to dictate to the colleges how they are to adjust their responsibilities and functions to the altered grant. It is still more reckless and reprehensible to claim to subject us to the officials of the Ministry of Finance, who, however excellent in their own domain, are quite unfamiliar with academic problems and educational matters.
I hold that the danger is still there, and that the comments which were relevant previously are relevant now. The danger to which they call attention being there, I take the responsibility of saying for them what they said to so many people, because this memorandum was widely circulated.
Comment on this
Have those responsible for the memorandum told the Deputy that they are included in the section, as amended?
Comment on this
Some person has communicated to the Deputy a memorandum prepared by these people. Are we to assume that Deputy McGilligan is not competent to speak for them?
Comment on this
I am speaking for them. I can finish with a very short quotation from the rest of it. They go on to refer to Section 12:—
The full measure of bureaucratic control now proposed can be seen in Section 12, which professes to authorise each governing body to make such deductions in individual salaries "as such body, shall, with the approval of the Minister, think proper." Section 12 is consequential on Section 10, and both sections combined constitute that direct attack upon our autonomy to which we take the most emphatic objection. The whole system of university administration is swept away by this claim to empower the governing bodies to override and dispense with statutes and to make any or every alteration in the salaries of individual Chairs which has "the approval of the Minister." The power freely to fix salaries is central to the whole question of university autonomy and to the whole efficiency of the colleges as teaching institutions. Once that power is interfered with, no matter on what pretext or with what protestations, the university is thereby inhibited from freely making its own arrangements in respect of the wide variety of interests that fall within its knowledge and capacity as to the teaching needs of education. We brand as despotic and dangerous the principle of this innovation which, had it been enacted by the British Government, would have been denounced with fervour by the whole country. Individual and corporate liberty may be so slowly, separately and subtly undermined, that the process may proceed almost unobserved.
According to Section 12 the salary of each one of us is to be determined by "the approval of the Minister." And, therefore, according to constitutional usage, the Minister is responsible to the Dáil for every such act of approval. Hence it is open to any member to ask a question, and to start a debate on the adjournment of the House, on the salary of any Chair and on the teaching and qualifications of the holder. Thus the university institutions which are alone recognised for 93 per cent. of our people are to be subjected to complete Governmental and political control, while the minority is alone to have a free and independent university.
I can speak on another occasion on university professors as such, apart from university autonomy. I have been dealing with a certain amount of history in relation to the fight made for free university institutions. I think I may refer to the fact that learning as such was one of the things on which our ancestors were supposed to have prided themselves. They were supposed to have prided themselves, particularly in the facilities they granted to learned people, the honours bestowed on them, and the pay and the emoluments given them. This liberal group that is now a Government has decided on a measure which the Minister for Education, most appropriately speaking on this matter, said was aimed first and foremost as an attempt at a reduction of salaries. That was his phrase to-day. It is a good thing that we should have that clearly stated, and it is a good thing that in this context we are not sparing the literate. People whom the ancient Irish delighted to honour are going definitely to be cut, without any appreciation of the position which they previously occupied, or the salaries or emoluments which they previously enjoyed. Incidental to all this, and relative to the present discussion, even such grants as were given in aid of the collection of folklore in the country are being hacked about.
Comment on this
There is, generally, an attack in this Bill, and it is in the forefront, on every cultural institution the country has. That is done by two people who announced to the electorate of the University that they were going to improve it beyond all knowing. It is a great thing to promise—like most of the other promises. The Attorney-General was to work untiringly to make the University itself a seat of learning worthy of the nation and its traditions. The implementation of it is peculiar. He was to work untiringly to make the University worthy of the nation and its tradition. We had a tradition with regard to learning. A professor in olden times, we are told, was seated at the King's shoulder, sat beside him at the feasts, and shared his portions— he has got the Government's cold shoulder. He was picked out for honours, and not merely picked out for honours but took them as a man who was worthy. These people in the old days were given good conditions of living, were given everything that made life easy. They were spared, except there was definitely a savage attack made to destroy the culture of the country. Education suffered by the measures adopted now when attacks were made on the moneys paid them. It was recognised that there was a consequent lowering of the dignity of the people in these positions by the decrease which was associated, not so much with the men as with the particular things they taught, and so decay came on and grew. Now we are going to make the University a seat worthy of these traditions by hacking at these moneys.
Comment on this
I am discussing Section 10. If it is the wish of the Chair I will discuss the question again on Section 12.
Comment on this
I do not mind what the Deputy said about me and my election promises. I know that that election, and the memories of it must be very painful to the Deputy, and I suppose I cannot blame him for harking back to it. I stand by anything I said in the election circular. I should like to say that, as the Bill now stands, I seldom heard in the Dáil a speech more unjustified by circumstances. The Government have announced that they do not intend that universities should be covered by this section, and under the guise of the specious arguments that the words do not carry out that intention, the Deputy has succeeded in unburdening himself of the speech which, apparently, he had prepared to deliver as the section originally stood. I suggest it is bordering on the dishonest, and can only have been intended to get publicity for views, which it was quite unnecessary to state on this section.
I am going to deal with these views in a moment, although I did suggest to the Chair that they were out of order, but I take it that when the Deputy has been allowed to develop them I might be permitted to say what my attitude is in regard to the universities. When this question first arose I met a group of university representatives. The Deputy was also invited to meet them, but the Deputy was not there. Had he been there, he would have seen that the nine representatives from the three colleges had a friendly, frank discussion about the whole matter. I suggested to the representatives there that their fears with regard to the interference with their autonomy were, in my view, almost completely unjustified, but I listened to everything they had to say. I attended, subsequently, when they interviewed Ministers and others, and, as a result of my intervention, if I may claim it, concessions were made to meet their fears, fears which in my opinion were absolutely unjustified. Those who represented the universities never took up the stand which has been taken up here, that the Government were not entitled if the situation was such that economies were required, to ask the University to bear a share of the burden as well as everybody else. They did not take up that stand, and it would have been quite unreasonable to take up that stand. All they complained of, and the matter upon which I sought to allay their fears, was that by reason of the powers conferred upon the Minister by this Bill there might be some interference with their autonomy. I felt then, and I still feel, that the campaign in that regard was worked for purely political purposes and that the suggestion running through the Deputy's speech and running through the correspondence of those who suggested that here was a sinister attempt to allow the State to interfere with the autonomy of the University, was quite unjustified.
Here was a Bill introduced to effect economies in a certain way, to effect economies by attempting to spread the burden as widely as possible over all services which derived their supplies from the State. The suggestion that by some underhand means this Government intended to utilise that measure to cut the salary of Professor A. or B. in the way in which the Minister desired is absolutely unworthy of some of those who wrote these letters, and I am certainly astonished to hear it coming even from Deputy McGilligan. I say the intention behind the Bill as it originally stood, was to make the University bear its share of the burden, to spread the burden as evenly as possible, and to adapt to the University some of the scale contained in the latter part of the Bill. In the discussion with the representatives of the University we had none of the suggestions, or none of the heat, that we had here from Deputy McGilligan. Perhaps if he had been there we might not have been even able to get along as successfully as we did.
As I say, since the amendment was introduced into the Bill I have heard not one single word of complaint from those who feared that the Bill was an interference with the autonomy of universities, and I think that is some justification for saying that the fears of the University and the fears of Maynooth College, fears which I thought were quite unjustifiable, and fears which I say were aroused by some people from political motives, have been allayed by the amending of the section as it now stands amended.
The wording of the Bill, even as it stood, was the draftsman's effort to meet the intentions of the Government. It is the wording of the draftsman, for which I am responsible as Attorney-General, to meet the Government's intention. I suggest that the Deputy wandered away from the question of any ambiguity which might still be in the section. In my view—I have already said it and I have given it clearly as my opinion—the wording of the section does achieve the object of excluding the University from this section. That is not alone my opinion. The Deputy knows it is the opinion of the man who has been for a long number of years in charge of drafting Bills and settling amendments such as this, for the previous Government as well as for this Government. Even if I had not my judgment to rely upon I certainly should be prepared to take his opinion against that of Deputy McGilligan. I notice that not one of the legal gentlemen who were sitting behind the Deputy and who were listening to the debate, took the view that there is still in the section something which may rope in the universities. The words then are obviously intended clearly to exclude that. That being the position, the intention of the Government having been stated from these benches and the intention having been clearly embodied in the new draft, I do repeat that I think it is wholly an unjustifiable procedure on the part of the Deputy to seek to capture a few votes of university graduates by pretending that only he is active here on behalf of the universities, and that their fate or future would be seriously interfered with by the provisions of the Bill.
That is what I feel. I must repeat it and make this protest. I think it is a wholly wrong thing that this wrangle should have gone on because the Deputy must have known that these arguments were quite unnecessary to convince these benches after the Minister had stated that we had gone as far as possible to meet the fears of the University. He should have been quite content with that. If it turns out, despite the views of the draftsman, despite my views, despite the views of many other men who have examined the section, that there is still a slight ambiguity in the section, the Government is pledged, by what has been said here, to see that that ambiguity should be cleared up. After all that, a person of the Deputy's knowledge and experience should know the position created by the Government making such a statement here, and I do protest against the speech which the Deputy has made and against the way in which he has sought to excite the fears of those who are watchful for the University and anxious to preserve its autonomy.