Public Services (Temporary Economies) Bill, 1933—Report Stage.
Contributions 374–560 of 749. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 4 parts.
No. 12 of 1933 ›
I have been definitely challenged to intervene in this debate. Deputy McGilligan has read out for the House portions of an electoral address which was issued by the Fianna Fáil Committee in connection with University representation in this House at the beginning of this year. I did not write that address. My colleague, Deputy Conor Maguire did not write that address. I did not sign that address, nor did Deputy Conor Maguire sign it. It had far more force in my opinion because it was written by others. It has now become a mandate. It was not an expression of our opinion, but after that address was issued we went to the University electors of the country and we all know the result. Two of our candidates were returned, one at the head of the poll. I think that is a sufficient answer to Deputy McGilligan. I have only to add that over every word of that address I stand, and stand thoroughly.
With regard to another matter, Deputy McGilligan has said that certain expressions in that address were a threat to the autonomy of that university. I forget the exact expression he used, but it was something about Gaelicising the University. As regards the autonomy of the University I have no definite opinion on that. I have never studied the question. What I do say is that the autonomy of the University must always be subordinate to the autonomy of the country, and if we sinned in attacking it then we did so in very good company. I have before me an extract which goes to show that, on one occasion, this House went so far as to interfere with the autonomy of the University by actually prescribing the conditions under which professors would be appointed. If that was not a very much more serious interference with the autonomy of the University than a mere question of salaries I do not know what to say. In 1929 the Oireachtas passed an Act entitled "University College Galway Act." This was an Act "to make provision for increasing the annual grant payable to University College, Galway, and for securing that persons appointed to offices and situations in that college shall be competent to discharge their duties through the medium of the Irish language." One of the provisions of that Act reads:
It shall be the duty of the Senate of the National University of Ireland, the governing body of the college, or the President of the college, as the case may be, when making an appointment to any office or situation in the college, to appoint to such office or situation a person who is competent to discharge the duties thereof through the medium of the Irish language: provided a person so competent and also suitable in all other respects is to be found amongst the persons who are candidates or otherwise available for such appointment.
Under that provision there is far more interference with the autonomy of the University than in anything proposed here.
There is another matter to which I wish to refer which clearly shows that under the last Administration there was interference with the automony of the universities. Under the last Government, about 1923, when Dr. Eoin MacNeill was Minister for Education, the Ministry appointed a Commission "to determine how University College, Galway, could best engage in some special work of national importance, e.g. the fulfilling of the functions of an Irish-speaking university college through conducting university teaching and general subjects through the medium of Irish." The Commission reported in 1926. I think that is all I have to say. If the provisions of the Act dealing with University College, Galway, did not constitute interference with the conditions under which the professors are appointed, then I do not know what to say.
Comment on this
I take it from the speech of the Attorney-General that there is just a possibility of doubt, regarding the wording of this section, that the universities may be included. There is just that possibility, he said. If there be, what is the objection to accepting the amendment? The amendment leaves the matter beyond a shadow of doubt. We want to take that precaution. We have been told by the Attorney-General how interested the people he met from the University were when told that there was no intention of interfering with it. If that be so what is the awful objection to accepting the amendment. There is frightful opposition to this amendment on the part of the Ministry. Two members of the Ministry interrupted more than once when a case was being made for its acceptance. Their horror at the very mention of the amendment is so great that a Deputy on this side was interrupted during the whole course of his speech this evening.
If the Attorney-General had not said that the Government is pledged I would not be so suspicious. Twelve months ago the head of the Government, speaking from his place on the opposite side of the House, was asked by me if, in connection with an International Agreement enshrined in an Act of the Oireachtas passed in 1929 protecting the rights of civil servants, it was in the power of this Oireachtas to alter, repeal or amend that Act and he said no. But this Bill is doing it. It just represents what, in my opinion, a pledge of this Government is worth. A pledge from the same people is not worth while wasting words on. This amendment will place a question which is in some sort of doubt beyond any possibility of doubt. Deputy Mrs. Concannon spoke of the Act of 1929, and said that under it there was interference with the autonomy of the University. There was no such interference.
Comment on this
Did not that Act lay down the conditions under which professors in University College, Galway, should be appointed?
Comment on this
And the Senate of the University was to decide that. That is the best evidence one could have that the autonomy of the University was not interfered with.
Comment on this
There was never any interference, or any attempt at interference, by the late Administration during the ten years it was in office with the autonomy of the University, and the interruption of Deputy Mrs. Concannon clearly proves that. If the Oireachtas gives a grant to a university is it the Deputy's contention that the University may do what it pleases with it? Surely if I make a disposition in respect of a certain sum of money to any body that I have control over, it is not interfering with the autonomy of that body if I express a preference as to how the money should be applied.
Comment on this
I submit there was interference with the autonomy of the University by laying down the conditions under which University professors were to be appointed.
Comment on this
If it be held that laying down conditions, under the circumstances I have mentioned, was interference with the autonomy of the University then I have nothing further to add. Grants were given, but the appointments were to be made by the Senate of the University. The Senate had the appointment. Therefore, I hold their was no interference.
Comment on this
Yes, but the conditions were laid down beforehand by an Act of this House under which the appointments were to be made.
Comment on this
So far as the pledges of this Government are concerned I regret, in view of the specific statement made to me across this Chamber that it was not within the power of the Oireachtas to alter, repeal or amend the Act of 1929—enshrining an international agreement—to have to say that the pledge with regard to this Bill is not worth much. The Minister for Education stated to-day that this was a Bill for cuts in salaries. It is more than that, and no case whatever has been made against the amendment.
Comment on this
Deputy Cosgrave is like Deputy McGilligan on that famous occasion when the representatives of the University met the representatives of the Government: he was absent during the greater part of this debate and did not hear Deputy McGilligan himself admit that possibly there was this ambiguity which we deny in the section. On that we are much more competently advised than either Deputy McGilligan or Deputy Cosgrave. If there was ambiguity in the section which we deny, there were other ways in which it might be removed. The Deputy himself suggested that a certain form of words might be incorporated "to a board, commission, company, association or other body whether (corporate or unincorporated)," which would quite clearly, to his mind, exclude the University.
Comment on this
Because they are not necessary. As I have said, we have competent advisers. We do not have to rely on the apprentice hand of Deputy McGilligan to help to draft our Bills for us. The apprentice hand of the Deputy betrays itself in this amendment—this ridiculous amendment, which would, quite possibly, involve the University in the very dangers about which he has been so eloquent all day. During that portion of the most ridiculous and unprincipled speech I have ever listened to in this House——
Comment on this
——the speech in which the Deputy quoted documents which he had no right to quote, I asked him, through the Chair, to tell the House whether or not he had the authority of those who prepared that memorandum to quote it here.
Comment on this
As to that question, there was a covering letter addressed to "Dear Mr. McGilligan." I think that is me.
Comment on this
I asked the Deputy to quote the authority and he said he had the permission of the authorities of Maynooth College.
Comment on this
You said that you were competent to speak for them, at any rate; and I deny that. It is characteristic of the Deputy—the Deputy who is sitting on the threshold of university representation and who, if there is another election will be kicked outside.
Comment on this
Of course, he took responsibility for reading it. Anybody who accepts his responsibilities in the same light manner in which Deputy McGilligan accepts them would take responsibility for the breach of confidence of which he has been guilty to-day. These documents were not sent to him in his capacity as a party politician but to inform him of the case that the representatives of the University were going to make to the representatives of the Government before they met them. Once they had met the representatives of the Government and expressed their satisfaction at the way in which the Government had met them, it was a breach of trust for Deputy McGilligan to use those documents in the manner in which he has used them.
Comment on this
I got that communication also and I have not been informed of the satisfaction of the persons whose names are appended to it.
Comment on this
At any rate, the representatives of the University have not addressed any remonstrance or any protest or any communication of any kind to say that the amendment in the form of Section 13 has not met their case fully and fairly.
Comment on this
Deputy McGilligan is now trying to set himself right with the representatives of the University. He could not attend with the others on the occasion when they were meeting representatives of the Government. He was elsewhere on private business. He was elsewhere, and with as little profit to his clients as he is to his constituents when he is present here in the Dáil.
Comment on this
The Deputy is now trying to save his face with the University by making a political speech.
Comment on this
Deputy McGilligan has asked about my attendance on the occasion. I was willing to attend if the conference could be put off until 2 o'clock instead of 12 o'clock. On the Thursday I got notice to attend on Friday at 12 o'clock. I had important business to attend to and I communicated with Dean Hynes and asked him if it would be possible to put it off till 2 o'clock the next day. I had no car and no means of going. Dean Hynes knew my views and was perfectly satisfied with the attitude I took in the whole thing, and, therefore, I have no apology to make for that.
Comment on this
Deputy McGilligan, the custodian of the rights and privileges of the University, was here and was free to attend. He was not there and he knows nothing about what transpired at any of these discussions.
Comment on this
Deputies will note the ingenuous mind of Deputy McGilligan. I said he was not there when the University representatives met the representatives of the Government.
Comment on this
Is it relevant to what we are discussing whether Deputy McGilligan was at the meeting or not?
Comment on this
At any rate, Deputy McGilligan was conspicuous by his absence on an occasion when it was desirable, in the interests of the University, that he should be present. He did not meet them at that time and, apparently, he has not met them since or he certainly would not have read to the House a memorandum which was prepared when circumstances were entirely different and before the views of the University representatives had been heard by the Government and before the position of the University in regard to this Bill had been met by Section 13.
It is too late now for the Deputy to endeavour to repair the consequences to himself of his own neglect of University interests. The University people know what he is. Some four years ago the Deputy's position as a representative of the University might be considered to be unchallengeable. At the election of 1932 he was definitely replaced in that position of triumph at the top of the poll and since the election of 1933 he has been——
Comment on this
——he has been sitting on the doorstep of the University; and all simply because, during the years he was in power as their representative, he definitely and shamefully neglected the interests of the University. The reason he took up the time of the House to-day is in an attempt to repair and restore his own position. I think that, so far as he personally is concerned, his position has not been improved by the exhibition he made here to-day when, as I say, and as I repeat, he read to this House a document which was prepared in entirely different circumstances and which to-day, at any rate, after the position of the Government in regard to the University, has been clarified, I am certain would not emanate from any responsible representative of the University.
Comment on this
I would like to suggest to the Minister and the Attorney-General that this proviso is not in its right place. It is really a matter of drafting. If you read the words:
...moneys provided by the Oireachtas to any educational institution, board, commission, company, association or other body (whether corporate or unincorporated) not being a university, a university college or a secondary school...
I do not think there could be any doubt about it. I ask the Minister to consider the drafting of the section and, if he considers it impartially, he will find there is ambiguity.
Comment on this
The Attorncy-General has already indicated the position of the Government in regard to that.
Comment on this
Question put: "That the words proposed to be deleted stand."
Do you agree with this result?
Not a separate decision. I move amendment 37:—
In page 5, Section 11, to delete all words from and including the word "or" where it firstly occurs, line 32, down to and including the word "authority," line 33;
and amendment 38:—
In page 5, Section 11, line 38, after the word "concerned" to insert the words "and after consultation with the local authority concerned."
Amendment 37 seeks to cut out of Section 11 the words indicated. In amendment 38 I want to put in other words after the word "concerned" and to insert "and after consultation with the local authority concerned." The first amendment is aimed at this: I want to take away from the scope of the section the words "or to any committee or other body the members of which are appointed wholly or partly by the local authority." Let these deductions be made from grants to the local authority and let it not be done in the case of subsidiary bodies which are appointed partly or wholly by local authority. There has been no indication put before the House as to the groups to which this might have reference. When the Minister is going to make these cuts he is to make them after consultation with every other Minister who appears to be concerned. There is great delicacy in not treading upon other Ministers, but the people who apparently should be consulted are the local authorities and that is what I move to do. This seems to be an entirely different matter from the matter which arises under Section 12 although it has some relevancy to it. Here again we have the curious matter that the Minister makes the deduction from the grant which is payable to the local authority, but when it comes to doing the odious work, that odious work is left to the local authority. That arises under Section 12. All I am asking at the moment is that where the deduction is made there should be at least consultation with the local authority.
Comment on this
The local authorities are to be driven. Surely the Minister ought to have the courtesy to explain his refusal. His proposal is to take a slice of the grant without consulting the local authority. He would consult his colleagues, but the subsidiary statutory body set up by the local authority and the local authority would not be consulted. He is going to commit the local authority to a fight with the local employees. He is to go out to the local authorities' constituents and tell them as he has already told them and as Deputy Brady told them in the County Dublin, that the moneys were there available to help the people of County Dublin, while as a matter of fact, these moneys were not there. He wants to use this quietly to deduct the grants from the local authorities. Take the local authority of the County Dublin which he represents. He deducts from the Dublin County Council and the subsidiary bodies constituted by the county council these grants. Then when the odious job of recoupment comes along it is the local authority which is to be recouped out of the salaries and wages of their employees. The Minister stands aside and Pilatelike, washes his hands of the case and tells his people that it was not the Government did this but the local authorities.
Comment on this
Amendment 38 is in the name of Deputy McGilligan. Do we take it that the discussion on 37 will rule 38 and that there will be no further discussion on 38?
Comment on this
What I want to get clear is that the discussion will not be repeated on 38. There could be a division on it if the Deputy desires it.
Comment on this
We know that the cast iron majority will drop in here at the end of the discussion and vote the way they are told. We know what will be the final result, but we want to demonstrate to the public outside that no sympathy has been shown by the Minister, not even the courtesy of a reply or a comment as to why he rejects this amendment. He is going to cut grants off his own constituents. We can make the case a one constituency discussion, but it is applicable to all constituencies in the same way. He is going to cut a lump sum off the grant and then we are to make up the loss by taking it off the salary of the employees with the approval of the Minister. If, for instance, we try to recoup ourselves and we reduce the salaries of certain officials, is there any likelihood that the Minister may say in his own mind: "This official has been very good to me in the elections and I will not sanction a cut in his case." Why is there this reluctance to consult with the local authorities? If a sum has to be deducted, why should not the local authorities be consulted? I am afraid the Minister has fallen in with the bad ways of his colleague and that he is going to mandamus all along the line now. If he wants local authorities to co-operate with them he should start off by co-operating with the local authorities. He will find his path a very thorny one if he sets out to drive the local authorities. Starting with the cut on the grants in bulk if he wants that apportioned without any friction, he had better show sympathy with the local authorities and ask their co-operation. He would gain more in one half hour's consultation than in six months' fighting, even with a strong Bar, including the Attorney-General and the ex-Minister for Justice, etc. If he wants fight he will get plenty of it from the local authorities. If he wants co-operation he will get it equally. If he throws down the glove we shall take it up, if he refuses co-operation and refuses to accept the amendment providing for consultation with the local authorities. If he accepts that I, as a member of a local authority, will feel satisfied. Although I oppose the principle of the Bill. I must feel that the Minister and his Government want to co-operate in the adoption of the principle of the cuts and that they want to co-operate with the local authorities and meet the convenience of the local authorities. If he does that, I can speak for some who are opposed to the principle of this Bill, and say that he would get co-operation, where perhaps otherwise he would not get it. Is it worth while for him to refuse that? Objectionable as the Bill is, and more objectionable still as are the causes which brought it about, he should try to remedy the causes and root out the weeds, instead of cutting the weeds. If the Minister wants co-operation, he has his chance now, and probably it is his last chance.
Comment on this
One of the most unpleasant features of this Bill, which I object to as a county councillor, and which county councils object to, is that whereas we are not allowed to play any part in the making of the appointment of officials when vacancies occur, the Ministry hold the power to make us reduce the salaries when it suits them. In other words, the odium is placed upon us to say to these officials: "We are going to reduce your salary; we are going to bring down your standard of living and to place you in a lower position than you originally thought you were going to occupy." It is the Minister who is doing it, but we are apt to take the blame. It places local authorities in a most invidious and most unpleasant position. We get all the knocks and none of the credit. When vacancies occur, the Appointments Commissioners send down three names in alphabetical order. We discuss these names and we send them back and the appointment is made. They shoulder the responsibility of making the appointment, but we are to do the dirty work in the way of reducing salaries and lowering the standard of living of these officials.
Comment on this
Question put: "That the Section proposed to be deleted stand."
Do you agree with this result?
I move amendment 37a:—
In page 5, line 35, Section 11, after the word "shall" to insert in brackets the words "(save as is otherwise provided by this section)."
Comment on this
I think the explanation is clear. The amendment is "after the word ‘shall' to insert in brackets the words ‘(save as is otherwise provided by this section)."
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 39a:—
In page 5 to add at the end of Section 11 a new sub-section as follows:
"(2) No deduction shall be made under this section from a grant to a local authority, committee, or other body for or in respect of services administered by or under the control of the Minister for Local Government and Public Health where the Minister is satisfied, after consultation with the Minister for Local Government and Public Health, that such body has made, from the salaries earned and payable in the current financial year by and to persons in the employment of such body, deductions approved of by the Minister after such consultation as aforesaid."
The purpose of this amendment is to reserve to the local authorities the fruits of any economies which may be effected under this Bill in the salary of local servants.
Comment on this
That requires a little bit more enlargement in the way of explanation. It is a very amusing finish to a measure which was required in the public interest. Of course, we had the change mentioned by the Minister for Education to-day that the primary purpose is to cut salaries. Here we have an amendment brought in which proposes to follow an entirely new principle from what was spoken of on the Second Reading. Originally we were told that it was necessary to cut the grants given to local authorities in order to save that money for the Central Fund, and the people who would suffer by the saving which was going to be a gain for the Central Fund were the people whose salaries were to be cut. Now all that is changed. Provided always that the salaries are cut, the grant will be given in full. It is such a differentiation from the old principle that it requires a little bit more explanation than the Minister has given. Previously the proposition was to save money for the Central Fund by reducing the total amount payable to the local authorities. A necessary consequence of that was that the salaries were going to be cut. I suppose this is in accordance with the new bit of savagery announced by the Minister to-day that the primary purpose is the reduction of salaries. Once the Government is assured that the salaries will be cut the grant will not be reduced. It is something to which attention should be called.
Comment on this
May I enquire whether any legal sanction has been given to this particular section by the advisers of the Minister? Have the local authorities, by reason of this section, power to reduce salaries other than what is enshrined in this particular statute? It seems to me that normally they have not got that power, but do they derive it from this section? It may be found, after a moment's consideration, that they have not got that power. I do not think they have. I have had some experience of local authorities; and our local advisers usually put the formula that a salaried officer had entered into a contract which could only be changed by agreement between the two parties. Does this section, as drawn, give to local authorities powers they have not got at present? I do not think it does.
Then the situation will be this: That if a local authority does something which appears to them on the face of it that they have the legal right to do they are entitled to make that saving. If on the other hand, they do not, the Minister will deduct from them such an amount as would equal the deduction itself.
Comment on this
This appears to be nothing short of diabolical bribery by which the full grant will be given to county councils or local authorities provided they reduce wages and salaries. There is nothing more unpleasant for a county council or any representative of a local authority than to be put in the invidious position, when facing the electorate, that he must fall in with the reduction of salaries with a view to obtaining an extra grant from the Government. How long this is to last I do not know. It is not easy to explain to the people the wrong position in which county councillors can be placed. It is diabolical bribery, nothing more nor less. It is most grossly unfair and places local authorities in a position in which they never ought to be placed.
Comment on this
As Deputy Minch has said, this is a bribe offered to local authorities to hurry on the cuts they are to make in the pay of local officials. The Minister has not answered the point made by Deputy Cosgrave whether this does give local authorities the right to cut salaries. I do not believe they have the power, and I think it is due to the House that the Minister should answer that point. If it is legal for local bodies to cut salaries, still, the Minister is placing a tremendous responsibility upon local bodies, if they accept this bribe, to cut salaries in this financial year. To what purpose are they to cut salaries? There would be no gain to the State. If the local bodies accept this bribe to hurry on and rush in with the shears to cut the salaries of local officials the State will not gain anything by it.
Comment on this
This amendment is intended to compel the local authorities to reduce the salaries of their officials. That is, in effect, what it means. Whether the local authorities wish to reduce the salaries of any officers in their employment under this section they will be compelled to make such deduction, whether it is justified or not, unless they are to suffer a reduction in the grant given by the Government. Why? Because I take it the Government have at last realised that the finances of local authorities are even in a much worse state than the financial affairs of the State after two years of administration by the present Government. I put it to the Minister that the local authorities will be compelled to make this reduction in order to make up for the great increase in, among other things, home assistance which they have had to pay as a result of the failure of the present Government to provide employment for the people of the country. Even in my own county I find that because of the failure of the Government to provide for the unemployed and destitute, the rates have been increased very substantially. That increase is far greater than can be met by any saving or reduction on salaries that would be carried out by the local authorities under this section.
I think it will be admitted by Deputies who have experience of local administration that, generally speaking, the officers employed by local authorities are poorly paid and particularly in view of the circumstances obtaining in the country to-day. Will anybody, with a knowledge of local administration, suggest for a moment that the dispensary doctor with anything from £200 to £300 a year is overpaid, especially in view of the fact that if the dispensary doctor does his work properly, under modern conditions, he must keep and maintain a motor car. It used to be said some years ago, and with some justification, that the dispensary doctor had a certain amount of private practice. So far as I know, and I have got the opinion from many dispensary doctors in remote parts of Ireland, they still have private practice, but there is no money in it because the people have not got the money to pay the doctor. Doctors are still called out to a farmer or to his family, and the doctor, being a doctor, attends to the call, but the farmer, unfortunately, is unable to pay him. Deputies from rural districts know what I say is quite true. I observe that one Deputy does not agree with me, but, perhaps, the conditions in his part of the country may be better than in mine. I am quite satisfied of this that it would take much more in reduction, than would be made under this section for the South Tipperary County Council or Board of Health to make up for the increase of 3/7 in the £ in the rates this year. 2/3 of that is due to additional outdoor relief that had to be provided by the board, to meet the increased distress and unemployment in South Tipperary, and 1/4 is as a result of the Government's reduction in the agricultural grant. But what I object to in this is the Minister's attempt to force the local authorities to do what he thinks should be done by means of bribery. I say, so far as I am concerned as a member of a local authority, I refuse to be put into that position. I protest against the Minister trying to put me and other members of local authorities into the position, that whether we are satisfied or not, that the salary paid to any official is sufficient or not, unless we are prepared to sacrifice our grant, we must reduce that salary.
I do not think any such proposal was ever made or suggested in this House before. The Minister did not even attempt to justify it. He did not even give an explanation. If the Minister would give half the thought to these amendments or be half as anxious to accept these amendments and other amendments as he is to obstruct Deputies who are trying to make their own case—and he has been indulging in obstruction all day—we, perhaps, would get through the Bill much more quickly and we might know what the mind of the Minister and the Government is on this particular amendment, if they have any mind on it at all. Certainly, it has been changed very often, but I am now putting it that this is unfair to local authorities. I am not concerned with whether it is going to hinder or harm any candidate in the forthcoming election, but I do suggest that it is unfair that the reduction will have to be made by the members of the local authorities from the salaries of all officials, whether they are well or ill paid. Deputies ought to keep that in mind.
There may be officials in this country employed by local authorities who are well paid. There may be officials who are in receipt of salaries which, in the opinion of the members of the particular local authority, are greater than they should be, but this provision, if passed by the House, will apply to those who are badly paid, and I have no hesitation in saying that there are officials in this country employed by local authorities who are not paid the salary they should be paid or a salary equal to their experience and the amount of work they do for the particular local authority. As a member of a local authority and as a member of this House, I want to put that point of view before the House. As I said before, I have never seen anything like it in this House and I hope we will never see it again.
Comment on this
How is a local authority to approach this matter at all? As pointed out by Deputy Cosgrave, no local authority has power to reduce the salary of an official. Where does it get that power in this amendment? Section 11 says:—
Where a grant is made annually, under statute or otherwise, out of the Central Fund or a fund under the control of a Minister or out of moneys provided by the Oireachtas to any local authority or to any committee or other body the members of which are appointed wholly or partly by a local authority and such grant is wholly or partly available for the payment of salaries there shall be deducted from the amount of such grant
It is at the Government's option. Previously, the Minister refused to accept an amendment providing for consultation with the local authorities. The Government have the right to deduct the grant in Section 11 and the proposed amendment says:
In page 5 to add at the end of Section 11 a new sub-section as follows:
(2) No deduction shall be made under this section from a grant to a local authority, committee, or other body for or in respect of services administered by or under the control of the Minister for local Government and Public Health where the Minister is satisfied, after consultation with the Minister for Local Government and Public Health, that such body has made, from the salaries earned and payable in the current financial year by and to persons in the employment of such body, deductions approved of by the Minister after such consultation as aforesaid.
What authority has a local body to reduce salaries? The Minister is going to add this to the section and, up to that point, there is no section in the Bill and, I understand, there is no Act of Parliament—of course, I have not at my command the able legal advice the Minister has—which gives that power, but, as a member of a local authority for a number of years, I can say we have always been told that we have no authority to interfere with the salaries of permanent officials and I should like to know from the Minister where and when we got such authority. I think that some councils have, in the last few years, suggested a reduction and appealed to the Local Government Department but they were told that they had no authority to reduce the salaries of permanent officials. Here, we are told that, if we do not, this grant will be reduced. We are, at present, dealing only with Section 11, but Section 12 says:—
(1) Whenever a deduction is made under any of the foregoing provisions of this Part of this Act from a grant, any board, authority, committee, or other body receiving (directly or indirectly) such grant or part thereof may make, from the salaries earned and payable in the current financial year by and to persons in the employment of such body, such deductions.
We are empowered to deduct from the salaries whatever deduction is made in our grant, but have we any authority to make the deduction from the salary until there is a deduction from our grant? The Minister, in the section he now wants adopted, says that, if we make the deduction in salaries, there will be no reduction in the grant. Which of them is telling the truth, or where are we? Where do we get our authority? We have no statutory authority, up to the present, to cut the salaries of officials of local government bodies. My reading of these sections is that the Minister can make a cut in our grant commensurate with the amount of that grant that goes for the payment of salaries. In the next section, he empowers the local authority to cut the salaries of the officials to an extent that will recoup the local authority for the amount of the grant that has been deducted from them. That can be understood. Whether we accept it or not, it is logical, but here, in what he now proposes to insert, he says that no deduction shall be made in the grant if we have already cut the salaries, which we have no authority to do. The Minister merely rose and said: "I move." Does he move that we break the law? I wonder where is the learned Attorney-General, who told our local authority the other day of all the pains and penalties we incurred and what blackguards we were because we questioned the authority of the law and the learned judges who gave a solemn decision against us with costs without any deduction. He is absent now. Really, every member of a local authority would want and Attorney-General at his elbow to be able to do his job at all so involved is this matter. Certainly, it is an important matter and I should like to hear the superior intelligence of the Minister for Finance adumbrate this amendment.
Comment on this
This amendment is an amendment which, most certainly, gives rise to difficulties and an amendment in respect of which I think the House was entitled to some explanation from the Minister when he was introducing it. It was introduced by the Minister for Finance with a statement which appears to me to be an entirely misleading statement. The Minister told us—these were roughly his words—that this amendment is an endeavour to give to the county councils the savings which will be made in the salaries of officials. I cannot see that at all.
So far as I can understand, this amendment, placed where it will be placed in this Bill, will have absolutely no such effect. We must consider now the position of affairs. As the Bill originally stood, it was a logical document. Under Section 11, the Minister was entitled to make deductions from grants made to various local bodies. Under Section 12, the local bodies were entitled to pass on the effect of these cuts to their officials. That is how the Bill stood when it was introduced. The savings in consequence went into the general exchequer. What is the effect of this sub-section? (Amendment read). That takes away from local bodies the powers of cutting down under Section 12. They can only cut down under Section 12 when a deduction has already been made from their grant. Therefore, this visualises a cutting-down completely and entirely apart from the effect of Section 12. That is perfectly obvious. Where is the power given to cut down? It is not given by Section 12, because that section could not come into operation until after certain sums had been deducted. Therefore, there can be no cutting down under Section 12 and there is no power in the local bodies to cut the salaries of their officials. Consider what the local bodies are supposed to do. They are supposed to cut salaries not only from the officials who are paid out of the various grants which are mentioned in the first part of Section 11, but from all their officials—"salaries earned and payable in the coming financial year by and to persons in the employment of such body." There is no limitation in that sub-section to persons who are paid out of the grants mentioned in Section 11 as it stands at present. They are to cut down the salaries of all their officials. And by how much? They do not know. The Minister for Local Government and Public Health and the Minister for Finance are to be complete and absolute masters of the situation. They will say: "We shall make deductions from you, unless you cut down the salaries of your officials completely and entirely out of proportion to the grants which are being given."
There is nothing tying down or limiting their powers in this proposed amendment. It makes the Minister for Finance and the Minister for Local Government taken together, absolute dictators. It enables them to say to the county councils: "Unless you reduce your salaries by 75 per cent., we shall reduce the amount of your grants." I do not believe in the principle of giving absolutely unlimited power into the hands of Ministers. As I have pointed out, I believe that this sub-section will never and can never be brought into action. There will be no saving for the ratepayers—absolutely none. The savings will go into the Exchequer as before. This sub-section, as I read it—I should like to hear it explained otherwise—is merely an endeavour to make local bodies believe that they are getting the savings, whereas, in fact, the Minister is going to bring the savings into the Exchequer precisely as he would have done if this amendment had never been introduced.
Comment on this
On a point of order, is the Minister entitled to make a second speech? We are not in Committee.
Comment on this
——Before Deputy Belton asks the Minister to make an explanation, he had better consult Deputy Morrissey. Deputy Morrissey, quite obviously, does not want an explanation.
Comment on this
The Minister has been so keen on points of order himself that I want to keep him in order.
Comment on this
Deputies had asked the Minister to speak and I assumed that the Minister had not spoken on the amendment.
Comment on this
I move amendment 41:—
In page 5, Section 12 (1), lines 49-50, to delete the words "with the approval of the Minister."
Amendment 41 is a biggish item in itself. Amendment 43 is quite a different matter. It proposes to cut out the sub-section which says that, before giving approval, the Minister shall consult with every other Minister who appears to him to be concerned. That is a very small matter—consulting with Ministers supposed to be concerned. But since this Bill aims at the whacking down of salaries, I do not see how anybody else is concerned but the Minister for Finance. Amendment 41 deals with an entirely different point. I am moving to cut out the words "with the approval of the Minister." I am still of opinion that Section 10 applies to the University and, consequently, that Section 12 applies. As Section 12 still applies, in my opinion, to the University, I want to have the Minister removed from any interference with University salaries.
If a body is going to have a grant cut, and if perforce it has got to make a cut in salaries, I want, at any rate, to have no interference by a person not capable of understanding university requirements with no qualifications which entitle him to put himself up as a judge in that matter, and even if he had qualifications, by the fact that he is as a member of the Government bound to forbear from interference in the University, if the principle of university economy is to be maintained. Consequently, this is a vital matter and very different from the amendment with which it is suggested it should be taken, amendment 43.
Comment on this
As the section stands, with the words to which I object, "with the approval of the Minister," it would run this way:—
Whenever a deduction is made under any of the foregoing provisions from a grant, any board, authority ...receiving such grant... may make from the salaries earned and payable...such deductions as such body shall with the approval of the Minister think proper having regard to the amount of the deduction so made from such grant... the proportion of such grant or such part thereof, ordinarily applied towards the payment of such salaries, and to the other circumstances of the case.
What extra is added by getting the approval of the Minister I do not know, if it is not to be used in the way I expressed my fears. The Minister tried to make out that the phrase mentioned in reference to the University means nothing really, that it does not give control over the salaries, or individual salaries. If that is so, drop the phrase. I know there is an objection to dropping the phrase, and it is a substantial one. The phrase is meant to have a meaning, and the only meaning is to give the Minister power which, if thoroughly understood by the bodies concerned, would excite their very violent apprehension. As I said when quoting the document from the University, this is not a commission which has been set up to enquire into this matter. It is not even a representative body—elected representatives of the people. It is simply that the Minister, acting through civil servants, is going to decide individual payments. It might be any employee, say of a local authority, or any educational institution, such as there is in the Bill, which has been specially excluded, or
any educational institution...or to a board, commission, company, association, or other body (whether corporate or unincorporated).
The individual salaries of all these people, say the individual salaries of those on the Electricity Supply Board, are to be subject to the approval of the Minister, and people established by the Oireachtas at one time as governors of these institutions are not going to have their full powers in relation to very important matters, that is to say, the pay to be given those servants. If the phrase has not the meaning which I am assured is there—and I do not see that it gives the Minister anything except embarrassment—if it has the force that I think is there, then it is an undesirable thing that the power should be given to the Minister. He makes a deduction from the grant given to a body. It is open to that body then to make whatever economies it can to meet the reduced grant. If it cannot make them otherwise than by way of cutting salaries, it has to cut them, setting whatever standard it likes to set up. The only thing is that there are terms of reference given and that it will have to fashion it to the amount of grant "ordinarily applied towards the payment of such salaries, and the other circumstances of the case." Who is better qualified to judge the other circumstances of the case—and there will be a variety of circumstances about every individual case—than the body which appoints, and which has to pay? As the phrase stands, "with the approval of the Minister" that is thrown into the hands of the Minister. He is the final authority. It is quite true, as Deputy Belton stated on another amendment, that he gets rid of the odium, and passes down the responsibility of making the cut to the institutions, the local authority or the body getting the grant. They are the bodies that Tom, Dick and Harry will regard as interfering with their salaries. It is on them the reduced salaries will come, but, in the background—when the cut in the salaries is made, and a cut of a special kind in individual salaries—is the Minister in this phrase.
The phrase ought to come out.
Comment on this
Question put: "That the words proposed to be deleted stand."
Do you agree with this result?
Amendment 44 which relates to the officers of a vocational education committee has never been under discussion nor has anything remotely approaching it.
Comment on this
Amendment 37 had nothing to do with local committees. This amendment at any rate does not mean that the cuts shall not take effect. It only says that they shall be postponed. I move the amendment which is as follows:—
In page 5, at the end of Section 12 to add the following sub-sections:—
(3) This section shall not take effect in respect of any officer of a Vocational Education Committee unless and until the Minister for Education shall have prescribed a scale of salary applicable to such officer under Section 3 of the Vocational Education Act, 1930.
(4) Whenever this section takes effect in respect of any Vocational Education Officer the deduction from the salary of such officer shall not exceed a sum calculated in accordance with Part IV of the Schedule to this Act.
The amendment is to the effect that this section shall not take effect in respect of any officer unless and until the Minister for Education shall have prescribed a scale of salary applicable to such officer under Section 3 of the Vocational Education Act of 1930, and it goes on to say that whenever the section shall take effect in respect of any such officer, the deduction shall not exceed a certain amount. There is a reference to the Vocational Education Act of 1930, Section 111 of which gives the Minister power as follows:—
"The Minister may by regulations made under this Act prescribe scales of salaries for the various classes of teachers employed by vocational education committees."
Sub-section (2) of the section is the important one. It says:—
"A vocational education committee shall not pay to any teacher employed by it a salary which is less than the salary to which such teacher is entitled in accordance with the scale prescribed by the said regulation in respect to the class of teachers to which such teacher belongs."
That Act therefore gave the Minister for Education power to prescribe scales of pay and when these scales of pay were prescribed they were mandatory. It was mandatory on the particular body affected to pay them. The teachers have been always pressing that these compulsory scales, that is scales which would be compulsory along the lines set out in the section, should be established.
The power has not been used. There are certain scales in operation at the moment, but they are not of the mandatory type that Section 111 refers to. These vocational education teachers make the point, and I think there is substance in it, that until their position has been regularised and a certain amount of thought and deliberation given to the matter of their pay —until it has been fixed in accordance with Section 111—there is nothing firm upon which to operate such a cut as this. What is happening at the moment is that salaries fixed low provisionally are being taken as the foundation for a cut. These teachers take up the position, and I think there is a certain amount of strength in it, that the first step should be to approach this in the normal way—to find out what is the scale that will operate here in normal times, and then, if necessary, put them in the position that other people are being put in by imposing a provisional cut limited to a year.
Comment on this
I should say with reference to this amendment that, as the Deputy probably knows, this matter of scales of salaries is not one solely for the Minister for Education in consultation with the Minister for Finance. It is a matter also for the local committees. The Minister for Education has only permissive powers under the Vocational Education Act of 1929 in connection with this matter. Scales of salaries for vocational education teachers, so far as I am concerned, is a matter that I am endeavouring to push forward. It is also a matter for local authorities. As regards the proposed sub-section (4) that in making deductions from the salaries of vocational education officers regard shall be had to Part IV of the Schedule to the Act, I think I can assure the Deputy that that matter will be considered. With regard to the general principle, the proposal of the Deputy is simply to postpone this Bill, so far as it affects the employees of vocational education authorities, for what may be an indefinite time. There would be no justification for postponing the operation of the Act in regard to these particular officers. So far as their interests are concerned I do not think there is any question but that there will be no injustice in the treatment of them. The whole position in regard to them has been carefully examined.
Comment on this
This is the second time I think that the Minister, in refusing an amendment, has tried to convey that the Bill does not mean anything so far as the classes concerned in the amendment are concerned. At least I take it that is what the Minister was trying to convey. Now he must know perfectly well that, owing to the circumstances that prevail in this country and owing to the rather recent growth of this particular type of education, these are a particularly poorly paid type of public servant. I do not think the Minister will contend the opposite. If he says that no injustice will be done to them, does that mean that so far as they are concerned the Bill is not operative, because he must know that there can be no real interference with their salary without doing an injustice to them.
Comment on this
I mean no injustice in regard to them as compared with other classes under the Bill, in particular with regard to the classes mentioned by Deputy McGilligan in Part IV of the Schedule to the Act.
Comment on this
I am sorry the Minister is taking up that attitude, but I am glad we have clarified it at all events because undoubtedly twice, as I have said, the House, due no doubt to no fault whatever of the Minister, could be under the impression that though the form was kept to that when he came to apply it the reality would disappear. Now I gather that is not the case. The Minister has pointed out that there are difficulties in applying the scale. I suggest that these difficulties are precisely the reasons why this class should be exempted. If the scale the Minister thinks is a just scale cannot, owing to certain difficulties and owing as I understood him to imply to the opposition of his colleague the Minister for Finance——
Comment on this
——But the Minister was careful to point out that there were other people concerned in the making of these scales of salaries besides himself. He mentioned particularly the Minister for Finance. Of course I do not blame him for that view, but may I be excused if I thought that he had some reason for mentioning, particularly, the Minister for Finance and the local authorities. The fact that there are difficulties in prescribing the scales is no reason why they are not prescribed and should not be taken into account when we are considering the question of cuts. I understand that some time ago a deputation was received by the authorities at which the vocational education teachers were told that their salaries would not be raised. They had applied for better terms and they were comforted by the fact that their salaries would not be raised because the salaries of other teachers would have to be cut. I suggest that at that time the Ministry had made up its mind to cut the salaries of other teachers. What I have stated has been represented as an accurate account of what took place. If so then what was conveyed to them is not contained in the Bill. I am sorry the Minister does not see his way to accept the amendment which is a very reasonable one because, as he says, it cuts across the whole policy of the Bill.
Amendment negatived.
Comment on this
Amendments 45, 46, 47, 48 and 49 seem to have the same principle running through them.
Comment on this
But they have the same principle running through them. Could they not be discussed together?
Comment on this
It may take a very long speech, for instance, to deal with the case of the doctors. Then there are various other classes.
Comment on this
I will deal with the case of the doctors, and after that the Chair can possibly give a ruling as to whether or not it would be well to have the other people dealt with separately. I move amendment 45:—
In page 5, at the end of Section 12 to add a new sub-section as follows:—
Notwithstanding anything contained in the foregoing sub-sections of this section this Part of this Act shall not apply to medical officers in the employment of such body.
There can be no controversy that the Act is intended to apply to medical officers, nor can there be any quibbling that the Act, as drafted, carries out that intention. I want to get all medical officers withdrawn from the scope of this measure. The medical men who are affected by this, or who felt that they were going to be affected by this Part of the Act, met to consider their position as it is at the moment under the local authorities and to consider what change was going to be made adverse to them if the measure went through as it is phrased. The meeting was given a certain amount of publicity in the Press and they have since circulated a memorandum, I think, to all Deputies of this House. In that memorandum they dealt with the various categories of the medical people, who are attached to local authorities, under the different headings of county medical officers of health, assistants to county medical officers of health, those medical officers who are in the mental hospital service, county hospital surgeons and, finally, the poor law medical officers or, as they are better known, the dispensary medical officers. Then they call attention to their salaries and fees and want to know are they being cut also. I asked previously whether it was intended to cut the fees for the registration of births, deaths and marriages and also the fees in relation to the Vaccination Acts. On that, the only satisfaction that I got was to be told that these fees were going to be cut, although there was a little bit of a dispute as to whether they would be cut under Part II or under Part III of the measure.
However, the doctors make their case apart from the distinction of the groups into which they divided themselves. They make their main case on two or three broad lines. They say that their position differs from that of other people who are being cut in their salaries, such as the lay civil servants, the Civic Guards, the national school teachers, and so on. They also point out that they are a learned profession and into that they read this meaning: That they have been required to spend many years of study in order to equip themselves, even technically, for the posts that are thrown open to medical men. They point out further that the posts thrown open to them are those that require rather specialised qualifications, and that necessitates that, in the case of the ordinary medical man who, in the main, would not get qualified until he was somewhere between 22 and 23 years of age, he cannot get any experience that would be counted sufficient to consider himself as qualified for such a post. Added on to that, he has to have considerable experience of a post-graduation type and, in the main, it is required now that those appointed to public positions in the medical line have to study for and obtain the Diploma in Public Health. That, again, entails special study, and it means that a man must work himself up to the point in his practice where he is able to leave his practice for the year, or possibly a longer period, that he has to study in Dublin or in one of the other University Colleges in order to get the Diploma in Public Health. It is no small thing to ask a young man who has just entered into the profession that he should work for a sufficient period to enable him to have sufficient savings put by on which he can afford to leave his practice, and possibly have to pay a substitute in his area to look after his practice for him while he comes to one or other of the colleges to take out his diploma.
Not merely is this requirement of a diploma almost necessary now in public appointments, but, in addition, the struggle for them has got to be so great that a man has to be qualified, not merely by having that diploma, but by having considerable experience in actual public health work. That cannot be got here in the main. That means that most of these people have to take themselves to England and acquire an experience in some way related to the work or the activities they will have to perform afterwards if they succeed in getting one of these appointments. That again means a postponement of the date on which they can be ready to make application for any of these posts and it is an extraordinary case if a medical man, making an application for a post of this kind, should succeed on his first application. There have been cases of medical men succeeding on their first application for a post as county medical officer of health; but that is a post which has been established only recently in this country and the people who applied for it found themselves to be the only people with the requisite qualifications. Consequently, they succeeded on the first attempt.
All that, consequently, means that when any medical man has secured a position in the public service, he enters it at a much later age than, say, lay members of the Civil Service. As a result, the period of service which he has to look forward to for the purpose of making savings on which to live for the rest of his life, or for the purpose of piling up pension rights, is a very small period; with the necessary consequences again that any pension for which he qualifies will be a very small one indeed. This makes it all the more necessary that he should save, and save considerably, before taking up any of these posts.
The medical teachers in the university—and I presume that they come under this also—have to be rather specially commented upon. It has been recognised everywhere that they have been cut in their salaries as fine as they can be. The universities, which have been rather cramped for financial resources have, in the main, not been liberal, to say the least, towards anybody who can be described as a part-time teacher in a university. The medical men are, in the main, amongst that group. Their salaries have been reduced to a very small point indeed. There is no saving possible in what they get from the university and it is very hard to see how the man who has achieved the position of teacher in a medical capacity in the university can make any great saving in his family budget. Certainly, the Dublin man can make none. These men require a certain amount of leisure to fit themselves for their work. They are nearly all in outside practice and they have got to add on to that the work of teaching and examining. If they do not get a sufficient amount of leisure it means that neither their teaching work nor their professional work is going to be up to the mark or up to what is expected from them. If these Chairs are finally brought to the point that the emoluments got from them are not sufficient to pay a professional man for the loss of his time—merely evaluating it on that point—then, of course, the necessary result is going to be that the best men will not offer themselves and those who afterwards will be instructing the youth of the country, who are devoting themselves to medical pursuits, will not be the proper type of people. They will not be the type of teachers from whom the best medical knowledge can be derived.
The county medical officers of health are a somewhat new body. They constitute one of the newest of the medical services of the country. It is quite definitely laid down with regard to these appointments that in order to be qualified a man must have a diploma in public health, having gone through a two years' course for that. The only place in which he could get training in administrative work is still England, or else on the Continent, where such schemes have been established. It means, at any rate, that the great majority of our people have to spend a period of time in England. The great majority of those who have got appointments have spent some time in England. Having got appointments in England, they were induced to resign these appointments and take up positions here where the salaries are undoubtedly much smaller, and where it can also be said that the work is harder in the sense that there are probably more cases brought under a doctor's notice. They surrendered promotion chances and pension rights, very valuable indeed, and came here to take up work at salaries fixed on a lower scale.
It can be readily recognised why these salaries were fixed on a low scale. Anybody who looks back on the period, not so long ago, when these county medical officers of health positions were established, will remember that the county boards of health did not, at the start, favourably receive these appointments. In order to gild the pill as much as possible for local authorities who had to foot the bill, the salaries were scaled down in an extraordinary way. The officers who first took up the appointments had held out to them these inducements, that if they succeeded in their work and if they succeeded in impressing on the minds of the people in the locality that their work was of benefit, then they could count upon a betterment of their conditions, and particularly a rise in their pay. Not merely did they suffer from the point of view that the salaries paid here in the medical line are much lower generally than the salaries paid for similar work in England, but they suffered particularly from the fact that it was a new service, one that had to be forced in somewhat on the local authorities.
Considerable reluctance was displayed by local authorities in the adoption of these medical officerships and the removal of that reluctance was only secured by having the salaries reduced as low as they could possibly be reduced. It is now proposed to have the salaries of these men cut still further. At the time when the salary was first fixed for these posts there was an association of county medical officers of health. After meeting and discussing the matter they passed a recommendation to the effect that £800 should be regarded by the members of the association as the minimum at which any one of them would take up the work. The scale was fixed then.
The county medical officers of health have assistants, and whatever can be said about the principals themselves it will apply with much greater force to the assistants. The assistants are in receipt of salaries which are already far too small to permit any deduction being made if there is still to be a livelihood left to them. The work they are engaged on is mainly connected with tuberculosis and, outside that, the inspection of school children and school clinics, two types of work which have always been regarded as of the utmost importance. The assistants, in view of the nature of the work they do, are paid at scandalously low rates, yet it is now proposed further to reduce those rates.
Those in the mental hospital service have been suffering from a peculiar disadvantage for years past. Their salaries have always been regarded as very low in comparison with the salaries paid to men in similar positions in England. The allowances they get, which count for pensionable purposes, are rated very much lower than the allowances given to their colleagues in England. The people who go into these positions go in at a relatively late period. The peculiarity of the new situation is that under the Local Appointments Commissioners it has been a rarity, if it has ever happened, that one of the senior medical officers in the asylum has secured any of the better appointments that fall vacant and that are thrown to the Local Appointments Commission for filling. Invariably the younger men obtain the posts and the older men have been left to follow along as before.
Comment on this
I am not blaming anybody. I am merely stating it as a fact to be taken into consideration in this discussion. I am blaming this cut. These people are cut in these circumstances. The surgeons in county hospitals are also paid on a very small scale. They have been for years agitating about a betterment in their conditions. In the main, their grievance has been that they are supposed to be specialists of certain work, all-round people almost of a certain type, and they get rates which would be offered to very junior people getting into practice for the first time. These county hospital surgeons have to be expert so far as surgery of the eye, the ear, the nose and throat is concerned. They have to be expert workers in abdominal surgical work. That work very often falls to be done by them. In recent years they have been asked to fill the bill in reference to x-ray and pathological work. Notwithstanding all the work that is definitely coming in to them, there has not been any change for the better in their salaries. Now it is proposed to take something from them, something of the poor emoluments that are paid to them.
The cases of hardship to which I have referred are insignificant in comparison with the ordinary dispensary doctors, the poor law medical officers. Their salaries have been the subject, I suppose, of meeting after meeting, agitation after agitation, and deputation upon deputation has visited Government offices to complain about the salaries paid. The salary here starts at £175, rising to a maximum of £300. Some of them start a little higher. It can go in exceptional cases to £350 a year, but that £350 maximum which a doctor gets at the end of a certain period includes his out-of-pocket expenses. I think it will be admitted that a dispensary doctor in the country can hardly get along without at least a Ford motor car. When it is considered that the doctor has to purchase the car and pay the expenses of running it, it will be observed how very little he is getting as actual salary for the work he does.
Deputy Morrissey referred in an earlier part of the discussion to what was told to him by certain dispensary doctors. They certainly described their situation in a very pointed way at the meeting they held to discuss this situation when it was developing. They pointed out that they are probably worse off than anybody else as a result of the serious conditions existing in the country. It has been their experience for years past that in a time of depression it is the doctor's bill that is the last one to be paid.
As far as the present depression is concerned the doctors have got to the point of admitting themselves that they would rather not get a call from a private patient than get one, for while they suffer from the fact that a great many people now pass themselves off as destitute for the purpose of getting red tickets, they get some payment in these cases. Though their travelling expenses are increasing every day while they are drawing something from these visits, they feel there is to be some payment, whereas in relation to the private patient in the main, the person who still has enough dignity not to place himself amongst the ranks of destitute persons, has another way out of the difficulty. That way is to postpone the payment of the doctor's bill until conditions improve. That means that whatever addition doctors used to have to their official salaries arising out of private practice, has almost altogether gone now.
I think the consulting rooms of the medical men in Dublin would bear witness also to the devastated condition of the country as it is at the moment. Certainly, as far as the poor law medical officers are concerned they have been subjected to extraordinary hardships recently and they see no prospect of things improving. They further see that they are going to be called more and more to come to the relief of persons who are amongst the new group who are calling themselves destitute. The salaries of the medical officers are not increased by reason of the extra numbers they attend. I know one medical officer who detailed to me the number of red tickets on which he has attended, and he said right through the year the average which he would get would be about 4,000. The average would be three visits on each ticket. That would be the number of visits he would have to pay entirely. If you take the turnover of that in a year and relate it to the salary of say £300 in the year paid to that man for attendance on the poor, it means if the whole lot is to be regarded as a salary, and he has to pay his locomotion expenses around his area out of his own pocket, he is getting something in the nature of sixpence per call for medical attendance on those people. It is proposed to cut that because the Minister for Education is anxious that salaries should be reduced.
I have already spoken of the fees that are paid for registration of births, marriages and deaths, and the fees that are paid in connection with the carrying out of vaccination. There are certainly other fees which medical men get and about which there has been trouble for years past. That is in connection with the fees paid for attending members of the Gárda Síochána and the payments for medical assistance under national health insurance schemes. There are payments also for appearing at coroners' courts and at other courts. I am to assume that as far as any of these funds are paid from grants or alleged to be paid from grants made from the Central Fund in all these cases they are to suffer cuts. There is an exceptionally good case to be made in relation to medical men generally.
Even Ministers themselves know that there is a special case to be made for dispensary medical officers and certainly it is approaching something like knocking the pennies out of the blind man's cup to cut down the small payments that are paid for these additional services that medical men do, that is, these registration fees and those fees which they have always regarded as moneys that could not be offered to a good type of clerk for doing the work which they, as medical men, are asked to engage upon. I do not know what the saving is to be. We can get no statement as to the saving there will be in the separate groups proposed to be cut. But I cannot imagine that there is going to be anything great in the way of saving by tackling this particular group of professional men in the country.
I think there should be even at this late moment some hesitation on the part of the Government before proceeding further with this Bill. It is the most extraordinary case of hardship that has yet come for discussion. I do not believe there was any thought given to the consideration as to the position in which these men will find themselves. If any thought were given to the position of these men when they were induced to take up certain work this section would not be in the Bill. I doubt if there has been any time given to the consideration of the position of medical officers of health or the ordinary dispensary doctors. I think most people would shrink aghast from any proposal to cut the salaries of those folk no matter what the position is to which the country has been brought.
Comment on this
Will the Minister not reply? I see he does not intend to. I am sorry. Perhaps he is right. He made a very poor defence in any case in which he intervened up to the present and possibly he feels that there is no defence to be made now. I only want to stress one particular case and that is the case put forward by Deputy McGilligan—the case of the ordinary dispensary doctor. I quite admit, as far as the county medical men are concerned, a great deal could be said. Anyone connected with the establishment of these services knows that at the time the salaries for the county medical officers of health were fixed they were fixed as low as possible owing to the great difficulty in getting a number of county councils to have them at all. Considering the qualifications that are required from those men it is a question whether it would not be better to scrap the services altogether or to do them properly. That is not what is being done. You are really calling upon men to do very expert work and not paying them properly. Whatever may be said against the comparison with salaries elsewhere, remember that where the medical profession is concerned comparison with the salaries in England is highly irrelevant because numbers of our young men go over there and there is the danger that you will have the less better qualified men attracted to the positions at home so that we would keep at home only the men who are mediocre. That has been the result of the salary-cutting that has gone on and you have seen it in other spheres as well.
I want to ask the House to consider what we are doing so far as the ordinary dispensary doctor is concerned. It brings my mind back to what used to be a common thing when I was a young man. The boards of guardians used to meet fortnightly and fortnight after fortnight they would spend the time of the meetings discussing whether they would pay a medical man £100 or £130 a year. At the same time, they would not mind squandering a couple of thousand pounds in other directions. The whole battle at the Board was over that miserable salary. It is in that way precisely that the Ministers are acting now.
I would ask the House to consider how these medical men are hit at present. They are hit in different ways. In the first place, so far as their income is concerned they are hit by the increased income tax. In the second place they are hit, as everybody who comes across medical officers in the last six months knows, because they are getting no payment for private practice. A medical officer does not take up a position as dispensary doctor because of the salary attached to it. Everybody knows that it is not because of the salary of £270 to £350 a year that a man takes up a position as dispensary doctor. That is not the consideration or at all events it is not the main consideration as to why he takes up the position. He does it in order to establish himself in a particular district. Now, unfortunately, as a result of circumstances which we need not touch on particularly here, but with which we are all familiar, the doctor's private practice is, to a large extent, destroyed. One of the principal considerations is gone, and whilst that consideration has gone the medical officer is being cut down in his salary for the work he has done for the poor. There were many instances in which the Ministry put up no case whatever in defence of the policy they are pursuing. I am not surprised that the Minister, who for the moment is in charge of the Bill, should prefer to meet this particular matter with silence.
Comment on this
Amendment put.
Do you agree with this result?
I have not mentioned the words "veterinary surgeon" since we started. I propose to speak entirely of veterinary surgeons now. I move amendment No. 46:—
In page 5, at the end of Section 12 to add a new sub-section as follows:—
Notwithstanding anything contained in the foregoing sub-sections of this section this Part of this Act shall not apply to veterinary surgeons in the employment of such body.
Surely a special case can be made for veterinary surgeons. There used to be a very flourishing veterinary college in this country, because there was once a flourishing business for veterinary surgeons to look after. By degrees, as the motor car and other forms of transport replaced the horse-drawn vehicle, the possibility of employment for veterinary surgeons decreased. At the moment, I doubt if there is any great livelihood for veterinary surgeons in the country, other than what they get when they are attached to local authorities. Private practice is almost at vanishing point. There is an exceptionally lucky individual here and there who gets attached to a training stables, or who, living in the vicinity of a training stables, is brought in for work in connection with that establishment. In the main, the veterinary surgeon, if it were not for the little bit of foundation he has got to rest on in whatever he gets from the local authorities, could definitely despair and leave this country. We would have done with that type of professional men. The emoluments they get from the local authorities are very small. The private practice there is to be done is very small indeed, and the fees that are given have gone down from what they used to be.
[An Ceann Comhairle resumed the Chair.]
Veterinary surgeons used to rank very highly amongst the professional men in this country from the point of view of the moneys they were able to earn, and the life they were able to lead. I suppose there is no type of professional man in whom there has been such a change wrought by circumstances as in those people. Although I do not think their case of hardship is equivalent to that of dispensary medical officers, they specially merit some consideration at this stage. I move to have them exempted from the proposals of the Bill.
Amendment negatived.
Comment on this
I move amendment 47:
In page 5, at the end of Section 12 to add a new sub-section as follows:
Notwithstanding anything contained in the foregoing sub-sections of this section this Part of this Act shall not apply to engineers in the employment of such body.
There cannot be the same case of hardship made with regard to these people as with regard to dispensary doctors or veterinary surgeons, but there is this consideration which can be put forward with regard to them. There is very little outlet for professional men in this country. There was a time when no engineer could get employment here. For some years past there was an increase in the employment for engineers, and we got to the point where we had to call back engineers from other countries. They got fixed into certain positions, and as those called back were the younger men who went abroad to enter into engineering there is no great hope of vacancies arising at a sufficient rate to give people a reasonable prospect of employment. Outside of the engineers who got employment in the country on account of electrical development, there is a small number of people who were employed by the local authorities. There is a certain number of others who are employed in a temporary way under the Board of Works for drainage schemes and things like that.
As far as these people are concerned, they have been for years past agitating that the emoluments which they receive are very meagre and ought to be increased. Instead of there being an increase there is to be a decrease. The prospect has always been held out to them that an increase would be given if things got better, but there was no suggestion that their salaries were regarded as excessive or that there would be a cut imposed. We are now cutting in succession medical men and veterinary surgeons. If this amendment is refused the engineers will also be doomed, and, no doubt, we would go on to cut other classes of professional men.
Does the Minister hold out any hope for trained people in the country? What inducement is there for people to get educated for professional work if the salaries that they receive for work done in relation to the county councils are to be subject to decrease in this way? We hear a lot of talk about the State being a good employer, and about the State being the best employer. We now have a reversal of that principle here. People are simply picked for this type of slaughter because they are nearest to the Government. No argument has been made that they are paid excessive salaries. No such argument could be made with regard to any of those groups I am speaking for at the moment. They are singled out because they find themselves located peculiarly near to the Government, and because their salaries are controlled in some way owing to their being attached to a Body which gets a grant from the State. No argument, capable of exciting anybody emotional, could be advanced to show that they are paid too much, and that consequently there is a justification for their being cut. They are just being picked because of their location near the Government or local authority. If we are going to look for the development of any sort of engineering in the country surely we ought to try and keep in the country as many of those people as we can. We should look for a variety in the pursuits of the people of the country, because when there is a variety in the pursuits of the people there is better intellectual development. We should aid that by seeing that when they have educated themselves they are not going to have their salaries hacked and torn because they are in a position near to the Government.
Comment on this
I rise to support every possible defence against the attacks on professional grades. The engineering profession in this country at the moment is in very low water. I am quite sure the House appreciates the position in which a Bachelor of Engineering of the National University, a man who took an honours degree, had to accept four guineas a week and was glad to get it. It is quite obvious that if this position in which the professional people find themselves to-day is to be attacked by salary cuts, it will make it thoroughly impossible, uneconomic and unattractive for them to seek university education and qualify in a professional capacity in this country at all.
Amendment 47 negatived.
Comment on this
I move amendment 48:—
In page 5, at the end of Section 12 to add a new sub-section as follows:—
Notwithstanding anything contained in the foregoing sub-sections of this section this Part of this Act shall not apply to solicitors in the employment of such body.
Comment on this
I have only this to say about this amendment that nobody who knows anything about the work that solicitors attached to those local bodies have to do, and the peculiarly arid branch of law that they have to make up, and the special expertness they have to show in their handling of the local matters, would, approaching it from that angle, ever attempt to reduce their payments. Most of the people who attach themselves to these bodies as solicitors, find, in the end, that the work is of such a specialised character that in the main, in a large number of cases, at any rate, they can do no work other than the work they do for the local authorities. It is a specialised branch of law in which a person has got to be an expert going into it at all. It is very intricate and complex. People who have gone into it have done so with the knowledge that there was a great amount of work there to be done, and work that brings them in nothing in the way of excessive salaries. Solicitors attached to local authorities are among the hardest worked of professional people. It can be said, and with justification, that there is plenty of work in the country for solicitors. But a man who specialises in that type of work, when he finds himself, in middle years, forced out because there is not the same livelihood in it as before, will find it very hard to change into the general line of practice in the profession. It is hoped that this is only an emergency we are in and is only temporary. If so then these people might very well be left out and exempted from these cuts.
Comment on this
Deputy McGilligan finds himself in the happy position of being everybody's advocate to-night. He has advocated the case of vocational officers, medical officers, veterinary officers, engineers, civil servants, members of the Gárda and of the Army and so on. I was wondering what case he was going to make for the solicitors. I find that, perhaps, he has made a worse case for them than he has made for any others. The solicitors attached to local bodies are not full-time officers, and they earn fees outside their special work for the local bodies. I would certainly oppose this amendment because I think the solicitors receive fees amply sufficient for the work they do for the local bodies. It is very hard to understand the attitude adopted by the Opposition. One day we are told there is an economic war and that the farmers in the country are suffering. Another day we are told there is unemployment, and another day we are asked where are the economies we promised. Another day they come along, just as to-day, and tell us not to economise, and oppose every effort we make to bring about economy. I think I might be pardoned if I refer to the fact that when the Opposition were in power, and went to look for economies, they reduced the old age pensioners, and they took ten per cent. off the teachers. In view of these things it is very hard to understand their attitude to-day. I certainly oppose the amendment to have solicitors excluded from the scope of the Bill.
Amendment put and negatived.
Comment on this
I move amendment 49:
In page 5, at the end of Section 12 to add a new sub-section as follows:—
Notwithstanding anything contained in the foregoing sub-sections of this section this Part of this Act shall not apply to county surveyors or assistant county surveyors, with professional qualifications, in the employment of such body.
I am going to add this group, also to those for whom I am making a special advocacy. I am very glad that Deputy J.P. Kelly drew my attention to the fact that there are still a number of Fianna Fáil Deputies who do not understand the promises made of economies by the Fianna Fáil Party. The Deputy said he could not understand the attitude of the Opposition. He told us there is an economic war on. That is not denied. He told us the farmers are suffering. That is not denied.
Comment on this
But they never got the castigation before they are getting now. There is now the 40 per cent. of plunder put upon them and that is added to whatever was added to them before.
Comment on this
They are standing it well. They are not going to sell their country for the price of a bullock, as the Cumann na nGaedheal Party wants them to do.
Comment on this
That is the attitude of a Fianna Fáil Deputy sitting here in regard to the impoverished farmers. He tells us they are standing it well. If they are standing the Deputy as well as they are standing the deprivation they are suffering they will come out of the struggle very well. We are told by Deputy Kelly that we do not want any more taxation. But the Deputy's Party promised two years ago that there would be no more taxation, that there would be a reduction of taxation. The Deputy says that we are objecting to their economies and that when they come along with economies in this Bill we object. We object because that is not what they promised. It was denied that that was coming. Would the Deputy listen now, if he never heard before, to what the policy of the Fianna Fáil Party was with regard to economy? We were told that the Fianna Fáil Party was satisfied that substantial economies were feasible without reducing the social services, without inflicting any hardships upon civil servants or those in Government services or without impairing in any way the State machinery.
Comment on this
Deputy Kelly's investigation compels us, apparently, to have a Second Reading debate.
Comment on this
The Second Reading debate, so far as I am concerned, will not go very far. Fianna Fáil had examined, we were told, the Estimates and was convinced that a saving of many hundred thousand pounds could be made, not including such items as the sum of £1,152,500 paid to the British Government in respect of R.I.C. pensions and other similar payments not required by the Treaty. The burden of taxation could be lightened by £2,000,000 per year. Where has it been lightened by £2,000,000 per year?
Comment on this
The Deputy has voted for dead men, in his time, according to his own profession. I think he must represent a dead man, so far as his observation is concerned. The Minister for Finance said that we were to have a reduction of £2,000,000 of taxation without in any way impairing the public service. Instead of reducing taxation by £2,000,000 he has already added another £4,500,000 and the man who sees nothing strange in that has no appreciation of figures. On a recent occasion I pointed out that Deputy Cooney promised to reduce the Army by £2,000,000. I was challenged for that quotation and the date of it. I am not yet able to supply them, but I am able to say that the statement was made by Deputy Cooney in Grangegorman, not at it. May I say that that is an appropriate spot for most of the Fianna Fáil promises to be made in.
Comment on this
If Deputy Kelly is not satisfied, we can take up this point on the next amendment which deals with the National University.
Comment on this
The Deputy did turn away from the solicitors to the economies which Fianna Fáil had promised. I have only this much to say about the surveyors. "County surveyors and assistant county surveyors who have professional qualifications"—I have specially put in that last phrase because, if there is any examination or any test which is supposed to be of difficulty in the country, it is the test which county surveyors and assistant county surveyors who have professional qualifications have to pass. I have known engineers and men of standing in different professions who had, for years, been trying to get the county surveyor's examination because of the high standard of attainments it indicated and who had to apply, time and again, before they got that particular qualification. Here, we have people who not merely got the mark of having that qualification, but who got a post in competition with others who have the qualifications—and they say that this qualification marks a very high degree of attainment, indeed —and now, just because the Government are out to reduce salaries, these people are to be reduced. There is no appreciation at all of the work that men give in relation to the pay they are receiving. There is just this blind reaching out; there are folk near us and we are going to catch them and cut their salaries and whether it is an injustice to individuals, or whether they deserve it, we are not stopping to consider. Their salaries are going to be cut and it is going to be done by a scale, but in the application of the cut itself and of the scale to individuals, consideration of their attainments, the time they take to get into their positions and the work they give in return has gone by the board. We just want a cut and we are going to get it.
Comment on this
I should like to support Deputy McGilligan on this amendment and I should like to ask members of the House if they would take into consideration the fact that there are assistant county surveyors in this country to-day employed as whole-time officers at £300 a year.
Comment on this
I did not quite catch the interruption from Deputy O'Brien, but I think it was "not bad." The Deputy gets an allowance of £1 a day, or £360 a year——
Comment on this
Not bad for the Deputy. An assistant county surveyor employed as a full-time official cannot possibly carry out his duties without a motor car, for which he gets no travelling allowance.
Comment on this
The Deputy questions that? The Deputy knows nothing whatever about the work of local authorities or about the work of any officer of local authorities.
Comment on this
If Deputy O'Brien would consult some of his own colleagues, who are members of local authorities and have some knowledge of the work being performed by county surveyors and assistant county surveyors, they would probably put him right. The Deputy should know that the duties of county surveyors and assistant county surveyors have been increased tenfold within recent years. The amount of work which has to be performed by these officials in the making of roads and other matters is altogether out of proportion to what had to be performed a few years ago. The Deputy should know that. Any of his own colleagues will tell him that and that work which they have to perform must be increased if employment is to be given to those who are unemployed to-day. I put it to any member of the House that it is utterly impossible for an assistant county surveyor on £300 a year to do his work efficiently and well as a whole-time officer and maintain a motor car and to provide for himself and, if he is a married man, for his family, even the ordinary decencies of life on that salary. I suggest to the House that to offer £300 a year to a man in that position, who is a Bachelor of Engineering and whose education must have cost a considerable sum of money, is no inducement to parents to go to the expense of giving their sons a university education with a view to securing degrees.
I want to say this that, so far as I am concerned, irrespective of the position occupied by any man in this country, he is entitled to get a salary or a wage sufficient to maintain him in decency and comfort and to enable him to do his work efficiently. £300 a year—and that is to be reduced—to a man who, at present, is probably responsible for seeing that anything from £20,000 to £60,000 is well spent and that the taxpayer and the ratepayer who provide that money get value for it. I am suggesting that a man who is not decently paid is not going to be in a position to get the most efficient service and to get full value for the money spent and when Deputies cannot make up their minds as to whether a full-time officer, who has to do, at least, as much travelling, if not more, than any T.D., and who has to maintain a position at least as high as most T.D.s can afford to maintain, and who has as many calls upon him as the average T.D., can maintain his proper position, they should have some regard to whether they can themselves make any money, if they are doing their duty to their constituents and doing their duty here, out of the £360 they get. I think it will be admitted by most Deputies, and, particularly, those who represent rural constituencies, and who have to travel at their own expense from town to town and village within those rural constituencies and attend to their correspondence, that there is no member who can make any money out of that £360 per year. Certainly, no member who has to come from the country and remain here from Tuesday to Friday or Saturday can do so and we ought to have some regard for those men who are trying to do work in very difficult circumstances and who, I suggest, are already, in very many cases, inadequately paid.
Comment on this
I want to make a few brief observations in reply to Deputy Morrissey's remarks. I think he should have more respect for the intelligence of those members of the House who are members of local bodies than to make the statement he has just made in regard to surveyors and assistant surveyors. In the constituency I represent, Donegal, we have eight assistant surveyors and two county surveyors and these gentlemen, in addition to their salaries as whole-time officers, receive an allowance of 5d. per mile for travelling expenses. In addition to that, they get a bonus or grant from the fund for main road upkeep, the lowest of which grants is £80 per annum.
Comment on this
These are additions to their salaries and I think that Deputy Morrissey should acquaint himself with what county surveyors and assistant county surveyors throughout the Free State get before he accuses Deputies of not knowing what assistant surveyors get.
Comment on this
I move amendment 50:—
In page 5, at the end of Section 12, to add a new sub-section as follows:—
Notwithstanding anything contained in the foregoing sub-sections of this section this Part of this Act shall not apply in any way to the National University of Ireland or to any of the colleges of that University.
This amendment brings us back to the National University. We have already passed Section 10, which has an admitted ambiguity, to say no more.
Comment on this
At the end of the discussion, if one could get hold of any argument at all, the Attorney-General wound himself to the point that there might be an ambiguity and that if there were discovered to be a loophole, we had a Government assurance —as if the courts are going to take cognisance of a Government assurance and as if the courts are going to take cognisance of an assurance given particularly by a Government which, as Deputy Cosgrave mentioned to-day, gave an assurance regarding an international agreement on Civil Service salaries when they compare it with the position under this Bill. There is the possibility—I think the certainty—that the University is still covered by Section 10 and, that being so, the University is subject to all that is in Section 12. On Section 12 there has been a refusal to take out the phrase "with the approval of the Minister." That is the phrase that excited the anxiety of the University people in the memorandum which I read. When I am speaking of that memorandum, as it has been asserted, firstly, that it is not lawfully in my possession and, secondly, that it was supposed to be something in the nature of a confidential or secret document, I feel bound to put on record the covering letter sent to me with it. The letter is as follows:—
Dear Mr. McGilligan, I suppose I should introduce myself as the person referred to.
We enclose copy of a memorandum submitted to the Executive Council by the staffs of the three colleges.
That shows that this is not a document submitted to me prior to discussion with the Executive Council.
It concerns the inclusion of the colleges within the scope of the Public Services (Temporary Economies) Bill.
It goes on in a later part to say:
As we consider it vital to the whole future of university education that the principles embodied in Sections 10 and 12 be deleted from it, we are asking the leaders of the different parties as well as the representatives of the National University to give the matter their sympathetic attention in case it should come up for debate.
That document, sent to the leaders of parties—at least stated to me to have been sent to the leaders of parties—as well as to representatives of the University, with the request that leaders of parties, and representatives of the University, would give the matter sympathetic consideration in case it comes up for debate, does not appear to me to be a confidential document. Apart from that, I took the precaution of asking the person who sent me this document if it was open to me to use it in debate and I got the answer "yes." I wonder is everybody's conscience at ease in the matter now?
The final part of the letter is as follows:—
"Trusting to have your sympathy and support."
The Attorney-General got that letter, as I got it, and, notwithstanding that, he says it is a confidential document. He has his own view of confidential and secret documents. He tried his views out in the courts without a great deal of success to himself. I think he should suffer a little embarrassment in speaking here about secret and confidential documents.
Comment on this
I do not think that I made any reference to a confidential document at all.
Comment on this
I take credit for the discretion. It was I who referred to the document as confidential.
Comment on this
The Minister is going to take credit, or discredit, for a bit more. Let the Minister take this warning from me. If, later on, he chooses to refer to me professionally in connection with the University, and to any profits which I may derive, he should tread very lightly on that subject—as delicately as if he were going on eggshells, because there can be a fearful repercussion and kick-back on him. I say no more but I hope the warning will stick.
Comment on this
I am not going to be enticed into competition with the Minister on that particular ground. The Minister ought to recognise how vulnerable he is in that particular matter.
Comment on this
The Minister is not vulnerable in any respect and nobody knows that better than the Deputy.
Comment on this
So far as vulnerability is concerned, one can hardly speak in this House without exciting the Minister. Vulnerable! One can hardly speak about the Minister without exciting him. He is silent at last.