We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

Public Services (Temporary Economies) Bill, 1933—Report Stage.

Contributions 561–749 of 749. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 4 parts.

Bill Public Services (Temporary Economies) Bill, 1933
Enacted

No. 12 of 1933 ›

Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Amendment 50.

Comment on this

I am moving this amendment on the strength of the representations made to me and on the strength of that document. It is not a confidential document and cannot be classed as such. Nobody can attempt to say that it is, after hearing the covering letter which I read. That document states that the anxiety of the University people was aroused by the proposals that were, and in my opinion still are, in this measure. The Attorney-General has told us that he met university representatives, or representatives of the different colleges, at a time he said, when I did not meet them. The Minister for Finance, who did not know enough about this, referred afterwards to a meeting of representatives of the University with representatives of the Government. There was never such a meeting to which I was invited. There was a meeting of representatives of the different colleges. I indicated that I should be there at a certain time. I was there at or about that time. Some of the members of the deputation thought fit to wait to meet me and to tell me what had happened. Since the Attorney-General has thought fit to talk about that interview, I may say that they told me that they thought there had begun to dawn on the Attorney-General an appreciation of the danger they thought was in the Bill. I knew the dawning that would come to the Attorney-General; it would be no Easter dawn, no sudden emergence. It was about the Report Stage that he realised that there was some danger in this provision. That is the situation in which we are. So far from that deputation feeling that the Attorney-General had been convinced by their arguments and was coming to their aid, I am afraid the people I met did not express themselves as kindly towards the Attorney-General as the Attorney-General expressed himself to-day. The other representative of the National University thought there had been previously an interference with university autonomy. I think that this House will have a better appreciation of what university autonomy means, and not so much appreciation of the value of university representation, after hearing that Deputy.

What was the example? The example given was an example which showed clearly that when more money, or new money, was being given in aid of a new faculty, or for the better building up of an old faculty it was brought within the ordinary framework of university conditions. The money was given on the basis that the Senate and the governing authority of the University College referred to would take the most competent person and the money was given, in relation to the Irish language, on the ground that the person knew Irish. That is supposed to be interference with the autonomy of the University. I am very glad the example was given, to pick out the argument that the Deputy had before her. It was going to serve the Deputy's purpose very well. It served its purpose very well, but it shows how particularly anxious the late Government was, in giving money, not to have any interference with the whole scheme of the University. If there is going to be money given to provide faculties not hitherto there, I say that the only way that can be introduced is by granting the moneys inside the ordinary competence of the University, and the only way is by declaring that the Senate and the governing body of the University Colleges referred to will determine who the professors are to be. If the phrase is not interference with university authority, we have a funny use of the phrase, and I do not know what university autonomy means. The phrase I referred to in the document, and to which I called special attention in an amendment is "with the approval of the Minister." I propose to quote again the section from the memorandum:—

"The full measure of bureaucratic control now proposed can be seen in Section 12, which professes to authorise each governing body to make such deductions in individual salaries as ‘such body shall, with the approval of the Minister, think proper'."

These are the people for whom the Attorney-General has not much to say. He thinks they were urging this for political purposes, or some of them. That is his method of meeting the criticism of these people. Three representatives were appointed by each of the governing bodies. The Attorney-General's way to wipe out their argument is to say that he was convinced some of them were using this for political purposes. They had met previously. There was discussion in the three colleges and so disquieted were they that they appointed three representatives to go to a meeting. These nine met, and these nine eventually delegated the drawing up of a document to some one or two, which was approved by the lot. It shows that there is fear.

"The full measure of bureaucratic control now proposed can be seen in Section 12, which professes to authorise each governing body to make such deductions in individual salaries ‘as such body shall, with the approval of the Minister, think proper'."

That is the phrase upon which they found the whole anxiety. We were told that the approval of the Minister meant nothing. When we got to the section and discussed taking out the phrase for which there is no excuse, that it meant nothing, there was no attempt to put up any argument. No attempt was made to do so. I say if it means nothing let it be removed. It clearly puts control in the Minister, and it is still there. If Section 10 is held still to encompass the University it gives the Minister power to interfere with individual salaries, and that being the case nobody can say there is not outrageous interference with the University. That is recognised everywhere as a lever by which a Government can enforce its will upon a teaching body. Because there is Government control of certain institutions in France the Catholics in France established a special Catholic institution; because of the same cause in Italy, the Catholics in Italy established a special institution there; and, because of the same control over the institution, the Catholic University at Georgetown was set up; because there was the same flaw in the proposals previously made here by the British Government, before the 1906 Act was passed, the hierarchy declared against the proposal put forward. That is now in this Bill, and merely to say that it is not intended, that there is an attempt to remove it does not get away from the original crime of introducing this thing without consultation with people with more knowledge of the matter, who could have given them warning about the danger.

There is no excuse now for ambiguity, to put it no higher than that. No Government is going to be accused of intent to take up that attitude towards a university body. The phrase always has got to be used: "Think of what some other Government with the same power might do." Think of it in that line, but let us assume that the present Government having this power, is not going to interfere, is not going to discriminate and is not going to pay attention to the doctrine taught. Is some other Government going to operate in the way we fear? How can it be denied? There is the possibility of the Government acting in that way when we know what happened in France, Italy, the United States, and previously in this country, and that not only were proposals made and institutions founded in which there was distinct control in the State in the subject matters of teaching, but that control made it impossible for Catholics in these countries to accept the institutions so founded. There is only one way to end this. Anxiety has been caused and it is still there. It is not asking too much of people that they should end this whole matter and put it beyond dispute for all time. No matter what we have blundered into at the beginning, here is rectification of the whole situation by taking the amendment notwithstanding anything done, so that nothing in this part of the section shall apply to the National University or any of its colleges. That puts the thing beyond dispute and that is what should be accepted.

Comment on this
The Attorney-General

I have already made an ineffectual effort against Deputy McGilligan's outlined amendment, in which he dealt with this matter as glibly as if the Bill had not been altered in the way it has been. He has made the suggestion that it takes a long time to dawn on me that there was some new argument in respect of the University. I should think if it was ever to dawn on his intelligence, that between the discussion of the last amendment and this one, there is nothing in his argument to show that the University is still captured by either Sections 10 or 12. I drew the Deputy's attention particularly to Section 13, which makes it quite clear that the method of dealing with the University is different from that set out in Sections 10 or 12. I am convinced that the Deputy knows he is quite wrong in his assertion, that the Bill can be said to affect the University.

Comment on this
Division

Amendment put.

Tá 34
·
Níl 50
Result Lost The question put was not agreed to.

Do you agree with this result?

In the course of his speech on the last amendment Deputy McGilligan, so far as I could hear clearly what he said, used in regard to myself an expression something in the following terms: "On this question of profits, the Minister is particularly vulnerable, so vulnerable that he should tread lightly, as lightly as if he were treading on egg-shells."

Comment on this

I did not say that.

Comment on this

Will the Deputy be good enough to repeat to the House what he did say?

Comment on this

I said that if hereafter the Minister decided to talk to me in relation to profits which I derived from the University, he should remember to walk delicately on that matter as if he were treading on egg-shells.

Comment on this

Now we have heard what the Deputy did say. I know no reason why, in regard to the University or anything else, I should tread lightly or speak delicately. If the Deputy does he should be good enough now to put before the House the reasons which led him to make that suggestion here, and in some way to impute to me something which was dishonourable or discreditable to me as Minister. If he does not, I think he should be asked to withdraw the statement.

Comment on this

Is this a point of order or what is it?

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Minister asked my permission to raise this matter. I gave him such permission as I understand, from the Deputy's words, that it was a reflection on the personal honesty of the Minister.

Comment on this

It was not by any means, and was never intended.

Comment on this

Why should it be a delicate matter to me unless it is a matter of which I have reason to be ashamed or one which I wish to be withheld from the public? I am not conscious that there is anything. I have no connection with the University. I am proud to say that there are associates and relatives and people who are very dear to me associated with the University, and I am certain that they have no reason to be ashamed of that association. The University has no reason to be ashamed of it either. If Deputy McGilligan wishes in the House to raise this matter, as he has raised it, by innuendo, I think at least he ought to be man enough to say plainly and bluntly what he does intend to convey to the House and to the public.

Comment on this

May I ask again is this a point of order or what is it?

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

I have explained to the Deputy that the Minister asked my permission to raise the matter of a reflection made on his personal honesty by the Deputy.

Comment on this

I did not make any such reflection.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Then the Deputy should state definitely that he meant no personal reflection.

Comment on this

I will not state any thing of the sort. That would convey the impression that I had done so. If the Minister is going to raise any point like that he ought to raise it in its context, and state what he said about me.

Comment on this

I did say in regard to the Deputy, if my recollection is right, that if his presence elsewhere brought as little profit to his clients as his presence here did to his constituents. It was a matter of regret——

Comment on this

That was a personal reflection on the Deputy.

Comment on this

I do not think so.

Comment on this

The Minister said a great deal more than that.

Comment on this
Mr. Rice

It was an offensive reflection.

Comment on this

I do not regard it as offensive because of where it comes from.

Comment on this

It is not a matter on which I should expect the Deputy to have any delicacy whatsoever.

Comment on this

I have not, seeing that the Minister said it.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Amendment 51. I take it the amendment is not being moved; that it is covered by amendment 5.

Comment on this

No. I intend moving amendments 51 and 52 and to discuss both together.

I move:—

51. In page 6, line 4, Section 13, to delete the words "in the current financial year" and substitute the words "in respect of that portion of the current financial year subsequent to the passing of this Act."

52. In page 6, line 5, to delete the word "five" and substitute the word "one."

Section 13, in the amended Bill, provides:—

Where a grant is made annually, under statute or otherwise, out of public moneys to a university or a university college, there shall be deducted from the amount of such grant which falls to be made in the current financial year such sum, not exceeding five per cent. of the amount of such grant, as the Minister shall determine.

It is proposed to amend the section by the insertion of the words set out in the two amendments. The situation we have reached with regard to the universities is this, that they are still capable of being open to attack under Sections 10 and 12. The Minister may decide that it is not politic, in certain circumstances, to use that power; that he may only use the power given here under Section 13. What is the power given under Section 13? To reduce the grant up to a maximum of five per cent. What is going to happen then? I suppose the Minister will tell me that he has washed his hands of them and that the universities can make ends meet as best they can. Now if cuts are going to be imposed I think this is a better way of doing it than what was proposed in Sections 10 and 12 originally. But the power taken under Sections 10 and 12 will still operate under this section in regard to the National University and its colleges. It is an indefensible proposal. If the grants are going to be cut by five per cent., then that means that the salaries in the colleges of the National University are going to be cut. There are other ways in which savings could be made. Savings could be made in expenditure on and upkeep of buildings. For the future there can be no putting aside of whatever little sums may have been put aside from time to time to equip buildings and rooms in buildings. That may mean that, for the future, students will not have the same amount of equipment at their disposal in the laboratories, or that they will have to pay more for breakages than they are paying at the moment. I doubt that even scratching out all these things and scratching out of them as much as possible that it is going to be open to the governing authorities of the National University and its colleges to refrain from imposing a cut on their staffs.

The moneys that were granted for the upkeep of buildings were always very meagre. Members of the staff of the National University in its early days, for the first 12 years after the buildings were erected, know well that it was almost the bodily heat of the professors and students that dried out the walls of the building. It was certainly notorious that the students used to congregate on the steps to get whatever there was of winter sun rather than stay in what were supposed to be centrally-heated class rooms. That was due to the small sums given for coal for heating the building in its early days when it was very damp. The sum allowed was so small that the building was only heated during a limited portion of the year, and then only for certain hours of the day during the portion of the year it was heated. Some of the grants have recently been increased, but the colleges have grown and the equipment of the students required is much more expensive than before. The moneys spent on equipment and laboratory material as well as the moneys spent yearly on breakages now far exceed what was spent in the old days of which I speak. From what I know from past experience of the University and its finances the reduction of the grant means that there is going to be a cut imposed on the members of the staff.

So far as I was concerned we were dealing during most of the day with the University as an institution and paying little attention to the personnel of the staff. Now university professors occupy a peculiar position in this country and one that should be adverted to. I made a distinction already between the civil servant and the business man, the business man who submits to the vicissitudes and changes of life, who takes the good when it comes and the bad when it comes. The civil servant, amongst others, opted for a life of more security but less chances of success. He did not find his emoluments increased when there was a boon, but he had the advantage of not in the main suffering when the slump came. That is changed now. As I said before, that old-time security has disappeared, and if it disappears once there will be further attempts made hereafter as and when times get worse.

The civil servant, at any rate, had this: that there were positions open to civil servants which they could get when they were fairly young, and, although they entered at very small salaries, they had increments, in the main, yearly; and there were some plums which a man might get after a fair number of years' service, but not by waiting until almost the end of their days before these prizes came within their grasp. At any rate, there was promotion outside the ordinary incremental advance made from time to time. Compare that with the case of the university professor. I think there is no doubt that it can be said with regard to those at the top of the civil service that they could earn more by their ability in the outside world but that they have been willing to forego that in return for security. Similarly with regard to university professors. It will be admitted that, as a whole, they are men of sufficient calibre that, if they had gone into outside posts and engaged in ordinary activities in the world, they would be in receipt of much greater salaries than they are getting at the moment. But they are distinguished from the civil servants in this way: that they do not, in the main, go into these positions young. They go into these positions, at the best, in early middle age, and ordinarily they go in in later middle age. They have no annual increment. They do not rise from year to year. They generally go into university posts from other teaching activities and there is no work so badly paid in this country as the ordinary teaching activity; and the man who enters into a post at late middle age has had very little opportunity of having savings put by before he gets that post, and he has a very small period of years as a professor in which he can make any savings against his later years for the education of his family and for anything in the way of dependency that there may be attaching to it.

There is a special case for these people, and they are specially singled out in this further way—that the number of university appointments in this country is very small indeed, and the competition for them is very great. Amongst an exceptionally clever group of people the men who get these posts are marked men so far as attainments go, and they have, in the main, succeeded in getting these appointments, of whatever type they may be, only in their later years when they have had no chance of saving and when they have a limited amount of time left to them in which to make up enough against their declining years. There is a pension fund attached to the University, or rather the college, of which I speak. But it is a very small thing. It is made up of deductions from the salaries of the professors from year to year, and the fund still suffers from the same disadvantage as the professors—the disadvantage to which I have referred in regard to the professors themselves. The moneys from which the fund is built up are deducted from the salaries of these men who have a limited period in which to draw these salaries. It is notorious about the three colleges—I have no pleasure in saying it—but I do not remember an occasion in my period in University College, Dublin, in which one of the professorial body died, that there had not to be some attempt on the part of their colleagues to assist their dependents. We take these men of exceptional ability, for whom there are very few posts, and who are doing good work, notwithstanding the criticisms of people who are appealing to the credulity of university electors, and we are going to cut the salaries of these people or, at least, to put them in the position that, if they cannot scratch out this money, which the Minister is going to take from them, by depriving the students of some of the advantages they should get in laboratories or else by putting a strain on their own health and the health of the students by cutting down the fuel, they have got to have their salaries cut. If that is the attitude of the present Government in relation to learning and the people who stand for learning in this country, they should stop the hypocrisy of pretending to the country that there is anything of liberalism in their composition.

I referred previously to the kind of traditions that this country had in relation to learning. There was a time when the institutions of a scholarly type that were here were attacked and when the professors of old were defeated in their emoluments and the positions they held. I have here a quotation from the Annals which talks of the special provision of Ireland as being the provision made outside religion for knowledge. The statement was that:—

"Every tribe maintained and rewarded its own poets, judges, historians, preceptors in law, music, or literature. In their hierarchy a king, a bishop, and an ollave, were the three most noble. They had the same ‘honour price' and the same rights of giving sanctuary. ‘According to the ordinance of science' no king could set anyone above an ollave, or chief professor of his branch of learning."

Then follows a list of things that were supposed to be due to him. There is a reference to the story told that, when one of the English Kings, Richard II, met certain of the Irish Kings, he objected to the custom they had of sitting down to table with their men of learning and insisted that a special and a lower type of table should be brought for these people, but the kings objected to this and "looking on each other refused to eat, saying they had been deprived of their old custom in which they had been brought up." Now, an Executive Council, which is acting on the calculation that it is not going to have any deductions by way of income tax or otherwise made in the salaries established for themselves, is going to cut the salaries of the ollaves in the country.

Comment on this

What Annals are you quoting?

Comment on this

I will not answer when I am addressed in that way.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Deputy McGilligan will continue.

Comment on this

I will not take much longer. There came a time when there was an attempt made, as an attempt is being made now, to cut down the moneys being paid to those people and there is one phrase here that I think should get currency. A variety of phrases was used by the scholars of the time when engaged on their manuscript work. One man wrote "A dinnerless Tuesday is a cold thing, Donall, and immediately before Christmas, too". Another wrote—and I hope this phrase will get currency too, because it is going to have peculiar application to this country very soon:—

"Here we are at Shrove-Monday: and in my opinion, James, the watercresses of starvation-land are hard fare."

That is what our professors are getting; that is what the whole country is getting, of course. The watercresses of starvation-land—that is the fare that we are going to mete out to a body of exceptionally qualified men and we are doing it just because the Minister for Education says that salaries have got to be reduced.

Comment on this

They have £800 a year and not the watercresses of starvation-land.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Order!

Comment on this

The Deputy is talking about the watercresses of starvation-land.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Order!

Comment on this

Let us get the comparison. There are many statements as to what were the rewards of art and letters in the old days.

Comment on this

£800 a year is not bad now.

Comment on this

The salary of £800 a year is just what strikes the Deputy. That is the mentality we are up against now.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

If the Deputy cannot restrain himself I shall have to take notice of his interruptions.

Comment on this

I kept quiet all day, sir.

Comment on this

To go back again to the Annals:

The rewards of art and letters were great.

The currency had changed.

Twenty cows was thought a fair price for a poem, and costly gifts were offered, jewelled goblets, horses and hawks, fine feather belts and spur-straps, and the like;

But even in those days there was a certain amount of forethought in regard to these men of learning.

but, cried the judicious bard, "without borders in which to maintain cattle, without a share of imperishable patrimonial soil, the very pick of thy treasure and of thy various gear is but all vanity to me!..."

They wanted security in those days, too. The imperishable patrimonial soil, something the Minister could not cut, was what they were looking for, and that they got in the later days. They thought professors in our days had security also, and civil servants thought they had security. Now they find they have not, and it comes to a question of whether they are going to be forced away from their secure positions. If they are so forced it is not by reason of any consideration of excess salaries paid to them, because that has not been argued. No question of excess salaries has come along here.

Again, I submit on this matter the case I have made in relation to other groups. Nobody has shown that there was any sitting down and calm thinking applied to the question of the attainments a man must have to get any of the posts to which I have referred, the money he gets and the work he does in return. In these particular instances there ought to be some regard paid to the dignity of the work, the character of the work, the people they are teaching and the benefit the country hopes to get eventually from the people whom they are teaching, if their teaching is what it should be. We just get again the little bit of pettiness that the Minister for Education was so free with to-day. Salaries have got to be reduced, and when salaries have got to be reduced we are not caring whether the previous salary was too small or too great. There is a salary there and the salary at the moment is the thing to be hacked, and we are going to hack these people as well as everybody else.

If the reduction in the grant to the extent of 5 per cent. is made, that will impose upon them the necessity for cutting the salaries of the professors. A reduction of 1 per cent. could be effected without doing much harm to the institution or the students, but if they make a reduction of 5 per cent. there is something to be taken off the salaries and, in the present situation, notwithstanding all I have spoken this day in relation to medical officers, veterinary surgeons or anyone else, no greater crime could be committed than making the cut apply in the case of the professors we have in the country at the moment in these university institutions.

Comment on this

I should like to say that if the House were to accept those two amendments, amendments 51 and 52, we would be committing an outrage on the principle of university autonomy, of which the Deputy professes to be a protagonist. I understand from the university representatives, with whom I have been in close touch for the last few months, that the provisions contained in Section 13 are the direct result of negotiations between the university and the Government and, therefore, they have been freely accepted by the university authorities as quite a satisfactory settlement of a difficult question. I do not think, when that agreement was arrived at between the university authorities and the Government, that we here have any right to impose any other interpretation.

Comment on this

It is easy to make an arrangement when you have a pistol at your head. Does the Deputy mean to say that was freely entered into?

Comment on this
Division

Question put: "That the words proposed to be deleted stand."

Tá 50
·
Níl 32
Result _

Do you agree with this result?

I move amendment 53:—

In page 6, in Part I of the Schedule, to delete in the tabular statement the following:—

4 per cent. per annum from the first £100 of the annual rate of salary.

Plus 5 per cent. per annum from the next £100 or part of £100 of the annual rate of salary.

Plus 6 per cent. per annum from the next £100 or part of £100 of the annual rate of salary.

Plus 7 per cent. per annum from the next £100 or part of £100 of the annual rate of salary. and substitute the following:—

"Where the annual rate of salary does not exceed £400—Nil. "Where the annual rate of salary exceeds £400."

The purpose of this amendment is to endeavour to secure that in the case of commissioned officers and chaplains in the forces of Saorstát Eireann there shall be no deduction in the salary where the salary does not exceed £400 per annum. It seems to me that, quite apart from financial considerations altogether, it is an extremely undesirable thing that reductions in salary should be inflicted on officers in the defence forces of Saorstát Eireann. One finds it difficult to understand the justification for cutting these salaries, except, as was often said during this debate, that they are convenient to the hands of the Minister. They are within the range of his axe. They are suffering this cut because the Minister does not want to take other and more sensible methods of raising the necessary funds to balance his Budget. That is why he proposes to inflict very severe salary reductions on officers in the defence forces of the State who come under his axe. There are also deductions on chaplains to the defence forces. Looking over the Estimates I find that in the case of chaplains they are paid a rate for part-time services, I presume, varying from £30 to £130 per annum. That low rate of salary is paid to chaplains.

I would say at once that our Army officers are paid a rate of salary lower than that paid in any other army in Europe. When you consider that a lieutenant in the Army gets a salary approximating to £4 10s. a week; when you consider that he is obliged by the Army regulations to conform to certain social standards; when you consider that he is prohibited from frequenting certain parts of the house in cinemas and theatres; when you consider that he is obliged to keep out of the path of the common people, and generally to behave as if he were well endowed with money, one wonders how it is expected that such an officer could live on his pay as an officer in the defence forces of the State, maintain a decent social standard, pay his way, and support his wife and children in decency. Yet that is the kind of one which is singled out for attack in this Bill.

Comment on this

Do I understand the Deputy to say that it is lower than every other army in Europe for lieutenants?

Comment on this

I said our Army officers.

Comment on this

It does not apply to this particular grade.

Comment on this

Perhaps not in one or two countries, but I would say in respect of this country that we do not want, at all events, to see going into the defence forces of the State exclusively the kind of people that go into the defence forces of other States. If we take our next-door neighbour as an example, many of the people who go into the Army in Great Britain are well-to-do financially. Many of them have parents of considerable social prominence, and many are well endowed with this world's goods. Our Army is, in the main, a working-class Army—an Army of working-class people who, in other years, one might meet earning their daily bread with the sweat of their brow. It is because we have excellent officers, and because they are obliged to depend exclusively on the salary which they receive as members of the army, that we ought to ensure that the salary is adequate, that it is a decent salary, and such as will relieve the members of our defence forces from the constant anxiety of wondering how they will pay their debts and conform to the high social standard set forth in the military regulations.

I regard this section, and I regard Part II, Part III, Part IV and Part V as a very definite tearing up by the Fianna Fáil Government of the promises upon which they secured the votes of the people at the last and previous general election. In February, 1932, we had the President's statement at the Rathmines Town Hall. We must remember that Rathmines, which is in the Minister for Finance's constituency, was selected as the venue for this oration by the President. I am perfectly satisfied that it was no stray oration by the President; that it was no accidental curtain by the President. The President went to the Rathmines Town Hall to make a very definite statement in the centre of a constituency where it is well known that civil servants and many other people affected by this Bill reside. I am not suggesting that he was brought there specially by the Minister for Finance, but I would have no hesitation in saying that when the speech was reported in the Press next morning the Minister had added a few more thousands on to the No. 1 votes got in that district. The Minister knew that that trick out of the bag of political tricks would work well in Rathmines and resound over the County Dublin. The President's declaration was not sufficient. The Fianna Fáil Party published, not merely in its own newspaper, but in other newspapers, a declaration over the signature of the President, and this is the contract which the public servants of the country have with this Government, if one is to regard public declarations made in this manner as binding upon a Government once a Government is elected. Before I quote that, I want to quote the words and figures of the President in the Rathmines Town Hall. He said that persons in receipt of salaries of £300 or £400 per year were getting nothing excessive. £300 or £400 per year was not excessive, according to the statement in the Town Hall, Rathmines, on 1st February, 1932, in advance of the general election of that year. Nine days later there was, apparently, still no case for reducing these salaries, because over his own signature, and very likely written by himself, the President declared: "We do not propose to seek economies by restricting the social services or by cutting the salaries of the middle and lower grade civil servants. These salaries"—obviously the £300 or £400 that the President referred to nine days previously—"are in most cases barely sufficient to meet the costs of the maintenance of a home and the support and education of children." Notwithstanding these wise words from the President, we now find that the Government has completely somersaulted in its outlook on the salaries of public servants. £300 or £400 per annum was barely sufficient to meet the costs of maintenance of a home and the support and education of children. Yet to-day, in this Bill, the Fianna Fáil Party are trooping into the Division Lobby against the very declaration made by the President in February, 1932. Under this Bill we are cutting the salaries which the President said, in February, 1932, were barely sufficient to meet the costs of maintenance of a home and the support and education of children.

Right through this whole discussion there has been no attempt to justify the tearing up of that solemn declaration by the President, the tearing up of that bargain which public servants of the country regarded as something binding on them, on the one hand, and the Government on the other. The only one justification we have had for this until to-day was that it was necessary to do this in order to feed the poor and lowly. It came out much more frankly to-day when the Minister for Education said that this is frankly a Bill to cut salaries. A Bill to cut salaries, without any trimming, said the Minister for Education! To feed the poor and lowly, said the Minister for Finance, in an earlier declaration. You may deprive the poor and lowly of this country of food and physical nourishment, but you cannot deprive them of their intelligence. There is not a poor man or a poor woman, or a lowly man or a lowly woman, who does not know that a statement of that kind made by the Minister for Finance is the merest claptrap and dope. Everybody knows that the poor and lowly are going to get nothing whatever out of cutting salaries in this manner. What will happen is that the purchasing power in respect of these people will be contracted. What he saves by contracting their purchasing power, and what he takes out of the pockets of these people, the Minister says he is going to hand out to the poor and lowly. If the Minister imagines that he is discharging his social responsibility, and that the full sunlight of his Christian social policy will be let in on the people when they get the quarter of a million taken out of the pockets of these people, in defiance of a moral contract with the Government, the Minister misjudges the intelligence of the people, even though he may have some appreciation of their physical necessities.

This part of the Bill is unjustified. It is particularly unjustified in respect of the members of our defence forces. Our commissioned officers, as I said, come from the plain people of the country. They are all ordinary working-class people who donned the uniform as a means of livelihood, in the same way as a carpenter, perhaps, will wear his overall when he goes to his work. We ought to make sure, if we are going to have an Army, that it is a decently paid Army, and, in any case, we ought not to expose ourselves to the odium of maintaining an Army and, at the same time, not paying decent rates of wages to those whom we are prepared to call upon at all times, not merely to give their energy to the nation, but if necessary to risk their lives in its defence.

Comment on this

I rise to support Deputy Norton's very able appeal on behalf of the army officers. Anybody associated with an army knows that if they are financially worried or if distressful conditions are imposed on such officers the whole organisation suffers.

During the Great War one of the big difficulties which the British Government and the War Office had to face was the demoralisation that was setting in amongst the second-lieutenants. What was the cause of it? After inquiry it was discovered that it was the bad pay they were getting which brought about the demoralisation. There is not the slightest doubt whatever that if the army officers of Saorstát Eireann are to be reduced to a lower standard the whole social position will suffer. As I have passed through the Curragh on many occasions, and have seen the spendid way in which they turn out, and the splendid manner in which they uphold the national dignity of this country, I feel that I would be lacking in my duty to this House if I did not stand up here to-night and make the strongest possible appeal that they be not brought under this cut. I have made an appeal on behalf of every single profession, but the Army particularly is dear to me. I strongly support Deputy Norton that even at this eleventh hour something should be done to give them security of tenure, and make them, what we would all like to see them, the finest and the best Army in the whole world.

Comment on this

This is a matter, sir, on which I already spoke. I then suggested that the whole Army ought to be excluded from the operation of this Bill. I still think that is the proper line, and I am sure Deputy Norton quite agrees with me.

Comment on this

I put down an amendment on it.

Comment on this

Quite so. I think that we both had an amendment on this particular line. I am now supporting this amendment because it is the second best, and not because I think it is the most desirable in itself. In addition to the circumstances which I am very glad Deputy Norton reiterated—one of them particularly—when he made a contrast with other countries, I had occasion to point out that not merely have we a lower standard of pay here than in any other country with which most people are familiar, but in that particular country many of the officers have private sources of revenue. That is not the case here, and we demand in many respects that they keep up the same standard of life. We take steps to see that they have not the same pay, but we make the same demands on them. That is not fair. There is another reason which I think should not be lost sight of, and it is this: as was pointed out already, the officers here, even those holding senior positions, are all young men, owing to the fact that our army has only recently been established. The chances of promotion are accordingly very slight, comparatively speaking. That is all the more reason, I suggest, for the House to accept this amendment. Deputy Norton referred to various promises made during the elections. There are many simple people in this country, and I have not the slightest doubt that those promises and speeches were effective in the main purpose they had in view. They did take in a large number of simple people. The figure of £400 has been mentioned. I gather that the Treasury expect to save, roughly speaking, about £280,000. Has anybody asked himself how much of that is going to come out of salaries under £400? By far the greater bulk of the saving will come from precisely the same people to whom protection was promised. Take the national teachers, for instance. The great bulk of the saving is to come from them, and the great bulk of them have salaries under £400. You have, therefore, a gross violation of promises. We have here, and the present Government has tested it, an Army that has shown itself loyal to this State no matter what Government is in power, and it is an insult that they should now be treated in this way by the Government.

Comment on this

There is just one point which has not been mentioned in connection with this Schedule, and that is that a commissioned officer in receipt of £100 a year is subject to a reduction of £4 per annum. That does not happen in any of the other Schedules, and it is an extraordinary thing that a person with a little over 35/- a week is suffering a reduction. The Army is singled out to suffer in this way, and it falls heavily upon people with such a small salary. Certainly no case has been made for it, and we might hear some reason for the reduction.

Comment on this

I did not intend to intervene but for the ridiculous point which has been made by Deputy Cosgrave. There is not in the Army any officer who, when his allowances are taken into account, has less than £300 a year.

Comment on this

Why put it down then?

Comment on this

The scale has merely been put forward in order to ensure that equal deductions would be made in the Army scales of pay.

Comment on this

The words of the Schedule are: "Where the annual rate of salary does not exceed £100—4 per cent. per annum of the salary."

Comment on this

Deputy Cosgrave had much longer contact with the Army than I have had, and he had many more opportunities of studying the Army. If he had really given it the consideration which he wishes to induce this House to believe he gave it he certainly would not have got up here and made the foolish and futile point which he has made. I again repeat that when allowances are taken into consideration there is no Army officer, as far as I know, who has less than £300 a year.

Comment on this

Then what is the meaning of that sentence?

Comment on this

Superabundant caution!

Comment on this

I think it is most unfair to this House, and certainly requires some explanation, that the Minister, having introduced a Bill the Schedule to which contains these words: "Where the annual salary does not exceed £100—4 per cent. per annum of the salary," now gets up and tells us——

Comment on this

Before the Deputy makes as foolish a statement as I think he is going to, may I point out that no officer——

Comment on this

With great respect, I am in possession, and unless the Minister is raising a point of order he is not entitled to intervene. The Minister now comes into this House with the absolutely ridiculous statement that there is no person to whom this Bill will apply whose salary is less than £300 a year, and yet he introduced a Bill which has these words in it: "Where the annual salary does not exceed £100—4 per cent. per annum of the salary." What is his explanation? "I wanted it to look nice and to look very much like the other cuts." What way is that to treat the House and the country? In other words the Minister gets up and informs us that he has introduced a Bill in which there is absolutely sheer nonsense.

Comment on this

Oh, no.

Comment on this

That is the position he has taken up on the last amendment.

Comment on this

There are chaplains attached at present.

Comment on this

And you are going to cut them.

Comment on this

The House has decided that.

Comment on this

Now we completely understand the Minister's mentality. I would much prefer—and in this case I can be very, very charitable—I would much prefer to attribute it to the Minister's complete ignorance of the Bill, rather than a deliberate attempt to deceive the House. Here there are persons in receipt of 35/- per week.

Comment on this

But not officers.

Comment on this

And from them this amount of 4 per cent. is to be deducted. A good deal was said to-night about Fianna Fáil promises. The whole country must now perfectly well understand what Fianna Fáil promises are. This Schedule, and everything else going through this Bill, makes it perfectly clear that the Fianna Fáil Party considers that it is entitled, at any time it likes, to turn round and say, as they said to-night in substance, that their election promises were made in order to deceive. They have deceived, and done their work, and now they are flung aside. For years the Fianna Fáil Party have made it clear to the country that such a thing as honour they have not, and they have made it clear that the binding force of the Ten Commandments is a matter of no importance.

Comment on this

I think it is iniquitous that the Minister should make a statement such as he has just made. In anticipation of what Deputy Fitzgerald-Kenney was about to say the Minister interpolated the insulting remark that Deputy Fitzgerald-Kenney was about to make a fool of himself. These are not the exact words, but that was the insinuation. The Minister himself has attempted deliberately to deceive this House on that question, when he said that £100 a year did not apply to anybody.

Comment on this

No, I said to officers. Officers was the word I used.

Comment on this

The Minister attempted to conceal the fact from this House that there was any such position as an officer receiving £100 a year. He knew there were chaplains receiving £100 a year, and these were to be cut without informing the House. And this is the Minister who has the audacity to say that an ex-Minister was about to make a fool of himself. I say this is trifling with the House. I say if anybody made a fool of himself, or deceived the House, it was the Minister himself.

Comment on this
Division

The Dáil divided: Tá,

Tá 49
·
Níl 32
Result Carried The question put was agreed to.

Do you agree with this result?

I move amendment No. 54:—

In page 6, in Part II of the Schedule, to delete that part of the tabular statement dealing with the rates of deductions from salaries of unmarried Gárda, married Gárda, unmarried sergeant, married sergeant, unmarried station-sergeant, married station-sergeant.

The purpose of this amendment is to secure the exemption from any cut of Gárdai, sergeants and station-sergeants. This amendment was the centre of a debate on the motion to delete the members of the Gárda Síochána from Section 6 of the Bill, and it probably is not necessary to travel very far over the ground, but I might say to the Minister that precisely the same case as was made for the previous amendment can be made for this amendment. Here is a body of people in a wage-earning category, and it is sought in this Bill to single them out for special attack and, as I said to the Minister on Committee Stage, the action of the Minister in slashing wages amounting to £3 per week is an event which will not go unnoticed by the employing community in this country. The Minister, the last day, expressed astonishment in the way only the Minister can express astonishment, finishing on a very high note, that any responsible Deputy could possibly challenge the morality or economic justification of the Government cutting a salary of £160 per annum in the case of a person, to quote his own words, living in the circumstances of an unmarried guard. That, of course, if it means anything, means that a single tradesman ought to be singled out for attack. It means, of course, that we have a declaration from the Minister and a headline for private employers in the country, that £160 per annum for a single person is something that, if cut, nevertheless leaves a person as much as he is entitled to from this Government, and, presumably, as much as this Government thinks he is entitled to.

On the last day the Minister made a lot of play with the statement that nobody with less than £3 4s. per week would be cut under this Bill. I made inquiries in the meantime, and I find that, on that occasion, the Minister exaggerated the figure he used. In any case, here is the plain position in the case of an ordinary Civic Guard who reaches a maximum weekly wage of £4 3s. per week, he reaches that figure only after 22 years' service. Assuming that a guard enters the service of the State at the age of 20 years, he will be 42 years of age before he gets the normal maximum of 83/- per week, and, after that 22 years' service, he will not get even that normal maximum of 83/-, because he is singled out for attack in this Bill. I do not think it is a wise proceeding for the State to underpay its police force. Our police force is not merely normally paid less than the police force in Great Britain and the Six Counties, but, here in this Bill, it is sought even to pay them still worse, and that is the attitude that apparently the Minister is attempting to defend in this House. In my opinion, it is very bad business for the State to underpay its police force. Underpaid police officers are not good police officers and can never be good police officers. Underpaid police officers are subject to all kinds of temptation, and if they are compelled, through economic necessity, to succumb to that temptation, there is a very serious risk of the integrity of the whole force being undermined.

It has been the accepted policy of the Government that, in order to free the police officer from certain financial liabilities, and in order to avoid any exposure to certain other kinds of vices, he ought to be paid a decent salary. Here, apparently, the State is proceeding on the assumption to squeeze the police officer down to the lowest possible figure. Every time you are in financial difficulty, try to squeeze the police again. I tell the Minister definitely that while he may imagine that, in one respect, he saves the pay of the guards, I think that what he saves in that respect he will lose in efficiency, and there is grave danger that continued economic pressure on the Gárda may produce in this country, through sheer economic necessity, the evils which have been produced in another well-know country through the same cause.

Comment on this

I rise to oppose this cut in the pay of the Gárda Síochána and to support Deputy Norton. Everybody knows that, in the country towns particularly, the Gárda Síochána contribute to every single charitable object during the course of the year. They have to participate in the local social life of the station, wherever it may be, and it is deplorable that we should come now and lower them to the position which Deputy Norton referred to, in which they are open to corruption and will, probably, lose the dignity which the force has upheld. It seems to be monotonous to be getting up here time and again and putting forward arguments here. The Minister is absolutely silent. We make the strongest appeals on the different amendments, as they come before the House, and we are met with nothing but silence. We can do no more than protest. The machinery of legislation beats us in the Division Lobby. One thing we are doing is making a strong fight for those who cannot come in here and defend themselves. I hope that even at the 11¾th hour something may happen to nullify this onslaught of wage-cutting and salary-cutting in the case of the Gárda, the army and other professional classes.

Comment on this

I feel obliged to support this amendment by Deputy Norton on the ground that the Gárda Síochána have got such extraordinarily difficult duties to perform owing to the special circumstances that prevail in this country at present and on the grounds that so much has already been done to provoke discouragement and despondency in their ranks. I am very loath to oppose any part of the Economy Bill on the general ground that it is due to the farmers to spread the sacrifices due to the economic war amongst all classes of the community. But I feel that the farmers, many of whom are poor men living in isolated districts, have a very special interest in seeing that the Civic Guard be kept efficient and contented. They have very difficult conditions to contend with owing to what I conceive to be the very mischievous general policy of the Government. I do not think that we can afford to try the Civic Guard any more severely than we have already tried them and are trying them as a result of recent events.

Comment on this

I am supporting—and supporting wholeheartedly—this amendment. It does not go quite so far—it deals only with a certain class of Guards—as the amendment which stood in my name which has already been dealt with.

Comment on this

Or mine.

Comment on this

I am referring at the moment to my own views rather than to those of Deputy Norton, though on this matter our views entirely coincide. We were told some time ago that the object of this Bill was to make savings for the State. The Minister told us that, having wrung every single farthing out of the taxpayers' pocket, having exhausted every possible source of revenue, he was driven to make cuts in the salaries of persons who, admittedly, were not overpaid. I must here deal for a moment with one thing that Deputy MacDermot said. Deputy MacDermot said a few moments ago that since the farmers were bearing losses every other class of the community should bear losses. Deputy MacDermot does not seem to be aware that every other class of the community is not bearing losses. A clerk or servant employed by a private company or by a bank is not suffering any loss. His salary is not being reduced.

Comment on this

He will probably lose his employment.

Comment on this

There are persons employed by private individuals and by public companies at salaries far greater than any civil servant gets and these persons—

Comment on this

Might I put it to the Deputy that large numbers of these people are losing employment.

Comment on this

I am perfectly aware that a considerable number of people are losing employment, but those who are being kept in employment are not having their rates of pay reduced in the slightest. This is not a measure which is saving money for the farmers. So far as it is saving money, it is saving it in order that the Government may have ammunition that they can fire off against the farmers for the destruction of the farmers' interests. That is what this Bill does. This afternoon, we had a new departure—a change of front. Another Minister, not so guarded in his utterances, came in and he let us know what the whole of this matter was about. It is not a Bill to effect economies. It is a Bill to effect cuts. It is not because the State wants the money that they are taking £33,000 from the whole of the Guards or a considerably lesser sum from the sergeants and men of the Gárda. That is not the main object of the Bill. The main object of the Bill is wantonly to deprive these men of portion of their pay, wantonly to lower their pay. That is the position in which the Bill stands at the present.

If there is one thing—I have said this on many occasions in this House, but I take advantage of this Bill to repeat it—necessary to any State, it is a thoroughly efficient and contented police force. That is necessary to every State. It is more necessary to this State than it is to most States and it is more necessary to this State at the present time than it has been at any time since the State came into existence. This is not the time at which an attack should be made in any shape or form upon the salaries of the Guards. They have more than police work to perform. They have a great number of other duties to perform. They are saving thousands of pounds to the State by doing work which would otherwise have to be done by inspectors specially appointed. They are doing a tremendous amount of work besides their police work and they are carrying on their police work in face of greater difficulties than they have ever had to face. We know that, at the present moment, the Guards can see offences against the law being committed and that they are powerless to intervene. Men may drill. Men may go out with machine guns. Men may practise as much as they like and the unfortunate Guards, endeavouring to keep the peace, can merely stand by and look on. Their difficulties are becoming greater and greater every day. The call which the country is making on them is greater and greater, and the exertions which they have to put forward are daily becoming greater and greater. It is under these circumstances that this House should show it is solidly behind the Guards, that it is fully determined to show the Guards they have got the sympathies of this House behind them in carrying out their duties.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

In respect to their pay. We cannot discuss them otherwise.

Comment on this

Quite so. But the House will not show that if it does not say to them: "You are at the present time face to face with tremendous difficulties." This is just the time, in which we are under a debt of national necessity to them, that, for the sake of making a cut, their pay is cut down. That, as we have been told by the Minister for Education, is the main object of this Bill. This amendment does not go far enough, as it is confined merely to sergeants and Guards. It does not touch the officers or the inspectors.

In my opinion, there should be no cut in pay for any class of Guard, whether officer, inspector or sergeant. Since it does go a certain way, since it does help the sergeant and the unmarried Guards I intend to give it my whole-hearted support.

Comment on this

I would have elected to have spoken on the subject of the cuts in the payment of the Guards at a much earlier stage of the Bill, but, for reasons which I have already explained, I was unable to do. At this late hour very little time remains, so that I will confine my remarks to one or two observations. Deputy MacDermot's reason for his exceptional support of the clause in this Bill was grossly unfair to the farmers. He based it on the thoroughly selfish reason that the farmers have a very special interest in seeing that there is a contented police force, in order that they will have some measure of protection. It was only because they have that selfish interest, that he and his Party will support an amendment designed to protest, if not to secure some measure of justice for the Guards. The farmers of this country have a better reason for supporting this amendment than a thoroughly selfish reason. They have two primary reasons for doing so. In the first place, the Guards, officers and men, are largely recruited from the sons of small farmers, and I should say that it would be of very special interest to the fathers of these men to see that they are not made the victims of the Minister's axe, victims, not for the purpose of economy, or for the purpose of helping them in their struggles for economy, but for the purpose of carrying out, or pretending to carry out, election promises, and to cut for cut's sake. They have a better reason than that for protesting against cutting the pay of the Guards. The reason is that this country cannot afford these economies. I pointed out on another section that this country cannot afford the economies alleged to be contained in the Bill. The whole social structure in this State depends upon the impartial administration of justice, and the impartial administration of justice in its ultimate analysis depends on the proper conduct of the Guards "on beat," and finally, on having a proper type of Guard doing that duty, and doing it for the State and for the citizens of the State. The lives, the liberty and the property of the people of this State depend upon the impartial performance of their duties by the Guards. We have every reason to be proud of the way the Guards have performed their duties in the past, and it is poor recompense to them for the services they have given, that these cuts in pay are being imposed. The House should remember this: Deputy Norton has put forward the plea against these cuts from the point of view of a Labour representative, that it is setting a headline for employers. It has a deeper significance than Deputy Norton thinks, because the pay of the Guards has been related, so far as it has been related to anything, to the pay of labourers and the pay of unskilled workers, when in fact, the humblest Guard "on beat" should be related really to the skilled craftsman, as he cannot be turned out on the street to do duty by merely putting a uniform on his back. He has to go through a specialised course of instruction. He was expected by the last Government, and by this Government, to devote his leisure time to improving himself, and in particular improving his knowledge of the Irish language. It must be remembered also that from the ordinary ranks of the Guards are recruited the officer ranks. A man must have been a Guard before he can become an officer, and must go through the ordinary routine of a Guard in the street. That means that you must get men of a good type and with a fairly good education for the Force. If you are going to subject them to cuts in pay, if you are going to subject them to being political puppets in a political campaign, as in the last few elections, you are not going to get the proper type of men in the Civic Guards. If you do not get the proper type of men you will not have impartial administration of justice between man and man.

You will not have men in the Guards who will stand fairly in the courts of justice, in criminal courts particularly, between the State and the prisoner.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

I do not think it is right to say that the Civic Guards are the puppets of political parties, or were the puppets of political parties in any general election.

Comment on this

I stand corrected. What I intended to convey was that in the propaganda of the last two elections of certain political Parties, the cut in the pay of the Civic Guards was made one of the points in their political programme. I think the Guards, being deprived of votes, should be left outside politics. That is a point I wish to make. It is time for all political parties to recognise that. This cut in the pay of the Guards is one of the greatest sins in this Bill. It cuts deep down to the fundamentals of sound State policy and I protest against it, not on selfish principles, but because I think it is being subjected to a political test.

Comment on this

I would not intervene in this debate were it not for the remarks of Deputy Costello. This Party is supporting this amendment, but not for the reason the Deputy suggested, simply because the Guards have been recruited from the agricultural community. That is not so. The farmers have a special interest in the Guards.

Comment on this

I quoted the Deputy's leader.

Comment on this

I took a note of the words used by Deputy Costello.

Comment on this

What words of mine were quoted by Deputy Costello?

Comment on this

That the farmers have a very special interest in having a proper force of Guards.

Comment on this

That is perfectly true, but that does not imply that I have only a selfish interest.

Comment on this

I have taken down Deputy Costello's words and I can say that he made use of these words. We are not supporting this amendment or standing over it because the Guards have been recruited from our people. We stand over the amendment because the Guards are the one body in this State that we recognise have done very useful service. I know that if they were living on their fathers' farms at the moment they would not be able to get 50/- or 7/- a week or whatever rate of wages they have. Their wages would be nil but at the same time they are doing very useful service. They are a clean body standing for law and order against any individual or body of individuals. Because we recognise that we are here to support the amendment.

Comment on this

Is the Army not a clean and efficient body?

Comment on this

I am not dealing with the Army now. I am dealing with the Guards and I am supporting this amendment.

Comment on this

It would be a good thing to get clear, although it is only an incident, why Deputy MacDermot on behalf of the Farmers' Party intends to support this amendment. I understood that his remarks to-night, if not exactly phrased as before, followed along the lines of a previous statement of his. He had previously stated in the House that the Government were either under the guardianship or the sway of the I.R.A. and that Cumann na nGaedheal had got something in the way of protection from the A.C.A. while the people whom he had the good fortune or misfortune, if you like, to represent, had nobody to look to but the police.

Comment on this

I did not say that to-night but that is quite proper.

Comment on this

What was said to-night was the follow-on of that.

Comment on this

No it had no bearing on that. It was an interlude.

Comment on this

At any rate, there is some reason why Deputy MacDermot should be supporting this. I had understood it to be that the farmers in the country wanted protection and that the farmers hereafter would be looking still more for protection and that the only protection they could get—this is how his thought ran—was from the Guards and therefore we must have a contented Gárda Force. I think that is a fair statement of what he said.

Comment on this

That is one reason.

Comment on this

That is one reason, the reason on which Deputy Costello commented and Deputy O'Donovan criticised Deputy Costello for so commenting on the phrase used.

Comment on this

What phrase?

Comment on this

The phrase upon which Deputy Costello has commented and the thought is there in Deputy MacDermot's mind, whether expressed or not, that what he is looking to is that the Guards must be a well-satisfied force because the farmers need protection. I support him in that. Everybody in the country needs protection.

Comment on this

On a point of explanation, what Deputy Costello said was that we had a special interest in the Guards because the Guards were recruited from the agricultural community. That is not the reason we are standing for this amendment.

Comment on this

Deputy Costello did not say that that was Deputy MacDermot's point of view but he said that it should have been. He said that was the reason which Deputy MacDermot should have adduced but which he has not adduced.

Comment on this

That would be a still more selfish reason.

Comment on this

Possibly but the whole thing is a combination of various types of selfishness. Every argument used here is really based on selfishness.

Comment on this

We are not discussing it from that point of view.

Comment on this

I also think it is necessary to have a contented police force in the country. I do not care who is looking for protection, whether it be the farmers or anybody else. I think that what Deputy Costello said was quite to the point, that if the police forces are not going to be contented, are going to become discontented by reason of the frequent attacks made upon them, by reason of the fact that they are apparently getting contrary orders in regard to the carrying out of their duties, by reason of the fact that there is no certainty of the treatment which will be given them if they do carry out their duties, and if, on top of all that, their salaries are going to be cut—in all these circumstances it can hardly be expected that the police, being a human body, will behave between man and man with that impartiality which up to the present they have shown. It is very hard to ask these people, in all these varying circumstances of contrariety, not knowing where they are, with this lack of certainty in their position, and now with an attack upon their livelihood, to behave with the old impartiality and with the old zest for their duty which they had previously shown.

I want again to refer to some statements of the Fianna Fáil Party in regard to cuts in the Guards' pay. I do not see any of the more famous economists of the Party now present. I want to repeat again that Deputy Briscoe said that "because Fianna Fáil had opposed the Government attitude on the question of the Gárda reduction the Gárda reduction had not been enforced. That was the Fianna Fáil attitude as expressed by Deputy Briscoe on the 19th January, 1932. Deputy Cooney, speaking in Grangegorman, said that "the Fianna Fáil administrative programme included the saving of two millions on the Army and half a million on the Civic Guard, and that, with the savings that could be effected on other overpaid Departments, would be put into productive industry." In this way, he said, they had come to the conclusion that they could solve the unemployment problem in 12 months. In the opinion of Deputy Cooney this saving of half a million on the Civic Guards was to be done without inflicting any hardship on the force.

Comment on this

You have the wrong Minister for Finance.

Comment on this

Deputy Briscoe thought that the intervention of the Fianna Fáil Party had saved the reduction in the Gárda pay, but let us leave these lesser lights. The present Minister for Industry and Commerce had something to say in reference to this matter. Referring to the reduction in teachers' salaries and in the pay of the Gárda, he said there were 101 avenues in which economies could be effected without inflicting hardship on anybody, and that the reduction of the Gárda remuneration—in this he shares Deputy MacDermot's views— was unwise, because it was obviously desirable that in any country they should have guardians of law and order who were adequately remunerated. He said further that the cuts were unfair, because there were 101 other ways in which economies could be effected without inflicting hardship. Why should we not have a little committee consisting of Deputy Briscoe, Deputy Cooney and the Minister for Industry and Commerce, and let us get an idea from them of the manner in which these economies could be effected without inflicting hardship on anybody, because, remember, the Minister for Industry and Commerce considered it was a hardship to cut the remuneration of the Gárda? There should be some appreciation on the part of the Ministry that that type of phrase as used by them got them power. They staked their whole case on being able to effect economies without cutting the salaries of the Guards. Have they anything to say now in their own defence when they are asked the question why these cuts are necessary? We are told at one time that it is because of the economic war, and Deputy MacDermot agrees with that. We are told on another occasion that the economic war has nothing to do with it. There is a denial when one reminds the Ministry that they used to flaunt the salaries of various people, including some of the Guards, on their election posters, and we are told that there is no definite policy on the part of the present Executive to cut salaries. After that had been stated in the House, the Minister for Education to-day admitted that this is not a Bill to effect economies. The Minister boldly confesses that it is a Bill to effect cuts for the sake of cutting. It is on that, I think, Deputy Norton is founding his main objection to these cuts.

It is a reduction of salaries that is aimed at. It is not economies that are to be effected, but with the resulting savings we are going to get cuts made and enforced. I think that is what rightly excites the apprehensions of Deputy Norton. In the case of a Guard with a salary of a little over £3 a week we are going to get some reduction made. Surely that must immediately bring to the minds of employers of unskilled labour in this city and throughout the country the thought that if a Guard, with whatever training and experience he has had to fit him for his work, and at present earning something like £3 a week can be cut by the Government, which is supposed to be the best employer, then individual employers will proceed to hack at the wages paid at the moment, and once a salary grows, the more incentive there is to get a bit knocked off it. Undoubtedly there is going to be a little bit of a model set here to employers through the country. They will have the same excuse as Deputy MacDermot would give with regard to every other cut for which he has voted to-day: that it is necessary to spread the burden of the economic war. I often wonder, when we speak of the burden of the economic war, what frame of mind we are drifting into in regard to it. We do not like people to celebrate the victory, and yet we are told——

Comment on this

On a point of order. I note that on the Committee Stage on amendment 27 we disposed of the question as to whether we were going to make any deduction from the remuneration of the Gárda Síochána. The Deputy is now confining his speech entirely to that question, as to whether a cut should be imposed on them or not, though the matter was settled in Committee.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

This amendment deals with the rates of deductions.

Comment on this

And the rates will have to bear some relation to the circumstances in which the cut is being enforced. If the effects of the economic war were just about half as beneficial as they are we might only have to cut by half, but why are we cutting to this extent?

Comment on this

I would again draw the attention of the Chair to the terms of the amendment we are now discussing. "In page 6, in Part II of the Schedule, to delete that part of the tabular statement dealing with the rates of deductions from salaries of unmarried gárda, married gárda, unmarried sergeant, married sergeant, unmarried station sergeant, married station sergeant." The purpose of the amendment is to rescind a decision which has already been given by the House on amendment 27 in Committee. Accordingly, I do not think the Deputy is entitled to discuss the question of rates at all. I think the discussion so far has been very largely out of order.

Comment on this
Deputies

Oh!

Comment on this

It is very delicate on the part of the Minister to suggest that the discussion has been largely out of order.

Comment on this

I do not think it could be avoided.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

Deputies, of course, should confine themselves to what is before them, that is the rates of deductions from the salaries of certain members of the Gárda Síochána as set out.

Comment on this

I am directing myself, I think, entirely to the point to which you have referred. This is an amendment to delete portion of a certain tabular statement.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

Dealing with rates of deductions.

Comment on this

And I am speaking in support of an amendment in the name of Deputy Norton and others that a certain tabular statement dealing with rates of deductions should be deleted; in other words that these deductions should not be taken from the people who are mentioned in the amendment. That is the topic I am discussing, and in discussing it I am referring to the reasons we were given for having deductions at all, and particularly for having these deductions. I was saying that Deputy MacDermot introduced the matter of the burden that various people have to bear: the repercussions on this country of the economic war and of the necessity that came from that to keep the reductions in force against the people in regard to whom we propose an exemption. I would like to get the full effect of the present circumstances—how these circumstances will be changed by the acceptance of this amendment—considered. What saving is going to be achieved by this amendment? How much does it come to in the year? How much of the £280,000 will not be secured to the Government if this amendment is accepted? What fraction of the brunt of the economic war will have to be borne by somebody else if not borne by those people referred to in the amendment? I will put the matter in another way. Why are these people to be deprived of the fruits of victory in regard to the economic war? We have got all the moneys that we looked to to get out of it. We are building up a new economic war situation in the country. Deputy MacDermot said to-night, with a great deal of brazenness I thought, that he knew a considerable number of people who were losing their employment. Has he ever heard the Minister for Industry and Commerce talk on that subject? Does he not know that the figures of unemployment are going down at the rate of nearly 2,000 or 3,000 a week? For one week in the neighbourhood of Athlone we got the figure of 2,000 people.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

What has that got to do with the amendment?

Comment on this

It has to do with it in this way that we have been told these cuts are necessary because of the situation to which the country has been brought. I am analysing the situation to which the country has been brought any why it has been brought there, and I am attempting to establish the case that the individuals named in the amendment should not have their salaries cut to the extent proposed.

Comment on this

A Second Reading speech.

Comment on this

The Deputy is not in the Chair. What is the necessity for cuts in the circumstances that Ministers so often boost as having been achieved? The moneys that we sought to gather in from England are here. We have more employment, more tillage, a better economic situation, but there are a few flaws in the argument, of course. Both property tax and income tax cannot yield 1/- more. The Minister announces that savings have got to be made in the easiest possible way, and this is the best way to achieve them. For this reason they are going to cut 2/6 a week from an unmarried guard, 4/6 from an unmarried sergeant, 2/6 from a married sergeant, 5/- from an unmarried station-sergeant and 3/- from a married station-sergeant. The House is being asked to negative the amendment without the Minister telling us how much of this £280,000 that he looks to get will leave him if the individuals mentioned are cut to the extent set down here. You have got to meet the case in another way. Deputy Costello referred to it in an incidental way; but let us get more concrete about it. Supposing there is discontent amongst the Guards by reason of these cuts in their salaries and that they feel that keenness in regard to their duty no longer merits their attention and may, in fact, draw down condemnation; and suppose that they become—I will not say neglectful of their duty—but not so keen on it as they were before, how many little bits of destruction of property would it be necessary to have in this country to wipe out the savings that may be effected under this? I do not believe there is a Guard in the force who can think of this "cut" without thinking at the same time that the Government, which insists on cutting his salary in this way, just prior to this Bill, introduced another Bill which imposes about £70,000 on the country for property which was destroyed at the time when the Guards were trying to save it. If that sort of folly were cut out this particular cut in the salaries of the Guards and public servants would not have to be put into force. If that discontent does spread, nobody can be very critical.

Comment on this

A disgraceful statement coming from an irresponsible Deputy.

Comment on this

What I have just said has been criticised as disgraceful. Is it disgraceful to call attention to the hardships the Guards are suffering at the moment? Is it more disgraceful to call attention to these hardships than to inflict them. Is it more disgraceful to put the Guards in such a position that they do not know where they stand if they do their duty under the law, or to call their attention to it? I consider that the disgrace is in putting them in such a position and in nothing else.

We had built up a force in a particular way. We got them, at any rate, content about their work. They were not always content about their emoluments, but we got a return from them in service which is, at least, as good as was given by a similar force in any other country. Now, in this reckless, blind, grabbing at money we are going to demoralise the entire force.

Comment on this

The question at issue in this amendment would appear to have been decided in amendments 27, 28 and 29, and, as the Deputy is largely traversing the ground covered on that occasion, I should like you, sir, to take a motion from me that the question be now put.

Comment on this

This is the second time that the Minister has made an appeal against the decision made by the Leas-Cheann Comhairle. I think it is grossly unfair for the Minister to appeal against the decision of the Leas-Cheann Comhairle.

Comment on this

That is an unjustifiable statement from Deputy Norton. The Leas-Cheann Comhairle did not give a ruling with regard to amendment No. 29. I am not challenging any ruling of the Leas-Cheann Comhairle. I am merely pointing out that the whole thing has already been covered by Deputy McGilligan in a long debate, and I invite a motion that the question be now put.

Comment on this

Was the Chair not appealed to on the point raised now?

Comment on this

On amendment 27, but not on 29.

Comment on this

The Minister said 27, 28 and 29.

Comment on this

May I ask, with all respect, is the Minister engaged in a campaign of obstruction or is he trying to intimidate the Chair? He is doing either one or the other. My point is that he has challenged a ruling on amendments 27, 28 and 29. It is on the records made two minutes ago. The Minister is either indulging in a campaign of obstruction or he is trying to intimidate both the Leas-Cheann Comhairle and the Ceann Comhairle.

(The Ceann Comhairle resumed the Chair.)

Comment on this

I should like to repeat that I did not raise any point of order as to amendment 27. I said that it was debated at length in the Committee Stage on amendments 27, 28 and 29. I now move that the question be now put.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

I am not prepared to accept that motion now.

Comment on this
Deputies

Hear, hear.

Comment on this
Division

Question put:—"That the said new sub-section be there added."

Tá 27
·
Níl 44
Result Lost The question put was not agreed to.

Do you agree with this result?

On behalf of Deputy Anthony, I move amendment 55:—

In page 6, in Part II of the Schedule, to delete the words "inspectors and" where they occur.

In moving this amendment, I am actuated again by a desire to limit the proposed cut to the smallest possible number of persons. There are in the Free State 55 inspectors. It is sought in this Bill to include these inspectors in Part II of the Schedule and thereby to bring them under the axe which is busily at work right through the whole Bill. In my opinion an inspector of police is an officer who has many important duties to do. He has of necessity a decent social position to maintain. He cannot be eternally worried with debts, or how he is going to live and pay his bills. Where an inspector is a married man with a family, he finds it extremely difficult these days to live on wages which are something slightly over £5 a week, with a maximum of slightly over £6 a week. The inspector in the Gárda Síochána starts off with a salary something slightly over £5 a week, never reaching more than something slightly in excess of £6 a week. He is not the kind of person who has anything to spare to make contributions to the poor and lowly referred to by the Minister in his Second Reading speech.

I suggest to the Minister that in the case of these people who hold important positions in the life of the community, people whom we are entitled to expect will be trustworthy, honest and of the highest integrity, that it is impossible for them to maintain that position if subjected to these cuts in their salaries. The amount of money that the Minister will receive by reason of including them in the scale of cuts on superintendents' and other officers' salaries will be negligible. I say that because there are only 55 such officers in the State, and having regard to the duties they perform, their present rate of salary is inadequate. I hope the Minister will agree that in relation to these officers there is not the good case for cutting their salaries that he imagines there is. They are important officers discharging important duties, and their pay, far from being excessive, is, in my opinion, utterly inadequate.

Comment on this

I rise to suppost this amendment. An inspector of the Gárda is in a very curious position, because he does not receive the pay of a superintendent, and yet an inspector is, for a great number of purposes, forced to keep up the same position that a superintendent has to maintain. The House may be aware that one of the principal duties which an inspector has to perform is that when the superintendent goes upon leave the inspector takes up the position of superintendent, and while the superintendent is on leave he discharges the duties of the office. While he is carrying out that position and discharging its duties, it is pretty obvious that he has got to live at very much the same rate as that at which a superintendent would have to live. I have pointed out already, and I wish now to reiterate it, that it is essential for the well-being of the Gárda Síochána that the inspectors and superintendents should be adequately paid. If not they get into debt, and I have already pointed out that the Gárda Síochána has lost the services of very many excellent men, very many excellent officers, because they were unable to make ends meet. It is absolutely essential to the police force that an inspector and superintendent shall not get into debt. That is so much so that when it is found that an inspector or superintendent is in debt his dismissal from the Gárda follows immediately. And that must be. That is necessary, because a debtor is always in the creditor's power, and you cannot have an efficient police force if you have your officers, to any extent at all, be it great or be it small, in the power of other people. I am satisfied that inspectors at the present moment are, if anything, underpaid. I believe a good case could be made for that. In fact, I think I would be nearer the mark if I cut out the words "if anything" and said definitely and distinctly that they are underpaid. Cutting their salaries lower would be a very great blunder indeed, and at the same time a very small saving to the finances of the State. While at the same time it will be a very great loss and detriment to the proper discharge of their duties by the Gárda.

Comment on this

I wish to support this amendment. Everybody knows that one of the first things that gets around in a rural town is the fact that an inspector of the Gárda has got into debt. That brings him down completely in the eyes of the people of the district in which he officiates, and at the same time it affects his influence and efficiency as an officer with the members of the Gárda themselves. Those who serve under such an officer could not look up to him when they know that he cannot stand in an independent position and cannot uphold a good social position. An inspector has something a little over £5 a week, and in these days that is a very low salary. It is not enough to maintain the position which these officers are supposed to keep up. That will affect the efficiency of the Gárda as a body and not alone will it react on the inspectorate but it will have its influence down along the whole ranks of the force. As I said here before, one of the big causes of demoralisation setting in amongst officers was that their pay was inadequate. It was only when they got out of debt and were put in a position to pay their way that they became efficient officers and got the respect from those under them which was so essential for the morale of the force as a body. It is not my intention to delay the House much longer, but I want to say that over and over again I have had reason for opposing these cuts no matter at what category or force they were aimed at. I honestly believe that it would be a bad day's work for this House when they would bring the Gárdá down to such a state that they would take little interest not only in their country but in their own social life and standard.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

In the Committee Stage of this Bill it was stated by me that there would be two Divisions on amendments dealing with the Gárda Síochána, one on an amendment of which I think the old number was 27, and the other on the old amendment 103, which is covered by No. 56 on the Order Paper.

Comment on this

Is that the amendment which was to meet the opportunity which was to be given to Deputy Dillon?

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Yes, No. 103 and this amendment, with No. 54.

Comment on this

Deputy MacDermot has left the House. I happened to meet him and I gathered from a remark he made that he had no knowledge that this opportunity was going to be allowed to-night. I therefore suggest that it might be held over.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

It was definitely stated by me twice to Deputy Dillon, when the dispute arose, that there would be a Division on amendment 103. However, if Deputies desire a Division now, they can demand it.

Comment on this

They are not here. I am not referring to what happened on the Committee Stage, but I do not think any member of the Centre Party has adverted to the fact that an opportunity was to be given to-night to move on that very point. It was not clear on the Order Paper. It seems to me that in equity that chance should still be given.

Comment on this

May I point out that the members of the Centre Party already had an opportunity of expressing their point of view in regard to those who do not belong to the officer ranks of the Gárda Síochána on amendment 54. They have exercised that right on that amendment.

Comment on this

That may be the Minister's view on the matter, but I am taking it from the ruling that you yourself, sir, are not convinced that the chance promised has been given. If that is so, I think the chance might be held over.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

My statement was accepted by Deputy Dillon that on amendment 103 the Division would be taken on amendment 54, and the Division has taken place on it. I am not saying that amendment 56 is covered by amendment 54.

Comment on this

I misunderstood it.

Comment on this

It was disposed of on the Committee Stage by agreement.

Comment on this

Do I understand, sir, that you are limiting action on this amendment to a division? Are you ruling out a discussion?

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

On the understanding that was reached in the Committee Stage. I do not know, in face of that agreement and two pronouncements from the Chair, that there should be a discussion.

Comment on this

I do not want to break any general agreement. I did not understand it in that sense but if there was general agreement I do not want to break it on this particular amendment. It is a matter for other Deputies.

Comment on this

As far as I understand the agreement was with regard to a division. I do not think there was any agreement for the curtailment of discussion.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

There was a distinct agreement that there was to be a division on amendment 103—the discussion took place in the Committee Stage—and that 54 would cover 56.

Comment on this

May I remind you, sir, that the whole question of the Gárda was to be disposed of by two divisions. One was to take place on amendment 27 and the other on amendment 103.

Comment on this

There was to be no limitation of amendments to be put down on Report Stage. The amendments might be disposed of by two divisions, but nothing could be said in the Committee Stage to bind other amendments for the Report Stage.

Comment on this

Do I take it that as far as 56 is concerned there can be a division, but that there ought not to be discussion?

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

If the House desires a division on it, very well. Do Deputies wish to challenge a division?

Comment on this

I do not wish to challenge a division if there has been general agreement.

Comment on this

There has not been general agreement.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

I shall put the question.

Comment on this

There has been a certain amount of confusion in regard to an agreement. If there was such agreement, as Deputy McGilligan pointed out, you could not limit the matter to two amendments. There could conceivably be a half a dozen amendments.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

I have been asked what was the attitude in Committee regarding the two amendments which were then before the House. It was distinctly understood that on some six amendments there were to be two divisions, one on 27 and the other on 103 which is now amendment 54. I wish to know whether the House now desires a vote on 56?

Comment on this

If you are clear on that, I think the House will be quite prepared to accept it.

Comment on this

As far as I understand, a Chinn Comhairle, in the Committee Stage you made a statement, which was clear to the whole House, that there would be two divisions. As a matter of fact the second one was never reached. What I understand now is that the Chair says he is anxious that an opportunity should be given to Deputy Dillon because he did not have the opportunity before, but I submit that anything that happened in Committee does not affect any amendment which is properly before the House on Report Stage and this amendment is properly before the House on the Report Stage.

Comment on this

Has the amendment been moved?

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Deputy Norton moved the amendment.

Comment on this

May I suggest that you should take the Division in view of your ruling in Committee Stage?

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

If the House desires it.

Comment on this

I move amendment 57:—

In page 7, in paragraph (a) of Part III of the Schedule, to delete the words "Is less than £175" and substitute the words "Is over £400" and to delete from and including the figures and words "200 but not less than £175—5¼" to and including the words and figures "Is £450 or more ...8."

This amendment deals with the position of teachers in national schools.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

And 58 is covered.

Comment on this

58 deals with the same subject, but it seems to be not necessarily covered by 57 because it is asking something less.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

If 57 is defeated 58 falls with it.

Comment on this

This is a most extraordinary Bill in many respects, and the Ministry's attitude in the matter has been still more extraordinary. Here we have a Bill dealing with the whole position of the scales of remuneration, not merely of officers definitely in the public service, but officers even remotely connected with the public service and only to some extent paid out of the Central Fund. The purposes of this Bill is to legislate for a definite reduction in the salaries of all the people affected by the Bill. I have seen many efforts by Governments in European countries to inflict wage reductions on public servants. I have had an opportunity of reading many of these Bills, but I would say that, from the point of view of vicious comprehensiveness, this Bill would easily win a prize in any of the Treasuries in Europe because the cuts imposed by the Bill are not merely comprehensive but almost every corner is scraped to squeeze money out of people whose remuneration is affected. This Bill has been notable for one chief fact: that is, that not once during the Committee Stage— and we are now on the 57 amendment out of 63 amendments submitted on the Report Stage—has the Minister budged from his original intention, as set out in the Second Reading of the Bill. The Minister would steam-roll this Bill through the House, not by argument——

Comment on this

The Deputy has not yet come to the point of the amendment, and as the whole matter was discussed on amendment 30 I ask that the question be now put.

Comment on this

Why?

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

I am not accepting the motion, but the Deputy should come to the matter which deals with salaries of teachers in national schools and not continue a Second Reading speech.

Comment on this

I am coming to that now. I suggest to the Minister that this is an amendment that he might well accept, because of his personal commitments in this matter. When the Teachers' Organisation made some kind of a bargain with Cumann na nGaedheal—an unsatisfactory bargain, in my opinion—one of the people who denounced that bargain, lock, stock and barrel, was the present Minister for Finance, and in that attitude he was supported by the present Minister for Industry and Commerce.

Comment on this

Come to the amendment.

Comment on this

The Minister is trying to dictate to the Chair and to every Deputy in this House. I suggest, sir, that if it is possible you should vacate the Chair and let the Minister take it.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

I suggest that the Deputy should move the Adjournment.

Comment on this

I move the Adjournment of the debate.

Comment on this