We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

Dáil Eireann Loans and Funds Bill, 1933—Committee Stage (Resumed).

Contributions 1–177 of 368. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

Bill Dáil Éireann Loans and Funds (Amendment) Bill, 1933
Enacted

No. 26 of 1933 ›

When the House adjourned last night, I was dealing I think with the statement that was made by Deputy MacDermot. He suggested that while he believed there was no sharp practice, that there was nothing wrong being done by the Government at the present time, still that something indelicate was being done. I resent as much the charge of indelicacy in this matter as I do the charge of fraud or corrupt practice on the part of the Government—just as much—because indelicacy in this matter can have but one meaning, as far as I can see, and that is impropriety which is of a kind approaching more to sharp practice, either on my part as an individual or as head of the Government. I suggested to the Deputy, when speaking in that way, that he should develop that point a little more and show exactly where there was what he thinks was delicacy or indelicacy. I should like him to tell us whether he thinks it would be indelicate if National Loan Bonds, let us say, were given to his Party and accepted by his Party. Would it be an act of indelicacy on their part to accept them simply because it might some day happen that his Party would be a majority in this House, and that it might be his duty, in his capacity as member of the Executive Council, to bring in a Bill here providing for the repayment of those bonds, or for the payment of interest upon them? Would it be indelicate on the part of the Labour Party, if in a similar position, to accept Dáil Eireann Bonds or National Loan script for their Party even, let us say, simply because the payment which would be made to anybody who held those bonds would be made to them as a Party when they happened to be the Government?

Comment on this

Perhaps it would shorten matters and save time, if I intervened at this stage. I distinguished sharply between these bonds and such an issue as National Loan.

Comment on this

Why?

Comment on this

For this reason, that as I understand it what is going to be done about these bonds was a matter not definitely settled. Here we are actually called upon to legislate. It was not a chose judgée. It was something that required legislation by the Oireachtas to settle in due time. It appears to me I might take a couple of illustrations though they are not exact parallels to this case. Take what was known as the Marconi case in England which occurred somewhere about 1910 or thereabouts. Certain members of the then British Cabinet acquired shares in the American Marconi Company at a time when the British Cabinet was entering into contracts with the British Marconi Company. No impartial person imagined for a moment that Mr. Rufus Isaacs, as he then was, and Mr. Lloyd George would allow themselves to be influenced in the government contracts by the fact that they held Marconi shares. Nevertheless when the matter was brought to light it created a great stir and scandal and it was considered that it was an undesirable thing for Ministers to lay themselves open to this sort of insinuation that actually was made at the time by some of their political enemies.

Take the case of the German Dawes 7 per cent. loan. A week or two ago Herr Hitler announced that the interest and sinking fund on that loan was going to be paid. The holders breathed a sigh of relief because nobody knew quite what was going to happen after the upheaval in Germany. Now if it transpired that Herr Hitler's Party had a substantial wad of Dawes bonds assigned to it by German-Americans it would certainly have laid Herr Hitler open to the sort of insinuation that British Ministers were left open to in connection with the Marconi case.

Here we have a loan which is not like any of our other State loans. It was a loan that from various aspects had been the subject of violent controversy and the ultimate fate of it was still uncertain. As I understand it, unless I am wrongly informed, there were matters quite uncertain about it apart from the date of payment, which had to be decided by negotiation and compromise, such as the settlement of the back interest. Now I suggest that whether as leader of the Opposition or prospective leader of the Government, the President was bound to be intimately concerned in the discussions that would take place here in the Dáil when the time came for legislation to be introduced; and that it was not desirable that he should put himself in the position of being personally interested already. The President went so far last night as to say that, even if he accepted these bonds personally and not for his newspaper, there would be nothing objectionable in it. I suggest it would be objectionable, and that it was objectionable for him to go after them even for his newspaper.

Let us suppose that the Cumann na nGaedheal Government had still been in office when this legislation was called for. Might not this occur, judging by the description of the character of Cumann na nGaedheal Ministers which we heard from the Government Benches last night—might it not come about that, owing to the fact that the Fianna Fáil Party organ was going to benefit immediately by the repayment of the loan, the Cumann na nGaedheal Government might keep postponing and postponing the payment of the loan in order not to benefit the Irish Press? That was a possibility which I suggest the President must have considered, taking the view he did of the character of Cumann na nGaedheal Ministers. If so, was it fair to the American holders of these bonds that such an obstacle should be raised in the way of their getting their money. I put it to the President that that sort of problem might have arisen here and other problems connected with this loan, which it would be his duty to deal with whether as Leader of the Opposition or Leader of the Government, and that his attitude towards them might quite conceivably in theory be influenced by the fact that he had assigned to him a considerable number of these bonds for the benefit of the Irish Press. Supposing the Irish Press had been in a much worse position than it actually is. Suppose it was in a state of absolute insolvency and could not carry on, would not the position be that even if this was a most unsuitable moment to pay off this loan, the President would have very strong pressure put upon him to do it for the purpose of saving the Irish Press from destruction. It appears to me in these circumstances that there is absolutely no parallel between this particular loan and the loans to which the President has been comparing it where nothing still remained to be settled by legislation.

Comment on this

I have listened to the explanation and the parallels and I hold that not one of them is satisfactory. It is suggested that the difference between this and the others —between these Dáil Eireann Bonds and the National Loan Bonds—is that nothing was definitely settled. Now, the dates are rather important. I gave to the House here a whole series of statements, starting immediately after the Treaty and continued uninterruptedly down to a little over a year ago, when the present Opposition were in office, and throughout all of that, there was not the slightest suggestion that there was not an intention to pay on these bonds, not merely their face value, but also the interest that had properly accrued on them. When I went to America and took assignments of these bonds in lieu of cash—and I pointed out to the House that roughly there was about as much cash subscribed as there were bonds subscribed, at the same time that there was cash subscribed here in Ireland—we had Deputy Fitzgerald, representing the Government here, telling us for years ahead of that, as these extracts which I have read informed us, that he told everybody in America that it was the intention of the Government to pay the money on these bonds. Already the receivers in New York had decided on distributing the balance pro rata and, I think, probably about that time, if not just at that time, stating publicly the amount that was being distributed on each bond. The receivers were actually operating. Money was about to be distributed. Every person who assigned one of these bonds had the knowledge that they were going to get, either through the receivers, or through State action here, the full equivalent value of these bonds; and if ever a State was pledged—there was an Act in 1924—this State was pledged to redeem these bonds, and nothing but sharp practice on the part of the previous Executive Council could possibly prevent that being done.

It was suggested last night by Deputy McGilligan that, while he had told the American Minister and communicated in writing to him that this Government could not pay this money until the receivers had handed in their final report, that did not bind him to pay it at that time. But what was the clear implication? The Government here officially had stated that they intended to pay this money—I will read the paragraph—but Deputy McGilligan tries to make a quibbling point to the effect that all that was said was that they could not do it before a certain date. This is what Deputy McGilligan, then Minister for External Affairs, wrote to Mr. Stirling, the United States Minister. The Minister for Finance, I think, explained to the House that that was presented to us as one of the documents when the legal representatives of the bondholders came over here a short time ago to make inquiry as to what the present Government intended to do in regard to the implementation of that promise. I pointed out to the House that that was the beginning of definite action on the part of this Government—that the legal representatives of the bondholders came over here, sought an interview with the Minister for Finance and myself, presented us with these formal documents which had been forwarded to them by the State Department in New York, and asked us definitely what this present Executive Council intended to do with regard to the implementation of these promises that have been repeated over and over again in public statements on these benches and in a very definite form in this official document. This is what occurs in this document:—

"The Government of the Irish Free State has repeatedly acknowledged this obligation to repay the bondholders of the External Loan and this view has not been modified as a result of the decision given by the New York Supreme Court. The question at issue is, accordingly, only one of the proper time and machinery to be adopted for the repayment of the loan. My Government is satisfied that no action can be taken until the receivers in New York have distributed the amounts they hold."

Now, the Deputy, who was then Minister, sees in this an opportunity to quibble although, in fact, when you take it along with the public statements that were made by the Minister for Finance, there can be no doubt whatever about it and what its intention was—no doubt whatever. The obligation was there. It was a long outstanding obligation. The duty to pay was there and to pay as promptly as may be, and the only excuse for not paying was given to the effect that the receivers had to present their final report to the court before it could be done and that after that was done machinery would have to be established. I said that, taking that in conjunction with the statements that were made by the Minister for Finance, there could be no doubt about it and, of course, I had only to look up a few of the files to find an explicit statement on the part of the Minister for Finance that payment would proceed immediately after the completion of distribution by the receivers,—which was the natural conclusion to be drawn from that letter and from the acceptance of the obligation and the previous general statements. Besides that, we have it here expressly set out in a cutting from an interview in the New York Sun. Speaking about the payment of these loans, Mr. Blythe, it says, pointed out:—

"It will be necessary, of course (Mr. Blythe pointed out) for officials of the Free State to make a thorough examination of all accounts and records held by the American courts and to be supplied with a list of names of subscribers, together with the amount of the subscriptions and the amounts already paid."

Of course! And the records are now available. However, Mr. Blythe goes on to state:—

"That will take some time; but once it has been checked, the Free State Government will proceed immediately to establish connection with one of the big New York banking houses and, with the co-operation of the Dublin Government, will be asked to settle all the claims in full."

What is the use of quibbling, as the former Minister for External Affairs was trying to quibble last night? What is really the difference between these bonds and any other bonds? The Ministers certainly, at any rate, accepted full responsibility for their payment. The Government stated that it was going to pay them and mentioned the time, and the time is this very time, because at this moment the final report of the receivers is being presented. We have to be in a position to make claims in the court now for these documents and we have to show our good faith in all these circumstances by producing a completed Act of Parliament under which these payments will be made. Now, I say that any ordinary person under these circumstances, had as much security as he can ever have in cases like that, that these bonds were going to be paid. It is quite possible, of course, to repudiate debts and people with State bonds of this or any other Government have always to face that possibility. It is not a likelihood. States know they have to borrow money again; communities know that their credit is an important asset, and they are not likely to behave in that manner. This Government, no matter what we wanted to do, if we were at all to take over and accept the continuing responsibilities would have to accept that.

Comment on this

Might I ask the President was it a matter of course that his Government would accept all the financial responsibilities settled on by the previous Government?

Comment on this

There was no trouble whatever in this respect, because all Parties had been agreed upon it. I quoted from General Collins's statement. I quoted from the statement of the previous President, Deputy Cosgrave.

Comment on this

I quoted it when the Deputy could have heard it if he were in the House. I am not going to quote it again. I quoted from several Cabinet Ministers, the most important being the Minister for Finance. In every one of these, continuing right through, there was the clearly expressed intention that this State and the people of this part of Ireland, through their elected representatives, were going to accept that responsibility. The Marconi case has been suggested. If there was a question here of our coming in to do something special for somebody or other then a case might be made, but I submit there is not. I submit that there is clear definite proof—proof that I challenge any committee of the House to go and examine—that this time was chosen for the payment of these funds owing to circumstances over which we had no control whatever, namely, the time at which the receivers had completed their report. I do not know the details of the Marconi case, but I do say at least on the surface of it that it is a very different thing to act as a trustee and to put assignments in an enterprise, from taking shares in some corporation or other in which Government contracts would come in. There were no Government contracts in this case. There is no action taken by the Government in this case except action that was determined by things in which this Government had no real determination—by outside events. We are paying this money because it is due. We had Deputy Rice last night telling us that it was not due.

Comment on this

On a point of order, that is not what I said. I said it was not payable at the present time.

Comment on this

It would be very interesting to get the records.

Comment on this
Mr. Rice

I made it quite clear that I meant it was not payable at the present time as the conditions are not fulfilled.

Comment on this

My hearing is not too bad and I can understand words when I hear them. I am quite prepared to take the Deputy's correction, but I want him to understand that I believe it to be a correction. I do not say that people cannot make mistakes. The Deputy now is not going to say that these were not payable. Now he says, not payable at the present time. I stated that this was the time indicated by our predecessors and that, from a business point of view, it is not an unsuitable time. The rate of exchange was suggested by some Deputies opposite as being the reason, but I pointed out yesterday that the rates of exchange when these pledges were made on previous occasions were respectively 4.41 dollars and 4.45 dollars, and that the rate of exchange is more in our favour to-day than it was then and, if we are at all capable of reading the course of events, it is much more likely to be in our favour when the full machinery is set up and the payments are actually being distributed.

I pointed out that we have no complaint and can have no complaint on the score of the exchanges; that these moneys were given to us at a time when 3.67 dollars or, say, 3.70 dollars, taking an average over the period, purchased for us the £ and now that same £ is going to repay 4.52 dollars. It was 4.52 the day before yesterday. I did not see the figures since.

Comment on this

Will the President give the wholesale prices of commodities?

Comment on this

If the Deputy wants to ask a question let him wait. I said that the rate of exchange was so much in our favour that we were actually paying our interest charge out of the benefit in our favour of the exchange. The economic war was mentioned by Deputy Minch.

Comment on this

Before getting on to the economic war, I should like to ask if the speech of the President is in order—if it is referable to the amendment before the House at all, or if it is not a Second Reading speech? I submit to the President that he is not dealing with the amendment at all.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

In reply to the Deputy's question, it is my opinion that 80 per cent. of the debate was not relevant to the amendment. But the debate having followed those lines, the President is now in order in answering statements made by other speakers on the amendment.

Comment on this

On a further point of order, may I point out that this is the second Second Reading speech which the President has made on the amendment?

Comment on this

And the thirty-second impertinent remark by the Deputy.

Comment on this

This whole debate ranged over a wide field.

Comment on this

May I put a question to the President before we get away from the particular point he was at? At the time when he was in America raising subscriptions for the Irish Press were these bonds readily discountable in American banks at their face value with merely the ordinary discount for interest; and, secondly, arising out of that, were shares in the Irish Press forthwith issued to the people who assigned the bonds to the President or have they not yet been issued?

Comment on this

I will come to those points in a moment. I was just dealing with a statement made by Deputy Minch. Deputy Minch suggested: "We got those moneys for a physical war; let us retain them now to fight the economic war." If we did want money to fight the economic war, and if we did want help again from the sources from which we derived it on previous occasions, I say that the proper way to get that help is to acknowledge and to honour the obligations that we have voluntarily taken upon ourselves.

Comment on this

What about your attitude?

Comment on this

It is easier to explain my attitude in regard to it than it is to explain that of the gentlemen opposite. That English war cuts in two ways. When we hear Deputies talking about the need that this country has at the present moment of conserving its resources, and when we hear them trying to suggest that we should use some legal technicality to get out of some obligations that were as clear as any obligation ever undertaken by any people, when we hear those people trying to get out of them now by legal quibble, it is astonishing what a difference there is between their attitude towards England, towards keeping here money which would be only part restitution for what we were robbed of, and their attitude towards money which was given to us by others to help us in our hour of need when we were struggling against that enemy. However, I am dealing with the question of keeping those moneys at the present time, as they are needed. I say if we do want money again, if we ever again want from our friends abroad money to defend the interests of this country, then I say it does not matter what body of men are here representing the Irish people, it is their duty on the first possible occasion to pay this money back, and that is the wisest course to take.

We are doing that. How are we doing it? In the case of the smaller subscriptions, because of the large number involved, we are paying in cash. The larger subscriptions are being paid in bonds of this State. I submit, then, that in choosing the present time for the payment we are not choosing a time to suit ourselves. That time was already predetermined and definitely decided upon by our predecessors, in circumstances over which neither they or we had definite control. I submit that it is a duty to pay this, that it is a favourable moment to do so, when we come to view the amount of money involved, and that, if we ever want to raise an external loan again, the payment of this money on terms that have been arranged, and which I for one consider quite fair, should be proceeded with out of hand.

We have an amendment which says that a certain class must be excluded from the payment; that, for instance, the Irish Press, which went ahead with the work of establishing a newspaper, and which entered into commitments with those who assigned the bonds, is to be deprived of the capital on which they had counted, simply because that enterprise is not one that is in favour with the Opposition, or with some of the Deputies of this House. To my mind, it is practically on a par with an action of this kind taken by an Executive; suppose that the funds, let us say of Deputy MacDermot's Party, consisted of those bonds that are to be redeemed in a few years, and that coming on to an election time the Government, because they knew that that Party had those bonds, brought in an Act to exclude that Party from getting those moneys. That would be corruption, to my mind, and studying the attitude of the Opposition to-day, and carefully studying some of the statements that they made at the time, there was just that danger, that there would be in office men who would abuse their office by making that discrimination. I know it is gall and wormwood to them that they are not here to do it, and that is the whole trouble. They are not here to do it, and it is the great and supreme pleasure of my life to know that they will have to digest that gall and wormwood.

Comment on this

The President does not look very pleased about it.

Comment on this

I am more pleased than the Deputy may imagine. I am very pleased that they have not got the power to do the dirty thing they intended to do.

Comment on this

The President had a better expression than that.

Comment on this

I am delighted that you have not got the pleasure of doing it.

Comment on this

Better again.

Comment on this

There is not going to be any discrimination here. The Gaelic American newspaper is one of the newspapers, I believe, to which those bonds were legally assigned. Are we going to discriminate there because that paper opposed us in every possible way for a number of years, and supported the people opposite? Not likely. As long as there is a legal transfer of bonds this money has to be paid back to the legal owners, and it will be paid back to them. That is the purpose. We are not going to accept the amendment, which we know was designed for purely Party purposes. It is asked whether the bonds were quoted on the American Stock Market——

Comment on this

Not on the American Stock Market.

Comment on this

They were not quoted on the Stock Market, nor were they being discounted as far as I know. They may have been, but I do not believe they were. The individuals who had them had an assurance as definite as it could be, published ten times over in the newspapers, and privately conveyed to them by the letters which they got from the Receivers, that the moneys which were due to them on those bonds would be paid. Now for the next question. I have answered the first one. The next question is whether bonds of the Irish Press were immediately given to them. Instead of getting shares of the Irish Press an American corporation was formed, and the dividends on all the shares purchased with their money are to be transferred under trust deed to them for division in America amongst their own shareholders; for a very good reason, that, in America, American Corporation Stock would be more readily transferable, and more information could be obtained about it than Irish Stock.

That was an act of the representatives of the assignees, an act taken for their own defence, for their own protection and in their own interest. The position then is that the moneys that are paid on these bonds, like on any other bonds, go to their legal owners and in so far as those that go and are assigned to the Irish Press or to me, the moneys will go to the Irish Press, and the bondholders will get in America an equivalent number of shares of the American Corporation which will carry with them their pro rata dividend on the stock, and if there is any distribution of assets——

Comment on this

Dividend on what?

Comment on this

I remember very well another statement made some time ago by the Deputy on the other side when he happened to be sitting here. He was asked would he suppress the Irish Press and he replied: “No, it will suppress itself.” It suppressed him. It helped to suppress him and it will suppress——

Comment on this

It is going very rapidly in the direction I indicated according to the balance sheet I have seen.

Comment on this

The balance sheet! Let us get back to the balance sheet.

Comment on this

Let us get back to the amendment.

Comment on this

There is no question, I take it, of the opposite side suggesting that there is to be no reply by me. I pointed out quite clearly that in newspaper enterprises one of the things that has to be safeguarded when you are starting the paper, one of the things that you have to see to is that you have capital to meet the losses that every newspaper expects to make for two or three years after it has started. In our prospectus of £200,000 we put roughly half of it to meet the losses which we expected, not losses which occurred but losses which we naturally expected in such an enterprise, losses which everybody who knows anything about the business knows will occur in the first year. What the gentlemen yonder are trying to make much of is that instead of having lost the £100,000 that we anticipated, the Irish Press has lost £59,000, or half of what we anticipated.

Comment on this

So far.

Comment on this

Oh! well, we can be just as good prophets as the Deputies on the other side, and we will see. What is more, I do not know the 8,000 shareholders in the Irish Press if everyone of them does not take very good care, as a result of the debate in the last few days, that the interests of the Irish Press will be pushed as they have never been pushed before. And if I were looking for money in America for the Irish Press I believe that the debate for the last two or three days would enable me to get more money than I otherwise would have got, not less.

Now I have only to show certain things. Firstly, that this money was due. It was due because any representative body that claimed to be representative of the Irish people could not shirk the obligation and shirk it with honour. Secondly, the time was not the time selected by us. It was the time selected outside of us. Thirdly, that the amount that is being paid is a fair one in all the circumstances and that our people's interests in the matter are being well protected and those to whom the money is owing and to whom the money is to be paid are getting a fair bargain anyhow.

With regard to this amendment, I say we are rejecting it because it was designed from a mean Party motive, namely, to try to prevent going to the Irish Press the money which is legally due to it—money on the strength of which the Irish Press started perhaps earlier than it would otherwise have started. I say the attempt to deprive it of this money by any subterfuge of this kind would be an act of positive injustice, an act which the attitude of the gentlemen opposite showed they were quite ready to perpetrate, if those gentlemen had been on this side.

Comment on this

In the speech to which we have just listened we got a historic account of the bond issue, in the first place, and of subsequent events in the second place. It was rather reminiscent of the newspaper which the President has mentioned, for there were certain gaps in the story. In the first place, when these bonds were issued in the United States of America they were issued by a person acting on behalf of the people of this country, a person filling a national position, not leader of a Party, not leader of a section, and not a divider of the people. In the course of the speech mention was made of the promise that the late General Collins had given and the promise given by myself. I interjected a request for the date and I did not get it. It is characteristic of the discourtesy which other members of the Executive Council acquire from the example of the President of the Executive Council that I could not get that information. People who posture as gentlemen and as being national in character and so on must give better examples of public courtesy.

Comment on this

When he learns a little of it himself he will get it back.

Comment on this

When I asked for the date I was denied it. Why do I ask for the date? Reference was made to the promise by General Collins that this money would be paid. One of the first questions put in the Dáil when the Treaty was under discussion was whether these moneys would be paid; whether the Dáil bonds would be redeemed; whether the bonds issued in America would be redeemed. The answer was that they would. I asked for the date in respect of that question. I had a special purpose in getting the date. I wanted to know whether or not it was before or after the time that as leader of a section of this country, as a person who has divided this country, that the President of the Executive Council entered the courts of the United States objecting to this State taking possession of these moneys that had been unexpended after an undertaking had been given that the money was to be repaid.

Just look for a moment at the picture. We are asked if we are going to pay. We are denounced if we say we are not. Fortified by the pledge that was given by the Minister for Finance that the moneys were going to be paid, this sectional leader goes to America or instructs some person in America to move in the courts to prevent this State which had been pledged to pay these moneys from entering into possession of the residue of whatever sum was left. These are the gaps that are left in the story to which we have listened and I say it is characteristic of the newspaper that is begotten by the same person that this story should have the same omissions. During the course of the debate we heard about documents. My position is that unlike the present President of the Executive Council we did not enter into possession of documents that were held by our predecessors. All the documents in my possession when I was President of the Executive Council are in that office now. I stated that we really did not want these moneys, that what we wished to do and were going to do was to add to the money in America a sufficient sum to pay all our liability in respect of the Dáil bonds in America. All that is on the records. But notwithstanding these facts and notwithstanding that pledge and that statement this case went on in America. This case, brought by Mr. de Valera and his friends, went on. It is a case which has cost this country an enormous sum of money which it could ill-afford, money which the people of this country must pay. It was the policy which the last speaker, the present President of the Executive Council, put upon the people of this country. Having all the time undertaken to pay this money, we are now taxed by people who endeavoured to prevent this State from entering into possession of this money, with refusing to honour our bond.

On the plea that it was the money of the Republic it was got by people who called themselves Republicans, but it was to be paid by people who were styled as traitors, usurpers, or people who had perpetrated a coup d'êtat, or something of that sort. They were willing to take our money, delighted to take it; there was nothing wrong with it, but we were not to enter into possession of the assets in connection with this debt.

Comment on this

You had already entered into possession of them, all you were entitled to.

Comment on this

All we were entitled to?

Comment on this

Who was entitled to the rest of them?

Comment on this

We were entitled to pay the full sum and now we are told we entered into possession of all the assets we were entitled to. Was Saorstát Eireann entitled to pay that money? Would it be just that it should pay that money and not enter into possession of the assets? The President says we entered into possession of all the assets we were entitled to. What did we enter into possession of? Whatever was left out of the £375,000 collected here, plus whatever remained of the unexpended balance there was from America. We paid the £375,000 with interest and this money would have been paid five years ago but for the action of the President of the Executive Council and his pawns who went to America, putting cost upon this State, endeavouring to prevent the State from getting that money. Why? Because it was not a Republic. What did he succeed in doing? He was asked by the judge: " I am told you had a Republic?""Yes," he said. "Had you your own currency?""We permitted the British to circulate their currency here.""That is not the question I asked you," said the judge. "Had you your post office and did you issue stamps?""No," he said, "we permitted the British.""That is not the question I asked you," said the judge.

In his sectional capacity, and having lost his representative character, the President dragged this country in the mud in America; dragged the differences amongst the people in this country before the people of America and exposed every weakness he could possibly expose of the Irish people. I did not do that when I was in America. When I left there it could not be said that I uttered a single word of criticism in relation to any persons, and, God knows, if there is a man who could speak about them it is [. The grin that comes from the Deputy opposite is the last grin that should come from any man in Ireland, and well he knows it. I could make a greater exposure of the Deputy than any other man, if I wished to do it.

Comment on this

Do it.

Comment on this

There is no man in this country who has less right to say a single syllable than the Deputy, and many on those benches over there know that. Stop the grin; it ill becomes you.

Comment on this
Mr. Crowley

Why not take up the challenge?

Comment on this

I will take up the challenge at any time I please. There are no puppets on this side.

Comment on this

They are all well bred.

Comment on this

Yes, sir. I wish we could say the same of others.

Comment on this

Are you going to do what you said you would do?

Comment on this

I will, any time I please.

Comment on this

You will select your own ground for it?

Comment on this

Perhaps I will.

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

At a Cumann na nGaedheal Convention.

Comment on this

Whatever delay there has been it is of the President's own making; it is his own design all the way through. The American courts found we were not the successors, that there was no such thing in existence as an Irish Republic and this money should be returned to the bondholders. What is the purpose of the amendment? It is to pay the money to persons from whom the money was borrowed, to carry out the terms of the bond with the words "not negotiable" written on it. It is to ensure that the people in America, whoever they were or from whatever class they came or whatever their subscriptions were, having put the money up, should get it back.

The President has certainly brought discredit upon Government in this State in seeking to get for Party purposes money that was subscribed for a national purpose. He is perfectly at liberty, having passed the amendment, to go to America and to vindicate the terms he made a short time ago. He said that if he went to America now and asked for money for his Irish Press he would get it. Let him go and get it. Let us here at least endeavour to ensure that our Government will be free from allegations of anything in the nature of political aims in a matter of this kind.

Comment on this

When are you going to select your ground?

Comment on this

Any time I wish.

Comment on this

You are a bright boy.

Comment on this

I am very bright and I may tell the Deputy that he was not very bright on many an occasion when I met him.

Comment on this

The ex-President on good breeding.

Comment on this

Blue blood.

Comment on this

The well-bred man.

Comment on this

Why do you not stand up and do it like a man?

Comment on this

One remarkable thing in this debate was the endeavour of the President to explain to us that he is under no suspicion, that he has done nothing wrong, that he has done nothing upon which any man could conceivably ground a charge against him. He is perfectly above suspicion, and to show that he is completely above suspicion, that there is nothing that anybody could find fault with in the slightest way in any part of his conduct, he took two hours yesterday and 40 minutes to-day to explain his clear, apparent rectitude. Although he required two hours and 40 minutes to make his statement, I am afraid that even at the end of that time he has failed to establish his point. The fact that there was a great deal to explain and the fact that his conduct was to himself inexplicable is, I think, demonstrated by the extraordinary length of time which the President found it necessary to take.

Last night Deputy Norton declared that this was an important question, that it was a question which would be considered outside this country. I agree with him. Deputy Norton said he hoped the speeches of Deputy Fitzgerald and Deputy McGilligan would not be reported in American papers. I hope they will be. I hope the debate will be fully reported in American papers, including the speech of the President. Then let the American people who are interested in this matter make up their minds and decide upon this issue. Let it be brought home to them firmly and clearly that there are men in this House who are determined to vindicate the integrity of the House; that there are men who are determined to make it clear to the world that we consider integrity in our public men is a matter of the very greatest importance, a pearl of the highest price. I do not want to discuss this question with anything approaching some of the heat or passion which President de Valera has endeavoured to introduce. The whole House is upon its trial in this matter and I think it is better to approach this discussion very quietly, very calmly, not having its path directed by any fiery blow given in a passionate exhibition of rhetoric, but rather led by the quiet, cold light of pure reason. Observing that, I cannot see how any Party will come to the conclusion that at any rate, if not worse, the President has acted with a want of judgment that does him infinite discredit as a public man. I put it no further at the moment than that he displayed a terrible want of judgment.

Of course the President was very careful to tell us that not one penny of this money has reached his pocket. There is an assignment here of money to him, not one penny of which has gone into his pocket. What has that got to do with the question at issue? How does that help us one single step forward? Very few people value money for its own sake. Nobody, except a miser, values money for its own sake, but people value money for what it brings them. Some people value it because it gives them pleasure or luxury. There are other people who value money because it can give them power. If President de Valera had a very considerable amount of superfluous money of his own, I wonder on what he would expend it. If he was in the happy position of his colleague, the Minister for Justice, and had a great amount of superfluous money, I do not think the President would spend it or adopt such an expeditious way of getting rid of it as setting up a racing stud or keeping a yacht. I do not think he would buy a steam yacht. I think if he had a considerable amount of superfluous money he would spend that money in a way which would help him to realise his ambition. I think if he had a considerable sum of superfluous money he would invest it straight away in a newspaper and, therefore, although this money may not go, and is not going, into the President's pocket at all, still everybody in this House knows from his public career what is the polar star by which the President steers his course. The establishment of a newspaper is one of the instruments by which the President hopes to obtain and keep power. This money is being expended just as much by him, in satisfying his ambition, as if it was spent on satisfying his pleasure in the establishment of a stud farm or a steam yacht or anything else.

Of course we have been told there was in America when this money was in the air, a sort of snatch and grab business, that everybody was trying to grab some of it from the persons who advanced it, and owned it; that some of it was going to this religious purpose, and some of it to another religious purpose, and that the President came in just merely competing amongst others in order to get some of it for his newspapers. But there is an enormous difference between what happened in his case and in the others. The persons who gave money to the Chinese Mission and to the Yorke Memorial, and for other similar purposes mentioned by the Minister for Defence last night, knew they were giving the money for charitable purposes and were not expecting a return.

Comment on this
Patrick Joseph Ruttledge Minister for Justice (Mr. Ruttledge) Fianna Fáil

Does the Deputy exclude those religious bodies?

Comment on this

I will deal with that fully if the Minister will allow me to make my own speech in my own way. They spent that money on a completely different footing from those persons induced by the President to part with their money. These people were induced by him, Leader of the Opposition in this House as he then was, to invest in nothing less than what purported to be an industrial undertaking, a business undertaking which was to be a profitable investment for them and their money. I am not going to repeat what I said, on the Second Reading, I content myself by saying there was this money which did not reach the hands of the persons entitled to it. It was that money which the President set himself out to get. He asked here what difference was there between these and other classes of bonds. Why may I ask, if there was no difference between those and other classes of bonds, was it that those bondholders were circularised? Why? Because it was judged to be easier to induce those bondholders to hand over their money to President de Valera; that is the reason they were circularised. Why was not that form sent out to other bondholders—to holders of National Loan in this country, whether First, Second, or Third National Loan, and asking for power of attorney? Why was not a circular sent to them with the request: "Will you send me your security with power of attorney making me master of this money?" Why was that course not taken? That course was obviously taken with the American holders because President de Valera knew it would be easier to get from people something not in their possession than it would be to get money they had at their bankers or that was safely invested or money that was in their touch, that they could realise at any moment they wished. This is always a very suspicious procedure. After all, there is no contract which comes into the courts, that is more easily set aside than what is called a catching contract with heirs. A bargain is entered into by somebody to purchase from an heir—from a person who cannot realise his money, who has to wait for it until some special event in the future happens. To acquire, by reversion of that nature, is always regarded by the courts as a very suspicious circumstance and it is a sort of contract very rightly and easily set aside by the courts. Yet this is just precisely what happened here. There has been here a catch bargain, in that the person concerned was going to receive a sum of money at some very indefinite time in the future. Now, the President, according to the document, is absolute owner and master of this money. It is a carefully prepared document which says that every right, title and interest, every single bit of title that the person possesses as entitling him to the money, every single penny of that, is transferred to President de Valera for a consideration of one dollar. I wondered why the sum of one dollar was mentioned. I think I know. Though not familiar with American law, I think it bears sufficient resemblance to the law we know in this country, to make it plain why this false statement was drawn that there was one dollar paid. It was this: In that assignment to President de Valera a statement of that kind was introduced in order to make the sale binding. I do not actually know whether it does or not. I take it that that has been put in to show that it is not a voluntary assignment, that it is not something that a person can go back on if he wishes, that once this fly had been induced to enter into the spider's web there was going to be no retreat—no way out again.

The Minister for Justice, a few moments ago, asked me what would be the effect of this amendment upon persons like the Chinese Mission. With regard to that, I hold that if President de Valera even at this eleventh hour takes that course, which I think he should take, the same thing will happen to the Chinese Mission as will happen to the Irish Press; that is to say, the money, the owners of which have said they will invest it in the Irish Press or give it to the Chinese Mission, will be returned to them and be at their disposal. It will be absolutely free for them, if their minds remain unchanged, to hand the money, if they get it in hand, into the coffers of the Chinese Mission, or into any fund they like, and to dispose of it exactly and precisely as they wish. That is what we want. We want to see that every person who has lent this money, every single person who is a bondholder here, gets back his cash and gets it into his possession here and now and that he has an opportunity when he gets this cash to deal with it precisely as he likes and not to be told: “Oh, indeed you are poor, no doubt you want it now.” President de Valera told us the other night that plenty of the people who advanced this money and who were well-off then are no longer prosperous and that it would be a god-send to them to get it now. They will not get it now. As far as this money has been assigned to him, they will not get it now. They will not get it now even though they may be in need of the actual necessaries of life. They will get nothing but a bit of waste paper in response for what they gave before.

The President, of course, has told us: "I do not want this money at all for myself. I want it to expend on the Irish Press to satisfy my own ambition, and I am a trustee.” He admits here now in this House, and I do not see how he can ever go back on it now that he has made the admission, that he is a trustee of this money, that he is not the owner of it. He says: “I do not claim under that assignment to be the owner of this money. I claim to be nothing more than a trustee.” Well, how should a trustee act? There is one thing which the law does expect and which every person, whether he is a lawyer or a laymar does expect, and that is that a trustee will use the utmost care and circumspection in the way he invests or deals with the money of those who entrusted their money or property to him. The President is the acknowledged trustee. What is he going to do with it? He is going to invest that money of these deserving people, as he himself admits these people have trusted him with their money, in a concern called the Irish Press, the shares of which I do believe are not worth a farthing at the present moment.

Comment on this

The Irish Press settled you.

Comment on this

We have seen the balance sheet of the Irish Press. It is a very interesting document. It is this company, that has just issued this balance sheet, in which President de Valera is going to invest the money which he holds, as he himself says, as trustee. Rumour, of course, does not always tell the truth. Rumour is sometimes, to use a famous expression, a lying jade; and the rumour I have heard is that when the general shareholders of the Irish Press met together to see this balance sheet and have it read to them and discussed, that the police had to be called in. That may or may not be true. I am not vouching for the truth. All I can say is that it is a rumour that has had very wide circulation and, as far as I know, is absolutely true. If it is not true, I can be contradicted.

Comment on this

It is about as true as the kicking cow story.

Comment on this

Let us examine this balance sheet for a moment in order that we may know the position the company is in in which the President is going to invest the money he holds as trustee. It has issued capital shares of £183,783 out of a nominal capital of £200,000. Therefore, at the present moment, it has issued shares for all except £16,000 worth of this total nominal capital. That is rather interesting, because we were told, of course, by the President, in the course of his argument, that the Irish Press had been established because of the commitments of these persons who had presented him, for investment, as he says, in the Irish Press, with their share of these moneys. I do not know the exact figure of the amounts which were given in this fashion to President de Valera. nor has he told the House: but the figure was mentioned in debate here as being something between £80,000 and £100,000. I do not know whether that is correct or not, but I think it is pretty well-known that a very large sum indeed of that nature is represented by assignments made to President de Valera. So, therefore, he has had all except £16,000 of the necessary £200,000 to make his paper a success. and he now is evidently going to increase the nominal capital of the company by another £70,000 or £80,000 or £100,000. I have no means of knowing the figure, but it is some very large figure indeed, because in everything that he said and every representation he made was “This company can be made a success if I have £200,000.” He has got £200,000 all except £16,200 odd and a sum of £19,503 which has not been called up but which, I presume, is owed by solvent people and can be called up. What becomes of the commitments? The President had his 183,000 shares issued and would have floated his company if he had got no answer from these people. That is all we can see from the published figures.

What is the condition of this company? We see that its working expenses are enormous—£223,000 a year. We see that its revenue is only £188,000 and that at the present moment it has not only no available ready money but that it has got a colossal overdraft with the Munster and Leinster Bank of £19,500. Yesterday, Deputy Fitzgerald described the Irish Press as a bankrupt concern. President de Valera grew very angry. No doubt, the Irish Press is not a bankrupt concern in the strict meaning of the term. No order in bankruptcy has been made against the Irish Press. Looking at this balance sheet can anybody say that if the Munster and Leinster Bank issued a debtor's summons to-morrow against the Irish Press there is any available asset shown there with which they could meet that sum of £19,000? Looking at this balance sheet it must be obvious that this paper is at present carrying on at the sufferance of the bank. It may be said that £90,000 has been invested in buildings, premises, plant and furniture, but it is equally well known by everybody, because everybody can remember the time when the Freeman's Journal was for sale, that no matter what the plant and buildings of that nature may have cost their value becomes very small when they are being sold second-hand. They are valueless to anybody except a person who wishes to carry on a newspaper. In consequence, I repeat that if a debtor's summons were issued to-morrow, nobody reading this balance sheet can see how this paper could resist an order being made against it.

Comment on this

That is what you would like.

Comment on this

It does not matter what I like or do not like. I am dealing with hard facts, not with likes and dislikes. It is in this concern that the President says he is going to invest money which he admits he holds as a trustee.

Comment on this
Mr. Kelly

Three hundred men will be knocked idle, but that does not matter to you.

Comment on this

If the President took what I think would be the right and proper course, if he stated to the House "I am going to be above suspicion——"

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

He is.

Comment on this

——"I am going to take a course with which nobody can find fault; I am going to give every single person who handed that money to me, now that the money is available, a chance of getting his money back." You can ask him to invest it; you can give him your own views that you think this paper—if you do think it—will ultimately make good. Send him that balance sheet; send him your own comments on it and then ask him: "Are you still willing to invest your money in this paper?" That would be the straightforward course, that would be the honourable thing to do. It is not only what a man of extreme punctiliousness in the matter of honour would do. If I might quote one of the most famous passages in English literature: "The chastity of whose honour would feel a stain like a wound"—not merely a man of that kind, but I believe any man who has got real self-respect and respect for the position which he holds would take that straightforward course and say: "Your money can be paid to you in cash if you wish; I am not going to hold you to that voluntary assignment you made to me some years ago." If the President did take that step, a great deal of the strength that lies behind the arguments in favour of this amendment in my judgment would pass away. But will the President take that course? I am afraid not. If he did take that step, there would be another very strong objection to refusal to accept the amendment. Of course, every member of the Fianna Fáil Party can, at the bidding of the President, order his mind not to work, and pretend that his mind cannot work, and the Labour Party may do the same at the bidding of the Chief of its allies. But is not that the only reason why this money is being paid at present?

Comment on this

That is absolutely a falsehood.

Comment on this

Because of the needs of the Irish Press. Is not that what every person would have to say?

Comment on this
Mr. P. Hogan (Galway)

Of course they would.

Comment on this

Every person who looks at this matter would have to say that. Let us consider where we are. We have a Minister for Finance who comes into the House and tells us: "I cannot by taxation raise one single penny more; I have come to the end of my powers of raising money by taxation except I come down, and come down hard, upon the necessaries of life of the very poor. There is no possibility of raising money otherwise by taxation." The Civic Guards, whom they say are not overpaid, are to have their pay cut. Civil servants, whom they say are not overpaid, are to have their wages and salaries cut. The Army and the teachers, whom they say are not overpaid, are to have their pay and salaries cut. "All State servants are to have their pay cut, because we cannot balance our Budget unless we do. We have come to the end of our financial tether." That is what the Minister for Finance says. It is in these circumstances, in the present condition of the finances of this country, that the Government choose to make this enormous payment. They have to make reductions amounting to over a quarter of a million pounds in the pay and salaries of persons whom they say are not overpaid. Then they come along and propose to make a payment of well over, I think, £1,200,000. That is a payment they can make no matter where the money comes from. Why is that? The country has owed this sum of money for a considerable number of years and we are asked to believe that, by a strange accident, just at the time it is necessary for the continued existence of the Irish Press it is absolutely necessary, apart from any other considerations, to pay it. All over the world States are finding it hard to pay their public debts. All over the world they are making application for time. But in connection with this particular debt we will not say a single word about time. Why not? The Irish Press cannot give time, because the Irish Press will be dead.

We have heard a great deal about legal obligation. If the President were logical there would most distinctly have been no legal or moral obligation. I myself very much question if, in the strict meaning of the term, there was any legal obligation to pay this money. I very much question whether, in the strict meaning of the word, there was any legal obligation that could be enforced in the courts against the present Government or any Government of this State. I do think that there is a moral obligation. I do think that it was of the very essence of this loan that it would, be repaid when this State had a sovereign Parliament of its own. I do not think it was of the essence of the matter at all that there would be a Republic. I think it was of the essence of the matter that as soon as this State had a sovereign Parliament this money would be repaid. It had a Parliament very closely approximating to a sovereign Parliament after the Treaty, and owing to the exertions of the Cumann na nGaedheal Government it has at the present moment a Parliament which is absolutely sovereign. Although it may not be of the absolutely strict letter it is according to the very spirit that this money should be repaid by a sovereign Parliament in this State. There is a very strong moral obligation, but at the same time we should bear in mind that it is in the nature of an ex-gratia payment. When the finances of this State are really sound, when the finances of this State are in a position that they can afford this payment, then and then only is the time at which this repayment should be made. It is the condition of the finances of this State, and not the condition of the finances of the Irish Press, that should dictate the time of repayment.

Comment on this

If the debate had finished up last night, as many people thought it would, it would not be so clear—even though it was fairly clear then—as it is to-day that the one motive behind all this debate, and behind the amendment introduced by the Opposition, is a bias and a certain grudge against the Irish Press. Anybody listening to the hysterical speech of Deputy Cosgrave a few moments ago could see that he still feels very sore because the Irish Press—it must be admitted—played a big part in removing Deputy Cosgrave across the floor of the House. It is because of that that Deputy Cosgrave was able to get himself into such a hysterical mood to-day in trying to endanger the Irish Press, and at the same time endanger the credit of this State. I remember on one occasion here before when, in the most important debate that came before this House for a long time, Deputy Cosgrave was making the principal speech from the Opposition Benches in defence of a case about the economic war, and that England was entitled to £5,250,000 a year out of this country, and he finished up that debate with the main argument— because he had made no other argument as to why it should be done—with the belated boast that he was well reared and well bred. Because he is well reared and well bred, in his own belated words, we are to take his attitude as being bona fide on this question, and assume that it is on the interests of justice he is backing up a motion of this kind.

There have been certain imputations made against the President of this Assembly from across the floor of the House. There were imputations made yesterday that he, in the first instance, and again that members of his household benefited out of a particular industry in this country, and that, because of that, the President was trying to boost up that industry by having it backed out of State funds. The imputation came across the floor of the House that his family were benefiting, and that there was corruption in the administration of public funds because of that.

I want to make this assertion, that as far as documentary evidence is available there is only one bench in this House where corruption did take place as far as public funds are concerned, and that is the Front Bench opposite. If there is any doubt about that let members of the Front Bench opposite go to the Public Accounts Report of 1926, and they will see there that some of the men who made those imputations have not a clean sheet themselves as far as conduct is concerned. They are throwing across the floor of this House imputations to try not only to ruin the industry but to try to ruin the clean name of a good family in this country. That imputation comes from men with dirty hands and dirty records.

Comment on this

And then they are pious!

Comment on this

If any members on the back benches doubt what I say let them go to the Library and read the Public Accounts Report of 1926, page 407. They will read there about some of the dirty work done by those men, and it was not talked of as being a disgrace for members of the Front Bench then to meddle in public funds. They should look to their own hands and their own records before they fling imputations across the floor of the House, but any tactics are good enough to try to ruin the name of a particular individual, or to try to belittle this State now that they have no further interest except an abstentionist interest in this Assembly. We had strange faces in Leinster House yesterday evening on the Front Bench opposite. We had back in the House the man who has adopted an abstentionist policy now that he is no longer Minister, Deputy Hogan. Mind you, his abstentionist policy has not changed his tactics. He did not come back to the House to discuss agriculture, which he used to be interested in. He came back to try once again his old tactics, and the old tactics of the Front Bench as it used to be constituted, of trying to bemean the name of President de Valera. They should be tired of doing that. Did they ever fail in any instance when they could fling mud, when they could make insinuations? Did they ever fail during the past ten years to try to bemean his name and belittle him as far as propaganda is concerned inside this House and outside? They failed. They got their answer. Surely, under the changed circumstances, they are not so muddle-headed as to think that they are going to succeed now, but of course they have got to obey the call. There was very little talk of an amendment of this kind on the Second Reading of this Bill. There was no suggestion about corrupt dealing to the extent that there was mentioned yesterday. A few days afterwards the Irish Independent issued its instructions that the slander campaign against President de Valera should be started again, that it was again time that the lash should be taken out. The Irish Independent call for a slandering campaign was obeyed by Cumann na nGaedheal leaders with just as much promptitude as Maxwell obeyed its call in 1916. The Irish Independent boasts that it is an independent organ. It is so independent that it can dictate policy. It was so independent in 1916 that it could dictate policy and spill blood through its appeal at that time to General Maxwell, and it is so independent that it can launch a slander campaign not only against the President of this State but honourable Irishmen in America, men who took an interest in the Irish movement when the man who last spoke was interested in a British recruiting campaign. That slander campaign has been launched again. It is a very independent paper. I give it that praise. Its call was never lost sight of in Irish history. They never failed. They have launched again the slander campaign, but it will fail as dismally as the efforts of the Party opposite to slander Irishmen at home and abroad in the past.

Deputy Norton expressed the hope yesterday that the report of this debate might not be published in America. I wonder would it be wise to have it published there or not? Perhaps it is wiser that it should be published there, because as far as the State here is concerned the people of this country know too well the men who are engaged in that slander campaign, and they know too well the organ that dictated it. Surely to goodness the Irish in America are just as well informed of the dispirited position of the Cumann na nGaedheal Party as the Irish at home. I think, therefore, that it will do no harm to Ireland to have it known that those men are still on the war path, as far as belittling the name of Irishmen is concerned. Having it published abroad would not injure the Irish cause. We all know that Deputy Fitzgerald-Kenney has a particular interest now in trying to injure this State. He spoke a few moments ago about the bonds that were transferred in this instance.

There is a great campaign now to prevent people who are legally in possession of these bonds from being paid. He was anxious to emphasise that there was a legal way of this payment. He was the very man with certain other legal officers in Cumann na nGaedheal who was particularly anxious to bolster up the case for the British Government a few months ago. I wonder what would be the attitude of the Cumann na nGaedheal Party if this Government were paying the £5,250,000 to England? Would they introduce an amendment here that the payment of the Land Purchase Bonds would be only to those from whom the lands were purchased some years ago, and that the money would not be paid to those who had got transfers from the original holders in the same way as these American bonds stand now? Would they introduce an amendment that this money would not be paid until the bona fides of the holders would be proved in court, and that the money would not be paid to the people who owned the land bonds now? As a matter of fact, they do not make any such objections.

From the very start of the case the Irish Press is entitled to these bonds. The pity of it is that Cumann na nGaedheal are not on the Government Benches! All they can do now is to try to slander the members of the Government of this State, to injure this State and, at the same time injure the Irish Press. Did we not all notice the delight and did we not all notice the gloating that was expressed in the Cumann na nGaedheal Benches when Deputy Fitzgerald read out the balance sheet of the Irish Press? What a delight they felt that that balance sheet showed that there was a little bit on the wrong side or on the short side. It did not matter to them that 333 people would be put out on the road. Then the Irish Independent could go ahead and tell any lies they liked and cover up any lies that the Cumann na nGaedhael Party wanted covered up. Would it not be grand if the Irish Press were beaten? Is it not a grand thing that they are able to gloat over the Irish Press balance being on the wrong side?

I am firmly convinced, however, that there are numbers of men on the Cumann na nGaedheal Benches who do not agree with this attitude. I know definitely that there are going to be a few notable absentees from the Division Lobbies when this Vote is being taken. I am glad, anyhow, to know that the Leader of the Centre Party has dissociated himself from the attacks and the charges of corruption that were made yesterday by the discredited leaders of the Cumann na nGaedheal Party. Personally, I would be sorry if the balance sheet of the Irish Independent were on the wrong side. I would be sorry if the 300, 400 or 500 people employed were thrown out of employment. I think it would be a tragedy to these employees, and I would not be at all delighted. It might mean a lot for the Republican movement and for the Fianna Fáil Party, but I do not think it would be good for the country, as a whole, as far as employment is concerned.

But thanks be to goodness we are in a position to look at things now in a broader way than the Cumann na nGaedheal Party are. After all, maybe we are too hard on them. They had a hard time recently. They are discredited. Their policy has gone bankrupt. They have concentrated their hopes now on Deputy Alfred Byrne, who is trying to get some unique collection of individuals again together. They hope that they might get in amongst them and in that way might again win back to power in this country. Cumann na nGaedheal is in a transition stage if a transition stage is the proper way in which to describe it. One cannot blame them for this. It is hard to blame them for their mean tactics, when you consider their record. By their mean tactics they want to injure their opponents. When a certain type of terrier dog is cornered he will bite you. You cannot blame him for that. That is the position of the gentlemen of the Cumann na nGaedheal. For years they were monarchs of all they surveyed, and now they have fallen. All they have now to boast of, in the words of their Leader, is that they are well-reared and well-bred. If that gives them any consolation we accept it. Where they are carrying this thing too far altogether is when they want this State to refuse to fill its obligations. They are carrying their bitterness and bias too far when they slander the name of the elected representatives of the people here.

The Cumann na nGaedheal Party go beyond all reasonable methods when they try to slander Irishmen abroad. That is going a little too far. I think they themselves have now realised that they have gone too far with their campaign of slander. The Irish Press has got a good advertisement. The last speaker wondered what would happen if President de Valera had to go to the Irish people in America, and tell them that the Irish Press was in danger of collapse. I know that if the President would go to Irishmen in this country and tell them that the Irish Press was in danger of collapse he would get the biggest amount of money that has ever been collected for the Irish cause. The Irish Press has got a good show by this attempt to bring discredit on it, and to charge the Government with corruption. Corruption has been imputed to them, but all these imputations will go back to the Cumann na nGaedheal Benches, from which they came.

Comment on this

I would like to give my assurance to the last speaker that I certainly do not wish to see the Irish Press fail. So far as my information goes on the question of newspapers in this country, and my information is from sources which should know something about the matter, the Irish Press is beginning to show itself a good advertising medium in this country. It is not a good thing in any country for one paper to hold an autocratic position. It becomes impossible for business people and advertisers to deal with a paper which has a monopoly. From that point of view it is a good thing to see the Irish Press coming along and proving itself a success as a paper and as an advertising medium. All that seems to me to have nothing at all to do with this particular amendment.

It is my belief, and I hold the belief for obvious reasons, that the sole object of the whole Bill which we are now discussing is defeated by this amendment. The amendment proposes something which would undoubtedly make this an inconvenient time to bring forward this Bill. I did not put myself in possession of all the facts which are indicated on this question of the Dáil funds. But from the information which I have gathered as the debate progressed it seems to me that the Irish Press is entitled to benefit. As I said, I am not in possession of all the facts but so far as this discussion has gone it seems to me that when these funds are being paid, whenever they are being paid, that the Irish Press will certainly be a beneficiary. The way the whole matter appears to me is this, that I regard it as an extremely expensive way of providing £100,000 for the Irish Press to impose on the people of this country a capital liability of £1,500,000. I would much prefer to see a Bill introduced for the sole purpose of providing £100,000 for the Irish Press in its present condition than to see the nation saddled at this precise moment with a capital liability of £1,500,000.

As Deputy Fitzgerald-Kenney pointed out, the Minister for Finance came here a few weeks ago and pleaded, as the sole justification for the "Cuts" Bill, that the Exchequer is in desperate need of money. That was the justification pleaded on every stage of the Economy Bill. In that condition of affairs we have this Bill brought in. The President told us that the receiver has closed his account, that the rate of exchange is in our favour and that money can now be borrowed at a lower interest than has been the case during the last twenty years. They are facts which undoubtedly should weigh with anyone trying to arrive at a conclusion on this amendment, but placed beside the fact that the Minister told us here that he was desperately in need of money for the purpose of carrying on the economic war I think what was mentioned by the President fades into complete insignificance. I believe that this Bill could be postponed to a more convenient date, a date when this country would be better able to support this capital liability of £1,500,000. I think there is no member of the Government Party who will dispute the statement that this country is at present unable to foot such a capital liability.

There are two or three matters which need consideration when arriving at a conclusion upon the question of whether one is going to support or oppose this amendment. One is the financial condition of the State, and another is whether or not the present is a good time at which to introduce a Bill to raise money. Another point which must occur to the mind of anyone studying the question dispassionately is the present condition of the Irish Press. It seems to me that one cannot overlook the position of the company when trying to arrive at an impartial judgment on this amendment. The way I work it out is that the Irish Press, as proved by the last balance sheet, is in need of a considerable sum of money. The next point is that it would, if this Bill were passed, get into its possession £100,000. It is going to cost the country £1,500,000 to do that. I base my support of this amendment upon my discinclination to cost the country in its present condition £1,500,000 in order to provide £100,000 for the Irish Press.

Comment on this
Frank Aiken Minister for Defence (Mr. Aiken) Fianna Fáil

The Deputy who has just spoken questioned the advisability of undertaking a capital liability at this stage. He did not seem to realise that when he used the term "undertaking a capital liability" he completely destroyed his argument about last year's Budgetary position. After all, the Deputy must realise that even though he was against this capital liability being undertaken by President de Valera in 1919, even though he and the people for whom he speaks thought that President de Valera and those associated with him were murderers and should be shot or hanged by the British, it was, nevertheless, a capital liability undertaken in the name of the Irish people and on behalf of the Irish people. He should realise that the proposal is that this capital liability should be met by the creation of another capital liability, not by payment in cash. Of course we realise the Deputy does not think this is an opportune time to do it. He probably hopes that it may never be done. We realise that another rival newspaper the Deputy is interested in——

Comment on this

——is in a rather poor condition at the moment.

Comment on this

I certainly am not interested in it.

Comment on this

We realise that another newspaper in which the Deputy is interested, which used to boast——

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Deputy has definitely stated he is not interested in the other paper to which the Minister has referred. It must also be remembered that a Deputy represents here the people who elected him.

Comment on this

I did not say the Deputy was financially interested in the paper.

Comment on this

I have no interest good, bad or indifferent. If anything, it is quite the other way about.

Comment on this

And the Minister should accept that.

Comment on this

We realise, therefore, that the Deputy wants to see the Independent fail. I put it to the Deputy that one of the best ways in which he could see the Independent failing is to examine its balance sheet and to put the details——

Comment on this

On a point of order. The Minister has not withdrawn the statement he made and I think, in accordance with procedure here, the Minister is supposed to do that.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Minister has stated definitely that he did not mean a financial interest. In questions of this sort it is usual to take the Deputy's word. The Deputy has not mentioned any newspaper except the Irish Press.

Comment on this

I take it the Deputy agrees that he, like myself, is interested in seeing the Independent fail.

Comment on this

Are we to have a withdrawal—an acceptance of the Deputy's word—or not?

Comment on this

The Deputy assured me he has no interest good, bad or indifferent, and I am taking it that, like myself, he wants to see this paper fail.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Minister is taking the Deputy's word?

Comment on this

Surely.

Comment on this

It is quite clear now.

Comment on this

I am taking it that the Deputy, like myself, wants to see this paper, the Independent, that called for the execution of James Connolly, and the other 1916 leaders, meet the fate it deserves. I suggest to the Deputy that one of the best ways to act would be not to oppose this motion but rather to get the Independent newspaper to put out placards stating their present circulation. The Deputy, like myself, will realise that a couple of years ago the Independent used to represent itself as the paper with the largest circulation. Quite recently they changed over from that plane to one to the effect that they had the best circulation.

Comment on this

What has this got to do with the amendment? Let the Minister come down to business.

Comment on this

Deputy O'Connor will realise the effect of what I am saying, that one of the best ways that the Independent can beat itself would be to publish the fact that they have deserted the claim to have the biggest circulation, and that they now are satisfied to claim that they have the best circulation.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

We had a discussion dealing with the Irish Press for hours yesterday. The Deputy to-day referred to the Irish Independent. I do not know what paper will come up next, but it would be better to get down to the matter before the House. There is no reference whatever, whether in the amendment, or in the motion before the Dáil, to any newspaper.

Comment on this

There is to the Irish Press.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Yes, incidentally, that question arises.

Comment on this

The Irish Press seems to many Deputies to be rather like sour grapes. Thanks be to goodness for the amendment, and thanks be to goodness, also, for the fact that there are people in this State very jealous of the Irish Press. It was the greatest satisfaction to me to be here to-day and yesterday, and to see the pains taken by Deputies opposite to speak of the Irish Press, because I regard that as the best guarantee of its success. It was a delightful treat, and I only hope Deputies opposite will continue this treat for another few weeks. I say it was a delightful treat, because it was a long and arduous job to build up a paper that would stand for the Irish people, and we are delighted to see that those who stand for the British are now taking the attitude towards the Irish Press that the fox took towards the grapes. When the fox could not get at the grapes or bring them down, he said they were sour. The Irish Press is up on top; it has come to stay.

Comment on this

This debate has wandered very far afield. The Minister for Defence, in his first speech, spoke a lot about honouring our bonds and so on. There is nothing in the amendment which proposes not to honour our bond. When the Minister came near to the amendment an analogy was drawn between the assigning of these bonds and the assignment of National Loan Bonds. There is no analogy whatever. Why were these bonds asked for in America instead of cash? If anybody came to me and asked me to hand over any stock that I might have in National Loan, I would answer that it was perfectly ridiculous. I would tell him I have only to open the daily paper and get the quotation for National Loan, or ring up a banker or stockbroker to learn that National Loan is quoted at 100 and so and so. National Loan is subject to an arrangement so that it might be registered for transactions that might take place in it. When the bonds we are now discussing were issued in America no such arrangement were made. First of all they were not negotiable. Nothing would arise upon them until such time as certain conditions were fulfilled. Until that happened there would be no question of payment upon them. No register was kept.

Some strange points were made by Deputy Norton, but President de Valera has spared me the trouble of answering Deputy Norton. Deputy Norton put forward a clearly bogus case. Having lost the balance of power, Deputy Norton and his Party have still to crawl behind President de Valera. I say here that President de Valera was quite right in springing a general election, because although the President does not give me much credit for the affection I have for him, I have this esteem for him that I think he was quite justified in showing that he had sufficient self-respect not to continue any longer relying for support on Deputy Norton and his Party. Deputy Norton's case was practically demolished by President de Valera himself. I know how the President got the support he did get. I know his methods rather well. Deputy Norton said that I could not believe that the bonds were valueless, but I would remind the Deputy of what President de Valera himself said in 1926. He said, in page 43 of the White Paper (a) and (b): "I have been convinced from the start that while it was important to maintain the position, our chances of success were very slight." He was then fighting in the American courts, claiming that the residue was due to himself and his friends calling themselves the Second Dáil. He went on to say: "The Free State had made a gesture that they will pay the bonds whether they get the money back again or not. They have not done anything so far. I doubt very much that if a portion of the bond money is paid back to the bondholders the Free State will do so." That was in December, 1926, and that was the President's view then. He doubted very much if the Free State would pay. He had a certain amount of justification for that. We had from time to time made statements that we intended to pay this money back. But there was no commitment; these were mere statements. Although it was certain that we would pay this money back, still, so far as I can judge, we could not pay back that money at a moment when we would have possibly an interest in making a case to England that we could not pay money she was claiming to be legally due to her. The President is right when he says that these Ministerial statements were quite different to people having the money in their pockets. Deputy Norton says that we could have paid it any time from 1922 on. We could not. These loans, as they were called, which were raised in the years 1920 and 1921, were not ordinary Government loans. When it came to paying them back there would have to be an organisation set up and an enormous amount of work would have to be gone through in making lists of the people, and notes of the amount of their subscriptions.

Here I am prepared to defer to the President if I am wrong, when I say, that either what information was available of the bondholders or guaranteed members of the organisation was being gathered together was in our office in Washington. We were trying to get together a list of the names of the subscribers and the amount that each subscribed.

Comment on this

That is all nonsense.

Comment on this

And then came the moment in this case when the court ordered that all documents in our possession should be handed over to the court. My memory may be wrong, but I think that the court ordered that the lists and documents should be handed over to the court. We could not proceed, therefore, to pay out money when we had no lists of the people nor of the amount each subscribed. There was also a difficulty in this country. The President is quite right when he says that really it was not possible effectively to pay back, because the Government as the trustees of the people must take care that it does not pay back what it does not owe. We would have to exercise enormous care to see that the money was only paid back to those who had subscribed it. Deputy Norton may talk about an organisation. He says that not even Deputy Fitzgerald could believe that these bonds were valueless. I have not access to the files now, but the President has access to them and so have his officials from the various Departments. The Dáil will remember that a number of years ago we announced that we were going to pay back the loan that was raised here in Ireland. If the President looks up his files he will find that very serious consideration had to be given to a situation that was arising here at that time.

To the best of my memory, we issued a public warning that we would not recognise transfers because, to my knowledge, the moment certain people, who were watching things rather closely, saw from various indications that that money was going to be paid back, they proceeded to go around to people, who were less alert than they to their own interests, and to buy up bonds for small sums that had no relation to the value the bonds possessed provided we intended to pay them. I myself, in the Cabinet, advocated it and I think that Finance accepted it. I would not swear to that because I am speaking from memory. But I advocated that a warning should be issued against transfers. I think, after that, it was agreed that no serious traffic of that nature, which was effectively swindling the subscribers, was taking place and, consequently, the clause that was intended to be put in was not inserted. But we had to advert to it here, and just note this: Here we are, a small country of about 3,000,000 people, rather like America to the extent that both nations are self-centred and preoccupied with their own affairs. In France and other countries the man who buys his paper in the morning wants to know as much about Russia or Germany or Yugo-Slavia as about France. In Ireland it is different. It must be remembered that in 1925 this matter of repayment was a matter of importance and of very big news in the Irish newspapers and the vast number of people here only read Irish newspapers and are only interested in Irish news. In spite of that, here where the information about, the repayment of loans was a matter of great national importance and public interest, it was necessary for us to issue a warning to save people from parting with their bonds for some small consideration that bore no relation whatever to their value.

In the United States of America there is a vast population. I believe that in some speech in the Carlton Hotel in New York President de Valera described the size of the country compared with Ireland. Some of the newspapers there have 120 pages in them. No person could read them in one day. In such a country and in such newspapers, Irish news is of comparatively small importance and gets very little space. The published notice and the whole knowledge of this Government's intention was not able to be conveyed to the people there in the way in which it could be conveyed here or anything like it. There were tens of thousands of subscribers there, and probably are thousands there at the moment in America who have no idea at all as to the proper idea of this thing. The President read some document and said that it would not be sustainable that the people were not aware of the value attaching to the bonds. He did not mention that the only value that could be known to the people at that time was 58 cents to the dollar and not $1.25.

The Government has issued advertisements here in this small country from time to time with regard to contracts, and I have known potential contractors who have complained with regard to the contract that they have not seen the advertisement here in one of our own newspapers in the country. The position in America was something that bears no relation to the position here. The chances in America, unless the man belongs to some Irish organisation, of hearing of the Government's intention here or seeing it advertised in the papers, are infinitesimal, comparatively speaking. If you issue a notice here which is a legal notice, the person cannot claim that they were not aware of it, although they may not have been aware of it. We could not have gone into the court in America and suggested there were no means for the people to know that these bonds were worth 58 cents of their value. That could not be argued, but I am satisfied that there were thousands who had no clear conception of what the value was. Why was big machinery set up under the control of one of the most able lawyers in America—as I might almost have called Horatio Bottomley the most able man in England—to persuade or induce the people to hand over these bonds? If the bond was worth 50 dollars and realisable at any moment there was no point in going over the amount. It is just like a ragman coming to your house. You say to him: "As far as I am concerned this stuff is of no value to me." Often he can take it away for nothing. I remember George Bernard Shaw telling me that when he was moving he invited a man to take away a lot of papers and books he had and the man said: "I will give £50 for them." Shaw said: "I thought you were going to ask me to pay you for taking them away." In the same way over there, at a certain moment a person came along with the glamour of Irish patriotism about him and said: "I am not asking you to make any further sacrifice; just hand over that bond to which you do not attach any value; it may be of value to me to the extent of 58 cents."

These people had given the money not as a gift. It had been announced, particularly by the Party opposite, that the object for which that money was given had failed in attainment, and, consequently, legally on the face of the bond it was not due for repayment. There have been three cases in the American courts. One was the case in which President de Valera was directly interested, claiming that the residue should go to himself and to his friends. Another case was the Hearn Bond case, and ours was the Noonan case. Our case was that the residue should be handed over to the Free State on condition that when it was handed over the Government would accept full responsibility for the full amount and would guarantee to pay the full amount, but the court refused that.

Comment on this

Deputy Fitzgerald, when he was in America some time in 1929, did his best to get some of these bonds and failed.

Comment on this

Never! I assert on my honour that I never asked for these bonds.

Comment on this

What was your interview with Cardinal Hayes about?

Comment on this

Cardinal Hayes is a public man, and anything said here will probably be reported. My interview with him had no reference whatever to finances or to these bonds. I went to pay a visit to Cardinal Hayes in New York, as he was a great man and a public figure, and a supporter of the Irish cause, and as I was a public man here. If we spoke of Irish affairs at all, I would certainly not have made a reference to anything like that, or any reference to Party differences here. I do not admit I got one bond from any person.

Comment on this

I cannot accept your statement because I know otherwise.

Comment on this

I am prepared to meet the Deputy outside, if he can produce any proof. I should like him to give the name of any person from whom I tried to get a bond. Let us get any name from him.

Comment on this

All right.

Comment on this

The court had refused to recognise the responsibility of this State for paying all back and had refused the Noonan case. The court found that the trust for which the money had been subscribed had failed in attainment and had no prospect of ever attaining that condition. That is to say, that there was no prospect of the condition which would warrant the claim for repayment ever being attained. Some of the people at that time would realise that there was going to be the repayment which we have had at 58 cents to the dollar. The majority of them, I assert, did not attribute any value to the bonds they parted with. The vast majority of the rest of them did not attribute a value of more than 58 cents to the dollar. There is no analogy whatever to this red-herring that is dragged across. If someone comes along and asks you for your scrip of National Loan, and if you take up the Irish Independent, the Irish Press, or any other paper, you will see there that one share has a value of £103 to-day. Nobody can do that with regard to these bonds in America. On their face, they were valueless unless the trustees were empowered to redistribute the residue pro rata. There is one point that is overlooked. The President now, by this Bill, is announcing that this Government is due to pay back this money. He brought a case in the American courts to deny that. It was a very costly case. He also promoted the second bondholders' case, which was also a very expensive case on both sides.

Comment on this

I think I made it quite clear that the bondholders intervened themselves and in most matters my case was quite contrary to theirs.

Comment on this

I shall read from page 39, documents A and B:—

"Mr. Seán T. O'Kelly: The Ceann Comhairle was in America previous to my going over and this litigation was going on before that. I first came into this matter when I was appointed as envoy and landed in America in 1924 and when, shortly after my arrival there, I was sent by the then President power of attorney which gave me power to act as representative of the trustees and took their place as far as the lawyers were concerned, and gave opinions and advice that might seem useful to the lawyers in the case. Later on, acting on instructions from here, and arising out of advice given by the lawyers, I was instructed to get formed a bondholders' committee, and that committee took a practical form about April, 1925."

That is enough for that. The suggestion all the time is that we are trying to prevent the original bondholders from supporting the Irish Press. People have talked about the Irish Press employing 333 persons. That 333 only represents to me half of 666, the number of the Beast. I will say frankly that I should like to see the Irish Press stop publication.

Comment on this
A Deputy

That is the whole truth.

Comment on this

Just as the Minister for Defence would like to see the ruin of the Irish Independent. I shall give my reasons. The very style in which it is written is moulded in the most appalling——

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

We are not discussing whether the Deputy would like to see the Irish Press suspended. We cannot allow that to go on.

Comment on this

Very well. Personally, I would not regard it as a national evil if the Irish Press ceased publication. Speakers on the Government side have expressed the opinion that the election of the Government to their present position was due to the existence of the Irish Press. They may be right. The President said he was completely disinterested in the Irish Press. But, if what they say is right, he is now President of the Executive Council, and drawing the emoluments of that office by virtue of the existence of the Irish Press. I am not asserting that. Personally, as far as I can judge the political movement of this country during the years, and the appalling disregard of truth on the part of that Party in speaking to the people of this country, whose historical circumstances had made one believe that, once they attained national freedom, somehow or another the evils which afflicted humanity were going to pass away, it seems to me that without the Irish Press the Government would probably have got a majority. But that is only my opinion. Deputy Norton would not like to prevent the Maynooth Mission to China from getting the money. I think Deputy O'Brien was also terribly upset about that. As far as that is concerned, the people gave these bonds over to the Maynooth Mission to China. My amendment would mean that the Government here would see to it that the money due on the bonds would go back to the original subscribers. I am one who believes that these persons wanted to give that money to assist the Maynooth Mission. Then they will hand it over.

Comment on this
Donnchadh Ó Briain Donnchadha O Briain Fianna Fáil

Did they not do it already? Of course they did, and once is enough.

Comment on this

The position at that moment was that they were worth 58 cents in the dollar. Another 67 cents are to come along now.

Comment on this
Donnchadh Ó Briain Donnchadha O Briain Fianna Fáil

They assigned the whole bond.

Comment on this

The bond was not negotiable.

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

It was assignable.

Comment on this

Yes. This Bill is to bring in a special form to provide that the money will go to the assignees. Why should we think that the people who, in 1928, handed over the bonds to the Chinese Mission would now, if they got the money, refuse to part with it to the Chinese Mission? I do not think so. Why is it assumed, on the other side, that if these people can get their hands on the 67 cents to the dollar before the Irish Press gets it, that the Irish Press will never see it? Why is it assumed that the acceptance of the amendment means that the Irish Press will not get the money. I have no doubt that some of the people would still pass over the 67 cents. I have equally no doubt that a good many people would not pass on that money. When the people have the money in their hands, and their minds are fully informed on the subject, if they want to give the money then they can give it and nobody is proposing is that they should be prevented from doing it. What we are proposing is that they themselves should have an option in the matter.

There is a point which I wanted to bring out when I was interrupted. There was a question raised on the Money Resolution for this Bill as to the amount of the residue in America in December, 1922, and the amount distributed. There was interest accruing on the residue there. It was announced in the court that it was at 2½ per cent. I think the court ordered that a higher interest should be demanded from the date the order was made. Consequently, there was an amount there in 1922, plus the interest accruing, when the money was distributed—the 58 cents in the dollar. Do Deputies think that that represents the money that was there in 1922, plus the interest that was divided pro rata amongst the people amounting to 58 cents? Out of that money was taken the law costs, law costs imposed through the action of President de Valera. Another matter that has not come here is this, that in America—I do not know what is the position here—when there is a question of trust money like this in dispute, and it is decided by the court that it be returned pro rata to the original subscribers, trustees are appointed by the court, and those trustees deduct for their services a percentage of the whole amount. Consequently, out of this original money has been deducted a percentage for the trustees, and the law costs in a number of expensive cases in America. That whole situation, involving an enormous sum of money, has been brought about by the action of the President in America. It does seem to me rather scandalous—I should not like to be as severe as Deputy MacDermot and say indelicate—of the President, having imposed those enormous costs on the unfortunate people of this country, to insist that this Bill should go through in a special form that will permit him, as trustee for the Irish Press or whatever it may be, to get possession of this money without allowing the original subscribers to opt as to whether or not it will be handed over to them. Deputy Norton said that my objection to the organ is that it does not support us. That was a very nice way of putting it. I would go further and say that one of my objections to the organ is that not only does it not support us, but it does its best to misrepresent and malign us in every possible way. What is going to happen? The Irish Press, when the President loses his temper and shouts at me across the House, comes out with a big heading: “Stinging Replies of the President,” and I am going to be taxed to permit the Irish Press to misrepresent me, to misrepresent the Party I represent, and to misrepresent what I think are the best interests of the Irish people. I am going to be taxed for that, and everybody else is going to be taxed in this country to assist that. You can talk about equity and justice and honouring your bonds, and all the rest of it, as much as you like. The Fianna Fáil Party denounced us as not being a national Government. Why? Because we were the Government of the Irish Free State. We were not revolutionary, so we were traitors and not national. Why? Because we worked the Treaty. When they became elected and worked the Treaty, breaking it here and there when it suits them, we are told they are a national Government. The Minister for Finance said the other day that only for the Irish Press there would not be a national Government here now. A great many of the people who voted for the Government in power are people who are Communists, who belong to the I.R.A. and various other organisations, like that which to-day announces that they thoroughly disapprove of this Bill, and disapprove of the Irish Press incidentally. We are all going to be taxed to keep that paper going, and to keep that Government in office. That does not seem equitable. If anybody proposed that I should be taxed to keep the Irish Independent going I should object also, but not quite so vigorously, because, though the Irish Independent may have its little prejudices here and there, it is not a bought organ. At one moment the Minister for Defence gets up——

Comment on this
Donnchadh Ó Briain Donnchadha O Briain Fianna Fáil

What about its action in 1916?

Comment on this

——One moment. The Minister for Defence gets up and talks about the Irish Independent as being controlled by us, and the next minute he talks about it as controlling us and giving us our orders. The truth is that the Irish Independent is independent as far as I am concerned. I should strongly object to being taxed to keep it going, but I object much more strongly to being taxed to keep a paper going which I think represents a policy against the best interests of the people of this country, which consistently attempts to mislead people by the suppression and twisting of truth, and which by its very style is calculated to bring about a sort of liquefaction of mind.

I must say I nearly fell down when Deputy MacDermot got up and talked about the President being indelicate. I am not going to pretend that I wore kid gloves with the President yesterday; I did say quite a number of harsh things, but I should really hesitate before I used that word "indelicate." I may have talked about sharp practice, and pulling the wool over people's eyes. That does not affect him much, because he might say that he got Frank P. Walsh to do those things. Just as he said to me at one time last year, when I pointed out that his Minister for Posts and Telegraphs had recommended that we should not be allowed to have free speeches, he can say that he was not present. He was not present when quite a number of things were being done in America, so he feels quite right in his conscience, but when it comes to accusing him of being a bit indelicate that is a personal matter. I know exactly what the President felt when that was said. It required great self-control on his part to prevent that lock from coming down when replying to Deputy MacDermot. That is a thing that should not have been said. My sympathies were all with him. You can say really harsh things such as I do at times about the President, but that sort of thing is not to be borne.

With regard to Deputy Norton, that independent man, he got up and disapproved of the speeches which I made and which Deputy McGilligan made, and proceeded in a clumsy way—which must have disgusted the President, who likes a little delicacy about those things—to support the money going to the Irish Press. I know Deputy Norton's type. He likes, when he goes around the constituency and into Government offices to get a good reception. I should just like to put one thing to any intelligent man in the House, or woman for that matter. Suppose Deputy Cosgrave, when President, had gone to America and had run a big campaign with an organisation there for getting possession of those bonds; suppose, having done that, he then brought in a Bill for the repayment of those bonds, and resisted any attempt that was made to let the original subscribers opt as to whether or not they wanted him to get possession of the money to be paid on the assigned bonds; does anybody here think that Deputy Norton—clumsily or delicately —would have got up and said that he disapproved entirely of what was being said of President Cosgrave; that he entirely held that the bondholders should not be given any say in the matter, and that the money must go to President Cosgrave? If anybody wants to test the honesty of Deputy Norton in this case, let him put the question to himself: “If President Cosgrave had gone over to raise this money, would Deputy Norton have got up, repudiated the people who raised a question about it, and stood up for President Cosgrave's action?” Every man in this House knows that if that had been done, Deputy Norton, if he were here, would have got up—or Deputy Johnson, if he had been here— and would have denounced in the name of purity in public life such an action on the part of Deputy Cosgrave.

But Deputy Norton gets up to defend it when President de Valera does it. Why? A very good reason. President de Valera has a certain amount of personality, and he has got it fairly fixed in Deputy Norton's mind that his place is to be crawling before him whether Deputy Norton holds the balance of power or does not. I am rather flattered in this matter, because the last place I spoke when Deputy Norton was on the platform was in the Rathmines Town Hall, in 1927, when Kevin O'Higgins and I stood up on the platform and, in spite of howling women, insisted on saying what we had to say. Deputy Norton got up and tried to make a speech, but he did not go on with his speech. He was not able to stand up to them. At the time I told him what I thought of him, and I am flattered now at knowing I was then right.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

That has nothing to do with the amendment.

Comment on this

It is only a little reminiscence that goes occasionally with me as it does with the President. One of the Deputies on the Government side said that there was very little talk of this amendment on the Second Reading. Anybody who takes the trouble to read what I said on the Second Reading will remember that I advanced a series of suggestions about these bonds just as the man says in court that he is innocent, that he did not use the words, and that if he used them he used them in a different sense. In this debate I went on rather the same line. I said that this was not the best time to pay back the money, it was not the time to pay it back, and that if we insisted on it a case could be made against it by those people who went into the American courts, but still, if we intended to pay it, then it should be paid to the original subscribers and not to the assignees. Then this Deputy gets up and says there was little talk about this amendment until after the Second Reading. But on the Second Reading this amendment was indicated. The Deputy suggests that the Cumann na nGaedheal Party has got its orders from the Independent, while all the time the Deputy knew that this amendment was implied in what we said on the Second Reading Stage. There has been a lot of discussion about the President as trustee for these moneys. He told us that all the moneys that came from America for the Irish Press will be credited to these people and that the subscribers to the bonds are going to get whatever interest is due to them. I take his word. I am not saying that that is not so, but if that is so it is a variation of the proposal that was made to them in America, because it says on the prospectus:—

"Whilst these funds are being solicited by way of donations, Mr. de Valera will, of course, not derive personally any monetary profit from them. He intends to make the necessary and proper arrangements to ensure that if any profits accrue from the enterprise, or, if there should be any distribution of assets, such profits and the amount of any such distribution will be made available for the donors, according to their respective donations. For that purpose a register of those on whose assigned bond certificates a payment of ten dollars and over is made will be carefully kept. Payments of amounts less than $10, and the fractional parts of one dollar in payments amounting to more than $10, will be accredited to the assignors as advance subscriptions, for which they will receive an equivalent number of copies of the weekly edition of the proposed newspaper when issued."

I mention this in fairness to the President. He changed his mind afterwards. He said that in the case of every penny he brought from America that the bondholders would receive a share of the profits made or it may be that in the heat of the moment he spoke hastily when he should have qualified what he said. I raise this point now to allow him to clear it up. As Miss MacSwiney said the majority of the people who subscribed heavily in America were actually Free Staters. I know that a great many Free Staters were misled into handing over the bonds. Quite a number of them representing the more intelligent section did not part with their bonds. Miss MacSwiney said as stated in page 42 of this book which I am reading: "The largest bondholders are Free Staters, but it is better that it should go back to the bondholders than that it should go to the Free State and how far will that implicate us in any statements they may make that the Republic has failed?" One would deduce from that that a large number of those bonds that have been assigned were bonds of a small denomination and possibly of less than ten dollars.

I gathered from President de Valera's statement that the original intention set out in the prospectus was varied. But we want to be quite fair to him and I think he should be able to announce why that variation was made. On the Second Reading I was challenged as I am always challenged when I refer to things in the Dáil. One is always challenged about the column and the reference and if you put an "if" or an "or" where it should not be you are denounced as misrepresenting the case. President de Valera however gets up and suggests a case or puts it by implication or says that he thought it was so and you have got his word only. But you have to get his word in print in some authoritative way and read it as it was uttered and then he will proceed to give you what he really meant and not what is in print before you.

On the Second Reading the Minister for Finance got up and when I referred to these things he challenged me to produce the documents. What was the implication? That I was concocting what I was saying, and the Minister for Finance did that when the Minister himself knew perfectly well that what I was reading out were the words of the document that had been distributed in America. When I told him that I was reading from the United Irishman he said that he did not believe anything that appeared in the United Irishman. Now I have since carefully dug out the original document that was distributed in America and I am ready to hand it over to the House to be printed as a White Paper if necessary. The President will recognise his own handwriting produced “photoscopically” to show to the people in America that this was the great de Valera himself writing to them. The House can have this; if anybody questions it I am ready to hand it over and have it printed as a White Paper.

To come back to my amendment, my amendment does not deprive the Irish Press of one penny. It in no way proposes to dishonour our bond. In no way does it propose that. My amendment proposes that we will pay back with interest to the people who subscribed it the money they subscribed and, if, presumably, they are honest people and some of them have parted with these bonds fully realising their value, we presume they will hand over the additional 67 cents in the dollar to the people to whom they assigned them. Some of them sold their bonds for what was a fair sum considering the money was not realisable at the time. They will now presumably hand over that 67 cents in the dollar to the people to whom they sold them. But if some of them parted with the bond on a misunderstanding they will then have the option of retaining the money or giving it, and moved by patriotism they will assign that to the Irish Press which, as the Government put it, is a valuable financial property. Now there is nothing in my amendment to prevent them handing over the 67 cents in the dollar to President de Valera or to the Irish Press or to whomever the money may be owing. There is nothing whatever. The only thing proposed in my amendment is this: that the money shall go back to the people who subscribed it.

That same proposal would be incorporated in the Bill that provided for the payment of the Dáil Eireann Loan in Ireland, if we had not been satisfied that as a result of the warnings issued on the part of the Government here when the traffic in the Dáil Loan Bonds in Ireland commenced and when people were asked to part with their bonds for sums that bore no equivalent to their value, if we had not been satisfied that the warning was effective. If we had not been satisfied that that traffic had been stopped and that there was no serious situation to be met, an amendment similar to this would have been inserted in the Act under which we repaid the Dáil Loan. I myself knew cases where £1 worth of bonds were sold for 7/-. If that traffic had gone on to any extent a clause similar to this amendment would have been inserted in the Act. The President will find that very matter on the files in Government Buildings. At that time there was no question of the Irish Press and there was no question of the political colour of the people who were trying to get these bonds cheaply from unwary people. I am quite prepared to be told that all the people who were engaged in this traffic of buying these bonds were Cumann na nGaedhealers. They might have been but if we were not satisfied that the thing had not been stopped a section exactly similar to this amendment would have been inserted in that Act without any reference to the Irish Press or Fianna Fáil or President de Valera. The President has got up and said there is only one thing operating in our mind and that was a desire to injure the Irish Press.

Comment on this
A Deputy

Of course.

Comment on this

Very well. The President will find that we had a desire to prevent a similar traffic in 1924 or 1925 and it was only when we were satisfied that that attempt was nipped in the bud that we stopped. Whom were we trying to injure then? Simpleminded people up and down the country who in our hour of trouble in this country had subscribed the money. We wanted te see that these people were not going to be defrauded and that they were only going to part with it for the value. That was the purpose then. I am satisfied now that if the President will refer to his officials he will find that whole matter was gone into here in 1924 and 1925 in regard to the repayment of the bonds. As far as the repayment of the bonds in America I must say that I did think that if this amendment was going to be resisted some sort of decent case would have been made against it.

The Minister for Defence said that we must honour our bond. There is no suggestion that we shall not honour our bond. Every other thing is dragged across to misrepresent and try to convey a false impression as to what the exact purport of the amendment is. Its exact purport is to see that the money is paid back to the people who subscribed it and if anybody attempted to swindle them on a previous occasion—I am not saying anybody did—the original subscribers will now have an opportunity of defending themselves from being swindled. If they have lost their 58 cents on the dollar nothing can be done to get that back; but at least they will not now be swindled, without an attempt to protect themselves, of a further 67 cents on the dollar. If any of them desired then and desire now that their interests should be handed to President de Valera to keep the Irish Press alive to fulfil whatever functions it does fulfil, there is nothing in the amendment that handicaps or hinders them from doing it. There was no argument brought forward, but there was a lot of abuse thrown away at us. I admit we occasionally give a little back. What argument is brought forward? Something that the Irish Independent wrote 17 years ago, as if that has anything to do with it. If any good case could be made against my amendment it would have been made. It was not made because it could not be made.

Comment on this
Patrick Joseph Ruttledge Minister for Justice (Mr. Ruttledge) Fianna Fáil

I do not propose to worry the House with a long speech after what we have listened to. I think one of the most tiring things the House can experience is having people who think they are showmen perpetrating their theatricals here. There is another place for that and if Deputy Fitzgerald wants to amuse himself by gesticulating with his fingers and his hands he can go to some second-class show house and parade as long as he likes to an empty house.

Comment on this

The people sent him here.

Comment on this

That was their mistake.

Comment on this

To get back to the amendment, there are a few pertinent questions I would like to put to Deputy Fitzgerald if he were here. He complained that we have made no case against the amendment. I want to know from him what case he has made for it. An amendment is put in here which suggests that an attempt is being made to defraud certain innocent people in America; in other words, pull the wool over their eyes. Is Deputy Fitzgerald trying to pose as the great protector of those innocent people? I have listened to his two speeches and there has not been an indication that any of these people alleged to be defrauded have written to him or anybody else declaring they were and that they did not know what they were doing. That is the essence of it. Of course I am not surprised at anything that comes from the Deputy or his colleagues; but why come here and suggest by implication, by innuendo, perhaps even by direct words, that these poor people did not know what they were doing and they were defrauded? Did a single person write to him and say so? Has any one of those alleged defrauded people sent a petition or a communication of any sort to Deputy Fitzgerald pointing out the circumstances under which they were taken in? Not one. It was his duty and not ours to make the case. It is our duty to answer any case made. He has not given a solitary scintilla of evidence to show there was any individual defrauded or taken in by what happened.

Let us examine the facts in order to see how easily Deputy Fitzgerald could have secured evidence, if there were evidence available. It was pointed out by the President that the previous Government made several promises to pay this money. It has been suggested that certain announcements that would be made in newspapers, owing to the size and so on, would escape public notice. The Deputy has not suggested that notice would not have reached the people interested in those bonds as to the payment by the Free State Government, as to the honouring of the bonds. The people knew perfectly well, long before President de Valera went to America in 1927, that those bonds would be honoured, and they had the definite statement that they would be paid. President de Valera did not go to America at that time in the darkness. He did not go out on some secret boat or anything of that kind. There is no suggestion by Deputy Fitzgerald that he did. He went out quite openly and issued statement after statement about the Irish Press being founded. These statements were circulated freely in America. At any rate, when he went there he made it clear to the people the type of project that was in hand. A certain sum of money had been collected here and a further sum was collected in America at the same time as those bonds were being assigned.

No attempt has been made to suggest in regard to those documents that were executed at that time that the people who executed them did not know and approve their contents. No suggestion was made that undue influence was used in getting the people to execute them—no suggestion, except by the sort of sideway that only Deputy Fitzgerald can be guilty of. There was no suggestion that they were got by fraud. Those are grounds on which documents can be set aside, but Deputy Fitzgerald made no attempt to show that such grounds existed. He has not referred to one individual out of the hundreds who assigned bonds who complained and said he was defrauded. Was there ever such a ridiculous or absurd case made in this House? The Deputy seemed to convey that we are a most fraudulent people. Surely Deputy Fitzgerald, who must be a pillar of the Church, a great gospeller and the bulwark against everything anti-religious and all that sort of thing, the type of man who must be expecting in the quickest possible time after he dies that he will be canonised, does not suggest that those who got assignments for the purpose of helping the Mission to China got them by fraud. Nevertheless, the Deputy comes with an amendment which will prevent the money assigned to the Mission to China and other religious purposes going directly to them.

Comment on this

Not at all.

Comment on this

"Not at all," from another bulwark of the Church.

Comment on this

That is very cheap.

Comment on this

What does it mean? I put it this way to Deputy Morrissey: supposing one of those persons who made an assignment has since died does that mean that the money which that person had assigned to the Chinese Mission is recoverable from the Chinese Mission or is the Chinese Mission to get it? Will Deputy Morrissey answer that question? In the lapse of years a large number of people who held these bonds will have died. According to the amendment whether those people assigned their money to the Chinese Mission or not does not matter, the money will go to another purpose altogether. We have heard a lot here about the purpose to which this money is going. We have heard a lot about the Irish Press. Unless Deputy Fitzgerald is able to prove that those people who assigned their moneys for the Irish Press were weakminded, and did not know what they were doing, or that some extraordinary influence was used upon them, it does not matter one whit what they do with their money. It was their money and it is for them to do what they wish with it.

We hear of extraordinary things in wills and assignments made under wills. We hear of people cutting out their relations altogether, but that is their own affair. They can leave their money to anybody they like and nobody should be entitled to come along as Deputy Fitzgerald does, and say, these people should not do so and so. The people, who are referred to in this amendment, acted with their eyes open, and they acted in a national spirit. What was in the minds of those people was that they gave this money for the advancement of the national movement. That movement advanced up to a certain point where it was held up. Later when they found another national advance was being made they decided to take part in it and they were glad to have the opportunity of allowing the money which they subscribed earlier to be made available in order to allow the present advance to go forward.

What annoys me in this debate is that people are making charges, and bandying them about without one single bit of evidence to support them. We had Deputy Fitzgerald-Kenney coming along and saying he heard the police had to be called in to a meeting of the Irish Press shareholders. He said it was only a rumour. Deputy Fitzgerald-Kenney may have forgotten, through his continued absence from a certain place, about the rules of evidence. Somebody should remind him about those rules, for if ever he goes back again and if he makes a statement in court if he has not evidence to back it up, he will be told he will have to withdraw it unless he produces the evidence to support it. But he comes in here, having forgotten apparently what he learned, and tells us that the police were called in to the Irish Press meeting, and he adds that it was only a rumour. He would believe anything that would injure the Irish Press. I do not want to say anything personal, but some people have reasons for that kind of feeling. No case has been made for this amendment. There has been no evidence put before the House to show that there was default. All these people who gave this money, and who are being made catspaws of by Deputy Fitzgerald, who is trying to use them for political advantage in order to try and damage the President and throw a slur upon him, are being used for that purpose without their consent. The Deputy is using people who are not with him either in national feeling or in national sentiment. He is using these people without having their authority, and using them for one purpose, in the hope that they might go back on the promises they have made.

Comment on this

There was one thing that I liked in the speech of the Minister for Justice, and that was its brevity. It is a pity, for the sake of order and for the good of the country, that the President was not as brief in his first or second speech as the Minister for Justice was. But I object to the President and the Minister for Justice putting the Chinese Mission on the same level as the Irish Press. I have no doubt whatever that whatever may have been the methods used to get this money assigned to the Irish Press, that such methods were not needed to get the Irish people to assign their bonds to the Chinese Mission or to the Yorke Memorial.

Comment on this

Can the Deputy prove they were not needed?

Comment on this

I am suggesting they were not.

Comment on this

The Deputy has no evidence of that.

Comment on this

Nothing that has been said by the Minister or the President has removed that. Perhaps the Minister would allow me to make my own speech. It has been said in this House that it is not possible to prove things, and I think that is a very useful ruling from the point of view of the Government Front Bench. It is quite true, anyway. During the litigation in America the President either personally or through his representative, at a cost of roughly 190,000 dollars to this country, saw to it that the Irish Free State would not honour her bonds that we heard so much about. If I remember aright, I think it is the opinion of most people in the House that the President's argument was that the Free State were not the legitimate successors to the First and Second Dáil. Does the President claim, as President of Saorstát Eireann, that he and his Government are the legitimate successors to the First and Second Dáil? Does he claim that, particularly in view of the official statement issued by those who claim that they are the only legitimate successors and the only persons entitled to carry on on the authority of the First and Second Dáil? I want to know what happened since the litigation in America that enabled the President to come in here and to put up a case, after his effort, at a cost of 190,000 dollars, to prevent the Free State carrying out their obligations in 1925.

In raising this issue I do not speak of the President in his personal capacity but of the Government as a whole. So far as I am personally concerned I dissociate myself absolutely and completely from the accusation that the President, at any time either during his period in America, or now, had any desire whatsoever to benefit himself personally or any member of his family. Although I do not agree with the President politically, and so long as he follows his present bent I never will agree with him, still I believe he is a man completely honest and straightforward.

I want to say now that it is well known to most people in this country that the Irish Press cannot continue to live unless it gets this money. I want to remind the President of this, that when the Irish Press was looking for subscriptions in this country they said it was for a non-party paper. What has happened since the Irish Press was first issued shows that the money obtained in this country was obtained on false pretences, because the Irish people were asked to subscribe to a paper that was to be non-party, because the people were asked, and it is on record, to subscribe to a national newspaper that was to be a non-party paper. What does a national newspaper connote? To-day, we have the position that it is neither a newspaper nor national. It is a party organ.

Comment on this

We would like to know what the Deputy means by a party organ?

Comment on this

The President knows much better than I do what a party organ means. He can explain it much better than I can. If there is one thing for which the Irish Press is bought to-day—and let me pay it this tribute— it is for its sporting news, its tips on English races.

Comment on this

As a party organ?

Comment on this

I am talking about its news. If the President can get, to use his own words, a legal quibble, he will be glad to jump on it, but the fact remains that the Irish Press is neither a newspaper nor national. It is simply a party organ of which the President was the controlling director. I wonder why he has ceased to be the controlling director. The President told us last night that they were advised that the Irish Press, just like any ordinary newspaper, would have to be prepared to lose a certain amount of money for the first two, three or four years. I am quite prepared to accept that statement from information which I got from people who were in a position to advise on that matter. He said that £200,000 was subscribed, and that £109,000 of that went into machinery and other overhead expenses, which left him with a capital——

Comment on this

I spoke of the prospectus.

Comment on this

I understood the President to say that there was a sum of £200,000 subscribed.

Comment on this

The Deputy should be careful about his facts before making a statement. I was quoting from the prospectus showing, before the paper started, what were the intentions.

Comment on this

I am prepared to accept the President's correction, unlike some members of the President's Party. I do not want to misquote him. I am bound to receive his correction. I had thought that the President said that £200,000 had been subscribed to the Irish Press. I am more inclined to believe now that that was the sum mentioned in the prospectus. The President said that £109,000 of that was going to go into machinery and other overhead expenses, and that £200,000 of working capital would be required and that was considered quite sufficient. Would I be correct in saying that the President as a director of the Irish Press, was advised by experts that he would want to be in a position to lose £200,000, before the Irish Press, or any other Irish newspaper, for that matter, could be put on a paying foundation? I think I would be correct in saying that.

Comment on this

Again I ask the Deputy to quote what he knows instead of surmising.

Comment on this

I am telling the President that I was informed that the President was advised that the directors of the Irish Press, or of any Irish newspaper, starting at that time as a party organ, or as a newspaper attached to a party, would have to be prepared to stand a loss of at least £200,000 before they would get upon their feet. That is my information, and I am suggesting that the £91,000, plus the £100,000 that must be got from the American bonds, is the reason for this Bill.

There is another point I want to put. What would be the position of the people in America who assigned their bonds if, as might quite easily have happened, the present Government had not been returned to power, if the Irish Press had failed within the first six months? Would their money have been lost completely, or would there not be a clamour that, because the people were so foolish as to assign their bonds, we would be in honour bound to pay the money? I should like the President to look into that. I want to make this point and to let the President if he is going to speak again in this debate answer it; and let us hope, sir, if we are going to get away out of this House at all before Christmas, that there will not be the same liberty on every Committee Stage on every Bill that comes before us as the President and others in the House have had on this, because if they are to have the same liberty on all the controversial matters that come before this House, I am afraid we will be lucky to get home for our Christmas dinner. But it is not a question of honouring our bond. Every Party in this House agrees that the money should be repaid to the people who subscribed the money. There is no legal quibble about it—none whatever. We heard Deputy Cleary and the Minister for Defence talking. It is a pity the Minister for Defence did not tell us all he might have told us seeing that he spent six months during the time he was in this House in America, trying to raise money for the Irish Press, and told us on his return that when he arrived in New York on a Christmas Eve, there might have been a sober man or woman in New York but he did not see one. Then we have this from the President: “If we want to borrow money again the wisest course is to pay all we owe and not indulge in legal quibbles.” I wish the President would apply that all round. There is no suggestion on this side of the House that the money should not be repaid, but we are trying to see that it will be repaid to those who lent it and not to those who intercepted it.

(The President and Mr. O'Connor rose.)

Comment on this

There is an objection to long speeches and I would be happy to end the debate if——

Comment on this

Is the President going to reply?

Comment on this

Deputy O'Connor——

Comment on this

Deputy O'Connor has not spoken yet, and the President has made two long speeches.

Comment on this

Deputy O'Connor has taken me up incorrectly. I said I would be very happy to end the debate if there were no people on the other side to stand up and add a new list of things to all they have already said. I was about to say that if Deputy O'Connor got up I should like this to be the last, but if not there might be other things to answer.

Comment on this

Tá go breagh!

Comment on this

I was accused of discourtesy by the Leader of the Opposition, because I did not give him the quotation or the reference which I gave in the Second Reading speech. I try to be as courteous as I can, but when I am met, as I was a couple of days ago, in dealing with the time of the House, I think that courtesy would be lost on people of that kind. I told Deputy Cosgrave, when he asked for the information, that if he had been in his place in the House he could have got it, and I do not propose to go any further to get it for him.

Deputy Fitzgerald, in his last speech, and other Deputies after him, referred to the cost to this State of the litigation in America. Just as they have got away for ten years with the cry that I caused the Civil War, that I put the Irish people at each other's throats, so also Deputy Cosgrave and Deputy Fitzgerald would like to get away now with the suggestion that the expense of this litigation was my fault. I was appointed trustee by Dáil Eireann of certain large funds. It was my duty to defend these funds in accordance with the trust, and I went over to America to defend them against the claim that was being made here by the Executive of the time to get possession of the funds. It is suggested that it was I who was defeated in that instance. I was not the plaintiff. I was defending the trust. Those who brought the action were the Executive of the day, and they claimed in the American courts to get these funds as a matter of right. I denied their right to get the funds. There was a body of American citizens, representing those who had subscribed to the funds, who also put a claim in against the Free State claim, as Deputy Fitzgerald indicated. If the judgement in the American courts meant anything, it certainly meant that an outside court at that date did not regard the Irish Free State as entitled to get the balance of that money. Was I as trustee not entitled to hold such a view?

I knew better than anybody living the circumstances under which that money had been obtained, because I had been one of the principal people in soliciting it. I knew the purpose for which it was subscribed and I claimed at that time, and I would do the very same thing to-day, that the balance of that money was not, at any rate, clearly due to be paid over here to the Irish Exchequer. That money was subscribed for certain purposes. A part of it had been spent. The remainder of that money was either for the purpose of continuing the effort for the original object for which it was subscribed or it was to go back to the original owners. The American court held that it should go back. I say that the judgment of the American court was a complete defence of my attitude in denying the right of the Exchequer of the Free State at that time to get the money. It is now suggested that, because I denied the right of the Government at that particular time to get that money, I should logically say that we had no obligation to pay back the money. Certainly I have never claimed that you have to pay back the money twice. The money that was not spent here for the purpose for which it was originally intended was being sent back and you were going to get due credit for it. But for the money that was spent here you had a full obligation, and this Bill is carrying out your obligation precisely in that respect. You are taking credit for the money that was distributed, and you are completing the fulfilment of the obligations, which I hold were obligations for any Government that was functioning here and that claims to represent, as we claim to represent, the majority of the people even in the Twenty-six Counties.

These are two different things. I know that people who would be inclined to take advantage of a legal quibble—Deputy Cosgrave suggested it —might possibly be inclined to say: "Well, if the court did not adjudge this balance ours, we have no responsibility for paying anything," even though everybody knows that the greater part of that money was spent here from 1920 to 1922 for the explicit purposes for which it was subscribed. Some speakers, of course, deny that there is any suggestion that this money is not due. Deputy Rice corrected himself to-day. I stated that he had said that the money was not due, and he denied that. I said I was prepared to take his correction, but I have since got the transcript of his speech. It is a matter of record, but here is what he is reported as having said: "This country, through its Government, now proposes to pay a debt which is not due." That is what he said. He corrected that to-day when I charged him with it. Other Deputies, whom I heard speaking, are apparently of a like mind. There are two questions here. Is this money due or not? Do we accept that it is due? I am willing to accept the assurance of the Leaders on the opposite side that officially their Party accept it as due. I hope that is understood anyhow. Am I right in taking it then that, with a few exceptions, we are all agreed in this House that this money is due?

Comment on this

Does the President mean legally due or morally due? I think Deputy Rice was referring to the legal case.

Comment on this

Deputy Rice is well able to make his own case. He did not make that case this morning. I cannot know what he meant. I can only take the words he used. We regard it as a moral obligation anyhow and our predecessors regarded it in exactly the same light. Why, then, does a Deputy say that the whole object of this Bill is to saddle the Irish people with a burden of £1,500,000 in order to get £100,000 for the Irish Press? I take it that Deputies, with one or two exceptions, are agreed that this money is due and that we are bound to pay it. As regards the time of payment, I have shown, step by step, that the time of payment was clearly indicated as the time at which the receivers would be furnishing their official report and the necessary machinery for repayment would be set up. I told the House, and it is a fact, that the first step was taken by representatives of the bondholders, who came over here and asked me and asked the Minister for Finance what we are going to do about implementing the promises that had been officially given, and officially communicated to the American Minister and to the American Government. We told them that we would implement those promises. I was told that the time was approaching when the receivers would be putting in their final report. Our Finance Department indicated that, in order that payment could be made, records and so on would have to be got possession of. We were advised that in order to get possession of those records, and to meet any claims that might be made against them, we should make it quite clear beyond any question of doubt whatever that payment was about to be made on those bonds. We took the proper steps to do that. This payment is being made as an obligation due at a time and in conditions under which any Executive Council sitting here would have to make that payment. We are told that this is all beside the point. Very well. Why do all the Deputies talk about it if it is beside the point? I am as willing as anybody else to come down to the narrow terms of the amendment. The Minister for Justice has spoken on that amendment, and shown clearly why we should not accept it. I wish to say that one of the reasons why I would not accept it is because I regard it purely and simply as a political manoeuvre by our opponents. I have not the slightest intention whatever to give way to a political manoeuvre of that kind.

Comment on this

Hear, hear!

Comment on this

Those moneys will be paid to those to whom they are legally due.

Comment on this

Legally?

Comment on this