Dáil Eireann Loans and Funds Bill, 1933—Committee Stage (Resumed).
Contributions 178–368 of 368. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
No. 26 of 1933 ›
No person will get those moneys except persons who are entitled to them according to law. Every person who claims repayment will have to show reason for his claim. Deputy Fitzgerald spoke a while ago as if those records over in America were in the state of confusion that they were in here. They were nothing of the kind. Conditions in America were different. A perfect record was kept in America, and the only difficulty there has been in America was the difficulty that a number of subscribers did not continually register their changes of residence. Those subscribers, at the time they assigned their interest in the bonds for the Irish Press, knew the value of them. One would think that, as was suggested, there were private circulars sent around and that there was a lot of hole-and-corner business about this question of raising money in America for the Irish Press. Quite the contrary. There was a campaign here for raising money for the Irish Press. I said that, before I went over to get money in America, applications had been made for shares for the amount of capital that it was intended to get here in Ireland. In America, subscriptions in cash and subscriptions in assignments, roughly about fifty-fifty, were made. They were taken pound for pound of their value, in the sense that every person who assigned a bond knew that he was going to get the equivalent interest to a similar amount in actual cash. There were public meetings held. The organisation and work were done by American citizens. They went around and canvassed for cash and for those bonds. It was quite clear that in all cases the bonds and cash equivalent were the same. The assignment had to be in strict legal form. There were two witnesses, and the witnesses' signature had to be attested before a notary public.
I told the House last night why it was, to use the terms that were used in the United Irishman recently: “de Valera takes no chances.” I explained to the House why I could not take chances. There was a large sum of money being invested in plant and machinery. We were starting on the minimum capital on which this enterprise could be successfully started. I wanted to be assured that there was no bird in the bush business about this assignment of the money that was involved, that the assignments were at least as valuable, and that I could regard them for the sake of the enterprise as being of equal worth to their face value. I probably thought that it might come to more, but I had to take them, for safety sake, at that value. Knowing that the receivers were actually about to distribute the money, knowing the money that was immediately being distributed, roughly judging the time in which that distribution should be completed, knowing the estimates for the losses which a newspaper starting had to face, and studying those estimates, I came to the conclusion that the moneys that would be required for the Irish Press would come in at the times they were required. I had a good deal of facts upon which I could base my calculations. I was not a prophet in the sense of being able to know that I would be sitting on those benches when the payment was to be made. I had seen the statements by the Minister for Finance before we actually bought the plant and machinery. I had to make a further subtraction because I saw that it was clearly the intention of the Executive Council that was then in office by hook or by crook to prevent the Irish Press from getting the money that it was legally entitled to, and to try to get away with that on a pretence of anxiety for the interests of the people who had subscribed their bonds. I personally did not do much, in the sense that I did not come into close quarters with the individuals who assigned their bonds. There was an American Committee—a Promoting Committee—set up. That Promoting Committee published literature. I gave that letter which was referred to to-day in my own handwriting. They solicited those subscriptions, and canvassed just as they had canvassed for subscriptions for the Republican Loan. Every public statement I made had the effect of making it clear that those who were assigning those bonds were subscribing those bonds as capital to an Irish enterprise.
That is the ultimate use that would be made of it. I have kept my promise. The accounts have been audited. They have been forwarded to the American corporation. The moneys that will be received will be similarly invested and the accounts sent over to the American corporation, and that American corporation will receive any dividends and will have its title to any assets of the Irish Press pro rata, exactly the sum in dollars and cents that we pay to the Irish shareholders. That sum the American shareholder would be paid in cash.
These being the circumstances, I want to know why there should be a clause here which is intended, if possible, to deprive the Irish Press of the assets that it is entitled to?
Just the same as I would be entitled to get my interest from this State if I had held some of these bonds myself, when the time for redeeming them came about, if I choose to give them for a Party purpose at election times I would be entitled to do so. It is all nonsense to talk about the ratepayers' or the taxpayers' money being used to support the Irish Press. Would Deputy Cosgrave get interest on any National Loan Bonds he may have? Are we entitled, because we are here in a majority in this House, to say that we are not going to give the taxpayers' money to support Deputy Cosgrave if Deputy Cosgrave wants to make that money available for his Party machine? Are we entitled to say that because that money does come from the common purse, in lieu of something which the common purse got, not as a present, that we will not pay it? If that is going back to individuals who are legally entitled to get it from the common purse, what is wrong with it?
One Deputy suggested it is indelicate. I tried to find out what was indelicate about it. We had Lloyd George and the Marconi shares spoken about. I do not know the facts of the Marconi business, but from the explanation the Deputy gave there is no comparison between them because that was a question where there were Government contracts and the members of the Government were taking shares in a concern in which the Government was directly interested. There is no parallel whatever between this case and cases of that kind. Then it was suggested by a Deputy last night that Cæsar's wife should be above suspicion. There are only certain distances that you can go. If an angel from heaven came down to this country at the present time and stood on this side at any rate, with an Opposition that has been for ten years doing everything that was humanly and inhumanly possible to misrepresent the position which some of us occupied, I do not believe that even that angel could hope to defend himself against suspicion. Not the slightest hope would he have of being above suspicion under these circumstances.
One Deputy said that I should have foreseen all this; that I should have foreseen that the Leader of the Opposition might come into office and that he should be very careful. Well, at the time, as I said, in dealing with that particular matter, I was not considering whether I would be in office or not. I was calculating and I knew that if I were in office I would act towards the Irish Press in the same spirit as I would towards any legal owner of the bonds. I knew that if my opponents were in office, from the statements they had made, that they would do everything in their power to abuse their position and to prevent the Irish Press from getting that money. Well, the wheel of fortune changed that. Fortunately it has put me into a position in which that effort can be defeated. If ever there was a case where my inclinations would be to resist an appeal to change, it would be in this case, because I believe there is only one motive behind the bringing in of this amendment. If I have over-reached anybody, if anybody in the United States has assigned a bond as a result of my over-reaching him, he has his remedy. But I am not going to start once more a new campaign to get what was already given. Even regarding myself as a trustee, not for a part of this, but as a trustee for the whole lot, I would not be entitled to go and risk the money that was put into that enterprise by sending back money which belonged to that enterprise on the faith of which and on the giving of which that enterprise was started.
Comment on this
Does not the President see now from what he has just said that he has a dual capacity, that he is in the position of having one duty as a trustee which might conflict with another duty as head of the Government?
Comment on this
No duty whatever conflicts with my duty as head of the Government. That is where I differ from the Deputy. I do not see any conflict whatever. The moneys are due to be paid to those who have the legal title to them. Nobody attempts to claim these assignments which have already passed the scrutiny of the American courts. These assignments have been adjudged as proper legal assignments. If anybody has any legal case to make let him make it, let him prove it. There is no conflict between my duties as President and my duties as trustee, none whatever. Those who have legal rights are going to have their rights safeguarded.
Now, unfortunately or fortunately, the history of years back has been brought into this debate. One part of it had reference to my attitude in the bond litigation in America. I have tried to explain to the House that I was defending a trust, to see that the balance of the moneys which were unexpended would not go to those to whom I thought they did not properly belong. I was upheld at least to that extent by the American court, and the fact that I was upheld in the American court is proof positive that my action at that time was not purely for the purpose of causing trouble. I had a trust to the Irish people on the one hand and a trust to the American subscribers on the other. I carried out that trust and defended it to the best of my ability. Anything I said with regard to that I am prepared to stand over to-day, not something that Deputy Fitzgerald, who did not even remember the newspaper, may quote. If anybody has documents in which there is any inconsistency shown between the attitude I am adopting to-day and the attitude I then adopted, let him show them to me.
I stated that the moneys belonged to the Second Dáil. I believe it. If in 1927, whilst we were still outside this House, we had got a majority in the election, we would have summoned the Second Dáil and accounted to it. But we did not get that majority and our opponents took very good care that such a case could never again arise. They put it out of our power to go to the Irish people again under such circumstances. We came in here and in a new election we told the Irish people what we proposed to do. We are paying this money, not as a determination of the rights or wrongs of a particular case as to whether the Free State was entitled to get these moneys or not. I say to-day that they were not entitled to get the moneys. Why are we paying them? We are paying them for the reason that I have already stated, that any assembly purporting to represent the Irish people could not afford to ignore their obligations in that regard. Miss McSwiney was mentioned by Deputy MacDermot yesterday, and he suggested that she and other people associated with her were not prepared to pay these moneys. I am perfectly certain they would be. If they are aggrieved with our action, my action, to-day, the reason they are aggrieved is because we are doing something which they think it would be their privilege to do.
We happen to be in the position in which we have control of the resources of the people for whose benefit the money was subscribed, and because we are here at the time when this payment is determined upon, we are prepared to fulfil our obligations. The question of a succession of States is a nice question. The question of how long a de facto Government may have to continue and the conditions under which it would have to continue before its full rights would be recognised is also a nice question. Our position is that the Irish people have deliberately accepted a certain policy which we put before them at the election. They have supported us in that policy, and as their representatives we are carrying it out. Our right to pay this money is that at the moment we represent the majority of the people concerned.
Deputy Cosgrave said that there have been gaps. I have documents here from which in the future the history of the last ten years will be written. These documents are here, they are in Government Departments, and there are many other documents of a parallel kind outside. In the future, when history is being written, it will be written from these documents, and I for one will not be afraid in the slightest to have, in history, my conduct during those ten years judged with the conduct of the gentlemen on the opposite benches. We have Deputy Fitzgerald-Kenney trying to pretend that I am a most inconsistent and changeable person. I told the House last night what has been the basis of our policy. We believe in the independence of our people—the right to complete and absolute independence. We believe that our people as an independent people would choose a Republic. We mean to help them along that road, and the only way in which the Irish Press can be said to be a Party newspaper is in the sense that it is animated with the same purpose that animates us. It is not a Party-controlled organ. The Executive of the Government could wish to put into it whatever they choose and it need not be put in.
The terms on which the money was subscribed for the Irish Press were very definite. The pledge I gave was that it would be a newspaper as good as we could make it; that that newspaper would have for its policy the support of the Irish people in their efforts to secure complete independence and a Republic, if the people, when they got independence, choose to have it in that form; and that, so far as the economic policy was concerned, the economic policy of the paper should be that of reversing the economy of the past, the economy which was forced on this country, the economy of British free trade. It was pointed out that the policy of the paper would be to support the establishment of Irish industries and the balancing of our agricultural industry with manufacturing industry. That is the only sense in which the paper can be said to be a Party organ. It belongs to the proprietors, who are the Irish people. I think I said 8,000 shareholders. I believe there are 10,000 Irish shareholders and the paper is their property. I launched it; I set it going. It is going.
Comment on this
It is going as rapidly as it possibly can in the direction of becoming a real, big daily newspaper.
Comment on this
The Deputy will never sing the auctioneer's word "Gone" in connection with it. It is going all right.
Comment on this
The loss that has been referred to here was anticipated. It was in the nature of the enterprise. Again I say it is not a Party newspaper in the sense of a Party-controlled organ. The Party does not own it or control it. It is owned by the shareholders and its policy can be controlled by the Board of Directors. The only case where I would intervene actively —and I would intervene as trustee on behalf of those who subscribed the moneys—would be if the policy of the paper were to depart from that of supporting the movement for Irish independence and supporting the policy of economic independence also. Are its rivals Party organs? It is no more a Party organ than they are. They are Party organs in the sense that they support the policy of our opponents. You have, for example, the Irish Times. Is it not quite clear that the Irish Times supports the Unionist policy? Then you have the Irish Independent. What has been its policy for the last ten years except supporting the Party opposite?
Comment on this
When I went to America I said that there was in Ireland a need for an Irish national newspaper. One-half at least of the electorate in this country, I stated, had no paper in which their opinions were voiced, no paper that would give them the truth, because the opposing newspapers were hiding the truth whenever it told in favour of the policy of our side. The paper is established under conditions which make for success and, if it is not successful, then it can only be attributed to the fault either of the Irish people who will not support it, if they refuse to support it; the power of advertisers, if they are able to exercise the power to prevent it getting the advertisements to which its circulation would entitle it, or some action outside ordinary business affairs which might be taken by those who would be in a position to do it harm.
Undoubtedly if the Opposition were on these benches, at this moment when this Bill is going through, they would try all in their power to do it harm, but they are powerless, thank God, now, absolutely powerless to do it any harm, because their attacks upon it will only rally round it, every one of the 10,000 shareholders to whom it belongs, and every single person who realises that this attack is made upon it because it is a powerful defence of the Irish people's rights. It is because of its importance in the life of this nation, to the people, that those Deputies on the benches opposite have been venting their venom upon it for the last two or three days. I have said all I want to say upon that now. We have not come to the end of the discussions that will take us back to the history of the last eight or ten years and I shall have more occasions still in which I shall be able to explain what really happened.
Comment on this
The President has just expressed himself as anxious to see the history of the last ten years rewritten in a different sense from that which he says now obtains. For my part, I think far the best thing that could happen for this country would be, if the history of the last ten or 15 years, instead of being rewritten, could be obliterated from our memory altogether.
Comment on this
When I listened to the President to-day saying seriously that it was the supreme happiness of his career to watch Deputies on the opposite benches digesting gall and wormwood it confirmed my view that it would be far better if the memory of those years could be obliterated, because that expression of his reveals the predominance of Party hatred and not of statesmanship or patriotism. The supreme happiness of his career ought to be, and I hope will be, to see the country reunited and the Border abolished.
I made up my mind, at the beginning of this debate, that I could not support this amendment unless I could see definite proof that there had been sharp practice and misrepresentation in inducing American hondholders to assign their rights. I have not found what seems to me to be adequate evidence of that in this debate and, accordingly, I do not feel able to vote in favour of this amendment. But I do not recede in the least from the point I tried to make this afternoon and last night, that it was an unfortunate thing, an indelicate thing for a person occuying the position that the President then occupied, as Leader of the Opposition Party in this House, to go round canvassing American bondholders to assign their rights to him, when the value of those rights was something that rested upon the decision of the Irish people, as expressed through the Oireachtas. The President confirmed every word I said when, just now, forgetting himself, he made the statement that to adopt the course that the Opposition had been inviting him to adopt, of accepting this amendment and giving the people an opportunity of deciding now whether they wanted to subscribe to the Irish Press or not, would be a breach of his duties as trustee. That absolutely confirms my point of view that he put himself in the position where two duties might conflict. He says they do not conflict. I do not say that they do conflict, but I say that they might conflict and he should not have put himself in the position where his motives could be, as they have been, misinterpreted or vilified, where insinuations could be made, as they have been made, in this case, and in other similar cases to which I have alluded.
Comment on this
I did not intend to speak on this debate but I trust my remarks will be brief, or rather will be comparatively brief because we can only speak in comparisons, judging by the long speeches we have had from the President. I suggest so far as this amendment is concerned that at least seven-eights of the speeches were completely and entirely irrelevant. Whether they would have been irrelevant to a Second Reading debate is open to question, but they had nothing to do with the amendment we had been discussing. I am not saying that possibly from the President's point of view that was not a wise course to pursue.
We have had examples of the President's logic on several occasions in this House. We have had examples of his extraordinary love of "arguefying" and we had one again this afternoon. I certainly am not going to waste the time of the House by following the example of these extraordinary logicians. To the man who can prove to his own satisfaction that the Irish Press is not a Party organ, and can do that by logic I say that is quite enough of his logic so far as ordinary people are concerned. It is only a mind of that kind that could not see the point raised by Deputy MacDermot of the conflicting duties owing to the dual position of the President. Nobody in this House or outside this House has been ever able to convince the President of anything, at any stage of his career, by argument or anything else. I quite admit that it is only people legally entitled to the money that will get it. The President and his legal advisers in America have taken very good care that he could make that promise and stand by it. I have not the slightest doubt that those who assigned over these moneys to him for the purpose of the Irish Press have done so in a manner that is legally unquestionable. But I suggest if that is so he should not, speaking in his capacity as head of the State, if he has any sense of decency, state that anybody in America who is dissatisfied has his legal remedy. He has taken good care they have no legal remedy. I can at least give that much credit to his legal advisers in America that they have made it perfectly clear that there is no such remedy. What I would like to put before the House is this.
Everybody will remember the circumstances in which this money was collected. I am not going into the history of it and I am not going to follow the President in his irrelevancies. I want to be strictly relevant to this amendment. Everyone knows, so far as this country is concerned, and the same holds good so far as America is concerned that most of the people who subscribed to this Dáil Eireann Loan never expected to be repaid. I wonder is that denied. It was said by President de Valera's own lawyer in America when making his appeal. "I presume" he said "that you are one of those many people who never expected to get this money back."
I suggest that the very circumstances under which this money was subscribed coloured the whole minds of the people for long years afterwards. I know it did in this country though the Government in office, from 1923 to 1927, determined to pay the internal loan and issued notice to that effect. They prescribed a last day by which all applications should be in, and yet the fact remains that even though that was solemnly stated by the Government and that the issues were announced in the paper and payments were made, the bulk of the people never put in their claims until that date was passed, with the result, as everybody knows who had anything to do with this business, whether as a Minister or in his capacity as a Deputy, that there was a tremendous delay in the payment of the claims owing to the fact that they did not come in. Everybody knows why they did not come in. They did not come in because the people did not believe that payment was going to be made, and that after the definite advertisement by the Government that payments were going to be made. It was only when the first payments went out that the great bulk of the people in the country who had subscribed to the Dáil Loan began to get busy and to send in their claims. That was the mentality that prevailed in this country at that time and I suggest that that was the same mentality that prevailed when Mr. de Valera was in America asking the people to assign these bonds. It would take a great deal to convince me that these people did believe that these bonds were worth their face value. Legally, they should have known it, I agree, and from the point of view of legality the President has an absolutely copper-bound case. He made sure of that. That is one of the objectionable features of the case— that he has seen to that and that there would be no going back now when the people see that these bonds are worth something. The President has seen to it. I will admit that.
The President suggested in his speech that he went as Leader of the Opposition to America and that he kept out of sight the fact that he might be President in the future. Yet he relates, as he said, that if the Cumann na nGaedheal Government were kept in power this assignment would be made ineffective. That extravagant prophetic vision of the President that was able to segregate the fact of the bonds being good under the Cumann na nGaedheal Government and that he might come into office and that he might be President—it was only the President's mind that could perform a piece of logic of that kind and make that sharp division between the different lobes of his brain. He held himself aloof in America. He did not do any nasty work. He kept himself above all that. Nevertheless, the fact does remain, and this is what the House ought to consider if this country is to avoid a first-class scandal so far as the ordinary decent-minded people are concerned, that this is the man who was at that time the head of the second largest Party in the State, the man who, even when he deliberately excluded the idea, must have believed, and strongly believed, that he would come into office. The man who, we know from various speeches he has made, has believed for a number of years that he has a divine mission so far as this country is concerned— except when he excluded all that, that man went over to America and got the money in this particular way.
If the President is quite so sure of his case, why does he not do what this amendment allows him to do? Why does he not give back the money to these people who subscribed it? There is doubt—and considerable doubt, to put it at the very lowest—as to what value the assignors put on these particular bonds. There is considerable doubt. Talking as an ordinary commonsense man and avoiding the legal quibbling which the President always brings in so effectively, at least to his own satisfaction, but speaking from the point of view of ordinary commonsense, it is impossible to believe that those who held these bonds assigned the full value to them. Many of them, I am convinced, looked upon them as so much wastepaper. Many of them never thought they would be worth their face value and a great deal more. Why not give these people the opportunity to do what they like with the money? Let them subscribe to this great national organ that is not a Party organ, we are told. Judging from the humour of the President, when Deputy Morrissey paid the tribute to the paper for its sporting columns, it evidently ceases to be a Party organ because it has sporting news and other side-shows as well. What else is it but a Party propaganda sheet?
Is there really any serious doubt about that I wonder? What we are asked now is to take advantage of the unpreparedness of mind and those who subscribed out of their generosity—to quote the Minister for Finance—to take advantage of their short-sightedness and give that money over to keep alive for a little longer period a propagandist sheet of that kind. There has not been for many years in this country an example of a Party organ like that. Does any sane man believe that anything can get into that paper, or be allowed to remain in it once it has got in, if the President of the Executive Council objects to it?
Comment on this
I am asked for proof. I leave it to the commonsense of the House and of the country to judge that. The President mentioned many reasons why that organ might fail. They were quite amusing. We were told that the advertisers might not see the great advantage of using its columns notwithstanding its magnificent circulation. There might be some cult against it—it was not quite clear what —some malign outside influence—but it would certainly be some interference of an extremely vicious kind with the organ of the Irish people. The Irish people themselves might not appreciate it. But the one reason why a paper of that kind might fail was left unmentioned, namely, its recognition by the people and by the ordinary public as a tied Party organ, so far as practice is concerned, of a most pronounced type. Other papers were mentioned. The Irish Independent was mentioned as a supporter of our Party. I would be glad to know that. I may say that before the election of 1927 I doubt if any organ did us one-tenth of the damage that that newspaper did with its wide circulation. I am not aware that at any time our Party, even when we were a Government, had the slightest power of influencing either the views or the news in that particular paper.
Comment on this
I know perfectly well that it did a great deal more to put us out of office than it was alleged here last night the Irish Press did. To say that it is a Cumann na nGaedheal Party organ is ridiculous. I would ask Deputies seriously to consider the futility of the pretence made by the President. At one period of his speech he almost left us under the impression, with that sweet reasonableness he always professes—I notice that most obstinate men always profess sweet reasonableness; it is one of their outstanding characteristics—that he would accept the amendment were it not for the fact that this Party brought it forward to make Party capital out of it. I think I am not misrepresenting the President when I say that one particular portion of his speech went along these lines. If that was his only objection, why did he not himself who, as far back as the time he was in the United States, and I presume every month since, saw all this, draft his Bill to put the Government of this country and this nation above suspicion. He did not expect perfection in Cæsar's wife. That sort of thing can be carried too far. He did not want to be above suspicion. Well, certain things ought to be thoroughly above suspicion. I am not aware of any degrees so far as the business of Cæsar's wife is concerned. I am not aware of the degrees that the President hints there may be there; nor am I aware of the degrees so far as the public honour of the Government of this country is concerned. I think that, in these circumstances, the House would do well to accept the amendment. It gives the House an opportunity of saving, not the Fianna Fáil Party, but, at least, the Government of the country, which is an important thing. For that reason, I would ask the House to support the amendment. As I said, at least seven-eights of the speech of the President—I had not the misfortune to hear his other two speeches but I was told about them; and I am sure they were on the same lines—had nothing to do with the amendment. If one quarter of the professions of the President are worth their face value, if they are worth any more than a number of subscribers thought the Dáil bonds were once worth, then I suggest this amendment ought to be accepted.
Comment on this
It is difficult to comprehend why this amendment should not be accepted, if there are no ulterior motives behind the Bill. The amendment merely asks that the money should not be paid back to anybody but the subscribers. I think it was not fair to have the debate develop on the lines of a competition as to the relative merits of two daily newspapers. There is nothing about newspapers in this amendment. Strong points were put up to the President from these benches and I, for one, who have an open mind on this matter, would like to have heard those points replied to. It would be not only useful but necessary to have them replied to in order to help Deputies to make up their minds. It is also essential for the sake of history. When the future historian of this period is studying the materials at his disposal there will be no truer records of this and other matters than the records of this House. It is due to the House, in the first instance, in order to help Deputies to make up their mind, and it is due to posterity that the President and his colleagues should clear themselves of the imputations levelled against them, not so much by the amendment, as by the proofs as to the motives actuating the President and the members of the Executive Council in resisting the amendment. It is due to the fair name of this country that their characters should be cleared, if they can clear them.
The President made statements here to-day that a schoolboy would not make. It is quite apparent from the evidence adduced to the House, which has not been attacked by the President or his colleagues or any member of his Party, that they had the records of those who subscribed to the Dáil Loan in America and that they used that information, and also information that these bonds would be redeemed, notwithstanding that there was a general impression, both here and in America, that they would never be redeemed. I am not a lawyer, but there are two very expensive lawyers in this House. as we know. One of them has just flown—Deputy Geoghegan. There is another expensive lawyer—the Attorney-General—a very expensive one. One of them was worth seven guineas a day to Hamar Greenwood. He is worth twenty guineas a day now.
Comment on this
I am not hammered yet, but that hammer will hammer the Minister. It has levelled him up more completely than his failure in agriculture will level him up. The premier agricultural county of Ireland will not be the last to find that out. The people there have found a portion of it out already. Longford and Westmeath have found out the other gentlemen.
Comment on this
The President said to-day that it was as natural to deal in the scrip of the Dáil bonds as in the scrip of National Loan. Again, I repeat that I am not a lawyer, but I know a little about the English language. These Dáil bonds were not negotiable, and yet the President of the Executive Council negotiated in them. As was explained here to-day by Deputy Cosgrave, the ex-President of the Executive Council of the Free State, a few years ago there was a residue in those funds created by the Dáil bonds. Claim was laid to them by the Government of the Free State. They presumably were prepared to accept responsibility for redeeming those bonds, but Mr. de Valera, as he then was, although he claimed to be President of the living Republic, the Executive Council of the Second Dáil, said: "No, the Free State is not entitled to that money. We, the successors of the established Republic of Ireland, are alone entitled to it." When he was asking us to-day to believe this, that, and the other, and the logic of all his actions, which no human being could follow, I was quite expecting him to say that he was in the direct line from Saint Peter, and that he was infallible. I know how fallible he is, and so do the Members opposite. If we are to accept the statements made opposite, the Irish Press has been responsible for putting the Fianna Fáil Government in office. It might have had something to do with it. I am quite prepared to admit that after ten years of any Government, even if it were a Government of archangels, a change is good and healthy for a democratic State, but if the Irish Press is going to take responsibility for putting the Fianna Fáil Government into office, and take responsibility and pride for the depredations that Government has done in the last year and a half, then the memory of the Irish Press and the memory of the Fianna Fáil Government in this country will be a similar memory to the memory of Cromwell. The erstwhile friends and colleagues of the President, the members of his Executive Council, and a good many members of his Party, when he made claim to those bonds in America, make that claim of being the direct successors, not of Saint Peter, but of the established Republic. Even his colleagues at that time, those of them who were manly enough, found him out and sacked him—turned him out of the Second Dáil. What have they to say now? I will quote from the Irish Independent of to-day:—
"The Executive Council of the Second Dáil, Government of the Republic of Ireland, declares that it intervenes because Mr. de Valera persists in an attempt to assert a claim on behalf of the Free State Executive similar to that which he opposed in the courts of the United States when advanced by his predecessors in the Government."
Comment on this
This is the man who could not tell a lie. This is the man who could not err. This is the man who never blew hot and cold. This is the man who said here that he believed that the people who carried on what they are pleased to call the Second Dáil support his action, but here are the words. If they are not their words there is a good action against the Irish Independent and there is another way of getting soft money for the Irish Press.
Comment on this
I got no mercy from them and they will get none from me. I know all the lies that were told. I know all the hypocrisy that was in the Party.
Comment on this
They bite the hand that fed them for the last seven years. £1 a day! And I am responsible for it! What a crime I have committed against this country in bringing them in here. The Irish Independent report continues:
"Last March, when the intention to tax the people to the tune of £1,000,000 to repay American bondholders was mooted by the Fianna Fáil leader, the ‘Executive Council of the Second Dáil' directed attention to the fact that the bonds carry on their face the provision that only on the lapse of one month after the international recognition of the Irish Republic would they be exchangeable at the Treasury of the Republic— and redeemable at par within 18 months after Britain's soldiers had evacuated the Irish shores for ever.
"In addition they were to bear interest at the rate of 5 per cent. per annum from the first day of the seventh month after the freeing of the country from British military control.
"These essential conditions being disregarded in the present proposals, the arbitary and autocratic scheme which Mr. de Valera sponsors for political ends, must be exposed and resisted.
"The Executive Council of the Second Dáil has been at pains to prevent factious Irish conflict on this matter in the United States. It becomes its duty now to notify the Government of the United States that the Free State has no right to the pertinent documents lying there which Mr. de Valera has signified his intention to apply for.
"Equally does it become its duty to oppose any effort to tax the citizens in this guise to provide funds for a partisan newspaper, and create a false precedent regarding the owner ship of moneys withheld on different pretexts from the Government of the Republic and its political arm."
Now, who has the right to shout "Up the Republic." The solitary occupant of the Front Bench, if he has kept abreast of political events here, knows who were in the Executive Council of the Second Dáil, but he would want to have kept more abreast of political events than he has kept abreast of agricultural events to be able to give an enlightened opinion on it. What does the Second Dáil think? What is the opinion of the direct successor of the Republic established in 1916, re-established after the General Election of 1918, in the month of January, 1919, and the living Republic that we have been told has existed down along the line? Will any Deputy opposite get up and deny that the sponsors of that statement are the successors of that living Republic as claimed on many occasions by President de Valera? Was it not as President of that Republic he sent us an illuminated address or picture signed by himself as President of the Republic to the relatives of every man who was executed and of every man who lost his life on his side in the Civil War? Will he deny that? If he denies it perhaps he might be put in a queer place if one of these were produced in this House and they can be produced.
Comment on this
No. The living Republic! What does it mean? If these bonds are redeemable now, if, as the President said to-day, I forget his exact words, but it amounted to this that if there was an obligation on any nation to honour its bonds by payment it is on this nation to redeem those bonds now. All of us who knew anything about them have a reminder of it here by the living Republic. I will not say whether it is living or dead. But those opposite? Let them say it is dead and see how long they will live. Let us get the opinion of the twenty guinea a day gentleman on the legal position of the living Republic.
Comment on this
The Deputy must remember that Deputies are here as Deputies and not in their professional capacities.
Comment on this
According to the President we are in honour bound to redeem these bonds when the receiver has made his final report. We are in honour bound to redeem them regardless of our ability to pay at that particular time. Will the Minister for Agriculture or the Minister for Justice or the Attorney-General of any of the other few Deputies on the opposite benches tell us how these bonds are now matured? Have we got a republic? Is not that the test of the maturity of the bonds or is the latest development, the latest twist of President de Valera, that we have a republic now? Is his latest twist that it was an Imperialist Parliament when somebody else sat on those benches? Were they Imperialists when it was Deputy Cosgrave and his Party sat there?
Comment on this
Yes, the King's Ministers and now it is a republic. That is the obvious implication in this Bill. These bonds are now matured and should be redeemed regardless of our ability at present to redeem them or not. They must be redeemed. Those bonds bore a statement, I think, that they were redeemable some time subsequent to the international recognition of the Irish republic. Not only have we not a republic but we have not a public man in authority in this country to-day courageous enough or honest enough to declare a republic and yet these bonds must be redeemed.
Let it be clear that no case has been made from this side that they should not be redeemed. No case has been made though the President has astutely tried to make that case. The Minister for Defence taunted this side with not wanting to redeem the bonds that were subscribed by friends in America, while we were paying £5,500,000 to England. It was nearly time that the gentlemen opposite found out that we should not pay that money to England. They know when that hare was started. They know who stared it. They know it was started by Peadar O Domhnaill——
Comment on this
Yes, and Colonel Moore, and the Front Bench kept out of it until they were able to weigh what election timber was in it and if it was likely to gain them any votes.
Comment on this
It is a hare that has been chased all round this room a million times in the last few days.
Comment on this
Well, if I am not allowed to participate in the hunt I will accept your ruling. However, I think the hare will come home to her seat anyway. The President said a terrible lot of interesting things. I wonder where the agitation started to have these bonds redeemed just now? Has there been any agitation from America? It has not been mentioned. I have not heard of any. I do not hear many things and it could pass without my hearing it. But in making the case the gentlemen opposite do not make any point about that. The President went into the realms of high finance to-day, but he resented a mere Deputy asking him a question on it. I submit, a Chinn Comhairle, it would be no harm to pursue the President into those realms of finance for a little bit. I will not trespass too much on your indulgence.
Some previous speaker has made the case that this was not an opportune time to redeem these bonds. There is such a thing operating between countries as the gold standard. The paper that we have to lean on now, the paper that our friends opposite on a famous occasion could not understand, is the paper that is backed by King George and all his works and pomps. Our issue of the £1 note is not equal to its face value in gold. That point was made by a previous speaker, and the President said neither was the £1 equal to its face value in gold when we borrowed this money from America. As a matter of fact, I think these are substantially his figures:—We borrowed the money when the dollar stood at 3.75 to the £1. I doubt that figure, but for the sake of argument I accept it. We are now proposing to repay this money when the £1 note is worth 4.45 dollars. The advantage is with us compared with our borrowing. But the President, poor man, I am afraid, walked into it. When 3.75 dollars were equal to the £1, we borrowed the money. I should preface what I am going to say by this that we cannot take a bunch of currency notes over to America to pay this debt. They are not money. They are only tokens of value. We have got to pay America in value, not in paper. How are we going to get the value to America if we are to pay America £1,500,000 worth in gold to send them? I take it we have little or no securities over there. Then we have got to send the value and we have got to have that £1,500,000 in goods. We have got to pay it with the bullock, the pig, the butter, cream, etc., that we produce. Let us come down to the terms of values and wholesale prices when this money was borrowed. The bullock that sold at £40 when we borrowed this money, and when the rate of exchange was 3.76 to the dollar, would fetch about £15 to-day.
Comment on this
The Deputy will unbalance me in my figures. Deputy Curran says £10 and I believe he is nearer the correct figure than I am.
Comment on this
We have a racing gentleman occupying the Front Bench opposite and I wonder if he will take you up. We are all glad, of course, to see his sporting colours going past the post on the Curragh. Anyhow, let us assume the animal would be worth £15 to-day. The sum of £40 would represent 150 dollars. That was the price of a bullock in 1919-20. One bullock would pay back 150 dollars. If you talk business here you must talk of commodities, because international indebtedness is paid not by money but by commodities. A bullock will now fetch £15. That would get you 66 dollars at the present rate of exchange. If it is a sum of only £10 it will get you 44 dollars. It will take very nearly four bullocks to-day to pay in gold currency what the value of one bullock was in 1919-20. The President and the intelligentsia of this State say that now is the proper time to pay this money.
The Minister for Finance and some Deputies were talking here to-day about breeding. I wish this well-bred, well-fed, well-read Minister for Finance were here now to give us some idea of what he has in the back of his head and what are the responsibilities and duties, as he conceives them, of a Minister for Finance. A Finance Minister should not be a taxing master or a tax gatherer. He should be a responsible man capable of looking after the finances of this country. The Minister was not even permitted by the President to reply to criticisms on the Budget statement. The President, who would not allow the Minister to reply to Budget criticism, came here to-day and said that now was an opportune time, because the rate of exchange has risen from 3.76 to 4.45 to pay the money back. He left out the essential point, the quintessence of the whole matter. I asked him what was the wholesale price level and I was told that I could find out, or something like that. Will the President make a proper comparison on the basis of our ability to pay now as compared with when we borrowed the money? Is there any intelligence amongst them at all? They have shown that there is very little by all the abuse that has gone on for the last couple of days over this matter.
The President resented the suggestion of sharp practice. What is sharp practice if it is not to collar these American bonds, not for a national purpose but for a Party purpose, not for the purpose of helping Ireland, but to crush the country, as it has been crushed since this great Government organ won its victory, and since the Government and the destinies of the country were handed over to a Party who have shown, in the arguments they put up here to-day, that they are unscrupulous as regards national interests so long as they can serve Party interests? They are incompetent to deal with international finance, as has been shown by the President here. We borrow money. Our money is not gold. We do not dig gold in this country, but we produce cattle, sheep, pigs and crops. Is there anything else we do produce? Yes, we produce a lot of wood—on the heads of certain men in this country. That is going to be improved upon and we are now going to put turf on their heads. We do not produce precious metals. We produce the necessities of life and when we have to pay a foreign debt we must rely upon the produce of our own land, so that in the last analysis we pay our international indebtedness with our country's products.
What is the price of that produce now? What is the price in gold currency, the international standard? What was the price in 1919-20? That is the correct basis of comparison, but the President overlooked it. He probably did not know; in fact, I am sure he did not know. The Minister for Defence was glad that this matter was raised so that he could show what the British side was going to do. He waved his hand as much as to say that we on this side are the British side. Another Minister asked why was this debt not paid during the last ten years. The whole debt comes to £1,500,000. If the Party opposite did not blow up bridges it could have been paid six months after the Treaty was signed. The Minister for Justice laughs. Why should he not laugh at the irony of the whole thing—the man who led the bridge-wreckers across the Mayo and Sligo mountains. The people of this country had to pay 6d. in the £ for six years for all the damage then done, and we are coolly asked why was this indebtedness not paid before now. Twenty times what would have liquidated this debt went up in smoke and the Party opposite were responsible. We were told a few days ago about the necessity for keeping out the wreckers. No less a person than the President came down to the level of the ward politician. "Keep out the wreckers."
Comment on this
The recent Dublin election surely has no bearing on the subject-matter under discussion.
Comment on this
In this amendment the President and his Government get an opportunity of showing that their transaction was a bona fide transaction. It is questionable if this House could legally, in face of their contract, pay these bonds to anyone else. It is pretty evident that from the nature of the case people in America had no intention of subscribing to the Irish Press. They had this old scrip in their hands and they said: “We have been giving all our lives to help Ireland. Here is this thing. It is no good to us”; and, in that way the President and his organisation in the States raked in what filled up the capital to start the Irish Press. The obligation to redeem the bonds which they carried was that after a certain time, after international recognition of the Republic, these bonds are redeemable. That does not put any obligation upon this Government or Dáil to redeem these bonds. As pointed out, I think, by Deputy Fitzgerald-Kenney, if as a result of the Bill now going through these bonds are redeemable by this Dáil the money is not in the strict technical sense redemption money but ex gratia payments. The Irish Press can keep this scrip, but they could make no claim upon the ex gratia payment. If the whole thing was bona fide and if such enthusiasm was displayed in America in subscribing to the Irish Press as we are told by Ministers on the Government Benches, then, the same sympathy must be in America for the Irish Press now. If they wanted money in the morning for this paper they would get it quite readily if America is in that frame of mind, and so they should let this amendment go through. Let the original subscribers get their money back and then, if they have the enthusiasm for Fianna Fáil which the Party claims the people in America have, this money, when it is received by the people in America, will be sent back to the Irish Press. They should show the same thought for the Irish people in America as for the people in Ireland.
Comment on this
Deputies have been told three times in the last half-hour that they must not interrupt. The next reminder will be much more severe.
Comment on this
It would be better, I think, if Ministers would not try to misrepresent the issues raised in this debate. The President was at pains to create an issue that did not exist and he was helped in that by the Minister for Defence. We were told that the previous Government honoured what they should not have honoured, that is, that they honoured their loans to England, but that they would not honour the redemption of these bonds. Nobody that I heard speaking here made a case, on his own behalf, or on the behalf of any Party, against the redemption of these bonds. It is dishonest to try to create that issue, or to use it as a smoke-screen.
Comment on this
May I interrupt for a moment? I thought it was arranged that at half-past eight the debate on Estimate No. 9 should be resumed. I wonder is that arrangement to be fulfilled, or whether there is any possibility of getting this debate speedily concluded, and allowing us to get along with other Parliamentary business?
Comment on this
I tried to speak in this debate, but I was not called upon when I rose. Another person was allowed to speak who had already made two speeches.
Comment on this
I think that Deputy Mulcahy, who is in charge of the Opposition at the moment, should express some opinion on the matter.
Comment on this
In announcing the Order of Business it was stated that certain Votes would be taken at 8.30 o'clock; I think Votes 9 and 2, but I am not aware of any arrangement that this matter now before the House should be adjourned.
Comment on this
If an expression of opinion is required from me I think this debate ought to conclude soon. I think it would probably help business and would be more satisfactory to allow this debate to conclude rather than to let in, on another occasion, Deputies fresh to continue the discussion as we saw to-day.
Comment on this
That is my opinion also. If there was any possibility of this debate concluding, at a reasonable hour, I do not want to interrupt it for the purpose of taking Government business.
Comment on this
As a number of other Deputies wish to speak upon this, and as there appears to be general agreement, on both sides, that the debate be brought to a close as soon as possible I will not say any more.
Comment on this
My few remarks will not delay the House because I intend to speak to the amendment. I support the amendment for the reason that it advocates the repayment of this money to the subscribers and I am somewhat surprised at the great row kicked up by the Government against that very honest amendment. As Deputy Belton has already said, we do not refuse repayment to the subscribers but we want it done properly and correctly. There have been points made from time to time about the subscribers and about their assigning their bonds over to the Irish Press. Friends of mine have written to me from America who have stated that they got circulars asking them to put their money into this wonderful national newspaper that had been promised to the Irish people and they wrote home for advice to know was that really true and was Ireland going to have one great national paper that would not belong to any Party. That was the idea that was sent around when they were advocating that those bonds should be made payable to the Irish Press.
Listening to the debate, and to the President speaking on the debate, it was rather amusing to me to see the attitude the President adopted. I understand his mentality fairly well. I was associated with him for a great many years, from the very night the Volunteers were first started. It was amusing to me to see the attitude he strikes when he wants to impress the people—the great tub-thumping and shaking of the hand. He has a wonderful understudy in my friend, Deputy Cleary, and, mind you, he gets away with it. He leans back and looks around and sees what effect it has. Well, it has an effect, because, according as the President gets excited, the "yes men" get excited also and there is wonderful enthusiasm and if anyone on this side of the House dares to open his mouth he is told to sit down. The great patriot, the Great White Chief, the great leader of the Irish people, is the one man who is endowed with Irish nationality and we on this side of the House have no room for Ireland. We are John Bulls, friends of the English, and we have no spirit of nationality. That is the dope that goes down and the "yes men" drink it all in. A good example was the remark of the Minister for Defence, Deputy Aiken, the other night, when, questioning some speaker, who was making his case just like I am making my case, he said: "What right have you to speak who did not subscribe to the Dáil Loan?" That was a wonderful thing to say. If I might claim the indulgence of the House, if having subscribed to the Dáil Loan is any hallmark of nationality and if it entitles one to speak I can say that I have been a substantial subscriber to the Dáil Loan. I challenge any Deputy on the other side to have subscribed as much as I did. Not alone that, but I collected some thousands for the Dáil Loan and can prove it from the Minister for Finance. That was in the days of danger, when, perhaps, we had no security that we would ever get paid. And yet, we are the people who have no love for Ireland or no spirit of nationality! When the Sinn Féin Press was smashed and the machinery destroyed, the Press which was doing the work of those days, some of us subscribed close on £700 to put up the machinery so that Sinn Féin could be set going again. That was not John Bull's work. We are still the same men and if I get up to advocate that there is no necessity to pay this money just now, I am speaking in the interests of Ireland exactly as I have always done all my life and not because John Bull has any hold on me.
Deputy Cleary and President de Valera stated that when all the rest of Ireland is wrong all he has to do is to look into his own heart to find what is right. That is the kind of stuff that goes down. I admit it goes down. There are still a great many "mugs" in the country, but our roots are deep in the soil of Ireland, and we have a wonderful love for it, and we made every sacrifice that could be made by an honest Irishman and that entitles us to stand up in this House and say that we support this amendment and for no other reason. It is an honest amendment, giving the right to the American people to get back the money which they subscribed for certain objects. Why this indecent haste in paying it anyway? The Americans are not shouting or bawling to have it repaid. As Deputy Belton said, it takes four bullocks now to repay what one bullock would repay a few years ago. It is no time now to repay it, especially when the American people themselves are not howling for it. The different countries in the world to-day are trying to rearrange their money matters and to see how they can postpone settlement of their debts. This is a little country. Owing to the policy of the Government who went across the way and are supposed to be the extreme patriots, this country to-day is not able to repay that £1,500,000. Let us take time. The indecent haste about it is that you want to get control of this money to help you out of your difficulties with your daily paper. Ireland should be first in your thoughts and not your daily paper. Think of the conditions of the farmers of the country. Think of the cutting of the salaries of the teachers and the civil servants. You did that because you said the money was needed and now you pass a Bill to pay £1,500,000. That is why I advocate the amendment. If we are to pay it let us give it to the people who subscribed it and, when they have it, if they want to hand it over to you after that we will not stand in your way. It is about time this humbug should stop and that honest Irishmen should be allowed to have their say in this country.
Mention was made of the wool being pulled over the eyes of the people in America. I was speaking with Americans yesterday and they said that they had subscribed but they had forgotten all about it and that anyway when they did subscribe it they gave it as a free gift and did not care what happened after that, just as when subscribing to the Dáil Loan we never thought we would see the day that we would get it back. But we did not mind. We knew it was for Ireland and we thought that nothing was good enough for our country. As I said, we should put our country and its welfare before Party politics and a Party newspaper. The debate we have had here for the last two days and the long speeches which we have had from the Front Benches were all due to the fact that they hoped to get this money for Party ends.
Comment on this
I am supporting this amendment because I stand for the repayment of this money directly to the people who subscribed it. I think it is a dirty trick on the part of the Government to turn round and take advantage of the people who put money into this loan and ask to have this money assigned to them, because I believe that the subscribers were under the impression that there was no possibility of repayment being made to them. President de Valera is seeking to get the money for the support of the Irish Press. I myself have had some experience of putting money into business. Unfortunately for me, I was induced by a friend to put money into a business. I did not know enough about balance sheets to ask to see one, but when I looked for something out of my investment I found that the business was in bankruptcy. For that reason, I will never be a party to allowing a business like this to pass in any institution with which I am connected. I suggest that the money be paid back directly to the people who subscribed it. Then let the President, or anybody else, put their balance sheet before these people and if they wish to subscribe money to the Irish Press, or for any other purpose, let them do so. I want it to be known that I am not going to be a party to having the people deceived and deprived of their money.
Comment on this
Before we go on to the section, I should like to ask when does the President propose to make available the document from which he quoted last night?
Comment on this
I am perfectly certain that the President does not propose to deal with the misrepresentations of Deputy McGilligan. He did not read any document last night, or quote from one.
Comment on this
The President himself did purport to quote from a document last night, did so flagrantly, and did so after a warning had been given by the Chair as to what the procedure of the House was. So much did he know that himself that he urged the House to reconsider its procedure, and stated that he did not consider it was quite right. Under those circumstances, I think I am quite within the procedure of the House and quite within my rights in asking when it is proposed to make available for Deputies in the ordinary way the document from which the President quoted.
Comment on this
May I take it then that a Deputy is not to be precluded from his rights simply by the disappearance in the obvious way in which the President disappeared—by the runaway fashion in which he disappeared? May I take it that I may hold this question over until the President does make one of his infrequent appearances?
Comment on this
We are now dealing with a Bill which has in its first section this definition: "the word ‘subscriber' includes (in addition to the meaning given to it by the Act of 1924) any person claiming through or under a subscriber." I said last night that that was an enlargement of the original group to whom those moneys were, by anybody, declared to be due at whatever time they became due. I asserted last night and I assert again that that amendment has been introduced for one purpose, and one purpose only, and that is in order to get in a particular Party organ which supports the Government. We have heard to-night that it is not a Party organ and that it is strain upon the patience of some members of this House to have that point made. It certainly put a strain upon their mentality to have it argued as it was argued. What is the position we now arrive at? There is a story told by O. Henry of a man who committed a particularly despicable act. When he got to Heaven, as the story ran, there was a cluttering up of the worst type of criminals, and those guilty of the most despicable acts, to avoid the glance of St. Peter. They were looking for this man. They clutched one man and he said: "I did not do that. I only robbed the pennies from the blind man's cap." Another man said "I did not do that; I only robbed a widow of money that she wanted for the support of her children." A number had other excuses, admitting themselves guilty of very mean and despicable acts, but always clear that they had not done the one thing for which the particularly mean criminal was being sought. That Party opposite can pride itself that it has got away with the loot. It has. The President can say, or his Parliamentary Secretary when he is questioned, "I did not rob the public purse for a Party organ. I only cut the labourers' wage." You can hear the Minister for Finance say: "I did not rob the public purse for a Party organ. I only got men thrown out of employment which they had been in for 20 years to give work to people who were on the streets owing to my Government's activities."
They came to make inquiries about particularly mean and despicable things done to this country, which is leading it to poverty and destruction. The President alone, I should say, bears the burden of this looting of the public purse for a Party organ. History repeats itself. Seán T. O'Kelly was envoy of the republic in America in 1924. He got together the bondholders, acting on President de Valera's advice, in order to put up a case against the republic, when the President was standing apart—as he always is—for the republic. At one time, Seán T. O'Kelly found that his mission had ended. Whether he had been recalled, had resigned, or was kicked out, does not emerge. But he had to leave, and in Documents "A" and "B" which we published, he announced, to use his own words, before he left the office to which he was attached in America, representing this State, "I grabbed all I could, and got out." The Party that sent that man to America as envoy is now in possession of the public purse and, while the going is good, they are making good. They are grabbing now what they can get preparatory, I hope, to getting out. At any rate, this debate has done one thing. Don Quixote long ago made a mockery of the ancient code of chivalry. We have a new type of Don Quixote at the moment, and a peculiar and comic type of Sancho Panza, standing by his side, in the person of the Minister for Finance, to aid him. What was an honourable transaction between the people of this country when fighting nationally for a certain purpose, and the folk in another country, kindred of ours, who lent their money to support that national cause, is now being demeaned, and the whole transaction sullied, just because this mouldy newspaper has, even in its second year, become decrepit, because they want to get a little more capital to prolong the weak existence of a newspaper that already has signs of death upon it. They can do that. They have got the votes. They have certainly no mandate for this robbery.
Comment on this
Deserved. They have got no mandate for this. They never said anything about it in the election address, no matter how extravagant their promises were about moneys to be saved, industries to be started, new markets that were to be found, and general prosperity achieved. There was not a word that this country was going to be taxed this year to the extent of £1,500,000 for the discreditable purposes for which these moneys are going to be raised. It was said long ago, in connection with that, that if people were going to sell their souls for a mess of pottage they might, at least, make sure that the mess of pottage would give them a decent meal. Looking back on the whole transaction now, having passed away from the amendment that would have saved the scandal of having to find this provision of £100,000 extra for the Irish Press, the hungry have an opportunity with an unwholesome type of diet, to make a good meal of it. The people about whom the President referred last night in such glowing terms are now being made to stand by—what? A Party newspaper in its hour of necessity. That is all there is to it. We had many foolish statements made in the debate last night that: “This paper was not a necessity.”“It is not a Party organ.” I hope that phrase will be blazoned forth throughout the country. It is a good index of the pitch to which the Government was brought in the debate. “The Irish Press is not a Party organ; it is not a necessity. Its prospects are good.” We are learning like the Minister for Finance, the longer we live.
We come now to the invisible markets for agriculture. We know a little about the invisible factories for industrialists. Up to this we had heard nothing at all about the invisible profits. We have all three now. Can the Minister for Finance, who is left alone to try to clear up the mess the President has left behind him, say that there is any other purpose in the phrase used in the Bill than that it is an enlargement of the 1924 Act, so that "the word ‘subscriber' includes (in addition to the meaning given to it by the Act of 1924) any person claiming through or under a subscriber"? Can he say whom he has in mind, other than the people whose money has been clutched for the Irish Press? Can he even give the case of an individual, with a decent sum subscribed, who has sold to somebody to whom it was right this money should be paid? Can he give a single example to warrant an enlargement of the phrase, other than the example which shouts itself aloud to everyone, and which has been shouting itself aloud since the Bill was introduced?
This should not be called the Dáil Eireann Loans and Funds (Amendment) Bill. It is a poor law relief Bill—outdoor assistance. We had the pathetic appeal made yesterday that there are 333 people employed in the Irish Press. Only one conclusion could be drawn from that, although it was not uttered by the President, that if the £100,000 is not paid to them they may not have 333 people employed there. That, from the very people who can destroy factories in this country, or who put, at least, an equivalent to that number of people on the roads by their activities in the last Budget. Of course, that does not matter. That can be viewed in a detached way. No one in this House was getting any profit, any sustenance, or any joy from these people being in employment, and there are not going to be many hearts sick on the side of the Government, if they are thrown on the streets. If the Irish Press went down there would be sick hearts and sore heads on the Government Benches, but it would not be because of any human feeling for the 333 people but a great deal of human feeling, and very human feeling for 11 people who sit as members of the Government, because the Irish Press is in the background now, and they are afraid that if the buttress of the Irish Press were removed from them, they might not sit there much longer. At any rate there has been a conscience aroused in the country in the last 24 hours over this transaction, a definite conscience aroused that it is trafficking in public moneys in the open way in which it is now seen that that trafficking is being conducted. Better still than all that, there has been another awakening and the sanctity, the odour of incorruptibility, the austerity that certain people had clothed themselves with, has departed. Mind you, on the whole, it is nearly worth while paying £100,000 to the Irish Press for that.
Comment on this
Section put.
Do you agree with this result?
Would this be the proper time to raise again the point about the confidential document?
Comment on this
Amendment 2 seems to be consequential on amendment No. 1 and I presume that it falls with it.
Comment on this
On this section I should like to give notice that it is intended to move, on Report Stage, an amendment extending the time within which applications for redemption may be made until, approximately, August, 1934.
Comment on this
I should like to ask whether that is the only amendment the Minister intends to move to the section on Report Stage, because I think another amendment is both necessary and desirable and, in justice to the Minister's own position as Minister for Finance, it ought to be introduced by him. He told us when we were discussing the Money Resolution that the amount of money left in the United States in December, 1922, was 2,377,434 dollars, and that the amount subsequently paid out, after the American court judgment had been given, was 2,188,379 dollars. There is missing as between these figures a sum of 189,055 dollars. There is missing also the very considerable amount of interest accruing on the main sum lying in the United States banks from December, 1922. The President told us to-day, when going back and standing very solidly over the attitude taken up by Collins, Griffith and Cosgrave, that these sums were proper to be paid by the State to the subscribers in the United States.
Comment on this
I do not like to interrupt the Deputy, but it seems to me that what he is saying now has no relation to the particular section we are discussing.
Comment on this
We are discussing the fact that remains in Section 4, now that an amendment has been defeated that would have limited the definition of the word "subscriber" that certain people would be authorised, under Section 4 as it stands, to make claims.
Comment on this
Not, I think, on Section 4. That is all I am suggesting to the Deputy at this stage.
Comment on this
I would ask you, sir, to keep me in order if you think it necessary to do so, but it is because the amendment has been defeated that it is necessary, in the interests of the Minister for Finance and in the interest of such integrity as members on the far side wish to claim, that I make this other point. I ask the Minister if he proposes to introduce, on Report Stage, an amendment to deal with the matter? The President to-day said, with regard to us on this side of the House, that "at the first possible occasion, it was their duty to pay it back," that is, the moneys that were subscribed in the United States towards the Dáil Loan Fund and the President reminded us to-day that at the first possible occasion it was our duty to pay it back. The President will now be coming to the Minister for Finance, as the head of a Party, and presenting to him certain claims as a subscriber inside the new terms. The President, as the head of a Party, was responsible for the grave deficit in those funds which I am now pointing out and which amounts to 189,055 dollars, together with the amount of interest that accrued on the major sum. I want to ask the Minister for Finance whether he will deduct, when he receives claims from a person who, contrary to the case he makes to-day in the United States and before the court, drove this country and the taxpayers of this country to the expense and costs that are represented there and then, in the circumstances described to-day, got power of attorney over some of these funds, from the amounts claimed by the President as head of a Party, the amount which will recoup to this country the amount lost to this country by the President's action in the American courts.
Comment on this
I suggest again that that cannot possibly arise on the section. This section does not deal with moneys. It deals with applications for redemption.
Comment on this
The Minister for Finance will receive applications from the person who was responsible in 1927, and in the intervening years, for a loss of 189,055 dollars, together with more, perhaps, than that sum again in interest. He will be presenting to the Minister claims as a subscriber inside the enlarged term here. Will there be deducted, from the amounts that will be paid by the Minister on these claims, the amount that will recoup the taxpayer of this country for the loss sustained by the actions of the President when, as head of a Party, he took the action I speak of in the United States, and I ask the Minister whether, in the first place, he will introduce an amendment to deal with the matter on Report Stage and, in the second place, whether he thinks it right that the taxpayer should again pay out a sum equivalent to this loss to the head of a political Party in this country?
Comment on this
May I direct your attention, sir, to Section 2, which deals with the redemption of the external loans and sets out the terms and conditions on which redemption is to take place? Section 3 deals with the method of redemption. Again, I suggest that what the Deputy is saying is out of order. The terms of redemption have been accepted by this House by the passing of Section 2 of this Bill. It was on that section that the Deputy, if he had been awake, should have raised this matter. As to what the Deputy has said, he well knows that there were several committees of bondholders participating in these proceedings. Some of them were inspired by the Government of which the Deputy was then a member. The Government of which the Deputy was a member was a party to these proceedings. In fact, I think it initiated them to compel the trustees to do something which their deed of trust forbade them to do. If there was any money dissipated in the whole of these proceedings, it was the Government of which the Deputy was a member was responsible for the dissipation of the assets. The courts competent to try this issue, having heard the case put forward on behalf of the then Government of the Free State, decided against that Government and determined instead that these funds should be repaid to the bondholders who entered into the litigation in order to protect their own rights. If there is any question of any person being made responsible for the recoupment to this State of the money so squandered, it is the Deputy and his colleague who sits beside him.
Comment on this
The Minister appears to be misinformed about the facts. He talks about one bondholders' committee being instigated by the Government of which we were members. It was. Why? In order to protect the interests of this State. Another bondholders' committee, instigated by the President, was taking certain action. It was our duty, as the President says, to pay back this money. Consequently, it was our duty as custodians of the interests of the Irish people to see that the residue of the assets became available here before we became responsible for repayment. The money was in the Federation Trust Bank in New York. We wanted that money handed over. The men who had been trustees under the First Dáil and who had been supplanted, I think, by the Provisional Government or the Third Dáil, resisted. We had to take the case into the courts because they resisted the handing over of that money to us. The Minister says that the court found against us. The report in the Journal of International Law indicates clearly that in no circumstances would the court have found in favour of the case put forward by the present President of the Executive Council. The case went against the President, who put this country to the expense of running those cases in the United States. When he found that that case was going against him, he instigated another case by a bondholders' committee. It was our duty to safeguard the moneys for the people in this country and we certainly did instigate another committee.
What would have been the position if we had allowed the matter to go by default, as the Minister suggests we should have done? He says that we were to blame for fighting the case in the American courts and, consequently, that we placed the cost on the people here. What would have been the position if we had not fought the case? The country has through the action, as I maintain, of President de Valera, been put to the loss of the legal expenses of these cases, plus the rakeoff, or commission, of the trustees who had the distribution of the residue in America. What would have been the position if we had not fought the case? In that event, a sum of money belonging to the people of this country, which President de Valera now says we are bound to repay—a sum of about 2,500,000 dollars—would have been placed in the hands of men who wanted that money for no other purpose than to resurrect and carry on the campaign of destruction that took place here in 1922 and 1923. If we had not resisted that case, the revolutionaries in this country would have taken possession of 2,500,000 dollars or more. They would have used that to the detriment of this country. When President de Valera had decided that the oath he fought about was only an empty formula, he would come in and say to the unfortunate Irish people: "I got that money; I held on to that money to use against you and now, by Jove, I am President of the Executive Council, comptroller of the public funds, and I am going to make you pay that money back." Anybody must admit that if we had sat idly by and allowed that money to come into the hands of those other people who had no intention of repaying it but who were leaving it to the public purse here to repay it, we would have been rightly condemned as failing completely in our trust. That money was desired by those people for the sole purpose of using it against the elected Government of the Irish people.
The picture presented by the Minister of our going forward with a vexatious case is not the true picture. President de Valera said in Documents A and B that he was always satisfied that he had no chance of winning the case. He thought he had no chance of winning it, but he pushed it forward knowing that. What was running through all the correspondence—Documents A and B, the White Paper, the letters of E. de Valera and others published in 1922—was:"Let us keep the Free State from getting that money." What is the Free State? The Free State is the people of this country and the elected Government——
Comment on this
A point of order was raised by the Minister. I shall now allow the Minister to reply to the statements that have been made, but I want to advert to the point that was raised by the Minister——
Comment on this
I think that my point of order should have been taken before certain statements were made by Deputy Mulcahy.
Comment on this
I am telling the Minister that I shall now allow him to reply. This point should have been raised on sub-section (2) of Section 2.
Comment on this
I should like to argue that very briefly. This is the only section on which the matter could be dealt with. The amendment that would be necessary would either have to be put in under this section or the point raised would have to be dealt with in a new section, because the type of claimant I spoke about is a special type of claimant that will have to give special information. Under no circumstances, could that special type of claimant be dealt with under No. 2 or No. 3. I submit that we are dealing with a special type of claimant and whether the matter could be dealt with under No. 4 is really very arguable. What we want to get from the Minister is what his intention is in the matter.
Comment on this
No type of subscriber has been specifically excluded from sub-section (2) of Section 2. That is clear. The sub-section refers to "full satisfaction and discharge of the capital of the external loans and of all claims in respect of interest thereon." I should think that Deputy Mulcahy's point as to whether certain moneys should be deducted by the Minister for Finance when certain claims have been submitted, would clearly have arisen under that sub-section. The Minister did not direct my attention to that sub-section when raising his point of order. But Deputy Mulcahy and Deputy Fitzgerald did proceed. I will allow the Minister to reply. The only thing that we can discuss on Section 4 is the form and manner and time in which application for repayment is to be made.
Comment on this
May I explain the cause of my interjection? The Minister, in replying to Deputy Mulcahy, made a statement the import of which was that when we were a Government we acted wrongly by not letting the 2,500,000 dollars in America go by default to another body. I got up to correct him historically, and to point out that the suggestion that he has made there as something desirable to have been done is a suggestion that we should have done something which would be nothing less than treason to the people of this country. I feel that my interjection was justified for the sole purpose of replying to and correcting the statement made by the Minister. I had no other purpose in making the interjection.
Comment on this
I am not saying anything at all about the Deputy's intervention. I am merely pointing out that I will allow the Minister to reply to Deputy Mulcahy and Deputy Fitzgerald, and that all that can be discussed on Section 4 is purely the form and manner and time of the application for repayment.
Comment on this
The point has been made that because the President was a party to certain proceedings in the United States, that when certain bonds that have been assigned to him are presented for payment, the expenses of that litigation will be deducted from the amounts which may be payable on those bonds. In that connection Deputy Fitzgerald has spoken with a candour which is unusual coming from the benches opposite. He has made several important admissions which I would like to recount so that I can show the effect of them. He said that there were trustees appointed by the Second Dáil to hold this loan. That was his first point. The first admission Deputy Fitzgerald made was that President de Valera was a trustee appointed by the Second Dáil. These moneys, I would remind the House, were collected on behalf of the Second Dáil by President de Valera as President of the Irish Republic.
Comment on this
The Deputy had better rid his mind of that obsession, and there is documentary evidence to prove that, so far as the Deputy is concerned, it is an obsession.
Comment on this
The document that has appended to it the signature of the then Acting President, the late Arthur Griffith—the trustee deed upon which those loans were held by the President with his Lordship the Bishop of Killaloe and Mr. Stephen O'Mara. At the foot of that document appointing the President as one of the trustees is appended the signature of Arthur Griffith, the Acting President of the Irish Republic, acting for Eamonn de Valera, President of the Irish Republic, and the signature is witnessed by the former secretary of the Executive Council, Mr. Dermot O'Hegarty.
Comment on this
There are many other documents. That is one, at any rate, which should be before the mind of the Deputy.
Comment on this
The Deputy has had the unpleasant experience in this House, when on a previous occasion he made a statement which he repeated to-night, of having one of the members of his own Party getting up and giving him the lie.
Comment on this
The point, at any rate, clearly emerges that President de Valera, the person who collected these moneys in America on the authority of the Second Dáil of the Irish Republic, was appointed by the Second Dáil a trustee, and charged with the custody and safe-keeping of these funds in America. That is the first point that emerges from what Deputy Fitzgerald said.
Comment on this
Is the Minister speaking with knowledge? Was the appointment by the Second Dáil or by the Executive Council of the Second Dáil?
Comment on this
I am dealing with Deputy Fitzgerald's admissions now, and with nothing else. The second point that emerges is that, once again, on Deputy Fitzgerald's own admission the Second Dáil, to use his own phrase, was supplanted by the Provisional Government.
Comment on this
The Deputy did. I took it down and it is on record, and it exactly represents the facts as nobody knows better than Deputy Fitzgerald. What then was the position? This supplanter of the legitimate Government—the Provisional Government—which by a coup d'état secured control of the forces of the State, proceeded to endeavour to secure control of the funds of the State which were then lodged in America, and they took action against the trustees. It might very well happen that a trustee, looking at all the circumstances of the time, might feel convinced in his own mind that the possibilities were that the courts would decide against him; but, whether that was his opinion or not, he at any rate was bound to defend his trust, and it was in defence of his trust that President de Valera became a party to these proceedings at all. Therefore, his participation in these proceedings was in no way vexatious and in no way unnecessary.
Could that be said of the Provisional Government? They had no claim to this fund. Nor could that be said either of the intervention of the bondholders' committee, which was set on foot by those supplanters, to use Deputy Fitzgerald's own phrase. If there was one person who was justified in participating in these proceedings at all, in using any part of the funds to defend the trust, it was the trustee, particularly when he had the support of a second out of the three trustees. Therefore, there was a majority of trustees, who felt that these moneys should not be handed over to the Provisional Government as they did not rightfully belong to the Provisional Government. But there is no suggestion—the suggestion has not been made by Deputy Mulcahy or Deputy Fitzgerald—that when the members of this committee of bondholders which they brought to birth, this ill-begotten child of their own viciousness, present their bonds for repayment that they are to be penalised in the same way as the person who defended his trust; those people, whose sole idea was to secure a violation of that trust, are to be allowed to go unscathed. They are not to be mulcted in any way. Their vexatious litigation which, undoubtedly, did result in an unnecessary expenditure of these funds is to be condoned, is, in fact, according to Deputy Fitzgerald, to be commended.
I do not know whether it is necessary for me to do more than point that out to the House, and ask the House to draw the conclusion from it that the whole of this debate has been motivated by nothing except disappointed spleen—that the people who, when they were in power in this country, made up their minds to do something which would be dishonest and dishonourable and to withhold from the original subscribers their full rights, or to withhold from the representatives of the original subscribers——
Comment on this
——their full rights. These people, since they are no longer in a position to do the material injury, which they first contemplated, are now prepared by flinging mud from the midden to damage as far as they can the reputation of the man who stands at the head of the State and whose name will go down in history when theirs are forgotten and when their descendants will be glad that they are forgotten.
Comment on this
I think I should on this section like to say a word to the Minister to urge upon him to look into this matter of the Fenian Bonds before the Report Stage. The President in the United States said that the holders of the Fenian Bonds should also be recognised by the Dáil Republic. I do not know what the position is with regard to them now. Perhaps the Minister would have that matter looked into before the Report Stage. I am not sure that under this section they would be entitled to apply as other subscribers are applying.
Comment on this
No. There was an opportunity afforded on the previous sections for this matter to be discussed and fully discussed. When I came into the Chair sub-section (4) was under discussion and I could not then have informed myself immediately as to what were the particulars. The Minister for Finance raised a point of order. I did not give a decision, pro or con, at the time not knowing what had happened. I wanted to make myself acquainted with the provisions of the previous sections and having made myself acquainted with them I discovered that the matter which Deputy Mulcahy raised should have been properly raised on Section 2 (2). Now I allowed Deputy Mulcahy to proceed, and I allowed Deputy Fitzgerald to supplement what Deputy Mulcahy had said. In fairness to the Minister I thought I should allow him to make a speech in reply. But the statements were concerned with certain litigation in America. Deputy Mulcahy gave his view as to that and so did Deputy Fitzgerald. The Minister than gave his view. The position now is that I cannot allow the discussion on that matter to be carried any further. The only discussion that I can allow is on the application forms for redemption.
Comment on this
You, sir, allowed Deputy Mulcahy to speak. The Minister replied to Deputy Mulcahy and in replying to Deputy Mulcahy he made certain statements which were contrary to facts. I got up to reply to the Minister for Finance, not to supplement what Deputy Mulcahy had said. The picture you have given is that Deputy Mulcahy spoke and that I supplemented what he had said and that the Minister replied. That is not what happened. I repeat again that Deputy Mulcahy spoke, the Minister replied to him and I replied to the Minister.
Comment on this
There were two speeches. Your point of view was given on two different occasions. Then this was started, but I could not allow that matter to be discussed on Section 4, so that ends the matter.
Comment on this
Yes. And I gather from what you said that you had in mind that we had spoken on this side twice. As a matter of fact the Minister had already replied to the point made by Deputy Mulcahy, but in that reply he misrepresented things as far as I can make out. Feeling that nobody was to be allowed to correct his statement or to state otherwise, I ask to be allowed to reply. The Minister made the most fantastic statements as to what happened.
Comment on this
I should like to ask the Minister whether he proposes to make any arrangements so that the form of the application will be of such a kind that he will be able to inform himself as to the claim and where and to what extent did the Minister think they had in any way been responsible for the loss.
Comment on this
I have definitely ruled out that. Deputy Mulcahy had plenty of opportunities under Section 2 (2) to raise the matter as to whether subscribers should be asked certain questions and whether certain information should be demanded from them. Now the Deputy is trying to ask the Minister if he will, in the form, ask if certain people were responsible for certain things. That is clearly endeavouring to get in what was dealt with in a previous section.
Comment on this
On Section 5 I would like to ask the Minister why he considers that the present is the time to impose this burden of borrowing on the country?
Comment on this
I consider that the present is the time because of the very explicit undertaking given by our predecessors that the moment that the receivers had taken their discharge this loan would be repaid. That undertaking was given by the Minister for External Affairs in the Cosgrave Government to the representatives of the U.S.A. in this country in a letter written in October, 1928. I consider further that this is a very desirable time to repay the loan because the circumstances favour the repayment of the loan at this particular moment. The third reason is, that we are able to make the repayment upon terms that are particularly favourable to this Government.
Comment on this
Are we to understand from the Minister that he is basing the obligation to pay this money simply and solely on the undertaking given by the previous administration and on nothing else connected with the status of the State?
Comment on this
Surely the Minister cannot say that the present circumstances favour the payment of this loan when every single branch of the public services is being cut; when every labouring man in the country is suffering intense distress caused by the reduction of wages and salaries? Surely the Minister cannot say in these circumstances that this is the time to send 1,500,000 dollars over to America?
Comment on this
Question put: "That Section 5 stand part of the Bill."
Do you agree with this result?
I would like an explanation as to what the exempted clauses mean, or what is the meaning of exempting those clauses.
Comment on this
If so, the Deputy is aware that sub-section (1) of the section reads:
"It shall be lawful for the Minister to take such steps as he shall think proper to ascertain the names and other particulars of all subscribers to the external loan or either of them and the amounts subscribed by them respectively."
Comment on this
Because the promise of repayment provided for in this Bill is much more favourable than the terms under Section 6 of the Act of 1924.
Comment on this
What can be more favourable than giving to the Minister powers to purchase such certificates for such price as the Minister thinks proper? Why take that out?
Comment on this
Yes, if the Minister does not understand what is in his own Bill. It is proposed to take out sub-section (3). I shall read it:
"That Minister may at any time redeem all or any of the stock certificates issued under this section."
Why take that out?
Comment on this
If the State enters into this, I should like to give the Minister power to purchase such certificates at a price that he thinks proper.
Comment on this
I do not think the Deputy has read the Bill. If he had he would see no certificates of the kind contemplated in this particular section are going to be used under this Bill.
Comment on this
Then what is the harm in leaving the section in? It gives the Minister power to purchase certain stocks and some of them may be lying around from the 1924 period. Is that a hardship? He is asked to pass judgment that something he is going to do is proper.
Comment on this
There is no reason why a statute of this date should suffer from any such verbosity as the Deputy is labouring under.
Comment on this
Question put: "That Section 7 stand part of the Bill."
Do you agree with this result?
I should like to know when does the President propose to lay on the Table of the House the document he quoted last night, that being a confidential document which, according to a former ruling, should be laid on the Table of the House when it is quoted?
Comment on this
May I point out that the President has already stated that he did not quote from the document, but Deputy McGilligan, by innuendo at least, has several times made the statement that the President did quote from the document. Is the Deputy entitled to continue to make that assertion after the President's statement?
Comment on this
It is interesting to see that the Minister for Finance has changed his tactics. Last night he said that the President had quoted but that it was not confidential.
Comment on this
Does the Minister for Finance deny that he said last night that it was not a confidential document?
Comment on this
He now says that he was merely paraphrasing and denies that he said that the document was not a confidential one.
Comment on this
I say that I said last night that the President did not quote from a confidential document. I said that he did not quote.
Comment on this
This is a matter we will have to find out when the Official Report is before us, but it is my recollection, and I think it will be the recollection of most Deputies in the House at the time, that the Minister's attempt to defend was not that he did not quote but that what he quoted was not a confidential document.
Comment on this
The Deputy is allowing his verbosity to get the better of him and is mixing up his imagination with his recollection.
Comment on this
Well, at any rate, I have both imagination and recollection, which the Minister has not yet been able to give evidence of to this House. That was the statement he made last night. The President said he gave an answer. I heard him give four answers, in his usual way. First of all, he said he was going to quote from a confidential document. Is the Minister going to say anything? Secondly, he said that he would challenge anybody to deny that there was in the confidential document what he was going to state; and, thirdly, that he would only quote slightly from the confidential document; and his fourth answer was that he did not think it was a good rule of this House that, when a document has been quoted from, it should be made available for Deputies.
Comment on this
With all respect, I suggest that this discussion is not in order at this stage. The only thing is whether a Deputy, after the President having stated that he did not quote from a document, is entitled to continue to assert that the President did quote from a document. I think it is the usual practice in the House to accept the statement and not to allow the matter to be brought up continuously and vexatiously.
Comment on this
I am not aware that the President said that he did not quote from a confidential document. Last night, when the Minister for Finance blundered into that statement, the President brushed him aside.
Comment on this
Not for the first time, as the Deputy says, and I am sure not for the last time either if he has any sense of right and justice. The President has not yet made the statement that he did not quote from a confidential document. In fact if the President had not made that statement, why did he go on to state that the rule of the House, which required that a confidential document from which a quotation had been made, should be laid before the House, was a bad rule and should be inquired into? I am persisting in this.
Comment on this
I understood that we are now on Section 8 of the Bill, or, at least, we ought to be.