In Committee on Finance. - Vote 56—Industry and Commerce (Resumed).
Contributions 1–127 of 269. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
We are now about to embark on a 48 hours discussion of these Estimates and it has puzzled the minds of some as to why we are going to do it. The more I consider these Estimates, the more evident it becomes to me that the members of the Fianna Fáil Party have made up their minds that, for them, there is in this country only one place where the wicked cease from troubling and the weary are at rest, and while they can escape from their constituents into this House and there is an ample force to protect them from cross-examination by the people they are supposed to represent, it is very difficult to dig them out of that safe refuge. I should not be in the least surprised if we had many motions of this kind, particularly in view of the legislation introduced yesterday. This will become, by the time the Land Bill of 1933 is explained to the people of this country, the most popular refuge for members of the Fianna Fáil Party in the whole country. Deputy Mulcahy to-day dealt with the failure of the Minister for Industry and Commerce to meet the problem of unemployment as he promised to meet it, and I think Deputy Mulcahy was too severe on the Minister for Industry and Commerce. What can the Minister for Industry and Commerce do? If you wreck the whole economic fabric of a country, if you deliberately put your hand to a national policy the principal consequence of which is the destruction of the purchasing power of the public, how can any Minister, no matter how he administers his Department, prevent the rise, the daily increase of unemployment amongst our people? It does not matter what the Minister or the Acting Minister does, if the present policy of the Government continues, the tide of unemployment will rise and continue to rise in this country. The policy of this Government is reducing the consuming public in Ireland, the agricultural community, to destitution and you cannot employ men manufacturing goods if there is nobody left in the country who has any capacity for consuming them. When the goods accumulate to a sufficient extent, then manufacturers, no matter how good their will may be, must pay off their men when they cannot sell what they have already produced, and the longer the present situation goes on the higher will flow the tide of unemployment in this country, and it does not matter what means the Minister adopts, he will be absolutely powerless to deal with it.
Considerable fault has been found with him for the way in which unemployment grants have been administered. The unemployment grants have been administered for the purpose of pouring out money at the most propitious moment from the Government's point of view; and when you are trying to make people forget the destitution and the poverty that Government policy is bringing upon them, the best way in which you can do it is to pour out relief grants on the eve of the occasion when they will be called on to make a decision and to give their verdict on Government policy. That is what the Government has done and, so far as the Minister for Industry and Commerce is concerned, he deserves high credit from his own Executive. No man skipped into the breach more agilely than did the Minister for Industry and Commerce with a relief grant and, if there is a general election in October, be perfectly certain of this: the relief grants will pour out to the country like a revivifying stream.
Comment on this
The policy of the Department of Industry and Commerce is now under review. The question of giving relief grants does not come within the jurisdiction of that Department.
Comment on this
I respectfully submit that the Minister for Industry and Commerce was concerned to assure this House that if any complaints were made to him, as to the invidious selection of any one employed on relief works, or in the administration of relief grants, he, through the labour exchanges, would take every possible step to see that relief grants were administered in accordance with the will of the House. I am suggesting to the House that the way he is demonstrating that is this: that when things are getting hot with the Government in the country he will cool them with relief grants.
Comment on this
The giving of relief grants at elections is not a function of the Department under control of the Minister for Industry and Commerce.
Comment on this
It is astonishing how he makes provision to make them flow in the right direction when the elections are on.
Comment on this
To a Deputy who publicly advises impersonation that is corruption. I do not think there is any corruption in connection with what the Minister did, astuteness, perhaps skill, but not corruption. All the Deputies in Deputy Kelly's Party are not so honest as he is.
Comment on this
So much for unemployment. I want to refer again to what I consider to be a very grave scandal in connection with the administration of the Department of Industry and Commerce. I referred to it on two or three occasions before but, so far, the Minister has never attempted to meet the case. Under the legislation to regulate the milling of flour in this country, the Minister was given authority to issue permits to certain individuals to import flour free of duty, if he considered that to be in the public interest. In County Donegal one particular case came under my notice in which a certain individual set up a bakery. In the course of time, there were some labour troubles on the railways in the Free State, and that individual then represented to the Government that, as a result of these labour troubles, he was unable to secure supplies of bakers' flour for his bakery. Deputies who are familiar with the flour trade will know that bakers' flour is an entirely different commodity from household flour; that the average housewife could not use bakers' flour in her kitchen, because it would be quite unsuitable for the purposes ordinarily employed in the kitchen. On the other hand, a baker could not ordinarily use household flour in a bakery, because it is not a suitable grade of flour for the manufacture of bakers' bread. At this time there was a duty of 5/- a sack on flour, and the Irish millers, of course, raised their prices by about 4/- a sack in order to get the benefit of the tariff.
All the flour factors in Donegal were obliged to import English flour and to pay the 5/- duty or to buy Irish flour from Irish millers at 4/- a sack above the English price. This gentleman came to Dublin and got a permit to import bakers' flour, on the ground that he could not get supplies in the Free State. He got the permit to import, free of duty. Having got the permit, which was probably simply a permit to import so much flour free of duty, this prudent gentleman went into Derry to Spillers's agent, and got half the quantity of bakers' flour, and half the quantity of household flour. When he got back to Donegal his flour came after him. He then sailed round to all the customers of his rivals in the wholesale flour business and asked them what so-and-so was charging for flour. These customers said, perhaps £1 9/- or £1 10/- a sack, which was the Irish price. He said to them: "Do not bother dealing with them. I will give it to you at 27/-." So well he could, because the Minister for Industry and Commerce had given him a permit to import flour, free of duty, and no one else could get a permit. Let me be clear about this. I am satisfied that the Department of Industry and Commerce believed that the man wanted bakers' flour and gave a permit to bring in bakers' flour. Having got it on these representations this man went on to use that permit, partially to bring in household flour, which he sold for the purpose of injuring his competitors in the trade. I asked the Minister for Industry and Commerce to inquire into that locally and, if he found the allegation I made in this House true, to bring that man to justice, if he had not given a satisfactory explanation.
Comment on this
I have already placed the facts in the Minister's hands, and it is quite probable that Deputy Brady is as well able to put these facts in the Minister's hands as I am. This gentleman does not live 100 miles from Deputy Brady. The Deputy knows the man, and knows that what I am saying is true.
Comment on this
When I had something to say about lobster breeding, the Deputy's only contribution was that my statement was not right. I repeat the charge. Every syllable that I utter now I challenge the Minister to inquire into, by sending down a responsible officer from his Department. Every word I have stated will be demonstrated to be true. I challenged him to do that three times in this House. He can do it now.
Comment on this
The Deputy is using his position to make charges in this House that he cannot substantiate.
Comment on this
I will substantiate the charges, but it is not in accordance with the well-established precedent of this House to mention the names of an individual, because the person is not here to defend himself. I formally inform the Minister that I am at his disposal now, or hereafter, to place the name and the circumstances in his hands. I gave them to the Minister for Industry and Commerce before he fell ill. That specific case falls under the head of this system of issuing permits. On the general question of permits I say that the whole system is breaking down, and making the conduct of business in this country virtually impossible. Omnibus tariffs are being imposed, and merchants are told that if they find omnibus tariffs take in something they are not meant to take in they can get permits. When they go to get permits it may take three weeks or a month to do so. I am quite satisfied that the permanent officials are doing their best to expedite the consideration of applications for permits, but these are so numerous that it is physically impossible to deal with them with any degree of expedition. The result is that it is daily becoming more and more difficult to carry on ordinary trade in the country—such trade as is left, and that is not much.
We have just passed through this House a Cement Bill, about which I want to say a word with reference to the administration of the powers conferred on the Minister.
Comment on this
I do not for a moment desire to avoid your ruling, but it is the declared policy of the Government to sponsor the manufacture of cement in this country. I think I will be in order if I say that in sponsoring an enterprise of that kind they have got to remember that cement is not a standard article. There are varying qualities of cement and they have got to remember——
Comment on this
I suggest that the Deputy is out of order in discussing that matter, which arises under the Cement Bill, which, in fact, may again be under discussion in this House, the Bill not yet having passed through the Seanad.
Comment on this
Is what the Deputy says related to the passing of the Bill at all? Is it not related to the Government's policy in dealing with a certain commodity?
Comment on this
That is precisely my position. I am not trying to wriggle out of your ruling but the Minister and the Acting-Minister have stated repeatedly that it is the policy of their Party to take such steps as may be necessary to promote the manufacture of cement. I suggest that when they proceed to act in pursuance of that declared policy, they should bear certain considerations in mind. I want to say a word on the steps they should take before they put their hands to the task. No other opportunity will arise for dealing with that question. They have got to remember that cement is an essential element in the housing of the poor and that every shilling per cwt. put on cement is going to be borne by the people who pay the rents. The most difficult problem that the Department of Local Government and Public Health have is to provide decent houses at a rent within the capacity of the people to pay. What everybody concerned with housing has been trying to do is to secure that houses will be built at a price which will make it possible to attain that objective.
Comment on this
I suggest that if we are going to discuss questions already discussed on the Cement Bill, the time of the House will be unnecessarily taken up with repetition.
Comment on this
The Minister is not supposed to quote a Standing Order. He can raise a general question. Obviously, this matter has been discussed here and may be discussed again. However, it is a matter of policy and I cannot prevent the Deputy from discussing it now if he wishes. It is a matter of Government policy.
Comment on this
If it is the purpose of the Government to create a monopoly of the manufacture of cement without providing that the consuming public will have cement of a sufficiently high specification at a reasonable price, then, in my opinion, Government policy on cement is going to cut clean across Government policy on housing.
Comment on this
Will the Deputy before he continues his speech tell us what the increase is going to be. It has been definitely stated—I hate to interrupt the Deputy in an eloquent mood— that any increase likely to take place in the price of cement will be infinitesimal and will not affect housing costs.
Comment on this
The Acting-Minister for Industry and Commerce says that the increased cost will be infinitesimal. Without the slightest desire to answer the Minister abruptly, I tell him that he is talking through his hat. If the Minister believes that cement of the commercial quality which is being used here can be manufactured in this country at a price anything like that at which we are importing it at present, he does not know what he is talking about. Estimates were submitted to this House showing that on the basis of certain suggested increases in the price of cement per cwt., the increased cost per house would be infinitesimal. I think that these estimates were wrong.
Comment on this
The trouble with this situation is that it is a question of one "think" against another "think." If I had any reason to believe that the Minister's thoughts were founded upon substantial facts, I would be very much swayed, but my experience of the Minister for Industry and Commerce is that they are founded on nothing at all, or on the assumption that what he wishes to think is true. The fact remains that when I proposed that a specification of the standard cement to be produced by the monopoly which it was Government policy to create should be forthcoming, the suggestion was scorned as absurd and unworthy of consideration. But when some worthy gentleman with sound Tory background got up in the Seanad and made the same proposal, the Acting-Minister for Industry and Commerce fell upon his face and said he accepted it unreservedly.
Comment on this
Are we to discuss here what took place in the other House? We shall never get to the end of the business if we do that.
Comment on this
The Acting-Minister went on to add that he begged to be excused from the necessity of making a specification for the cement that would be imported between the date of the passing of the Bill and the establishment of the first cement factory. He is doubtless going to come back to this House at a future date and tell us that this prudent recommendation, having been explained, is one that he recommends to the House. When this House had the temerity to make that suggestion, it was beneath his dignity to consider it. It was quite superfluous and unnecessary. The Minister has learned differently since, and I only hope that he may make a few more excursions to the Seanad between this and the time his cement policy takes final form. I hope that in those hallowed surroundings he will learn more from his respectable instructor of the dangers and pitfalls of the policy to which he has put his hand.
Lastly, I want to refer to the beneficent influence exercised by the Minister of Industry and Commerce over the milling industry. As a result of his activities since the Cereals Bill was passed, we discovered on last Monday morning that there was no bakers' flour at all in the City of Sligo. The bakers announced their intention of closing their doors because there was no flour left. The operation of quotas and restrictions had been so effective as to dry up the supply of flour. We had excluded from Donegal bread from the Six Counties. We had arranged that bread was to be supplied from Sligo, and, on Monday morning, there was not an ounce of bakers' flour in the whole City of Sligo. The bakers could not get it. They went to the usual source of supply and they were told that the Minister for Industry and Commerce would not allow any increase for Sligo, that they had milled their quota and would be allowed to mill no more. I got into communication with the Minister and, as usual, received a very courteous reply. I think one or two other Deputies drew his attention to the situation. But it shows the extravagant absurdity of the administration of this legislation when a situation can arise in one of the principal cities of the country, in which there is not an ounce of bakers' flour or the wherewithal to make a loaf. That is the favour that has been conferred on the milling and baking industry by the administration of the Cereals Bill.
I do not know if the Minister for Industry and Commerce was concerned in a certain transaction in wheat recently, but I understand there was a transaction in wheat in Dublin to which the Government was a party. If the Minister for Industry and Commerce had anything to do with that transaction I think it would be of great interest to the House to know the profit the Government derived from the sale they made.
Comment on this
That accounts for the Minister's complacency; he looks happy and undismayed. Perhaps if he knew as much about that transaction as I do, wrinkles would appear on his brow. I suggest he should have a chat with the Minister for Agriculture and I think he will get information from him that will startle him.
Comment on this
I do not want to shock the Deputy too much. His neighbour, when I proceeded to tell him what was happening in Donegal, nearly fainted away.
Comment on this
The Deputy said I do not know what is happening there. At least, what I do know, I communicate to this House. The Deputy's colleague, Deputy Neil Blaney, was recently described by "Truth in the News" as being dead. They heard so little about him since he came here to represent Donegal that they assumed he was dead, and they described him as the late Neil Blaney. They felt that no man could be so silent, and they assumed that he was in the grave. However, I am happy to see that my friend and colleague, Deputy Blaney, is as brisk and as well as ever. I met him in the Lobby this morning about his business, and I trust he will be spared for many years to come to represent Donegal as eloquently as he does now.
Comment on this
I do not know whether the fact that a Deputy is living or dead has anything to do with the matter under discussion.
Comment on this
I will leave it to the Minister for Industry and Commerce to tell Deputy Kelly all about the wheat transaction and, I would recommend Deputy Kelly, if he wants to spare his colleague embarrassment and dismay, to slip down to the Minister's office and ask him about it there. When he hears all about it he can make up his mind whether he will ask any further information in the House.
Comment on this
I am going to spare the Deputy from himself; I will ask him merely to take a note of it. In my opinion the dominant question that arises under this head is that referred to by Deputy Mulcahy, and that is the question of employment. I think all Parties will agree that it is not a question that should be made one of Party capital. So far as I am concerned, I am profoundly convinced there is nothing the Minister can do to remedy that situation so long as the Executive Council continues their present line of policy. I think it is a mistake to find undue fault with the Minister on account of the unemployment situation. Unemployment must grow where there is universal destitution. If you wreck the consuming capacity of any community, in that community the tide of unemployment will grow.
In 1920 the farmers in this country were never so prosperous and they have never been so prosperous since. In those years labour was never better paid and there was never more employment for everybody than there was then. The farmers in this country are now reduced to a depth of destitution that they never plumbed before in the memory of living man. Unemployment was never more rife in this country. Those are two coincidences which I would like Fianna Fáil Deputies to consider and, when they have considered them, perhaps they will connect them. When they have connected them, perhaps the farmer Deputies in Fianna Fáil will try to help their own. Those who represent the constituencies where there is a large labouring population will do their best to help that population. If they see the problem as I have seen it, I am sure they will co-operate with us in bringing an end to a situation which is leading the farming community to ruin and destruction. If they succeed in doing that they will do more than anything else to put an end to a situation which has perplexed this country and which will continue to perplex it so long as you smash the industry upon which the country depends.
Comment on this
It is an extraordinary thing, in connection with a Department that claims to represent the industry of this country and in the case of a Minister who claims to administer what he once described as the revolutionary policy of the Government, that no effort was made in the introduction of this Estimate to give the House any idea of the results of that particular policy. It is not the first time we have had occasion to call attention to this lack of respect for the House on the part of the Ministry. Having heard no statement from the Minister, I think the House is fully entitled to make full use of its rights on the Committee Stage, so far as this Estimate is concerned. Even after the Minister has at least given some statement to the House as to the administration of this Department during the year, the House will still be entitled to discuss that policy as revealed by the Minister. I think it is well we should issue that warning, so that when the Minister replies it will be distinctly understood he is not going to conclude.
The House is entitled to a statement from the Minister on the results of what he described as a revolutionary policy. We are all the more entitled to expect a statement of that kind from the Acting-Minister, because it will be in the recollection of the Deputies that some 12 months ago, in answer to various challenges, the Minister fixed eight months as the time that would see the triumph, the proof of the success, of that policy. I hold there was no excuse for the line adopted by the Minister in the present instance. He did not attempt to give to the House any idea of the results of this policy. No justification has been attempted so far as this policy is concerned and right through the year, as Deputies will remember, attempts were made again and again from various quarters, and particularly by Deputy Mulcahy, to extract information from the Minister as to the effect of the policy that has been pursued.
Though he promised this House that in eight months after he had spoken, now some 12 months ago, the country would be convinced of the success of his policy, he and his Department have absolutely refused to give any information to this House or any information to the country on which they could form some estimate as to the value of the policy that the Government has embarked on. Many of us see in this particular policy the ruin of many old-established industries, and interference with a great deal of employment in the country. Yet no justification, except the glib answers of the Minister and the somewhat more ponderous answers of the Acting-Minister, has been given on this particular matter. As a compensation to this country for the loss of our principal foreign market we were promised that we were getting control of the home market. When attempts were made from various parts of the House to find out what that home market has proved to be worth, even to the manufacturers for whom it was apparently preserved, we could get no information.
Deputies will remember that Deputy Keating from Wexford—and I think that there is no difference of opinion between him and the representative of the Labour Party from Wexford— has tried again and again to get information as to the amount of increased work there was, for instance, in his own town of Wexford as a result of the tariff policy of the Government, as to the type of employment that was given, and as to whether or not there has been diminution in the higher paid types of employment. There were no figures and no information available. I should have thought, seeing that the attention of the Minister had been drawn to that and other facts in the course of the year, that the Acting-Minister would have utilised the opportunity of taking the House and the country into his confidence by giving concrete facts about the increase in employment and the value, so far as wages are concerned, of that increase in employment. We have no evidence whatever of the value of the employment that has been directly given as a result of those tariffs, but I suggest that we have evidence—and every Deputy who has been through the country knows there is plenty of evidence—of the unfortunate results of the Government's policy so far as employment is concerned. The results that would inevitably follow as a consequence of the Government's policy have been pointed out. Here, I thoroughly agree with Deputy Dillon. The burden of our complaint is not so much against an individual Minister, or against an individual Department. It is against the policy which the Government has blindly persisted in. They were warned that it was bound to have certain results detrimental to every type of industry, agricultural and otherwise, in this country. It was pointed out that as a result of their policy the positions of men who had been in employment for years would become insecure. Has not that particular warning been more than justified? We have seen the line attempted to be adopted by the Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for Finance so far as employment is concerned.
Comment on this
I suggest that the Deputy is quite out of order in suggesting that what the Parliamentary Secretary said or did has reference to the administration of the Vote for the Department of Industry and Commerce.
Comment on this
I suggest that it is highly relevant, and one of the most relevant things that could be said on this matter. I suggest, before you give a ruling on the point of order raised by the Minister, that I be allowed to point out that the action of the Parliamentary Secretary was the natural consequence following from the results of the general policy of the Government.
Comment on this
The Minister for Industry and Commerce is not responsible, so far as I understand, in connection with the wages question which the Deputy refers to. There is no responsibility whatever as far as the Department is concerned.
Comment on this
I am dealing with the question of employment, and not with the amount given in wages. There has been an increase in unemployment. There has been what has been justly called casualisation of labour as a result of the policy of the Government, of this particular Department and of this particular Minister. I suggest that that is one of the most relevant things I can discuss on this particular matter. Naturally I am quite aware that the Minister for Industry and Commerce and the Government as a whole may say they are not directly responsible for what local bodies did, but what local bodies have done in the same direction follows from this whole insane tariff policy and economic policy of the Government. I suggest, sir, that I am quite entitled in connection with the administration of the Department of the Minister for Industry and Commerce to discuss the economic policy——
Comment on this
If the Minister cannot really follow an argument I candidly confess that I will not try to make him do so. I made it distinctly clear that the Government are not responsible directly for that, but it is a consequence of the Government's policy. Unemployment has been increased all over the country as a direct result of the Government's policy. So far as local bodies or private employers have been compelled to get rid of their employees, I hold that the policy of the Minister for Industry and Commerce is, to a large extent, responsible. It was pointed out again and again to the Ministry that one of the results of their policy would be that people who are now in employment would have to be dismissed. Members of the Fianna Fáil Party stood up on public platforms and found fault with individual farmers because owing to the action of the Government they had been compelled to get rid of employees. To suggest that they are doing that for political reasons is a slander on the farming community of this country. The same thing is bound to happen with shopkeepers, and with everybody engaged in business. It is happening, and it is lamentable that when a situation of that kind is in existence the Acting-Minister does not attempt to justify this Vote to the House, though it is evident to everybody in the country that those things are occurring. The actual amount of unemployment caused by the Government's policy is one of the serious things that the country has to consider. The driving out of employment of people who have been in permanent employment for many years is one of the things that has to be considered by the country. It is no good for a Minister to confess that he knows the farmers find it hard to make ends meet, and for other members of the Party, no matter how obscure, to take the line that farmers are getting rid of their workers, and are doing it for political reasons. They are doing it because the policy of the Government is driving them to do it, and for no other reason. So far as the administration of the tariff policy of the Government is concerned, no attempt has been made by the Ministry either in this debate or at any time during the year to show that that tariff policy has been successful, but every attempt has been made to avoid any definite statement on it. That is the situation that we have now to face.
There was another matter raised again to-day which inevitably flows from the policy that has been adopted by this particular Department. It has not been answered. For the third time Deputy Dillon raised that definite question here to find out what steps were being taken. The Minister has not refuted the charge that the Deputy made. He refused to face up to that particular charge. The Deputies who listened to him were surprised to find that no effort has been made by the Department to deal with that particular charge. I suggest that no amount of mental agility on the part of Ministers can get away from the appalling situation which the policy of the Government has brought on the country, so far as industry and employment are concerned. I do not intend to deal with the activities of other Departments to beat down wages —the type of wages that is being given. I have no doubt if I did anything of the kind we would have the Minister quickly rising on a point of order and saying that I was making an attempt to discuss that particular matter. I have never seen a Minister quite so anxious as the present Minister has been to prevent discussion on this particular matter. I think he raised points of order about ten times for the purpose of preventing discussion. Of course, he is perfectly entitled to do that, but I am not aware that a ruling was given in his favour. His action shows a distinct eagerness on the part of the Government to prevent discussion. They have done that already with the help of the Party, in the case of the motion they carried through the House to-day. Now they are trying tactics of raising pretended points of order to prevent discussion.
The situation, as I have said, is an appalling one so far as the country is concerned. The Government, by their policy, have deliberately shut us out from the foreign market, and, by doing so, they have made the home market, so far as town industry is concerned, the industry for which this Department is supposed specially to cater, largely unproductive. How can industry possibly flourish even if the home market is reserved to it, when that home market is made largely unproductive by other portions of the Government's policy? No Department can save a situation of that kind, no matter how active or how glib the Minister may be. It cannot be done. The farmers cannot buy because they cannot sell, or if they sell they sell at such an uneconomic price that they have not the money to buy. That is the situation. Every shopkeeper in every country town knows that. It may not be felt to the same extent here in Dublin, but it is felt in the various country towns. When that position is put before this House it is generally jeered at. We get the impression, listening to debates in this House, that the farmers were never so well off, whereas everybody who has been through the country and through the country towns knows that the opposite is the case. Not merely do we find fault with the Government because they have killed the foreign market, we find fault with them because they have also killed the home market and made it worthless so far as the manufacturers of this country are concerned. We can get no information from Ministers. I suggest, therefore, that an effort should be made by the Minister to introduce the Estimates which he has failed to do up to the present.
Comment on this
I think the speech to which we have just listened is one of the vaguest that we have heard in this House for a long time, and it is surprisingly vague coming from a Deputy whom we all recognise as a trained thinker. When Deputy O'Sullivan asserts so emphatically that the position in industry is extremely bad one would think that he would be able to quote some particular manufacturer in support of his view. Surely our manufacturers are not so deaf and dumb that they are not capable of expressing their grievances. Can the Deputy quote a flour miller, a clothing manufacturer, a boot manufacturer, or a furniture manufacturer who says that the purchasing power of the people is disappearing rapidly, and that he can find no market for his produce?
Comment on this
Surely mere assertion on the part of a Deputy who has a considerable reputation in every part of the House as a trained thinker is not sufficient, especially as he professed to find fault with the lack of seriousness on the part of the Government with regard to this Estimate. I think that Deputy O'Sullivan must know very well that the position is not as he described it. He must know that, not only would we hear about that position from individual manufacturers, but that we would be bound to hear about it from their different organisations. The manufacturers of the country are very closely organised. They have a Federation of Irish industries, and other organisations. You do not hear from any of these people that the policy of the Government has been fatal to their business or industry. As a matter of fact you hear quite the opposite. Some of us who were expecting to hear reports of that kind—because one would think that the reduced purchasing power of the farmers throughout the country would inevitably have that effect—were rather surprised that we never got a report of that kind from a manufacturer. On the other hand, you do meet manufacturers who give the most glowing report of their businesses. I quoted a statement a few weeks ago, and offered to give the name privately to anyone who asked for it, of the manager of a very big clothing concern who said that their whole difficulty was that they had not capital enough to enlarge their business in accordance with the demand for their goods and, so far as the payment of their accounts was concerned, that it was very much more satisfactory than it had been for some years previously.
On the employment question, when the former Government was in power, the only guide we had was that provided by the official statistics. When we raised any question as to the extent of unemployment, we were referred to these statistics. The official statistics for several weeks past show, as we know, a constant decline in the numbers of the unemployed and, in view of the circumstances of farming, the Government is to be congratulated on that fact. The Government is also to be congratulated on another thing, namely, that they have created a tremendous industrial spirit throughout the country. As a matter of fact, that industrial spirit looks as if it would be an embarrassment to some extent, because you have it so active in the country at present that practically every town and village is crying out for industries. They are thinking intensely of the development of the local resources and they are demanding Government help to secure that end. How that is going to be achieved for a small population, and how that desire for industrial development and for the universality of industry is going to be satisfied in view of the small population in this country, is something that I cannot answer. I think the Government will have to consider that position. The Government have said again and again that they are in favour of the decentralisation of industry, and the impression prevailed throughout the country that the Government are able to influence manufacturers who are about to start new industries to go to the provinces with these industries. The feeling prevails that Dublin is getting rather more than its share of the industrial development that is taking place. I think the Government ought to take serious notice of that feeling, and if it be the case that they are helpless in the matter they should make it clear to the country that although they favour decentralisation, they cannot influence manufacturers—that that is a thing on which they will not be able to help those in the provinces who desire to get a share of such industrial development as will take place. It will be regrettable, in my opinion, if the Government are forced to make a statement of that kind, but I think they will have to do so. I cannot see how they can tell a manufacturer to set up his factory in a particular town rather than in Dublin, or how they can use pressure on him. If they cannot do that, I cannot see how they can influence industry towards decentralisation to any appreciable extent.
As I say, they have created a very active industrial spirit throughout the country; so much so that the main subject of discussion as far as I can see, throughout the country, especially where there is any local organisation, is the development of local resources. To cater for that and so to encourage it that it will not be disappointed with the delay is, in itself, a big problem. There is also the question of mass production—whether the Government are satisfied that mass production is a thing that is to be encouraged in this country and whether they can hope to place any substantial number of people in industrial employment so long as mass production prevails. In my opinion, again relative to the small population of the country, if mass production is to prevail the number of factories which we can hope for will not be very considerable. It looks to me as if there were to a certain extent an incompatibility between the two things—the desire to put everybody into employment and, at the same time, approval for mass production methods. It seems to me that the two things can hardly go hand in hand. Mass production is, obviously, the enemy of employment. It is too soon, perhaps, for the Government to consider how far they can counteract mass production and replace it by methods that would be less objectionable and more satisfactory, both from the point of view of actual employment and from the point of view of the nature of the work of those employed in such industries. It is too soon yet, I think, to expect the Government to be able to deal with that matter, but the time is coming when they must deal with it because, if they are to encourage, as apparently they have already encouraged mass production—they have encouraged it in the clothing industry—it is obvious that by that encouragement they are limiting the numbers of people who can be employed in industry and limiting the chance of fulfilling their expressed wish to put everybody into employment.
There is just one other matter to which I want to refer. It is in the nature of a complaint. I consider that, with regard to the issue of licences, there is reason for complaint. It does look absurd that, with regard to a very important article required in the process of manufacture, the firms concerned are refused a licence to import, and referred to one particular person in the country for their supplies, on the ground that that person is a manufacturer, whereas he is only, to a very small extent, an industrialist at all— only to the extent of merely packing up the material. They are referred to him regardless of what prices he chooses to charge for his material. I am referring now to a very important article of manufacture. I have already raised it in the Dáil. It is an experience I have had myself during the past few weeks. I think it is altogether unbusinesslike to expect manufacturers to place their orders with one particular concern and at the same time not to attempt to control the prices being charged by that concern. That is one defect with regard to the licensing system. I was glad to hear the Minister say some weeks ago that he hoped to get rid of the licensing system altogether. I think that would be a good thing, and while, on the whole, the Department have given great satisfaction with regard to the working of the licensing system, there have been some defects in it which have irritated business people very much. At the same time, I think that the Department are to be congratulated on the amount of work they have done, and on the vigour and enthusiasm they have aroused amongst those engaged in industry in this country.
Comment on this
Deputy Moore said that he was very pleased to see from the unemployment returns during the last few weeks that the numbers of unemployed were decreasing and that he felt that the Government was to be congratulated on that. I wonder does the Deputy believe that? I do not believe he does. I am satisfied that the Deputy is more conversant with the unemployment market in this country than to believe that it follows from the fact that the numbers registered are being reduced week by week, that there is a greater number being absorbed into employment. I am quite satisfied, and I do not think there is a Deputy in this House with any knowledge of the actual state of affairs who will not agree with me, that the reduction in numbers is due altogether to the fact that thousands of unemployed, who were induced to register last year by the promises held out by the Government, have got tired of registering, because they saw there was no possible chance of getting employment, and said to themselves, as many of them have said to me, and as, I am sure, they have said to other members of the House: "What is the use of going through the form of signing for employment month after month (and some of them have been unemployed for a year and a half) when there is no possible chance of getting employment?" If we ourselves were in that unfortunate position we would very soon get tired of going to the labour exchange every morning or, in rural areas, sending in a card every morning to the manager of the labour exchange to inform him that we were still on the unemployed list. The fact is that there is more actual unemployment to-day than ever there was before. The fact is that there are fewer men employed on the farms or on the land at this time of the year than in any year in living history, because farmers who formerly employed men at this time of the year are unable to employ them now, as they are unable to pay them. I go further and say—and I could give several cases in my own constituency—that many farmers who, a couple of years ago, were in a position to employ men, are themselves to-day looking for work on the roads or anywhere they can get it. Deputies on all sides of the House know that is quite true. There is no use in trying to fool ourselves with the figures published in the newspapers every week and the attempts to convey, both in this House and in certain sections of the Press to the country, that because there is a fall of 10,000 in the figures that means that 10,000 people have been absorbed into employment. Of course, it means no such thing.
While I am on that I want to say that I was disappointed that the Minister in his opening speech did not give us some information about the new schemes put into operation by his Department during the past 12 months. I refer to schemes for the placing of unemployed workers. The House will remember that last year the Minister for Industry and Commerce scrapped the system which was in operation when he came into office, and substituted another scheme putting the responsibility for placing men on the managers of the local employment exchanges. That scheme created such a row in the country and in this House among members of his Party that he had to substitute another scheme. I think I can venture to say that the scheme that the managers of the exchanges are trying to operate is not any improvement on the scheme which has been replaced. We know quite well what is happening. If a county surveyor requires, say, 30 men for a particular work, he sends to the branch manager of the labour exchange, and the manager selects the 30 men. They may be the most unsuitable men that can be picked because the manager does not know the particular type of work for which they are required. In some cases he does not know exactly where the men are to be placed. The county surveyor has to take these men. I submit that is unfair, and I think that under that scheme, we are not going to get the best possible return for the money expended. As far as my experience goes, I do not think county surveyors ever did employ men on political grounds. They were able to use their own discretion, and give employment to men who would be considered most in need of work, having regard to their suitability for the particular class of work that was to be performed. I, therefore, suggest that the present scheme is unsuitable from every point of view. I do not think it should be left to the managers of the exchanges to select these men.
There is another matter I should like to refer to, and that is an order recently issued by the Department to labour exchanges that any man in receipt of a pension of 15/- or upwards is not to get employment so long as there is another man on the unemployment register. I quite agree that a man with a pension even of 15/- is better off than an unfortunate man who has nothing, but I submit that this order, coming from a Department, the head of which told us that they had a plan to solve unemployment, and that it would be solved within six months, is an admission of their inability to deal with the problem in any effective way.
Comment on this
If the Acting-Minister has time to look up some of his own election literature he will probably find that statement in black and white.
Comment on this
If the Deputy wants to make a speech he should get up and make it. I am not going to make any answer to the Deputy.
Comment on this
The Deputy is very fond of looking for quotations. He knows well that I can get the quotation quite easily. If the Minister were here, and I hope he will be here very soon, I do not think he would deny it. It is not the first time that I have made that statement in this House and in the presence of the Minister, and it has not been questioned before. This is a serious matter. We had a lot of talk in this House within the last few weeks about the standard of living that was being set up by the Fianna Fáil Government. There was a great deal of talk about 21/- and 24/- per week. This is a new standard—15/- per week —a standard by which thousands of British ex-service men and thousands of others, who have pensions, say, of 15/- per week, are not to get any employment so long as there are other men unemployed who have not a pension. That means that it is likely they will never get any employment so far as this Government is concerned. I can give the names and addresses of three such men in the town of Nenagh. One man there is in receipt of a pension of 16/- per week and has a wife and eight children and they are compelled by virtue of the order issued by the Department, to try to exist upon 16/- per week. I think that is grossly unfair.
Comment on this
He has. The county surveyor has a certain discretion in the matter. If he is satisfied that the persons are not, in fact, in the order of preference; if, in his opinion, the question of means is different from that laid down by the local employment branch office, that is, if he is satisfied that the man is really more in need than appears to be, he can give consideration to that fact. Of course, he has full discretion with regard to the actual selection of men on main road work.
Comment on this
I think the Minister is misinformed. I realise that it would be unreasonable to expect the Acting-Minister to be conversant with all the details of such a big Department as this. I think if the Minister will look into it again he will see that, so far as this question of men with pensions is concerned, the county surveyor, or the branch manager, has no discretion whatever. It is an absolutely hard and fast rule laid down by the Department.
Comment on this
I should like to have it cleared up because if that is not so, then the order issued by the Department is being interpreted wrongly. I should like to get it cleared up. On the interpretation put upon that order, no British ex-serviceman or any other pensioner with a pension of 15/- per week or over—as far as I remember I think the figure is 15/- can get any employment or can be placed on any job, whilst there are others without a job. That means that they are compelled or are driven into the position that they will be unemployed for the remainder of their lives, as far as we can see. On the other point the Minister said that the county surveyor has a discretion regarding the placing of men on grant work on main roads. I must confess that is something new to me. That must be a variation of the order made very recently because as far as I know he has not any such discretion. He has got to accept men sent to him by the manager of the exchange. That is what is happening down the country. What the Department may be thinking about, we do not know. As a matter of fact the first intimation that this House or the country got that there was any variation whatever in the scheme laid down by the Minister was when Deputy Flinn announced the other day that as far as the minor relief schemes were concerned, for which his Department was responsible, that particular rule was not being enforced rigidly. The reason he gave was that it was more difficult to secure registration in certain counties than others. He quoted of all counties, County Mayo. We all know what happened in County Mayo last year when it was announced by the Government that the grants would be allocated on the basis of the number registered as unemployed. We know the famous case of the town of Ballina, where nearly 7,000 men were given as registered. I am quite sure that if I were in the position of the Parliamentary Secretary and if I were trying to make the case of the difficulty of registration I would not select County Mayo as an example in view of what happened last year.
I do suggest that the Department cannot be congratulated on its administration for the past year, or on the way in which it had attempted to deal with the unemployment problem. I think the Department deserves the censure of this House, not only for not getting more workers absorbed in employment, but for making the lot of those unemployed much more difficult than it was. We had a scheme providing that 25 per cent. of the men employed in any particular work were to be single men—one in every four. Is the Minister satisfied that that is working out well? I doubt it very much. Is the Minister satisfied that the reduction in the number of unemployed registered represents the true state of affairs? I do not believe the Minister or his Department is satisfied of any such thing. I am not blaming the Minister or his Department for that, because, at no time did I, personally, believe that the figures supplied by the Department of Industry and Commerce, either under the present Government or under the late Government, reflected the actual position as far as unemployment is concerned. I do not think that we should be told, through the columns of the Press or in the House, that because there has been a drop of 30,000 in the number registered that that means that 30,000 have been absorbed in employment. It does not mean any such thing. As I say, I realise that we cannot expect the Acting-Minister to be able to deal with all the details and the points raised from this and other sides of the House, but I think that the Minister ought to get from the responsible officials in the Department what is the actual position regarding the working of the new scheme and regarding the placing of men in employment. I think the Minister ought to give the House an explanation of the order sent down in regard to the placing of men on work. I think it is a scandalous order that should be either withdrawn or modified.
Comment on this
As Deputy Morrissey has stated, the House is at a certain disadvantage in discussing this Estimate owing to the absence of the Minister for Industry and Commerce. Personally, I am sorry for the circumstances that have been responsible for his absence. I think it is the wish of all Deputies that the Minister should soon be back again in his place. There are several matters in connection with the Vote to which I would like to draw the attention of the Acting-Minister. Deputy Moore stated in the course of his speech that the Government had nothing whatever to do in regard to the placing of new industries in this country. I wish that were the case, because it, unfortunately, has been our experience in Dundalk that the Minister has, on many occasions, sent people who were prepared to start industries in Dundalk, Drogheda, or other parts of the country, to places in the Midlands and places down South. I, as representing that constituency, would like to have from the Minister a statement as to whether that is the considered policy of the Department in future.
I might remind the Minister and the House, that although there may be very acute differences of opinion existing amongst people in that county, on matters affecting the welfare of the people in the county in general, politics are left out of the question. We all work together for the prosperity of all concerned and, incidentally for the prosperity of the State. With a view to helping the Minister in his policy of the creation of new industries, there was formed in Dundalk a committee composed of business men of all shades of opinion, men who had experience in various branches of business. By an intensive campaign of advertising, which necessitated very considerable expense, they were able to draw the attention of many people in other countries— manufacturers engaged in the manufacture of certain classes of goods which owing to the tariff policy of the Government could not be imported into this country—to the advantages which Dundalk possessed as a manufacturing centre. These manufacturers were prepared to come here and manufacture. I can produce, if necessary, a whole sheaf of correspondence dealing with the matter. I content myself by stating that the people down there feel very sore, whether it is due to the action of the Minister or not, that certain of these factories have not been set up there, although the people prepared to set up these factories were very favourably impressed with the conditions prevailing within the county which I represent.
I hope that the Minister when replying will intimate to the House what policy his Department intends to follow in the future with regard to the setting up of these particular factories. Members of that committee have been very busy; as I say they have hunted the hare, they have not caught the hare, and they think that it was very unfair to hand her over now to other people. If people down in other parts of this country want these factories let them take the same steps to secure them as we have taken in Dundalk, Drogheda and in other parts of Louth.
Attention called to the fact that a quorum was not present. House counted and quorum being present,
Comment on this
I would ask the Minister if he is not prepared to issue a permit to these people to start any little factories in Dundalk, Drogheda, or any other parts of Louth that he would, perhaps, be prepared to place facilities at their disposal to set up factories. I refer now to places in mid-Louth, to the village of Castlebellingham which formerly was a very prosperous little village. It was very prosperous a few years ago, but in consequence of the closing down of the little brewery there it is suffering to-day, and as a result of that closing down there are many people there who find themselves without employment at the moment. The Minister can see that these industries cannot be set up unless the people secure a permit. This slowness and delay in the issuing of these permits by his Department have more or less given grave dissatisfaction to the members of that industrial committee which was set up some time ago and is functioning at the moment in Dundalk.
While on this question of licensing I would like to draw the attention of the House to the fact that there are very many fittings which are necessary for the carrying out of work of public importance such as sewerage and waterwork schemes, and these fittings cannot be obtained in this country for the reason that they are not manufactured here. These fittings can be obtained in Great Britain. I understand that very many applications were made to the Department of Industry and Commerce for permits in order that these fittings might be imported free of duty. The Minister can see the force of these applications for the reason that these works are mostly works of public utility such as sewerage and water schemes and work for the carrying through of which the Government make grants. The cost of the schemes would be considerably reduced by the issuing of permits for the free import of these commodities. I ask the Minister to bear that in mind because the delay in the issue of permits is holding up work. I am aware that in many cases the Department has absolutely refused to issue permits. Instead of issuing permits it has replied that suitable substitutes for these fittings can be procured at home, but they have not specified where they can be procured. I would urge the Minister to give that matter his consideration.
There is another matter affecting the question of unemployment benefit and I would like to refer to it. On the 4th of last May I put down a question to the Minister in regard to the payment of unemployment benefit to the workers on the Great Northern Railway. These workers as a result of the strike that took place during the month of April last were debarred from receiving unemployment benefit on the plea that their unemployment was directly caused by a strike. These cases were referred to the umpire and he gave his decision, I think, on 24th April refusing to grant unemployment benefits to these men. The acting Minister is aware that that decision affects 500 or 600 men in the various trades in the railway works, engineering, boiler-making and other allied trades.
Comment on this
I was only just making a reference to the question so as to press upon the Minister the necessity for introducing legislation to——
Comment on this
I was hoping to bring the hardship inflicted upon a section of these workers by the law, as it stands at the moment, and I thought——
Comment on this
I do not want to interrupt the Deputy. Probably he is not going to go very far with this matter, but on the Estimates it is not permitted to advocate new legislation.
Comment on this
I was anxious to draw attention to the law, as it stands, so that the Minister would put the matter before the Executive Council in order that the necessary legislation might be introduced later. However, as An Leas-Cheann Comhairle says I can raise the matter on Vote 60, I will bow to his ruling now.
As regards the question of staff in the various labour exchanges, I find that there has been a very perceptible increase in the number of clerks employed throughout the various exchanges in the Saorstát. I do not complain of or disagree with that. Perhaps the explanation is that the work has greatly increased there and that this increase in the staff is necessary. What I would like to be assured of is this: that the procedure with regard to the recruitment of such clerks or the filling of such positions in the labour exchanges should be carried out in a proper manner. My information with regard to the labour exchange in Dundalk is that very many people have secured jobs there as clerks who never registered at all. Their names were really sent down from the Department in Dublin here. I think that is most extraordinary in view of the fact that at the particular time there were registered at the local labour exchanges from ten to 20 local people who, by virtue of their previous experience in such work, should, in the ordinary circumstances, be entitled to receive some little recognition, and whose applications should receive some little consideration on the part of the Department.
I feel very strongly upon this. I am one of those who do not like to indulge in pin-pricks, or to criticise the Government for the sake of criticising them. Members of the Executive will see, as far as I am personally concerned, that I have not gone out of my way to criticise them merely for the sake of criticising them. I never will be a party to that. I have not done so in the past, and will not do so in the future. For my part I would like every man to get a job upon his merits, independent of politics. But I feel very strongly that people can get jobs of a temporary character, which makes it worse when their names have not been upon the register for unemployment at all. I hope the Minister will see to it that, so far as filling vacancies in the future is concerned, people who are actually registered will receive some little consideration. It is well known that people get employment through the labour exchange in Dundalk who are not residents in the Free State at all, but are from Northern Ireland. I have no objection to people from Northern Ireland getting work in the Free State. I know what nationalists in the Free State suffered in 1916 and afterwards for their political opinions. I would be the very last to raise any objection to these men. But in view of what took place I think I am right in bringing this matter to the notice of the Minister with a view to preventing such recurrences again in the labour exchange in Dundalk.
I referred to another matter incidentally on the Local Government Board to which I want to call attention now, and that is the policy of the Department of Industry and Commerce imposing indiscriminate tariffs on commodities used in the building of houses. The Minister, no doubt, is anxious to set up as many industries in the Free State as he possibly can with a view to increasing employment. With that end in view there is at the moment before the House a Cement Bill. If the Minister is so anxious to manufacture cement in this country, I think he should be equally anxious to manufacture bricks at an economic price, and one that will compare with the price paid for such articles in Northern Ireland or in Great Britain. It is a well-known fact that bricks can be imported into the Free State, as I said on the Local Government Estimate, at anything from £1 to 30/- per ton less than they can be delivered in Dundalk, from any brick works manufacturing at the moment in the Free State. As I said on that occasion it is loading the dice unfairly against the bricklayers and other trades engaged in building. I would point out now, as I did before, that these trades have a record behind them, and that Ministers should be slow in loading the dice against them. I would seriously suggest to the Minister that in order to give the Dundalk Urban Council an opportunity of building houses with brick at a price that could more or less compete with houses built either of concrete blocks or in situ, he should allow a certain quantity of bricks to be imported from Northern Ireland in order to enable public bodies in places like Dundalk and Monaghan that are in close proximity to the Border to erect houses of brick.
It is a well-known fact that many people prefer a house built of brick to one of concrete. There is the danger, also, as I said, of those trades becoming a thing of the past. In view of the fact that bricks cannot be purchased in the Free State at a price that will compare with bricks made in Northern Ireland and Great Britain, the Minister should make some arrangement whereby these bricks can be imported, and should allow public bodies to import them if they desire to erect houses of brick in the future.
As regards the policy of the Department on the question of strikes, I do not know whether I would be in order in referring to that matter or not. But seeing that the Department of Industry and Commerce is looming very largely before the public in regard to strikes I, as one with some little experience of trade union matters, am apprehensive, at least at the moment, as to whether it is quite good policy on the part of the Department to interfere in disputes that occur between employers and employees. I am referring to this matter by way of helping the Department, not by way of criticism. It is a very important matter and one that affects the future of this country whether from the industrial or economic point of view, and it affects the Minister's Department from the point of view of the setting up of industries. What I am coming at is this: Rightly or wrongly, I suspect we would not have so many of these strikes at all if those responsible for them did not feel convinced of the easy approach to the Minister, to get him to interfere in these matters and to settle them. I am one of those who can afford to get up and discuss this question with the leaders of the Labour movement. I am one myself. I think it is about time that the Minister should come out boldly and let the people in this State, and all concerned, know that no section of workers in this country can hold up the trade or business of the country at will. I am one of those who are out for the rights of trade unions and workers as well as any man, but I am against any section of workers flouting the authority of the trade unions and taking part in what I may call unofficial strikes.
Rightly or wrongly, there is a suspicion that these sectional strikes would not take place if these people were not assured of what I might call sympathy, tacit or otherwise, on the part of the Minister. It is a very important matter for the Minister and for the country and I think it would be up to the Minister, and, in fact, to the President himself, to take such steps as will prevent the trade and commerce of this country being held up by any section of workers who, by reason of having a grievance, real or imaginary at times, embark on an unofficial strike. I should also like the Minister——
Comment on this
I have allowed the Deputy to make his point and he should rest content with that. The settling of strikes or economic disputes is not an official function of the Minister for Industry and Commerce.
Comment on this
It is not his function, but I might add that there are many matters which, while they might not be quite relevant, are almost relevant. It is, however, a matter of very grave importance to the country and it may be that the Minister may see the wisdom of my remarks, so far as the future is concerned. With regard to this question of unemployment, I may say that there, again, I do not propose to criticise the Government in regard to whether or not there is an increase in unemployment for the simple reason that I have always taken the view, and take the view still, that it is not the absolute duty of a Government to solve unemployment, and I do not propose to criticise the Government, merely for the sake of criticising, in regard to whether or not there are more unemployed to-day than there were, say, 12 months or two years ago.
I know that all Governments would be anxious to solve this problem but it is a problem which is very difficult of solution and one about the solution of which there are great differences of opinion. I think that, at the moment, there does exist very serious unemployment but it is no more serious here than in any other country and the only criticism I make of the Government's policy is that I think they are going rather fast in the matter of tariffs. The imposition of many of the tariffs has led to unemployment in many directions and it would be a wise policy on the part of the Government to hasten slowly on this question of tariffs. There is no doubt that it can be argued, as it has been argued by Deputy Moore, that, as a result of the policy of the Department of Industry and Commerce, certain industries have been set up and certain people engaged in the manufacturing line have experienced a kind of boom in trade during the past 12 months. It is also a well-known fact, however, that, side by side with an increase of employment in certain directions, there is an increase in unemployment in other directions and that applies, in particular, to those engaged in the agricultural industry. You cannot legislate exclusively for city and urban areas and leave out of reckoning altogether the position of those who live in the rural parts of this State. Both interests are interdependent and I would urge the Minister for Industry and Commerce to be exceedingly careful in this matter of tariffs lest by his policy he may be reducing the capacity of that very large section of our people engaged in agriculture to purchase the commodities that will be manufactured in the new factories set up in many counties of the Free State. I hope that unemployment will decrease but it will only decrease if everyone co-operates and gives a helping hand. I hope and trust that that co-operation will be forthcoming because—there can be no two opinions about it—this is a matter which must arrest the attention and must command the support and co-operation of everyone who is interested in the material welfare of the people of this or any other country.
Comment on this
I regret very much that the Minister for Industry and Commerce is not here and we all regret the cause of his absence. Deputy Morrissey referred to the inconvenience and, I might say, the difficulties that county surveyors had in providing labour on certain works and I think the Minister assured him that the county surveyors had certain rights in that matter. I hope that is true because I also was under the impression, as, apparently, Deputy Morrissey was, that county surveyors had to take whatever labour was offered to them by the labour exchange.
Comment on this
They never had to do so until they were satisfied that the men offered in order of preference by the local employment exchange were satisfactory from every point of view.
Comment on this
I am glad of the assurance of the Minister, because some of us were under the impression, and were definitely told when we made applications for work for certain unemployed men that the county surveyors had no power whatever in the matter. I think every Deputy must have had that experience to some extent. I, personally, had, and I am glad of the assurance of the Minister that they have some option in the employment of labour. Deputy Moore asked somebody to point out any manufacturer who had had difficulty in finding a market for his produce. When the Minister for Industry and Commerce last year introduced the Cereals Bill, certain of us criticised it very strongly and we pointed out many of its possible effects. We pointed out the effects it might possibly have on existing industries in relation to the expansion of their business and the finding of markets for that expansion. The flour industry has been referred to. The particular constituency I represent is vitally interested in the flour industry and if the Cereals Bill directly affected any industry it affected the flour industry, and one of the direct results of that Bill and the other restrictions the Minister has imposed on this industry has been that the price of flour has advanced considerably. It has, perhaps, advanced more than it ought to have advanced if one takes into consideration the current market price in England. The principal cause of that advance, which has affected the poor people especially, is that the flour millers find it extremely difficult to dispose of the offals, and when I say "offals" I think Deputies will understand what I mean. I refer to the bran, pollard and other offals of which they have to dispose. When discussing the Cereals Bill we pointed out that in insisting on the mixture the Ministry was putting a serious hardship on feeders of live stock. Unfortunately, circumstances have since arisen which have made it rather difficult for feeders to use any particular food for cattle, or which have made it uneconomic to feed live stock with what they were fed previously. Representations have been made to Deputies that the mixture supplied is not a suitable feed for certain animals.
Another difficulty millers have is in disposing of offals. Farmers are not buying bran, pollard and other offals to the same extent as hitherto. With the extension of the milling industry there has been a rapid increase in the production of bran and pollard. In recent months I believe the flour millers have had to export these products to outside markets, which were already saturated, and to dispose of them at scrap prices. Because of that it was necessary to put the loss sustained on the sale of offals on to the flour that the people are using. That is one direct result of the policy of the Ministry.
I referred previously to another matter that vitally concerns the City of Limerick, and that is the discrimination that is made against that city in the charges for electricity, as compared with other parts of the State. In Limerick the citizens are subjected to a charge which is 25 per cent. greater than that charged for electricity in Dublin and 12½ per cent. greater than the price in Cork. In fact Limerick is put on a par, for electricity charges, with small villages.
Comment on this
I think the fixing of rates for electricity is not one of the functions of the Minister for Industry and Commerce. That is controlled by the Electricity Supply Board, and the Minister has no power in the matter.
Comment on this
Possibly the Minister has no direct power, as the Electricity Supply Board is not directly under his control, but, if any Minister has any power over the Electricity Supply Board, it is the Minister in charge of this Department.
Comment on this
The Deputy knows that in that matter the Electricity Supply Board is autonomous, and that the Minister does not control prices.
Comment on this
I suppose I am precluded from referring to it but if the Minister could use his good offices in that respect, on behalf of the citizens of Limerick, we would be glad. In the course of the debate reference was made to a difficulty about employing people who had small pensions. I believe I am right in saying that at the labour exchanges the services of certain people have been dispensed with, because they had small Army pensions. I do not think that is a highly defensive procedure. It was mentioned in the debate previously. If there is one part of this State that has been adversely affected by the policy of the present Ministry, and by tariffs, and other restrictions, it is the City of Limerick. When speaking on the various Votes, Estimates and tariffs, I pointed out what would happen to Limerick. Other Deputies pointed out, when the package tax and other taxes were imposed that they would necessitate centralisation of any new industries which would be established in Dublin, and that in consequence cities like Limerick, Galway, Cork, Sligo and other places would be affected. They have been affected by these tariffs. Limerick has been affected more than any other part of the State by the increasing depression. Unfortunately there is a great deal of unemployment there. It must be within the knowledge of the Minister that during the last few years the railway works have been closed in Limerick. I suppose that was inevitable. The railways have suffered owing to the depression. A large number of people were put out of employment when the railway works closed, while dockers have been unemployed as a direct consequence of the policy of this Government. One would have expected that any attempt made to provide employment for these people would have had the sympathy and the encouragement of the Minister.
In Limerick, we have, unfortunately, very few large employers of labour. We have a few noble-minded citizens who are trying to expand their business, and who at present employ a considerable number of people. One firm of contractors there is competing very successfully with big outside contractors and has obtained work far away from Limerick. This firm proposed to expand its business and to embark on new work which would provide employment for a great number of people. An application was made to the Department of Industry and Commerce for permission to import certain machinery under licence. This machinery included a concrete machine, a lining machine for the making of roof tiles, and a woodwork machine. So far permission has not been given to import these articles under licence. I am informed that the firm asked the Department, in case the necessary licence would not be given, to supply the names of firms who could supply the machinery, but, so far, that information has not been given.
This particular firm had a big contract in the County Clare, as they have various contracts in other parts of this State. If it had not been for the good offices of another contractor, who supplied them with the necessary machinery to keep going on that contract, that work would have had to be closed down eight or ten days ago. Certain works which they have in contemplation cannot go on unless they get the necessary permission from the Minister to import this machinery. I am reliably informed that if the order allowing them to import this machinery is not issued, 200 or, possibly, 300 men will be disemployed in the course of the next few weeks. I do not want to give the name of this firm because both the Minister for Industry and Commerce and the President himself are aware of the circumstances. The matter has been going on for some months, and I would have refrained from mentioning it in the Dáil if there was any other course open to me. It does seem to us in Limerick unfortunate that, while we are suffering as the result of depression, tariffs and other causes, there should be an addition to our unemployed on the railways, at the docks, and elsewhere, when we have the opportunity not only of keeping a certain number of men in employment but of increasing that number permanently. It is unfortunate that that should arise because a certain firm needs machinery to carry on their work and will not get the necessary licence to import it.
We have now had 12 or 15 months' experience of the tariff policy of the Ministry. I assume that the Department of Industry and Commerce is, in great measure, responsible for that policy. Whatever new industries have been established as a result of these tariffs have gone, practically exclusively, to Dublin. Outside Dublin, practically every city has suffered as a direct consequence of this policy. We were promised that this policy would lead to a great increase in employment everywhere. In the part of the country which I represent, we have found that that policy has lamentably failed. We may be particularly unfortunate in Limerick, but I venture to say that other Deputies will assert that they are suffering equally. Our agriculture has suffered, and it is difficult to imagine how cases such as I have mentioned should arise at this particular time. I hope that the Minister will reconsider the matter I have referred to, and that the President, to whose knowledge it was brought, will use his influence so as to enable this firm to carry on and extend its work, thus giving useful and continuous employment to a great number of people in the city I represent.
Comment on this
When the Minister for Industry and Commerce speaks with one voice and the Acting-Minister for Industry and Commerce speaks with another voice, it is very difficult to understand what is the real policy of the Department. We were told to-day that there were no definite instructions, and never had been any definite instructions, that workmen employed on Government schemes should be recruited through the labour exchanges—that there was always a certain choice left. That is what the Minister for Education, acting for the Minister for Industry and Commerce, told this House within the last few minutes. Yet, when I turn to the Debates of November 3rd, 1932, when the Minister for Industry and Commerce was himself laying down the policy on which his Department was going to work, I find he said:
"We insist in every case in which work has been given—that is, work provided out of State funds—that the employees be selected from the labour exchanges and that the manager of the labour exchange is to select the people who are to do that work. The manager does select these people."
That was the voice of the Minister for Industry and Commerce on the 3rd November, 1932. Now we are informed that there never were any such instructions given by the Minister, that that was never his policy. When we hear, as I have said, the Minister for Industry and Commerce speaking with one voice and telling us what his intention is as regards the policy of his Department, and when we hear the Acting-Minister for Industry and Commerce say that such a policy has never been carried out by the Department, we begin to wonder where we are. What is the use of telling this House that a certain policy is to be adopted when it is not the intention to adopt that policy and when that policy has not, in fact, been carried out, as we have now been told...
On the question of unemployment, which has been rightly debated at much length, I do not see how Deputy Moore could have drawn the conclusions which he drew from the official figures, that unemployment is decreasing in the State. These figures, as Deputy Morrissey has pointed out, are, especially under present conditions, very illusory and misleading. I should like to ask Deputy Moore, if he desires to think about this matter at all, how he would reconcile his conclusions with the appalling increase in home assistance. The last date for which we have any official figures—about these official figures there can be no mistake—is the last Saturday in May. We find that there are well over 30,000 more people on home assistance than there were the year before. If the numbers of unemployed are dropping, in fact, as well as on paper, I would like to know why the number of persons living on home assistance is going up by leaps and bounds. We have only the figures, so far as they relate up to last May, but there is not a Deputy who knows anything about conditions in the country who is not aware that more and more people in the country districts are being driven to home assistance every day.
Closely allied to this is the question of unemployment. The question of unemployment should, to a very considerable extent, dictate the policy which the Department of Industry and Commerce takes up. If you have unemployment upon the one hand and, if you know, also, there are a number of people driven on the rates to obtain subsistence and to keep away from starvation, and if those numbers are steadily increasing, and have gone up by 30,000—by what would be the whole population of what we would almost call a city in this State—then everything that can be done by the Department of Industry and Commerce to minimise that condition of affairs should be done. If there is one way better than any other to drive persons, who are almost on the brink of destitution, right over the brink, and into a condition of destitution, it is to make the necessities of life dearer. People may be just able to pull along if the necessities of life are cheap, but they must get on the rates if the necessities of life are being kept up by a deliberate Government policy.
That is precisely the course which the Department of Industry and Commerce is adopting at the present moment. If you want to keep people off home assistance, then what you should do is rather to subsidise the necessities of life so that the people can get them as cheaply as possible rather than tax the necessities of life, making them dear for these unfortunate persons. If there is one necessity of life greater than another in this State it is flour. At this period of the year, especially, flour is almost the main staff of life of the working population. The policy should be to keep down the price of flour and to make it as cheap as possible to the consumer, so that in this desperate condition of affairs, which the Government have brought about by the mismanagement of the affairs of State, the poorer classes of the community should be made to suffer as little as possible. What do we find? Instead of endeavouring to make flour as cheap as possible, they are making flour, relatively to what it ought to be, appallingly dear.
I have it upon impeccable authority that the same class of flour that costs 18/- in Northern Ireland costs 27/- in this State, and the higher class of flour that costs 22/- in Northern Ireland costs 32/- here. These figures vary from day to day. In other words, for your bag of flour—and I do not care so much about the price of bread, because, so far as my constituency is concerned, and so far as all the western constituencies, and, perhaps, other constituencies, are concerned, it is not the price of bread that matters so much as the price of flour—you pay practically twice as much as is paid in the North of Ireland. The bulk of the people here bake their own bread, and that is why the price of flour matters so much to them. If in this State you have people who are selling two head of cattle for the price of one, and those same persons are driven to pay the price of three bags of flour in order to get two, you are subjecting them to gross injustice and you are bringing about a condition of affairs which is going to add enormously to the existing destitution. You are going to make people who are suffering from your economic war not merely suffer, but suffer most unnecessarily.
As regards unemployment in country districts, we have it that it is not now, in certain counties, the persons who are most in need are receiving benefit. We are told now that the principle that they are to be recruited through the employment exchanges is, in some counties, anyhow, a dead letter. We find, in consequence, that dictation comes from Fianna Fáil clubs as to the persons who shall get employment. We know that is going on all round the place. We know there is a regular campaign inaugurated to prevent anybody who is not a Fianna Fáil supporter from getting work. Unless the Government takes a very clear and strong stand against that, unless the Department for Industry and Commerce takes a strong and determined attitude against that, it may at the moment be doing itself some little good, but it will do itself and the Government precious little good in the long run. It certainly will do an infinity of harm to the State. If you are going to demoralise the people by giving work, not to persons who need it, but to persons who have got political credit for something done, you are setting up a desperately bad principle, a principle that will not even pay you.
Comment on this
Deputy Coburn pointed out that clerks have been sent to labour exchanges, whose names were first sent to Dublin. I know there have been changes in the personnel of the labour exchanges and I have a shrewd suspicion why these changes were made. I have a shrewd idea what is the particular political complexion of the gentlemen who were sent down. No matter who they may be, no matter whom we nominate to be clerks in labour exchanges, I would much rather trust them to see that work was being given out fairly than trust those other gentlemen who dictate the persons who shall receive work. I know the same efforts are being made in the case of the Land Commission. I believe all over the country the Irish Land Commission are trying to stand out and see that the work is fairly given. It will be impossible for the Land Commission, or anybody else who is giving employment on relief work, to stand out if the Government gives way in any one particular direction. If you want clean administration in this country, if you want to keep the country clean, you must be firm in that matter, and you are not firm.
I am glad that here we have an opportunity of getting in this House a little bit of information—perhaps I should call it a big bit of information —which this House and the whole country have been thirsting for for a very long time. There is an opportunity now given to the Acting-Minister for Industry and Commerce of satisfying a bit of curiosity, and a very legitimate curiosity, which has been in the minds of the people of this State for a very long time. He is now in the position to-day of having an opportunity to tell us where the 300 factories have been set up. He is in a position to-day to tell us there are so many in this county, so many in that county and so many in the other county, and that they are giving so much employment. He has a grand opportunity—a gorgeous opportunity. All that information which the Minister for Industry and Commerce has so carefully kept locked up within his own bosom, so terribly afraid that anybody except himself should be aware of the location of these mysterious hidden factories, can now be given to the public, if the Acting-Minister for Industry and Commerce has got it. I am afraid he has not. I am afraid that all the search that the Acting-Minister for Industry and Commerce has been able to make has not been a search which would enable him to find the non-existent. Therefore, though I request him to give us all the information at his disposal upon this important question, I do not flatter myself that the Minister will give this House the slightest information about it.
Comment on this
Industry and commerce have one particular object, and that is to bring technical effort and capital together, to endeavour to stimulate industry, thereby increasing the wealth of the nation, and to solve the unemployment question if possible. There is not any doubt whatever that the Minister for Industry and Commerce, no matter what punch of fight he puts into his job, no matter how hard he works, if the Department of Agriculture is not able to walk in step, is only wasting his time. It is on the basis of a paying agricultural industry that this country can rise to support its own needs. It is on the basis of the agricultural community being able to have an open, clear and profitable market that an attempt can be made with any sort of chance of success to establish industries in country towns. Everybody is aware that in regard to the position of the country towns, as far as industry is concerned, as far as any chance of entering into commerce outside the ordinary local purchasing that goes on is concerned, there is no chance whatever of establishing industry or commerce there under the present conditions that exist.
The President went down to Kilkenny quite recently. He must have got some information there about the condition of unemployment, because he stated that unless the opportunity was taken now by people with capital, whether it be small or whether it be large, in the near future there would be regrets for not having taken that opportunity. Protection is offered to the people of this country who start new industries, protection which, I submit, will be to the benefit of the few as against the many. No matter what protection has been employed, no matter what action has been taken to prevent outside products coming in here which we can make ourselves, apparently the protection has not been high enough, strong enough or great enough up to the present to achieve the results that were in view. Nobody is anxious to see this country with large chimney stacks emitting smoke all over the place. That was never the idea in connection with the development of industry in this country. As I have stated, unless those two Departments walk in step, inch by inch and yard by yard, and have an equal balance of development, there is not the slightest chance of bringing about a development in industry and commerce which will solve or attempt to solve unemployment in this country. Go around to any of the country towns at the present moment, and what do you see? Nothing but fellows standing at the corners with their hands in their pockets. If you interview them you will find that they are living under most appalling conditions. It is quite probable that the vast majority of them have no hope whatever of getting employment, and are completely demoralised. A C 3 nation will be the result. County homes were never so full, and home assistance was never so much called for or drawn upon.
Complaints have been made about the present conditions under which employment is given under Government grants for minor relief schemes. Complaints are coming in in ever increasing quantities every day. Why? When this matter of relief schemes was being discussed, and the Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for Finance was here, I deliberately refrained from making any acrimonious remarks. It is obvious, however, that there is Fianna Fáil occupation of the country at the present moment; that the clubs which are started are not playing the game between those who are in distress as against their immediate followers. I have received letters stating beyond yea or nay—they can be published if necessary—that there is no hiding the fact that very unfair discrimination is being made as regards the giving of employment under grants for minor relief schemes. The young fellows are told: "If you do not go on in and join the Fianna Fáil club you have no chance whatever of getting work under this scheme." What is the use of the Minister for Industry and Commerce issuing instructions, or pretending that he can run in a fair way the distribution of relief schemes and give fair and honest employment in the country districts if this kind of thing is allowed to run rampant? I suggest that impartial inspectors should be sent down to the country districts; that they should be allowed to see the lists showing the same old group taken on again and again. The same names will appear on the list, and the same fellows will be victimised unless they are "tough guys," big enough and strong enough to fight their way in, and hammer out any opposition that stands in their way. I have advised them on several occasions "to hell with politics." Excuse me, sir, I am sorry. I have advised them not to allow politics to stand in their way, and if necessary to return force for force. That is the position to which the country is rapidly coming. Ex-service men, and those who were in the British Army during the great war, no matter under what circumstances they joined it, are at the present moment being victimised in the County Kildare.
Comment on this
Might I draw attention to the fact that there are only four Cumann na nGaedheal Deputies present? They are deliberately absenting themselves from the House.