In Committee on Finance. - Vote 56—Industry and Commerce (Resumed).
Contributions 128–269 of 269. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
British ex-servicemen, who may have a pension of about 15/- a week, and who have large responsibilities as regards those dependent on them, are being and have been victimised.
I would like to call attention to the way this unemployment relief is being administered. There are R.I.C. pensioners who, because they throw their weight into the Fianna Fáil clubs, are now becoming leaders, and it is they decide who should be employed and who should not be employed. It is only a week or so ago since Deputy Norton referred to that in the debate on minor relief schemes. It is not in one part of South Kildare that that is going on, but in many parts of the county. The hardship that is being inflicted on decent people as a result of it is appalling, and is grossly unfair. If that is the way that Fianna Fáil are going to recruit new voters and to increase the membership of their clubs, by victimisation of that sort, then I can tell them it will recoil on their own heads later. It will be impossible, sooner or later, to hold some of those fellows to whom they are pandering now. It is quite wrong to be making this a purely political business. Some of us want to play the game and to see this employment distributed fairly, without politics being brought into it. The day will come when some of those fellows will get out of hand, and then we shall see what will happen.
That is the sort of thing that happened in parts of South Kildare last year. Unless the Minister for Agriculture and his Department carry on their work by ordinary legitimate trading means, instead of by a system of subsidies and bounties, then industry and commerce will not only be not able to mark time, but they will drift backwards. There will be no chance whatever of solving the unemployment problem, or of reducing the number by a substantial figure. The present policy of the Government is doing infinite harm to people who have regular and constant employment. Many of them, unfortunately, are losing that employment, and it is feared, because of the Government's policy, they will never be able to get regular employment again. I do not want to detain the House on this Estimate. I have no desire to sit here until 12 o'clock to-morrow night or until 6 o'clock to-morrow morning. I just wish to enter my protest against the unfair methods that are being used in connection with the relief of unemployment. In my opinion, it will be impossible ever to solve the unemployment problem in view of the manner in which the Government is pursuing its agricultural policy.
Comment on this
The Minister in introducing this Estimate took considerable pride in the fact that the staff in the Department of Industry and Commerce had been considerably increased, and instanced the amount of work that had to be done in connection with licences and permits. In my opinion, if the Government would really take a long-sighted view they would find that was a distinct disadvantage, not only to the Government but to the country as a whole. The Government are very anxious to promote industry, and I will give them credit for that. I believe they are sincerely and wholeheartedly endeavouring to promote industry here, but I am afraid there are certain fundamental errors in their industrial policy which will, in the long run, defeat the objects they have in view. I am afraid they are confusing the promotion of industry with the relief of unemployment. Now the unemployed in this country are the outward and the visible sign of the state of agriculture and industry.
I do not want on this Vote to refer to the position of agriculture or to the state of affairs which exists in that industry. I wish to confine my remarks simply and solely to industry and I am convinced that the Government in their desire to promote industry have paid too little attention to certain essential facts. I have said that they are mixing up the cure for unemployment with the promotion of industry. When you look narrowly into certain measures that the Government have introduced you find that while undoubtedly certain people have been placed in industry as a result of those and other measures other people have been displaced. That is what the Government are overlooking. It reminds one of the story that used to be told during the war about the demolition of a munition factory. It was this: that a contractor was putting up the factory, and that before he had finished it workmen were engaged at the other end taking it down. Now something like that is going on in industry at the present time. I am afraid that the Government pay absolutely no attention to the way that they are raising the cost of living and the cost of production and the difficulty of doing business in the case of other industries throughout the country. Everyone in this House would, I think; concede that when an Irish manufacturer is prepared to make a certain range of goods at something approaching the market price he should be given a measure of protection, but I am afraid that what happens at the present time is that a very much wider range of goods is protected than the local manufacturer is prepared to cater for. This results in raising the price of certain goods to the community at large. In other cases the output of the local manufacturer is so small that goods have to come in from outside to supplement his output.
I think every Deputy in this House is aware of the extraordinary anxiety the Government have in catering for people who are prepared to manufacture. But there are other features, and I would like to remind the Government that there is a very large distributing trade in this country. If that were in the hands of somebody else, the Government might find that they had paid too little attention to that portion of the economic wealth of the country. If you are going to put two people into manufacture and take three people out of the distribution, that may be a satisfactory solution from the Government's point of view of the numbers taken on, but it is producing an amount of uncertainty the effects of which are only very slowly being felt. The President, a short time ago, told us that people were not investing in Irish enterprises to the extent that they should. Apparently, they did not appreciate the investment that was offered to them; but I should like the Government to give some concrete example of what the policy was in regard to industry in order that people might prepare for it. Some manufacturers, who have no distributing facilities, have found that an impost on goods is a protection to them, and they are the only people who can import the goods that they are about to manufacture, presumably with the idea of establishing their place in the market. I should like to remind the Government, however, that there are distributors, who have a very extensive organisation and give very extensive employment, and who have found that they are cut off from the importation of goods and are left high and dry with a large portion of their supplies cut off from them. The Government may argue that manufacture is the most important thing in this country, and that distributors really are not wanted. I suggest to the Government that a survey of the taxes or duties that they have put on would reveal that some of those duties are very useful. They are giving a manufacturer the protection he needed and employment has been given, and industry is being carried on. They would find in other cases, however, that the duties they have put on have really only increased the cost to the consumer, and have not really benefited anybody. In other instances they would find that not only has that taken place, but that a very considerable distributing unit has been left in a state of uncertainty as to what their future is. Nobody will deny that there must be a certain amount of dislocation, but I feel sure that if the Government could review a number of the duties, duty by duty, they would find that they have needlessly placed duties on certain things that are not giving any measure of employment in industry, and that in other cases it has merely raised difficulties which have got to be got over by reason of numerous licences and permits.
I suggest to the Government that, in a time like this, when it is very difficult for people to know what their future is and how far they are to be permitted to carry on their business, the Government ought to show that they are not prepared to displace anybody who is carrying on business or industry in this country unless it is for the interest of the country as a whole that some change should be made. I feel sure that the Government have entirely under-estimated the effect on the industrial community of the present uncertainty which has been brought about, firstly, by a number of taxes which did not produce any good effect and, secondly, by a want of a policy by the Government which proceeded clearly and logically along certain lines. I do not wish to upset the Government's idea if they think that every single thing that is brought into this country can be manufactured here, but certainly I should like to assure them that the change over can only be accomplished by a slow and gradual growth of experience and confidence and by taking into counsel those who are employed in industry and carrying on the distributing industries as well as the manufacturing industries of this country. There are certain frightful anomalies in the Government's policy to which I will refer under another Vote, but it seems to me as if the Government have not paid sufficient attention to the cost to the community in trying to promote industry and commerce.
Comment on this
Is nobody going to speak on the Government side on the Vote on Industry and Commerce? Well, I shall go on. This is the Vote which gives a Minister for Industry and Commerce, who is knowledgeable about his post, or even a substitute who is acting for the Minister, an opportunity to reveal what his policy has done for industry and commerce in the country during the 12 months that have gone. It would be appropriate for the Minister under these circumstances to give the House some details, if any details are available, of the increased productivity in the country as well as the increase in the wealth that we are told is so marked around the country towns as well as in Dublin; and to give us a better indication than we have got up-to-date as to where the extra establishments are located, what are the wages paid in them, the hours worked, the proprietors who control them, and the capital, whether it is national or otherwise, which has been involved in them. That would be appropriate any time, but it would be particularly appropriate on this occasion when, for the first time, the Minister who announced his policy as a revolutionary one in industry can say that he had a fairly clear year in which to make good, and it would be still more appropriate to have such a clarifying statement from the Minister when that Minister, previously challenged with regard to his policy, said that he was prepared to take a certain challenge that had been flung out, "a challenge that had been put that in eight months' time we shall find out whether our policy has been a success or not. I am prepared to accept that; I am prepared to back that policy." He talked then about the signs of improvement that he was going to put before the people's eyes in eight months' time, and the eight months date from 12th May, 1932. Here is an opportunity in which not merely have the eight months elapsed, but that extra period which would necessarily be agreed upon to enable the Minister to measure up the full fruits of the success of the eight months and to present them here in a lucid and persuasive way, so that doubts that are at the moment in existence as regards the new policy might be all swept away. The opportunity has not been taken. There has been nothing indicated by the Minister with regard to progress of the policy.
From time to time questions have been asked in this House about single industries, taking mainly the form of asking the Minister for Industry and Commerce to state how many new factories have been established in——, and then the name of the industry occurs, to state where these factories are, to state how many new hands are employed, the wages that they get, and the hours they work, so that we could form an impression of the increased wealth produced in the country and how it is being distributed. There have been a variety of excuses in answer to these questions. We were told at one time that it was not considered desirable to give figures. We were told a little later that the staff was so busily engaged in promoting new industries that they could not stop to count those already established, although they must have records of them in the Department. We were told later on that it was better to present the matter in a comprehensive way and that a booklet dealing with Irish trade and industry was being prepared. When that line was followed up later and questions were put as to when the booklet would make its appearance, we were confronted again with the usual evasions, until at last the Minister was asked had he sent out the type of a questionnaire which was necessary to collect the information about trade and industries. We then found that this sheet of questions had not been yet sent to the industrialists of the country. I do not know if it has yet been sent. I certainly take it that no return has been made to it. I suppose I should not go so far as that, but I take it that, if a return has been made, then it was so disappointing that it cannot be produced.
In those circumstances, we have to examine the Minister's attitude towards trade and industry in the country and his many flamboyant phrases as to the great progress made, the new ground that has been opened, the new sources of wealth that have been tapped. From one detailed indication we can see pretty clearly what reliance is to be placed on the Minister's statement. After persistent inquiry, Deputy Mulcahy recently got a return made to him covering a certain number of industries about which no excuse could be presented to the House for failure to give the return. That was a group of industries on which tariffs had been imposed in 1924, 1925 and 1926, and in relation to which returns had been collected and presented half-yearly to the House. Recently Deputy Mulcahy did get an indication from these figures of the new employment in the industries mentioned, and from these we can get some criterion by which to judge the Minister for Industry and Commerce and some of his great phrases. Speaking in the House on 11th May, 1933, as reported in volume 47, No. 3, column 911 of the Official Reports, the Minister for Industry and Commerce said of the apparel industry that it covers a range of different forms of production and has also progressed much more rapidly even than was contemplated. I am going to refer to the advertisements which gave detailed figures which show the Minister's contemplation. On 11th May, 1933, he stated here that the progress in the apparel industry had been greater even than he contemplated. Then he continued:—
"Deputies who read the newspapers these days will find them full of advertisements for skilled workers in that trade. Every skilled worker in the country has been employed. Increased production has been held up by the fact that additional skilled workers are not available, and the people concerned in that industry are writing to my Department asking for sanction to bring in skilled workers from abroad."
That is a most satisfying statement to anyone who believes in it. The apparel industry has progressed far greater than was ever contemplated. Advertisements were appearing in the newspapers asking for skilled workers in that trade. That was the Minister's own statement, and he has the records of the skilled workers and knows where they are employed and how many are idle. He said every skilled worker in the country had been employed—I am assuming in that trade. Increased production had been held up, because there were not sufficient skilled workers in the country to deal with the increased production. Application had been made to him by manufacturers for leave to bring in people from abroad.
Then lately we got another jolt back to the truth. The number of people employed in the wholesale side of the clothing end has gone down between September, 1931, and March, 1933, by nearly 500 workers. That is according to official statistics. There is something wrong somewhere. If the Minister's own statistical department says that there were 500 people less employed in March, 1933, than there were in September, 1931, the Minister needs to do something more than merely assert that there are no skilled workers in the country without employment in the apparel trade; that there are advertisements appearing daily, with the implication that the advertisements are not being answered, for skilled workers; that production has been held up because there are not sufficient skilled workers in the country and that employers have asked leave to bring in skilled workers from outside. Either of these two statements is untrue. Which is it? Both have been given here officially as from the Department of Industry and Commerce; one by the Minister, speaking in the House, and the other in answer to a question to the Acting-Minister the other day.
We have heard that type of statement from the Minister for Industry and Commerce before. In that debate on 11th May, 1933, it was stated that there was not an industry that had not done better than was contemplated. There was hardly an industry in which production had not at least doubled. There was not one that had gone back. There was not a hint or a breath of suspicion that the detailed figures would reveal that there was less employment round about the period of two months earlier than the month in which he was speaking, than there was two years ago.
I take one other phrase to get it reduced to its true proportions. Speaking in the same debate on the 11th May—the quotation is this time from Column 910, Vol. 47, No. 3 of the Official Debates—the Minister said:—
"Take the confectionery industry. Employment in it has been doubled. The output has been more than doubled and it is still increasing. Progress has not yet stopped in that industry. One new factory of considerable magnitude is being built and there are more to come."
The meanest and the dullest intellect can understand that—"employment in it has been doubled, the output has been more than doubled and it is still increasing." Then we get the detailed figures. Employment as between September, 1931, and March, 1933, went up from 5,096 to 5,247. That is 151 people extra employed in confectionery appears to the present Minister for Industry and Commerce, when he is in one of his high spots of oratory, as double 5,000 people. These are two statements I have taken from the Reports and I have set them against the increases as they were given in the detailed figures. I think that, on reading this, the Minister for Industry and Commerce, when he returns, will have some cause of complaint against his acting colleague for having given away these figures. His policy of not saying anything was far better. It sounds far better for an election poster to say: "Look at the confectionery industry; employment doubled; output more than doubled and still increasing." It brings people with a terrific bash back to earth when, after reading that, they suddenly find that employment instead of having gone from 5,096 to something over 10,000 has merely gone to 5,247. I presume for the future we can adopt in relation to the Minister's speeches that ratio, that his speeches have the same relation to fact as 5,247 has to 10,000. We should certainly get back to the old humorous calculation of taking a number, doubling it, and then subtracting a whole lot from it, if we are going to arrive at the truth of the statements of the Minister for Industry and Commerce.
I gather that to-day reference has been made to one really discovered factory. I pride myself on having discovered this even earlier than the Minister for Industry and Commerce because some time earlier this year I found that a number of people in a certain district in the country were having a competition in which they got points for every new factory they discovered and lost points for every industry that had been destroyed. The funny thing about it was that all the people engaged in the competition lost because when they had totted up they had all minus points. They had discovered more destruction than they had new factories, but they did discover one factory which has been referred to here to-day, a factory opened under the auspices of the Minister for Industry and Commerce at Naas and under the special aegis of Deputy Briscoe—the same Deputy Briscoe who, the President said, had done more than any other person in the community to relieve unemployment.
Comment on this
Yes, a bet of a few sausages from the Naas factory if we can get them. I read more about this factory than I have read in the Irish Press. A paper called Irish Industry published what, I suppose, American phraseology would best describe as a “blurb” of this factory, that they were going to produce 300 different types of delicatessen. It is not called sausage. The names of the directors were given but they were not given accurately in the Irish Press. It says or indicates that amongst the directors were a man called Caplan and two men of the name of Witstun. That name, by the way, according to Irish Industry, is not Witstun but Whizton and Caplan is not Caplan but Caplal. Then there was Deputy Briscoe. According to this paper, there were to be 400 different types of delicatessen produced in this factory. I have taken 300 as the number in memory of the number of factories supposed to be established in this country and I have asked on a number of occasions in restaurants for the 300th type of the Caplal—Whizton-Whizton Briscoe delicatessen made in Ireland. The waitress had nearly always gone before I had completed my order but I did succeed on some occasions in retaining her attention. However, I have not yet been successful in getting the 300th type of delicatessen from the Naas factory.
Comment on this
I do not think so. I have searched through Naas and I have not yet succeeded in getting an ordinary native sausage, let alone the delicatessen. Let me read what the Minister said about the factory on the occasion of its opening. It was described as "the Viennese sausage factory". There has always to be a touch of musical comedy associated with these new factories. It was on this occasion "the Viennese sausage factory". The report says:
"The Viennese sausage factory which has been established in a portion of the old Military Barracks, at Naas, County Kildare, was formally opened to-day by Mr. Seán Lemass, Minister for Industry and Commerce. The most modern Continental machinery has been installed in the new factory and the sausages and meat products are manufactured under the most hygienic conditions."
There was a little bit of a forecast. Very little has been manufactured there since. Then it talks about the features of the plant, the grand abattoir and the great refrigerating rooms where meat can be kept fresh for long periods. I am afraid that most of it has not emerged from the refrigerating plant since it was produced.
The report further states that the factory is capable of producing ten tons of sausages and food products every week, that if necessary an additional machine can be installed, the output increased to 20 tons, and that upwards of 50 different varieties of sausages will be manufactured. Irish Industry is far better than the Irish Press in that respect. They increased the figure to 400 different types of delicatessen in this “bawneen” country. We are going to have something further. “It is hoped to open up an export trade with France, Germany, Switzerland and Belgium.” The Minister for Agriculture could not do much better than that in relation to providing alternative markets. For this famous sausage, made at Naas, Co. Kildare, we are going to have an export business with France, Germany, Switzerland and Belgium. That is only part of the blessings of this great factory. The company will also consider, in the near future, the possibility of starting a new subsidiary industry. What is it? Tanning, if you please.
I do not know whether they wanted the skins to be recoverable or what the idea was, but a tanning industry was going to be associated with the new Viennese Sausage Factory down at Naas. The Minister for Industry and Commerce gave it his blessing—if that is not an inappropriate word to use in relation to delicatessen.
Comment on this
No; a requiem, I think, would be more appropriate than a blessing. The Minister said:—
"It gave him great pleasure to perform the opening ceremony, firstly, because of the enterprise of those who had started and supported the project; secondly, because it would help to relieve unemployment in the town of Naas, and thirdly, because his friend and colleague, Mr. Briscoe, was associated with it. The type of industry which has been established was in some respects a new one——"
I do not know why,
"——and the proper art of sausage making was being introduced here for the first time."
The occasion was when the Minister for Industry and Commerce visited Naas, sometime in February of this year. Then the report goes on:—
"The industry was necessarily a small one, and should not be compared with the gigantic industries in other countries, but all big things have small beginnings. Those responsible for the management of the factory had taken advantage of the most highly skilled technical advice that was available to them."
Then we had Franz Vogel and A. Caplal, and M. Witstun——
Comment on this
I suggest to the Deputy that the personnel of the directorate of a company scarcely arises on the Estimate for the Department of Industry and Commerce. The personnel of the directorate should not be debated.
Comment on this
I might have been hired to keep the factory alive, because it has gone west since. I intend to do nothing more than to mention the names of the directors and to indicate, as it should be indicated, to this House that if people are buying sausage products it can hardly be said that the money recovered from the customer goes to the nationals of this country. It is part of the programme of the Minister for Industry and Commerce that in the case of factories that are established except under licence capital should be controlled, in the main, by Irish nationals. Here you have names as examples of Irish nationals: Franz Vogel, Caplal, and Witstun.
Comment on this
I submit that these names are material. I will just finish this extract:
"The Minister and the guests sampled several of the different varieties of sausages."
Where is that factory now? Is there a Deputy here who can say that he knows where it is now? Has that factory been working since? Does any Deputy know where it is?
Comment on this
How many men does it employ? We had a promise of 200 people to be employed there. Are there five people employed there at the moment? The Deputy said it was open still. Does he know anything more about it than that there are notices posted on the walls stating that it is shut? Is the factory really open from the trade point of view? Is it doing business? How does the Deputy derive his information?
Comment on this
It has got more or less chronically into that state. There is the sort of thing this paper was publishing with regard to Irish industry. It is aligned with what the Minister was saying as to the total number of factories in this country and what he was telling us with regard to the apparel factories in the country, that the industry was being held up because there were not enough skilled workers available, and that people were applying to him for permits to bring in outside workers. All this at a time when employment in these factories had actually decreased by 500! We have got to find out where the truth lies.
Comment on this
What the Minister for Industry and Commerce said was the truth. Persons in charge of factories came to the Minister and said they could not get skilled workers here. The Minister told the House what he had been told by people in charge of the factories. The Minister told the truth.
Comment on this
That is the excuse! We have often put that to the Minister and we have often said to him "people who are looking for a tariff will say almost anything to you if you are foolish enough to believe them." The Acting-Minister is arguing himself a simpleton, but the Minister did not say what the Acting-Minister says he did. What is the preamble here? That "every skilled worker in the country has been employed."
Comment on this
What the Minister said was that the manufacturers told him that every skilled worker in the country had been employed.
Comment on this
He did not say that. He said that the apparel industry, which is covering a very wide range, has progressed, and then he added that every skilled worker is employed, and yet when he was saying that there was actually a decrease of 500 workers.
Comment on this
The fact was that the factory was not able to get skilled workers and skilled workers had to be brought in.
Comment on this
There were at one time 3,858 people employed and in March, 1933, that number had been reduced to 3,360 or a decrease of nearly 500.
Comment on this
The Minister has given the figures himself. Let him read those figures. He has them in front of him.
Comment on this
I will make my speech and the Minister can answer it. He has been strangely silent all along. Let him give us the figures. I will have a chance of going after his figures.
Comment on this
Will the Minister prove me wrong? Nothing would more delight a great many people on his side of the House than to see the Minister proving me to be in the wrong.
Comment on this
These are your usual tactics, and it is not the first time you threw a slur on people who wanted to invest money in Irish industries.
Comment on this
On a point of order, I want to point out that these remarks should be addressed to the Chair, and no Deputy should be addressed in that form—"you."
Comment on this
It is a good topic, it is a great topic. If I were going out to make a cross-road speech I could rant as well as the best that Deputy Kelly could do about his lack of interest in the people looking to get employment in the Naas factory and who have not got it. I could talk about his alleged inhumanity and indifference in regard to other workers in the country. That was all being done by the Deputy in the same circumstances. I am taking a concrete case. I have said about the Minister for Industry and Commerce that he has the faculty that is supposed only to be possessed by gases that have been able to expand and fill in a given space. He has expanded over one and a half times to fill the vacuum in the factories. I have given one or two concrete cases about the confectionery business, the apparel business and this single delicatessen factory. If there had not been collapse in that factory you would have the Minister standing up and telling us that the factory had an export trade. It is very easy to get away from the phrase "it is hoped to open up an export trade with France, Germany, Switzerland and Belgium." The Minister very easily crosses the border line between his hopes and his statement of facts. He would have said "things have gone much better than I hoped." It was hoped to establish a trade with France, Germany, Switzerland and Belgium, and then he would have gone on to say that they were opening up a trade with the Argentine.
That is a very simple statement for the Minister to make. It would be all right if somebody had not gone into his Department while he was away and given out the detailed figures and facts which go to expose him. Then there was the transition and the hope of establishing a subsidiary industry and using tanning, a most improper one, I think everyone will agree, in relation to the Naas factory. There were markets, at any rate, indicated there. There were special markets, but I do not know why these countries were chosen. It is a fact that we have for a long time been talking about the development of foreign trade.
I notice there was a meeting of an association last night which got down to bedrock as to where our exports should go. They decided upon Spain as the spot, and they have been very anxious to get to work in providing new markets. They appointed a subcommittee to get down to bedrock. No doubt their efforts will be crowned with the same success that the Minister for Industry and Commerce and the Minister for Agriculture have found in their search for markets. They may be able to get the delicatessen sausage factory of Messrs. Caplal, Whizton Whizton and Briscoe—the produce of that completely Irish national industry transported to Spain and later on we may make our name in this new product.
Comment on this
That may be, and that may be the thing the Minister may find himself up against about a variety of products. I am not sure whether Deputy Moore is a member of the particular society that met last night and was getting down to bedrock. He has as much right to be a member as many of those who were present. The body I am alluding to is known as the United Farmers' Protection Association, not the body under the leadership of Deputy MacDermot. The Chairman of the body that met last night is a member of the Bar, a senior counsel, who deals with land and things relating to land in the garden at the back of his house on Raglan Road.
Comment on this
I suggest that the Deputy is quite out of order in referring to the activities of this association upon this Vote. It has nothing whatever to do with Industry and Commerce.
Comment on this
The Minister is right in his contention that the activities of the association referred to by Deputy McGilligan are not in order upon this Vote.
Comment on this
Possibly; they were a bit dull last night. I would like to conform to anything that the Minister acting for the Minister for Industry and Commerce desires but there seems to be nothing that I can speak on that will not put him into a bit of a temper.
Comment on this
I dislike the Deputy's personal references. I think they are contemptible and I have always thought so.
Comment on this
Your experience need not change. We both know where we are now. The Minister for Education who is acting as substitute for the Minister for Industry and Commerce promised more than I have read out. I am not sure whether it was a promise but I used to read it as such. He promised that a number of additional workers were to be employed.
Comment on this
I wonder when was that, but apparently there is another angry Deputy in the House. He promised that there were to be a number of additional workers to be employed. I do not know what meaning to put on that phrase "to be" since we had the debate on the Oath Bill. To the ordinary man it means that there were to be a number of men employed when the Fianna Fáil Government came into power in new industrial concerns. If the Minister is questioned about any of these I am sure he will answer. The additional workers to be employed in the boot and shoe trade for example were 5,801. Can the Minister answer as to whether that number have been so employed, or as to whether he is under any obligation to them? Can we start by being sure that one additional has got employment? Have the 800 got employment? Let us leave out the 5,000 as a bit of exaggeration in the heat of a general election. What about the 801? Have we had that number additional employed in the boot and shoe industry? If the Minister for Education representing the Minister for Industry and Commerce will not answer I say we have nothing to go on with regard to the Minister's figures.
Comment on this
Can you prove that the 801 additional have not been employed?
Comment on this
The Minister said so in reply to a Parliamentary question. Apparently the Deputy does not believe his own Minister. Sometimes I do not either. I do not regard anything the Minister says as proof. It is of course the best he can do. He gives figures and if they do not prove that 801 people additional are employed he cannot help it.
Comment on this
They were not weeded out of employment at any rate as you weeded them out.
Comment on this
This is in relation to new employment. There was an additional number of 658 people who were to find employment in bacon curing. When the Minister was asked to answer about them he was lucky enough to preserve a discreet silence. In woollens and worsteds we find that 6,983 were to find additional employment. Again let us drop the thousands and come to the 893 extra people who were to be employed. Does the Minister know whether they were or not? Has he any figure? Then we come to grain milling. This was a very good business for no fewer than 14,069 additional were to be employed. Have we got them? What advance have we made towards getting them? This is an occasion in which the Minister should be anxious to show his form in carrying out these promises. Surely we ought to be able to get something more than a smile with regard to over 14,000 people in this country promised employment in the grain milling industry. Then we come to cloth, subdivided into linens, cotton, hemp, jute and canvas. 10,501 were to be engaged. Have we had 501 engaged leaving out the 10,000? Then there are confectionery, chocolates, jams and marmalades, 1,620 persons additional were to be employed. That is a small lot. The Minister told us on the 11th May that the number of people employed in these industries in Dublin had doubled. When we got the actual figures we found that they had gone up from 5,096 to 5,247. That is what the Minister calls doubling. Multiply 5,096 by 2 and you get 5,247! "Fertilisers, chemicals, drugs and paints, 2,046"—any offer as to what we have got? Can the Minister state a figure at all? I remember when the debate was here in progress on one item of these, fertilisers, as such, we were not promised a single man in employment but we were told that if we did not do certain things 1,000 were going to lose employment. We had got off the perch of the new employment by that time and there was only a saving of people in employment. "Paper and stationery" were going to give us 4,653 additional employed people in the country and when we asked about that we got silence. We did not get any indication of what the new employment is. There are a whole lot of others.
Comment on this
Grain milling, I suppose that would be. 14,000—the Deputy has not been listening—how many extra has the Deputy got in his own constituency?
Comment on this
If you can break the price of the native combine's increase, it would be a good thing. I doubt if there are 100 people extra employed arising out of everything Fianna Fáil has done as a Government in relation to grain or flour. I do not believe that there are 100 extra people in employment——
Comment on this
That is not all right. That is the type of economics that we are being served up with. We are paying 5/- per sack of flour more.
Comment on this
Certainly; you cannot call 5/- per sack of an extra whack on flour dumping by any means.
Comment on this
The people who have not got so many 5/- might find it a little more difficult than they used to to get flour and to get bread, and to go talking to them about the stoppage of dumping will not get the Deputy many votes.
Comment on this
There was a figure of 14,000 promised in the way of extra employment. Surely, here is an occasion for the Minister in charge of the whole thing to tell us what is being done. We have only had a prospect—a rosy prospect, of course, but only a prospect. Cannot we be told the facts now on this Vote for Industry and Commerce? We have a variety of others. There were 1,339 people to be employed in relation to printed matter; 4,000 in manufactures of wood; 5,098 in the manufacture of metal; 2,205 in the manufacture of implements; 2,726 in the manufacture of vehicles and parts; 3,496 in the manufacture of bricks, cement, masonry and earthenware, and then the really good one kept in reserve for the last—11,902 this time—in mine and quarry products, not metals. The Minister has a special mining department with a special economic geologist put before us on the Estimate, and I want to be told if we have got the 902 people, let alone the 11,000 people.
Comment on this
The Minister does not remember the boast of the real Minister for Industry and Commerce: "Give us eight months' time." That was from 12th May, 1932. Has he got the eight months? "Give us eight months and we will prove that policy" and that was the policy. I do not ask to have this terrific rush of 11,902 people in the mining and quarry products industry. Tell us if we have got 100 extra people. Give us some indication of where we can find 50 extra people employed in this industry.
Comment on this
"Not metals" does not include sausages. Let me get back to the sausage factory. Who are at present employed in the Naas factory besides the directors? Could we have it said that Franz Vogel is still here and, if he is, is he manufacturing sausages? Let us be told, at the height of their fame, to what point all these 400 types of delicatessen have arrived. Did they get to 500 types and why did they fall off?
Comment on this
It had so much to do that the Minister who is in charge of it went down to open that factory and to listen to all this about the export trade we were going to get with France, Germany, Switzerland and Belgium and about the subsidiary industry of tanning which was to be established in connection with the sausages. That is an important factor. The man who had so much to do since I left took the day off to go down to this place and it is one of the onerous obligations of his office that he had to sample some of the different varieties. What happened?
Comment on this
A suggestion which the Deputy is needlessly repeating and taking up the time of the House.
Comment on this
The Minister reminded me that the Minister whom he is substituting is an exceptionally busy man and I had to refer to this.
Comment on this
I did not say that he was. I said the Department has no time to prepare statistics for the Deputy.
Comment on this
I hope there is no implication against the Minister. I had joined the Minister in with the Department and he is busy starting factories here, there and everywhere. This is one of them. I have spoken really to three items only to-day and the Minister for Education should not really be so easily aggravated. I have taken only three examples and I have put in contrast performance and promise, and something more than a burst of anger is required as a reply. There must be some explanation and the Minister must be capable of giving it or else the Executive Council must be capable of getting somebody who is capable of giving it. Let him take the three things I have spoken of. I just mention the Naas factory. What has happened there; how much money is there; what is being done there; what directors are in it; and what money is in it? It is easy to answer all this with regard to one factory and he can add the details, all the little bits of trimmings, in the way of what export trade we have in these things and what progress we have made towards the subsidiary industry. If he does not want to deal with that factory at all—all this talk about it is probably somewhat nauseating to him—let him turn to the sugar confectionery business. Can he explain what the Minister meant when he said that employment would be doubled and, then, figures are produced which show that it has increased by 151 hands, on a tot of 5,096, making it 5,247.
Can he tell us what the Minister meant when he said that skilled workers could not be got in the apparel business; that production was held up for want of skilled workers? How does he compare that with the note which shows that there are 490 less employed between September, 1931, and March? If we could get an answer to these three questions we could have an instructive debate on industry and commerce in this country.
Comment on this
Not with the lesson to be learned that the Deputy wants to learn. The Deputy would like and we would all like to have rosy factories mounting up; that these promises were coming somewhere near fulfilment.
Comment on this
And Cuibranovitch, who is probably a director of the Naas sausage factory. I do not see why a Montenegrin general should not be as good a sausage maker as Franz Vogel and the two Witstuns.
Comment on this
Marino would draw ahead of them all. He is a very enterprising man. Your colleague knows all about it.
Comment on this
There are two or three items in the Vote which would require explanation. Sub-head K makes provision for the cost of exhibiting at the Paris fair including the rent and the hire of show-cases. May we be told what exhibits were sent, or what it is proposed to send there? Who are exhibiting? How much of the £450 set down is for rent as opposed to the hire of certain show-cases?
Comment on this
I asked already whom the exhibits were in charge of. Was it a member of the Civil Service here, or someone specially hired for the occasion?
Comment on this
The Minister does not know what has been done for the £450 voted for the Paris Fair?
Comment on this
Except that the Commercial Attaché in Paris made arrangements to have an individual to look after the stall. I do not know the name of the individual. I take it that the Commercial Attaché takes responsibility in that matter.
Comment on this
The Minister knows that someone was hired by the Commercial Attaché, as he calls him, in Paris. Does he tell me that he has not the name on the files?
Comment on this
I am speaking of an individual who left this country and who was specially selected. It appears now that the Commercial Attaché in Paris was looking after the matter.
Comment on this
It is true that the House is in Committee, but no progress would be made if the discussion were to degenerate into question and answer across the House.
Comment on this
The Minister need not answer now. I would rather if he delayed and got the information, instead of saying that he has not got it on the files. It is inconceivable to me that the Department would have allowed the Commercial Attaché in Paris to appoint someone from this country to take charge of this exhibit. I can imagine appointing a person where he was to be engaged on the spot, but if the Minister agrees that someone was sent out from this country, it is incredible to me that the Minister did not say: "I want the name of that person and what he was paid." I presume the Minister in the apportionment of the expenses can give what was paid. When he is replying, I want to get that information.
Comment on this
I put it that it should be disclosed, and that the Minister should take steps before he replies to get further information, because it is certainly in the possession of his Department. On sub-head I— The Chicago World Fair, 1933—there is provision for the cost of an exhibition of Saorstát industries. The total cost, including rent of space, is £5,000 of which £300 was provided previously. Therefore, we are now voting £4,700 rent of space and incidental expenses, while the phrase used is "total cost." I take it, therefore, that there is something beyond rent of space and what are described as incidental expenses. I would like to know what these are. Are we giving any help to exhibitors and, if so, to what exhibits? Are we giving the same help to all who apply or is there any process of selection? If there is a process of selection, how is it carried out? Have any exhibits been refused, and on what grounds? Can we get, generally, some indication of the exhibits it is proposed to have at the Chicago Fair?
Under the heading of "Appropriations-in-Aid," I would like to know if we could have the contributions and fees payable under the Gas Regulation Act, and under the Weights and Measures Acts, and why there has been a drop in the amount for the coming year. In 1932-33 they amounted to £1,840, and this year to £1,600. Does that mean that there has been any relaxation of activities on the part of those in charge of the Weights and Measures Acts or in relation to those responsible for looking after the Gas Regulation Act? At any rate, there is a drop indicated, and it is good to have an explanation why that drop is estimated.
Comment on this
The practice for ten years, with one exception, has been, and I would like to emphasise that fact, that when the Minister is called upon to conclude he does so. Technically Deputies have a right to ask a question subsequently, but I wish the House to realise that it is a deliberate departure from precedent to resume the discussion when the Minister has so spoken.
Comment on this
May I respectfully agree but when the Minister is called upon to conclude it is not the practice that the Minister makes the first speech at the conclusion. The Minister has not interfered in the debate. Questions have been put, and it has been the practice that the Minister speaks at least three times on an Estimate.
Comment on this
I should like to call the attention of the Chair to the fact that I was standing when the Minister was called upon to conclude.
Comment on this
A great many things have been alluded to on this Vote, with some of which I would like to deal. First of all, Deputy McGilligan was very vocal—I am glad he is runing out—about the number of people who are employed now and the number employed 12 months ago. In my constituency, on the day that Deputy McGilligan gave over pretending to represent industry and commerce, we had 170 men employed in the flour industry. Two flour mills were ordered to be closed down and the foreign firm that was brought in to take over the mills under the Cumann na nGaedheal regime had the agents measuring the plant and machinery for removal. These two flour mills have increased the number of their employees by 37 and are now working overtime, whereas the former workers were only employed half-time. A flour mill closed down during the regime of the Minister, who did not represent industry and commerce, has also been re-opened. The flour mill at Clondullane, which has been re-opened, is giving permanent employment to over 60 hands. The Mitchelstown factory, now in full working order, has 70 hands in employment more than the number employed 12 months ago. Glanmire waterproofs factory closed down owing to the penal preference given to British manufactures in this country by the ex-Minister for Industry and Commerce. That factory has now been re-opened and is giving employment to 130 men. The woollen mills at Glanmire have 30 extra hands employed and are working overtime. These mills were not working full time at any period during the three years before Cumann na nGaedheal left office. The new shovel mills at Templemichael are giving employment to over 30 hands. The increased number of persons in permanent employment in my constituency within the last 12 months is 260, besides 140 who were employed in the flour mills and who have been kept in employment owing to the kicking out of office of the ex-Minister for Industry and Commerce.
The mineral wealth in my constituency has also been developed. About 140 men were employed for five months in development work. As a result, applications have now been handed to the Trade Loans Department for plant and machinery which will give permanent employment to 60 men in one mine alone. The celluloid factory, in respect of which a trade loan has also been applied for, will give employment to 150 hands. Those are particulars of one constituency alone, and I think they furnish a complete answer to the activities of our ex-Minister for Industry and Commerce, who was so vocal for the last hour. Deputy Coburn wants to import bricks across the border from the northern Orangemen, to whom we have to pay 40 per cent. on our cattle going out. Does Deputy Coburn consider that it is a contribution to the relief of unemployment in this State to bring bricks made by northern Orangemen across the border?
Comment on this
Deputy Bennett was very vocal on the mixture scheme of the Minister for Agriculture. He told us about the hardships feeders of stock were enduring on account of not having a suitable mixture. Apparently, bullocks in Limerick if fed on Irish grain die of starvation. Deputy Bennett wants to have it both ways. He wants to get the benefit of an increase of 100 per cent. on the value his milk would have under the Cumann na nGaedheal regime and he wants to allow no benefit whatever to the other class of farmer who ploughs his land and produces his grain. He is to have no market but Deputy Bennett is to have the market guaranteed by Fianna Fáil and which he had the pluck to vote for against his own Party. That secured him an increase of 100 per cent. in the price of the milk he produces. Deputy Bennett wants to keep that benefit, conferred on him by Fianna Fáil, but he does not want a market opened for the grain farmer who ploughs his land and employs the men that Deputy Bennett lets go to the County Home from the 1st November to the 1st March. These men are to remain idle but Deputy Bennett is to have the benefit of foreign maize to feed Irish stock.
I did not intend to interfere in this debate until I heard Deputy McGilligan's speech lasting an hour. That gentleman spoke about the amount of unemployment under a Fianna Fáil Government but I know the condition of my constituency under the penal regime of the Minister who did not represent industry and commerce, whose whole policy was to get in the foreigner's stuff. "Show the people the flour coming in from Manchester and Liverpool while their own flour mills are closed and they are walking the streets." That was the policy of Deputy McGilligan. That was bad enough but one would think that, when turned out of office, Deputy McGilligan would have the decency to shut his mouth here. He knows very well that the arguments he put up can be refuted. We are sick hearing these tunes. We have a little waterproof factory in Glanmire in which the largest number employed during Deputy McGilligan's term of office was 20. Deputy McGilligan brought in a tariff to aid Irish industry, whereby 20 per cent. was placed on foreign waterproofs and 25 per cent. on the material for making them, with 5 per cent. preference for British products. That was Deputy McGilligan's cure for unemployment in that case. The contract for the waterproofs for the Gárda Síochána and the oilskins for the postmen was handed over to the Victoria Rubber Company, of Manchester, for the sake of the difference of 9d. a suit. That is the difference at which Irishmen could make them with a 5 per cent. allowance against them and what they were being made for across the water. The money subscribed by the Irish taxpayer was handed over to the Victoria Rubber Company, of Manchester, by Deputy McGilligan. That is the kind of employment that Deputy McGilligan provides. The factory in my constituency which I have referred to was closed down for four months before Fianna Fáil came into office in consequence of losing this contract. That factory is now giving decent employment and a living wage to 130 hands. We did not hear a word of that from Deputy McGilligan. We did not hear anything about the Clondullane flour mills, which were closed down. When asked questions about them here by the late Deputy Daly, on his own benches, Deputy McGilligan said that it was a completely uneconomic proposition to have flour mills so far away from a port. These people do not find it an uneconomic proposition to employ 50 hands. But it was an uneconomic proposition under Deputy McGilligan's rule. We had many uneconomic propositions under his rule, when a message was sent across: "There are special reasons why you should subscribe to Cumann na nGaedheal funds." I knew very well I would get Deputy McGilligan on the run. We saw the actions of Deputy McGilligan's Party in our constituency for four or five years. We can, therefore, speak from experience of what happened under the benevolent rule of of Cumann na nGaedheal in our constituency. You cannot have it both ways. You cannot have special reasons why flour millers across the water should subscribe to Cumann na nGaedheal funds and at the same time have your mills working here.
Comment on this
I listened to Deputy McGilligan and I must confess I could not understand what he was talking about. I wonder where he got his information from. I have not got any from the Department of Industry and Commerce. I have only got information on what I have actually seen. I know something about the position in County Meath, which is not an industrial county at all, and is not supposed to be. We have there an extremely prosperous fruit-growing industry. We are now able to supply 25 per cent. of the raspberries used in the country. Within the next two years —we have the assurance that the canes are already planted—we expect to be able to supply the full requirements of the country. Three years ago I found that industry in County Meath absolutely decaying. I visited the Minister for Industry and Commerce and the Minister for Agriculture. They barely knew what a raspberry was. That is so far as the agricultural side of the question is concerned.
As regards the other side of the question, I know Balbriggan fairly well. It is the neighbouring town to mine. I am perfectly satisfied that in the hosiery industry they are working full time. Sunday is the only day the factory is idle. Deputy Coburn told us something about Drogheda. I am informed three or four factories there, including an iron foundry, are working full time. In Navan there is a well-known woollen mill. Since the Saorstát was established I do not think that mill ever worked for more than six months in any year. To-day, I am glad to say, it is on full time. In Kells we have a boot factory. It was started five or six weeks ago.
Comment on this
I will return it if I get the opportunity. There are 60 people employed in that factory, and I am assured by the manager that within a year there will be over 100 people employed. That industry is in Kells, and I suppose since the Book of Kells was written it never had an industry working so well until the present time. I do not understand what Deputy McGilligan is driving at. I know he is a really good talker, but good talkers do not always have a great deal upstairs. Really I was afraid the man had become unbalanced. I am talking from my experience of conditions in the country; I know nothing about the figures. I thought it was only right to his fellow Deputies that they would have definite information.
Comment on this
As regards the number of factories, I have looked out for them——
Comment on this
Question—"That the Question be now put"—put.
Do you agree with this result?
Vote put.
Do you agree with this result?