In Committee on Finance. - Vote 3—Department of the President of the Executive Council.
Contributions 1–157 of 311. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
I move:
Go ndeontar suim ná raghaidh thar £7,010 chun slánuithe na suime is gá chun íoctha an Mhuirir a thiocfaidh chun bheith iníoctha i rith na bliana dar críoch an 31adh lá de Mhárta, 1934, chun Tuarastail agus Costaisí Roinn Uachtarán na hArd-Comhairle.
That a sum not exceeding £7,010 be granted to complete the sum necessary to defray the Charge which will come in course of payment during the year ending on the 31st day of March, 1934, for the Salaries and Expenses of the Department of the President of the Executive Council.
Comment on this
Is the Minister adopting the usual practice on this Vote and offering no explanation of policy?
Comment on this
We have to take it then that the Executive Council are pursuing a deliberate policy of not explaining to this House or to the country what their policy is on certain matters. This is one of the most important Estimates we have to consider, because the policy for which the President stands is involved in this particular Estimate. Yet, though the country has suffered from that policy for 12 months, since we last had an opportunity of discussing the Estimate for this Department, the Government will not vouchsafe any view on some of the most important aspects of their policy—aspects with which the country is deeply concerned and in which it is vitally interested. What is precisely the policy of the President on the issue which has been most in the minds of the people of this country for the last eight or nine months? I doubt if anybody knows it. The President himself knows it? I wonder whether the members of the Executive Council know it. We had, during the past month, glaring examples of flagrantly contradictory statements made in this regard by the Minister for Agriculture and by the President. It will be in the recollection of many of the Deputies present how, some few weeks ago, the Minister for Agriculture astonished this House by saying the Government had found markets which would replace the British market we had lost. Apparently, the head of the Executive Council knew nothing about them. I am not surprised.
Either the Minister for Agriculture did not know what he was talking about or, else, the President is not aware of what his Ministers are doing. We had a confession on this matter from the President the other day. When I gave him an opportunity of dealing with the question, he said he had dealt with it and that I was not present. I was present but it never struck me the the President was referring to the few words he then uttered. I thought he was referring to his opening statement. In reality, he had not dealt with the question of markets. So far as he mentioned them, what he said was in complete contradiction, so far as the principal countries of Europe are concerned, with what the Minister said. There may be countries in Europe in which we have not representatives and in which we are likely to have markets. That may be so of the east of Europe and of the south of Europe, but the President did not even mention that markets were available there. What he did say, so far as his remarks can be paraphrased, was that the position was most unsatisfactory, that, in fact, unless these countries mended their ways, so far as we were concerned, and bought more from us, serious steps would have to be taken.
That does not suggest that markets have been found. Yet what was the foundation of the play made here by the Minister for Agriculture when he said that such markets had been found? Where are they? What is the worth of them? There are very few matters agitating this country at the present moment—they are not much agitating another country—so much as the policy for which the President is responsible, the policy of ill-will prevailing now between the two countries and the two Governments, the policy of the economic war. It is quite evident that supporters of every Party are seriously concerned with that particular matter. Why else the rumour we have heard, about once every two months, since this war started, that it was going to be settled? Rumours have been assiduously circulated. Almost every two months during the last year rumours have been put about that there was going to be a settlement. There was not a tittle of foundation for these rumours, not one bit of justification for Ministerial statements here and in the Seanad that a settlement might be expected, or for the alternative statements that markets had been found. Why, then, were the rumours put about? The rumours were put about because the Deputies of every Party, the Deputies of the Fianna Fáil Party quite as much as the Deputies on this side of the House, realise that the people want the matter settled. Else there was no point in putting the rumours about. There were rumours put about some six weeks ago.
Comment on this
The President will keep order. He is too much like a caricature of a schoolmaster, continually asking footy points. I am making a speech and the President has a habit of continually interrupting, saying: "Prove it,""Where is your proof?""What can you quote from?" I am satisfied with what the people in the country know and not with what the President knows or appears to deny. We have had many denials from him in the last couple of days and we know the value of them. I am quite satisfied the people in this country know the rumours have been put about.
Comment on this
The grunter is at it now. I understand he is a particular protégé of the President. These rumours have been circulated in order to keep up the spirits of the supporters of the Fianna Fáil Party. I am bringing that forward as proof of the statement I made that everybody in this country is vitally interested in a settlement of this question and it is nothing less than a scandal—and we have had many from the President's Party and from himself within the last couple of weeks—that this Vote should be introduced without any attempt at justification, without any statement of policy from the President. We cannot regard the few words from the Minister for Finance as an appropriate introduction of this Vote. Again, if we see fit, we shall have to exercise our privileges of treating this strictly as a Committee Stage, and Deputies on this side of the House will exercise their rights and continue the discussion even when we have heard what the Ministerial policy is.
What we do want to know because, unfortunately, the country is in complete ignorance on the matter, is whether there is any real wish—I do not mean a wish that means nothing, but any real practical wish—any real desire, on the part of the President to settle this dispute. I suggest that anybody who throws his mind back on the history of this dispute, a dispute that has meant such a lot of misfortune and disaster for this country, will see that there is unfortunately—at least it is the only evidence we have—no such desire on the part of the President. Every time, as days and months went by, we found him further away from a settlement. Every conference and every negotiation he entered into found him further away from a settlement, putting up new difficulties. That was so last October and last November when he put up his extraordinary additional payment. That was so when, during the election, we had a new barrier put up in the way of a settlement, namely, that until the Boundary was brushed aside there could be no settlement.
Comment on this
Not in so far as any statement of the President is concerned. Now, Deputy Cleary is a bit—well, I would be very slow to say what I think of him.
Comment on this
There are, unfortunately, certain limitations. He is one of the few Deputies that I feel inclined to say certain things about.
Comment on this
I will say this much, that I think it would require a miracle of Divine providence to raise him to the lowest depths of degradation. The policy, as revealed by actions and not as explained by the Minister, has been one of putting more and more obstacles in the way of a settlement of this matter. I suggest the whole future of the country is being deliberately destroyed by the man who thinks he has a mission so far as this country is concerned; that he is appointed to carry through a certain policy in this country, no matter what it costs the country in the way of pauperisation and degradation. I suggest that it is time the people of the country are not asked merely to rely on inferences that they are compelled to draw from the actions of the President and from the rumours that are continually being spread about the country, and that we should have a plain and definite statement of policy from the Government.
They have their opportunity on this particular Vote. I think it is nothing less than a continuation of their usual cruel and callous treatment of this nation—the way in which rumour has been put about practically every two months and the way in which this country has been treated by that particular Party, just as a very well-known domestic animal is treated by putting a carrot before it. That has been the policy of these apostles of nationality opposite. They have been fooling the country in that particular for 12 months. I believe the great bulk of the people who support every Party in this House want a settlement.
Comment on this
I suggest that after 12 months of that policy and within a month of the adjournment this is the last Vote on which the Executive Council has an opportunity of explaining its action, its policy, and saying precisely where it stands. I do not want heroics from the Deputy from the Mountains. I want a plain commonsense statement whether there will be any effort made to have a settlement or not, whether the mere presence of that great negotiator, Senator Connolly, in London, and the opportunity he has of coming into daily contact with those with whom we are in dispute, has been utilised. Let the country know where we stand. I will confess that it is by no means easy to unravel any statements of the President, or to pin him down to anything. Tht only statement that he was pinned down to to-night was, unfortunately, not heard by the bulk of the House, namely, a denial. The opportunity for repeating it was not taken. We know the extreme difficulty, the impossibility, in fact, that he finds in making a definite statement. That one was definite. Unfortunately, with unusual modesty on his part, he deprived the House of an opportunity of hearing it fully. We accept, as we are bound to accept—and so far as the individual is concerned we willingly accept—the statement of the Leas-Cheann Comhairle in regard to it. So far as policy is concerned, when the President gets up to make a statement I confess that the House is a little more confused after he has been speaking about it for some time than it was before he got up. Still, I do suggest that he should explain how it was that his Minister for Agriculture was able to state that we had markets abroad, markets apparently—because that was the significance and application of the statement—that would compensate us for the market which we had lost. Consequently, I think an opportunity should be taken of stating what the policy of the Government is on the economic war, and whether they are anxious to take, or have recently taken, any steps towards a settlement.
Comment on this
I wish to take this opportunity of making some comments upon the manner in which the President has exercised the duties of his office. I hope that he will not wait until concluding the discussion on this Estimate to get up and tell us something about it. I hope that he will give an opportunity to some of us to comment on what he has to say, and possibly to make some suggestions which even he might conceivably find useful. I confess to having a weakness for the President. In the first place he was a great friend of one of the men I most liked and admired among those I ever knew. In the second place I have been influenced, as I think most people who came into contact with him have been influenced, by his courtesy and his charm and his dignity. Nevertheless, I feel obliged to say about him now what I said about him once in this House already that I disagree with practically everything he has done in the course of his public life, and that I do not believe any man since Cromwell has inflicted more harm on this country.
Comment on this
I said in speaking upon the question of the election of the President that in view of his special qualities, and in view of the hold that he undoubtedly possessed— and still possesses, though in a very much lesser degree—over the hearts of a large section of the people of this country, he was a potential asset of tremendous value. I still think so, in spite of what I think about his past actions. When I was a child learning Church history I used to be taught that the fact that the Church had survived the immoralities of certain mediæval Popes was one of the strongest proofs of its divine origin; and the mere fact that the President's reputation and position have survived the appalling injuries he has inflicted upon this country is very good proof that he could be worth something tremendous to this country.
Comment on this
Somehow or other he remains a potential asset, with the accent on the word potential, and I am terribly afraid that the accent will remain on the word "potential" until the end of the chapter.
There are two particular matters that I wish to refer to in commenting on his performance of the duties of his office. One is that which has been referred to by Deputy Professor O'Sullivan, that is his attitude towards the question of settling the economic war. The President put in an interjection just now as to who it was started rumours a short time ago that a settlement was coming. As far as I am concerned, those rumours reached me from two directions and both directions were Fianna Fáil. One of them was a Deputy sitting on those benches at the present moment, who gave me to understand in the month of May that from what he knew a settlement was probable not merely at the Economic Conference, but even before the Economic Conference began.
Comment on this
Well, that point was not stressed to me. It is perfectly true that those rumours represented the general desire of this country, and still represent the general desire of this country. What is the President doing, or what has the President done to bring about a settlement? Why is he sitting here at all? Why is he not over in London? Is not that where he would be doing some good at the present moment? Why is he not over in London trying to make a settlement? This matter could have been dealt with, as has been frequently pointed out, in two ways, by negotiation—by making a business offer, in other words—or by arbitration. I maintain that the President has blocked both methods. From all we can hear, he blocked the negotiation method completely during the Ottawa Conference. The negotiation method was made impossible in connection with the Economic Conference now sitting, and my hopes of anything being accomplished for us at that Conference were almost completely shattered when I read the speech which the President made in Paris on his way back from Rome, a speech so aggressive and so obviously calculated to excite annoyance among the British that it was impossible to think that at the time he was making it he could have had any serious desire that a settlement should be attempted by negotiation in connection with the present Economic Conference.
What about arbitration? I must admit that at first I was impressed when the President announced in this House that he had accepted the principle of arbitration, and that the only thing he insisted on was that it should be a fair tribunal and not a tribunal comparable to the Feetham Tribunal. I was impressed by that. I think now I was "taken in" by it. I think he never had the slightest desire for arbitration of any kind. He has never allowed this arbitration question to be brought down to a narrow issue. He has refused to allow it to be brought down even to the question of who should be chairman, or from what nation the chairman should be drawn. I made an attempt last year, as he will remember, to get him to go as far as to say that the delegates from the Irish Free State would be Irish Nationals. Surely that was not an unreasonable proposition to expect him to agree to. He would not even agree to that, and I think the reason was that if he agreed to that it would bring the matter at issue down to the narrow question of a chairman, and he was afraid that by some means or other a reasonable proposition with regard to the chairman might be put forward, which he would be practically bound to accept. I can see no evidence that he really wanted arbitration. I am convinced that if he had really wanted arbitration, means could have been obtained for bringing it about. Now what I am saying about his attitude towards a settlement to-night is no more confined to my personal opinion than it is to the personal opinion of Deputy Professor O'Sullivan. It is becoming the general feeling in the country that the individual who is standing in the way of a settlement is the President. The bulk of his own followers want a settlement and would like to see some efforts made to bring it about. It is perfectly certain that at the last general election the majority of the people who supported Fianna Fáil did so because they erroneously believed that the President had not been given a fair chance to get a settlement, and that they by returning him to power again would give him that fair chance, and that then they might expect to see results. These people were absolute mugs just as I am afraid I was a mug when I thought that he seriously desired arbitration in any shape or form.
Heaven knows the agricultural industry has suffered enough now and I keep hoping against hope that even at this late hour the President will take some steps towards bringing about an accommodation; and there is every reason to believe the people on the other side would be willing to contribute to its coming about. Of course I agree it is not a suitable moment for them to make an accommodation with us, if we make jingo speeches or foolish declarations; I can see that there is a special difficulty for example in connection with India. We can see that Mr. Baldwin is having trouble with his die-hards about India, and that he probably would not be in a position to take on more trouble with his die-hards about an Irish accommodation. Therefore it is necessary that if an Irish accommodation is to be brought about, we should refrain from making the position impossible by beating the war drums. I do not think it is a difficulty which a reasonable man should not be able to overcome.
I pass from the economic war to another matter in which I have a serious complaint to make of the conduct of the President. This is the matter of individual liberty here in Ireland. I have referred to the subject already on the Vote for the Minister for Justice. I then said that I would refer to it again when the Vote for the President's office came to be discussed. We have in this country at the present time two semi-military bodies. There is a great difference between these two bodies; one exists for the express and clear purpose of crushing individual liberty and not only for the express purpose of doing that, but having largely achieved that purpose. I have had my own individual liberty interfered with by the members of the body calling itself the I.R.A. The other body came into existence for the express object of defending liberty for the individual, not suppressing it, and for securing freedom of speech, and on the whole I consider that it has done a useful and perhaps absolutely indispensable service. I doubt very much whether there would have been anything like freedom of speech at the last general election had it not been for the existence of that body.
Notwithstanding that, I am frankly going to say that I do not like its existence in principle, because I do not like the existence of any political army in principle and I am exceedingly nervous that developments may occur here such as occurred in Germany where you had a number of political armies that in course of time, especially after they started wearing uniforms, were breaking each other's heads and committing the most appalling outrages on inoffensive citizens. The A.C.A. in its present form came into existence as the result of the I.R.A., just as the Southern Volunteers, before the European war, came into existence as the result of the Ulster Volunteers. One violence produces another. One licence produces another.
Now what has the President done to prevent this state of things arising? What has he done to bring about a situation in which each individual citizen can be the captain of his own soul, can be secure of his own spiritual and physical liberty and need have no fear of any bullying by organised bodies of tyrannisers? What has he done to prevent military recruiting of any kind? Has he ever said since he came into office, he who carries so much weight with the youth of the country, has he ever said to or advised any young man to stay out of these bodies? If he has I have never heard him nor have I seen him reported as having said so. I allege that there are large numbers of the President's followers who are glad to see this organisation in existence and who do not wish it to be discouraged. They wish it indeed to refrain from interfering with them, to refrain from making trouble during their period of power, but they want it to be there too as— to use an image that I used before— a mastiff on a chain that can be let out whenever they think a suitable time comes for it to be let out. It is a force that they want to be there in case the time arrives for them to make use of it for their own purposes.
I suggest to the President that that is not worthy of him and that it is not worthy of the reputation that he has gained in foreign countries which he has been visiting: a reputation as being a man in touch with world ideas and with world polities, not living in isolation, but capable of drawing lessons from elsewhere, a man who wishes this country to be considered on a level with any other country, a man who wishes this country to be a first-class country with first-class ideas of liberty, of honesty, decency, freedom of speech and freedom of thought. It is not worthy of him to continue to allow this state of things to develop. I submit to his earnest attention that besides taking the steps that he ought to have taken long ago to bring an end to the economic conflict which is absolutely ruining the main industry of this country, he should also take steps to bring about a healthy state of public opinion and put an end to this marching and counter-marching and let us live like men in other lands under conditions of liberty and decency and with freedom of speech.
The President rose.
Comment on this
Does the President not want anyone to speak after him? The President is not concluding.
Comment on this
There was a custom here, whether it was good or bad, set by our predecessors. It is suggested now that we should have at the start the explanation of the Government's policy. I would like if Deputy O'Sullivan would point out an instance in which on the Vote for the President's office Government policy was set out at the beginning. It is possible that it was set out as the result of criticism at the end. As far as our policy is concerned, there is no need to set it out. It was set out to the electorate on two occasions within a year and a half. In the election in which we were first returned we told the people in very definite terms what our policy was; and in the first year of office we proceeded to carry it out as rapidly as we could. At the end of that period we went to the people, having done and having started that policy in certain respects, and asked the people to return us again in order to complete that policy both in regard to our economic programme and in regard to the question of external relations, which has been the subject of remarks by the two speakers who have just spoken.
It is very interesting to hear these Deputies talk about making settlements. Of course, we know they are geniuses. They are wonderful people these, who can tell you at election time that within three days they will make a settlement. I remember reading a document of Deputy MacDermot's in Athlone which he published at that time telling us that it could be done. I remember asking him how it could be done. Of course, all we have to do is to go over to England and say: "Dear Mr. Thomas, I am really very fond of you; won't you make a settlement so that I can go back to the Irish people and tell them what a great fellow I am?" It is most interesting to hear them talk and say that they are going to make a settlement in three days, but they never told the people on what terms the settlement would be made. I could make a settlement quite easily in the sense of making a settlement satisfactory to the British, but we want a settlement that would be consistent with the rights of the Irish people; and I suggest that the only way in which that settlement can be got is by the Irish people showing that they will not have any other kind of settlement, and that is what they have been doing.
Comment on this
Might I save time if I put this question to the President? Has no compromise ever been offered by the British?
Comment on this
I have heard Ottawa mentioned numbers of times here. Deputy Mulcahy has mentioned it two or three times. He has got his dictaphone somewhere about. Will he tell us what is this Ottawa business he spoke about?
Comment on this
I am prepared to hear the President on the subject even if I never said anything about it.
Comment on this
I should love to hear what the Deputies on the other side have to say about it because all I have ever heard is statements and suggestions that are false.
Comment on this
I do not know. I only know that it is like the rumours Deputies are always talking about. Of course I am only a mere schoolmaster when I ask them where did these rumours originate. I think that when people make suggestions of that——
Comment on this
——they might at least indicate where they got them so that somebody might correct them. They say "tell the truth." Am I to start and tell all the truth of the history, let us say, of the last ten years? The truth with regard to what?
Comment on this
The suggestion is being made that I stated here that there was something about Ottawa that would be worth hearing. Let the President mention a single case when I mentioned in this House that any proposals were made at Ottawa.
Comment on this
I am quoting the Deputy because he is an adept at making statements of that sort without any foundation for them.
Comment on this
Would the President mention any occasion upon which I made a suggestion that would lead him to understand that I was suggesting that there could have been a possibility of agreement at Ottawa?
Comment on this
The suggestion that the Deputy has just quoted. It is so clear in his mind and he did it so very deliberately that he remembers even the very phrase he used after a number of months.
Comment on this
It started in a fog, apparently, and it has continued in it. It is the sort of a smoke-screen about which his colleague spoke on a former occasion. That is the fog that the Deputy is a good hand at raising when he wants to.
Comment on this
The suggestion was that somehow I stood in the way, and blocked some settlement that was made at Ottawa. I may be wrong with regard to Deputy MacDermot, but I think he suggested something of that sort also. Will any Deputy tell us definitely in what manner it is suggested that I stopped a settlement? There was no such offer of a settlement at Ottawa or anywhere else. The only offer of a settlement we have ever got is that we should go into a Dominion court, and equally we have said definitely "No." This is the only offer we have ever got. Mr. Thomas, of course, talks of the open door. There is a very open door here, too; but in our regard, we believe that these moneys are rightfully ours, and we are not going to pay until it is proved very definitely that they are due from us. That is our position, and there will be no settlement until it is clearly understood on the other side that that is our attitude, and that it is the attitude of the vast majority of the Irish people. Deputy MacDermot went around suggesting that if we were prepared to pay £15,000,000 or £20,000,000, a settlement could be made on that basis, and because Deputy MacDermot thinks that by talking softly like that to the British we will be able to make a settlement, is there any reason for us to believe that a settlement can be made on that basis? Why is it that we have got to be offering all the time? Is it not time now, one would think, that an offer ought to come from the other side?
Whenever a suggestion of negotiation was made we responded, and I, for one, am not going to respond again, simply to sit on the opposite side of the table, until I see that there is something going to come out of it. We went over several times, and we have something better to do than giving each other's points of view ten times across a table. Everybody know what the question is. What is involved is that payments of £5,250,000 roughly were being made out of this country, and have been made for years, and wrongly made, made without the reason why being put either before this House or the Irish people; made on the basis of a settlement, the terms of which were never before this House. Because they were not before this House, and were not ratified by this House, and because they were unjust payments fundamentally, we do not propose to make these payments, or to continue to make them. Over £50,000,000 of Irish money has already been paid during the period of the previous Administration. If justice were done, what we should be looking for is a return of this £50,000,000 or the greater part of it now. Why should we go and make an offer? If a man has got property which he believes is his own, what is the proper thing for him to do? To hold it. If anybody else has a claim to it, let him make good that claim. Our policy, as was suggested, is not one of ill-will. Of course, it was suggested, by those who wanted to misrepresent the Irish people, that the age-old conflict between this country and Great Britain was due to Irish ill-will. Because the Irish people stood up for their own rights, because they said the British had no right, good, bad, or indifferent, to any part of this country, because they said that which was a fact, they were abused by other people, who said: "This is simply hatred of England." I do not believe the Irish people who struggled against England at any time hated her in that sense. They hated iniquity and domination by a stranger and their efforts were directed to getting rid of that. The Irish people have never been the aggressors in that fight. Never throughout their history have they been the aggressors.
What right have the British in this country? What right have they to demand these moneys from us? I say they have none. As long, at any rate, as we are here representing the Irish people, we are not going to recognise that they have any right to these moneys. They say they have. Then let them prove they are right in an impartial court, if they have.
Comment on this
Money is the only difficulty that we have immediately raised, anyhow, at the moment—at the moment, because there is a bigger question at issue between the two countries—I do not deny that for a moment—than the question of money; an issue which will yet be won out by the Irish people. That issue is, that no foreign power has any right over any single part of the territory of this country. We may not be able to win out and make that right effective to-day, but as long as that right remains without having effect, as long as a foreign power claims to dominate a single foot of the territory of this country, Great Britain may know that there will be an effort made by Irishmen to get them out of it. That is the fundamental position. As far as we are concerned, there is no indication of ill-will, except that we are not going, in so far as we are able to get rid of it, tamely to submit to having a foreign country exercising any form of domination over any part of our country.
British publicists suggested that they would like to be on friendly terms with this country and would like to have the issue between these countries solved once and for all. Nobody wishes that more than I do— nobody in this country, I believe, could possibly wish more than I do to have this fight settled. But I have sense enough to know that there is only one way in which it can be settled and that is by those who are the invaders and intruders getting out. That is the way to get it settled. When they are out, then there will be a possibility of co-operation and of working together with the real goodwill of neighbours. I do hold that, and I always believed it. Any settlement which falls short of that will never be completely satisfactory. From day to day we have to put up with things, submit to things, but we do it with no more good will than others who have to submit to interference from an outside Government. There is no ill-will in the sense that we are animated by hatred against the British as such. Wherever there is dislike or hatred, if you like, it is against the imposition of foreign rule in any regard on our people.
I made a public statement to the British to the effect that if there is to be a complete and final settlement, and if there is to be real good will and co-operation between the people of this country and Great Britain, then certain fundamental things will have to be satisfied. The unity of this country is essential before we will ever get a complete and final settlement with England. Those who are looking for a complete and final settlement on any other terms, and who want to bury the hatchet, as they say, completely, will have to realise that that can never be. Two, three or four of us on these benches might be foolish enough to think that, because we wished it, it can be done. Nothing of the kind.
The Irish people, in that regard, are animated by the same spirit that the British would be if the Germans had won the last war and had brought part of Great Britain into the German Empire against the will of the British people. Do you think that there would not be people in England always who would say: "We are going to struggle until we get back our freedom"? Of course they would. The people of France paid a big price for their freedom in the security that they tried to effect in various ways. The people of other countries who have been free are willing to pay a big price for their freedom. The price that subject peoples have to pay is the cost of the constant endeavour to get back their freedom. The Irish people recognise, and have recognised it through the centuries, that the struggle they have had to make to get that freedom was worth while. I am perfectly certain that no matter what may be done by us, or what might be done by the Opposition, if they were in our place, as long as— to use the phrase of a famous Irishman—grass grows or water runs, so long will there be people in this country who will strive for Irish freedom, if it is denied.
We have to recognise these facts. There is no use in burying our heads in the sand and thinking that some sort of gesture towards Mr. Thomas, or something of that sort, is going to finish this. It is not going to finish it. This contest between Great Britain and Ireland will be finished when those who are the aggressors and the invaders make up their minds that it is not in their interests, and that it is not right to continue that aggression and invasion. We do not want anything from England. We are not taking anything belonging to England. We are simply holding our own. I said, in answer to British publicists who spoke about a final settlement— something that would really enable this country and the people in this country to settle down in peace and co-operation with their neighbours across the water—that one of the essentials for the unity of this country was the ending of partition. That may not be secured in our day, but until it is secured then that co-operation between the two countries that the English publicists spoke about and say they desire, cannot be got.
There is then, if you wish to go into it, a wider sphere as to the relations between those two countries; there is a wider question than the money question, but the immediate difficulty is that money question, and there are no dicussions which we have had yet which went beyond that sphere. We went to London to a Conference and the terms of reference were on the note. We went in connection with this financial matter. We put our point of view, and they put theirs. There was no chance, apparently, of getting agreement and we came home. I see no use whatever in going into any of these conferences if the mere purpose of them is for each of us to state our case again. We know that that is no use. They know our side and we know theirs. That is with regard to external affairs.
Another matter referred to by Deputy MacDermot was the question, I think, of individual liberty. I claim that there is probably no other country in the world at the present time in which there is a greater amount of individual liberty.
Comment on this
Yes, but what is wrong with the Deputies is that there is too much liberty, I suppose.
Comment on this
There may be licence in liberty and it is possible that some gentlemen think that they can take licence with liberty and try to do something such as they have seen done on the Continent. We tell these gentlemen that they will not be allowed to do it. We are anxious to see individual liberty and free expression of opinion, but we are not unmindful at all of developments and we are not unmindful at all of the aims, so far as we can judge them, of certain people, and the moment we are satisfied that any actions on the part of these gentlemen become really dangerous, then, you may be perfectly certain that the liberty of the people as a whole will be defended, and defended with all the forces at our command.
I have made, on more than one occasion, my position and the position of the Government, clear. When our predecessors were in office I always thought of them as people who had tremendous resources at their command, and having these resources, they behaved as if they did not have them. They behaved as if a big man were dealing with a child, and they used their brute strength where there was no need whatever to use it. We have had peace, at any rate, in this country. We have had more liberty, more security in this country than they had for ten years before. And why should Deputies be so anxious that that position should change? Is it not obvious that no Government, with any sense of responsibility and any desire to see liberty being preserved, would take action only until they are compelled to take it, until in their judgment there is development taking place which would mean conflict finally? I do not believe at the present time there is likely to be a conflict, but I said on previous occasions that we are not going to permit people to parade in uniform, and we are not. That is definite. We are not going to allow people to parade in uniform. When it comes to that stage, we believe that it has come to a dangerous stage, and it is the duty of the Government to step in.
Comment on this
If there is any attempt by people to parade here in uniform, so long as we are the Government, we will prevent it and use all the forces at our command to prevent it.
Comment on this
We cannot get at every place where there are arms. We are not able to get them, we are not able to do that, but we will prevent any attempt at parade by armed men. We can do that and we propose to do it because we are watching certain developments, and whilst we are very anxious to avoid having to use force in any regard—we wish to give the fullest liberty possible—there are gentlemen anxious to move in certain directions towards certain objectives, and we have made up our minds that they will not move in that direction, whatever other directions they may move in.
Comment on this
A Deputy suggested that one organisation in particular helped to preserve individual liberty during the election. There is not one bit of truth in that. Wherever there was disorder, any disorder that the regular forces at the Government's command could have dealt with, it was caused by these people who pretended they were the guardians of order.
Comment on this
When we want support we can call for it. We do not want officiousness on the part of people who have no authority. These people only get in the way of the regular forces. They only cause the police more trouble.
Comment on this
If there is any property stolen and taken away what is wrong if other people give it back?
Comment on this
In the City of Limerick there were certain inscriptions on the walls and in order to work up a bogey which the gentlemen opposite had been speaking of so long and to make it appear that we were people against the Church, they added the words "Don't mind the Church." It was the A.C.A. did that. That is well known.
Comment on this
Evidently it is only the gentlemen opposite who are to be allowed to refer to rumour.
Comment on this
On a point of order, Deputy Belton quoted something indirectly in a motion in this House and he was called to order by the Chairman and now the President says that he knows somebody who knows somebody who says that somebody in Limerick told him something about somebody.
Comment on this
Apparently it is only the gentlemen in the opposite benches can make a reference to rumours.
Comment on this
The President made no reference to any Deputy in this House. He made reference to happenings outside the House.
Comment on this
There are two points then, and with regard to the second question, the policy of the Government is to give all the liberty it can to the citizens and not to use the powers at our command until we are satisfied that it is necessary in order to preserve liberty. We have not been unmindful of the developments on the Continent and elsewhere, and we have not lost sight of the fact that apparently certain people in the country are organising themselves with a certain model in front of them and, whilst we are loath, and will not interfere until we feel that it is necessary, the moment we see people attempt to parade in uniform and——
Comment on this
On a point of order, what would the position be regarding uniformed parades in public? What is public?
Comment on this
We will get back to the rumours again—the rumours about the settlement. I was surprised to hear that the rumours came from anybody on our side. I take the Deputy's word for it, but no member of the Executive Council was responsible for any such rumours. We have said from the beginning to the Irish people that if they want to get their rights they will have to be prepared to stand for them. Anybody can surrender; it is very easy to do that. It is not easy, when there are aggressors about, to hold your own, but we believe we can, and I believe that settlement will come quickly only when it is clear that those who are the aggressors will not succeed in their aggression. That is the only way to make a settlement. Anybody at any time can surrender. There is no doubt that the former Executive Council, if they came over here, could surrender their rights as they did before. Deputy Hogan, the former Minister for Agriculture, used to come along and tell us of the good bargain we could make. He is a good judge. They told us before that they made a great bargain, "a big nought," but it turned out that there were five other noughts and a five in front of them.
Comment on this
I did not say anything of the sort. It is a pity that the Deputy would not try to think a little, to get a little knowledge and to fill up the chaos of ignorance that is over there.
Comment on this
Only when Deputies show that they are repeating catchcries. The statement about the £19,000,000 was——
Comment on this
The British in 1921 put in a claim for money from this country up to about £19,000,000 and I told the Irish people the amount of the British claim at the time. It is a fact that they were claiming £18,000,000 or £19,000,000 and I went to the Irish people before this financial settlement was entered into by the people on the other side. I told them that the British were claiming a big sum like that. I pointed out that that was an indication that the British were after a good sum of money. I went to them at that time and also when the Boundary settlement was made. There were two things outstanding in the Treaty; the Boundary was one of them. I pointed out to the people that we had been cheated over the Boundary and I warned them about the attempt to cheat on the money question. I told them of the amount that the British were claiming in the negotiations and it is a fact that they were claiming that £19,000,000.
Comment on this
There are not many lessons you could teach. You would not be able to give a good grind.
Comment on this
I have told you that our attitude on external relations is a policy we went before the people on and the people supported us on it, and it is that policy we are carrying out. With regard to our internal policy, the fact that we have had real peace in this country for the past one and a half years is the best testimony that our policy was right. We have the power, we know, to meet any people who try to interfere with our authority, and because we are conscious of the forces at our command we do not mean to use those forces until it is absolutely necessary, and there is no one in the country need have the slightest fear that because our attitude is one of giving as much liberty as possible that either irresponsibility or shakiness is preventing us from action. The majority of the Irish people appreciate that. We will regret, and the majority of the Irish people will regret, the day we are forced to depart from that policy, and we will only depart from our policy the day that forces try to flout our authority here.
Comment on this
I claim in all seriousness that the President has purchased peace at the price of wholesale intimidation.
Comment on this
I have been interrupted several times at election meetings. When people go out on public platforms to speak to the public they are always likely to have interruptions. You cannot have the orderliness of the classroom.
Comment on this
Well, then, I should like to know where the intimidation arose. There is a remedy against intimidation, and there are remedies for attacks on private property.
Comment on this
Any time there has been evidence of attacks, those who were guilty of such attacks have been pursued.
Comment on this
I should like to ask one question. Why was not the person who put his fist through the car of Deputy Cosgrave when he was passing through my village, prosecuted?
Comment on this
I was consulted on that matter and I said that on no account was there to be a prosecution.
Comment on this
As I said, only two points have been raised. The general policy of the Government I have indicated. We genuinely desire to be on friendly terms with Great Britain, but we want the conditions satisfied, the only conditions on which the two peoples can be on good terms. I do not see that we are the aggressors in this matter. We simply say to the British: "Will you for goodness' sake cease your aggression?" They have been asked by generations of Irish people to stop that aggression, and have been told that there will then be genuine peace between the two countries. I say that we, who take up that attitude, are fundamentally more friendly to the British than those who pretend that they can be friendly with Britain by getting some sort of settlement. Our attitude towards Britain is one of peace and goodwill. I think it would be to the advantage of our people, and to the British people, if we as neighbours co-operated in the things that are of common interest to us, but we must be the judges as to the extent to which that co-operation should go, just as they are at liberty on their side, to agree to the extent that they should co-operate. If there is to be co-operation, it must be between two equal, independent people who co-operate on a basis of mutual advantage. That is what we are striving to get. We believe there is only one way, in view of the whole history of the relations between Britain and ourselves, to get that co-operation, and that is an acknowledgment by Britain, that the people of this country are completely free.
Comment on this
The two matters which have been discussed by the President in his speech have been so inextricably mixed that I find a difficulty in approaching the subject with the solemnity that is due to it. However I shall take the last matter to which he referred as it is present to my mind. He says there has been no intimidation, there has been no disorder, that there is peace, order and so on throughout the country. I have never made public any complaint against the Ministry in respect to the maintenance of order in the country, but I shall give my own experience. I went to my constituency after the General Election in 1932. I believe I secured more first preference votes than were cast for any other person in that election. There may be a dispute between myself and the Lord Mayor of Dublin in that connection, and I bow to him if there be anything in his favour.
Comment on this
I addressed a meeting in my constituency, but I could not be heard. They were not Cork citizens who interrupted me. They came in from outside. I do not know why order was not kept at the meeting, or why it should not have been kept, but I do say that until that moment the organisation which has been mentioned here to-night did not come into existence to help to preserve for the people of this country the liberty of speech which has been guaranteed by the Constitution. I got no representation, apology or excuse from the Executive Council in connection with that. It was due to me having regard to the fact that I delivered them after the Civil War, alive and well, every one of them. What was my experience during the late electoral contest? I was informed when I was having a meeting in Cork, going into the city, not to enter by a certain road, that there was danger of an ambush and the information came from the Fianna Fáil headquarters. I was to approach Cork by a circuitous route, and at a later time. My meeting was held up in Cork for an hour and a half. On the following morning I was informed that I was to be escorted to Dublin by a procession, a whole pilgrimage of military and police—an armoured car, two military units, and a C.I.D. car, so that anybody travelling the country could see that there was no chance of that person being elected anyhow. That was on the advice of the man who tells us he knows of conditions in the country.
Look at the mockery of it. A fortnight afterwards I was approached at my own house by a military officer, who asked me: "Are you going out to-day, sir?" I said: "I am." He then told me the name of a high officer who expressed a wish that I should not go out on that day. I said "Why?" and he replied: "I cannot tell you, sir, but he wishes that you would not go out." I said: "The day I cannot go out of my own house is not worth living in this country. I am going out." I went out and walked for an hour and a half. On looking round, what should I see? A lorry load of troops with tin hats. Was not that a nice spectacle? And the President of the Executive Council says there is liberty in this country!
Comment on this
What a mockery to expose one's political opponents to. What was the information at his disposal which necessitated his exposing public men in this fashion? What was the need of it? None at all. There was a military guard on my house, and they removed in a month. The necessity for the demonstration had passed, and the mockery had then got to cease. So much for law and order. It is due to the Executive Council, the inefficiency, the incapacity of it, the fact that the people of this country have got no confidence in the members of it, that there has been created an organisation which will ensure liberty for the people. Had the Executive Council not any information that the military cars that accompanied me to Kerry when I was visiting that county, were bashed from one end to the other, and the glass broken in them, on an occasion when I addressed a meeting either in Listowel or Tralee? Was there ever one of the President's cars smashed during any election while I held the office that he holds now?