We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

In Committee on Finance. - Vote 3—Department of the President of the Executive Council.

Contributions 158–311 of 311. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

You have heard more to-night than ever you expected to hear, and all we can get out of you is a groan. So much for the preservation of law and order. It is not a creditable record and nobody knows it better than Ministers opposite who know the conditions that prevailed during the ten years which we held office. What is the second case? All the rumours are denied. Nobody ever said there was going to be a settlement! There was never a rumour of a settlement! There were never stories circulated, that within a week, a fortnight or three weeks, there was going to be a settlement!

Comment on this

Within three days.

Comment on this

Within the last couple of months the Minister for Finance almost abused me in the House when he said that I was interfering with the possibilities of a settlement, previous to Senator Connolly's advance on London.

Comment on this

Would the Deputy quote me?

Comment on this

I never quote the Deputy.

Comment on this

Do not forget the Deputy's three days.

Comment on this

I am rather pleased that the Minister for Finance has reminded me of that. I was nearly forgetting it. We heard here to-night something about payments to the British made in 1921. I quoted here in this House statements that were made by the President when he was in Opposition, in connection with that time and they were much more damaging than the £19,000,000. But the £19,000,000 was mentioned. And £19,000,000 was not the sum that the British asked for in 1925, but a very much higher sum. Those people who pride themselves upon their knowledge of figures should not commit such an egregious blunder as to confuse £150,000,000 with £19,000,000.

Comment on this

I have the documents, and the Deputy should have them too.

Comment on this

Oh! excuse me. Allow me to say again here in this House that I took no State documents out of my office and the strange thing about it is that some files which ought to have been filed from other people have my name on them in the archives of the Government buildings. I could have got them as heirlooms just as much as the Simon Pure. Now £150,000,000 was the sum mentioned, not £19,000,000 unless the President wants to make it an annual sum.

Comment on this

£19,000,000 was the sum referred to.

Comment on this

That £19,000,000 was the sum that he mentioned and which he stated this State should pay.

Comment on this

The sum to which the Deputy made a reference was £19,000,000 a year.

Comment on this

The correct sum which the British asked for, as far as I can remember, was £150,000,000. Why did the President mention £19,000,000?

Comment on this

Because it was in reply to a suggestion by the Deputy.

Comment on this

I have those figures. I have the quotations here. Will the President deny that he ever mentioned £19,000,000?

Comment on this

I explained to the House the conditions under which I mentioned that sum.

Comment on this

Now we have it all clear. Everything is clear about the £19,000,000. The British asked for £150,000,000 and the President said £19,000,000.

Comment on this

The British put in a claim for £19,000,000 a year.

Comment on this

Now is the President holding on to that? That is the sum which I had to deal with when I was negotiating with the British Government in 1925. That is the sum; the British Minister said to me, "If you get a lesser sum than £19,000,000 can you not go back and say you have scored over this man?"

Comment on this

Oh! Now we have it! Now we have it all!

Comment on this

I went to London, the statement having been made by the President of the Executive Council here who was then outside the Dáil. The Dáil was untouchable at that time. We were liable for £19,000,000 he said and he warned the Irish people about the Bill that was going to be put upon us. What are the facts of the case? The facts are that our liability in respect of Article V of the Treaty was eliminated from the Constitution, we undertaking to pay the damage to which the British were put, amounting to £5,000,000. Otherwise we paid the whole cost of the Anglo-Irish War here, in so far as the damage was concerned, excepting personal injuries. What was the Dáil told on the occasion on which the amendment of the Treaty was proposed here in 1925 by me? They were told the case that had been put up to the British. What was it? The case was very simple. We had to pay £3,000,000 a year for Land Commission Annuities and, approximately, £2,000,000 in pensions. That was £5,000,000 that was going out of this country, and I stated that we could afford no more. That was stated here on the night the Second Reading was passed. Where was the President of the Executive Council at that time?

Comment on this

Where was the big nought?

Comment on this

I am explaining it. The President was in the Shelbourne that night.

Comment on this

And signing his name in a copybook at the Rotunda.

Comment on this

That was the nought; that was the liability of this country for the Public Debt existing at a certain date. Our responsibility for the pensions amounted to £2,000,000 a year, and we got out of everything under Article V. The Dáil and the country was told that we were liable for £3,000,000 for land annuities, and £2,000,000 for pensions making £5,000,000 in all.

Comment on this

What about the selling of the Nationalists of the Six Counties?

Comment on this

Just a moment now. That is a red herring and to help the President his henchman comes in. What about the Nationalists of the North? I will tell about them. What is the basis of this dispute? There is the President protesting to the dispute, that particular Agreement of 1925 which relieves this country of its responsibility for the public debt. Is the President protesting to the British that he is to reopen that and take back the Nationalists of the North and take back the Border, or push it back five, ten, or 25 yards? Not likely. He is holding on to that Agreement, and it is not that Agreement that made partition.

Comment on this

What about Article XII?

Comment on this

Not this one. You can reopen Article XII when you say: "We will reopen that second or third Treaty Agreement." You can reopen all that. You can reopen all the agreements that were made from the day the Treaty was signed. You can go over now and say: "Gentlemen, we are reopening the whole business: we are starting from scratch again." There has been no suggestion that you are going to do that. I would like to see you do it. I would like to see you facing the £19,000,000 per annum that the people were warned about. Now they are more silent about Article XII. They are holding on to Article V and that is one of your legs in this dispute with the British. Are you going to take it away?

Comment on this

You cut it off.

Comment on this

Well, I did not chill it. You can go back and reopen it. We have learned one or two things to-night. First we know of the mockery about liberty in this country. We know the discreditable methods adopted here by these know-alls. The President cannot but know the condition of affairs in this country. They will exercise impartial treatment towards all citizens. We know now that there is to be no settlement. We know now that all their speeches were bunk. There is one thing that Fianna Fáil have not learned yet, and that is whether it is paying this country to continue.

Comment on this

We have not learned to compromise.

Comment on this

The Deputy knows all about that—the man who would die in the last ditch before he would come in here! He sailed in like the celebrated bachelor who on one occasion when he heard there was to be a tax on bachelors said: "If there is, there is no man in this State who will not go in and ring down his five dollars on the counter and say ‘hang the expense, it is worth it all.'" In fact most of the trouble over there on the Government Benches is that they did not come in long before, that it was a waste of time. Where do we stand? Where are we going with this dispute? We are standing on our rights! Well, there are a great many people in lunatic asylums who are doing the same thing. But let us sit down calmly, make up accounts, and say whether or not it is costing us more to continue the dispute than even to pay the £5,000,000. Is not that a fair suggestion?

Comment on this

Whether it is due or not?

Comment on this

That is another question; that can be decided also. It is not the most important matter at all. I should say from my knowledge of affairs, and as a man reading what has transpired at the Economic Conference, and examining the speeches made over in Great Britain, that the subject can be approached and the case properly presented and a case made for the exceptional circumstances of the country, or of the two countries without any provocative treatment of the matter, with a simple-mindedness and without introducing personalities, I observe a disposition rather to indulge in these personalities than deal with the subject in dispute. It would be up to the British just as well as it would be up to us to settle. They might come down very much from their present status and they might not be unreasonable if it was pointed out to them that the future relations, and the present relations, which exist in the present Commonwealth of Nations, is their concern as well as ours. There are legal questions here, and the majority of the people in this country will not be satisfied unless there is a pronouncement upon those legal questions by some other persons. They have that duty in respect of the great difficulties on both sides; they are bigger than we are and they have more resources than we have.

I would prefer to fight the British upon any other question than on their cash box. Members of the Party opposite too will ultimately come to the conclusion that it is not wise to fight what is perhaps the most financially sound country in the whole world at this moment. That is what the issue is. There are our natural markets. We must sell what we have got to sell. We cannot expend money and resources in trying to get other markets and if we did and if we had them, would it profit us as it would to keep the one that we do want? Now after all the heat and turmoil of the last 12 months let us, as businessmen, examine exactly, and as nearly as we can what are the disadvantages of this contest during that 12 months. Let us balance these disadvantages with the advantages we have derived. Let us consider whether or not it might be to our interest or not to present to the British our case, not as a request if you like, not as a kind of contest to be entered into by two people one of whom must yield but to approach the subject in a natural businesslike way and with the idea that this thing should be settled in a proper statesmanlike manner. Let all the past be done with. Let us reopen this matter and settle it without noise and without flag waving, having an eye entirely to the best interests of the country. That is the spirit that should be in evidence and the most enthusiastic of all people in the country who wish to see reunion always postulate that pretty well in advance. I would like to see that spirit very much nearer. It might be that by approaching this subject in that statesmanlike way we would bring that very much nearer.

The longer this particular quarrel lasts, the less desire there will be on the part of certain people in the other part of Ireland to join with us. And the less that desire exists the more remote is the possibility of union. It is no use to them to come in and be united with us if the reunion be one in which suspicion remains on both sides, because the greatest obstacle to putting an end to our long quarrel would be suspicion on both sides. The allaying of suspicion in the negotiators, and those besides the negotiators, and the allaying of that suspicion between Great Britain and ourselves would do much to allay suspicion and objection on the part of some of our fellow countrymen in the North. It is not to be allayed by the experience we have gained in the last 12 months by saying that the people on the other side have not made money out of it either. If our purchasing capacity is lessened, they also have lost and surely it is to their interest to see that state of things pass. If that were done it would bring much nearer the project for peace and reconciliation in this country than a dozen general elections.

Comment on this

The Deputy has forgotten his 1919 speech in Carlow.

Comment on this

I have forgotten nothing, but unlike the Deputy opposite I have learned a good deal.

Comment on this

Irish nationalism and British imperialism can never mix.

Comment on this

We have lived to see things differently and the Deputy will yet.

Comment on this
Seán MacEntee Minister for Finance (Mr. MacEntee) Fianna Fáil

"Cannot you come back and say you have scored over this man?"

Comment on this
Deputies

"Words taken from St. John."

Comment on this

Precisely, words taken from the man who signed the secret agreement. Words taken from the man who encompassed the Boundary betrayal. Words taken from the man who, for the last 12 months, notwithstanding the speech he made here to-night, speaking with his lips but not with his heart, has endeavoured to uphold and defend British claims in this country. Yes. "Cannot you come back and say you have scored over this man?" That is the real reason why the Boundary was accepted, and the Six Counties given away. That is the reason why, six months after the secret agreement of March, 1926, they attempted to confirm the previous agreement of 1923 so that Deputy Cosgrave might come back and say "we have made a damn good bargain," so that he might be able to deceive and delude the people even as he did here to-night towards the conclusion of his speech.

£150,000,000 is mentioned as the British claim against this country. The Deputy who talked about that £150,000,000, and wanted to pose that he had induced the British to forego that claim is the Deputy who was head of the Provisional Government and Minister for Finance in 1923, who signed an agreement which settled upon the people of this country a capital burden of not less than £161,000,000. He gave away, in the agreement of 1923, £11,000,000 more than the British themselves demanded. His Minister for Finance subsequently in 1926 confirmed that agreement by his signature also. They endeavoured so far as they could by their loyal and secret acts to endeavour to bind the Irish people in these agreements. And the reason once again was that they might obey the injunctions of their British friends, come back and tell the Irish people that they had scored over this man.

Deputy Cosgrave opened his speech in a rather melodramatic frame of mind. He told us about the terrible happening in Cork on the night of the election. I happened to be in Cork on that occasion. Deputy Cosgrave has told us about rumours that came to him from Fianna Fáil headquarters that he was going to be attacked on the road. I was in the Fianna Fáil headquarters and I can tell what was the opinion about that episode there. It was the common knowledge of every one of them that members of the organisation with which Deputies opposite are associated, following up the old dodge that had been tried in every general election and by-election that was held in this country during the time that Deputy Cosgrave was head of the Government, had planned to have a sham ambush——

Comment on this

Does the Minister know that?

Comment on this

——and the Deputy has put the cap on. He knows the organisation I was referring to. He has betrayed himself and that is the truth of the Cork episode.

Comment on this

To a point of order. I should like to know if a Deputy of this House is entitled to make statements with regard to an organisation in this country and to refuse to answer a question as to whether he knows what he is stating to be a fact or not?

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Chair has no power to control a Minister in such matters.

Comment on this

Might I ask the Minister a question——

Comment on this

I threw a cap and a Deputy caught it and put it on and that Deputy is on his feet now.

Comment on this

Might I now ask the Minister a question? Some 25 minutes ago the President made a statement in which he said that he knew of a certain thing. When he was asked did he know it he said "No," but that he was informed to that effect. I am putting the same question to the Minister now. Does he state to this House that he knows the facts as stated by him, or is it that he was informed by somebody else?

Comment on this

Why did you wear the cap?

Comment on this

How else would I know it except that I had been informed? The Deputy was listening to what I said, and I tell the House that it was well known in Cork City that, as I say, a plan of this sort——

Comment on this

I should like to ask——

Comment on this

Deputy Cosgrave said he received this information from Fianna Fáil headquarters. Does the Minister deny that?

Comment on this

Fianna Fáil sent no message.

Comment on this

Does the Minister know what he said? Does he deny Deputy Cosgrave's statement?

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Deputy O'Neill, on a point of order.

Comment on this

More or less on a point of correction.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Minister may give way, if he so desires.

Comment on this

I happened to be principally in charge of the matters referred to. They happened in the town of Kinsale, and I know from two messages brought to me by the police in charge of the western section of the county and the police officer responsible for the City of Cork, who both came to Kinsale that night, that there is no foundation for the insinuation made by the Minister.

Comment on this

On a further point of order, having made an unfounded statement, for which he could not produce any evidence, the Minister in amplifying that statement, implied that a Deputy of this House knew about that association and their aims and actions on that occasion. It is just like the statement to which I referred a while ago by the President.

Comment on this

It is extraordinary that members opposite should be so anxious, at this stage, to disavow the tactics they adopted through the preceding elections. After all, the people of this State have memories. They can put two and two together and when they see occurrences continuously associated with each other in a way that cannot be ascribed to mere coincidence, but that, logically, could only be put down to definite planning; when they see that, at the general election of 1923, we had the same sort of story; when they see that, at the two elections of 1927, we had at these armed outrages and unknown individuals attacking prominent members of the then Government; when they see, at every by-election, people shot in Dublin and incidents occurring here and there, and every one of these occurrences made the excuse for filling the streets with troops, for parading armoured cars and for sending men out with all the panoply of war, in order to intimidate and cow the electors and to induce the people to believe that this State was living on the brink of revolution; when we know they did that at the first election at which they were beaten in 1932, is it surprising that reasonable men should credit the statement that they were planning to do that again in 1933, that the old tactics were going to be pursued once more and that, when they had been talking about Communism and disorder and revolution and revolt and public turmoil and civil strife they were going, so far as they could ensure it, to give to the election all the appearances of that state of affairs.

I say, and I repeat, that, so far from any information of the sort having been conveyed to Deputy Cosgrave from the Fianna Fáil headquarters in Cork, on the contrary, the general belief and opinion in Fianna Fáil quarters in Cork, on the eve of the election, was that there was to be, as I have said, a sham attack made upon Deputy Cosgrave by members of the organisation whose conduct, by whatever else it may have been characterised during that election, was not characterised by any desire to preserve public peace or order.

Comment on this

You did not say it when he was here.

Comment on this

I would have, but he ran away, and not for the first time.

Comment on this

He knew you were codding.

Comment on this

Why did they not make the attack?

Comment on this

It was only the very strong judgment of the Minister that kept him from interrupting.

Comment on this

Would the Minister accept my statement——

Comment on this

Would the Deputy allow me to proceed?

Comment on this

The "blue shirt" that got cold feet.

Comment on this

The Deputy then went on to say that he was escorted, after these rumours had been circulated, admittedly, by the Deputy's organisation, through the City of Cork; that, following the circulation of these rumours, the police had to take heed of them and to take, as they had been instructed by the Minister for Justice and the President of the Executive Council, every possible precaution to safeguard, not merely the person of Deputy Cosgrave, but the person of every other candidate in this election, including every member on the Opposition Benches. Admittedly, Deputy Cosgrave may have been escorted by a strong force through Cork; admittedly, he may have been escorted, after the election, through the streets of the city by a strong guard, but it was not the first time that Deputy Cosgrave enjoyed such an escort. When he was President of the Executive Council, and when the members of his Front Bench were members of that Executive Council, in what way did they go around the streets of the city and in what way did they go around this country? Was it as humble individuals anxious to walk the public streets? Oh, no. They went around in armed cars with machine guns, as Deputy Mulcahy told us the other day. It was not an unusual sight during the election, when they were on the hustings.

Comment on this

Will the Minister accept a correction? From the general election of 1923 I went to any part of the country that I wanted to go, unescorted, unattended and unarmed, until Fianna Fáil were coming back into practical politics, and Kevin O'Higgins was killed.

Comment on this

Once again are we blamed for the murder of Kevin O'Higgins? Does the Deputy want that ventilated now?

Comment on this

I have given my opinion on that before. We went through the country unarmed and unattended. I say that from the general election of 1923, from that campaign, until the members on the Front Benches opposite were preparing to come back into practical politics members of the Executive Council went through the country, wherever they wanted to go, unarmed and unattended.

Comment on this

The Deputy has made a statement which I regard as of some importance. He stated that until we came back into practical politics they went round this country unescorted and unarmed, and when we came back to practical politics, and when we were challenging the Cumann na nGaedheal Party for the control of the resources of this State, then the Cumann na nGaedheal Party, as I have stated, adopted this as an electioneering plank, and as an electioneering dodge; when they could go around posing as strong men, men who were in danger from these turbulent forces they were endeavouring to subdue, attended by armed cars and providing themselves with armed guards, military escorts, and soldiers with tin hats, to which Deputy Cosgrave in 1933, takes such strong exception. He took no exception to these precautions from 1927 to 1933. He could not have walked the streets of Dublin in 1931. I say he could have walked them, but he did not choose to walk the streets of Dublin in 1931 as an ordinary private citizen. That would not be effective at all; it would not help him to sustain the rôle which he was playing, as one of the preservers of the public peace in this country. If these escorts were a mere demonstration in 1933, they were much more a demonstration in 1927 and 1931, after Fianna Fáil, in the words of Deputy Mulcahy "was coming back into practical politics."

Comment on this

After having sworn in Burgh Quay that they would never come in, they came in a fortnight afterwards. After denouncing the Deputy as a traitor for coming in, the arch-traitor came in in a fortnight.

Comment on this

After your expulsion.

Comment on this

There is hair on that.

Comment on this

Having disposed of Deputy Cosgrave's heroics, I might come to the more rational portion of the speech and examine it. He asked: "What is the cause of the dispute?" Let us examine it precisely. At the very utmost it can only be costing this country what the bounties amount to, £2,450,000. Why do I say that? Because responsible members of the British Government, people who are in a much better position than Deputy Brennan, Deputy Minch, or any Deputy opposite— except possibly Deputy Belton, who has a mission on all matters—to know and to weigh up the cost, and the relative advantage to this country——

Comment on this

I caught my train when I went for it.

Comment on this

Responsible members of the British Government, like Mr. Baldwin and Major Elliot, have admitted that the effect of their import duties and tariffs have been wholly countered by the export bounties and subsidies which we have provided.

Comment on this

In the case of butter.

Comment on this

In the case of live stock, particularly. If that statement be true and correct, and I believe it is, then we find, with the aid of the bounties and subsidies as free access to the British markets as we would have if the tariffs were not there.

Comment on this

Nonsense, and you know it!

Comment on this

Just to meet the Deputy's point, supposing we are not, and supposing that the market might be somewhat wider, if the restrictions were not on, would the prices that our farmers would get for their produce be any higher?

Comment on this

Much higher! Does the Minister mean to say that a bounty of 35/- is able to counteract a tariff of £6? I would like to have that explained.

Comment on this

I asked that question the other night.

Comment on this

Let us examine this proposition. If the import restrictions were not on, and if these tariffs were not imposed against us, according to Deputy Brennan, the prices in the British market would be much higher——

Comment on this

Certainly!

Comment on this

——there would be a greater flow of our produce to the British market; there would be a larger supply of Irish catttle in the British market, if these tariffs were not on. Is that what Deputy Brennan is saying?

Comment on this

I am talking about the question of price.

Comment on this

I am asking if the Deputy's case is, that if there had been no tariff there would be a larger supply of Irish cattle on the British market.

Comment on this

I asked the Minister a question, and he is asking me another one. I am talking about the price of cattle. I say that a bounty of 35/- is unable to counteract a tariff of £6.

Comment on this

I am putting it rhetorically and not for the sake of interruption. I will put the question again, in the hope that Deputy Brennan may rid his mind of prejudice, and see the significance of this. If there were larger supplies of Irish cattle in the British market, would these cattle be fetching a higher price than they are fetching to-day? Deputy Brennan says yes! If there were no tariffs would there be a larger supply of Irish cattle in the British market?

Comment on this

Sure! Let us see where the Minister is going.

Comment on this

We are finding the position the Opposition are taking up, and it explains a good deal of queer things that happened in this country during the ten years they were in office. The position they are taking up is this, that the larger the supply the higher the price.

Comment on this

Nonsense!

Comment on this

How high would the price be? I like to give my authority when I make a statement of this sort. According to the Irish Times of Wednesday last the price of fat cattle in the Leicester cattle market during the month of July ranged from 17/- to 35/- per cwt., and that with a restricted supply.

What price, if there were no other imports into the British market, does Deputy Brennan, or any other Deputy, think our store cattle, or any of our cattle, would be fetching if fat cattle in Great Britain were standing at from 17/- to 35/- per cwt?

Comment on this

Have you put down the loss of goodwill?

Comment on this

He is avoiding the principal question.

Comment on this

I was dealing with the injunction of Deputy Cosgrave to examine what the economic cost of the dispute is. I say it cannot be, at the very most, £2,450,000, if it is even as much as that.

Comment on this

Nonsense.

Comment on this

Let the Minister prove that.

Comment on this

Because the tariffs imposed against us have, undoubtedly, restricted the supply to the British market and have, inevitably, raised the price of all produce there, whether it is ours or whether it is native. They have raised it as high as it could be raised by any artificial restriction. Yet, what is the position in Great Britain to-day when the British farmer is having even that limited chance in the British market? I told the House what the Irish Times had said of the situation. Here is what the Daily Mail, of 11th July, says about it:

"The graziers of the Midlands"——

The Midlands of England that is.

"find that their fat cattle are selling at ruinously low figures or are quite unsaleable because of foreign dumping"——

Because of the Irish cattle that, with the aid of the Irish bounties and subsidies, are climbing the British barrier.

Comment on this

And are £4 5s. less.

Comment on this

"And they are threatened with ruin. The danger is that they may be driven out of their industry altogether, with the result that land will become unlettable, and that men will starve if something is not done very quickly." What I have read from the Daily Mail, you may read in the Daily Express, in the Morning Post, and in every responsible organ of public opinion in Great Britain. What is the moral that the Opposition must draw from that? Are you going to ask us to believe that the British Government is going to have no care for the British farmer or the British people, that they are going to allow the British farmer to be driven out of the industry altogether, with the result that the land of the British farmer will become unlettable and that British men will starve if something is not done quickly. Does any member on the Opposition Benches want us to believe for a moment that a Conservative Government, a Tory Government, a Government representative of the landed interest in Great Britain more than any other interest, is going to allow that state of affairs to come to pass?

Comment on this

There is not the least fear.

Comment on this

There is not the least fear——

Comment on this

As our Government did.

Comment on this

Therefore, if there had been no economic dispute, and no quarrel about the land annuities, if our cattle had been flowing in in an unrestricted stream, bringing the price lower and lower in the British market, and making the miserable position of the British farmers, as described in the Daily Mail, more miserable still, does anybody on the opposite benches think that the British Government, or any British Cabinet, would sit idly by, folding their hands and doing nothing?

Comment on this

Is the Minister doing for this country what the Conservatives would do for England?

Comment on this

It is their job. They would make it their job.

Comment on this

That is the moral of the whole argument.

Comment on this

I am glad the Deputy has still such a glimmering of intelligence left that he can realise that that would be their job and that they would have to do it or face a revolution.

Comment on this

According to your argument.

Comment on this

Or face a revolution in a country where revolutions are very thorough-going when they start and where they do not mind dealing with a Government when they find they are not doing their duty to the people. That would be their job and they would have to impose such restrictions, whether by way of tariff or by way of quota, about which they are talking now, as would limit the supply of Irish cattle to the British market and enable the British farmer to get some semblance of a fair price for what he himself was rearing and feeding. That is the position which would have come about whether there had been any dispute about the land annuities or not.

Comment on this

Now who is playing England's game?

Comment on this

I was in the Seanad yesterday and a Senator who had just come back from Scotland said our export bounties and subsidies were annoying them there, that they were creating ill-feeling against us.

Comment on this

They are annoying the people who have to pay them.

Comment on this

He said they were creating antagonism. Why were they doing that? Solely because these export bounties and subsidies were enabling our cattle to get into the British market—to climb the British tariff barrier.

Comment on this

Into the Empire with their tails up.

Comment on this

We are a green people.

Comment on this

If the British Government merely imposed these tariffs that they might collect what they claimed to be due to them, why should they be annoyed if the provision of bounties by us increases the flow of our produce into the British market, gives them a greater volume of taxable commodities, and makes it easier, as some people opposite might have told me, for them to collect what they claim to be theirs? If that was the case, why should they be annoyed? Should they not be pleased because these export bounties and subsidies were, at all events, making their task easier to that extent? Should they not welcome an increased flow of Irish cattle into Britain?

Comment on this

They would get the money anyhow.

Comment on this

Should they not be glad that our trade was maintained at its former level—that is, if these tariffs had been imposed merely that they might collect the land annuities. But does not the Senator's description of the feeling in Great Britain with regard to these tariffs, do not the pronouncements of Major Elliott and Mr. Baldwin with regard to the effect of the subsidies, does not the fact that they are considering the questions of quotas—do not these things at once explode the whole of the hypothesis upon which Opposition propaganda throughout the country during the past 12 months has been based: that these tariffs were due to the fact that we were withholding the land annuities and that the present attempt to keep the Irish farmer out of the British market was motivated merely by the desire to collect what was due? Is it not plain that it was nothing of the sort—that while the land annuities might be made the excuse for putting on the tariffs, they were not the real reason the tariffs were put on?

Comment on this

Why did you give them the excuse?

Comment on this

To come back to what Deputy Cosgrave said, let us examine the balance of the account. Whether we held the land annuities or not, the restrictions would have been put on. We would have had to do what every Dominion inside the Commonwealth has had to do—to submit voluntarily, or involuntarily, to some restriction being imposed upon us. We would have to take the same position as Canada and Australia and other countries have done—as the Argentine and Denmark have done. We would have to agree in order to give the British farmer a chance, and our export trade to Great Britain would be reduced in volume and in value, too.

Whether we keep the land annuities or pay them, the condition of the British farmer and British agriculture is such that any agricultural country wishing to sell its produce in Great Britain will inevitably have to accept some restriction upon its exports to that country. Then where would we be after those restrictions have been imposed, if we were still paying the land annuities and £5,250,000 which we have withheld? We would still be paying that money and we would have nothing for it. Examine, as Deputy Cosgrave says, this account and see how we stand. At most, the dispute about the land annuities is costing us £2,450,000 a year, if it costs us even as much as that. Before this Government came into office we had extensive commitments in the dairying industry, commitments of huge capital sums, and we would have had to provide a subsidy. As Deputy Hogan, when he was Minister for Agriculture, realised, he would have ultimately to provide a subsidy for Irish butter if we were going to keep the British market for that commodity.

Therefore, I say that the dispute is not even costing us as much as £2,450,000 a year. That is the very limit at which it can be placed. Against that we withhold in this country at least £5,250,000, and when you subtract £2,450,000 from that sum you see there is a balance, and, thank God, as far as the Irish people are concerned, that balance is on the right side of the account.

Comment on this

I listened to the Minister for Finance, and, while listening to him I was struck by the fact that if he went in less for noise, we might get a little more sense. If he would take advice from an humble member of the Opposition, he would certainly keep off agriculture. We know he has not been a success at finance. Let him find some other subject with which he can deal. The last man in either Party entitled to talk of agriculture, the man who, by his talk, displays least knowledge of the real conditions in the country at the moment, is the Minister for Finance. Even with regard to Fianna Fáil Deputies, I am pushing the open door when I state that, owing to the tariffs imposed by the British Government, the farmers in this country are being faced with bankruptcy. The President has repeatedly shown far more appreciation of the suffering of the farmers, and the real conditions that exist in the farming community, than has the Minister for Finance. Time and again he has repeated the fact that they are undergoing hardship, that they are up against a very tough struggle, that their profits are falling as a result of those tariffs, but that they must be endured in order to bring the economic war to a successful termination.

His glib-tongued, noisy Minister gets up here at the end of July, 1933, when his own Party are in the same position to contradict him as I am, and he tries to make a case that the farmers are, in fact, losing nothing, and that the bounties are equalising the tariffs. Is one to be surprised at the bad conditions in the country when you have the important Department of Finance in charge of a man who argues that 35/- is equal to £6? That kind of twaddle, accompanied by noise and gesture, may sound well, but not to the people who are paying £6. Let the Minister advance that argument to any farmer, and he will get an answer that I would be slow to give him here. And all this on the one Vote of the year that gives Ministers the greatest scope for explaining to the Dáil and to the country what is their policy.

We had this kind of twaddle from the Minister for Finance, and we had from the President, I regret to say, as contemptible an exhibition of double-shuffling as ever took place on a front bench in any country. We had an absolute failure to face up to the facts, and we had an absolute funk to state the policy of the Executive Council. We had one step in advance, and one step back, and as a result we had a kind of stagnant twist with which we are getting rather familiar in Presidential statements latterly.

We had one statement from the President's lips this evening that stands out clearly, and I think it is a statement on which this House should ask for more information. We had a statement from the President, the man who bragged to us of all the forces at his command, that arms would not be allowed to be carried in public in this country. Three times in the course of his statement he repeated that his Government would not allow people to carry arms in public. The President is a great master of phrase; he is a great master of quibble; he is a man who, in every expression he uses, can escape either through the front door or through the back door. I think this House is entitled to a clear explanation as to why those words "in public" were added to that statement every time it was made, and it was made on three occasions. Is the President such a simple soul that he believes, looking back on the recent history of this country, that the man carrying arms to do any foul or cowardly deed carries those arms in public display? The President has more sense than that, and the President knows that there would be less harm, less evil, and less danger associated with arms, if they were carried on all cocasions publicly.

I would far rather have a pronouncement from the Government Front Bench, and I believe it would make for the safety of the country, and for the safety of the individuals who have to live in the country, if we got a clear pronouncement of public policy, compelling every able-bodied man to carry arms and to carry them openly. Such a statement would mean more safety for the ordinary citizens of this country than a sneakish Presidential pronouncement to his own allies, to his own tools, that as long as they do not carry the guns openly they are free to carry them. That statement to-night does not stand just alone. We had a previous pronouncement by the same individual that all the forces at his command would be used to prevent the importation of arms—not to prevent the use of arms, not to prevent the use of arms as a threat or argument, not to prevent the quiet secret carrying of arms, but to prevent the importation of arms. That was a safe and a smug statement, after, by his inactivity and by his spineless rule in this country, he had secured a condition where every follower of his own had already procured arms in order to intimidate or to threaten the life of others.

I am one of those who hold that neither wealth nor prosperity nor trade nor progress in any direction matters one whit if the life and property of the individual in this country are not safe. I believe all sides of this House will agree with me, that our very traditions, the very successful revolution that brought this State into being, the aftermath of that revolution, and the years that went by since are years that should warn every one of us of the dangers and evils associated with arms. They should warn every one of us what a curse it is to a country such as this to have that kind of spinelessness on top, that failure to grasp the realities of the situation, and that failure to face the dangers of the situation.

I say, as I said before, that this country can only be saved one way or the other. It can only be saved through a courageous Government— backed up by all those great services which the President spoke about, and for which I have, I think, more respect than the President—insuring that no man is allowed to possess or carry a gun, whether he carries it in public or not; or alternatively, if the Government is not prepared to protect individuals from the secret menace of the secret gun, then it should insure that at least there is equality, that every man is bound to carry his gun and to carry it openly. There would be no such thing as street murder; there would be no such thing as murder on the public highway, if every man going on the highway was, by law, the possessor and carrier of a gun. I do not particularly desire that state of affairs, but I do urge that it has got to be one way or the other. That kind of weak-kneed pronouncement, whistling one tune to the Dáil and whistling another in the ears of the armed men outside, is one of the greatest curses that could be inflicted on a country. That kind of left-handed incitement to individuals to carry guns, provided they do not carry them in public, is one of the most damaging statements that could be made in a country such as this, in times such as these.

If any mistake was made by the President, if the repetition of that particular phrase was made in error, or the clear meaning it had to this House —and the clearer meaning it will have to the organisations outside this House—was a mistaken one, I hope, before this debate ends that either himself or some responsible Minister on his behalf will get up and clear the air; that we will get a clear declaration, which would be the first since Fianna Fáil came into office, that the law as it is made by this Dáil and as it exists in the country is going to be carried out by the Government; that the criminal who commits a crime in secret is going to be dealt with as rigidly and as strongly as the man who does it in the open, and that it will be made clear that membership of any organisation, whether it has politically aided the Government in the past or not, is no excuse for defying the laws that are made by this Dáil, and no excuse for defying the laws that are supposed to be administered by that Government over there.

We got from the President a long lecture on how to negotiate. I submit, and I think everyone in this House will agree with me, that he is the one man in this country who is entitled to deliver a lecture on how not to negotiate. He may have his good qualities. He may have many great characteristics, but the outstanding success of that man in life was never associated with negotiation. At home or abroad—and Members of his side as well as Deputies on this side know that—on no single occasion in the public life of the President has he ever brought a negotiation to a successful termination. Even negotiation, not between two countries in the depths of an economic war, when passions are roused and people are hurt and injured, but with regard to divisions and dissensions inside the camp of his own followers every time he put his hand to negotiation he made the situation worse, and the tragedy of the last 18 months is that a man who might be successful in other directions but who has been repeatedly proved an abject failure as a negotiator, jostled away from the negotiating tables better men in that line than himself who took control when he himself had failed as he always did before. That is the man that stands up here to-night to deliver a lecture on how to negotiate. Following on that, it was not right or in keeping with that atmosphere when the Minister for Finance gave us a lecture on agriculture and agricultural prices. "Like master, like man." But I think that we ought really to discuss the situation as it exists and to settle down to try and realise that the present situation between this country and England is harmful and injurious to both countries, and that the longer it lasts the more both countries will lose, and, like any drainage test, where the bigger fund is, that country can afford it best and that country can hold out longest, and that the dominating point of this squalid, unnecessary squabble can only be the financial annihilation of the greatest industry of the country.

We heard the Minister for Finance last night telling us that industry in this country was rather lop-sided, that when Fianna Fáil came into office they found a lop-sided condition of industry —some 85 per cent. being agricultural and the balance industrial, and their first big attempt to alter that position was to wipe out, in fact, the 85 per cent. industry that was paying. You probably equalised the proportion of profit-making industry in agriculture as against the rest by bringing down the profitable percentage of agriculture to some 10 per cent. or 15 per cent. to balance the other, but I suggest that is not good business, I suggest that is not sound national economy, and I suggest that the Fianna Fáil Government, now close on two years in office, should have long ago—in the first year —seen where these reckless, insane kind of actions were leading the country. Perhaps it could be excused on the ground of political history and insanity. But in the second year of their office the responsibility should have begun to steady them a bit, and they should see that they have got to wake up to the fact that if all countries adopted the attitude of the President towards negotiation this world would be in one chronic state of wilderness; that if Government Ministers and representatives of different Governments with a controversy between one country and another adopted the same policy as he adopted in this country no controversy could ever be settled by peaceable means, or, in fact, there would never be a settlement.

Comment on this

What about President Lincoln?

Comment on this

I suggest that negotiation and the effecting of a settlement of international disputes is the hardest work that Government Ministers may be called upon to do, because it tests men. Any lop-sided lout can make a quarrel and any ignoramus can keep a quarrel on, but it takes men of ability and courage to end a fight, and I would like, although I am opposed to that Front Bench, to see evidence of that type of ability and courage. Remember it is all very well to indulge in cheap heroics at a crossroads, or, for that matter, at election times—we can make allowances for that—but this kind of cheap clap-trap of "Up the Republic!" our "national enemy" and our "historical enemy is not doing this country any good. It has done it harm, and is going to continue to do harm, except Government Ministers do what Ministers do all over the world—meet and bargain on behalf of the people, obtain the best bargain they can, according to the strength of their case, and the courage and principles they are gifted with, and bring it back to the people here.

We had a statement here from the President with regard to the situation in the North—partition. Partition is deplorable and is deplored by people on this side of the House as well as on the other side, but the hotch-potch type of statement made here by the President to-night— mixing up the partition of this country as if that were a part of the old age-long struggle between this country and Great Britain—can do nothing but real harm. Everybody on both sides of this House who deplores partition, or the continuance of partition, and realises that mixing up the present partition, which everyone of us must hope is a terminable partition and a temporary one, with the old controversial feuds and the bad blood of centuries gone by, can do nothing but harm and can have no effect but to make partition more permanent and more lasting than it is at the moment. That type of irresponsible speech about Orangemen in the North——

Comment on this

Who referred to Orangemen? I think if the Deputy is quoting the President he should quote him accurately. He has already devoted a large amount of his speech to partition but he did not go to the trouble of getting notes of what the President said. The President made no reference to Orangemen.

Comment on this

I did not mention the President's name in association with or in regard to Orangemen. The lateness of the hour probably explains the Minister's lack of grasp. I said the mention of Orangemen can do nothing but harm and can have no effect but to make the rift wider and deeper than it is at present. I believe the Deputies opposite really hope for the termination of partition, and there are many who would hope for it in spite of the fact that a certain catch-cry would be removed from the political arena, but, if we are ever really to work towards the ending of partition we have got to begin by altering our statements in regard to the North. We have got to begin by recognising and preaching to those who support us and those who follow us that the people in the North though they may differ in religion are just as Irish as the people in the South, and the division between people of the same nation is unnatural and unnational, and by introducing a bit more toleration, a little bit more understanding, and a bit more charity into our remarks on these things, concerning the North of Ireland, then we would be doing something real to terminate partition in this country.

Comment on this

I think the speech of the last Deputy is the grandest apology that could be made for every connivance on the part of England towards the subjection of this country and for those who have largely contributed to every difficulty that exists on both national and religious matters dividing the world to-day. The whole contribution is one argument in favour of his own attitude and the attitude of his Party on this question. He advocates an adjustment of our affairs with England from the English point of view. He advocates that every difference with this country is based upon the attitude that we occupy and for which we stand in advocating our rights to the national independence of the country. He further advocates that all the ills that have flown to this country are due to the same principles —the principles of this country—and he subjugates all those rights to the domination of outside authorities.

Dr. O'Higgins might well be excused for that line of argument. He has made very well out of that line of reasoning. He is to-day in possession of a valuable position of medical officer of health, because he was one of those people who thought that the rights of this country should always be subject to the dictation of an outside authority, and that position brings him in a emolument in the neighbourhood of a £1,000 a year. If we are to advocate along the same line of argument we could see the value of advocacy of everything material, but if there is nothing greater in life than that, then all our ideals are a failure. I suggest for his consideration that he might well consider that if these are the only arguments of importance, he himself to-day would not be a Deputy of this House nor any House, nor would he be in possession of the emoluments coming to him as medical officer of health under the authority of the Dáil. He refers to the settlement of the economic differences that exist between this country and England and he blames the responsibility for non-settlement on our policy. I have waited for the reasons that he might give in justification of that. They were not forthcoming. It was merely a general statement that the policy of Fianna Fáil was responsible for the continuance and existence of those economic problems. I suggest to him as a medium of consideration that if he would only look back on the records that exist for the past five or ten years, he would find the responsibility was not due to the Government in existence to-day, or the Government in existence for the past two years, but would be due entirely and with full responsibility upon the Government that existed before us, and the Government he supported and the Party he supports now in Opposition plus the support that is always forthcoming to any renegade Irishman who advocates the interests of England against our own country. The economic problems are directly due to the policy carried on and advocated by Cumann na nGaedheal while they were in this country as a Government supported by the English interests whose purposes they serve, and who in return were bound to support that English interest. There is no economic policy to be served now, other than a national economic policy, and the Government in existence recognises that it can only be served by utilising the general resources of this country in the general way that Christianity and a Christian social policy would see them utilised.

Deputy O'Higgins referred to the double shuffles of the President. There is no double shuffling of the President of this State, or any double shuffling connected with the Party controlling affairs now. Double shuffling was conceived and carried out by the people endeavouring to serve two countries— this country and England—and I assert England first. The double shufflers are Dr. O'Higgins and the Party he belongs to. The President has outlined national policy and Fianna Fáil are endeavouring in spite of terrific odds to carry through that national policy and the greatest enemy we have is Dr. O'Higgins with his double shuffling of accepting a salary of £1,000 a year——

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

That does not arise on the Vote of the President, clearly.

Comment on this

Besides being an outrageous falsehood.

Comment on this
Mr. Maguire

It is not.

Comment on this

Outrageous falsehood I have said.

Comment on this
Mr. Maguire

The man holds a dual position.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

It does not arise on this Vote if he held ten positions.

Comment on this

It is a scandalous and outrageous falsehood.

Comment on this
Mr. Maguire

The deplorable partition is due in this country as a result of the policy of Dr. O'Higgins and the Party he belongs to. Let him not endeavour to seek by any form of what he calls double shuffle to transfer the responsibility for partition of the country from the Party to which he belongs to the Party who always stood and will always stand against it. He further sought to saddle us with the responsibilities of making slanders against the Orangemen of the Six Counties. Some member of our Party interrupted him on that question. He was quite unjustified in making that statement, but if I am called to order for making certain statements—I accept that Leas-Cheann Comhairle is within his rights in calling me to order —there is certain justification for extending my limitation by reason of these unlimited charges that were made by the last speaker.

When he refers to the President of this country as making a charge against the Orangemen of this country or any other section of the people he knows, and he must know, he is the slanderer and maligner, because everyone both inside and outside knows that the President is the one man that stands for unity, not class or creed, but equality of all interests and all sections. The men, and the only men, responsible for the division of our country are Dr. O'Higgins and the Party he belongs to. They are the Party who signed their signatures to the division of our country, and that is the most outrageous charge that can be levelled against any individual or against any Party in this country, and when Dr. O'Higgins wants to refer to the division of the country, and to make that charge against us as a Party, he must know that he is speaking and making a statement that is unfounded, and when he charges the President of the State with making allegations or charges against a section of our people he does know and must know that these charges are unfounded. All these evils belong to Dr. O'Higgins and his Party. If we are partitioned in this country it is due to him and his Party. If we have sectarian differences they are due to Sir James Craig, Dr. O'Higgins and Cumann na nGaedheal. If we have an economic war raging in this country, that economic war is due to Cumann na nGaedheal and their allies, the British Government in this country. Let the people not misunderstand that, and if statements are made from the Opposition that these matters are due to any action of this House I will repudiate them, and will always repudiate them.

Dr. O'Higgins said: "Let every man carry arms." Of course, let every man carry arms! Why does not he carry arms himself—this Medical Officer of Health for County Meath, a Deputy of this House and the leader of the A.C.A.? Why not all carry arms? Of course, it is a splendid appeal! I assert to Deputy O'Higgins and to the Party for whom he speaks that his plea in this House for permission for every citizen to carry arms is based upon cowardice. He has endeavoured to organise a force in this country that would upset every ordered condition of society in this country, if he dared, but he, and the Party to which he belongs, and the people he has endeavoured to organise have not enough courage to put into practice the policy for which he pleads.

He found his material, but he found that he was lacking in courage to put the policy into operation, and he comes forward now with the appeal for us all to be allowed to carry arms. Is that the appeal we should expect from a man who puts himself forward as a Constitutionalist? Is that the end of his A.C.A. ism? Is that all he can accomplish by his efforts to bring into existence a force that would overthrow and displace every force for the maintenance of order that this State has set up—the Civic Guards, the Army, and the other necessary forces for maintaining order? He sought to acquire and put into existence a force that would conquer them all, and it seems that he failed, because the material he had, I assert, was not capable of that courage that would enable them, without the authority which Dr. O'Higgins——

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Deputy O'Higgins.

Comment on this
Mr. Maguire

Deputy O'Higgins, by his appeal to this Dáil, advocated the authority that they would by all means apply if they dared, but which they find they can only apply if they are allowed to carry arms. That plea is based, not upon equality, but upon the hope that, if arms were allowed to be carried, the section he hopes to lead in this country would be enabled, by reason of the right to carry arms, and by reason of their organisation, to terrorise the community into subjection to the will which he would enforce upon them, and the will which Cumann na nGaedheal would wish to enforce upon this country. That is the will of a dictator, as against the expressed wish of the democracy of this country.

Speaking of the Republic, Deputy O'Higgins uses the phrase "cheap clap-trap.""Cheap clap-trap" from a man who sits in this Dáil to-night by reason of the declaration of the Republic many years ago! He is one of the men who advocated the Republic, but he now vilifies the name of the Republic mentioned in this House as "cheap clap-trap."

Comment on this

Are not you in the same position?

Comment on this
Mr. Maguire

I am not in the same position. I say it is an honoured name and an honoured cause, but the man who designates it as "cheap clap-trap," after he has secured position and security of office, well-being and a livelihood—I say that that man is a traitor, and I charge not alone him but the Party to which he belongs as being in a similar position—traitors to their country; men who have acquired all they hoped to acquire and who now denounce and spurn the means by which they acquired it.

Comment on this

Your Front Bench.

Comment on this
Mr. Maguire

The Front Bench are able to answer for themselves. I am replying to the statement made not by one of your "Front Benchers" but by one of your back benchers who would, if he dared, be a dictator in this country, and whose ambition is, ultimately, to become a dictator if this country would allow him. You are all following him, and you probably hope to be one of his satellites.

Comment on this

I never followed anybody. I always led.

Comment on this
Mr. Maguire

"Cheap clap-trap!" I think that phrase might very well be applied, not alone to your Front Benchers, but to every man of your Party.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Deputy should not address fellow Deputies in the second person.

Comment on this
Mr. Maguire

Before I conclude, I should like to mention that it has just been called to my attention that during my speech I made a reference to Sir James Craig. I meant to refer not to Sir James Craig, but to Lord Craigavon, and I wish to make that apology and correction.

Comment on this
Seán MacEntee Minister for Finance (Mr. MacEntee) Fianna Fáil

I beg to move that the question be put.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

I am accepting that motion.

Comment on this

Sir, I submit that we have 23 hours to go.

Comment on this
Division

The Committee divided:—Tá

Tá 56
·
Níl 38
Result Carried The question put was agreed to.

Do you agree with this result?

Division

Question declared carried. Main question put.

Tá 57
·
Níl 38
Result _

Do you agree with this result?