We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

Land Bill, 1933—Second Stage (Resumed).

Contributions 1–149 of 305. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

Bill Land Bill, 1933
Enacted

No. 33 of 1933 ›

It is somewhat of a disadvantage not to have the interesting statement made by the Minister who introduced this Bill before us now when resuming the discussion. It would be of great advantage to us if we had it. The Minister's statement made, perhaps, an impression that perhaps was not intended, and if we had the text now before us it would be a decided advantage to us to see exactly the mind behind the Bill. The points emphasised by the Minister and the emphasis itself would, perhaps, be more eloquent than the text itself. In the very hurried notes that I took when the Minister was delivering his address on the Bill, I gathered that he stated amongst other things that for the acquisition and division of one million acres of land it would take about thirty years. If he is going to divide the lands I do not see how, if there is to be any regard for the rights of property, he can much reduce that period.

He also stated that it is one of the principles on which Fianna Fáil was founded to establish as many families as possible on the land. We shall see, in the course of discussions on this Bill and from the amplification of its general character and of its detailed character, whether the Minister's proposals are going the right way about establishing as many families as possible on the land. I rather think that it will clear as many enterprising families off the land as possible and will lead directly, if not immediately, to that communal State which we are fast approaching. The emphasis which is being put on contradictions to allegations of that kind is a signal proof that Ministers are conscious that their policy is leading directly and inevitably to Communism. That, we shall see, as we discuss this Bill.

The Minister gave figures for arrears to be funded. I believe he said that the amount in all would be about £4,500,000. If he has the figures available, I would like the Minister to give to the House such information as is very relevant and material to this discussion. I wonder has the Minister at hand figures that could be classified as arrears to be wiped out? Could he tell us what are the arrears that will be funded, exclusive of arrears for annuities that accumulated during the financial year 1932-33? Later on I will deal with those figures, and I will be glad if the Minister will assist the House with information of that type.

One would have thought that the way to approach land administration is from the point of view that it cannot be separated from agricultural administration. I think it was a pity that land and agriculture were ever separated. I cannot see the dividing line between land and agriculture, because the national policy worked in agriculture must control the national policy carried out with reference to land and vice versa. If you are going to run a land policy more or less in a water-tight compartment under the control of one Minister and run an agricultural policy more or less in a similar water-tight compartment under the control of another Minister, I do not think that that separation of immediate control over lands and agriculture will ultimately be the best thing for the country.

We have a policy in this Bill which aims at splitting up land ad infinitum. There is no use in fixing the £2,000 farm as a limit. The important thing about fixing a limit on a farm is not the size at which that limit is fixed but rather the principle adopted. Whether you fix it at £10,000 or £100 you are adopting a principle which successive Governments need only shift up or down. It destroys the security that people heretofore felt in their farms. It also destroys the real estate value of land. It puts back the hands of the clock 50 years. The so-called owners of land to-day in this country are tenants at will, just as our grandfathers were 50 or 60 years ago. The land, as property to offer for security in order to help farmers over times of stress, is as valueless to-day as when our fathers and grandfathers were at the will of evicting landlords. After all, the landlord was human, but a Government Department is not, never has been, and never will be human. The farmer in the future will have to face the red tape of a Government Department if, through some causes over which he has no control, he is let in for strenuous times. But even the worst landlords had a human side, and they responded to a human touch. They could be approached in a human way, but Government Departments, never.

The section of the Ministry that is going to control land policy aims at splitting up the land into small farms and no occupier—you cannot call him an owner any longer—of these farms, big or small, can have that same sentimental regard for the farm that farmers generally have to-day. Everybody who was brought up in the country has heard farmers of this generation, the last generation and the preceding generation say: "This is the homestead where generations of our family were born and reared and we would not part with it for any money." That sentiment is now waived aside by a heartless Administration that seems to have no regard for, or no knowledge of, the sentimental attachment of the Irish farmer to his land. It was not the little value of the farms that was the motive power that put backbone into the people to fight the land war; it was the sentiment they had for the homes of their fathers and that sentiment is now being brushed aside by this Bill. I hope that this House will not think of passing the Bill, for this even if for no other reason. Taking purely a commercial view of it, we have the Minister for Agriculture pursuing a tillage policy based on very much increased corn production, and, perhaps, among the various cereals that could be produced in this country, banking on wheat.

I will not go into the purely agricultural side of it, beyond saying in passing what I have repeated in this House several times, that there is no strain of wheat in this country at the present time which would warrant any Minister for Agriculture going in for extensive wheat production. The Minister knows further, if he has consulted the best authorities on wheat in this country, that there is a positive danger in extensively cultivating the strains of wheat known at the present time, because a lot of those wheats are subject to diseases, and an extensive cultivation of them over wide areas might impregnate the wheat lands of this country with disease which would render them for a long time unfit for a better strain of wheat if we got or bred it. It is not so many years ago since I heard the substance of that statement which I have just made, in different language, emphasised by the best authority on corn production in this country. I hope that some time before the Dáil rises at the end of this session the Minister for Agriculture will controvert that statement if he can. We all know that the countries which predominate in the cultivation of corn at the present time——

Comment on this

On a point of order, surely the question of the growing of wheat has nothing to do with the Bill?

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Neither the question of the growing of wheat nor the question of the diseases of wheat is relevant to this Bill.

Comment on this

I submit that the line of argument I took up on this point arises by way of contrasting the two policies which have been adopted here, and which are mutually antagonistic. If we are going to split up the land into small holdings we are going to provide holdings that cannot grow corn economically. Another Ministry has adopted a policy with the approval of the majority of this House, and in fact, forced the cultivation of corn on this country. Now the Government cannot blow hot and cold, and it is in that connection that I introduce this matter. I prefaced my remarks on agriculture by saying that I only referred to that matter in passing on to discuss the proposed land legislation. If I strayed at all, a Chinn Comhairle, I think you took the wise course in allowing me a little latitude, rather than this officious Deputy opposite who perhaps was not following the line of argument intelligently and was only waiting for an opportunity——

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

When a Deputy rises to a point of order, which he is quite justified in doing, his doing so should not be made an occasion for an attack on him.

Comment on this

I am not attacking the Deputy.

Comment on this

Again, on a point of order; a statement has been made by Ministers throughout the country that this Bill will provide an opportunity for taking land from people who, in the opinion of the Government, are not working it properly. It has been argued that the proper way to work certain lands is to grow a certain amount of wheat. I would submit, sir, that while the detailed question of the growing of wheat may not be entirely relevant to this Bill it is in order to refer to arguments which have been put forward in the country by Ministers. Ministers have definitely made statements in that regard.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Chair has stated definitely that it is not in order to discuss the diseases of wheat on this Bill. That was done for three minutes. It was out of order.

Comment on this

The remark of Deputy Mulcahy recalls to my mind that the Minister in introducing this Bill said in effect that in regard to people who are not using their land in what he considered the proper manner it would be taken from them and given to people who would use it properly. I have enough to do to discuss this Bill without going in detail into the agricultural side, but I do submit that that statement of the Minister in introducing the Bill leaves a very wide gap for Deputies to go into in order to show the nonsense of the Minister's statement. The land policy that he reveals in this Bill is a sure and royal road to the diminution of tillage as prescribed by the Minister for Agriculture. Those notes which I took hurriedly when the Minister was making his statement I will leave in cold storage, and deal with the Bill as it is. I cannot very well go far out of order when I stick to the Bill. The first part of the Bill deals merely with definitions. The second part gives extraordinary powers to the Minister, and it would seem that those powers could be made very particular use of by—I will not say the Minister— an unscrupulous Minister. I am speaking entirely in the abstract when I say that. That section is more on the legal side, and we have plenty of lawyers on all sides here to delve into the legal ramifications of it, so I will pass on and leave them to juggle with the legal points.

I shall now pass to Part 3 of the Bill. There the things dealt with are mundane matters, and the citizen who does not understand these does not understand much, especially if he has to face the task of meeting them. Sub-section (1) says: "The following provisions shall have effect in relation to proceedings by the Land Commission for the recovery of arrears of any purchase annuity to which this section applies," etc., and paragraph (c) of that sub-section reads: "No such proceeding which was begun before and is pending in the passing of this Act shall be further prosecuted or proceeded with by the Land Commission after such passing"—I would like to have that explained—"unless a defence was filed or entered in such proceedings before such passing." Now if it stopped after the words "such passing" it would be intelligible, but when it proceeds "unless a defence was filed or entered in such proceedings before such passing" it needs some explanation. If proceedings were taken against the annuitant, and he had entered a defence why should that preclude him from the alleged advantage or disadvantage whichever you like, and why should such a man who stood up in his own defence be pilloried?

We remember a statement was made, before the Government thought there was any way out of this position, except to make the farmer pay his annuities up to the end of last year. A statement was made by a public man, the Leader of the Opposition in this House, to the effect, that during the continuance of the economic war there should be no annuities, or that there was no obligation on the farmers to pay these annuities. The Government organ immediately stated that that man should be put in jail. If my memory is correct many Ministers went round the country saying the same thing and numerous Fianna Fáil Deputies danced to that tune on various platforms. To give effect to their threats thousands of civil bills were issued, demanding of the farmers the payment not merely of half the annuities but the whole of the annuities. The right of the Government to collect this money, in the circumstances, was challenged. Defences were filed and in some cases I think decrees were obtained against the farmers. In some cases time was given by the justices. However the Government mentality was that the farmers should pay the whole of the annuities and where they had been proceeded against they should also pay the costs. Now, the Government want to show how considerate they have been with the farmers; they are going to forgive them half the annuities. The arrears of annuities are going to be funded and henceforth half the annuities are to be remitted. What great consideration, that! The Leader of the Cumann na nGaedheal Party was the first public man that proclaimed the need for that but the Government challenged it. But when the Government saw that the people of the country had made up their minds upon the matter then they made a virtue of necessity.

Now what does the latter phrase in paragraph (c), sub-section (1), mean It means nothing more or less than a display of vindictive spite so that the Government may get their own back on the farmers who faced the music and brought the Government to their knees. They are not going to give any consideration to those people who stood up in defence of their rights, and the rights of the other annuity-paying farmers in the country. They are not going to give these public-spirited and public-minded men the benefit that they are ready to give to other classes. That shows on the part of the Government that spirit of magnanimity that will follow an opponent and make a victim of him unto death, and that even after death will turn him over and roast him as well. No other case can be made out for these words. The time will come when we can go into this matter in more detail when the Bill is in Committee, if it ever gets that far. Then we come to sub-section (2), which reads: "As soon as may be after the passing of this Act the Land Commission shall ascertain the amount of arrears of every purchase annuity to which this section applies which were due and owing on the 15th day of July, 1933, and the amount of the costs and expenses (if any) incurred by the Land Commission before the passing of this Act in proceedings for the recovery of such arrears, and immediately upon such ascertainment..." If the Government could only see further than their noses, why did they not say 12 months ago what they say now? Why did they encourage these expenses which they are now going to fund, and make the farmers pay? Did they not know the position to which they were driving the agricultural community? Did they not know that the agricultural community, having paid the annuities twice over, could not afford to pay them the third time? They see it now that the expenses were incurred by the Land Commission, and they want the farmers to pay these expenses for which their own stupidity was responsible. They say in paragraph (a) of sub-section (2): "Where the amount so ascertained of such arrears does not exceed the aggregate amount of such purchase annuity payable during the three years ending on the first gale day in the year 1933, such arrears, together with the amounts so ascertained of the said costs and expenses shall (if not otherwise paid before the passing of this Act) be payable by means of a funding annuity, and (b) in every other case the amount so ascertained of the said costs and expenses, together with so much of such arrears as is equal to the said aggregate amount shall... be payable by means of a funding annuity and the residue of such arrears shall not be payable."

I wonder who gave the Minister authority, or what morality prompted him in the case where a debt due to another man and another authority is not paid, to remit that debt? The Minister knows, if he knows anything of local administration in connection with agriculture, that arrears of annuities are deducted under the agricultural grant, and he knows that those arrears which he is going to forgive are those due to the county councils. The county councils have paid these annuities to the Land Commission and there is not a bob due to the Land Commission of these arrears at the present moment, and the Government that promised the Land Commission that amount are not giving the county councils anything, but, on the contrary, are taking £500,000 off their agricultural grant while remitting these arrears. These arrears were paid, and then without having consulted the county councils to find out if they are satisfied, they forgive these arrears. That is the position roughly in regard to the arrears that have accrued in the last three years. The dates do not exactly coincide, but there is a difference of only three months. The arrears ensued up to three years ago, and it is for this purpose I am wanting the figure that completes the £4,500,000 that is going to be funded, and the arrears that are to be forgiven. I should like to have those figures segregated so that we would see exactly the monstrosity of the generous gesture, in inverted commas and with a very large note of interrogation behind that, when the Minister delivered his carefully prepared and typewritten address. Not only was the Minister not speaking at random, but he was giving the considered opinion not only of himself, but of his Cabinet, and the considered, calculated policy of the Ministry was disclosed in the address of the Minister. When you go back for a few years it amounts to this, that the Land Commission gathered the last halfpenny of the arrears from the farmers and what the individual farmer was not able to pay they made the county councils pay in rates, and those people who did not pay are now generously forgiven by the Minister. That is what the section means that deals with arrears remitted.

The next two years of arrears that have accrued and that are going to be funded have been paid also by the county councils through deductions in the agricultural grant during these two years. When they are funded and paid in the annuity that the Minister is spreading over 50 years at unjustifiable usurious interest, instead of that debt due to the county councils going back to the county councils it is going to go into the national Exchequer. The agricultural ratepayers have already paid it into the Exchequer, and it is due to them by the individuals who did not pay their annuities. The Government, presumably, are going to make political capital by showing their generosity with other people's money. They are going to have these funded and they are going to collar the swag.

Then as to the last year, that is going to be funded. Owing to the little holiday we had on Friday and Saturday, I was not in a position to check this in any county council, but I believe it has been stated by the Minister for Finance, and I certainly accept his word, that, regardless of arrears of annuities, last year the agricultural grant was paid in full. I think the Minister for Finance said that here, and I accept that statement. As to the other two years' arrears that are going to be funded, as far as the Government is concerned there are no arrears there—the county councils have paid them. For the last year, in which they paid the full agricultural grant, there are arrears to the Government, but purely from the Government's point of view, not from our point of view. In Land Commission book-keeping there are arrears there, but in Land Commission book-keeping there are no arrears for the previous years. According to county council book-keeping there are arrears, and these arrears are due to the county council out of this £4,500,000 that is going to be funded. It would be interesting to know, and I think this House has a right to know, how much of that £4,500,000 accrued in the two years of the period of three years that is going to be funded, and how much accrued last year. That is really the only sum that the Government, out of its own account, is going to fund; and it is going to charge 4½ per cent. interest on it, while the British Government can borrow money at 2 per cent. Even when high rates of interest were ruling in 1923, the finance of the Land Act of 1923 provided only for 4½ per cent. interest. To-day, when money on long term loan can be secured by the British Government at 2 per cent. our Government is going to fund arrears and charge 4½ per cent.

It is not by accident that the Government did not provide for the finance of this Bill in the Bill itself. It has been well thought out and not without reason. Of course, the rough and ready methods shown here the other night, when they were afraid that the skeletons would have appeared out of their cupboard, may be applied to this Bill, but if they are the country will understand.

Sub-section (3) states:—

The amount payable by the purchaser in respect of any instalment accruing after the first gale day in the year 1933 of any purchase annuity to which this section applies shall—

(a) in the case of a purchase annuity payable by an allottee in respect of a parcel of land purchased under the Irish Land (Provision for Sailors and Soldiers) Act, 1919, or under the Land Act, 1923, or any Act amending or extending that Act, be 45 per cent. and no more of the full amount of such instalment...

That provides for a 45 per cent. reduction. I candidly admit that I am not conversant with the provisions of that Act of 1919, but I understand from superficial knowledge that these people have a decided grievance. I hope the Government will not make the country shoulder any of the responsibility and liability properly attaching to the British Government under these Acts. Any agitation by ex-soldiers and sailors about this particular matter has not been directed against this Government, or the late Government but against the British Government who they allege did not carry out their contract.

The same procedure is followed to deal with interest in lieu of rent and land that will be acquired and resold to allottees and is set out in various sections. Substantially they are the same, with slight variations necessitated by the nature of the matter they are dealing with. The financial proposals throughout are the same in principle. The proposition is that there will be a reduction of 50 per cent. in the land annuities. The Minister did not tell the House how the Government arrived at 50 per cent. reduction. There is the absence—and the absence even of the atmosphere— of any settlement of this annuity trouble with England throughout this Bill. The Bill, throughout, has an air of challenging. We can only deduce from that that this Bill accepts the present position to continue and, by accepting the present position to continue, let us examine what 50 per cent. reduction in annuities means. Economic holdings and ability to pay annuities, advances made in land purchase from the beginning and inception of land purchase—all were anchored to and had relation to the capacity of the land to pay those commitments. What are the commitments now, and what does the alleged 50 per cent. reduction in the annuities mean?

We know that the trouble with England is not settled. One would imagine that ordinary business methods and business common sense would have suggested that, before any Bill of this nature was introduced, the Government would have staked their whole reputation on a settlement of the dispute with England or that they would confess their failure to do so. I can only argue against this Bill and these special provisions that the Government have failed and that this Bill is an acknowledgment of their failure. They are proceeding to deal with the situation that has arisen in the position of having failed. They throw out a sop to the farmer and they say: "Well, we are going to reduce your annuities 50 per cent." But what position does the farmer find himself in? He finds that he is paying the whole of the annuities through tariffs. No attempt has been made to contradict that. What right has the Government, then, to come along to collect any 50 per cent.? What right has it to fund any annuity for the last twelve months? If I may, for a moment, presume to speak for the farmers, and speaking as a pure matter of presumption on the question of whether or not the farmers have paid their annuities, is there a Minister there or a Deputy behind him who will contradict that statement or can contradict it? If you are going to fund a sum equivalent to the annuities for last year, it means not a relief to the farmer but an imposition on him to that amount. Ministers know that. It is not necessary for anybody here to have to labour it. They are all men of 21 years of age and upwards, of average intelligence, and they know the position on that side as well as we do on this side. If that statement is wrong, that the farmer has paid his annuity last year more than once—or, for the purpose of argument, we may just say that he has at least paid it once—is there a Minister on the opposite benches who will contradict it? Is there a Deputy opposite who can contradict it? What moral justification have you for funding the annuities for last year when the farmer has paid his annuity and it has gone to England? No; we get the stereotyped reply—we heard it oftener before the Dublin Municipal elections than we hear it now—namely: "We went to the country and the country returned us." But you did not go to the farmer; you did not go to the country and tell the country: "England will collect the annuities from you and we will make you pay them as well." Is not that what this Bill says? If it does not say it, I cannot read or understand the English language. I cannot understand the position that I not only see but that I feel.

It is sheer audacity for any Minister to propose the funding of one penny annuity for last year, because they have been paid twice over at least, and three or four times over; but we are only dealing with the principle of whether they have been paid or not. Let the Ministers contradict that or let them not contradict it. They propose now to fund these debts. The question of arrears has been admirably dealt with by Deputy Hogan here in the first speech delivered from these benches on this Land Bill, in which he pointed out that up to three years ago there were very few arrears, or not a great deal, but that the best farmers paid their annuities and there are always "scroungers" among the farmers who do not want to pay anybody. Not only are those "scroungers" getting off, but the good farmers have paid their annuities as well as their own and the Government comes along and says: "We will remit them." You are going to remit a debt due, not to you, but to the good farmers by the fellows who do not want to pay anybody. Are those the people you want to cater for? Are they the kind of people that are going to build a nation? The same applies for the first two years of those you are going to fund; but, of course, for the first two years I see no objection to the funding from the individual farmer's point of view, but I see the objection that that debt is due, not to you, but to the good farmer who has paid his own annuity and has had to pay the annuities of the defaulter in his rates. You are not entitled to them and the only title you have to them is the title the robber has to his loot. You have no other title to them and you can go on looting until you will be found out, and I think you are getting found out. Now, you propose to fund these at 4½ per cent. for fifty years. It would be interesting to know how this finance will work out. I suppose the Government are aware of the principle of land finance. Well, when they have shown such palpable ignorance in simple and obvious matters, it would not be surprising if they muddled finance. The theory of land finance from the beginning of land purchase was that a sinking fund was established which could be re-invested at the rate of interest at which the money was advanced and that would liquidate the debt in the term of years the annuity ran.

This Government will understand that under the 1903 Act the money was lent at 2¾ per cent. plus ½ per cent. Sinking Fund. In the 1923 Act the annuities were always made to approximate but the advance was lower, the interest was higher and the Sinking Fund was less. It was ¼ per cent. instead of ½ per cent. The reason of the less purchase money in the 1923 Act was dictated by the prevailing high rates of interest. I should like to ask the Ministers opposite if the principle they adopt here in financing these proposals is sound? If it is sound they must visualise some gilt-edged investment in which they can invest the Sinking Fund at 4½ per cent. for 50 years. I think there is not a man or woman in this country who has a £1 to invest who would not pay a good deal for the tip from any Minister. Instead of working the few pounds I have, I would be glad to know where a guaranteed rate of interest for the coming 50 years could be found to invest money at 4½ per cent. It is not to be found and the Ministry proposes land finance based on that principle. If it is not based on that principle well then the Government have departed from the practice and theory of land purchase and it will be illuminating to see what their principles are on land finance when they come to be disclosed.

They also propose to buy land and allot it to the allottees at half the price at which they buy it. That is really what it means. They also propose, if there is any tenanted land about or any farmers who have not purchased up to the present to buy such land at a certain standard price and resell it at half that price. Why do they not talk land purchase language and say "we are going to give the landlords and the landowners 50 per cent. of a bonus"? Is not that what it means? The 1903 Land Act first established the principle of bonus. There was a gap between the price at which the landlord would sell, and the figure the tenant was prepared to pay and Mr. Wyndham stepped in and said: "The Government will fill the gap." Our Government say there is a certain price for land and we mean to give the landowners that price and they then said to themselves—but took care not to let anybody else hear it because of the depression in land—"because of our policy there is depression and we cannot allot this land to allottees at only half the value or half the sum we gave the others for it." Of course the taxpayers will have to pay up the difference. That is the proposal. If it is justifiable to take land for the good of the country and buy it at the price and give it to landless men why should the State lose on the transaction? The value of land is what can be produced by it or what it can make. The whole thing here is a fiction. I am not going to argue too far on that line for fear I might be misunderstood to this extent that I was supporting the confiscation of other people's property, a thing which emphatically I am not doing.

If I had the mentality of the Minister who introduced this Bill it would be different. He certainly showed by his own personal demeanour when he emphasised strongly that this is the very minimum that the Government will accept, that his mentality was fixed; that rambling out on the road and just nodding that he would take this fellow's farm and the other fellow's farm and we will put on men on it and the question perhaps can be fixed afterwards. That is really in plain every-day language what the Minister meant by the statement he made. We are to buy this land for £100, and we are to allot it to some friend at £50, and the taxpayer will have to make up the other £50. If the land is only worth £50 to the man who is to get it, it can surely be worth no more than £50 to the man from whom it was taken. If it is worth £100, why should you give it under the market value? If £50 is the market value, why should you give the other man £100 for it and make the taxpayers pay up the difference? Of course, this is exactly like the whole finance of the Bill. Then we come to what is probably the star-turn of this Bill. I think it was Lord Barrymore who was responsible for New Tipperary, but he was only in the halfpenny place compared with the Minister and his colleagues. There will be many New Tipperarys if this Bill goes through. Even the evicting landlords had to take the defaulting tenants to court, but the Minister is not going to take them to court. Courts are only in the way of the Minister. Get the tenants by the back of the necks at once. Somebody can do it—the county registrar or the sheriff, or the hangman if you like—for the man who will do this will be of the class of hangman. I will not be surprised if the Government will not have to bring in from England sheriffs and registrars as they have to bring in the English hangman here to do a job for them. What is he going to get to do? The lists are to be sent out from the Land Commission to these people. These are lists of the defaulters, nothing more. They are to go and make seizures. Will they? Does the Minister know the history of this country? Do the representatives of Donegal in his own Party here not know that six or seven years ago when they started a campaign up there they branded their cows and horses long before they started the campaign and long before their animals were seized for the rates, or seized for annuities? Has this Donegal policy amongst the defaulters spread down south? The Minister is going the right way to spread it. Before 12 months, if this goes through, nobody will be asking the Minister to collect arms. There will be nobody as anxious to collect them as the Minister and his Government.

I have a faint recollection of the land war. Other members of my family went through it; they were evicted before I was born. We are now, apparently, going to have evicting landlords and tyrants a thousand degrees worse, and the Government claim that they have a mandate for it. I do not think that in Ireland any Government could get a mandate to deprive the farmers of their rightful heritage, certainly not by Wild West methods. The registrar gets his list from the Land Commission, the sheriff gets it, the hangman gets it. Out he goes to seize. What is going to happen? Has the Minister forgotten what we learned about ambushes? Sure, he is asking for it. He is going to turn the whole country into turmoil.

Many a man who is hard pressed, but who recognises that the debt is in equity due, will make an effort to pay if he is met with some consideration. When a man gets a solicitor's letter—we have all got them from time to time about annuities and various things—it is a very stern reminder that it is time to sit up and do something. I spent many years working in the collection department of the Land Commission. We used to send out what country people call solicitors' letters, but what were really in the form of a printed solicitor's letter and constituted a six days' notice. Those letters brought in a lot of money. At another period letters were sent out by the solicitor for the Land Commission and they brought in a certain amount of money. Those people who had not responded then got a civil bill and that civil bill, before hearing, brought in a good deal of money. Boiled down, it was the fellow who could not or did not want to pay, the chronic defaulter, who had to go to court. No man went to court if he could possibly get out of it unless he was a hardened individual and did not want to pay.

I am sure the Minister has not the advice of any man with experience in the Land Commission. Along with being an official in the Land Commission, I was on the other side of the fence and I got solicitors' letters and civil bills from them, but I never let one go to court. If the Minister sent out his sheriff to take some of my property away it is quite possible, even if I had the money, that I might not pay it. That game will not go down with the people. I cannot understand why such a thing was prompted. County councils, notwithstanding what the Minister might have said about them recently, are anxious to get in their rates just as the Land Commission is anxious to get in the annuities. The Land Commission have only to pass over the money, but the county councils have work to do with the money. The county council is more or less a board of directors of a concern. In the Land Commission it is a question of getting in the money if they can, but even if they do not get it in, the work does not suffer. In the case of the county council things are totally different.

I am not aware of any county council that tolerates rate collectors proceeding under their warrants to collect rates by seizure without first putting the matter through the courts. The county councils have great experience. I venture to say they have more experience of administration than the Executive Council. They know from experience that the better way to get in money is to take the ratepayers gently though firmly and, if necessary, put them through the process of law. Of course the Executive Council think they know everything. They have taken a new line of their own and, if I remember rightly, the Minister was very strong that this method should be applied. Is it that the Minister fears the obvious—that farmers are seeing more clearly every day, even the benighted farmers who voted for the Government, how they are being made to pay unnecessarily for the maintenance of the Government's foolish policy? If they spoke the truth, I am sure the farmers who adorn the Government back benches— the Government would not let them to the front for fear they would blow the gaff—will agree with every word I say.

Is it not dawning on the farmers that if the economic war is going to continue the farmer will have paid more than his contractual liability, under the land purchase agreement, for his land? He will in a very short while ask himself why he should pay this half-annuity. He will ultimately refuse to pay, and he will be justified in refusing. If the farmer does not refuse to pay, and the economic war continues, I will say he has not enough backbone to hold his land. People respect other classes just according to the respect paid to themselves, and if the farmers do not show manhood enough to stand up for themselves against this imposition of 50 per cent. they are too spineless to hold their land, and I say that with all sense of my responsibility. They are, under the system imposed on them by the Government opposite, paying their annuities twice over.

Let us analyse what the 50 per cent. means. There are to be no more bondholders paid; there are to be no more stockholders paid; England is collecting that by confiscating our goods when they are sent over. England is collecting the annuities by that means. What does this 50 per cent. annuity really mean? Boiled down to pounds shillings and pence, and looked at in its proper perspective, it is simply a new tax on land. It has lost all the character of a land purchase annuity. It is a tax on land. Land is paying to the British Government its full contractual liability. Any more it is asked to pay is only a tax, and nothing else. This 50 per cent. land annuity is not payable to liquidate any debt. There is no debt to be liquidated after England gets her piece out of the confiscation. She gets £5,000,000 by confiscating our goods. That is more than the annuities payable to England. Some Ministers say: "Well, she is not getting it all." At the moment I am arguing only the point that she is getting the full annuities, and that is sufficient for the argument. This Bill is going to impose not a 50 per cent. reduction on the land annuities, as it is put here, but is going to impose a tax on land equivalent to 50 per cent. of the annuity. President de Valera need no longer say that he has been misinterpreted. He need no longer trouble himself about trying to cover up his tracks, at which he is an adept. This Bill puts it on record, and beyond yea or nea, that the Government policy, as enshrined in this Bill, is to impose a tax on agricultural land to the extent of 50 per cent. of the old annuity, which is no longer payable in the form in which it has been payable but is payable in the form of the confiscation of the farmers' produce when it reaches the other side. I hope the Ministers, particularly the Minister in charge of this Bill, will realise that if it ever becomes an Act it will reduce the farmers of this country to the position of conacre men. Peasant proprietorship, the bulwark against Communism, will be removed if the land is handed over to a gentleman from Belfast—he is not a worse man for coming from there— born and bred in the city, without any land outlook or land mentality, or any knowledge or tradition of the sentimental value the Irish farmer has for his homestead, in short—a soulless townsman. There was never trouble in this country until then.

Comment on this

I never heard of such a thing as a soulless townsman.

Comment on this

The Deputy will hear a lot yet.

Comment on this
Mr. Kelly

I am sure I will.

Comment on this

And he heard a lot and he did not learn from it. We are going to have farms limited to £2,000 value. The market value of a farm fluctuates as the market value of anything else fluctuates, and how to standardise a farm at its market value is really beyond me; I cannot comprehend it. I know that the man who will escape now with the £2,000 farm would not have had the proverbial snowball's chance of escaping three or four years ago, because that farm would have been worth about £4,000 then. In a year hence under the benign administration of the present Government, if we will be cursed with them for another 12 months, you will get land for the proverbial song. I dare say there will be Deputies even on these benches then, like some of the Deputies on the opposite benches, who will not take land when they are offered it without even having to sing a song. Land will be worth nothing, so that even the ranchers whom Deputy Corry is so anxious to get after will escape, because there will not be a ranch in the country worth £2,000 in another year if those people remain in office. It is not the size which should concern this House. It is not whether a £2,000 farm is going to be a 50 acre farm or a 5,000 acre farm. What we are concerned with is the principle involved in the limitation of the size of a farm, and the principle involved in breaking the back of peasant proprietorship in this country and interfering with private property.

Of course it is argued that the people who have big farms, the people in the Eastern counties and part of the Midlands, are all only settlers. One speaker when visualising this Bill talked about allowing the people of the West to get back to the land of their fathers. I think in the East there are just as many Gaels, and as good Gaels, as there are in any part of Ireland. They certainly have not been behind in showing leadership, but I am not going to argue from that standpoint. Even assuming that the land of the East is held by settlers, the descendants of the Stuarts, Williamites and Cromwellians, I should like to ask Deputies why they go every year to pay homage at the shrine of Wolfe Tone, who was a descendant of a Cromwellian settler.

You cannot have it both ways. If what is styled settlers in this country are not entitled to equal treatment with what are styled the older settlers because the latter rest their claim on a longer settlement in the country, how are you going to solve the problem? These older settlers took the land from someone else and the newer settlers perhaps took it from them in turn and so on, as wave after wave of new settlers came into the country. If the Cromwellian or Stuart settler is not entitled to equal treatment with the earlier settlers in this country because they were Cromwellian, why do homage each year to the shrine of Wolfe Tone? It comes to this: that our friend, whoever he may be, is always right, no matter what his ancestry so long as he marched in step with us, but if he does not march in step with us he is always wrong, again, no matter what his ancestry.

Now with regard to the taking of the land from those who have it, there is a big principle involved in that. It is strange that what was a household word and glorified as the truest principle of patriotism 50 years ago, when Parnell, Davitt, Dillon, O'Brien and Bigger unfurled the banner of the Land League, and enshrined upon it the words "Peasant Proprietorship," is to-day to be completely scrapped. That is what this Bill is going to do. If there is one bulwark we have in this country against Communism it is peasant proprietorship. I see no reason for the removal of peasant proprietorship except to let in Communism. Nothing will keep it back if the barrier of peasant proprietorship is removed. Personally I am glad that representatives of nearly all the leaders of the land war are in this House and will be true to their traditions. They will vote and stand by the policy of their fathers in this country. When this whole matter is submitted to the country there can be no doubt I think as to the verdict that will be pronounced upon it.

I wonder if the Minister is trying to make a case for more production by division of the land. He spoke about taking it from people who are not using it to the best advantage and giving it to people who will. I suppose the Minister would say that a man who has 100 acres in grass would not be using it as well as the man who had 100 acres in crops. I had 100 acres in tillage this year and I could swear an affidavit I regret it was not growing weeds. I could show the Minister market notes for £3 a ton for early potatoes in the Dublin market last Saturday. We must till some; we must work our land and give employment. I gave employment; what did I get? Are farmers in the County Dublin to continue to till land under these circumstances? If that land was growing weeds we would have made £3 a ton on it; we would not have had to pay for labour, for manure, market charges, etc. Suppose we let it grow weeds, we would not have to pay the annuities which the Government has no right to because they are being collected in other ways. We would not have to pay rates that the Government, by mandamus order, is compelling us to pay, and we would not have to come in here and listen to the hypocritical talk about tilling land by people who never tilled a sod of land in their lives. If they did, from what I hear, their experience would have been worse than mine, who got only £3 a ton for potatoes. After all, while that is the condition of agriculture the Minister will concede, I am sure, that a farmer, whether he got his land by heritage or by purchase, who is making his living out of it, whose financial interest is in it, surely has a greater interest in the land than the man you would take off the roadside and gave a piece of land to, to till and work it. If the man already on the land with a fully-equipped farm cannot make it pay, I put it to the Minister, considering the prevailing prices of produce at the present time, to show how land can be made to pay even if there were no rates or annuities. Is this a time for the Minister to incur national expenditure in order to take land from the people who have it and give it, at national expense, to people who cannot possibly have the same interest in it as the people who have put their money and their labour in it already?

If the land which the farmers generally cannot make pay to-day is to be given over to landless men and planters whom the Minister proposes to put upon it, how are they going to make it pay? Is it not sticking out— and I note that the Deputy who raised a point of order when I was beginning my speech has disappeared—that the first thing to do with the land is to make it pay? Let the people in farming at the present time show a balance sheet with a credit, then you might perhaps propose that some of the land might be divided, split up and handed over to some people who deserve it. I am sure the Minister will not be able to get any member of his own Party to back him up in the statement that the land is paying in any circumstances at the present time. What is the use, therefore, in wasting public money in this matter and disorganising the whole land system? If the farmer as a peasant proprietor cannot make his land pay, then how do you think he will make it pay as a conacre man?

What objective has the Minister and his colleagues to turn the farmers into conacre men, if it is not to pave the way for Communism? Are you not right in the middle of it? What is the next step? When I say conacre men, I do not want it to be understood that I am casting any aspersion on any man who may be an allottee. If this Bill is passed, I will be a conacre man and so will every farmer in the country. He has no more fixity of tenure, no more freedom of sale than the conacre man, no matter what apparent property he has in the land. If he has 500 acres of land, and he is pressed for £100, once this Bill is passed no farm will be accepted for any accommodation by any bank, and if they did accept it they would not be fit to be bankers. This is the first time that the Government by their legislation have unmasked themselves and the sooner they raise the banner of Communism and disclose their identity the better. This is 100 per cent. Communism. No matter how they may talk here or elsewhere, they may make up their minds that the country is not going to stand idly by and see peasant proprietorship scrapped. The occupiers of land are not going to allow themselves to be legislated back to the position that our fathers and grandfathers were in 50 or 60 years ago.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Deputy is aware, I presume, that there is a rule against persistent repetition. For the last ten minutes the Deputy has been repeating almost verbatim what he said an hour ago.

Comment on this

I said these things in a general way an hour ago and I am dealing with them in more detail now. I hope some Deputies opposite will take them up and contradict them when I am done, and then we will see on what side the laugh will be. I am dealing with them now in a more detailed way and in the natural sequence of what I have to say. Section 34 deals with certain classes of holdings that abut on the seashore or on the basins of rivers. I suppose a detailed interpretation of that would be more a matter for the Committee Stage than this Stage. It would be well for Deputies representing constituents to which that section would apply to see that it is made clear who will own the submerged or partially submerged piece of holding if the annuity is reduced only on the piece that is submerged. Many farmers had bitter experience of that in the past in relation to bottom land and rough grazing and bogs that they did not show as part of their holding as the astute landlord fenced it off and took it from them. I think we have as astute landlords now as ever our fathers had and as good a landlord mentality as ever the old landlords had. The question of turbary is raised here. It is not sufficiently amplified here to say much upon it and it is better left perhaps to the Committee Stage. It is astonishing that there is no provision made in this Bill for the finance of it. I do not think there is any Land Act that I have not read and that I am not fairly conversant with and all of them made financial provision——

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Deputy has dealt with that matter already. Moreover there is a Land Bond Bill coming before the House in the immediate future.

Comment on this

I am not aware of this fact, whether that Land Bond Bill is going to be dealt with as a Money Bill or a Bill that can be amended by the Seanad.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

That is a matter for the Chair.

Comment on this

Yes, but until it comes to the point of the Chair deciding, I submit that a Deputy must feel curious about any departure from established principles in legislation.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Deputy has been reminded that he is repeating himself. He has discussed that matter already. He has been informed that the manner of financing land purchase is not before the House. He has asked the Minister a question, and he is now repeating it verbatim.

Comment on this

Yes, but my point is that it should be before the House in this Bill.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

If the Deputy persists in repetition, he will have to sit down.

Comment on this

According to the precedent of previous Acts, it was provided for. Now this finance has a very important bearing on the price given for the land. It is indicated in the Bill that the price will be paid in bonds. What are these bonds going to be worth? What is going to be the backing for them?

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Deputy will now resume his seat.

Comment on this

Am I to take it that I am stopped from discussing the Bill?

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Deputy has been stopped because he has persisted in repetition.

Comment on this

That is all I want.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Deputy must be content with what the Chair wants. The Deputy was ordered to resume his seat because he was repeating his arguments for a second or third time.

Comment on this

I am not satisfied.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Deputy knows that there is a method of testing the ruling of the Chair by an express motion, and not by mumbling or sotto voce expressions of disagreement.

Comment on this

I did not hear what the Chair said.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Not by mumbling or otherwise expressing dissatisfaction.

Comment on this

I do not mumble. Anything I have to say I say it.

Comment on this

This Bill has been sought to be justified on the ground that it is for the purpose of speeding up the operations of the Act of 1923. If the Bill was directed towards that end, and without any objectionable features, I would have great pleasure in supporting it, because the Act of 1923, we must all admit, has been working too slowly. However, this Bill is so objectionable in many features that I feel it my duty to oppose it. I am not going to go over the Bill at any length because it has been dealt with by others more competent than I am to discuss it; but as an ordinary individual without a legal mind I should like to refer to just a few of the salient points which appeared to me to be the most objectionable. In Sections 6 and 7 proposals are made that are sufficiently objectionable, if there were no others, to induce me to oppose the Bill as far as I can. Section 6 simply annuls every Land Act for the last 50 years. That section puts an individual —the Minister for Lands and Fisheries —above the law. Laws have been made here and elsewhere to deal with the administration of land and to give the occupiers and owners of land certain rights. The section to which I have referred takes away every right, so far as I can understand it, and puts it in the power of an individual, who happens for the time being to be the Minister for Lands and Fisheries, to take away all the rights which previous Acts have given to occupiers and owners of land, and puts it into the hands of the Minister to do as he pleases.

Section 6 puts the Minister, as I said, above the law. His will becomes the law as far as land in this country is concerned. Section 7 puts nominees of the Minister above the Minister. If I were to choose between the Minister and his nominees I would have no hesitation in bringing my case before the Minister. The appeal tribunal is made up of a majority of the nominees of the Minister and, therefore, I would have no hesitation, if I wanted a case decided, in going to the decentest man of the crowd, and I feel that that would be the Minister. What is the Minister that he should be above the law? We all know that a Minister is the product of a turn in the political wheel of fortune. We know that a Minister is not an angel, and, even if he were an angel, it is on record that the angels themselves have fallen. What happened once might happen again so that, after all, we have a great deal to be thankful for that the Minister is not an angel and that he is a mere human being, but human nature is also likely to fall, and if the just man, as we are told, falls seven times a day, how many times will a Minister fall? Some people might imagine that he would fall more often but certainly I do not agree with that. I think he would fall only once, because the weight of all the political clubs and other organisations around him would be such that he would never get a chance to rise again. That is my opinion about it.

A good deal has been said on both sides of the House about the Minister's intentions. I am not concerned with his intentions. We have been elected and sent here to enact, not the Minister's intentions, but the law for this State. I think we should confine ourselves to the Bill and not to the Minister's intentions. I have no desire to question the Minister's intentions; I believe they are all right. But why should we tempt the Minister by putting him in a position of being above the law? I believe that the law should be made as distinct and clear and put upon the Statute Book in as clear a form as it is possible for human ingenuity to do it, and that the persons appointed to administer the law should be people who are competent and who will not be influenced by any outside forces and will only be guided by the Act of Parliament they have before them. It should be their duty to administer that, and to that alone they should be confined.

There is another view which I should like to put to the Government Benches. The Fianna Fáil Government are not elected for all time. The next Government may be a Cumann na nGaedheal or Centre Party. They are putting machinery into the hands of these parties, when they come into power, to do to the Fianna Fáil Party as they might do to others. I am not saying that anything drastic is going to be done, but it has been said—and even the Minister for Agriculture threw out some hints—that something like that would be done. Then, when it is the turn of some other party to come into office and with the machinery put into their hands which they will have if this Act goes through, there would be retaliation and what would it all lead to? It would lead to another civil war, and I believe it is the duty of this country to avoid civil wars in the future. Whatever is done, it should be put into the Act in plain words and the Act should be administered by people who are impartial and who are not influenced by anything but the Act of Parliament before them. Part III of the Bill deals with the collection and funding of annuities. This matter has been discussed on many occasions here and it has been dealt with at great length so that there is hardly anything to be said about that, only that there is no justification in the present circumstances—I refer to the circumstances of the economic war —for the Minister to ask from this House powers to collect money that, admittedly, has been paid already to Great Britain. The only weakness in the case is that the farmers have not got receipts for their annuities. Nobody denies that they have paid them for the last year or two, and, so long as the economic war continues, they will continue paying the annuities, but simply because they have no receipts, although they have paid them, is that any justification to enact a law that would compel them to pay again?

I think it would be a very shady thing to do. I have a great objection to that section. If the economic war were settled the circumstances would be entirely different and I would have great pleasure in supporting a reduction in the annuities to meet the depressed time. But so long as we are in the midst of depression and that over and above the depression the farmers are actually paying the amount of their annuities, I think it is hardly fair, and it cannot be defended as just and reasonable, to bring in such a measure at this time. I think it should have been deferred until after the economic war had been settled. To pass this Bill would be a violation of all right principles, a violation of the Constitution and of Divine Justice. It is a breach of the Seventh Commandment to vote for a Bill providing for the payment of money a second time simply because the people who paid this money on the first occasion have not got their receipts.

Then we come to Section 27. That section gives very drastic powers to the Land Commission. It gives power to hand over to the sheriffs the right to seize for these moneys whether they are due or not. I think from what I have said with regard to the right of the collection of these moneys a second time that it is wise for the Minister not to go into court, because if you have not a case fit to go into court it is much better to take the power of enforcing payment rather than to go into court and expose a bad case. The justification that the Minister gives for this section is that it cuts short the lawyer's bill of costs—the costs which the lawyers impose on people owing anything in the way of annuities. I think if there is any force in that argument it disappears when we turn to Section 28 and see what Section 28 means. I have carefully studied Section 28. I racked my brains trying to find out what it means but I found I could make neither head nor tail of it. I decided it was a wise thing to consult somebody who was wiser than I. I did not go to a lawyer. I went to a man who, I consider, was competent to explain that section. He told me that it simply meant that any man who had over £2,000 worth of land could insist upon his right to retain £2,000 worth; but that any man or woman who had less than £2,000 worth could have that taken away from him, and could be sent anywhere the Commissioners liked.

I was not satisfied with that explanation and I said I did not see how any Minister could make such a proposal, especially how Fianna Fáil Ministers could single out a man with less than £2,000 worth of land for specially hard treatment of that kind. I went to another man and asked him for an explanation, and he said: "You got the exact truth as far as he told you, but he did not go far enough. The real explanation of that section is that they can go along and take all over £2,000 worth first, and come again and take the rest, so that a man or woman can be evicted out of their holding no matter how much or how little they hold. All the Land Acts passed in the past are now a dead letter." I thought that this man might be wrong in his opinion, and I decided to go to a still wiser man, the wisest man of the three, and I asked his opinion. I did not believe the opinion of the second man because I did not believe that the Fianna Fáil Government would bring in a Bill with a section so very drastic as that. I went to the third man and put the matter to him and he said: "Do you know what this section means?""No," said I, "and that is why I came to you." Then he replied: "This is a lawyer's section—do you know what that means?" and I said I did not. He said: "A lawyer's section is a section that each man can interpret as he pleases, that puts you into contact with a lawyer. You first go into a solicitor's office, and if your measurements are right you come out perhaps at the Supreme Court. Do you follow me?" he asked; and I said: "I follow you a part of the way.""How far?" he asked, and I said: "As far as the Supreme Court." I said I did not understand about the measurements, and I asked him: "Do you mean red tape or legal tape?" and he answered: "I prefer to call it fool's tape or foolscap because, whichever way you look at it, or whatever happens, when the fool goes into the lawyer's office to have a section like that explained his measure is taken, and if his mentality and his resources match, the gentleman inside will see that the foolscap will match them both, and he will see to it that the end of the fool's tape will coincide with the end of the fool's resources. Now do you understand it all right?" he said. I said I was still undecided and unsatisfied, because one of the things that Fianna Fáil told us was that they would not put any lawyer's section into a Bill. "Then," said he, "you believe still in Fianna Fáil?"; and I said I believed in some of them, not all, and his reply was: "I am very much afraid that you are so green that the Fianna Fáil geese will eat you." I decided on the advice of the third man that this was a dangerous section, and that between the Fianna Fáil geese and the lawyers, the farmers were in danger, and that it was my duty to oppose this Bill, if for no other section but Section 28. I have just dealt with a few salient points that appear to be most objectionable in the Bill. If only any one of these points were in it, I would feel it my duty to oppose it. With all these points I consider it a bad Bill for the farmers.

Comment on this

The fact that the Land Bond Bill has not seen the light of day yet makes it somewhat difficult to discuss some sections of this Bill intelligently. At the outset I might say we are dealing here in this measure not with one Bill but with two Bills, or perhaps I should say three Bills. The funding sections should be embodied in a Finance Bill and a few sections of the Bill might properly be embodied in a Land Bill. The Minister when introducing the Bill here—I am referring at the moment to the Land Bill, not to the finance portion of the measure—stated that it was introduced for the purpose of dividing up the land quickly. That is certainly very interesting information in view of the fact that the Minister has already at least 250,000 acres of land in varying stages of acquisition; that there are at least 100,000 acres of that land actually purchased, and according to information which the Minister supplied to myself in the last few weeks there are schemes already prepared in his own office for the distribution of at least 60,000 or 70,000 acres of land. Some of that land was actually paid for and some of it was actually bought before the Minister and his Party assumed the responsibility of office. Yet this land has remained undivided.

The Minister tells us that it is necessary to introduce a measure of this kind and get it passed rapidly through the Dáil in order to enable him to deal with the urgent problem of congestion. What has happened the 250,000 acres that are being dealt with by Land Commission officials? The greater part of that land was near the stage of completion before the Minister's Party assumed the responsibilities of office. The files relating to the land remain in the Land Commission offices and nobody in the country knows what is happening to them. Why has not the Minister divided the 60,000 acres for which schemes have been prepared? Some of the schemes were prepared by Land Commission inspectors before the Minister assumed the responsibility of office. These schemes still remain in the Land Commission offices and the lands are as yet undivided. Some of the land had actually been bought before Fianna Fáil got into power. It seems something of a joke now for the Minister to come with another Land Bill in which he asks for special powers to deal with what he calls the urgent problem of congestion, in view of the fact that files are in the Land Commission relating to 250,000 acres. Nothing has been done during the past 18 months with the land to which these files relate.

To deal with this land, even with the accelerated powers which the Minister seeks in this Bill, would take at least three or four years. I submit that it will take at least three or four years to dispose of this land. Why is it necessary to come here at the end of a session and ask Deputies to rush a revolutionary Bill of this character through the Dáil? There is no justification for it. There is no justification either for the Minister incorporating the funding sections in the Bill. These sections should be dealt with in a Finance Bill. This Bill should never have been brought in the form in which it has been introduced. The 250,000 acres, if divided, would provide economic holdings for approximately 9,000 people, allowing each person 30 acres. If these 9,000 people got such holdings it would somewhat relieve the problem with which the Minister is confronted. Does anybody imagine that by transferring power from the Land Commission to the Minister you are going to hasten the problem of land acquisition and distribution?

Anybody who knows the circumstances in this country intimately and has had experience of the Fianna Fáil Government and their peculiar technique during the last 12 months will realise that this transfer of power from the Land Commission to the Minister will not hasten the acquisition and distribution of land; on the contrary, it will retard that work considerably. In almost every part of the country Fianna Fáil clubs are active. They have prepared lists of holdings suitable for acquisition in every townland and, needless to say, every political opponent is marked down for destruction. The Minister will be bombarded by every Fianna Fáil club in the country, every Fianna Fáil Deputy in the House, every Fianna Fáil organiser and agent. When this Bill is law exactly the same thing will happen as happened during the last 12 months.

The Minister did not proceed with the distribution of land because he was afraid to do so. There was a demand made by the Fianna Fáil clubs that every scheme prepared by the previous Administration should be revised and reconstructed. Every Fianna Fáil Deputy brought pressure on the Minister to revise the schemes and get certain people whose names were included in the schemes removed from them. That has happened, and it is because of the fact that there was so much pressure put on the Minister that he was afraid to put these schemes into operation. He was afraid of the opposition he would meet from his own supporters and from the members of his own Party. We are asked here to give him powers which the Land Commission have hitherto exercised, admittedly fairly.

Section 6 is really the operative section, and it is interesting to notice, first of all, the excepted matters. You have, in the first place, the determination of the individuals from whom land is to be taken. It is significant that the word "individuals" is used there. The lay commissioners will have the right to select the persons from whom land is to be taken, but the Minister will have the right to say to the lay commissioners: "I want 20,000, 30,000 or 40,000 acres in a particular county." That inevitably will mean that the men even with the £5, £10 or £15 valuation will, in certain circumstances, be interfered with. Why has the Minister inserted the word "individuals" instead of the word "land"? Surely a fairer way would be "the determination of the land to be acquired in a particular district." That has always been a matter for the discretion of the Land Commission in the past, but the Minister, naturally, when he has that phrase inserted, is thinking politically. He knew perfectly well that by taking the power to himself of selecting the individuals from whom the land is to be taken he would incur a certain amount of political disfavour for himself and his Party, and, consequently, he threw the responsibility on to the lay commissioners.

The same thing applies to the people to be selected as the allottees. The Minister has thrown that responsibility on the lay commissioners because he wants to avoid the political odium that would attach to himself or his Party if they selected wrong individuals or if the selection gave rise to discontent amongst his supporters in the country or his Party in the Dáil. This definition of duties for the lay Commissioners has been arranged with a purely political aim. All this is being done for a political purpose, and the Minister has refrained from accepting these responsibilities and this power, although he has assumed every other power hitherto exercised by the Land Commission, together with a majority of the powers exercised by the Judicial Commissioner, because he was afraid that the exercise of that power would bring a great deal of political odium on himself and his Party.

The danger I foresee, so far as those excepted matters are concerned, is that the Minister has, as I said a moment ago, the power to say to his inspectors and lay commissioners: "I want so many acres of land in a particular county." He has the power to particularise. He can say: "I want 300 acres of land in a particular townland, and I want land of a certain quality in that townland." It may and probably will happen that the only individuals in that townland who will have the land of the particular quality he wants will not be political supporters of his, but will be supporters of the Party here. There is in this power, which is given to the lay commissioners but which the Minister will really exercise, an opportunity of discriminating, and discriminating in the most flagrant manner on Party and political lines. So much for the excepted matters.

In the following sub-section the Minister assumes the most extraordinary power. He has taken the power of life and death over every action of the Land Commission. In the past those functions which the Minister is now assuming in this sub-section were exercised by the Land Commission. I think everybody will admit that even though charges of delay were made against them from time to time they exercised those functions fairly, justly and equitably. I do not imagine that the Minister, when he asked his officials to insert this particular sub-section in the Bill, embodying all these extraordinary powers, was fully aware of the extent of the responsibilities which he was assuming. I imagine that if the Minister were really aware of the extent of that responsibility he certainly would have mellowed the draftsmanship of that section somewhat.

His justification, according to his opening statement, for the action he has taken in this particular sub-section is that the Land Commission must be brought into line with every other department of Government. Surely anybody who has any knowledge of this country at all must admit that the Land Commission is called upon to deal with a special problem, a problem which is unlike in every respect the problem which any other Department of Government has to deal with; that land, after all, is the biggest and most fundamental asset we have in this State; that it is on this asset the whole credit of the State is based; that every institution in this country is interested in that particular asset— the banks, educational institutions, and all branches of the courts that there are all sorts of highly intricate, legal and technical questions arising for determination as to the relationship between the land of this country and the courts, banks, commercial houses, and even the educational institutions in this country; that even in the relationships between landlord and tenant, in the relationship especially between the tenant and the State, all sorts of difficult legal and technical questions arise. Yet the Minister in this sub-section has taken to himself power to resolve all those highly legal and highly technical questions, questions involving experience in various directions, questions involving expert knowledge, questions involving expert training. The Minister, in his humility, has assumed in this section full power and full responsibility for dealing with all those matters, problems arising out of which it has taken a considerably long time for experts to solve in the past. Yet the Minister, a layman, subject to all kinds of political influence and pressure, has taken on himself almost complete responsibility for determining all those highly intricate matters, involving, as I say, the biggest asset of the State, on which the whole credit of the State is based, and involving as well the relationship with the banks, the courts, educational institutions, commercial institutions and every institution in this country. I think every Deputy who ponders on this question for a few moments will realise the nature of the problems which arise even in determining questions between owner and tenant. Those questions have given rise to considerable delay and considerable difficulty in the past. We have also the threefold question of the State, the owner, and the tenant. Very often those questions have given rise to very considerable delay.

At all events, the point I want to make is that all those questions involve a knowledge of the law, a knowledge very often of business, involve a certain training which the Minister had not had an opportunity of getting, and involve a certain amount of experience which is in the possession only of experts. Consequently, if those questions are to be determined fairly, if they are to be determined justly as between the interests concerned, they can only be determined by an absolutely independent tribunal, which will not be susceptible in any way to outside pressure or any kind of political influence whatever. I am quite prepared to give the Minister all the administrative power he wants. If he feels at the moment that he has not adequate administrative power, I am quite prepared to give it to him, but in regard to these very highly technical, highly legal and highly specialised questions which the Minister has taken power to deal with in this particular section, I am not prepared to give it to him, for the reason that I believe if it is given to him it will not be exercised in the way it has been exercised in the past. It will not be exercised fairly, justly and equitably as between the different interests involved. This question of the jurisdiction of the Land Commissioners was raised many years ago. As a matter of fact, the British authorities themselves, at one time, considered that the Land Commissioners had too much power and too much authority. Under the Act of 1903 the Estates Commissioners were brought directly under the control of the Lord Lieutenant. They were brought directly under outside control, and, naturally, being under outside control, they were susceptible as well to outside influence. After four years' experience of that control, the British were satisfied that it was neither healthy for the Land Commission nor healthy for the Land Commissioners that they should be subject to this sort of influence, with the result that under the Evicted Tenants Act, 1907, they restored the Land Commission and the Estate Commissioners to the position which they had from the first date they were constituted, that is, a status similar to county court judges, free to exercise their functions as only judges can exercise them, free from outside influence, free from any sort of contaminating influence whatever.

I want to draw the attention of the Dáil to paragraph (b), sub-section (3), where we are told that lay commissioners are to be appointed. That lay commission has certain defined and specified functions set out in sub-section (1) of Clause 6. It is set out in sub-section (2) that the lay commissioners "shall save in relation to excepted matters act under and in accordance with the directions whether general or particular of the Minister, and the Minister shall have, and may exercise in so far as he shall think proper full and unrestricted power of regulating and controlling every and any exercise or performance by the Land Commission or of the lay commissioners (as the case may be) or any such power or duty not relating to an excepted matter and also power of reserving to himself rights of approval and disapproval or of reconsideration, revision and confirmation of every or any act of the Land Commission or the lay commissioners not relating to an excepted matter."

Surely, no Minister could ask for more autocratic powers than are asked for in this Section. These powers place him, in effect, as dictator over the Land Commission. He is created a virtual dictator by the powers which he is seeking under this Bill. In regard to the Lay Commissioners there is not a single act of theirs whether it involves a question of law or is merely a question of fact which the Minister, according to this sub-section, cannot revise, reconsider or disapprove as the case may be, and even according to paragraph (b) of sub-section (3) which gives the Minister power to arrange, classify and allocate the duties of the Lay Commissioners he has power to influence the price of land and the selection of allottees.

This paragraph has a particular bearing on the functions of the Lay Commissioner. It says: "the Minister may, if in so far as he thinks proper arrange by reference to the class or classes of case or the county or counties in which the land concerned is situated the distribution among the lay commissioners of their work in relation to the excepted matters, but not so as to allocate any particular case or land to any particular lay commissioner." Now the Minister can appoint any particular lay commissioner he likes to any particular part of the country he likes, and he can appoint any particular duty to any particular lay commissioner. So that if the Minister wants to carry out a certain political job for the purpose of pacifying a friend he can select a particular lay commissioner, send him to that particular district, knowing well that that particular lay commissioner will act according to the very definite instructions he received before he leaves Dublin. This sub-section actually gives to the Minister the right certainly indirectly to control the distribution of land in this country.

Comment on this

Had not you the same power?

Comment on this

Now we come to Section 7, but before I pass from Section 6 I just want to make this comment. I do not know who drafted this Bill but whoever it was I cannot compliment the draughtsman on his work. It is a very badly drafted Bill and particularly bad in some of its parts. There are sections complementary and explanatory of each other which are not related at all. There are other sections very badly and loosely drafted, but I submit this section is vitiated in the sense that the Minister cannot assume these extraordinary powers he is seeking without repealing certain relevant sections in the Act of 1881 and without amending in certain respects and repealing certain sections of the Land Law (Ireland) Acts and subsequent Acts. I submit only then would this Section 6 be legally watertight; as it is worded at the moment and if it is not amended it will afford plenty of employment for lawyers in interpreting its real scope and intention.

Section 7 deals with the appeal tribunal. Sub-section (1) reads: "On and after the appointed day the judicial commissioner and any two of the officers of the Land Commission for the time being nominated by the Minister under this Part of this Act to exercise and perform jurisdictions, powers and duties on his behalf shall constitute a tribunal, to be known and in this Act referred to as the appeal tribunal, to hear and determine all such applications, matters and things as are by this Act or shall hereafter be authorised to be brought before it," and sub-section (2) provides: "The Judicial Commissioner shall preside at every sitting of the Appeal Court." It is interesting to note, in this connection, that the judicial commissioner has been shorn of every one of his functions except on matters arising in connection with title and the disposal of the purchase money of estates. He cannot decide, even on questions of law, because when there comes before him in any particular case a question of law he cannot decide it unless he receives the support of one of the lay commissioners on the tribunal. In other words, he might have two lay commissioners sitting with him without any knowledge of law, yet if a question of law arises in a Land Commission case, and either of them says he does not think it is a question of law, the judicial commissioner cannot say that it is a question of law unless he gets the approval of one or other of the lay commissioners not trained in the law.

Deputies will recognise that land law is not like the ordinary law. The land court is one of exceedingly difficult practice. It is a court highly developed through years of experience, and even ordinary lawyers in the country cannot easily interpret the land code. Nobody but a most accurate lawyer, trained in that particular code, can elucidate its intricate details, yet here we have the extraordinary proposal to put men on the tribunal without any knowledge of law. If the judicial commissioner who is accustomed to handling these questions when a matter of that kind comes before him says it is a question of law, the views of the lay members of the tribunal may prevail against him. It is simply a joke. I do not suppose in any other country a member of the High Court would be placed in such a ridiculous position.

Turning now to sub-section (4) of Section 7, we find "No officer of the Land Commission shall sit or act as a member of the Appeal Tribunal to the determination of any question relating to an order or thing in the making or doing of which he took part or was concerned." That is rather an intriguing sub-section. On reading it at first, I began to wonder how many lay commissioners it was contemplated to appoint. According to the wording of the section, no Land Commissioner shall sit on a case with which he was in any way associated. Unless the administration of the Land Commission has been radically and fundamentally changed since I was there, there is scarcely a single Land Commissioner who is not brought into contact with a majority of the cases passing through that office. But yet because he is associated with the case in any way whatever he is not allowed to act as a member of the appeal tribunal. The obvious inference is that for everyone of these cases they are going to bring in outsiders. There will be special lay commissioners appointed at a high fee. Lawyers can hold their heads high in future, because they see here an opportunity of really high rewards in the administration of this Bill. The obvious interpretation seems to be that two outsiders will be brought in to preside with the judicial commissioner in order to deal with, probably, a simple case, and a Land Commissioner will not be allowed to be associated with the tribunal because, probably, he will have signed a simple note or some paper relating to the case. Surely the thing is farcical.

I pass over the funding sections for the moment, and I come to Section 27. The Minister referred to the inclusion of this section in the Bill with a certain air of triumph. One would imagine that he was the author of it himself. He tried to convey to the Dáil, in his reference to it in his introductory statement, that it was the last word in achievement for the tenant farmers. I want to remind the Minister that four years ago this particular proposal was under consideration in the Land Commission, and I turned it down. Again, it was submitted to me for approval before the Act of 1931 was introduced, and again I turned it down. I was advised, for one thing, that it was unconstitutional, but I turned it down primarily because I considered it was a most inhuman clause to insert in any Land Act. The Minister seems to think that this clause is going to lessen the costs on the unfortunate defaulter. I do not believe that for a moment. This question was investigated exhaustively by the Committee set up to examine the working of the Courts of Justice Act. There were some very clever lawyers on that Committee, including certain legal members of the Minister's own Party. The case, as I say, was examined exhaustively and, in the end, they turned it down in fact, because their recommendation was somewhat to this effect, that the Minister should take some steps for the purpose of reducing the costs to unfortunate defaulters in respect of Land Commission decrees.

Comment on this

It was the lawyers turned it down.

Comment on this

That proposal was turned down by the expert Committee set up to investigate the working of the Courts of Justice Act. It was also turned down several times in the Land Commission. Now the Minister comes along with an air of triumph thinking he has discovered something new to insert in this Bill. I do not believe that this section will reduce the expenses of the unfortunate defaulter in any way whatsoever. I am inclined to think, on the other hand, that it may have the effect of increasing the expenses. This is a terribly drastic power to give to any official in any Department of the Government. Somewhat similar powers have been given under previous Acts, but so far no official of any Government Department has been given such drastic power as the Minister proposes to give to the Secretary of the Land Commission, I presume, under this particular section. What are the circumstances at present? It is admitted that the fact of a case being heard in court will mean a certain amount of costs and there is no doubt about that. But there is one thing—the court in any event can give time to the unfortunate defaulter. The county registrar or the sheriff has no power whatever to give time to him. How will this section work out in actual practice? I do not believe for a moment that the defaulter will be in a position to pay and he will run the risk of a seizure with perfect equanimity. However, assuming that he has anything to sell by the time this section is in operation, what will he do? Rather than run the risk of the execution of this warrant, he will take a beast or a pig or a sheep to the fair and sell it— at what? Probably one-third of its value, in order to realise sufficient money to cover the amount of the warrant. Will that unfortunate defaulter not lose much more by that transaction than if he had to meet the costs of the decree granted by the court?

The State solicitors in the past made matters very easy for the defaulters. They knew the local circumstances intimately and the capacity of the majority of the defaulters to meet their liabilities, and they accepted payments from them on the instalment system, they accepted whatever amount they were in a position to pay. The system worked out quite admirably and, so far as I am aware, it was quite satisfactory even from the Land Commission point of view. But the State solicitors are to be wiped out. The sheriffs and the county registrars are to be given complete control. They are to rush out the moment they get the warrant and seize whatever stock they can find on the holding if the defaulter is not in a position to meet the claim; and then, having left him penniless and, probably, hopeless and helpless, they will report back to the Minister that they have realised the amount of the warrant. Surely the tenant farmers of the country expect something better than that from a Christian social Government with pretensions to such a high ethical tone in matters of legislation and in matters of morals as well?

Comment on this

Cannot every rate collector do that at present?

Comment on this

He does not do it and the Deputy knows that well. He never does it. He goes to the court in every case. In any event, the county registrars and sheriffs will tell you that it is quite impossible to levy decrees at present. If they did attempt to levy them, it is impossible to realise anything on them. Quite recently in a certain county a sheriff went to levy some hundreds of decrees and after a whole week came back with £17.

Comment on this

He was lucky.

Comment on this

And this is the time selected by the Minister to introduce a drastic proposal of this kind! I shall deal with Section 28 very briefly as it has been dealt with rather exhaustively by previous speakers. Deputy McGovern retailed some of his experiences with advisers as to the meaning and interpretation of this section. I happened to discuss it with a friend of mine down in the country on Sunday and I asked him what he thought of its meaning. He studied it for some time and then said, "It appears to me that it is a land-grabbing-made-easy section."

This section is undoubtedly the most dangerous section in the Bill. It does destroy the security which the farmer enjoys in his land at present. After all, in interpreting this section you have to relate it to Section 31. The Minister in this section is taking the widest possible power for the purpose of enabling him to deal with this problem of congestion. At the very outside I should like to know from the Minister if he has formed any estimate as to what the cost will be to the State of the operation of this section and the following sections relating to the relief of congestion in this country. We have no Land Bond Bill to guide us and there is no financial section in this Bill to give us any indication of what is going to be the amount involved in the issue of Land Bonds, the rate of interest or anything else. I hope that the Minister, in his reply, will give us some indication as to what amount of money is involved in these sections relating to the problem of congestion.

This section repeals every safeguarding sub-section in the parent Act of 1923. Sub-section (4) of Section 24 of the Land Act of 1923 is repealed, and "in lieu thereof it is hereby enacted that where the Land Commission declare that any land (in this section referred to as the declared land) coming within clause (a) of sub-section (2) of the said section 24 is required for the purpose of relieving congestion, the Land Commission shall, if within the prescribed time and in the prescribed manner the proprietor or tenant of the declared land requires them so to do, provide such proprietor or tenant as soon as practicable with a new holding which the lay commissioners (subject to a right of appeal to the Appeal Tribunal, whose decision shall be final) consider to be of not less market value than the declared land." I observe that the Minister has departed widely from the parent Act. The Minister says: "Of not less than the market value." In the original Act it says that the holding "shall be equally suitable and of not less value than the declared land." The Minister merely says that the land shall not be of less value than the market value of the declared land. What is market value at the present time? There is no market value for land in many parts of this country to-day, and if the Minister does provide one of these migrants with a holding in some district where there is no such market value for land, on what basis will he compute the value? Will he go back to what is called Land Commission value, which is mentioned in the Act of 1923, and in every subsequent Act? Market value is a very variable thing to-day and, as I say, it does not exist in many parts of the country. I think it was an unfortunate expression to introduce into this section of the Bill.

Under this section every registered holding on which there is not a residence can be acquired by the Minister for the purpose of dealing with this problem of congestion. Every single holding on which there is not a residence can be acquired by the Minister no matter what is the size of the holding, no matter what its area is or no matter what are the peculiar circumstances relating to it. There are many small farmers in the West of Ireland who, perhaps, live on a registered holding of, let us say, three Irish acres and who have two or possibly three other holdings for which they hold separate receivable orders. Under this section of the Bill the Minister, according to my interpretation of it, can acquire these holdings although the total area of the four holdings may not amount to 25 or 30 acres. According to this section of the Bill three of these holdings are not residential and can be acquired by the Minister.

Comment on this
Conor Alexander Maguire The Attorney-General (Mr. Conor Maguire) Fianna Fáil

Could not the Minister have acquired them under the 1923 Act?

Comment on this

Not at all.

Comment on this
The Attorney-General

The Deputy cannot have read the Act.

Comment on this

Let the Attorney-General quote me what section of the Act. Again, take the case of a small country publican whose premises, let us say, are built on a holding of two or three Irish acres. He may have two outside holdings, non-residential, but equally small in area. Under this section of the Bill the Minister can acquire these holdings for the purpose of relieving congestion. He can acquire every unoccupied holding in any part of the country. Every western Deputy knows that many farmers have three or four small holdings for which there are three or four receivable orders, and yet the Minister can acquire them even though the area of the total holdings may not amount to ten acres of land. That is an extraordinary power, and yet the Minister for Justice waxed indignant the other day because Deputy Dillon said that the Bill interfered with fixity of tenure. Surely there is nothing that interferes more with the security the tenant farmer enjoys at the moment than this power of the Minister.

Comment on this
Frank Aiken Minister for Defence (Mr. Aiken) Fianna Fáil

Unless what you did in the 1923 Act.

Comment on this

We heard a great deal in the past about the three F's but certainly this section completely removes two of the three F's, and I am not so sure but that the funding section removes the third F as well.

Comment on this

If you had all those powers what do you want them again for?

Comment on this
A Deputy

The Parliamentary Secretary says he has not the powers.

Comment on this

We come now to the clause which says: "that he or his wife must reside on the declared land and that he or she uses such land in the same manner as an ordinary farmer in accordance with proper methods of husbandry." Will the interpretation of the phrase "proper methods of husbandry" be accepted as a fact or is the Minister, by virtue of the new and extraordinary powers he is seeking under this Bill, going to put a new interpretation on it? Will the new interpretation of it be that every farmer must grow a certain area of wheat, be it large or small—the Minister for Agriculture may vary it slightly and introduce something else for the sake of making it novel—but in any event is it to be accepted as a question of fact or is it to be a matter for the Minister to determine what are proper methods of husbandry? If the Minister proposes to set aside the interpretation given by the Land Commission in dealing with such matters in the past then we should have that new interpretation embodied in the Bill.

There is another matter which I consider of importance. The Minister, having taken all these outlying small holdings and utilised them for the relief of congestion need not give the owner its equivalent immediately. The section says that he shall give it "as soon as practicable." What exactly does that mean? I admit that these words are in the Act of 1923, but no tenant was ever removed out of a holding under the 1923 Act until the other holding was ready for his occupation. The Minister has told us that he is most anxious to speed up the acquisition of land for the purpose of relieving congestion. Does "as soon as practicable" get the same interpretation as these words have got in the past or will the unfortunate tenant have to wait until such time as it pleases the Minister to provide him with a new holding and, if he has to wait until such time, how is he going to exist in the meantime? He is deprived of his holding. He is deprived of his money and has not got a new holding. How will he exist in the meantime? Is he to apply to the board of health for home assistance? Will the Minister suggest he ought to go on the dole?

Comment on this

I will tell you about it in a minute.

Comment on this

This section raises a very interesting point. It says here that nobody can hold more land than £2,000 worth in value. We will assume that a man who has a holding of land value for £2,000 realises an income of £100 a year from that land. After all, I think he would be a very fortunate farmer under the present circumstances who could realise an income of £100 a year out of such a farm. Are we then to take it as the declared policy of the Government that no farmer is to hold a farm that will yield him more than £100 a year? Are we to assume that the possessor of any farm is not to have an income of more than £100 a year? That in effect is what this Bill states. It seems extraordinary on the face of it. I now pass on to Section 29, and I only wish to raise one point in connection with it. Is the annuity to start from the appointed day or from the day on which the price of the land is finally determined? Section 31 is complementary to Section 28, because it gives the Minister extraordinary powers. We will have an opportunity of dealing with that more exhaustively on the Committee Stage.

There is just Section 43 to which I wish to refer. That section relates to the acquisition of bogs. I was always under the impression that bogs could only be acquired by the Land Commission for the purpose of providing turbary for the convenience of their own tenants. Here we have a section introduced for the purpose of enabling the Minister for Industry and Commerce to acquire bogs for the purpose of carrying out certain experiments under this Department. It appears to me that such a section should never be incorporated in a Land Bill, because the purpose for which this section is to be used goes completely outside the land code altogether. If the Minister wants to acquire a bog in any part of this country, he should be prepared to pay the owner of the bog a commercial price for it and not be empowered to obtain that bog at Land Commission value.

This appears to me to be purely a commercial matter and has no relation whatever to the ordinary purposes of a Land Bill and consequently should not be incorporated in this Bill at all. It appears to me that if the Minister wants to take a bog in any part of the country he should acquire it by some other means and not through the medium of a Land Bill. In conclusion I want to say that this Land Bill throws the whole land code into the melting pot again. This Bill on the face of it bears evidence of the fact that it is only the first instalment of Fianna Fáil land legislation. If we are to take this as a sample. I think Deputies can quite easily visualise what the future instalments will be like. In my opinion this is a most dangerous Bill. It will do incalculable harm in the country and will do more to bring the Fianna Fáil Party into disrepute than any other Bill they have introduced here.

Comment on this
The Attorney-General

I am surprised the Deputy who has just spoken has joined in what seems to me a campaign due to a complete lack of appreciation of the provision of land legislation as it existed up to this, or that it is a deliberate determination to run a political ramp on this Bill. Deputy Hogan opened the attack. He charged us with introducing a Bill which was solely a political measure designed to benefit our political friends. Deputy Hogan, I think, must himself appreciate more than anybody else the difficulty of introducing satisfactory legislation to deal with the land problem in this country. I consider that his speech which was delivered on this Bill—the opening speech of the Opposition—was from the very beginning to the end a dishonest speech. Deputy Hogan himself was responsible for the Land Act of 1923. Deputy Roddy administered the Land Act during the years which preceded the handing over of the reins of office to this Government, and he ought to know perfectly well the problems with the proper solution of which those concerned with the Department of Lands and Fisheries have been faced, problems some of which remain undealt with in earlier legislation and some of which grew out of the 1923 Act itself.

I do not think Deputy Hogan went to the same lengths as the ex-Parliamentary Secretary for Lands and Fisheries. He joined in the ramp started by the Farmers' Party on this question of security of tenure. He referred again to the three F's and the suggestion that this Bill according to its critics is now endangering something which has remained fixed and permanent up to the present. I think the Deputy who went farthest along that line was Deputy Dillon. Some time ago I heard that when Deputy Dillon fought his first election campaign in Donegal in 1932 he fought it on the Home Rule Act of 1913. Apparently he is going to try to run his next election on the Land Act of 1881. Deputy Dillon in the course of his speech called upon me several times to explain this, that and the other point in the Bill. As second in command, or perhaps I should say as one of the twin leaders of the Centre Party, I think Deputy Dillon owes it to the House that he should have made himself more familiar with land legislation before he delivered his philippic in this House. The Farmers' Party always prided themselves on the fact that they do not indulge in the irresponsible criticism that we so often hear from our friends opposite without considering its effect upon the general community. I submit that it is a very serious thing for a Deputy in the position of Deputy Dillon to indulge in an attack which can only have been based either on failure to understand the provisions of the legislation which has gone before this Bill or with the deliberate intention of ignoring them and engaging in the general policy of panic-mongering which was started by Deputy Hogan. If Deputy Dillon and the last Deputy who spoke had made themselves familiar with the history of land legislation in this country they would have known quite well that the three F's as such were buried fathoms deep under Section 24 of the Land Act of 1923.

Comment on this

They were not.

Comment on this
The Attorney-General

If the Deputy still persists in saying that, I can only say that it is my opinion and he can familiarise himself with the provisions of the Land Act through others who are familiar with those provisions, if he doubts what I say.

Comment on this

What is to become of the phrase "shall be equally suitable for the said proprietor"?

Comment on this
The Attorney-General

That is another hare. We will deal with that here later on.

Comment on this
The Attorney-General

I am not going to leave the particular hare I am following at the moment. The three Fs, fixity of tenure, free sale, and fair rent were, of course, the creation of the 1881 Act. Much water has flowed under the bridges since then; many Acts have been passed, and if Deputy Dillon wants a slight sketch of the history of land legislation and the revolution effected by Section 24 of the 1923 Act he will get it in Deputy Roddy's speech when introducing the Land Act of 1931. It hardly needs statement, I think, that the protection given by the 1881 Act to tenanted land disappeared under Section 24 of the 1923 Act. Anybody who happened to be a tenant at that time came under the jurisdiction of the Land Commission and his land could be acquired without any obligation to provide him with an alternative holding. Does the Deputy challenge that statement?

Comment on this

Yes, I do challenge it.

Comment on this
The Attorney-General

If that is so, where was the fixity of tenure? I will refer Deputy Dillon to discussions on the Bill. If he cares to trace the course of that Bill, as I have done, through the two Houses, he will find that Deputy Hogan refused point blank to give any consideration to a proposal that a tenant of land should be given an alternative holding and he confined any protection which he gave to the owner of a registered holding, a purchased holder.

Comment on this

Which was secured—that is exactly what I referred to.

Comment on this
The Attorney-General

Then I was under the delusion that Deputy Dillon understood the words he was using.

Comment on this

The people of this country will understand them.

Comment on this
The Attorney-General

I am offering all this as a serious criticism of what the Deputy said. I do think it is a shame that a campaign should be started suggesting that we are doing something radical and revolutionary and that people should be mis-describing what is being done by this Bill, altogether overlooking the fact that what we are doing is bringing to its logical conclusion the work started under previous Land Acts and brought to a stage, under the 1923 Act, which it previously had not reached.

Comment on this

Does the Attorney-General deny that under the terms of this Bill every tenant farmer, whether he holds five or 500 acres is liable to have his holding taken from him and an offer made to him of land of equal market value wherever the Minister for Lands or the lay commissioner chooses to offer it to him?

Comment on this
The Attorney-General

It seems to me the Deputy will have to clear his mind or else have to be clear as to the correct use of words. He asks me whether a tenant of land——

Comment on this

I said a tenant farmer, a man who bought his land under the Land Purchase Acts between 1885 and 1923.

Comment on this
The Attorney-General

A purchasing tenant.

Comment on this

Yes, commonly called, in this country, a tenant farmer.

Comment on this

In the Bill before the House a purchasing tenant, if he works his land in a workmanlike manner—I intended to deal with the wording of the section which has been commented upon by the last speaker. That very wording is taken from Section 44 of the Land Act of 1931.

Comment on this

You will get it earlier. Get the Land Act of 1927, Section 11.

Comment on this
The Attorney-General

I thank the Deputy. The interruptions and the laughter from the Opposition Benches are shown to be very much out of place or, shall we say, premature. As regards the Land Act of 1923—

Comment on this

The Attorney-General did not complete his sentence. He said the tenant farmer, if he worked his land in a proper, businesslike manner... What then?

Comment on this
The Attorney-General

If his land is under £2,000 in value he is entitled to a holding of equal value elsewhere.

Comment on this
The Attorney-General

Under the 1923 Act where was he to get it but elsewhere?

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

He could not have it in the same place.

Comment on this

He was to get land where it would be "equally suitable for the said proprietor".

Comment on this

But it was elsewhere all the same.

Comment on this

"Equally suitable for the said proprietor"—what is to become of those words?

Comment on this
The Attorney-General

The Deputy misunderstands me. He thinks I am not going to admit, but I do admit, that the section in this Bill is a considerable advance upon that.

Comment on this
The Attorney-General

The very point which the Deputy has made, is, I am informed, one of the very reasons why the purpose which Deputy Hogan told the Dáil and Seanad in 1923 that he had in mind has failed of attainment. Deputy Hogan told the Dáil and Seanad that the purpose of the Land Act was then to provide land for 100,000 congests and after that, to deal with evicted tenants and, subsequently, landless men. I do not know whether I have taken too much on myself if I tell the House that that is the purpose of this Bill. I have the report of the discussion in the Seanad here.

Comment on this

Read it out for us; it is very interesting.

Comment on this
The Attorney-General

I will leave that to the Deputy. Apparently there is something interesting in it from his point of view. I will refer to a portion of it later and, perhaps, a good deal more when we come to the Committee Stage. A great deal of this discussion is appropriate to the Committee Stage.

Comment on this

The Attorney-General will read it when he has time to think it over.

Comment on this
The Attorney-General

Deputy Hogan told the Seanad that he intended to deal radically once and for all with congestion and there were 100,000 congests. I make bold to say that not a tithe of the 100,000 congests have been dealt with since the Bill was passed, and the phrase upon which the Deputy laid his finger has to be got rid of, and I am sure Deputy Roddy will admit it will have to be got rid of, in order to enable the object of the Bill to be carried through. That is why that particular amendment comes in. This Bill in a sense goes very little further than the Act of 1923. In principle the objects which are sought to be attained are the same; the principles underlying the Bill are substantially the same. The same inspiration is there to deal with the problem of congestion first, to deal with the evicted tenants second, and the landless men third.

Comment on this

Would the Attorney-General say under what section the evicted tenants are covered?

Comment on this
The Attorney-General

Evicted tenants are described by Deputy Hogan as landless men. I repeat again that criticism of this Bill on the grounds that it is an attack on security of tenure is unjustified. The powers which are being taken here are being taken because the efforts of the Government to deal with land distribution and with the establishment of peasant proprietorship on the land have failed of attainment because of certain restrictions of the legislation as it now stands. If Deputies will look at the 1923 Seanad Debates they will see that practically word for word the same criticisms are levelled against this Bill as were then levelled against Deputy Hogan and his Bill. In the Seanad he had to meet the criticisms of Sir John Keane and Senator Bagwell. He was told that the security of the small tenants had disappeared. At that time it was the Seanad who were so interested in the small tenants——

Comment on this

Do not forget Colonel Moore, the Fianna Fáil Senator.

Comment on this
The Attorney-General

Apparently Deputy Hogan did not listen to Colonel Moore any more than to any of the others. In 1923 Deputy Hogan had to deal with the suggestion that the Bill created general insecurity. He says in column 1777 of the Seanad Debates "Senators are quite sure that the provisions in the Bill are going to lead to general insecurity. You can be far more certain that you cannot deal with congestion, and that you are only playing with congestion if you do not give the Land Commission power to take purchased holdings in certain cases."

Comment on this

Yes, "in certain cases".

Comment on this

We are only taking them in certain cases also. We are extending the number of cases I quite admit. Deputy Hogan goes on to say: "The Government realise fully the seriousness of re-opening the operations completed under the 1903 and 1909 Acts. We know it is a serious thing for the State to give a holding, and then to come afterwards and take it back. That can only be justified by very serious reasons, and should only be given to the Land Commission under very definite safeguards."

Comment on this
Deputies

Hear, hear!

Comment on this
The Attorney-General

We are giving the safeguards which we consider adequate, and which will allow us to carry out the work which Deputy Hogan laid before himself and failed to carry out. "To meet the case of the general insecurity"— Deputy Hogan was forced to deal with the suggestion of general insecurity—"the case put up that small purchased tenants all over the country are at present trembling in their shoes for fear we are going to take their holdings, I had thought of putting in some maximum". That is the very same case which is being put up to-day, that the small tenants are trembling in their shoes for fear we are going to take their holdings. "There are 13,000,000 acres of land purchased out of a total acreage of 20,000,000, including towns, waterways, bogs, etc., and I should say that nearly 75 per cent. of that area represents holdings under £25 valuation. Does anybody suggest that any of these tenant purchasers of £20 or thereabouts valuation are really trembling about this Bill and the prospect of the Land Commission taking their land? There is no use talking about general insecurity." That is what Deputy Hogan said in 1923. The suggestion now is that we are going to do what it was suggested Deputy Hogan would do under the 1923 Act.

Comment on this

You are repealing Section 24 of that Act.

Comment on this

The Land Commission was a very respectable institution at that time. What will it be when this Bill passes?

Comment on this
The Attorney-General

The Deputy interrupted me at a most appropriate moment. I will read what Deputy Hogan said about the Land Commission in 1923: "I have not the slightest doubt myself, no matter what Government is in power, that the Land Commission will carry out its duties as impartially in the future as in the past." Of course, when a new Government comes into office that tune is changed.

Comment on this

The Land Commission has no power under this Bill.

Comment on this
The Attorney-General

The Land Commission has been attacked. Suggestions have been made against it. Suggestions have been made that they will be puppets in the hands of the Minister; that they will not carry out their duties impartially in the future as in the past. What are the grounds for that suggestion? I understood Deputy Costello to say here in the debate that the very powers we are taking under Section 6 we already have.

Comment on this

You did not understand him aright.

Comment on this
The Attorney-General

I suggest that I certainly did understand him. It is almost sufficient to leave one speaker in the Opposition to deal with the others. We had, I think it was, Deputy Lynch waxing eloquent about the unheard of proposal to give the Minister the control which it is proposed to give him under this Bill, and then we have Deputy Costello apparently holding the view that we had power under the Land Law (Commission) Act, 1923, that the Minister had control, as Deputy Roddy knows he had, and as Deputy Roddy was in a position to exercise over the Land Commission. In fact, under Section 6, which has been so much criticised, we are going to give the Land Commission powers which they had not got before. In dealing with individual farmers, individual tenants, and persons from whom land was taken we are specifically providing in this Bill that they are to be safeguarded. Deputy Roddy a moment ago was dealing with the extraordinary powers given to the Minister. I certainly gave Depuy Roddy credit for knowing more about land law than he showed in his speech. He had brought to his attention on several occasions the power of direct control under that section. That is what was at the back of Deputy Costello's mind when he asked the question I referred to. If we are to take Deputy Costello's view about the Bill we are introducing it is taking power out of the Minister's hands and giving the Commissioners the right to have complete control in matters which were previously controlled by the Minister.

Comment on this

Subject to appeal to the new tribunal—that independent body.

Comment on this
The Attorney-General

Perhaps I might make the matter clear to Deputy Dillon, unless he has spent his week-end making himself up on these matters. Under Section 24 of the Act of 1923, as was pointed out, landlordism disappeared, and the Act of 1881 and the three F's went with it. Under Sections 28 and 29 dealing with tenanted and retained holdings, the Land Commission have power over all tenants, and Deputy Hogan refused point blank to give the tenant who had not bought out any rights or claims similar to those which he gave to the purchased tenant.

Comment on this

I am talking of purchased tenants.

Comment on this
The Attorney-General

That should have been made clear. I cannot see what case can be made against Section 28 of this Bill. In any one district you may find a man occupying a purchased holding not working it in a husband-like manner. Opposite him you may have a man who got his rent fixed under the Land Act of 1881, and under the provisions of the Act of 1923 the man with rights conferred upon him by the Act of 1881 may have his holding taken from him and distributed, while the man opposite goes off scot free. That is not justifiable, and we are altering that state of things and giving rights to people who work the land in a husband-like manner. If there was land enough to go round, and if it were possible to do what Deputy Dillon says he would wish to see, if it was possible to give a man with a fair rent fixed upon his holding and working in a husband-like manner and, also, to a man who purchased out under previous Acts more land elsewhere I would not be opposed to it. I quite agree that that would be an eminently desirable thing and everyone would agree. But if it is found in practice that after the work Deputy Hogan described, that it is not possible to provide sufficient land to relieve congestion, not alone in the West but all over the country, and if that has to be done in the way in which legislation intended it should be done, then the privilege and protection given to those persons brought in under the earlier Acts must be modified. We have modified that, so far as we think reasonable, having always in the forefront of our minds the object of land legislation, and particularly that attempted by Deputy Hogan in the Land Act of 1923 of dealing with congested problems and restoring evicted tenants. If these objects are to be achieved we find, and we believe it has been found in practice, that these restrictions imposed by the Land Act of 1923 must be modified. We have modified them.

Now, it is a strange thing, before even this Bill saw the light, the Irish Times published a leading article dealing with the Bill entitled “This Lets in the Jungle.” Of course, the native Irish getting back to the land were comparable, in the eyes of the Irish Times, to the wild beasts from the jungle. On the other hand, the more astute Independent waited, and for some strange reason, especially when one hears what is being said from the opposite side of the House about the Bill, they described it as a moderate Bill. Deputy O'Donovan of the Farmers' Party a few nights ago made an impressive speech on this Bill. He said in normal times something like this Bill would have to be introduced. He agrees, apparently, that a problem has to be dealt with and that it must be dealt with at some time in this country, but, for some reason that I could not follow, he thinks this is not the appropriate time to deal with it.

I have been interested in the distribution of land for a number of years, and I have had close contact with it from different points of view. I was in charge of the land settlements commission under the first Dáil. Deputy O'Sullivan, speaking the other night, paid a tribute to Sinn Féin in 1920, for the manner in which it dealt with the land agitation which grew up all over the country and threatened to spread chaos. He said that the Sinn Féin Party of that day won support in the manner in which they tackled that agitation. I think I may claim some part of the credit for that. I was in the centre of the disturbance. It was at a time when land values were rising rapidly and a land agitation broke out and spread rapidly. Some of us approached Arthur Griffith and asked him to set up an arbitration court under the Dáil to deal with the situation. As is well known, we had a very great difficulty in dealing with the matter, but with the assistance of the I.R.A.— and sufficient credit has not been given to them for the part they took in this matter—we were able to get that agitation completely under control. I remember myself being involved in cases in which some of the young fellows of the I.R.A. had to go in and arrest some of their own relations and take them away to an unknown destination in order to stay the fury of that agitation in one place. The reason that we were able to hold the agitation, at that time, was because a promise was made that as soon as possible, and as far as possible, that matter would be dealt with and the problem would be tackled as a national problem. Anyone who has any knowledge will agree that the great trouble with land legislation is that it is generally the fruit of agitation. A Government sits idly by and then suddenly great agitation breaks out, and the Government rushes in to deal with it by hurried legislation. I think this is the most appropriate time to deal with it. We have studied the problem and we have observed the working of the various Acts and the objections that may be made to the Act of 1923; and this is the time we believe to calmly and dispassionately try to carry out the views of those who believed the land problems should be solved in a national way. To harken back to what Deputy O'Donovan said if he agrees, and apparently he does agree, that there should be a change——

Comment on this
The Attorney-General

His Leader was not here to check him upon that occasion.

Comment on this

Perhaps the Attorney-General would quote his speech.

Comment on this
The Attorney-General

I submit to the House that in all the circumstances this is the proper time for tackling this great question. Under the Bill as a whole, as under the 1923 Act, as explained by Deputy Hogan when piloting the Bill through the Seanad amid fierce opposition, opposition which came from a different section, but which was precisely to the same effect, the same words being used as are being used now by the Opposition here, the handling of the land problem is, to a large extent, the work of the Land Commission. The Land Commission are charged with the administration of land purchase. The Land Commission have their officers, who are familiar with the difficulties which have arisen and with the objective which is being aimed at. In order to enable them to carry out the work unhampered, we have taken these powers.

I think it is the most outrageous statement for Deputy Hogan to make that this Bill takes us back to 1881 instead of being, as I regard it, the logical completion of all that Deputy Hogan aimed at and specifically stated he aimed at. It is the logical development that legislation along these lines would have to be introduced in order to carry out the aim which Deputy Hogan, as I say, stated that he was aiming at in the 1923 Act. After all, the basis of all recent land legislation has been to establish persons in economic holdings. The aim is, as far as is possible, to provide economic holdings for the congests in congested areas; as far as it is possible to restore the evicted tenants; as far as it is considered prudent and possible to give the land to landless men. How Deputy Hogan can suggest that that in any way is calculated to reproduce the conditions which existed here prior to 1881 I do not know. Peasant proprietors established upon the land, we believe, as has been stated by several people before us, and as was stated by Deputy Dillon's own father on many occasions, is the best thing one can hope to see.

Comment on this

You are wiping it all out by this Bill.

Comment on this
The Attorney-General

Apparently it is impossible to convince the Deputy.

Comment on this

I asked the Attorney-General a question and he did not answer. I ask him again: Under this Bill, has the Land Commission, under the direction of the Minister, any right to take a farm off any purchased tenant in this country and offer him land of equal value, without any regard to the suitability, in exchange therefor? Can they not according to the law, take that farm of a purchased tenant in Mayo and offer him land at equal value in County Cork? Can they or can they not?

Comment on this
The Attorney-General

In the first place, I will make the reply made by Deputy Hogan, that 75 per cent. of the purchased tenants are under £25 valuation. I do not think it can reasonably be suggested that there is any intention whatever of depriving them of their land.

Comment on this

Can they do it?

Comment on this
The Attorney-General

I shall answer the question in a moment. Is the suggestion of the Deputy the same suggestion as was made by the Senators, who were so interested in the small men in 1923, that it is proposed in the Bill to take land from a man in County Galway or County Mayo and give him land in County Cork?

Comment on this

I will make suggestions as I think necessary when the section comes to be discussed. The Attorney-General has invited questions to clarify the issue. If I ask him now, will he answer "yes" or "no" to the question I put to him? If he answers honestly he must answer "yes" and he knows it.

Comment on this
The Attorney-General

I am not burking the question. The answer is "yes", and the answer is "yes" under the 1923 Act.

Comment on this

Yes.

Comment on this
The Attorney-General

Of course it is.

Comment on this

What is the necessity for this then?

Comment on this

It is not the answer under the 1923 Act and the Attorney-General knows it is not the answer.

Comment on this
The Attorney-General

Under the 1923 Act, a holding could be taken from any small tenant and land be offered to him equally suitable.

Comment on this

"Equally suitable".

Comment on this
The Attorney-General

If I do not carry the Deputy with me on this aspect of the matter I can see that it is hopeless to attempt to convince him. I am pointing out to him this fact: Deputy Hogan with great hesitation, with many apologies, interfered with the position of these under the 1903 and 1909 Acts. He said he did it because it was necessary that the problem of congestion should be dealt with. He said he did it because there were 100,000 congests to be provided for. Having done so, we have seen the working of this Act for ten years, and we are now in a position to tell the Deputy that the words upon which he is placing so much reliance have rendered, to a great extent, the section which Deputy Hogan brought in to carry out the object I have mentioned quite a dead letter. Unless the Deputy suggests that we should abandon the task altogether of relieving congestion and put up our hands and say: "We will not solve the question; we will not deal with these people; we cannot deal with them, because there are people who have such sacred rights that we cannot touch them"—unless we are prepared to take that attitude we must cut down the protection given to the purchased tenants.

Comment on this

Have you not 250,000 acres of land at present on hands?

Comment on this

That is Deputy Roddy's fiction and it is all wrong.

Comment on this

These are the Minister's figures in reply to my question.

Comment on this
The Attorney-General

So far as I can see, I have advanced the reasons which induced the Government to cut down the protection given to the purchased tenants.

Comment on this

There are 250,000 acres on your hands.

Comment on this
The Attorney-General

We are going a step farther. We are allowing the land to be acquired for any of the purposes described in Section 31 of the Land Act of 1923. Again in the 1923 Act, as I read it, the Land Commission had power to take land from any judicial or other tenant and give it to any person there described. So that we are only extending the powers to a certain extent. Again, in the discussion on the 1923 Act, Deputy Hogan pointed out that would happen. The Deputy well realised that that is what must happen where he has a certain amount of congests to deal with. He takes up purchased land from a man on the plea that it is required for the relief of congestion. He finds that, either from local opposition, or from the fact that the number of congests to be provided for are so much smaller than the land will enable him to provide holdings for, he has to give the land to landless men. That is what was going on under Deputy Roddy's administration; that landless men were provided for on holdings which had been acquired on the certificate that they were required for the relief of congestion. It was pointed out by Deputy Hogan himself when he was introducing the Act that that situation would arise. That situation has arisen and in several cases the lands which the Deputy referred to were handed out to landless men. We are taking powers under this Bill to do what apparently has been forced upon the Land Commission owing to the difficult circumstances to which they have often to face up. So much for the interference with the security.

Comment on this

Is that to be stopped now? You are only going to deal with congests? Is it proposed under this not to deal with landless men until all the congests have been supplied with land?

Comment on this
The Attorney-General

That is a matter of policy for the Minister and not for me at the present moment.

Comment on this

Has the Attorney-General any view upon it?

Comment on this
The Attorney-General

I have already made my views clear.

Comment on this

I do not think so.

Comment on this
The Attorney-General

The suggestion is that the whole administration of the Land Commission is to be diverted to a wholly new purpose, and that we are going to use the machinery for political purposes. That is the suggestion. The same suggestion could have been made, and the same suggestion was made, in 1923. Here on a Bill where we are actually limiting the rights of interference of the Minister, that charge is being persisted in. The Land Commission, which Deputy Hogan complimented in 1923 as an impartial body which would, as he said, under any Government act impartially, are now being told that they would be ready to do the bidding of whatever Party is in power. I do not know what inspired such criticism. One feels rather odd about it, and one cannot help feeling that the Deputies who make that criticism must have indulged in something like that themselves.

There are one or two other aspects of the Bill with which I should deal, perhaps, as they have been referred to. One is the question of the appeal tribunal. I suppose it will be more fully dealt with in Committee. Deputy Costello threw out the suggestion to me that I advised that this appeal tribunal was unconstitutional. I have not so advised. He also asked me if I had read carefully the judgment in Lynham v. Butler. I have read it carefully, and I think the judgment, so far as I understand it, suggests that the courts are not taking the extraordinary view that a good many people suggested they would take about the delegation of the task of inquiring in a judicial way into problems delegated to the Land Commission. I have the report here, and throughout the report —and particularly in Mr. Justice Johnson's judgment, where he elaborately reviews the whole history of land legislation—it becomes apparent that most of the functions of the Land Commission—practically all of them—are administrative. In the very opening words of his judgment he says: "The task of carrying out the code is primarily and essentially the administration of them for the purpose of carrying out a great social work of the highest importance." In the closing words of the judgment he says:

"The work of carrying out the land purchase code, especially since the passing of the new legislation, is an administrative task of national importance and of colossal magnitude. It was begun 60 years ago, and was in active progress at the very moment when the Constitution was being framed and in the full view of the constitution-makers. The work could only be carried out by an administrative body consisting of men of wisdom"—

I suppose that even that will not be admitted by the Deputies opposite—

"equipped with the most complete knowledge of the agrarian and social conditions of this country and actuated by an absolute determination that every citizen and every class of citizen should get fair play and honest treatment."

I suppose it is questioned by the Deputies opposite that that now applies to the Land Commission.

"As part of the procedure, it was necessary that there should be some machinery for the ‘ascertainment' of the lands to which the Acts applied and the Legislature has declared that this ‘ascertainment,' being part of the whole work of administration, must necessarily be left in the hands of the body or tribunal which was constituted to perform the entire task."

I should have said that the body referred to were the Land Commissioners other than the Judicial Commissioner. He goes on to say:

"I do not think that any other course was possible, and I am absolutely satisfied that such ‘ascertainment' of the land is not in any sense an exercise of judicial power within the meaning of Article 64 of the Constitution. Any other result would have a most paralysing effect upon the whole work of the Land Commission. The repercussions of a decision in favour of the appellant would extend to every branch and every Department of that work. If this court were obliged to give to the Constitution the meaning and effect which the appellant seeks to establish, and if the expression ‘the judicial power' were to be held the extent so far, then, I think, I would be inclined to adopt the words of Taney C.J. in Luther v. Borden (1), in regard to a very famous constitutional controversy in the United States and say that the guarantee contained in the Constitution ‘is a guarantee of anarchy and not of order."'

The result of that judgment is to make it quite clear that practically all the work of the Land Commission is of an administrative character. Criticism has been levelled against the form of the appeal tribunal to which we allow aggrieved persons to apply. I do not suppose that anybody will think, for a moment, that I, as a lawyer, am anxious to see the powers of judges curtailed in any way, but I think the criticism levelled at this tribunal is quite unjustified. Deputy Costello let himself go in unmeasured terms. I see that Deputy Fitzgerald-Kenney is waiting, and I suppose he is going to let himself go also. I would suggest, however, to the Deputies who have criticised this tribunal that the matters which will come before this tribunal are matters which do require not alone a person of judicial experience, but men of experience in the work of the Land Commission itself. I am not to be taken for one moment as criticising in any way the person who holds the present position of judicial commissioner. I agree with Deputy Roddy when he said that there are very few men in the whole country with a better knowledge of the Land Acts than that gentleman has, but the suggestion here is that the type of tribunal, and the fact that one of the lay members must agree with the judicial commissioner as to whether a question is a question of law or not, is something that is unprecedented and that it has never been heard of before. Deputy Costello, I think, described it as the best joke of all. It is useful in these things to have a precedent, and we had a precedent in the Railway and Canal Traffic Act of 1888. A Commission was there appointed, consisting of three persons, and to it were delegated all the questions which arose in connection with the railways. Two of the persons to be appointed were lay persons. One had to be a man of railway experience, and for the third person an ex-officio commissioner was appointed by, I think, the Lord Chancellor, who was to be a judge of the High Court. He was to sit with the two lay commissioners, and here is the section which deals with what happened when a question of law came up. Deputies will see that it goes much farther even than we do. It said that when in the opinion of two of the commissioners a question was a question of law, the opinion of the ex-officio commissioner shall prevail.. So that two commissioners had the right to say whether or not a question was a question of law or not. Whether Article 64 of our Constitution is being contravened or not is a question upon which I am not going to claim to be able to give a final decision. That matter will be tested, I am quite sure. Deputy Costello has already suggested that it will be tested very quickly after the Bill comes into operation, but whether the position of judicial power given to the judges prevents us allowing a tribunal such as this to deal with the matters coming before it or not, you have this position, that in England such a tribunal as that would not be considered as in any way absurd or ridiculous or be laughed to scorn as this particular tribunal is being laughed to scorn in this House.

Comment on this

Is the Attorney-General saying that there is not a right to get the English tribunal's decision reviewed by the High Courts? Does any such thing apply here?

Comment on this
The Attorney-General

I am dealing with one point here. I do not think that Deputy Dillon is deliberately trying to side-track this matter, but I am dealing with criticism of the section touching the tribunal which has been uttered by the Deputies opposite. That section has been laughed to scorn. It is suggested that it was absurd that persons who are not lawyers sitting on the tribunal should say whether a question which was not a question of law should be left to the decision of the presiding judge. There is an example of legislation in an analogous matter in England where after a decision was given——

Comment on this

Is there not an appeal there from that tribunal to the High Court? There is no appeal from this according to the section.

Comment on this
The Attorney-General

I think the Deputy is wrong in suggesting that there is no appeal from the tribunal on a question of law.

Comment on this

If there is an appeal to the High Court where is it in the Bill?

Comment on this

It is not in the Bill.

Comment on this

Sure it is there already. We cannot teach you everything.

Comment on this
The Attorney-General

I suppose there will be ample opportunity to deal in more detail with these other sections when the Bill comes to be dealt with in Committee. I think a great deal of this is more appropriate on the Committee Stage than it is on this stage.- But I repeat again the pro tests which I seriously make against the way in which it has been sought to represent this Bill as something which is introducing a wholly revolutionary idea in dealing with the problem. As I said a moment ago, and as I have endeavoured to show, this Bill is necessary. I believe in their honest hearts if the Deputies who have spoken on the opposite side had been here where we are they would have to admit that a great many of the provisions in this Bill were necessary in order to clear away the obstacles and allow the work of the Land Commission to go on. If these Deputies have not changed since 1923 they must be in favour of this Bill. Unless they think that the friendship of the landlords is of more value to them than the friendship of the people of this country, they will have to admit that this is a useful Bill. If the objectives set out in 1923 are to be fulfilled, a great deal of the provisions we have inserted here are necessary. They are provisions that would have to be introduced by any Government in office in this country.

Comment on this