Land Bill, 1933—Second Stage (Resumed).
Contributions 150–305 of 305. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
No. 33 of 1933 ›
I am aware of course that the Attorney-General is an extremely sensitive person. I know that the Attorney-General resents anybody criticising him or putting forward any arguments against his proposals. I know the Attorney-General regards it as rather seditious for anybody to deal with his arguments and in a special way if I challenge them he regards it as high treason. The Attorney-General regards his arguments and views as sacrosanct and as things that should not be touched by any criticism. I am afraid, however, that I may have to commit high treason in this case, as I will have to deal with the singular disingenuousness of the speech which he has just delivered to this House. A great deal of his speech was taken up by references to speeches which Deputy Hogan made in the Seanad in 1923. I would like to point out to the House—if the House is not already aware of it—that speeches made in defence or explanation of the Act of 1923 are speeches which cannot be read to the courts as an interpretation of this Bill which is now before this House. I would also like to point out that when Deputy Hogan was piloting a particular Bill with particular safeguards in it a perfectly different situation to the present situation existed, when we are discussing a Bill in which the safeguards to which Deputy Hogan referred have been swept away or are in process of being swept away. There are just a few things in the Attorney-General's speech to which I would like to advert before I get down to a discussion on the Bill itself. He says the Land Commission is being attacked; that we say there is to be no confidence placed in it or in the persons who form the staffs of the Land Commission. That is perfectly untrue. That is not the point of view that this Party holds. The point of view of this Party is that the Irish Land Commission is extremely ably manned, that it is manned by men of the highest honour, by men of the highest principle, and that if these men are allowed in the future as they have been allowed in the past to work without political interference the work of the Land Commission will be well done. What I find in this particular Bill is that all through it there is a steady determination to take powers into the hands of the Minister which no Minister and no Administration except this would dream of taking into its hands. Really I am inclined to think that if the Fianna Fáil Party did completely understand the implications of this Bill, if they completely understood the powers which are being put into the hands of the Ministers by this Bill, a very considerable number of them at any rate would hesitate very long before they would give them such powers, and that a great number of them indeed would find it a great strain upon their consciences to give such powers as are proposed in this Bill.
But I do think that as this is a Second Reading speech and as the House is not in Committee it would be more appropriate for me to deal with the main principles and what will be the general effect of this Bill rather than go into a more detailed analysis of the particular provisions of the Bill. When I come to consider a Bill of this nature the first thing that I want to do, and the first thing I think that anybody should do who takes an interest in the welfare of the people of this State, and who looks at the country as something to be served rather than at a Party as something to be served, is to look at the measure as it will affect the entire people of the country. Legislation should be directed to the general advantage and to a promotion of the public good rather than a promotion of the interests of a political Party. I think any person who is animated by such views or sentiments will first look to see what is going to be the general effect of the Bill upon the country as a whole, upon the agriculture of this country as a whole. After all, the main thing is the welfare of agriculture in this country. The main thing, taken from the point of view of the State, is how to divide your land, how to deal with your land so that you will have the maximum output from the land and the greatest production of agricultural wealth from the land. After all, these are the main considerations. The next consideration should be what is the best method in which you can divide the profits made out of the land.
The first question, therefore, which I think the House should consider is, what is going to be the effect of the Bill upon general agricultural habits in this State? Regarding the Bill as impartially as I think the Bill can be regarded, I cannot see that it will have anything except the most pernicious effect upon the agricultural community. I think it is a commonplace that nobody can controvert that the real foundation of agricultural prosperity lies upon security of tenure. There were famous words uttered by Arthur Young, I suppose the greatest authority upon agriculture, and certainly the best observer of agricultural conditions, in his time. His books on conditions in England, and especially following his tour in France and Ireland, are standard works in the English language. He was a very keen observer. I will paraphrase rather than quote a particularly famous passage. He said that if you give a man a lease of a desert he will turn it into a garden, but if you make him the possessor for a short time of a garden he will turn it into a desert. Then he used the remarkable phrase: "For the magic of property turns sand into gold."
We find that this Bill shakes to the very foundation security in the land which any tenant-purchaser has bought out. If you wish to have agriculture in a thriving condition in this State you must, above all things, give to the proprietors of land a complete sense of security. What man is going to till his land to the very best, to improve his land as far as he can improve it, to look forward to the future and to take, in the management of his land, steps which may not have their immediate reward but which will have their reward in a few years' time—what man is going to take these steps, to go to expense like draining and liming the land, better fencing, better outhouses, and endeavour to bring up the general wealth of his land by using more and better manures, better types of grass seed and everything else, if he is not sure that he and the people who come after him are going to get the benefit of those improvements? The desire to improve land is the very thing that, under this Bill, you are taking away from the ordinary registered owner of land.
This Bill clearly indicates that the land problem is no nearer solution now than it was two generations ago. A great number of people in this country had hopes that there was going to be, some time or other, and that in our time, a final solution of the Irish land question. When I say final I mean final, at any rate, for several generations to come. There were hopes there would be such a solution because, until such a solution is reached, there is no likelihood of the agriculturist setting himself to make the very best that he possibly can out of his land. I do not find that here. I find there is no difference between the position of a tenant-purchaser under the Land Purchase Acts who is the registered owner of his land than there was given by former Land Acts. There is no substantial difference as regards fixity of tenure, real sense of ownership in his land, and there is no greater sense of security now given than there was given by the Land Act of 1870 or the Land Act of 1885. A tenant may have purchased his land. If it is land upon which he does not actually reside that land can be taken away from him, be it big or small.
The Attorney-General told us that of course in the Land Act of 1923 there was power to resume for cash the lands of tenants who had not purchased, and he wishes the House to think there is no difference between tenants who have purchased and tenants who have not purchased. There is all the difference in the world between the two. There is the case of the tenant who has not purchased or has not become the fee-simple owner of his land. That man would be approaching the final stage by gradual steps. He would not be the owner of his land, but as soon as a man discovered himself to be the registered owner, with that land vested in him, he did consider he was rooted there firmly and there was no power to take it away.
Comment on this
That is what the Land Purchase Acts set out to do, and now we find that that security is to be taken away. That absolute and complete security in the land which he purchased could not be given in completeness is indeed a fact, because it was considered, and I think rightly considered, that a re-distribution of land was advisable in the State interests and, accordingly, power was given, which was only exercised in certain cases, so that land could be taken up from a person, even though he were the registered owner of it, but he got elsewhere land of equal value. That principle has for practical purposes been swept away. The reservations are very few. In the first place, so far as any non-residential registered holding is concerned, there is no security at all. Let me take what is a very ordinary instance. A small farmer in the County Mayo, or any similarly situated county, has a holding with a valuation of £10 or £15, or possibly less. A saving man, a thrifty man, puts money by. There is a holding adjoining his holding which is for sale by public auction. Possibly he has the purchase price, or he may get some of it from a bank in order to purchase that adjoining holding. Usually it is the most thrifty people who have such holdings. Let us say that he buys the holding adjoining his own. Later he is told: "You have absolutely no security in that holding; it can be taken away from you to-morrow for cash." It may be that he gets only five or ten acres, but even so, he has no security in it, and it can be taken away from him for cash.
To a working farmer, as everybody must know, cash is no compensation for the taking away of a man's land. You might as well say in reference to a carpenter: "I am not going ever to allow him to work again as a carpenter, but I will be very fair and I will be very generous to him; I will give him absolutely the full value for all his carpenter's tools." That is a very analogous position. The land is the place where a man gets employment, where he gets scope to exercise his energies, and gets scope to exercise his abilities and brain power as well. It is, of course the ablest farmers, the men who are the best tillers, who get on. A great number of them get on because they have the incentive that although they start with 10 acres they may die with 20 acres if they are able to buy them. If you tell them, as you do in effect under this Bill, "You will have no security for any outside land you buy," I consider that you are doing a very great injury, because you are killing the spirit of enterprise in the country.
Let us come on a little further and see what are the safeguards. We have a safeguard put in the most extraordinary fashion, that if the tenant or his wife resides upon the holding, if the holding is worked in a husbandlike manner, and if it is not over £2,000 in value, it will remain. That is very curiously put. If the tenant is a man and his wife resides on it then the place is safe. Let us turn it about. Let us assume that the tenant is a woman, and her husband resides on the place; then the safeguard is completely gone. Why is there this distinction? Why is it not "if the husband or wife of the tenant, as the case may be resides on it"? It has not been put that way. I do not know why there is that exception. If a woman owns land and her husband resides on it the land can still be taken. That is a very curious position. I should like to know from the Minister what is the reason for that, to my mind, strange provision.
The land must be worked in a husbandlike manner. Who is to be the judge as to whether it is worked in a husbandlike manner? I think the best people to judge as to whether a holding is being well worked is pretty nearly always either the holder himself, or somebody who knows the land and who is in touch with local conditions. I should hesitate to give any inspector the power to go round and say "This land is being well worked" or "This land is not being well worked". I see here in this section "that he or she uses such land in the same manner as an ordinary farmer in accordance with proper methods of husbandry". Who is to be the judge in that matter? Who is to decide what is an ordinary farmer as distinct from an extraordinary farmer? Very often the farmers who are not ordinary farmers are the most valuable. After all, the man of enterprise, the man who is streets above the ordinary, is far and away above his neighbours. He cannot, of course, be described as an ordinary farmer. He is not using his farm in the fashion of an ordinary farmer. His land can be taken away because he is too good; he is not an ordinary farmer. "In accordance with proper methods of husbandry"; I am at a loss to know who is going to decide what are the proper methods of husbandry, because proper methods of husbandry vary almost from one portion of a townland to another. Each particular kind of land must be treated in its own way, if you are going to get the very best results out of it.
Then there is the safeguard that, as well as residing on the land, the total market value must not exceed the sum of £2,000. I cannot see how the market value is going to be determined, or who is going to determine it. The market value of land is very difficult to determine. It fluctuates from day to day. Personally I would have thought that it would be far and away more sensible and more fair if instead of a market value of £2,000— if you are going to fix a limit of this nature—you took the poor law valuation of the land as a basis on which to fix the value. This would be a fairer and more sensible method of approaching this matter. Let me draw the attention of the House to the real danger in this connection. You may say "Two thousand pounds' worth of land is enough for any man to have." Even if any Deputy is of that opinion will he just consider for a moment how far the sense of security goes? We have a value of £2,000 to-day. Portion of a man's land is taken away, and he is left whatever is valued at £2,000. I have not the remotest idea how many acres that would be. If there is a boom in land it might not be more than 20 or 25 acres. Land, of course, includes buildings, and if there is a good house on a farm of 20 or 25 acres it might very easily be value for £2,000. Suppose a man is left with 20, 25 or 50 acres, what sense of security has he got? To-day the value is put at £2,000. How do we know that in 12 months' time somebody anxious to place persons who have no land may not come along and fix the value at £1,000? Somebody else may afterwards come along and fix the value at £500. Where is finality to come in? I press this upon the House as vigorously as I can; I consider that finality is necessary, if agriculture is going to flourish. If a man thinks "There is a field there which may be taken from me any day," how is he going to farm that field? He is going to take everything he can out of it and keep nothing in. I would ask Deputies very carefully to consider that. The Deputy who says: "Oh, £2,000 is all right" should bear in mind that when you start on that principle there will be a tendency to cut the figure down still further.
There is another aspect from which I want to approach this question— the indiscriminate breaking up of grass lands all over the country. I hope Deputies in this House will bear in mind that what I have said on other occasions is still my view—that I do not think that there is in this country any one possible system of agriculture. Agriculture should vary from place to place, according to the nature of the soil and its capabilities. I am looking at the matter now from the point of view of those who live in that part of the State which I know thoroughly. Looking at it from the point of view of a person who has a reasonable bit of a holding of land in Mayo, Galway, or Sligo, and I am sure it is the same in the other poorer counties, the indiscriminate breaking up of the grass lands in Kildare, Meath and other counties of that nature is going to do them very real injury. There is no single farmers' Deputy in this House who will not agree with that, and that the most profitable way of finishing cattle is on good land. There is not a farmers' Deputy who comes from the richer parts of this country who does not know the value of ancient pasture, and who does not know that if you have really rich land in ancient pasture you have a source of wealth that should not be lightly flung away. When I consider what is the ordinary condition of affairs in the counties to which I allude, I have discovered, and it is always the way, that cattle are kept in these parts of the country where the land is bad, and very bad, only up to a certain age. They are not kept there now as long as they used to be kept. They cannot be properly finished upon land in the western counties. If that industry of breeding store cattle, which is always to be for the western counties the main source of livelihood, is to be carried on as profitably as at present, there should be in reserve that enormously rich and fertile land into which these cattle can be turned and finished. That is the necessary condition under which farming is carried on and must be carried on in the poorer parts of Ireland. I consider that if you set to work to break up all the pasturage in these rich counties, you may, to some extent, be helping the people in those counties, which I doubt. I very much doubt that the breaking up of any great national asset like this, the richest pasture in all Europe, possibly I would not exaggerate if I said the richest pasture in the whole world, would be to the benefit of any people. By doing so you will greatly diminish the gross output of national wealth, and I am certain you will do a great injury to the poorer people in Mayo County and in Galway County, and the same will apply to the poorer people in other counties.
I do not think, when this Bill was being considered, that an enormous amount of thought was given to it. I think in the iaudation that some members of the Fianna Fáil Party gave it they did not give it much consideration either. I heard two speeches delivered by Deputy Cleary in the last week or so in this House. Deputy Cleary is always a very vigorous, though not always a very sensible speaker. He put forward two propositions in those two speeches which were wholly contradictory one of the other. I do not, of course, say that what Deputy Cleary says in this House is to be taken as an indication of what was in the mind of the Executive Council, but I put it forward as an example of the astoundingly loose thinking going on in the Fianna Fáil Party. But a short time ago Deputy Cleary alluded to me personally complaining about the conditions of the people in the West of Ireland, because 75 per cent. or 80 per cent. of them, he said, never made a living out of their holdings, and could never make a living out of their holdings because they had to wait until they got money from America or England to pay their rents. In other words, Deputy Cleary was bringing the most huge indictment against the whole work carried on by the Congested Districts Board and the Land Commission under various Governments. He was springing upon the House the view that practically all the land given to make economic holdings was no good. What you would call an economic holding is not an economic holding; that no matter how much you broke up the grass lands in any county in the West of Ireland you were simply always condemning people to live on land out of which they could not make a living. That summed up his first speech; which meant that you were establishing a completely unsound agricultural economic system by dividing the country into holdings on which the people could not live.
Then I discovered that on this particular Bill there comes from the same Deputy a magnificent eulogy most eloquently put, in praise of the very thing which he condemned a week before. It was a magnificent eulogy of the breaking up of the land so as to enable the people to live upon it entirely, obviously forgetful of the fact that within a week he declared such a thing was impossible. I am afraid that is the sort of spirit that is running through Fianna Fáil, and, therefore, in setting this down they did so without inquiry into this grave land problem, which, of course, is the most important of all our problems, because it is the one most concerned with the welfare of the majority of our people, and because out of it the main supply of our wealth as a country must always come. I have dealt now with the question of want of security. The same spirit is running quite through this Bill. I turn to this most extraordinary section. I am very sorry the Attorney-General has left the House, because I would like his views on this Section 27. If the Attorney-General does me the courtesy, as he is not here to listen to my speech, to read my speech, I should very much hope that when this Section 27 comes to be debated in Committee he will be prepared to answer the case I am now making against it. I do not believe this House knows what Section 27 means. I do not believe there is a farmer Deputy in the House would consent to give the power to the Government that they are securing by Section 27. Though I may have to quote law in connection with this matter, I think I can do so so very simply that no Deputy, although he may know nothing about law, will have any difficulty in following me completely. Under Section 27 the Land Commission may issue a warrant, and that warrant has the same effect as an execution order, under the Enforcement of Court Orders Act, 1926.
I want the House to understand what an enforcement of court order under the Act of 1926 is:
"The expression ‘execution order' means and includes any writ, decree, warrant, or other document by whatever name called, issued by a court in a civil matter directing or authorising the execution of an order of the court for the seizure and sale of a person's property or by putting a person in possession of lands or premises or delivering to him specific property."
I should like Deputies opposite to know that any and every form of writ or court order comes under that definition of an execution order, and that in consequence the Land Commission have got full powers, by a mere stroke of the pen, to issue in respect of a person who is in arrears with his land annuity any order that a court at present could make. They can issue a certificate which will give them power to act as if they had got any order that a court could make.
Before I go on to explain how wide that power is, I should like to point out that under sub-section (3) of this section it is provided:
"Immediately upon receipt from the Land Commission of a warrant under this section the county registrar shall, after serving such notices and doing such acts as may be prescribed in that behalf by regulations to be made by the Minister for Justice, proceed to levy the money therein certified to be due by the defaulter in the same manner as execution orders at the suit of the Land Commission are by law leviable, and such county registrar shall, for that purpose, have all such rights, powers and duties as are for the time being vested in or imposed on him by law in relation to the execution of an execution order."
There are very significant words left out of that section because, under the Enforcement of Court Orders Act, when a court order was to be enforced not only were the same powers given, but also the under-sheriff—it is now the county registrar—in most cases was subject "to the like duties and obligations as similar writs of execution of the High Court have heretofore been executed by the undersheriff." These words "and obligations" are for some particular reason left out of this section. I take it that the object of that is that no action shall be brought for an illegal seizure in any case in which an illegal seizure has been made; that when a seizure has been made upon the wrong person he shall have no remedy either against the sheriff or the Land Commission. I take it that that is the reason why these words have been left out. I think it is really shocking that you sweep away the safeguard of the court to see that no mistake has been made and then, if a mistake has been made, you abolish the liability of the Land Commission or of the sheriff.
I come to a worse thing still, and I think that when you consider the power that the Minister is to get now, it is really striking. I am sorry the acting-Minister is not here, because I should like to ask him whether he has considered the effect of Section 25 of the Land Act of 1891. I presume he has and that he knows thoroughly what powers he is taking. I presume he is not taking these powers without knowing what they are. It is really staggering to see the powers he is taking. Section 25 of the Land Act of 1891 gives power to the High Court, at the suit of the Land Commission, to give an order to the sheriff. I might incidentally say that the Land Commission gives an order for a holding to be sold if one gale of annuity has been in arrear for 40 days. Section 25 of the Land Act of 1891 states:
"Whenever the Land Commission are entitled to cause any holding to be sold for the non-payment of any sum due to them, they may, if they think fit, apply to the High Court, in the manner prescribed by rules of the High Court, for an order to the sheriff to put them in possession of such holding, and it shall be lawful for such court, if it sees fit, and upon hearing such evidence as is offered, to issue an order accordingly, and such order shall be executed by the sheriff in like manner as a writ for the delivery of possession."
That order can be made by the High Court as the law stands at present, but only when the occupier has had due and proper notice. This matter is now to be under the control of the Minister. By this Bill he gets complete control over the collection of annuities. Under this Bill the Minister can say to whoever is in charge of the collection branch of the Land Commission, "Let me know the names of all the annuitants the last gale day whose annuity is 50 days in arrear." He can look through that list, and if there are any Deputies, let me say, in this House whom he does not like, or any other prominent political opponent whom he does not like, possibly a man who, through illness or some other cause, has allowed his gale of annuity to go into arrear for 50 days, then, without notice to that man, without anybody in the world knowing what is being done, inside the office of the Land Commission there can be, by direction of the Minister, an order made that that man is to be put out of possession of his holding, that the holding is to be put up for sale, and that delivery is to be made forthwith of that holding by the sheriff. In other words, what never happened before, you have complete eviction for non-payment of an annuity done behind the scenes in the Land Commission; and you are asked to give that power to the Minister.
I ask anybody if he thinks that power should be given. We all remember the Act of 1887, and the eviction-made-easy clauses that were talked about. They went, after all, to a court. There was a judgment of a court, but here, if a man is fifty days behind in the payment of his annuity, the Minister, by a stroke of his pen, can deprive him of all the land he possesses. Of course, it is put up for sale and if it goes for more than the amount that is due he will get, I grant you, the amount of the purchase money over and above the costs; but there and then he is evicted and put out. Is that a power that any Minister ought to get? It is astonishing to me that any person who thinks there ought to be any security in a man's home for a man would allow any Minister, no matter who he is, to be able to put out that man by a mere stroke of his pen if the man allows one half-gale of his annuity to be fifty days in arrear. That is the power given to the Minister by that section. I suppose the Attorney-General and the Acting-Minister for Lands and Fisheries will get up and say: "Oh, of course, that power is there, but we never intend to exercise it; we are most reasonable persons." I do not know whether they intend to exercise it or not, but the power is there and I think that when the Acting-Minister for Lands and Fisheries introduced this Bill into this House instead of saying that this is a Bill which is going to save the occupiers and registered owners of land expenses, he might have told this House what was the entire extent of the powers he was taking up himself. On this question of expense, does that deceive anybody? Is anybody taken in by it? Is there a single one, even of the most vehement supporters of the Government who is most anxious to keep his mind closed to reason in order that nothing but the words of the Front Bench may sink in—is there a single one of them who thinks that it is going to save expense? Which do you think is the more expensive— the sheriff's seizure or a decree made in the Circuit Court or the District Court? The whole expense is the sheriff's seizure. The sheriff goes there and he takes the man's cattle—perhaps five or six of his cattle. He may get no purchaser for them, even though the amount of money due is small; he keeps them in a pound for heaven knows how long and all that is done without the man having had any opportunity of explaining that no money was due by him or, if there were a decree made against him, he has no opportunity now, knowing that it would take some time before that decree could be levied, of trying to collect his little resources and see if he can make up the amount due before the sheriff comes. Now, the sheriff is to come at once and seize his cattle.
There is another matter to which I should like to refer. Under Part III, Section 21, of the Enforcement of Court Orders Act, 1926, special powers were given to the courts to stay execution when a person could not pay. Very special powers were given. It must be remembered that the Enforcement of Court Orders Act was a very strong Act. It made ordinary judgments more easily leviable than they had been before. It took away a certain number of things which surrounded a sheriff such as that a sheriff could not give a better title than he had himself and other things of that nature, but because it was recognised to be so drastic there was in 1926 this saving clause about the stay of execution. There is no method now by which a man, no matter how poor he may be, can get a stay of execution. The sheriff can come down upon him at once. There is no way of telling, except by a letter to the Land Commission, that he cannot pay, and down the sheriff may come upon him.
There is just one thing to which I should like to draw the attention of the House. It looks as if you really want trouble, because I believe that this section, no matter how moderately it may be put into operation, will inevitably lead to grave trouble. Fling your minds back to Irish history for a little time and I think you will find that although a landlord always could distrain for rent without going to court, and could send his drivers, as they used to be called, to the holding and drive away with the man's belongings without legal process—it was called distraint—yet that had completely fallen into desuetude. I do not believe that even the oldest farmer Deputy in this House could say that he heard from his father of a case of distraint. It was looked upon with such dislike that it fell completely into desuetude. Right down to the present moment the landlord of a town house can distrain for rent, but it is never done. You are bringing back this principle now. It is said, of course, that the income tax people can distrain for rent. The Revenue Commissioners are not thought to be a very soft-hearted body, and yet I would venture to say that the number of times in which the Revenue Commissioners distrain for income tax is very small indeed. Deputy Walsh said that there is power to distrain for poor rate. It is very rarely exercised. I do not know myself of any case, and I have practised a good deal. I think the number of cases in which there is distraint for rates is very small indeed. It is that principle, which is falling into desuetude everywhere, except where it is not quite dead, because it is against the sense of justice and fair play which there is in the community —that is the very method which you want to revive. You say you save costs. Why should not a shopkeeper be in a position to send the sheriff without legal process at all to collect his shop debts? That could be done at one time. They could seize the body of the debtor and put him into prison without the intervention of the courts, but it was found to be so grossly unfair that it had to be swept away. Here you have this most unpopular thing, which has fallen into desuetude everywhere owing to its unpopularity, being revived again. I think—in fact I am certain— that when you, without legal process, send out the sheriff, whether he be sub-sheriff or county registrar, to seize on a man's goods without any preliminary proceedings in court, you will create an amount of resentment that will be infinitely greater than any feeling that might be aroused by a seizure made by a sheriff after due hearing in court when the defaulter had every opportunity of bringing forward any case that he might have.
There are some other provisions in this Bill to which I should like very much to refer at a later stage, but I will confine myself just to one or two now. I think that play-acting is a very dangerous thing, and where Ministers play-act they ought to be quite sure that it will come off. There was a bit of play-acting here the other day which must have amused, possibly aroused, the same contemptuous feelings in the Minister's own Party, as it did over here. There was a great flourish of trumpets, a map was produced and it was handed all around the House. Every Deputy got a copy of that map. And what was it all about? That there was a village on the Palmer estate in Mayo held in rundale. There is a story in one of Macaulay's Essays that the one-time Prime Minister of England, the Duke of Newcastle, was a man not very well-informed as to what was happening. There had been a great deal of fighting around Cape Breton in Canada, and everybody in England was talking of Cape Breton. Suddenly it happened that the Ministers made a discovery that Cape Breton was an island, and the Prime Minister said: "Oh, Cape Breton is an island; I must run and tell the King that Cape Breton is an island." It seems to me that an approach to much the same kind of thing has happened here. Deputy Aiken has gone to the Irish Land Commission for the first time. He had never heard of rundale before, and he says: "Oh, there are holdings held in rundale, and I must run and tell the President that there are such things as rundale holdings." The President had not heard of holdings in rundale, and when the President is told of them he says: "This is a great thing; we must tell the House that there are holdings in rundale." He, too, evidently never heard of rundale holdings before.
Comment on this
Certainly, there are plenty of rundale holdings all over Mayo. Anybody who knows anything about Irish history knows the origin of rundale holdings. Rundale holdings are direct descendants of the tribal system of land tenure in Ireland. The land was divided amongst the tribe and each person got a particular bit of the land. How that has altered with the passing of years I need not go into now. Its descent is traced in many books. Sir Henry Mayne is the leading authority on the question. In Mayo where land was let upon lease—and it is the same all over the rest of Ireland —the land was not divided amongst the lessees but they were allowed to do the real division themselves. Eight or ten persons might get a lease for a particular tract of land and then they divided this land amongst themselves. Of course it was very difficult for them to divide the land so that no one would have a better bit of the land than anybody else and in consequence when there was a good field they divided it into a great number of strips and that sort of thing lasted down until the present day.
Rundale, whatever may have been its advantages in olden times, was a most complete and absolute failure in latter days. Rundale brought the most unpleasant consequences. You would have two or three people in one field with only the lockspit between them and you had the children out on the field on wet days to prevent the cattle of one man grazing on the other's plot. Between these plots there was nothing but the little lockspit. But what has this Bill got to do with rundale? I find not one single provision in this Bill which deals with rundale at all. The Land Commission have now got ample and adequate powers, powers which they have exercised for some time. These powers which they have are known as "striping" which is a new word. I know that it has often happened that certain individuals object to the land being striped by the Land Commission. But the Land Commission have got that power already. There is not a single word in this Bill about rundale. There is not a single section which deals with the matter and why it was dragged in here I do not know, except that the President and the Acting-Minister for Lands and Fisheries wanted to show the House that they had discovered that there was such a thing in existence as rundale.
There is just one other thing. We had a great flourish of trumpets and we were told that there was going to be very quick distribution of land under this Bill; that there were great legal delays sometimes that prevented the acquisition and distribution of land; that these delays were to be done away with and that the land could now be taken over even before the purchase money could be fixed or the title of the land ascertained. What is the reason for all that? We know that since Fianna Fáil came into office there has been practically no distribution of land. There is an enormous amount of land, something like 250,000 acres which was purchased before Fianna Fáil came into office and it has not been divided yet. About the division of this land there are no technical or legal difficulties of any kind. Why not set to work and divide that land first? One would imagine that this would be the obvious thing to do. What is the reason for the delay? It is not caused by any legal difficulties. There are difficulties inherent in the question itself such as getting persons to exchange holdings. The real reason for these delays is that there are not sufficient inspectors in the Land Commission to do the work adequately. All that has been said by the Government Party shows that there are no legal difficulties and that the delay is not due to legal difficulties at all. Then what is the meaning of this Bill? You cannot keep pace with dividing the land that you have acquired in the ordinary way. Then why start taking up more land before you have completed the business of giving to the tenants the land you have? Why take up additional land when you are not able to divide the land you already have?
There is just one other matter to which I wish to allude because it shows what is running right through this Bill. There was a provision in the land code that no land should be taken up while other and more suitable land in the neighbourhood was available. That provision is to be taken away. Why? Why should not the most suitable land be taken up first? I would like to have an answer to that? When your political opponents have unsuitable land and your political supporters have suitable land will it enable the unsuitable land to be taken up first? Is that the reason? Going right through this Bill, taking it and summing it up, nobody can come to the conclusion, looking at it fairly and squarely, that it is a Bill which will do anything substantial towards improving the agricultural population in this country. It will shake confidence everywhere. It must shake confidence. It will not hurry in any single way the distribution of land which is to be distributed. It will be no help to anybody. It will be worked, as I very much fear it will be worked, as a method of punishing persons whom the Government dislike and for rewarding persons whom the Government want to reward. I cannot understand otherwise why that terrible provision is in the Bill—that if for 50 days your annuity is in arrear you can be ejected there and then by the sheriff if he is so told by the Minister for Lands and Fisheries. If this measure is going to be properly and fairly administered, and if it is not going to be made an engine of Party tyranny, I ask the Minister to explain why those extraordinary and absolutely unnecessary powers are taken in the Bill?
Comment on this
The Deputy who claimed in this House to have been the cause of everything that was of any use to the country from 1922 onwards was the first person to speak in opposition to this Bill to-day. I was surprised, and I am sure if the Ceann Comhairle did not cut him short he would be still talking. Looking over, in the Official Debates, the discussion on the Land Act of 1923, I find, in vol. 3, col. 2094, that Deputy O'Donnell stated he had received a communication from a man named Mr. Belton asking him not to support the Land Bill as brought forward until he had become a member of the Dáil. In 1923 Deputy Belton had prepared his speech on the Land Bill. We heard him to-day. He ignored everything that has happened since. Of course, he will tell us next year or the following year "I was the cause of everything good in that Land Act of 1933, and anything that is bad in it belongs to the other crowd." If there ever was a Land Bill around which was centred such a campaign of misrepresentation, this is the Bill. It has been attacked from every angle. We are told that every kind of corruption is going to be practised under it.
We are told that this is a political Bill. It is, no manner of doubt about it. It is a political Bill, and it is such a political success that it has got every single one of the Deputies on the opposite benches on the go. We are told there is to be a tribunal and the Minister is going to nominate two of his chums. That is what Deputy Hogan said. What do the Irish people want? Do they want a tribunal set up by the Irish people or a tribunal the same as the one that operated here for the last ten years, which was set up under a secret agreement made with the British in 1923? Do the Irish people desire that the price of land in Ireland shall be fixed by an individual appointed under a secret agreement made in 1923 between Cosgrave and the British Government? The Irish people have paid dearly enough for that. Something like £600,000 was clapped on the unfortunate farmers who got the land. As it is, we will have to revalue a lot of the land and the State will have to bear the loss of the loot handed over under that tribunal. There is no use in burking it.
Comment on this
Is it in order for Deputy Corry to suggest that one of our judges has been handing over loot?
Comment on this
I take it the charge was not a personal charge. If it were, it certainly would not be in order.
Comment on this
Is it in order for a Deputy to refer to another Deputy by his surname only? I think the least that Deputy Cosgrave is entitled to is the respect of members of this House.
Comment on this
I did not mean to be disrespectful in any way. I am sorry if my remarks were taken that way. The present condition of things in regard to land distribution needs to be changed. The division of land in this country has proved a failure, and you all know it. There has not been a single estate divided to which any of you can point and say: "That is a success." You know there was a very definite conspiracy existing by which land in this country, when it came to be taken over by the Land Commission, went beyond all value. I have cases before me of estates that were valued by the Land Commission at £11 10s. Od. and when they came into the land courts they were valued at £16 10s. Od.
Comment on this
The Deputy must not make charges of conspiracy against any official. He may object to the price paid, but he must not accuse a judge or one acting in a semi-judicial capacity of conspiracy.
Comment on this
What I am saying is that there was a very definite conspiracy in the manner in which those Acts were administered during the last ten years.
Comment on this
We will not divide your land, anyway, for you have none, not a danged sod, not as much as half an acre. We cannot divide the Eiffel Tower. Anyway, the conspiracy ran on those lines: They are thinking they are going to divide the ranches, but we will see that those placed on the ranches will have to pay such an annuity that we will have the land back to-morrow or after on the 11 months' system. You know it has happened and that the greater portion of the land divided six or seven years ago is back again in the hands of the very individuals from whom it was taken and they have got the money that was paid for the land. It reverted for the only reason that land was taken over at three, four or five times its honest and proper value. That is going to end now.
There is an accusation levelled at us that there are 100,000 acres not divided. Deputy Fitzgerald-Kenney asked why they are not divided. What is the use of putting any man on that land at £2 or 30/- an acre? The unfortunate man will be there only for a year or two and then the land will go back to those who had it before. There is no use dividing land under that system. It can be divided when we are finished with this Bill, because the State then can bear the loss. The State can bear the loss of the loot.
Comment on this
The next statement that has been made is: "Oh, they are going to take the land off the farmers. There is no more security of tenure." Deputy Dillon was very eloquent on this. Deputy Dillon has apparently not studied the effects of previous Land Acts, or the manner in which the law stands at the present time. As to the reasons for the insertion of Section 28 in that Bill, I will give them from the lips of a prominent Cumann na nGaedheal Deputy, who, I regret to say, is no longer in this House, but who was a fairly sensible fellow while he was in it. In volume 29, column 681 of the Official Debates, Deputy Hassett said:
"Take the question of the division of ranches. I come from a district where between 5,000 and 6,000 acres of untenanted land were divided under the British régime. There are thousands of acres of untenanted land which have not been touched by our own Government since they came into office. I have brought every possible pressure to bear upon the Land Commission to take over these ranches, but with little effect, and they offer the most flimsy excuses as to why they should not proceed to take them over. Twelve months ago I put a question on this matter to the Minister for Fisheries. I asked:
‘If he is aware that the Irish Land Commission recently refused to take any portion of the lands owned by Captain Moore, of Mooresfort, Tipperary, for the relief of congestion; if he will state the reason for such refusal; the number of acres at present in the possession of Captain Moore; if he is aware that there are a number of small holders living near this estate; and what steps he proposes to take to bring them up to the economic standard.'
This was the reply of the Parliamentary Secretary:
"‘Proceedings were instituted by the Land Commission under the Land Act, 1923, for the acquisition of 61a. 2r. Op. of the lands of Kilross, on the estate of Captain Moore, Co. Tipperary. The owner objected to the acquisition of the lands, on the grounds that for many years past they had been worked by him as part of his home farm and farming industry generally, including that of a stud farm, and that if he were deprived of the lands the result would be to materially interfere with the stud farm.
"‘The objection came before the Land Commission Court, who, having considered all the circumstances, gave judgement allowing the objection, and the proceedings were in consequence discontinued. In addition to these lands, Captain Moore is returned in the Schedule of Particulars lodged as holding about 722 acres of demesne lands and 5,000 acres of mountain and woods.'"
Here is a man with 5,722 acres in County Tipperary. The Land Commission wanted to take 61 acres from him, and they failed. Then we have Deputies, whether it is through idiocy or not I do not know, getting up and talking about the poor farmer who is going to have his 10 or 15 acres taken from him. It is to meet cases like that that Section 28 was brought into this Bill. It is about time there was a Government here having the pluck to do it. Here is a gentleman with 5,722 acres of land, and we are told by Deputies opposite that it would be wronging him to take some of it from him; that the poor devils whom Deputy Gorey used to talk about here could go to America or hell or Connaught, but the gentleman from Tipperary must keep his 5,722 acres. He kept it for the past 10 years, and Cumann na nGaedheal were unable to take it from him. We will deal with him now. Deputy Hassett went on to say:
"I know that estate particularly well. We asked that a small portion, 61 acres, of that estate, which Captain Moore had been trying to sell, and which was in the public market, should be divided among the small holders in the neighbourhood."
Mind you, here was 61 acres of land, which the owner had been trying to sell and which had been put on the public market. He afterwards went before the appeal tribunal, told them it was portion of his home farm, and that he could not part with it. When the "poor devils" wanted it he said that to them. The tribunal decided that it should not be touched; that he could not part with 61 acres out of 5,722. That is the kind of thing we got——
Comment on this
Might I ask the Deputy if he is suggesting that they had not the power to take it, or if he is suggesting that they acted improperly?
Comment on this
If the Deputy would learn a little more law—he would be far more likely to get it as a farmer— he would not be asking such a leading question.
Comment on this
I am giving you the facts, and for the moment I do not grudge you to become the judge yourself and weigh them up. I should like you to weigh up those facts yourself.
Comment on this
The Deputy has had sufficient experience in this House to know that he should not address fellow-Deputies in the second person.
Comment on this
I am sorry, but the Deputy asked me a question. I should like if Deputy MacDermot would weigh up this matter himself. There is a man with 5,722 acres of land. He put 61 acres up for sale in the public market. The Land Commission tried to take 61 acres from him. He immediately opposed their taking it from him, and in the Appeal Court he was held to be right. Judge for yourself whom you will lay the blame on. Deputy Hassett continues:—
"The same thing has been going on in other ranches in my neighbourhood. Take the Timoney estate of 1,200 acres, and the Braddell estate, Two-Mile-Borris, of over 500 acres, non-residential. This gentleman holds another big farm in County Cork, the Trant estate, which has an area of 1,688 English acres."
I am sorry Deputy Roddy is not here. He told us about all the "pull" and influence that would be worked by the Fianna Fáil clubs throughout the country. I am sorry he is not here to listen to this:—
"Only 300 odd acres of this has been taken over for distribution. Through the efforts of the Cumann na nGaedheal clubs, and as a result of different resolutions that were passed and supported by some of us, an inspector from the Land Commission was got down in regard to the Braddell estate. The owner was a cute boy, and though he had not previously resided there, he came up and took possession of a little holding on the place, with the result that the Land Commission declared the property to be a residential holding. That man, as I have said, had a large estate in Cork, to which he went back again soon after, and we have not seen him since."
Comment on this
Yes; he has 1,600 acres there, which we hope to divide up one of these days. Here is this gentleman with 1,688 acres in Cork. He had 500 more in Tipperary, and in order to evade the meaning of the Act he went to reside in a cottage on the 500 acres. He stayed there until the coast was clear, and it was adjudged to be a residential holding; then he went back to Cork again. That is just a small instance of the reason why Section 28 is in this Bill. There is another matter. We were accused of every kind of corruption. We were told we wanted lands for our friends; we were told we wanted to give land to landless blackguards all round the country. The people who made these charges were in reality only echoing what they did themselves. They carried out these matters very successfully. What they accuse us of being anxious to do they actually did themselves. I will show what was done with land taken for the relief of congestion by these heroes. It was not the congests who got it. They rewarded their friends very well. I shall give another quotation. I will not take any statement that might be attributed to those wild boys, as we are called in Fianna Fáil. I will give a quotation from Deputy Hassett.
Comment on this
Because the Party opposite took good care he would not be here. He was steamrolled out. Here is what Deputy Hassett said— volume 29, column 683, of the Official Reports:
"We got the Land Commission inspectors to come down there. There are from 100 to 120 small uneconomic holdings there, and after the greatest pressure we got the Land Commission to take the small amount of 325 statute acres, leaving the balance, 1,688 acres, to the descendants of those who turned the people out of their property."
There you have what would be described as another estate divided. Mr. Hassett goes on to say:
"The Land Commission can be very generous with some people in my neighbourhood. There is a district justice living near me, a man who has a salary of roughly £1,000 a year with his expenses, running I suppose into £300 more. He has a beautiful house with about ten rooms, hot and cold water baths, and he has between 50 and 60 acres of land. That gentleman has been allowed by the Land Commission another 351 acres with another beautiful home."
That is the way the land was divided among the congests and the landless men by the Cumann na Gaedheal Party. Now I am not quoting any speech but that of Deputy Hassett, and as we know he was a member of the Cumann na nGaedheal Party in Tipperary, and here is what he says about that transaction:
"I think that was the biggest scandal that was ever perpetrated by the Land Commission. I do not know how anybody could stand over it. It is simply disgusting, because if a man with a smallholding in my county of five or six acres was given a holding in another county he would have to hand over his five or six acres to the Land Commission. He would have to hand over the land out of which he was taken for division among the congests."
We can all understand that. When a congest is taken out of land the land from which he was taken had to be divided among other congests. What happened in this case? Was the land divided up? No, it was not. Mr. Hassett goes on:
"If such a man were given a farm in Westmeath he would have to hand over the few acres he has in my county to the Land Commission, but in this case that man was allowed to sell his very fine mansion at a big price, and in addition he was allowed to sell four or five holdings by public or private auction."
That was the way they divided the land among the congests and landless men, and these are the heroes who now talk of corruption. "He was not asked to give them up. He was a live servant of the Government, I suppose, but when the fight was on against the Black and Tans he was not of much use." That is a statement of the manner in which estates in this country were divided up under the Cumann na nGaedheal Government. These are the people who talk now about corruption and that we are going to give land to cornerboys.
Surely we have to consider a very serious problem in this country. There are 25,000 or 30,000 young men and women growing up every year. The greater portion of them were reared on the land and have no other outlook. They cannot now emigrate to America or any other country. They have to be put upon the lands, and I hope there is some special clause in the Bill that will enable us to take that 351 acres from that district justice and hand it back to those for whom it was intended in the first instance, namely, the congests and the landless men. I hope that individual is not going to be allowed to get away with that loot.
We have to face this problem of dividing up the land. We cannot stand by and allow individuals such as the one to whom I pointed, where the last Government failed to get 61 acres for the congests out of a holding of 5,722 acres, to get away with it. We cannot allow that to continue. We may be told these were the poor peasant proprietors. God knows who has come in under that flag. There are other matters involved in this Bill. There is a special section of the community for whom Deputy Dillon and Deputy MacDermot profess great sympathy when talking of derating, sometimes. They appeal repeatedly on behalf of farmers who were not paying annuities, and they refer to long leaseholders and others. But these people are going to come in now. We have another section of the community, the unfortunate man living near the towns whose land is spoken of as potential building land. He was there, but he could not purchase, and he did not know the day on which he might be thrown out. But he will now be able to come in and purchase his holding independent of any grabbing landlord. We were told in connection with some cases that the judges were giving time in the case of people sued for land annuities. But they would not allow time to the leaseholders who were now lugged in before them. They had to pay on the day the money was due. I saw that a judge in Cork last week, when dealing with such cases said these men were able to go to the dogs, and shows and race meetings, where they could be seen any time. These are matters which we have to consider. We have to consider those who were forgotten during the old days, and who were forgotten under the new régime. For ten years these unfortunate farmers were left without any hope of getting from under the heel of the landlord, they were paying three times the rent they should be paying, and there was no mercy for them. They had a lease, or if they happened to go into a farm on which there was a fairly decent house, they were told it was a residential holding. There was no hope of relief for these poor people. They are brought in now. Then we hear Deputies talking about fixity of tenure for the District Justice with 351 acres, fixity of tenure for the gentleman with 5,700 acres. Peasant proprietors! We had a tale of woe and of misery. We remember those things and we are sick of hearing these things for the last few days. When we look at the position and judge it for ourselves we know where we are. I did not expect anything better from the Centre Party, knowing the actions of these Deputies on previous Land Acts here. I remember a famous case brought in here after a long struggle outside. They had no scruple in decreeing those people. We hear of the special powers being taken under this Bill, and of the power of a sheriff to seize without going into court. The sheriff came into my place and made a seizure without going into court in 1924, just after I had got back from enjoying the hospitality of Deputy Cosgrave. He came to seize for income tax due from 1919 to 1920. For portion of that period I was in Wormwood Scrubbs with Deputy Cosgrave.
Comment on this
Now you know. You walked out, but I had to do a hunger-strike to get out. The income tax gentleman in that case sent me a notification to pay up and look pleasant. I went to see him and told him that I did not take the farm until June, 1920, and, even then, I was in jail most of the time and had not enjoyed any of the benefits of the holding. He said: "If you do not pay I will have the sheriff sent down to you." I said, "You can sue me in court." He said, "We need not sue you in the court at all." He sent down his sheriffs and bailiffs and two lorries of military to collect the amount. That happened and it can happen again, because you never repealed that particular Act which is there still for the income tax people. That was the only time I ever paid and it is the only time I will ever pay.
Comment on this
You are just showing how dangerous it is to give such powers to the Land Commission. I was placed in the same position myself.
Comment on this
I am giving you facts and you can use them. I am not at all surprised at the action of the Centre Party. I remember seeing unfortunate tenants in my constituency decreed by the Land Commission repeatedly— decreed for what annuities? For annuities that were 10 per cent. and 15 per cent. higher than the rent they had been paying to the landlord. These were tenants who got 30 per cent., 35 per cent. and 40 per cent. reduction in 1919 and 1920, who under the benevolent administration of the Hogan Act had the old rent returned to the Land Commission by the landlord as the rent they were paying, while for four years, from 1919 to 1923, they had been paying that reduced rent. In 1923 the landlord returned the old rent to the Land Commission as the rent paid. They got 25 per cent. reduction off that and that left them paying 10 per cent. more to the Land Commission than they had been paying to the landlord. A case came before a Land Commission Court consisting of three fairly honest decent men and that court gave a verdict in favour of the tenant. The case then went to the Court of Appeal and this Court of Appeal, which is supposed to be so upright and honourable that nobody should touch it, turned down the tenant's case. On 18th June, 1931, I brought a Bill into the Dáil to give justice to these tenants. That Bill had the honour of being the first Bill which was objected to on First Reading by the then Government. I sent copies of the Bill to the various Farmers' Unions. The Secretary of the Cork Farmers' Union wrote back stating that his executive examined the Bill, that it was remedying a crying injustice, and that he had written to their Party in the Dáil to vote for it. What did the Farmers' Party do? They went into the Lobby in favour of the landlord against the tenant. These are facts and facts are not nice things. I have the names here. Deputy Holohan is here.
I will give just a case in point in connection with that decision. The tenant was paying £20. He got an abatement of 40 per cent. reducing it to £12 in 1919. The decision stated that for the purpose of compounded arrears of rent and interest in lieu of rent, that is, from 1923 until such time as the land would be vested, the rent would be further reduced to £9, but on vesting the tenant would have to go hack and pay £13. That was the judgment. I shall leave you to judge who was wrong. There was another tenant who was paying £12 rent to the landlord, and it was reduced to £9. By the decision given on the day that land would be vested he would have to go back and pay £13 per year. That was the kind of decision you got under the Hogan Act. Is it any wonder that we are setting up a tribunal which we hope will be fairer than that kind of thing?
I wish Deputies speaking here would at least be fair and not be making charges they cannot substantiate. Any charge I make I can bring evidence to prove it. Deputy Belton to-day, for instance, waxed very eloquent against giving the farmers who owed five or six years' annuity any chance. What do you think of the unfortunate fellow who has been paying ever since 1923, under the Hogan Act, to 1933, 10 per cent. or 15 per cent. more rent to-day than he would pay to the landlord? Is he not to get a chance? Has he no hope? The very individuals who were speaking here, and blaming the economic war for everything, owed the annuities before the economic war started. I do not want to be personal by any means but I want fair play all round, and when they say that this was brought in in order to benefit the followers of Fianna Fáil they are making deliberate misstatements. It will benefit the followers of every Party. I think that the fellow who has been paying this 10 per cent. or 15 per cent. more is entitled to get a chance of coming up again.
Comment on this
I never quibbled or refused to answer a question. I admit that the statement is substantially correct.
Comment on this
I was asked were not those arrears paid by the rates, and I say that that statement is substantially correct. The case was made that our reason for introducing the Bill was that it would benefit Fianna Fáil supporters. The individual who said that was a person who owed annuities before the economic war came on.
Comment on this
I regret, sir, that I went so far outside the rules of debate, but when one is asked a question one has to reply. There is another aspect of this Land Bill for which I should like to get consideration. There are a large number of holdings along by the sea coast and beside large rivers where the sea eats in and where portions of the land are constantly submerged. I know of one particular holding where the occupier is paying land annuity on 47 acres, but where the actual area which he has at present is only 21 acres. No remedy was found for that under the 1923 Act and the landlord was paid the full amount. He was paid for 47 acres, when at that period there were only 30 acres. No relief was given to that tenant under the 1923 Act, the 1927 Act, the 1929 Act, nor under the 1930 Act. No relief, whatsoever, was given to him. That tenant is now brought in and relieved. That unfortunate man, who was paying for 47 acres where he only had 21 acres, is now brought in and given relief. These are points that Deputies should consider when they examine the Bill, if they ever do examine it. Judging from all the speeches I heard here to-day they seem to have hit upon three or four sections for which there is an unanswerable case. They built on these sections and did not look towards the good portions of the Bill at all. I know that the lawyers are squirming over this Bill. It is the biggest wallop the lawyers ever got. We had Deputy Roddy telling us that the proposals contained in Section 27 were considered by the Committee before and were turned down. He informed us afterwards that he had considered them about four years ago and turned them down. Another statement was made here by the former Minister for Agriculture in which he used the very same words. He used the very same words when we brought in the Butter Prices (Stabilisation) Bill. He said: "That scheme was put before me about 12 months ago and I turned it down." If that scheme was not there to-day where would the farmers be? They would be getting 2d. a gallon for their milk. Deputy Roddy turned this down too. I should like to see the lawyers drawing their costs.
Comment on this
I do. I approve of every section and every clause in it. Everyone of them is wanted, especially at the present time. Perhaps there will be more wanting. I hold that the Bill is a good one and I hold that the Bill was never more needed. It gives the farmers a reduction of 50 per cent. in their annuities.
Comment on this
And it was never more needed, as the Deputy says; but when Deputies opposite speak of hard times for the farmers I ask them what did their Party do?
Comment on this
When the price of agricultural produce went down by £13,000,000 in five years was there one single step taken by Deputies opposite or by the late Executive Council to give the farmers one bit of relief? I drew £750,000 out of them the year before last, but it was with a corkscrew I had to draw it. We are now giving the farmers 50 per cent. reduction. When we hear that kind of statement and when we hear Deputies talking in that way, we wonder if Deputies opposite are in any way honest. A few nights ago here they gave us a famous statement that was made when they went over to negotiate, which was to the effect that: "Cannot you go hack and knock that cock over with this; it might lead to a settlement of the economic war." It probably would lead to it very quickly if they went over before and got a certain stick to use against the other fellow here, as it was put by the British at the time. Perhaps they went over again. Either they did go over or they are terrible frauds. The guarantee was to be no annuities until the end of 1934 and 50 per cent. reduction then. What were the grounds for that guarantee?
Comment on this
The Deputy is not entitled to demand that information on this Bill, nor would any Deputy be entitled to give him the information.
Comment on this
They claim to be honest and patriotic and, surely, when they are patriotic and honest they will tell us the heads of that agreement. I recommend this Bill to the House as a Bill that is a remedy for grave injustice. It is a good Bill. It is doing the best on behalf of the farming community of this country. It is a Bill, I admit, that the Party opposite could not bring in. I admit that when the Party opposite were in office they were working under a very severe handicap, particularly from 1927 to 1932. In that time they had a very severe handicap because the landlord Party in this country held the balance of power in the Free State and the Government could not be expected to do much. This Bill will do its part now and I hope that Deputy Dillon will take very seriously to heart the position as regards fixity of tenure. I hope he will take that seriously to heart. I have explained as best I could the reason why that particular section has been inserted in that way. It was because those landlords, those peasant proprietors with 5,760 acres or 5,770 acres of land were getting away with that and it was time they were stopped.
Comment on this
I find it rather difficult to bring my mind back to the Land Bill after that rather amusing exhibition by Deputy Corry. I congratulate him on having done his work remarkably well and with far more success, if I may say so, than the Attorney-General. It was quite obvious that both the Attorney-General and Deputy Corry were put up to take the attention of this House off the very exhaustive analysis of this Bill that was made by Deputy Roddy, the ex-Parliamentary Secretary for Lands and Fisheries. Deputy Roddy went through this Bill section by section and clause by clause. He examined it as an expert and he put up some very pertinent questions. The answer of the Government was the procedure that we are getting accustomed to, that was, putting up an expert who in rather a serious way spoke about every subject under the sun except Deputy Roddy's speech and, if I may say so, every subject under the sun except the Land Bill. Then we had Deputy Corry put up to do the same thing in a rather humorous, if less expert, but in a more successful way. I would like at the opening to bring the attention of the House, particularly the attention of the Minister, when he closes this debate, back to the particular statement made by Deputy Roddy. I hope that the Government will not use the same trickery as they did last week of allowing Ministers or Secretaries to escape from the case made. I merely say that in order to switch the attention of the House and the Minister back to that particularly thorough and exhaustive examination of this Bill that was made by Deputy Roddy. I may say that I regard this Bill—and in that I am quite at one with Deputy Corry—as a purely political Bill. It is rather encouraging after a week's debate that we have at last a Deputy standing up on the Government Benches to say that this is a political Bill; that they have nothing to be ashamed of in the fact that it is a political Bill and that they are ready to announce to the world that it is a political Bill. I agree with Deputy Corry there. But I go further, and I regard this Bill as a political Bill and as a particularly corrupt thing. Really dangerous sections of it are hidden and submerged in a mist of words. It is rather a bulky volume. In Bolshevist Russia a Bill containing its provisions would be introduced perhaps in a half-page of foolscap. The Russian Bill would merely declare that half the land of this State belonged to the Government for the time being and would be divided amongst its political supporters. That is all they do in Russia, and all I say about them is that in that they are honest and courageous. They do what they mean to do and they are not ashamed to do it. Here we have every petty attempt to hide the really operative clauses of the Bill and to submerge the intentions behind it. What does this Bill do? It is difficult to follow the Government speeches. In one breath they complain that the division of the land was not sufficient in the years gone by. In the next breath they complain that the land divided was divided at too high a price, and that the persons who got the land could not carry on. On which foot are they standing? Is the real cause that land distribution was too slow and that sufficient land was not divided? And if that is the case, how do they meet Deputy Roddy's assertion that there is something like 250,000 acres in process of purchase; that there are 100,000 acres in the hands of the Land Commission since his time in which the purchase has been completed and that there are 60,000 acres in the hands of the Land Commission for which schemes of division have been prepared?
If there is the acute want of land that we are told necessitated this Bill, and if the urgency is so great, why not subdivide some of that 250,000 acres, the 100,000 acres, or the 60,000 acres that have been there undivided during the full period of the Fianna Fáil administration? There has been scarcely one acre of that land given to those people whom we are told are starving for a little land. What is the explanation? If that land is there undivided, what is the urgency about this Bill? Why is it being rushed now when the Minister responsible for that particular Department is not here to answer to the Dáil and when we have a Minister piloting a Bill who more or less confesses to his ignorance of this subject in the course of the lengthy statement he made to the House on the Second Reading? If there are 60,000 acres in the hands of the Land Commission, for which schemes are prepared, would not the Land Commission and the Government be better engaged subdividing that land amongst uneconomic holders than in rushing a Bill of this kind through the Dáil? Here again we have the old trick of failing to face up to a responsibility. We have somebody else who can reasonably advance the plea that he is not conversant with the subject.
We have in this debate a miserable attempt on the part of the Government to keep itself bolstered up between its predecessors on the one side and the economic war on the other side. As far as we had any reference to this Bill by the Attorney-General, we had the contemptible attempt to shelter behind the Land Act of 1923. The Act of 1923 was introduced by the Government at that time. That Government was not ashamed to stand up to that measure. They did not blame anybody else for it, nor they did not try to excuse themselves in any way either in that or in any other measures they introduced. Let this Government stand for their own measures, and let them tell us even at this stage if this Bill represents their policy with regard to the land. If it does, there is no necessity to shelter behind their predecessors or behind the economic war. Let them sponsor the Bill; let them say that is their policy, and then we can see what are the outstanding features of this Bill.
In this Bill we have an arrangement by which all the rules governing the procedure in the operation and administration of this Bill will be framed by a majority of a Committee consisting of the non-judicial commissioner, the secretary of the Land Commission, and an officer appointed from the Department. The rules will be made by a Committee acting under the Minister, and with this security in advance, that the only big voice that will be heard will be that of the Minister, and the rules relating to finance will be made by the Minister for Finance. This House is asked to consider a Land Bill for the compulsory acquisition of land from the farmers of this country without telling the House one bit about that Finance Bill or how it is proposed to do that when the land is being taken over. We are asked to go into this blindfolded like so many Deputies in blinkers. It may be that so many shares in the Irish Press will pass out to the man deprived of his land, or it may be in the form of token coinage. We are not told how the land is to be paid for. I think, in any business community, if compulsory acquisition or the purchase of any article is being discussed, the first thing the people are entitled to know is the price and the particular type of coinage in which they are to be paid. Here all that is shirked. By virtue of a Parliamentary majority this Bill will be put through; but the Bill will be forced through without any knowledge as to how it is to be paid for.
We have a further section of the Bill giving powers over people's property, powers over the homesteads of Irish men and Irish women. All those powers are to pass over to the temporary political head of a Department and by way of eyewash we are told that there are certain exempted matters, certain matters with which the Minister alone cannot deal, such as from whom the land will be taken, the price to be paid for the land and exactly what particular person will get the land. We are told that these are excepted matters. These excepted matters merely go out by one door and back by a back-door to the Minister's office. These excepted matters are referred to a special tribunal called the appeal tribunal. That appeal tribunal consists of two officials nominated by the Minister, plus a judicial commissioner. The proviso is laid down that a majority of the three will be the deciding factor. In advance it is secured that an absolute majority of the three will be nominated by the Minister to do the Minister's work and will be removable by the Minister if they do not do his work. I think the farmers of Ireland would rather have no safeguards than that kind of safeguard that is merely a humbug. There again I think it would be more decent and more courageous for the Minister to do away with these exceptions and retain all those powers for himself. There is no real safeguard there. The real safeguard that was there is deliberately removed, and now we have a majority of that committee consisting of removable nominees of the Minister.
We have a further section in this Bill dealing with arrears of land annuities. So far as I understand the matter, arrears of land annuities prior to three years ago are to be completely forgiven and arrears of land annuities which accrued in the last three years are to be funded. I would like some justification for that. Is it the pricking of a guilty conscience? Is it the uneasy conscience stimulated by the knowledge that the arrears which occurred between 1923 and 1929 were the direct result of the gospel preached by the Fianna Fáil Leader, and is it because of that that we have a complete forgiveness of the arrears prior to 1930? If it is not that, what is the explanation? Why should people who failed to pay their land annuities when there was no economic war, when prices may have been poor but the markets were open and no tariffs were operating against the farmer—why should people who went into arrears during such a period have their arrears completely wiped out, whereas those who went into arrears during the period of the economic war, when the markets were practically closed against them and when they were trying to throw their produce over an impossible tariff wall, have got to pay up every penny by way of a funding arrangement? I think some explanation is due to the House in defence of that particular discrimination. It would strike me that if there is to be any discrimination it should be the other way about entirely. That discrimination should be in favour of the individual who ran into arrears during the period when his produce was carrying an impossible tariff. That is the point I raise in the hope of getting some information from the Minister when he is closing the debate.
I regard this Bill as sounding a very definite retreat. I believe that the Bill sounds a retreat back to a period prior to the passage of the first Land Act. I believe this Bill is undoing all the work of our fathers and our grandfathers. I believe this Bill is trampling on the graves of all the great patriots who took part in the land struggle in the past. When I want information as to the sentiments that stimulated those men or the object that bound them together I would rather have those sentiments expressed to me by a Dillon or a Davitt rather than by a Ruttledge or a Corry. I listened to the Minister for Justice here last week when he told us that the land war was a war to place the very small farmer in his holding and that it was never fought in the interest of the bigger farmers. I differ absolutely from the Minister for Justice in that interpretation of the spirit of the land war.
The spirit that animated those who took part in the land war was a spirit of unity and cohesion. Farmers of all classes, farmers of all creeds, big farmers and little farmers, farmers' labourers and townsmen, were all knit together in one great national movement and it comes very badly from this Dáil in the year 1933, 12 years after the establishment of an Irish Government in an Irish State, for anyone to stand up and belittle that movement and the founders of that movement. It was a great movement of masses and classes and that is why it won out. The desire and the ambition of those who participated was to make the Irishman's home his castle, to plant the Irishman down with deep roots in the land and to make the purchased tenant in this country as fixed in his land as the Rock of Gibraltar. When land was acquired and when land division took place then the benefits flowed further and you had 40,000 agricultural labourers placed in decent cottages with a plot of land at the back. Such work would have been impossible but for the Land Acts and the victory won by those who participated in the land war. I think it is about time that that particular expression of the Minister for Justice was challenged in this House. It is unfair to those who participated in that war and it certainly is rather loose and a rather anti-national interpretation of the spirit of the land war.
Under this particular Bill one of the things that will strike the country most harshly is the particular powers which the Land Commission takes of seizing the stock of a farmer who goes into arrears, and seizing that stock by merely sending a chit down to an officer in the county. Heretofore persons in default had an opportunity of going into court, asking for time and explaining, if they could, the failure to pay the annuities. They were brought into court, remember, after they had put up their case to the Land Commission; the Land Commission then brought them into court. The result of such court proceedings, so far as I know, was that in nine cases out of ten time was given to the farmer to pay. Now we have the proposal that the Minister can not only wade in and take anybody's land but that he can wade in and take it at the price ruling at that particular date; and that, following a campaign to reduce the value of land and everything associated with land. I think there is a fair case to say that no such Bill as this should be considered as long as the economic war lasts. No matter which side is responsible for the economic war the facts are that there is an economic war between this country and Great Britain; that the chief losers in that economic war are the farmers of Ireland; that one of the direct results of the economic war is a slump in prices of agricultural produce; and that another result is to reduce correspondingly the value of land. There is no denying that, as I say in such circumstances, with stock value reduced to rock-bottom figures and with land values reduced to rock-bottom figures it is nothing short of criminal for any Government to take advantage of such a situation to go in and take the land from the farmers at the present value of land.
Comment on this
We have listened to some very able and some very lengthy speeches on this Bill. I am opposed to this Bill, and I propose to state the reasons for my opposition as briefly as I possibly can. It is not easy at this stage to make new points, but I shall try to crystallise in as few words as I can my main objections. I should like to say that I have sought to approach the matter as impartially as I possibly could. I am, by sentiment and upbringing, a radical. When I hear rights of property pleaded on the one side against the greatest good of the greatest number on the other side, my prejudice would rather lead me to take the side of the greatest good of the greatest number. When I hear much talk of the sanctity of property rights, when I hear expressions about the right of every man to do what he likes with his own, and "What I have I hold," my natural tendency is to be on the opposite side to the people who use such expressions. I think I can fairly say that I approached this measure in a spirit of impartiality. Having given to it as much attention as I am capable of, and having read and listened to all I could read or listen to about it, I must say that I am convinced that the Bill is a bad one. I object to it in the first place because it is untimely. In the second place, so far as I have been able to judge up to the present, it is economically unsound. I object to it in the third place because it gives power to the Executive which I believe it to be politically and morally unhealthy for the Executive to have. As regards its untimeliness, Deputy O'Higgins has just put it to the House that at a moment when the value of land is abnormally depressed it is unfair to proceed with the compulsory acquisition of land on the basis of prices which at present might be considered to represent the market value. I agree with that, and I think he might have gone a step further. I think he might have considered the same point from the angle of the people who are to be put on that land. Is it fair, just or reasonable to those people to embark them on this experiment? Is it reasonable to settle them on the land until you have provided some sort of market for what you expect them to produce? Have you at present got sufficient markets for what we are producing? If you have not, where is the justification for putting a number of congests or landless men in possession of more land, inviting them to embark on a course of speculation and to produce things which they will not be able to sell at a profit? So much for untimeliness.
What about the general question of the economic soundness of this policy? We have been told by several speakers that it is the logical continuation of the Act of 1923. It seems to me a waste of time to argue whether it is or is not the logical continuation of the Act of 1923. I was not called upon to consider the Act of 1923 at the time, but I certainly would say that if this Act is the logical and inevitable continuation of the Act of 1923, then the Act of 1923 was a bad Act. I look at this Bill on its own merits, and I say on its merits that it is bad. It is a matter of indifference whether or not it is the lineal successor of the Act of 1923. It appears to me that in voting for or against this Bill we are voting for or against the question as to whether Parnell was right in his views about the economics of this country. Every vote given in favour of this Bill is, to my mind, a vote in favour of the view that Parnell was wrong. It is a vote in favour of the view that instead of its being the best practical policy for a man to feel secure in the possession of his land, the whole land system of this country should be in a perpetual state of uncertainty. There is nothing temporary about this Bill. The powers which are being taken are apparently being taken for all time. There is no limitation to the period during which a man with a small amount of land may be whisked away from one end of Ireland to another at the decision of the Land Commission, perhaps inspired by the Minister. When people talk so much about lazy ranchers and so forth, about the necessity for taking away the land from people who use it badly and giving it to others who, it is hoped, will use it well, I think it is extraordinary that absolutely no weight whatever is given to the ordinary forces of economics; that it is not considered that in the case of land, as in the case of other things, the man who is lazy and inefficient will go to the wall; that in course of time the land will pass out of his hands into the hands of other people who are more capable of working it efficiently. I do not say that that happens as rapidly or inevitably as one would wish, but I would trust largely to automatic causes of that kind for securing that the land of this country was properly utilised rather than to the arbitrary decisions of whatever Government might be in power at the time.
It is not as if Irish history was a history of all sorts of evils arising from people having too firm a grip upon the land. Of course we all agree as to the evil that arose out of the landlord system. But taking Irish history as a whole there has been a series of upsets. Ownership of land was in the melting pot stretching away back Heaven knows how long in Irish history. The closest parallel to what is attempted to-day, that is the attempt to upset the whole land policy followed by Parnell and his successors, is what occurred in the reign of James I. The English land system was then introduced and individual title to land was created in Connaught and land distributed amongst big people and small people. Not many years later, because it happened to suit English policy, Strafford, who represented British rule in this country, had all these titles invalidated and the system of land tenure was thrown into the melting pot again. It seems to me that the closest parallel to that is what the Government is attempting at the present moment. This Bill is a right-about-face and a complete upset of what has been accomplished hitherto. I see no finality in this measure and, as I have already put it, it seems to me to imply that the Irish land system will be in a state of perpetual flux.
I do not want to be understood as saying that in no circumstances must a holder of land be interfered with at all. I think that in the case of land, as in the case of all other property, but particularly in the case of land which is so fundamental to the community, the Government has a right to intervene if that property is being used in a definitely anti-social manner. But that is a thing that arises, in my opinion, rarely and any interference of this sort with the ownership of property, whether landed or other property, must be hedged round with close restrictions. Otherwise the power of interference is certain to be abused. As a general proposition, if we desire to promote the happiness and prosperity of this country and the best use of the land, I maintain the less State interference with the individual the better. I am certain that is a true and sound proposition.
Advocacy of this Bill as the logical successor to the Act of 1923 leaves me unmoved, because I should oppose it even if it was, but in such advocacy certain things are left out of account. There are certain things in this Bill of which I have heard no defence yet. I am waiting with interest to hear if there will be any defence of them. One is that while increased powers and responsibilities are taken for the Land Commission, simultaneously increased power over the Land Commission is taken by the Government. It is true that the Attorney-General suggested that Deputy Costello had said that the powers of the Government had not really been increased over the Land Commission, but I prefer to take as the proper authority the Acting-Minister for Lands and Fisheries, who introduced this Bill. He certainly represented that the Government were taking increased power over the Land Commission and that it was desirable so to do. I maintain that at the moment when you are increasing, to the extent you are, the powers and responsibilities of the Land Commission itself, that is the very time when instead of clothing itself with more power over the Land Commission, the Government should reduce its power over the Land Commission. The more responsibility the Land Commission has for exercising justice amongst the citizens of this country, the more its operations are extended, as Deputy Hogan pointed out, to questions involving the entire possessions of many citizens of this country, the more they should be freed not only from Government control, but from the semblance of Government control.
Another point. What is the justification for the abolition of the arrangement in regard to land such as home farms and residential holdings that such land should not be taken if other suitable land in the locality was available? Why is that swept away? Deputy Hogan asked that question but no answer was given. I cannot imagine what answer could be given except the general one that the Government wished to throw over every restriction. The third point that seems to be as outstandingly objectionable is that the judicial powers to be exercised are to be exercised by people who are removable. We all remember how resident magistrates used to be sneered at as removable magistrates. Now, instead of the citizens of this country being able to rely upon the protection which consists in having their cases disposed of by judicial authority, not removable at the will of the Government, we are to have two commissioners associated with the judicial commissioner, who are removable if the Government so desires. I cannot imagine what satisfactory explanation there is for that change, or how it will be maintained that it is a necessary or logical development of the 1923 Act. May I say again, in relation to the 1923 Act, that we have really heard extremely little from the Government about that Act or its working. Coming in here more or less as a newcomer, hoping to have a full picture of the situation given when this Bill was introduced, I was extremely disappointed not to hear anything in the nature of a lucid account of what had come about as a result of the 1923 Act, to what extent that Act had been a success, or to what extent the Land Commission was crowded up with more work than it could do, to what extent the Government had bitten off more than they could chew. If this was merely a Bill intended to enable the Land Commission to chew what was already bitten off we should be supporting it. It seems to me that this Bill means that the Land Commission are again going to bite off more than they can chew. It seems to me that it will plunge the Land Commission into a morass more deeply than ever before. We should like to know how much land is already in their hands waiting to be divided up, how much has been offered to them for voluntary purchase, and what has been the fate of people settled on the land under the 1923 Act, before we are asked to pass such a Bill as this giving tremendous additional powers of compulsory acquisition.
I think that is as much as I shall say about the general economic policy of the Bill. I want to say just a few words with reference to its political aspect. I think it was really a very great pity that the Attorney-General was not here to hear Deputy Corry's speech. The Attorney-General had told us that the Land Commission had always been above all suspicion of being influenced by the Government of the day; that they had carried out their work on business principles and in a satisfactory manner and that he had no doubt that they would continue doing so in future as in the past. Deputy Corry told us quite flatly that the land purchase conducted under the 1923 Act had been corruptly conducted under undue influence from the Cumann na nGaedheal Government. He did not put a tooth in it; he said it quite clearly. He made it equally clear that "we," Fianna Fáil, were going to have things conducted in "our" way from now on. Nobody could have made it clearer than he did that, in his opinion, the Land Comission had been the tool of the Cumann na nGaedheal Government, and that it was going to be, and that he desired it to be, the tool of the Fianna Fáil Government in the future.
Comment on this
I am sure he would not like that way of expressing it, but it is the only possible meaning to attach to his speech.
Comment on this
I take it he said that it was certain Imperial interests that controlled the Cumann na nGaedheal Government.
Comment on this
Ministers affect to be exceedingly distressed when anyone suggests that the administration of this Bill will be conducted on Party lines. If that is suggested, they have nobody to blame but themselves and their own followers. The Minister for Agriculture himself went galloping around the country and, amid the delighted cheers of his supporters, told all and sundry that this new Land Bill was going to result in taking away land from the ignoble persons in the Cumann na nGaedheal and Centre Parties and giving it to others more deserving. If, at the very moment when the Government wanted to put the best face on this Bill, he could not resist saying that to please his own supporters, how are we to expect that the Government will resist the temptation to administer the Act when it is on the statute book in the way their own supporters would like them to administer it? What is the driving force behind this Bill? You have only to read the speeches of Fianna Fáil back benchers and the articles in Fianna Fáil papers throughout the country and you will see that the driving force behind this Bill is Party spite plus Bolshevistic sentiment. That is without question the driving force behind it. I see every day allusions to the Imperialists that are to be driven out by the Land Bill, the demesne walls that are to be levelled and the Imperialists driven out——
Comment on this
Exactly, why should they not? If a man is dealing with his land in an anti-social manner I have already agreed that, in principle, and subject to proper safeguards, I have no objection to the State taking such action as shall stop him from dealing with it in an anti-social manner. But it is perfectly plain to me that there is much more than that in the minds of the bulk of the people supporting this Bill, perfectly plain even from the speech of Deputy Corry when he spoke in a voice of horror of anybody possessing more than a certain amount of land. I should like to know whether, in the view of the Minister, or in the view of the Government, the owning of a large amount of land by one individual is in itself a bad thing or a criminal thing, provided that the land is so used as to give a proper amount of employment. Supposing a man has a thousand acres and, because he is prepared to run the place at a loss, because, perhaps, he has got an income from dividends on stocks and shares, or for whatever reason, he is prepared to employ more men than could in fact be provided for on that land if it were taken from him and split up, I should like to know what is the view of the Government upon the situation.
Comment on this
I would not consider any maximum required at all if the land was giving its full quota of employment. I am very much afraid of State interference. But, in so far as the State has a view about how land should be used, and in so far as the State interferes in order to enforce that view, my principle would be that the amount of employment the land provides should be the test.
Comment on this
I am not so sure that Deputies are not sneering at the doctrines of the Catholic Church.
Comment on this
I am afraid the principle of distribution is too vague a one for me to deal with. I am no lover of extremes of wealth on the one hand and extremes of poverty on the other. I think I have made it clear that I have no undue respect for the sanctity of property rights as such. But I do not believe that State interference, as a general practice, works well. I do not believe that the sight of demesne land ought to excite a frenzy of indignation in any one's mind. I believe that people should be satisfied if they are conscious of the fact that land is being reasonably used and is giving a reasonable amount of employment. I wonder again what the policy of the Government would be. This Bill is really extremely empty in some respects. It gives you no idea of what the thoughts in the minds of the Government are about how land should be used and what principles should be applied in order to provide that it is used in a satisfactory manner. I heard Deputy Davin make a speech on this Bill which was nominally in support of the Bill but, as a matter of fact, I thought the speech extremely damaging to the Bill, because he pointed out a number of important practical difficulties, including the difficulty that a great many of the men hitherto settled upon land had failed, either from lack of skill or from lack of adequate capital. He said that while he made all these specific objections to what was in the Bill, nevertheless, he was in favour of the policy aimed at by the Bill. The usual reference of the Labour Party to a Governemnt measure is to the policy "enshrined" in it, which seems to me to give a most undeserved odour of sanctity to Fianna Fáil legislation. On this occasion, the Deputy did not use the word "enshrined," or even use the more natural expression "embodied" in the Bill. He said the policy aimed at by the Bill. He gave us no hint as to what the policy aimed at is. I do not really know what is the policy aimed at by the Bill, unless it is, which I strongly suspect it to be, that the Government, for political purposes, desire to be in a position at any given moment to take land away from A and give it to B because it suits them to do so. I should like, for instance, to know what their view is with regard to the small holders— the settlers that are to be put in— supposing they are using the land in an uneconomic manner and that their system of farming is unsatisfactory. Is it only unsatisfactory farming in the case of the lazy ranchers, or is it unsatisfactory farming by anybody who happens to be lazy or shiftless, or inefficient, that is to come under the attention of the Government and to call for action by the Government?
I have spoken for a longer time than I intended to speak. I feel that this Bill confers far more wide-spreading powers on the Executive than it is at all healthy for the Executive to have. I feel that we have ample evidence from the speeches of the Government's own supporters up and down the country that the greatest pressure will be put on the Government to misuse those powers even if they start off by trying not to misuse them. I feel that there is not enough in the Bill to guide them as to their proper use, and, as nature abhors a vacuum, that that vacuum created by the absence of guiding principles in the Bill will be filled by the Fianna Fáil clubs.
I suppose this Bill will pass. It is one link in the chain of measures by which Fianna Fáil are putting a stranglehold upon every department of life in this country. I suppose the cause of individualism is a lost cause. I suppose the cause of enabling a man to feel that if he works hard and is thrifty and honest he is not going to be disturbed in his land by anybody, is a lost cause. Like an ancestor of mine who was hanged by Queen Elizabeth, I was educated in a university which gloried in the reproach of being the home of lost causes. I have lived long enough to see many a lost cause triumph, and to see victory often snatched from the ashes of defeat. I doubt if the policy that the Government are inaugurating in this Bill is really going to be tolerated for very long. I doubt it greatly. We had some remarks here the other night by the President of the Executive Council about invaders and intruders. I thought the remark came oddly from him, applied as it was applied to about a quarter of the population of this country because they were of British stock. I do not think it will come oddly from the Irish farmer, if he finds his land taken from him by politicians, to consider the politicians as invaders and intruders and I think he will know in the long run how to defend himself and repel the politicians.
Comment on this
One of the points raised by Deputy MacDermot and other Deputies in this debate is that this Bill is untimely. Deputy MacDermot knows, I am sure, and the other Deputies know it also, that legislation is necessary to give the benefit of the 60 per cent. reduction on the annuities. That is, of course, the main provision in this Bill—that the annuities of the farmers are being reduced by 50 per cent. It means, in effect, a gain of £2,000,000 per year to agriculture in this country, which gain would have been impossible were it not for the policy adopted by the Government in keeping these annuities at home. At any rate, the first and most important matter dealt with in this Bill is the halving of the annuities. The second most important matter dealt with is the provisions which will expedite the division of land. Deputy MacDermot asked what was the experience under the 1923 Act. I have not got tables or figures, but I know that the division of land was not being proceeded with at a satisfactory rate. Any Deputy who cares to look at the Order Paper here any day will realise that, because there is no Minister in the Government who gets so many questions addressed to him as the Minister for Lands and Fisheries. All these questions are asked with the view of getting information with regard to delays in the division of land. The principal complaint against the Land Commission always has been the complaint of delays in the division of land. Every Deputy representing a country constituency is continually getting letters from his constituents asking when is such and such an estate being divided. I am quite sure that if any Deputy went to the trouble of going back over the Order Papers for the last three or four months he would find that these questions were not coming entirely from Fianna Fáil supporters, but from supporters of the Cumann na nGaedheal Party, the Centre Party and the Labour Party. These complaints were coming just as much to Deputies opposite as to Deputies on this side of the House.
There are clauses in this Bill which we need not discuss in detail now, but which can be discussed line by line on the Committee Stage. These clauses were inserted as being, in our opinion, the most effective way in which the division of land could be speeded up. Some Deputies here who opposed this Bill, if they only examined the question, will have to admit, I think, that they are against the division of land if they do want these provisions inserted, because I have never heard a Deputy in this House yet when we were in Opposition and the other Party were on this side of the House, or since the other Party went across to the other side of the House, saying that the division of land was going on in a satisfactory way. I think that any Deputy, if he were asked the question, would say that it was not going on in a satisfactory way. I think that any Deputy, if he were asked whether he thought the question of the relief of congestion was being dealt with in the manner in which it was expected to be dealt with ten years ago, would admit that it was not being dealt with in a satisfactory way. Every Deputy knows quite well that that problem was not being dealt with properly. Every Deputy will admit, I think, that the Land Commission were doing their best under the powers they had, so that if Deputies oppose the extended powers that we are looking for in this Act they are in reality opposing any satisfactory solution either of the problem of congestion or of the division of land. Of course, they will not say that. No Deputy from Connaught on the Cumann na nGaedheal side will say that he does not want congestion dealt with. They will say how unfair the provisions of this Bill are politically, and so on. They will make general charges of that nature and will not come down to the concrete question and point out to us how the thing could be done in any other way so as to speed up the problem of the division of land and of congestion. Let them point out how it can be dealt with in another way—keep the Government out of it altogether, if you like—but let us have an alternative. All they are prepared to do is to sling charges against the Government of political motives and so on.
There are Deputies who implied by their speeches, at any rate, that the division of land, or a further division of land is not necessary. Deputy MacDermot, for instance, gave the case of the owner of 1,000 acres who might be able, through his private means or in some other way, to give good employment and keep a number of families in better circumstances than they would be in, if the land were divided amongst them, and he asked what would be our opinion. As far as I am concerned I would advise them to work for that man as long as he could pay the wages There may be some exceptions in the way the Deputy mentions. There may be a farmer with a large farm here and there who is paying very good wages, and if the farm were divided up amongst those people they might not be so well off as they were. I think that is the type of farm with which the Land Commission would not interfere. As I have already pointed out there are certain phrases about proper methods of husbandry in the Bill as in the previous Acts. They have been interpreted in a certain way by the Land Commission, and there is no suggestion that they will not be interpreted in the same way in future.
Comment on this
What about the magic of property that we heard so much about to-day? A 1,000 acre farm would make a good many economic holdings.
Comment on this
In the Land Act of 1923 there was a clause inserted that land could be taken from people in the interests of food production of the country. If we had put such a section in this Bill we would be told that the Minister for Lands and Fisheries would interpret that in such a way that he would wipe out all his political opponents.
Comment on this
The landless people would be satisfied if they had sufficient land to grow food for themselves.
Comment on this
You will not be allowed to grow thistles now. That is one of the things we stopped. I would like to refer to the returns with regard to the size of the holdings, the production of animals and farm produce per 1,000 acres. These are taken from the census of 1926 under the Cumann na nGaedheal Government. Anybody who would look at these figures would be firmly convinced that the division of land is desirable in every way. Here is what we find: two-thirds of the rural population of this country were living on one-third of the land, and the other one-third of the rural population is living on two-thirds of the land. This one-third of the land on which two-thirds of the population is living is the poorest part in the country. It is in the congested and poorer land that two-thirds of the rural population is living. Then when we see how they are living we find that these people in the small holdings are producing more per acre on the poorer land than the other people are producing on the good land where the population is not so congested. Deputy Belton made the point that we were anxious to have more tillage. We would not break up the ranches without producing more tillage. Deputy Hogan made the point that if we were to take away the land from the ranchers to any great extent we would deprive the labourer of his living. But in these returns we find there is much more employment per 1,000 acres on the small farms than on the big farms. It is a remarkable fact with regard to production that in every single thing with the exception of two-year-old cattle and sheep production increases as the size of the farm goes down. We find from these returns that tillage increases inversely with the size of the holding; hay increases inversely with the size of the holding; milch cows increase, pigs increase, poultry increases and the total number of cattle reared increase with the size of the holding. The only exceptions are, as I have mentioned. That is because in small holdings they do not keep so many sheep and so many two-year olds. It is desirable, therefore, in the interests of production to have small holdings, and it is certainly more desirable from the point of view of meeting the increased population that is inevitable in a country where emigration is denied.
Comment on this
Might I ask a question? Why is it with a number of farms advertised for sale throughout the country that the Land Commission do not go down and buy up and divide those farms amongst the congests?
Comment on this
Does the Deputy mean land offered for sale on the market?
Comment on this
The Land Commission has no power to buy land on the market. They must take the land according to the procedure laid down. They cannot go into an auctioneer's room and buy land. Deputy MacDermot says that in this Bill there is no finality. I do not think there is. Nobody would expect finality in the matter of the land problem. It would be very foolish to do so. This matter of land purchase has gone along by evolution from somewhere back in the 'seventies up to the present.
Comment on this
I would not say that; it will go forward until the Centre Party comes into power.
Comment on this
There are certain small points in this Bill with which I do not want to deal to any great extent. Certain injustices are removed with regard to mill holdings. Derelict holdings, submerged lands and potential building land are dealt with in the Bill. These are matters that, perhaps, can be better dealt with in Committee. They do not arise to any great extent on the principle of the Bill and they have not been referred to by any speaker on the opposite side.
A question that has been referred to at great length was the question of the arrears. Deputies opposite say that we are almost immoral when we are putting down a rule that we will not go back beyond three years in funding the arrears. I agree with Deputy O'Higgins that it is no defence at all to say that we are sheltering ourselves behind what was done in the 1923 Act. I would not like to have to defend our actions by sheltering in any way behind the Cumann na nGaedheal Government actions. But where you have practically what is a precedent, that is a principle in all the Land Acts that preceded this Land Bill, it is a different matter.
In practically every Bill that preceded this you had the principle that some relief should be given in the way of arrears of annuities. When we came in we followed this rule and we are taking three years arrears. Any thing over that was forgiven. We thought that we would do the same as was done in previous Acts. We did not want to be less generous than the British Government or the Cumann na nGaedheal Government. It may have been, perhaps, wrong to forgive the people those three years. I know there are people with seven or eight years' arrears and some even with 20 years' arrears. But if you go much beyond three years you will be bringing the annuity to be paid when this Bill goes through to practically the level at which it stood before. What would happen may be that in five or six years' time that holding may change hands and the new owner will then say: "Here I am paying 15/- an acre and my neighbour is only paying 8/- or 9/-. This is an injustice." Very likely in four or five years' time some Government would have to bring in a Bill to make this injustice right just as we had to bring in a Bill to give relief to people who got land under the 1923 Act and which was distributed by our predecessors. Looking at it from the point of view of the Land Commission, the position is that there is a large number of years of arrears, and if these were added the rent charged would be as high, if not higher, after the reduction as it was some years before. In that way in a few years we would create a position when the holding would not be a security to the Land Commission for the amount due. We had to draw the line somewhere. We had to go back to ten years or five years or somewhere. In all the circumstances the precedent of the previous Bills was adopted and that was to make it three years. I did not find it possible to be present last Thursday when this Bill was debated, but I read the papers afterwards and I gathered what was the criticism offered to this Bill.
I have been here most of the day and I have heard criticisms which were much the same as were submitted on the last day. There has been really no great criticism levelled against the Bill. There has been that general sort of camouflage about politics, injustice, doing away with security of tenure, Bolshevism, confiscation, and so on. There were general charges, but no attempt on the part of any speaker to point out where they were contained in the Bill; no attempt to support any charge. Deputy Hogan said it was purely a political Bill, that it would do no good but would do unlimited harm and unlimited injustice. I remember distinctly the first Bill I brought in here, the Dairy Stabilisation Bill, and Deputy Hogan said the very same things about it—that it would do no good, but a lot of harm and that it was a political stunt. He described the Cereals Bill as a political Bill brought in to please the barley growers and, as he called them, a few mugs.
Comment on this
I knew very well Deputy Hogan would say the same things about this Bill. He did tell us that it was a political Bill to help Fianna Fáil supporters and that it would do a lot of harm in the country. He said the Dairy Stabilisation Bill was a thoroughly bad Bill. As regards this Bill, he mentions that no matter how drastically it will be administered it will benefit very few people. As regards security of tenure, Deputy Hogan did not stress that very much. I suppose he feels he was the first offender in that respect.
Deputy Costello made a most extraordinary statement—if the newspapers reported him correctly. I will quote the Irish Times, because it may, perhaps, be regarded more as the official organ of Cumann na nGaedheal than any other paper. He is there reported as saying: “Under Section 28, if a farmer with a farm of less than £2,000 is carrying it on in a way that the nominee of the Minister thinks is not the way an ordinary farm should be carried on, the Land Commission, under the direction of the Minister, can acquire the land, may retain it and give him nothing whatever in return.” Surely, Deputy Costello, if he had read the Bill, would have seen that the owner of the land must be paid in land or bonds. If land is taken from an individual because he is not using it in a proper way, it certainly cannot be taken without giving something in return. He must get either land or bonds.
Comment on this
The market value. The Land Commission will decide that. Deputy Belton, who made a record speech for this House, used a good many of the arguments that he submitted when my estimate was being considered and he used similar arguments on the Agricultural Products (Exports) Bill, the Musk Rats Bill and some other measures. There was one statement of his that I caught. He said that it was a fallacy to think that by dividing land we could increase village. He went on to say that better employment was given by the large farmer—it was practically the same point as that made by Deputy MacDermot—and that the men who were working for large farmers were better off than if they were living on small farms, the big farm being divided. Perhaps in some places and with some employers that is true, but if such cases are there, I am sure the Land Commission is not going to interfere with them. But when we take other cases, the case, for instance, of a man with 1,300 acres in County Roscommon, where it is impossible to get the land from him and where he is not employing anybody, why should not the Land Commission get power to take such land and divide it amongst the congests who are getting nothing from the owner of that land at present?
In reply to Deputy Belton's argument that we would not get more tillage, I would like to point out that when the large estate is divided into 30 or 40 acre lots the smallholders would naturally have much more production. They would go into the production of pigs, poultry, mixed farming, perhaps dairying, and the rearing of cattle and sheep.
Comment on this
The Minister has laboured the question of production. Three months ago I asked him about the price of oats in Donegal and he told me flatly he did not believe me when I said oats were sold there at 6d. He declared the price was 9d. Is the rest of his story about production on the same lines? Just let us get down to pure facts.
Comment on this
I am talking about production. The Deputy is talking about prices.
Comment on this
I told the Deputy on another occasion that I did not believe oats were being sold for that price in Donegal, and I do not believe it yet. I have been interested in several enquiries about oats in Donegal.
Comment on this
I still adhere to what I said on the last occasion. At the time the question was asked oats were sold at 6d. in Donegal. They will not fetch that to-day.
Comment on this
It is a pity that Deputy O'Leary would not put all these interruptions into a speech.
Comment on this
I was accused by Deputy MacDermot of making an inciting speech to the effect that land would be taken from his followers and the followers of Cumann na nGaedheal under this Bill. Unfortunately the daily Press thought it a good point that we should take the land from the followers of Cumann na nGaedheal and the Centre Party and distribute it amongst congests and uneconomic holders, but they did not report me in full. I have here a copy of the local paper which, perhaps, gives the speech more fully. It is unfair to quote a person out of the context. I was talking about all the benefits that we have conferred on the community about the old age pensioners, the people who require houses, the disabled and the wounded in the War for Independence, and then I came to the farmers who had lost their living, especially, as they said, after the last election. There are people who say they are very poor and cannot go on any longer. I declared that we were going to do something for them, too. I said a good many followers of the Cumann na nGaedheal Party and the Centre Party complained that they could not carry on. I said we had no malice against these men, and that we were prepared to give them a good price for their land if they were not able to continue to work it. I also said: "If there is a poor farmer who is a follower of Fianna Fáil and who cannot make his farm pay, we will take it from him and give him a good price for it, too." I did not leave them out. If there are benefits going I do not see why the Fianna Fáil supporters should not get them as well. I said that in Clonmel, and it is the Clonmel Nationalist, if Deputies want to see it.
Comment on this
Perhaps it is. I have only Clonmel on it and I do not know what the second word is. At any rate, it is one of the local papers. The next point is about the appeal tribunal, which has been criticised severely. The charge is that we are putting in removable men to sit on that tribunal. Our predecessors had removable men also. The Land Commissioners were appointed by the Executive Council, were removable by the Executive Council and were, in fact, removed by the Executive Council.
Comment on this
The judicial commissioner was not removable. I will come to the appeal tribunal in one minute. We had the Land Commissioners removable by the Executive Council at their will. If we liked we could say—but of course we would not say it—that they had to do what the late Executive Council told them. That is the suggestion from Cumann na nGaedheal now that those men will have to do what we tell them.
Comment on this
Does the Minister hear Deputy Corry behind him? He should hearken to the words of wisdom.
Comment on this
The appeal tribunal can decide as to whether the land shall be taken or not. On matters of price it is referred to the judicial commissioner only. Exception has been taken——
Comment on this
We know all that. Do not go over it again. It is unfair for Deputies to go out for four or five hours and then come back when the question has been completely explained by the Attorney-General and raise the matter again.
Comment on this
I did not want to insult the Minister and I apologise to him. I am sure he did not mean to make the slip he has made that the question of law is decided by the judicial commissioner.
Comment on this
The question of law is decided by the judicial commissioner when it has been referred to him as a question of law.
Comment on this
Provided the lay member agrees that it is a question of law, but the judicial commissioner decides then. Deputies opposite object to two laymen sitting with the judicial commissioner and deciding whether land should be taken or not.
Comment on this
Then it is all right. I I need not develop that point.
Comment on this
We are all agreed that the judicial commissioner, with two laymen sitting beside him, can decide whether the land should be taken or not.
Comment on this
I am sure what is in the Bill is right. There is no objection to 12 laymen taking away the life of a man.
Comment on this
The only objection is, therefore, that the jury may be packed?
Comment on this
I wish we could get agreement on this matter from the Opposite Party. It is a great idea for the Opposite Party to have one man saying one thing and another a different thing. They then have one foot on each side.
Comment on this
That is what is happening on the Front Bench opposite. On Minister is saying one thing while another is saying something else.
Comment on this
It is very hard to get any good out of an Opposition like this when they do not know their own minds. There is no agreement. Let us take the question of price.
Comment on this
I am quite prepared to make a speech if Deputies will stop interrupting. On the question of price I notice that in practically all the courts the matter of assessing damages is left to the jury. I was told long before this Bill was thought of that judges do not like to have the burden cast upon them of deciding the amount to be paid in the case of damages. They like to have it referred to a jury. I think at any rate there cannot be any fault found with the principle that two men should sit with the judicial commissioner and decide on the price.
With regard to the question of law, if the judicial commissioner can get one of the laymen to agree with him that it is a question of law then the judicial commissioner will decide it and there is an appeal——
Comment on this
The Attorney-General quoted here an exact precedent for this clause in the Bill——
Comment on this
There is another matter which I should like to mention before the adjournment, and that is that although there is great criticism of this Bill from the Cumann na nGaedheal benches they went down to Kiltimagh and made long speeches but did not say one single thing about the Land Bill. Kiltimagh would be a hot place to criticise a Land Bill, but Deputy Hogan and the other Deputies had more sense than to criticise the Land Bill there. It is all right to criticise it here in this House——
Comment on this
The Minister is wrong. The Land Bill was criticised, and Deputy Hogan was not at the meeting.
Comment on this
I withdraw that, but there was no word about it in the daily papers.
Comment on this
There is one other thing I should like to say, and that is that the Cumann na nGaedheal Deputies have said that this means a general election. Whatever they may say about the Bill they have at the back of their minds that it is a popular Bill, and that is why they say we are playing politics. We are, therefore, bringing in at any rate a Bill which seems to suit the majority of the people of this country.