We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

In Committee on Finance. - Land Bill, 1933—Committee.

Contributions 1–241 of 473. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

Bill Land Bill, 1933
Enacted

No. 33 of 1933 ›

Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Some amendments have been tabled to Section 2. It is not customary to take amendments of principle on a definition section if an opportunity is afforded on an operative section for discussion of such amendments. I suggest that amendments relating to the appointment of lay commissioners might be taken on Section 7, in connection with amendment 14. Those would be amendments 1, 2, 4, 13, 14, 15, 17, 19 and, possibly, 16, although that raises a somewhat different point. Amendments 1 and 2 might, therefore, be postponed until 14 is reached. Amendment 14, on Section 7, which is a Government compromise, might meet the points raised to a certain extent, and, if it does not go far enough, Deputies might consider tabling amendments for the Report Stage.

Comment on this

The Chair suggests that these amendments should be discussed together.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Yes, with No. 14.

Comment on this

And then, with a general agreement that the Government amendment be accepted to the exclusion of all others?

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Yes, and Deputies might table amendments for the Report Stage if they are not satisfied. As regards amendment 3 to Section 2, the amendment is out of order because, if read in conjunction with subsequent amendments, it would increase the charge on State funds. I have notified Deputies as to the amendments that I consider out of order on those grounds. If Deputies would look at Section 12 (3) and Section 26 they will see the reason why I am so ruling.

Comment on this

You are not ruling upon all those amendments just now, because there is a point in connection with them which must be present to your mind. In the first place none of these amendments would impose a charge upon the taxpayer nor would they increase the charge on the taxpayer. Imposing a charge on public funds would mean the distribution of moneys arising out of or flowing from the amendment in question. In this case the imposition is upon the Land Commission annuitants. The Minister to-day in reply to a question as to what was the meaning of this, stated that the charges which it was anticipated would arise in connection with his Bill would only arise on 31st March next. That finishes that particular item up to 31st March next and consequently in that connection no charge arises or is arising by reason of that amendment. In the second place, in so far as there is any remission of the liability on the Land Commission here proposed in those amendments 24 to 30 and so on, the particular amendment in question relieved the Land Commission annuitants of burdens which this Bill proposes to impose upon them and in respect of which the Government by reason of this legislation may be said to be imposing taxes upon individuals.

Furthermore, in connection with the whole scheme of funding annuity arrears it will be within your recollection that it was mentioned here in the Dáil on more than one occasion by Ministers as well as by members of the Opposition, that there had been deducted from the Guarantee Fund grants to the local authorities of sums amounting to £660,000 ranging over the last nine or ten years to make good whatever deficiencies there were in connection with the Land Commission annuities. As the Bill stands there is no provision for re-imbursing the local authorities for that particular sum and in addition if we take out that particular amendment, I think it is amendment 102, what would happen is this, that not alone have the local authorities already subscribed £660,000 towards making good the deficiencies in Land Commission annuities but they would now be liable under this Bill for an additional £410,000 of these Land Commission annuities. What is still more remarkable, the Guarantee Fund is again to be responsible for this sum.

Comment on this

On a point of order, what has this to do with amendments 1, 2, 3 and 4?

Comment on this

Notices have been served in connection with all these amendments.

Comment on this

Does the Ceann Comhairle rule that amendment No. 3 is out of order?

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Yes.

Comment on this
Mr. Lynch

How can a definition impose a charge on public funds except beyond taking it in relation to the amendment to Section 12?

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

In the first place, the "appointed day" does not relate to the whole Bill; it relates only to Part III. Apart from that consideration, it is obvious that this amendment must be read in conjunction with subsequent amendments; otherwise it would be meaningless. Therefore, I rule it out of order.

Comment on this

I submit, sir, there is a distinction between these. I addressed you in connection with amendments 24 to 30 but this is a different line. I understood at the moment I stood up that you were considering all these. I submit in that connection that there is no charge on public funds by these amendments nor is there an increase on any charge. The Minister said to-day that up to 31st March next there is no liability arising out of any deficiencies in land purchase funds.

Comment on this

That statement is true taking the Government proposals in this Bill into account. But if the amendments the Deputies here propose are passed the Central Fund will be drawn to the extent of half the annuities plus the funding annuities that will be collected next November.

Comment on this

The Central Fund has already provided for all the funds that are wanted for the current financial year. The Minister was asked distinctly did this provide for all the changes which it was anticipated would arise in connection with this Bill until 31st March next and his answer was in the affirmative. There is nothing in this amendment increasing the charge on these funds until the 31st March next. I am addressing myself only to amendment No. 24. If we wish to take 24 when we arrive at it, that is another matter.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

I am taking amendment 3 in relation to amendments 24 to 30 among other amendments.

Comment on this

But amendments 24 to 29 are altogether different. In so far as they are concerned they are dealing with a proposal in this measure which the Government seeks to get. It would be the same as if I were to move a reduction of say 11d. in an income tax of 5/-. The House is entitled to consider those matters. These amendments are dealing with reductions, and they have relation to the imposition of charges. They have relation to the imposition which is now being made in this measure upon land annuitants and for which the State has no liability, that liability having already been discharged. Therefore there is a case, a more extraordinary case than any of those on the Guarantee Fund. There is a sum of £660,000 which has been allocated, and which flowed from year to year. That sum has been made good out of the Guarantee Fund in the deductions which have been made from the local authorities. If this Bill passes, plus the amendment put in by the Government, the Government would again be entitled to make a raid on the Guarantee Fund to the extent of £440,000, and that for money which has already been made good. I submit that the amendment does not increase any liability on the Central Fund. These amendments are, I submit, in reason and in order by reason of the fact that the liability for the £660,000 has already been discharged. I will do no more than advert to the prodigality of the Government in seeking to impose this additional heavy burden on the local authorities. It is a course of action which has not been practised so far.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

That is not on the point of order.

Comment on this

No, but it is a part of it. If you owed £500 to the Minister and I came in here some day and said "I reduce your liability to £300," it would have just as much moral effect as that.

Comment on this

I must say the Chair has my deepest sympathy in trying to discuss a point of order arising out of the Land Bill with Deputy Cosgrave. I advise Deputy Roddy to get a good tough string, and tie it to Deputy Cosgrave's coat-tails to tie him down at opportune moments if Deputy Cosgrave is going to take part in those debates.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

On the point of order.

Comment on this

We are coming to it.

Comment on this

On the point of order, I have replied to Deputy Cosgrave when I said that the anticipated charges on the Central Fund had been met by supplementary estimates; anticipated because it is anticipated that this Bill will pass as the Government desires it to pass, and that therefore the Central Fund will not be called upon to meet the additional charges which it would have to meet if the amendments proposed by Deputy Roddy and Deputy Lynch in the third part of the Bill were to pass. Obviously, to anybody who has any knowledge of land finance, if the moneys are not collected from the land annuities they have to be taken out of the Exchequer in order to pay bond holders and recoup the Guarantee Fund. Deputy Cosgrave knows so little about this matter that a couple of weeks ago he endeavoured to persuade the Deputies of the House to vote against a supplementary estimate providing £800,000 for the bond holders who got bonds in exchange for their lands under the 1923 Act. Of course, as I say, a Chinn Comhairle, Deputy Cosgrave does not understand those things, and I can quite realise your difficulty in persuading him he is out of order when he is clearly out of order.

Comment on this

I submit that the Minister has not concerned himself with the point at issue here. The point at issue in connection with these amendments is not the question of the payment of a Land Commission annuity or Land Commission annuities. It is a question of the funding of Land Commission annuities in arrear—quite a different problem. Would the Minister concern himself with that and direct himself to the point at issue—the arrears which are proposed to be funded and in connection with which the House is perfectly entitled to say what particular sum and from when those arrears are to be collected. The Government has already done it itself. The Government has, in this particular case, funded three years of annuities where three years and over are owing and due, or where they have accrued. They have wiped out anything in excess of three years. Had they the right to do it? Has the House the right to amend that? I submit that it has. It does not impose any increased charge upon public funds by reason of doing so. I say that the Bill itself as drawn does not seek to pay back moneys which have been utilised from the local authorities for the purpose of discharging the liabilities of Land Commission annuities which are in arrear, and neither does it propose to reimburse those local authorities to that extent. I say further that, if the amendment which I have pointed out is to pass, a further liability will arise on those local authorities for the same sum that they have already paid. Will the Minister concern himself with that?

Comment on this

I will concern myself with some of the arguments which the Deputy has put forward, at the proper time and in the proper place. The Ceann Comhairle has tried to get the Deputy to behave in an orderly fashion, and discuss the Bill in an orderly way.

Comment on this

He has not told me to come to the point yet.

Comment on this

The Deputy should remember that at the present time he is only a private Deputy, and that he cannot move amendments which will put a charge on public funds.

Comment on this

Explain how the charge is put.

Comment on this
Mr. Lynch

Might I respectfully draw your attention, sir, to amendment 27, since we are discussing that whole bunch from No. 24 to No. 30? That amendment, which is down in my name, merely proposes to swop one year for funding instead of another; to swop the gales of November-December, 1929, and June-July, 1930, for November-December, 1932, and June-July, 1933; in other words, to have the three years which are funded the three years ending in the June-July gale, 1932, instead of the June-July gale, 1933. I do not see how there is any charge on public funds there. It may mean that some lesser sum may accrue from the amount collected or funded, but I respectfully submit that it is a legitimate amendment.

Comment on this

Some of those amend ments are in my name. I should like to know how amendments 25 and 26, which have no relation to the arrears or the funding of arrears or rents or interest in lieu of rent, come to be a charge on public funds? Those are in relation only to the costs and expenses of the proceedings. The Minister has told us to-day, by way of answer to a question, that he did not know what were the costs of the proceedings which the Land Commission took. How does he propose to fund them then, and what machinery has the State at its disposal to pay the State solicitors for the proceedings which they undertook? I maintain that certainly all the amendments relating to the funding of the costs and expenses incurred by the Land Commission do not under the wildest stretch of imagination propose to put any charge on State funds.

Comment on this

The Deputy obviously does not understand his own amendments, because if the costs are not recovered from the land annuities, obviously the State solicitors have to be recouped their costs. Unless the Deputy wants to repudiate them completely, they have to be borne out of the State funds.

Comment on this

Did the Minister tell us here to-day that he did not know what the costs were? Does he tell us now that the State has any machinery for the payment of those costs to the State solicitors? What is the machinery for this purpose? Are those moneys to be funded against the tenants, and are the solicitors not to be paid at all?

Comment on this

The fact of the matter is, if the Deputy only understood the reply to the question, that the Land Commission has not received the full returns from the State solicitors in regard to the costs that were incurred. Those costs will come in and will be dealt with in the ordinary way by the Land Commission.

Comment on this

In the ordinary way?

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

It is stated that the anticipated charges have been met, but if amendments 24 to 30, for instance, were carried further charges would fall on the Central Fund.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

That is my interpretation of Sections 12 and 26; any costs not recouped would also fall on the Central Fund. I am therefore not allowing amendments Nos. 24 to 30 to be moved, nor Nos. 32 and 33.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Amendment No. 4 will go with No. 14.

SECTION 3.

Comment on this

Is not there an amendment to Section 3?

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

I suggest that No. 4 be taken with No. 14.

Comment on this

It is not the same subject at all.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

If you prefer it we will take it here.

Comment on this

I presume we will have an opportunity of discussing those sections afterwards?

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The section may be discussed now.

Comment on this

What about the amendments? Shall we take the amendments first?

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

No. 4 may be taken now if the Deputy desires.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 4:—

(4) In sub-section (1), line 40, page 4, to delete from the word "and," down to the word "with," line 42, and substitute the words "a land commissioner of not less than two years' standing nominated by the Minister for the purpose and".

I move this amendment because, in the past, Land Commissioners were responsible for drafting rules and regulations for the purpose of implementing the Land Acts. This follows naturally on my amendments 1 and 2 but, apart from that, it appears to me that to draft rules and regulations implementing a Land Act of this character, it is necessary that particularly experienced officials only should be engaged in such work. At least three of the present Commissioners have experience of drafting rules and regulations in connection with previous Land Acts. According to the wording of the section it appears to me that the Minister has power to appoint any officer of the Land Commission, not necessarily a commissioner, but even a junior officer without any experience, to draft rules and regulations of this kind. The sole aim and object of the amendment is to get the best human material available in the Land Commission, at the Minister's disposal, for the purpose of drafting rules and regulations.

Comment on this

I have no objection to the idea behind the suggestion in the amendment, because, obviously, if we are to have a rule-making authority, the Minister will appoint the best officials he has. The term "officer of the Land Commission" according to the definition includes Land Commissioners. If the Deputy wants to press it I would be quite prepared to change the words "officer of the Land Commission" into lay commissioner or land commissioner, but I do not think the Deputy should press for the insertion of the words "not less than two years' standing."

Comment on this

If the Minister will accept my first amendment——

Comment on this

That is a different point altogether. I would be prepared to say an officer or land commissioner appointed for the purpose by the Minister, but not to accept the words "of not less than two years' standing."

Comment on this
Mr. Lynch

You would accept land commissioner?

Comment on this

Land commissioner. Is not that good enough? He would be an existing land commissioner at the time when he was appointed by the Minister. Has Deputy Lynch any guarantee that the Land Commissioners are going to exist for ever?

Comment on this
Mr. Lynch

No, but I assume that they will exist until the rule making starts.

Comment on this

That is all right. If the Deputy agrees I shall introduce an amendment on the Report Stage changing the words "officer of the Land Commission" to "land commissioner."

Comment on this

I am concerned about one thing only, that is, that those participating in the making of those rules shall have as much experience as possible in the administration of the Land Acts. It seems to me nonsensical to bring in an outsider who may be only an hour in the Land Commission, and who would then be put forward as one of the officers responsible for drafting rules and regulations. Surely the Minister will admit that if proper rules and regulations are to be drafted in dealing with big problems that will arise from day to day, these rules must be drafted by individuals who have experience of the Land Acts. For that reason I put down this amendment and in order to ensure that a land commissioner with experience shall be appointed as one of those responsible for the drafting of these rules and regulations.

Comment on this

I am as much concerned with having proper rules and regulations drafted as Deputy Roddy is, and I am as anxious to have experienced officers of the Land Commission to go on the rule-making authority as the Deputy is. If the House will agree I shall introduce, on the Report Stage, an amendment changing the words "officer of the Land Commission" into "land commissioner."

Comment on this

With experience? Personally I think the Minister's acceptance of this principle does not mean anything at all. An officer of the Land Commission with ten or 20 years' experience might be a much more useful person for drawing up rules and regulations than a land commissioner created only an hour before. It is experience that Deputy Roddy wants to get on this body and that is what the Minister wants to avoid. He wants to get newly made commissioners on the body.

Comment on this

Could not the matter be easily settled if the Minister would say what is in his mind as to whom, exactly, he will appoint to the rule-making authority? Does he intend to appoint an existing commissioner?

Comment on this

If it was to be done to-day I would appoint an existing commissioner.

Comment on this

And may we take it that it is not his intention to appoint a commissioner who has only just been selected?

Comment on this

Not the slightest.

Comment on this

Will he say that he will not appoint a person without any experience at all?

Comment on this
The Attorney-General

It is open to the Minister to appoint a land commissioner to this rule-making authority. A man will be a commissioner the moment he is appointed. These rules are rules for the setting up of machinery, and the Minister has indicated that he has no more desire than Deputy Roddy to select anyone for the rule-making authority who does not know his job.

Comment on this
Mr. Lynch

What is the objection to putting in the two years' experience?

Comment on this
The Attorney-General

The man appointed will only be one member of the rule-making authority.

Comment on this

But what is your objection?

Comment on this
The Attorney-General

The suggestion that the Minister would appoint anyone without experience is so absurd.

Comment on this

Surely the Attorney-General will admit that for drafting rules and regulations, even under this Bill, it is necessary that the individual so engaged should have practical experience. My only concern is this. I have had some experience of the Land Commission, and I can speak with a certain amount of authority, and I recognise as vitally important that the individuals engaged in this work should have experience of Land Commission administration. If they have not that experience I do not see what use they could serve. Hence it was that in drafting this amendment I put in the words "of not less than two years standing" and to substitute a man of that experience for an officer of the Land Commission. The Minister admits that it is necessary that an individual engaged in this work should have experience. No one understands that better than the Attorney-General. I think my amendment is exceedingly reasonable, but I am perfectly ready to let it stand over to the Report Stage if the Minister accepts my draft that the commissioner appointed shall have two years' experience of Land Commission work.

Comment on this

If the Deputy does not accept my undertaking and is not satisfied with what I have said, we had better decide the matter now. The words "an officer of the Land Commission" includes a land commissioner. If I made an appointment to-day I would appoint an existing land commissioner. I will not yield to the Deputy in my concern about appointing an experienced official. That is what is required.

Comment on this
Mr. Lynch

What is the Minister's objection to a man of not less than two years' standing?

Comment on this

I am meeting Deputies in an ordinary way, in a manner that can be carried out under all the circumstances.

Comment on this
Mr. Rice

Perhaps the Minister will indicate whether he intends to appoint an existing land commissioner or some new man ad hoc for that purpose?

Comment on this

I have already answered that question.

Comment on this

I gather that when the Minister went a certain distance, as he thought, to meet Deputy Roddy, he must have come to the conclusion that what he proposes to do on the Report Stage will be an improvement so far as the Bill is concerned, from the point of view of drafting, anyhow. I gather that unless the House accepts what the Minister proposes to introduce on the Report Stage and drops this amendment he will not go on with his proposal on the Report Stage.

Comment on this

I am quite satisfied that as the section stands it enables the Minister to do what Deputy Roddy wants done. In ordinary circumstances that would be done.

Comment on this
Mr. Lynch

It is a thing that should be done.

Comment on this

Enabling the Minister to do it is one thing.

Comment on this

The section is so wide that it enables a whole lot of other things to be done as well. Nobody disputes that the section as it stands enables what Deputy Roddy wants to be done, but the amendment is an attempt to limit the power of the Minister—that is obvious. I gather that the Minister's mind now is this, that unless what he calls a concession is accepted by Deputy Roddy, he does not intend to introduce the modification he promised on the Report Stage. Is that the intention? In other words, if this is pressed to a division the Minister is not going to introduce the modification.

Comment on this

The modification which Deputy Roddy wants is not necessary at all. In order to expedite business I am prepared to accept the words "land commissioner" instead of "an officer of the Land Commission."

Comment on this

And if that is not accepted you will not introduce the modification you promised?

Comment on this

That is so.

Comment on this

The Attorney-General mentioned that this particular individual would be only one of three. What is the point?

Comment on this
The Attorney-General

He will not be the sole person.

Comment on this

To me it seems there is no point in making the remark that he is only one of three. If there is any force in the Attorney-General's remark it would mean that the other two would have experience and this man need not have. The Minister indicated that if he were making this appointment to-day he would appoint one of the existing Land Commissioners. If he is making it in three or four months' time is he going to appoint a land commissioner who will then have had two years' experience? That is what the House is anxious to know. We are not interested in any hypothetical matter such as if the Minister were making an appointment to-day.

Comment on this

Deputies are insisting on two years' experience in regard to the third land commissioner. They have not introduced any amendment insisting on the secretary having two years' experience. For that matter a secretary with a day's experience could be appointed and the same might apply to a judicial commissioner. If Deputies want to take the line that the Executive Council is not to be trusted with anything we will fight it out on that point. If they want to have this rule-making authority an authority that can do its work, then the section will cover all that. If they want to ensure that the officer of the Land Commission shall be a land commissioner, I am prepared to put that in.

Comment on this

Surely we have arrived practically at agreement on that point. The Minister, unless deliberately guilty of equivocation—and I am not prepared to believe that—has clearly indicated that if the existing Land Commissioners are available when he is making his choice he will choose one of them.

Comment on this

I know you can trip up words, but broadly speaking, those are the Minister's words. Suppose we put in Deputy's Roddy's amendment as it stands, and suppose a land commissioner died to-morrow morning—though God forbid that that would happen— it would mean amending legislation in order to appoint another person. The Minister is prepared to accept the words "land commissioner" and he says that if he had the appointment to-morrow he would appoint one of the existing Land Commissioners. I think we can safely assume that that is the meaning of the undertaking he has given here to-day.

Comment on this

The understanding is that I will introduce an amendment on the Report Stage changing the words "officer of the Land Commission" to "land commissioner."

Comment on this

I beg to move amendment 5:—

In sub-section (1), (a), line 34, to delete the word "individuals" and substitute the word "persons."

"Persons," I understand, is the expression used throughout all the Land Acts instead of the word "individuals."

Comment on this

I am also moving an amendment to this particular section. The Minister's amendment is purely a verbal one. It does not alter the sense of the clause at all, nor is it likely to alter the interpretation which the Land Commission will place upon it.

Comment on this

That is true. It is only a verbal amendment.

Comment on this

I beg to move amendment 5a:—

In sub-section (1), (a), line 34, after the word "whom" to insert the words "or the locality in which."

The idea is that by specifying the locality the Minister could, in effect, determine who the persons were to be. The object of the amendment is to prevent the intention of that exception being defeated.

Comment on this

The Executive Council and myself wanted the Minister excepted from the power to determine any particular lands, and we wanted to take from the Minister that power by indicating the locality that he would point out or by excluding the possibility of any other lands being excepted, except some particular lands which he himself wanted taken over. The draftsman was told to draft the section accordingly, to take such powers from the Minister, but the legal people say that these excepted matters are provided for just as the Deputy wants to see them done. That is the opinion of the legal people.

Comment on this

It does not appear that this is a matter in which the word of a lawyer carries more weight than the word of somebody else. It seems a matter of common sense. There is nothing in the sub-section to prevent the Minister from determining the locality.

Comment on this

The Deputy should read sub-section 3 (b) and he will get the point.

Comment on this

That is a different point altogether. The distribution of work. I submit that the Minister, by accepting the amendment I propose, cannot do anything to injure the intentions of the Government. He might consider it superfluous, but I cannot see that it would be. It exactly carries what he says the intentions of the Government are.

Comment on this

Assuming that the section states the determination of persons from whom land is to be acquired, there is nothing in the Bill to prevent the Minister saying he wants land in the townland of Drumkeen.

Comment on this

There is. 3 (b) says that the Minister may, if and so far as he thinks proper, arrange by reference to the class or classes of case or the county or counties in which the land concerned is situated the distribution amongst the lay commissioners of their work in relation of the excepted matters but not to allocate any particular case or land to any particular lay commissioner.

Comment on this

That only involves the work which the commissioners might consider to be excepted in a particular case, but there is nothing to prevent the Minister from saying he wants land in a particular area, and he could put pressure on the Land Commission to acquire certain lands. This amendment in no way impairs the Minister if the purpose of the Executive Council be as he described, because to insert the words "or the locality in which" simply gives implementation to the intention the Minister says he has.

Comment on this

I am opposed to this clause. I agree that the amendment would improve it somewhat in the sense that it would prevent the Minister particularising so far as townlands are concerned, but I do not think it improves the clause in any way. The Minister has got the most extraordinary powers under sub-section (2). I do not suggest he would do it, but the Minister has undoubtedly the power to particularise and whilst the individuals might not be named, there are other ways of getting at individuals rather than mentioning their names and I have no doubt that he knows that farms have certain local names and I have no doubt that in carrying into effect these particular clauses the Minister is likely to be bombarded by his supporters from all parts of the country and the supporters have compiled a list of the lands that they expect will be acquired under this Bill and distributed amongst them. It appears to me that this clause has been unfortunately phrased. I cannot understand why the Minister will not accept the amendments. There is a departure from the previous procedure in regard to Land Acts. It should be the aim of this particular clause to avoid discrimination in any way and leave it completely to the discretion of the Land Commission to select the land rather than the individual. In the existing political circumstances in this country a clause of this kind is a positive source of danger and it should be removed. If that is done it will be a sign that the powers which the Minister has got under sub-section (2) may not impose the great hardship that a certain number of people in the country expect. The "determination of the land to be acquired," it seems to me, would be a very much better expression and certainly much fairer, and I would submit to the Minister that if he accepts this amendment he is indicating his desire to administer the Bill fairly, justly and equitably and will give the people in the country who are naturally deeply interested in the Land Bill the impression that they are not being hit at in any way by any section of the Bill, and that it will be operated fairly, justly and equitably and that there will be nothing in it which would give any official or inspector or supporter power in any part of the country to hit at any particular individual.

Comment on this

I submit that the amendment achieves the object which the Minister has in mind; it will protect the Minister against charges of partisan administration because assuming a desire to administer the Act in a partisan way you could do so without specifically determining the actual lands. You could give such instructions that you could, while avoiding mentioning actual lands, indicate the area. I hope now, on the basis of what the Minister said that he will accept this very simple amendment to carry out the very proper intentions of the Government to protect themselves against pressure to administer the Act in a partisan way.

Comment on this

Read sub-section (2) again. Deputy Roddy says he is afraid of sub-section (1) because of sub-section (2), but in sub-section (2) the Minister's powers are restricted to matters other than excepted matters. That is stated in the sub-section.

Comment on this

That is why we want the excepted matters extended. The Minister does not quite get out the point, if I may say so. Sub-section (2) undoubtedly gives the Minister very much greater power than any Minister had before over the Land Commission. Sub-section (1) is framed to curtail that power to some extent. We want to extend that curtailment as far as we can. It is for the Minister's good. It will prevent him from being bombarded with a series of resolutions by people who want particular lands taken. I would like to say that the amendment proposed by Deputy MacDermot and the amendment of Deputy Roddy and myself will tend to protect the Minister. That was obviously the intention of the draftsmen, but it seems to have been overlooked. Nobody reading that section, and I am sure the Attorney-General will agree with me, can say that that does not prevent the Minister pointing out localities in which lands might be taken while it does prevent his pointing out individuals. It is not a legal matter at all. It is a matter of understanding ordinary English, and if the Minister is right, and I accept his word, that the Government want to prevent the Minister being put in the position that he should determine the actual lands to be taken over, then I think it has not been met by this section.

Comment on this

The Minister stated clearly what was the intention of the Government, but the Opposition does not feel that legally the intention of the Government has been carried out, and it is a weakness unless the legal power of prohibition is there. The Minister is open to any amount of pressure, and any person with experience of administration knows that it would be a great safeguard. For instance, the Revenue Commissioners are to a tremendous extent independent of the Minister. All that is wanted is to make it definitely clear what is the intention of the Government, as stated by the Minister. Nothing else is wanted, as far as I can gather, by these particular amendments. It may be the firm intention of the Minister to do what is the Government's intention, but unless it is made very definite and clear, the amount of pressure brought to bear on him will be tremendous. I do not care who he is, or what Party he belongs to, the only safeguard in the long run, stretching over a period of years, would be to make the prohibition quite clear. The Minister can say he has not the power, that that rests with a body which for this particular purpose is independent. I am sure the Minister, if he thinks of it, will see that these amendments are only carrying out what is the intention of the Government.

Comment on this

I think the Deputy has indicated the effect of sub-section (1) and that is, the determination of the persons for whom lands are to be acquired is to be exempted from the Minister's power. He has nothing good, bad or indifferent to say about it. For instance, he cannot say to the Land Commission "John Murphy has a farm, take it." He cannot ring round a certain townland knowing beforehand that the only person to be affected in the townland is John Murphy.

Comment on this

He cannot do it.

Comment on this

For instance he could take the townland of Killeen. He does not mention the person whose lands will be taken, but in practice he does, for the reason that there is no other farm there.

Comment on this

I think it would save a great deal of time if he carried out what he says is the intention of the Government by accepting those amendments.

Comment on this

Let the Deputy describe what he means by locality. Would it cover Connaught or Mayo or an area like that? What the Government is aiming at generally in the Bill is this: as the Minister is responsible to the Land Commission, and Deputies hold him responsible even though up to now he has had no responsibility, and as it is an urgent matter that land should be divided and distributed, recognised by all the members of the Dáil that the Minister should do it, and if the Minister is responsible he should also have authority. If the Dáil thinks and the Minister thinks that congestion should be relieved in a certain county or half county the Minister should be able to turn the Land Commission on to the doing of that work. While leaving those powers in the hands of the Minister, the Government wants to take out of his hands the power to indicate any particular holdings, and I believe we have succeeded in doing that.

Comment on this

To my mind the Minister has gone back on what he has already said here. I think he said the Government wished him to have the power of closely indicating the locality. I think he may reasonably state his wishes to relieve congestion in a particular area but that is not necessarily done by acquiring the land in that area. I should have thought that "locality" would carry a perfectly common-sense interpretation and would not extend to any such gigantic areas as a province.

Comment on this

How far would it extend?

Comment on this
Mr. Lynch

The Minister, I think, accepts the principle that it should not be within his power to indicate particular land to be acquired of his own. I gather that he accepts that principle. I would suggest to him that if he would bring in an amendment on the Report Stage both Deputy MacDermot and myself would withdraw this amendment. That would be the obvious way if he accepts the principle.

Comment on this

Are not the localities in existence, and some, very well known?

Comment on this

I hope that Deputy Lynch's interpretation of what the Minister said is not correct, and I hope he will not accept those amendments. I think the Minister is being shoved back too far and that he should have some voice as to the policy of the Land Commission. The relation between the existing Land Commission and the old days do not seem to have been very happy. I think the Minister has gone too far in investing the Commissioners with such powers and that he has given too much away already and should not give away any more.

Comment on this

I realise the Minister has a difficult problem to deal with, but this sub-section is not going to help him to deal with it in a speedy way. As regards the powers which the Minister stated a few moments ago he is taking for dealing with congestion he has got every one of them already without this Bill.

He has got all these powers already, and he does not require this particular sub-section in order to enable him to deal with congestion. My objection to this particular sub-section remains the same as in the beginning. I consider the sub-section an unfortunate one. I consider the section, in operation, will give the Minister an opportunity of discriminating against townlands and against individuals, and that is not a good thing. It is not a good thing to give the Minister power to indicate a certain land in a certain county or in a certain townland. He has, undoubtedly, these powers. There is no other possible interpretation in sub-sections 2 and 3. I have read them several times. There is no doubt about it the Minister is getting that power, and in view of the fact that he has got that power——

Comment on this

Give me the words in which he has got that power.

Comment on this

He has it in paragraph (b) of sub-section (3). He has also got it in sub-section (2).

Comment on this

Read the words.

Comment on this

He has got the power "of reserving to himself rights of approval and disapproval or of reconsideration, revision and confirmation."

Comment on this

That is in relation to excepted matters.

Comment on this

The point I stressed on the Second Reading, and the point I want to stress now, is this, that the Minister, indirectly, can indicate the persons from whom lands are to be taken. Without relating this clause to the powers in sub-sections (2) and (3) there is no question about it if the Minister were unscrupulous enough to go into any particular case and to indicate in a particular way even individuals from whom particular land is to be taken he can do so. That is why I am anxious to get the wording of that particular clause altered. I see no reason for introducing the words "individuals" or "persons" or the determination of the actual lands to be acquired for the relief of congestion. I am quite sure that the Minister, with the assistance of the Attorney-General, could have a better clause inserted there. I can assure the Minister that this clause has given rise to a great deal of uneasiness down the country already. The feeling is that this section gives the Minister power to point to certain individuals and to say to them through his inspectors or commissioners: "I have a right to take your land." That is the danger, and I think that danger is inherent in this section. The Minister, in the interest of his Department and in the interest of himself and of the farmers, should introduce some other section which would give him the power which he wants.

Judging from the Minister's remarks, he gave the Dáil to understand that he does not mean to utilise these powers unfairly or unscrupulously, but there is no doubt about it the power is there. I am not relying now on my own interpretation of it, for I have confirmation of my interpretation by certain legal men outside. The Minister should substitute another clause for the words there. The Minister has these powers if he chooses to exercise them. It is not right that any Minister should be given such powers as these when dealing with the problem of land acquisition. The position of the Land Commission in dealing with the problem of land acquisition is that while many charges of delay were made against them, certainly no charge of delay can be laid at their doors for the past 18 months and there can be no charge that the problem of acquisition has not since then been dealt with expeditiously. I want to see that there is nothing in the Bill that will give the Minister power to act unfairly in respect of the acquisition of land. I submit that this section gives the Minister that power. That power will interfere very much with the discretion of the Land Commission.

Comment on this

Why does the Minister want power to include the locality? Why should he want power to indicate the locality in which he wants to acquire the land? The object of this amendment is that the Minister should say: "I want congestion abolished in such a place," and the Land Commission should take land to relieve the congestion, with which the Minister is concerned. If the Minister does not except himself from designating the locality, how can he resist the pressure that will be brought to bear on him afterwards by deputations and by individuals? Take the case of the Minister for Industry and Commerce. He said that his life has been made a misery by the permit system because of the power left in his hands as to what should be let in or kept out. If the Minister for Lands and Fisheries has that power he will be in a constant state of war with deputations. He should divest himself of it. He can still instruct the Land Commission to prepare a scheme for the relief of congestion.

Comment on this

The Minister referred to sub-section (2). That gives him power with the exception of excluded matters. The locality is not one of the excluded matters. Our case is this: by defining the locality the Minister can actually define the person, if he mentions the townland. It is very unlikely that there will be any other large farm which can be taken in a particular townland. In fact he would be dealing with a person, a thing that the Minister is anxious to avoid. We quite admit that he has great powers in Section 2. We quite admit that these powers are curtailed by a reference to excluded matters, but when we turn to the excluded matters that is where our difficulty arises. They are drafted in such a way that they seem to give the Minister more power than even the Minister professes he wants to get.

Comment on this

I think, first of all, Deputy Roddy wants changes in this Bill merely for the sake of change.

Comment on this

I will put it to the House in this way: The Deputy suggests that it should be changed to read "the determination of the question whether any lands proposed to be acquired are required for the relief of congestion." The land must belong to somebody and what is in the Bill is the determination of the individuals from whom the land is to be acquired.

Comment on this

That is my objection.

Comment on this

I cannot see any difference between what is in the Bill, "the determination of the individuals from whom the land is to be acquired," and the Deputy's amendment.

Comment on this

I want both these matters to be left exclusively to the Land Commission.

Comment on this

Surely the determination of the persons from whom the land is to be acquired is as restrictive on the Minister as the determination of the lands to be acquired. We are going as far in this Bill as we can. We want to keep the matter of adjudicating between the claims of any two citizens altogether out of the Minister's power. We want to take from the Minister the power to say that land must be taken from any particular individual. We have done that. We also want to give the Minister authority over the Land Commission and a general direction on the performance of their functions. If the Dáil thinks that the Minister should not have that power then the Dáil should not give the Minister any power.

Comment on this

No. We have not said that.

Comment on this

What we are endeavouring to do here is this: when you have a system of the Minister being responsible to the Dáil you must have authority. If you are not going to operate that system, then the thing to do is to set up somebody completely like judges for whom no Minister would be responsible—that the Land Commission would simply carry on its functions independent of the Ministry altogether and be directly responsible to the Dáil.

Comment on this

The Minister definitely told us 15 minutes ago that the Government did not want to have the determining of locality. He definitely told us that, and it can be confirmed from the Official Report. Is the Minister going back on that? If he is not going back on it, I suggest that what he is saying is quite irrelevant.

Comment on this

If I used the phrase "locality"...

Comment on this

The Minister did.

Comment on this

——I had in mind—and I am sure the Deputy will find that that is what I said—that the Government was anxious to take out of the Minister's power the determination of the locality as regards pointing to any particular individual. I think that the only point all the Deputies opposite are making is that, by some manner of means somewhere in this Bill, it is left to the Minister so to arrange that a particular individual——

Comment on this

Or group of individuals.

Comment on this

——or group of individuals can have the lands taken away from them on the instruction of the Minister. We are definitely excepting, from the Minister's powers, the determination of the persons.

Comment on this

Not the lands.

Comment on this

The determination of the persons from whom land is to be acquired.

Comment on this
Mr. Lynch

Surely, the Minister must realise—it has been said at least half a dozen times—that while he specifically puts down persons there——

Comment on this

Persons from whom land is to be acquired.

Comment on this
Mr. Lynch

——he does not put down that he can say that such and such lands could be acquired without specifying the individual. The Minister prevents himself from saying: "I want John Sullivan's farm at such-and-such a place to be taken," but he does not prevent himself from saying: "I want a farm in Coomaclowkane of such-and-such acreage to be taken up", by which he will indicate the person just as specifically as if he actually named the person.

Comment on this

I challenge Deputy Lynch to read sub-section (2).

Comment on this
Mr. Lynch

I read it.

Comment on this

I challenge the Deputy to read the words of it and try to get the full effect and meaning of it.

Comment on this
Mr. Lynch

I am quite satisfied that I realise the meaning of it just as well as the Minister does.

Comment on this

I am quite prepared to grant that, because, on the Second Reading, every time the Deputy came to the words "not relating to an excepted matter" he mumbled the phrase.

Comment on this
Mr. Lynch

Not at all.

Comment on this

Let the Minister take a concrete case. Has he any power under this Bill to direct the Land Commissioners to acquire land in a particular townland? Has he the power to say to the Land Commissioners: "I direct you to acquire land in the townland of Baile Uachtar"?

Comment on this

I would say not.

Comment on this

Cannot the Minister clear it up?

Comment on this

Sub-section (2) says:

On and after the appointed day, the Land Commission, in the exercise and performance of the powers and duties for the time being vested in it by law (including this Act), and the lay commissioners, in the exercise and performance of the powers and duties for the time being specifically vested in them by law (including this Act), shall, save in relation to excepted matters,

One of which is the determination of the individual from whom the land is to be acquired.

...act under and in accordance with the directions, whether general or particular, of the Minister ...

Comment on this

There you are!

...and the Minister shall have and may exercise, if and so far as he shall think proper, full and unrestricted power of regulating and controlling every and any exercise or performance by the Land Commission or the lay commissioner (as the case may be) of any such power or duty not relating to an excepted matter and also power of reserving to himself rights of approval and disapproval or of reconsideration, revision and confirmation of every or any act of the Land Commission or the lay commissioners not relating to an excepted matter.

Comment on this

Where is the indication of the townland being one of the excepted matters? Where is it excepted in sub-section (1)? The indication of the townland was the specific case put up by myself and Deputy Dillon.

Comment on this

What the Deputies want is that power should be taken from the Minister to determine individuals and that is definitely excepted in clause (a).

Comment on this

Has the Minister not power to indicate to the Land Commission that he desires them to acquire land in a given townland, say, Baile Uachtar?

Comment on this

I have already explained to the Deputies that the Minister is precluded from the determination of the persons.

Comment on this

Has he any power to say to the Land Commission: "you must acquire land in the townland of Baile Uachtar"? Has he that power?

Comment on this

I will say that if there were only one man in the townland who had land worth over £2,000—the figure indicated here—the Minister would not have the power to determine that the Land Commission should take the surplus from him.

Comment on this

Surely there is an aswer to my question of either "yes" or "no." Has the Minister or has he not power under sub-section (2) to say to the Land Commissioners: "You must proceed to acquire land in the townland of Baile Uachtar." Has he or has he not that power?

Comment on this

Surely, Deputy Dillon does not want to contend that if land is available in a certain townland there would be anything wrong in indicating that that land should be made available for sub-division?

Comment on this

The Deputy thinks the Minister has that power?

Comment on this

If he has that power, I do not see why we should quarrel with it. Where is the difference between the Minister's having power to say, in relation to any particular county, that so many acres of land is required there for the relief of congestion and saying it with regard to a townland? Why should you try to tie us down to a townland? If land is not available in a townland, then, surely no direction can be given to the Land Commissioners to acquire land there. If the land is available for that purpose in that particular townland, I do not see why the Minister should not have that power in relation to that townland in the same way as he has that power in relation to a county or counties.

Comment on this

Has the Minister power to direct the Land Commissioners to acquire land in the townland of Baile Uachtar?

Comment on this

The Minister has the power, of course.

Comment on this

If the Minister has the power, it simply means that he can go and name an individual from whom land is to be acquired. I know that the Minister does not want to do that. It is merely to protect him from that possibility that I put the question to him. In my opinion, if I had, say, Deputy Smith as a neighbour, he might come to the conclusion that congestion was particularly bad in Baile Uachtar. I happen to be the only person in Baile Uachtar. The Minister can prepare a schedule of townlands in which he directs the Land Commissioners to acquire land which comes to the same thing as naming an individual. I suggest that the words "or the locality" should be inserted. That puts it out of the power of the Minister to interfere in that way.

Comment on this

The Minister cannot determine the individuals from whom land is to be acquired.

Comment on this
Mr. Lynch

Not by name.

Comment on this

If he is going to do it indirectly you will want some other amendments.

Comment on this

I maintain that if anybody is seriously concerned—if it is not simply for the sake of argument here or in the country—with the Minister having power to say that the land shall be taken from John Murphy or somebody else, rather than from Patrick Johnson, they have a safeguard here in the Bill in that the Minister cannot determine that the land is to be taken from one individual rather than from another.

Comment on this

Suppose John Murphy is the only man in the townland——

Comment on this

If John Murphy is the only man in the townland or locality or province, or whatever you like to call the area, and if he is the only man who has, say, 1,320 acres of land, when there is dire congestion in the area I think the Minister has the right to say that in that particular province or county no man should hold more than 1,320 acres.

Comment on this

What suggestion is there that he should hold 1,320 acres?

Comment on this

We have the Minister's interpretation of the legal aspect of it, namely, that he has the power. Whether it is 100 acres or 1,300 acres does not matter so far as the legal interpretation is concerned. We have it now from the Minister that the power is there. The mere fact that it is 1,300 acres does not interfere one way or the other with the question as to whether the legal power is with the Minister. Up to the present I understood the Minister to argue the very opposite.

Comment on this

Up to the present—perhaps not quite up to the present, but up to a quarter of an hour ago—I understood him to say that the intention of the Government was not to interfere in matters of indicating the locality in a narrow sense. Now, and in the previous statement of the Minister, I understand him to correct that position. Furthermore, the argument which he used, namely, that the Minister is there and must be trusted, is a reason that could be adduced for this House refusing to discuss any legislation and adopting the attitude: "We appoint a Minister, and we give him power to do what he thinks fit." It is the business of this House to see that the legislation which it allows through the House is properly drawn up, and carries out the intention of the House. Up to the present I was under the impression that that was also the intention of the Government, but I confess that at the moment I have not the remotest idea what their intention is.

Comment on this

Might I put it to the Minister, and indeed to Deputy Smith, that the retaining of those powers really assumes that the Land Commission would not carry out its obvious duties? They are perfectly capable of seeing where there is land to be acquired, and why should the Minister consider it necessary that he should have that power in reserve to exercise his influence over them? I can assure the Minister now that, as far as I am concerned, I put down this amendment in a perfectly genuine desire to improve the Bill, and not for the purpose of making capital out of it either here or in the country. That amendment is a reasonable one. I think the Minister would find it of great advantage to himself in the administration of the Act. I think his first thoughts were best, when he said that it did really carry out what he intended, and that it was only a matter of drafting to get the thing put right. I appeal to him now to maintain his acceptance of that principle.

Comment on this
Division

Question put—"That the words proposed be therein inserted in the quotation."

Tá 41
·
Níl 54
Result Lost The question put was not agreed to.

Do you agree with this result?

I move amendment No. 6:—

In sub-section (1) (a) line 35, after the word "acquired" to insert the words "or resume."

This is merely a drafting amendment.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 7:—

In sub-section (1) before paragraph (b) to insert a new paragraph as follows:—

the determination of the actual lands to be acquired.

Almost every argument that could be very well used in support of previous amendments that I moved can be used in support of this. I still hold the opinion that Deputy MacDermot's amendment does not really meet the point that he was anxious to cover. The Minister is attempting here to exercise the right to indicate to an inspector that he wants land in a certain townland. Indirectly he has the right to indicate that he wants land belonging to a certain individual. It has been demonstrated, in the course of this discussion, that the Minister undoubtedly has these powers under sub-section (2) in Section 2. If any Deputy has any doubt as to the extraordinary powers the Minister has got in regard to these particular matters, let him read Sections 28 and 31. In Section 31 the Land Commission, in other words the Minister, is given the widest possible power to take lands to relieve certain persons under the Act of 1923. He is given powers far in excess of any powers given under the Act of 1923. I still hold that the Minister under this particular sub-section can particularise, and give an indication to his commissioners, and through the commissioners to the inspectors in the country that he wants land in a certain townland indicating possibly the class and quality of the land, and even under the peculiar name that certain particular lands bear.

As everybody knows, there are many farms of land which bear certain local names. Even with Deputy MacDermot's addition to (a) the Minister can still get at the individual in another way. He can indicate indirectly to his inspectors: "I want Rockfield," in a certain townland of, say, County Kerry, or perhaps he may want another farm known by another local name in some other county. It is always possible, so long as this clause remains, for the Minister, the Land Commission, the commissioners or inspectors to particularise against certain land owners. My object is to remove that discrimination altogether from the Minister. There is no reason why the Minister should have any discrimination of that kind or should have any power which would permit him to discriminate against any landowner. In the past the Land Commission had a right to say, and the Minister had no right to interfere with them, what land they required in any particular county. As a matter of fact, that arrangement worked out very satisfactorily.

The Minister can rest assured that unless he does make some alteration in sub-section (1) (a) he will cause a great deal of uneasiness amongst many landholders. Amongst legal people the feeling exists that under this section the Minister has the right to say that he needs land from any particular individual in any townland in this country. Perhaps the Minister cannot say it directly, but indirectly he can exercise that power. That is a positive source of danger and, even though the power is never used by the Minister, the fact that it is incorporated in a Land Act is bound to cause insecurity and uneasiness. There is no justification for it.

The Minister says he wants power to deal with the relief of congestion. In my opinion he has all the powers he requires. The Minister is not going to succeed in solving the problem by taking those additional powers to himself. If he wants to deal with the problem of congestion he should look into the machine he is controlling in the Land Commission and see if, by loosening that machine in certain respects, he will not achieve much more than he will under the certain additional powers he is seeking here. These powers will not help him to speed up the relief of congestion. So long as this section remains in the Bill it will create uneasiness amongst tenant farmers. It may be that many of them, as a consequence of this power and the possibility of the Minister acquiring their lands, may allow some portion of their lands to go derelict. That will be a danger to the industry. I suggest that the Minister should reconsider this clause between now and the Report Stage. Perhaps he might draft a fresh clause which will remove the words to which we are taking objection and which will place the acquisition of land solely and absolutely in the Land Commission.

Comment on this

I have no objection to accepting the amendment, but I believe that it is already in sub-section (1) (a). We have the phrases "The determination of the actual lands to be acquired," and "The determination of the individuals from whom land is to be acquired." There is no difference in practice. If the Deputy thinks the thing will be improved and he wants to force the amendment, I am prepared to accept it.

Comment on this
Mr. Lynch

We would like to have it.

Comment on this

The Minister appears to be adopting the same attitude with regard to this amendment as he adopted in the case of Deputy MacDermot's amendment.

Comment on this

But he is prepared to accept it.

Comment on this

I am accepting it.

Comment on this

I move amendment 8:—

In sub-section (1) (b), line 37, after the word "acquired" to insert the words "or resumed."

This is purely a drafting amendment.

Comment on this

I move amendment 9:—

In sub-section (1), after line 41, to insert a new paragraph as follows:—"The determination of the question whether any lands so proposed to be acquired are required for the relief of congestion."

This amendment is drafted for the purpose of placing the problem of the relief of congestion entirely in the hands of the Land Commission. It covers perhaps a somewhat wider field than amendment 7, in the sense that it covers all classes of land this country required for the relief of congestion— tenanted and untenanted land, retained and resumed land, and so on. This amendment follows logically on my previous amendment.

I am anxious that any possible trace of discrimination should be removed from this sub-section. It would be a matter exclusively for the commissioners to say what lands are to be acquired for the relief of congestion and what lands are not to be acquired. I am anxious that that should be removed from the Minister's control altogether. It would be a matter also for the Land Commissioners to direct the inspectors as to what lands they are to visit for the purpose of ascertaining whether they are suitable for the relief of congestion. It would be for the Land Commission also to say what portion of a particular farm shall be retained or resumed for the relief of congestion and what portion the tenant will be allowed to retain for his own use. These matters in the past were left at the discretion of the Land Commission. They are matters which I want left to the complete discretion of the Land Commissioners in future.

Comment on this

If the Deputy is aiming at preventing the Minister from determining the person from whom land is to be acquired, I think that is definitely covered in sub-section (1) (a). I have already accepted the Deputy's amendment in reference to the determination of the actual lands to be acquired.

Comment on this

Sub-section (1) (a) does not cover my amendment at all. My amendment means simply that the Minister shall exercise no control whatsoever over the Land Commission in the acquisition of land for the relief of congestion. Under Sections 28 and 31 the Land Commission is given most extraordinary powers, and according to Section 2 of this Bill the Minister himself is really the Land Commission for the purpose of giving effect to Sections 28 and 31. I want, under this amendment, to substitute the Land Commissioners for the Minister; in other words, to give the Land Commissioners complete control so far as the carrying into effect of Sections 28 and 31 is concerned.

Comment on this

Will the Deputy explain the determination of the lands "so proposed to be acquired"? Where are they "so proposed" and what does the "so proposed to be acquired" mean?

Comment on this

Any lands which may be acquired—which will be acquired. The amendment only relates to this particular Bill. I want to ensure that the Minister shall have no authority whatsoever to say what lands shall be acquired for the relief of congestion, that that authority shall rest entirely and absolutely in the hands of the commissioners.

Comment on this

The Deputy wants excepted from the Minister powers of determination of any particular land required for the relief of congestion from any individual person. That is already in the Bill. The Minister cannot determine that land shall be taken from any individual.

Comment on this

The Minister has admitted himself——

Comment on this

I cannot follow the Deputy's amendment, I must confess. The words "so proposed" have no relation to anything.

Comment on this

Surely the amendment is perfectly clear, that it is to remove from the Minister power to direct the Land Commission to acquire any land on which they may have their eye for the relief of congestion. Under the Bill can they not say that any land is required for the relief of congestion and immediately all the safeguards fall to the ground because they will have a perfect answer when the same land is required for another purpose? It is proposed to withdraw from the Minister the power to make the Land Commission issue the necessary certificate. Under Section 31, where the lay commissioners certify that the land is required for resale, "the Land Commission shall have and may exercise in respect of such lands all or any of the powers that they may have in relation to acquiring land for the relief of congestion." Heretofore they have a right to make that certificate and there was an appeal to the judicial commissioner. Now, the proposal is, that the Minister shall have the power, and in that case the appeal would be to the appeal tribunal. But the Minister has absolute control over the lay commissioners. He has absolute power under Section 2, and here it is proposed to make an excepted matter of where the land is to be acquired for the relief of congestion. If Deputy Roddy's amendment is accepted nobody can make the certificate except the Land Commission.

Comment on this

I press on the Minister to accept the amendment because it really carries out and amplifies sub-section (1) of Section 6 which relates to the individuals, the land to be acquired and other matters connected with the acquisition of land. This question as to whether the land is or is not required for the relief of congestion, is in connection with the determination of the lands to be acquired and the amendment should be accepted to keep the section in harmony with itself. It is a matter which ought to be excepted in the powers of the Minister. This question as to whether land is to be acquired or not for the relief of congestion is treated in a very particular manner in later sections. It has been pointed out by Deputy Dillon that there is no appeal from the Land Commissioners to the appeal tribunal and if the object of the section is, as I take it, to be that the Land Commission is to acquire without external political pressure, the safeguard in the amendment should be included. I would press upon the Minister to have the matter left for the determination of the Land Commissioners and not for the Minister.

Comment on this

Thé determination of the persons from whom land is to be acquired is already excepted and so is the resumption of any land for any particular purpose. I cannot see the force of this amendment and I do not want to agree to anything which would appear to be excepting from the Minister the authority and responsibility for seeing that lands are acquired for the relief of congestion. The Minister cannot say that any particular lands are to be acquired for the relief of congestion or that so-and-so's lands are to be acquired. That is in the section. I do not see any force in these amendments and I am not going to accept them.

Comment on this

Would the Minister accept an amendment relating to the definition of the purposes for which lands are to be acquired?

Comment on this

That is already done. It was done in the 1923 Act and we have an amendment in Section 31 of this Bill. It could be discussed on that section.

Comment on this

Surely there are other matters besides relief of congestion for which land can be acquired. Then, if so, the argument which the Minister has put forward completely falls down. I would point out to him another answer in the actual wording of this amendment.

Comment on this

Will the Deputy relate the words "so proposed" to the section? Let us take it the "so" goes out.

Comment on this

"The determination of any lands proposed to be acquired for the relief of congestion." Surely it refers back to the lands mentioned in the previous clause. The determination of the individuals is excepted and the determination of the price is to be excepted and the determination of the purpose when the purpose is the relief of congestion is also to be excepted.

I suggest to the Minister that he should not keep in his own hands the determination of this question of whether the lands are to be acquired for the relief of congestion when that is a matter which is taken out of the judicial discretion of the appeal tribunal and left to the lay commissioners. If this clause does not go in, then the lay commissioners are not free and not unfettered in their judgment. In fact, if they give a court decision, they must obey, under that court decision, the orders of the Minister under sub-section (2) unless this clause or some clause similar to it is inserted in the Bill. If it is only a question of wording or anything of that kind, I suggest that the Minister should accept it subject to redrafting for the Report Stage. It seems to me that this is a very important amendment, because it would appear to me that this is giving the Minister, unless this is inserted, control over the lay commissioners in the exercise of their judicial discretion which, I think, everybody would think undesirable and which, I am sure, the Minister does not want. It is very much better for the Minister not to have powers which he does not want than to have them.

Comment on this

In clause (a), as it stands the determination of the individuals from whom land may be acquired is excepted from the Minister's power. The lands must be acquired for some purpose or other, and the widest power the commissioners have is to acquire land for the relief of congestion, so that one of the excepted powers is the determination of the persons from whom land is to be acquired for any purpose, including the purpose of the relief of congestion.

Comment on this

Those words are not here.

Comment on this

Lands must be acquired for some purpose. They are not going to be acquired merely for the fun of it. The Land Commission could not acquire lands simply for the fun of it. They acquire lands for certain specific legal purposes and, no matter for what purpose they propose to acquire land, the Minister has no finger in the pie as to the particular individual from whom land is to be acquired. That is already in the section.

Comment on this

There is a question as to whether land is or is not required for the relief of congestion. That is going to be determined. Let us assume that the present occupant says that it is not required for the relief of congestion. The Land Commission says it is. Those questions are determined in court from time to time, as everybody knows. Unless these words, or words similar to these, go in, the Minister makes himself the sole judge as to whether the lands are or are not required for the relief of congestion. If they are not required, they cannot be taken up in certain circumstances, or they can only be taken up for certain purposes, principally for the relief of congestion. That is a question which the present occupant wishes to have tested. He says the lands are not required. The case goes before the Land Commission and the Land Commission, because it is not an excepted matter as the Bill now stands, must decide as the Minister tells them. I should like to know from the Minister, if he says they are already included, what is the harm in putting in these words into the Bill? To my mind they are not included and it would relieve a certain amount of doubt, in my opinion, and, I am sure, in the opinion of a great many other Deputies, if this question was left to the lay commissioners as a tribunal and not to the Minister.

Comment on this

Does not this apply to Section 24 of the Land Act of 1923, which led off by stating that certain lands which the Land Commission should declare to be acquired for the purpose of relieving congestion should vest in the Land Commission, and then went on to state in clauses (a), (b), (c), (d), (e), (f) and (g) the various classes of land to which it would not apply. Then sub-section (3) stated:

Notwithstanding anything contained in the foregoing sub-sections, where the Land Commission before the appointed day declare in the prescribed manner that any land wherever situated, hereinbefore excluded from the operation of this section (other than land which comes within the description in clause (f) of sub-section (2) of this section), is required for the purpose of relieving congestion, then such land shall vest in the Land Commission pursuant to this section.

Then there are other provisions which apply in the event of that declaration being made. That was the function of the Land Commission, and by sub-section (2) of Section 6 of this Bill the Minister has the right to tell the Land Commission to do anything he wants them to do, save in so far as certain things are excepted. The object of this amendment is to make the thing provided in sub-section (3) of the Land Act of 1923 a reserve matter. If the Minister can find a better means of doing it, perhaps he will say so, and I have no doubt that Deputy Roddy will withdraw his amendment for redrafting on the Report Stage.

Comment on this

I cannot see what the Deputy is driving at in this amendment unless he is endeavouring to tighten up clause (a), which, I think, is tight enough already. However, if he wants to bring in an amendment on the Report Stage I will look into the matter again, and the Deputy can have a vote on the amendment on Report Stage if he thinks the matter is not already covered. I think, however, if he gets down to the real reading of the clause, he will find the point is already covered.

Comment on this

Will the Minister refer to sub-section (3) of the 1923 Act?

Comment on this

I am going to consider the whole matter.

Amendment, by leave, withdrawn, to be reintroduced on the Report Stage.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 10:—

In sub-section (3) (a), line 25, to delete the words "appeal tribunal" and substitute the words "judicial commissioner."

This amendment raises, in my opinion, one of three vital issues that have been challenged by the Land Bill of 1933. I propose in sub-section (3) (a), to delete the first reference that appears in this Bill to the appeal tribunal. In order to explain my reason for doing so, I must advert briefly to Section 7, which prescribes the manner in which that tribunal will be constituted.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Would the Deputy be prepared to take amendments 10, 11 and 12 together?

Comment on this

I am quite prepared to discuss them all together, and, accordingly, I move amendments Nos. 11 and 12:—

To delete sub-section (3) (b).

In sub-section (4), line 34, to delete the words "or to the appeal tribunal"; and in lines 36 and 37 to delete the words "or their functions by the appeal tribunal."

These raise the questions of the appeal tribunal. Section 7 defines the manner in which this appeal tribunal shall be constituted. It is to be constituted by "the judicial commissioner and any two of the officers of the Land Commision for the time being nominated by the Minister under this part of this Act to exercise and perform jurisdictions, powers, and duties on his behalf, shall constitute a tribunal, to be known and in this Act referred to as the appeal tribunal, to hear and determine all such applications, matters and things as are by this Act or shall hereafter be authorised to be brought before it."

The first question arises as to whether this tribunal is in conformity with the provisions of the Constitution at all. As I understand it, no person has a right to impose obligations—I think these are the words, the actual words escape me at the moment—there is a question in the Constitution on matters that affect the rights or impose obligations. I had the correct words a few moments ago, but they have escaped my memory.

Here we have a proposal to instal two persons who will have all the powers implied by that definition and who are for the time being nominated by the Executive Council. They are removable. It is necessary, to understand the situation to consider the circumstances under which the peculiar terms of the tenure of a judge were first evolved. It is only right that members of this House should remember that the peculiar position occupied by judges in this country and in Great Britain arose from the fact that at one time the Executive Council attempted to corrupt and coerce judges to do injustice to the citizens of the State in cases in which the Executive Council was interested. It was found that where there are two parties to litigation, one the State and the other the citizen, every time, in the opinion of the Executive, judgment had to be for the State. So the administration of justice between any Department of State and the citizen became an absolute travesty. The State could do what they pleased versus the citizen. The State at that time happened to be virtually a despot king, and it was then that the British Houses of Parliament intervened and extracted from the sovereign of the day legislation which gave complete protection to any high court judge and made it impossible for the Executive to interfere with his emoluments or to dismiss him from his position except for cause stated and with over a two-thirds majority of the two Houses of the Legislature.

Comment on this

Is the Deputy's objection to the appeal tribunal based on the fact that as this Bill stands they are not being given any fixity of tenure——

Comment on this

If there was a proviso that the two lay commissioners were to be removable not by the Executive Executive Council but by the Dáil, would the Deputy have the same objection to the section? I ask that because I propose on the Report Stage to bring in an amendment which will cover the fixity of tenure of the two lay commissioners and that they will not be removable except by the Dáil.

Comment on this

By the wishes of the Oireachtas?

Comment on this

Well, say by the Dáil.

Comment on this

If the Minister proposes to constitute these two lay commissioners high court judges my opposition disappears.

Comment on this

A high court judge has to be five or ten years a practising barrister—is not that so? I do not believe that a man who has practised at the Bar for ten years is the best possible man to fix the price of land. I believe that a member of the Land Commission is a much more practical man to be a judge of the price of land than a man who is simply a lawyer. About fixity of tenure we can meet that point. But to have the same status and to be actually high court judges, these are matters with which we could not agree.

Comment on this

Would the Minister consent to this—would he accept the spirit of my amendment No. 12—that he would give them the fixity of tenure of the high court judge and (2) that he would provide that questions of law would be decided to be questions of law on the certificate of the judicial commissioner and not decided by a majority of the appeal tribunal?

Comment on this

No.

Comment on this

We are discussing perhaps one of the most complicated codes of law that have been evolved in this country. We have two persons of wide experience in the administration of the Land Commission in collision with the high court judge, on the question whether somebody has not got a legal right under the statute passed by this House, to certain consideration. Now I maintain if such a question comes for decision the only person competent to decide that is a high court judge. Observe this that you have an appeal on every point of law from a high court judge to the Supreme Court but you have no appeal on any point which will have been decided by the appeal tribunal.

Comment on this

Seeing that there is no appeal on a question of fact or price from the appeal court is it not better to associate with a legal man two men who have a thorough knowledge of the working of the Land Commission?

Comment on this

Certainly, but the Minister misses my point. The Bill prescribes that the tribunal is to be composed of one judicial commissioner and two lay commissioners. The judicial commissioner says: "This is a pure point of law, and no question of fact at all", the lay commissioners say: "Nonsense, it is purely a question of common sense."

Comment on this
The Attorney-General

We are getting rather into a difficulty in discussing two things at the same time. In order to come to a decision in this matter Deputies may require some enlightment. Is not this a question—as to whether a question of law is to be decided by a majority of the commissioners—a separate point entirely from the question of tenure?

Comment on this
Mr. Lynch

It is.

Comment on this
The Attorney-General

We are prepared to bring in on Report a sub-section giving fixity of tenure to the new commissioners. This will give them tenure analogous to what the High Court Judges have under the present system. That disposes of one point and it is better not to discuss the second point until we come to it.

Comment on this

The reason I venture to raise it now is because both are connected.

Comment on this
The Attorney-General

We are agreeing to one point, that is about the fixity of tenure. We cannot agree to the second point about who is to decide what is a question of law.

Comment on this

I propose to delete references to the appeal tribunal and we have another amendment down to delete references about commissioners deciding a point of law. The Minister has met me on the question of the fixity of tenure for the lay commissioners. On the second point to allow the commissioners to have a right to decide whether a point was a point of law or not is a difficult matter from our point of view. It would make the position of the judicial commissioner absolutely impossible because he would be sitting there and might never be allowed to give an opinion.

Comment on this
The Attorney-General

Are we discussing that particular point now or not?

Comment on this

I am profoundly affected in my decision as to whether I would be prepared to accept the appeal tribunal at all by the question as to whether this right is to be retained for the lay members of that tribunal to override the judicial commissioner.

Comment on this

If that is the Deputy's objection we had better fight it out now, because we have definitely decided that as to whether a question is a matter of fact or a matter of law is to be determined, not by the judicial commissioner alone, but by a majority of the appeal tribunal.

Comment on this

I desire it to go on record now on that question, that I consider it is of vital importance and, so far as I am aware, is at complete variance with the whole practice of the law. The Attorney-General will correct me if I am wrong when I say that at present, if there is an appeal from the Circuit judge to the appeal commissioners, it is for the High Court judge to say whether, in respect of any matter, the question is a matter of fact or a matter of law. If the High Court judge certifies that it is a matter of fact, I think I am right in saying that no appeal lies to the appeal commissioners.

Comment on this
The Attorney-General

I do not follow.

Comment on this

Suppose you had an appeal to-morrow from the Circuit Court to the appeal commissioners here in Dublin——

Comment on this