We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

In Committee on Finance. - Land Bill, 1933—Committee.

Contributions 242–473 of 473. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

Bill Land Bill, 1933
Enacted

No. 33 of 1933 ›

The Attorney-General

The High Court.

Comment on this

The two judges sitting together for the hearing of Circuit Court appeals. The Attorney-General is familiar with the position?

Comment on this
The Attorney-General

Yes.

Comment on this

Suppose the Circuit Court judge certified that he has found any particular issue that was a matter of fact, you are immediately precluded from an appeal. There is no appeal from the Circuit judge on a matter of fact.

Comment on this
The Attorney-General

There is. It more or less works out that way in practice, but there is an appeal on fact just as on law.

Comment on this

The determination of whether a matter is a question of fact or a question of law is very specifically reserved to the judge in an ordinary court, and the jury has nothing to do with it. For instance, take any case in which a judge and jury are sitting together; the judge will refer certain questions to the jury, but the judge on the bench will decide which matter is a matter of law and which is a matter of fact. Certainly the jury is never called into consultation as to whether a matter is one of fact or of law. Will the Attorney-General admit that?

Comment on this
The Attorney-General

The jury are given directions as to what is the law. They decide on the question of fact.

Comment on this

And in this case it is the jury that is going to direct the judicial commissioner as to whether it is a question of law or not. That is the proposal. The proposal is that the jury, two ordinary intelligent citizens, two members of a special jury, are here going to rise up from the jury box and tell the judge "this is a matter of fact and not a matter of law, and, therefore, your decision is not required." I desire to reverse that, and establish the ordinary practice of court that where you have a question of pure law no members of the jury are qualified to decide; that the judge will direct the finding on the question of law, and that it will not be in the power of the jury—the common or special jury—to withdraw from the judge the direction on a point of law. The power we are giving to the two lay commissioners here is just the same as if we gave power to a special jury to dispense with the direction of a High Court judge on a point of law. I say it ought to be in the power of the judicial commissioner to say: "This is a point of law; as a High Court judge I decide it." As it is, the judicial commissioners can override him, and I think that is wrong.

I am glad the Minister is prepared to meet us on the first point, and I hope he will see his way before the debate concludes to meet us on the second one. If he does, in my opinion the primary objection to the appeal tribunal is gone, but if not I think the appeal tribunal becomes a very dangerous instrument.

Comment on this

I have more confidence in the jury than Deputy Dillon. I think that it should be possible for the judicial commissioner, if a matter of coming to a decision between a question of law and a question of fact arises, to induce one member of the jury to agree with him as a lawyer that the matter is in fact a question of law. Deputy Dillon referred to a special jury. I take it that the two men who will act as lay commissioners on this appeal tribunal will be intelligent men.

Comment on this
Mr. Rice

On a point of order, is this discussion relevant to this amendment? There is an amendment further down to delete certain words from the section; in other words to provide that only the judicial commissioner shall decide whether the question is a question of law or not. I suggest that the discussion at the moment is out of order, because we are not dealing with that amendment which expressly raises that question.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Deputy is right. It would be more relevant to the subsequent amendment.

Comment on this

That question was decided in advance, and it was agreed, I think, that this was to be thrashed out now. I am following up the case made by Deputy Dillon.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

If the House desires it that way.

Comment on this

As I was saying, the two men who would be acting as lay commissioners on the appeal tribunal would, I take it, be fairly intelligent men. While they would not necessarily have the understanding of the law that a legal man would have, I am sure that they would be capable of following the arguments that would be advanced by the judicial commissioner if a dispute arose between the members of the tribunal as to what was a question of law and what was a question of fact. I think the Minister is entitled to insist upon that section as it stands—that this matter can only be determined, not by the judicial commissioner, but by a majority of the appeal tribunal.

Comment on this
Mr. Rice

I think a Chinn Comhairle it is your ruling that a discussion of the later amendment is relevant on the present one?

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Minister I think expressed a desire to have it thrashed out now. The three amendments, Nos. 10, 11 and 12, are being taken together.

Comment on this

Does that mean that if we do not speak at this point we cannot speak later?

Comment on this
Mr. Rice

It comes along again on amendment 17, and if that amendment is discussed now I should like to say a few words with reference to the matter. The proposal in the section as it stands, sub-section (3), introduces a revolutionary principle into our system of law. In our system of law, and in every other system of which I have any knowledge, the functions of a judge and jury, or other lay members of the tribunal who may be sitting with a judge, are carefully separated, so as to leave to the judge the decision on questions of law, and to leave to the members of the jury the decision on questions of fact. That is a fundamental distinction in our system of law, and it is a fundamental distinction in every system of law, English, American and every other of which I have any knowledge. Where a judge is sitting with a jury the judge intervenes to withdraw from the jury certain considerations which may arise on the evidence, telling them that these are matters for his consideration, being purely questions of law. Here it is proposed not merely to take from the judge the power of deciding what is a question of law, but it is also proposed to vest in the members of the tribunal, that is the majority of two, the right to overrule the view he forms. He may say: "Here a question of law arises," and the other two members of the tribunal may say that they disagree with him. He is ipso facto by that decision of theirs, overruled, and they decide— and finally decide—whether any question of law arises. Of course, I said— and I do not want to repeat what I said on the Second Reading debate— that one of the most difficult questions which judges have to determine, after long experience is whether a question that arises is one of law or of fact. Sometimes it may be a question of mixed law and fact. Here you are putting into the hands of the lay members of the tribunal the decision of a question which is one of the most difficult for judges to decide. This is introducing an entirely novel principle into our system of law. I think it is a vicious system, because laymen cannot have the qualifications to determine these matters. Juries have been set up because it is the experience of people that they are better judges of fact than lawyers. In that I agree. But that a layman could be a better judge of law, even against a judge with the training and experience he has, is a bad principle to assert. I say it is introducing a vicious system to provide the two laymen can overrule a judge on what is in its nature a question of law.

Comment on this

I want to express the hope that the Attorney-General, when he comes to reply, will indicate clearly what the reasons are that induced the Government to withdraw a question of determining whether a question is one of law or fact from the judicial commissioner. I am rather inclined to agree with Deputy Smith in thinking that there could be no great objection to two lay commissioners, chosen on the grounds of their intelligence and knowledge of affairs, deciding on matters of law or fact except that it is a departure from established principle and one on which the Government seem to be rather suspiciously keen. I confess that suspicions are aroused by the fact that they seem to be anxious to take away the determination of these matters from the judicial commissioner who, we think, could be relied upon to come to a saner conclusion on these matters.

Comment on this
The Attorney-General

My opinion about this section is that in practice it will work out that the judicial commissioner's view of what is a question of law or fact will be accepted on every occasion. This discussion is largely academic. I am not prepared to answer Deputy MacDermot's question as to why it was brought in.

Comment on this

The Attorney-General is not prepared to answer the question. Why?

Comment on this
The Attorney-General

Simply I am not, but I do object strongly to Deputy Rice's statement. Either he did not hear my speech, or did not read what I said, on the Second Reading. He repeated here just now almost verbatim what he himself said on Second Reading.

Comment on this
Mr. Rice

Does the Attorney-General suggest that I ought to accept his views on the matter?

Comment on this
The Attorney-General

I do. As I say the Deputy repeated what he said on Second Reading, when he characterised this section as introducing a vicious and a revolutionary principle. If the Deputy bears with me for a moment I will point out to him that in the Second Reading debate I gave a precedent for a similar provision. That was the provision which gave two commissioners wider powers in deciding what is a question of law and what is a question of fact than we are giving here in this Bill. I then read the section of the Railway and Canal Traffic Act

Comment on this

There is no analogy.

Comment on this
Mr. Rice

And the Attorney-General should not refer to a matter that is still sub judice.

Comment on this
The Attorney-General

We are in Committee, and the Deputy can make as many speeches as he likes. I was referring to the fact that I gave, as a precedent for this type of legislation, the provisions of sub-section (3) of Section 5 of the Railway and Canal Traffic Act of 1888. That section lays it down that no less than three commissioners should attend a hearing, the ex-officio commissioner shall preside and his opinion on any questions which in the opinion of the commissioners is a question of law shall prevail. That section was quoted by me and unless the Deputy is prepared to say that no such law is in existence, or unless perhaps he is so national that in referring to "our" system of law he only includes what has been enacted since 1922 he must accept that argument. But this section to which I referred of the Railway and Canal Act would be accepted as a precedent in England.

Comment on this
Mr. Rice

Perhaps I know more about the law since 1922 than the Attorney-General does.

Comment on this
The Attorney-General

I do not intend to be offensive to the Deputy, and I do not know why he should be offensive to me. But I think I am entitled to complain that when I made an answer to his speech on the Second Reading of this Bill, he did not take the trouble to familiarise himself with what I said, but rather repeats verbatim what he said on the Second Reading. Deputy Cosgrave spoke after me on that occasion, and he referred to this, and his answer to the analogy was not that there was no analogy, but it was that it was not on all fours with the present instance, because the commissioners there had a certain tenure of office which the commissioners here under this Bill have not. The force of that particular criticism has now been removed. We are now putting the commissioners under this Bill in much the same position as the lay commissioners under the Railway and Canal Traffic Act. There they were appointed by one of the Ministers of the British Cabinet. He appointed two lay commissioners as men of experience in these matters. These two commissioners had the same jurisdiction committed to them that we are committing to our commissioners here. Again, Deputy Rice seems to have confused the matter of deciding a question of law and deciding whether a question is one of law or of fact. As Deputy Smith put it, we are appointing two men of intelligence and experience in the working of land legislation, with some conception of what are the outlines, shall we say, of our land legislation, and with sufficient intelligence to appreciate the difficulty as to what is a question of fact and what is a question of law. I would say, with all respect, that two men of very high intelligence are quite capable of deciding as to whether a question is a question of law or of fact. I should say the number of cases in which this point will arise at all, if it ever does arise, are infinitesimal. Since we have given an undertaking that we would give the lay commissioners tenure corresponding to that of judges there seems to be no urge upon such a commissioner to decide in any way except the way in which his intelligence guides him.

Comment on this

Can we assume that the Executive Council will not appoint to these offices political partisans?

Comment on this
The Attorney-General

The effect of giving security of tenure to any office is that the moment a man is appointed he can snap his fingers at whoever appointed him. This whole matter has been dealt with in this debate in an abstract way. No instance has been given of the type of question that might arise, and that might give trouble in this regard. Deputy Rice talked wildly about this revolutionary principle. But here we are dealing with a code of laws which to a large extent is shaped towards the administration by the Land Commission of the land code and shaped so as to enable it to carry through the just distribution of the land in certain ways.

I should rather think that it would be quite logical to remove the judicial commissioner away from the Land Commission altogether and allow the Land Commission as a body to administer the land code. That would be quite a logical and defensible thing to do. I am sure I cannot be accused of wishing to curtail the activities of the judiciary in any way. I consider that in administering the land code an experienced man such as a lay commissioner is a much more important cog in the wheel than the judicial commissioner. We are leaving the judicial commissioner there. As Deputy Smith said, he cannot be credited with very much power of persuasion if he is not able, on a mere question as to whether a matter before them is or is not a matter of law, to bring one of his colleagues with him. I do not see the slightest danger from this section. I do not admit it is revolutionary. I think the position of the commissioners in relation to the administration of the land code is very close to the position of the commissioners under the Railways and Canal Traffic Act, and the reasons which induced the British Parliament, which Deputy Dillon seems to think are so impressed with the necessity for having an independent judiciary and committing matters to judicial personages, to embody that section in that Act are very much like the reasons which induced us to embody this section in our Bill.

Comment on this

There is this vital difference, that in connection with the tribunal set up under the Railways and Canal Traffic Act there was a means whereby any person aggrieved by any decision of the tribunal could bring the whole matter up for review before a High Court by a writ of mandamus. Is not that so?

Comment on this
The Attorney-General

I could not say offhand.

Comment on this

Surely the Attorney-General is aware that the findings of such a tribunal can be reviewed by the High Court unless it is specifically ruled by statute that such findings are definitely final.

Comment on this
The Attorney-General

I do not see that that makes any difference in the case that I have made.

Comment on this

Here we have a tribunal from which there is no appeal. You have put it in the power of the lay commissioners, who are not judicial persons, to decide not only the case brought before them, but to decide also whether the person concerned shall have the right of appeal from them or not. They can decide not only as between the Land Commission and the aggrieved party, but also whether the aggrieved party will have the right to go to the High Courts. In my opinion, the analogy which the Attorney-General makes between this tribunal and the Railway Tribunal falls to the ground. So long as you have a right of appeal from any decision of a tribunal to the High Courts, then you can go a long way towards having your wrong redressed if your case is a just one, but the moment you make the findings of a tribunal final, that chance of appeal is lost.

Comment on this
The Attorney-General

There was no appeal on a question of fact from the commissioners under the Railway and Canal Traffic Act.

Comment on this

Where it is definitely stated that the findings of the tribunal should be final, the aggrieved party has no redress. In the ordinary course a right of appeal would lie to the High Court, where a case would be fully reviewed.

Comment on this
The Attorney-General

I cannot at the moment see any method of testing them on a question of fact.

Comment on this

The Attorney-General must know that in the case of any body held out as being a body which is to give a decision as between two parties, unless there is something in the statute debarring one from applying for a writ, an aggrieved party is entitled to have the finding of that body fully reviewed by the High Court. I am quite well aware that the Attorney-General can play ducks and drakes with me if he starts querying what the procedure is. He knows that very well.

Comment on this
The Attorney-General

I do not think the Deputy is quite right.

Comment on this

Surely the Attorney-General will agree that the ordinary citizen feels he has a right to invoke the High Courts on the grounds that justice was not done him. Does not the statute say in this case that the determinations of the tribunal shall be final and no appeal can follow?

Comment on this
The Attorney-General

There can be no appeal.

Comment on this

Would the High Courts entertain an application in that respect?

Comment on this
The Attorney-General

That is a matter for the High Courts.

Comment on this

It is a matter in regard to which the Attorney-General has a shrewd idea. I fancy he knows the High Court will not. That destroys the analogy the Attorney-General has sought to establish between this tribunal and the Railway and Canals Act.

Comment on this

What puzzles me is that the Attorney-General is calling on the Opposition to provide illustrations. Surely it is for him to provide illustrations of the sort of questions that might arise.

Comment on this

I want to know from Deputy Dillon and those opposed to the section if they can give us some indication as to what question would be likely to come before the appeal tribunal. In what way is an injustice likely to be done? It seems to me that the determination of a question of law or fact might not come before the tribunal very often and that the opinion of the judicial commissioner would likely be accepted. I would like to have some case that might arise where an injustice would be done.

Comment on this

Why not from the Attorney-General, who is proposing an innovation?

Comment on this
Mr. Rice

The Attorney-General replying to what I had to say, thought fit to suggest that I had not heard or read some relevant matter and what he suggested as relevant matter was his own speech. I did not refer to the Attorney-General's reference or the example he had given, because I thought it was not a proper course to refer to a matter that was still sub judice. The Attorney-General knows well that the question as to whether the Railway Tribunal has the powers as suggested under that section is pending decision in the High Court.

Comment on this
The Attorney-General

In what High Court?

Comment on this
Mr. Rice

Before Mr. Justice Sullivan, Mr. Justice Hanna, and Mr. Justice O'Byrne. It is a case at the instance of the Great Southern Railways.

Comment on this
The Attorney-General

Against me?

Comment on this
Mr. Rice

The Attorney-General is a party to the litigation.

Comment on this
The Attorney-General

Surely the Deputy is aware that my reference was to the Railways and Canals Traffic Act of 1888.

Comment on this
Mr. Rice

Well, whether the Attorney-General referred to the Railways and Canals Traffic Act or to the Railway Tribunal, the particular question to which I have referred is pending decision at the present moment and therefore should not be discussed here.

There is another matter. The Attorney-General said that the discretion is a matter of form, because in practically every case the view of the judicial commissioner will be accepted by the two lay commissioners. Why then is the exception made? Why is the provision inserted that the lay commissioners can override him, and does the Attorney-General take the view that the lay commissioners will regard it as farcical to ask them to determine what is and is not a question of law?

Comment on this

This is my first contribution to this measure. Anything I have to say about it I said before I came into the House. I am astonished at the opposition that this Bill has received at the hands of the lawyers. It has been attacked by four of them, and what is the reason for the attack? Apparently their objection is that if there is to be a decree against a farmer in future and it has not the solicitor's costs added to the bill it is a very grave hardship. Another point is about the appeal tribunal. We are told that lawyers and not farmers are able to decide on that question. They say that no farmer is intelligent enough to do so. I wonder will they follow that argument a little further, and if they do in the near future we will have a House full of lawyers and nobody else. I would ask the lawyers in the future when they are debating this Bill to remember that this is a Land Act and that the men who have to work the Land Act are the farmers and they are going to work it without so many lawyers' costs in the future.

Comment on this

You will be disillusioned.

Comment on this

Intervening in this debate it seems to me as an ordinary layman that what the Attorney-General said that it was not at all likely that the lay commissioners would disagree with the judicial commissioner is correct. I do not think that there will be any difference of opinion between them. I am in agreement on that point with the Attorney-General and Deputy Smith, but while it is not at all likely to arise, it might arise, and there is no reason why it should be included. It is not a very sound principle to embody this in an Act of Parliament giving power to two lay commissioners to override the judicial commissioner. It is a principle that ought not to be adopted. Perhaps in many matters of life it would be very pleasing to many litigants if some of their difficulties could be determined in that manner, the principle that the Minister insists upon in this Bill. Litigants outside would be pleased if this power could be extended to give people who are not lawyers power to determine the law. What are lawyers and judges for? Surely they are there to decide the law. If this section is passed it might be extended and laymen would usurp the functions of the legal men. Perhaps I am exaggerating.

Comment on this

You are not exaggerating one bit.

Comment on this

I am not exaggerating what could possibly happen; perhaps I am exaggerating what can likely happen. We should be very careful to prevent impossible things happening, and it is not outside possibility that these two lay commissioners would question the law of the judicial commissioner and refuse to agree with him. That is the principle we should not agree to. That is the reason I am opposing this section.

Comment on this

I find it very difficult to understand any proposal in which a judge becomes an advocate on the bench and must persuade one of his lay brethren that he is right before he can get his support. That, in substance, is what this section comes to.

Comment on this

It means to withdraw from the judge and the bench the decision as to what is or is not a question of law. It gives the power to a special jury that a judge should have.

Comment on this
The Attorney-General

No.

Comment on this

Yes. The special jury will decide.

Comment on this
The Attorney-General

There is no special jury now.

Comment on this

You have special juries in Great Britain—men well versed in the habits of trade or something of that kind. It was customary in the courts for the judge to decide what are the pertinent questions for the jury to take into consideration. Here we have the reverse process and are going to establish that the jury will decide what are the proper questions for the judge. The Attorney-General has dug up a most disreputable precedent in advocating this section. The whole practice of the law is against him. I see Deputy Geoghegan sitting there in silence and I would like him to enter into the fray and tell us whether he thinks this is a desirable thing. It is a rotten precedent. I wonder would the Attorney-General himself like to take the position that the judicial commissioner is put in by this section. It is putting the judicial commissioner on the shelf. If the Attorney-General were a High Court Judge would he like to have his status altered? If the Government can find a gentleman who will accept a judicial commissionership on these terms it will be a source of very considerable surprise to me.

Comment on this

Is the Deputy not making a mistake that the judge is to be relegated to the background, in any case, even on a question of law? The analogy of a judge and jury is quite imperfect. The jury decides certain things for itself. In this case what Deputy Dillon is calling the jury will not decide questions of law.

Comment on this

In this case the privilege will be conferred on the judge of coming into the jury box himself, when the jury will let him in.

Comment on this

What the Deputy calls the jury will not decide by itself any particular thing. The only question is that there are certain things in which the judicial commissioner will alone have the deciding voice.

Comment on this

But not on what he knows most about, law.

Comment on this

On that question one cannot be very prejudiced because when you look around and see ordinary persons—taken at random you might say— making the law, it does not seem a strange step to take. Presumably these commissioners who are working day after day on a particular specialised task will be asked to give their advice in deciding whether a question is a matter of law or of fact.

Comment on this

Why should they?

Comment on this

I think Deputy Dillon is exaggerating when he says it is outraging the law and that it is revolutionary. With regard to the fault he has found with the Attorney-General's analogy, I call his attention to a fact that the Attorney-General has not emphasised; the Railways and Canal Traffic Act goes much farther than the Bill before the House. In that case the commissioners must be unanimous, so that we are not going as far as the Railways and Canal Traffic Act went. That analogy is no use, Deputy Dillon will say, because there is an appeal there. There might be an appeal against that Railway and Canal Commission with regard to any particular matter, but on this question, whether any particular question was a question of law or of fact, I do not think there is any decision, and if a Deputy is satisfied that there is an appeal I should like if he would quote the Act and show it.

Comment on this

There is no Act; it is common law.

Comment on this

I gather that there cannot be any difference between Deputy Moore and the Attorney-General on this matter. I assume it represents the same point of view that a good layman is at least as good as a lawyer.

Comment on this

In deciding whether a question is one of law or of fact.

Comment on this

But that is often one of the most difficult things to decide and the Deputy may remember that when the Courts of Justice Act was going through one of the most difficult problems was what was a question of law and what of fact. Some people said: "Why cannot you have an appeal on questions of law alone?" Most of the judges I have discussed the problem with say that it is one of the most difficult matters, but according to Deputy Moore, any layman or woman can do it with a certain amount of instruction. I would be very much surprised to learn what was in fact a question of law and there would be no appeal from them in that because that in itself is not a question of fact, it is a question of law. That is why I object to the section. You are putting into the hands of two laymen the power to give decisions on what are questions of law. However much the Government may care to disguise whether it is a question of fact or of law that is a question of law. We ought to be in agreement in that that we are putting the deciding of questions of law into the hands of these lay commissioners. It may be easy to disguise it, but no matter how you dodge them it is there. I cannot say from my knowledge of the Land Commission whether there are mixed matters— matters of law and fact, which arise every day in law and in fact. Who is to decide that matter? The lay commissioners and the judge? Surely if there are such things as mixed matters it ought to be made clear if we are to take judicial decisions out of the hands of the judge and put the power into the hands of laymen. I hold that it is fundamentally wrong.

Comment on this

Certainly there are some matters on which I would prefer to get the opinion of two commonsense laymen rather than the opinion of a foolish lawyer. I think if the Deputies will look at our proposals they will see that they are a reasonable compromise. We want to get certain work done. We want to have associated with it a man who has a thorough knowledge of the law, a man with a thorough knowledge of Land Commission work. You get some lawyers who would not let you step on the floor; they would say "that is a question of law"— whether you have a legal right to do it. Some lawyers contend that everything is a question of law. We are setting up this tribunal and we are associating with a judge—a man who has to have ten years' practice at the Bar—men who have experience of Land Commission work. When the question is one of law the judicial commissioner has the deciding voice. When a question is one of fact the whole three members of the tribunal vote on that particular question. If there is a question about any decision, and there is a dispute whether it is a question of law or fact, then the laymen decide whether or not it is a question of law.

As far as land law is concerned, I believe that if you take any of the senior officials of the Land Commission who have been dealing with land for 20, 30 or 40 years you will find that they have a much more thorough knowledge of the law than any judge could possibly have. Any barrister practising at the Bar has a general knowledge of the law going through but Land Commissioners have a most detailed knowledge of the most complicated code of laws that it is possible to imagine and I think that in order to do the difficult work we require to be done the proposals we have put forward are the best possible. Of these men who will sit two of them will have a knowledge of land work and one man will be a lawyer or judge. Questions of fact, price of land, etc., should be assumed as questions for the tribunal as a whole and purely questions of law, matters for the judge.

Comment on this

Is it not quite clear that the Minister and Deputy Moore are standing on the same ground, that is, the judge is to be distrusted and the official is to be trusted.

Comment on this

Not necessarily.

Comment on this

Not necessarily —that is the force of the argument. The judge, because he is a judge, is not to be trusted.

Comment on this
The Attorney-General

Is the Deputy aware that we propose to confer the tenure of judges on the commissioners?

Comment on this

He says he would prefer to have the opinion of one working in the Land Commission for a number of years rather than one appointed as a judge. Now may I suggest that there is hardly a Government Department in any State, and possibly not even in this State, that does not think it has a perfect knowledge of law, a better knowledge of law than the lawyers outside or than the judges who decide. That is a common failing, I suggest, of Government Departments but it is not a failing that necessarily ought to be—if I may use a phrase that Deputy MacDermot says Labour Deputies use—enshrined in the law of this House, namely, that an official, because he has that administrative experience, is a more capable person to give a decision even on legal matters, as I gather now from the Minister, than a judge. I suggest that the Minister has gone quite beyond what is in the Bill itself in the revelation that he has made as to what is in his mind in reference to this particular matter.

Comment on this

Is not the determination of whether a thing is a matter of fact or of law itself a matter of law?

Comment on this
The Attorney-General

Deputy Dillon said that I produced a disreputable precedent, but if the Deputy had looked at the Act, as I thought he might have, he would find that the provisions in it are very elaborate, and that the judge who was to sit with the commissioners was appointed in England by the Lord Chancellor, in Scotland by the Lord President of the Court of Session, and in Ireland by the Lord Chancellor of Ireland. Apparently, it was not considered undignified to put a judge sitting with the lay commissioners created under that Act. I do not want to quarrel with Deputy Dillon because, apparently, he does not appreciate the way in which appeals may be taken and the way in which decisions of the court may be questioned, but he suggests that there is some very vital difference between the new tribunal which we will have under our Bill and the position which the commissioners held under the Act of 1888. Now there is this provision in the Act of 1888. "No appeal shall lie from the commissioners upon a question of fact, or upon any question regarding the locus standi of a complainant.”

Comment on this

Who decided whether it was a question of fact or law?

Comment on this
The Attorney-General

Of course, I knew that Deputy O'Sullivan's subtle mind was playing around——

Comment on this

Will the Attorney-General answer the ques-question?

Comment on this
The Attorney-General

I will give the Deputy an answer in a moment. I think that at one time I took the Deputy too seriously when he got up on the Committee Stage on various occasions to raise points and when I sought to meet his points. I have come to the conclusion now that he enjoys letting his mind play round these points, but, apparently, he is not aware that this section in the Act which I have been quoting—the section in the Railways and Canals Traffic Act—is being relied on to show that this provision gave to the commissioners the right to decide whether a question was a question of fact or law, and that I was relying on it as a precedent for what is in our Bill. Apparently the Deputy is not aware of that. The Deputy asked who was to decide under that Act whether it was a question of fact. I already referred to that Act on the Second Reading of the Bill.

Deputy Cosgrave referred to my introduction of it in the discussion, and made the point, which we have now met, that there was a difference in the tenure of the commissioners. We have met that now and put the commissioners somewhat in the same position. Deputy O'Sullivan enjoyed himself on this during the afternoon, and now asks me: who decided under that Act what was a question of fact? The commissioners. Does that knock the bottom out of all we had from the Deputy this afternoon. The Deputy asked those questions with a certain unctuous hilarity and thought the answer was going to be in his favour. The answer is that there is an Act dealing with railways and canal traffic that was introduced in the British Parliament under which an elaborate provision was made for a tribunal very like the one it is proposed to set up under this Bill, and that had to handle problems such as the commission here will have to deal with. Apparently, the proposal in this Bill overwhelms the Deputy with absurdity; that a layman should be allowed to say what is not a question of law. I would be prepared personally to accept Deputy O'Sullivan's own opinion, as an intelligent and highly educated man, on what is a question of fact just as readily as I would accept the view of many judges. If we put intelligent men on this tribunal I should say that any normal person would accept their decision on this question. Here, as I have said, is an old Act which set up a tribunal to deal with a somewhat analogous type of question. This section which we have introduced, as Deputy Moore has pointed out, does not go quite so far as the section of that Act went.

Comment on this

The Attorney-General mentioned something about the tenure of office of the commissioners. I missed what he said. Would he be good enough to repeat it?

Comment on this
The Attorney-General

As I indicated earlier, it is proposed to introduce an amendment on the Report Stage conferring upon the commissioners who sit on the appeal tribunal a tenure analogous to that of judges.

Comment on this

Apparently we have impressed the Government to some extent. Would the Attorney-General say what was the salary that was to be given to the commissioners on the Railway Tribunal in question, and if there were only two?

Comment on this
The Attorney-General

Is the suggestion that they were bought?

Comment on this

No. The suggestion is that they got very high salaries, practically as high as judges, and that the salary that was paid to the additional Land Commissioner was within £500 of the salary paid to a High Court judge.

Comment on this

Deputy Cosgrave seems to forget that at one time the Land Commissioners in this country had the same tenure as county court judges, and that they had very much higher salaries than they had at present. It was Deputy Cosgrave's Government that was responsible for destroying their fixity of tenure and of turning them into commissioners at the will of the Executive.

Comment on this

Will the Minister quote the section for me? I have not forgotten it at all.

Comment on this

Under the Land Law Act of 1923.

Comment on this

But the section dealing with the will of the Executive.

Comment on this

I am referring now to the Land Law (Commission) Act, 1923. I take it that Deputy Cosgrave was in charge of the Government here then. Sub-section (4) of Section 4 of that Act provided:—

So much of sub-section (3) of Section 28 of the Purchase of Land (Ireland) Act, 1891, as provides that each commissioner of the Irish Land Commission shall hold his office by the same tenure as if he was a county court judge in Ireland shall not apply to commissioners appointed under this section.

Comment on this

I understood the Minister to say that the Executive Council in my time passed an Act appointing Land Commissioners at their will. I would like the Minister to find that out for me, if their tenure was at the will of the Executive.

Comment on this

The Land Commissioners had the tenure of county court judges, and what I said was that Deputy Cosgrave's Government took that tenure away from them.

Comment on this

Can the Minister then say what tenure they had after the passing of that section?

Comment on this

They were appointed by the Executive Council.

Comment on this

And removable at the will of the Executive Council?

Comment on this

Yes.

Comment on this

Will the Minister point out where that is in the Act? Will the Attorney-General or will the whole of the Front Bench opposite show me that?

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Is Deputy Dillon pressing amendment 10?

Comment on this

I would prefer to have the question that we have been discussing decided on amendment 17. Really the point on which we join issue is whether the lay commissioners will have power to override the Judicial Commissioner.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Of course the point decided will be the point in the amendment.

Comment on this

Will the Ceann Comhairle look at amendment 17?

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Deputy will get a division on that later.

Comment on this

Then I shall withdraw my amendment 10.

Comment on this

I move amendment 11:

To delete sub-section (3), (b).

This is a sub-section which gives the Minister power to arrange the duties of the lay commissioners; to arrange the areas they will have control of and generally to control their activities in every respect. I should like to know what is the object of this sub-section. These are purely administrative powers and the Minister has got those powers already. Why is it necessary now to introduce this clause in the Bill for the purpose of dealing with powers which he already has? These are purely administrative powers and, as a matter of fact, the other Ministers who preceded him in control of the Land Commission arranged the duties of the lay commissioners and even arranged the districts which they were put in control of. We cannot understand why the Minister has introduced this particular sub-section for the purpose of taking powers which he already has in his administrative capacity as head of the Land Commission.

Comment on this

The Deputy, therefore, does not object to the powers being given?

Comment on this

What is the object of introducing the sub-section?

Comment on this

Perhaps the Minister will hear my objections to it as the amendment also stands in my name. I did not apprehend that under sub-section (2) the Minister had power to differentiate between one particular commissioner and another. As I understand, under sub-section (2) the Minister had power to direct the Land Commission on anything that lay within its administrative power save in respect of excepted matters. Sub-section (3) (b) goes further and says that the Minister can go into the Land Commissioners and say "I want this particular Land Commissioner to deal with this particular class of cases or with this particular county." I do not know why the Minister wants that. My assumption is that one Land Commissioner is as good as another for the purpose of doing the work that the commissioners normally undertake. Why should the Minister take power to delegate work particularly to one member? Under sub-section (2) he has power to direct the Land Commission in the exercise and performance of the powers and duties for the time being vested in it by law. I understood Deputy Roddy to say that sub-section (2) gives the Minister all the powers he seeks to take in sub-section (3) (b). I challenge that. I suggest that while the Minister had power generally to direct the Land Commission, he had not power to segregate the work between individual commissioners. I am fortified in that suggestion by the appearance of this sub-section and I am suggesting to the Minister that, if Deputy Roddy be right, he should meet my objection by taking out sub-section (3) (b) and, if Deputy Roddy be wrong, and sub-section (3) (b) gives powers of discrimination, they are powers he should not have, and I invite him to accept our amendment dealing with this sub-section. I do not think it will be of the least assistance to him and it may involve him in difficulties of a very undesirable kind. The House is of opinion that one Land Commissioner is as effective as another, and it ought not to be in the Minister's power to differentiate between them.

Comment on this

I think we have discussed this ad nauscam already on sub-section 1. I believe that the Minister responsible for the Land Commission should have full authority over the work of the Land Commission, as a whole, save in regard to the matters which have been excepted. As the law will stand if this passes, the Minister is responsible to the Dáil and to the country for the work of the Land Commission. It would be foolish for anyone to accept responsibility without having authority, and we want to make clear what is not clear. Deputy Roddy says it is. As a matter of fact, power was taken under certain Orders, and Acts were passed to give the Minister complete control, but it was found that that did not work out. We want to give the Minister authority to direct the activities of the Land Commission, save in regard to the excepted matters. It is absolutely necessary, if we are going to make progress, that that should be done.

Comment on this

I am convinced that this sub-section is inserted specifically to give the Minister powers over the excepted matters which sub-section (1) denies him. I think that is the object of it, because this sub-section is in relation to excepted matters. By sub-section (2) the Minister may not exercise authority over the excepted matters, but he may exercise authority by way of class or classes or types of cases over the individuals who look after these cases in excepted matters. Personally, I think that sub-sections (a) and (b) annul to a very large extent, in fact, completely, as far as the Minister's powers are concerned, the section with regard to the excepted matters.

Comment on this

I think Deputy Brennan should have had a chat with Deputy Roddy before he came into the House. Deputy Roddy thought the Minister in fact, had these powers already.

Comment on this

I disagree with Deputy Roddy entirely.

Comment on this

We cannot hope to please the Opposition in this. All we can hope is to please the majority of the Dáil. We believe that these powers are necessary. We believe that a definition of the division of duties and responsibility between the Land Commissioners and the Minister is necessary, and we have attempted to define it here. We think it is a scheme which is workable; that it gives the Minister such powers as he should have and keeps from him such powers as he should not have.

Comment on this

I should like to ask the Minister a question. He stated a minute ago that he would prefer the opinion of two competent laymen on a question of law rather than the opinion of a lawyer. I am putting a question now to a competent layman from a lawyer as to the reason for the powers sought to be obtained in this particular sub-section. What additional powers does he propose to take under this that are not already given to him by the Act of 1923 and the Ministers and Secretaries Act? If he has got additional powers, what are they? If he has got them, what is the necessity for this section? I find that Section 12 of the Land Law (Commission) Act of 1923 directs that "the Irish Land Commission shall, in the exercise of such of its powers and duties as are of an administrative or executive nature, be subject to the control of the Minister for Agriculture." I am speaking from recollection, but the powers contained in that section have been greatly amplified by the provisions contained in the Ministers and Secretaries Act of 1924, and I cannot imagine any wider powers than the Minister has under the Act of 1924. If he has those powers, what is the necessity for this provision in this Act? I fail to see it and I am asking the Minister, as a lawyer to a layman, what additional powers he thinks he is getting under this section which he thinks he has not got already.

Comment on this

What about the excepted matters? As far as I have read this Bill, I think we are right in our belief that sub-section (1) of Section 6 withdrew from the Minister for Lands and Fisheries certain excepted matters. Now, as Deputy Brennan points out, and I quite agree with him, the Minister, by a back door, is coming in on the excepted matters again. It does not matter what previous powers he had under previous Acts, this Bill withdrew certain of these powers, but back again he lands in sub-section (3) having had a fanfare of trumpets about all the powers he was debarred from using in relation to excepted matters. Sub-section (3) states that:

All powers and duties for the time being vested by law (including this Act) in the Land Commission or the lay commissioners in relation to an excepted matter, shall, on and after the appointed day be exercised and performed in all respects as if this section had not been enacted save that

(a) any appeal which may lie by law (including this Act) from the determination of an excepted matter shall lie to the appeal tribunal, and

(b) the Minister may, if and so far as he thinks proper, arrange by reference to the class or classes of case or the county or counties in which the land concerned is situate the distribution amongst the lay commissioners of their work in relation to the excepted matters, but not so as to allocate any particular case or land to any particular lay commissioner.

Is not one commissioner as good as another? What is the reason for this? He says that it is for no particular reason except that the Minister is responsible to the House and ought to have the fullest possible powers; but he began by taking off the power in sub-section (1) and now gives it back in sub-section (3). That is why we seek to delete sub-section (3).

Comment on this

Deputies Roddy, Lynch and Dillon do not seem to have sought the deletion for the same reason. I have endeavoured to explain the matter and to show that under Section 3 (b) the Minister gets general powers over the activities of the Land Commission and also particular powers save in regard to the excepted matters.

Comment on this

Yes, general powers over the excepted matters.

Comment on this

Particular powers in regard to other matters that are not excepted, and the excepted matters are clearly set out in sub-section (1).

Comment on this

What does the Minister want with the powers in paragraph (b)?

Comment on this

Deputy Dillon wants this deleted because it is giving to the Minister certain powers which Deputy Roddy says we have got already. I leave it to the two of them to fight it out.

Comment on this

That is nonsense.

Comment on this

I leave it to the Dáil, and the best thing to do is to leave it to the Division Lobby.

Comment on this

What Deputies Roddy and Brennan argue is that there are certain powers already with the Minister. Either these sub-sections, to which we are referring, give extra powers or they do not. If they do not give these powers why are they enacted? If they do give them, what are the extra powers? Deputy Dillon's point and, to a certain extent, Deputy Costello's point, is: are we not getting in here powers that seem to be taken from the Minister? If not, why is the Minister not satisfied with the powers given to him already, for instance, under Section 12 of the Land Law (Commission) Act of 1923? The Minister has not explained to the House the necessity for the powers he now seeks over the powers he has already got under the two Acts referred to by Deputy Costello. He has not justified the existence of the sub-section. I suggest that it is the Minister's duty to the House to supply that justification and not to find subtle differences between other members of the House, but to explain the reason why he is advocating these particular sub-sections. Do they give him more powers than he had under the Land Law (Commission) Act of 1923 and under the Ministers and Secretaries Act? If so, what are these powers? The House is entitled to know. If they do not give any additional powers, why are the sub-sections there? If they do, what are the additional powers?

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Is the Deputy pressing the amendment?

Comment on this

Yes. I want to have some explanation as to this section and as to what is the object of the Minister in incorporating it in this Bill. Under Section 12 of the Land Law (Commission) Act the Minister was given certain powers. I presume that the power the Minister is seeking in this section is administrative power. In what respect are the powers conferred by the Land Law (Commission) Act of 1923, which were amplified since under subsequent Acts, deficient, and why does the Minister want them amplified now? Apparently, the Minister's reason is to give him greater power over the activities of the Land Commission. I want to find out in what respect the present powers which he has got are defective, or in what respect it was necessary for him to amplify them in order that he may have the power which he is now seeking and have greater control over the Land Commission in the future. It appears to me that he has all the administrative power he wants under the existing Acts to carry out the duties he has outlined here in this particular clause of sub-section (3). If he has, what is his object in introducing this clause into this Bill? Deputies Dillon and Brennan have said that his object is to give him greater power over the commissioners in regard to the excepted matters, and I think that is the only reason. That is why, a moment ago, I was anxious to get an explanation from the Minister for the introduction of this clause. He has got all the power he wants already—far greater power than in this. In fact, he has got power of life and death over every act of the Land Commission. Even in regard to the excepted matters, he can exercise powers. Is he not prepared to offer some explanation as to why he has incorporated this clause in this Bill?

Comment on this

It is rather amusing to see the lawyers and the laymen on the opposite side fighting as to the particular powers taken in this Bill. I am rather surprised at Deputy Roddy. I can excuse Deputy Dillon's inexperience of the House and I can also excuse Deputy Costello because we do not see his fair face here very often. Deputy Roddy, however, was here in charge of this Department for five or six years, being bombarded every day by questions about the Land Commission, and knowing, at the same time, that he had no power whatsoever. He had to answer questions about grievances which he had no power of remedying. We do not intend that our Ministers should be in that position. We hold that the Minister should at least have the power of seeing that his Department is worked. We have too much administration and power by officials in this country, and it is time that it should be checked. The country is run by officials and lawyers. That is the reason for any extra powers that are given. Our experience of Deputy Roddy in that particular Department for five or six years showed that he had no power whatever over the Land Commission Department. Deputy Bennett, sitting beside him, could tell him that the poor fellow could not do a thing. Deputy Bennett knows it. He used to be questioning Deputy Roddy day after day and week after week and he knew that the poor fellow had no power to remedy his grievances. We have had enough of the tail wagging the dog in this country and it is time that the dog had something to say for himself.

Comment on this
Division

Question put: "That the words proposed to be deleted stand."

Tá 61
·
Níl 44
Result _

Do you agree with this result?

On the section I am sorry that the Attorney-General has left, because he did not answer the question which was put as to who would decide on the question of law, and that certain things are only questions of fact. He quoted the Railways and Canals Traffic Act of 1888, but there is a distinct appeal to a higher tribunal, and there is no indication that that higher tribunal, namely, the court, will not decide as to whether a question is one of law or of fact.

Comment on this

I suggest that that dis cussion would be more relevant to the next section, which deals with the appeal tribunal.

Comment on this

I object to the passing of this section, because to my mind from the attitude taken up by the Minister it has become manifest that in fact he had sweeping powers under previous Acts, and that he has come to the House and—for the benefit of the effect it will create throughout the country—magnaminously divested himself of all power to deal with the excepted matters set out in paragraphs (a), (b), (c) and (d) of sub-section (1). That was for the purpose of creating a feeling of security amongst the public; then in a comparatively unimportant paragraph, sub-section (3), he marches back again, and resumes effective power to deal with the questions which he alleges to divest himself of in sub-section (1). In that connection, let me point this out; what is to prevent the Minister, on the day on which the Act passes, delegating a commissioner to deal with County Roscommon, and instructing him to deal with that class of cases which shall be constituted by persons who did not grow sugar beet? There may be only half a dozen people in the County Roscommon who do not grow sugar beet, and by that means he can put in the hands of a chosen commissioner the very duty that he is divesting himself of under paragraph (a) sub-section (1).

I regard this section of the Bill as being drafted for the purpose of creating a false sense of security amongst the public and in this House. On closer examination it proves that the Minister desires to have his share of the credit. He wants to have the appearance of acting in a disinterested detached way, and, at the same time, to have effective power to do what Deputy Corry wants to do, and what Deputy Smith wants to do. The most illuminating speech in the whole course of this Committee Stage was made by Deputy Smith, whose absence I regret. He rose and attacked the lawyers who dared to interest themselves in this matter. He forgot that some of the lawyers happened to be farmers as well, and not Fianna Fáil farmers either. He said: "Why are we to be hindered in the administration of this Act?"; not the Land Commission, not the Minister for Lands and Fisheries, but "we"—a back bencher in the Fianna Fáil Party. That is what Deputy Smith wants, that the back benchers of the Fianna Fáil Party should administer this Land Act; that the back benchers of the Fianna Fáil Party should be in a position to tell the Minister what commissioner is to deal with certain classes of cases in County Cavan, in County Roscommon and County Sligo. "Why should we be restricted in the administration of this Act?"; the powers for "we" are in paragraph (b) of sub-section (3), and "we" consists of Deputy Smith and Deputy Corry. If the fate of the tenant purchasers of this country is to be in the hands of Deputy Smith and Deputy Corry, God help the tenant purchasers of this country who are not prepared to purchase immunity by joining the local Fianna Fáil Cumann. Thanks be to God there are some tenant purchasers in this country who would be prepared to defend their holdings without joining a Fianna Fáil Cumann.

Comment on this

They did not run away to America like Deputy Dillon when there was trouble in the country.

Comment on this

Deputy Dillon came back, and Deputy Dillon is here now, and if Deputy Carty tries any more tricks like he tried in connection with the Land Commission, Deputy Dillon will be here to retard him. Every time there is jobbery adopted by Deputy Carty, or any other Deputy on those benches, Deputy Dillon will not be afraid to get up and tell him about it. I propose to challenge a division on this section. It is a dangerous section, and will eventually put the Minister in a position which I believe he himself does not desire to occupy.

Comment on this

Deputy Dillon has alluded to what he calls the back benchers of Fianna Fáil, and what right they have to have any voice, apparently, in this House. Deputy Smith was sent in here by 8,000 people from the County Cavan. I was sent in here by 11,000 people from the County Cork who elected me. I do not know what end of the booth Deputy Dillon came in at. We came in here to carry out the wishes of the people who sent us here. When Deputy Dillon talks of the "tenant purchasers" and the "peasant proprietors" like the gentleman to whom I alluded the other day, who had 5,700 acres in the County Tipperary and could not give 61 acres to the Land Commission for distribution, I am hanged if he will get fixity of tenure for them if I can help it.

Comment on this

I do not think that Deputy Dillon objected to Deputy Corry or Deputy Smith speaking.

Comment on this

We are working farmers, what you are not.

Comment on this

Personally I am always glad to hear Deputy Corry speak. I have expressed my view on that matter before. He expresses himself always much more clearly than the members of his Front Bench, and I am always glad to hear the views of the present Government which we get much more readily and clearly from Deputy Corry than from themselves. He always makes revelations. Six months, sometimes, before the Government announce their policy we get it from Deputy Corry. I did not understand Deputy Dillon to object to Deputy Corry or Deputy Smith. I rather thought he welcomed their speeches as showing what is behind this section. We had a long discussion on the section. Can anyone who was in the House tell us definitely what was the policy of the Minister? He announced three conflicting policies, and he gave three different interpretations of the section. It was only when Deputy Smith got up that he made it clear that he thought the Minister ought to have the power to deal with these individuals in this particular way. Deputy Corry agreed with that. There was full agreement between Deputy Corry, and Deputy Smith and myself as to the meaning of this section. There was sometimes full agreement between us and the Minister and sometimes full disagreement. As I pointed out he gave many different and conflicting interpretations as to what the section means and as to what the policy of the Government is on the matter. Under Section 12 of the Land Law Act of 1923 the Minister has the following powers:

The Irish Land Commission shall in the exercise of such of its powers and duties as are of an administrative or executive nature, be subject to the control of the Minister for Agriculture.

That Minister mentioned there is now the Minister for Lands and Fisheries. What else in addition to that is wanted?

Comment on this

Ask Deputy Roddy.

Comment on this

Deputy Roddy is not responsible for the compiling of this Bill, or for the existence of this section. Other matters are only judicial. We asked for information and did not get it. We got no explanation as to why there is this attempt at legislation, or as to why the Minister is not satisfied with the full powers given him over the administrative and executive matters, under the Act of 1923. What else does he want? We must assume he wants something else. We have had various attempts on the part of the Minister to explain this section. He has given no justification and his explanations are conflicting. Deputies cannot blame us if we find a certain amount of difficulty in seeing what purpose the Minister has in view when nobody listening to him could understand his explanations of the provisions of this section.

Comment on this
Division

Question put: "That Section 6, as amended, stand part of the Bill."

Tá 62
·
Níl 45
Result Carried The question put was agreed to.

Do you agree with this result?

Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Amendments 13, 14, 15, 17, 19 and also amendments 1 and 2 are to be debated together. They might be all taken on amendment 14. That course was suggested in order to see how far the compromise suggested by the Minister meets the amendments. In case it does not meet them fully, Deputies might submit other amendments on the Report Stage.

Comment on this

I beg to move amendment 14:—

In sub-section (1), page 6, to delete all words from the word "any," line 39, to the word "behalf," line 42, and substitute the words "two lay commissioners nominated for the purpose by the Executive Council."

Comment on this
Mr. Lynch

This amendment meets ours only to the extent that the Minister met a former amendment. He stated that his intention was to have persons of experience, but already he has refused to have the qualification of two years' standing for the commissioners.

Comment on this

Are we discussing amendment 13?

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

Amendments 1 and 2 and 13, 14, 15, 17, 19 are grouped on amendment 14. Amendments 1 and 2 were postponed pending a decision on amendment 14.

Comment on this
Mr. Lynch

Amendment 1 proposes a change in the definition of an officer of the Land Commission. It says "the expression ‘officer of the Land Commission' for the purposes of this Act means a person holding office as a Land Commissioner of two years' standing, other than the judicial commissioner, or, in the event of a vacancy arising in the office of Land Commissioner an official of not less than 13 years' service whose basic salary on the 1st June, 1933, was not less than £700 per annum, appointed by the Executive Council to be a Land Commissioner."

Amendment 2 goes on to define the expression "lay commissioner," again stating that that person is to be a Land Commissioner of two years' standing or an officer appointed for the purpose who has had 13 years' experience. I think the Minister certainly agrees with the principle of having a man with experience and I can see no reason why he should not put into his amendment the qualification of two years' standing.

Comment on this

The Minister was speaking when I returned from the Division Lobby, and I do not know if he expressed the intention of accepting in principle the amendment in my name, or of rejecting it.

Comment on this

I was dealing with amendment 14.

Comment on this

The object for which I put down amendment 13 was to secure that the lay commissioners would command the ungrudging respect of every person who might fancy he had a grievance under any administration laid down by the Land Commission. I do not wish to mince words in this matter. The House will observe that I put down a period of 12 years, which would have brought us back to the period before Saorstát Eireann was established. We are aware that it is conceivable that somebody might feel if two, three or five years were laid down that the amendment was designed to secure that some persons who held office under the Cumann na nGaedheal Government should have a pre-eminent claim to the position of lay commissioner. What I was desirous of emphasising was to ensure that they should be persons of experience, whose record in the Land Commission would command respect, and that they should be persons appointed to their present posts by an administration other than that for which any Party in this House was responsible. The appointment by the British Government in itself would be no guarantee of suitability for this office, but the record of a gentleman in the Land Commission is in itself a guarantee of suitability. The fact that they were appointed by a Government other than for which any Party in this House was responsible, disposes of the suggestion that there was a desire by any Party in the House to secure a position of this kind for one of its own nominees. The Minister has stated, and I quite accepted his assurance, that it is his intention, in ordinary circumstances, to appoint a Land Commissioner to the position of lay commissioner under the Act. I think it would be to his advantage, and to the advantage of everyone, if he accepted my amendment, or the spirit of it, and undertook to appoint to the position of lay commissioner only such officer of the Land Commission who had 12 years' experience, prior to the passing of this Bill.

Comment on this

I thought Deputy Dillon was not aware of the full force of his amendment, but it seems that he is, more or less. This amendment would definitely exclude existing Land Commissioners who have had less than 12 years' experience in the Land Commission. There are certain Land Commissioners with 30 or 40 years' experience in other Departments who were changed to the Land Commission in order to strengthen it.

Comment on this

If the Minister accepts the principle that officers should have some years experience, without hesitation I waive the number of years.

Comment on this

The position is this, that I think the present Government is as capable of choosing men to be lay commissioners as either the British Government or the Cumann na nGaedheal Government.

Comment on this

When we appoint lay commissioners we will stand over them in the Dáil and in the country. When we appoint two lay commissioners to be members of the paid tribunal we will appoint efficient and competent men upon whose honesty the country and the Dáil can rely.

Comment on this

With experience of the Land Commission?

Comment on this

With experience in these matters.

Comment on this

In the Land Commission?

Comment on this

I would point out that if we accepted this amendment it would exclude men who have 30 or 40 years' experience of Governmental administration, but who have only recently come into the Land Commission. This would exclude many of the present Land Commissioners. When we appoint persons to be lay commissioners we are quite prepared to stand over the appointments in the Dáil and in the country. We are not going to accept any of these restricted clauses.

Comment on this

Then the Minister's attitude is that he is inclined to appoint men who happen to have some Land Commission experience but, in fact, desires to have freedom to appoint men who have no experience of Land Commission work. I mentioned 12 years in the amendment. I am quite prepared to reduce that period to such minimum years of service as will ensure that the person appointed will have experience of Land Commission administration. If the Minister says that in his opinion five years' service in the Land Commission would be sufficient, I am quite prepared to accept that number of years. I ask the Minister if he will accept the principle, that he will be restricted in his choice to persons who manifestly are men with experience of Land Commission administration.

Comment on this

I do not know what Deputy Dillon means when he mentions 12 years' experience. I regret that the Deputy opposite who was connected with the Land Commission has nothing to say on this matter. One of the commissioners should be a farmer who got land on the estates divided up by the last Government, and who has had experience of trying to work it and to pay the annuities that were put on it by the old tribunal, about which we heard so much. One of the men should be appointed from the farming community, one who will have to take up this land and to make a success of it. These people should have some voice in the price that is going to be paid for it. There is too much talk about officials here, officials there, and everywhere. One would think that no one knew anything in this world except the officials and the lawyers. It appears to be necessary to be either one or the other to know anything, especially about farming. If you want to know anything about farming you are told to go to the lawyers or the officials. It would be a very wise thing, a Godsend and a blessing, if an ordinary farmer who got portion of one of the divided up estates, and who has been for four or five years trying to pay the landlord's share, the tenant's share, as well as compensation for disturbance— three annuities rolled into one—was appointed. I urge on the Minister the necessity of having a representative of those who will have to try to make a living out of the land appointed. Let these people have some voice in the price that is to be paid in the division of the estate as well as in the other matters that will be considered by the tribunal. Do not have them coming into the land like swallows and leaving when the winter comes; stopping as long as they could and clearing out when Deputy Roddy put the bailiffs after them. There are a number of men who could be brought in as they have experience of the working of estates and the fixing of prices.

Comment on this

The object of amendments 1 and 2 is to secure that the lay commissioners to act on the appeal tribunal would be selected from existing Land Commissioners. In the course of a discussion on an earlier amendment of mine the Minister admitted that it was his desire that men of experience should act on the committee to be formed to draw up rules and regulations. If he admits that it is necessary to have officials of long experience on the committee to draft the rules and regulations implementing this Bill, surely he must admit that it is absolutely necessary to have an official of experience acting as lay commissioner on the appeal tribunal. This tribunal will have to deal with many matters hitherto dealt with by a High Court judge.

Under this Bill the Minister is going to restrict the functions of the High Court judge and the judicial commissioner to two questions, (1) questions relating to the determination of matters arising on questions of title and (2) the distribution of the purchase money. All matters in relation to the adjustment of disputes in connection with bounties or the adjustment of mistakes that may be made in the issuing of receivable orders, the adjustment of the many difficult legal matters arising out of the vesting of land and so on—all these matters will have to be determined by this lay tribunal now. Yet according to the Minister's statement —at least, one is entitled to infer it from the Minister's statement this evening—he proposes to go outside the Land Commission for the purpose of appointing laymen to assist the judicial commissioner.

Surely he must admit that this lay tribunal will be called upon to discharge highly important duties and in the discharge of these duties the members of the tribunal will have to decide very difficult legal questions. If these legal questions are to be decided satisfactorily, if all the interests concerned are to be satisfied, if justice, equity and fair play are to be meted out to them, surely he must admit that he will require to have on that tribunal persons of experience in the working of the land code. If the Minister goes outside the Land Commission he will find it very difficult to find even any member of the legal profession who has that wide knowledge of the land code. Everybody must admit that it is particularly difficult to get persons outside possessing that highly specialised knowledge of the code that is required for dealing with these problems. It is only the legal members of the Land Commission who have that specialised knowledge of the working of the code that would enable them to act on a tribunal of this kind. Whatever may be said about the Land Commission it is, at all events, admitted, and it must be admitted, that in determining questions between the tenant and the owner or between the tenant, the owner and the State, the Land Commissioners have always acted fairly in the past. Everybody must admit that they did mete out justice fairly and squarely to all interests concerned. Yet, apparently it is the Minister's intention to pass over the claims of the existing Land Commissioners, the men who have administered the Land Acts in the past and the men who admittedly discharged their duties fairly as between all the interests concerned. It is his intention to pass over the claims of these men and to appoint presumably political supporters of his own to act with the judicial commissioner on a tribunal of this kind.

If the Minister does proceed to appoint supporters of his own as members of the tribunal, I ask him will the tenant farmers have the same confidence in that tribunal as they had in the tribunal that operated in the past? Is there any likelihood that the tenant farmers of this country will have the same confidence in a tribunal of that character, the members of which have been put into that position because they happen to be political supporters of the Minister's Party? Do you think the tenant farmers of the country who have claims to be decided before that particular tribunal will have the same confidence as they had in the tribunal which functioned in the past for the purpose of determining questions of that kind? It seems to me utterly unfair and unjust that the Minister should pass over the claims of the existing Land Commissioners and proceed to appoint two outsiders in conjunction with the judicial commissioner for the purpose of determining questions that will come before them arising out of this Bill. If the Minister had any sense of gratitude he would take into consideration the claims of the existing commissioners and see that two of them were appointed on this particular tribunal. If he wants experience, as he must admit, for the purpose of enabling him to resolve the problems that will inevitably arise for consideration under this Bill he has got that experience among the present members of the Land Commission and there seems to be no justification for going outside these men for the purpose of appointing other individuals.

Comment on this

I do not agree with Deputy Roddy that there is general agreement that the past administration of the Land Commission was above board or that there was no differentiation made between individuals. I strongly object to the statements that have been continually made this afternoon both by Deputy Roddy and Deputy Dillon, that at every available opportunity the Minister's sole desire is to bring into the administration of this Bill in some capacity—inspectors, on the appeal tribunal and in other ways—persons who are specially associated with Fianna Fáil. One would imagine that this Bill was merely brought in to place the political followers of the Government in jobs. That statement has been made almost continually this evening by Deputy Roddy and it was hinted at on a few occasions by Deputy Dillon. I resent that. What ever failings this Government may be suffering from, they do not suffer from that, to the extent that Cumann na nGaedheal did when in office. It is probably because their own tactics in the past are troubling them that they believe the same thing is going to happen now.

We have heard that the Fianna Fáil clubs have decided how the land is to be divided. We hear now that political followers of Fianna Fáil are to be appointed to these positions, in order to prevent men who are ten years, 12 years and 20 years in the Land Commission from being appointed. We hear that these men in the Land Commission are the only persons capable of being appointed to these responsible positions. There are men in the country who have as much ability to decide matters of this kind as have men who have been tied down for years in administrative positions. I understood from the statement of the Minister that the Government is taking the responsibility for that and that they are going to see that none but men of wide experience are appointed. The Minister has that responsibility, and mind you, I am of opinion that he has as great an interest in the welfare of the tenant farmer as either Deputy Roddy or Deputy Dillon. He has more and he has proved he has more. He is tackling this problem in their interest. He will have to answer to this House. He will have to answer to us.

Comment on this
Deputies

Hear, hear!

Comment on this

He will have to answer to the country for his actions.

Comment on this

Do not go beyond the "us."

Comment on this

The Minister realises that responsibility, and having an interest in the people, he wants to have power in these matters. I think it is a tribute to him that he is not afraid of the responsibility. He does not want to throw it over on some other body. I would prefer to have matters in a different position to that in which they were when Deputy Roddy, who is a particularly energetic man, was in charge of the Land Commission and could do nothing. Are we to take it that Deputies opposite want the Land Commission to have no more powers than they had under the 1923 Act? Are we to take it that they are to have no more power to deal with the land problem? Surely, when the Deputy, who piloted through both Houses the Land Bill of 1923 admitted that after ten years there was a very drastic problem to be dealt with, it is time that some change must be made. I do not think it is at all wise, as an attempt has been made this evening, to allow a mass of red tape to tie down the Minister, tie down the Government and the Land Commission. I do not object to the Land Commissioners. In the past they had functions——

Comment on this

On a point of order, the Deputy will excuse me for interrupting him, but are we dealing now with the Second Stage of the Bill or an amendment specifying certain qualifications for the persons to be appointed to the appeal tribunal?

Comment on this

I do not object to individuals in the Land Commission, men of long experience, men with an interest in the country and in the welfare of its people, being appointed to this tribunal but I do not want too much red tape tying the hands of everybody and preventing an advance being made. We have other objections raised by Deputy Roddy and when these insinuations are thrown about as to Fianna Fáil camp followers getting this and that, I would remind Deputy Roddy that the Fianna Fáil camp followers, as he calls them, throughout the country have as much interest in justice as has Deputy Roddy or his followers and they are not afraid to face the music and the Minister is not afraid to face the responsibility, which is a great responsibility, which he is taking on himself in this Bill. I am glad that he is not accepting the amendment.

Comment on this

The last speech was quite interesting but it was rather hard to see what it had got to do with the amendment before the House. Deputy Cleary was very strong in the questions he put to this side of the House as to whether the Land Commission were to have no more powers than they had before. I do not see in this Bill any increase, apart from one section which is not under discussion now, in the powers the Land Commission had. Deputy Cleary says, in effect, that every single clause of this Bill increases their powers. I am afraid I cannot see the increase of the powers of the Land Commission under this Bill. What we are debating now is how the existent powers of the Land Commission are to be exercised and who are the persons who are to exercise them. There is one part of Deputy Cleary's speech with which I was completely and entirely in agreement. He expressed the view that justice would be done between all parties and he said that was the view of the Fianna Fáil Party. Upon that question, there may or may not be agreement. I will not, however, stop to answer that question but if Deputy Cleary is completely and entirely sincere—and I am not suggesting that he is not—in his view that this Bill should be impartially administered, then I, for my part, completely fail to follow Deputy Cleary's method of procedure, because if Deputy Cleary is completely convinced of that he has an amendment here which is making it reasonably certain that the Bill will be justly administered. If the Minister does not accept these amendments and if Deputy Cleary is completely honest —and I do not suggest for a moment that he is not—and consistent, as I hope he will be, there will be no room for Deputy Cleary in the lobby behind the Minister and Deputy Cleary will find himself forced by his own arguments to take his place in the lobby against the Minister. I wonder whether Deputy Cleary's conscience will be sufficiently strong to compel him to take that logical course which would follow from the speech he has made. I am greatly afraid, although, of course, that issue will be decided in the next few minutes, that Deputy Cleary on this occasion will not quite live up to the sentiments he has given utterance to.

Comment on this

If I had not a conscience, I would be in the Deputy's Party.

Comment on this

I do not think the Deputy would. It is not quite easy to get into our Party, especially for some persons.

Comment on this

That is the biggest joke of the year.

Comment on this

Let me consider the Minister's amendment and the other amendments. The other amendments make it certain that the persons who are appointed as lay commissioners on this appeal tribunal with the judicial commissioner are men who know something about the work that they have to perform. As this Bill stands, the judicial commissioner is not to be the sole judge of a question at law, because what is a question at law has to be decided by those two lay commissioners and not by the commissioner himself. Are we then going to have persons who are completely inexperienced in this matter who are going to decide what are or are not questions of law, or are we going to have persons who are experienced in these matters? In other words, is this tribunal to consist of men who know their work or is it to be a tribunal which gives an appeal from commissioners who do know their work, possibly, to commissioners who do not know their work? That is what it comes down to. If these are going to be two new gentlemen appointed for the purpose, they will not be as competent a body as the body they are deciding appeals from, and to have an appeal from an experienced, competent court to a court that may be constituted by persons of no experience at all—and, seemingly, that is going to be the case or the Minister would accept these amendments—is, to my mind, an absolutely wrong thing to do. After all, if you are setting up an appeal tribunal, the justification for the appeal tribunal surely is this, that not only that two sets of minds shall get to work on the same problem but that a better set of minds and a more experienced set of minds shall be the minds to give the final utterance and yet you are going to reverse all that. You are going to put the pyramid on its apex, unless you accept these amendments or, at least, you are leaving it open to yourselves to do so and why leave it open to yourselves to do a thing if you do not intend to do it? It seems to me that if this Bill is to leave this House in the condition in which a Bill should leave this House, these amendments should be accepted.

Comment on this

There is no doubt that it is amusing to hear Deputy Fitzgerald-Kenney on this, but it is particularly amusing to hear Deputy Roddy talking about the confidence the tenants reposed in the old tribunal. I wonder what confidence the tenant of the Gunn Estate in County Clare who was paying £12 a year to the landlord and who found his annuity jumped to £20 by the commissioner reposed in the tribunal? I wonder what kind of confidence the unfortunate 24 tenants in my constituency who find that they are paying 15 per cent. more to the Land Commission to-day than they were paying to the landlord in 1920 reposed in the judicial tribunal. We hear a lot of talk about this, and Deputy Roddy has again come along with this talk of corruption—"two nominees of Fianna Fáil, two supporters of Fianna Fáil." Who appointed the old tribunal and what discussion was there here on the appointment of that last tribunal—this tribunal that had the confidence of the tenants and of the people and which was appointed by the British Government under a secret agreement of 1923? In which of the two tribunals will the people have the more confidence—the tribunal appointed by the representatives of the Irish people or the tribunal appointed under the secret agreement made with the British in 1923? I think that the ordinary tenant farmers who happened to get these divided up estates and whose annuities have been increased altogether by a sum of £660,000 in seven or eight years have reason to feel that their confidence has been shaken in this famous tribunal we hear all the talk about. We are sick of all this thing, but when I look at amendment No. 17 I am not at all surprised. It is an amendment proposed by three lawyers and a half. No wonder that all the lawyers are coming to the front and gathering around the legal luminary at the head; the lesser lights to protect the larger one. Amendment 17, as I have said, has been proposed by three lawyers and a half. That is the kind of thing we are getting on this Bill. I certainly would have far more confidence and so, too, would the tenant farmers of the country in a commissioner who was an ordinary farmer, say, like Deputy Holohan or Deputy Bennett, practical farmers who have some idea of what land is worth, than I would have in any official of the Land Commission. I think that such men would be far clearer in their judgments and would give a fairer decision than would this famous tribunal that we hear so much of from the supporters of this amendment. No one is supposed to be a judge of anything here except lawyers and officials. They had too much power in this country in the past. We were sent in here to curb their power and to end it and let there be no doubt about it we are going to do it. I and the farmers of this country, as I have said, would have far more confidence in an ordinary farmer like Deputy Holohan, who knows the value of land, administering these Acts than we would have in any official or lawyer.

Deputy Roddy comes along and talks about corruption. I never heard any reply from Deputy Roddy to the statement made here by Deputy Hassett in 1929 about the district justice who got 351 acres of land. Deputy Roddy has never told us anything about that. I suppose this district justice who got the 351 acres would be one of the peasant proprietors, one of the poor fellows for whom Deputy Dillon's heart bleeds. He is very much afraid that fixity of tenure will be taken from such people. The people opposite are an amusing lot, particularly when one remembers their actions here during the last five or six years. Look at the list of amendments that they have put down to this Bill. They certainly are well qualified to talk about corruption. They think that every Party in this country is fouled with their own dirty brush. They are mighty anxious to see that, by hook or by crook, the nominee of the British Government is still kept here to fix the price that the Irish farmer should pay for his land. Because of the proposals in this Bill there is a great fluttering in the dovecots opposite. I wonder was any guarantee given to the British Government, in connection with these Land Acts, that no future Government would ever dare to remove this Buddha or god, or whatever you like to call him, who is there for the purpose of fixing the price that the Irish farmer must pay for his land? We had Deputy Dillon coming along with his most illuminating clause, that if this tribunal appointed by the British Government is to have any assistance, then it should have the assistance of two or three of the brethren whose chief qualification is to be that they also in their day were appointed by the British Government. We had 12 years' experience of that, and very good care was taken that these people were appointed neither by Cumann na nGaedheal nor by Fianna Fáil. We are going to end that, to see that the road is kept clear and that the peasant farmers of this country are not going to be put in the same category as the district justice who got the 351 acres, or that other poor peasant proprietor, Captain Moore, of Tipperary, with his 5,700 acres. We are going to see to it that the peasant farmers will get a slice of these estates and that they will not have to pay through the nose for it. We had for far too long a period the nominees of the British Government fixing the price that the farmers of this country should pay for their land. As I said before, we are going to end that. We got a mandate from the people to end it, and we are going to do it.

Comment on this

I have been very interested in listening to the last speech on an amendment which we were told was proposed by three and a half lawyers. The answer that we got to that, if I may describe it without offence, was a speech from the vulgar fraction of a farmer. It was very good to have that point of view expressed by that Deputy. Again, I hope he will not take it as an offence when I say that in this debate he represents the battering ram of the Executive Council.

Comment on this

I represent more than the Deputy does.

Comment on this

I hope the Deputy understands what I mean: that he represents a point of view the Minister is going to stand up and justify before the House—that it will be a great thing to get rid of lawyers and commissioners and that sort of people and get in farmers who know what it is to work land under certain conditions. The logical conclusion to be drawn from the Deputy's speech is this: that the worse farmer a man is the better he is going to be in this job, because he will have a better realisation of the difficulties.

Comment on this

Does the Deputy mean to say that Deputy Holohan and Deputy Bennett are bad farmers?

Comment on this

Under those conditions, possibly the Deputy himself may qualify, but only under those conditions. Deputy Cleary expressed the same point of view: that the Minister is going to take this grave responsibility upon himself and justify himself before this House. Now the Government that can justify the giving of £100,000 of the people's money to a mouldy Press——

Comment on this

What about the 351 acres that your Government gave to the district justice?

Comment on this

The Government that can do that will not be afraid of other responsibilities. We are told that this Bill is not to give places to Fianna Fáil dependents. If it is not, then it should be so marked in the long title. Why not put in the long title that it is not a place-hunter's Bill? What about the new Commissioner of Police? What about the Agricultural Credit Corporation and what about the numerous Committees appointed by the Government since they came in? Is there a defeated T.D. that they have not placed somewhere, and if there is, is there not a place waiting for him when this Bill goes through? He has the promised land stretching before him when this Bill gets through. What is objected to in the amendment? That you have got to confine yourself to experience in this particular type of work. Deputy Dillon said that so far as that is concerned he is taking out the particular period of years. Deputy Corry either forgot that, or thought it better to neglect it for the purpose of getting in the phrase "nominees of the British Government." Who are the nominees of the British Government who have been imposing these hardships on the poor farmers of the country for the last ten years?

Comment on this

The present judicial commissioner.

Comment on this

Is he being sacked or is he being retained? If he has imposed those hardships on the people, why is he being retained? Who are the others? One was a colleague of the present Attorney-General in a particular Department, and unlike the Attorney-General he did not pledge his faith before the people that he could never serve the Free State. He is doing it openly and always did so. Who are the others? Let us have the names of the nominees of the British Government, other than the judicial commissioner if he is going to be so described, and let us be told by the judicial commissioner why he is being kept on. Who are the people who are so anxious to justify this Bill before the House and who are so strangely silent on all these points? Deputy Corry does represent the mind that the Minister is going to justify and probably Deputy Cleary in a lesser degree; he can be thrown aside a little more easily. Deputy Corry has powerful lungs if he has not very much else, and he can make himself highly objectionable; not that I deny Deputy Cleary that particular talent either.

Comment on this

We can almost cry quits.

Comment on this

Not entirely. If I might parady another expression—the Deputy does that sort of thing naturally; I may do it by deliberation.

Comment on this

You will soon be going away to your job and we shall miss you.

Comment on this

Like the way you missed the point of my argument on the particular section.

Comment on this

We shall miss you.

Comment on this

I shall be sorry for that.

Comment on this

You will get your job.

Comment on this

That is the mind that the Minister has to cater for in this matter, the mind that Deputy Corry typifies—I cannot say characterises, as it is too nice a word for him. What does it mean? This is going to be somebody who hereafter is going to see that no matter how bad a farmer may be he is going to be able to make enough to pay whatever will be charged for the land.

Comment on this

Your mentality was that no matter how good he was he could not make it pay.

Comment on this

Somehow the logic of that has not gone home. That is the mentality that has to be catered for; that is what the Minister is going to stand for. Deputy Corry is the representative of the particular type of people that matter. That is why this section is in the Bill and that is why the amendment will not be accepted. They are not to be men of experience in relation to certain things that have to be decided on just and equitable lines, because you want people in who will make it easy for a farmer, no matter how bad a farmer he may be. That is the point of view that Deputy Corry represents—distinctly so. That is the whole force of his argument—that he must get payments and charges and everything else scaled down to the point that certain people will be able to make a living. The Deputy wants experience. What is the experience he wants? The experience of the man who has found it impossible himself to make a living. Does not the Deputy admit that the way he will drive his point home logically is that the worse the man was and the more difficult he found it to deal with the land in the past ten years, the better commissioner he is going to be for the future? Is not that so? Will the Deputy admit that?

Comment on this

Do you want an answer?

Comment on this

Certainly.

Comment on this

Then I will give it to you.

Comment on this

By way of interjection though—I do not want a speech: at least, not immediately.

Comment on this

My answer is this, that your Government was in office for ten years and I challenge the ex-Parliamentary Secretary for Lands and Fisheries to name one single estate, out of the hundreds of thousands of acres divided up, to which he could point and say that the division of the land was a success; that the men who got the land are able to live on it. Let him give the name of one estate. I can name 25 that were failures, at any rate, to my knowledge. Of course, as far as Deputy McGilligan is concerned, I regret that he will be going away to his job.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

That has nothing to do with the amendment.

Comment on this

The Musk Rats Bill has been passed and he will be going away to his job.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

Deputy Corry should confine himself, both in interruptions and in speeches, to the amendment and not indulge in personalities.

Comment on this

I have not got the enlightenment I wanted to get as to whether or not he wants the sort of man appointed who will make it easy for the bad type of farmer to live irrespective of anything else—that no other question of equity or justice is to be brought into the consideration except that one item.

Comment on this

I must say you are most insulting to Deputies Bennett and Holohan.

Comment on this

I do not see that I am, because if really bad farmers can make good under the conditions which Deputy Corry envisages, the appeal tribunal deciding things, Deputy Bennett will make far more. He is not going to be annoyed by conditions which will be based on the really bad farmer. Deputy Corry is pleading for a certain type of persons; he pleaded quite ably for them to-night. The whole force of his argument is that the Minister dare not accept the amendment. It would be an impediment upon him in his free choice if he had to take people of experience. That is the full force of the argument and the justification that was given here both by himself and Deputy Cleary, that the Minister must face this House, and Deputy Corry thinks of this House as being a number of people like himself. That is his mentality. These are the people the Minister has to face, according to Deputy Corry. It is quite clear what is wanted. This would be a terrific impediment upon the Minister. If the Deputy objects to the phrase used, that this is to get Fianna Fáil people placed, he has to think of the logical outcome of his own words. He will only get the hopelessly bad type of farmer put in as commissioners and you are going to get them mainly amongst the ranks of Fianna Fáil farmers. Deputy Cleary might have left it at that. He appealed to the House on the ground that the Minister was taking a grave responsibility. Deputy Corry represents the gravity of the responsibility. He is the criterion. The whole Party pivots around Deputy Corry. The backbenchers will be driving the Minister forward. The Government dare not accept an amendment such as Deputy Dillon seeks to have inserted. The whole thing lies in that particular argument that Deputy Corry so very forcibly put in his own particular way, and the Minister dare not flinch in front of Deputy Dillon. He knows that behind him is the horror of Deputy Corry, therefore the section must go through and the amendment cannot be accepted.

Comment on this

Deputy McGilligan butted into the discussion on this Land Bill and I do not know what the particular reason is. He spent a long time analysing the mentality that the Government are to try and please. One thing he cannot get away from is that the type of mentality that the Government are trying to please is not his type of mentality. There is one thing anyway that no member of this Government can be accused of doing and that is what Deputy McGilligan did—placed every member of his own family at the public expense.

Comment on this

And they have proved as inefficient as he did.

Comment on this

The one charge is about as exact as the other.

Comment on this

I have already explained the Government attitude on this and the other amendments, and I am not going to defend the honesty of the Government to the Party opposite. There is no need to defend it before the country. The people of the country realise the difference between Cumann na nGaedheal and Fianna Fáil.

Comment on this
A Deputy

They do.

Comment on this

And the people of the country made their choice and decided that they would prefer Fianna Fáil to Cumann na nGaedheal.

Comment on this

Give them another choice.

Comment on this

We will give them another choice in our own good time. There is certainly one thing to the credit of Cumann na nGaedheal, that they did not put Deputy Rice in an irremovable position. It is to their credit that they did not sink so low anyway. As I say, I have already given the Government's point of view, and I do not propose to delay the House further.

Comment on this

There were a couple of speeches which I think the Minister might have made some attempt to answer. These were the speeches of Deputies Corry and Cleary. If the Minister has such contempt for this side of the House he might at least have attempted to answer the speeches of Deputies Corry and Cleary. There was a fierce attack made by Deputy Corry on the Judicial Commissioner and on the Land Commission officials for whom the Minister is responsible. We had not one word of defence from the Minister on that particular matter. He allowed one of the members of his own Party to get up and attack the Department which he is now entrusting with the administration of this measure. He said not one word in reply to the attacks made very openly and very strongly by Deputy Corry and in a very veiled fashion by Deputy Cleary. Deputy Corry not merely was guilty of the offence once, but he repeated it. There is, therefore, no excuse for the Minister, so far as the particular attack was concerned—an attack on the Judicial Commissioner and on the whole Land Commission, their procedure, their uprightness, their competence, their ability; an attack on them, in fact, from every point of view.

There was another point which he did not answer. That is, the demand put up by Deputies Corry and Cleary as to the type of experience of the commissioner that the Minister should appoint. The Minister said it was his intention, in so far as this section gives him the power, to appoint a person of experience. It was very clearly demonstrated by Deputies Corry and Cleary as to what they meant by men of experience. I suggest that there was ample opportunity for the Minister both to defend those who were attacked by Deputies Corry and Cleary and also to let us know whether the Minister accepted Deputy Corry's and Deputy Cleary's definition, if I may call it so, of what men of experience were so far as this particular section is concerned. We know perfectly clearly now what are the views of the Fianna Fáil Party on the matter. We had them from Deputies Corry and Cleary. We know perfectly well, therefore, the pressure that is being brought to bear upon the Minister and that will be brought to bear upon him when this measure becomes an Act. We know precisely the demands that are going to be made upon the Minister, whether or not there has been discussion already upon this particular Bill in that Party. That may or may not have been the case. At any rate, we know that it has been delayed.

Comment on this

Is that the way your Party used to do it?

Comment on this

I did not catch what the Deputy said. Did you bring in the Bill without discussing it? Anyhow, we know what the demand is, and we know the type of commissioner for whose appointment pressure is going to be brought on the Minister. Perhaps the Minister may adopt the high and mighty attitude that the Government does not need to be defended from the attacks of the Cumann na nGaedheal Party, but I suggest that he might defend them from the attacks of the Fianna Fáil Party—or from the help of the Fianna Fáil Party. Which was it, I wonder? Is the Minister going to deal with the, as usual, illuminating remarks of Deputy Corry? On many occasions I have congratulated the Government, and, indeed, the country, on having Deputy Corry here, because he does blurt out six months ahead generally— what the Government are going to do. In fact, the Government seem to follow the line marked out by Deputy Corry. The Deputy need not blush. What I am saying is quite correct.

Comment on this

You are forgetting Deputy McGilligan's references to Deputy Corry's mentality or status. Which of you is to be believed?

Comment on this

If the Deputy will keep order for a moment I shall satisfy him. I was simply saying that the Government follow Deputy Corry's line. That is not a compliment to him. All I say now is that there was an opportunity for the Minister to make the matter quite clear. He chose not to do so. We must take it, therefore, that the Government accepts the point of view of its two outspoken spokesmen from the back benches.

Comment on this

I have been accused here, first of all, of an attack on the Land Commission, which I deny.

Comment on this

Which I deny! Secondly, I have been accused of pointing out a special type of commissioner, which Deputy McGilligan translated into meaning the type of commissioner who would fix the rent of a farm so that the worst possible type of farmer would live in it. I said that I would far rather have—and I am sure the tenants would far rather—have a commissioner of the type of Deputy Holohan, who is a farmer, or of Deputy Bennett, who is also a farmer and knows the value of land.

Comment on this

Are you going to get a job for me?

Comment on this

At any rate, you would have a greater right to it than the district justice with the 351 acres. I issue a challenge to Deputy Roddy with regard to the division of land. They say they put the best type into it. They put in the present secretary of the A.C.A. He got a gratuity of £800 on leaving the Army and a pension of £80 or £90 a year, and yet he was not able to keep the land at the price. Undoubtedly the district justice might be able to keep his place with the £1,000 a year he got. He might be able to hang on to the 351 acres he got.

Comment on this

He did not get it from the Land Commission.

Comment on this

I have been challenging Deputy Roddy since 1929 to deny it and he had not the pluck to deny it when Deputy Hassett was still a member of the Dáil. The statement was made and it was repeated on several occasions since.

Comment on this

And answered.

Comment on this

No, it was not. Those are the people who got the land and I would like to know from Deputy Roddy why these pensioners with £80, £90 and £100 a year were not able to keep the pieces of land they got. Was it not because of the impossible annuity which they found they had to pay? Here is a man who got his slice of it—Commandant Cronin. I do not know whether he got in as a congest or as a landless man. He had £800 of a gratuity on leaving the Army. He had £80 or £90 a year of a pension. He got a present of this farm and could not live on it because of the annuities clapped on. I saw another congest moved up from West Cork. He got 110 acres and he got £170 going into it. He held it for seven years and was put into jail out of it in 1931 owing five years' annuities out of the seven. They are the men who got the land. We are told about the bad farmers who are going to get the land by Deputy McGilligan—an authority on farming, no doubt! Those are the gentlemen who got the land under the Cumann na nGaedheal Government— the Army pensioners with £800 or £900 or £1,000 in their pockets and their yearly pensions. Surely to goodness, if they could not live on it, how could an ordinary farmer live on it under the price that was fixed when it was finished out at the Appeal Court? I had experience of the Land Commission Court.

I move to report progress.

Comment on this