Land Bill, 1933—Committee (Resumed—Amendment 14).
Contributions 177–352 of 352. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
No. 33 of 1933 ›
The future of this State is in the hands of the Fianna Fáil Party at present. I have no responsibility for Fianna Fáil policy. As far I can judge the Fianna Fáil Government are going to do even more detriment to the country than that. If the Deputy wants me to suggest a policy for them, the best policy I can suggest to them would be to resign and make way for a Government that would not lead the country into the bog into which they are leading it. I think this country can stand very little more of Fianna Fáil policy. We are doing our best to save the country some of the most disastrous results of the Fianna Fáil policy, but we are having a hard time, and our very best endeavours cannot protect the country very much longer. I am providing the means by this amendment to enable the Fianna Fáil Party to give effect to their second thoughts. I trust that as they must have at last begun to realise the distress and injustice that the unfortunate results of their policy are bringing upon the country, they will accept my amendment. When I have brought the Fianna Fáil Party that far I trust they will go further. When I have got them to that extent, perhaps I could persuade them to go a step further. If I could make a match between them and commonsense it would be a good thing for the country. If I could marry the Fianna Fáil Party to commonsense I would be entitled to retire from public life as one of the greatest men in Irish public life. I think it may be clear to the Minister what the purpose of this amendment is and why I put it down. Whether it was quite so clear before I elaborated by amendment is another question. I am quite content to have the decision on this amendment taken on all the analogous amendments which stand in my name.
Comment on this
I said that the effect of Deputy Dillon's amendment would be to prevent the Government funding any of the arrears. I also said that this amendment would prevent the Government halving the future annuities, but that is not the effect of this particular amendment.
Comment on this
I withdrew too hastily my accusation against Deputy Dillon that the passing of this amendment would prevent the Government halving the annuities. We can discuss the economic war or anything you like on this Bill, but I think all the country is concerned with is and what we should confine ourselves to is whether or not this section is to carry out the Government's intentions. The Government are forgiving all arrears over three years in the annuities. I think in doing that they are doing a good thing. They are giving an opportunity to people who got into several years' arrears and giving them a chance of finding their feet. A similar chance was given in all Land Acts. That chance was given to those heavily in arrears. Three years was mentioned in the 1923 Land Act. There are some people who are going to be forgiven arrears, and if we could prevent it in the ordinary way without doing more harm, I would like to see them being called upon to pay up. But for one waster who should be made pay up there are 100 or 200 people who got into arrears through no fault of their own. It would be impossible for the Land Commission to adjudicate between the two. We are forgiving all the arrears over three years so that in future no tenant paying his debts will have to pay more than 65 per cent. of his old annuity. That is to say, half the annuity plus the funding of those arrears will not amount to more than 65 per cent. roughly of the annuity he paid formerly. If we were to fund the arrears or to collect the arrears on this 50 per cent basis and to include all the arrears we would find that the annuitants would be called upon to pay a sum which would be in some cases more than the rent which they failed to pay formerly. The Government made no promise whatsoever at any time that the annuities due in the second gale of last year and the first gale of this year would not be collected. However, we are making their collection easy by extending the payment over a period of 50 years. It will come to only 6d. or 1/- in the £ per year, on the arrears due up to three years. I think this is a fair proposal. The effect of Deputy Dillon's amendment, if carried, would be to prevent the Government funding the arrears, and therefore to put on them the duty of collecting those arrears in some way, not through a funding proposal.
Comment on this
I have to correct the Minister on that point. My amendment would not put on the Government any duty at all. It would simply dispose of the proposal that arrears, where due by persons who fell into arrear during the last three years, should be funded at all. There would arise, in the event of the Minister accepting that proposal, consideration of the question as to how those arrears should be dealt with, and consequential suggestions would be made. The issue clearly raised there is the justice of collecting arrears from persons who fell into arrear as a result of the economic war. If you admit the justice——
Comment on this
The sum of money which was in arrear in 1930, under the pre-1923 Acts, was £336,338. That closely approximates to the sum which the Government proposes to write off —the arrears which they do not propose to collect. Those arrears are not the property of the Government; they are not the property of the Land Commission. The Land Commission is in the position of an agent only, and whatever arrears are being forgiven are being forgiven at the expense of the local authorities, who voluntarily made good any deficiencies there were in the collections during the last ten years. What the Government is doing in this case is telling the local authorities that they cannot collect and need never expect that £250,000 which they are wiping off. The collections which were made during the years previous to that had been very good. There had been more money collected than the ordinary annual liability on the Land Commission annuities. Some £642,000 was outstanding in 1923, when this State took over the Land Commission. In 1930 the sum outstanding was £336,338 for the pre-1923 Land Acts. When the Minister states that they are forgiving £250,000, that amounts to saying to the local authorities: "You cannot collect and you need never expect that £250,000"; but there is more in it than that, in so far as it is proposed here to collect the arrears and in so far as the Bill is constructed at the present moment the local authorities have provided over £600,000 of uncollected annuities up to the 31st March, 1932. The Government is presenting that money to the Land Commission, although the local authorities have already made it good.
Members probably know—with the exception of the Deputies who came in at the last general election and who had not previously been members of the House—that the provisions in respect of the funding clauses of the Land Acts secure or endeavoured to secure that the State is at no loss in connection with whatever deficiency might arise in connection with the Land Purchase Fund. The Land Purchase Fund is supposed to fill on the 31st January, and I presume at a corresponding date in July, but not necessarily. Normally it must fill on the 31st January each year, and there must be in that fund in respect of the Land Acts previous to the Land Act of 1923 a sufficient sum to discharge the obligations—£2,900,000 odd. If that sum of money is not in the Land Purchase Fund it must be made good from the Guarantee Fund. The Guarantee Fund, in turn, is fed from the Agricultural Grant and other moneys made available by this House for the relief of rates on agricultural land. The sum so far made good out of that fund is over £600,000. The Government proposes to collect that £600,000, and to pocket it, or to put it into the Land Commission to use it for any purpose they wish. In so far as they do not do that, in so far as they wipe off £250,000, the local authorities are being told that they are not going to get that sum in those circumstances.
There is a good case for the amendment that has been proposed by Deputy Dillon, apart altogether from the question that the people who did not pay when 90 per cent. of the Land Commission annuitants were called upon to pay are not now in a position to pay any funded arrears in the much more difficult times we have at the present moment. If it be conceded that it is an act of justice or discrimination or genius or wisdom or anything else to wipe off £250,000 which cannot be collected now, arising out of the year 1930, or coming along from any previous years, how in the name of commonsense is it going to be collected now when the profits of agriculture are nothing to be compared with what they were at that time? Not alone that, but any arrears that accrue in the meantime are to be added, with costs and expenses. The Minister told us here the other day that in one case where the annuity amounted to 16/3, the costs were 19/11; 19/11 on three years at 16/3 equals £2 8s. 9d. I do not know whether two particular years were free of costs, but supposing there was only one set of costs at 19/11, it means that £3 8s. 8d. is going to be funded in this particular case. I do not know whether the 4½ per cent. arises in this connection or in another. It is being charged at 4½ per cent., and for months past we have been listening to statements made by Ministers that they were in a position to borrow money far cheaper than we did. That arises out of no virtue of theirs; it arises from no act or series of acts of theirs; it is not by reason of the policy of the Government that that is the case. It is by reason of the fact that money is cheaper now than it has been practically in living memory, certainly not since 1894. At a time when money is at its cheapest, and having boasted of having borrowed on short-term bills at 2½ per cent., the Government is going to charge those unfortunate people, for whom they profess considerable sympathy, two and a quarter times the percentage that they themselves were charged by the banks a short time ago. There are two very strong reasons for objecting to this. In the first place nobody here can make the case that if a man were unable to pay his annuity during the last 12 months he can afford to pay it in the future. Having regard to the statements we have heard from the Government Benches within the last week or fortnight that the present economic conflict is to continue, is it likely that he will be able to pay half the annuity plus whatever arrears may be funded at 4½ per cent. plus the costs?
Comment on this
I think it would be a pity to let those particular sections pass without at least some comment in an effort to make them somewhat clear. I daresay they will be passed, but I do not believe they will last. I do not believe that that scheme could possibly last. There is more immorality concentrated in these two sections than in any other sections of any Bill ever introduced in this Dáil.
Comment on this
Nos. 12 and 13, or we will confine ourselves to 12; there is enough in that.
Comment on this
Yes, we are discussing your amendment, and immorality. What does this amendment come to? The arrears up to 1930 are to be forgiven, and after 1930 and up to 1933 they are to be funded at 5 per cent. The years 1926, 1927, 1928 and 1929 were all good years. In any one of them a man could pay his annuity, unless he met with misfortune. Cattle were 50/- a cwt. in some of those years. Everything the farmer had to sell was at least 75 per cent. dearer than now. During those years most of what he had to buy was cheaper—flour, Indian meal, everything he had to buy. On the other hand, lambs were 47/6, 50/-, or thereabouts; they are now 12/-. Even Deputy Smith knows that much.
Comment on this
Pigs in those years were not less than 80/- a cwt. live-weight. Deputy Smith is getting serious now. Pigs were actually 80/- live weight in those years, and Indian meal could be bought during some of those years at £5 a ton.
Comment on this
Exactly, without any sawdust in it. It was under those conditions that the farmers were operating then, and it was under those conditions that those arrears were contracted— the arrears which are now to be forgiven. Those arrears, contracted under those circumstances, are to be wiped out. In those times the ordinary Galway farmer could pay not only his annuity but his rates out of his lands. He did pay his annuity out of his lands, for he was an honest man, and his rates as well; which rates were lower then. He paid them out of his lands alone, apart altogether from his cattle and pigs. He was able to do it and he did it. The same thing applied in every other county in Ireland. The men who did not do it, the men who put that money in their pockets in those times or allowed their sons and daughters to spend it foolishly, or spent it foolishly themselves, are now going to be forgiven. Honestly, it is a shameful proposal.
Comment on this
Absolutely. That attempt to establish an analogy between an annuity and a rent is exactly the attempt which President de Valera made three or four years ago.
Comment on this
As that point has been raised, I remember the time when people used to say to us: "Look here! If you go on advocating those measures which you are advocating the time will come when people will not pay their annuities." That was said in 1920, but it was also said before that. It was said in the British House of Commons any time between 1880 and 1900, as Deputy Dillon knows well. Before those Acts were passed the English Government and the English credit that was being put behind all land purchase had those critics. There were plenty of people in the English House of Commons who got up and said: "The Irish will not pay anything. They will not pay rent; they will not pay annuities." The ordinary members of the Irish Party and the leaders of the Irish Party said: "No. The Irish people are capable of distinguishing and discriminating. They realise that money lent must be paid back, if lent on reasonable terms." They absolutely refused to agree with the suggestion that there is any analogy between rents established in the old days and annuities established under new Acts. Anybody who talked in that fashion in the House of Commons was told that he was defaming the Irish people, and so he was because, as Deputies know, they paid up in those days. That was before Mr. O'Donnell started his game in connection with the land annuities. The general commonsense and financial morality of the country did realise the distinction, and did realise that annuities and interest at 3 per cent. on money lent was in a totally different category, and that anybody who attempted to make a distinction between interest repayable on money lent, and old rents in the way we knew them, would be an enemy of the country.
All that is changed now. It is patriotism in comparison with what the British talked about 20 years ago, when they said that the Irish were incapable of discrimination, and that the agitation against landlordism in this country was dishonest because, they said, the same thing will be done again when it comes to ordinary financial obligations. They are being proved to be right now. Here in the year 1933 we have patriots on the benches opposite making exactly the case that was put into their mouths by anticipation 20 years ago in the British House of Commons. Of course, most of these people opposite have no national tradition and do not understand what they are doing. That is the real trouble. But that is a digression due to Deputy Smith's attempt to establish an analogy between rent and annuities. What has happened now? The rotter or waster who did not pay his annuities in 1928 or 1929 is to be let off free. He is in a glorious position, because, remember the honest man who is penalised here has already paid his annuities which are now being funded. If you analyse this section it is a priceless piece of legislation. Not only does the laggard and the waster, who failed in 1928 and 1929 to pay his annuities, be let off, for he might have paid these annuities at that time, when he failed to pay them, but his annuities are now to be paid by the honest farmer who himself only failed to pay when his land became profitless and when his production had to be sold at tremendous loss. Not only has that man now to pay the annuities since 1931 and 1932, and which accrued during those catastrophic times, but that man has to a great extent to pay the annuities of the gentleman who did not pay in the years 1928 and 1929, when he could have paid. For instance, we find now that AB, who is a hard-working farmer, and who while times were good paid his annuities, and in his rates paid his neighbour's annuities, because he was too lazy to pay them himself, has now to pay that man's annuities as well, which that man did not pay because he was too lazy to work. There may, of course, be exceptions amongst those who could have paid their annuities at that time and did not pay, but, generally, the position is as I have stated. The honest man paid his annuities all the time, and paid those of his neighbour who refused to pay.
Now when it comes to the year 1931, the honest farmer, no more than anyone else, cannot pay. No one can pay his annuities. It is no use to say that they are only called upon to pay one-half. We cannot get half the price for our produce at the present time. It is no use to say only half the annuities will have to be paid. The farmers are now forced to pay all these annuities, at 4½ or 5 per cent. interest, whereas the gentleman who did not pay in 1928 and 1929 will get off free. This is a disgraceful section. It will get through, no doubt, but all the same, I do not think the Government will get away with it. I do not think it possible in any country that so sinister a section as that could last. You will not be able to collect these annuities. No doubt you will collect them from some people. Deputies know the people from whom they can collect. I know people who will pay because they work like slaves; they do not give in easily; they always try to pay their way. You will make that few pay up. But do you think that you will make the general run of people pay? I say you cannot do it, because the money is not there. You cannot collect it. There is not a single farmer in this country who is farming in the average way, producing live stock, and live stock produce, who is in a position to pay out of the profits of his land. There are farmers who have other ways of living—shops, professions, and so on. They will pay. But there is not a single farmer living on the land who is able to make his annuities out of it. A young farmer whose father and mother are living with him and drawing 10/- a week each in pensions may pay. A farmer whose sons are getting 26/- a week on the road, at the expense of the working farmers, may be able to pay. But taking the general run of farmers, you will not be able to collect the half annuities, and this section will, therefore, not be operative.
There is no doubt whatever that Deputy Dillon's point in regard to the man who has to pay the funded annuities is absolutely sound. That man has paid already, not only his own annuities, but he has helped to pay his neighbours' annuities. He has paid in the reduced price he is getting for his stock. Mr. J.H. Thomas, the British Dominions Secretary, has collected a lot of it. These men have paid 100 per cent. in that way of the annuities that are to be funded at 5 per cent. I do not care what majority you may have for this section. You will find in the end it will never work.
Comment on this
Most of us here, enjoy listening to Deputy Hogan. I remember when we were in Opposition and he occupied a seat on the Government benches on this side of the House, he used to irritate me very much. I could barely sit and listen to him. But now the position is changed, and I would rather listen to Deputy Hogan now than attend a concert. Deputy Hogan referred to our attitude in regard to the matter of wiping out arrears, and he says we are legislating for the rotter and the weakling, and the man who will pay nothing. He was a member of the Executive Council for ten years, and in many matters in relation to legislation passing through this House, he legislated for the rotter and the weakling and the man who would not pay his rent.
Comment on this
I am trying to make my own case. Deputy Dillon had his own say, and he should try to keep his mouth shut now for a while. I was saying that Deputy Hogan had referred to the way that we proposed to treat that type of farmer. In every piece of legislation introduced here by his Party, they put a premium on laziness. The man who did not work his farm got 10/- a week, the man who did not pay his rates, got likewise; and the man who did not pay his annuities was treated in the same way. That is the Deputy who now says that we are the people who are establishing a precedent in this way by our proposals in connection with the wiping out of certain arrears. He tried to make a point against me for saying that there is no substantial difference between arrears of rent and annuities. But while there may be a substantial difference between arrears of rent and arrears of annuities, does it not all boil down to this, that the man who has eight years arrears against him, whether they be in the shape of rent or annuities, and who is not likely to be able to meet them in actual practice, is in the same position whether you call the arrears, arrears of rent or of annuities?
Comment on this
Deputy Hogan also referred to the man who works his farm and has been industrious and said that he has also paid the annuities or rent of the waster for whom now, for the first time in his life, he has so much contempt. Surely that is a matter in which the local authority must be interested, and in which every farmer who is working his land must be interested. This contribution to which Deputy Hogan has referred must be a matter of importance to them. It must be a matter of importance to them also to know that every man who was in arrears in the payment of his annuities or his rent will have these arrears wiped out and will be given a new start on a more or less clear footing. We know Deputy Hogan exaggerates when he says that every man was a rotter and a weakling who fell into arrears.
Comment on this
I said nothing of the kind. I said there were exceptions.
Comment on this
You said there were exceptions, but you said the majority of them were of that class. I do not think the Deputy had any right to say that. The Minister admitted there were certain types of individuals that it was not desirable to forgive arrears, but it was impossible to select them and distinguish them from those in regard to whom it is desirable to take this course. I gave an instance where the Party opposite, when they were in power, penalised the industrious and energetic small farmer who worked his land, painted his doors, and got his house thatched, by not giving him his old age pension. These are the people now who talk of the immorality of Sections 12 and 13 of this Bill. I say the proposal contained in Section 12 of this Bill is a reasonable proposal. We are always inflicting some injustice on those who work and always pay. But even if you inflict that injustice in the interests of the people generally, it must be admitted that they are still better off than the man answering to the description which Deputy Hogan gave. I say this section is a perfectly reasonable one, and is less entitled to be criticised from the point of view that it was criticised by Deputy Hogan and other Deputies than any other part of the Bill.
Comment on this
Let us examine the reasonableness of this section. As a matter of fact, I myself have put down many amendments to this section, but they were ruled out. I am not cavilling at the ruling of the Chair, because the Chair ruled them out of order on the ground that if my amendments were carried they would impose a charge upon the public funds. Lest there might be any misunderstanding about it, I want to say that it is not impossible to have those amendments put in. If the Government want to insert them, they know they can do so. If the Government want to impose a charge on public funds, they can do it. I know some Deputies in the Government Party have an idea that because these amendments are now ruled out it is not possible to have them reintroduced. That is not the position, and if the Government want to insert the amendments they can easily do so.
Let us examine sub-section (2). Is it reasonable to ask any man to pay the same debt twice over? Is not that what sub-section (2) asks? The Government proposal is to fund the second gale of 1932 and the first gale of 1933. The British Government have collected the annuities at their ports; the annuitants have paid them. People in this country have suffered considerable loss in relation to agricultural produce by reason of the depression at home. If the Government are to fund any arrears the amounts involved in the second gale of 1932 and the first gale of 1933 are the amounts that should be funded, because the people have already paid them over to Britain.
Comment on this
What I meant to convey was that if any arrears are to be forgiven, the amounts involved in the second gale of 1932 and the first gale of 1933 should be forgiven. Deputy Smith says the whole thing is quite reasonable, and Deputy Corry tells us he agrees with every section of the Bill. Does Deputy Corry agree that when the tenant farmers have already paid the second gale of 1932 and the first gale of 1933 to Britain they ought to be asked to pay it all, or even half of it, to this Government? Will Deputy Smith agree with this?
As soon as may be after the passing of this Act, the Land Commission shall ascertain the amount of the arrears of every purchase annuity to which this section applies which were due and owing on the 15th day of July, 1933, and the amount of the costs and expenses (if any) incurred....
Is Deputy Smith convinced that that is a reasonable thing for the Government to demand, after instructing the State Solicitors all over the country to institute proceedings and then to withdraw them? By so withdrawing them they admitted they were wrong.
Comment on this
Why then did they not continue to institute proceedings? After admitting they were wrong in instituting proceedings, they are now going to fund the costs against the unfortunate annuitants. We have all this coming on top of the people as distinct from the hardships they are suffering by reason of the economic war. Is there any sense at all in the Government's attitude? By the abandonment of the legal proceedings the Government admitted that the people were not able to pay. They said in effect: "We will not ask them to pay." Some people say that the reason the Government did not institute proceedings was because they were looking for support in the general election. It looks rather suspicious now that having abandoned legal proceedings, they now propose funding moneys that have already been paid over to Britain. The plain fact is that our Government abandoned the collection of the money. In the circumstances, is it fair that they should now fund those arrears?
The most glaring injustice is the funding of the costs and expenses incurred in the attempt to collect those annuities. What did the Minister for Justice say on this question a few days ago? I would like Deputy Smith and Deputy Corry to give us their opinions on this matter. The Minister for Justice said:—
"I will give an example of the costs that are incurred. A man owed one year's arrears to the extent of 16/1. The costs amounted to 11/-, drawing the certificate 2/-, lodgment fees 7/-, making a total of £1 16/1. That is to recover 16/- the unfortunate man had to pay 19/11 in addition to the 16/- that was the ordinary proper legal cost. (Vol. 48, col. 2435, Parliamentary Debates).
Comment on this
The lawyer got none of it; that is the peculiarity of the whole case. According to the Minister, the lawyers got none of it; the State solicitors did not get the costs; they were irrecoverable. We have no evidence that there is machinery in operation whereby the Minister can pay the State solicitors' costs in cases like that where they are really irrecoverable. I understand the Minister stated here yesterday that he does propose paying the solicitors those costs and he proposes to fund the cost in the case of the unfortunate people against whom proceedings were taken. I do not think there could be a more glaring injustice than that. Deputy Corry, speaking on the 18th July, said:—
"I remember seeing unfortunate tenants in my constituency decreed by the Land Commission repeatedly —decreed for what annuities? For annuities that were 10 per cent. and 15 per cent. higher than the rent they had been paying to the landlord." (Vol. 49, col. 111, Parliamentary Debates).
Those are the annuities and costs that Deputy Corry says ought to be funded against the people who paid them to the British Government last year or the year before. Deputy Corry thinks it is a proper thing to charge all this up to the people at 4½ per cent. Personally, I think the proposal to fund the last gale of 1932 and the first gale of 1933 is absolutely immoral. The funding of the costs and expenses is immoral. I do not think there is a precedent for it in any part of the world. If there are people in this country unable to pay the annuities that were due in 1930 and 1931 or previous to that, I wonder how does the Minister expect they will be able to pay even half their annuities in the future? Conditions in the country are certainly deplorable. We have increasing rates, falling markets, diminishing exports and we have an increase in home help. Within the last year the people on public charity increased by 33,000.
Comment on this
Of course it is. Our resources are fast dwindling away, but of course the Government does not see that; their eyes are closed to that. How do they expect the people to continue? We are drawing on our resources at the present moment just the same as if a man were drawing on whatever money he might have in the bank. Just imagine if you were to withdraw the old age pensions, the grants, the bounties and the subsidies, what would you then have in this country? Would you have anybody who would be able to continue? That is evidence that we are absolutely living on our resources. I agree with Deputy Dillon that the Minister ought to withdraw those sections and replace them with something that would be in accordance with morality and justice and in accordance with the people's ability to pay. I protest against the inclusion of a section of this kind.
Comment on this
It seems to me ridiculous and absolutely wrong to have the costs in connection with land annuity decrees funded. Deputy Corry spoke here recently and his whole speech was against the costs which lawyers impose. This Bill proposed by Fianna Fáil proposes to make the farmers pay these costs.
Comment on this
It is absolutely wrong, but the Deputy tells us it is going to be for the last time.
Comment on this
Now let us come to the question of funding the arrears. If there is any justification for funding arrears there is certainly justification for suggesting that the arrears that accrued this year and last year should be the first to be wiped out altogether. Does Deputy Corry agree with that?
Comment on this
I know that honest, hardworking farmers were able to pay their annuities until Fianna Fáil came into power and started this economic war. I hold that under the present circumstances arrears are not due either legally or morally because we have already paid them to the British Government by way of tariffs on cattle. I know there is absolutely no chance of getting arrears which have accrued longer than three years. I know well too who owes them—all the wasters in the country, and they are supporters of the Fianna Fáil Party in my district anyway. You might as well have it straight out. That is the reason you are anxious to forgive them.
Comment on this
Deputies ought to have learned by now that every member of the Dáil is entitled to express himself without interruption. Deputy Curran is entitled to make his speech in his own way and he should not be interrupted. Other Deputies may reply to every statement Deputy Curran makes, if they have any desire to do so.
Comment on this
Deputy Curran charges people outside the House with being rotters, rogues and robbers, because they do not pay annuities.
Comment on this
I could make some references as to how supporters of the Deputy's Party stand in that respect.
Comment on this
I think Deputies ought not to be so thin-skinned in matters of this sort. Statements are made from every side of the House regarding the political supporters of every Party, and Deputies must not stand up to defend them every time statements of that kind are made. Deputy Smith will have an opportunity of saying what he wants to say when Deputy Curran is finished.
Comment on this
I so very seldom stand up to say anything here in this House that I really thought I would get a better hearing. I wonder on whose corns I trod? As as a rule, I do not tread on anybody's corns. However, I am saying what I know to be a fact in connection with this problem of funding arrears, and I say again—and I am sure that any reasonable man will agree with me—that if any arrears are to be wiped out, the arrears accruing in 1932 and 1933 should have first consideration. These are the first that should be wiped out, and Deputies know it well. I have sympathy for farmers who cannot pay, and I know some hard-working farmers who cannot pay. Even if they are supporters of Fianna Fáil, what is wrong about that? I know some genuine cases.
Comment on this
If the Deputy would only listen to reason! I never like to be personal. I am stating what I know to be a fact. I know farmers who have not been able to pay the last rates that were due. I know cases where they have been brought to court in connection with it, and I know of cases where they got facilities from the rate collector in connection with their rates. How will these people be expected to pay annuities? They certainly will not be able to pay them, and they will be in the same position in which a good many people were before, and that is that they will not be able to pay. I appeal to the Minister and to the Fianna Fáil Party to look at this thing from a reasonable point of view. I think they should agree, and I hope the Minister will agree, that the annuities which should be remitted altogether are the annuities which accrued in 1932 and 1933. They should have the first consideration because, as other Deputies have said, these annuities have been paid by the farmers already. As regards arrears of annuities due prior to those years, what responsibility is on the Government at all, or on any fund in connection with these arrears? They have been paid by the ratepayers of every county, and well the Fianna Fáil Party knows it, and well the Minister knows it too. Any deduction or remission in connection with the annuities was paid or made good by the ratepayers through the grants. They were deducted from the estate duty grant and from the agricultural grant. Any arrears that were due in the past had to be made good by the ratepayers. These are the ratepayers and the farmers against whom you now want to turn around and charge up costs and to whom you do not want to give any remission in connection with any arrears that have accrued.
As a last word, I appeal to the Minister to be reasonable in this case and to agree that the first annuities that should be remitted altogether are the annuities for this year and last year. I do not think that anybody can cavil at that. As regards the other annuities, they must be wiped out, whether anybody likes it or not. They cannot be collected. They are not there to be collected, and there is no good thinking about them.
Comment on this
I do not see any objection to the section whatsoever. I think it is a most essential section because I think it is better to put people in a position to be able to pay something than to leave them in such a way as not to be able to pay anything, which has been the case up to the present. Deputy Curran made a reference to the funding of costs. We have no responsibility for the incurring of those costs or for the system under which the costs were incurred, and it is now proposed under this Bill to end that system.
Comment on this
That is a different matter. With regard to Deputy Hogan's previous point. He made a reference to the fat years of 1926, 1927, 1928 and 1929.
Comment on this
I deny that. I should like to bring Deputies' memories back to 1926, when that disease called fluke came in and killed the cattle of this country wholesale. Instead of the then Government coming to the aid of the farmers they swept away whatever cattle they had left. I think that the Cumann na nGaedheal Government would have been well advised at that time if they had introduced some such measure as this instead of sweeping away whatever cattle the farmers had. I think this is a very wise section—this section by which it is proposed to cancel the arrears—because, if the situation were allowed to continue as it is, there would be a further burden placed on the people who are trying to pay. I submit to the House that in this section we are covering casualties that were incurred, to a great extent, during the Cumann na nGaedheal régime.
Comment on this
I have two or three points to make. The first is to repeat what Deputy Curran said, that there is no justification whatever for collecting any annuities from tenants for the greater part of 1932 and all of 1933 so far. The tenants have paid their annuities more than double, to put it at the least, and they should not be called upon to pay anything further. There is only one other thing to which I should like to refer relating to this section, and that is the forgiving of the arrears beyond three years to certain people. I do not think any Deputy would argue against the forgiveness of arrears to certain people— people who cannot pay, or who find it difficult to pay. There will be others who could have paid. We would not cavil at any tenant farmer being forgiven anything if the cost did not fall upon other people who made efforts to pay and who did pay their own arrears and, incidentally, had to pay his. The Minister is going to forgive these annuities. I think that is the wrong word, because he is forgiving what is not his to forgive. This is the ratepayers' money and it is due to them. If the Minister is in this forgiving spirit, I suggest that he should provide some way in this Bill by which this money that is being forgiven will go back to the people who have already paid it—the ratepayers of this State and the tenant farmers who are now being called upon to pay rents or annuities which they have already paid themselves, as well as the annuities of the defaulter who is being forgiven here, which they have contributed to in their rates. Personally, I have no objection to any tenant farmer being forgiven his arrears. In fact, I would argue as far as I could that he should be forgiven; but if the Minister is forgiving these we should make some provision in the Bill to see that somebody else besides the ratepayer will be asked to foot the Bill and that the money the ratepayers contributed to pay these arrears must be in some way refunded to them.
Comment on this
First of all, we had Deputy Hogan's argument. He told us there was a very substantial difference between rents and annuities. Yes, there is; and some of the unfortunate tenants know it to their cost. The tenant, who was paying £15 a year rent from 1919 until Deputy Hogan blessed him in 1923 and increased his annunity by 15 per cent., knows it. I suppose the unfortunate tenant did not care very much whether it was annuity or rent or rates he was paying. All he knew was that he had to pay £2 extra.
Deputy Brennan alluded to his case a while ago, but Deputy Brennan was one of the Deputies who, when there was an amending Act brought in here to remedy that case, walked into the Division Lobby in favour of letting that dirty landlord get away with that loot. He was one of the Deputies who did it. So was Deputy Roddy, who led the van. The tenant who was paying £12 from 1919 to 1923, who went up before a final tribunal and was there told that until his land was vested he would only have to pay £9 but that on the day it was vested he would have to pay £13, or the unfortunate tenant who got a reduction in 1919 and enjoyed that reduction to 1923 and who then, under the blessings of the Hogan Act, had to pay 15 per cent. more and to pay up his arrears and all the rest of it—those poor fellows came in here looking for justice. They went first to the famous tribunal for justice and got kicked out there. Then they came in here and every Deputy on those benches opposite, and the scattered members of the Farmers' Party who are still left to us, marched into the Lobby here in favour of compelling the unfortunate tenant to hand that money over to the rack-renting landlord who had admitted in 1919 and 1920 that it was 40 per cent. too high. Those tenants have been paying it for the last ten years and those are the unfortunate tenants of whom Deputy Hogan now stands up here and says with his usual sarcasm that they are lazy, they are robbers and thieves and they would not pay their annuities. It would be hard for them to pay them. That is the mercy Deputy Hogan had for them.
Another argument that has been made here is that, if anybody is to be forgiven arrears, those who owed last year's annuities or the year's before should be given first consideration. I do not agree with that, and I will tell the House why. Take those tenants who came up here before the Land Commission Court and who fought their case here to get a 15 per cent. reduction in their rent. They would chance putting five or six years' rent into the pockets of the lawyers. They chanced it. They would chance it again before the appeal tribunal and would have to pay the lawyers' fees and the refresher to which my friend Deputy Belton alluded a while ago. They had to pay all that. They chanced that for a 15 per cent. reduction.
Comment on this
The farmers of this country are making a big fight. They gave us a mandate to make the fight for them.
Comment on this
We are doing it well, but if we had not so many judges we would do a lot better. Even if they have to pay a little extra bit now, even with that burden upon them, I say it is well worth it. They had to face a lot more to get very small concessions in the past. Now they are getting a 50 per cent. concession. We hear a lot of talk about democracy and all that, but we should remember that the value of the farmers' produce was reduced from 1924 to 1931 by £13,000,000. That represents the fall in the prices they suffered between 1924 and 1931, and yet Deputy Cosgrave says they must pay their debts. When he was asked for relief what did he say: that "agriculture is a decaying industry and where is the use of bolstering up a decaying industry?" These were the famous words used by Deputy Cosgrave.
Comment on this
The Deputy might give me the reference. I have no recollection of saying that good, bad or indifferent.
Comment on this
I thought the Deputy knew them so well that I would not have to give the reference, but I will get it for him.
Comment on this
I have not at the moment. I usually come prepared, but I did not think you would deny it.
Comment on this
I will give it to you before I go back; you may be sure of that. You told a deputation that it was a decaying industry and there was no use in bolstering it up.
Comment on this
I take very good care that any statement I make in the House I am able to support. The truth is bitter.
Comment on this
Would the Deputy state to what deputation, in what year or what month I made the statement?
Comment on this
Dang it, I was not with you. That is the kind of thing we get, you know, and the facts bear it out. We got £13,000,000 less for our produce in 1931 than we got in 1924. We were unable to pay the annuities then. We found it very hard to pay the annuities but we got no relief from Deputy Cosgrave. All he was troubled about then was to see that the rack-renting landlord got enough going away, to see that he got loot for Monte Carlo. He did not care what happened the tenants. Nothing amuses me as much as Deputy Hogan's talk about the difference between rent and annuities. These unfortunate fellows found it when they had to pay 15 per cent. more in annuities than they had to pay in rents.
There are some matters here on which I find myself in certain agreement with Deputies who have already spoken. I honestly do not think that the lawyers' costs should be charged, but admittedly some of the rogues get away with it. For instance, there was a case tried in the Cork Circuit Court recently in which a father-in-law sued his son-in-law for certain moneys.
Comment on this
I am going to allow the Deputy to proceed as far as I think he should. Is he going to refer to a decision given by the courts regarding costs?
Comment on this
Has the case any reference to proceedings regarding rent? I have warned the Deputy that he will have to be very careful.
Comment on this
Very decidedly. Portion of the money claimed was for a half year's annuity which the father-in-law alleged he had to pay for the son-in-law. The son-in-law stood up in court and swore that there was no occasion whatever for that, that the father-in-law had no right to pay. He said that he could have paid it himself, "but," he added, "my organisation advised me not to pay it and that is why I did not pay it." That is a statement that was sworn to by a tenant farmer in Cork within the last three months, that his organisation had advised him not to pay his land annuities.
Comment on this
They have not. This was an organisation in West Cork. You know the West Cork fellows were always fighting that way. You should know that. That is a fact and that is why I am very slow to advocate that they should be relieved of costs. I am very slow in advocating that members of organisations who conspired together not to pay their annuities, and who incurred costs on account of it, should now be freed of these costs.
Comment on this
Did not you tell them at the Cork County Council that they had them in their pockets and to keep them there? Will you deny that?
Comment on this
I denied that statement when it was made before in this House and I deny it now. It is only what one would expect from a paper that has been subsidised——
Comment on this
I am not responsible for what appears in the Cork Examiner, or I could never be responsible for it.
Comment on this
I cannot understand you. You will want to get another accent. As regards the tenants who are being relieved of their arrears, tenants who owe more than three years' annuities, there is no tenant farmer in the Free State to-day who is not anxious to see those unfortunate tenants at least getting a chance of getting on their feet again. There may be an odd, lazy fellow like the rogue who would not pay his land annuities a while ago, but the vast majority are men who have worked hard and who did their best but who, through no fault of their own, found themselves unable to pay. There are a large number of them in that position. What was the Cumann na nGaedheal cure for them? Leave the farms derelict with no rates and no annuities out of them. They were thrown there with the fences falling all round them. That was the only cure for them, and we have them dotted like leper's sores here and there throughout every county in the Free State. The tenant who had so many years arrears was thrown out and the land was left derelict. Give these unfortunate fellows a chance of getting back on their feet. Their neighbours would like to see them getting back on their feet and they do not grudge the few pounds they lose to enable them to get on their feet. Give them their chance. They are entitled to it.
We are endeavouring in this section to give every man the opportunity of getting back on his feet and let us agree to give it to them. If Deputies opposite consulted their constituents in regard to these three years' arrears or if they consulted their own minds, they would certainly return a verdict in favour of giving these unfortunate men who, through no fault of their own, ran into arrears, a chance of getting back on their feet. Who knows what happened? You have the case I mentioned a while ago of the unfortunate men who came up here in 1930 and had to pay two or three bunches of lawyers here—and you know what those fellows are—and then had to launch all that money out to a rack-renting landlord in the end. Surely, if they are in arrears to-day, it is not through any fault of theirs but through the fault of the Cumann na nGaedheal Government, which left so many loopholes in previous land legislation that every lawyer fattened and battened on them for the past ten years. They could not turn out lawyers fast enough to take the money, the expenditure of which was necessitated by all these legal loopholes in previous Land Acts.
Comment on this
Now, do not draw me. These are certainly cases for which I should like to see fair play. I submit that there is a case for not funding the law costs and I would appeal to the Minister if it can be done to let it be done on Report Stage.
Comment on this
The annuities during the war are part of a fight. Stand up to it like men and do not be always growling. I know a lot of your crowd and, by Jove, they refused to pay the June annuity before there were ever any tariffs put on. They started howling before the war ever started. The like of you never won a war.
Comment on this
We had the Public Safety Act then and you would take damn good care about what you would do if they did start.
Comment on this
You might not like a taste of it if you got it and certainly from the evidence of the gentlemen in the court the other day there would be very good reason for it. However, in regard to these law costs, I would appeal to the Minister. I do not think it fair that these should be clapped on even though there may be an odd person who should pay. We must give the honest fellows a chance even if we have to allow a rogue to slip off. So far as the other portions of the section are concerned, I entirely agree with them. They give the down and out man a chance of getting back on his feet and it is time he got it. If Deputies opposite consulted their constituents they would find a 99 per cent. majority in favour of giving him that chance. I challenge any Deputy opposite to say that he would find many people amongst his constituents who would say "There is Mick So-and-So who is being forgiven two years' arrears; he should be made pay." You will, however, get an odd mangy fellow who wants to grab the land to say that he should pay but the majority will be in favour of and will be glad to give him a chance.
Comment on this
I think there is very little left to be said by anyone speaking in favour of this amendment after Deputy Corry has spoken for at least half an hour in favour of it. Deputy Smith also spoke in favour of a remission of arrears, so that I think it is up to the Minister to accept the amendment or, at least, to accept that portion of it that deals with annuities which ran into arrears during the economic war. During the entire debate not one single word was said to justify the collection of or to prove that it is morally right to collect, that part of the arrears which have run since the commencement of the economic war. With regard to the older arrears, Deputy Corry and others have spoken in favour of their remission and the best thing, therefore, that the Minister can do is to do graciously what must be done in the end, that is, to accept the amendment. Whether he accepts it or not, it will be impossible, while conditions continue as they are, to collect those moneys.
Comment on this
What about the people who did not take advantage of the moratorium and who paid their annuities?
Comment on this
It has been stated here that 50 per cent. is being remitted under this Bill, but so long as the economic war continues, we are paying more than 100 per cent. That has been proven a hundred times and never refuted.
Comment on this
There is no use in telling these people because they do not understand anything about it.
Comment on this
The farmers are losing much more than the amount of these arrears. Nobody has attempted to disprove that, and, seeing that Fianna Fáil speakers are in favour of remitting the long-standing arrears, and that justice demands a remission of the arrears which have accrued since the commencement of the economic war, the Minister would be well advised to accept the amendment in its entirety. After all, this is a sort of war debt that has accrued during the economic war, and whether it is admitted that it is being paid over, or whether it is paid willingly or unwillingly, it has been collected from the farmers. Nobody has denied that and it is only fair and just that the money should be remitted. As Deputy Corry and all the other Fianna Fáil speakers have spoken in favour of remission of the long-standing arrears, the best thing the Minister could do is to accept the amendment in its entirety.
Comment on this
Deputy Corry is coming on by degrees. He told us that he is convinced that the law costs should not be funded or be demanded of the annuitants. He also told us that his Government is coming to the rescue and giving us a reduction of 50 per cent. in our annuities. Now, Deputy Corry is too astute altogether to believe one word of that. I put this to any Deputy opposite: is England collecting the annuities, or is she not? The President admitted here that England was collecting them, and that the Land Commission were not getting them. It is immaterial to the farmer who is getting them so long as he has to pay them. This 50 per cent. alleged reduction is not a reduction of the annuities, and this whole Bill is a confession of the failure of the Government to carry through negotiations to end the economic war. They are not going to use the annuities, and they tell us, notwithstanding the fact that we are paying nearly twice the amount of the annuities to England through tariffs, that we are getting a remission of 50 per cent. We are not getting anything of the kind.
The proposal of the Government that the Land Commission is to collect 50 per cent. of the annuities is really a new imposition, a land tax amounting to 50 per cent. of the old annuities. That proposition has been put up here before and it has not been controverted. No attempt was made to controvert it. We have the advantage of the Attorney-General being present now, and I hope he will controvert it. When the Minister in charge of the Bill was making his concluding speech on the Second Reading I asked him: "Why does not the Government bear the loss," that is of the arrears that are proposed to be remitted, and the Minister replied, "The Government is bearing the loss." Now I notice that since I got up to speak a member of the Party opposite, Deputy Gibbons, who is chairman of a county council, has returned to the House, and that Deputy Corry, who is also a member of a county council, is present.
Comment on this
May I ask the Deputy this: Will he give a guarantee that he will continue speaking while I am at my tea?
Comment on this
Deputy Corry will sit down and not engage in further frivolous interruptions of that kind.
Comment on this
I did not expect a remark like that from Deputy Corry. I want to put this to these two members, who are both county councillors. I am speaking now of the arrears that are proposed to be remitted. Has the Land Commission not got those arrears by a deduction of the grants payable to county councils? Will Deputy Corry or Deputy Gibbons deny that? Any arrears that will be remitted in the County Cork have been paid by the Cork County Council, and there is not one penny due to the Government. Yet, when the Minister in charge of the Bill was concluding on the Second Reading these statements were made:—
"Mr. Belton: Why does not the Government bear the loss?
Mr. Aiken: The Government is bearing the loss.
Mr. Belton: No, the county councils are bearing the loss.
Mr. Aiken: The Government is bearing the loss."
I challenge Deputy Corry or Deputy Gibbons to get up and prove that one penny of the arrears that will be forgiven in the County Kilkenny or the County Cork is still owing to the Land Commission, because every penny piece has been paid by the ratepayers of the respective counties.
Comment on this
That is the point that I want to bring home to the representatives of Cork and Kilkenny.
Comment on this
I am also a member of a county council and I can say that we have not lost a shilling from the grants payable to the county council.
Comment on this
Deputy Flynn is speaking for the Leitrim County Council. I presume there were some arrears in the County Leitrim. Am I to understand now from Deputy Flynn that to his knowledge the Leitrim County Council got the agricultural grant in full in every way?
Comment on this
And yet we were informed by the Minister for Finance only a couple of weeks ago that the only years in which the Government did not recoup themselves for defaulting arrears of annuities was the year ending the 31st March, 1933. That was the statement of the Minister for Finance, and it is now contradicted by Deputy Flynn.
Comment on this
Then the Minister for Finance and his predecessor must have made a special case for the County Leitrim, and did not deduct anything from the agricultural grant on foot of arrears of annuities. I am not going to say that Deputy Flynn is a man who, to his knowledge, would make a statement that he believed to be wrong, but I think the Deputy has been badly informed on that particular point.
Comment on this
I asked the secretary of the county council the question.
Comment on this
The position in Kilkenny, and I am sure it is the same in other counties, is that when the annual budget is being prepared, credit is taken for the full amount of the agricultural grant. That is done at the time of the striking of the rate.
Comment on this
I must ask Deputies to keep to the point. They have already tried to side-track it. Let us take it that the position was this: that at the 31st March, 1930, the arrears due to the County Kilkenny, Dublin, or any other county, amounted to £5,000. Has it not been the practice, and is it not still the practice, supposing the agricultural grant payable was £20,000 or £30,000, to deduct the £5,000 arrears from the agricultural grant payable to that county?
Comment on this
But I am talking of the arrears that never came in, and these are the arrears that have been remitted. If arrears came in afterwards, then there was nothing to remit but this Bill proposes to remit arrears in respect of which deductions were made to county councils in the agricultural grant. I say that these arrears have never come in. Now who is footing the bill for these arrears? The county councils, of course. Yet you have members of county councils getting up here and supporting a Government to rook their respective county councils of moneys that are legally due to these bodies. As the law stands at present, if those arrears that are now proposed to be remitted were paid to the Land Commission by the present-time defaulters, would not the Government be bound to release the amount of the grants that had been deducted for those arrears? There is a little more than that in it. The county councils were at the loss of these grants for three years and members of the county councils here are going to support their county councils being deprived of that money that, by law, is theirs and going to pass a law to alienate their councils from possessing what is rightly theirs. You have the Minister in charge of this Bill making a wrong statement that the Government is footing the bill for the losses sustained by remitting these arrears, whereas they are indisputably due to the county councils. There is nothing due to the Land Commission. Did the Minister in making these proposals ask the county councils were they prepared to remit these arrears? Of course he did not. Why should he when he claims that they are due to the Government and not to the county councils. So much for the arrears.
Comment on this
Has the Deputy considered the desirability of allowing us to divide on this amendment, or does he intend to move to report progress?
Comment on this
I am going to continue until I have made my case, which will take more than six minutes. This section means more to the country than all that has been debated on this Bill in Committee up to the present. We are down to brass tacks in this. We are down to what I might describe as the bread and butter of this Bill. Deputies opposite do not take this matter seriously enough. The Minister in charge of the Bill speaking on this —he was addressing Deputy Hogan more or less—said:
"Why did he not put that principle into the 1923 Act? In that Act the arrears over three years due were forgiven, but the farmers had made money from 1920 back to 1914, all over the country. That was an easier time to make money for the farmers than from 1920 to 1922, yet prior to 1920 the arrears were forgiven. In every Land Bill introduced by the British the same principle was followed. We have decided to give the people a clean start in this country and not to have them burdened with a volume of arrears. We adopted that old principle."
The principle then was the forgiveness of arrears that were due on foot of what were original rack rents and due to an individual. If the individual tenant or tenants did not pay the rents their neighbours had not to pay in the same circumstances. I am sorry to hear farmers to whom the section applies being so frequently called tenant farmers. Farmers who have purchased their holdings are no longer tenant farmers. They ceased to be tenants the day they purchased their holdings. They agreed to purchase and they are the owners in fee when they pay off the mortgage to the Land Commission. Why should their neighbours, who had to struggle in similar circumstances to them and under precisely the same conditions and meet their obligations in respect of rates and annuities, be burdened with a debt due by the defaulters? The epidemic that came over the country a few years ago was referred to by a Deputy opposite, but he did not attempt to prove that the arrears had all accumulated as a consequence of the fluke.
Comment on this
The Deputy took good care not to try to prove the case that the arrears originated because of that epidemic of fluke.
Comment on this
This deals with arrears in general all over the country. The Deputy did not correlate the epidemic of fluke to the starting of these arrears.
Comment on this
I am not getting away from the point. The Deputy knows that every Deputy in the House has sympathy with people who lost their stock through the fluke. If the arrears were segregated in certain districts where we knew the epidemic of fluke was severe, then a good case could be made for a remission of these arrears. I am not speaking against the remission, but I am speaking against other farmers having to foot the bill for the remission. If the Government want to do the generous thing we will not oppose them if the Central Fund will meet these losses, but the county councils should not have to meet the losses. We have no objection to the arrears that accumulated prior to three years ago being remitted.
Comment on this
There was an objection put forward by several Deputies over there. They pointed out that it was immoral and unwise.
Comment on this
There is a tinge of immorality accentuated by the fact that, because one man does not pay his annuities, the law is going to be invoked against his neighbour, who has paid his annuities to make him not only pay his own, but to pay those of his neighbour, who did not pay them. Is there not a tinge of immorality in that?
Comment on this
If that principle is to obtain, why pay home assistance then if it is going to wasters or people who will not work the same as their neighbours?