We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

Land Bill, 1933—Committee (Resumed).

Contributions 1–163 of 491. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 3 parts.

Bill Land Bill, 1933
Enacted

No. 33 of 1933 ›

At the conclusion of the sitting yesterday I was dealing with the arrears proposed to be remitted. Those arrears which accrued up to three years ago have been paid to the Land Commission indirectly, by the Local Government Department deducting the amount of arrears from the agricultural grant. The Minister in charge of this Bill, in his concluding speech on the Second Reading, said:—

"I do not stand for the principle that we should squash these decent people who got into arrears through no fault of their own, and put their families on the roadside in order to get hold of the waster who should be made to pay his land annuities."

I interjected on that occasion: "Why does not the Government bear the loss?" The Minister replied: "The Government is bearing the loss," to which I remarked: "No, the county councils are bearing the loss." The Minister then went on, and he said: "The Government is bearing the loss." He insisted that the Government is bearing the loss. I insist that that is not true, that the Government is not bearing one penny of the loss. The Government has not at any time indicated to this House any departure from the usual practice, namely, that the amount of annuities irrecoverable at the end of the financial year is computed, and the final payment of the agricultural grant is made to county councils less those annuities which are irrecoverable for the time being. If any of those annuities are subsequently paid to the Land Commission that amount is intimated to the Local Government Department, and the amount of agricultural grant against that piece of arrears is transmitted to the county council. I was well aware of the operation of those acts, but since last night I took an opportunity of checking my information, and I can state positively that as regards the arrears irrecoverable up to 31st March, 1932, the amounts have been deducted from the county councils. As far as the Land Commission is concerned there are no arrears of annuities, because those annuities have been made good out of the agricultural grant.

The information given the House by the Minister in charge of this Bill is not correct when he says that the Government is footing the bill for those annuities which it is proposed to wipe out. In his opening speech on the Bill he said: "The arrears which have accumulated under all the Land Acts over all the years to 31st December, 1932, amount to the sum of £2,972,000," all of which the Land Commission have been paid at the expense of the local ratepayers in every county, each county having to bear the loss that the Land Commission temporarily sustained by not being able to collect the arrears of the annuities. They simply passed the bill on to the county councils, and by the manipulation of the grants the county councils had to pay those bills. To carry the matter further, when the county council found itself, at the end of the year, short of its grant, it had to make up the deficiency on savings, or it had to budget increased rates next year. The Minister went on to say: "From this sum of £2,972,000 has to be deducted about £250,000, representing the arrears over the three years mark, which are now to be written off as bad debts;" bad debts of the county councils, not of the Government. I wonder is the Government going to make good to the county councils those arrears which by this generous gesture they say they will remit? We are not concerned whether a man should have paid or whether he should not have paid. It is not my business to know whether my neighbour has paid his annuities or not, but it becomes very much my business if I have to pay his annuities along with paying my own. The attempt to make an analogy between the remission of arrears of rent under the 1923 and previous Land Acts was an attempt to pull the wool over the eyes of the people of this country. Arrears of rent were always a concern between the landlord and the tenant owing those arrears. If the tenant did not pay his rent to the landlord but allowed it to run into arrears no other tenant farmer had to pay it. It was the landlord's loss. Under the annuity system if the tenant purchasers do not pay their annuities their neighbours have to pay them; that county has to pay them by increased rates. These arrears have been paid in respect of the counties. As far as I have been able to ascertain something like £8,000 was paid by the County Council of Dublin, and that money is due to the County Council of Dublin and to the ratepayers of Dublin. The Minister says we are going to forgive this and he further says it is the Government that is bearing the loss. I hope he will endeavour to prove that point.

In passing, I might remark that a member of the Cork County Council, who is a member of this House, stated yesterday afternoon that it was not true that the county councils had to bear the loss; that it was not true that the county councils had their grants stopped to meet this liability. I was speaking to another member of the Cork County Council since, and he informed me that, speaking from memory, the Cork County Council was at a loss of about £60,000. Before this Bill goes through its final stages, I intend to put down a question asking how much has been deducted, severally and collectively, from the county councils in the Free State on foot of land annuities and the dates that correspond with the dates of remission and funding in this Bill. Then we will be able to find out the truth and I hope the Minister will then stand up for the statement he has already made. The net amount withdrawn from the Guarantee Fund in connection with the Land Purchase Act for the year 1931 in the Free State was £581,790 13/3. The Minister in charge of this Bill wants to take credit for that money which the Government got at the expense of the ratepayers. The Government wants to pull the wool over the people's eyes and say the Government, by this generous gesture, is remitting that amount of money which they have already in their pockets.

The same applies to the proposed funding of annuities, from the three years mark up, roughly, to the 31st March of last year, or to be correct, to the 1st of July, but we can deal with the financial year. These annuities that are proposed to be funded are the proceeds of the funded annuities which will be paid by the farmers to the Government over a period of 50 years on an annuity basis of 4½ per cent. interest. It has been definitely stated in this House by the Minister for Finance that these funded annuities will be the sole property of the Government and will be paid into the Exchequer, whereas it is the local ratepayers that paid that amount. The Minister in introducing this measure said the total arrears will be £4,500,000 which he proposed to fund. The first part—remission—I have dealt with, the second part is that of funding up to the 31st March last. These have been paid by the county councils also and as the law stands, if these arrears were paid by the farmers into the Land Commission, then the Land Commission should make a corresponding allowance to the county councils concerned and let them have the benefit of the withheld grants. But this section proposes to wipe that out and the Land Commission is claiming this money that does not belong to it, while it tells the farmers that it is doing them a service by funding that money over a period of 50 years, notwithstanding that the Government has not the slightest claim to these funds any more than I have.

We now come to the next class of arrears that are proposed to be funded, namely those that have accumulated roughly from last year and are now accumulating. It is proposed to fund them. What right the Government has to fund them it is very difficult to understand, considering that England has been collecting these annuities from the farmers during that period. I put a question yesterday: whether there was any Deputy on the opposite side who would contradict the deliberate statement that England has been collecting those annuities during the last year. That challenge was not accepted. Perhaps Deputies opposite will accept the words of the President and I hope the Minister also will accept them. The President speaking in this House on the 12th May, 1933, is reported in the Parlimentary Debates, column 1004, to have said:—

"So far as the contributions from the agricultural grant are concerned, we are to give half and to give the farmers a remission of half the annuities during the whole period that they would otherwise have to pay. We have funded the annuities for the first half of this year and we have reduced them for the second period by one half. That means that we have given to the farmers this year in that way £3,225,000.

Mr. Belton: And you have taken £5,000,000 from them.

The President: We have done nothing of the kind, but the British have done it."

Will Deputies opposite accept the words of the President there that the Government did not take the £5,000,000. We never accused them and never suggested or insinuated that they took it. We said deliberately that the British did, and the President accepted that. The British have taken £5,000,000 and over the period during which the British were operating, extracting that £5,000,000 a year from us, the Land Commission wants us to pay that same debt to them; and they claim, as a generous gesture, the funding of an alleged debt incurred on foot of the land annuities during that period, and they are asking the farmers to pay that amount at the rate of 4½ per cent. for 50 years. That we have paid it to England in that time is accepted by the President. In view of all that, this is the most monstrous and iniquitous piece of legislation ever attempted on any people by a native Parliament. The British Parliament never had anything to its credit like it in the history of its legislation for this country. We paid that money to England; they extracted it from us. Why now does not our Government step in and stop them extracting it from us? They are not able. We admit that. But then why has our Government the audacity to come round and ask us to pay them again? I hope that everybody on this side of the House will, in debating this measure, from this day forward, not plead poverty even although we are poor but will put in the plea that we are not able to pay, and make the manly defence that as we have already paid we are not going to pay again.

It is admitted by the President that we have paid, and that should be good enough. During the period in which we were paying those annuities to England, a shower of civil bills was sent all over the country and costs were incurred for the very debt that the Government now recognise they should not collect. They incurred costs by making fools of themselves and now the farmers must pay for it. If a local authority did a thing like that the members of that local authority would be surcharged. Not only would their intended victims not have to pay, not only would the county council not have to pay, but the individual members would be surcharged, and rightly so, for their incompetence.

It is proposed under this section to reduce the land annuities by 50 per cent. If that were to happen, as the Minister would have us believe, we would all throw up our hats and we would be hurrying this Bill through. This section clearly indicates that we are to continue paying the £5,000,000 to England and while we are continuing to pay that sum which should liquidate all our obligations and all England's claims, just or unjust, our Government comes along and tells us they are going to halve the land annuities. In reality, they are going to create a tax on the land equivalent to the amount of annuities heretofore paid. The money when paid is going to go into the Exchequer. We have to pay the annuities indirectly to England in order to meet the claims of the bondholders. That amount, the equivalent of 50 per cent. of the old annuities, should be called by its proper name, a land tax.

It is provided in this Bill that the money collected should go into the Exchequer; there is no other provision made for it. British tariffs are to continue. That is the assumption in this Bill and in such an atmosphere this Bill has been formulated. It is proposed to pay an annuity for those arrears. The amount of that annuity is not specifically stated. The only intimation we get about it in the Bill is that it will be at the rate of 4½ per cent. The only intimation we got of the size of the annuity was in the Minister's opening speech, when he said that these arrears would be funded and paid over a period of 50 years at an annuity which would work out at 6d. in the £ every half year. It seemed a round-about way of stating that the annuity would be at 5 per cent. I wonder how he bases that calculation.

We are told in this section that an alleged debt will be liquidated in 50 years. I think they mentioned it would be amortised in 50 years at a certain annuity. How long is this annuity to run? We are told it will run for 50 years. If the Minister is going to lay claim that this debt that he wants to amortise is going to be paid exactly in 50 years he is going to stand over a statement that no British Minister ever stood over when introducing a Land Bill. I will give this quotation from the Irish Convention Report of 1917-1918:

"No period was fixed in that Act for the duration of purchasers' annuities; but if the sinking fund was uniformly invested in 2¾ per cent. stock the annuities would run for 68½ years."

If the Minister is banking on charging 4½ per cent. and is banking that the annuity will amortise the debt in 50 years, he must be prepared to show this House that the sinking fund can be invested in sound securities earning 4½ per cent. I would like to know where this can be got when the British Government is borrowing long term money at present at 2½ per cent. We do not know how long this will have to run, nor does the Minister know. He is, however, taking jolly good care that he is going to put the farmer in the soup by charging him 4½ per cent. He is making the farmer pay out of a bankrupt concern—the agricultural industry of this country.

A lot of criticism has been levelled at the 1923 Act. We know the rate that prevailed in 1923 and yet the 1923 Land Act was financed at 4½ per cent. This Government cannot do anything better than that, although the general level of interest is about one-third what it was then. If these bonds have good backing behind them the £1 bond will be selling at 30/-. Where is the profit to go to? Into the Exchequer. The farmer paying 4½ per cent. will be contributing the profit that the Exchequer is going to scoop in. The Exchequer will make the money out of the sweated labour of the farmer and the sweated labour of his family.

If we pass this section the principle of practically all the finance is accepted. If we agree to this usurer's rate of interest we are going to create the land problem of the future. It has been rumoured about that, because of the strenuous and the continuously hardening opposition to this section, the Government proposed to recoup county councils for the arrears that are going to be remitted and for the arrears that are going to be funded. I hope that is true. The House would welcome an assurance from the Minister to that effect. I hope it will be done and, if it is not done, there is nobody that will pay bigger dividends on the default than the Government opposite. Let us hope it will be done, and then I hope that the opposition will harden against paying anything on foot of alleged arrears for last year, because no arrears are due. The President stated that we paid them to the British Government. I could carry that on further to the local loans, but I am not going to deal with local loans now. That matter will come up on another section. But we have paid them also to the British Government, and we owe nothing to the British Government or anybody else on foot of these except what is owing to us.

I do not want to repeat what I have said already, but I would refer Deputies to page 1004 of the Parliamentary Debates here. I am not going to read it again but, when Deputies opposite read it, I hope they will obey their Leader and accept his word as gospel. I hope Deputies on this side will stand firm, and there is no doubt that if we stand firm here the country outside will stand firm. We should stand firm on the fact that we have paid our indebtedness on land purchase during the last 12 months. The British Government has collected it, and it is nothing short of plunder for our Government to attempt to collect a debt which we have paid twice over to the British Government.

We did not pay the British Government of choice, but if our Government blame us for doing so, we are paying them to protect us. We are paying them enough for protection. They tell us they do not want any more protection. They do not want "Blue Shirts." Perhaps they do not, but we did not get protection from the British in the last 12 months, and when our money was taken to pay a certain debt, we could not stop it. Our Government subsidised the sending of produce over to pay that debt and then they want us to pay that debt again. They are starting now to put a land tax on the people, and I hope that on this side of the House we will not any more plead poverty or plead pity for the farmers during the last 12 months, but let us stand up on our dignity and say that we have paid our debts on foot of land purchase once and that we will pay them no more.

Comment on this

We will see.

Comment on this

I intend to support Deputy Dillon's amendment, perhaps not altogether on the same grounds as Deputy Belton, but on somewhat similar grounds. Sub-section 2 of Section 12, as it stands, provides for the funding of the accumulated arrears during three certain years. I have no objection at all myself to the funding of three years' arrears. My objection is to the three particular years chosen for funding. As you are aware, sir, I had put down an amendment with a view to changing the three years from those ending on the first gale day of 1933 to those ending on the first gale day of 1932, and that was ruled out. It is, undoubtedly, inevitable that a person who, during all the years past, met his liabilities to the State and who, through no fault of his own, in the last 12 months found himself unable to pay, should find himself in the position that the one or two gales he owes will not be wiped out, but will be funded; whereas the person who deliberately avoided meeting his liabilities to the State for a number of years—we will say nine years, if there are any such—will have all but three years wiped out, and only those three years funded. It is not fair play to the man who pays his way, especially the man who fell into debt during the period of the economic war.

Every farmer Deputy in this House knows perfectly well that where payments were made during the last 12 months they were not made out of profits from the land. They were made out of reserves or out of other sources of income. These payments were not made out of the land or out of agricultural produce. There were very few persons who had reserves or other sources of income, and those who had not those reserves or other sources of income, were utterly incapable of paying, and through no fault of their own. While the section stands as it is, proposing to fund the arrears for the period 1932 and 1933, I think the Bill is utterly bad. There were even Fianna Fáil Deputies who opposed it. Deputy Cleary, for one, said that he did not like to see the arrears being wiped out in the years, as he put it, when Cumann na nGaedheal were in power. In fact, he used this choice phrase, which is rather a curious admission. "If he was not able to pay his rent when Cumann na nGaedheal was in power he should not be entitled to any reduction now." That, at any rate, is an admission that they were better times then; the farmer could have paid then and because of that Deputy O'Clery said that there should be no pity for the farmers now. That shows his mentality on the Second Reading reported at column 2451 of the Official Debates. I was not allowed to give Deputy O'Clery an opportunity of supporting an amendment which would meet his wishes in that matter, but I think he should have sufficient influence in the Government to get a member of the Executive Council to amend the Bill to that extent. I have no objection whatever to the funding of three years' arrears. I think it is quite reasonable and I believe that the county councils would have no grievance so far as that is concerned, but I believe the grievance is where the county councils have had deductions made from the agricultural grant. The arrears should be utilised to recoup the county councils for their loss from the deductions of the grant. I do not believe that it is strictly relevant to this section, but I would like to have an assurance before the Bill leaves this House that the county councils will be recouped the amounts deducted. The date for which it is proposed to remit the arrears should be changed. I am supporting the amendment for the deletion of the sub-section merely because of the date. I would not support the deletion of that sub-section if the three years for funding instead of ending on the first gale day 1933 were for the three years ending on the first gale day 1932. I will support the amendment because of the gale days it embraces.

Comment on this

On Sections 12 and 13 and 14 I put down a number of amendments which you very properly excluded, sir, on the ground that they would imply a charge on the Central Fund. These amendments were put down on those three sections and were substantially on the grounds that had been put forward here in the speeches and in the debates. In the Second Reading debate and also in the debate for the deletion of the sub-section a couple of errors have arisen that I would like to see corrected. In the first place, in the Second Reading debate and also on the debate on the Committee Stage when it took place yesterday we had what was apparently a complete misunderstanding as to the meaning of two terms. One of these is rent as it existed prior to any contract to purchase under any of the Land Acts. What is being funded here is interest on borrowed money. I would like to direct your attention, sir, to the speech of the Minister on the Second Reading when that point was put to him. It showed an ignorance on the part of the Minister that might be legitimate coming from any other person. On the Second Reading, page 267, Vol. 49, No. 1, the Minister said:

"We have decided to give the people a clean start in this country and not to have them burdened with a volume of arrears. We have adopted that old principle."

Now the old principle he referred to is the principle which he said was contained in the earlier Acts preceding the Land Act of 1923. No such principle was ever adopted in any Land Act and I want that on record, because every previous Land Act dealt with the contracts for the purchase of land from the landlords. This section here of this Bill deals with the interest on borrowed money. Rent is for the use and occupation of land. The Minister dealing with this section here is dealing with interest on borrowed money. They are quite distinct and separate things. The farmer who purchased his land became a freeholder in every case. It was an amortising of arrears of rent for the use and occupation of land.

Now, sir, reference was made here by Deputy Hogan to what took place on the earlier Land Acts in the past on behalf of this country in the British House of Commons. The principal charge and the only charge that could be made against the principles of these measures in the British House of Commons was first, that it was confiscation of the landlord's property, and, secondly, a charge was made that the tenant farmers of this country would not pay the interest on the money. That was the capital charge made by the die-hards and Tories in England; by the Times, the Morning Post, the Daily Telegraph and the members of the then House of Lords. The Irish leaders—happily they are all dead now —they have not lived to see the pledge that they gave on behalf of the tenant farmers in this country being broken. Happily they are all gone. During the years they lived the tenant farmers faithfully, regularly and religiously discharged the obligations given on their behalf by the then leaders of the Irish people. The second important objection to this is the funding of these arrears. I wish it to be understood that there are no arrears of rent but arrears of interest on borrowed money to purchase land to make the Irish tenant farmers freeholders. For the moment let us pass over the question of whether it is good business, and see whether it is a practical proposition. The second thing that I wish to emphasise is what has been stated here by Deputy Belton. That is, that it has been stated by the Minister on the Second Reading of the Bill that these moneys are due to the Government. Now, that does not want any argument to controvert. That statement is untrue, because it has been quoted here that every penny of this money has been retained from the local authorities out of the agricultural grant and the total amount retained from 1931 is £581,790 13s. 3d. This money is not due to the Government. If that be true, the second point I wish to make is this: let it be bluntly stated here and I do not mind what effect it will have outside. This is a land tax, certainly during the period of the economic war if the economic war is to continue. The speech made by the President has been quoted, but, even though it was never quoted, or even if it was never made, everybody acquainted with the farming industry and the agricultural industry knows quite well that each individual farmer is not only paying his annuities once, but three or four or five times over. I know cases where they have paid five times over. Is it fair, or is it right, under the pretext of increasing the revenue that a subterfuge of this kind should be adopted in order to further extract these moneys?

I have raised this question already and I asked the Minister for Finance last week on another Bill if he would recoup the local authorities for the amount of the remissions under these Bills, because this Bill here deals with the moneys advanced by the Board of Works and under the Irish Church Act and the Land Purchase Acts. The Minister said not, because they could only be returned to the local authorities when they would come in, and as they were being remitted they could not come in. I submit that the Government has no alternative but to return the moneys to the local authorities from which they have been deducted. We are supporting the deletion of the sub-section also because it includes the annuities falling into arrears up to 15th July last. A number of amendments which you, sir, have shelved cover that period and have that object in view. Whatever about earlier years, it is a gross injustice to the great majority of the honest, industrious farmers of this country who have not got into arrears for the past 12 months, who in all the previous years paid their own annuities and those of their defaulting neighbours by loss of the agricultural grant and who further, sir, have paid the rates of many of the defaulting annuitants because many of these defaulting annuitants also defaulted in the payment of rates. The deficit in that branch of the recovered rents in the previous financial year was met out of the rates. They have paid their annuities and rates and in many cases those of the defaulting annuitants, and they have paid the defaulting annuitants' annuities, and for the past year by the policy of the Government —whether rightly or wrongly is beside the question—they have been put into the position financially that they are unable to pay. Now they have got to pay arrears at 4½ per cent. over 50 years.

I am not to be taken as agreeing in principle to the remission of any interest that is chargeable on borrowed money and I want to make that distinct from the remission of rent that would be charged for the use and occupation of land because no rent is at least morally payable on land unless a profit is made on the land. That is a quite distinct and separate question, that when a man borrows money and enters into a contract to pay it back he should ask for a remission of it. They are two separate and distinct things. What he borrows the money for does not arise. It may be to buy horses as well as land but to mix up these things is quite wrong because they are separate and distinct. The Minister was wrong in this House last week when he spoke on the Second Reading of the Bill and compared these remissions to the remissions under the Act of 1923. That was a remission of rent. This is a remission of interest on borrowed money. You have been kind enough to allow the debate for the deletion of this sub-section to wander over the whole field covered by Sections 12, 13, 14, 15, and 16 and I only wish to state now that we support the deletion of the sub-section.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

I hope the House will agree not to duplicate this debate on the section.

Comment on this
Division

Question put—"That the words proposed to be deleted stand put."

Tá 59
·
Níl 40
Result _

Do you agree with this result?

Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Deputy Dillon takes the decision on amendment 23 as covering the following amendments which will, therefore, not be moved. Nos. 31, 34, 37, 39, 50, 61, 70, 82, 84, 85, 87, 97, 100 and 105.

Comment on this

I move amendment 35:—

In sub-section (4), line 58, after the word "arrears" to insert the words "of rent or of interest on purchase money or," and in page 9, line 2, before the word "interest" to insert the words "rent, interest on purchase money," and in line 3 to delete the word "of."

This amendment is purely a drafting amendment and it is brought in, in order to make sure that all payments are covered by this section.

Comment on this

Is it all annual payments?

Comment on this

Yes.

Comment on this

Does that include the rents payable under lettings for temporary convenience?

Comment on this

These are not purely grazing agreements, but it covers all these.

Comment on this
Mr. Hogan

I want that point cleared up. The position is that for the last three or four years a large number of tenants purchased their lands under a letting for temporary convenience until they are vested.

Comment on this

Those are covered.

Comment on this
Mr. Hogan

And those payments include rents and rates, I think. They are covered anyway, that is definite?

Comment on this

Yes.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

I have no desire to curtail the debate. It is admitted that the debate on this amendment has ranged not only over this section but one or two others. I think it was understood that there should not, at any rate, be a prolonged debate on the section.

Comment on this

I will only detain the House for a few moments. I should like to draw the attention of the Government to the fact that under previous sections we have many excepted matters, but under this section there is only one exception, the tenants of labourers' cottages. I wonder if there is any valid reason why the 50 per cent. reduction should be withheld from that particular section of the community. I wonder if it is legal for the Government to withhold those moneys? If it is legally advisable to make a reduction of 50 per cent. in the land annuities I should like to know by what process of reasoning this particular section should be excluded.

Comment on this

Does the Deputy mean tenants under the Labourers Acts?

Comment on this

They do not come within the scope of the Bill at all. There are special Acts, the administration of which the Local Government Department or the Department of Finance is responsible for.

Comment on this

Does the Minister want to make out that the moneys which are being withheld, and which represent the repayment of loans in connection with labourers' cottages, is being used for the purpose of reducing the annuities of landowners, or do we understand that a Bill will be introduced at a later stage——

Comment on this

No such thing. It is a different matter altogether. It is a special matter, and if the Deputy wants to raise it it can be discussed. Those people come under the Labourers Acts. This is a Bill dealing with land purchase and the distribution of land.

Comment on this

Surely the Minister does not object to the Labour Party doing its "stuff."

Comment on this

Whether there are objections or not we will do our "stuff."

Comment on this

And the Labour Party only won by a short head from Deputy MacDermot.

Comment on this

Those people are paying their rates and their rents, and in that way are contributing towards the debts of the defaulting ranchers in a great many instances. I would ask the Minister to look into the matter and see if he can give the justice which is due to those people.

Comment on this

What I want to ask before we pass from this section is whether there is any chance of the Minister making a concession in regard to costs that are to be funded—the costs of the civil bills brought in since the beginning of the economic war. It seems to me there really is a special case for making a concession in that regard. The Government has withdrawn all those civil bills; therefore, by implication, they have suggested that they ought not to have been issued. The people who did not pay and who waited to have civil bills served on them had quite unusual grounds for doing so, because the legal position did appear very obscure to the great majority of the farmers of this country. A big number of them understood that there was great legal doubt as to their liability to pay. I suggest to the Minister that it would be just and reasonable and a gracious gesture if at any rate he wiped out the costs even if he cannot see his way to wipe out the arrears.

Comment on this

A decision has been taken to that effect.

Comment on this

In that connection I should like to point out that the Centre Party guaranteed to pay costs in a great many cases in my county. I think they should be made to honour their bond.

Comment on this

On the section——

Comment on this

In reply to Deputy MacDermot, I want to explain that a decision has been taken to that effect. The Government withdrew all the civil bills in respect of the first gale of 1932. The State solicitors had already taken action in a number of cases, and the Government is going to meet the costs.

Comment on this

The Government is going to meet them?

Comment on this

Yes.

Comment on this

Is the Minister not being more than usually kind to some people as compared with others?

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Deputy Brennan to resume.

Comment on this

I am glad that the Minister made that announcement. There were a good many amendments down to meet that situation I want to make a further suggestion to the Minister. In connection with the second gale of 1932 and the first gale of 1933 I would ask the Minister to seriously consider why those arrears should not be at least forgiven to the extent of 50 per cent. The Government consider that for the future the annuities must be halved; and the people are not able to bear any more than half. As regards those gales our case on this side is that they ought to be remitted altogether, that there is really no case for collecting them at all, because the people have already paid them to Great Britain. Certainly if they are going to be funded they should only be funded in half.

Comment on this

I should like to support Deputy Brennan in that. It will be observed that the last amendments by Deputy Brennan and myself were put down with the object of obtaining a remission of the entire amount of those two gales, or alternatively, a reduction by 50 per cent. I think the Minister will admit that if the Government is justified in reducing the annuities in future by 50 per cent. that should equally apply to the two gales since the beginning of the economic war. As to the costs the same principle applies, because the Government thought it was not justified in executing those decrees in the circumstances. I should like if the Government could see their way to make that reduction. It would be accepting the justice of the claims of the farmers under the present depressed conditions, and it would be some relief to them in a period of this kind. I support Deputy Brennan in making that appeal to the Minister.

Comment on this

I just want to make one suggestion. Deputies Brennan and McMenamin have suggested to the Minister to fund half the annuities. I personally do not see any case for funding any of those particular annuities. The Minister has admitted just now, indirectly, that the tenants during the continuance of this economic war should not have been pressed for their rents, that the issue of processes was in fact a mistake, and that the tenants would not have been able to pay even if decrees were got against them. It is admitted that the annuities could not be paid and in these circumstances it is unjust that they should be funded and that people should be asked to pay them.

Comment on this

The Deputy says that because the Government is not going to exact the costs on the writs that were issued that is an admission that the annuities should not be collected. He also says that the tenants should not have to pay them. If we were discussing this really in a calm manner I am sure all Deputies interested in the country would be persuaded that that is not so. The criticisms of this section have fallen under three headings. The first is that the arrears should not be paid at all.

Comment on this

That case was not made.

Comment on this

Deputy Belton should remember that there are more people than he in the Cumann na nGaedheal Party. Deputy Hogan definitely stated that it was immoral that the arrears should be forgiven.

Comment on this
Mr. Hogan

What I said was that it was a disgrace to forgive arrears that had accrued up to 1930, and not to forgive arrears that accrued afterwards.

Comment on this

I do not want to make any point at all against the Deputy. I am only pointing out to Deputy Belton that one of the criticisms directed against the Government was that they were forgiving arrears, and that another was that if we were going to forgive arrears they should not merely forgive those prior to the year 1930, and fund those that occurred in respect of the period of the economic war. The criticism was that that was wrong. The third line of criticism was that the halving of the annuities was wrong; that no annuities should be collected during the period of the economic war. I think that is a fair general summary of the criticisms directed against the Government in these respects. I disagreed with the arguments that were put forward from the benches opposite, but if we could discuss them free from the atmosphere of the economic war I think we could get general agreement that it is a good thing that the arrears prior to 1930 should be forgiven. If anyone wants to rely upon the Ten Commandments I refer them to the power in the Bible: "Unto this last." I maintain also that it is right that the Government should fund the annuities that were not collected in respect of the first gale and second gale after the economic war commenced, and the further proposition I would make is that it would be a good thing that at least half of the annuities should be collected. If we could get into this position that this particular economic war which started on the 15th July of last year was in some way or other over——

Comment on this

We would be all very happy.

Comment on this

Let me put it in this way: That we could take it as settled in either of three ways: (1) that we surrender to the British and said: "here is your £5,000,000"; (2) or that we agreed with the British proposition and went before an Imperial Tribunal and the Imperial Tribunal said that we did owe the £5,000,000; or (3) that England accepted our demands for an International Court; that that court had sat and given its award in our favour, that we are not to pay the £5,000,000. Take either of these things as having happened, that we were in the happy position of this war being over no matter on what basis. Take it that yesterday this thing was settled and that we signed along the dotted line that we were to pay £5,000,000 to England and that we were in the position that we would have to tax the people in order to keep a lot of our public services going and to pay for a 40 per cent. tariff——

Comment on this

On a point of order, I suggest that the line the Minister is now taking would carry us into a very wide area of discussion. If the Minister is allowed to proceed on these lines it would be almost impossible for Deputies on the Opposition Benches to refrain from replying.

Comment on this

I think we should welcome the line the Minister has taken.

Comment on this

I have been sitting here for six days. I did not interrupt Deputies even once when they were speaking of the economic war.

Comment on this

I deplore repetition as much as the Minister, but my desire is to try and see this Bill proceeded with in a businesslike way.

Comment on this

My observation was only a preliminary or introductory remark in order to get down to the three propositions I put up. If we took it that the economic war, which was started on the 15th July was over, and that to-day I was coming into this House and had to announce that the British had made a further demand; that they were not satisfied with the £5,000,000 and had made a demand for a further £2,000,000 in respect of bridges or roads or houses or public buildings that they had built here in their time we might be up against a proposition whether we should pay that or not. If the British said that they would put 40 per cent. on our cattle if we did not agree to it, we would have to consider then, as the Government had to consider before, if we made up our minds that we were not going to pay, and that this further £2,000,000 was an unjust imposition, what we were going to do for the relief of the farmers if agricultural produce was to be taxed to the extent of 40 per cent. Personally, I put this to Deputies, that it is not every farmer who is paying for the economic war. There are certain farmers in this country better off under the economic war than before.

Comment on this

The fellows who do not pay anybody are.

Comment on this

The farmers who are producing things that are protected here are better off. Take, for instance, the dairy farmer producing butter. He is getting more under our Government than he got in the normal way when there were no British tariffs. The export bounty amounts to almost as much as he would have got then.

Comment on this

But the home consumer has to pay that.

Comment on this

I am only saying that there are certain farmers not feeling any burden from the economic war.

Comment on this

On a point of order, I was instructed by the Ceann Comhairle when I touched upon the economic war to get off it. He would not allow me to continue on that subject. The Minister, if he wants to get through this Bill with dispatch, will endeavour to avoid such a controversial subject. If he is going to enter into a long discourse on the economic war, I will find it necessary to answer him at great length. He, I am sure, desires, just as I desire, to facilitate matters in every way. The Chair ordered me to pass off the economic war when I was speaking and I immediately did so. If it is to be brought into the discussion now I, and I have no doubt Deputy Davin, who seems to be rearing to talk, will find it necessary to reply.

Comment on this

Where is the point of order?

Comment on this

Deputy Dillon will be talking anyhow, no matter whether it is on the economic war or not.

Comment on this

Is the Minister in order in discussing the economic war?

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Minister is in order in replying to points that were undoubtedly made, but I think it is most inadvisable to discuss all the aspects of the economic war now. I agree with the Deputy that such a discussion would inevitably lead to a prolonged debate on this section.

Comment on this

I have no desire at all to enter into a debate on the economic war. I think that is evidenced by the fact that I did not reply to the six days' debate on the question. Deputies made the point that the annuities should be wiped out. My preliminary remarks were devoted to setting aside altogether the economic war so that we could consider this matter from the real, fundamental point of view. I say that there are farmers who are not suffering because of the economic war.

Comment on this

Where are those farmers?

Comment on this

They are the farmers who are producing for the home market.

Comment on this

How much less are they getting for their calves?

Comment on this

There are certain farmers who are making most bones about the economic war and who are really not paying much towards it. I refer now to the grazing farmers.

Comment on this

You have some of them on your own benches.

Comment on this

The grazing farmers undoubtedly sold their cattle at a loss for the first year. They bought their fresh stock, however, at a lesser cost than formerly.

Comment on this

From the small farmers.

Comment on this

That is exactly the point I am coming to. They bought them from the small farmers at a price which gave them a reasonable chance. They knew the 40 per cent. was on. They bought the stock at a price which took into consideration the fact that they would have to pay the 40 per cent. or the £6 a head at the end of their period of grazing. The man who is making most of a howl about the economic war is the grazier, the man who pulls out receipts and says "I sold 100 cattle and it cost me £600. I have paid my land annuities ten times over." That man did not do it at all; as a matter of fact, it was the man below him.

Comment on this

What about the dairy farmer?

Comment on this

Might I suggest that the Minister should postpone these very contentious points until the Fifth Stage, if he must make them at all? Surely he knows that what he is saying cries out for an answer. Why introduce those matters at this stage?

Comment on this

Let him go on. We will answer him.

Comment on this

We are prepared to answer the Minister at very great length.

Comment on this

The Minister's statements are most interesting.

Comment on this

It would be wrong in those circumstances to forgive land annuities all round, because all the farmers are not suffering equally and it would be wrong to give a complete remission in respect of annuities to farmers who are not suffering. It would be wrong from the ordinary national point of view, if a man owed something to the community, to let him remain on his land free. There would be a temptation for any man to sit tight and to employ nobody. He could dig in his back garden with a spade and manage to keep himself alive. The fact that annuities have to be paid compels the farmers to produce, and that it what we want. We have not the slightest intention of forgiving the land annuities altogether. The arrears that have been funded in respect of the second gale of 1932 and the first gale of 1933 can be very well treated as a loan. There were some farmers who paid their annuities then. Some people will say that anybody who paid them during those years should get a refund. Instead of doing that we are treating the annuities that were not paid as a loan to the farmers. We regard the fact that they did not pay as a proof that they wanted a loan at 4½ per cent. If they do not want that loan they can pay the money to the Government. There is nothing to stop a farmer who does not want to pay 4½ per cent. on his arrears from paying up the arrears. There is no compulsion on him.

Comment on this

Except lack of capital.

Comment on this

If he wants capital he has got a loan at 4½ per cent. for 50 years and that is 1½ per cent. better than he can get it from the Credit Corporation.

Comment on this

Does the Minister not recognise that the farmers have paid those annuities already?

Comment on this

Some of them have.

Comment on this

I could agree with the Minister's argument if the economic war were settled, but while it continues, I cannot.

Comment on this

There are some farmers producing for the home market. They do not sell outside and they have not paid anything to England.

Comment on this

Surely the Minister knows that the effects of the economic war ramify through the whole of the population.

Comment on this

If it goes through the whole of the population, and if we are to say that it is spread out equally, then, if England were compelling us to pay the full £5,000,000 by means of taxation, we are no worse off than we were.

Comment on this

England is making us pay the £5,000,000 and you are insisting that we pay land annuities to your Land Commission. We are that much worse off.

Comment on this

The Deputy says that the effect of these payments is going through the whole community. I maintain that in those circumstances we are no worse off than if we were paying England £5,000,000.

Comment on this

England is making the collection and if you give a clean cut at that we are no worse off; but you want all the annuities up to the 15th July of this year and you want half the annuities afterwards. We who have to pay them will be that much worse off and that is our case.

Comment on this

Deputy Belton's point, therefore, is that it is a land tax.

Comment on this

It is, and I would like the Minister to prove that it is not.

Comment on this

If it is not collected on the land it will have to be collected on something else.

Comment on this

At last it is out.

Comment on this

I am not saying it is a land tax, but if Deputies want to call it a land tax, well and good.

Comment on this

Will the Minister deny that we are not paying the annuities to England through the economic war? Why should we be asked to pay them again to the Land Commission?

Comment on this

I did not go to the British Treasury to examine their figures, but, according to their figures, we paid £3,600,000 out of £5,000,000 in the first year.

Comment on this

That is more than the annuities; the annuities are not £3,000,000.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Minister must be allowed to put his case. Deputies who are interrupting were not themselves interrupted and the Minister has as much right as any Deputy to make a case. That should be understood.

Comment on this

I think Deputies will agree that £5,000,000 a year is something worth fighting for. If any man here thought that he was owed £50 he would think it worth his while to spend a few pounds in seeking to recover it. That is what this country is doing. I think that all the Deputies in the House should keep it in mind that, if this particular economic war is over in the morning and if England can succeed by pressure of one sort or another in getting us to pay a debt which the majority of the people in this country think we do not owe and should not pay, that is only the beginning, and any time England wants to make us bow to her will and take off tariffs or sell our produce at a certain price, she can always threaten us with more taxes. We have got to stick our heels in the ground, and I believe that if Deputies in Opposition would put half the energy into helping us to make a success of this fight that they put into attacking us it would be over long ago. I know that the temptation of an Opposition is to seize on some particular point, particularly a point that is easily argued. They have been shouting "economic war" and "give us back our markets" and all the rest of it. They want us to give back the British market to the farmers of this country, and the British farmers themselves cannot get that market unless they take very drastic steps.

We are going to ask the farmers of this country to pay the 50 per cent. Look at it from this point of view: if the land of this country on which so much public money has been spent in purchasing and distributing it to certain people—or leaving it with certain people, if you like—if that land cannot pay anything, what right has one person to it more than another? A lot of the Deputies talk about Communism, but we want to see that the farmers of this country, who are utilising their land and who are paying what they can afford for it, are secure. If they pay nothing, then the temptation on the part of the men who have no land or no houses and who have nothing to eat will be to say: "Since that man is paying nothing to the State for the land, we have as much right to it as he has." This has been called a land tax. It is land security for the people who are working the land. That is what we want to see. We want to see the farmers who are working the land secure on it, and we want to see that they pay to the community what the community thinks they should. This clause is simply implementing the decision that was come to that the farmers should pay 50 per cent. of the land annuities. I do not care what arguments Deputies use down the country. I think that, if their supporters look into it, they will see that it is in the best interests of the country as a whole that half the land annuities should be collected, and that it is only right that people, who got so badly into arrears that they could not pay, should be given a chance to find their feet again.

If we started to collect all the arrears of land annuities that the Cumann na nGaedheal Government handed over to us as a bad debt we would be putting some 6,000 or 7,000 farmers out on the road. If it is immoral to forgive those annuities, why were they not collected when Cumann na nGaedheal were in office? They were handed over to us as a bad debt and if we were to enforce the collection of these annuities at the moment the only result would be that we would be rendering derelict a lot of land that is keeping families at the moment. No farmer will be called upon to pay more than 65 per cent. of his former annuity and I think it is a good thing to start with a clean sheet and give them a chance.

Comment on this

I want to deal, first of all, with that portion of the Minister's statement which referred to the fact that the Cumann na nGaedheal Government had not collected the Land Commission annuities. I have stated repeatedly in this House what the position was as regards the unpaid instalments as from the date when we took over the Land Commission in 1923. The sum then due, and due to the propaganda of the Front Bench, as I stated here before in this House, when, under the sign manual of the so-called Minister for Home Affairs of the Republic in 1922, people were threatened not to pay their Land Commission annuities, their income tax, and so on—when the Land Commission was taken over by this State in 1923, the total amount withdrawn from public bodies by means of the Guarantee Fund to make good the unpaid instalments amounted to £652,749. That was the sum owing, when we took over the Land Commission, in respect of the Land Acts from, one may say, 1891 to that time. After nine years the sum total of those arrears had been reduced to £526,095. That is to say, that not alone were the whole of the Land Commission annuities collected during those nine years, but there was £106,000 collected of the arrears owing. I have come to the conclusion, having listened to more than one Minister speaking on this question in this House, that they spoke without knowing what the whole thing really means. So far as the Land Commission is concerned, it is not at a penny loss. So far as the Central Fund in this country is concerned it has not contributed a single sixpence towards that. The farmers had paid in 1923 that £600,000 from the sums of money that were available for relief in rates on agricultural land provided by this State and provided, for some years before that, by the British Government when they were here. The sum and substance of the whole thing is that not alone was the whole sum paid but that £126,000 were paid off the instalments which had been unpaid when we took over the Land Commission.

There is a slightly different situation with regard to the 1923 Act. The situation is slightly different for more than one reason, and not the least of these reasons is the propaganda that had been carried on by this irresponsible Government when it was in a less responsible position than it is now in this House, when I heard in this House one of the back benchers—from Tipperary, I think—make the remark, Deputy Hogan having taxed the Opposition with having criticised the payment of Land Commission annuities, "Quite right; they should not be paid." The Minister, apparently, intended to deal with the question in a reasonable manner and asked the House to deal with it likewise. We are always prepared to do so. In the first place the Government proposal to deal with unpaid annuities is not a good business proposition. They wipe out £250,000 from the arrears. They are wiping it off the liability of the Central Fund. They will not put up 6d. towards that wiping out. They are simply saying to county councils: "we are wiping it off." I could agree that in this as in other matters we must look at it from a business-like basis. The Civil Service is not run on a business-like basis. Acts of Parliament are not on a business-like basis. Each must be administered by the State, the Executive Council of which has to report to the Dáil. There is practically no such thing as the wiping out of bad debts or irrecoverable debts. The proper course is for the State to come forward and put up each year a sum which, in their judgment, is a fair sum to regard as an irrecoverable debt in this case and relieve the county councils of the responsibility, that is if the Government think that a case for such a policy could be made. Unlike the gospel case which the Minister quoted, the gospel case I have heard of is that the person to whom the money was owed exercised the prerogative of mercy and charity. Here the Government is exercising that same prerogative of mercy and charity at somebody else's expense. If they knew anything of municipal finance they would know that they are not entitled to do it. The ratepayer of to-day may not be the ratepayer of to-morrow or next day.

The proper course to take in connection with it is to examine those cases not on a question of time, but on the question of the ability of the person to pay. No other system could possibly grow up than one in which we are going decade after decade to take into consideration people who owe arrears of instalments to the Land Commission, and every ten years we are going to wipe them off. We are going to invite defaulting annuitants, and particularly those with the Fianna Fáil financial complex, to allow their arrears to grow, seeing that the Government must come along after a period of years and wipe them out. It may be that people who are well able to pay may be allowed off. I have often heard of people well able to pay being slower in their payments than those much worse off. The only way to deal with instalments is on a business basis—examine each case on its merits. If you find a man is unable to pay through misfortune, illness or loss of stock, then, by all means, write off the arrears as irrecoverable, but let this not be done in an arbitrary manner, or in such a manner as to do injustice to somebody else. Realise that if you are going to take over responsibility for some other people's debts you have got to pay compensation to those who are deprived of money they are entitled to. The second point we were asked to consider is whether 50 per cent. was a fair reduction under the circumstances. We had from the Minister what he himself must know, and what every other member of the Executive must admit if they consider the case at all, that it is not an answer to the general body of farmers or annuitants of the country to say that a certain moiety, a certain small percentage of them have lost no money by reason of the conflict to which this Government lightly rushed this country. Not 1 per cent. of the annuitants has not lost for the past 12 months in the carrying out of their business and in the operation of their agricultural economy, even those farmers to whom the Minister has referred and described as graziers, and there are very few of them who devote themselves exclusively to grazing, or even those who bought cattle at the cheaper price which the Minister mentioned.

I have not heard, and I would be glad to hear, any of those who have made money even buying their cattle at a cheaper price. I have heard of people buying cattle at November, December and January fairs who had to admit that if they put them on the market again they would not get the price they paid for them. The country has been rushed into this conflict. I am prepared to sit down calmly and discuss the problem. Do we solve it by taking up a pen and saying: "You will only pay 50 per cent. in future?" Do we solve it by assuming for a moment that the State has a right to the ownership of the land? Do we solve it by saying that a man must pay something for the land he holds? When the Minister says that huge sums of money had been advanced by the State for the purchase of land he does not know what he is talking about. The only sum the State has provided since it came into existence was the money which was issued under the 1923 Land Act. The total sum outstanding is about £24,000,000, and the interest and the principal on that is the total liability of this State. I am taking it from the Minister's own point of view. I believe we are liable under the previous Acts under which we borrowed the money in Great Britain and that we owe it just as much, and I am prepared to assist them in any case they will make to the contrary or any negotiations he wishes to inaugurate with the British Government to point out that the country is not prepared to pay what it undertook to pay, but that it is willing to pay what it is morally or legally liable for. The situation here is that we are invited to ask the farmers to contribute annually towards the State a sum of money for the land they occupy based on some relation to the existing annuity. I do not agree the State owns the land. I take the line that if a farmer in this country undertook to purchase his land and buy out the landlord and met his obligation year after year that farmer does not owe that money to the State. The State is merely the agent for the collection of the annuities which go in their turn to liquidate the money advanced to enable land purchase to be accomplished. It is not to-day or yesterday we took up that point of view.

We have adhered to it all through. There is no such thing as an annuity which the farmer is not legally or morally bound to pay which does not go for the purpose for which it was originally collected — towards the reduction on the purchase price. If the liability under the Land Act from 1891 to 1909 falls and if there is no liability then the present holders of the land accustomed to pay their annuities have not a single penny to pay for the liquidation of that debt. It was to pay that debt that annuities were first inaugurated. If there was no debt then there is no annuity payable but there is quite a different situation in connection with the Land Act of 1923. There we owe the money. Quite a different situation ensues in connection with the Land Act of 1923. The person whose annuity is owed under that Act is liable for the amount. If it be beyond his capacity to bear the State applies its responsibility in that connection and is bound to step in; it is bound to see what can be done because agriculture is the main source of wealth in this country and unless it prospers there is no hope for the country. Would the Minister advert to the fact that in this conflict with England there are two Governments now trying to collect the same sum of money? Will the Minister remember that only £3,000,000 of the £5,000,000 are due in respect of annuities but on the farming community rests the full responsibility for the British duty? The British Government hold they are not liable for the Sinking Fund of the Land Acts of 1903, 1909 and possibly 1889.

The Minister has referred to the home market. What is the home market? Its prices are regulated by the price we get for our agricultural produce in the export market. A man gets the same price for his bullocks or cows or his sheep in the home market as he would get in the export market. If we get only 4d. a dozen for eggs from the British we might reasonably say that that regulates the price in the home market. We regulate only his loss in respect of the reduction of the sums we get for our agricultural produce in the export market. The other sum amounts nearly to the same figure, so that the position the farmer is in is that he is paying £3,600,000 to the British in respect of agricultural produce and he is practically paying the same amount here for home produce and nobody gets the benefit except perhaps the purchaser.

If we are to consider the question of the capacity or ability of the Land Commission annuitant to bear taxes of any sort we must take full stock of the present position of agriculture and even at this late hour the Minister would be very well advised to review the whole situation in the light of these circumstances and to say whether it is possible for agriculture—bearing in mind the present price for agricultural produce and live stock, to pay £2,000,000 a year in Land Commission annuities, and £3,600,000 to the British Government. That is £5,600,000 that the tenant farmer of this country is asked to pay and there is a further sum of over £100,000 for interest on something like £4,000,000 for the funded arrears. We have, then, three sums: £3,600,000 to the British, £2,000,000 to the Land Commission and £100,000 funded arrears. The agricultural industry is asked to bear nearly all that and the industry cannot afford it. Something in relief of these burdens must be given by the Government if they are going to continue this economic conflict. Economic conflicts are unwise between peoples, very, very unwise. If, as the Minister said, a man owes you £50 you will take great care to ensure that you are going to get back your money. A successful business man would ensure that the collection of the £50 would not cost £51 or £52. The time he crosses the line when it cost him more to collect a sum than the debt due is the proper time for him to trace his steps towards the mental home, and if in securing for ourselves this £5,000,000 it costs £6,000,000 or £7,000,000 or £8,000,000 or £10,000,000 a year it is not a sound proposition, and that is the sum and substance of my view. It would have been possible, in my view, during the last 12 months to have got a fair and equitable settlement of this transaction but that cannot be done unless it is approached in a commonsense, business-like manner and sound business acumen is brought in towards finding the solution.

Comment on this

In making arrangements for the reduction of the existing annuities and the funding of arrears due over the period mentioned in the section the Government are merely giving effect to public pledges given to the people of this country and, in supporting them, in so far as we are supporting them, we also are bearing the responsibilities that we pledged ourselves to do the same thing. Now Deputy Cosgrave, I will admit, has just made a moderate speech, more moderate than any I have listened to or read from him since the beginning of the economic war. If that type of speech had been made by Deputy Cosgrave at the commencement of the economic war I am inclined to say that from what I know of prominent public men on the other side it would have long since concluded to the satisfaction of the people of this country. If Deputy Cosgrave would not think so much about politics and would go on the lines of speeches like the moderate one he made to-day there may be some hope that some satisfactory solution of this dispute will result; a solution satisfactory to the people of this country, in the near future.

Comment on this

That is good news.

Comment on this

I read a famous speech, a speech that will go down in history, delivered by Deputy Cosgrave in the town of Naas three or four days before the conclusion of the last general election campaign. It was an offer to halve the land annuities but I have never heard Deputy Cosgrave since say or read in any speech from him how he was going to do it. Will he tell us now how he intended to do it? Where would the money come from?

Comment on this

It would be too much for you if I told you.

Comment on this

The Deputy said he could settle the dispute in three days, one day to go over to England, another day in negotiations and another day coming back. He said that he could make that settlement which would have reduced the annuities then payable by 50 per cent.

Will he tell us when he is speaking again on the issue how he proposed to find the money which would have to be found to give effect to that famous public pronouncement which he made in Naas during the last general election? I am in fairly close touch with the working farmers in my constituency and I am in fairly close touch with my constituents as a whole since I became a Deputy of this House 11 years ago, and it is five or six years since I said in this House and in the country as well that the fall in agricultural prices would compel some Government to reduce the annuities to a figure which the farmers would be able to pay. I was then satisfied that the head of any Government that would be put into office by the Irish people, or any Government in office to-day, even if no economic war had been started, circumstances so far as the land annuities were concerned would compel that Government to reduce these annuities to an economic level. Will anybody deny that except somebody who is not in touch with the farmers of the country in the last five or six years?

Comment on this

They are 40 per cent. worse off now.

Comment on this

That economic war was to be settled.

Comment on this

I am not going to deal with the interruptions of a Deputy who has been talking here for three or four days.

Comment on this

He was talking about something he knew.

Comment on this

I will say this, that I am in agreement with some of the points put forward by Deputy Belton.

Comment on this

And Deputy Davin would be in agreement with all the points if he understood them.

Comment on this

I never posed in this House as a person with so great a knowledge as to make me fit for the office of Minister for Agriculture, or the coming President.

Comment on this

Neither did I.

Comment on this

I have very strong personal objection to the policy of a Government which compels one set of honest working farmers or ratepayers to pay the private or public debts of others and allows another set off these payments. To that extent I am very strongly opposed to the proposal of the total remission of the land annuities. I think other ways or means should be found without granting total remission of these annuities to 7,000 or 8,000 defaulters and without having made some exhaustive inquiry as to the position of the persons concerned and their circumstances. They should be either made pay themselves or their successors should be compelled to pay them. I admit and I think every Deputy who knows the position will admit that it is very wrong that the idle ranchers —to use an expression I have heard on those benches—should get out of paying their annuities at the expense of the small hardworking farmers of the country and even at the expense of the people living in labourers' cottages. I very much object to the policy of these people being allowed to get off the payment of these arrears. If I could get any clear amendment which would give a clear right to vote against this policy of the Government I would go into the Lobby against the Government on such an issue.

Comment on this

That has already been ruled out.

Comment on this

There are numbers of people who will get rid of their responsibilities and obligations in that way. I should not wonder that these people would have the check later on to go to some members of this House and ask them to bring in a Bill to relieve them from the payment of their private debts. There is just as good a case as far as the idle rancher is concerned in asking the Dáil to give him relief against his shop debts and other local debts as to ask the local ratepayer to pay up this money for the idle rancher, and under this Bill he is being obliged to pay. I know there are included in these 7,000 or 8,000 some people who through some domestic or other reason might claim that they should not be pressed for an immediate payment of the sums due. Would it not be possible to arrange for some separate funding system which would enable the arrears of such people to be passed on to their successors or to posterity rather than compel honest farmers and cottiers to pay that money now? I would not make that statement if the Minister had answered the point raised by Deputy Belton.

Deputy Belton asked the Minister to say whether the sums deducted from the agricultural grant would be made good to the local ratepayers. The Minister did not answer that. If the Minister promised that or had given some explanation I would not be expressing myself now in the way I am expressing myself. I do not want in the course of this debate to discuss the question of the economic war. It is interesting to hear what are the views of a great many Deputies on this matter, but it would be much more interesting to me to see the time when the Ministers on the Government side and the ex-Ministers on the opposition benches would think more of their country and less of their Party. I would be more interested to see them big enough and patriotic enough to rise to that height and if they did the issue would not be one for discussion here to-day.

Comment on this

The note on which Deputy Davin wound up would be more appropriate in the beginning or middle of his speech than at the end. The Deputy began by heaping compliments on Deputy Cosgrave for his moderation and good feeling and then he proceeded to speak of Deputy Cosgrave and about the wrong agreements he made and the weakening influence he was having on the nation. It is fair to say of Deputy Cosgrave in connection with any undertaking which he gave about the settlement of the land annuities that he could have dispensed with the land annuities for the last 18 months since Fianna Fáil came into office at less than the increased expenditure of six millions, which the Fianna Fáil Government has imposed on the country.

Comment on this

When is Deputy Dillon going over to the Front Opposition Bench?

Comment on this

Perhaps not as quickly as Deputy Davin will move over to the back benches of Fianna Fáil. Perhaps the most important statement made on this Bill was the confession extracted from the acting Minister for Lands and Fisheries that it was the policy of the Fianna Fáil Party to impose a land tax. I invite Deputy Davin and other Deputies, who speak for the small farmers in the House, to go down and put this policy of the Fianna Fáil Party in connection with the land tax before their constituents.

Comment on this

Who is Deputy Dillon quoting?

Comment on this

I am quoting the Acting Minister for Lands and Fisheries.

Comment on this

I think the Deputy is quoting Deputy Belton's words.

Comment on this

No. The Minister was elaborating the resolution of this Government to extract land annuities in one form or another from the people regardless of the surrounding circumstances and he said they could just call it a land tax. What he said was "call it a land tax if you like."

Comment on this

On a point of order——

Comment on this

This is not a point of order.

Comment on this

On a point of explanation——

Comment on this

Very well, on a point of explanation I give way.

Comment on this

I do not think that Deputy Dillon wants to misrepresent me, but I think the Deputies here will recollect that what happened was this: Deputy Belton was arguing that this was a land tax and I said call it a land tax if you like.

Comment on this

That is exactly what I said the Minister had said.

Comment on this

It was Deputy Belton called it a land tax. From a general point of view I may say that I am not going to spend my time refuting every single thing said by the Opposition, and if they want to call it Bolshevism or Capitalism or any other "ism" they like I do not mind. I want to do the work here and not to spend my time refuting everything like that.

Comment on this

I do not want to call it Bolshevism or Capitalism but a land tax, what it is.

Comment on this

On a point of personal explanation. Deputy Dillon said that Deputy Smith could go down to the country and tell small farmers that the Acting-Minister for Lands and Fisheries had announced the Fianna Fáil policy of imposing a land tax. Now I think that the Deputy will realise that that is a wrong statement for him to make.

Comment on this

I shall not hesitate to withdraw this statement if the Minister assures this House that he had no such intention but just listen to what he subsequently said:

"A land tax if you like to call it, but whatever it is this Government will make the people who own land to pay in respect of that land what the community thinks the land should bear."

Is that a declaration that—no matter whether they are annuities or not—the community, acting through this House, will impose upon the people such tax on their land as they think the land will bear? I say that the Minister said that. If the Minister says he thinks that is not a land tax I say it is.

Comment on this

Call it that and claim credit for it.

Comment on this

I am quite prepared to let the Deputy look up the Official Report and see if he will not find a declaration by the Minister that in his opinion, call it what you like, this Government will make the owners of the land pay such sum as the community thinks the land can bear. You have the Minister beginning by saying: "If you choose to call it a land tax, call it a land tax," and he adds that paragraph. If that does not mean that the Fianna Fáil Government is prepared to impose a land tax upon the people of this country, then I do not know the meaning of the English language. I am quite well aware that the Minister is right in trying to save his face, because there is not a man on those benches who would attempt to repeat that statement in his constituency. He would be hunted out of it.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

There are two or three Deputies here who persist in interrupting. I would like them to understand that the Chair does not consider it necessary to give a specific warning before taking action.

Comment on this

At an early stage to-day, when an amendment fixing a principle was rejected, I withdrew 15 amendments, on which I could have demanded a division, in order to facilitate the Minister in the Committee Stage of this Bill. I mention that in evidence of my good faith, and my desire to avoid obstruction. I want the House to remember that the Minister for Defence is the same Minister who got up here 12 months ago and told the members of this House and the country that the only result he could foresee from the economic war was that the farmers and the people of this country would get so fat through thriving on the economic war that a new industry would have to be started to widen the doors of Irish houses so as to let the people in and out. Deputies will remember that. That was the responsible declaration of a Minister of State, speaking from the Front Bench, when this country was being launched into the economic war. That was his contribution. This is the same Minister, who to-day had the effrontery to announce that the farmers are not suffering at all, that they buy cattle from the little farmer, that admittedly they sell them at a reduced price, but they also buy them at a reduced price. What about the little farmer from whom they bought them? What about the farmer who was getting a fair price for his eggs, for his cattle, for his pigs and for everything else that the small farmer produced in the congested areas of this country?

Comment on this

The Minister did not deny that that farmer is suffering.

Comment on this

Does he deny that they represent by far the greater bulk of the farmers of this country?

Comment on this

No.

Comment on this

Does he deny that they represent the bulk of the people of this country?

Comment on this

No.

Comment on this

He cannot deny it because it is true. I ask the Minister to correct me if I am wrong when I quote him as saying that the fact that the farmers have to produce the annuities makes them produce. Does he remember using that expression?

Comment on this

That is right.

Comment on this

What inducement is there to produce in order to pay our debts if the Government creates a situation in which production is made at a loss? The more you produce the more you lose. The more you produce the worse you are. The Minister is quite wrong. The fact that the farmers will have to continue producing their annuities during the course of this economic war will undoubtedly make them dependent upon Fianna Fáil doles, grants and bounties. They will have to come hat in hand to get bounties and doles from whoever they can get them from. If they do not get them they cannot pay annuities, rates or anything else. The Minister may disabuse his mind of the thought that the screw of the land annuities will make them work. They want no screw to make them work. They would be glad to work if they would be let work. They would be glad to earn their livings if they were allowed to earn them. All that the small farmers want is that the Minister, and those who are blocking their path and making it impossible for them to earn their livelihood, would get out of their way; they want no screw to make them work. They paid their land annuities ever since their fathers undertook to pay them, and they wanted no screw to make them work. They would be ready to do it again to-morrow if they were given a chance.

There are a good many more things that I should like to refer to as regards what the Minister had to say on this stage of the Bill. Perhaps it is as well for the dispatch of business that we should await another occasion. There were some things he said that had to be answered now. I think they have been pretty fairly disposed of, and I trust that if he wants to discuss the merits of the economic war again he will wait until the business we now have on hands is disposed of. He must realise that if he is going to get up and draw allusions of that kind across this discussion there are those on these benches who will get up and answer them.

Comment on this

After listening for six days to taunts from the two benches opposite about the economic war, the Minister took ten minutes to reply to them, and he was interrupted about 15 times while he was speaking.

Comment on this

That is a shock to you.

Comment on this

I intend to deal with a few matters. First, we are told that we are issuing a prerogative of mercy at somebody else's expense; that it is out of the ratepayers' pocket the money is coming for the three years' annuities. I grant it, in one way, but against that, what will the ratepayers gain by having those farmers put on their feet? You all know the position around your own constituencies. You know there are farmers there who have paid no rates for eight, nine or ten years, and there is no hope of getting the rates out of them. You all know that.

Comment on this

I, for one, do not know it.

Comment on this

I am not going to stick too many interruptions from you.

Comment on this

You put a question to us.

Comment on this

Put all your interruptions together and make a speech of them, and make it some time.

Comment on this

You will not be able to answer me when I do.

Comment on this

I should love to hear it. As a member of the Cork County Council, I have taken advantage of the fact that farmers were relieved of paying annuities this year. How? To make a settlement with those men who were four, five or six years' rates in arrears; to get them to pay two years' arrears and square up with them on that basis. That was all we could get from them.

Comment on this

That is all you could take from them in any case.

Comment on this

Yes, and we got those two years' arrears of rates out of them and squared up with them on that basis. We were very glad to get it, and very glad that the Minister gave us an opportunity of getting it. It is just the very self-same thing as when in 1924 we were compelled to get a loan to pay a portion of the rates in order that the Land Commission might get an opportunity of squeezing out the land annuities. It is the self-same thing; six of one and half-a-dozen of another. These people now, relieved of that expenditure, will be put in the position that in future they will be able to pay their rates and the ratepayers will gain to that extent. How could the ratepayers hope to get money out of a man who was four or five or six years behind with his annuities? They had not a ghost of a chance of getting it.

Comment on this

Make their successors pay. What about funding the annuities?

Comment on this

That is a different matter altogether. All that goes into the funding arrangement is one year's rates. That is a side of the question not looked into. When these arrangements are made it will mean that a large section of the community, who previously were not able to pay, will be able to pay their rates in future after being put on their feet. We have heard some of the old arguments about the economic war. It is the self-same story over and over again. I think Deputy Davin was right when he said if ever people opposite saw the least semblance or tendency of the economic war coming to a close they would be very anxious to wire to Mr. Thomas to prevent it. They were always ready to have the alarm bells rung whenever anyone made an attempt towards a decent settlement on this question. On all such occasions the alarm bells were rung and warnings given to Great Britain not to settle, and these warnings will be found in the official records of this House. We have seen Deputy Fitzgerald-Kenney jumping up on such occasions and saying, before any arrangement could be made the half-year's annuity would have to be paid over. We had other gentlemen on the benches opposite echoing the same kind of cry. Every bullet fired by Mr. Thomas was prepared, welded and had ammunition packed behind it by Deputies on the benches opposite.

Comment on this

Owing to the inordinate length of the discussion of this section to-day, and yesterday, and the endless repetition of arguments about the economic war I put it to you, a Leas-Cheann Comhairle, that you should accept a motion that the question be now put.

Comment on this

They do not like to hear what we have to say. Some Deputies in this House seem very anxious for the conclusion of the economic war but I will suggest as a special contribution towards that end that Deputy MacDermot should pack up his bag and leave the country.

Comment on this

You will not put him out of it anyhow.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

We are not discussing Deputy MacDermot so I wish Deputy Corry would come back to the section.

Comment on this

It shows the kind of mentality that is behind this Bill.

Comment on this

I am not concerned much with Deputy Dillon's arguments here. He spoke about land taxes and we have been repeatedly told about the 50 per cent. taxes that the farmers are paying. When I came here first in 1927 I used to get an average of four or five farmers coming to me every month asking for a couple of months time to be allowed to pay their annuities. As a result of that I would go across and interview the Land Commission. I would say to them "if you wait until the August fair so-and-so will pay up." To give the Land Commission their due, they always gave time and acted fairly in that respect. In 1928 I had about 20 farmers following me with that kind of request. In 1929 I had about 80 and in 1930 and 1931, during the Recess, I had to come up here every week with a bag full of appeals from farmers who could not pay their land annuities. The value of the farmers' produce was taxed in these years not by 40 per cent., but it was taxed to the tune of £13,000,000, which is the difference between the 1924 and the 1931 prices.

Comment on this

How much are the farmers getting now?

Comment on this

I say that any Deputy who reads cross-Channel papers can see that even the English farmer to-day is not getting anything like for his produce what he was getting then. I quoted extracts from the Scottish markets some time ago for the education of gentlemen opposite but it does not seem to have done them any good.

Comment on this

They are getting 40 per cent. more than we are getting.

Comment on this