Land Bill, 1933—Committee (Resumed).
Contributions 164–332 of 491. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 3 parts.
No. 33 of 1933 ›
I am prepared to lay a level bet with you that if the economic war were settled to-morrow there would not be an increase of 20 per cent. in the price you would get.
Comment on this
Order. It has been pointed out to the Deputy before that he must only refer to other Deputies in the third person. These exchanges in the second person cannot be permitted.
Comment on this
I am referring to a different matter and the Deputy knows it. I am pointing out that there is a Standing Order which says that Deputies must be referred to in the third person.
Comment on this
I regret that I referred owing to interruptions and in replying to them, to Deputies in the second person. But as I was saying, the farmers were ground down year by year in their prices. Prices were falling all the time and have continued to drop. What efforts did we make during these years to give any chance to those farmers in the Free State? It does not seem to be a matter of concern to some people whether you can pay your rates or not or whether you can pay the shopkeeper or not. They do not mind that because they say: "We will make you pay it." That is their cry. That was the cry of the late Executive when they were in office. The result of it is that there are many poor fellows in the country to-day out on the roadside looking over the ditches at their derelict farms on account of that policy.
Apparently it was a crime for a man not to pay his annuities when they were being collected in order to be handed over to Britain, but it is no crime, in fact, it is the advisable and honourable thing, for a man not to pay his annuities now when the money could be used for the benefit of the Irish people. That is the policy outlined by the Opposition week after week. We would like to get at the root of this thing, to get some definite statement about the bargain to which Deputy Davin referred a while ago. Where has that bargain gone to? We were told by Deputy Cosgrave three days before the General Election that the farmers need pay no annuities until 1934 and there would then be a 50 per cent. reduction. What arrangement did he make in that connection? What pledge did he get from Britain to enable him to make that bargain? He was either honest or a rogue. If he was honest in offering those terms to the Irish people, then he must have made some agreement with Britain. It is his duty to hand over that secret agreement to the Executive Council. It might hold some advantage in settling the economic war. Where is that agreement? How was he going to do it and pay the £5,000,000? Was he going to get it out of home assistance, from labourers' cottages or from the old age pensioners? Where was he to get the money if the farmers were not to pay it?
Comment on this
On a point of order. Ought Deputy Cosgrave be referred to as "Cosgrave" and, further, have these questions which Deputy Corry is asking anything to do with Section 12?
Comment on this
Nothing whatever. The economic war is entirely irrelevant to this debate. Further, Deputy Cosgrave should not be referred to as "Cosgrave."
Comment on this
Since the economic war has been ruled out, I do not intend to refer further to it. I would like to emphasise that this section is giving the down-and-out farmer a chance of getting on his feet. That is a thing which any farmer's neighbours would be glad to approve of. If there is any honesty amongst Deputies opposite they will agree that every poor farmer is entitled to a chance. The only person who wants to see the poor fellows mulcted is the old gombeen man who lives in the vicinity and who watches to see if a man is thrown out so that he may snap up his land.
Comment on this
There are not many. The Deputy can have a present of them. I think he already has his share of them.
Comment on this
I think I have put the arguments fairly. If Deputies opposite have any honesty they will demand the production of the agreement that little Willie made before the general election.
Comment on this
I welcome the statement made by the Acting-Minister. He certainly widened the discussion from what was strictly before the House. He mentioned that all farmers were not affected and that some farmers were doing better than before this trouble started. He instanced the case of the dairy farmer. I am sorry some of the farmers from the dairying districts did not take him up on that point. There is a very good representative of dairy farming here. If he were not here I would make an attempt to deal with the matter. As there is a Deputy here who knows the dairying business much better than I do, I will leave it to him to deal with. I do not think it is such an El Dorado for the dairy farmer as the Acting-Minister would have us believe.
The Acting-Minister made a general statement that those farmers who are producing for the home market are better off than ever they were. That is not so. I produce a good deal of stuff. Not an ounce of it was exported in recent years. Indirectly I am more affected than many people who are dealing in live stock. If I had an open field in order to go into details I could prove the statement I am making. To-day potatoes were sold in the Dublin market at 2/6 a cwt. and this is the month of July. The refuse of those potatoes is thrown out because it would not pay anybody to feed pigs, thanks to the economic war. If the Acting-Minister, who lives on the opposite side of the city to me, wants pig feeding I will give it to him at 15/- a ton, which is much better than the offals we were told by the Minister for Agriculture the other day are so valuable, the offals from sugar-beet. I will give him about 20 tons of old potatoes merely for the taking away. They would be useful for feeding pigs. He also stated that the people who are grumbling the most are the graziers. He said that, undoubtedly, they got a knock when the economic war burst on the country; that they had stock in for which they paid a certain price, and that they got a blow when the economic war came and depressed the level of prices of all live stock; but that when they cashed in and went out to buy new stock they got them proportionately cheaper. He did not go into the details, however, of how the economic war works now—that young stock are dearer proportionately than older stock. As a matter of fact, there is an increased export of calves this year over last year because of the discrimination in the tariffs in the ages of cattle. If the Minister's argument about the grazier, or the man who buys stores or weaning calves, were sound, then he would be in as good a position as he was in before the economic war, and perhaps a better position because he would be stocking his land with less capital.
The Minister should apply the principle that he wanted us to accept here one day about the bounties. Just on the question of bounties I will say this: if the grazier and the cattle exporter—they are pretty well one and the same persons—are as well off as they were before the economic war, and it is only the small farmer and producer who is hit, has the Minister not come a long way to the argument put up from these benches here that the bounty should be applied to the relief of the small farmer directly instead of having it filter down from the cattle exporter and the grazier who, the Minister told the House to-day, are better off now than before the economic war? He has made a case for it, unconsciously, perhaps, in dealing with another aspect of this question, but the Minister knows that the economic effect of a reduction in the price of the stuff we have to sell, say, 40 per cent., is not exactly a 40 per cent. imposition on a bullock, or on a heifer, on a cow, or on a pig. It is 40 per cent. reduction on the production of this country and on the raw material of this country. It is a 40 per cent. capital levy on this country. The value of the amount of food, let it be grass or hand feeding, that a bullock will require for six months, has been reduced 40 per cent. If the Minister will only think for a moment he will see the economic force of that. So that, the whole thing has been distributed in that way and no farmer is better off than he was before the economic war, nor could he possibly be. The dairying industry got an artificial fillip and that industry is better off now, or perhaps a little better off, than if nothing were done to it and there had been no economic war, considering the world price of butter.
I do not differ very widely from the Minister when he came to deal with the remission of annuities and said that if we made a good bargain with Great Britain on these annuities perhaps the State should benefit largely rather than individuals who held land —whether bought land or inherited land—subject to a certain annuity. What I should like the Minister to come closer to is the problem that is confronting us to-day and that was contained in and being dealt with in the section of the Land Bill that has given rise to this discussion; that is, that we are paying the annuities in another form to Great Britain. They are leaving our pockets. We have to procure them and when we discharge that liability, either by seizure or otherwise, how can the Deputy Minister in equity come to this House and claim that we should pay 50 per cent of those annuities again? I would not find much in which to differ with the Minister if he showed that we are not paying the annuities at all to England and that that portion of it is wiped out.
Comment on this
Sir, I desire to draw your attention to the fact that there is not a quorum at present in the House.
Notice taken that 20 Deputies were not present; House counted and 20 Deputies being present—
Comment on this
It should not be a question of making a man pay something for land. The case that has been made from this side is that we have been paying too much and more than we were bound, in equity, to pay— more than our contractual liability. I think the Deputy Minister has been somewhat shaken in the beliefs he held prior to this discussion. This discussion, obviously, has made an impression on him and shattered little idols he had set up to direct his line of conduct in these matters. It might be as well to leave those things to work themselves out in the mind of the Minister, or perhaps, the minds of the Ministers, rather than to push them through an open door. I will not deal with the question of whether the Minister admitted that this 50 per cent. which you cannot call a land annuity, is not being paid to liquidate any land purchase debt. The machinery is provided in this Bill and in the Land Bond Act complementary to this Bill and which must be read with this Bill, and the Land Bond Bill must be read with all the Land Acts, and all the revenue accruing from this 50 per cent. alleged land purchase annuity will find its way direct into the Exchequer. Provision is being made also for the redemption of that 50 per cent. of alleged annuity to anybody who wants to redeem his annuity. The redemption price will go directly to the Exchequer so that it has all the characteristics of a tax and none of the characteristics of a land annuity. Why should it have any of the land purchase annuity when these land purchase annuities are finding their way to the destination they always found their way to, only that the method of collection is somewhat different? The case put up here is that while these are being paid by the farmers, no other authority should ask to collect them either in whole or in part. I am sorry the Minister is not here to address himself to that point. He came very much closer to that than any Minister, including the Deputy Minister himself, that I have heard speaking in this House. He appealed for a better atmosphere, a quieter and calmer atmosphere, to discuss this matter. That calmer atmosphere will be always here if he would add to that a saner atmosphere, but from this side we are not going to support the paying of the debt twice, even a fractional payment—I will not say a vulgar fractional payment.
Comment on this
I do not intend to prolong the debate as I agree with Mr. McDermot that it has been prolonged, but the Minister has rather challenged us in regard to the dairy question. I have no intention of getting myself ruled out of order but I should like to deal with one of the statements of the Minister.
Comment on this
When a proper time did occur in this House in discussing the question of butter bounties the Minister for Agriculture definitely promised that a day would be given for a discussion of the whole dairy question and the Minister would make a statement. That day has not yet arrived nor have we heard anything more about it. We are prepared to discuss it with the Minister for Agriculture any day he likes but certainly not with the Minister in charge of this Bill who knows nothing whatever about the subject.
Comment on this
With regard to Amendment 39, I notified the Ceann Comhairle that there were certain amendments consequent on Section 23 which I did not propose to move.
Comment on this
I assume this relates to annuities under the Acts of 1881 to 1891. I should like to know what is the position of a tenant on whose holding there is an annuity in respect of a drainage rate. I do not know if such annuities have been consolidated with land purchase. In the Land Commission I heard of some cases where they were consolidated and I am wondering how it is proposed to deal with them in this particular section.
Comment on this
I am not in a position to say whether there are such annuities and I will have it looked into, as I am sure there is no intention of differentiating.
Comment on this
I move amendment 59:—
In sub-section (4), (b), line 19, to delete the word "paid" and substitute therefor the word "payable."
The position as regards that section is that the Land Commission take the sole right to collect annuities and the sub-section as worded provides that the owner is to receive only the amount of money paid to the Land Commission. The hardship I see in that case is that the right is taken away from the owner to collect himself, and the only money he is entitled to receive under the sub-section as it stands is the money actually paid to the Land Commission. The right is in the Land Commission to collect, therefore, and in them alone, and the money can be collected because they have the machinery to collect it. Nobody else has and nobody else can collect it. My amendment is that they should get the amount of the money legally collectable and payable. Under the sub-section they will not get it if the Land Commission did not collect the full amount. The owner has no remedy—he is deprived of his rights of collection himself and at the same time he is deprived of his right to the amount. I think the difficulty there ought to be met because the right to collect is taken away and the only thing he can receive is a sum paid to the Land Commission. I think the Minister could meet the point by accepting my amendment or by making some other amendment; perhaps he could think of a better one to meet the difficulty.
Comment on this
I imagine this amendment is out of order but the position with regard to payments of interest in lieu of rent is there are 151 tenants who are liable for payment in lieu of rent and they are collectable in half-yearly instalments amounting in the aggregate to £358. They are a very small class. As the law stands the Land Commission are only bound to pay over what they actually collect. What will happen now is that this payment will be reduced by 50 per cent.; 50 per cent will be payable by the Government and if the other 50 per cent. is collected it will be paid over.
Comment on this
If it is not collected the owner has no remedy. Will the Attorney-General consider the point and if he sees that we are right will he introduce an amendment on the Report Stage?
Comment on this
I do not think I can give such an undertaking.
Comment on this
The owner is deprived under the section of his right to collect himself money that is collectable and still he has no remedy if the Land Commission fail to collect.
Comment on this
If the Attorney-General is correct that the Land Commission is only liable for the amount of interest in lieu of rent that is actually collected, then, of course, his position is logical, but that is not the view I take. I thought that the Land Commission was liable for the actual interest whether it was collected or not. Has the Attorney-General any reference?
Comment on this
Under the 1909 and the 1903 Acts it is also collectable as far as I know and the Land Commission is liable for the full amount of interest.
Comment on this
I do not think there is any difference in the provisions under the later Acts, the 1896 Act is the basis of the later Acts. I have not got the Section with me.
Comment on this
If the Attorney-General says that the Land Commission is liable only for the amount of interest in lieu of rent that they collect, it is news to me. I always thought that the Land Commission had to pay the full amount of interest whether they collect it or not, and I would like to be sure on that point.
Comment on this
I think that I am in a position to assure the Deputy on that point. Perhaps the Deputy is confusing that with payment in lieu of rent.
Comment on this
That is under the 1923 Act. I am talking of interest in lieu of rent.
Comment on this
Will the Attorney-General look into the matter on the Report Stage if he is satisfied that our view is right?
Comment on this
I am certain almost that interest in lieu of rent is payable to the full. It was collected on a receivable order before vesting in the 1903 and 1909 Acts and paid direct to the owner of the lands until such time as it was vested. I am certain that the full amount was always paid.
Comment on this
I take the view that what Deputy Hogan said is right. Will the Attorney-General introduce an amendment if he finds that our view is correct?
Comment on this
I do not think so. The number of cases is very small.
Comment on this
I submit no. This is a proposal that money which is legally payable and collectable should be paid to the persons who are entitled to receive it. There is no proposal that a State should make good any deficiency in funds. It is only for the State to ensure that the money collectable should be handed over to the persons entitled to it.
Comment on this
The Ceann Comhairle decided to hear the Deputy on the point as to whether it was or was not a charge on the State funds and not on the merits of the amendment and I cannot say that the Deputy has convinced me that it would not come as a charge on State funds if this amendment were accepted.
Comment on this
That is quite clear. State funds would be liable in the event of failure to collect.
Comment on this
Assuming that it was admitted that they did not; as the law stands at present the Land Commission before this Act——
Comment on this
Before the Deputy goes further, there is a Standing Order and as the Deputy is not a member of the Executive Council he is not entitled to move an amendment that will impose a charge on State funds.
Comment on this
I think it is existing legislation that is doing it. If I am right, what you are doing here is you are taking a charge off the State that used to be on it. If it is out of order to move an amendment that that charge shall remain I have nothing further to say. I think you are taking a charge off State funds that was there already.
Comment on this
I can assure Deputy Hogan that he is wrong in his view.
Comment on this
The Deputy had not convinced me that it would not ultimately come as a charge on State funds.
Comment on this
I wish that the Attorney-General would go into the matter before the Report Stage and if we are right would introduce an amendment himself. There is an alternative course here that people who are deprived of the right of collecting money that is due to them by an Act of this legislature might be given the choice that if the Land Commission do not collect them they ought to get the right to collect them themselves. There are alternatives to the course suggested here.
Amendment ruled out of order.
Comment on this
I move amendment 79:—
In sub-section (3), (a), line 6, after the word "land" to insert the words "which was" and in line 7, after the word "or" to insert the words and figures, "was, on the 28th day of June, 1933, vested in the Land Commission."
Comment on this
I move amendment 80:—
In page 13, before sub-section (4) to insert a new sub-section as follows:—
(4) The next preceding sub-section of this section shall apply to rent or interest on purchase money notwithstanding that the price at which the Land Commission is prepared to sell the holding in respect of which such rent or interest is payable in an enhanced price owing to expenditure by the Land Commission on improvements, but the said sub-section shall not apply to any rent or interest on purchase money payable wholly in respect of expenditure for improvements sanctioned specifically after the 28th day of June, 1933, for the improvement of a holding or parcel of untenanted land, nor to so much of any rent or interest on purchase money (payable partly in repayment of such expenditure) as is attributable to such expenditure.
Comment on this
Is it clear that the term "rent" there includes rent payable under lettings for temporary convenience? Sub-section (1) says that "the following provisions shall have effect in relation to proceedings by the Land Commission," and so on. This is a point similar to what I made before. Most of the tenants who have not their holdings vested are holding under lettings for temporary convenience. Are these covered?
Comment on this
We are satisfied that these are covered.
Comment on this
I move amendment 88:—
In paragraph (g), lines 13 and 14, to delete the words "by the sub-tenant."
Comment on this
I move amendment 90:—
In paragraph (h), line 15, after the word "holding" to insert the words "the Land Commission shall apportion it between the separate holdings into which the holding has been divided and."
Comment on this
I move amendment 91:—
In paragraph (j), page 14, to delete all words from the word "so" in line 50 to the word "with" in line 52.
Comment on this
It enables the Land Commission to apportion the funded annuity or the undivided portion of annuities into the amounts applicable to the parts in occupation of the sub-tenant.
Comment on this
I move amendment 94:—
In sub-section (1), line 39, after the word "arrears" to insert the words "or an amount equal to three times the amount of such annual repayment, whichever is the less."
Comment on this
I move amendment 103:—
In sub-section (1), to insert at the end of the sub-section the following words "and such purchase annuity shall be deemed to be the first or original annuity referred to in Section 5 of the Finance Act, 1923 (No. 21 of 1923).
Comment on this
What is the significance of that? What is the point of bringing in Section 5 of the Finance Act of 1923? Is it for income tax purposes?
Comment on this
The Deputy will remember that Section 5 of the Finance Act of 1923 was introduced to meet the position which was created by the annuities. There was formerly income tax payable on land purchase annuity or the rateable value, and the situation arose under a case which was decided in the High Court. The insertion of that would make the income tax payable on the original purchase annuities.
Comment on this
I move amendment 104:—
At the end of the section to add a new sub-section as follows:—
(4) In this section the expression "purchase annuities" includes annual sums and additional sums payable under either Section 9 or Section 27 of the Land Act, 1931.
Comment on this
Sub-section (1) is clear enough that the annuities will be fixed in the future as in the past. Sub-section (2) deals with the question of the percentage of the annuity to be paid in the future. The sub-section specifies that the annuity shall be either 45 per cent. or 50 per cent of the full amount of the old annuity. That is clear enough. That the future annuities will be 50 per cent or 45 per cent. of the actual annuity fixed. Then it makes a certain exception. That exception is in regard to annuities fixed under Section 11 of the Land Act of 1927. That is one of the Acts which deal with fee farm grants and long leases. There are other sections and other Acts which deal with fee farm grants. In fact fee farm grants are dealt with now to a very great extent under Section 44 of the Land Act of 1931. They are dealt with if the rent of the lessee or grantee is not less than a third term judicial rent and I suggest to the Minister that that particular section of the Act of 1931 should be quoted here as well.
Comment on this
No, only one clause of it is repealed. Section 44 is a very important section. Section 44 will be in use after this Act is passed. It is clearly the intention there to give a certain benefit to fee farm grantees and lessees. That was clearly the intention, because Section 11 of the Act of 1927 is quoted, and it gives those benefits to people who purchased under Section 11. That section is now practically out of date. It is out of date we will say. All the fee farm grantees can now apply under Section 44. I suggest that it was clearly the intention of the Minister to give those benefits to a fee farm grantee or a lessee who purchased under Section 44 of the Land Act of 1931, and I would suggest for the Minister's consideration that there should be inserted there "otherwise than under Section 11 of the Land Act of 1927 and Section 44 of the Land Act, 1931." That is only a minor point. The real point I want to draw the attention of the House to is that under that section every annuitant in the future will be paying only half the annuity that is fixed on his land, with one exception, and that exception is the annuitant who owns land in fee simple, who sells that land to the Land Commission, and who repurchases that land.
Comment on this
Or part of it. That is a most extraordinary exception to make, and I want to put this matter very seriously to the Ministry, because I think they are doing a very grave injustice, and the amount of money involved is practically nothing. I know farmers who since 1931 purchased fee simple land. They purchased 50 or 100 acres. They purchased it when times were fairly good, in 1921, 1922 or 1923, and they purchased it to some extent with borrowed money. They hold that land now, and have to pay interest on the overdraft in the bank. This Bill does not relieve them in any way—good, bad or indifferent. Some of them are men who own other small farms, on which they live,—maybe 20 or 30 acres—and they have 50 or 100 acres of fee simple land which they bought with borrowed money. That money is, to a great extent, owing still. It is open to them, perhaps, to offer that land to the Land Commission. The Land Commission might buy it, and resell it to them. They would resell it to them unless it was required for the relief of congestion. I do not mind what safeguard you put in to empower the Land Commission to hold land, if it is offered to them, for the purpose of relieving congestion or any other legitimate purpose under the Act. Suppose they resell that land to the owner, he pays the full annuity. He is the only annuitant in the country who must pay the full annuity on his farm.
Comment on this
Certainly. That is the reason I dealt with that point first. I admit that there the lessee or fee farm grantee gets all the benefits. The point I suggest is that as well as quoting Section 11 of the Land Act of 1927 you should quote Section 44 of the Land Act of 1931, because that is the section under which most grantees and lessees repurchased their lands. I admit that if you do that, so far as grantees and lessees are concerned my point is absolutely met. They get all the benefits. Now I am dealing with another class. That is the class who are not lessees or grantees, but who own land in fee simple, small holdings of 50 or 60 acres which they purchased recently. It was open to the Land Commission to buy that land from them, and resell it to them. If it does resell to them the full annuity is fixed, and they will be in the invidious position of being the only annuitants in the country who are paying the full interest and sinking fund on the full purchase money.
Comment on this
They will have the purchase money in their pockets.
Comment on this
In fact they have not the purchase money in their pockets. Not at all. That is, if you like, a valid point, and we will examine it from that point of view. What is the position? The full purchase money will go to the banks—to the National Bank, the Bank of Ireland or the Munster and Leinster Bank. The money will go there. Not one penny of it will go into their pockets in most cases. For the last eight or nine years they had to pay 6 per cent. interest on that money, while the annuitants had to pay only 3½ per cent. They get no relief. They are not big landowners at all; they are simply small and middle-sized farmers such as you will find in Wexford, Kilkenny, and in Waterford to a great extent, with 50, 60 or 70 acred farms. They bought that land to a great extent with borrowed money, perhaps long before 1921 or 1923. For the last nine years they have been paying interest on that money. I will come back to that section which we dealt with before, it says:
Where the owner of land applies to the Land Commission in the prescribed manner for such order as is hereinafter mentioned and satisfies the Land Commission that such land—
(a) is substantially agricultural....
It is substantially agricultural;
(b) is in such owner's own occupation;
It is in such owner's own occupation.
(c) is used and cultivated by such owner as an ordinary farm in accordance with the proper methods of husbandry;
It is. That land exactly satisfies all the regulations set out in that section. If you like to safeguard the Land Commission by putting in this clause well and good, but I do say that that particular class, who are ordinary farmers, who have been paying 6 per cent. interest on the money since perhaps 1920, and who are getting no benefits at all under this Act, should not have taken from them the very small benefit which you might give them under the general scheme of the Act by reducing the annuity to half. As a rule they are very enterprising farmers. They bought a bit of land for their sons or for themselves. They hold it now, and have been paying interest during the last ten years. They get none of the advantages which you are giving the annuitants under this Act, but you are taking away the advantage which they might get from the Land Commission by putting in that clause.
I put that very strongly to the Minister. Why should you discriminate against them? What is the reason for discriminating against them? The amount of money involved is relatively small; there is a big number of them, but they do not own a big lot of land. They should, at least, get that benefit from the Land Act. I know people who have come to me and said: "Look here! We have a small bit of land, 50 or 60 acres. We are getting absolutely nothing. We are working this land as ordinary farmers. We cannot complain about our 6 per cent. interest; we have to pay it every year and pay a bit of the principal as well." Why should they not be considered?
Comment on this
The Deputy realises that in the ordinary process of the acquisition of untenanted land the Land Commission bought out a landlord who had a large amount of land and sold a portion of it back. He has paid the full value and he gets an advance from the Land Commission to purchase. He gets the full value of his land. Why should the annuities be halved in the case of the landlord?
Comment on this
Might I not say the same thing in the case of the tenant who buys his landlord's interest in the land? He bought it under the Act of 1903 and he bought it at 2½ per cent. interest. Where are the landlords you mentioned? For every case of the landlord who is going to be resold his land, there are 50 cases of what would be ordinary farmers—men with 20, 50 or 100 acres of land. You are ruling them out because who do not want to bring in what you call a landlord. I think that is most unfair. If the Land Commission approached this question from the point of view of trying to solve it you could get a section similar to Section 18 giving preferences, where the land is substantially agricultural, where it must be in the owner's occupation, and where it must be used and cultivated by the owner as an ordinary farm in accordance with the proper methods of husbandry. You have all these fee-simple farms. I am concerned with a very big number of fee simple owners, farming as ordinary farmers and who got no concession from any Government for the last ten years. Imagine their position; they have got absolutely no concession.
Comment on this
Is not a bank debt a completely different proposition? There are bank debts not alone on fee-simple farms but on annuity farms as well. Bank debts raise a very much bigger question. But these people have no rents or annuities to pay.
Comment on this
That is a very technical way of putting it. These are people who bought their lands with bank money. While they have no payment to make to the Land Commission, instead of 15/- and 16/- an acre they are paying 35/- and 40/- an acre. They are paying that undoubtedly. They never felt they would get anything from the Land Commission or the State. They were self-reliant people, and they did their work. After all you have your interest in the working farmer, and these are the best type of working farmers. I am not insinuating anything revolutionary. The Land Commission have always the power to buy and resell to the farmer. Is that admitted?
Comment on this
They have done it if you like for what you would call the landlord. I find it hard to define a landlord of the kind you mean. Why should they differ from that other class? Previous acts did not make a distinction between landlords and farmers. They gave power to the Land Commission to do this. They exercised this power, and, to a great extent, for any type of fee-simple owner giving employment, tilling his land and so on, and who had not too much of the world's goods. I am asking you to extend the principle. Remember that and realise it! I am asking you to extend this principle. What you are doing is this: You are limiting it in fact. You are taking certain powers now in regard to all annuitants under this Act, and after taking this power you are going to make exceptions against a certain class. That is my answer when you say I am raising a bigger question. I do not think I am. I am asking you to take these powers in regard to a class you could have dealt with already. I am not insinuating any new legal principle or opening up any liabilities for the Land Commission that they have not already. I am asking you why are you limiting these powers you are now taking by excluding a certain deserving class.
Comment on this
If that is the attitude there is no use in my talking.
Comment on this
It seems to me always that when an owner got an advance from the Land Commission to enable him to purchase his land he got, as a fact, money at a very cheap rate. He got it at just 3¾ per cent., and that was a very great benefit. In many cases owners of estates got considerable sums, under one of the Acts up to £20,000. The effect was to put at the disposal of the landlord, an owner of a demesne, say, who might be in difficulties, money to the extent of £20,000 at a much less rate of interest than he could borrow from the banks. I am not impressed by the suggestion that the Deputy is making that we should go much further than we are going, and put at the disposal of the owner of land money at half of 4½ per cent., for that is roughly what it would mean. He argues that a good many of these fee-simple owners are burdened with bank debts. They have borrowed money from the banks, as I said in my interruption, but when they sold to the Land Commission they had the purchase money in their pockets, and they can at least do this with the purchase money: They can go to the banks and either considerably reduce their debts or wipe their debts out altogether. It is true that in substitution for bank interest they will have annuities, which will be payable to the Land Commission. What they will be able to do is this: Many of them will be able to reduce their bank liability, which at the moment is at the rate of 6 or 7 per cent. I do not think it is much less than 7 per cent. They will substitute for that liability to the bank, a 4½ per cent. payment to the Land Commission, and that is a very considerable advantage.
I suggest to the Deputy they are not at all in the same position as a tenant, although he makes a very ingenious case. We did consider this particular case, and it was deliberately excluded considering all the circumstances I have mentioned. Even though you do suggest that the small man should be considered and should get some benefit, I suggest that when he gets the purchase money into his pocket, and is enabled to reduce his liability to the extent of that amount, and has only to pay 4½ per cent. afterwards, he is doing quite well, and that it is quite unreasonable to ask the Government to give him any further benefit. Certainly I do not follow the case of the Deputy that he should be put on the same level as annuitants who are now to have their annuities cut in half. I see the same objection to this amendment as against the amendment of Deputy O'Sullivan.
Comment on this
You say he is doing quite well. Of course, the whole basis of this Bill is that the farmers are in considerable difficulty now and cannot pay their annuities. For that reason all farmers' annuities are to be reduced by half. There is sufficient agreement between the Government and the Opposition to see that you must, at least, give that assistance, but we say you must go further. It is agreed that as a concession to the bad times, at the moment, they must be reduced by half. But here is the only man who gets nothing. The Attorney-General mentioned the man who gets £20,000. How many of them are left in the country? They were big landowners who got advances up to £20,000. Are you dealing with a situation like that just now? If you think there should be a limitation to the amount of the advance put it down in the Bill. Make it £2,000, the amount you mentioned in another section of the Bill. There is no question of £20,000 now. I suggest it is unfair to deal with the case I put, by dealing with it on this basis that only one class of persons will get benefit. I think that is most unfair. You can rule a man out if you like by putting any limitation you like into the Bill. You can rule him out by making £2,000 or £3,000 the limit of your advance. You can further ensure that you are dealing with the particular class that I am concerned to deal with by putting in provisions regarding a residential holding or working the farm as an ordinary farm. I am not arguing the case of the man with £20,000 worth of land. I am arguing the case of the comparatively small man.
Take, as an instance, the cases of two men. One bought a holding subject to an annuity. He purchased it, to some extent, with borrowed money. He is very lucky. His arrears are either funded or wiped out and his future annuity is reduced to half. The other man bought fee-simple land, also with borrowed money. They are exactly the same type of farmer, but under this measure they are treated differently. One gets all the advantages and the other is penalised. Why should that be done? What I would like the Attorney-General to do is to drop definitely the case he is making of the man with £20,000 worth of land. Put in any provision you like that will rule him out, and that will ensure you are dealing with the ordinary farmer.
Comment on this
I did not intend to make that a typical case. I merely instanced it.
Comment on this
The Attorney-General's argument rested largely on that type of case. He said such a man would get cheap money and should be content. Any man with £20,000 worth of land who could get cheap money ought to be content. Let us come down to the ordinary farmer in exactly the same position as his next door neighbour, who is subject to an annuity. The man living next door and subject to the annuity is getting these concessions. Why should he? On what basis is he getting the concessions? Is it that he is a better farmer? I hold that he is no better farmer. He got borrowed money also. Why should not the type of man I mention get the concessions as well? He is as good a type of farmer; he is hardworking. Even if you do as I ask, he will not get anything like the same concessions with regard to arrears. His concessions will only be in the future. I cannot understand why the distinction is being made. The Government can put in any preliminary conditions they like so as to ensure that these particular concessions will go to the type of farmer for which they are intended, the man who is getting them as an annuitant.
Comment on this
In dealing with this point, has the Deputy considered the position of persons who redeemed their annuities?
Comment on this
Ought not all those amendments be taken together?
Comment on this
Is it the desire of the House to deal with all analogous cases or wait until various amendments arise?
Comment on this
The suggestion from the Government Benches is that we should deal with this and Deputy O'Sullivan's amendments together, amendments 161-2-3.
Comment on this
If the principle is accepted, it might be necessary to have an amendment to the section.
Comment on this
It is better to have the matter discussed now. If a division is challenged, it can be taken on the section. If the section passes, we may take it that other amendments of that description fall.
Comment on this
The suggestion apparently is that we should discuss the principle I have raised on Section 19, and also amendments 162 and 163.
Comment on this
The point that occurs to me is that all these farmers originally belonged to one class, the tenant farmers of this country. Some are purchased annuitants. They are paying annuities in the process of purchasing their holdings under the various Land Purchase Acts. Others of them acquired fee-simple land. A variety of circumstances has produced a state of affairs in which you have two neighbours who, under the provisions of this Bill, will receive entirely different treatment. The man who borrowed money from the Government and is repaying it by way of annuity is getting a very substantial concession. For exactly the same purpose and under very similar circumstances a man who was a little more enterprising than his neighbour bought a piece of land to add to his holding and he borrowed money from the bank to do it. He is going to get no concession at all. As I understand the reservation that is made here, he is going to be debarred from applying to the Land Commission to acquire his holding and pay him the purchase price of it, and then allow him to rebuy it by way of annuity under the advantageous terms described in this Bill.
I am concerned with another type of person, of whom there cannot be very many in this country. I refer to the tenant purchaser who redeemed his land annuity at the earliest possible moment he could. When the Land Acts were passing through, one of the great difficulties was to finance them. It was then deemed the patriotic thing, if you were in a position to do it, to redeem your land annuity so as to relieve the burden of borrowing as much as possible. It was a difficult thing to extract money from the British Government to finance these operations. The less money it was necessary to dig out of the Government, the less public credit that had to be pledged, the easier it was to get the job done. I think the Attorney-General will confirm me when I say there was a time when it was considered in the best interests of the country that any farmer in a position to redeem his land annuities ought to do it.
A great many well-meaning men did that. If these men said "We are not prepared to do any more than our neighbours are doing", they would be getting benefits under this Act. I think I am right in saying that; but simply because they were anxious to help and to do their part in speeding up land purchase and facilitating the operation of the Land Purchase Acts— they stepped into the breach and paid up all they owed—they are going to get nothing at all. They are going to get no concession at all. I imagine that a concession similar in principle to the one advocated by Deputy Hogan should be made available to these people also so that they might get the benefit of this Bill. These people made this patriotic gesture although we are told nowadays that in those days there were not any patriots at all. Of course, in the 19th century people were able to prove their patriotism through their pockets. They are not always quite so ready to do so now. These persons, however, who did give a proof of their patriotism through their worldly goods, now find that, having done that, they are called upon to pay, not a half of their annuities now but the whole of their neighbours' annuities, because, remember, that these unfortunate people are all sharing the burden of the economic war.
Comment on this
I do not want to. I will not make another reference to it except to ask that, considering these people's case, the Minister will bear in mind that whatever burden is falling upon the tenant purchaser, this class to which I refer is sharing that burden too. I do not think it is a very large class. I think they are a peculiarly deserving type of people and that they are entitled to expect some special recognition from the State after the fight is over. They were the very best type of people in the land war. They were ready to take all the knocks in the fight and, when the time came that they could help by redeeming their land and pledging their worldly goods, they were willing to do that. All I ask is that there should be as much consideration shown to the men of the 'eighties and the 'nineties who pledged their property in order to help on the good work as the Government is so anxious to show to the industrious farmers of 1927, 1928 and 1929. On the same ground, Deputy Davin asked for consideration for the evicted tenants and I join with him on that. I am even willing to go two years more than the Deputy.
Comment on this
I was only drawing an analogy between the evicted tenants, who were the best quality of those who fought in the land war, and the persons of whom I speak here, who were the best quality of the annuity payers and who were willing to lend a hand with their worldly goods after they did their part in the land war itself. I ask for special consideration for this deserving class of people.
Comment on this
Deputy Hogan's suggestion on this section is covered by the amendments which Deputy O'Sullivan has down to insert two new subsections later on. One is to the effect that where the annuity on land has been redeemed and the land is held by an ordinary farmer and farmed according to the proper methods of husbandry the Land Commission may purchase such land and re-sell it to the owner. The other is that where land is held in fee simple by an ordinary farmer and farmed according to the proper methods of husbandry the Land Commission may purchase it and re-sell it to the owner.
Comment on this
Yes. Where it is held by an ordinary farmer and farmed according to the ordinary methods of husbandry the Land Commission should be empowered to purchase and re-sell it. Automatically, land in fee simple is vested in the Land Commission on the appointed day, and if they do not want it they have to offer it to the owner for sale.
Comment on this
I wonder would the Minister agree to have the principle raised by Deputy Hogan discussed on these amendments rather than on the section?
Comment on this
All fee simple land is automatically vested on the appointed day in the congested districts. As a matter of fact, the Land Commission do not appoint a day unless they want the land. Where they do declare that they want the land—it may be a large demesne or a small demesne or even a small farm—they sometimes give the owner the option of purchasing portion of the estate back, but if we are going to do that all over the country it is going to be a big strain on the public purse. It is another way of advancing credit to farmers. There are several types of farmers besides the fee simple farmers who are going to get very little out of this. You have the fee simple owner and you have the man who redeemed these land annuities. He has no annuity to be halved. The people who were fortunate enough to purchase under the first Acts have now very little annuity to be halved. The principle we are going on is that the Government is trying to do something to meet the needs of the situation. The man with a heavy annuity to pay is in a worse position to meet life than the man who has a very small annuity or none at all to pay. If Deputy Hogan wants advances made to farmers to pay their bank debts in respect of lands they purchased, I think, if that is going to be argued, he could hardly stop at that. The Land Commission would have to make advances to farmers to repay other bank debts or shop debts or any other debts.
After all, the Land Acts are concerned with land annuities and we are only concerned in this Bill with halving land annuities, not with making advances such as the Credit Corporation does and if Deputy Hogan wants us to make advances—that is what it amounts to—at 2½ per cent. interest, to enable people who borrowed in order to purchase fee-simple land, it should be discussed on another day and on another occasion and if he says then that we will have to face the whole general principle whether or not the Government should make advances for 50 or 60 years, whether we should give long term loans to enable farmers who are in difficulties to pay their debts and recoup the Government by annual sums over 60 or 70 years——
Comment on this
Does the Minister say that it will be necessary to insert Section 44 as well as Section 11?
Comment on this
Legal advice in the matter is that it is not necessary, but if it is, we will go into it again.
Comment on this
I should like to say a few words in connection with this particular amendment and to point out specific cases in connection with this particular amendment. I bought a farm myself on which there was a land annuity, and, like many more farmers, I went into the bank to buy it. A neighbour of mine who is an equally good, hard-working farmer purchased a freehold land at a big price. He says now, and rightly so, that he is getting no benefit from his land, on the same terms as the man who is paying a land annuity. I stress the point that he paid a bigger price. Would it not be possible to do something for a man like this who is as good and as hard-working a farmer as anybody? I bring this question before the Minister in the hope that he will see reason in connection with the amendment. I have put it very briefly. I am getting some concession myself and I should like to see my neighbour getting something too, no matter what his brand of politics may be. I do not think the Government considered that and if they did they would be willing to do justice. If there is any advantage or remission it should, in my opinion, be distributed as evenly between all sections of the farmers as possible.
Comment on this
It was agreed, sir, in your absence, that amendments 62 and 63 would be discussed on this particular section. Deputy Hogan has already put the case clearly and fully before the House. I must say that there would appear to be a misunderstanding on the part of the Government in this matter. This particular section which we are dealing with— Section 19—relates to the remission of land annuities. Remission of land annuities is for one reason, namely, to give the farmers some relief and whether a farmer is an annuitant or a holder in fee-simple or a fee-farm grantee, he is still a farmer, provided as Deputy Hogan said, he carries out his work as an ordinary farmer as set out in the section—"where his holding is substantially agricultural or pastoral or partly agricultural or pastoral in character and is in such owner's own occupation and is used and cultivated by such owner as an ordinary farmer in accordance with proper methods of husbandry and (d) is subject to an annual payment to which this section applies." In other words, this section is in the Bill with one object, namely, to relieve the farming community in this country of something or another. Some people say that the farmers should be relieved by de-rating, others say by halving the annuity and others say by removing the annuity entirely. As a result of this section, a number of the farmers who carried on their work in that particular way as ordinary farmers and who have to take the risk of the ordinary farmer—I will not mention the economic war, because I am sure everybody is tired hearing about that, especially the Government.
Comment on this
Then I will answer here if you like—there is no battering ram associated with the O'Sullivans. It is necessary that this relief should be given to every class of farmer. There may not be necessity in the case of the landlord type or the £20,000 farm but the Government by an amendment can reduce the relief to certain limits. I think it is equitable and proper that the relief that is given to the annuitants should also be given to persons who possibly five or ten or 20 years ago redeemed their annuities on their farms, or the farmer who bought in fee-simple. After all, they suffer the same. The desire is, I take it, in this particular section to relieve the farmer, and I think that it is regrettable, and I am sure undesirable, that one particular section should be selected for treatment, and another important section omitted.
I do not think that I need stress this case, either to the Acting-Minister or the Attorney-General. Both know very well what are the particular conditions of the two types of those with whom the amendment deals. After all, why should the hard working farmer who redeemed the purchase annuity whether he had the money himself or whether he got it from America, or whether he paid it out of his farm, be now punished? Why should he be now punished to the extent that his next door neighbour, who is paying an annuity and continues to pay, gets off one year and is relieved of half the annuity? Why should the person buying in fee-simple, as everybody knows at a very high sum, provided as I say, that he carries out and fulfils these particular conditions, not get the relief that the Government is giving?
I put in these amendments with the desire that the Government themselves would realise the importance of the question. Why should not all the farmers be relieved, big and small? You can limit it if you like. You can ensure they are farmers, even the fellow looking over the hedge, as somebody said at the Second Reading. But I consider it is inequitable and unfair that one particular section should be relieved while another gets no benefit though their annuities are paid for by me and by non-farmers. Can we not extend it somewhat by taking the example, let us say, of an Act introduced in this Oireachtas for the purchase of houses? Why should I have to continue to pay rent while my next door neighbour, who has not paid it, is forgiven? Why should I be subject to a certain penalty simply because I have to pay rent? I do not think it is proper or legal or just. Why should I who have paid my rent regularly pay for my next door neighbour who has not paid at all, and why should I have to suffer simply because I paid? I think that the Government ought seriously to consider these amendments, and I would especially ask them to allow the particular section to pass, but to consider the matter before the Report Stage, so that amendments could be brought in giving relief to the good farmers of the country.
Comment on this
It is rather amusing at this stage to hear some Deputies sympathising with farmers who have no annuities at all to pay. That is what this proposal is. A landlord who got 300 or 400 acres and a mansion house is now going to get money from the Land Commission and he is going to pay them back by instalments. I met a man a few months ago and he told me he was paying four rents. I was surprised, and I made it my business to find out how. I found he bought a farm for £350. Then under the Ashbourne Act he became a tenant to himself. He got £350 from the Government at the time and he paid an annuity on the whole thing. He was then paying an annuity to the Land Commission. He was paying the rent to the landlord. He was paying a tithe charge and another charge. He was a tough boy. He turned round then and got his brother married on the farm. He got £300 fortune and put it in his pocket and went off, leaving his brother to hold the sack. There were quite a lot of them did that. Are you going to have a repetition of that here?
This Bill is a Bill to relieve the farming community who have heavy annuities to pay. It is rather amusing to find amendments brought in by gentlemen who refused unfortunate farmers relief, farmers living near cities who happened to get farms on which there were fairly good houses, with exorbitant rents, and prevented them from participating, or benefiting, in any of the Land Acts they brought in. It was only on Tuesday last that I had to stop over in Cork to appear before a judge to get time for one of those kind of men to pay. He got none of the benefits of the Hogan Act. He was outside the pale. Then we have the other type, the tenant who is being brought in now under this Bill, the man who happened to have land near a town or a city who did not benefit at all under the Hogan Act. He was excluded from it and that man had to pay for ten years. He was kept under the hammer and did not get the benefit of the moratorium given the tenants here for the last 12 months. He was kept out of all these benefits. It is rather amusing to see those gentlemen opposite who excluded these men from the benefits of the Land Acts now coming in looking for benefits for people who have no annuities at all to pay. The men who did not benefit before ought to be brought in now, and I do not see how the Minister could give relief to gentlemen who pay no annuities at all. Had these tenants to become tenants to themselves and be paid out of taxpayers' pockets? That is what these amendments mean.
As for Deputy O'Sullivan's allusions, my grandfather was an evicted tenant, evicted for a half year's rent. He had to fight it, and it took him 20 years to get back with my father's help and I get very little satisfaction from the sneers I get from tuppeny-halfpenny lawyers. I cannot see any reason why the taxpayer should be asked to bear any burden for gentlemen of that description. We are anxious to give the ordinary working farmer relief, and we are forgiving him 50 per cent. of his annuities; we are giving the benefits of the Land Acts to the farmers shut out under other Land Acts. Mind you, there are quite a number of them. I brought up a list of 130 here, of all classes, shapes, descriptions and forms, during the last month, farmers who were shut out under the various Acts. We are anxious to bring them in now, to give every farmer who is paying rent relief and by Jove we are not going to give the fellow who is paying nothing a whack out of the taxpayers' pocket. The Government is not going to him, and saying, in its generosity, "here is something for you," and let him get away with the loot. I have seen farmers in my constituency who held farms on which there was no annuity, and I saw them come in under the 1903 Act. They came in and the mother made the son the tenant and turned around and put the coin down in her pocket. I think it is time to bring in those who are excluded under the 1923 Act, but apparently Deputy Hogan wants to keep them out. We shall see that they get the benefit, and I advise the Minister not to have anything at all to do with the kind of gentlemen that the people opposite want to bring in in this amendment.
Comment on this
I move amendment 106:—
In paragraph (d), page 18, line 6, after the word "shall" to insert the words "where the holding is registered under the Local Registration of Title Act, 1891, or where the registration of the holding is compulsory under the said Act."
The registration of lands was not effected in many cases in the past, as it was not compulsory. This amendment makes it mandatory.
Comment on this
Section 21 provides the amount, duration and recovery of the funding annuities. Does this deal with the rate of interest to be charged on the funded arrears?
Comment on this
That is interest at 4½ per cent. I wonder does the Minister think that it is reasonable in all the circumstances to ask these people to pay 4½ per cent. on these funded arrears? Are not the terms stiff? It is admitted by the Minister and by the Government that these people were driven into arrears by circumstances of peculiar distress. The presumption is that generally they could not help getting into arrears, that it was not their fault. Many of them were encouraged to get into arrears, and they were told not to bother to pay, that arrangements were to be made in good time to fund the annuities. They are now to be debited with the annuities and not only that, but 4½ per cent. interest over a period of 50 years. Does not the Minister think that that is pretty stiff? Could he not see his way to reducing that rate of interest?
Comment on this
I agree with Deputy Dillon that it is pretty stiff. I think anything over 1 or 1½ per cent. is pretty stiff to pay for money if you want it for a certain purpose, but if you size up this rate of interest with the interest which was payable by people who got loans from the Agricultural Credit Corporation you will see that it is not so high. I grant the Deputy it is pretty high. I should like to see money for purposes of general development lent at a much lower rate of interest and I hope it will. But in the present circumstances, where the only loans available to farmers are at 6 per cent., I do not think that this particular rate of interest is too high. We are not saddling the farmers with this loan if they do not want to accept it, or if they can pay it off. They can redeem it any time they like. If a farmer has a sum of money in the bank at a low rate of interest, it will pay him much better to pay his land annuities or to pay these funded annuities. By doing so he will be getting a return of 4½ per cent. on his money rather than allowing it lie in the bank at 1 or 1¼ per cent.
Deputies must remember that there are quite a lot of farmers who did not pay their annuities, not because they had not the cash, but because they would rather use the money in other ways. Anybody who wanted to apply for this money in the ordinary way for 50 years would have to go through a lot of legal formality in the case of the Agricultural Credit Corporation. If a man wants a loan from the Agricultural Credit Corporation, he will have to prove title, undergo certain costs and prove to the corporation that he is an agricultural worker. This is a much simpler way of getting a loan, and I think, on the whole, this will operate to do a lot of good throughout the country. Generally speaking, annuities that were not paid by people who could pay them were utilised to a good purpose. Some of these farmers built extensions to their houses; some of them bought stock, others implements and others again got into tillage. The money that would have gone to the Land Commission in the ordinary way was used to capitalise these activities. It was a good way to give a general loan to whoever wanted it. While I should like to see the interest at a much lower figure than 4½ per cent., this is as low as can be fixed at the moment.
Comment on this
The Minister has mentioned the Agricultural Credit Corporation. I should like to say that our Party has already taken steps to ask the Minister for Finance to make money available through the Agricultural Credit Corporation at a much lower figure than it is available at present, and I would say that the figure that we had in mind was not more than——
Comment on this
The Deputy is not discussing the Agricultural Credit Corporation. He has made a passing reference by way of illustration.
Comment on this
The figure we were aiming at, as regards the rate of interest to be charged by the Agricultural Credit Corporation, was 3 per cent. or, at the outset, 3½ per cent. We had hoped that this Bill would operate to make a beginning which would help the farmers to pass through what is admittedly a period of stress.
Comment on this
I submit that all our sympathies should be, not so much with those who have to pay 4½ per cent. interest, but with those who paid their annuities in the last three years. These are the people who really deserve consideration. Many of them had to part with their cattle. Many of them are greatly hampered, because of the straits into which they were driven in the last two or three years. They have received very rough justice, and to think now that we are giving fine justice to those who have been lucky enough to evade the obligation to pay is going too far. I think the people in arrears are getting off very well. All our consideration should be for those who have made sacrifices and paid their annuities in the past few years.
Comment on this
Would the Deputy agree that the same consideration should apply to those who have housing loans?
Comment on this
In paragraph (b) of this section it is stated that this loan will be repaid in 50 years at 4½ per cent. interest. Is there to be any sinking fund in respect of the arrears?
Comment on this
It will be roughly 1/- in the £. That will be about 5 per cent. It has not been worked out yet.
Comment on this
Will it work out at 4¾ per cent., that is 4½ per cent. plus ¼ per cent. for the sinking fund, or will it be a ¼ per cent. or a ½ per cent. in respect of the sinking fund component of the loan?
Comment on this
So that if a man is £100 in arrears now he will have added to his annual payments a sum of £5 and in 50 years he will have discharged the whole of it. In other words for this £100 he will pay about £250.
Comment on this
If somebody lent a penny at the time of Noah he would be entitled now to ten million billion pounds.
Comment on this
I assume that this section has been drafted for the purpose of adapting the sections in the existing Land Acts relating to the repayment of land annuities to the funding arrangements under this particular Bill?
Comment on this
I should like the Minister to explain that section a little. I am not quite clear about the actual machinery which it is proposed to adopt in regard to annuities under the Ashbourne Act. The wording of sub-section (1) is not very clear in that respect, and I should be glad if the Minister would clarify it a little so that it will be intelligible to every Deputy in the House.
Comment on this
The situation is that the decadal reduction period comes at various dates. In order to enable the Land Commission to make up their books we are taking the date as the 1st May, 1933.
Comment on this
Even if it is to come in the future. We are taking the date as the 1st of May, 1933.
Comment on this
As the Minister is dealing with this I should like to know whether, supposing the third decadal period does not expire for, say, two or three years, is it covered by this sub-section as well?
Comment on this
So it does not matter when it expires? It is brought within the ambit of the section?
Comment on this
Instead of the Land Commission having to make up their books in future when the decadal date occurs, for the simplicity of book-keeping we are taking it that this decadal date occurred on the 1st of May.