Land Bill, 1933—Committee (Resumed).
Contributions 333–491 of 491. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 3 parts.
No. 33 of 1933 ›
What is actually going to happen is that all the Ashbourne tenants are going to be given their three decadal reductions on the 1st of May?
Comment on this
From the wording of sub-section (3) of Section 5 it appears to me that there is a new charge imposed on the Guarantee Fund. I am not aware that arrears of annuities under the Land Acts from 1881 to 1889, or 1891, when the Guarantee Fund was first instituted, were a charge on this fund. Under this particular section it is now proposed to make the unpaid land annuities under those Acts a charge on the Guarantee Fund. That would be a new drain on the Guarantee Fund for the future. I should be glad if the Minister would explain that point.
Comment on this
The Deputy has explained the intention of the sub-section. The annuities under the Acts of 1881 and 1885 were not covered by the Guarantee Fund, so it is simply to secure uniformity. They are all covered now by the Guarantee Fund.
Comment on this
I do not think the Guarantee Fund will be called upon to any great extent under these Acts.
Comment on this
How was the Land Bond Fund recouped in respect of the Acts of 1881 and 1885 if there were arrears outstanding?
Comment on this
All collections under the Land Acts prior to 1923 were paid into the Land Purchase Annuities Fund.
Comment on this
There was no Guarantee Fund in respect of the Acts of 1881 and 1885. How was that fund filled?
Comment on this
I move amendment 108:—
To delete sub-section (2).
This is an amendment from the Department of Finance. At the time the Bill was being drafted the Department of Finance had not taken the decision to recoup the Guarantee Fund by introducing a supplementary estimate. Deputies will remember that we have introduced and passed in this House three different supplementary estimates in relation to the Guarantee Fund. Since the last one, for £1,420,000, has been introduced and passed by the Dáil this sub-section is not necessary. It is, therefore, proposed to delete it.
Comment on this
Am I to infer from the Minister's statement that the Guarantee Fund has now been completely recouped of all the advances made out of it to the local authorities?
Comment on this
Is there not still a balance of £400,000 odd which has to be paid into the Guarantee Fund?
Comment on this
No. It has been completely recouped. We had three supplementary estimates, and the Guarantee Fund has been completely recouped. The Government did not collect the second gale of 1932 or the first gale of 1933. In order to pay the bondholders under the 1923 Act, the Guarantee Fund had to be recouped out of the Central Fund, which was merely a book-keeping transaction. The Minister for Finance paid it into the Guarantee Fund and paid it back into his own pocket again. It was legally necessary to do that in order that local authorities should not be called upon to pay it. The whole idea was we wanted to keep the Guarantee Fund in being to cover any deficiency that might arise in respect of the halved annuities, and, since we were keeping it in being, we had to go through the form of paying the moneys out of the Central Fund into the Guarantee Fund in respect of the land annuities of 1923.
Comment on this
That point arises in the earlier operations in regard to the remission of annuities prescribed in this Bill. The Minister suggested this was done at the expense of the local authorities. It was subsequently suggested the Government intended to provide money from the Central Fund wherewith to recoup the local authorities for the sums collected from them, to keep the Guarantee Fund in funds. Would the Minister say now, before we depart finally from the question of the Guarantee Fund, if the Government has already provided, or intends to provide, money to recoup the local authorities for the £260,000 approximately of which they have been deprived by the terms of this Bill in so far as they remitted annuities more than three years due?
Comment on this
The Government will provide funds, from time to time, to pay the local authorities the sums which are being repaid to them by means of funding the annuities over a period of 50 years.
Comment on this
The situation was this. We are funding arrears, and forgiving arrears, amounting to between £700,000 or £800,000.
Comment on this
Yes, we are forgiving about £250,000. I will come to that later. The sum we are not forgiving, that is being funded and spread over 50 years, has been withheld from the local authorities for a period of, say, ten years. The local authorities have had withheld from them over a period of ten years a sum amounting to about £1,000,000. That is admitted. Some arrears were paid off but some were accumulating. The sum was roughly the same at the end of the period as at the beginning. The moneys that will come to the Exchequer by means of funding the annuities will be paid to the local authorities. The Government recognise it would not be fair to the local authorities to keep them out of that money for 50 years, and the Minister for Finance will take steps to pay the local authorities that £600,000 in advance of the period of 50 years over which he will be recouped. With regard to the £250,000 referred to as forgiven altogether, we are treating that as a bad debt. It is a bad debt. A number of Deputies and a number of county councils—I may say all of them—want to have this debt treated as a bad debt and have it wiped out, so that these people will get a chance of finding their feet and be able to pay their rates. At the present time you have a number of farms which are simply derelict. The occupier is simply a squatter. He owes land annuities and he owes rates. He has not the heart to pay his rates because he is up to his ears in debt with his land annuities. If his land annuities were reduced to an amount that he could pay it would give him heart and he would pay both land annuities and rates. He seems altogether in a desperate situation at present. That man cannot hope to meet the arrears of the land annuities that have accumulated, and he holds on to any cash that comes into his hands and pays nobody, neither the shopkeeper nor anybody else. On the whole, I think it is a good thing to forgive this £250,000 and treat it as a bad debt.
Comment on this
I hope the Minister will not be disappointed in his high hopes. I can see this tenant rushing out to the rate collector anxious to welcome him in and pay his rates. I am afraid someone will be disappointed and so, perhaps, will the rate collector, but it is clear that the remission is being made. Let us not comment upon it. A remission of £250,000 is being made at the expense of the ratepayers, not at the expense of the Central Fund. It is necessary to get that clear because, remember, that Deputies in the Minister's own Party were under the impression that that was not the case. In fact I was taken sharply to task for suggesting that it was the case. I want to have it clear, before we pass from Part III, that the remission of £250,000 arrears of land annuities, which accrued due prior to 1930, is being made by this 1933 Land Bill at the expense of the ratepayers of the country and the local authorities, not at the expense of the Central Government.
Comment on this
That may be right or wrong but at least we have it definitely established that it is a fact.
Comment on this
Do I understand from the Minister that the funded arrears will be paid at some time to the local authorities?
Comment on this
From time to time. There has not been a definite decision as to whether it will be one year or five years but they will be paid from time to time. That is a matter that can be raised on the Budget statement each year. I am not in a position to state anything more definite at the moment.
Comment on this
Will the Minister make a promise that at least a substantial payment will be made before another Budget? Would the Minister give any indication of hope for payment in the current year? The Minister knows that things are in a bad way.
Comment on this
I do not think I can say anything more but perhaps the Deputy might hope for next year.
Comment on this
I am appealing to the Minister to try and have something paid this year because as he knows a pound when you are hard up is worth five pounds when you are not. A payment would count for a terrible lot this year. We may be worse, but I hope not. We will live in hope. I will ask the Minister not to make his answer a final answer.
Comment on this
I beg to move amendment 109:—
In sub-section (1), lines 49-50, to delete the words "if and when the Land Commission think proper to" and substitute the words "to issue a summons in the prescribed form requiring the defaulter to appear before the district justice and show cause why a warrant in manner hereinafter mentioned should not be issued to the county registrar and if on the hearing of such summons the district justice shall so determine, the Land Commission may thereafter if and when they think proper.
Comment on this
Before the Deputy begins to address himself to this amendment, might I inquire from the Minister if it is the intention of the Attorney-General to be present while this section is being discussed?
Comment on this
My amendment has the effect of giving the District Justice a much wider discretion than in the past in relation to Land Commission cases. To that extent it will reduce the costs very considerably. This section was discussed at very great length during the Second Reading debate. Many of the legal Deputies dealt exhaustively with the main objections to the inclusion of a section of this character in a Land Bill. This proposal was under consideration in the Land Commission for a great many years. The proposal was submitted to myself on at least three different occasions. After consultation with the ex-Attorney-General and with other legal experts, I decided to turn it down. I was advised, first of all, by the ex-Attorney-General that it was entirely unconstitutional, contrary to the spirit of the Constitution, and I was later advised that, even assuming it was adopted and put into operation by the then Government, it would bring no tangible relief whatever to the unfortunate defaulters.
I had a personal dislike to this section from the beginning, because I felt it was really an inhuman piece of legislation. If the Land Commission are about to take proceedings against a defaulter in any part of the country for the non-payment of annuities, it is only right, just and equitable that the defaulter, if he has any case to enter against the proceedings, should have an appeal to some court. Consequently I insisted, during the whole time I was in the Land Commission, that the defaulter should have the right of appeal to the courts. In the discussion on earlier amendments to this Bill the Minister displayed great anxiety to preserve all the legal formalities which have been maintained in the Land Commission for a great many years past. In fact, in certain directions he was inclined to go very much further than any of his predecessors in order to safeguard the interests of the vendors and owners of land. I appreciate his anxiety to preserve what the tenant farmers have won through the efforts of the people who fought their battles in the past.
In this particular case the Land Commission is, or should be at all events, in identically the same position as is an ordinary business man or trader who may be suing for the non-payment of a debt. There is no reason why the Land Commission should be treated differently to the ordinary business man or trader. A business man or trader, if he has to take proceedings for the non-payment of a debt, has to go through the courts. I could never quite see why the Land Commission, if they have to institute proceedings against a defaulter, should not proceed in identically the same way. I realise perfectly well that there has been a difficulty in the past in collecting annuities from a certain class of people. We have heard a great deal here about the difficulty in getting a certain class of tenant purchaser to pay annuities. I admit there has been difficulty in that respect. It is inevitable there should be a difference amongst tenant farmers. There are some very industrious men, keen men, who avail of every possible opportunity in order to improve their position and standing in the country. There are others here, just as there are in other countries, who are indifferent and inclined to be negligent. They inevitably get into arrears, not alone in respect of Land Commission annuities, but in respect of the payment of rates and shopkeepers' accounts.
It has always been a problem in the Land Commission to find ways and means of dealing with these people. In any event, the problem never reached such proportions that it was necessary to take the extreme step which is proposed here in order to collect instalments. Deputy Fitzgerald-Kenney referred to the fact that already, under the Act of 1891, it is possible for the Land Commission, even assuming a defaulter may be in arrear for one gale, to apply to the High Court for a decree. If that decree is granted, then the Land Commission can proceed to execute it and secure possession of the farm. I do not think that the Land Commission, in the last ten years, at all events, has ever applied to the High Court for such a decree.
It is quite unnecessary for the Land Commission to take such powers as are proposed in this Bill. The Land Commission have all the powers they want to proceed against defaulters. If the Minister examines the files relating to Land Commission defaulters, he will find that 95 per cent. of the cases are cases of genuine default, where the unfortunate annuitant is unable to pay. Why is it necessary to introduce a section like this for the purpose of taking such extreme powers in order to deal with the other 5 per cent. who may, or may not, be in a position to pay? At all events, in their cases there may be a certain element of doubt as to whether they are able to meet their liabilities. This section will, undoubtedly, inflict a grave hardship on many unfortunate Land Commission defaulters. It will inflict a hardship on the type of person willing and anxious to pay his annuity, but who, owing to the circumstances of the last 12 months or two years, is unable to meet his liabilities. I do not think that the Minister could have selected a more unfortunate time for the purpose of introducing a section of this character into a Land Bill.
In the past, as the Minister knows perfectly well, before the decrees were granted by the district justice, he invariably went into the individual merits of each particular case and, in the majority of cases at all events, when he was satisfied that the defaulter was not in a position to meet his liability at the moment, he invariably gave time or he made an alternative arrangement to enable the defaulter to pay by instalments, probably extending over a period of 12 months. The State solicitors, even before the case went into court at all, made arrangements themselves with these defaulters and agreed to accept payment from them by instalments extending over a certain period of months. All that is to be set aside by this section in the Bill and instead of the reasonable, humane way in which these defaulters were dealt with in the past, we have this drastic section introduced which will give a certain official in the Land Commission the right to issue a warrant to the sheriff and, on the receipt of that warrant, the sheriff must proceed out to the place of residence of the defaulter and seize whatever he has on the land. It was stated here that the Revenue Commissioners and the rate collectors have the same powers, but the fact is that the rate collectors have not exercised those powers and the Revenue Commissioners do not exercise them and have not exercised them for some time past. Why is it necessary to take these drastic powers? The Minister professes in this Bill to be treating the annuitants, who are not in a position to meet their liabilities, generously, and yet, although in other sections of the Bill, according to his own statement, he is treating them very generously—particularly in regard to the funding of the arrears and so on—he proceeds in another section to mete out the most drastic treatment to these people that it is possible for a Government to mete out.
I think there is no justification whatever for introducing a drastic section of this character into the Bill, and I would ask the Minister, in the name of ordinary humanity, to introduce an amendment before the Report Stage which will do away with the drastic character and nature of this section. I am sure the Minister realises as well as any other Deputy in the House the sort of abuses that may arise if this section is passed into law. He must realise it as well as any other Deputy in the House. I wonder would the Minister feel perfectly happy in the knowledge that this section can be operated by an official of the Land Commission—I do not care how highly placed that official may be. Civil servants in this country are, undoubtedly, a wonderfully efficient body and, there is no question at all about it, this State owes a great deal to the civil servants in the country, but does the Minister for one moment think it is right or fair or just to the ordinary people of this country that such extraordinary power and authority as is undoubtedly embodied in this section of the Bill should be placed in the hands of one individual civil servant, or even two or three civil servants? I feel that it is unjust and, although I am not a lawyer, I feel that it is contrary to the whole spirit of the Constitution. I was advised three or four years ago, by the ex-Attorney-General, when this proposal was submitted to me for consideration, that it was contrary to the spirit of the Constitution and that no Government could possibly stand for a proposal of this character. I feel that it is unjust and utterly unreasonable. I feel that it is entirely unwarranted by the circumstances of the time and I feel, furthermore, in view of what has happened during the last 18 months— happenings, due largely to the Government, whether through good or bad judgment I am not going to say at the moment—but in view of all these happenings I think it is really an insult to the decent and honourable purchase tenants of this country who are prepared to meet their liabilities, if they are in a position to do so, to introduce a section of this kind into the Bill and to impose upon them such a threat as is embodied in that section.
Comment on this
Before the Minister speaks, I should like to ask him if the words in line 45, "an additional sum," are correct, or is it a misprint? They do not appear to make sense.
Comment on this
"An additional sum" is simply the name of one of these annual payments. There are various payments. The Deputy will have noticed that in an earlier part of the Bill relating to the revision of annuities there were sections almost identical, such as revision of interest in lieu of rent, revision of purchase annuities payable to the Commissioners of Public Works, and so on. There are various payments to the Land Commission. This additional sum is a payment under Section 28 of the 1923 Act.
Deputy Roddy's speech on this sheriff's clause reminded me of what used to happen before modern anæsthetics came into fashion. Before that time, when there was an operation to be performed, one of the people engaged for the operation was a man to keep the patient engaged in pleasant conversation. Deputy Roddy's amendment to put this thing back to the District Justice is, I think, of a somewhat similar character. I would agree with Deputy Roddy and with the other Deputies who are violently opposed to this section if there was any fear that the Land Commission were going to disturb a number of people in the wrong. The fact of the matter is that at the present time there is hardly ever a case of the Land Commission demanding payment from a farmer in the wrong.
Comment on this
I do not wish to interrupt the Minister, but surely it is inevitable that mistakes will arise. I believe that you have in the Land Commission as efficient a Department as you will find anywhere in this country, but no matter how efficient it is or how well it is manned, it is inevitable that mistakes will occur.
Comment on this
I grant that it is inevitable that a mistake may occur and if there were going to be many of these mistakes I would feel very different about introducing a section such as this. Supposing that a mistake does occur and that the Land Commission send out a warrant or a demand note to, say, John Murphy in a certain townland, and that John Murphy is the wrong man and does not owe the money, what will happen? John Murphy, when he gets the warrant, will communicate either with the Land Commission, in the first instance, or, if he does not communicate with them, surely he will tell the sheriff, when the sheriff sends him a notice, that he is not the man who owes these annuities or that he does not owe the amount he is charged with, as the case may be.
The one person who will be aggrieved under the section so far as I can see, will be the sheriff because the sheriff will have to deal with annuitants in the same way as the State Solicitor had heretofore. The sheriff will be the negotiator. He will try to extract the land annuities with the least possible friction from the defaulting annuitants. All that happens in 999 cases out of 1,000 when defaulting annuitants go to court is that the justice simply signs his name to the Land Commission warrant certifying that the amount is due and the defaulter has to pay a few pounds more simply for getting the district justice's name at the bottom of the paper as well as the name of the Land Commission. There is nothing more than that in it. Supposing we take it that a farmer gets a notice from the Land Commission that annuities are due by him. If he should not have got it, surely he will write to the Land Commission to say that he does not owe them any annuities or that he does not owe all the annuities charged up to him. After all, there is sufficient education in the country. There is practically no household left in which there is not somebody who can read and write and the Land Commission are pretty well aware of the fact that people in the country can read and write, because they are bombarded with letters of all sorts and descriptions. The tenant will write to the Land Commission and say that the assessment is wrong. If he does not write when he first gets the warrant from the Land Commission, he will do so after he gets the six days' notice. If he does not do it then he will surely do it after the sheriff in his own locality sends him a notice. If there is a man who will not do it even then, and who simply lets the thing go through until the sheriff sends out the bailiff, then if the Land Commission has made a mistake that man has a right of action against the Land Commission. The Land Commission in these circumstances will take good care that there are no mistakes made because I am sure if the Land Commission made a mistake and took cattle from a man who owed no rent the costs given against them would be very heavy indeed.
Comment on this
Damages, if you want the legal phrase. The damages that would be given against the Land Commission for taking a man's cattle wrongfully would be very heavy. As I say, I do not fear any injustice under this section. If there was any great danger of injustice being done or any great danger of disturbance at all we would not have brought it in. I think Deputies who are opposing it are unduly alarmed.
Mr. Dillon rose.
Comment on this
On a point of procedure, is it possible for anybody but a lawyer to talk on the section?
Comment on this
The situation created by this section reminds me somewhat of the situation that might arise if you put a two-year-old child sitting on the floor with a delicate chronometer and a hammer and then waited to see what would happen. Eventually, after fiddling with the chronometer for some time trying to get it open and to find out what was inside, the child would resort to the hammer and that would be the end of the chronometer. The Land Commission are impatient with the ordinary process of law in this country. They cannot see why, if they want to collect any sum from 6/8 up to £200 from a citizen of the State, they should not grip him by the throat and squeeze it out of him. There is to be an end to all this nonsense about going into court and proving that the money is due. When they say it is due, it is quite enough and let the defaulters pay up. Of course, that is the rule of law that prevails in the African jungle. When I think that my neighbour owes me something, I cut a club and start after him, and if I can catch him I beat him to the ground and strip him of whatever skin is tied round his middle. Civilisation has, however, laid down that there should be another means of settling differences as to our liabilities one to the other. It has been generally accepted that it is desirable to have an impartial third party to decide a matter of that kind on any issue joined between individuals.
Comment on this
President de Valera has been dancing the "can-can" all over Europe and America calling for the interposition of a third party between two States who are at variance as to their respective claims, one from the other. That is all right so long as it is a matter between Great Britain and Ireland but when it is a matter between the Land Commission and Pat Murphy——
Comment on this
——not at all, it is no longer necessary. Once you set out, to establish in this country the principle that any body of civil servants, no matter how exalted a body they may be, have a right to abrogate the duties of the judiciary there is no knowing where it will end. The Revenue Commissioners have extraordinary and, in my opinion, scandalous rights. The rate collector has extraordinary rights. Now we are going to extend the principle and confer this right on the Land Commission. What do we want the courts for at all? Why not get rid of them? One of the most essential functions the courts have to discharge in this country is to stand between the individual and the State. The most formidable antagonist one can have is the State. Whatever hope there may be of inducing a fellow-citizen to compromise in a matter of litigation there is no hope that you will get a Department of State to do so. It is the most powerful antagonist that an individual citizen can possibly have. There is no individual in the State against whom the citizen requires as much protection from the courts as he does against a State Department. Remember that if you once admit the principle that a State Department should be given this right, it is not going to stop here. Other State Departments will want it. There are people in this country who do not understand the meaning of the word "liberty". They never understood it and I do not think they ever will understand it.
Comment on this
I do not think the Deputy had better draw me on that question, because I saw enough liberty on the streets of Macroom last Sunday. There were people there to look for it, people who got it, kept it, and secured it. If the Deputy would like a description of it I would be very glad to give it to him. In the course of the proceedings I may say that we wiped the Square of Macroom with 80 supporters of the Deputy's Party, and before we could secure liberty of speech or liberty of any kind in Macroom that day, it was necessary to wipe the Square of Macroom with 80 of the Deputy's supporters, and to put them up a side street behind the cordon of police.
Comment on this
Never mind whom we had with us. We had enough with us to do that. That is what I mean by liberty. When I am dealing with the Deputy's supporters, there is only one way of dealing with them, and that is to wipe the Square of Macroom with them. I cannot wipe the Square of Macroom with the Land Commission.
Comment on this
I take it that I would not be in order in discussing the differences this country had with Great Britain and other foreign countries since 1798?
Comment on this
I cannot adopt those methods towards the Land Commission and, therefore, it is very necessary, if we are to maintain the principle that the body to interpose between the individual citizen and the Department of State shall be the courts that this section should not pass. It may be argued that in this particular case, it does not make very much difference. The principle is now at stake and it is for this House to say now whether that principle is to be adopted. If it is, it is not going to stop here and this precedent will be up-cast to us again and again. What is the excuse for this —that the costs imposed on the people by these proceedings are out of all proportion to the sum of money that is to be recovered? I quite agree. Law costs in this country are preposterous. They are far too high and, in my opinion, are operating to deny justice to the people who stand in greatest need of it. If the Minister will prevail on his colleague, the Minister for Justice, to introduce legislation or, preferably, to set up a committee with a view to examining the whole question of law costs in this country, I shall do everything I possibly can to support him. I quite agree that law costs are too high. They ought to be reduced, and the law ought to be made available to the humblest in the land. That is not what we are doing here. We say that if the poor people are to go to the courts they will have to pay so much that it will cripple them. That is not a good reason for keeping the poor out of the courts. Nobody wants the protection of the courts more than the poor. Let the costs be cut down, and let the courts be thrown open to them. Do not let us meet them on the threshold and say: "The gentlemen who own these institutions demand too high a fee to permit of your entering here." Our job is to bring down the price of admission, so that the poorest man in this country can go into the courts and get justice from the richest man or the most powerful Department of State.
People talk about the Land Commission never making a mistake. I know a case in which the Land Commission switched receivable orders between two men with the result that A.B. had the receivable order which was right for C.D.'s land and C.D. had the receivable order which was right for A.B.'s land. Under this Bill, the sheriff could march down and seize A.B.'s property because he refused to pay annuities that were due on C.D.'s land. As it was, when they made an attempt to do it, the man was in a position to go into the court and explain to the district justice that although, apparently, he owed this sum, for this peculiar reason it was not due at all. He was being asked to pay annuities on another man's holding. It was a case in which a father had sub-divided his holding with the consent of the Land Commission between his two sons and new receivable orders were issued but in some peculiar way, they were switched, so that while the Land Commission very rarely makes mistakes, like everybody else, they can make mistakes. Therefore, I suggest to the Minister that instead of interfering gravely with the whole system of legal administration in the country and the rights of the poor people to go into the courts for justice, he should insist that the Executive Council should ask the Minister for Justice to set on foot an inquiry immediately to reduce law costs in this country so as to make the law available to the poor. If he does that, he will achieve the purpose set out in Section 27 much more effectively and, besides, he will do a useful public service and if the name of Fianna Fáil is associated with the reduction of law costs in the country, it will not go down to destruction altogether unwept, unhonoured and unsung.
Comment on this
Everybody who knows Deputy Dillon and who has listened to his speeches and, particularly, the speeches he has been delivering in this House since the last general election, knows that no Deputy is more capable of working himself into a fit of rage whenever the rights and liberties of lawyers are challenged. Deputy Dillon is much more concerned with the rights, the liberties and the fees of lawyers than he is with the question as to whether defaulting annuitants should be called upon to continue to pay the highly excessive fees they have been called upon to pay by the Cumann na nGaedheal Government in the past. The Deputy waves his hand and talks about the courts being called upon to stand between the citizen and the Government of this country. I wonder how the Deputy could so conveniently forget having voted so recently in this House for a section of a Bill which gave this Government the power by retrospective legislation to take from the servants of this State moneys they had no legal right to take from them. The Deputy has gone away. He cannot, of course, hear that and he does not want to hear it either, I am sure, but I invite his Leader who is left with one follower in this House if he speaks in this debate, to justify the action of Deputy Dillon and to compare it with the plausible appeal he now makes.
Comment on this
So far as I can recollect, it is only quite recently that the lawyer Deputy came into the House. I am not sure if he was here when Deputy Dillon started his speech.
Comment on this
I was here all last week, when the Deputy was away on a fruitless mission.
Comment on this
I am supporting this section of the Bill with the greatest possible pleasure, realising as I do that it is going to obviate the necessity for defaulting annuitants in future to have to pay the highly excessive fees for recovery of the sums due. We had the Minister for Justice on the Second Reading debate making a statement to the House which proved conclusively that it cost 19/11 to collect a sum of 16/1 in a case in which the annuitant had not, presumably, been brought to court. I can quote a case, and I can produce the receipt for Deputy Vincent Rice or any other lawyer Deputy, who may defend his colleagues in the profession on an issue of this kind, showing that for the collection of a sum of £5 1s. 5d. the State solicitor charged a sum of £1 12s., in a case in which the annuitant had not been brought to court, and in which a friend of the poor person concerned had sent the sum due to the Land Commission direct four days after the expiration of the six days' notice. I am sure many Deputies could quote similar cases. It is only necessary to learn about a few of them in order to justify the arguments in support of the section as it stands, and in opposition to the amendment. If Deputy Roddy speaks again, I would like to hear from him, or from Deputy Fitzgerald-Kenney, who I know is anxious to jump up to justify the amendment, what is unconstitutional about the section as it stands. Deputy Roddy said it was entirely unconstitutional, and that when he was in charge of the Land Commission he was so advised by the ex-Attorney-General. Can we hear the arguments of the ex-Attorney-General to prove that?
Comment on this
The Deputy will have an opportunity of speaking, and it will be a pleasure to hear him justify that statement.
Comment on this
I gave it in one sentence. Judicial acts to be constitutional must be performed by judges, and not by officials of the Land Commission.
Comment on this
I do not like to engage in any argument with Deputies who are lawyers, but I think even a lay Deputy could answer that very quickly, by referring to certain actions of the late Executive in regard to the Public Safety Acts that were passed in this House.
Comment on this
Is the Deputy defending the power of the sheriffs? I am not prepared to agree with the Minister that it is impossible for the Land Commission to make mistakes. I have a distinct recollection of listening to a question being raised in this House on the adjournment, by ex-Deputy White who, at one time represented Donegal, and he proved conclusively that during the régime of the late Cumann na nGaedheal Government, people were prosecuted and decrees given against them in court for annuities which had been paid previous to the issue of the civil bills, or in some cases before the cases went to court. For that reason I would like to hear the Minister developing a little further the argument why the Land Commission should get this power. Are we to understand that they will only proceed further when they are perfectly satisfied from reports received from Land Commission inspectors, or from other persons, that the amount was due in a particular time, that they are perfectly satisfied the person could pay at a particular period, as a result of reports from reliable officers? When speaking later will the Minister state under what circumstances the Land Commission will proceed to issue a warrant as defined in this section? Apart from that trivial point in connection with this section, I say, in view of the limited experience I have of the costs charged for the collection of annuities from people who, in some cases could and did not, and invariably in cases where people could not pay, I have no hesitation, between the amendment and the section, in strongly supporting the section.
Comment on this
I should like, if I may, at the start, to deprecate the needless introduction of personalities, of which Deputy Davin gave us an example. The suggestion was that Deputy Dillon supported this amendment, and was against the section, as it stands, because he happens to have legal training; the suggestion being practically that he was looking after his own interests in doing it. I think that is a suggestion the House should not tolerate. It is becoming increasingly common, and it is certainly a most undignified and improper attitude for Deputies to take up. Undoubtedly the suggestion was there, that when Deputy Dillon spoke of the liberty of the citizen, that was being infringed, as a whole, by the section as it stands, the reply of Deputy Davin practically was: "You are looking after your own profession, after your own class, and you do not care twopence about the people".
Comment on this
Was the Deputy here when Deputy Dillon made allegations against members of this Party?
Comment on this
I am speaking of what Deputy Davin said now. The mere fact that a man knows something about law has certainly no bearing on his being able to speak on the legal aspect of the matter, or even on the constitutional aspect of it. I am not aware that Deputy Dillon is a lawyer in the sense that he practises. I do not know whether he is or not. I mention this in his particular case, owing to charges of that kind being levelled across the House. I can quite well understand the attractiveness of the section as it stands, from some points of view, to the Minister, to the Department and to the Government. When I say attractiveness I do not necessarily mean it in an objectionable sense. I can quite understand this consideration. We know that the Department, the Government and the Minister can in this way claim that a certain amount of money will be saved to people who are proceeded against. Undoubtedly that might be one of the things that makes this attractive to the Government. There are other reasons still that make it attractive to the Government. I suggest that it is precisely in that very attractiveness the danger of this section consists because, though Deputy Davin has the greatest possible pleasure in supporting it, I noticed that in the last couple of weeks he had the greatest possible pleasure in supporting things that cut away fundamental rights. He had the greatest possible pleasure in supporting that. In reality, it does cut away the ordinary rights of the individual citizen. That was the sole reason why this proposal, having been considered, as has been indicated, by the late Government, was rejected by it. We realised that what could be said against it was much greater than what could be said in its favour. That is the reason it was rejected. It was a solid reason for rejecting it.
When you deprive—as you are practically depriving in this particular case—the ordinary citizen of his right to the intervention of the court, I suggest that you have to put up a much stronger case, and that a much greater crisis would have to arise than has been indicated in the present case. The mere loss of money is not sufficient to do away with the principle that this section does away with. It is because the amendment tries to restore these primary rights to the individual that we are supporting it. I understand quite well how this could make an appeal from some points of view. That is the danger of it precisely. What you are doing, and what has been evident from many speeches here, the whole trend has been "sweep away the judges. They are bound up with red tape. Government Departments are much quicker, much more efficient, and less expensive." That is the line taken up, not merely on this particular matter, but throughout this Bill. If you look at it from one point of view there is a good deal to be said for it, but, remember, it is depriving the individual citizen unnecessarily of the protection of the courts. There is not sufficient reason for doing that. The tendency of Government Departments will inevitably be in that direction. If it is done here in the case of the Land Commission, I do not see how you are to stop short there, and why other Governments should not be given the same powers, why the private citizen should not be given them, or the ordinary shopkeeper, whose books are sometimes kept as carefully as those in the Land Commission. It would save expense in the ordinary case of private debt collection.
Why is not that power being used? I understand that it is a power that was at one time in existence but was swept away. Examples have been adduced of the power, theoretically, at all events, in the hands of rate collectors and in the hands of Revenue Commissioners. But it has been pointed out that this power has to a large extent become dormant. What use is made of it in practice? If use is not made of it in practice, is not that proof that the sense of justice of the community is against the practice and against legislation of that particular kind? At all events, this was power that was there always. What are you doing here? Introducing something for the first time, and apparently not merely for the purpose of having it, but for the purpose of using it on a large scale. I suggest in these circumstances that any appeal to the example of the Revenue Commissioners or of the rate collectors' power to distrain cannot be allowed to weigh in any way. I say that, although I am perfectly aware that a particular case could be put forward for this particular clause. I suggest that the case is not nearly strong enough to deprive an ordinary person of his rights to the protection of the court. There was a further advantage that was enjoyed. I understand that a person could go to the district justice and get a stay on the proceedings so far as his claim was concerned. I may be answered that he can get that now from the Land Commission. Quite so. We have all had a fair amount of experience in these matters. I think it is a much preferable thing that a judge should have the decision in a case of that kind rather than the Land Commission, or in having Deputies going to the Land Commission. I was rather amused by the references made on the Second Reading of the Bill, and this evening, to this particular power: that the Revenue Commissioners were looked upon, more or less, as the ideal. Well, it is pleasant to hear, at least, in one short debate, at all events, that much abused Government Department looked upon as the ideal to be striven after. I never heard them elevated to that particular pedestal before. But, apparently, powers similar to those possessed by the Revenue Commissioners should now be entrusted to the Land Commission, and such powers are to be the ministering angels to deal with the wounds of the unfortunate land annuitants who are incapable of meeting their demands. I can well understand, from another point of view, why this might be attractive to the Government. I will just give one view why what has been said in favour of this clause might be attractive to the Government and to a number of people in this House. There are other reasons why it could be attractive to the Land Commission. It will enable them to deal with these cases much more quickly. They can proceed much more summarily and much more stringently with defaulters, and, possibly, in view of the economic situation that presents itself to us, I can well understand why the Land Commission should be anxious to get that particular power.
Now mistakes may be made just as they may be made by a private individual, by an ordinary shop-keeper having shop debts, but certainly if a person is willing to risk the expense he should not be deprived of his right to appear before the court. Supposing, for instance, that there are, in the cases that Deputy Davin brought forward, grounds for complaint as to the percentage amount of the costs in comparison with the amount of a debt itself, is the proper way for dealing with abuses of that kind that it is suggested may exist, to cut away the root principle, or at least the spirit, of the Constitution in this matter without grave necessity? Is that the method of doing it? I suggest that the Deputy who plunged in with great delight to support this clause is going further than he intends. I stress that because undoubtedly the tendency of many of the speeches on this Bill has been this: "Away with judicial decisions, with judicial authority and judicial consideration. Put bureaucracy in its place and you will have more efficiency, more economic and more satisfactory, results." That is a very big change. I suggest that the House should not give its assent to such a principle as is involved in this section before it considers well what it is doing.
Comment on this
If this proposal of the Government is intended mainly or entirely for the purpose of reducing expense to the people who are proceeded against, why would it not be possible to limit it to those who admit liability? If a man does not admit liability it seems only right and proper that he should be given an opportunity of proving his case in court. If he has got absolutely no grounds for denying his liability and is not paying merely because he does not feel inclined to pay or because he is not able to pay, well then summary procedure without the intervention of the court, and without subjecting him to additional expense, may be the more suitable.
Comment on this
May I intervene for a moment? The passage of this section will not compel the Land Commission to proceed for the recovery of annuities from defaulters in the manner laid down in the section. But the section enables the Land Commission to do so if they think fit. The Government or the Land Commission are not out to establish bureaucratic government in any way. If they think that the person who is assessed for land annuities has any legal claim, or that he is assessed in the wrong, they would be quite prepared to have that issue tried out in court, and would do so. No Government would stand over the Land Commission trying a legal question in the Land Commission offices in Dublin. But in the ordinary case where a tenant does not dispute his payment, we do not want to see him mulcted in additional costs. In 999 cases out of 1,000 or even in 9,999 cases out of 10,000 the tenant never disputes his assessment. If he disputes his assessment on legal grounds, then definitely the Government would insist that the Land Commission would have that tested out in court.
Comment on this
I welcome that assurance from the Minister, but would it be impossible to introduce something into the Bill itself that would give that protection? Would it be possible to put something in the Bill that where a man had a prima facie defence he should not be deprived of access to the court?
Comment on this
Could not something be devised on those lines? I followed the law for a short time in my youth, and I seem to remember that in certain classes of cases you could get a summons to proceed by ex parte methods provided you could tender a certain kind of evidence of a debt that was considered to be good enough to enable you to go ahead by summary procedure. Possibly something of that kind might be devised in the case of persons alleged to be indebted to the Land Commission. As I say, I welcome the Minister's assurance, and I do not at all take up a pedantic attitude in these matters, but I think that more protection ought to be given than is given in the wording of this section, and that it ought not to be beyond human ingenuity to insert something that would ensure that where a man has a prima facie case he would be able to protect himself in the courts.
Comment on this
I want to point out to the House again that the Land Commission in this are not the last word. If the Land Commission act wrongly in seizing a man's cattle they are subject to the legal penalties that a district justice or a court of law may impose upon them for that action. I give the House the assurance, on behalf of the Government, that if there is really a doubt about the matter we will let it be carried into court, but if we find that the person is only play-acting we are not going to allow it to be tried in court.
Comment on this
I have often heard it said that the Revenue Commissioners always take the view that in the particular cases they are dealing with frauds, and I am afraid that the Land Commission would discover always that the people are play-acting.
Comment on this
After the assurance of the Minister I do not think it is necessary to reply to the arguments advanced against the section. Deputy Dillon and Deputy O'Sullivan seemed to speak against the section on the assumption that there would be a doubt as to the amount due by any tenant.
Comment on this
The Deputy gave some sort of analogy between the position we are trying to create here and that of a shopkeeper to whom certain moneys would be due. Surely there is no analogy between these two cases at all, because where it is a matter of annuity the tenant knows the amount, and in the matter of another debt you know the amount in the same way. Now Deputy Dillon referred to the fact that poor people should be given an opportunity of defending themselves and having such matters tested in court, but as the Minister has said, and as every member of this House knows, you never in a case for the recovery of annuities see the annuitants making any defence, or attempting to deny that the annuity is due, and that being so, I do not see why or what right there is in having a judge adjudicate on cases of that kind. Deputy O'Sullivan referred to the fact that it may be necessary to get a stay, and that by having cases tried in court the judge could put on a stay for one month or two months or three months, but the Deputy proceeded to give the reply to his own argument when he said that the tenant making the application could make the application in writing to the Land Commission asking for a stay. He also referred to the fact that in this Bill there is an effort being made to sweep away judges. No such effort is being made. As far as we can see, and I think that every one in this House who knows the position with regard to the collection of these annuities should know, costs have been imposed on people who in many cases have neglected to pay.
Comment on this
I believe that in many cases people neglected to pay in time and in other cases they had not the ability to pay what was due. They were not in a position to pay. If the Land Commission know that in cases where the money is due that it is due through inability to pay they will be dealt with sympathetically. I do not know any member of this House who intends to support this section who wants to do it by cramming things down the necks of the people of the country. We know in this section we are interpreting what is in the minds and would be in the minds of the majority of farmers if they were here and I think especially after the assurance given by the Minister in charge that the section should be accepted.
Comment on this
I support the amendment for the simple reason it seems to me to clear one of the worst defects in the Bill. Deputy Davin seems to think it an extraordinary thing that anyone should think that Section 27 is unconstitutional. One need not have any great learning in the law to know that under the Constitution the judiciary is provided with the object of having judges, to sit in judgment on disputes between citizens in the State. But, to put it in a more rough and ready way, the object of the judges is to stand between the people and the under-sheriff. To put it in that way brings to mind more clearly what one's opposition to this section should be. This section proposes that a creditor— because the Land Commission is nothing more in this matter—should be able to get into direct contact with the under-sheriff and put him in on the defaulting annuitants to seize the goods. The criticism which has been chiefly levelled at the present procedure from the Government Benches is chiefly on the matter of costs. I made inquiries since the Second Reading and I have learned from authoritative sources that the present procedure is somewhat as follows: First, the Land Commission sends out its demand note; when it is not complied with the charges are sent to the State solicitor and he issues a civil bill. I understand that the civil bill is served in about 40 per cent. of the cases. The money is then paid by the defaulting annuitants. In another 40 per cent. of the cases the money is paid out after the case has been entered but before it actually comes on for hearing. In the remaining 20 per cent. of the cases decrees are made by the district justice or the Circuit judge, as the case may be. The State solicitor then gets the decree and it is only in about 2 per cent. of all cases that the decree is actually lodged with the sheriff. The instances which have been given here of the heavy costs incurred by these defaulting annuitants are instances in which the sheriff's fees must have been included. I know of no other way in which the heavy cost of these cases could be explained. I am told that the chief item of costs is the sheriff's costs. The sheriff has to send out his court messengers, very often 20, 30 or 40 miles. They go to the land. They cannot get the money and they take cattle off the land and drive them away. These cattle have to be kept for several days and then sold far away from the county from which they were taken. They have that power now, I believe, under fairly recent legislation. The chief item of costs, as I have said, is the sheriff's part, and that is the very part which is being retained in this Bill. In conclusion, I should like to say that I see no reason whatever why the Land Commission should be placed on a different plane from any other creditor in the State. It seems to me just as much an injustice to put this power into the hands of the Land Commission as to put it into the hands of any shopkeeper, trader or creditor of any kind in this State.
Comment on this
I hope the Minister will seriously consider accepting the amendment. This proposed change in procedure is no doubt induced mainly by a consideration of the hardship on defaulting annuitants—that they put themselves to a certain amount of costs by resisting payment. That is one consideration in the mind of the Government in introducing this. Another consideration, no doubt, is on the part of the Department that it will facilitate their work to have this summary process. It is introducing a new principle to enable a Department, who are creditors themselves, to issue an order for collection without any intervention by any court. I do not think it has been mentioned in this discussion so far that this proposal by the Land Commission was put forward three or four years ago in evidence by one of their prominent officials before the Joint Committee on the Courts of Justice Act. That Committee included representatives of every Party in the House, including the Party for which Deputy Davin spoke this evening. That Committee, having heard the evidence of the official who advocated the issue of a warrant, unanimously refused to recommend that proposal.
We have heard a lot of cheap gibes on the part of Deputy Davin about the rights, liberties and fees of lawyers and that was referring to what Deputy Dillon said. The whole of the profession that Deputy Dillon belongs to do not, in my opinion, receive one guinea amongst them in three years from these disputes about the payment of land annuities. It is time that Deputy Davin stopped that kind of cheap gibes in this House. The Minister for Justice last week referred to the cost of collection of these annuities and he did mention a sum of 16/- costs on the collection of an annuity of 19/-. Of course, that is an excessive sum and I do not justify it. I do not know how it has occurred. Instead of depriving the annuitant of the right to defend himself and show that he is not a defaulter, the Minister should consider how these costs could be reduced. There are obvious ways in which that could be done. Speaking from recollection, I think that some recommendation of the kind as to reduction of these costs was made by the Committee of which I was a member, and which sat about three years ago.
It is attempted to justify the giving of these powers to a Department by saying that there is another Department that has these powers already— the Revenue Department. Two wrongs do not make a right. My opinion is that the Revenue Department have no right to have these powers, and should not have them. That the wrong exists already is not an argument in favour of extending that wrong, and giving those improper powers to another Department. I think that the Minister, if he considers the matter, will be able to devise a process by which the costs of these decrees on people who have really no defence could be reduced. The Department should not be allowed, because it says a sum of money is due to it, to issue a process at once as the judge in its own case. A great many instances have occurred where annuitants have been sued for annuities which they did not in fact owe. The Minister will, no doubt, be aware that that has occurred in some counties so often that the district justice has commented upon the fact that processes have been issued against persons who had already paid. I do not say that by way of a charge against the Land Commission. I know that it is a highly efficient Department. It is, however, a very big Department, and it has an enormous number of cases to deal with, and, inevitably, no matter how efficient it is, cases must occur in which mistakes of that kind would be made. Think of the impression you make on the public mind when a person who has discharged his liabilities is hauled up in court—I am talking now of the present proceedings before a district justice—and comes up and says that he paid his annuity already and produces a receipt. That has happened in many cases. But think of the far worse impression on the public mind when, without any process of the kind at all, the sheriff walks in on a man's land and takes his cattle, or, his cattle being of no value at present, takes his furniture, if he has any, for an annuity which he has paid already. That is the substitution that it is proposed to make now—to allow the sheriff to walk out and, on the ipse dixit of the Land Commission, take a man's chattels whatever they may be, in payment of a debt that he does not, in fact, owe.
I suggest to the House that this is a wrong extension of a wrong principle. We all know the origin of this idea that the Revenue should be able to walk into anybody's premises and take what is there for a debt that they say is due, and do that without any process of court. Of course, it is the growth of the old idea that the debt is due to the king, and that the king can do no wrong; that the king is entitled to walk in anywhere without any process of court; that the debt is due to him, and that he can collect it. I do not think that principle should be carried any further. I am very much surprised to see Deputy Davin and his Party standing for this principle, that the king can do no wrong, for this is an extension of that old principle. A revenue debt is a debt due to the king, and, therefore, can be collected without any order of a judge.
I suggest to the Minister that he might consider this matter from this particular point of view and give the defaulting annuitant an opportunity of defending himself if he has a defence. If he has not a defence, or if he has only got the ordinary human principle that he will chance a summons and wait for it, he should get this opportunity of coming into court. Let the Minister cheapen the process of the court. Give the annuitant a short time and cheapen the process, but give him an opportunity of making his answer; give a smaller sum to the State solicitor for appearing in court, but do not take away from the annuitant the right of coming into court. He is entitled to do so. Do not take that right away. Where he has no case at all cheapen the process. That can be done by reducing the costs, but give him the right to come into court and to say, where the money is not owed, "I do not owe this money."
Comment on this
I think the proposal contained in this section is a splendid one. I have had a number of cases in my county, which includes a number of small farmers, and I have instances there where the costs incurred were alarming, so much so, that the tenant had to pay a sum twice as large as the amount originally sued for, when the amount was finally assessed and levied by the sheriff. These are ordinary cases that one meets with very frequently all over the country. I fail to see where there can be any injustice at all in the operation of this part of the Bill. On the contrary, I can see in the Bill quite great benefits to the tenants. The only point against the section is that, possibly, the Land Commission may make a mistake. That has occurred in the past, but nobody will deny that that danger is comparatively small as against the entire number of tenants involved. It would not be right for the sake of a few to jeopardise and punish the whole body of tenants by applying to them a system of costs with which they should not be saddled. The same principle applies to the ordinary collection of rates in various counties. Nobody has suggested that has been unduly harsh on the ratepayers. It has worked out satisfactorily.
Anything that can establish a saving of expenses in law costs, particularly to the small farmers, is a good system. Where can the hardship come in? I suppose there will always be a certain number of tenants who cannot afford to pay their annuities. Processing these men and handing over their cases to the State solicitor very often costs a great deal and the money involved is not secured though it falls ultimately to be paid by the tenant. There is no suggestion in the present proposal to do more than collect the annuities as they become due. If those annuitants are not able to pay the amount, the cost involved under the new system will be infinitesimal as compared with the system up to now. These people have been harassed with the burden of costs. I can see nothing against this Bill. I have listened to the speeches from the Opposition Benches and the only point I can see against the section is that it deprives State solicitors, their officials and the sub-sheriffs of certain emoluments that they have been getting in the past. That may be a loss to these people, but so far as they are concerned I do not see how they can come into this measure at all. This measure is conceived with the idea of securing the best possible benefits and bringing a saving to the small farmers. This will be done without any undue hardship. A certain amount of revenue will be taken from State solicitors, civil bill officers and sheriffs. These are the only people that will be aggrieved. There may be some way of meeting their grievances, but I suggest that it is unfair to make the case that the interests of the tenants are not being served by removing from them the liability for these costs, which are undoubtedly a great hardship on them. That is my opinion, and I have a very wide experience. I say that the proposal is one of the most democratic in the sense that it endeavours to serve the best interests of the poor of the country and saves them from legal charges that have been very excessive in the past and that have borne heavily on them. In the interests of the farmers I am supporting the proposal.
Comment on this
I do not suggest for a moment that Deputy Maguire is not completely honest and sincere in the speech he has made to the House, but his speech suggests that he has not read the amendment, or if he has, he has read it without understanding what it means. He says nobody will be aggrieved by the passing of this section except the State solicitors, civil bill officers and sheriffs. I can assure the Deputy that out of every sheriff's office and from every sheriff's bailiff there will go up a chorus of gratitude for this section. These people will know of no man so admirable as the present Minister for Lands and Fisheries, because there never has been such a gold mine opened before them as is opened by this section.
Comment on this
I will explain that. In a few counties there are still sheriffs left, and they are provided for by this section, but in the ordinary county the registrar does the duty of the sheriff, and when the existing sub-sheriffs die or leave office there will be no sub-sheriffs left. The sub-sheriff is merged in the registrar.
Comment on this
My point is that there are in existence sheriffs who are not registrars.
Comment on this
There are in some counties. There are existing sheriffs and these sheriffs make the seizures in the counties where they exist. In the sub-section here, sub-section (6), the sheriff will make the seizure in the counties where there are sheriffs. In the counties where there are no sheriffs the seizures will be made by the registrar. The sheriff's bailiffs and the registrars are the persons who are going to find this section, as I said, a gold mine. This is a sort of Sheriffs' Relief Bill. This is a Bill to give employment to the sheriffs and the sheriffs' bailiffs. This is a section designed obviously for the purpose of finding jobs for some unemployed persons, because if this section is put into force the number of sheriffs' bailiffs will want to be very substantially increased. It is a sheriff's bailiffs' Bill; it is a Bill for the relief of sheriffs' bailifs. That is the way in which it might be accurately described. I do not believe that if Deputy Maguire really understood what the section meant he would have given it the encomium which he did. I do not know about Deputy Davin, because I must confess that Deputy Davin is an absolute mystery to me. When he stands up I do not know on God's earth what he is going to say or how he is going to say it. I am very sorry he has left the House at the present moment. He talked about Deputy Dillon running away, and then proceeded to skedaddle himself. Even in his absence, in the great hope that he may read what I state or that his two colleagues may convey something of the kind to him, I should like to point out that at any rate a great number of the things he said were absolute nonsense. He said the tenants had to pay sums of money fixed by the Cumann na nGaedheal Government. The Cumann na nGaedheal Government did not fix scales of costs, neither did the Fianna Fáil Government. The scales of costs in the District Court, Circuit Court, and the High Court are fixed by an independent body called the Rule-Making Committee. That Committee fixes the costs, and they are not controlled by the Minister for Justice at all.
Comment on this
It is not the Incorporated Law Society. It is the Rule-Making Committee. The Rule-Making Committee settles the amount of the costs. Deputy Davin referred to costs of 19/11 to collect a 16/- decree. I should like to point out that the costs in Land Commission cases are not in the slightest bit different from the costs in any other class of case heard before these courts. They are not the slightest bit different from shop goods cases. The scale of costs is exactly the same in Land Commission cases, and if there is a case for revising one there is a case for revising all. Deputy Davin challenged me, why I do not know, but I happened to be here, and I suppose I caught the impetuous, mediæval mind of the Deputy, because Deputy Davin is extremely mediæval and wants to go back to mediæval systems. I am glad to see that he has now returned to the House. He likes something old-fashioned; he likes something mediæval. The only thing that surprises me is that Deputy Davin has not come in clad in a suit of armour or mounted on a horse clad in armour generally. He wants to go back to the Middle Ages. He wants to give a power of seizure, as Deputy Rice pointed out, to the Land Commission, which the Revenue Commissioners have. The debts that are due to the Revenue Commissioners, as Deputy Rice pointed out, are debts due to the King. He wants to put the Land Commission in the same position. Deputy Davin, with his passionate love for royalty and kingly power, and steeped as he is in mediævalism, is entirely in favour of this section. He was quite wrong when he said that it would be of some advantage to my profession, which is the same as Deputy Dillon's profession. Not in the slightest. Those cases are heard before the District Court or before the Circuit Court or in big cases before the High Court; the number of cases in which barristers would be retained, unless there was some very big issue indeed, would be very few. I do not think there have been any within the last few years.
Comment on this
I do not know what the Deputy calls the loot. If he means the costs, the sheriff has been getting the most of those expenses we have been hearing about here. Deputy Davin, who is the sheriff's Guardian Angel, Deputy Davin who wishes to see the sheriff and the sheriff's bailiffs in affluence, is in favour of the section. It is the sheriff and his bailiffs are going to have the loot if this particular section becomes law. As far as the costs in court are concerned, the persons who receive them in undefended cases—and I presume that cases which it is expected would be undefended are the cases to which this section would be applied— are the State solicitors, and the State solicitors only. I can assure Deputy Davin that neither I nor any member of this Party or of the Farmers' Party is related to the State solicitors. I am not in the slightest bit interested as to whether the fees of the State solicitors go up or down. If they are not adequately paid by the State for the work they do, the State can pay them a larger sum. I am not interested in the State solicitors in the slightest bit. I am interested in seeing that the persons who are land annuitants get fair play. To get down to some of those very curious points which have been made; the Minister intervened as if he had made some marvellous discovery. He satisfied Deputy MacDermot, seemingly, but I must confess it was a bit too deep for me. The keener intelligence of Deputy MacDermot seemed to have grasped that some very real grievance was being done away with by what the Minister said, but I could not grasp it.
Comment on this
I am not conscious of being satisfied. I do not know what the Deputy is referring to.
Comment on this
I am afraid his assurance did not carry me one yard. Nobody has ever suggested that the Land Commission is corrupt. Nobody has suggested that given those powers the Land Commission is going deliberately to misuse them. Nobody has suggested that if the Land Commission knows a person does not owe a debt they are going to issue a warrant under this section. What is the good of the Minister getting up and saying: "Oh, the Land Commission will never issue a warrant when they know the amount is in dispute"? How does that carry us any further? Who, from this side of the House, ever suggested that those very competent and very honourable gentlemen who are carrying out the duties of the collection branch of the Land Commission are going to act consciously dishonestly? It has never been suggested. What we have said is, in the first place, that they are capable of making mistakes. Of course, they are capable of making mistakes. There could not be any men who are collecting an enormous sum of money as those are, £5,000,000 a year, who do not make or could not make mistakes from time to time. What is the use of getting up and telling the House that the Land Commission are not consciously going to make mistakes? How does the Land Commission know the cases that are going to be defended and the cases that are not going to be defended? The Land Commission has got at the present moment a privilege that the ordinary litigant has not got. Its certificate that money is due is prima facie evidence in court. They need not produce any witness. Anybody else who goes to court in a defended case must produce his witness, but not the Land Commission.
At any rate their certificate is prima facie evidence that the amount is due. They do not know what case will be put in defence; they could not know. In a case in which there is going to be a defence, and in fact a complete bona fide defence, even though they may be completely in error, they will issue their warrant. A man who owes nothing, and who has paid his annuities may inevitably, if this section is put through, find that the sheriff has issued a warrant against him and that his stock is being seized. I think this section is appallingly impolitic if nothing else. I have dealt with a case where a mistake is made. Let me deal with a case where no mistake is made. Suppose a man owes his annuity and gets a solicitor's letter, and after that a process. He knows there is time yet, plenty of time. He is prepared to make a payment. He may borrow the money from his friends, or by any other method collect it rather than have a seizure. That is what happens now. What is going to happen under this Bill suppose it becomes law? Within a single week, a single annuity being due, the Minister, because this is under his own control, may say to his officials in the Land Commission, and they must obey him: “Go and seize so-and-so's stock.” His annuity may be only a week due, but he may be somebody that the Minister does not like, and he has power to have his stock seized. This power ought not to be in the Minister's hands. It is very well for the Labour Party and the Fianna Fáil Party to sneer at such things as the rights of the individual and the liberty of the individual, but the individual has his rights.
Comment on this
What about the kicking cow in Clare? If the Deputy refers to a case in which a certain young man was knocked down by a cow, and endeavoured to make out that the Guards had assaulted him, and, thereupon, made a false charge against the Guards, he, and people who dislike the Guards, and believe these false charges, may object to have these false charges investigated.
Comment on this
Deputy Davin was irrelevant in his interruption, but when he made the interruption I submit I am entitled to say that Deputy Davin has insinuated a falsehood.
Comment on this
The Chair has no knowledge of the case referred to and does not see the relevance of it.
Comment on this
The Leas-Cheann Comhairle is, of course, not always in the House and could not be aware of references made from time to time in his absence. But when Deputy Davin makes this statement he shows he is the type of man who believes anything that is said against the Guards.
Comment on this
I pass from that and come back to the particular matter under discussion. I say that the rights of members of the Civic Guards would not get much consideration from people if they are minded as Deputy Davin is in regard to that. But that the rights and liberties of the ordinary citizens of this State should be subjected, as they are subjected by this Bill, to a Department of State which is practically under the control of a Minister, is absolutely wrong, and those who support this measure and, particularly this section as it stands, are people without any regard for the ordinary farmers who pay land annuities in the country. It is sought here to put the payers of land annuities under the feet of a Department which can trample upon them if they wish. If a man does not happen to be able to pay his debts within a week or so after they are due, you are putting him absolutely at the mercy of a particular Department; that is what some Deputies in this House think is right. They cannot increase the central power sufficiently and they must decrease the ordinary protection of the individual as much as possible. I know that is the view of Deputies opposite and it has been expressed not for the first time in this debate.
As far as this amendment goes it simply insures that the bare certificate issued by the Land Commission must be followed by a summons from the Department to the individual who if he likes can go into court. Where does the question of solicitor's fees arise there? When the Department sends out a summons it gives an opportunity to the individual to come before the district justice. Where are the fees there that frightened Deputy Davin so much? If a man does not wish to go to court then he takes no steps, and does not give a reply because under this section certain rules will have to be drafted. If he makes no reply a summons can be issued. Yet that very simple sending of a summons is too much trouble for a Government Department, and Deputy Davin, who does not wish to see a Government Department put to any trouble, will not accept this amendment, and will vote against it. There has been more sham and hypocrisy talked about this section than was ever talked in this House before. What is the use of anybody, with an ounce of brains, getting up and saying that this section is going to save costs and expenses? Does not every single person who reads this section, and is capable of understanding it, know that it is going to increase the costs and to increase them heavily upon the annuitants in default? Is there a single person in this House who does not know that ordinary legal expenses are trivial in comparison with sheriff's fees? Is there a single person who does not know that, once a decree gets into the sheriff's hands? Here you are making provision for decrees and substituting the sheriff for the court decree which means getting into the sheriff's hands. As I said at the outset this is a sheriff's relief bill and nothing else. It is going to increase, out of all recognition, if put in force, the costs upon the annuitants. As far as this section is concerned I certainly have one hope and it is this: that the Land Commission will try this section for about a fortnight, or a month, and if they do the outcry will be such that the section will become a dead letter. That is the only hope I have got. If this House has any respect for itself, then it should not leave it to the ordinary man in the street, to the public, to the outcry which the passing of this section must evoke, to set things right. The House should not do a thing which, in its heart of hearts, it knows is utterly wrong and then trust that the public outcry will be so great that the powers which the House is giving to the Minister and the Department dare not be used.
Comment on this
I have great pleasure in supporting this section. I have had a fairly long experience of proceedings in the Circuit and District Courts and I think there is nothing more pitiable than to see in those courts hundreds of civil bills presented by the Land Commission and scarcely any defence entered against them. Decrees are issued as a matter of form by those courts simply for the purpose of mulcting unfortunate tenants in costs. I have had tenants coming in to my office and asking me to enter a defence. The defence was really only a plea for time. The mere fact of asking to enter a defence really meant that I also would be entitled to costs, additional to the costs already incurred. I have seen thousands of decrees issued and I have never yet seen a successful defence offered in the case of Land Commission processes.
Deputy Fitzgerald-Kenney has said that extra costs will be imposed and he laid great emphasis on the point that the sheriff will have to be called in. In addition to the costs previously incurred in the courts the tenants heretofore were also obliged to pay the sheriff's costs.
Comment on this
I will deal with that later. I am sure that under this section the very same facilities will be given to tenants to pay by the Land Commission, as in the past. I am sure as long a time as formerly will be given to tenants to meet their liabilities. I am certain the Land Commission will give very favourable consideration to applications for time to pay. I do not see how any tenant derives benefit from having the civil bill officer calling on him. The hearing of the case in court only involves heavy costs. As a lawyer, accustomed to pity these tenants in the past, I say that there is no section in the Bill that appeals more to me than this section.
Comment on this
There is a certain element of danger in connection with the payment of annuities to which I would like to refer. In the very recent past there was a certain system of collection in vogue. I do not know if that system still obtains. I do know that that system exposed annuitants to very grave danger. An annuitant might pay his annuity at the local bank. He would probably pay in cash, but before that cash would be accepted he had to hand in his receivable order. He was not entitled to a receipt from the bank at the time. I know one instance in which very grave hardship and injustice were inflicted on annuitants because of that system of payment. One cashier of a bank, in a moment of weakness, gave way to temptation and absconded with a lot of money lodged by annuitants. This occurred at a time when the annuities were being paid and a considerable amount of money passed into the cashier's hands. The annuitants paid cash and got no receipts.
This man absconded and, as a result, there was a considerable amount of litigation. These people had no receivable orders and no receipts for their cash payments. How were they to defend their cases? The man who had received the money had left the country. That is one instance of the grave danger to which annuitants are exposed. That system was a very detestable system and I do not know if it still holds good. The man who would pay by cheque would, at all events, have the protection afforded by crossing his cheque and that could be cashed only through a person who had an account in the bank. If made payable to the Land Commission it would have to be endorsed by a Land Commission official. In a matter of that sort the annuitants require protection. If there has not been an alteration in that system, I would be glad to have an indication from the Minister that that whole matter will be thoroughly investigated.
I do not desire to cast any reflection on Land Commission officials. I know they have great difficulties and trials in dealing with the collection of annuities. Often when a man sends a cheque, together with his receivable order, several months elapse before he gets his receipt or receivable order back. If you send a money order and anything happens to it in transit you run the risk of losing the whole amount, together with your receivable order. If your receivable order is mislaid you have to apply for a duplicate. I confess I have no sympathy with lawyers in a matter of this kind. Our chief concern here is the annuitant and how best to protect him. In the case I have referred to grave injustice was inflicted on the annuitants. They handed their cash to this young man, who subsequently absconded and the annuitants had to pay their annuities all over again. What are we going to have to indemnify the annuitants against a repetition of that, unless the system is completely altered with regard to the manner of collection? Doubtless, it was voluntary on the part of the annuitant when he went in with the receivable order and handed in his cash to the bank, but he got no receipt and was not entitled to get it. That was the system that held good.
Comment on this
At the present time the banks all have instructions to give receipts whenever money is handed in with a receivable order.
Comment on this
The Minister knows that, as a matter of practice, these receipts are not given in many cases unless they are asked for.
Comment on this
That was the system for a while, but recently the Land Commission has given instructions to the banks that they are to give receipts whether requested by the annuitants or not.
Comment on this
I have mentioned a case here where, to my own knowledge, the people had to pay over again as a result of not having receipts. I am very glad to hear the Minister say now that that system has been altered. I think that in a matter of this kind it is rather high-handed and autocratic that the only opportunity an annuitant has now is to have to pay the sheriff. If he misses the date now and the sheriff is sent in with his document to seize his cattle we have, in that way, revived a system of tyranny, to my mind, unparalleled and unprecedented in the whole history of this country since the days of Cromwell. We have heard of many kinds of tyranny in the past, but they were mild forms of tyranny in comparison with this. We are talking about the sympathy we have with the poor, but if, when a man is in such circumstances of financial difficulties that he cannot overcome them, the only remedy held out to him now is that the sheriff will be sent in to distrain, I wonder what message that will convey to the struggling people of this country? Certain people will not fear this because they will be people in a good financial position who will be able to meet their liabilities and discharge them. I think I can say—and the officials of the Land Commission have full knowledge of it— that as far as the annuities are concerned, they have been met and paid. The annuitants have discharged their liabilities in a most creditable manner and I think their action in the past should be given the fullest consideration. I feel that they are deserving of very great credit, and they should receive the greatest consideration, rather than rushing them into the position now with this sword over their heads that they will have no opportunity of defence when the sheriff is sent in, as I said before, to seize their chattels. I do hope that the matter will receive consideration. I am not suggesting that the Minister or the Land Commission are desirous of acting in a harsh or tyrannical fashion as far as these people are concerned, but I hope there will be some protection, something that will be held between the Land Commission, with all due respect to them, and those people who, in trying circumstances, may not be able to meet their obligations. The judicial court would be the one and only remedy that I can see.
Comment on this
If this debate this evening has done nothing more than extract from a lawyer-Deputy, in this House, the admission that the scale of charges for law costs in the past has been out of all proportion to what the country can bear, it will have done one good turn for this country at any rate. I am glad to hear the lawyers crying out over what will happen to the poor farmers. I think we in this House who belong to that class of the farming community should at least make our voices heard. I agree with Deputy Dillon that the scale of costs which was allowed to be fixed under the Cumann na nGaedheal régime was out of all proportion to what the country can bear. As a practical illustration of that, about five years ago I bought a farm of land and the solicitor who had been acting in the sale sent me a bill of costs. I asked him how it came about that he had done similar work for a neighbour of mine at half the money and his answer was that there was a new scale of charges which permitted the costs to be doubled. As I say, if this debate brings about the admission that the scale of charges is too high it will have done one good work for Ireland.
I was amazed to hear the argument that the registrar of a court will be more harsh and severe than a district justice. I have no acquaintance with either class of gentleman, but I fail to see how one of them cannot understand the feelings of the Government and of the country any more than the other. With regard to State solicitors, I heard Deputy Fitzgerald-Kenney say that there are no costs. My experience is that there were always costs.
Comment on this
I did not myself, but I saw them with the neighbours. I heard Deputy Davis say something about mistakes in the banks. Undoubtedly, there were mistakes in the days gone by. I knew of a case of a poor woman who went into the bank and paid her money, but she threw receivable order away. The next thing she knew was that she got another demand and had to pay again. It does not follow at all that because State solicitors costs were added to the decrees the thing was more favourable to the tenants then than now. I support this clause in the Bill, and I support it as a farmer, knowing the hardships inflicted on farmers, and I do hope and expect that they will get as much mercy from the registrar of the court and the Land Commission as they ever got from the State solictors.
Comment on this
I am opposed to this section in principle. Deputies in this House will recall that an attempt was made in the British House of Commons, when the Land Act of 1903 was introduced, to insert a similar clause, and the Irish Parliamentary Party of that time so strenuously opposed it that it was withdrawn. Here the same principle is going to be accepted in this Bill. There has been a lot of what I can only call "tosh" talked in this House about costs. Not a solitary speaker here has told you, sir, and the House, what are the costs here. I am opposed to this in principle. It is a violation of the Constitution and of the rights of the citizen that his property can be taken from him without the operation of law. On that account, a proposal to insert a section of this kind in the Act of 1903 was defeated in the British House of Commons. I oppose this section for a similar reason.
Comment on this
If Deputies would refrain from answering interruptions there would be fewer interruptions.
Comment on this
Perhaps there would and I am sorry for answering. Deputy Davin burst forth into a regular tornado in an attack on Deputy Dillon as representing a certain branch of the legal profession. To test that attack I challenge Deputy Davin to name one solitary case in the Free State where counsel has earned a fee from the Land Commission. I have been 17 years at the Bar and I have never seen counsel earn one penny from the Land Commission. I would ask Deputy Davin to name one case for the House or withdraw his statement and so put an end to loose talk of that kind.
Comment on this
This section is going to enrich one class and one class only—the sheriff and the sheriff's bailiffs. The sheriff and the sheriff's bailiffs are going to be the wealthiest class in the country under this section. Let there be no mistake about that, and let it not be said hereafter that it was not stated. I am sure that the Minister does not intend that this section should have the unfortunate consequences that undoubtedly will be involved in it. What has been the practice in the past? When the half-year's rent became due and was not paid, the schedule was sent down to the State solicitor. He had printed forms available, he put in the name of the tenant and the amount of the annuity, and sent out the demand to the annuitant. What did that cost? 2/6. This House ought to look upon these matters as if they were ordinary debts. Society, as regards debtors, at all events, is divided into two classes, people who are negligent in paying and people who cannot pay. These people, as I say, receive a printed intimation from the State solicitor which costs them 2/6. In the case of a private debt, if the debtor receives a solicitor's letter, he has to pay 6/8, but all it costs the land annuitant is 2/6. He has then got seven days within which he can pay or, perhaps, he is allowed even a little longer. If he does not pay within that period a civil bill is issued. What does that cost? I have the figures here. If the amount of the annuity is under £2 and if it is paid before entry, the cost of the civil bill is only 5/-. I am taking these figures from the scale of costs. If it is paid after entry the cost is 6/-, and then the costs of the decree are 11/-. Where the amount exceeds £2 but does not exceed £5, the cost of the letter sent out by the State solicitor is the same, 2/6. In the case of an ordinary debt it would be 6/8, or perhaps up to 10/-, according to the status of the solicitor. If the amount of the annuity is over £2 but does not exceed £5 the cost of the civil bill is 8/-, if it is paid before entry, and, after entry, it is 14/-. These costs were not fixed by Cumann na nGaedheal or by the present Government. These are the costs as drawn up by the rule-making committee. They apply to private debtors as well as to the Land Commission. This system may be costly and you can try to cheapen it if you like. I said last year myself that there should be some means of reducing the costs, but in principle I think this is the best method of collection you can get.
Comment on this
Might I ask the Deputy if the State solicitor lives 14 miles away from the District Court in which the case is to be tried, will he not get additional expenses?
Comment on this
No, not a penny. These debts in certain respects are in the same category as shopkeepers' debts. You have got to deal with a similar class of persons. You should remember that they are human beings, and you should approach the collection of these debts in the same way as you would the collection of ordinary debts. If you think that the costs at present paid to the State solicitors are too high, reduce them by all means. I spoke last year in favour of reducing them. I think, as one who spent a part of my life in business and who has some knowledge of the machinery employed in the collection of debts, that the machinery that has been in operation by the Land Commission in the past is the best and most efficient. The Minister has got the figures before him, and I am sure he will admit that about 75 per cent. of the arrears are paid after the first typewritten letter is received from the State solicitor by the annuitant. About 20 per cent. more would be paid after the civil bill is issued. In my experience I have never known of a case of seizure by the Land Commission in County Donegal. It is where the sheriff is sent out that the costs mount up. The law costs are not so great, taking them on the whole, and they can be reduced if you wish to reduce them. I think that if the Government adopt this section and try the new system, they will be compelled to go back to the old system of collection after a while, because they will find that it is the most efficient and the best for the annuitants. Again I say to the Minister that you can divide these people into two classes. We have, of course, the people who pay half-yearly, the moment the annuity falls due. Then you have two other classes—the people who cannot pay and those who are negligent in paying. This latter class will pay the moment they get the letter. Then there is the class who cannot pay, and they are deserving of all mercy. Look what will happen to these people. Their annuity will be in arrears, the Land Commission will send down a warrant to the county registrar, and the sheriff will be put in motion. I move to report progress.