We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

Land Bill, 1933—Committee Stage (Resumed).

Contributions 1–197 of 423. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

Bill Land Bill, 1933
Enacted

No. 33 of 1933 ›

In connection with the amendment before the House, I should like, for the purpose of saving time, to draw your attention to amendment No. 113:—

At the end of sub-section (1) to add the words "and to be equally suitable for the said proprietor".

That amendment was put down by me prior to the production of amendment No. 111. If amendment No. 111 were accepted by the House it would be difficult to insert amendment No. 113 as it was originally intended. Therefore, with your permission, sir, I would ask leave to discuss 113 and 111 and to allow a decision to be taken on both principles at the same time, that is the general principle involved in the Government amendment and the additional principle involved in my amendment.

Comment on this

I presume we can take these two amendments and discuss them together, because as the Minister indicated when introducing his amendment, his contention was that it covered a number of other amendments and it also involved the principle of the section.

Comment on this

All the amendments to sub-section (3) of Section 28 so far as they involve the principle can be discussed on amendment No. 111.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

A difficulty has arisen, as has been indicated by two Deputies. The Ministerial amendment is really a re-drafting and amalgamation of sub-sections (1) and (3) of Section 28. Technically, if amendment No. 111 is carried, amendments 112, 113 and 114 cannot be moved. They might possibly, on being re-drafted, be moved to the new sub-section, but such re-drafting cannot be done in the House. A further difficulty arises— Deputy Rice admits that amendment No. 112 has been met by the re-drafting of sub-section (1) and amendment No. 118 may possibly also have been met. If amendment No. 116 is carried, amendments Nos. 117 to 124 cannot be moved. If amendments 111 and 116 are carried such of the lapsed amendments Deputies desire to offer could be offered on Report Stage. The discussion may range over these amendments now or on amendment No. 111.

Comment on this

I presume I would be in order in moving amendment No. 115 when discussing sub-section (4) of Section 28?

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

It seems to be in order. The House should not assume that the Ceann Comhairle is an encylopoedia on land law.

Comment on this

Are we to take it then that the debate may be resumed on the lines I have suggested?

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

That is for the House to decide. Perhaps the House would agree to accept 111 and 116, to re-submit the amendments on Report.

Comment on this

Better re-submit on Report.

Comment on this

When it comes to those particular amendments the Deputy cannot move them?

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

He could discuss them now.

Comment on this

He cannot move them now?

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Chair does not like to accept on Report Stage amendments proper to the Committee Stage, but in the circumstances, I am prepared to allow lapsing amendments to be re-offered on Report.

Comment on this

In the circumstances, they cannot be moved now.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

They can be discussed.

Comment on this

Yes, discussed, certainly.

Comment on this

In my opinion, when we arrived at Section 28 to which amendment 111 is moved, we arrived at the most vital section in this Land Bill. When the Acting-Minister for Lands and Fisheries was speaking on this Bill on the Second Reading Stage and when he came to discuss Section 28 he mentioned in passing that there had been deleted, or there would be deleted from the Land Act of 1923 sub-section (4) (b) of Section 24 of that Act. That sub-section reads as follows:—

"If within the prescribed time and in the prescribed manner the proprietor or tenant of the declared land so requires them to do, the Land Commission shall, as soon as practicable, provide the said proprietor or tenant with a new holding which, in the opinion of the Land Commission other than the judicial commissioner (subject to the right of appeal to the judicial commissioner, whose decision shall be final) shall be equally suitable for the said proprietor or tenant, and of not less value than the declared land...."

That sub-section is being materially re-enacted in the Bill of 1933 save in respect of the all-important words "shall be equally suitable for the said proprietor or tenant". The Minister in defending the deletion of these words said that they had constituted, in practice, practically impassable barriers, when the Land Commission sought compulsorily to acquire purchased land. The reason that the Minister gave for deleting those words is, in my opinion, the most forcible and the most unanswerable reason for retaining them. I discharge the Attorney-General from any deliberate intention of confusing the issue. But when he was speaking at an earlier stage of this Bill, he spoke of the security of tenure being buried fathoms deep for the tenant farmers of this country, and it subsequently transpired that he was referring to persons who were still paying judicial rents at the time of the passing of the 1923 Land Act.

My protest is made on behalf of the purchased tenants. The people who entered into agreements with the Land Commission to purchase their lands were put in possession of their holdings by the Land Commission on the secure understanding which just represented the final settlement of the land question in so far as they were concerned. The Bill at the present time before us means that every purchased tenant in this country whether he has five acres, ten acres, 50 acres, or 100 acres of land can be put out on the side of the road in the morning by the Land Commission acting under the direction of the Minister for Lands and Fisheries; and by way of compensation he can be offered land of equal market value, 100 miles or 200 miles away from where his father and grandfather and the people who went before him were born. I was recently discussing this question with a distinguished supporter of the Fianna Fáil Government and when I put it to him that this Bill meant that every farmer in this country was stripped of the security which the Land League gave and made a pawn on the Minister's chess board to be moved about wherever the Minister chose to put them, he denied it. He said it was incredible and he would not believe that the Fianna Fáil Government would introduce such legislation and that I had misread the Bill. That supporter of the Fianna Fáil Government is in the House to-day. That member of the Party will hear from his own Attorney-General confirmation of what I now say. I hope that member of the Party will have the courage to vote according to his convictions. Those of us who are not ashamed to confess ourselves agrarians, people who consider that the final settlement of the land question in this country is of paramount importance, know with what trepidation leaders of the Land League set that movement in motion. They realised how great was the danger of stirring up the people on the question of the land; how deep and violent the reactions of our people became when their homestead was at stake, and it required the utmost endeavour to keep that movement within prudent and permissible limits.

The Government to-day for the purpose, according to themselves, of speeding up the settlement of the congested districts question, propose to wipe out the security of tenure of the small holders of this country. I warn them that if they do that they are putting their hand to a work the end of which none of us in this House can fully see. If any attempt is made to shift about the tenant purchasers of this country, to clear people out of their homesteads in order to use those homesteads for the purpose of dividing them up amongst their neighbours, feuds and quarrels will be set on foot in every district where that is attempted which may have disastrous consequences for the country at large. Everybody knows of his own acquaintance now, 30 years after the land war finished, the loathing with which the land grabber is looked upon in the country still. It may be 40 or 50 years since he grabbed land, but he and his children are remembered as land grabbers and the children of land grabbers. Very often that understandable feeling has boiled over and terrible things have been done; and it has taken all the leaders of the people could do to restrain them, to hold them back within the bounds of justice, to prevent them from doing terrible injuries to the people who they believed unjustly grabbed their lands. The whole object of the land code was to make it impossible for anyone to grab his neighbour's land. Here this Bill provides that where a jealous neighbour wants to grab his neighbour's land he can set the machinery of the Land Commission in motion; he can get that land declared as being necessary for the relief of congestion; and it may be that that man will be swept clean out of the area. The only defence that individual who is about to be removed has is to ask is he going to get land of equal market value. If the Land Commission say "Yes, although you were born and bred in the County Donegal, we are going to give you land of equal value in County Kerry" he has no answer to their demand but to quit, to get out. He can be evicted.

So long as the words "shall be equally suitable for the said proprietor" were there that man had a right to go before the Land Commission and plead that the land offered to him at a great distance from the home where he was born was not equally suitable to him. He had the right to go beyond the Land Commission to the judicial commissioner and make that case. The Land Commission never attempted so long as that safeguard was there to disturb the ordinary small tenant purchaser. That safeguard is taken away; it is being taken away for a purpose. It was not taken away for the fun of taking it away.

When we came into the House here to discuss the Second Stage of this Bill we were told that the Minister had prepared a map for us. We were shown a rundale division. You would imagine that nobody in this House who was interested in the land or the land policy ever heard of rundale before. Armed with the weapons that this Bill is going to put into the Minister's hands, he is going down into an area of that character, full of the most dangerous possibilities, full of the most delicate situations, and he will have power to shift these people about like pawns on a chessboard. He is going down to settle the problem that puzzled the late Cardinal O'Donnell, that puzzled the late Father Denis O'Hara, and the original members of the C.D.B., and that took them years to solve each individual case they undertook. True, these men were puzzled by individual cases, but knowing their people, with patience, even with endless and marvellous patience, they worked away on this rundale division and they did their best by agreement and conciliation and persuasion to get the people to come together and facilitate the rearrangement of the land in order that the thing might be carried through. Everyone who knows the land question knows that any attempt at strong-arm methods in circumstances of that kind will be fraught with disaster, and the business of rearranging these rundale divisions will be a thousand times outweighed by the enmities and hatreds that will be stirred up in this area if an attempt is made to do it by any other means than patience, conciliation and persuasion.

I am reluctant to trespass too long on the time of the House, but, to my mind, this is a decision fraught with the gravest possible consequences for the country. We all know that in the days before any group of tenants had fixity of tenure their holdings deteriorated, their houses became wretched. They became so, not because the people wanted them to be so, but because the people had no faith in the endurance of their tenancy and their right to remain there. They had no heart to improve, they had no heart to make the repairs that they wanted to make because they were afraid that they were going to be taken from them. Now, if there are seven tenants in any townland, and it is decided that that townland is a congested townland, and it is proposed to take steps to relieve that congestion—now, lest the Fianna Fáil Party might think that I sought to be offensive, let us assume that there was a Centre Party Government in office and that they found seven tenants, five of whom were Centre Party, one Fianna Fáil and one Cumann na nGaedheal, and that the land of some one of these was needed for the relief of congestion. Let us suppose that a Centre Party Minister for Lands and Fisheries was in power. I am putting the question as strongly as I can against myself, but I simply want to try and drive home what the Fianna Fáil Party is up against and what they would say in the case that I am giving.

Comment on this

You have a wonderful imagination.

Comment on this

Many people think that such a case as I have mentioned is remote, especially people not born on the land, but Deputy Smith ought to know something about the land.

Comment on this

And so I do.

Comment on this

Let us suppose this land has to be acquired. Do Deputies realise the pressure that would be brought to bear upon the Minister for Lands and Fisheries if he had to exercise the powers contained in this Bill and to make a requisition of that land? Is it not as certain as anything can well be that in these circumstances it is the land of the Fianna Fáil farmers or the Cumann na nGaedheal farmers that would be acquired? Let them consider that. Let us suppose for a moment that the Minister resisted that temptation and that he said to the Land Commission: go and acquire whatever land you think is best without regard to individuals at all, and that it so happened that the Land Commission in the discharge of their duty took the Fianna Fáil farmers' land, will Deputy Smith convince me or will anyone convince me that that will not be denounced as a dishonest act?

Comment on this

We cannot help that.

Comment on this

Will it not be said that you are land grabbers, as it was said before, when the land grabbers came and took the land of the people and when the people knew what to do to pay them off? Let the Government consider well before they put their hands to such action, and before the Minister, or anybody else, tries to persuade these people that there is nothing in its operation except what is ordinary, unbiassed and impartial administration of the law. It simply means that the land is taken from these people and that they will have to shift their homes. Those who are thus evicted will look upon the people who took their land as land grabbers, and I tell the Government that if they let loose upon the land the feeling that the people are going to be faced once again with the land grabbers they will live to regret it. It took years to quieten down the feeling let loose in the country by the evictors and the land grabbers in the past. If that is let loose again, under the conditions that prevail, no Government will be able to put an end to it and God knows where it will lead our people. I am defending what I consider to be absolutely essential to the interests of our people on the land. They have a deep and profound conviction that the land is theirs and that no one should take it from them. If you pass this Bill in its present form every holder of land will be stripped of his tenure. Once the people are stripped of their security of tenure you are going to open up in the country again a terrible state of unrest. If that state of things is once opened up under the conditions now prevailing no Government, whether the present or any other, will be able to put an end to it and God only knows where it will end.

Comment on this

I am in agreement with Deputy Dillon upon one point and that is that this is the most vital section in the Land Bill. After that I disagree with him. I know of no country in the world in which security of tenure is absolute. The settler in Ontario 50 years ago had absolute security, until civilisation made its inroads and towns became established. The settler in Western Australia 100 years ago thought he had security, but there is no such thing as security of tenure in the absolute. The State has its rights. Under the operations of the Land Act of 1923, in the constituency I represent, and the adjoining constituency of the County Meath, we have seen that a section like this is absolutely necessary if land settlement is to come about. I heard Deputy Hogan painting a picture of the 250 acre farmer, and the great asset he was to the State and all the wonderful things he did. I am not disputing with Deputy Hogan the things that the 250 acre farmer does. I have nothing to say as to his progress. That is not the problem in the Midlands. The problem in the Midlands is not the non-resident grazier who has a farm in every second parish. These farms are subject to land purchase annuities. But we are unable, under the Land Act of 1923, to get even the smallest of these farms for the relief of congestion in the Midlands. And mind you there is congestion in parts of the Midlands, but in trying to relieve it we are baulked by the Land Act of 1923.

We were told in correspondence with the Land Commission during the time of the Cumann na nGaedheal Government, and even during the time of our own Government, that we were bound, not merely in the case of the possessor of 250 acres, but very often the possessor of 2,500 acres, from whom we wanted to take 50 or 60 acres for the relief of congestion, to find another holding equal in size and value to the one we took from him. The people can remain in the bogs and the marshes because of those tenant rights on which Deputy Dillon is so eloquent, which will leave in undisturbed possession of their farm men in my constituency giving the least possible labour. These men do not rear herds of suckers or breed Oxford-Downs, or Polled-Angus cattle. They go down to the West and buy the cheapest Galloway breeds of cattle, and finish them off in the quickest possible time and give the least possible amount of labour. I am ready to believe that the eloquence we have heard for the past week is not poured forth on behalf of the 250 acre resident farmer who works his land according to the rules of good husbandry, but on behalf of the grazier who is master of the Midlands and is fast turning it into a wilderness.

Deputy Dillon has referred to the land war. Deputy Dillon invaded my constituency lately, and it brought to my mind the time of the land war. It brought to my mind a person who suffered imprisonment and torture over that land war, the late J.P. Farrell. I was surprised to see on the platform from which Deputy Dillon spoke in his most eloquent way in defence of tenant right the very people whom J. P. Farrell fought in that land war.

Comment on this

Tell me your company !

Comment on this

The Deputy had better be damned careful or I will tell him some of his company. There will be ructions on the benches behind him if I do.

Comment on this

Referring again to my constituency, one has only to go down to certain places in it, such as the Hill of Uisneach, or stand at the crossroads of Killare, and see the absolute desert there. Deputy Dillon has quoted some people on these benches in reference to this Bill. Let me quote some one who does not support Fianna Fáil, but who still supports Cumann na nGaedheal. Under the 1923 Act a large area of land was divided up near the small town of Delvin. This man's comment recently was that there was one thing on which he agreed with Fianna Fáil, and that was the sub-division of land. Previous to the division of the land around Delvin, trade was stagnant in that town. With the settlement of the people on farms around it there came some trade into the town, and the man to whom I am referring agreed with us on our policy of land division because it stimulated trade.

I do not like to go into this question of land grabbing. If I did, I could tell a great many tales of modern land grabbers who obtained various farms up and down the Midlands by very questionable means. Deputy Hogan referred in his speech to the thrifty farmer, to the economic farmer, to the good business farmer, who minded his business and who was better than the other fellow. There was many a thrifty farmer in the country who got broken. He got broken because his sons, instead of being economically-minded and thrifty went out in the Sinn Féin movement. The time which might have been devoted to thoughts of economics was given in the service of their country. All the blame cannot be put at the door of the farmer for the position he may find himself in.

This, as I said at the beginning, is the most vital clause in this Bill. If we examine the origin of the land war we find that it originated when the national leaders of the time saw the clearance of Meath and Westmeath, the taking of the land from the people, and their banishment to the emigrant ship or into hovels in the bogs. They wanted to put an end to that. That spirit is there still. I think Deputy Dillon talked about patience and forbearance and all that kind of thing. Patience and forbearance was what we showed in County Meath. The sooner this clause is put into operation the better. The sooner the ordinary people get back to the land and get work on the land the better. We do not stand for excessive sub-division, which leads nowhere. We certainly do not stand for interference with the residential farmer, but we do want to put an end to the absent grazier, who is no benefit to the community. The sooner he is cleared out of the Midlands the better.

Comment on this

This proposed sub-section, as it now stands, may undoubtedly do something to meet some minor but still important objections to the clause, which as Deputy Kennedy rightly pointed out is a vital clause in the Bill, but in reality even the amendments that have been introduced by the Minister, in so far as he has met some of the amendments put down from other sides of the House, leave the main question untouched. I think the Minister himself realised that, because he thought it necessary to put up a defence of this particular section even as it now stands. Whatever the purposes of the Minister may be, and whatever the purposes of Deputy Kennedy and the various members who spoke from the Fianna Fáil Benches on this particular Bill, it means the end of the farmer's security on his land. It means the end of security not merely for the £2,000 farmer but for practically every other farmer as well—the big farmer, the middle-sized farmer and the small farmer. Anybody who has any knowledge of the country must know perfectly well that if this Bill is put into operation you are not going to stop at this Bill; you are not going to stop at the legal provisions of this Bill. In this clause we have gone back on the agrarian development of this country for the last 50 years. Some people may think that that is progress. I myself look at it as reaction of the worst type. Some countries—there is at least one—would regard such a thing as progress. I think we strike at the roots of security, prosperity, settlement and decent living by acknowledging the principle that is embodied in this particular sub-section which we are discussing. Remember, we must read this sub-section not merely in conjunction with the knowledge gained from living in this country for 50 years, as many of us have done, but in connection with a number of other things as well. We must read it in connection with the original sub-section (3), which is now embodied in the particular section proposed by the Minister; and particularly we must read it in connection with Section 31.

Furthermore, it would be complete and wilful blindness on the part of anybody who has the welfare of the country at heart to leave out of account the whole policy of the Fianna Fáil Party, as announced from many a platform. I suggest that it is useless for the Minister and the back benchers of the Fianna Fáil Party, Deputy Kennedy or anybody else, to say they are not going to stand for too much sub-division. It is not what they are going to stand for will matter in five years' time. It is whether the avalanche they are now starting, and deliberately starting, can be stopped.

I suggest that anybody who has a knowledge of this country, who has a knowledge of land hunger in this country, and of the danger of stimulating and stirring up that particular passion, will know perfectly well that it would be extremely difficult for any Government to stop the sub-division that is now being started and that is to go on. When we look at this particular section, look at it in its full reality and consider what it stands for—not the mere temporary provisions that are now in it—but look upon it as portion of a policy, as a portion of the development of farming in this country, I say there is nothing in the Bill or nothing in the speeches we have heard, even in the cooing voice of the Minister on the last occasion on which we discussed the Bill, to allay any of the anxiety which is felt throughout the country as the result of the introduction of this measure and this particular provision. On the contrary the more anybody thinks over what is involved in this particular section, the more he must be fearsome of the results for the future of this country. Take even what for the moment may seem a somewhat remote contingency. Remember we are living in revolutionary times. We have a revolutionary Government in power. It is quite true that the Minister says that this is evolution and not revolution but we might consider that there are people in this country who think that the proper form of evolution is revolution and in many ways they follow the Party and follow the particular country in which these doctrines have got acceptation. You have a revolutionary spirit and that is being fostered by the Government. That being so, it is quite clear that we must take all contingencies into account.

I suggest that a clause which in the year 1923 might be perfectly harmless, a clause that might not cause any anxiety normally, namely the phrase "in accordance with proper methods of husbandry," may become an instrument of tyranny and eviction in certain developments in this country. Remember we had supporters of the Government and, if I mistake not, even members of the Government, practically telling the people from public platforms that they will have to clear out of the land if they do not farm their lands in the way the Government want them, if they do not, for instance, fall in with the wheat policy of the Government. We have heard that policy propounded in this House. It has been pointed out to us by members of the Government that the salvation of the country depends on the success of that policy. What is more easy for the present Government in one of its more revolutionary moods or for any revolutionary Government that may succeed it, to take up the line that because of the way in which the ordinary farmer farms his land, for producing cattle, etc. he is using it if I may quote the words of the Minister, in an anti-social manner? Who is to decide whether or not he is using his land in an anti-social manner? In this case, is it not the Minister? Is that one of the excepted matters or not? Therefore I suggest that sub-section (3) as the Bill now stands is in itself an element of danger.

But, leaving that aside there is so much that threatens the future of the country in this section and Section 31, that it is difficult to understand how any Government, having the welfare of the country at heart, and having any kind of imagination whatever, any grip of the realities of the situation, could have ventured on a policy of that kind. What is the excuse? The relief of congestion. What is the reality? Section 31? The excuse is to relieve congestion, especially in the West, but in reality Section 31 carries you far beyond any such problem. It is to provide land for the landless. Remember it is no longer a comparatively small number you are dealing with. The congests may be large in number but taken as a whole they are a comparatively small number. In addition you are now dealing with all the landless. Where are you going to stop? Does anybody think that Deputy Kennedy is going to receive the people from the West with open arms? As he pointed out clearly, there is congestion in Westmeath and there are landless people in Westmeath. They will have to be provided for. I doubt if very many congests from the West will come from any other county under this particular Bill to the rich lands of Kildare, Meath and Westmeath. Yet you are offering to provide land for the congests and the landless. Does anybody suggest that there is enough land in this country to satisfy that particular demand? If so, if it is to be satisfied, where is the line to be drawn? At the £2,000 worth of a farm or at the 30 acres mentioned by the President? Can you stop there or will you reach the ideal of Deputy Moore, the Hungarian ideal, where they chopped up the land so much—he is my authority—and went so far that they had to amalgamate the lands again?

Surely, anybody who knows the history of this country must know perfectly well the dangers of stirring up the agitation which the Government is stirring up. First of all there is a bad principle involved and on that account we should oppose this section. Apart altogether from the question of opposition to the principle, there is the deliberate stirring up of an agitation that the Government cannot stop. It was only the other night that the Attorney-General said, in connection with the land agitation that started here during the Black-and-Tan period, that enough of a tribute or enough of appreciation had not been paid to the I.R.A. for the work they did in suppressing or in dealing with that agitation. That is precisely the fact. See what that means. It means that in the course of a year an agitation was got up and was spreading like a forest fire through the country. It took an army, at a time when there was a war on, to deal with that situation. That is the kind of agitation the Government is now attempting to stir up. The Minister states that he is for evolution and not revolution. These are his words, and he made great play with them. In reality, as I say, he is so steeped in revolution that he does not know it when he sees it. The Government here as elsewhere are so simple as to believe that you can start a revolution and then buy it off by cajolery and bribery. You can do nothing of the kind. The one excuse—it may be an excuse or, if not an excuse, an explanation at all events—for the Government, so far as this section is concerned, is that they do not know in this case, any more than they knew in other cases, the strength of the forces that they threaten to let loose on the country. If they did realise the strength of these forces, I think that even the present Government would hesitate. It took a very long struggle before the solution, or what is looked upon as a solution, of the land question in this country was reached. It goes back even before 1881. Various methods of solving that particular question were tried. They all failed until, finally, everybody was agreed that the only solution of that acute question that would bring about the welfare of the country and allow anything like prosperity in this country, especially amongst the farming classes and, therefore, amongst every class, was full proprietorship for the farmers. That is being got rid of now. The old insecurity is being brought back, disguise it how you may or limit it how you may, in this Bill. The insecurity is there. The land is no longer in the hands of the landlords, it is quite true; but so far as the owner of the land or the farmer is concerned, the insecurity is even greater for him now than it was under the landlords, because he will have to deal with a situation in which, as a result of the Government's propaganda and the Government's policy, class is being goaded against class and hatred is being stirred up. It is in a situation of that kind and at that very time that the Government proposes to start an avalanche of this kind in the shape of a new land agitation and, possibly, a new land war.

If we look at the benefits that are promised under this Bill I suggest that there are not many. I am leaving aside, as I said on the Second Reading, the question of the morality or the ethics of the transaction. I do not understand the morality or the ethics of the Government so far as public policy is concerned and, therefore, there is no need to discuss that question. Looking at it purely from the point of view of national prudence and national policy, however, and when you think how it concerns the number of congests in the West, and when you think of the great dangers that may be let loose upon the country, I do not see how any person— even a supporter of the Fianna Fáil Party—can gleefully vote for this particular section. I am satisfied that very few congests in the West are going to benefit from the division of the lands of Meath, Westmeath and Kildare. There will be plenty of local landless people in the neighbourhood of any estates to be split up in these counties who will put in their claims and they will see that their claims are heard. Everybody knows the difficulty of moving even one person from a neighbouring county, at the present moment, to a place where an estate is being split up. Everybody knows the danger of bringing in a stranger from outside. Nobody believes that congestion in the West will be helped by this Bill. You will still have the problem of congestion, and along with that you will have the whole security of land tenure torn up by the roots. Running through this Bill is the same contempt for the farmers and for the farming community that the Government have shown right along. They pretend to be greatly in favour of benefiting the farmer. They pretend to be stirred up by the fate of the farmer and the losses he is suffering. In reality, right through their policy, they have shown nothing but contempt for the farming community. The House should think very seriously before it determines to give a big fillip to an agitation that has been stirred up already on the platforms of the Fianna Fáil Party.

Comment on this

I do not think there is any section of this Bill more necessary than the one that is being discussed. I am speaking now as a farmer, and as one whose land, I suppose, if the arguments of Deputy Dillon or Deputy Professor O'Sullivan are in any way correct, will be divided up also.

Comment on this

What is to prevent it?

Comment on this

I want this House to tell me in what manner they intended dealing with the following estates, which have cost this country already very large sums of money in an endeavour by the Government to recover those estates for the relief of congestion. I quoted them here before during the Second Reading of this Bill. I quoted the case of the estate of Captain Moore, of Mooresfort, County Tipperary, where the Land Commission endeavoured to take 61 acres of land from Captain Moore and where Deputy Roddy, in reply to Deputy Hassett, who was a Cumann na nGaedheal T.D. for Tipperary at that time, stated that Captain Moore had 5,722 acres in addition to the 61 acres they were trying to take from him, and where Captain Moore beat the Irish Land Commission in the Appeal Court on the question of taking those 61 acres from him.

Comment on this

Read out the whole of it. Did you read the whole of it?

Comment on this

Yes, certainly I did.

Comment on this

Give the reference.

Comment on this

Vol. 29, col. 681 of the Official Debates. Deputy Hassett said:—

"Twelve months ago I put a question on this matter to the Minister for Fisheries. I asked:—

‘If he is aware that the Irish Land Commission recently refused to take any portion of the lands owned by Captain Moore, of Mooresfort, Tipperary, for the relief of congestion; if he will state the reason for such refusal; the number of acres at present in the possession of Captain Moore; if he is aware that there are a number of smallholders living near this estate; and what steps he proposes to take to bring them up to the economic standard.'

"This was the reply of the Parliamentary Secretary:—

‘Proceedings were instituted by the Land Commission under the Land Act, 1923, for the acquisition of 61a. 2r. 0p. of the lands of Kilross, on the estate of Captain Moore, County Tipperary. The owner objected to the acquisition of the lands on the grounds that for many years past they had been worked by him as part of his home farm and farming industry generally, including that of a stud farm, and that if he were deprived of the lands the result would be to materially interfere with the stud farm.

‘The objection came before the Land Commission Court, who, having considered all the circumstances, gave judgment allowing the objection, and the proceedings were in consequence discontinued. In addition to these lands, Captain Moore is returned in the Schedule of Particulars lodged as holding about 722 acres of demesne lands and 5,000 acres of mountain and woods.'"

Comment on this

There is nothing in this Bill that helps you to secure these lands now.

Comment on this

Deputy Roddy tells us that there is nothing in this Bill that will enable us to take 61 acres of land from a man with 5,722 acres, despite all the wails from Deputy Hogan and the tears and the bleeding heart of Deputy Dillon in connection with this matter. That is what Deputy Roddy tells us from his experience, and no doubt Deputy Roddy has a lot of experience since he was for so many years in charge of that Department. If that is so, what are they trying to do? If Deputy Roddy's argument is correct, that under this section we are unable to take 61 acres from a gentleman with 5,700 acres, what is all the noise at the cross-roads about? Who is going to take the 10 or 20 acres off the small farmers of the country? What is it all about if Deputy Roddy's statement is correct, or what is the joke? I think the bottom must have gone out of that balloon. Then we had the other case that was mentioned by Deputy Hassett, the Braddell Estate in County Tipperary. There, there was a non-residential farm of 500 acres. The Land Commission endeavoured to take it over from this gentleman who had another estate in County Cork of 1,188 acres. The Land Commission endeavoured to take 500 acres from him and to leave him with 1,188 acres. What happened? This gentleman went to reside in a three-roomed cottage on the 500 acre holding. He appealed to the Tribunal, and again the Tribunal found that the 500 acre holding was a residential holding because this gentleman was living for a period in a three-roomed cottage on it, with the result that his objection before the Tribunal was upheld. He was left in possession of these 500 acres together with all the other land that he had. These are types of cases that we are getting from the opposite side. Every member of the House is familiar with the ridiculous statements that have been plastered all over the country during the last month or six weeks in connection with this Bill, and particularly with this section dealing with security of tenure. Does any Deputy on the opposite side seriously suggest that the Dillons and the Davitts who went out in the Land League days would say, if they were asked, that they were out fighting for gentlemen of the type of Captain Moore, to give him the right to hold 5,700 acres that he had evicted his tenantry out of. What would their reply be if they were asked that question? Does anybody seriously suggest that they were going to stand for security of tenure for that class of bucko? Were they going to stand for security of tenure for a gentleman with 1,188 acres in County Cork and with another 500 acres in County Tipperary? Were they going to stand for security of tenure for the Smith-Barrys or for Lord Barrymore, who at present owns a couple of thousand acres in my constituency? I hope to have a word to say in dividing up some of that, and there will be no bones about it either.

We have been accused by Deputy O'Sullivan that we are going to take land for the landless men. For whom did the Government of which he was a member take land? Was it for congests or for landless men? What about the district justice down in County Tipperary who got the 351 acres?

Comment on this

On a point of order.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Deputy Corry should know that that question does not arise now.

Comment on this

I have contradicted the Deputy's statement on several occasions in this House, and notwithstanding my contradiction Deputy Corry keeps repeating that lie.

Comment on this

The statement that I made——

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Is not to be repeated.

Comment on this

I just want to say, in reply to Deputy Roddy's interruption, that the statement I was referring to was made in this House, in 1929, on the Land Commission Vote, by Deputy Hassett, a Cumann na nGaedheal T.D. for Tipperary. Deputy Roddy replied on that Vote——

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

And that ends the matter.

Comment on this

And Deputy Roddy did not deny the statement while Deputy Hassett was here. May I put this question to Deputy Roddy: Was it for the relief of congests or of landless men that the secretary of the Army Comrades' Association was given a farm?

Comment on this

It must have been under the Fianna Fáil Government that he got it.

Comment on this

No, he got it from the Government of which the Deputy was a member. That land was given at such a price that it would have been of no use to a congest or a landless man. It was divided up at such a price that nobody except a pensioner who, in addition to his pension, got a good slice of a bounty, could ever hope to hold it. When we hear all this talk about Fianna Fáil taking up a new line and of giving land to the landless, I think it would be very much to the point to know under what definition as landless men or as congests the people who were given land under the last Government—the particular cases to which I have just referred—would come? I could also quote other very glaring cases where land was taken over for the relief of congestion, cases in which men from whom land was taken were given large areas of land elsewhere, and where the land that was taken for the relief of congestion was given to single individuals, in some cases to the first cousins of those who left it. Surely there was no need to give any congest or landless man 200 acres. Undoubtedly, the gentlemen opposite were generous to their own. It is with the knowledge of what they did themselves in the past that they are judging the Government in office to-day. That is why we are accused of going to do this, that and the other; that we are going, as Deputy Dillon said, to divide up the land amongst friends of Fianna Fáil. It is because of what the people opposite did in the past in regard to the division of estates that we are hearing all this talk now.

Deputy O'Sullivan spoke of the anxiety there is throughout the country. In spite of all the efforts of the Deputies opposite to, so to speak, raise some steam in the country by means of platform orations and otherwise—the orations which they have been pouring out through the country on this Bill during the last month or six weeks—I have not seen one bit of anxiety in the country. There is no anxiety whatever in the country in regard to this Bill. Is the Government to be accused of leaving gentlemen in possession of 5,700 acres and taking, say, 50 or 60 acres from men like Deputy Kent——

Comment on this

Or myself. Is there anybody going to insinuate that we are going to do that? And yet that is the insinuation that is being made.

Comment on this

What section of the Bill prevents it?

Comment on this

Commonsense.

Comment on this

What section of previous Land Bills prevented it? Deputy O'Sullivan, as I pointed out a moment ago, based his argument on this: that landless men were going to get land under this Bill, but may I ask what particular section of previous Land Bills prevented a landless man from getting land? How was that particular section evaded in the case I mentioned? I like to give definite cases when I make such statements. We found that the division of land had proved an absolute failure, and that is the reason for Section 28.

Comment on this

How would it be improved?

Comment on this

If the Deputy examines the Bill he will see. If we do not improve it there is no need for fear. Deputy Roddy told us that we could not take 61 acres from a gentleman with 5,700 acres. What is all the noise about so? What is all the fear about? We stated that we were not going to stop at this Bill. If the division of land proves a success under this Bill I hope we will go further. If the Bill proves to be a failure I hope we will not stop in office for ten years, looking at the failure—as the people opposite did—without making an attempt to remedy the situation. I spent a short period in Deputy Kennedy's constituency during a by-election a couple of years ago. We wiped out Cumann na nGaedheal and the Farmers' Party combined there. I know that we are welcome back there any time. What did I see there? I saw farms of 1,000 acres. I walked them while engaged in canvassing. I saw herdsmen on these farms.

Comment on this

I saw a man and a dog on each of these farms.

Comment on this

There is no farmer in Westmeath with 1,000 acres.

Comment on this

Unfortunately, I cannot remember the name of the place. That is what I saw in other districts in the same constituency, and in other constituencies nearer home. We are told that we should not prevent a man using land any way he likes. I know people in my constituency with three or four farms, containing 250 acres, 350 acres and 100 acres, on which no employment is given. When these farms were in the hands of their former owners, from 12 to 15 men were employed. That land is practically derelict.

Comment on this

We were not responsible, seeing that the land has been derelict since 1929-30.

Comment on this

Deal with what has made it derelict?

Comment on this

The owners bought farms after the war, or during the war, when the managers of the bank stood beside them and said: "You can give another £1,000 for this farm and I will stand by you." When the fall in prices came, from 1924 to 1931, these people went down, because the money that they could make out of the land would not pay the interest on the purchase price.

Comment on this

Why were they not lifted up then?

Comment on this

Cumann na nGaedheal was in office and let them down—left them in the mud. Undoubtedly the people who own these farms would be very glad to get rid of them. I do not think there would be any great pressure needed, or that there would be any weeping or wailing, of which Deputy Dillon told us, to get out. They would be very glad to get out on any fair terms. I am sorry Deputy Dillon was not here when Deputy Roddy stated that there is nothing in this Bill to enable us to take 61 acres off a man who has 5,700 acres. If Deputy Roddy can prove that statement, what is all the noise about?

Comment on this

I want to ask the Minister whether there is any prospect of his making a concession in this section, on the lines of amendment 115, in the name of Deputy Roddy, and a further concession on the lines of amendment 119, in my name, which seeks to take care of the case where a man is acquiring land with the intention of making it a residential holding for one of his children. Deputy Roddy's amendment seeks to restore a very legitimate safeguard, and it appears to me, if the Minister could see his way to make concessions on the lines of these two amendments, it would mitigate the objections to the section as a whole, very considerably. I will not press that further. I will let the Minister reflect on it. I want to say a few words with reference to the speech that we heard from Deputy Corry. It is really too bad that the Attorney-General is again absent. Unfortunately he is always absent when Deputy Corry is speaking, because it would be so interesting to get him to try to reconcile Deputy Corry's views on the Land Commission in this Bill with his own. There may be two views as to the extent to which this Bill shakes security of tenure, or will shakes it in practice. One thing is certain, that if the Fianna Fáil contention is correct, that it is not going to shake it in practice, it is very undesirable that the people of the country, as a whole, should think that it will shake it. If this Bill passes into law it will become the duty of all of us to reassure the people, as far as possible, as to the spirit in which the Bill is going to be administered, and as to the maintenance of security of tenure, especially for small people. We all know that it would be absolutely disastrous for agriculture if the people got the idea into their heads that they are insecure. No one wants them to get that idea into their heads, unless that idea legitimately should be in their heads. The Minister has made some important concessions already on this Bill, and has made some very reassuring declarations, as to the spirit in which this Bill is going to be administered, if it becomes an Act. He was particularly emphatic about noninterference from the political side with the work of the Land Commission. Yet, what are we to feel when we listen to Deputy Corry stating that he is looking forward in the near future to the dividing up of estates in his own constituency?

Comment on this

I would like to reassure Deputy MacDermot that, when I said I was looking forward to the dividing up of estates, my sole reason was that I think it will be for the benefit of the people, and will largely relieve unemployment. If there are 2,000 acres of land on which there is only a man and a dog, I will ask that that land be taken, and that people be put on it who will work it.

Comment on this

I am not desirous of casting any reflection on Deputy Corry's motives. I dare say he would select estates for division in the spirit of the purest patriotism, as he conceives it; but if the Bill is going to be administered by Deputy Corry, it is going to be administered quite differently from the manner in which the Minister and the Government have told us it is going to be administered. The feeling of insecurity about this Bill that has been created in the country has been mainly due to indiscreet declarations by persons on the Government Benches. There have been, first of all, declarations by some Ministers. Even in the course of debates in the House, if a Minister becomes discreet, a good many of the supporters of the Government remain indiscreet. If this Bill is not going to do far greater damage than by its terms it actually should do, there ought to be a different attitude and a more discreet tone adopted by the supporters of Fianna Fáil.

Comment on this

I certainly cannot follow the last speaker. The spirit in which this measure will be administered will depend entirely on the outlook of the Ministry of the day, and an assurance from the Minister in charge of it now as to how it is going to be administered is not worth the making, because Governments and Ministries will come and go, but this will remain an Act until it is repealed and any guarantee now will have little effect on the manner in which this government's successor will administer it or, for that matter, any other Act of the Oireachtas.

Comment on this

I quite agree with what Deputy Belton has said. It is not inconsistent with my point, which is merely this, that if the Bill is once an Act and is placed on the Statute Book we must do all we can to have it well administered. We will do everything we can now to prevent interference with security; but once this is an Act it becomes our duty to do all we can to have it well administered and to reassure the minds of the people.

Comment on this

It is time enough to consider how we will slide down the slippery slopes when this becomes an Act. There are principles involved in this Bill which we must oppose. We should not contemplate the position in which we will find ourselves when the proposals on this Bill will be embodied in an Act. This Bill could not be framed or conceived by any body of men except men imbued with a communistic outlook. This is the purest of communism, undiluted communism. It is dishonest. I will take the Minister up on his own statements. This section is particularly dishonest. The Minister is going to smash the principle for which the whole Plan of Campaign was initiated. He is going to destroy peasant proprietorship. It is immaterial whether he fixes the limit at £2,000 or £20,000. He is breaking the principle. If, in his opinion, it is right to dispossess the owner of real estate of anything he holds over £2,000 in value, he is working upon a very bad principle. He can say next year: "We will take land from a man if he has anything worth over £1,500." The following year he can bring the limit down to £1,000 and he can follow on till he finally deals with one or two acres that might be worth £100. There is no end to this if that principle is adopted.

The Minister recently expressed the hope that another section of the Bill would be discussed in a different atmosphere. He wondered if anybody thought the Ministry was going to interfere with the farm that was worked to the best national advantage. We hear a lot of those platitudes about working a farm to the best national advantage, but they are not used by any man doing practical work on his farm. What is meant by working a farm to the best national advantage? By their actions we shall judge them. I consider that this gesture on the part of the Government is dishonest. Take the case of any business. If it does not pay a dividend, the owner has an uneasy feeling about it. He wonders if it is properly managed. If that business, in addition to paying no dividend, does not pay its way, has not the owner 100 per cent. doubt about its soundness and management? Who are the farmers whom the Minister is satisfying at the expense of the farmers who are running their farms well? The Minister is forgiving those who do not pay their way and putting the expense on the men who do pay their way. That is embodied in Section 12, which deals with people who do not pay their annuities.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Deputy must remember that we are dealing with Section 28.

Comment on this

When dealing with this section the Minister said that anybody working his farm properly and to the best national advantage would not be interfered with. I want to show from the Minister's own words that he is subsidising the people who are not working their lands well. I wonder if he means what he says in regard to this section—that any man working his land well will not be interfered with, regardless of the size of the farm? I notice that he took very good care that neither he nor the Attorney-General committed himself to putting down an amendment to that effect.

If he were honest about it, on the face of it would he not admit that it is the business that is not paying its way that is unsound? Is it not unprofitably worked? Surely he cannot say that the business that is not paying its way is worked to the best possible advantage. Yet out of the local exchequer the Government subsidises that. In a speech which the Minister made a week or two ago he made a special plea for these people here. Are we to put those people, he asked, on the side of the road in order to enforce those arrears? No, but he is going to put people on the side of the road who are working their lands well. He is going to subsidise those people who, on the evidence before the Minister, are not working their lands well. He is going to subsidise them, not by means of the Central Fund but he is going to subsidise them from the ratepayers' pockets. He is going to subsidise them with the money from the men who are paying their way and working their land well. On that point, what does the Minister mean by working the land well? We hear a lot of talk on the Government Benches about hundreds of acres being run by a man and dog. Will any Minister get up—assuming that the farms are worked by a man and dog—and say that the man who is running his farm with a man and dog is doing it for the love of that kind of farming? Or is he doing it because that is the only farming that will pay him?

If you are going to take the farmers to task for the way they run their farms address yourself, first, to the problem of prices. If that farm were run in another way not only would it not pay him, but it may not be run to the best national advantage. It is all right for a man going along the road who sees a 50 acre field to say: "here is a 50 acre field, what a pity that field is not tilled, what a lot of people would be employed on that field." But that man never tilled 50 acres himself, and he had not to worry on a Saturday night to know where he was to get the wages for those men. It is extraordinary on a debate like this on land policy that we have not the presence here of the Minister who, above all others, should be here, the Minister for Agriculture. If a farm is grazed it is because the economic policy in this country did not permit of any other method of farming to make that farm pay.

I am sorry that the Minister in charge of the Bill went away and that we are only left with the legal adviser of the Government here. I have every respect for the Attorney-General both in an offensive and defensive capacity, but, after all, I think the House should have the Minister here whose job it is to look after land or agriculture or both. I am not saying perhaps that the Attorney-General does not know as much as any of them about land. I think he does. However, I think we can get on as well without the Minister.

There is one matter which I would like to put before the House, and I put it up as a direct challenge, if you like, to any of the Government spokesmen to stand up here and say that the agricultural policy in the last 80 or 90 years took any other direction than the natural economic direction dictated by the prices trend in agricultural produce that obtained over that period. In support of that challenge I have here actual data from 1840 down to 1925 to prove my statement. At the figure of 100 in the year 1840, the prices would be in 1925 as follows:— wheat 117, oats 139, barley 155, hay 117, potatoes 177, flax 207, butter 147, pork 144, wool 133, eggs 138, beef 138, mutton 145, store cattle one to two-year old 143, and store cattle two to three years, 200. All these figures would compare with 100 in 1840. That shows that store cattle were out on their own. I am sorry I gave the wrong figures there. I gave the figures, not for 1925, but for 1868. Now, the Attorney-General can lie back and laugh and explain those figures when I am done. He can laugh away after I am done.

If this Bill is treated seriously by the Government I want them to remember the prices of 1925. Now the price of wheat in 1925 as against the figure 100 in 1840 was 118; oats 172, barley 140; hay 189; potatoes 334, flax 237, butter 189, pork 260, wool 114, eggs 497, beef 183, mutton 269, store cattle one and two years old 443; and cattle two years old and upward 403. But we get Ministers here standing up and blaming the farmers for utilising their land to produce a certain product that as compared with 1840 shows a price of 443 as against 100. Has not the farmer shown business wisdom by pursuing the line of activity that pays him best? Will any Deputy on the opposite side get up and controvert that? Will any Deputy opposite get up and show 20 per cent. of the land that I can show under tillage? I am not arguing from the graziers' point of view. Will any Deputy opposite get up and show 20 per cent. of the agricultural wages that I can show or even that he is paying at a rate of 60 per cent. of the wages that I pay? I am not arguing from the graziers' point of view but from the commonsense point of view. The figures I have read to the House are figures compiled from the Census returns, probably by the ablest man who was ever in the Civil Service. We are told that the land is not worked to the best national advantage. Whose is the fault if a proper agricultural policy has not been formulated for working the land to the best national advantage? If you want the land to be tilled produce a policy that will make tillage more profitable than live stock grazing. When you do that you are on the right road. Until you do that you are only groping in the dark. If you want to get the land of the country worked in such a way that will pay the farmers you have to produce that policy first. If you will not what do you propose doing? What will the sub-division of large farms mean? If you sub-divide 5,000 acres into 100 small holdings what will it mean? It will mean that you will have so many small ranches instead of one big ranch. It cannot mean anything else, if the present agricultural trend of prices is allowed to operate. We will be told by men who know nothing about agriculture, men who never earned a week's livelihood by agriculture, "we want a different agricultural policy." Where is the Minister for Agriculture showing us a different agricultural policy here? He is conspicuous by his absence.

If you allow this trend of prices to operate the division of the land will mean that instead of one man running, say, 5,000 acres you will have 100 little grazing ranches instead of one grazing ranch. When you put 40 per cent. on their produce the whole hundred will be running to the workhouse. We have the ordinary methods of husbandry mentioned in this. I hold that while that system obtains the ordinary methods of husbandry are being pursued by these farmers.

The Minister said the Government would not interfere with farms of whatever size that were run according to the ordinary methods of husbandry. He has not made any attempt to get out of the entanglements he has worked himself into. I hope he will make an attempt. It is extraordinary to find people coming in here and saying that we must curtail agricultural activities. They want to undo the work of the Creator; they want to bring all the people down to one common level. In support of that the Minister for Agriculture said that two-thirds of the land was owned by one-third of the people, and that we should not allow that to go on. Will the Minister for Agriculture deny that two-thirds, and more than two-thirds, of the income from the medical profession in Dublin goes to less than two-thirds of the medical practitioners in Dublin? Will the Attorney-General deny that two-thirds of the income from the legal profession goes to less than one-third of the legal practitioners in Dublin? To use the words of Deputy Corry, why not distribute the loot? Does the Minister for Agriculture mean that proper agriculture is not a profession? It is the noblest profession in the world. We who make our livelihood at it are not one bit ashamed of it. We hold our heads as agriculturists higher than any lawyer or doctor can hold his head. We produce, while they live on our backs. We are carrying the lot of them—even on both sides of the House; but the professional gentlemen on our side of the House have not committed that blunder. Take the business of Dublin City. Is not two-thirds of the business of Dublin carried on by less than one-third of the shops in Dublin? Is it not the same in the industrial world? Why are not these singled out for distribution amongst the workless? Why is not Guinness' divided up into fragments and the unemployed given a bit each? Why is not Jacobs' divided up? Why is not the Shannon scheme divided up, and why do not the landless people of Clare and Limerick take up industry instead of looking for a piece of their neighbour's land? Why does not Deputy Corry become eloquent about the millions involved in the Shannon scheme? Why is not that given over to the landless men instead of the paltry 5,000 acres he wastes his time talking about? What is wrong with the Government is that they do not understand agriculture. Not one of them understands the first thing about it. Agriculture is a progressive science. Any farmer who is not able to take a sample of his soil and go through the simple process of analysing it to discover what fertilisers it is deficient in will be left behind in the race in this year of 1933 if he goes in for tillage. That is all Greek to the Front Bench opposite. There is no reason why there should not be a department which, on receipt of a postcard or a telephone message or a wire from a farmer, would send a person to look at the field he is going to crop, take a sample of it and prescribe for it just as the doctor would prescribe for a patient, so that the farmer could take the prescription to his manure merchant and be provided with the fertilisers that he should put into that field.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Surely the Deputy does not imagine that an analysis of the soil or the price of wheat in 1845 has any relevancy to the amendment or the section before the House.

Comment on this

The Minister said that the section was necessary and that it would apply only to those people who did not work their land according to the ordinary methods of husbandry. My reference, in passing, to soil analysis and so forth was to bring it home to the Minister that he is sublimely ignorant of what working the land according to the ordinary methods of husbandry means and, therefore, he cannot contemplate working the land according to the ordinary methods of husbandry under this Bill. I suppose if he saw me analysing a portion of my soil on the head of a shovel he would say that that fellow should be committed to Grangegorman. I submit to the Minister for his serious consideration, if he is honestly pursuing the course of putting more men on the land, that the division of land will not put more men on it. In his opening speech he said that had been the fixed policy of Fianna Fáil since its inception. We know that Fianna Fáil always adapts its policy to the circumstances of the moment. The Minister said that since its inception the fixed policy of Fianna Fáil was to put the maximum number of people on the soil. I suggest to the Minister that it is not his Department that is going to put the most people on the soil. It is the Department of the Minister for Agriculture. It is the agricultural policy that will put more people on the soil and not the land policy. We were told about the derelict farms which Deputy Corry said he saw around the country and the high prices that had been paid for them. The Deputy also claimed in various speeches and so did the Minister, that the principle embodied in this section was embodied in the Act of 1923. The Minister knows well that that is not so. Deputy Corry referred to the derelict farms that should be divided up. Again I would remind the Minister that in the case of these farms on which he proposes to remit the arrears if these arrears had been paid the farms would not be derelict. If they both want to be a little insistent and consistent in these matters I would suggest that the Minister and Deputy Corry should get together, and come to a common denominator on the point where Deputy Corry wants to show how these farms became derelict and to blame the previous Administration. He also taunted the Front Opposition Bench here about the Act of 1923 and said that the landlords were allowed to get away with the loot under that Act. That comes well from a Party which never raised its voice on any point against the Land Act of 1923 until now. I opposed the Act of 1923 when it was a Bill going through this House, in every county in the Free State, and I never met one single member of the Fianna Fáil Party to say a word for or against the Act of 1923 at that time. If they had any sense of decency, after taking 10 years to find out what was wrong with it, they would let the fault pass by now.

I know the Government Party will not change their mind with regard to this section, but I would ask the Labour Party to consider what they are doing. If they are genuinely interested in having more men on the soil, I put it to them that it is not by an alteration in land policy that that will be done, but rather by an intelligent formation of an agricultural policy. Perhaps if the owner of that 5,000 acres mentioned worked his land in a husbandlike manner, and paid good wages, he would employ more human beings than if the whole 5,000 acres were split up into 50 little farms. Again I would remind the Labour Party that, as they know, hardly any two men are of the same capacity. A man who takes up farming as a profession should be allowed to develop his own profession and business. Why say to a farmer: "Thus far you shall go and no further"? Why not say to the lawyer: "Ten guineas per day and no more"? Deputies opposite agree with that, but still they are supporting the limitation of the farmers' profession. The man who would put agriculture right in this country would be worth £10,000,000. I am not a person to set a limit as to what a man is worth. The job is the thing that counts; and the man that would put commonsense into the Fianna Fáil Party would be worth the whole nation. Why fix a limit in agriculture? How can there be any progress in agriculture if we are all to be brought down to a common level? You will find men who could live well on 30 or 40 acres of land and who would starve upon 100 acres of land; and you would get men who would do well upon 100 acres of land and who would starve on 20 or 30 acres of land. If a man through his own exertions is able to go freely into the market and buy 500 acres of land, and can work it in conformity with good husbandry, why should he not be allowed to do so? Is it not the same principle as the man who takes a little shop, starts huckstering, gets into business, then finds he has not capacity enough for his business in that particular little shop and goes out and purchases better? Are you to say to him, you cannot increase your business?

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan Mr. P. Hogan (Clare) Labour Party

That is not primary wealth.

Comment on this

Primary wealth! You will get very little primary wealth out of the land; you will get very little out of it except by the sweat of your brow. Wealth does not come down from Heaven like manna to the Israelites. There are not many of them here now. I am surprised that the Deputy from Clare suggests that you could get primary wealth down in Clare—that you could pick it up in the fields and on the mountains and in the bogs in Clare. There would be a great rush to Clare, if that were true. But I am afraid the rush is rather from Clare than to Clare. If you can pick up wealth in Clare, why piffle about dividing up a few farms? You will get no wealth without work, and the Deputy knows there is no wealth in 10/- a ton for Clare turf. Why circumscribe the small farmer any more than the shopkeeper?

If, for instance, I decided to start a sausage factory, and instead of having to pay trade union wages on my farm, and on all my equipment on the land, and running the risk of being boycotted if I bought an old cart or a set of harness from a shop that did not pay trade union rates of wages, paid 5/- to a girl for working a machine and registered that as an industry, then I could swell out my chest as a captain of industry, and there would be no limit to the extent which we could develop ourselves on 5/- a week to employees.

Comment on this

Snigging turnips!

Comment on this

But we must stop and limit our undertaking in what is called the primary industry. The Minister should put this matter properly before the House; he should deal with it in a broader manner and adduce evidence here beyond merely giving voice to the expression that small farmers and crofters are the best for this country. He has insinuated that. I challenge him to prove it. They are not the best things for the country. If the land of this country is divided up into small holdings and a blight comes on any crop, how are you going to rescue it? How are you going to have scientific agriculture? What use is going to be made of the Faculty of Agriculture? Is it not to be an unnecessary luxury? If the Minister wants to plant the most men on the land, why does he not suggest that every reaper and binder in the country should be scrapped, and the scrap iron sold to one of the Deputies behind him? Why not have all the mowing machines scrapped? Why not have all the potato-sprayers scrapped? Why not go back to the old mowing hook— the scythe?

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

On this section the Deputy cannot go into the scrapping of machinery as a method of employing men.

Comment on this

Of course I accept your ruling, a Chinn Comhairle, but we have been told that the fixed policy of Fianna Fáil is to plant the largest possible number of men on the land.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Under Section 28?

Comment on this

Under Section 28 no land will be interfered with if it is worked according to the proper methods of husbandry. I am suggesting to the Minister that—if his sublime policy of putting the most people on the land is to be carried out to the fullest —this is the way to carry it out. Deputy Hogan suggested that agriculture was a primary industry. I want the Minister to go back to primitive methods, and to make it a primary industry. That is how you will get the most people on the land. In this section he is destroying security of tenure. He is destroying something which people in this country value: something that a money value cannot be put on. Deputy MacDermot suggested that there should be some sugar coating on the pill. I suggest that there should not; that the real pill should be put before the country. If they are prepared to swallow it without any sugar coating then they stand behind the Government. The Government should be fair, and not put any sugar coating on it. They should say: "By this Bill we mean to destroy fixity of tenure. We take to ourselves the right to acquire the land." We were not told what size farm is referred to. Does the Minister not see what he has walked into now? No farm in the country would average more than £2,000 to-day. What man would give more than £2,000 for it?

Comment on this

Deputy Gorey,—£2,500.

Comment on this

Deputy Gorey is not in the House, and I think the Deputy opposite would not have much to say if Deputy Gorey were here. This Bill was not before the House when the farm in question was bought. Saying that there is no security in a farm over £2,000 in value automatically reduces all farms in the country to £2,000. No man is going to pay more. There is no comparison between the size of farms. The proposal is to acquire land and give economic holdings. The economic holding has not been defined for us. I suggest that the Minister should study the difficulty that the late Sir Antony Macdonnell found in conceiving the idea of an economic holding. I know places where an acre of land would be an economic holding and I know places where 100 acres would not be an economic holding. I know farms of four acres in County Dublin which gave a bigger return this year than farms of 500 acres. A lot depends on the suitability of the land. A lot depends on the technical knowledge of the worker, and a lot depends upon the track of trade. What have the Minister and his colleagues been doing? They have been destroying the track of trade in this country for the last year and a half. Now they propose to take the land which they say is not worked to the best national advantage according to the ordinary methods of husbandry, and give it to people who will work it economically and make economic holdings. The Minister has never defined what an economic holding is. With the market destroyed I think it would be impossible for him to define it, but he muddles on.

The whole idea of this Bill, and this section in particular—because all the rest are only padding; this is the kernel of the Bill—is to confiscate the land. They hope to carry the mob. They say: "We are going only for the big fellow" and they hope to carry the mob to get the big fellow by the throat. When they have got the principle the rest will be easy. It is pure Communism. They have not at all attempted to solve the problem by a scientific agricultural policy. They want to take the land off somebody who has it, and give it to congests and landless men. If a man with four or five acres is given a slice off this land, is he to work the increased holding with the implements with which he worked the four or five acres, or is he to get more machinery? If he worked the four or five acres with primitive methods and he works 30 or 40 acres with suitable machinery he will have employed as many men on the four or five acres as he will employ on the 30 or 40 acres. The whole aim is to get hold of the land, to destroy peasant proprietorship, to pull all the farmers down to a common level—to reduce them to the position they were in a hundred years ago when they were referred to as peasants. Any farmer to-day does not take it as a compliment to be referred to as a peasant. Not by any means. The professional class can make up their minds that if they want to reduce the farmers to the level of peasants their action will not find favour with the farmers. Let us have the communistic proposal stripped of all its padding. Let it be shown as it really is. If the principle is conceded, then those amendments count for nothing. If the principle of £2,000 value is given to the Government it can be brought down as low as the whim of any Minister of the day desires. It will destroy progressive farming. The Minister, if he made any study of progressive farming in other countries, should know that progress in agriculture—outside of market gardening and horticulture—both as regards cultivated crops and live stock, has been made by big farmers on big farms. If we had a proper agricultural policy, with big farms of 300, 400 or even 5,000 acres, run as ordinary agricultural farms, it would be better than any agricultural college which this or any other Government could set up in the country. But no such educative power can ever be established if we reduce the size of the farms to the £2,000 standard. It is going to be a serious loss to agriculture. We know the old idea that obtained in this country—the fool of the family given the farm. All the other members of the family were sent into the professions, into the Civil Service, into the police force or anywhere you like, but the "mug" got the farm. That is the idea the Minister has.

Comment on this
A Deputy

Is that how the Deputy got his?

Comment on this

I may have got a farm, but the Deputy got nothing, and even though I am to be classed in that category I am certainly a degree above the Deputy who interrupted. Why not leave the profession of agriculture open to the best brains of the country? Why not make it possible to have a career in agriculture in this country? If you are not going to allow a man to get beyond practically the spade and shovel stage, nobody is going to stick in agriculture in this country. Give it a chance so that brains may be applied to it. There is no calling in this country which requires more brains than agriculture, but it is going to be destroyed now if this is passed. This Bill has been introduced without an assurance being put before the House that the fundamentals of the agricultural industry will not be injured if these proposals are put over. The Minister has not applied himself at all to that. He has only appealed to the selfish passions of the mob, dishonest passions with very little regard for the Ten Commandments: "This man has land; why should he have so much land; why should you not have more?" You might as well say that because one man has a bad suit of clothes, and another has three or four suits, you should take some suits from the man who has three or four. The question is, does a man own the land legally, did he get it honestly and legally? If he did not get it honestly, take it off him, not because he has too much land, but because he did not come by it honestly. If he has it honestly, and if he is not working it to the best national advantage, that is the fault of the Minister, who has not shown brains enough to devise a policy that would enable that man to work the land to the best national advantage. The whole thing is in the hands of the Government, but this suggests the rule of the gun. They do not seem to be as fond of guns as they were. They are apparently getting afraid of them. Though the gun is in this, figuratively, no knowledge is shown of the sentimental value attached to their land by farmers, nor have the Ministry betrayed any knowledge whatever of how agriculture has advanced in other countries or the necessity for having farms of varying sizes in this country so as to suit the varying capacities of the people of the country. If you reduce the size of the farms down to a common level, and that a low level, you must look forward to the land of this country being farmed on a common level by the lowest level of intelligence amongst the people of the country.

Comment on this

Though he is always a bit of a bore, Deputy Belton is the most convenient speaker the Government has in this House, because he invariably succeeds in effectively smashing every argument he makes by a succeeding argument. He never puts forward an argument that he does not knock into a cocked hat, as the phrase has it, by a succeeding argument.

Comment on this

You can put it into a top hat now.

Comment on this

He is the best and the most convenient speaker the Government has though he sits on the Opposition Benches. Deputy Belton's idea of farming is rather unique though I must say it is very up-to-date. His methods of farming—he called it "proper methods of husbandry"—are rather advanced. He said that if we had a proper method in this country, if a farmer decided to choose a field for tillage and wanted to know what he could grow to the best advantage in it, he should be in the position that all he would have to do would be to telephone to the Department or send a post-card to it and have an inspector within a few hours, to examine the clay, tell him what crop he should grow and issue a certificate to him to go to the manure supply department to get a supply of the particular kind of manure that the Department had decided was suitable for that soil. He was interrupted at that point and I thought it was rather unfortunate because if he had been allowed to carry on and to develop his interesting views, probably we should have heard from him that the next thing the farmer ought to be able to do would be to press a button to get his hens to lay eggs. He has a very advanced idea of agriculture.

Comment on this

May I inform the Deputy——

Comment on this

If the Department of Agriculture are so advanced in this country that they are to tell the farmer everything he must do, I am not surprised at Deputy Belton's idea of the farmers as expressed a few moments afterwards when he said that the man who got the farm was the "mug." If Deputy Belton has that impression of the farmers, he is quite right in the contention that the Department must do everything for him——

Comment on this

On a point of correction I did not suggest that anybody should tell the farmer what he should grow but I did say that the farmer ought to be able to get advice as to the fertilisers he should use on a particular soil, after it had been analysed.

Comment on this

The Deputy made both statements. He made the statement I quoted and he also made the other statement. Practically every time he gets up to speak he uses two sets of arguments——

Comment on this

On a point of order, the Deputy said that I made a certain statement. I got up to say I did not make that statement and I think the Deputy ought to accept my word.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

He is merely construing a statement.

Comment on this

He made the statement that I said that a farmer should get advice from a certain Department as to the produce he should grow. I said that I did not make such a statement but that I did make the statement that a farmer should be able to get advice as to the fertilisers required for his soil, that he should be able to have it analysed and that the Department should advise him as to the mixture of manure he should get for that. Might I inform the Deputy that I got that done?

Comment on this

I regret that in an hour's speech Deputy Belton did not make himself clear to anybody in the House. I regret that, as one who has such an experience of farming, he has still to be told the kind of fertiliser that suits a particular soil. I know farmers who know a good deal more than most instructors of agriculture about their farms and about the type of fertilisers that suits them. They are able to make their little farms pay if they are anything like economic farms at all. They are not the type about whom Deputy Belton talked, and they are not "mugs" either. I resent that remark. I spent a good part of my life on a farm, and I know these farmers are not "mugs." Deputy Belton can only be speaking of the Cumann na nGaedheal type of farmer he knows. It should not be allowed to pass in this House that up to the present the men who have got the farms in this country were the "mugs" of their respective families.

Comment on this

On a point of order, I submit that I made no such statement. I said that there was an impression abroad that only the "mug" of the family got the farm. I did not say that it was the "mug" of the family who got the farm. It is quite evident from some of the interjections that there are more "mugs" than the farmers, anyhow.

Comment on this

If Deputy Belton's statement means anything, it must mean that the Government know what they are doing, and that there is a certain type of farmers in this country, who have large farms, who are "mugs," and that it is time to have these farms run in the interests of the country. Deputy Belton wants to have the maximum number of people on the land, he says, and he went back to the last century.

Comment on this

I went back to 1925.

Comment on this

As I said, Deputy Belton went back to the last century. I am not surprised at that, because when he was asked to state facts on a former debate he refused to come down to details. He is a century away from the details on this amendment, and we are satisfied to leave him a century away, because it would be a catastrophe altogether if he came up to date. He and other Deputies opposite talked about fixity of tenure. Deputy Belton boasts of being the only man in this House who knows anything about agriculture and, in fact, of being the only well-informed man in this State where agriculture is concerned. If his speech means anything, it means that the man with 2,000, 5,000 or 10,000 acres, as the case may be, is the only farmer who is able to run a farm economically in this State. If his speech means anything it means that he does not want small farms. He does not want a large farm of 5,000 or 10,000 acres to be divided up into so many farms of, say, 50 acres each. He is against that because, he said, it will mean that there will be a certain number of small graziers instead of one big grazier. If that is the Cumann na nGaedheal idea, I am not surprised that they are fighting shy of this Bill, because I do admit that it aims at the direct opposite. I think it is the first time that anybody, who claims to represent the farming interests in this State or to be a member of a Party with the interests of the farmers at heart, ever stated openly and above-board that the large farm of 2,000, 5,000 or 10,000 acres was the only farm that would be economical and that that was the type of farm that should be favoured by the Government. If that statement is made definitely here, I should like to know if the other members of the Cumann na nGaedheal Party or of the Centre Party are prepared to back it up and to say that is their policy also. At any rate, it is not the Government's policy and, so far as I can, I will do all in my power to see that it never will be the Government's policy.

Deputies in this House have talked a lot about fixity of tenure. If they have watched the progress of the 1923 Land Act they will know very well that a particular clause in that Bill, which they held safeguarded fixity of tenure, absolutely destroyed the intentions of the Minister for Agriculture, as he was then, when that Bill was being passed through both Houses here. Take the case of the West of Ireland. I do not blame Deputy Belton or other Deputies from the South for not being able to see this problem in its entirety. There is a different problem altogether in the West of Ireland and other parts of the congested districts from that which exists in the East and South. Some of the Deputies are looking at the problem too much from what I might call the eastern point of view. I know that there are extensive farms of land in the West of Ireland and the people who own those lands have fixity of tenure. They are simply graziers. To my mind, they are not running their farms under the proper methods of husbandry, nor have they done so for a considerable number of years. Some of them, whom I know very well, have been letting parts of those farms for grazing and conacre tillage to people with large families living on three or four acres of land. Because of a particular clause of the previous Bill, the Government, under the 1923 Act, could not interfere with those people and could not take over the land. This section that is now being criticised is designed to remedy that defect and I think that most people who know the congested districts, if they are just and honest, will have to admit that such a clause as this is absolutely necessary in so far as it remedies that defect.

Fixity of tenure can be described in various ways. Are we to take it that a man with 5,000 or 10,000 acres of land, with fixity of tenure, can do anything he likes with that land? Are we to take it, if in the vicinity of that land there are 2,000 people living in hovels and on slum holdings with an average standard valuation of 15/-, that that man with the 5,000 or 10,000 acres can absolutely waste it while the people in the neighbourhood are living under conditions of starvation? If that is the policy of Cumann na nGaedheal, and if such a man is not to be interfered with, are we to take it that that position will be a preventive of Communism? Deputies opposite talk a lot about Communism. Where is there a better breeding ground for Communism or any other "ism" than a position of that kind where a man with 5,000 or 10,000 acres of land can let it go to waste if he likes, while in the locality a large number of people are not able to exist on their miserable holdings? I hold that the best preventive of Communism is the Government's policy of having the land used by the people and safeguarding a very large number of the community under fixity of tenure by giving them economic holdings and placing on the land the men who are able and capable of working the land and providing for themselves and their families.

Comment on this

It seems to me that the driving force behind this amendment from the Government Benches is concentrated largely on this question of the farms of 5,000 or 10,000 acres and so on. At any rate, they seem to think so. I am not acquainted with some of the matters, although the constituency which I happen to represent has loomed largely in this debate here to-day, but I want to tell Deputy Corry that during the last week a Land Commission officer, or somebody in connection with the Land Commission, visited one of the best farmers in Tipperary, whose farming is so good that I defy anybody to challenge it. The visit was in connection with this Bill. This man is not a rancher but a farmer, and this kind of thing has been going on pretty extensively in my constituency. These men are not ranchers but ordinary working farmers, and I am stating before the House the position as we see it in connection with this Bill. Very recently I asked that somebody from the Government Benches, when they talked about the conditions of the ordinary small farmer, would inform us what section in the Bill would protect or safeguard the farmer with 50 acres or 100 acres. I was told "commonsense." I am not prepared to take that as an answer when I ask a direct question with regard to the purpose of a section in a Bill. A lot has been said about fixity of tenure. Some people seem to think that it should not be there at all. I think it was Deputy Kennedy who pointed out that there were a number of countries in which there was not fixity of tenure at all. It does not exist, I think, in Russia. I do not want to see this country brought to the same level as Russia. I would invite in particular Deputy Davin's attention to the following extract from the Report of the Commission of Inquiry into the sale of cottages and plots under the Labourers' Acts:—

"It appears to us that it is scarcely necessary to argue the advantages of ownership. The history of our country has been one continuous struggle both on the land and in the town to gain the freedom and security that go with ownership. This we regard as a basic and essential principle in any Christian State that bases social order on justice. In the security which it gives, better citizenship is developed, and men are encouraged to improve their holdings by the certain knowledge that the improvements effected will inure to themselves or their families. We are satisfied that when tenants become owners of their cottages they will gladly devote their spare time to improving and beautifying the homes which will be theirs for all time."

I would like to know if Deputy Davin subscribes to that doctrine. I would like to say that some of those whose names are appended to that document have very little regard for the rights of ownership in other directions, or for fixity of tenure. Notwithstanding that, they turn around and put that paragraph in their Report. I want to say that I do not object to it at all.

Comment on this

That does not prove the Deputy's statement.

Comment on this

Then you do not agree with it?

Comment on this

I did not say any such thing.

Comment on this

There is no use in anybody denying that this section of the Bill does interfere with every right. I asked a moment ago if any Deputy on the benches opposite could show me where, in the section, there is security for the 50-acre farm or even for the 20-acre farm? The security is not there, and I submit to the House that it only needs just a little stirring up of hostility in a certain district to turn that district into a congested district so that people can apply for any man's land. Very probably Fianna Fáil Deputies will say that that is not so, but where is there anything in the Bill to prevent such a thing taking place? No Deputy on the opposite side has been able to point out to me where there is any security whatever in this Bill. That is the particular objection that I have to it. If a hardworking, industrious farmer acquired an extra holding in the hope that some day it would be occupied by one of his children, had he not a perfect right to do so if he bought it in the open market? Who will deny that right to him? I know people myself who have holdings, and because of this section they are certainly very anxious about them. They have reason to be. Land Commission officers, or somebody connected with that Department, have been visiting farms—not estates and not holdings of 1,000 acres or 500 acres. It will all depend, I suppose, on the strength of a Fianna Fáil club in a particular district whether a particular locality is to become a congested district or not. I do not intend to delay the House further by dealing with other matters that have already been fully debated.

Comment on this

Anybody listening to the speeches made by Deputies on the Government Benches would come to the conclusion that they have a great anxiety with regard to the division of land. So far as my own constituency is concerned, I desire to refer to a few facts in connection with the division of land. Prior to the Fianna Fáil Government coming into office, the Land Commission acquired two estates there: one, the Saunders-Knox-Gore estate, and the other, Captain Jones's estate. As a matter of fact, the officials in the Land Commission were engaged on the division of the Saunders-Knox-Gore estate when a communication was sent to Dublin and a message came back from the Land Commission stopping the officials in their work. I am speaking with first-hand knowledge of what occurred. An explanation of that was subsequently made by the present Minister for Justice. He was then Minister for Lands and Fisheries. His explanation of the division of the estate not being proceeded with was that the land was not going into the right hands. The Minister's speech dealing with that was reported in the Western People in April, 1932. That is a fact and there is no going behind it. These facts and particulars are in the hands of the Land Commission officials, and there can be no denial of them. The Captain Jones estate was acquired in or about the same time. It is practically derelict to-day, while the Saunders-Knox-Gore estate is absolutely derelict. This latter estate is in the possession of the Land Commission. It is not being divided up, but the land is being grazed by anybody who desires to do so. I wonder what return the Land Commission is getting for the money that was paid for that estate. If that is the class of administration that we are to get, it surely is not surprising that there should be, as there is, a terrible anxiety throughout the country so far as the acquisition of land is concerned. I admit there is land in the country that requires to be acquired, and that should be acquired. I think myself some of it should have been acquired long since. If the present Government were faithful to the promises they made when they were seeking power and making a bid for the votes of the people to place them in power, then surely we should not have the class of administration of which I have given the House an example. I mention these matters for the purpose of bringing home to the minds of everybody what is going on to-day.

Deputy Kennedy referred to the question of land tenure. It has to be said to his credit that, when speaking on that question, he was very candid. The Deputy said that there should be land tenure, but that it should not be absolute. He did not, however, define for the House the difference between what is land tenure and what is absolute land tenure. In saying that, Deputy Kennedy also said that, while land tenure is quite all right in its own way and that people should have an interest in their land, the State had rights. I think the phrase used by the Deputy "that the State had rights" let the cat out of the bag, and that land is now going to become a State concern—State property. These were the sentiments expressed from the side opposite. These are the principles that we hear propounded by Deputy Kennedy and other Deputies on the Government Benches. I wonder do those sentiments convey any meaning, do they indicate anything with regard to the future policy of the Government? This section that we are discussing strikes at the very root of land tenure. The greatest and the ablest men that this country ever produced devoted practically their entire lives, and were successful in their efforts, to establish the right and title of the farmers of this country deep in the soil.

That whole system is being struck at to-day. It is being slashed at now, and the farmer is going to be deprived of his rights. He is going to be robbed of his rights, and his ruin will be practically accomplished. People talk about land tenure and ask what was the value of it. It is invaluable, priceless, because the right of a man to his property represents something that he feels no one can deprive him of. No one can claim that the people had an opportunity of knowing that anything like this would be attempted by the Government, when they were seeking office. Was it ever stated from any public platform that if the Government were given their vote the people would be deprived of their land? We have certain explanations from professional men, legal and otherwise. I do not blame them for giving these explanations. That is their job; to try to put the best complexion they can on these questions.

Let us consider the position of a farmer, if the Bill is passed. What security has he from his land? A Deputy opposite stated recently that a bank manager to whom he was speaking stated that he was prepared to advance any money on land. I was speaking to a bank manager yesterday, and I asked him: "What advance are you prepared to make on the security of land if this Bill is passed?" The reply was: "I would not advance a penny. Do you not think that I would be very foolish if I did?" I told him that I was very glad to get that opinion, as it agreed with my own view. I am sorry at the same time that this situation has been created. It means that when a man sees his title broken, he will have no ambition. Is it not the ambition of any man, when he has acquired property, which is properly safeguarded, to defend it against anyone? If he was a man worthy of the name he would work that property and make it more valuable, because he was creating an asset to hand on to those who succeeded him. What asset in land will a man have now? None whatever. That asset has been smashed. By the Act of 1870, he secured compensation for disturbance, and by the Act of 1881, fair rent, fixity of tenure and the right of free sale. That is being smashed now. Some of the best Irishmen that this country can boast of—Butt, Biggar, Parnell, Healy, Davitt, Dillon and O'Brien—gave the best years of their lives to place the Irish farmer in the position he now occupies. All that is now going by the board. I wonder what these men would have felt if they had foreseen the present position.

I do not desire to refer particularly to a statement made by Deputy Cleary, that if the farmers were any good they should be able to make their land pay. The week before last I remember that the Deputy stated that the farmers could never make the land pay. My answer on that occasion was that if they did not make it pay prior to the economic war they could not make it pay now, or even eke out an existence, as a result of the position that had been created. I do not want to say anything that might be irrelevant when I refer to the present situation. I pointed out how the administration of the Land Commission had been carried on in North Mayo since Fianna Fáil came into office. If it is carried out in a similar manner in other parts of the country it must do great harm. I do not desire anything I say to be a reflection on the manner in which the Land Commission officials acquit themselves. I know that their work is carried on under great obstacles. When the Land Commission officials went to a certain estate for the purpose of dividing it, I know that a message was sent to Ballina that they were not to do so. That was in April, 1932, since when that estate has been derelict. That estate should be in the possession of the Land Commission and proper accounts concerning it should be rendered. If everything else in the Land Commission is administered in the same manner, it must be a very unprofitable Department. I repeat that the Land Commission officials are not to blame.

Comment on this

I have been informed that the Opposition have agreed to finish the Committee Stage of this Bill by 9 p.m. By the time a division is taken on the section two minutes will be left for each amendment, of which there are 40 to be disposed of. Some of them are of great importance. I intervened to know if anything could be done to accelerate progress and if the division could be taken and have this stage passed by 9 o'clock.

Comment on this

I will do anything possible to facilitate the business by concluding my remarks now.

Comment on this

I would like to ask the Attorney-General if he has had an opportunity of ascertaining the legal meaning of the words "immediate neighbourhood." He promised Deputy Hogan that he would look into the question.

Comment on this
The Attorney-General

I do not think I could give a legal definition. I do not know if the words have already been the subject of a decided case. It would have to be left to the courts or to the Appeal Tribunal to construe the words. I suggested to the Deputies that if they were willing to meet me we might substitute some words like "in the same locality". The Deputy went further and asked for something more.

Comment on this
Mr. Hogan

I understood we got an undertaking that the Attorney-General would consider the matter to see if something else would be necessitated. I pointed out that under sub-section (3) (a) it would refer to a residential qualification.

"that he or his wife resides on the declared land and that he or she uses such land in the same manner as an ordinary farmer in accordance with proper methods of husbandry; and"

Has he considered it necessary to insert a safeguard?

Comment on this

Can the Attorney-General say anything about the point I put to the Minister this afternoon, that he should make a concession in the sense of amendment 115, to safeguard the position, to see that other suitable land in the locality was taken before the land of the owner was taken, and if he could make a concession in relation to amendment 119? That amendment seeks to provide for the case where a man has acquired a farm upon which he intends to settle his children.

Comment on this
The Attorney-General

With regard to what Deputy Roddy said, I think we did promise to look into the question, and I will undertake to have it looked into. As regards what Deputy MacDermot asked, I do not think the Minister could accept amendment 115.

Comment on this

What about amendment 119?

Comment on this
The Attorney-General

Nor could we accept 119.

Comment on this

Surely the Attorney-General will appreciate that it is very unjust to acquire registered land from a person so long as there is suitable untenanted land in the district—land equally suitable for the relief of congestion?

Comment on this
The Attorney-General

The Deputy knows that that is one of the things that gives rise to most of the practical difficulties.

Comment on this

I quite appreciate the difficulties of the situation. At the same time, it would appear to me to be obviously unfair that the Land Commission should proceed to acquire land in a certain district when alongside that land there is untenanted land equally suitable for the relief of congestion and which really should be first acquired. It has always been recognised in the Land Commission, and even under this Bill it is recognised, that registered land has a certain claim for special consideration. Untenanted land is dealt with differently under the 1923 Act. So long as there is untenanted land alongside or adjacent to registered land, then in all justice the Land Commission should first acquire the untenanted land, and then the other land subsequently, if it is required.

Comment on this

That will be the practice so far as possible, but the Deputy knows perfectly well that this type of clause has given rise to enormous difficulties heretofore. A clause similar to that which the Deputy wants to insert here was inserted in Section 24 of the 1923 Act. The result was that where land was needed for division the owner invariably said that there was other land in the district available, and that held up the work of the Land Commission. The Land Commission will not acquire land where there is more suitable land in the district. There is, of course, the other point of view. The Deputy knows that if you give holdings to people some distance away from their place of residence you make it impossible for them to work that land in an ordinary fashion. Instead of the land being portion of the holding it is situated quite a distance away, and they are half the day carting stuff along the road from one holding to another, instead of devoting that time to working on the land. I do not propose to accept this amendment.

Comment on this

Does the Minister propose to advert to the principle of amendment 119 suggested by Deputy MacDermot? Surely it is manifest that where a man wants to make provision for his children, wants to settle them on the land, he ought not to be impeded or restricted. That seems to me to be a very desirable purpose, and if the Land Commission can take land from that man and give it to someone else's children, that seems to me to be anything but a rational arrangement. With reference to Deputy Roddy's point, I think that throws added light on the danger this section carries with it. The people are going to be made pawns of and are going to be shoved about here, there and everywhere without any regard to the attachment of an individual for his own home. It is not right that the Land Commission should shift a man out of his home in order to make the pattern look nice. They are going to disregard a man's attachment to his home although equally suitable land might be within a mile from the place. They are going to put a man out of his father's home simply because it fits into their plan.

How any Irish Parliament could recognise a principle of that sort absolutely baffles me. How anyone professing to be a nationalist or professing the traditions of nationalism could stand over that sort of principle absolutely baffles me. The whole thing throws a floodlight on the purpose of the Minister and the Land Commission. It means that they have no regard for and no understanding of what a man's homestead means to him in this country. The Attorney-General ought to know. He was born and reared in a part of the country where that kind of thing obtains. The Minister for Defence comes from a part of the country where, perhaps, our outlook on the land question is not so rife. Other Ministers were born and bred in Dublin, and they do not understand the land question at all. The Attorney-General ought to understand it because he was born in the country. The idea of going to a man and telling him you are going to take his holding, although a mile away there is untenanted land which could easily be used for the relief of congestion—the idea that you are going to put him out and transport him to another part of the country is monstrous.

Comment on this
The Attorney-General

Then it will not be done.

Comment on this

Why not insert it in the Bill?

Comment on this

The Attorney-General gives his word that it will not be done.

Comment on this
The Attorney-General

As the Minister pointed out, in practice what the Deputy fears will not happen. There might be an exceptional case.

Comment on this

Then put it in the Bill and let us be satisfied. Of course you will not put it in the Bill. I have not the slightest doubt the Attorney-General speaks in good faith and he hopes he will be able to implement that undertaking, but I say he will not be able because when his own supporters get under way he will be forced to do things which he knows in his heart are wrong. Those amendments ought to be accepted. The amendment I have down ought to be accepted and the amendment that provides for the case of a man desirous of making provision for his children by putting them on his land ought to be accepted. If the Minister is not prepared to accept them, then it is clear what the purpose of the Bill is. They may have high hopes now, but when this measure comes into operation they will be driven down along the path which is going to land this country God knows where.

Comment on this

Perhaps the Minister will be prepared to make a statement later with regard to the elimination of the term "equally suitable." I would like also to know if there will be any advertence to the question of the provision of alternative holdings. There may be a case in which a man getting a holding of the same value as the one he has to leave may have to expend £1,000 in order to put it into a condition so that he may carry on the same class of farming as that to which he was accustomed. I would like to hear from the Minister in that connection.

Comment on this

The words "equally suitable" in the 1923 Act rendered the section inoperative. Even though the Land Commission wanted the land very badly for the relief of congestion, they could not take vested land simply because no one would be satisfied that the land they were getting was "equally suitable." It was only in very few cases that the owner would be satisfied that the alternative holdings were "equally suitable." Usually unless the owner got a holding that was two or three times the value of his original holding he was not satisfied. In cases where the Land Commission was compelled to give the owner an alternative holding that holding was worth several times as much as the holding he was giving up. For that reason, we are not going to stultify ourselves by accepting the amendment. I do not want, at this stage, to go into the objections raised to this particular amendment. We will have another day to discuss it. It has been already discussed at considerable length.

The next amendment 115, in the names of Deputies Roddy and Lynch, mentions "other unacquired land in the locality suitable for the relief of congestion." Well if these words "other unacquired land in the locality" go in, though there are 10 or 20 congests around the ranch that is not being worked and on which the owner never put his foot for years, the position will be that that land is to remain in his possession and the congests there are to remain congests. If there are other lands five or six miles away which can be given to these congests that land would not be suitable for them.

Comment on this

The amendment is dealing with untenanted land.

Comment on this

The untenanted land might not really be suitable. It might be 15 or 16 miles away.

Comment on this

My amendment says "suitable for the relief of congestion."

Comment on this

"Unacquired land in the locality." Can anybody set down in specific terms what "locality" means there?

Comment on this

That is what we have been asking the Minister this evening.

Comment on this

The Minister is up against that difficulty in his own drafting.

Comment on this

Not altogether. It is not quite so bad. If a man has farms in the immediate neighbourhood we bulk them together to ascertain what the bulk of his holding is and we treat them all as one holding.

Comment on this

Could not the Minister accept the amendment if the words "in the immediate neighbourhood" were substituted for "locality"? Would not that meet the objection?

Comment on this

In the first instance, the "immediate neighbourhood" renders the section more favourable to the occupier of the land.

Comment on this

It would meet the objection.

Comment on this

How many miles away?

Comment on this

Whatever the court will say.

Comment on this

We are laying down the law and they are to interpret it?

Comment on this

That is what we are doing. These words were used before.

Comment on this

I want to put this to the Minister. Take the case of a farm worked as an ordinary farm by an ordinary farmer. That is what we are debating. That is the class of land the Minister is taking.

Comment on this

We are taking more than that.

Comment on this
Mr. Hogan

In all these cases the net point we are debating is how far you can take land from the ordinary farmer; that is to say, land which is registered land where it is worth more than £2,000.

Comment on this

There is more than that in the section. If the man is not residing on his holding and if he is not working it as an ordinary farmer should work the holding, he gets no protection whatsoever.

Comment on this
Mr. Hogan

Exactly.

Comment on this

There are many such vested holdings on which the owner never sets his foot. There are plenty of farms in this country which are vested in the occupier and which the occupier has not seen perhaps for 20 years, and will not see for the next 20 years.

Comment on this

The Minister has not answered my question. He has been dealing with a suggestion which I did not make—that "equally suitable" should be inserted. My question was whether any advertence will be had to the suitability of the new holding for the occupier in the administration of the Land Acts.

Comment on this

The man will get a holding which the appeal tribunal holds is of equal market value to his holding.

Comment on this

We may take it from that that as far as "suitability" is concerned it will not be considered at all?

Comment on this

I think the Land Commission will always take that into consideration.

Comment on this
Mr. Hogan

Deputy Roddy's amendment does not affect untenanted land or land which is not over £2,000. It does not affect land which is not properly farmed. It only affects a holding which is being farmed by an ordinary farmer under a proper system of husbandry. He wants to see that man protected and he wants to see that such a farm is not acquired if there are other more suitable lands of a different category in the neighbourhood. Is that too much?

Comment on this

It will be reconsidered on Report.

Comment on this

I think that amendment points to one of the outstanding defects of the Bill.

Comment on this

We are accepting the change.

Comment on this

With regard to amendment 116, "To delete sub-section (3)," we are accepting that also.

Comment on this

The other amendments will not be moved. We will divide on the section.

Comment on this
Division

Question put: "That Section 28, as amended, stand part of the Bill."

Tá 50
·
Níl 41
Result Carried The question put was agreed to.

Do you agree with this result?

I move amendment 127:—

Before Section 29 to insert a new section as follows:—

A person who or whose predecessor, at the passing of the Land Act, 1881, was the tenant of a holding to which the Land Acts apply, and who (or whose predecessor) was evicted from the said holding, since the said date, in consequence of proceedings taken by or on behalf of his landlord and who or whose personal representative has not under any previous Land Acts been either reinstated in his original holding or been given a substituted holding, shall be entitled on making application in a form to be prescribed under this Act, to be restored to his original holding or to be given a substituted holding (as the case may be).

I am surprised that this Bill does not make any mandatory provision for the reinstatement of evicted tenants, or the representatives of tenants evicted from their holdings since the passing of the Land Act, 1881. The British House of Commons in the year 1907 passed an Evicted Tenants Bill making it obligatory on the Government of the day to reinstate all the evicted tenants in their former holdings. That Bill was held up by the House of Lords and did not become law. I understand that the Fianna Fáil Ard-Fheis passed a resolution something on the lines of the amendment which I now ask the House to accept, and, in view of that, I hope the Minister will see his way to accept the amendment. During the discussion of the Land Bill of 1927, ex-Deputy James Cosgrove moved an amendment providing for the reinstatement of all evicted tenants in their original holdings. During the debate on that amendment I endeavoured to point out that it would be absolutely impossible to give effect to it in the form in which it was moved. I have been reading some of the debates in the British House of Commons. In support of my argument I understand that in dealing with the 8,000 claims made previous to 1907, the Commissioners in their report at the time stated that "in 1,259 out of the 1,609 cases in which the applicants were considered suitable to be provided with holdings their former holdings are in the possession of other tenants." That, of course, made it quite clear even at that time that it would be impracticable to have the evicted tenants restored to their former holdings.

That is the reason why I am suggesting, in this amendment, that they be restored to their original holdings, or that they be given substitute holdings as the case may be. When ex-Deputy James Cosgrove's amendment was under discussion in the Dáil, in 1927. Deputy Hogan, who was then Minister for Agriculture, said that if the amendment were accepted there would be about 100,000 applications coming in from evicted tenants or their representatives. From information supplied by the Commissioners, who had invited applications previous to the year 1907, and who were the best judges as to what the exact number of such claimants was likely to be, Mr. Birrell, who was then Chief Secretary for Ireland, speaking in the House of Commons on the Evicted Tenants Bill of 1907, said that the maximum number of applications under this head would not exceed 8,000. He said, at the same time, there were some of the people who claimed to be representatives of the evicted tenants who, in his opinion, had as much right to describe themselves as descendants of evicted tenants as they had to call themselves astronomers. He boiled it all down to this, that in his view the number of genuine claims submitted would not exceed 2,000. Looking at the figures quoted from time to time in this House and elsewhere, I understand there were 3,359 tenants restored to their former holdings, or had suitable alternative holdings provided for them, up to the 31st March, 1914. I have not at my disposal the same information as the Minister and I hope he will give the House the number of tenants restored to their holdings or provided with suitable alternative holdings under the Act of 1923.

I asked on the Second Reading debate of this Bill that we should get reliable information on the aspect of the claims of those tenants, and I hope that the Minister now will be able to furnish the House with the information when he comes to reply on that matter. Mr. Birrell, dealing with the claims of the evicted tenants in the debate to which I have referred, said that in his opinion—and apparently that opinion was shared by the late Mr. John Redmond, the leader of the Irish Parliamentary Party, and by the then Mr. James Campbell, who was afterwards Lord Glenavy, and Chairman of the Senate—80,000 acres of land would make reasonable provision for the claims of the genuine evicted tenants. I quote these figures because they were made available by the Land Commission of that particular period, which apparently investigated the applications that were submitted to them previous to the discussion of the Evicted Tenants Bill of 1907. I am informed by ex-Deputy James Cosgrove, who is in touch with the organisation, so far as there is any organisation available, to promote the claims of the evicted tenants, that the number of cases awaiting settlement at the moment could not possibly exceed 500. I know Deputy Dillon will oppose this amendment simply because it is moved by a member of the Labour Party——

Comment on this

On a point of personal explanation, may I say that whatever the prescience of Deputy Davin may be, he has not yet developed the faculty of thought-reading and he, therefore, cannot know anything about what I may be going to say.

Comment on this

I said that one of the reasons that would justify Deputy Dillon in his opposition to this amendment was that it was moved by a member of the Labour Party. However, everybody recognises the fact that it was the agitation surrounding the original eviction of these tenants, and their claims for restoration, which led to the passage of the various Land Acts in this country. I think everybody associated with the land agitation and the passage of the various Land Acts holds that genuine evicted tenants should be reinstated in their holdings, or provided with suitable alternative holdings, if it is not possible to give them back their own original holdings. If the British Parliament in 1907 considered it feasible, for any good reason at that time, to introduce and pass a Bill for the reinstatement of those people, I think the present Government whose Party conference, already published, unanimously declared support of the same policy, should make provision in the Land Bill for the reinstatement of those people or their relatives. I hope, without saying anything further upon the matter, that the Minister will see his way to accept this amendment.

Comment on this

Perhaps, before the Minister replies, Deputy Davin will explain why it is he left out the evicted tenants of '79 and '80. I am in entire agreement with the Deputy in his attitude towards the evicted tenants. I agree that provision of a very specific character should be introduced into this Bill for the reinstatement of evicted tenants. But I cannot see why the men subsequent to '81 should be excluded from such benefits. The very best of the evicted tenants were the men in the years '79 and '80. These are the men who were evicted having very little hope of ever getting back. Something has been knocked out of Governments since the movement was started. The men evicted subsequent to 1881 knew that there was a great movement in being, and hoped that justice would be done to them in the long run, but the men who went out in '79 and '80 were the shock troops of the land movement. They did not know whether it was possible to break the power of landlordism but they went out all the same. The numbers evicted in 1881 may be small. The numbers evicted in '79 and '80 are still smaller but their claims are far stronger and seem even more meritorious than those men for whom Deputy Davin speaks.

The Minister, I have no doubt, will answer that there are very great administrative difficulties. I have no doubt there are. But I know that the prime objective of the leaders of the Land League movement was to put back into their holdings the men who were evicted in the land war. I remember, prior to the election of 1918, I attended the reinstatement of the last evicted tenant in East Mayo to his holding in the month of November of that year. I know it was the ardent desire of every land leaguer in Ireland to put back the evicted tenants into their holdings or into suitable holdings. It was hoped that the 1923 Act and subsequent Land Acts of an Irish Government would complete that work. This Land Bill, to my mind, has very few redeeming features, but if an amendment, in the sense of Deputy Davin's amendment, were inserted in the Bill, it would do something to redeem it from the deplorable character it has assumed. I cannot allow this occasion to pass without drawing Deputy Davin's attention to the apparent inconsistency of the position he has taken up. We have just passed a section of this Bill for the purpose of making new evicted tenants. We have just passed a section which puts it in the power of the Land Commission to put tenants out. Now Deputy Davin, very rightly I think, wants to insert a section to compel the Land Commission to put back the old evicted tenants. I hope when the time comes for reinstating tenants who were evicted by the Land Commission under the Act of 1933 Deputy Davin will co-operate with me. That time will probably come.

Comment on this

The Deputy is very pessimistic.

Comment on this

That time will probably come, and I should like to hear Deputy Davin speak as trenchantly and as eloquently on their behalf as he is speaking now for the evicted tenants of the landlord. So far as I am concerned I strongly urge on the Minister to accept this amendment, with one qualification,—instead of the words "at the passing of the Land Act, 1881" to insert the words "on the 1st day of January, 1879".

Comment on this

Why fix a limit at all?

Comment on this

The number of evicted tenants or their representatives provided for since the Land Act of 1923 is 153. Deputy Davin seems to be unaware of the power that the Land Commission has at the moment to deal with evicted tenants and their personal representatives.

Comment on this

I am.

Comment on this

As a matter of fact, they have power to go back three years beyond the date which Deputy Davin mentioned,—1881. They have power to go back to 1878. I should like to get fully from both Deputy Dillon and Deputy Davin their point of view on this matter. I do not think any Party in the House has a monopoly of sympathy with the evicted tenants. We are on common ground in that respect. We all know what the country owes to the men who fought the land war. We all want to see them properly dealt with, and we want to see their personal representatives dealt with. There is one thing we want to be clear on, and that is that under the previous Acts the Land Commission were compelled to take into consideration whether or not the personal representative of an evicted tenant was a fit and proper person, and was competent to work the land. The Land Commission, in their administration of the previous Acts, although they were directed by law to have regard to a man's competency, put a rather liberal interpretation on their legal instructions. In some districts they put in personal representatives who did not "hang on" to the land. Down in Kildare, I understand, there were 12 representatives of evicted tenants put in, and within a few months five of them sold out. There are some personal representatives of evicted tenants who have no great need for land. Sometimes the personal representative is very remote from the original evicted tenant.

There are cases on the files of the Land Commission where a woman has claimed to be the personal representative of an evicted tenant simply because her husband was the grandson of the man who was evicted. The woman is a shopkeeper; she has a fairly good business. Are we to put that woman on the land to the exclusion of a small uneconomic holder, or a landless man who has no other means of livelihood, and who knows how to work the land? Are we to deal with correspondence we have from Australia, from men who are personal representatives of evicted tenants, who know nothing about the land and have been all their lives in cities, by asking them to come back simply because they are the grand-children of tenants evicted in 1881 or 1878? As the law stands, the Land Commission has to inquire whether a person is competent to work the land or not. If Deputies agree that that is a good and proper direction to the Land Commission then the law does not require to be amended. In this Bill, however, we are amending the law in one respect, and that is to enable the Land Commission to more easily acquire land for genuine evicted tenants, and the personal representatives of evicted tenants, who are competent to work the land.

On the 15th June of this year the situation relating to evicted tenants was as follows:—There were 13,693 applications lodged. The number who were refused as being unsuitable, after inquiry, was 4,852. The number reinstated by the landlord or provided with land by the Land Commission was 3,461. That left a residue of 5,308. Some of those cases were lodged years ago, but the Land Commission have at the moment 240 cases noted for further consideration when land comes in. Up to the present, they have no power to acquire land specifically for the placing of evicted tenants or their personal representatives on the land. Under Section 31 of this Bill we are taking power to acquire land for evicted tenants. What I want to hear from Deputy Davin and Deputy Dillon is whether Deputy Davin's amendment is to go through as it stands, that is that the personal representative of an evicted tenant shall be entitled, upon the filling of a form, to get the original holding or a substitute holding, no matter whether or not he is competent to work the land, whether or not he is a man who is well-off in other ways, or whether or not he is living in the country. I want to hear both Deputy Dillon and Deputy Davin on that point. Heretofore, we had power to place evicted tenants on the land, and in this Bill we are taking power to more conveniently get land for them.

Comment on this

While Deputy Davin is considering what the Minister has said I want to state that there is no doubt whatever in my mind. When those men were being put out on the road Michael Davitt and the men with him went down, stood beside them, and said: "Go out in every confidence. We will put you back. They may evict you, they may kick you out, they may persecute you, they may do anything they like, but sooner or later we will put you back." That promise ought to be redeemed. That is the issue. The Minister says—and mind you, I have every sympathy with him in the administrative difficulties involved—that a lot of those people are unsuitable. Whose fault is that? Was not that the very object of the landlord who put them out? They drove them out on the roadside. The people had to live. They had to go and get work here and there as best they could, to keep body and soul together. Many of them drifted to the cities. Many of them drifted to the workhouse. Michael Davitt drifted to the workhouse. If he did not drift into the workhouse there might have been no Land League and no land war. I suppose if Michael Davitt were an applicant for reinstatement to-day he would be told he was not suitable because he was an industrial worker in a North of England city.

On the qualifications laid down by the Land Commission Michael Davitt was not eligible for reinstatement as an evicted tenant. Does the House stand over that? I make no bones about it. These men risked their all. Their wives risked their all. Their wives went out into the streets with their children. They went into the workhouses with their children, rather than give in, and they did that on the express promise that we would put them back. Now is your opportunity. It is a question of whether this House is going to honour this promise or not. In my opinion no administrative difficulty should be allowed to stand in the way. Every single genuine successor of an evicted tenant should have the promise from the Land Commission: "If you want a holding such as your parents were put out of, we will give it to you. We will redeem the promises made to you. We will put you back."

Comment on this

Supposing that they do not want to go back?

Comment on this

I think I made that point clear. All I say is that the Land Commission should be empowered to say to the personal representative of every evicted tenant: "If you want to go back we will put you back".

Comment on this

Is that not included in the Bill?

Comment on this

Section 31.

Comment on this

I would advise Deputy Donnelly to read the Bill more carefully.

Comment on this

I was listening to the Minister.

Comment on this

That is what I was going to say, that he should not pay too much attention to the arguments used by the Minister, arguments which were used equally effectively by Deputy Hogan, who was previously Minister for Agriculture, on an amendment similar to this to the 1927 Act. I venture to suggest that were it not for the land agitation, the Land League, and those associated with it, and the Party who advocated the policy, which originated in that agitation, in a foreign Parliament, the Government or the Minister would not be sitting on those benches to-day.

Comment on this

But for the Volunteers we would not be here.

Comment on this

I should like to hear Deputy Donnelly make his maiden speech either for or against this amendment. His constituents. I am sure will be glad to hear him speak for the first time in this House.

Comment on this

I got more votes than you got.

Comment on this

Do not be so parochial.

Comment on this

I have this to say, and I am sure that Deputy Donnelly will not challenge the accuracy of my statement, that during the discussions on the 1923 Bill and during the discussions on the 1927 Bill, I spoke in the same strain. I hope, now that we have in office and in power a Party which definitely pledged itself to a certain course of action through its delegates from the Fianna Fáil branches at the last Ard-Fheis, they will implement the policy which was unanimously approved of at the last meeting of the Ard-Fheis. I candidly confess that the Minister can pick out exceptional cases to justify opposition to the acceptance of an amendment of this kind. It is quite true, that some of the tenants evicted, and certainly some of their representatives, are to-day endeavouring to eke out an existence in Australia, America and in other foreign countries. Is there anybody in this House who would not say that an opportunity should be created, by the acceptance of such an amendment, to bring back from Australia or America or these other countries the tenants or their representatives who were forced to leave this country as a result of eviction?

The Government are paying pensions to several sets of officials who served in the Army and in the Civil Service. These pensions are being paid regardless of the other means of income of these people or whether they hold other positions or not. I know persons who are receiving at the same time salaries and pensions from the State at the expense of the taxpayers. I think that should dispose of the argument that there are some people well off, and that simply because they are well off—possibly in a few cases they would be unfit for immediate work on the land—they should not get land. Remember these people or their predecessors were evicted from the holdings and these holdings were taken over by grabbers. They are entitled to be reinstated in their original holdings or provided with alternative holdings or if you like, given compensation for the land taken from them, in circumstances well known to Deputies, in the days of the land agitation. I want to advise Deputy Donnelly on this. The Minister has stated that the Land Commission can, under their present powers, make provision for the reinstatement of evicted tenants or their representatives in their former holdings. I would like to remind Deputy Donnelly that the word used is that the Land Commission "may." My amendment compels them to do so. That is the difference between the present powers of the Minister and the amendment moved by me.

Comment on this

What time has the Deputy in mind when he says that they shall be entitled to reinstatement?

Comment on this

Provided the Minister is prepared to regard this as an obligation I am not going to quibble over words, as to whether the date should be after the 1st of January, 1879 or the passing of the Act of 1881. I am not an expert by any means regarding the method by which the Bill will be administered, but it should be possible to have all the land which the Minister hopes to acquire, acquired and divided within a period of three years. I am making that statement without any official advice—and I would like to hear the Minister on this—or without any access to those who hope to help the Minister with the Bill. I am prepared to admit that there may be exceptional cases as stated by the Minister, but I think that the House ought to make a real beginning, after all the discussions that have gone on in the British House of Commons and in the Dáil on the 1923 Act, on the 1927 Act and on this Bill, and that finally we ought to come to the time when the majority of the House ought to do the right thing for those who have been deprived of their holdings without any compensation. You can have it any way you like. You can reinstate these people—personally, I believe that will be impossible in many cases—or you can provide them with alternative holdings and if, that is impossible, you can make provision by way of compensation for these people who are deprived of their holdings.

I should like to ask Deputy Dillon whether he has any figures which he can give to the House to show the number of additional people he would cover by the suggested amendment in regard to the date. In other words, what was the number of people who were evicted between the 1st of January 1879 and the date of the passing of the Act of 1881? The Minister stated that only 153 tenants or representatives of tenants were reinstated in their former holdings or provided with alternative holdings since the passing of the 1923 Act. I venture to suggest that the majority of the people who will be administering this Bill will be the very same people who administered that Act. They will have the same outlook and the same mentality unless this House inserts an amendment of this kind and compels them to take these cases into consideration. The Minister may not be in his seat or his Party may not be in power 12 months from to-day. There is nobody who can get up and prophesy what will be the life of this Parliament or how long the Minister and his colleagues will remain in office but when the Government goes out of office it should have the satisfaction at any rate of being able to say to the people that they honoured the obligations placed upon them by their own Ard Fheis at its last meeting. There are 5,308 cases still outstanding. I listened very attentively to the Minister's remarks when the Minister assured the House that 240 out of 5,308 cases still outstanding, were noted for consideration. He said that the Land Commission, of which he is the acting head to-day, had noted for consideration only 240 cases out of a total number of 5,308. Would his own colleagues, sitting behind him, accept that as satisfactory, or do they regard that as the outlook of the Minister himself on the number of people who should be considered?

Comment on this

After all, the law is the law.

Comment on this

I am suggesting that he should take the claims of all these people into consideration.

Comment on this

Are all these victims of the land war or did they refuse to pay a judicial rent or a fair rent?

Comment on this

Does the Deputy remember the "No Rent" Manifesto? I suppose he never heard of it.

Comment on this

Deputies will be aware of the case of the Luggacurren Estate where a large number of people, or rather the sons and daughters of those evicted on that estate, have not yet been reinstated. The majority are still looking for reinstatement.

Comment on this

Yes, and it is at present planted.

Comment on this

It is a planters' quarter. I suggest to Deputy Donnelly that he should go down to that area and tell those people, who have genuine claims for reinstatement, that he voted for the acceptance of an amendment in this House which compelled his own Minister to have these people reinstated or provided with suitable alternative holdings. Before concluding, I wish to assure the Minister that I am not quibbling over areas or dates but that I want a statement of policy from him as to whether he is prepared to accept it as an obligation on the Department to make provision for the reinstatement of these people or for the provision of suitable alternative holdings for them.

Comment on this

The only thing is that I should like the Deputy to assure us that he does not want to compel the Land Commission to put people on the land who cannot work it or, in such a case, to provide them with compensation.

Comment on this

I said that I was not standing for it in this amendment. The proper way to compensate these people is to reinstate them or to provide them with alternative holdings.

Comment on this

Whether they want it or not?

Comment on this

If they do not want it, they can go elsewhere—and you know what that means.

Comment on this

The Deputy mentioned 1881. Honestly, I would like to have an opportunity of going further into this question in order to see where all its implications lie. I do not want to do something for one particular class of people that will make it impossible to deal fairly with the majority of the people. As I say, I should like to have an opportunity of examining this matter further in view of the discussion here to-day; and if the Deputy would withdraw the amendment and bring it up again on the Report Stage, we could discuss it then if I am not able to find an alternative amendment that would meet the case.

Comment on this